Newspaper Page Text
(gas ' 'nlrP tf VOL. 2. HONOLULU, TUESDAY, JANUARY "10; 1893. WHOLE No. 148L By M k rtii & Hawaiian Gazette. PUBLISHED BT t HAWAIIAN GAZETTE CO., (Limited,) EvufY Tuosday Morning, AT riVE UULUit PER ANNUM P A TA BLii .V VASCE. Ailiauee Which Includes postages prepaid. H. M. WHITNEY, Business Manager. Office, Xo. 4S Merchant Street RATES OF ADVERTISING. la oapriL K In 1 in 4 in 4 IS:::::: 1 ' K Col.... a coi.... 1 Col.... 1 w 3 w 1 m 2 in 3 m 6ra iy TiwTw 2tW 3U0I4W 6I 1000 200 300 400 500 600 1000 1400 300 500 6O0 8001000 1400 SO 00 400 600 750 1000 1200 1750 2100 500 730 900 1200 1500 2100 3000 750 1000 12O0 1600'2000 5000 50 00 9O0 1'W14O0 18O0;2100 S5O0 8000 1500 1800 i! 00 3000 4000 5000 10000 lTXOiJOOI'SOWMOOOlSOOll bOOO 12000 2000 2503 S200 500317500 11000 15000 Correspondence iutcndid for publication, Gazette, Post Oll.ec Box. O " Eos Correpondcnce relating to Advertisements, subscription and Job Printinjr, should bo adlreefcdtothe"3Ianascror llie Hawaiian Gazette, Post Office Box, O. " sarBusiness Cards and all quarterly or yearly advertisement are payable in advance or on presentation of tho bill V B ill foreign advertisements innstbe accompanied with the pay when ordered,!!., or no notice will be taken of them. The rates of chafes are clven in the above ca!e. and remittance's for European or American advertise or subscriptions ma be made by postal order. . T II 2 -Daily Pacific Commercial Advertiser iT'TrabUshed bj the llxn. aiiax Gazetxs Coa- rxsx at Us Office In Merchant Street, and de- lvered by Carriers In the City, at Six Dollars (86.00) Per Annum. 1ai.j and WceUj to one address. 510.00 per annum Oally tVForeizn Countries Postage paid, ... .7 S10.00 per annum W Address all Communications, I1AWAIIAS GAZETTE COMPACT, No. 46 Merchant Street gusintft PROFESSIONAL. CHARLES i.. CARTER, A,ttoraoy vt lays Xo.4 Merchant fetreet, A. ROSA, .tSuttorJOLoy eft w. NO. 15 KAAHCXAXB SlBEZT, 13JS Honolulu. II. 1. y CTXEiLIAM C. FAH.KE, And Afient to take Acknowledgments. OFFICE: 13 KAAHUaAMJ brr.EB, lyu Honolulu, II. I. V R. CASXIiE, And Notary Public. Attends all the Courts of 156 the Kingdom. J. AURED SIAGOON. Attorney and Counsalor At Law. OFFICE 12 Merchant js trcct. Honoluli., H. 1. 1313 l rocsc, Honolulu. Honolnln, Honolulu. EI UOFFSCUIiAEGEB Ac CO. Elng and Bethel Streets. Honolnln, H. I., ' Importers and Commission Merchants, 1S55 ' H. Ji. HOLSTEIN, o.t Law. CoLLEcnoss PnoxmT Attksdkd to. lS7i KOHALA,' HAWAII. ly aourv ii. patv, SOIABY PUBLIC and COMMISSIONER ef DEEDS For the Slates of California and New ork Ofnce at til a Bant of Bishop & Co., Honolnln. 1$ 1 J. M. WHITNEY, M. D., D. D. S Dental Booms on Fort Street, nice in Brewer's, Block, corner Hotel and Fort 1S56 y street Entrance. Hotel street. WILLIAM 0. SMITH, 64 Fort Street, Honolnln. E. G.HITCHCOCK, Attorney and Counsellor at Law. Omcc at HILO, HAWAII. : Bills PaorrrLT CoiirsTiD. "So ISTiUy WUIIAal C. ACHI, Attorney and Counsellor at law, and Eeal Estate Broker. ArrXXDS ALL THE CorETS OT THE KINGDOM. OFFICE: No. 3$ Merchant Street, UT2 Honolnln. H. I. ly NEIJJCE M. LOWREY, aSTotaocsr - I'u.'tollo. OFFICE with W. H. Cattle, opposite ,,1383 ly II. :. At uo. Grocery. Feed Store and Bakery. Corner Kins and Fort Streets, 1S56 Honolnln. H. I. r THE -WESTERN AND HAWAIIAN Investment Comnanv Money loaned for long o. uon periods, ON APPROVED SECURITY- Apply to W. L. GBEEN, Manager. 133 Block, Fort St, y ? fMxfJ&Uii Susincss Ulctrus. MISCELLANEOUS. BISHOP & COMPANY. Ei&rr r Biiiagimi xn loss, BANKEBS. ltO.VOl.ri.r. KAIVAXIAA ll.AXDs DHAW EXCHANGE ON THE 8W OF "CsUFGnMA. SAN r?.fi."ClC0 ib iHtm Aae?.T ij. Sk Vork. Botuu. i'nrf KE3SRS. K H. HOTHSCHILD 3 SONS. LOIIUM, Commercial Banking Co. of Sydney, London. The Commercial Banking Co. of Sydney, Sydney. The Bant of Ne Zealand, Auckland, and its Branches In Christcharch, Danedlnand The Bank of British Columbia. Portland, Oregon. The Azores and Madeira Islands. Stockholm, Sweden. Tie Chartered Bank of London, Anstralia and China, npnekonc. Yokobam, Japan. Andtransacla 135G General Banking UcMoeet y H. O. I3A1L.S, V J?. LIMITED. Importers and Dealersin Hardware, P!ov. Pain's Oils and Genera! - OFFICERS :- JmW Hall President and Manager E O White... Secretary and Treasurer VTm r Allen Auditor Thoa May and F Wnndenbarg.... Directors 1316 Corner Fort and Klne Sic r , w k : tv c tt r ll!ncccsor! to Lutsbs .t Dickson I Importor nd Dealers m Ltzaber, Ardallkirdr of Hcildin;: Matsrlals 13C6 0,'irrtreet.,'nno)iiln EMPIRE HOUSE, J OLD1". :.::::: Proprietor Corner Nnuauu Avenue and Hotel Streets Choice Ales, Wines and Iiiqnors 185b E. S. CUNHA' R.otnll "'CC'iis.o Xloalor. UNION SAXOON. Inriarof the "Hawaiian Gazette" building 1-555 Vo !TJ Merchant Street. HONOI.TJi.TI IRON "WORKS CO Js'p$tkL Sleam Enj;ines,Saf;ar Mills. Boilers,, .hi4i&L Coolers. Iron, BrassandLcad Casting Machinery of Every Description 3- Mado to Order. "E Particnlar attention paid to Ships1 Blackt smithing. JOB '.VORKex?cotdoa 1356 notice. y J. K. KAHOOKAJfO. Attorney and- Counsellor at Law. ATTENDS Atl. TnE COCKTS OP TIT3 KlSODOM. 1377 15 Kcahnmann Street. Honolulu. Iy J. S. SMITHIES, AND AGENT TO GRANT JfARRIAGE LICENSES. Mnhnkona. itobala. Hawaii. ISPOJIXEE AUD DS4LEH IN GENERAL JIEECHANDISE. l!5j Oneen .'Street. Honolnln y HAWAGBAIM WINE CO. TRANE BROWN. Manager. 2S and 30 Merchant Street, - Honolulu, II. I. C. E. W1XI.IAMS, Importer, Manufacturer, Upholsterer, AST) DEALIB IX - FURNITURE OF EVERT DESCRIPTION, Pianos and Musical Instruments. 13P 105 FORT STREET ly G. W. MACFARLANE & CO., Importers and Commission Merchants, Honolnln, Hawaiian Islands, AGENTS JOB Mlrrlces, Watson & Co.. Scotland Street Iron Works. Giazow. John Fowler & Co., (Leeds) Limited Steam Plow 1356 ana Locomotit e Works. Leeds. iy II. SIACKFELI) &. CO., General Commission Agents, 1S55 Qnecn Strcct'HonoIuln.H.I. I'. A. pJCBEAEl'Kai A; CO. Importers & Commission Wire's. IS5S Honolnln, Hawaiian Islands. y M. S. GRINBATIM & CO.. uiror.TEr.s' op Gon'l Mcrchandlso and Commission 1356 Merchants. Honolulu. H. I. y M. S. GRINBAUM & CO., Commission Merchants, No. 215 Front Street. San Francisco, Cal. Post Office Bos 2G03. 1356 y WILDER A: CO., Corner of Fort andQneenSteets, Honolnin, Lnxnber, Faints, Oils, Hails, Salt ft Building 1356 Materials of eTery kind- y UT31AI BROS.. Importers of General Merchandise, TBOX FRANCE, ENGLAND. GERMANY AND THE UNITED STATES. 1373 y No. 58 Queen Street, Honolulu. H.I, HYMAN BROTHERS. Commission Merchants, 206 Front Street, San Francisco. Particnlar attenUou paid to filling and shipping 1I7S Island orders. y TIIEO. II DATIES & Co., Importers and Commission Merchants, to AJTO A(iX!fT3 ro Lloyd's and the LlTerpoolUnderwziters, British and Foreign Marine I&snxascc Co., IISJ And Northern Assirrao co Ccoprnr. y JJustncss Cariis. MISCELLANEOUS HAWAIIAN Abstract and. Title Co. NO. 42 niERCBLA.JJ'.T ST. HONOLULU, H. I. JT. JI. Hatch - President Cecil Brown - Vice-President W.E. Castle - - - Secretary HenryE.Cooper, Treasurer & Manager W. K. Frear - Auditor This Company is prepared to search records and furnish abstracts of title to all real property in the Kingdom. Parties placing loans on, or contemplat ing the purchase of real estate will find it to their advantage to roniult the company ,in regard to title. gSTil orders attended to with prompt- ness. Mutual Telephone IJ Bell Telephone 152. P.O. Box 325. - DRS. ANDERSON k LDHDY, XE3SJ"TISTS. Hotel St., opj..JDr.J. S.HcGrew' B?-GAS ADMINISTERED. J.W. Wiktsb. So.. D1)S. "W. G. "Winter, MD., DDS. KEMOVAL. WINTER & WESTER gjgyGreat .Reduction in Prices. EASTERN PRICES! fXi"Wc produce a Fine White Mettle Amalgam and FLigji compound for Uio low prieo of $1; Gold Fillnigs, ordinary Cnvaties for ?3. Hechanic. Dentistrj at hastern Prices, foil sot or partial ret of teeth on Gold, Alumni cr Rubber R.ise, no finer Dental Work can be produced in Honolulu. Teeth extracted for 50j. JJSThi" office is a branch office of ifiti Ke.trnv ut , nu Francisco. j?0ffi(e: K3 Ueretania street. L. A. THURSIOlf. w. r. rnEAE. THURSTON & FREAR, Attorneys - at - Law, HONOLULU, n. I. over Bishop's Bank. April 2, 1891. J. S. EMERSON, Engineer and Surveyor Room 3 Spreckels' Block, Honolulu. 3212 PIONEER STEAM Candy Manufactory and Bakery, 35 . OH! O DR. 20" , Practical Confectiimcr, Pastry Cook and Baker 1356 71 Hotel St het.lfnnann and Eort y MISS D. LAMB, Xotary Public. Office of ;j( A. Macoon, Merchant street, near the Postoffice. St. fifiaithew's Ha!!.- SAN MATEO, CALIFORNIA. A School for boys. Send for Catalogic. h. Alfred Lee Srewer D.8.f Rsctor. 1SS5 ly C. HUSTACE. (Formerly with B. F. Bolles & Co.') Wholesale and Retail Crocer, 111 King Street, under Harmony Hall. Family, Plantation, and Ships' Stores nlled at short notice. New Goods oy every steamer. Order rrom the other islan ds faith- folly executed. 1356 TELEPHONE Xo. 1IO MR. W. F. ALLEN, AS AN OFFICE OVETJ MESSES. BISHOP & w CO, .corner of Merchant and .Euhnmizra streets, and be will be pleased fo attend to any .minus entrusted to b!m. 125Mm Administrator's Notice. A I,Ii CLAIMS AGAINST THK I XX. Estate of the late KEKAHA (K) deceased, of Waiehu, Wailuku, JIaui. H. I., must properly sworn to before a Notary Public, to the nnaersiened who has been duly appoint ed administrator of said estate within six months or they will be forever barred; all debts owinz said estate must be paid on or before uld expiration of six months. W.H. DANIELS, Administrator of the Estate of Kekaha, deceased. Wailuku, Hani. October 25, ISM. 1151-Sm. 'EiOiNA COFEEE. ' ?. A Meeting Held to Discuss the Advisability of Supplying vKona Coffee at the ? World's Fair. Saturday afternoon a meeting was held) at the Hawaiian Hotel to discuss ihe question of a Kona coffee cafe at Chicago during the Fair. There were present Thomas Rain Walker, Lewis J. Levey, A. M. Mellis, E. Ellsworth Carey, W. W. Hall, A. T. Herbert, X. S. Sachs, Prof. "W. D. Alexander, SI. Rose, and Curtis J. Lyons. Upon request, T. R. Walker assumed the chairmanship of the meeting, ! and Mr. Carey acted as secretaryr Mr. Walker stated that a preliminary meeting was held lasj. March to consider the advisability of establishing a cafe at Chicrjgo for tho sale of Kona coffee, and that Mr. Mellis had, in the' meantime, secured some information on the subject which would be presented to those present. Mr. Mellis read a letter from Hon. In A. Thurston, who could not be present, stating that he was in sympathy with the undertaking, and hoped it would succeed. Mr. Mellis then gave an outline of what he had (done, and read some letters from officials connected with the Exposition. He was offered a space in the grounds for a coffee booth upon certain conditions. Mr. Mellis then made a statement ah to the amount which would be required to carry out tho undertaking. He also argued that the establishment of this cafe would do more to advertise the country than a system of newspaper advertising, and it would also attract the atten tion of capitalists to the possibilities in coffee culture. He thought $10,000 would be required to erect a pavilion and place it in readiness for business. An informal discussion followed, and it ivas thought that an estimate of the probable receipts and expenditures of the proposed cafe should be prepared, and the secretary and Mr. Walker were requested to make such an estimate. The Fair grounds are seven miles from the city, and those, visiting the grounds will be obliged to obtain refreshments within the Fair ; and as the number of daily visitors may equal 100,000, it will be seen that a multitude must bo furnished with refreshments. On this account it is quite possible that a coffee cafe will prove a paying investment. Installation. Polynesian Encampment No. 1, I. 0. 0. P., held a meeting last Friday for the purpose of installing officers. C. J. Fishel, P.C.P. D.D.G.S., was assisted in the installation P.C.P. J. J. Lecker as G.J.W. ; P.C.P. M. D. Monsarrat as li.U.l'.; r.u.r. . J. Willielm as G.S.W. ; P.C.P. H. H. Williams as G.S., and P.C.P. Geo. Johnson as G.T. OFFICERS. W. D. Alexander, Jr., C. P. W. Boss, S. "W. P. C. P. L. L. La Pierre, S. P. C.P. E. Hingley, G. J. PrUctaanL J. W.. P. C. P. C. J. Fishel, 1st W. P. C. P. M. D. Monsarrat, 2d W. P. C. P. H. H. Williams, 3d W. P. O. P. J. J. Lecker, 4tU W. P. C. P. G. J. Willielm, G. P. C. P. George Johnson, I. G. Off for the Coast. The following passengers took their departure for the Coast, per S. S. Australia, on Wednesday: John Wood, Dr. Freeman, Mrs. Long, Hon. J. N. S. Williams, G. L. Jackman, C. H. Richardson, W. S. Maltby, C. C. Conwell and wife, Miss E. Lee, Mrs. E. F. Bishop, A. J. Magoon, wife and child, Miss Minther, S.. T. Alexander, J! N. White, Mrs. R. R. Hoes and child, J. M. Hind, F. C. Heath, A. R. Mackintosh, S. H. Blouger and wjfe, J. E. Miller, Colonel Z. S. Spalding, Louis D. Sloss, Jr., Dr. O. F. Lee, S. Ehlrich, R. R. Hind and wife, Mrs. James B. Castle and son, Dr. S. L. Lee, Rudolph Neumann. The Latest Slang. " Please take off your Eiffel Tower " is the latest slang phrase. It is addressed to ypung women who wear sky-scrapers at the theatre. TI LEGISLAM One Hundred and Sixty-First Day. Tuesday, Jan. 3. The House met at 0 a. ar. Boll call, twenty-three members present. Quorum at 9:15 a. Jr. The minutes were read aud approved. PETITIONS. Bep. Xahinu presented a petition irom Waialua, Molokai, praying for tne erection oi an English school-the house. Referred to Educational Committee. Bep. Iosepa presented a position from George Kekipi, superintendent of Sunday schools on Molokai, praying that he be permitted to enter the Leper Settlement on certain occasions. Referred to the Sanitary Committee. Clerk McCarthy read the following communication from the members of the Board of Education: Bureau Public Instbuction, ) IJoxoLOLU, Dec. 31, 1892. j Hon. J. S. "Walker, President of the Legislature. The undersigned members of the Board of Education beg respectfully to present to the notice of the honorable members of the Legislature, in Tiew of an Act limiting the appointing power of the Board to teachers, the following (acts : In presenting this petition the Board does not wish it to appear that it desires to dictate in any way, but solely to present the facts for the consideration of the honorable members of the Assembly. The principle has been well established for years in all the appointments that our'Hawaiians and those of Hawaiian descent, when fitted to occupy positions, should receivo the preference. This, in the interest of economy is quite an important point, for it i9 not easy in many of our districts to provide boarding accommodations for foreign teachers, and with the limited means at the disposal of thi Board, buildings required for Eome of the teachers will have to be postponed. From many Hawaiian parents and guardians communications hare been addressed to your petitioners praying that foreign teachers nuj; be sent, who can instruct their children in the English languago correctly, for though they do not complain of their present teachers as to deportment, they still desire that the vodiil' children shall learn the first prin ciples from a person versed in tbe language to be taught Your petitioners would also present the fact that the supply of Hawaiian teachers, skilled in the art of teaching, has as J et never been equal to the demand, and we do not know of a single ca?e where a properly qualified Hawaiian has been refused a position when there has been one available. At the present time the Board has 250 teachers on it roll, of which 120 are Hawaiians or of Hawaiian descent and 23 of Hawaiian birth. This law, it enacted, will apply to all but schools in the Kingdom, and out of 7,143 scholars in the Government schools, only 012 nrtf not in the primary grades. It will thus, we trust, appear to your honorable ''ody that the Board has always endeavored to carry out tho general policy indicated in the proposed Ac'. In view oi these facts we respectfully submit that the proposed action on the part of your honorable body would bo an unnecessary and injurious interference with the appointing power of the branch of this Government. (Signed) Walter Hill, Wm. W. Hall, W. D. ALEXANDER, . M. D.UIOX Tabled with tho hill. SELECT COMMITTEES'. Noble J. M. Horner reported on Bills 131 and 118, both bills having for their object the licensing of carriages for carrying of passengers in the district of Wailuku, Maul. The committee consider the object of the hill a good one, and they substituted a hill to Issue licenses for HIlo, and with that amendment recommended the passage of both hills. Tabled for future consideration. v RESOLUTIONS. Bep. Smith read for the first time a bill relating to administrators .and guardians (introduced by Neumann). The bill took the usual course. At 9:32 a.m. the House proceeded to the OP.DEP. OF THE DAY. Third reading of Bill 1C7, trie Registration Act. Deferred for the moment, as interested parties were not present. Tfiird reading oi niii l', relating to the appointment of school teachers in primary schools in this Kingdom. Bep. Smith moved for the indefinite postponement of the bill. He considered it, from a Hawaiian's standpoint, a great mistake to employ only Hawaiians in primary schools. Educated Hawaiians are not satisfied to become school teachers, they want to follow other professions. Some of the native teachers are not capable, and native parents are not satisfied with their results. Bep. Kaunamano8aid it was folly to say that Hawaiians were not competent to become school teachers. Some of the native Hawaiians have attended school for over ten years, yet they are said to be still in ABC. There must be something wrong in tbe educational system in this country. Natives have been taught English for the past forty years, yet they are not competent Bep. Tosepa favored the bill, as it provided for the appointment of school teachers in primary schools only. The speaker complained of discriminations. Noble Baldwin said that out of 7100 pupils, 6500 were in the primary schools. Bep. Ashford opposed the bill. He believed it would not be put Into effect. It endeavored to draw a line as to the manner of employing teachers in a way the Constitution did not warrant. If this bill Is carried out, it would ruin the system already in vogue. It Is something preposterous. For Ave years past, the had always given to Hawaiians the preference to appointment1 as school teachers. English Is the language of the future, but it will not drown out the Hawaiian language. Many of those who consider themselves fit to teach, understand only a half-white lingo. If tho Board 13 at fault, the Cabinet could appoint a native Hawaiian on the Board. He supported tQe motion to indefinitely postpone. Bep. Kamauoha considered the bill a good one. Ben. Blnlkano said that accordimr to the present system, Hawaiians would never be proficient in English. The policy of foreign teachers Is not to give too much. English to natives, because they would become too smart. Noble Cormvell did not think the bill a good one. He added the following amendment to Section I: "If found competent in the opinion of the Board of Educatiou." Noble Baldwin said that Noble Cornwell's amendment takes tho gist away from the bill. The bill la a dangerous one. There are 250 teachers employed in this country, nearly all of whom are in primary schools. The Board had found it difficult to find good teachers, either from here or from abroad. While ho appreciated the remarks of the member from Hana, still tbe bill was a dangerous one. Bep. Nawahi enumerated the scandalous habits of several persons In the employ of the Board of Education. Noble Thurston said that Rep. had kicked all the haoles. There was a great deal of truth in what the member from Hilo said. He sympathised with the opposition to continuously importing teacher?. There had been a great deal of rubbish In the way of imported school-teachers. But this law would not meet the He favored establishing first of all a normal school in this kingdom. He offered tho : "Be it resolved that a commission of five persons ho appointed to examine Into the present system of supplying teacher? to the common school of the country, and to report to tho next Legislature whether or not some method may not be devised whereby a supply of permanent teachers can better be obtained, and more particu larly to examine into and report the advisability of establishing a local normal school for tho instruction and training of teachers for the primary schools; and, if the same shall bo fdund advisable, to formulato legislation necessary to carry the same Into effect, together with an estimate of the additional expense of such proposition, and that bill 222 be laid on the table." Bep. Smith seconded the resolution. With all respect to the Board, there are some things which aro not altogether Satisfactory. Bep. Kamauoha appreciated the remarks of Noble Thurston, who had proved his aloha for Hawaiians. But $5000 had already been passed in 1890 for normal instruction for teachers. Bep. -B. W. Wilcox favored the resolution, and moved the previous question. Carried. The ayes and noes were called on motion to indefinitely postpone the bill, which was lost on the following division : Ayes -Ministers Wiitox, and Jones, Nobles Ena, Cutnuiiue, Williams, Kau-Lane, J. M. Horner, Hind, Mareden, Young, Baldwin, Walbndgs, Anderson, Thurston, Kanoa and Ureler; Kept. , Smith and A . S Wilcox 10. Xoes Minister Brown ; Noblas Bcrger, Pua, Peterson, Maile, Hoapili and ; Hep. Biptkanc, Aki, Pua, Kauhi, R W. WiIcox.Nawahi.Kaunamano, Kamauoha, Waipuilani, Nahlnu, Kaneulii, Edmonds, Kaluna, Iosepa and Akina .Absent Minister Robinson . Nobles Hopkins, W-. Y. Horner and icBrjde; Kep3. Wilder, Bush, lioahou, A. Horner, Kapahn and White. obIc Thurston's resolution was carried on a standing vote of 20 td 21, the President giving the costing vote. The President announced the commission . Nobles Thurston, Baldwin and Kauhane, and Reps. Kamauoha and Smith. The Clerk read Bep. Ashfonl's amendment to the Registration Act. Rep. Smith criticized Hep. Asu-ford's remarks the other day, and considered them scandalous. Noble Thurston considered Bep. Ashford's amendment as an iniquitous one. Why does the member from the Third Ward want to- protect Chinese in this town whom tbeHouse wishes to tie up. That is a mea Iapu-wale. Bep. Ashford's amendment "Would take the meat out of the whole hill, and if it passed, he would move to indefinitely postpone th6blll. It was traitorous for u man to say that ln favored the bill, when at the same time he wanted to stab his constitu ents in the dark. Tbe member from the Third Ward ran on tbe platform in theinterest of mechanics. He said that he loved them and would hug them. We passed a bill the other day allowing 5000 more Chinamen to come into the country. It was too much to expect that the member from the Third Ward would withdraw his amendment, but he would like to see a unanimous vote against It. Bep. Ashford said Noble Thurston's intimation that he was working In the interest of Chinese was entirely false. He was there In the interest of native Hawaiians and Anglo-Saxons. Noble Young claimed that hla constituents did not favor the bilL At 12 ji. the House took a recess until 1:30 p. M. ATTEBNOOX SE33I0N The House re-assembled at 1:35 P.M., X I