Newspaper Page Text
Iaaued Every Evening, Except Sunday, by THE BULLETIN PUBLISHING 00.
MIatred as eonomd-Class Matter, December 18, 1917, at the Postoffice at Butte, M.ntana
nader Act of March 8, 1879.
PHONES: Business Ofice, 52; Editorial Rooms, 292
5USINESS OFPICE AND EDITORIAL ROOMS, 101 SOUTH IDAHO STREET
SUBSC IPTION RATES:
One Mant, ....................76 Sit MoLtha .................... 8.76
Three Menths ..................$2')3 By the Year .................... $7.00
The Daily Bulletin is on sale every day at the following places in Butte.
Jacques Drug Co., Harrison and Cobban Depot Drug Store, 828 East PFrnt St.
George A. Ames, Jr., 816 1 2 N. Main St. P. O. News Stand, West Park St.
International News Stand, S. Arizona St.
Palace of Sweets, Mercury and Main Sts. Harkins' Grocery, 1028 Talbot Ave.
Everybody's News Stand, 215 S. Montana Helena Confectionery, 785 East Park St.
SFRIDAY, SEPT. 2C, 1919.
Anenit the recent decision il the Marmnorale case, wherein
Judge Lamb denied citizenship papers to an alien who had
served honorably with the American expeditionary forces in
France. and had been wounded three times. had also been I)lpr)
rooted by his superiors for faithful aid efficient service, the
Bulletin, being of the opinion that Mr. Mari orale had been
done an injustice. has taken the trouble to look iu p the law il
thlie case anid we hold to the view. afl'ter a carelful perusal of
the law and an interpretative decision of tihe Montana sli
preme court. that Judge Lamlb not only dli a grave injustice to,
Alarniorale. bi iut thiat el judge had no right whatever to derny
thie application for citizenship papers, and we predict that the
decision of Judge l.ainh in this case will he reversed by stome
court or agency which, is not subservient, to the Anlaclonlda Cn.p
per Mining compiany. aid that Mr. Marmorale, tfor'nmerly Ser
geant Marmorale. will be accorded a voice in the govelrnmentlc
of the Un:lited States, a right w\\hich tie carned on(rt the attlle
fields of France.
In additionl to b eng denied citizenshil ipapers, Mi. Marr
morale has been denied the right to earn a living by a niniig
corporation of which UCnr F. Kelley is the (chief executive, a I
man. by the way. who ipromotes war's but does not fight them.
We print below the law governing in Ihe case of M'r. Mar
miorale, and in doinig so we will leave it to thie sober ,juidgitientii
of our readers to say. aftel'lr fthey have read the law, w\\hether or .
rnot Rocco Manirorale. \-. uiiniled thro ee tiits ill the service of =
this counitry'. has niot onily as niuch but a belitter right to tihe
franchise than has Judge Lamb, w\\-hoise mnost nloteworthy
achievement wais his decision laIst spring disfiranchisinig a ima- fe
jority of the vor ters of the city of liutte. W
Suibdivision 1:- of' Secltionl 1 o'f an nict of congress entitled i.i
'An act to amend the naturalization laws anid to repeail certuin at
s:ections of the revised staitiutes of tihe lUnited States and other i
laws relating to naturalization. antd for other llitpurposes," ap
proved May 9,) 19 18. provides:
That any pei'rson whoi is serving in the mililtary ior iiaval
forces of the Un:iited States at the tcrrtllintii llni of the ex
isting war, altl ainy piersoni who betfore the terni atllio of
the existing war imay haive beeni h.nori.tly dischinarged
from tihe militrr'y o.or r iaval services o' tihe United Stlates inn
accounit of disability iincuri red in the line tof duty, shall, ift'
hie applies to the prlioper eoirlt fo'r adnmissioni us a citizeni
of tlie iiited Stales be r'elieved fralan tie nelcessity fl'
piroving lthat. inmunediatiely preceding thie date of his appli
cttiioni he ihas i'resided contitnuously within the United
States the time required byv Inw l f] othelr nliins, or withini
the state toi' the ye:r' immniediately iprecceding the de date of
his pietition I'for iiatiralizatiotn, but hIis petition l'oir niaturaiil
izationi sharll bie suppol. rted by the aTffidavits ut' tw-o credtible
witnesses. citizens iI' tlie U ited States, identifyiing tlhe
petitioner as the lI'i'person named( ill the cei'rtif'icat e o(f hiiior'
able discharge, W\lllIt SAIl) (I11tI(TII ICATEI MAY liE
A(UCIIEPTED AS EVIlENCE 1OF (i001l) MURIIAL CliAltA-tl
TEPR R'IIEQUlllED) BY LAW.
In thie case of the Montnau O(ire lPurchliasing Co. vs. Linidsa"y.
Judge 25. Montana 27. in conisidering the mieaninig of the word
''may'" the .uipremine court of this state saidl:
Thiis wairt is soinmetimes permiissive oniily; siietimes it
is ilmperative. Legislaitive intent determlliles w\heth'er it is
directory or mni datory. .\cc·rdinig to its inaturat l aii
usual significationi the w\\rd "'lmay' is enablling anild l'
missive only. and so it limust he inllterpreted w\hee nio r'ight
of or benefit the public nor right of persons otiher' tan he
onle upon whiir thie perlissii is coUfrredt, depolisii
ilponit givig to it lthe otbligatoiiiy uening; but the iwordic is t
iinteripreled to iimean shall" ior' "irmusti" whenievri tlhe
rights ot' the public or 1'f hird plersol ns idepenid l ti lei tl
exer'cise of tie powvet' r performance of' the dlty to whict,
W heni this statute is .nrstri ed in Ihie light li' ithe decisiinii if
the s tlupreme court it' th e state it ' Montanii, ithe conclusioiin is
inevitable that the judge whoi sits in nalitralizatol i pI'oceed
iigs brought niiderf te statute utii l itccepit ttie certilicate rlf'
honorablte disciharge ias evidenice if t'he icgood moral 'iicharacter'
requiied by law of thie per'son applying f.' citizenship.
The right oft the persoin applying for c'itizenshipi cOe'tainly
depends tiuc the exercise of the ipower i to aeccept the coeitifli
cate of holti'btile dischatrge as evideince of the goiod mlloral
cha'acr requi'red by ltaw of the iperson appll ying firti' iizeisle hip:s
atind it also seecis that the rights of the public eqire that those
whlo though bori beyondii the limits oaf the Unlited Strates have
seen fit to fight her battles tid to iisk their lives iii hier service
should. if they see f'it. le pei' itted lt n t hei l application to ii -
quire the benefits of citizenship anid to have a voice in thie aik
ing of tlhe laws undier whitch they urirst live.
Questions of political ir' econolic belief stihould not bi e tl
lowed to ernret' hito tihe qtuestilon. Thie ligirt ti di'fet' t ianii
these qunestions aid Ito selile tlhese dil 'fer'ences bi i resotf ti
tthe ballot is tire vei'y tornien' stone upon which the govelrinreil[
of this courtitry is foiunided ari(i is fhe essetititl eleite which
must be allowed full play if libertly i this couair try is to ciii
tiiue aitd de nt-or''acy is trot to pro\-o a r'aillute.
Tire denial of this 'ight led to ihe Revolution alid the pin'
pose of the constithtiti of the United Stales wns tm forever'
secure this right to the peolile living uider tihe authority of
the United States.
Section ' of the fouriteeith aineridrneirt to the cornstitutiori
of the United States provides that no state shall depi'ive arty
person of life, libei'ty, or property w'ithout due process of law,
nor deity to any person within its jurisdicltion the equal pnit
tection of the laws and any et'ot'i ott the tiart of the gove'irrnmeirt
of thre United States or of' anllr state to tirevent the issuance it'
riaturalizationt papers to airy personi because ft' his belief Ott
political or economic subjects is clearly coltrt'ary to the theory
of government, according tn tihe will of the majority and the
.xpre's pr'ov'isiolis of tIhe fundamental law of' the land.
Union Stock Holders in the
BUTTE DAIL Y BULLE TI
UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA--Locals: Sand Coulee,
Stocket, Roundup, Lehigh, Klein, Washoe. Red Lodge, Smith
FEDERAL LABOR UNION-Livingston, Great Falls.
I MACHINISTS' UNION-Great Falls, Butte, Livingston, Seattle.
" CEREAL WORKERS-Great Falls.
BLACKSMITHS' UNION-Butte, Miles City, Seattle.
ELECTRICIANS' UNION-Livingston, Deer Lodge, Butte, Anaconda.
BAKERS UNION-Great Falls.
SHOE WORKERS-Great Falls.
PLASTERERS' UNION-Great Falls.
RAILWAY CAR REPAIRERS-Livingston, Miles City.
BREWERY WORKERS' UNION-Butte.
HOD CARRIERS' UNION-Butte, Bozeman, Helena, Seattle.
STREET CAR MEN'S UNION-Butte, Portland.
METAL MINE WORKERS' UNION OF AMERICA.
PRINTING PRESSMEN'S UNION-Butte.
STEREOTYPERS AND ELECTROTYPERS' UNION-Butte.
i BRIDGE AND STRUCTURAL IRON WORKERS-Butte.
BROTHERHOOD BOILERMAKERS AND HELPERS-Butte, and
STEAM AND OPERATING ENGINEERS-Great Falls.
i BUTCHERS' UNION-Great Falls.
INTERNATIONAL MOLDERS' UNION, LOCAL NO. 276-Butte.
LAUNDRY WORKERS' UNION-Butte, Seattle.
PLUMBERS' UNION-Butte, Seattle.
SBROTHERHOOD RAILWAY CAR MEN OF AMERICA, LOCAL NO.
TRADES AND LABOR COUNCIL-Miles City.
BROTHERHOOD RAILWAY CAR MEN OF AMERICA, COPPER
LODGE NO. 430-Butte.
BUTTE FOUNDRY WORKERS UNION-Butte.
PAINTERS' UNION-Butte, Seattle.
CARPENTERS' UNION NO. 1335-Seattle.
TAILORS' PROTECTIVE ASSOCIATION-Butte, Portland.
BOILERMAKERS, SHIPBUILDERS AND HELPERS OF AMERICA
-Tocamo, Seattle, Livingston.
INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF BLACKSMITHS AND HELP
ERS, LOCAL NO. 211-Seattle.
WORKERS', SOLDIERS' AND SAILORS' COUNCIL-Painters' Hall,
BTTILDING LABORERS' UNION-Seattle.
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BRIDGE AND STRUCTURAL
IRON WORKERS AND PILEDRIVERS' LOCAL NO. 86-Seattle
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF MACHINIST HELPERS-Butte.
BROTHERHOOD OF RAILWAY TRAINMEN, NO. 580, BUTTE.
CARPENTERS' LOCAL UNION, ND. 1172Billings, Montana.
TEAMSTERS' UNION--Local 135, Billings. Mont.
I AND THOUSANDS OF INDIVIDUALS IN BUTTE AND MONTANA
· J·Y IL1-·- I-C-I-U.· - WC--·-..s n- -.ý.ý...ý,ý ýn-.-.ý.ý......ý.ý ý .
WILSON AND HIS FRIENDS.
The presidlent is unfortutinate in the mulltitlude .,' his de
cnilders. So imalIiy stronl. but, inihlaurnlolious dtefenlses niighlt
,vell he disleineit \ili. "'lie Publlic." n11 o tirely holiest
journal adi a si alluich clhatlipion of the league of nalionsi, pri(i.
iii article bIy (George Darien, American dramiatist and editor.
entitled: "!1w lPresildeilt W'ilson )Did Not Fail." Here are
4o11eO excerpt. :
S.. it' to Ie foriewa iirned is to lie lorearni ed, it cani
safel\y, ie issaiiiill lithat. President \W'ilsoin could enltertaiii
ii dt';lusioini ~ w\]littever' as to the ready acceeltaniice io his 1 .
pointi; 'roln the first he wist havet knowni that illiiliedi
ate anl compllllete success was (ot of the qulestioni. * *
'Presidtenit \VWilson did his tmiiost to have his lproposi
tiiio s acce'pted. uiit, all the while, lie cani have eniter
toinied no lype. He hal been illt'ortl ed----lioweveir iicoin.
pletely v l J--bet'fre, Iting \Vashingtton of the olbstacles he
woldl have to encoun.lil(er; I iil. once' il Paris, he hadil been
ible to see----and to l judge. * " *
Prel'csident W\'iliison hallls poiniteld out the wa\\y. lie coul
dl nilt more. Let the LEuopeulr peoples march toward tihe
lii the 5ii iie nilmagazine a. few weeks earlier Lou.iis F. Post. its
i itformer e'litori', delivereod ta tmltieiiitical demiiOllstratioii of how
all the li ploiints arie actutall"y realized iln the covenaiIt of lihe
ltel.i.ge. .\tld nw, Ihe 'presildent hiiimself sw\\ings around the
cirllo assuril'ig his a.idietcies that the tleaty aoid the league are
a lure \Vilsoniiaii pirodulct, the while his cabinet otfficers de
imnitd l lhlieardl-oft peace.-tilne riillnilments, iresumabilyl ) as a
seciind linii e tof (lelelise,. shouldtitl the league faii il to filinctioni.
'Thlis itpoundinitg i the people oni the back to swallow tlh'e
league has ifoly aie c( hatlie 'to' . ticcess --...the fact that tile
colallliin lk of the w\\ld (ar1'e sic'k of i wa, and not loath to say
sir. tiut coilinii11 people are also .1uiick to smell the uniisoulld
es.s thliiat litks lbelitd a liolth-pticlh iof diseordanit argunelints.
'They hive experieinced .al lnlialy politicias and some stantesmien-
enough t ii' the liatle to recognize ai real one as well as its coun
terfeit. They are fast leriinig thiat Wilson is an ordiinary poli
ic.ian. ievoiid ol' the texaltedl tiiotives ill which., with the aid ot
the war-spirit, lit' so Ili"g successfullO y Inasqueradedt, atnd
wthich nIow i appear as merel"y orcS.o l uchilil ego iisllm.
Poir \'ils.in! lie irode one niulte accepitably. lie tried I ridle
thrtee, anid Was to.t to pieces. The pieestal f.or the bu.st of tlhe
,econo l Lincoln still waits.
ANOTHER TURNIP HUNTER.
Ye .,lirdat we gave our readers on insighll into the personal
histivory of is W\einstock. recently appoinited state market in
s 'pe4't' by týover'nor Stewart. 1ltl we neglected in that article
to tell of' M. . \\'eini tock' s pt ilner' ini the market inspecting
business one "'aniiy" toluilinni.
In onei' o li'ry of Mi'. \\'eiistoc'k We made a grie'ivous mistake.
We sautl thai ..Ir. \\einstot'ck was marr'ied w\hen the "''idrafti, was
intllinelil." What we .11should htive said was that t;us was tmar
rieid aile' hie had takell his .i e ( ,4 tc e the distric' t board and, tp
lparenlly. hId received assuranci'les that hlle would 11not he catlled
for servi'ce. I'or wehich minstake we apIologize.
As ho' Mir. (ioodtmaitti. evet'\ body ii lIleleln and, in a'ilt. most
lieople in publlic life throughout'l the state know of4 him.
Sillndy' lhas been engaged iin attling thle chilps in 'various tiiga.l
storesi in lelei atnd llutte flor year. lie kiinows what 'l a blue
eliri is \\ ~rth and also wh1 t a white one is worth. and that. s5
ft'r a.s the tUnilltltin is tco 'ernled. i, his whole t and sole rieeom
e11nJ lilian as iimariket inispeetor. Possiblyv the gover'nor, know
in.g 1of Sanilly's expert' kinow'ledg4e of chips. thinks that thiat ac
cOmlplis.hment fit, him to delirintile the value of turnip, and
i abliges. llnut who Iknows? It is possible Ithat in hi, lifetime
Soiihy has- lUrci'h'liased seve tral Its of1' eg tables o'r a 'iimulli
\iliAnyhow, Sndily is now the statle maiirti'ket insptectior. ii com-
ptpai w\ith his 'fr'ieinid and co-w4iorker, inus \\Veinstoek. In addhi
lion to l knowing the value ofr chilpS of variousti colors. Sand-i ha
anotheri accomp lislhiiiient that shm ild! be inoted. 1He has served
as r'eading el'erk in the state senatliie l'fori' several sessioni. All of
which. of coursetl' , fits hiim to nit as state market iinspect''i'.
It is highly probaltble that Salindy. \ iite iinspectinig inmarkets
will ihave a hIelper ailiog in ori'deir to tell him what is a radishl
a.td w hat is a potato. Bul 1that his inspliection will be Ithornlgh.
is la I',o'eogfnie conclulsiOtl,
SHunting Season Opens
f-His 15 THE WAY WE CAMOVFLAGED
so 1'dE HUNTERS GAM NOrT .V
SEE HER IN
THEG PASTr RE
! // ý at
j9 k , (7
Thui column is conducted for
and .iitten by Bulletin readers.
If you have any suggestions to of
fer for the betterment of condi
tions in which the public in inter
ested, the Bulletin offers you this
opportunity for their expression
and interchange of comment with
your neighbors and friends.
Properly to protect this Open
Forum, all communications must
be signed with the name and ad
dress of the writer, but anony
mous signatures will be used in
the column if requested. Address
all communications to the editor
of the Bulletin and please be briet
and to the point.
Editor of the Bulletin:
For the information of the general
public, through the columns of your
malu.ble paper,. I wish to stale that
on Saturday last. Sept. 20. the pendo
graf of No. 1 locomotive at the Tim
ber Butte mill became entangled in
&he trolley and knocked out a break
rn in the Montana Power company's
station on Montana street. It took
Chief Electrical Engineer L. L. Quig
ley of the Clark interests. just two
hours to clear it. off so that street
2ar servcie on Montana street could
be resuned, since the mill circuit is
operating on the Montana street car
And to show the general public
who is doing the scabbing at the
Timber Butte mill. I will give the
That L. L. Quigley, assisted by
Clem Bartzen, who resides at 319
South Jackson street, made the pan
'.hat goes on the pendograf of the
'ocomotive mentioned, last. week, by
that scabbing on the electricians and
bheet metal workers. And that on
'ast Saturday they put the pan on
No. 1 locomotive and were assisted
by another scab at heart. by the name
of R. McGillivrey. superintendent at
he mill, who resides at 3041 Bush
street. That on Sept. 24, they got
'mother one of their clique by the
name of T. O. Proctor and that on
NOTICE TO SUBSCRIBERS I
Subscription .Rates Are Going Up
TO KEEP THE BUL L E TIN UP- i
For the purpose of helping to maintain The
Daily Bulletin; 3
F or the purpose of helping to make The Daily .
E .Bulletin independent of advertising;
For the purpose of having the subscribers bear *
a portion of the deficit under ,which The Bulletin I
I unavoidably operates;
For the purpose of continuing to fight for the I
people who toil; 3
* For the purpose of increasing the effectiveness I
n of The Daily Bulletin. N
i Subscribers to The Daily Bulletin on and I
after Oct. 1, 1919, will be asked to pay the I
" following rates: U
One Month . . . . $1.00 n
Three Months . . 2.75
Six Months . . . 5.00 H
* One Year . . . . . 9.50
S The inauguration of the above rates on Oct. 1 will not affect subscriptions I
* which have been paid in advance beyond that date at the old rate. n
n As The Daily Bulletin is conducted for the sole purpose of serving the peo- I
Sple, and not for the benefit of those who exploit the people, the, management *
I feels sure that all the present supporte rs of this FREE PRESS will readily I
recognize the necessity for the increase in the subscription rates and continue B
their support, nm
i : I THE BULLETIN STAFF.
L........ ..U.. . . ... ...
that occasion they tried to scab on
the blacksmiths. One of the scoop
shovels which they use at the old re
duction works to load the old tail
ings they are running through the
mill again, was out of repair and
that it was fixed by Master Mechanic
Bartzen, assisted by McGillivrey and
Proctor. AN INFORMANT.
o ---------·------ -·- r
She was the daughter of Sir
Thomas More, lord chancellor of
Henry VIII. No finer man ever lived
than Sir Thomas More. At the time
of the reformation, and the king's
divorce and subsequent marriage
with Anne Boleyn, his majesty de
manded that Miore, an ardent Cath
olic, should give assent to the pro
ceedings. Sir Thomas refused and
was committed to the Tower and be
headed. His head was stuck upon a
pike and exhibited on London bridge.
His beloved daughter, undaunted by
fear or danger, had a trusty servant
row her at nightfall to the bridge.
She kept the boat steady in the cur
rent while the servant climbed to
the piers, loosened the precious head
of her father and dropped it into
the lap of his devoted daughter. One
of the finest instances of filial faith
fulness in all history. She buried
the venerable head in the garden of
the home in Chelsea. With no real
ization of her heroic act she became
the mainstay of the afflicted family.
IN BUTTE CHURCHES
Congregational church, Harrison
avenue and Majors street, Berten
Emery Crane, pastor.--S u n d a y
school at 12:15. Preaching services
at 1 and 8.
Floral Park Congregational. 2)055
Phillips street.--Sunday school at
HAILiOAD TIME TABLE
Trains arrive and depart from
3utte as follows:
Oregon Short Line.
Arrive, 5:05 a. m. and 5:25 p. m.
Leave, 7:15 a. in. and 5:35 p. m.
East bound trains depart: Local
1:00 a. in.; stub, 10:45 a. m.; No. 2,
1:50 p. m.; No. 42, 10:00 p. m.
West bound trains depart: No.
11, 6:30 a. m.; stub, 7:35 a. m.; No.
1, 9:05 p. m.; Missoula stub, 5:55
Local from east arrives 9:15 a. m.
and 8:05 p. in. Stub from west ar
rives 1:00 p. m. and 8:10 p. m. All
other trains arrive 10 minutes prior
Leaves 8:00 a. m. and 2:45 p. m.
Arrives 2:45 p. m. and 9:30 p. sm.
Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul.
East bound leaves 10:45 a. m. and
10:25 p. m.
West bound leaves 11:55 a. m. and
10:10 p. m.
All trains arrive 10 minutes prior
Butte, Anaconda and Pacific.
Leaves 9:30 a. ai., 1:00 p. m., 5:00
p. m. and 10:15 p. m.
Arrives 8:40 a. im., 12:20 p. m.,
4:30 p. m. and 7:45 p. m.
With the Editors ]
LABOR TO. CORRECT EVIL.
Every fake plan proposed to avert
the triumph of the workers starts
out with the proposition that "capi
tal must be guaranteed an honest re
turn." which is a confession that its
returns heretofore have been dis
honest. Labor will, as soon as it
gets its correct hearings, use capital
just as it uses any other tool in
wealth production and distribution.
That's what capital is for-not some
thing for private ownership-but for
public use--- Huntington Herald.