Newspaper Page Text
Two Irish Leaders.
? HEALY AND MR. REDMOND?THEIR POSITION IN THE HOUSE
OF COMMONS?THEIR RELATIONS TO EACH OTHER?PERSONAL
NOTES ON MR. HEALY.
uo-,\?ii*?it. i>'4. b? Oeetga x\- Swelter.)
London. April ',).
??the H??usa of Commona has a f?.
_.? among iis .nsh Nationalist
taXibtT*. I' is- ' ?UPpO?e, Mr. Healy.
._fl rou print the name?
, .^bcs-t Snosm public men tutii the
iaful partlcularitjf of a eriminal in
... you w.'iild call hin Mr. Tlni
M y In the Hou?e t
le a-id aven eutalde of it. he is :
^m?^.'-)' ?mown SB Tim Healy; or
?.- as Tim. Wl be taken ns
n ?Sectionata nbt'revlaii'.n.
_ . sad Incorruptible
HP | ?"il If SOB this might make him
ir. ?t-deet of anspi'ion. They se. m to
? thai t?-? be a true friend ..f
jriliad yeu must be an enemy of Hug
?and. <?ri<1 tlK|at no ti"rm*' <Hn ha bepl
?ith the base and bruts] Saxon, nor
v..-? t" be- allOWOd te ketop
k ?tme ss th -he true Irishman. I has
.,-,, therefore, to say that it is not Mr
He?'.*''-'* iaul' il* np is 'Ik*3?* b> the Kng
He hSS never spared them. He is
rerhar* the moat implacable and ir
H.'ine Ruler in th?' frhol I
lag* . Nationalists, And be
Invective among them all;
-..?>? ci deal. As tO
rrlty of his ?leslre t?i see lre
?jiid a t.tr nation it may be
say that he regareis Mr.
to he found in the breasts ,?f
nd If dozen O'Brien?
; chiefly in Mr. Healy him
???d why the House likes
DOt til? rn-un rea
t fed i ire that any Home
be la a H ?'in.
:. s\r.j? the affection of the
- the great
? ? t" obstruct
bring the House into
? secret of it.
I in il Mr. PS-US- base?!
his whole s ; ?lies- on it; rind
I the art of obstrue*?oa to a
? obtained. Even
r Mr. Red?
mond, are tl ? the Liberal
pary as allies
rather than They have
for a Heal object
rrsonsl i ? tsse?-n the
rather remote, And there is
? ?? body of Liberals "?'bo aceepl
Slitloo, not f'ir love ?'f coalitions
? Irish, but aa u !.ar?i necessity.
? real ii- -,r itlce to
lut th. y .].? not like- b< ilng
admit, that their tenure of
? ? lit? -live- e?r
votea which, ?luring tho
tut ai3 I - ?-ti loyally pisen
to the ? iosernm? nt, anil eft? u tor aMas
. whl i the Irish disaj.proved.
d end bis CoHowsra bate?!
f i ;?"?.?. but vi.teil for it.
? Ilka the ?di; for th. Dis?
ndov/ment ol the
Church, but they steadfastly
t ?1 Th- v do 1."' like the- H'Uiie
? they accept II
?h and, though
. on many pointa have been
'liny know th?.
bill |g ? form is not I "pular
in iit-iaiiJ, but they try to psrsuada
that it is- And
8" ill- Coalition h m.lins unbroken snd
^ii. i; alna master. Rut all
not tend to make him an
? ?rant t.. i??- an idol.
to ? obeyed?and
. i. ihm Mr. Red?
il bul i' ape? ted.
?!?? has the confl
Nstlona_si ports In Irs
? :i to siuiK- e xtctit of Mr.
H? maintains discipline In the
practised speaker, a
:,? debater, and In present dr
oun? '-?1 s?? much
Parnell'a policy sa < oaslsted In
more elf? tlv? way. Instead
ha redil? e-.s it to
The note of deflai
He Issusa bit orders
|y hsmlel <'ti the West
: Ireland, "Full Btenas Ahead."
- his followers at Waterford:
trust Asqulth. Trust me.'' He
Mtjuiret. th? Prims Mlnlstsr te? "tot-the
, ala of conciliation
M Stade to lister It is Mr. Redmond
limit And the Chief Sec
Wiry for Ireland?the actual ruler of
Ireland i ? far hs the Government is
d announces to the Unionists
>-K tha] must "take it e?r leave il."
?r, Parnell la his best days never
pow? r ??s tins, not power
? kind He WS8 a
Sack greater man than Mr. Redmond.
He ?? one of tin great.ai
i er known; the great
. of Ireland; one of
l!ie grtiat? -t m the history of the
U.;tni Kingdom He ?ailed 8 Mtl ?71
'? anil?, it ,s Mr. Redmond's **pe
?i?its- to organise a people Into a Par?
ry fon e and. With tlM help of
"**r- Devlin to govern Ireland. ?>r BO
i is m?t Ulster, of
*>s*sans by which it has been and is
nothing. Mr. Gladstone
*f ?' | ti rough rapine to
P-aMhement" Rut that ?ras before
J** t-fcaim- satisfied that his surrender
^J Mr. Para? l ss.ia the price of his
2** Minlsterahlp. When that light
d ?SWned upon him he was able to
Ottlng and other out
f'Kn ware m? relj "forms of social and
A?d''?8t Mr. Redmond's authority Mi.
J*1* la m i. .::;,?,. The House as ? ?
?Pw,?1*<k*!' ""' ' "" tu *?**"**?-?* nim ,he
_!',!w that- 'n,,y ?|ud>?,, him ,,y his
1 ?"' ibordinstlon to?
J*^?rwhoa. supremacy he has .user
?T,nii!*,!- He is a free lance. In
*?>? he i? a ser? much cleverer
" til1"1 'i- Redmond Mr. Qlad
???0Bc' ??Id then were but three
ln -*? H? sa ssho really under? '
??t ?'<I his Irish Land BUI: Mr. t;ind
stone himself, the Attorney General f >i
Irelond and Mr. Healy. He is a law?
yer who lias a le?ral mind; a dCStTip
) tton which bj no means includ- ? ||
in? in1?th of the Rar; nOT e\en all suc
??ssfiil lawyers. He bSSjaa as in Irish
1 barrister. The [rieh Rar offers n?> gr?a'.
s?-opt? for < \. eptf-onal abilities; and no
first rate prises except official appoint?
ments. He is a fortunate man who
?can make *? 1? ?.? ?? h ? ? ?ear b* p**actl8lag
,!i Hi? insh Courts; even the highest of
Mr. Ilia.) maim d In ?SS'J a daugh?
tor ?>f Mr. ". D. 4-ullivan, by wiiom he
has three sons mid three daughter1?.
N? \ erihelcss, be remnined an Irish bar?
ris!? r for tw?niy years.' during five of
which he was a Queen'.? Counsel; which
docs not mean that he was employed as
??ounsci to the Queen, H<- w?bs no:
callad t?> the Bnguah Rar mi I90h\
Th? n began for him a i sa son of pros?
perity. He has been briefed in many
important ?anses. He is a familiar and
a formidable figure in the English
Courts. Meantime, he has been a Mem
li? r of Parliament: sitting SUCOSSShfly
for six different constituencies, from
1880 down to this moment, When he
ri'presents the northeastern d. : : n of
"Rebel Cork." During at le. si "*** !
election, when and because he tina ?m
independent cundidate, he has ,;one in
peril of his life.
The House gathers hin to i s'hosom
not because he is hii Ideal Member of
Parliament, for he is not but for what
he is. There is nohodv else who has
the same genial good nature expressed
with the same sharpness ?jf tongue, or
the same biting wit It may serve as n
proof of his expertnesa in Parliamen?
tary procedure hat be knows how to
| lash his ?"ii' nies to fury without being
pulled up by the Speaker. Mr. Lowther
rules the Hon.-" very strictly; with ln
tlexlble ? rmnc-SS and impartiality. He
has i? I 'I the Prime Minister for
usine the word "insolent." He has
, call? d in? l.cuder of the Opposition tu
?arder He lately compelled Mr. Win?
ston Churchill to withdraw the phrase
"hellish Insinuation" which he had ap?
plied t?i Mr. Amery. Mr. Lloyd Georg.
himself Is sometimes invited to keep
within the bounds of decent speech,
dnly the other day Sir Kdward ?'arson
had to abandon bis description of Mr.
Dsvlln'a statement that he, Kir Ed?
ward, had been a Home Ruler, as an
"infamous lie": though be was allowed
to substitute for it the not less con?
temptuous "wilful falsehood."
Rut during Mr. Henly's essay in
irt vituperation on the last day
Of th?' Home Rule debate, be docs not
? ? ??in to have come once Into collision
with the Chair. He told -Mr. Redmond
he Was gambling With Home Rule,
quoting Swift's account of a people
who forgot things and had flappers st
their Bars to rerhlnd them, he ?-.eoff.-i
' at Mr. I.?almond and h: T.'l followers
as flappers. ?When the Nationalists
I>r?.tested, he looked amiably round at
I hem, remarking: "There is some dis?
turbance in the menagerie." Ha d?
pitted the opposition as saying that
? p ion of Ulster meant a torrent
of bloodshed and as asking "Will you
sllow th.- free Traders i" free trade in
i.!?'"?]" ii.? said -and it will be re?
member? ?i i" bis honor:
"We are the only persons (he and the
O'Brienltes) entitled t?> be beard with
candor on this ??ubjoi-t lieeausc from
the day the hill iras introduced we ad?
??I conciliation and consideration
/or th.- Protestants of Ireland."
"Did Mr. Redmond melons any ona
of thes? proposals?1 Not until to-night
did I ever hear him Indorse any pro?
posa] in favor of the minority, and that
was only "hen be believed the proposal
"Contrast the sonorous and s.ap
? :,,i?"us phrases of Mr. Redmond in
dealing with sir Edward Carson to?
night, with his former talk of 'Orange
dogs' .'?nd carrion crows."
Then he quotes at length Mr. T. P.
O'Connor's "limelight" skstch -<f Car?
son in u weekly paper-?which h?- pr??
f?ra to call "quicklime.'1 "T. P." wields
the blackthorn with vigor, and sums
up with vanity as the chief iiigi?-dii-nt
in Sir Edward's character: of which a
bad digestion. ner\?s, and a melan
' holy temperament are other features.
"Fancy all thi?-." remarks Mr. Healy,
"at a penny a Una." Mr. Devlin in?
terjected an nnroported mort. An?
swered Mr. Healy:
"From Mr. Devlin at ltasl I exp.
fin?mes?^ m regard t.i Ulster, if only on
historical qrounds, for in ancient times
and down to the flight of the Baria
the Devlins were the hereditary horss*
boys of the CNeils."
All this while the orator's face
beams upon you from out a halo of
gray hair and heard; eyes looking
softly through gold-rimni'd spectacles;
a manner of disinterested detachment;
no malice or ii**rt*hariBblenaas, but ob?
viously a love of i-hstorical art for art's
sake, and his mood thut of the parent
who ? has'.ises his boy for the good uf the
buy; or of the judge who sentences the
prison? r to bu hanged by bis in ? k till
he is dead In order that others may live
In pea?.?-. No wonder the House thinks
jt a r.-freshing t ntci taium? nt. No
wonder that, except among his ricUtna,
' Tim" IS a favorite. No wonder that
ecu among Mr. Redmond'? Obedient
SSI vants there arc those who think
Mr Healy docs in his own way a real
service to Ireland. (',. W. S.
House Afire Kindled Romance.
[from The Tribuae i - ?at.]
MaotOtolr, N. J.. May ?-Announcement
.u mama here to-day of th- ?redding of
Mrs Arthur G. Weber, of KI Claremont
ttv and Friedrich Rosenberg, of M
Claremont av. The ceremony IMPS'
formed in St. Stephen's rrotesta.it Eple?
co-,,1 ,'h.uvb. Philadelphia, bf >
l,lll , (-.rammer. When they return
f.o'in a wedding trip Mr. and Mis. R.-scn
Baa-g will ?ive In Mont.-lair.
v. ?.??.. the hsena of Uro. fn**wm*
Hiroved by ?re last January ?he found
MISS (?KITA HOSTETTER.
AT BABY CONTEST
Political Union and Woman's
Party Booths Will Exhibit
Their Prize Infants.
suffrage organlaationa "exhibit
: tbe Baby Show Exhibition ? !on>
pany'a contest which opened y?
at the Orand Central Palace, promUe to
lend int real t.? tiie siio-.v during tt.m
Ina >? ek. Mixed In among the booths of
commet na, advertising dl aorta
or warea from condensed milk t? baby
carriages tha saffraglsta bave I ? r
At the booth of the Women's Pollticd
Union it y?as snnounced that a prize of $5
would be- ghen for the "best baby" res?
ist? red by tii? union, the baby to have .,
mother who wanted the sen.?. The
father's attitude on tha aubj. t waa n.it
to be a fSetOr, it was ?aid A- the booth
of the Woman Suffi a.-.? | era WBJ
a diSpOdtiOO to BCOflt al tb? ,'ii/.e ..f
fsred by its rival. As a counter attraction
those In charge of the beiotii dsdSTSd
that later in the ssce-k they ?scull exhibit
some real aa*?ragetto baMaa
I;.?Lies are- only Incidentdly ?ni exhl"i
ti"n at the- ihOW, 'I In;, ma? be .sen '?ii
dergoing an entrance examin?t ios bj tha
doctors of the "better ha hi as" contest."
conducted by a womsn'a magasin? Tha
management ?if tiie exposition is offering
$100 in gold and otlcr priXSS t" thS bablci
??ii.., according t" the. physkrisna, m.?st
nearly attain to th? ? ' I "f the "par?
ti . t la', y."
GENERAL SICKLES BURIED
Salvos of Artillery Fired as
Body Goes to Grave.
Washington, Maj I All the honora of
war were peld tr, the late Major General
Daniel \. Bitiklea, who wsa buried In
Arlington National Cemetery here to-do
To?- body "i th? referan wsa carried
from ?he- Union Btation, *??here it
tirougti the night, to the <
accompanied by an acsoit of eavdry and
artillery, following the caisson
ssiiicii bsra tbe i??.d>- was the general's
.? id?.-1? h horse
As tha procession i...- i . through the
grounds of Port Mse-i- a major general's
artillery adute \?as Bred, sad :.t the
grSVB thre-u saisi.s of i ?fie- shots and un?
ite m,uked the placing
of the body in IU last resting place. Tiie
Rev. Father J. i?. Houlihan, chsplaln at
Fort Myer, und the funeral ser rica
in addition to the- regular army escosl a
Bomber e.f <i\!l War veterana
i .i -,ri t be procession.
POYAL VISIT TO LONDON
King and Queen Oi Denmark to
Remain Four Days.
on May I King Christian X and
Queen Alexsi of 1 ?enmara arrived
here to-day on their first sisii since their
on to tin- throne. The] are t" t>,
t ?? guesta et Kinu- Qeorge snd Queen
Mar? for lour days snd sftsi tha stats
. ondud? d s? ui apend a few da) s
as the guests ol QUO? n .Mi.thei AI ? V -
andra. A seri'-s of state- entertainments,
Including a banqod and a gala opera per
.'? r matice, has | ? ? n UTSB| u in their
Prlnea of Wales wenl tn Port \ic
torla to sseli .?ne their majesti.-s ss'-en
inded and tt,-- Vessels of the fleet
.:? , I-.. 1.Ie.1 tl.' le p.lid lie 111 tiie USUill hOU
? ci tin i'- arrival In London they ?sere
m?", h? King <;.i?rg?- and Qusen Msry,
who a?sait?d tturn at the Victoria ter?
IN THE BERKSHIRES.
T.-l-ciu, I' ' ' : ??';;.;..
!.. | ..\. M.?ss . Ma? I'. Mrs. William
I! Bradford snd Mr. and .Mis. Lindsay
i'airfax w.ll n??t 8B*SS W?. side this aum
mer. They ?ill remain m Fian...
tiny hase taken a villa ??inside ,f PuriS
?'hail?s AStOT BrlStSd his gOSI 10 N'-?v
v,,[-k is j : Mra Brist? ? i ti..' Mtasaa
Bristed, who are return.ng from i
Herbert PSTSO?I CSBSS up to Stoneo?er
Para to-da] foi the week and?
Mi and Mrs I.. s?:s fl MSSIBB, Mrs
i;t.uge a Ci other. Misa I It Potter, mis?
i k Cooper, Mr, and* Mra Charles P.
? . e. William Prod? r and the Mi-jie-?
Murie- 4 SSd H. hu .1 K..II..*. of New
York, arrived to-day at the Htd Idea Inn.
ENGAGED TO WED
Daughter of Mrs. A. W. Burchard
Betrothed to Glenn Stewart,
Mrs An ion Wood Burchard, of this city
and Fu i-h\? rio.i. l.oiust Valley. Long I-l
snd, aanounessa tha engsgemsnl at her I
daughter by a former msrrlsge, Misa
Oreta Hoatetter, t?, Olsnn Btewart, son
of Mr. and Mrs. i ?asid Oleran Ste?v?rt, of
Miss Hoatetter wsa lotroduced to so
(iety ,-u a dinner dance ghen for her by
her mother at Sherry's on April 1". Mil,
Her debut In this city folios'.-el In r j ? s
entutiiiti at the i'oiirt Of fit lato-s's tiie
month before. Misa Hootettsr is a lover
of horses anil takes ,-reat Interest in all
open air sports, gbe is also deeply Inter?
ested in ? haiitalde ssork, ami during tiie
last winter sie- bot be-- u B student at the
Ne?s York School of Phllsnthropy.
Mr. Stewart was gISdUSted from Vale
in 1908, anil lat.-r from the School of Po?
litical Sciences, In Paris. He has ais.?
taken a post-graduate course at Harvard.
TO-DAY IS MOTHERS' DAY
President Proclaims National
Washington, Msj I President Wilson
to-day spprOVSd a rsedUtlOB setting apart
to-morrow aa Mothers' i?a?. snd issued
a proeles it."' .i mending that all flags
be displayed in observance e?t the oeca?
Assistant Bccretarj '?' lha Tressury
Byron Newton aaat telegrama tu cuato
diafl <'f ail i' ihlk bdldlnga throughout
the country, ?lire? ting them to display tue
Bag on federal buildings, in accordanca
with the President's proclamation.
| It is mother's ?luy to-das. There -.sill
. ,: -.i s -i. aa Is men) churches and
who honor tha day ssiii wesi a
s? tuts ' si ii lion, the i ml Ism bom cted by
tl . offli lala "i ii.? Mother's i lay I
Mother's Ds I on the
second Sunday in Mas for many sears.
and it is In no **??'?' aaeodsted ??ith the
observance of suffrage ?las.
Mim Anna "arris, founder and pead
dent <>f the as odstion, baa Issued a
statement from bST SSVa la PhilsdelpblS
to the affect that Mother's Daj has no
suffrage or political algnlficance
To Sell Butterfield Home.
<oi?i Berlag, N I . May I i
of the will of F."h ri? k Jsme
land ?>f Mrs. Julia Futte-rlie-ld. whose
death tied ii|. a 16,0 0.000 estate, ,i mo in? ??'!
to-day that Uralgirdde, the beautiful coun
trj borne of Mrs. Butterfield, will be Bold
at auction m tha partitloa suit. June W.
The mansion and huge grounds belong
in th?- James estai?-, in aralch Mrs But?
; who was the wido?v of General
Butterfield, of Gettysburg tame, had only
a life Interest, sun "?.-aie j. Bennett
Bouthard to-day authorized th?- ask
' 11-. T. left. .,,?). ??? Tt I Tr.i.i.i'.- )
Newport. May 'J ?The recent summer
arrivals added nesv Ufe to the BatUTdS)
afternoon danaant at M?senle Hall yes?
terday. Tiie' alta if ??a?. ,'? usual, under
tbe direction et Mies Helen M W
..id ssas largely attend.!
!:? ,r Admiral and Mrs Richard W'ain
wright, "i Wash ngton, are to arrive for
tiie BBS Sim '-n Ji MM
Bertram WinthlOP. of New fork, Is at
the MaeSM hinger King.
Hans I'ayi.e Whitney's new sacht 'as
! aandra, aralch he purchssad nun Her
niuun ?Virii hs, started to c'len Cove this
Mr. and Mrs. J H. Proctor, of l'"s'. in.
are speiiillng the WBOk end heie.
Mis I'd ward J. Berssind Is inspecting
Reoent srrivsla ??t the Muenchimter
King Include Mrs Hudulph Schirm? i Mrs
0adSVS ?ebWaser and Misa Schirmer, ? f
New \'?rk. Mr. a;.?l Mrs Mahlon Hutch?
ii.s.'n. of Philadelphia; Mr-, William He.. -
era and Miss I'iyeis, of Ar.dover, Miss.
The He-v Bad M - T. I. Fine, of Oya
ter Pay, l?otig Island, announce the en
. ?t "f then ?laughter. Misa Mildred
Hok-ardus Pries, to Harold Lamed Hut-h
lna, of New Haven, t'oiin The *.? ?
will take place In July
MISS TIFFANY BETROTHED.
.-,.i lira .I"?.-: -i Bui r Tiffaaj. e.f
. . i - I? ... N
nounre tt. ? engssemenl of their ?laugh?
ter, Miss \ era Gere I
Frederick Prince, son of Mrs ?George B
Prin.-e. ?>f 149 North Broadway, *? <>n
:-. i-, n v.
HEARD FIRST TIME
Affords Novelty Last Day
of Cincinnati Alusic
ON THE PROGRAMMES
H. E. Krehbiel Describes Two
n- H K. KKI IIRII-.I..
"'in--innati, Mav 9. The twenty ?first
biennial festival of the Cincinnati Music
Festival Association came to an end this'
evening. Thcie was a concert in the
afternoon, at which the one novelty of
the meeting was brought forward. Thi?
was Gustav Mahler? Third S\mphony.
which had never befas beata heard in
puhli?? in the United States. It filled the
second half of a progi ?rame, the tlrst
part of which was devoted to two over?
tures Kreis? h'.itz" and ' Tannhauser"?
two airs, "My Heart Kver Faithful," by
Rach, and "Penelope W. SVfaag a Gar?
ment." by Barsch, ?sung by Mme. Schu
nunn-ll Ink. und a son-,, "Night Hymn
m gea," by Tbuenpsoa, .sung by the choir
of ?even hundred school child!? n.
The children aiso took part in the new
?-?mphon:, a? dlil Mme. Schumann-lleink.
The s? heme of the evealag eonaert waa
laid out sa similar lines, the orcno-tra
placing tlie prelude to Wagiici'.s "Meis?
tersinger" and Reet'novan s Third I.eonore
' <?\ ?i turc." Mme Alma (Jlui-k sang the
ail with a violin obtlgaB from MOSSI t?
"II Re Pastore" and the Inevitable "De?
puis le Jour," from ? Tiarpentler's "Lou?
Then to fli! the Bscond par) cam.
thoven'fl symphony, nith ch?ma, win.-h
< inclnnatlana have been taucht io ref*ard
with a peculiar reverence, sine? it was
Ihe culminating feature of the first festi?
val. hel?l in 1ST:;, and has been lepeated at
eight festivals mine, Including t?o- pr?s?
ent one? since.
? in this work the solo singers, who were
those who BSag Is the \ er?h Rfrtl'ltQm on
i rula? night, BgSln BOeOmpttsbed notable
things. .<o ?-???i the ereheetrs and chorus,
whose performanc? i rennet iltsenss in
detail for want o? tima it was obv?ente,
however, that though l>r. Kunwald
Shirked nothing in his efforts to present
the other choral works, his sympathies
went out in larger measure to the Bach
mass and the lieethoveu symphony than
to i'.--i liez s dramatic legend and Verdi's
i ? ,1111-m.
Tell* of Mahler'? Work.
F".- the professional visitor the interest
of curiosity St least centred in the sym
phoay by Mahler. Though the composer
s;ienl the las't three wais ?'I his life in
New \ork as conductor at the Ml
t.ni Opera House and of the i'hilhaniionle
Bodety, the circumstance laile.d to create
a cu^t for bis composition, such Bfl ? Blsb d
In Vienna when lie was director of the
Imperial court opes a there.
Three or four of lu.? symphonies hav?
h?.n performed la He* Tork under the
dire? lion of himself, Dr. Muck an?l \V.li?
ter Damrosch, but thsy left no do'-p im
on. i cannot see why they .sho'ihi
have done BO; neither can I s?e any like
IIIkiihI that the Third Will share a happier
it baa elements which might make por?
tions of it agreeable fa,'tors In the pro?
grammes ol popular <??::? ?'its, hut it can
not tiini recosulUon as a sympbonia wsrk
m communltiea familiar with the sym?
phonies Of the masters, Old and new.
Its a ?? ill uses La equsll] 8 ? Ion to the
B< elliovenlun. the I'.rahmslst and the
gtrauaatta. it is in no w m ? bj raphe-ny,
but six movements which bear no reds*
ttonehlp with one another, snd the Brst
of which si -- I.susa
ol their overelaboraUon "i .sii???iie ma
terial arni their want of mood contrast
Th.- first movement la a march besed on
a melody which begin? ilk?? the Herman
foUrsong, "i'h Habe Mkb Ergeben," and
whose Brei period hi i the rhythm of the
hr??a?i them?- of the finale of Brahms'I
gymphony In < ' minor.
Th?- aecond movement la i-.i minuet t- m
P<?, but not in minuet form, Of form In?
<ii ad there la n'< ti a< a ? In the
work The third movemenl la again a
march, this lima <>ne "f an encore i bar?
scter. At the outsel II auggests thought
Of a marche miniature or m .se lo .o oni
pa?.y th?- evolutlona ??f toy soldiers. Then
:: it i banges, snd B dainty effects
of accompaniment a far ssray tru
playa a sentimental ditty, which inesisti
blj caus up thojsrhl in the minds "f the
lOV is of Schefrel's "Trompeter Vor, Basfc?
ktagen" of tbe music which J ing \\ araet
s.-nt up to ins lad* lovo'a castle from hi?
boal mi th.? I;
The fourth movement la ?? aona lor con?
tralto seto, the words being taken from
"spra.h Zarathustra," t" which Strauss
gave Instrumental Interpretation in one
of the ear splitting episode? bo his alter?
nat.:, fsscinatlng and "?mettent tone
Tin- sol.? is follow, i h) B tin.--voiced
ehoi - for children's roteas; angehe
voues tic-y are ?uppeeed to be, ami they
alna s nuaint folksong teken from "D?s
Kr'.nhe:i Wonder Horn. ' baglnnlng "Es
Bangen I'm Eagel Einen Bussen Oetasag?*'
which Bus of the admonition given by
the i>?rd to ivt-r when be asi amongst
the spostkai sreeping over hla Intractlonfl
of tile Tea Command sat
"Love thou but ?!'"1 i" et,-mit;. . th? n
Wilt thou attain tin'.o heav-nly !..
heavenlv MISS la f"i PStST r? -r\.?l,
through Jesus for all and evermasra
When lore tl-,.-:.- is glsdnflBfl amolli; the
angela, an?i they sing "Ding, Dong" along
with a b. 11 i-hlme.
t ,, contralto r-oto p-*oclahns man's woe
.-??p. b il j"? dei per iban ame '?'? ? -
is iisnslloT]. b it al . ? - lang f<
There ,s BO ? onrtnr.nit? ol llrein be
i!. n...-.. nient? iat lea.-t iione that
i i on Id rnacovB m tw.? hearings), nor is
an) spir.tuai bond between itiem.
toa t I la to be to md in the
banality of aaost <>f tha ta*a*nsa Fat,
Maas : baa a?o tad t give them i ???
herein? and M | -?? ** by giving then
[.ii-rrammati. sup? rs, riptior:??. When he
brought his first symphoo) forwart at a
t of Um Philharmonic Society lie
wrote to me that ii? was not a program
mist and that the symphony had no par?
ti?al conceit as its basis, anil when I
called hi? attention to the fa? t that he
had named it Titan w ,-.-n he gi
:? ,, ,? to i ?? wore!, (re asid ti,-it n- na?l
,-itui. ' TI.-> ?-ut a pistol
i.ra i.?t. ' was '.he ?ay he pat it.
\\ ,.en 1 sent turn a nroeicne wntten
l.v a friend and enthusiasm- a?inur?-i of
hi?, giving an inte? pretatlmi in Which
he '?uoted fi om a la-tf-r ?ruten by him
to the friend, be ?* ?-????? lettaf. 1
wss more than willing to put all thoughta
of Jean Pauls Titan." or any one ?>f ?he
creature? of ?Ire? Ian mythology bearing,
the name, out of my mind. If for no .
oth.-r rsSSSS than that I could not as
?en.ate any heroic conception with the
old French nursery round "Frere ?
Jacquee," which provided the melodic ma?
terial for one of the movements
The third r-ymphony aleo ha? a pro?
gramme? whlMi I am quite as willing to
?Wage Tic Inspire-?! annota tors tell us
thru aa a whole It Is a "Nature sytr
phoay," riving voice to the proclam?t!.in
of things Inorganic, organic, spiritual
and divine. So the first movement Is In?
scribed '/What the rock? tell me"; the
second "What the flowers of the meadow
tell me", the third. "What the animals In
the woods tell me"; the fourth, "What
man tells me": the fifth. "What the
angels tell me," and the sixth, "What
love tell? me "
My earliest records of the symphony
say that the first movement was once
entitled. Introduction, "Pan awake": al?
legro. Summer comes marching In"?
which Is certainly a more fitting pro?
gramme than "What the rocks tell me,"
for rocks can scarcely be conceised as
either making proclamation or moslng In
march rhythm and tempo. After all, how?
ever, when one hears the music one
recognizes that all this is Inconsequential.
The musl.? publishes only Itself, and is
nine-tenths color and only one-tenth real
Mahler was an ingenuous melodist and
his tunes, as a rule, breathe a folksong
spirit. By reiteration and variety of or?
chestration i he was predominantly a col
orlst) he sought to gi?e them signlficanc?-;
but with all his striving they remain
safra and unoriginal. The final would he
worth all the rest were It not o?elabo?
rated and burdened with noisy crashes,
Which finally run out lnt?> something
suggestive of the poignant rnu'-dc which
at Intersal.s meets our ears when we see
Parsifal in his march toward the temple
of the grail.
it ??a? ?vith thlB reminiscence in his
mind m ?loubt thai Mahler gave i
[Movement a motto, of uin. ii tha pro?
gramme booh appears to hase been ig
noraat Ile once arr?ts over it: "Pother.
, bet' )ld My WOundS; grant that SO C
Though Dr. Kunwald made copious
elisions in the symphony, it la?-.
hour and twenty minute-. It WSS mii
dltcted with great earnestness.
With B great deal "f r'kill and heard with
marvellous patien a
WINS PRiZE AS ORATOR
Leo Rogally First in De La
Salle Institute Contest.
The De l_. Salle prize oratory contest
Friday evening was won by l.eo J. Ro
Sally. Becond sad third honors were
awarded to David J Martin and Paul \.
Shea Other speakers were Curt?a ?'?
Lyons, Bdward J. O'Connor, John j.
Malley, Vincent P. flenbean. Arthur C.
Mayer, John J. Keogh and L?-o J. Mc
Corken. Among the itudenta of the com?
mere-ial department Clinton a
won the shorthand prise and Frederick
.1. K'iser the typewriting rrize
Brother Cdlxtus, director of the
tute, was the presiding officer, and -?..s
assisted by Brothera Joseph, Bdward and
HARRY E. HUTCHINSON.
Hairs K H'-t. hinsmi, ssho ?sas for
twenty aavin reara preatdenl of th..
Brooklyn Bank, ?ii>'?i ?m Friday from apo*
plexj at his home III Part Place, Hi""k
i?n. after a short Illness Ha was born at
Windsor. \"t , in 1 S;:7. the son of the Rev.
Blljsh Kutchtnson, a Baptiat minister, ol
? ftn old Vermont family, lie was gradu?
ated from Ambers! Collage In 1881 sad
afterward \?.n* tu Montgomery. Ala.,
wiiere he taught achool snd studied for
the bar. From IMJ to 1181 ha was as?
istsnt Asaeaaor <?f int.-mal Revenu H
wsa organist of Bt Peter'a Protaatanl
. ; al Church, a ?in?-' t"i ?.f th -
Brooklyn Amateur Opera Company and
pr?sidant of th- Brooklyn Chord >'?
He raa a member of st. Luke's Prol
ant Kpis? ?itiai Church, the New England
-, ti;- .-?uns of \'? rmont, th
Club, tiie Church <'i'.;i'. the i*t""k
i' n Dlspenasry and the ad? laory board ot
th? I'- ooklyn infants' Hospital He leaves
,i WldOW and three ' hildr.n. Th? '
?ill he held at the home at ?! o'l I
ELIHU J. GRANGER.
Bllhu .1 Granger, president of the
Brodklj a Eh al B?tate Exchange, ?:
Frida) at his home, i::? McDoaougk st .
BrooUyn, after an acute attack of dis?
ii v. ? s > m o ,,t C?nandslgus, N.
v.. im 1832 After studying me Im cama
te? this dt) m IMS, Where he became on?
of the founders ?.f the Hol 14* ??
, haaga and ot the tintos League Club
..s a s-idow an?l one daughter
Ti.- iu:.. i .il ?sill "?? h.id .n Bands] ?"
.it tiie home Tha t> irld r/lM be In
? |ri ana aod ? !< nsetei ?
MRS. HATTIE J. P. BABIN.
Mra ii.itt ' .ii t I in, wtdos of
Rear Admiral Hoeea John Babtn, II. s N.
,;...i ..u Fridav at t.:.- MBBdOn HOUfB,
Brooklyn. Bha wsa bora at Greenpoint
bong island, in ; ?i?, h.-r patenta being
. ?. James ?' snd Sarah ?' Provost.
descendants "f Blahop Provost, first head
..f ii,- Kpis, ..psi Church in New ?Tori
She leaves a son. Commander fro?
S. N. of the Wilmington, now at lion-;
The fun? ral ssill !>?? hehl to-mor
rOW morning at St. 'Ann's K;
Church. Burial will be m.nie m Jersey
THOMAS H. AUSTIN.
Gsrrlsoa, N. v., May k?Thoa
Austin, ?iliiesi reatdei l : Putaam Csua')
i- d< a ! at his home here in his |
scventu year. H?- mu a native of ih.s
? ilia?,?-, and raw tiie Bist wood-hurnei lo
ComOtiVB ??n its initial tri|i en tl..- H idsOO
River Rdlros?, He wsa s ssaaaber >.f
ti.e Church <>( st. Philip in the Hla
aixty-ttve seats For reara i.e ..
aole trustee of the ?'.arris .n publie v h I ?:.
wh.ie Hamilton ?fish, Wllhssi Church Os?
: d other kafluestial resident
ALBERT 0. WARBURG.
Aiheil i'. Wai Ml -g. a Stage dire tor.
?lied at St. Vim enl's Hospi'
Mr W a: burg ?am? here from New ? ir
leans tin ?re ?Jays ago He ??.?s for s..
fOUtt Sta??- 'llI'Ct'T of ti:-- ' ? . I'..
st,..k . i? d f.?r thn S ??a.
ssith Charles Frohssan.
ii-? WSS UM?arriad, and had been
ROMEO F. CHURCHILL.
Rome?? F. Churchill, ser.
I , ? ? ? . ice Ma ?? or ff 8?
h??s|ilti?l in New Y.-rk
and one In 8
I?r Churchill waa flfl ? era old
and a graduate of the Ness TOrh Col?
ls? of V*>t* inary Burgeons .?ml the
s. h"??i ?f ? omp? ? itlve Medicina
COLONEL MILTON PARK.
Dallai '.'? - Ma ? -? Mattel I
Park. ?1st ? - ? old. one ?.f the
founders I I P Hat pa and a
' leading. fi-'Uie in til?- Farmer?- Alliance,
?j,'-! :?? his home t'?-r* la>t night
COLUMBIA GETS ITS
SEAL, CENTURY LOST
Colonial Relic Restored to Suc?
cessor of King's College
Long Thought Destroyed.
After being I?->*t for ni"re than one hun?
dred years, the original seal of Kin?:'?
Coll?-ge, now ?'ol'imbia t'Diversity, wa?
placed yestenlay In the vault In the trus?
tees' room. The seal Is practically ?he
same In design as the one which is now
used by the university. I ntll It was dis?
covered in the library of George H
Harke, of Williamsport, Penn.. It wa? l?e
lleved to have been destroyed in the Rev?
olution, when King's College temporarily
went out of exi?ten -e. to be revived later
a? Columbia College.
.?.???"-?ling to tlie Inscription on It? di?
verse side, the seal wafl presented B
King's college by Gcrge Harison. a ve?
trysaaa of Trinity Church from
INa, The gift was made ami the seal
engraved in 1.5?. The cost at BBsjravtng,
...cording to the old record, was H
The seal for one hundred roOTS
been in tin? possession of trie Par he fam?
ily, and was originally obtained .?-.
by the grandfather of Georg? H. Parke
fi"in a man wiio was emplujed ov Be
trustees of the'college to engrave a new
The s.al will be placed on exhibition at
the coming commencement, together Wtti
:.,"ti?>n of the design in Be BfltBd?
writin-? of President BaUaTaTM-1 Job.; ?
which is SttScbsd a proof Impi ?-.-?.on at
Concerts to Aid Playgrounds.
\ ?eck sf band eomeorta for tire bene?
fit of the Parks and Plaj grorrtid
ciation of the City of New Yo. k will be
given by Lieutenant Henry I.PT and hi?
Veteran Corpa of Artillery militai \ I .
The trat ?' .ii.-ert Will le irriven ?n th ?
evening of May 18. children represeat
In*" BOBS Of the BSSOl iitions' thirfy-fo ir
play centres nil] ssrUetaats la fell?
dr.'ices at mStlaeSS There will als-' be
motion pictures .,f the eUldren st play.
Mai j s f Mai l'on.vd, M K
Mittiow. Frances C. McClure, Belle Hull
Fay, Gladys razia McCully, Sarah I..
Jav, Harriette A. Vanamec. William
ANGIER?Al Plalnfletd, S J. on Friday,
May ?. 1514, Mary Sanborn Fr. ?nch,
whIow of Gardner F. Ansier, la ;?? (
>-"ih year. I*un?*ral private.
BIOLaOW- At Plamiie'.d. M. J.. on Ma) ?.
1914, Frances ?'., wife of the late Frank?
lin H. i'igiow, in hei sah yeai
rices at her late residence, 120 Centre
av.. plain,i- ri. n .;., on Sunday, M i?
10, at 4 p. m. Interme it In Gr<
FAY -AT her resiil. nee. *fl? H0\ t st ,
Stan,for?!, ? 'onn . l-'i???la?. M r ?
Gladr? Casin Fay, daughter of H?l?ne
i-:. Casin and Charlea Edey Fay. In the
I8th year of hei asi ? rivate.
Intermenl at Trinity Cemeterj
st.. New York CM Bui . at ).;:?ip. in
jai ?m Frr.iny, Ma) ?. IBM, Harriette
A wife of Dr John Clarkson .lav. r-ja-r
i cea will be held at the church of the
Resurrection, 74th ?1 . between Park and
I.exiiurton avs., 10:10 a. m. Monday, Ma:
11. Interment !n the Jay Cemeter) at
Rye Train for Harrisoi N
in., returning 2:08 p. m Pleass omit?
MACDONALD Buddenly, on ;
Mi- ?, Mu-. Wesl MacDonald, widow
m John MacDonald. al bar lal
dence, BO Weal 76tli it Kuneral s-jr?
\ i.-es at ? ',: SCC '
way and 10th st., ->n Mond 13 . May 11, at
i 0 clock.
M'CLURB On May ?, ?14, at the rast?
dence of her sister. Mrs. Char!?
Mater, Atlant:.- Highlands. K. J.. Belle
Hull McClure, - :' the late IV.
.1 McClure and Elisabeth Barrido Mc?
Clure. Funeral - the above
Auburn st.. Peterson, N. J . I M p. m
M'CUIaLT At I'aters.iri. N .J . on Frida?.
May ?, 1914, Sarab !.. - ??ter of
t? ? late B imuel ind i 1 eland
M ? 'ull 1 Relal ai--- In
to attend th?; fu?era
May 11, from her la'. :
Auburn sr , Patei ion, N J . I p. m.
\ AN IMKE I in MB ? IMI In the Util
year of hla age, will
his rei at N< wl urgh, N ? Fu?
lierai sei . 1 ??? at St. G?K>rge's E
?'luiri b on Sunday, Ma
:itiit privat? II i?mi.
MANHATTAN AND THF BRONX
a 1 'i 'i >. Josephine, 2118 Bclmoi I
1 Msy ?"? sged II
ri IHN, I'r.nk. IS! Wesl
! urieial tO-mOTTOU. 1 n n. m
I'piT'/.F, Llbbis g. I in sv.,
11 \ i:'i ? il 130th at, M iy
1 to-day, 1 p. m
M'CONNELL, Alexander, 814 Fast IStth
?t , M iv 7 ??? -i il i'.-'la?.
Il a. m
Ri ''II (Kit. .I?.^a; I at 1 18th st .
Ma) 8. Funeral i.,-!,?; . :
BHIP81 ' 888 ?Yhitb.ck
Bi ons Ms - Fun<
77 p rn
ZIKOLER, lalward, til Fast lHHth st .
?T, 10 a. in
BABIN, Hattls '. at Mansion I
BAEHM, Robert W . len st
.\;a\ ; i'uncral to m
CA RNET, ' ' ;" Bummlt st.,
?,i.,v ' mer ,i to-day, 2 p m
DONALDSON, fcndrew, 11,: ltd st . May
EVERITT, Innies a, ." " 1st ?t .
Ma) I, aged 82
ORANOER. Ellhu J.. 121 MeDonough at,
... 1 ? :.
HL'TCHINbON. Henr) I-:., Ill Ca?
pia-. .May s, aged |7. Funeral to?
morrow, I p- m.
KRONER, Andrew 2021 0 . May
. i;;. : met ii to-morro?
HARKS, Mllee, I Hi '?
- s >R. Brldi
PITMAN William I. I ? Ith ll
THOMPSON Mary A. ?"S Green? a?.
? ri,'.?.i ?'? Funeral t?>-m*>rrow,
VON LENQERKE, Bu**frons, III East
-? m . Ma) .'. igad M
VIRKEL Betty, ' I ad hi Fanerai
today, Il a m.
CARMAN, Aadrew M, 84 Ten
11.1 ipste. d, Ma) 7. Funeral ?
?-.n IKE, M ?it P., 2211 Eighth -1
1-? \ v-' Thoma 1 '? ? '?' Oak I?
So? Mr i.-. ? ? *?fed II
KICW I KPSKY
CHURCHILL li'irie? T, at B?eaucus,
GARV?N, ! ' 28th St., Wood
cliff. Ma) ?? a-jed 7 lu
GRONNIGBR, '- ?
if. : p sa.
1< iNSEN, LaSfetl
Hasbn m .11.1 I, aged n>
SHARKE, ''*nnlngtea M
Paterson, Ma) ?'? I ineia I morrow,
I .1 ??!
I uneral t?>
THE BTgaoLAST? CBMETBatf.
?J3<1 fct B> Har'.am Train and by Troll?*
offlr?. :?> t??t aau c'_ S. T.