0 I HAPPl I IF IT T I THE SALT LAKE HERALD HERALDEstablished D WEATHER LAST LASI FOR EDITION EDITIONWEATHER EDrr SALT o oHAPPl LAKE LAKISPartly LAKEIT
I IT 1 ff > HERALDiopper Partly Cloudy CI0 or Y noIlbly Snow SnowSliver Feasibly Rain Rainor RalnU
U r JJ il J l Sliver Wo G Q Dee ounce ounceCopper ounceJIIJ
i1 17ERALO JIIJ 1 L D S Copper oQvune caseins ca6t1 I57ic per pound poundLead pountro pOUn
Lead in ore JS60 50 New York 5b 5bn 5bEsta 513
n Established Esta hshed June 16 6 1870 SALT LAKE CITY CITYlJTAH UTAH iTjfBAY F RDSX wAY ro NOVEMBER NOTE mER 17 I I90p L9O t Price live Cents 4
ODELL ODELLAND AND DEPEW DEPEWALSO DEPEWALSOIJENY ALSO ALSODENY ALSODENY
DENY HYDESSTATEMENT HYDESSTATEMENTFormer
Former FormerGovernor Governor Calls Upon theAlmighty as His HisWitness HisWitness HisWitness
Witness WitnessSenator WitnessI WitnessSenator WitnessSonator
I
Senator Gives His Version of Various Shady Transactions TransactionsHeretofore TranslctionsHeretofore TransactionsHeretofore
Heretofore Brought Out in the Testimony TestimonyMinor TestimonyMinorEquitable TestimonyMinorEquitable Minor MinorEquitable
Equitable Employes Examined
lI EV E YORK Nov 16 ICFormer Former Gov Govcrnor Go GornOl GovI
N I 4 crnor Benjamin B B Odell Ode jr and andUHit an anrult andvnlt1
UHit vnlt1 p Status Stat u Senator C M 0 De Deli DelI ¬
li 1 v W as wltnetwea wltn before the Armstrong ArmstrongI
I 2 rtislutive inaumncd 1nve 1nveilUgatlng Ugating com comimttif rom rom31Itttft con3uttit I
imttif today denied dent parts part ot the tes testimony t ttiltltlllY testiWI13 ¬
timony of Jam James H Hyde in which whichtin whichtitir I
tin tIir ir nameti were used Mr Odell in inti InHI htVh
ti foume of hia teutlmony called 1ied rMr rMrHMCK 111JI Ir
HMCK JI 1 litS iL statenietitK statem llUl uba bant calumny l and andin andIIIn andiLLt
in IIIn u he was Wa asked whether he direct director 1 1fll
or indirectly ind trectly had made threats tht > a t8 to toV toiV
iV V the eliart einutr r l of the Mercantile Mercantilerixust tercaptller I
rixust r r1 ust company COflifl revoked his face faciaJushed faceshed faceVshed
Jushed shed and striking etrtktn the arm of the thevtneas thetlH8 thethn
vtneas tlH8 chair with his h h4 fist fl t he ex extji exI cxI
tji I I 11 lined linedThere ttedThtre II ed edTlwlC
There is no truth in that statement statementiv statementIwln tatemeat1IIi
iv hH me God GodMr GodIr GodMr
Mr Ir Odell odd was wa the first witness of the theIk thei
< i > < > Ik I It said no political pressure was wasi ra rat
1 i Ught to bear in I the settlement of his hist hhI
I t it 11 against the Mercantile Trust com comiy comIV cornI
I iy and that Uu It was settled ettl l he same samesuilH m muih n1e n1eutti
suilH uih brought by b others lIe said he her het1
r ill I been bee advised by counsel that his hisiJitm hishim hisliim
him was a just one and that any anyutt Itn Itnun anyOFt
> OFt would have awarded him more morethiu moretll morelii
thiu tll q ho received le eled in the settlement settlementKnew settlementKnew settlementKncw
Knew of the Ambler Bill BillII BillI
II I knew of the introduction Int1O uctJOtt of the theAmbler themblfr thetinbler
Ambler bill which it is i said might mightluiYt mightIlW mIghtIhLVt
luiYt affected the Mercantile Trust com com1unys comlqnys cornI
1unys I tfly charter and while blle he did not notjUff notfU notuggtt
fU jUff uggtt t < 8t its Introduction he saw no ob obdf objfdillu ohjitiiiit
df jfdillu tioii to it itMr ItMr
Mr 11 Odell denied that he h ever made madestatement madestatment madeNtaternent
< statement to B 1 H Harriman or any anyii a1YIlk
Ilk ii iit t cisc > ise that retaliatory measures measurftstUld meaaiUrest measuresUld
t tUld Uld be b e taken against the th Mercantile Mercantileinpauy rerantnet
t Hli inpauy pal1Y The witness said he and Mr MrIlitrrimau MrHalTlman iIrJitrrimair
Ilitrrimau w we re peroonal nal friends but buttiuit butthft buttu
tiuit they the hud no business relations reilltionatJI
31 wrote rote a letter on behalf of Mr MrHvdes ohI Mrir
Hvdes I dtN candidacy for the post of am amliisudor Ilmhl Uflltjdor
liisudor hl udor to Franc This was ftS at the theJ thellullIt the1U4
J llullIt tjuist 1U4 st of O Wllliain H Mcintyre one of oftli ortl1 of11k
tli vlte ke presidents of the Equitable EquitableIIf TquItableIift
IIf > Assurance A Rur I1Ce society societyMr soclet societyMiS
Mr 11 Odell Odd said LII he had never solicited solicitedpolitical solicitedJII
JII r political Ii i if teal < al contributions but possibly possiblyiunif pouibltiU1P poesiblyt
iunif t iill moneys might h have ve come to him himthrough himthrough himthruugh
through the national committee < or ornator 011 011natot orkruttov
nator Thomas C Platt as the latt latter latterA r rliaa
A liaa Jlfl utt always irattMnd nd together the funds fundsJii tundJII
r Jii N Ntw tW u York state except in the last laatypir lastt
ypir 3011 t r
Depews Testimony Testimonynutor Testi mony monyIIltor I
nutor Beijew was wa examined e mll1fd with withJ wHhtrll withtrl
J > sjml trll to his h syndicate sy 4lcate partkli participation participationI1ht > atlon atloniii
iii > his duties as counsel tn the Equit Equitable ElultIhl Etiultsociety ¬
able Ihl society Regarding the Rmbwssa ambMaaItrhlJ ambtesaih Rmbwssaiiship
ih iiship iship to Parts Semttor 5fl lltor Depew 1f said saidTuliniue saiditr hl hlTr
itr Tr Hde came to him and solicited his lals1lllIttwe
Tuliniue 1 1 tiie to secure the appointment appointmentiator
iator ITenevr brouxfit tn the matter tter to toit totd toatteltUOfi
it attention of the president although althouhtold althoughtId
1 told Mr Hyde that he h wa wae II too tooJuiig Jand teiIig
Juiig iIig and the president ent said It was wasiif w WI
I iif It irly rly impossible iauPQ8 lble to make such an a aIf aItIfl p pMiunent I
If MiunentTlu Miunent 1lI1pntTh ItIfl flt fltTIu
Tlu senator advocated adv04ate In the inLeT inLeTS Int I
s of u t the public pblc the limiting UrlUnK of in inMjitii 11 inI
Mjitii f1jltle I t t < e risks rik and nd favored flore a public publi au auiir aUI aUIH anir
iir H of r th the
uiounts uunt fltIfl of comrmnies omWnl at atitl att11 att4J
itl ieriodh ltrlodt by a I chartered chaterei account accountini acount accountThis
ini 1 This he thought UOUCf would wld obviate obviateviany obvate obvateiY obviatel
viany l iY Il suits sui that tht are a n now w W fuetl frequently frequentlyULtht friii ntly
IiUfrht 11 ULtht ht for an accounting ac mtu on the part partC prt prtL
C 1 d i i policy polcl > holder holderHowThey hler hlerHow hoMerHowThey
HowThey How They Worked It ItThn I ItT
Jhl Thn T hI OtlchriHt al btt In charge of the then the1itV sA sAv
v anty n ty department 11tpment of the Equitable Euitble Life Lifeniranre Li LiteI
I niranre llunt society Ill told of millions millU of ofiirs ofL I
iirs L trs in loans ln made mae at the end of the thel
l iy i in the th names nme8 of clerks elera of Kuhn Kuhnb I
I b t Co Co to comply ctnply with wih the law lawv 11
v t the t ht HMrpluc rlu should huld be b Invested Invete or ort ort I
t > kep kp down the cash eh balances b e No Notrilateral No11tt9Ui
trilateral ltnll wa al held htld by the Equitable Equitablei Equitble Equitblet I
< > i these t loans lonl and the check chk which was I
I 11 4 M by h ¼ the Equitable Equiable on these the lotms lotmsiuat ldns Ins Ins1t lu
iuat llt 1t the tht check chek which whlCh was given en for forthose fort fortis I
those t tis hfst loans were deposited depied In the bank bankMid bnk bankfi
Mid t it fi a L tmlfleate f1If te of 01 deposit dtlt received receivedTi relved relvedlt receivedili I
Ti lt < check thtk however was wa never er cleared eIcredt clearediind 1e
iind t IHI on the first ft of the year ye the check checkvould cltek checkold
vould nuld old be b taken tken out and the t certificate certificateFurrrmlered erUdcte erUdctef11Ttller eerthlcteiirrndere4 I
Furrrmlered f11Ttller These Tbee loans lon were t1 made at attin a atnstance
tin instance of T D
li Jordan Jor former formeriuptroller forr formerttuptroller
iuptroller ttilptroler < > of the Equitable EquitableODELL Euitable EuitableODELL iquItableODELL I
ODELL AND DEPEW DEPEWSmirched DEPEWSmirched DEPEWSmirched
Smirched Officials Before the Inves Investlgatlni I InvestlJatIni nves nvestgatnl
tlgatlni tgatnl Committee Committeev CommItee CommIteeXfW
XfW cw > v York Yor Nov No 16 1B D R Odell OtI jr jr1111Twr Jr11leC
1111Twr ftmci 11leC governor gOfn of New York and ad at atrrrsent atJlfstnt atprfsnt
rrrsent Jlfstnt chairman lharman of the state Republi Republiu Reubl
c 4tfl II u < omnttn mn He r was 8 the first fnt witness witnesslfor fq i iI
I lflr f re the Insurance Ir < rne investigating inMl Ung cent eomTuiitee tnt tntrdltf centYuUti I
Tuiitee YuUti today Before
his
rdltf toay Betor testimony testimonyi lstlon lstlona
a i > begun Samuel Unttrmyer
begu Smuel UntttmYtr coun counei cunI eeocfor
> ei I for James Jaes H Hyde H yde d entered an ob obItion obition ohj
j Ition tion protesting Jrt ln < against aint the Investl Investlaioui I investia MU
< aioui a 1 i IOJt of the thf affairs atlr of the th United rnitedats nite I
suites s ats 1 h Shipbuilding hlpbujdln company by the thevumroittee tbe1Imltf theTflflittf
vumroittee vumroitteeMr 1Imltf Tflflittf TflflittfMr cmpny
Mr Ir Hughes Hupe counsel Nun l to the commit committ Cmmlt Cmmltl
t e began by b asking aln ask1n Mr Odell Odtl to tell tel i ih I
1 h > facts pettaining Ifln to the Mercantile
Tmst Tlst compqtoy om Oflpiy charter chae and MerntU witness witnessuiI wltnt witnessiL I
uiI iL he > would wo ld prefer rerer to tell ttl of the tbevh the1tl
vh I hl l transaction trcton leading leig up u to the theFttlpment th thettIinent tb
Fttlpment if rrmltted rrmlttedUntermyer pnnltf penflittedUntermyer
Untermyer Protested ProtestedMr
Mr Ir ITntermyer tnteryer protested prtpted that tat It the theCommittee theIlmite thetumittee
Committee Ilmite permitted rmltt this thi it would wold take takethem tke tkethm takethni
them far outside outade the legitimate legtmte 1 lne ne of ofiMquIry othquhT ofiiquiry
iMquIry Senator Setor Armstrong Arsrnl referral rferred referredti referralthe
the Hi ti protest protMt to Mr Hughes Hu he who ho said he heHould heouh heuli
Hould ouh uli call Mr Ir Odells OfUs attention atentin to t the theia thejt
ia jt t that the matter l1t4r which whith concern concernthe concernstin m mtw
the tw committee omndtP is h simply am ply the question questionv qUNtJ questionwitther
v nether ld1r there tlre was as any political pltcal intlu intlufne influffltP j
fne Iwe or pressure prMUI brought brusht to bear 1r upon upont
t he h Mercantile eta nUlp Trust Tul company cmpny directly directlyor dlrftl upn upnt Y
or < I Indirectly Indirtt to t induce Indue a settlement settlementThere settlementThere tlnlent tlnlenther
There her was wa wa not Raid Id Mr r Odell OdellWill Oel Odellwill II III
Will Wi you state 8tt governor JVen1r said Id Mr MrHughes r rJught rhughes
Hughes Jught whether you had hd any ay Inf Info Infonaton Infornation or ornation
naton nation with regard reaan to the introduction introductionf trtin I
f a a bill bi in the tb senate ste for the th purpose purposef PW
f repealing rilalng the charter che of the Mercan Mercantile Xercn Xercntih Mercantiit ¬
tile Trust Tru t company companyKnew cpn cpnKnew companyKnew
Knew of the Bill BUII Bil
I knew of It at the the time tm yes yesWho yesho a aWho
Who ho advised advis von of it itI I itr itrI
I knew of It before bor Ita It introduction introductionFrom ltuJ httreduet1ottFrom
mation mationOh maUonHQh matlonoh From Frm whom whm did d you yu get a et your ur Inter Information laOt laOtmaUon Intermatlon ¬
HQh Oh various varus people pple as to the proprie propriety prpr ¬
ty of the Introduction of such
Intrutin o sch a I mans measure mansure ¬
ure
ureDid rf
Did you ou suggest II get its It introduction introductionNo mtrueton1
No NoDid NoDld NoDid
Did you yourequot tU r rI It Its tnrodtiun tnrodtiunsaw thUr
I saw sw no 1 objection oltln to tot it itDid ItDid
uDld Did you stele a that tht ya yeg aw nw w so J e ob objection QbjfUon ohjoction ¬
measure measureAt meaure meaureAt jection jfUon to t the t introduction Intduo of o th thmeasure the themeaure themeasure
At the time Um it was w mentioned IM1 I Idid Idid Idid
did yes yesTo yesTo B
To 10 whom
His Memory Bad BadOh BadOh BadOh
Oh to any alY lute Hl > ne who asked aiktd me I Ihave Ibae Ihave
have forgotten forgottenWhat forstII forstIIJ forgottig
What was fhi tn Krouiil JIUd tor that ac action a aton aeJon ¬
g J Jon ton of approval approva
Simply because boaus the scandal sandal incident incidentto
to the shipbuilding hlp utdln trust was upper uppermost uppormOt uppermost ¬
most mOt in the peoples poplt mind mint and itwas itwasclaimed it itwasclaimed was waschdme
claimed chdme that tbat the Mercantile Mercante Trust com company comIM1 coinpatty ¬
patty IM1 had been ben behind fifteen ffeen or sixteen sixteencorporations slxteoncOlprton sixteencorioretIons
corporations cOlprton every eel one of them had hadbeen badbeen hadbeen
been insolvent and it was time tme I Ithought Ithought Ithought
thought such matters In tho state of ofNew ofNow ofNew
New York should shoul be stopped stoppedWhile stoppedWhHe stoppedWhile
While Mr lr Odell Od < 1 was testifying testfying Sen Senator Senator Seaator ¬
ator Denew Denw entered the room roomContinuing roomontlnuln roomContInuln
Continuing ontlnuln Mr h Odell OdeJ said the bill billwas bl billwa
was wa u introduced Introuced to provide for fO an inves investigation h1es h1estpton investigHtioli ¬
tigation tpton of the Mercantile Mercante Trust com company comHe corntinny ¬
tinny He could culd not recall rea1 that ho had hadan hadan hadan
an Interview with wih Assemblyman Asemblyan ombIyman Pish Pishwith Fshwith Fsliwith
with regard to the Introduction Introducton in the theassembly thelnbly theassembly
assembly lnbly rogar of a bill bi similar sImiar to Senator SenatorAmblers SenatorAmblers SenatorAmblers
Amblers repeal r pol bill bi His only inter interview Intorl interview ¬
view l W with wih Senator Senaor Ambler Ambllr about the thebill thebl thebill
bill bl was W8 wasafter after Arer i It had bean Introduced IntroducedSuit IntroducedSuit introducedSuit
Suit Was Brought BroughtAt
At that time tmo he had no suit pending pendingagaiast l1endlnga pendingagaInst
agaInst a hl the Mercantile Mer anU Trust rust company companyHI companyHII companyHis
HI His suit was brought in August 1904 1904When 190When 1904Whep
When the bill bi was Introduced in March March1woI
1604 1 0 the witness witnes said sid he still had every everydollars everydoUa everydollars
dollars doUa worth of his shipbuilding shipbuiding hold holdings boldInJ holdlogs ¬
logs InJ These The holdings were sold at auc auction aUclon auction ¬
tion lon and Ind brought brou ht 43687 against 164
171 11 paid Ial for them Since their sale wit witness wltnc witnose ¬
ness nc had had no interest in the ship shipbuilding shlpbulhlng shiphuilding ¬
building bulhlng company conpn The sale sle was made madebecause madebecause
because buse he felt fI that there would be bematters bematters
matters mater of legislation le islaton come up affect affecting afect afectInC affectIn ¬
InC In shipbuilding shipbuiding affairs afair and he felt feltthrft fel felttlit
thrft tutt the governor should not be inter interested intereted intereSte4l ¬
ested eted directly dreUy or indirectly Indirecty in the thebonds thebnd thebonds
bonds bnd He contemplated d bringing an anaction anHctitn
action acton against the Mercantile Mercantle Trust Trustcompany Trustcompy Trustcompany
company in August 1904 He had no nointerview noIntolle nointerview
compy interview with Ith J P Morgan regarding regardinghis rigarding rigardingkf
his kf shipbuilding claim but did 1d have havewith haewih havewith
with wih Charles Charle M L Schwab His inter interview interview interview ¬
view with wih Mr r Schwab was when the thecompany thocmpny thecompany
company cmpny was WiS in the hands of a re receiver rcc receiver ¬
ceiver c lnl S
Made No Threats ThreatsDid ThreatsOld
Did you make any an statement to any anybody alY alYby anybody ¬
body In tho city of New York that re retaliatory retlator retailatory ¬
by cty
taliatory tlator measures mesure of any an kind would wouldbe wouldbe wouldbe
be taken asked uke Mr r Hughes HughesNever HughesNeve HughesNever
Never NeverThat Neve NeverThat
That hat any measures mesure threatening the theMercantile theMercntie theMercantile
Mercantile Mercntie Trust company compn or 01 any anyone one oneelse Oneehae I
else e8 would be taken tko if you OU claim claim was wasnot wasnt wasnot
not nt settled settledNever itt settledNever
Never NeverHe Neve NeverHe
He never nEWtI made any such statement statementto
to Mr I 1 arrlman alhnn nor nol did he ever have haveany havean haveany
any an interview Intrview with Mr Harriman Harrinul in inwhich Inwhich inwhich
which it i was wal suggested that Harriman Harrlmanshould Harrimanshould Harrimansliouid
should UP u use his hi influence to urocure a asettlement aHttfment asettlement
settlement Httfment of witness wlt6 claim against aslna a ainhit the theMercantile theMerCnte theMercantile
Mercantile MerCnte Trust cetnimny cetnimnyThen l6m coinnyThien n nh
Then h s Mid i id Mr Hughes Hughe 1 under undersUt underyo undersstlMI4l
stlMI4l sUt d yoi yo yOIr r testimony titf fa is that you s ou nevec nevecdirectly ne nedhty nevordirectly
directly dhty or ind indllUY indlreetiy mly used use awy aU nias threat threatto tllet tlletW
to procure re a s jt sgtlmnetI ttil leu went qt q thfet suit suitNo sult1No suIt2No
No NoVap ajr ajrWas r 1 1 1Wu
Was the legislation legilatl which h111 WAS S pro prooosd proD propos
oosd pos d by Senator Satm Ambler mblet in any way waya
a D topic to of conversation conelton when hen the set settlement settement settiement ¬
tlement tement of your suit sui came up upNever upNever upNever
Never Excepting ExceptingYes ExceptingYeshNeer Yes YesNever
Never excepting exc exceptingyes ptnges yes when I had u utalk utalk atalk
talk with wih Mr r Hyde he spoke of it i and andI
I told him no n matter mater what the outcome outcomeof
of o our settlement might be whether I Ishould Ishould Ishould
stement
should go O into the courts ourt or the case caseshould ca cashould easeshould
should be bf settled sUI < by b the Mercantile MercantileTrust oercante I ITrut ITrust
Trust company opny that there there was no fear fearof fer ferof fearof
of retaliatory rtalton legislation legislationHad legislationHad legislationTIed
Had anything occurred occurrl to change changeyour changeour changeyOU
your our mind as to the propriety of the theintroduction theIntructin theintroduction
introduction Intructin of such measures measuresYe msure measuresYes
uYe Ye Yes sir si The fact f t that the base basecalumny baseclumny basecalumny
calumny clumny which hlrh Mr Ir Hyde uttered uttere here herehas her herhaR herohas
has been btn circuated CJcut in the papers P11ers and andT 1 1I
I called cale Senator Ambler in and I said saidthat sid sidtbat saidthat
that as desirable delrhlp as al I believe beleve the leg legislation legl8atln legislatlon ¬
islation l8atln i feared teretl that my 1y unfortunate unfortunateconnection unfortunateconnecton unfortunateconnection
connection connecton with Itli the shipbuilding shipbuiding mat matter ma nutttar ¬
tar was of such luch a character harcter that it itwould i Itwould
would woul be b better beter for him to drop dro this thislegislation thislldaUn thislegislation
legislation lldaUn That Tlu Interview took place placesome placeSme placeseine
some Sme time tme during the legislative legislate ses session 5essl sessloit ¬
sion sl of 1194 1194Interviews n nInte 1e4Interviews
Interviews Inte views With Colby ColbyMr Colbyr ColbyMr
Mr r Odell Oel then made IDde a statement sttement in inwhich inhl inwhich
which hl he told at some sme length of the theInterviews theItervltwl theIntervIews
Itervltwl Interviews of olonel Colby of Hydes Hydescounsel HydesMunl Hydescounsel
counsel Munl and James Jame H Hyde with re regard reInl regard ¬
gard Inl to the suit sui against aglnst the Mercantile MercantileTrust MercantileTrust ercrte ercrteTtu
Trust Ttu t company NnMUY Mr 01 Odell Ole1 said sid that thatMr thatIr thatMr
Mr Ir Colby Colb first ftt called aBe upon him after afterthe nfer nferthe afterthe
the cult ult was instituted Instuted in August 1904 1904and 11 1904and
and asked a ke him him to drop out Mr r Odell Odelldeclined Odtl Odolldeellned
declined d lne In the following fonoin month E H HHarriinan HHarrima ITIIarriinan
Harriinan Harrima told Mr 11 Odell Odel the witness witnesssaid wine witnesssaid
said ld that Mr r Hyde was anxious to tosettle totlf tosettle
settle tlf the suit But Air r Harriman sum summoned summone sumiflonod ¬
moned mone Mr t Hvde and Mr r Hyde and andOdell andOdel andOde
Odell Odel Ode went into a private room rom and andtalked audtalk apdtalked
talked talk it I over Mr 1 Odell said sid that Mr MrHyde MrHyde 1 1Hle
Hyde told him hlol the suit was 8S distaste distasteful distasteful Ustfte Ustfteful ¬
ful that he had been in the habit of ofcontributing ofcontlbuUn ofcontributing
contlbuUn contributing to the campaign cam l n commit committees committ8 commitHe ¬
tees t8 He also aI said si that Mr 1 Odells ad administration adminirtin administration ¬
minirtin ministration as chairman hahIDn of the state statecommittee statecnnlft stateemnnilttee
committee cnnlft was antagonistic antagonistc to him himHyde blmHydE himFlyde
Hyde Hydetr HydE FlydeMr
> Mr tr r Odell Oen said sid he replied repled that he heknew hekew heknew
kew knew nothing nothl about abt contributions contributons by bythe b bthe bithe
the insuranre Inlurnr companies ompnle and that thft I Ihad Ihad Ihad
had never directly dSret or indirectly ifdirect solici solicited slc cohicitd ¬
te ted a I subscription 1ublrJpton from the Equitable EquitableLife EQult1 Equittble141Cc ble bleIlfe
Life or any an other insurance company companym compny compnyi
m i ii the state tte of New W York YOk or in any anyother anvothr anyother
othr politics loIUcs other place plae during my connection conneton with withpolitics wih wihloIUcs withlGlitks
Had Heard From Platt PlattMr Plat Platlr PlattMr I Ito
Mr lr Odell Oen here interjected a remark remarkto
to the th committee eomlttee that he had hfd hoard hoardfrom hCrd hCrdfm heardfrom
fm from from Senator Smtor Platt that Mr Ir Hyde hart hartmade hnclmRdt badmade
mRdt made political piUl contributions iontrlbuUons but he heOdell heOdel heOdd
Odell Odel Odd told toll Hyde that his suit sui was wasaeporate waRfprate wasseparate
separate fprate from th political oUiel aspect a Jct and andthat andthat andthat
that if Hyde could culd not nt settle sette it i he hewould heoul hewould
would oul take tke it to t the courts courtsMr courts courtsMr
Mr 1 Odell Oel then ttn said Mi Mr oi Hyde called calledIn cUed
In Mr > 1 Colby who wh said si he was consider cnstderI ctmsiderInn i itag
tag I bID bringing a libel Jbl suit sui against aginst Mr MrOdell MrOdehl I I
Odell Oel for his hi complaint Cmllalnt and allegation allegationf aUe nton ntonor
or f fraud frud There Th re was no settlement settlementthen settement settementth settlementth
th then
th thIn i
In L the next ne t month after af or the election electionMr eleton eletonMr electionMr
Mr Odell Oel said gJc he again aC8lnlnet met Mr 111 Hyde HydeMid Hdead Hydeand
Mid ad Air 11 Colby in the Metropolitan Metropolan club clubby clubby clubby
by appointment appintmet and ad one on of them said saidlie snldl saidlie
l lie was anxious anxlul to settle stte the suit sui and androulrt andould andwould
would meet met Mr r Odell half way They Theynsked The Theaske Theyasked
asked aske the thf amount amunt of o his loss lo and told toldMm toldhim toldhim
him he had sold sld his bonds nt price pricelower pricelower pricelower
lower than they were than selling at atto ntto atto
to which Mr Odell replied that he hud hudlone hud110ne hadlOfle
lone so because b u e he did not want to toIwve tohave
have 1 ve any connection with the company
during his hi term as s governor At their theirHiggestioti thOl1IUcgestion theireugestioii
Higgestioti Mr Odell waived the loss lossda losshe lossho
da had sustained by sailing his bonds bondshastily bondshutUy bondshastily
hastily and either Mr Ir Hyde or Mr Mr2olby 111Colby MrColby
Colby offered to settle s ttJe the suit by b pay payment pa pament payment ¬
ment of ayWO Mr Odell stood out for for7SQ00
7SQ00 71 Thojf The reached reachedno no conclusion at atthat atthat atthat
that interview but a tow wees later Mr MrLhat Mrthat Mrthat
that inttrvfew inttr l but a fewlweeiks few hveeks later laterMr laterMr laterMr
Mr Odell received a chock for OJ 76000 76000The 76000The 7000The
The settlement of that suit suJ said saidContinued saidContinued < l lContinued
Continued on Page aDc 2
MCLELLAN MCLELLANALSO MCLELLANALSOMAKfNG ALSO ALSOMAKING ALSOMAKING
MAKING GAINS GAINSTwo
Two T Hundred Votes in OneDistric OneDistricNot On One District DistrictNot DistrictNot
Not Counted Co ntedforthet for the Mayor MayorDISAPPEARANCE MayorDISAPPEARANCE yor yorDISAPPEARANCE
DISAPPEARANCE OF KRU KRUINDICTED KRUP KRUPINDICTED KRUPINDICTED
INDICTED MAN FAILED TO AP APPEAR APPEAR 1 1PEAR
PEAR PEAR IN COURT COURTNEW COURTI URT URTNEW
I EW YORK Nov No IG ljThI9rJ Tjie original originaltally lnnl lnnltally
NEW 1 tally sheets sh ta In New CV w Yorks Yorks racentmtuoralt recent raeenimayoralty recentmayoralty
mayoralty election wore opened op ncd today loday to tPday ¬
day by tho board of county canvassers canvassersW eapvasserw
W V R Hearsts lawyers protested pt toeted eight eightof eightof eightof
of the first thirteen sheets taken from froirthe fromthe fromthe
the envelope because they the were found fountto foundto
to differ from the returns on which th thcount thcount tbcount
count electing Mr McClellan were werebased werebased verebased
based In one election district Mr MrHearst MrHearst 11 11Hearst
Hearst was found to have seven more morevotes morcvotes morevotes
votes than wore counted for him and li lianother In Inanother inanother
another the tally t Uy sheets showed thai thaitwentynine thnttwentnlne thattwentynine
twentynine votes were erp r mlsslriff from froirtho fromtho fromtho
tho published count Comparisons wow wowconfined woloeconftned woreconhined
confined to the votes cast for mayor mayorcomptroller m mayorcomptroller or orcomptroUer
comptroller and president of the t e board boartof boardof
of aldermen aldermenGain aldermenGain I IGain
Gain for McClellan McClellanIn
In one election district of Queons Queonscounty Queonscounty Queenscounty
county the board of canvassers found foundthat foundthat fQufldthat
that McClellan received 200 votes less lestthan lessthan lessthan
than he should have had hadOne hadcleclIon hindOne
One election districttho district tho Twelfth ol oltho or oftim
tho Second Assembly district in which whichWliiiam vhicliWilliam
William T Jerome wasnot was not credited creditedwith creditedwith
with a single vote ot was discovered dur during durlug ¬
the investigation today According Accordingto ccordlng ccordlngto
to the tally sheet of ofthts this district < Mr MrJerome tr trJerome r rJerome
Jerome received 57 votes but he was wascredited wascredited wascredited
credited with none noneThe noneThe noneThe
The board had decided not to Include Includethe Includethe includethe
the Jerome votes in the canvass bulhis but buthis buthis
his attorney requested that the office officeof officeof officeof
of district attorney be included Inclu cd and andsecured andsecured andsecured
secured an order from tho supreme supremecourt supremecourt
court to show cause tomorrow why this thisshould thisshould
should not be don doneGave donGave donGave
Gave Leg Bail BallA BailA BailA
A A sensation was created in Justice JusticeDavys JusticeDays JusticeDavys
Davys branch of the supreme court courtthis courtthis courtthis
this afternoon when hien John Krup in indicted indicted indieted ¬
dicted for Illegal me al voting in the recent iecentmunicipal rcentmunicipal recentmunicipal
municipal election failed to appear for forpleading forpleading forpleading
pleading and his attorneys expressed expressedIgnorance expressedIgnomnce expressedignorance
Ignorance as to his whereabouts whcreu out Ear Earlier Earlier Ear11cr ¬
lier in the day da Krups release had been beensecured beensecured beensecured
secured under Increased bail bailState banState bailState
State Attorney General Mayer Ma r who whowas whowas whowas
was in court was Indignant at the turn turnof tUt tUtor turdof
of affairs Tonight the attorney general generalmade generalmade generalmade
made public this statement statementEvery staU statementEvery ment mentuEor
uEor Every effort will be made to ascer ascertain ascertain ascerthin ¬
tain who put up the tle 55000 bail and andwho andwho andwho
who employed counsel tp defend Krup KrupThe KrupThe KrupThe
The failure of Krup to appear in court courtwas courtwas courtwas
was a flagrant defiance of law as I Iever Ieer Iever
ever heard of The he disappearance of ofKrup ofKrup ofKrup
Krup is the best confirmation of the thestatement thestatement thestatement
statement by me in court urging that thathis thathis thathis
his bail bo increased I believe there therewere therewere therewere
were reasons apart from reasons of his hisown hisown hisown
own why wh Krup did not appear appearBail appeatBail appearBail
Bail Declared Forfeited ForfeitedJustice ForfeitedJustice ForfeitedJustice
Justice Davy declared deelar d the 5000 Ooo bail ballforfeited bailforfeltf bailforteite4
forfeited d Krupscase Krup rose wals w reached re ehed at tt t tocloQk
2 ocloQk but at the request of counsel counselwa COUUsflWp counselvas
Wp wa vas postponed tponad for Hit hour At 3 oeloak oeloakthere oelookthere oeIoolcthere
there was still no signof Ign of tile defend defendant defendant defendant ¬
ant His lawyers Abraham Levy and andFormer andFormer andFormer
Former Deputy Attorney General GeneralCharles GeneralChatl GeneralCharles
Charles Chatl s P Dillon said they had left lefthim lefthIm lefthim
him but a short time before and he had hadassured hadassured hadassured
assured them them that he would be In court courtAttorney courtAttorney courtAttorney
Attorney General Mayer moving for a aforfeiture aforteiture aforfeiture
forfeiture of ball declared he was not notsurprised notsurprised notsurprised
surprised at the turn of affairs affairsIf affalrflJ
If this defendant has left town de declared declared dedared ¬
clared the attorney attorne general I know knowwith knowwith knowwith
with whom he was last seen and will willknow willknow willknow
know how to proceed I thought some somebody somebod3 sonicbody ¬
body must have been greatly interested interestedin
in Krup to put up 5000 bail for him himjust himjust himjust
just to secure his liberty Jtbert for a few fewhours fewhours fewhours
hours hoursCANVASS hoursCANVASS
II IICANVASS
CANVASS IS FINISHED FINISHEDCity
City Council Completes Its Work on onthe onthe onthe
the Returns ReturnsNo No Essen Essential Essential Esseittial ¬
tial Changes ChangesWithout ChangesWithout ChangesWithout
Without discovering sufficient errors errorsto errorsto errorsto
to affect the mmlts of tho election as asannounced asannounced asannounced
announced the following day da the city citycouncil citycouncil citycouncil
council completed the canvass of the thoreturns thereturns thereturns
returns last night Official totals on onthe onthe onthe
the canvass will be submitted su mltted to the thecouncil theouncH thecouncil
council at its meeting Monday night nightCity nightCft nightCity
City Cft Recorder J S Critchlows force forcewill forcewill forcewill
will compute the totals by the use of ofadding oradding ofadding
adding machines 5 beginning the work worktoday worltoda worktoday
today todayThe toda todarhe todayThe
The Third and Fifth municipal wards wardswere wtrtlswere wardswere
were canvassed last night ute work workoccupying wo workoccupying k koccupring
occupying but an hour lio and a half Tha Thareturns Ph9retUllts rhoreturns
returns from those wards were in ex excellent t x xceHent xcellent ¬
cellent shape as a rule and required requiredbut requiredbut d dbut
but little study studyIn stud studIn
In the Twentyeighth Twent eJghth the vote on onBrough onBrough onBrough
Brough was corrected to read 103 10 in instead Instood instead ¬
stead of 1S 1SIn 7SIn S SIn
In the Thirtieth Holloys vote ote was wasmade wasmnde wasmade
made 132 13 instead of 131 Wolsten Wolstenholmes Wolstenliolmes Volstenbolmos
holmes 70 instead of o 71 1 Parrys 149 la lastead Instood iiistead
stead of 150 150In 150In 150In
In the Thirtyfirst Thtrt th8t Swensojfs vote votewas yotewas votewas
was made 76 instead of 78 Vigils VIg > SO in instead instend instend ¬
stend of 82 Parrys SI instead of S7 S7The 87The SiThe
The Thirtysecond Thlrt seconcl was badly messed messedup
up although the errors wore not notgreat notgreat notgreat
great asx as a rule Morris rrls vote was wasmade wasnu wasmade
nu made de 152 instead of 120 Lynchs 123 in instead instead instead ¬
stead of 113 Critchlows 136 Instead of of12S ofUS of1S
12S Buckwalters 136 instead of 113 113Moretons 113Moretons 113Moretons
Moretons 70 instead of 08 Bramels 135 135instead 135Instead 135Instead
instead of 12S Hutchlnsons Hutchln ns 137 Instead Insteadof
of 113 Hiles 70 instead of 69 Caines CalneslaG
135 instead of 12S Beetles 138 Instead Insteadof
of 113 Swensons 71instead 71 Inst d of 69 Cun Cunninghams Cunninghams un unningharns ¬
ninghams 135 instead of 128 Vigus 13C 13Cinstead 13GInstead 136instead
instead of 113 AlJTs 70 Instead In8t ftcJ of 09 09Holleys 09Honeys 69Holleys
Holleys 143 Instead of 12S 128 Callisters
129 instead of 113 Wolstenholmes 71 71instead 71Instead 71instead
instead of 611 Fernstroms Ijffi instead insteadof
of 128 1 Parrys P rrls 134 instead In lead of ofl1 113 and andBrousrhs antIBroughs andBrougbs
Brousrhs 73 Instead of 71 71In 71In 71In
In the Thirtythird Benlles vote was waschanged waschan waschanged
changed chan ed from from 189 to 17 17In i iIn 7 7In
In the Twentyfourth Twentyrou h Critchlows Critchlowsvote Crftchlowvote Criteblowsvote
vote was corrected fo e iead 101 1 168 68 Instead Insteadof
of 65 an evident eld ftt typographical t3fU rapllical error errorthat erro errothat errorthat
that had already betfti a1 lakgn into ac acfount aerOUlH account
fount BramoJs vote was reduced from front16S
168 to 167 167Lynch 161Lnch 167Lynch
Lynch lost one i fa th thhht tIme Thirtyfifth Thirtyfifthdropping ftfth ftfthdropping tIm tImdropping
dropping from 135 13 to 1U 1UIn 114In 1LIn
In the Fortyfourth Thompsons vote votewas voteas ote otewas
was as changed han ed from 341 to tot2 2 B Beaties Beatiesflom Beatiesfrom aties atiesfrom
from 85 to 36 Vlgus from 83 to 84 Alffs Alffsfrom Alf Alffrom Alffsfrom
from 242 to 343 43 3 Bowers from J02 to 108 108In 109In IOLIn
In the Fortyfifth FOJty firh Moreton was given givenIi
172 instead of 171 Swenson 174 Instead Insteadof
of 175 Bower Bow r jiG instead of 119 119In 119In 119In
In the Fortyninth Swenson was giv given gol golen given ¬
en 224 instead of 237 Black 2S 1 instead insteadof
of 237 Bowor 110 instead of 117 117In 117In 117In
In the FIfMoth Lynch was wu given 63 63Instead 63Instead 63instead
Instead of S3 Beatie 64 instead Int insteadof teado of 60 60In 60In 60In
In the th > Fiftysecond Fifty socond Swenson Son on was wasgiven WtiSgiven wasgiven
given 182 instead of ISO AUf 1S3 15 instead insteadof insteado1159
o1159 of ISO
ur urCAUCUSES
CAUCUSES CALLED CALLEDWashington CALLEDWashlngtoll CALLEDWashington
Washington Nov 16 l6The The Republi Republians Itepublicans epubUcans
cans ans and Democrats of the house of ofepresentatives ofrepresentaUv ofrepresentatives
representatives 8 have each cala calillfl a cau cauus caucus caiiaug
cus us for the nomination of officers ott cors of the thoouso
ouso Tin Th Democrats will III caucus on onho onWI onthe
WI ho afternoonof or Saturday Dep D 2 and andho andt andthe
t the ho ORepnbllc Republicans JtepubhIcanI1vthpffiuIQ nSlntJ1 lvLifofyi Pftl1ClJllQ of that that3uy thatday thatday
day both ta InthehIDVheh the theh11Zjbe hifH MbeliOuse b lIsc
< >
THE HOUSE OF MIRTH MIRTHNo
No 616 Madison AvenueAlbany N Y Where Life Insurance Lobbyists aiid Iibers oULegis1ative Iii Iiisurance
surance Committees Mingled
j
c
A I
ERS I E EHtiiC
HtiiC POLICy
wry
p
I I
I
jq jqf
ii4j ii4jr
f
r = =
C CsoME =
soME O1 S zr zrI fJ I >
III
I C1 II
9 9a
ii iiHERZbo a
t f1 11 11HYDl
HERZbo htiE htiEriti
HYDl
I I1S 11 11I
riti TrtgV 1 I
11h
I
NavE E7 iffo Ltt a7
t MILIoI ti ILcO h 4 4IiISE 4I
IiISE IiISEi s
J
i
J
o c
I i Delter Donterlost Post
IDAHO OFFICIAL OFFICIALLOSES OFFICIALLOSES OFFICIALLOSES
LOSES HIS JOB JOBJohn
I
t
John B West Removed as Register Registerof Reg1steof
of lewiston Land Office OfficeCHARGES OfficeCHARGES OfficeCHARGES
CHARGES WERE NUMEROUS NUMEROUSDELINQUENTS NUMEROUSI NUMEROUSDELINQUENTS
DELINQUENTS SUCCESSOR NOT NOTYET NO NOYET NOTYET
I
YET NAMED NAMEDy NAM NAMEDfThIi4fINCJTON ED
ISjla tP JIr JIrf
f fThIi4fINCJTON tAj SiiI TON Nov l lgJohizY Jolm D DI BV
y VV V AVost register of the Lewiston Lewistonland LewlstonInQd Lewlatonland
I land office IdahQ was removed removedfrom lcmovedfrom removedfrom
from office today Oda by President Roose Roosevelt RooseI ¬
I velt for speculating in relinquish relinquishments rehnquishments relinquIshments
ments undue political activity etc etcNo etcNo etcNo
No successor has yet et been chosen chosenCharges chosenCharges chosenCharges
Charges were preferred against West Westsome WestSome Vestsome
some time ago alleging that he was wasmaking wasmaking wasmaking
making improper use of his office and andparticipating andparticipating andparticipating
participating too freely leel in politics politicsNumerous politicsNumerous politicsNumerous
Numerous Charges ChargesNumerous ChargesXumerous ChargesNumerous
Numerous Xumerous specifications were ere sub submitted submltted submitted ¬
mitted charging that West e8t aided by byhis b bI
I his brother had induced settlers to tomake tomake tomake
make filings on lands which had pre previously previously previously ¬
viously been entered by b other oth i persons personfiThey personsThey personsThey
They then induced settlers to Institute Instituterontests InstituteContests institutetontests
Contests before the Lewiston land of office office offlee ¬
fice and immediately entered into ne negotiations negotiations negotiaions ¬
gotiations with 1th parties to the contest contestpersuading contestpersuading contestpersuading
persuading one or the other to make re rellnquishment ielinquishinient I
llnquishment Whenever they the secured secureda
a relinquishment the West brothers col collected collected collected ¬ I
lected money mone from the successful succ ssful con contestant contestant contostant ¬
testant testantIn tostantIn
In brief West was using his office a aregister ai airegster aregister
register to give him power to bring bringabout btlngabout bringabout
about relinquishments in contests contestswhich contestswhich contestswhich
which he and his brother had planned plannedand plnnnedI plannedand
and was making considerable money moneyon
on tho side by b this practice practiceProved practiceProved practiceProved
I
Proved It on Him HimWhen Himhen HimWhen
When hen the charges were sent nl him himWest 111mVest himWest
West made a sweeping denial but two twoinvestigations toimcstlgatlons twoinvestigations
investigations wore made by Special SpecialAgent SpecialAgcnt SpecialAgent
Agent Goodwin and Inspector 1nsp ctor OPallon OPallonwhich OFalJonwhich OFallonwhich
which sustained the charges cha1g fl and on oni ontheir ontheir
i their recommendations recommends tlomis endorsed by byLand byLand byLand
Land Commissioner Richards and Sec Secretary So Soretao Seerotary ¬
rotary Hitchcock West est was summarily summarilyremoved summarilYremoed summarilyremoved
removed removedI remoedSenatol removedSenator
I Senator Heyburn will probably pr bobh be re requested re requested requested ¬
quested to recommend a successor to toVest toVest i iWest
Vest Meanwhile until the vacancy vacancyis vaC n nIs
is filled tho Lewiston land landOfilce Ofllce must mustremain i iremain
remain virtually closed save for receipt receiptof I
of papers papersMARRY papersIMARRYFAR papersIMARRYFAR
IMARRYFAR MARRY FAR FROM FR M HOME HOMEI
I Well Known Salt Lake Couple Take TakeOut TakeLicense TakeOut I
Out License to Vied in inChicago inChicago I
Chicago ChicagoSpecial ChicagoSpecial
Special to The Herald HeraldChicago HeraldChicago
I I
Chicago 111 Nov 16 16atthew Matthew Cul Cullen Cullen Culhen
len and Mrs lr5 Nellie T Rasche both of ofSalt ofSalt
Salt Lake City Utah took out a nar narriaeg Uprrlaeg ntttrrineg I
riaeg license in this thi city Jty today tOda They Theycould Theycould
could not be found at atany any of the hotels hotelswhon liotehitwhen I j jwhen
when sought later ami for this reason roasonit
it is not known whether hotll r the marriage marriageceremony marriageceremony
I ceremony took place placeBoth placeI I I
1 Both Mr Cullen and Mrs rs Rasche ar aN arewell I Iwall I
wall W ln < known in this city Mrs 115 Nellie NellieThomas NellieThomas NellIeThomas
Thomas Rasche is a sister of the first firstMrs firstMts J
Mrs hs Cullen who wh died several years yearsago yearsago efi1 efi111go
ago She has made her home In the theCullen theCulleri
Cullen family since the death of her hersister hersister hersister I
sister and has filled the place of a amother amother amother
mother to the orphart children childrenMatthew chihirenf
f 1 Matthew Cullen is wall known kp wn all allover alloer allover
over the west He made his fortune fortunein
in the Horn Silver mine in Beaver Beavercounty BCflercounty Beavercounty
county He was one of the th original originalowners orlglnalowners originalownets
owners of the property It Mas a in inBeaver 111Beaver InBeaver
Beaver county also that he met the theyoung theyoung I Ioung
young woman who afterward became becamehis becamehis
his wife He is the owner of the Cul Cullen Cullen Cullen ¬
len hotel property and has ha many other otherlarge otherIlrgQ otherlarge
large interests both here and in Chi Chicago Chicago Cliicago ¬
cago i iAPPEAL
I
APPEAL APPEALISDENIED APPEALISDENIEDSacramento IS DENIED DENIEDSacramento E IED IEDSacramento
Sacramento Gal Nov No 16 16Harl 16HarlBunkors 16HarryBunkers Harry HarryBunkers
Bunkers the former San Francjgco Franc Francmco co sen senator seaatom I Iator
ator convicted last April by a Jury jur in inJudge InJUdge inJudge
Judge E C Harts department depart 1ont of the thesuptome thesupome
I suptome supome court for for bribery and san sentenced sanI sonteneeti ¬ I
lanced to Jive years cars Imprisonment t at atSan atSan atSan
I San Quentln Quentlnn1ust must serve the sentence sentenceimposed flonlencoIml1Psed sontencoimposed
imposed ticgordfne uc iording to a decisionluuid decisionluuidnd d dt4Ion toJll hand h1ndnd handed
nd down d owntoday today by tho appolljato uppal1 oput oputdenying QOlurJ aqi aqiI
I denying t the he exlegislators et legislator s aSnVfliIte a aeq 1lip ro roI
1 < i t > v >
trIal
I a now
DOCTORS DISAGREE AS TO THE CAUSE CAUSEDeath CAUSEDeath
Death of R R1 A AI Roth at Cody Wyo a Mystery MysteryStomach Stomach and andKidneys andKidn andKItheys
Kidneys Kidn ys Sent to Chicago for Examination Examinationby I
S by Experts 1 I 1I
Special to The Herald HeraldQDY HeraldC t tCODY
I Ithat
QDY Wyo Nov 16 16It It develops developsthat developsthat
CODY C that the physicians Who ho conducted conductedtho I Itho
tho autopsy at tops on tho remains of R RA HItoth
A Roth the business man who died diedsuddenly dieddenl diedsuddenly
suddenly denl Sunday evening and who is issupposed ispposed istipposed
supposed pposed to have been drugged could couldnot couldot
I
not ot agree reC in their findings and the theatomach theWloma thestomach
stomach Wloma eh and kidneys have ha e been b cen sent sentt
I
t Chicago Clicq for forexpert or expertexamination e pert xfmlnJtton pffc pffcWkj d dnpct j
npct Wkj Wkjwith 9 9fq UjWsdIan IIMIJ IIMIJJwu ipInodjdettch
dettch with Jwu was due to t Ji Jiiittb 1M ia 4Rli JUS Jjo JjointO
intO htt the stomach stom ch an anequally and two others othersequally Wme Wmeequally
equally certain that Brights disease diseasecaused d disesecaused e ecaused
caused death deathGirls deathGirls deathGirls
Girls No Longer Suspected SuspectedThe Su pected pectedThe
The authorities have exonerated the theMisses theMisses I
Misses Hielda Ahlstrom Ah strom and Mary ar Ra Raner Hamier
nero the waitresses es who accompanied accompaniedRoth
Roth into the country on olla a carriage carriagedrive carrlQgedriv carriagedrive
drive from all blnmo blame for it has de developed deeloped ¬ j jeloped
eloped that they the went ent with him Sat Saturday Satl1rday Saturday ¬
urday and not Sunday Sunda as first sup supposed supposed supposed ¬
posed The girls did not see him again againafter againafler againafter
after their return from the country countrySaturday countr countrSaturdu countrySaturday
Saturday afternoon Roth was about abouttown abouttown abouttown
town Saturday evening and retired to tohis tohis tohis
his room over his saloon about al ut mid ¬
night He appeared to be well and was wasill wasiii
ill h an especially jovial frame of mind mindIt
It Is learned that the authorities now nowfeel nowfeel nowfeel
feel certain that Roths death was wascaused wascaused
caused by b the jedlousy jel loU y of a woman womanwith womanwith womanwith
with whom he had been keeping com company comJ cornpony ¬
pony J IIn Roth had a number uumh > r of women womenfriends womenfriends
friends and the authorities are yet ot un uncertain Uncertain ¬
certain which one to suspect suspectVisited SUSpetVisIted
Visited by Unknown U known Woman Womanilt WomanI
ilt 1 1It is claimed tajnu l that an unknown wo wojm w wYJslt woivsrniisIted
jm ivsrniisIted fciyiaUtHl YJslt d RotJjs room Sometimebo sornetiniebodi1hhr4 Sometimebotaraeip
t taraeip l mjanigh di1hhr4 tni hl1 JM6 6 a ftm m njait3 aj an 0 that thatthis tlratthta thitthis
this woman wOInim administered the i dlugtnat dlugtnatcaused dtU iftf1 lriat lriatused t
caused used death It is said the jealousy jealousywas jea10UsW Jealousyws
was W aroused by Roths attentions to tothe totime I
the thenan Ran Ranr i and Ahlstrom girls and oth other 0thcc ¬
er worn omen en A man has been found who whoclaims whoeJahns I
claims he saw sa a veiled and cloaked wo woman wornan woman ¬
man come from Roths rooms about 3 3oclock 3ocIok
oclock oco k Sunday morning morningWhen morningYhen morningWhen
When friends frlen S of Roth found him himSunday himSunda3 himsunday
Sunday noon ho was unconscious and andunable andunable
unable to talk He died shortly shortlyafter shortlyaftera after
5 a oclock that evening eveningThe eveningThe
The authorities are saying little about aboutthe aboutthe
the matter but until the th report of the theChcago theChlago theThcago I
Chcago chemists is received two or orthree orthree
three women who ho were classed as asRoths asRoths asRoths
Roths warmest female friends will be beclosely i
closely rio ly watched wa hIud
SITUATION IS FULL OF GREAT PROMISE PROMISEGovernor PROMISEI PROM1SEGovernor
I
I IGovernor
t
Governor Folk Says the Reform Movement Mov ment Will Gather Strength Strengthas
as the Years Go by and That the Reign of ofGraft ofGran ofGraft
Graft Has Ended
I
I AXSAS CITY Nov 16 lItEdward lItEdwardUosQwatol 10EdwardF1 Edward EdwardRosawater
KANSAS K F1 Rosawater editor C itOl of the Omaha OmahaBee OmahaBee OmahaBee
Bee and an Governor Joseph W Folk Folkof Folkof Folkof
of Missouri were the guests of honor honorat honorat I Iat
at thomonthly the monthly dinner here tonight of oftho oftho ofthe
tho Knife and Fork club clubGovernor dubGovern clubCovernor
Governor Govern 01 Folk in the course of his hisspeech hissneclm I ISIJeech
speech said saIdTIme i iThe i irhe
The next few years lmrs will iii be distin di distlnguished llnI llnIutshcd j jgulshed
gulshed utshcd as a the time in which industrial industrialproblems i iproblems i
problems are settled tho reign of spec specfal specmi j
I fal l privileges being beh g brought to an end endthe endthe I
the doctrine of o equal rights fixed in na natlonnl na1 i
tlonnl policies and in the conscience I ience of ofmankind i imankind ImankJnd
mankind We rC t are in the midst of f the theJilOSt I I Imost
most drastic period of American his history hilitor lilatory
tory tor the period in which hlch the peoples peoplesrights j
rights are to be defined and observed observedas j jas I Ias
as they the have never been before The Themon I Imon 1men
mon who share in these activities in a acapacity a1 a1capaclt acapncity
capacity no matter how humble are aretaking aretaking aretaking
taking part in the tremendous moral moralupheavals mornlupheaals moralupheavals
upheavals now going on onPromise onPromise a I IPro1lise
Promise of Better BetterThings BetterThingsThere Things ThingsThere j jThere
There have h o been great reform move moveipents j jments
ments in the days gone by b but they theywere the thewere theywere
were local the vampires ampire of graft were weredriven weredriven weredriven
driven away and remained but a sea ¬
son and then returned after the waves wavesof wan5of wavesof
of public indignation had spent their theirfury tItelrfur theirfUry
fury fur The present PIf 91ltprsents presents a situation situationof
of brighter promises to our vision Re Reform TIef81m Refmmn ¬
form shows signs of becoming univer universal unlers4il universal ¬
sal instead of local and transitory transitor The Therevolt Ther80It Therevolt
revolt from political lloJitl al oppression is rear rearing rearIng reambig ¬
ing its tt head in city cit after city clt and state stateafter stateuttel stateafter
after st tate te A civic regeneration is go goI golu golug
I lu lug g on all oet the land Will it last lasti lastis
i is the question Will TfJI not the people peoplesoou p Peoplesoon ple
soon 5 forget f rget and an ant allow things to con continue contiDue eontinue ¬
tinue In the same old way wa I answer answernp answerno
np Revolutions never gox go backwards backwardsand
and this is a revolution rQIUtion that has Im been beenbrought beenbrought beenbrought
brought in the conscience of men menMovement menMovement menMovement
Movement Has Just Begun BegunWe BegunWe BegunWTe
We are at the beginning of the themovement thfrmQEtuent tImemQvernent
movement for higher ideals in our life lifewhich litewhich lifewhich
which will gather pt er strength as the years yearsSD yearsgp etIR etIRgn
SD by The elections of last week were werebut werebut werebut
but the taking of the first breastworks breastworksof
of the opposition he e fight will go on onwith onwith onwith
with unvoasing vigor vl or and the time will willnever willneel ivillnever
never come when the people can rest on ontheir ontteh ontieir
their arms In idleness idlenessThe IdlenessThe IdlenessThe
The moral Idea in politics has come cometo cometo cometo
to stay sta This waye of the patriotism patriotismof
of peace will go on with increasing
force
SMOOTS BLUNOER FATAL FATALSpecial fATALSpecIal FATALSpecial
Special to The Herald HeraldWashington lIerldWashington HeraldWashington
Washington Nov oY 16 161n In an interview today Senator Burrows chair chairman ehairnltlJ chairnina ¬
man of the privileges and elections committee says sa 1 11 the case of Senator SenatorSraoot SenatorSinoot
Sraoot will not be taken up U before the holiday recess rc but will be given givenprompt gIenPompt givenlwompt
prompt consideration when the senate reconvenes reconvenestn In January Janu 1 It is im imHossjbje lmloS tinioble
Hossjbje loS Qle to tell when wh n the report will wiJbe b be made bect1u becauga further evidence is isto Isto iste
to he ue heard and It is believed in Washington that testimony detrimental detrimentaltoiSmooC detrimentalto
toiSmooC to t Smoor will be offered In liberal dos dOIf There wIll wlllprobnbl probably be a re reqe re reQe1i9 reQelkp
qe Qe1i9 of the late campaign campal n in Salt Lake ke and Smsota connection connectlon with withmunicipal withmu1cipal withnuilciaI
municipal campaigns Is Relieved to have ha6greaU greatly weakened his case cas before beforetl beforetile
tl t1t tile k senate nnt
OREGON MAN KILLS KILLSHIMSELF KILLSI
I HIMSELF IN OGDEN OGDENSpecial OGDENSpecial OGDENSpecial
Special to The Herald HeraldOgden HeraldOgden HeraldOgden
Ogden Nov No 16 16H H T McMahon of ofOntario ofOpfarlo ofOptario
Ontario Ore blew his brains out at atthe atthe atthe
the Boluringer rooming hbuse about 1 1oclock 1oclock Ioclock
oclock this morning by shooting him himself himSelf himself ¬
self in the left temple while lying in inbed Inbed inbed
bed The shot was heard by b the land landlady landlad landlady ¬
lady lad who summoned M C McMahon McMahona
a brother of the suicide The man was wasdead wasdead wasdead
dead when they entered the room Mc McMahon McMahion Ic IcItlhon ¬
Mahon was wai about BO years of age and andcame andcame anticame
came to Ogderi Ogd yesterday morning ac accompanied accompanied uccompanhid ¬
companied by his brother presumably presumablyfrom presu presumablyfrom nably nablyfrom
from Salt Lake No cause could be befound befound befound
found for the rush deed From letters lettersthat lettersthat lettersthat
that McMahon wrqte wrltebOOrctuklng before taking his hisjltlt
jltlt Is evident that the bUloldc was wasto was4tlr44tlly
4tlr44tlly fJ1lb planned He wasAmL ftSLnm1ber ftSLnm1bero muQJuber muQJuber1Tbe
to o 1Tbe U I O O Y li No o iio o or Ontarlo
Ore and one of the letters that he heIdft helaCt lieleft
left vas addressed to the local lodge of ofthat ofthot ottlrnt
that order in which he enclosed a draft draftfor draftfor draftfor
for fllO 160 and request that his remains be beshipped beshlPlOO beshipped
shipped to his 11l Homo HomoPLATT 110moPLATT HomePLAIT
PLATT IS MOVINGTO MOVINGTODITCH MOVINGTODITCH MOVINGTODITCH
DITCH THE TH GOVERNOR GOVERNORNew
New York Nov XO IGUI 16 I am going to toremain toremain toremain
remain the chairman of the Republi Republican ¬
can state committee declared cx exGovernor cxGovernoJ cxGovernor
Governor Odell tonight when shown shownthe shownthq shownthe
the dispatch from Washington In which whichSenator whichSenator whichSenator
Senator Platt was quoted quotedSenator quotedSonator quotedSenator
Senator Platt returned to this city citytoday tItywdn citytoday
today wdn but again declined to be Inter Interviewed Interviewed interviewed ¬
viewed ft was said however that he hehad h hbUd hehad
had sent sen t out ou a number 1l 1bOJ of letters lelto ts to toWiem to10Wh loloqa
10Wh loqa Leubliiin1i1ers 11b q n I dolS suyn sayIng le lieat
J 11 JJt1 f1l fA 8 Wiem ern at qt his l QfUcftns QftiC QMc 11 as S SenJYW1
enJYW1 9 YP l
WA WAY CLEARED FOR FORMOFFAT FORMOFFAT FORMOFFAT
MOFFAT ROAD ROADDepartment R ROADDepartment AD ADpepRrtmcnt
Department of Justice Abandons AbandonsFight AbaudonsFight AbandonsTight
Fight for Gore Canyon CanyonWORK CallyonWORK CanyonWORK
WORK IS TO BE CROWDED CROWDEDCONTRACTS CROWDEDCONTRACTS CROWDEDCONTRACTS
CONTRACTS WILL BE LET ON ONTOWARD ONTOWARD ONTOWARD
TOWARD SALT LAKE LAKESpecial LAK LAKSpecial LAKESpecial
Special to TJ thIs > HemWi HemWiASIUNGTON 11141WASIIINGTOX 110MMASIJINGTON
ASIUNGTON D Crt C Nov K 1CTb 1CTbMoffat Tb TbMoffat
WASIIINGTOX W Moffat railroad nUroadbNawoP rtkilroad hap hAWOii woo Its lt t fight ftsktfor fightfor
4 for Gore canyon Attorney Gen Genem Genaial
8181 em Moody ooll has deckled deeMed to dron the caws cawsagairt lUCa easeadst
agairt a atBt them and the ro road d from Den Dento Denynr Denynrto c cto
to Salt Lake can be constructed a as or originftlly orbIIfIIY originjtJly
iginftlly ulanned lllmnedGotlQ plannedGore ulannedQova
Gore canyon will not beoccupied be upied by bytho byho byhio
tho ho government as s an irrigation irrlnt on mace reservoir reaervoll macevolt ¬
volt site This decision is announced announcedtlio nnoupcedthe
the department of justice today and it itIs itIs itis
Is the understanding of all government governmentofllciala governmentofficials < oemment oemmentoOlels
officials that this ends the controversy controversyover controveuoer
over Gore canyon canyonThis ean canyonThis on onThis
This being b lng the case it will not notneCCo be benecessary beneeessnmy
necessary neCCo > S8rl for the Colorado and Utah Utahdelegations Utahdelegations Utahdelegations
delegations to introduce legislation in inthe Inthe inthe
the coming congress giving the Moffat Moffatroad Moffatroad offat offatroad
road the right of way through Gore Gorecanyon Goreeatnon Gorecanyon
canyon It Is barely possible pot lble that Cal California alcornla al alJfornia ¬
ifornia interests intere tg may bring brln < pressure to tobear tobeat tobent
bear on the attorney general with the thehope thehope thehope
hope of inducing his to reopen the case caseand caseand use I Iand
and compel the Moflfat road to vacate vacateGore vacateGore ftcateGore
Gore canyon but it notthe not the attorney attorneygenerals attornegcnarfis attorneygenerals
generals purpose to take t ke such action actionas a tlon tlonMi
as he has said the Moffat road has full fullright tulltlIht fullright
right to occupy this canyon with its itsroad itsro itsroad
road ro and he believes the reclamation reclamationservice reclamatfonIlerlce reclamationservIce
service is not entitled to drive the rail railroad railroad railroad ¬
road out outThis outThl outThIs
This decision is a Hat turndown urn tiown for forSecretary forSecrctal3 forSecretary
Secretary of the Interior Ethati Alien AlienHitchcock AllenH1tchcocl AlienHitchcock
Hitchcock who has shown s own intense intenseprejudice intenileprejudice intenseprejudice
prejudice against the railroad from the thestart thestart thestart
start and who has done all in his hispower hispower hispowei
power to make the railroad build bul1 < l to tosuit tosuit tosuit
suit the convenience of the reclamation reclamationservice reclamationservice reclamationservice
service
WILL PUSH WORK WORKMoffat WORKMoffat WORKMoffat
Moffat Gives Orders to Go Ahead AheadWith AheadWith AheadWith
With Contracts ContractsDenver ContractsDenver ContractsDenver
Denver Colo Nov Xo 1C 16lelegrams 16lelegramswere 16TelegramsVCl0 Telegrams Telegramswere
were received rec < ind in this city yesterday in indicating Indicating indicating ¬
dicating that all opposition to the Mof Moffat Moffat Melfat
fat road running through the Gore can canyon canyon canyon ¬
yon had been abandoned One was to toCharles toChnrles toCharles
Charles J Hughes jr who represents representsthe
the railroad from his legal correspond correspondent corre pond pondent ¬
ent at Washington informing him that thatthe thatthe thatthe
the department of justice had aban abandoned abandoned abandoned ¬
doned the Gpre canyon litigation litigationFollowing litigationFollowing litigationFollowing
Following this William A Deuel Deuelgeneral Deuelgeneral Deuelgeneral
general superintendent of the Moffat Moffatroad Moffatroad Motfatroad
road received a telegram from David DavidIT
IT Moffat now in New York to release releasethe relea8ethe releasethe
the suspended contracts on the big tun tunnel tunnel tunliel ¬
nel through the mountains and push pushoperations pushouor pushoperations
ouor operations tlons from both botl1e1id ends eidsHITCHCQCKISINDIGNANT f fHITCHCOCK
HITCHCOCK HITCHCQCKISINDIGNANT HITCHCQCKISINDIGNANTTPullishment IS INDIGNANT INDIGNANTPunishment INDIGNANJPullis1iment
Punishment of Nebraska Land Grab Grabbers Grabbers Grabbers ¬
bers Much Toe Light Accord According According According ¬
ing to the Secretary SecretaryWashington Secretaryu SecretaryWashington
Washington u ihlngton Nov 0 16 Secretary SecretaryHitchcock SecletalHitchcock SecretaryHitchcock
Hitchcock was today todo unofficially In Informed infornied ¬
formed that in the matter of the pros prosecution prosecution prosecution ¬
ecution of Bartlett Richards and W V G GComstock GComstock GCornstock
Comstock in the federal court at Oma Omaha Omaha Omaha ¬
ha for the illegal fencing fen ln of 212008 212008acres 1OOOacres 10Oacres
acres of government land upon plead pleading plOlidIn pleadlug ¬
lug In guilty the defendants had been beensentenced beennlenced beensentenced
sentenced to remain for six hours in inthe Inthe inthe
the custody of the United States mar marshal marshal maralmal ¬
shal and pay pa a fine of 300 390 1i each eachYou eachYou eachYoti
You cansay can saY said the secretary secr Lar in indiscussing indiIWussing indiscussing
discussing the verdict that I am sur surprised surprised ur urpristd ¬
prised and indignant The punishment punishmentis I Iis Iis
is utterly inadequate The indictment indictmentwas
was the result of four years of deter determined detetmined determined ¬
mined effort and the expenditure of ofthousands orthousands ofthousaiids
thousands of dollars by b the depart department department departneat ¬
ment We Ye had selected the large oper operators operators operators ¬
ators in the hope that the result would wouldbe wouldbe ould ouldbe
be a warning to those engaged on a asmaller astnnJJCI asmaller
smaller scale That the case was a astrong astrong astrong
strong one is evident by the fact that thatthe thatthe thatthe
the men pleaded guilty The result is isdiscouraging Isdseouraging
dseouraging but we shall not cease ceaseour C6 ceaseour ge geour
our efforts effortsOmaha effottsOmahel effomtsOmalma
Omaha Nov No 18 1ftSpeakln Speaking of the theAssociated
Associated Press dispatch to the effect effectthat effectthat effectthat
that Secretary Hitchcock of th the interior interiordepartment
department was surprised and indig indignant Indignant indlgnant ¬
nant on account of the 380 fine and andsixhour andsixhoUl andsixbout
sixhour sentence passed upon Bartlett BartlettRichards BoaUettflicimards tJett tJettTIIhards
Richards and William C Comstock for forenclosing torenclosing forenclosing
enclosing 212000 l OOO acres of government governmentland lovernmentland
land Judge Ju lte Monger who imposed ed the thesentence theSEntence thesemtezice
sentence in federal court said saidI
I think the result which hich the govern governI
I think the result which hi h the govern government go rn rnment ¬ I Iment
ment hoped to attain has ha been effected effectedThe effectedThe
The indictments and the prosecution prosecutionwere tO > eCutionwere
were primarily for the purpose e of caus causing ca cads cadsins s ¬
ing the men to abandon their unlawful unlawfulfences
fences The inclosing of the public publicdomain liublicdomain
domain is not a crime per se It is isnothing
more than a statutory offense offenseIn
In view of this fact and of the audi additional auditional ¬
tional fact f3 t that the defendants declared declaredthat
that they had removed their unlawful unlawfulfences unlawfulfences unlawfulfences
fences In part and avowed their intent intentof
of taking down any fence fencea which hlb might mightstill mi mightstill ht htIItm
still remain on government land I be believe beJieve ¬
lieve the sentence passed upon them themwas themwas
was sufficient to meet the situation situationWhen IIltuaUonhen nituatioWhen
When hen the district attorney was waeapked wasasked as
asked if he had anything to Ray in re regard tegard isgard ¬
gard to the th case he replied that he be believed beJieoo beileved ¬
lieved Messrs Richards and Comstock Comstoekhad C tock
had been acting in goodfaith good GOd faith as re renrds renrds regazds
gazds nrds the removal of their unlawful unlawfulfences unlawfulfences
fences and that they the would continue continueto
to act ingood In good faith in the matter of ofremoving ofremovfng otremoving
removing the remainder of their fences fencesAs fencesAs
II IIAs
As for the four year yea of determined determinedeffort
effort and the expenditure of thou thousands ¬ i
sands dS of dollars by b the government governmentbefore govfrnmenttbdPtendantswereil1dlcted
before the tbdPtendantswereil1dlcted tbdPtendantswereil1dlctedthat defendants were indicted indictedthat
that of course e was not a matter sub submitted liIubmUted subnutted ¬
mUted for my consideration All there therewas th therewas re reWas
was in the cas case tot me to decide Was Wasthe wasthe wastue
the sentence and that decision was not notmade notmade netmnade
made until I had given the matter thor tliqrough tltorough thorouglm
ough consideration considerationDistrict consldelatIonDistrIct considerationDistiIct
District Attorney Baxter has received receivedEL
a letter from the attorney attorne general which whichmakes whichmakes whicitmakes
makes the tte inquiry as to whether or not nothe Dothe nothe
he < Mr Baxter made any suggestion suggestionregarding sugggtionregardIng suggestionregarding
regarding a prison 1 lison sentence before Ote the thedefendants thedefendants thedefendants
defendants were fined The district J at attorney attolne attoincy ¬
torney tolne says he made no suggestion augge Uon to tothe tothe tothe
the court merely saying aaYln that he was wassatisfied wailsutisfied wassatisfied
satisfied that Richards and Comstoelc Comstoelcmerint Comltocltmeant Comatockmacdat
meant to comply with the law in regard regardto
to the th removing of their fences fencesSTRIKE fencesSTRIKE
0 0STRIKE
STRIKE BROKEN BROKENParis BROK BROKENParts N NParis
Paris Nov NO 1C 11lThe The strike of arcana arcanaemployees arsenal anenaJQmplo arsenalemployees
employees Qmplo ees has practically been broken ui uias UIas u uas
as a result of the minister of marines marinescircular hMrlae1Icircular marinescircular
circular giving < the men the option of go going lOIn going ¬
ing In back bnckto to work < or having their U r name namestruuk natnfstJuo samoastruck
struck stJuo from the rolls At t Toulon work workyardand VfrkIrKS workIsis
IrKS b1ien 6n resumed In branchui or the d ck ckar ekyartamid
yardand ar and work has ha been reumd at Ih IhRotJiofort illRoehofort n nRoenaort >
Roenaort arsenal At t Urtst iind g lid ltir ltirl9Ut 111I m m miQmtt
l9Ut I n the Jl Vtrik trilr Ts ruinij fil r lHI tn If uvikt lK im imdnajratiin I 1dn1r1tin ffi ffion8Jrl
dnajratiin on8Jrl tJltI1 < hut trie t11 t epltit of o tl Ut T PVc PVcllt imcmeat ye yemeut
meat llt 13 m broken
WHATS THE THING THINGFOR THINGFOR THINGFOR
FOR FOOTBALL FOOTBALLPosition
Position of University of Utah UtahArouses UtahArous UtahArouth
Arouses Arous Interest of Public PublicRIVAL PublicRIVAL PublicRIVAL
RIVAL VIEWS PRESENTED PRESENTEDFRICTION PRESENTEDFRICTION PRESENTEDFRiCTION
FRICTION EXISTS OVER DIFFER DIFFERENCES DIFFERENCES DiFFERENCES ¬
ENCES AS TO POLICY POLICYWHY POLICYWHY POLICYt
t A I H ha line Utah n net t maintained lh lhfootball the there thevv
WHY vv football re tb8U prestige preilU e which she won wonimder wOiuedr 01 01ueder
imder Coach Maddock in 1904 1904VThy 1961W1 1904Wky
VThy doe doosthe JJie University of Utah see seethe setthe seethe
the close ot the season approaching approachingwith approachinw1t11 approaclmlnwith
with tto defeats on the record HS HSthis IIil II g gthis Sthis
this situation been brought about aboutthrough aboutthrouglt aboutthrough
through lack of harmonious relations relationsbetween relatiol8between rehatiomSbotwei
between the two athletic bodies con controlling cofltrolling on ontrolllnt ¬
trolling football at the university Is Isit I IIt h hit
it th therult result of lack of material or neg neglect neglcwt negbet ¬
bet of some of the material already a ahand thnd ahand
hand Is it the result of any plot to toget t tot toget
get ot Coach Maddock as s some say sayOr sayOr sayOr
Or is it simply the result of a nr nrtake n ti titake i it >
take t made some time back in estab establishing eta etalIshing ¬
lishing two separate > athletic board boardhaving boarlhaVing barihaving
having coordinate cO OIHnate powers and differ different d1tfijent dltfiant ¬
ent polIcies DolielasWhat polIciesWhat lIcles lIcles11at
What 11at is the remedy to the situation situationIn situatinIn
In order that an impartial investi investigation lnv Itmvsigatlon H i iption ¬
gation might be made of all the phas phasof phaof pita pitaof
of the V Val VmsttI rftr football turmoil turmoilvolved turJUolJohOO turmoilvoived
volved inthese In these questions The Hemi1 Hemi1has Her 1 1hiss 1 1118J1
has secured interviews rpre rtprefOi repreemitim repreemitimevery > ntirf ntirfevery nt i 1 1eetj
every side Disguise e the > fact fa t as oiic oiicmay it itmay IIil IIilmay
may he cannot get away from the th fa fathat fI fIthat fithat <
that there are sides There nJ re8 5s but butconaplatIon o neonapl f fconsplation
consplation eonapl tlon in this and that is the > fs fsthat Isthat ar artbat > <
that each faction is conscientiously conscientiouslyworking conllClentiolIorklngfor censeientiommsworkingfor
working orklngfor for the best t interests of tin I Iof r rof 1of
of U football eleven olo > n as a it thinks besr besrAs ota ec ects
As ts a result re uJt there is friction This Thi naled ha1ed na Itsled
led to no little unpleasantness s at t ih ihuniversity tl1unltersit tI tIunIvtraity
university and has been to a great M Mtent IXtent e etent
tent a hindrance on the team Utah Utaheleven Utalleleveq ITiIeleveq
eleveq has been be ell defeated by h the theveraity Ini Iniversity i iversity
versity of Colorado and by the Colorado ColoradoSchool COnJa ohraUflSiieoi n nSchool
School of Mines this year despite de pltf t tsplendid tit titspendid jIispjendid
splendid work of Coach Maddook Maddookis 1 1is I IIs
is admitted to be one of the gicat gicatcoaches grilllt grillltcoaches gmmcoaches >
coaches evor seen in this part m It the thecountry5 thfcountl3 thecountry
country despite the efforts of Iv 1 111 111Cummlng5r i iCummings n nCummings
Cummings whose host name has IT 1 n nlinked 11linked 0linked
linked with Varsity athletics for In a aen doz dozen do doen ¬
en years eIlrs and more despite th hourst hourstendeavors l1nHftendeavors
endeavors of Dr C G I Plummer tin rnonibor Hlfmhot tinbet
hot of the board bo ld of regents and presi president prt Jrilent > fi fident ¬
dent of the advisory athletic coumil coumildespite oundldespite
despite thefact the met that on that round roundD uni uniD
D A Callahan one of the lntin lntinformed lJ 1 tin tinformed mi miformed ¬
formed men on football ll matters matlt > rs in inUtah I IUtah
Utah and whose ability has already alreadybeen ai md mdbeen
been proved by the victory vlet w of the Salt SaltLake al alLake uILake
Lake High school Chool team teamReasons teamReasons teamReasons
Reasons for the Conditions ConditionsAn
An investigation Inve8t1 ation of the whys anI anIwherefores 1 t 1 1wherefores Iwherefores
wherefores brings to light three eau5 eau5for < aur aurfor au aufor
for the lack of success of the Univer University lninrsit 11iiiversity ¬
sity sit of Utah football team They ar arFirst arFirstThe amFirstThe
First FirstThe The existence exl tence of o two athM athMboards atb11lboards ath athboards
boards with practically equal author authorty authorty auth authty
ty and the absence of a central dire dirIng t tinpr tIJ11t
inpr head hoadSecond headSecondThe hoedSecondThe
Second SecondThe The diflVen dltrWenM eof f policy i Ik Ikstied a asued
sued by these e boards with regard regardwhom rg regatiwhom rd
whom may me be tended bona fide am amteur anhteur n nteur
teur playe playeThird plyetl plgyeThirdThe i iThlrd <
Third ThirdThe The lack at organizer organizergetic zeJ orUxrgetic
getic J Uc effort on the k part of eithr pith t tstudent ti t tstudent
student body or o the atletJo at letk boaids boaisecure t tsecure tl tlseeure <
secure material for the t teiIJJn teiIJJnTo tsnTo un unTo
To elaborate on the > ttrstnamed llmstnainodthe ciiu ciiuthe U Uthe
the existence of an athletic board boardan af1 af1an >
an advisory advi orv council has caused u di 1iv 1ivsion Ii Iiskin i ision
sion of responsibility resPou lbllity which ha hag resuli resulied rt rbuIad > suh suhed
ed in a certain amount of neglect neglectboth negleitboth 01 01botll
both sides sidesThe aldefilThe sidesThe
The difference of opinion with regur1 regur1to 1t itg itgto < gn1 gn1to
to amateurs has been brought 10 10head 10head o oiieaul <
head by b the case of Jack Hum Humwhom Humwbom Humwhomn
whom President Pre 1dent Piummer of thf th ai aivlsory z zvisory
vlsory vl or board has forbidden to join tit tiiVarsity IcVarsity
Varsity eleven Cause Cau No 3 is oux ouxtoo 011 011too em emtoo
too apparent and d it alao involves involvesdifference hWolvesdifference ifloLesdifference
difference of opinion ontnl n between member memberof n111 memib memibof bfT bfTof
of the two board ix I to tojtmst just what nw nm ii iioda Iiods I Iods
ods may ma be termed fair fa ir and sport sportmanlike spottman1tke spot I Imanlike
manlike in securing material for th thteam thteaI I Iteam
team
Remedies s Are Suggested SuggestedBefore SuggestedBerort SuggestedBefore
Before > going oln into these caus CaUh CaUhrtahs cmLusLtahs > > f fUtahs
Utahs football weakness ll in detail t tquoting ll llqu t tquoting >
quoting qu tlng any of those Interview Int lntervlewlmay > rJetj It It11Ia > r rmay
may 11Ia be well to set forth some of em th thremedies Hii Hiiremedies t tremedies
remedies suggested Ugge too These t are areFirst areFt18tThe areFirstThe
First Ft18tThe The organization of a sm fltrClbody > i ibody
body for the purpose of obtaining uit uitterial wrteriaJ ii iiterlsI
terial and the guarantee that title thj o oganization lJnlzation i iganization
ganization nlzation would be given support supportSecond supportSecondThe supportSecondThe
Second SecondThe The centralization of author authority authrtIty autlirity ¬
ity In one athletic board whose who nr nrshall 1 1shaH y yshall
shall obtain in all matters regard regardifootball regar regarfootball I c ctootball
football at the university universityThird unlver universityThirdThe tt ttThhdThe
Third ThhdThe The securing of aid for to fh fhcoach 111coach
coach as is common in other eolleg eollegwhere eol1pglwhere ioilegwhere <
where former team members lend lendices se fWIces v vIces
Ices gratis gratisReverting gratisReverting gratisReverting
Reverting to the causes of frfct frfctwhich tderwhich fmh fmhwhich
which may ma explain away some of t tmystery tmystery I Imystery
mystery surrounding Utahs poor forn fornthe tOTtithe fT
the Advisory Athletic Courcil war warganised uaiganised II IIganlRd >
ganised a year ago last fall when fv fvwell 11 11ell f fwelt
well ell known college men I en of Salt LU LUCity L LCity LCity
City were ere Invited by President J T TKingsbury r rK i iKingsbury
Kingsbury K lg bur3 to aaaist aMi t in the advan advanment adal1ment athcmnent
ment of athletics at the U rr f I IThese r rThe VThese
These e men wete ewe Dr e U G Plum Plunll Plunllformerl inf infformerly i iformerly
formerly formerl of Northwestern universi universiD umsivtU i iD
D A Callahan Yale G A Kato KatoHarvard Ea E tl tlHarvard toHarvard
Harvard R II Channinic Cha un inc Print PrtntOland Prin t tanti n nand
and Dr J R n Anderson on Michigan MichiganThis JUchigalJThi ticlmjgaiThis
This council was to act with the th uni university un1vetty at I Ivarsity ¬
varsity board of t athletics This vaguf vagufdeflniUon vagudefinition agUfdeft1ltJon
definition of its > powers was all th thwaa tIwas a awa
wa was given ctvenAt givenAt srvenAt
At the head of the university buai bc I Iwas Iwas
was and is Professor profes or Byron Cun Cunmins Cu mi mintln n nmina
mina minaPosition
Position of Dr Plummer PiummerNow PlummerXo PlummerNow
Now Xo while Dr C G Piummer PiumimmcIfically sj sjcifically r rciftcaU <
cifically stated in an interview interviewyesterday gu guyeaterday f1f f1fyMterdlY <
yesterday that ho would speak speakfrom n nfrom 1from
from the standpoint of a member of c f tl tlodrtaary tJndvHlery tiadvisory
advisory council but a U a member merni r rthe f fthe fthe
the board of regent it is hardly lii m1 hi hithat I Ithat
that his views would change with t ttitle n ntlUe I ItItle
title therefore it is reasonable to t tpose ui uipose U i ipoee
pose that where wh re he te and Professor lUr lUrmfng < ur urmlngs urmimigs
mlngs differ d1 < er in the one ease they thEe tlmfdiffer v vdiffer i idiffer
differ m in the th other otherTo MIterTo otherTo
To be clear Dr Piummer 5 soliYTv soliYTvopposed oH1 sclhlopposed > oH1oppotted
opposed to offering any man any ai foni foniof fo f fof I Iof
of inducement to enter the univfrsi univfrsifor unifo11lfor universitot
for the purpose of playing football footballhis I Ihl 1h
hl h his own words and he states that thafleast
least two other regents are with liir liirhe l1 Iihe r
he will hew to the line for pure at atletics a aieties l lletlcs
letics in the university universityThe
The views of the two men oil oilwhom Cc Ccwhoni I Iwhom
whom It will be noted ie a member memberthe membtJthe rnemlicrthe
the advisory adi ory council the other of ci t tuniversity C Cunherllty t tuniversity
university board may m be best given JT JTtheir 1 1thplr i itheir
their own words wordsThe WordsThe wordsTue
The interviews following arC > in I t torder trl trlartier torder
order In which they were obtained obtainedter yc ycterday y yterday
terday ter aY afternoon afternoonRegarding atterftOOl1Regarding afternoonRegarding
Regarding Inducements to toand riay rjayr < r rand c cand
and speaking spe king as a regent regcntDl Dr Plumnn Plumnnsaid PlummroSId PluirnI
said SId
saidI
1 I want all the notoriety and pri priInence pr prIne1Ct rrlneice
Inence possible given to the fa fad < t tha thathe thath I ii iithe
the th board of regents r ents vlll not tokrar tokrarprofessjonaliun toltratprofes tol rLt rLtprofessionalism
professionalism profes kmltUam In University of VM VMafhletlcs r rathletiCS 1 1athletics >
athletiCS I ram aw opposed Qppo ed and hap hia c boi boiopposed tit titIpoSed ti tiopposed < >
opposed for year eaa to the idea hl a that l land lud I Iand
and brawn should be paid for coirm coirmto cmria nmlTtlJ
to a university uniuM ltj and joining jolnin the footed footedeleven footo1eleven fettr fettreleven
eleven I favor getting back bukthe 1 1Oie 1UIO
the oldfashioned methods nf al allowing a alowing alowIng ¬
lowing athletes to enjoy jo va vanus a aus i ius
nus us snorts wliil in n < villig villigthroij IlIkgfhrol1fCh Al Althremigit
throij fhrol1fCh li natural selection elN on N > nmn nmnby mnby
by opiui OlJ Pii1Ii vlHiTd FI < 1tl be b ollnwnl on em u fout foutContinued foutContinued o t tContinued
Continued on Page Pa je5 5