9 HOW DID IT ..if PEHs The Question of A ;linnesotans Regarding Saturday's Game. SOME COG IN DEFENSE SLIPPED Frequency of Successful Badger End Runs Point* to That as the Trouble. Somewhere the sun is shining, Somewhere the people shout; But there is no joy in Mudville, Mighty Casey. has struck out. —From "Casey at the Bat." .For "Mudville" read Minneapolis and for "Mighty Casey" read (Minnesota. It was a sad and silent crcwd of rooters that ar rived in town yesterday. They flaunted their colors defiantly but among them selves they busily sought an explanation for the Waterloo of Saturday. There were many explanations, almost as many as there were rooters, but they brought lit tle consolation for the toboggan slide the mighty gophers had taken from the apex of fame to the bitternesss of a decisive defeat. For the large Minneapolis contin gent that went down to 'Madison so joy ously, there was but one rift in the gloom. It was expressed iv this war cry: o o : They might have had the money; : : they only got the score. : o o That was the fiy in the ointment for the badgers. In the midst of their wild Joy, the thought that they had not had the ■ sand" 10 back their wonderful team properly was gall and wormwood. And when a gloating wearer of the cardinal tried to rub it in too vigorously on a despondent wearer of the maroon and gold, the latter would retort: "Yes, you have a great team. It is a wonder. Bui it has the yellowest support ever. You fellows didn't dare back your men. You were bluffed into your holes before the gam© and couldn't be coaxed out. You are quitters." And there was a good deal of truth in this. There was little or no cardinal mon ey in sight and it required heavy odds to get it into action at all. The fact was that Wisconsin hoped but hardly expected to win. It was a surprise party for 'Madi son as well as for Minneapolis, All Min nesota predictions went wrong. There are a few who can say "I told you so/ but they are very, very few. The Absorbing Question. "How did it happen?" is the question of every Minnesotan who is interested in football, and of many Wisconsin folk, for the badgers in demanding odds in their betting were actuated by other motives than those of business wholly. There was a fear in the hearts of the cardinal wear ers that the maroon and gold would tri umph. So, how did it happen? Wisconsin's Game Brilliant. First and foremost the Wisconsin team played a game that would have been .ter rifying in its swiftness to almost any team, though the gophers- shouldi have felt confidence in their own skill and strength to meet Wisconsin's speed. But the badgers played a splendid game and only the gophers' best could have expected to meet and overcome its effectiveness. But the gophers did «ot give of their best Saturday. They played away below their ability and form. Just why is a question very difficult .to answer. In some re spects the question is a pschological one. Its answer lies In the spirit, the mental attitude, in which the Minnesota boys went into the game and which prevailed In the game. Certain it is that before the game had gone very far there seemed to be a change of attitude or spirit. The show of that aggressive, unconquerable spirit, which was none too great even at the outset, seemed to disappear altogether very early in the first half, leaving the boys, fighting, not to cross the badger line but to protect their own. In other words they had allowed themselves to be placed on the defensive, an almost certainly fatal attitude in a football game. Minnesota Pnt on Defensive. What put the boys on the defensive? is the question then. All sorts of reasons have been assigned, such'as stage fright, flaying on the enemy's grounds, the fa ligue and excitement of the trip. But these seem hardly adequate, though in each there is doubtless at least a partial explanation of the menial condition that led to the slump. There must have been something more to account for the de- It at —a defeat by end runs, against which .Minnesota's defense has always been thoroughly effective. in the defense of a well organized and drilled football team against an enemy whose tactics are, in a measure, at least, known each man has a certain part to play, and the success of the defense de pends upon each man's doing his part to the utmost. It follows that if one man fails to do his part the whole mechanism of the defense may be disorganized and thrown into confusion. Judging from ef fects as seen in Saturday's game some such failure must have been made. Such a failure would account for the apparent ly disorganized condition of the Minnesota team at times, which was noted by the spectators and found expression in the re mark that the whole team was "off" in Its play. If one man was off, extra burdens must have been thrown upon the rest which were hard for them to carry In ad dition to their regular parts, and natural ly enough they would seem to be playing poor footbalL When the real inside of the defeat is known, if It ever is, it will probably be found that some one man, or possibly two fell down, tried to shift their play so as to meet Wisconsin's end runs in a way not prescribed In the Minnesota system of defense, thus throwing the whole machine out of gear. This would not have to be done all through the game. Two or three catastrophes as results of individual mis takes would have the effect of weaken ing the spirit of the whole team long enough to allow the enemy to make enough points to cinch the game. The Fatal Failure. The failure that seems to have been made Saturday was In not preventing the forming of the Wisconsin interference, so that the ends could get at the man with the ball. It can foe seen how this would ■work. An end run would be started by Wisconsin. Aune or Rogers, as the case might be, would be expected to stop the man with the ball. Suppose, however, that either of them could not get at the man for the interference, it would be plain that some one had failed to do his part In preventing the Interference from forming or breaking it up when formed. The frequency with which these sure ends were passed for gains by the badgers seems .to indicate that some one was play ing erratically, behind the line, though it Is diffioult for laymen to say ;just where the blame lies. But some one was playing I hia own game instead of that in which the team had | been drilled. „ Minnesota has ;' met swift end > runners . before and ' has al ways ; stopped ■ them, ■■ her: system : working perfectly. Why should It bar* lailea TffljgjiPprlcL of r'-t Saturday so frequently, unless gome of ' the backs were blundering? In making her end runs Wisconsin sev eral times used the double pass and worked it with a precision and rapidity that was most puzzling. Driver's t'uutlnu. Another thing that added greatly to Wisconsin's effectiveness, was Drlver"s punting. He punted as he has not done before this year, and even astonished his coach, Phil King, by the strength of his kicking. He raised the ball -well, so that the Wisconsin ends had time to get down under the ball to tackle the catcher before he could recover more than a few yards in any oase. Knowltoa's punting, on the other hand, was much below par, and late in the gamo the kicking was turned over to Dobie, who only did fairly well. The punting was not j of such a nature as to allow the Minne sotans to get down witJh the ball to stop the catcher, and the ball was often car ried back many yards after Minnesota's ' punts. It has been said that Wisconsin "let ; up" in the second half, which accounts for ; the fact that the badgers did not score in the last half of the game. If the players did let up, they disobeyed the in struotions of their coach, who told his men to go in and rub it In. The fact is that Wisconsin played as hard as she could in the second half, but couldn't score. She was "all in." The rapid first half had used up her strength. On the other hand, Minnesota had partially recovered and was more nearly playing her own game. Inhospitable Treatment. The boys of the team had a run of "hard luck" on the way to the grounds. The pole of the 'bus in which they were be ing taken out to Camp Randall broke and the 'bus almost unset. There was more or less excitement and finally the boys had to get into an expres wagon and ride the rest of the way. When they arrived at the grounds there was no one on hand to show them where to go and they were directed to some barn-like rooms, cold, cheerless and dirty, under the grandstand. Th,e (badgers, on the other hand had i\ nicely warmed tent near the entrance to the sidelines. The result was that the gophers, victims of such inhospitable treatment, went, onto the gridiron stiff with cold- King Violated Rules. Phil King was guilty of a flagrant vio lation of the rules governing coaches. From the side lines he was heard by a Jo vma 1_ representative to call to Lar son, Wisconsin's right halfback: "Play lower, Larson; play lower, Larson." It is said that Mr. King since the gam« has stated that he was sure of victory before the game began. His frantic de light, when Wisconsin made her first touchdown and when she added a second, however, were evinced in a way that would indicate that he was most happily sur prised. There can be do question, how ever, that he planned his campaign against Minnesota very shrewdly. "I'll give 'em the hottest fifteen minutes at the start-off they ever had," he is said to have remarked to a friend. And he did. He realized that if Wisconsin was to win she must do «o in the first half. He sent his men into the game gritting their teeth and determined to win if it took every ounce of energy in their bodies. It is such a do or die spirit that wins games. Minnesota didn't have it. GAME IX DETAIL Story Shows That Wisconsin Did Xot Do All of Ground Gaining:. "Heads," called Knowlton, captain of the Minnesota team, as a silver dollar was spun to decide who should have choice of ball or goal. Heads turned up, ! and Knowlton chose the west goal, gain ing the advantage fit the wind, which was blowing strongly enough to be well worth considering. The teams lined up on the field, the Minnesota rooters settled themselves to do the best so comparatively small a crowd could do against heavy odds, the Wisconsin followers let out a tremen dous yell and the game was on. The Min nesotans were confident, but there was the shadow of a doubt in the minds of the badgerW; never mind, the whole thing would soon be settled. And it was—much sooner and in a vastly different manner than the gopher contingent had any idea it would be. One will see how soon after I the game was called by following the de tail of the game; how differently the dis patches of Saturday announced. Here is the game in detail: Wisconsin kicked off to Minnesota's flf teen-yard line. Dobie got under the ball, as every Minnesotan knew he would, and taking it in his arm started toward the badger goal. Badgers got in the way, however, and Dobie had to stop at the end of a ten-yard run. The ball was crowded forward five yards, ] and then Knowlton had to punt. He sent the ball to Wisconsin's fifty-yard line. The lively badgers then took a turn at offensive play, and in short rushes took the ball back to Minnesota's forty-one-yard line, where the gophers went through a metamorphosis, be coming for the moment a stone wall, over which the badgers thought the easiest way I was by letting Driver Kick. Driver did the ! business in a way that showed that his kick ing leg had been well oiled for the day. He landed the ball on Minnesota's five-yard line. The First Mishap. Dobie signaled for a pipy, drawing right tackle back. Then, it seems, he changed his mind and called for a punt, starting the play before Sehacht cculd get back to his place. A swift badger got in the way ansl the ball bounded back over the Minnesota goal line. There were creepy feel ings chasing themselves up and down the spines of the gophers Just then. If a badger should fall on that ball any place back of the Minnesota line it would be a touchdowa. The supense In the gopher section of the grand stand, therefore, was intence as twent ty-two men piled up on top of the ball. Was it In the arms of a wearer of the maroon and gold or of a defender of the cardinal? The maroon and gold had it; but even that meant a score for the badgers—a safety. The gophers had been scored against for the first time this year. But, then, what did it amount to? Two to nothing was no very serious matter; the .gophers would soon wipe that out and turn things the other way That was the feeling of the friends of the Minnesota boys, and there wasn't a gophei heart that quaked unless It was among tho members of the team. Subsequent events seem to indicate that there may hava been a good deal of quaking there. But there was no time for philosophizing the game was going forward. Knowlton' from the Minnesota fifteen-yard line, sent the ball to Wisconsin's forty-two yard line, where it was fumbled, and Dobie fell on it. The Minnesota banners were waved, and there were lusty cheers from the throats of the ad mirers of the "giants." Ball Close to Badger Goal. A moment later, and even the badgers were compelled to admire, with Minnesota the charge of Fee, Minnesota's left tackle, for twenty-five yards to the Wisconsin nfte«n yard line. It had scarcely been made before Aune added a gain of five yards, and the ball was on the badger ten-yard line. "Now Minnesota Is playing In her real form; two or three minutes more and the pigskin will be over the cardinal goal line for a touchrdown, and the safety will bs wiped out," said the gopher rooters to on* another. But the gopher rooters were mistaken. Th« badgers responded to the call of their admir ers: "Hold! Hold!" and Minnesota had to surrender the 'ball to her adversaries, who punted to their own forty-yard line. Another Move- on Wisconsin's Line. I Again the ' leather began' to ' move eastward, i two short plunges giving • Minnesota four yards and two drives by Lafans adding a total of twelve yards. The ball was crowded to the> Wisconsin fifteen-yard line, but there it became necessary to kick, and the ball being well in front of the goal, a place kick was decided upon. -It went wide of the mark. Thatl was. Minnesota's last- chance at scoring; The ball was Wisconsin's for. a punt from, the fifteen-yard line. It I was sent to the center of the field, : where ; Dobie caught |it- and was downed on the spot. S»v«a yards was gained MHWBMWBWWIWH||HHH '" — -*—* --• ■ . —- -■;■— ■-- !®sp?j li lifl liKi 111 iSßi!iii •^-~*L — r.-,1.,..,5:.^...,,.£1,,-Y^.. !, r^ L. r.*./.*r u f~s,* n k >f v ,^.. 1\..'1.1., ..,..,,,,,, „.' „:*■'- t" <\ >' 1 Slf^SsS sr.ri^ fter F ee>s, • twenty-flve-yard run Mtonesota was held for downs on Wisconsin's ten-yard line The photograph shows the by Minnesota, and then the ball was given to Wisconsin on a third down. Falling Into position with great speed, the badgers by successive rushes soou had the ball at the center of the field. But they found rushing the ball "hard sledding," and Driver was called upon to punt. He sent the ball to the Minnesota twenty-flve-yard line. Min nesota tried to pierce the line, but without avail, and Knowltou punted back, landing the ball on the Wisconsin fifty-yard line. An Exchange of Punts. Wisconsin made ten yards with the ball, and then Driver, who was kicking in splendid form in the teeth of the wind, drove the ball to Minnesota's twenty-yard line. Minnesota immediately punted, getting the ball to the center of the field, where it was caught and by a swift run carried back fifteen yards to Minna&ota's forty-yard line. A punt again landed it on Minnesota's twenty-yard line. Minnesota Lasglng. Minnesota seemed to be lagging a bit, and her plunges ou the badger line at this junc ture were without gain. A punt sent the ball out of bounds at the Minnesota fifty-yard line, giving It to the cardinal. Troubles It.nin. Here the real troubles of Minnesota began. Larson, one of the swift cardinal halves, took the ball and, skirting Minnesota's left end, made twenty-five yards to Minnesota's twen ty-yard line before being downed. Larson's speed was terrific and his interference was formed with a speed equal to that of hi 3 own flying feet. Dobie made a star tackle, which was the only thing that saved a touchdown then and there. The work of the n«rt few minutes, however, made the maroon and gold rooters lor a sec ond or so think a touchdown (might as well have been made- on Larson's run. By a se ries of swift rushes which the gophers seemed utterly unable to slop, Wisconsin carried the ball, largely around Minnesota's right end, to the Minnesota otie-half-yarti line, and there, from desperation alone, the Minnesotas held hard and got the ball on downs. Wisconsin Gets Touchdown. But the fight was up hill. Minnesota was plainly in a slump. Knowlton punted, send ing the ball to the Minnesota thirty-fivd-yard line, where a fleet badger caught it and car ried it back ten yards before going down. Quick rushes took it to within the Minnesota .: <:M liMBPIIiiH mi i «-; ■•» ' .'^ t^^i^^W^^^T^^^-^^^^ sasß&srJS five-yard line, and there, almost before tbe Mitme-sotans realized the catastrophe, Curtis had taken the ball on a double pass, swept around Minnesota's right and landed the ball behind the Minnesota line for a touchdown. A goal was kicked and the score was 8 to 0 for Wisconsin. Gopher Faith Firm. . "We'll win yet," shouted a former Min nesota gTidiron hero, as a Journal man passed him on the side lines. Knowlton kicked off to the Wisconsin 15 --yard line. Wisconsin took the ball and rushed it five yards and then, by a run around right end, made 06 more. A few minutes later the ball was on the Minnesota 45-yard line, whence Driver "was compelled to punt. He sent the ball to Minnesota's five-yard line. Knowlton punted in order to remove the imminent danger in which lie felt bis goal • line "was at the moment, but he only got the ball to the Minnesota 35-yard line, and the Minnesota line was not out of danger. On the contrary, a moment later it was In even worse danger. Cochems, like an arrow from a strong bow, eped past Minnesota's left end and placed the ball on Minnesota's 10-yard line. At the rate Wisconsin was making gains, for the badgers to have the ball on Minnesota's 10-yard line meant grava danger to the Minnesotans. Juncnn Misses Drop Kick. The danger caused the Minnesotans to ral ly and to throw themselves Into the game for the moment with spirit, tackling the badgers for losses and compelling Juneau to try a drop kick from the field. It failed, and again the respiration of the Minnesotans on the side lines was normal. Knowlton punted the ball from his 15-yard line to Wisconsin's 40-yard line, but it was carried back to the center of the field before the winged badger who had caught it was stopped. Another for VViioomin. • ■ After a . few abort plunges . came a catas trophe. Wisconsin • punted to Minnesota's 20-yard line, where the ball was fumbled 'by Dobie. A moment later Larson made a touch-'' down around r Minnesota's left \ and. ' No \ goal THE MINNEAPOLIS JOURNAL. MINNESOTA'S ONLY CHANCE TO SCORE was kicked and the score stood 13 to 0 for Wisconsin. Was Minnesota beaten? It looked like it; but the gophers who had been doing loyal rooting were lcath to admit defeat and kept up heart in the hope that the tide would turn. And Still Another. Knowltou kicked off, but an offside play by some of his men compelled him to try again from the 50-yard line. He sent the ball to the Wisconsin 15-yard line, whence it was carried back ten yards on the catch. A punt sent it to Minnesota's 45-yard line, where Dobie fumbled. Curtis captured the ball, and by a run the lest of the distance down the field, made another touchdown. Juneau missed goal aud the score was, Wis consin 18, Minnesota 0. Minnesota seemed surely beaten. Even the moat hopeful could hardly expect that she would take a brace and overcome the lead the badgers had gained. Still, there was that Chicago-Beloit game to show what could be done by bracing. At any rate, defeat with honor, slaughter, or whatever might be in store, the Minnesotans were there to see it out. Knowlton kicked out of bounds. Trying over again, he sent the ball to the Wisconsin 15-yard line. Wisconsin got ten yards for holding by Minnesota, and the first half end ed with the ball on the badger 25-yard line in possession of the badgers. The Second Half. To -win the game in the second half looked an impossibility against such a team as the cardinal, playing such a .game as it was play ing. So the gophers hoped for nothing more than a rally, and that they saw. Wisconsin added nothing to her score in the second thirty-five minutes" play. Hoyt was substituted for Aune at right end. Knowlton kicked off to the badger fifteen yard line and the ball was rushed back to the thirty-flve-yard line on the catch. Wisconsin was then forced to punt, sending the ball to Minnesota's forty-yard line, where- it was captured and carried back five yards. Steady attacks on Wisconsin's line showed what Min nesota's heavy men could do when she was playing her game, though the men were still far from playing at the gait at which they had been expected to play the entire game. The ball was advanced steadily to Wisconsin's forty-two-