tlHi mWJt, . v owt w " iiniiwumimnmiMHiWH1 , ... . t . i-vvvvvvwrwwvwvwwviyiwfvviwv9'ttvtw&,itf&Hs y.ggysgjasg? V v -PVW ' ra 'fPrf! !fJK i BISBEE DAILY REVIEW "if fi MEMBER ASSOCIATED PRESS. BISBEE, ARIZONA. TUESDAY MORNING, FE BRUARY 4, J 913. NUMBER 181 VOLUME 15. iai M" ii r- whimi., - 'St. fc 1fc TMI A TTWnM-MMlMM THE rVj s M k I ir i i r f t f BUSTERS BF TRUSTS GET HARD JOLT Supreme Court Decision i Puts New Construction on i Sherman Law Meaning as) to "Intent" Provision ! 'MERE COMBINATION'' NOT1IELD UNLAWFUL Department of Justice Wilt Continue Fight on Shoe Machinery Combine for Criminal Acts WASHINGTON". D. C, Feb. 3. The supreme court of the Unltcl States held in effect today for the first time that the Sherman anti-trust law does not forbid the mere combia lug of non compet'tors. The decision was given In the Shoe Machinery "trust " case In which S llcltor Bullitt for the government, contended that, if combination brought into one hand an "undue proportion" of trade, it was forbidden by the anti trust law. "The disintegration aimed at by statute does not extend to reducing all manufacturers to isolated un'.ts of the lowest degree," declared Justice Holmes, in announcing the unanlmo.is decision of the court, and that lho mere organization of the United Shoe Machinery company, by the heads ut several non competing sroups of Shoe manufacturers, has not tie)"n a Viola tloh of the law." The Justice, continuing, said that it was unlaw ful no more for one corpora tion to make ever part of a steam engine and put the machine togethc than it would be for one to make the boilers, and another the wheels In explanation of th.s concise state ment of the law, he referred to the court's iVcent Minnesota Creamery decision, the older. Swift & Company decision, in which the court held "that Intent'1 was necessary as an element to attempt to monopolize Bring r.g non competing branches into, juxta position alone by means of a corlora tlon. he said in substance, was not furnishing sufficient "intent" to rai3 the conduct to the dignity of an at tempt to monopolize. Despite todays decision, officials' of the riemrtment of Justice declared that the Shoe Machinery company will be tirosecnted for alleged criminal viola iIoii or the Sherman law under one of the remaining counts in the indict ments returned, the validity of whtn have been susta ned by the lower court. lfflGl REPORT Congressman Pujo Deserts Office for Secluded Work Shop WASHINGTON. D. C Fab. S. The house banking and curren-y committee is preparing to consider the report of that body on the mon ey trust, which Chairman Pujo, with the assistance of Samue! Untermyer, counsel of the Pujo sub-committee. Is now draftlns. A meeting of the full committee Is called for Wednesday to consider routine business and soon thereafter the committee wm uKe p the money trust reiort. It will be well toward the end of the ses s'.on before the report, with execu tive recommendations, will be work ed through the sub-committee and tne full committee of the house. Fu o has deserted his office and is working day and night framing his ....inn nt the report, which will em brace recommendations on the fol lowing principal poinis. nr,iTaion of stock exchanges through the post office department by forbidding the use of mails in trans jnttUng certain transactions deemed evil such as snort saies aim i"'"i" latlon to establish false values; rege latlon of clearing houses through an act making their incorporation a con dition to the precedent to member shin of national banks In such or ganizations; stringent provisions o t national banks loaning to of- Sr. or directors and to prevent banks and their officers from parti cipating in synaica. """"""'. "' new securities. Opposition Is Iook ed for from both the sub committee and the full committee to these rec ommendations. The proposlt on that will causa the most trouble. It is be- "Interlock- .laved. Is inai u .ic.ti Jng directorates" PUJO COMMITTEE IS SOCIETY TO TAKE HAND IN INAUGURAL . FUNCTIONS; 3IRS. CLAYTON PLAICES PLANS I in sssssssssssssssssssssssk s I dBsssssssKPnssBBss&dliUiE? SssssssBslsKSsKnBssssfiMlv'wPjHiHK u BslBssssVSHHMrCBK 'v''-. $SaBB lftsssssssssWHSBSKtt&2lEBsssKA4tHi mbssssssB9bvkS3K: ste1-.BBKI ssssssssssssssssreSsBSKssssxsxsssK Ssstii- 1" jE&Bi Mrs. Henry D. Clayton (at the left). and Mrs. M WSHINGTON Feb T -(Special.) -Women are going to play a bigger part this year than ever before in the ceremonies incident to the inaugura tion of Woodrow WlUon. Women of the solid, substantial kind, not of th turkey -trotting variety. Mrs. Leonard Wood, wife of tha army chief of staff who Is to com mand the mlli'nry end of the pa Ieantry. holds a high social position at the capital and will not be entirely in the background during the early days In March. Neither will Mrs William Corcoran Eustis, wife of the chairman of the inaugural committee, nor Mrs. Bldndgc Jordan, wife of the vice-chairman of the committee These CHEIflKtS UNDER FIRE: House Commitree Goes Into Details, Taking Up Many Items of Raw Materials FAVOR PREVIOUS BILL WASHINGTON. D. C Feb. 3. The chemical schedule of the tariff law. nrodiving 4 per cent of the total goernment revenue from customs. was considered in -executnc session by the democrats of the house com mittee on wave and mean today. Manv items were taken up regard ing raw materials used in the manu facture of medicines, paints, dyes, and in tanning, dying processes, coal tar products and the like. The schedule wm not ne material' ly altered from th democratic bill. t j. -1 lln lmtnA H ltct DAB. rfS" Ir. ole of 179To 127? when' present Governor Hanna, of Northi Dakota, was the only republican whol voted with the 'democrats for the measure. The revenue ot wim,w)J chine gun platoon of the Mntn ca--gnlned from the chemical schedule airy. The circumstances of the horal last year win. rot be substantially dls- j c,je -are to the effect that Griffin tnrbed SUICIDE FOLLOWS ATTEMPTED I Woman Physician IS Victim nf Insane an Fran- ot insane ran rran CISCO janitor SAN FRANCISCO. Cal . Feb. 3. ; Dr Madeline E. John, a physician,; m nunrfcpd in her office this after- noon by a man named Pntthlck, a dis charged Janitor, who attempted to cut her threat and then committed sui cide by cutting his own. rr lohn was taken to a private hoi - pltal. where it was said that sholchlnerv men, but no decision was mUht live I reached as to any of these contracts. There was a sucffle In the office,. The contract for feeding the prlson- tha noise of which reached the cor i ers in the county Jail at Tombstone ridors of the down town building where Dr John was a tenant The police were summoned 'and an offlcci gained entrance to the locked office by climbing through a transom. Gutthlck obtained nis position or the recommendation of Dr. John and county was awarded to the Tomb It is supposed that he attributed bis moos Prospector. The Job printing discharge to ter. No other motive U went partly to the Douclas Dispatch known. The man is thought to nave been insane. Miss Lucy Hoke Smith (top right) orris Sheppard. women as well as Mrs. Wood, arc of the socially elect. Chief among the women who arc booming things in the Wilson and .Marshall league is pretty little Mrs llenrv D. Clayton, wife of the repre sentative from Alabama. She is goin In strong on the league plans, -which Include baHs and parties and lunch eons and receptions preliminary and subsequent to the inauguration itself. Included In the "working list" for these affairs are Mrs. Morris. Sbe pard. Wife of the congressman from Texas who will soon be a senator; Miss Lucy and Miss Callle Hoke Smith, daughters of Senator and Mrs Smith of Georgia, and a lovely scjuad of debutantes and matrons MIDE5 FREE MURDER CUE Colored Trooper, of Ninth Cavalry Has Case Dis missed After Testimony Is Given bv State SELF DEFENSE IS PLEA TOMBSTONK, Feb. 3. In the su perior court today. John II. Landes, the colored sol Her who killed one of his comrades in Douglas two months ago. was discharged today af ter the evidence for the prosecution had been taken. District Attorney Gllmore was dls appointed In the testimony and when be found that it would not support a verdict of guilty, fie, promptly' moved a dismissal of "the case rather than to continue, what he considered fruitless, prosecution. a Both "Landes tud Wilbur C. Griffin, who'VjvS, Killed, belonged to the mi had provoked a difficulty which led to a general fight In one of the tents, in which Griffin was stabbed by Landes, the knife .entering- his brain throush the forehead. Landbs claimed ; that he was acting In serf nerecae. 1 The defense was conducted by J. IT. Kingsbury, of" Tombstone, and liar 'old Elliot, of Bisbee. both of whom t .. .,. .nnnlntail Kv the AllrT 4h H Ch. jfendant being without means Vhis -- tne firsl appearance of Mr. El- n a crlmina, and he M: for liome tonight highly elated over i the result. ' Board of Supervisors, The board of supervisors was la session today, their entire time being taken up In the consideration of bids - . for bridge building, for road construc tion macmncry. ooaruius pnauwere and public nrlUng. A treat number of bids were re , ceived from bridge builders and ma- was awaruea to air. tt.ucnenvi:.. The contract for publishing the proceedings of the board of sunerris ors was awarded to The Bisbee Dally Review, while the contract for pub- i Hshlng all other legal notices of the ana partly to me iuSia wkiw tlonal. mm is LOSER FOR SPEAKERSHIP Democrats in Peadlock for Manv Hours'Over Selec tion of Speaker for Special, Session Yesterdav. BRADNER FIFTEEN . SAME FOR LINNEY S'"ck Member Sends Word He Prefers Linney and Then Bradner Withdraws and Ends Hot Fight. (Special to The Rev'ewi PHOENIX. Fel. 3-Th special ses sion of the Arizona legislature was or ganized today after a hot and deter mined battle between the friends of the administration and those opposed to Sam Brjidner. the admin stration candidate fdr speaker of the lower house. J II I Inney. of Yavapai coun ty. was elected fter Ilradner withdrew from the conlest !n the democratic caucus whj' v n ijst night and con 1nued in ermittently unt'l today noon. There are 3t democrats In the house, but one of them, Mr. Moore of Man- copa. was unable to be present ow ing to the fact that he Is down with the measles. The caucus reached a deadlock with 15 otes for nradner and 15 for Linney, and it was not until Mr Moore, the sick member made known his desire to the cau cus, which wfi"thar Linney he elect ed that Hradner. seeing that ne could not be elected, withdrew f oin the contest, leaxing Linney as the jonly aspirent to be pjsented fcr speaker Governor Hunt presented his mes sage, which was read to the Joint session. The message. Is very lengthy and goes into the conditions of the state very thoroughly. M G CunltT was elected president of the council without opposit'on. He held this position during the former ses sions of the council and while there had been some talk that he mlgnt have oppositon for the position ,a ' thls session, none made its appear mce when the time came for action ANOTHER ACCOUNT PHOENIX. Anz Feb. 3. The third session of the 'irst state legislature convened shortly prior to noon today by election In the house of Linney, of Yavapai county speaker and con tinuance of Cum.T of Yavapai as president of the senate. The last l.anHxl body presumed that old offi cers should be continued and thert was little delay In beginning thel'l work. In the lower house however a twenty-four hour caucus left the demo crat majority that was present equal ly divided fifteen votes for Linney and a like number for Bradner with Cocke, of Maricopa, absent oa account of Illness. With this situation confronting them the representatives made their way to the capltol where a last et fort on the part of the Linney men secured the withdrawal of Bradner In the Interest of party harmony and Linney was chosen unanimously. It was' Ilradners Idea that a grave political error would be committed should the house temaln In p. wrangle over" the speakership until Cjocke. the . . t ,-.. i..J Dsem memoer migni reiurn, nevo his action In withdrawing. Prior to taking such action however .... n nrua mtOA T.V tha Vinirfnc ' " -" "-- -j . I States senators on vveanesuay. men to win the election ot Billy Gra- . ham, of Cochise, to the- speakership, gANTA FE, X. M.,Feb. 3. -The in but the- Linnoy mn were obstinate come tax amendment to the federal and won the 'day hater organlzaUon constitution passed the house under of the house was made complete J" 1 suspension of the rules today. The the election of Sweetllng. of Graham j measure wag previously adopted uy county, chief clerk and Bra wrier, of tne senate Maricopa, sergeant at arms $. In the senate Con Cronln, of SanU MURDERERS MUbT DIE ('rut county, was named secretary . and Joe "Wiley, of Pima, sergeant at, ALBANY. N. Y.. Feb. ;.- Four raw- arms. The clerkships will remain . .,.... .h.. . r.M.k am 1 aAaei.n Before adjourning for the day Gov - ernor Hunt's message was read In each house, an indisposition cf thelto extend clemency. - governor's throat preventing his read-i -1 ' infi the document to the joint session.! BIG CALGARY FIRE LOSS. TROUBLE AT PIONEER HOME PHOnNIX, Feb. S. A phone mes- packing plant, at Calgary. Alberta, for agi received hem tonight from ftijil days, beginning Jan. 12. did I'rescott, says trouble In the Pioneer jaio.OOO damage, according to the re home of a serious nature Is on. iort of the New York Fire Insurance Caldwell, superintendent, ousted, adjusters made public todar. from tne home an inmate nameo tfraa ley. of Clifton, for disobedience of or ders. On Sunday some six Instate of the home met Caldwell on the streets of Prescott and attacked him. KTKILWS TO COME TO SICKLES' REfeCJE General Ttautel R. Sleklea.,. Veterans, irem tne ranks of the northern and southern armies during the Civil War, their widows and chil dren, and rich men thtougtK-ut the country are xpected to cancel the debt between the state of New York and General Daniel K. Sickles which resulted in the aged eteran's arrest cuarscd with having dekOted i'iZAI'i of a monument fund to bis own use. Mrs. Helen U. Ixmgstreet. widow o! the famous general vho foi.ghl Sickles .n the war. has oluntereu to raise the needed amount from the ragged and maimed followers of Iee." u PRIVATE SECRETARY Many Urge Barrett, of Geor gia, for Secretary Agriculture TRENTON, N J., Feb. 3 Charles u. Helfner, of Seattle, former chair man of the democratic committee ct Washington, called on Wilscu today. "and d'scussed with him the Alaskm situation and conservation ollctes. Wilson said that Heifner's er and was chiefly to arrange Tor a confer ence on the subject to enter March 4, with a view to earry legislation Representatives Stanley, of Ken- ucky. Goodwin, of Arkansas. Calla- way. of Texas, Cibble. of Georgia and Russel of Missouri, urged the governor to appo'nt t S Barrett, of noon-la. iirsli!piit of the National Farmer's union, to the secreta ybhirl of agriculture Wilson announced today the sele--tlon of Joseph Patrick Tumulty o continue as his secretarv when he becomes president, but declared em phaticalh that he had arr ved at no decision as to other appointments Tumulty has been secretary to Wilson since the latter became gov ernor. NGOME TAX FAVORED BY THE LEGISLATURES New Merico Makes New Pro vision a Law Utah Sen ate Passes Measure SALT LAKE CITY. Utah, Feb. 3. The Vtah legislature, by a vote of 13 to -4, passed a resolution vtbls- aft ernoon ratlfyluz the amendment to the federal constitution providing for n 1rmt ta Tho hflllajv Tina n,lt I a 4H.WU.. tu.h. ..w .vuuv .. u .. . w 0 n,,, reSs0lutIon The senate agreed td vote on the i ,, f Mrrt olofltinn. of rnlted ' .... . I derers will pay the penalty lor tneir 1 I ( .. ,h). ,n,. Itlnw thfl H.'.al? 1 beginniiig Feb. 11. Governor Sulzera"""'1's- .announced today that he had refuseui WINNIPEG. Win, Can, Feb. 3. necessitating a call to the sheriff Jor bis protection. ter has com to the governor's. office, SMfe. "IP W II B B TURKS HUE Current Report Says That Porte Has Already Offered Surrender to the Balkan Terms. MEANTIME WORD IS GIVE NO QUARTER Turkish Delegate Declares Allies Have Greatly Under estimated the Strength of Their Opponents i CONSTANTINOPLE Turkey, (Mltl-i nieht) Feb. 3. It was announced of fit-'ally that hostilities began punc- zens of the United 'Statesswhethf tiully at 7 o'clock tonight, both at derived from xldle capital or in Jhg Adrlanople and at the Tchatalja lines.lcouduct of business, was ,'madeAfG1i U Adrlanople Uie allies opened a ' sUj1 today by .the ratification of the general bombardment. At Tchatalja I sixteenth amendment to the .fpdeml Insignificant fighting occurred. i i iic siuies oi leiuware, vv y online LONDON. England. Feb: 3. Tho'and New Mexico, by endorsing 19 Times says tliat the reirart is Cur-income tax amendment through their rent among some of the Balkan rep I respective legialatures, completed rcscntatives that the porte has a!.fle ' st oD thirty-eight states that ready .telegraphed to Sofia offerlne to'have ?pl'j;?-ed " two more than th cede Adrlanople on the conditions' lT f necary laid down nnd that Bulgaria is ready nnal a(,P"on to accent. The report cannot be con ' .,. , 5!!"p Be'?r J" -.-. linn pel at the Bulgarian legation here, hut Is not considered incredible LONDON". England. Feb. 3. The Balkan nar has been resumed. Thb bombardment of Adrlanople began at 7 o'clock tonight and a small skirmish occurred at the Tchatalja lines. Incomes below $4,000 or $3,000 ami The armistice lasted exactly two w'" Provide a tax of one peV cc.it months. Bulgaria turned a -deaf ear for ,h majority of personal incomes to the remonstrances o p powers which do not run to an excessive and unless Turkey . if Id 10 tne Bal- sure. kan demands the allied armies will I . SuPplant corporation Tax now attempt to drive her completely! An Informal notice of the final out of Furope adoption of the new amendment wai "., ,, . , , given the senate by Senator Brown,' According to a dispatch tonight of Nebraska, who introduced the dls from Belgrade. Scutari point Is fall-j CUS!jon in jgos upon which the pro Ing. It is rerorted that the Turkish. sa , tiio Inmim. tax m suhmit. commander sent two representatives to the Seyvian commander to pronosn the capitulation or that town. Dr. Daneff. head of the Bulgarian delegation, in an interview tonight in Paris said that he has promised Sir Edward Grey, British foreign secre tary", if the Turks immediately ac cepted the allies' conditions, they virould conclude peace, but that what ever happened theie would be no further armistice. Sir Grey had a long Interview to day with, the king, after. which he at. tended a .brief meeting of the ambas- sadorial conference at which nothing! ot importance was transacted mere being no new developments sinco Saturday. Osman Nizlm Pasha, second Turk ish delegate, will' leave tomorrow tn resume his ambassadorial dutlei at Berlin. He tald tonight that, from information received from military re sources, he believed the allies Iwd un derestimated tho condition of th9 Turkish army and that they would find themselves confronted with a re - doubtable enemy the bst MllMlll.t man warriors, including veteran? from Arabia, who fought under Izzey Boy, tried soldiers, good marksmen, and lately engaged In Tripoli under Knver Bey and Fethy Bey. He added that "the ambassadors were right who predicted that. If driven to de spair, the Turks would tight llKe wua CHINESE ALERT Raising War Fund Here and In Can ada to Oppose Russia. SAN FRANCISCO. Cal, Feb 3. A fund of $300,000 Is being raisd by Chinese In the United States and Canada and In a few weeks will ha sent to Wo Hun Mun, governor of the province of Canton. China, to outfit an army which Is to march from Pekln to protect point In Mongolia against the Russians. Already $25,000 has been subscribed by Chinese here. For Authorization of Law Under Which Incomes .of Individuals, Firms and Cor porations Will Be Reached RATIFICATION BY AN EASY MAJORITY Two More States ThnmNec essarv Have Accepted the Sixtieth Amendment-A'ast Increase in Revenues WASHINGTON, D. 4 C. I Direct taxes on the Itic'omos of oitl- 4 &pu. constitution. tonight that through this, an author ! Izatlon law. which will be passed to levy a tax upon American Income' w'll be Introduced as soon as the tra session opens. The exact term.? have not been decided upon, but H is Lelieved that they will exempt Oil teu to the states. The drafting of a b'll to put the tax into effect. It is expected, will fall to Representative Cordell Hull, of) Tennessee, a mem ber of the- house ways: and mean's committee, who drew Sup the excise tax bill proposed last year by the. democratic house, but which did not become a law The income tax will be designed to supplant the present corporation tax and will apply te tlra incomes of individuals, firms and corporations. In a statement tonight, Hull declared that he favored mak ing the new tax an integral part f the financial system of the umtJ stntoa. to remain in full foree wth OI,t regard to the character ot tarK bills that congress may enact Ire time to time. Would Bring $100,000X00 ' One feature, 'it is believed, that will be Included In the law- will he a provision for "collecting at the source of the Income." This feature, now In operation In Hngland. would require firms to certify the amounts paid in industrials, salaries and fees and niy the lax direct to th frwn-enl. It u:i!ci m" ! ic..,u-o much of the complaint which mlgfct . be made if the government had to in vestigate every individual ettteefl's income and would also prevent .eva sion of the law. The annaal amount' the government may reaitos under tlie income tax Is estimated kr democratic leaders at arWHiate ly $100,000,000 and would IweNde $30,000,000 collected under th H ent corporation tax. "One of tw hn- portant results of the incow tax,"' said Hull, "will be the carfctug of " necessary federal expenditure. When a great part of the gevertHUtn(1i In Come is derived direct froni a tax or ' tho citizens of the nation. thy W scrutinize more carefully f aro pt latlon of congress." Official Announcement It will probably remain tor Prel dent-elect Wilson to maki the BK cldl announcement of tho .iirw tux amendment to the constitution Ufc to date the state department k-?s re ceived notices of approval by tfie lg islatnrcd of only 34 states. r t