sr t V
i
R 1
I THE METALS > Wantadvertise for WEATHER <
FORECAST
t 18 Sftver66c thats the only bvsinase j r
56c
1Y9dpesday
PAGES Capper cathodes 12525 II REPUBLICAN bsinaae Fair
help I Thursday j
I Lead per 100 lbs 440 I i I Fair k 4
t v 4st
Mountain Republican > st
I1IH a o t 4 SALT LAKE CITY UTAH WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 2 1910 Price 5 Cents The Salt Lake < > l li Herald No 61
A
l Hiffil PRICES I
t f WORlOVIDI
i I
Colonel Roosevelt Declares the I
Republican Party is Not
Responsible for the Cost of
Living in the United States iI I i i
STIMSONS RECORD IS
t I
AGAINST TRUSTS I
Democratic Party Used to
Complain That Republicans
Were Responsible for Prices I
When They Were Too Low t I
SPEAKING IN NEW YORK
IKKVI N Y > n L = 1he He
B ItHMItwu part > U Hut rewpunlhie l
fw the bitch test ef Ililuif Tbeo
I4ee HtMwevett arld In a campaign
plek brrr luulght The < iBii e of I
hick peteea in the main he uld were
lalerBBtlwBMl iuluurl lH < meelt tie
< lnr H < hut In eiuc Int uce triiMtn
Mol forred HH prleek xnil poluted lu the
rteord of Henry 1 Mliuuou Itepubll
run eoiMlMale for Kuxernttr an a prone
eNtor 1 mrpHrntloaii whleh had vio
lated the law BB proof that If elected
ke weatd d all the eoxerunr af the
Male m > HM tkt to prevent artificial In I
fLNw u wf value
teleaei Rorelt declaration on
This ub Jen wa made flrat at Niagara
Pall and tnsaal Buffalo at the eloae
of bla last peaking tour In the prseant
slate eampalvn
The ooJoBel poke twlo here tonight
aniU tAft eaThnatavm and then atari
vd for New York when 1M is to de
l > art for Iowa three hour after his ar
rival there in the morning
In hn speech here tonlcht Colonel
Kooaeve naid in part
Pourttxxi years ago 1 wa in Buffalo
MMakmg in the campaign fur Mr Me
Kluey against Mr Bryan and at that
lime our opponents held the Republi
cans rekpunkible because price were
too low I Vou rentfmher that Ml Bry
an area complaint wa that we liter 1 I
could l get wheat up to the dollar limit
> oa fourteen years after the t comlaint
i that trite are too hitch Real ruf
ftriK hu > unquestionably been caused
by ihr fact that prra B have cone up
hu the cent of living has increased
flesh at l > tUflsc tciHM
A deaiaamrue in Harry Stiraaon
place wu uld have promised that impoa
atus 1 reunite weald fellow his nuccena i
lOad our opponent play tiu denaotru I
ban for tht > say wo are lu blame fur I
high prtoMl lied net it they are uuj IB
> Melrs au be n dn lew They
WoJl t wftgtMrw IdalthtahegAalt = L
II pe nrm
vs Mr Htiasoa pointed out the oth
rr alarm there has neon a worldwide
movement tewajp HlflHi pries an the
last few yarfv f mAveteeaK dye tp va I
rious eauaea aotkf of VMth undoukted
H mill be changed In time
Colonel Roosevelt jpeke of Mr 8tim I
Cas pToeutten of the trusts while
nited States district attorney in New
York and said aa a result every big
financial corporation of the type that
we speak of aw M treat is now doing all
It DaD to back up Mr nix and to op
pose Mr tfiimson It Harry Stimsoa I
were not a menace to the big trusts
you would not find every big trust I
cnitroiled newspaper of New Tork
City against him If Mr Tits was not
wanted In office by the great corpora
tions you would not find them sup
porting Mr I > U ai eagerly as they are
in this eaapafga
Trwt 1roserutiont
It was not until I bcarue president
that the first really serious effort was
made to enforce the antitrust law
Ind while aa was perfectly inevitable
la the bginn1nt of a crusade of that
kind we aometlnaaa failed and while
U was physically Impossible for us to
take up more than a eaaall fractloH of
the ease that we would have to take
up jet we did aooompllan a treat deal
Who h4 e ben the people who at
tasked me moat violently The plain
t > ople at the wen who represent the
trusts It U the NlNfaaUyes of
treat eora MUatta their representa
tive la I the pr 611 their re ra entatlTeB
in I public life tkatr representatives in
private Ute thebig corporation laW
ear
r BOTH SIDfS i
NEEDMONEY
Judge Parker Denies Alliance
Between New York Democ
racy and Wall Street as
Charged by Col Roosevelt
1 tf rsiu IIG N 1 Vot IhlllK
PI llu II Inrker lu n speech here
tonight eallol nlteullon lo tul
unel HtHtfteielti dl eoerj of an al
leged all < nMr < between Mr Illx and
stall street anil aid that the onlj evl i
Uae Ike cwlunel bad pretended tu iid
duet wan n circular ttuklnK for fund
ssnel by the ehntrmait of the flounce
rununlltee of Tuiuniimj ball
I bold that flreular In ay baud
be weld aHit also similar clreulnr Issued
sued Iy the Iteiubllrau iiiiuinlttre and
the Democratic Mote eoramltlee
in u Aii raU Herein for funds
11 I + et d nut differ in substance but
> 4tr art marked differences in the
laufl a syrbd for the need of funds
t II I + n the affiliation it the
m < n Lan M II II them
i oaim < h > Sp feeling that the l > em
wrstic appeal N j more imiiresilv titan
that of Hit Republicans They speak
of tue i < eopte who will be I benefltted
hi tills election whereat the dominant I
Hrpubliean thought app art to be of
their part and what rn n or n > i > not
kipper tu it hereafter
the 11 tmocrats art i are i > HS
lii iKK fight which so n + nJ in ii +
lurtallit j a 1 party tie oj att + b
a lio I pine uttriotlsm abo < r + ij eai to
utif ano l rniulre the riving of an op
iurtun1 t i II to bare In the work
nd ha itdit or ii tut triumph The
smut 1 il u n < pme of the new Id I
ti < hdll > 01 P il I i ng ff 11 it l
Milt la i i in and labor 1 r
It I t rxl t J 6 r 0 1l
1 SJ fr t r < i i i ol fd rs
tonllnurd uu Jae eelCat 1
fit
II r ROBERTS JOINS THE ANANIAS I CLUB I
B H Roberts in his speech at the Democratic meeting in Logan on Monday night said
But I have reserved the most conclusive evidence for the last for the close of this branch of my speech Telegraphic message under date of January
30 1909 addressed to Senator Reed Smoot Senator George Sutherland Representative Joseph Howell Washington D C Gentlemen The state of
Utah is aroused and earnestly demanding prohibition at the hands of the legislators
Now let me halt a moment here to say that this dispatch I am reading carries the signature of Charles W Nibley Hyrum M Smith and Nephi L
Morris and I have halted at the close of this sentence in the dispatch to put this question to these gentlemen and to you When they said The state of
Utah is aroused and earnestly demanding prohibition at the hands of the legislators did those gentlemen mean local option at that time Or did they
mean statewide prohibition then
And if some one had stayed the handwriting the dispatch and had said to these three gentlemen Gentlemen will you not accept something just as
good as prohibitionlocal option with what mighty indignation would they have repudiated that suggestion The state of Utah is aroused and earnestly
demanding prohibition at the hands of the legislators Perhaps ninety per cent of the people want it The church wants it They ought to know for one
is the honored respected and loved bishop of the church of the whole Church of Christ not alone in Utah but throughout this intermountain west and all
the world Everywhere is he bishop of this great church of the new dispensation The church wants it the women voters demand it
My sisters fellow citizens is that true of you If it was true of you when this dispatch was sent in January 1909 isnt it true today also Have
you changed your views upon this subject if these gentlemen represented your views truly And indeed what occasion has there been for any change of
I views to anyone who had solid convictions upon this subject liThe women voters demand it The Republican party will be held responsible if it fails to
heed the wishes of the people The federal officeholders are the main obstacle in the way of prohibition That means the federal bunch They are ag
gressively resisting the wishes of the people and standing stubbornly between them and their representatives in the legislature In the name of all the
gods to quote the great English poet on what meat have these several members of the federal bunch been feeding that they have grown so great they
dare stand in between the people and the legislators selected by the people
The Republican party must be saved from disintegration and if the federal office holders who are allied with the TribuneAmerican party and the
saloon element succeed in their present efforts the Republican party will be called the antiprohibition party the saloon league party These are not
my accusations nor my words but the words of these earnest men who are Republicans and among the foremost Republicans of our state The Republican
party will be called the antiprohibition the saloon league party Do you gentlemen support the local leaders in their opposition to prohibition In our
judgment a little yielding on this point will not only save the party but will make r it stronger than ever Continued inflexibility will result calamitously
Please answer q CHARLES W NIBLEY
HYRUM M SMITH
NEPHI L MORRIS
Please answer Did they answer Not up to date No They did not answer What is the usual course of senators and representatives when ad
dressed by their constituents Why the humblest farmer or gardener the Humblest man in the state let him but do our servants down there in Wash
ington the honor to address a communication to them asking for a few garden seeds and the senator will quickly respond as he ought to because he is
addressed by one of his sovereigns not a henchman but these gentlemen refused to answer
Now think of it Here is a representation made to them that ninety pc cent of the people demand prohibition or ask or favor prohibition The
women voters of the state demand it The great church demands it They are told that their party will be considered the antiprohibition party of the state
if they do not get these federal officeholders out of the way and cause them ti1 cease opposition to this desired measure They are told that they will be
called the saloon league party disintegration and ruin to the party and three ° bf the foremost men of the state say Please answer and YET THAT
WHOLE DELEGATION REMAINED IN DEAD SILENCE
Now my fellow citizens try the question in two ways Suppose there was no deal in the way and this congressional delegation of ours were as innocent
RS newborn babes about the matter as they profess to be branding all the Republicans who spoke upon the floor of the state legislature of Utah branding
that great convention that was there representing more than eighty thousand bf t > petitioners representatives from every county in the state branding that
convention with uttering falsehoods if we are to believe the senior senator from the state of Utah
Suppose I say that they were innocent and there was no deal in existence what would our congressional delegation have done in that event Come
now take it home What would they have done THEY WOULD HAVE frURNED J UP THE WIRES BETWEEN HERE AND WASHINGTON BUT
WHAT THEY WOULD HAVE GOT A MESSAGE of consolation back to fese gentlemen who were saying to them Please answer
Ifow t then try Jtfrom this point of view Sunpoethere was a dMj tpppf f tjiy hajypiowledge of that deal suppose it had been made with tntir
consent M and approval they knew of its existence that it was of binding effect and by the way whenever you deal yh 1 liqupj dealers J they always look
out for it that it is of binding effect You may think that you have got them but it always turns out that they have got you and it never fails Now then
upon the supposition that they had knowledge of such transaction as I have described then what would you do
Tell me what would they do Would they not do just what they did remain absolutely silent Is there any other outcome for it Not a bit of it
not a bit of it Now then I hold that these considerations the charges that are made by the Republicans in the legislature and outside of it the silence of
these gentlemen in reference to that dispatch fixed the fact of this infamous immoral deal with the representatives of the worst element of society It
fixes it beyond any question
The moral certainty of it is established and no one who listens to the massed evidence in the case can have any doubt in regard to it and the knowl
edge of these gentlemen concerning it Therefore since the liquor interests has stretched forth its hand to defeat the sovereign will of the people and
corrupt their legislation Uncle Jesse Knight I am with you for prohibition I
The famous telegram upon which Mr Roberts lays so much stress was sent to Senators Reed Smoot Senator George Sutherland and Congressman
Howell during the session of the legislature in January 1909 and was signed by Charles AV Xiblev Hyrum M 1 Smith and Nephi L Morris The Herald
Republican yesterday sent a reporter to the three men named and asked each of them whether there was an answer received to their telegram
I Bishop Nibley said YES IN BEHALF OF THE UTAH DELEGATION AN ANSWER WAS SENT AND RECEIVED
Apostle Hyrum M Smith said HE SENATOR REED SMOOT DID MOST CERTAINLY ANSWER THE TELEGRAM
President Nephi L Morris said YES THERE WAS AN ANSWER RECEIVED
Xow Mr Roberts we will argue with you a moment on jour own basis and pause to see whether you will rectify your statements We will wait and
see whether you will correct your declarations and admit that when you argued that there was a deal with the liquor interests because the congressional
delegation did not answer the telegram you were wrong and that there was no deal with the liquor interests using your logic because the delegation
DID ANSWER the telegram
Mr Roberts in your Logan address you say Suppose I say that they were innocent and that there was no deal with the liquor interests in ex
istence what would our congressional delegation have done in that event They would have burned up the wires between here and Washington but
what they would have got a message of consolation back to these gentlemen who were saying please answer
Now Mr Robert < < our congressional delegation did burn up the wires as you say and they get back a message to these gentlemen who had
sent them thatfamous telegram You have the word of Bishop Nibley who you sayis the honored respected and loved bishop of the church that there
was an answer to that telegram and that that answer was received here You have the word Apostle Smith that Senator Smoot sent an answer to that
telegram and you have the word of President Morris of Salt Lake stake that there was an answer received
And to quote you again Mr Roberts
Now then upon the supposition that they had knowledge of such a transaction as I have described then what would they do Tell me what they
would do Would they not do just what they did remain absolutely silent Is there any other Outcome of it
Now then Mr Roberts you have the word of Mr Nibley Mr Smith and Mr Morris three prominent members of the Mormon church and honor
able business men that there was an answer to the telegram that the congressional delegation when it received this message from these three men an
swered that telegram What do you think you should do under the circumstances You do not doubt the word of these three men when they say their
telegram was answered do you 1
You have argued Mr Roberts that because this telegram was sent and supposedly no answer received that they were guilty of making a deal with
the liquor interests You have argued that if they were guilty of making a deal with the liquor interests that they would do just what you said they
did do never answer the telegram
Now that you have been assured Mr Roberts on the authority of these mon who sent the telegram that they received an answer will vou tell the peo
ple in your next speech that you were wrong that an answer was received and that your logic falls to the ground for that reason 1 Will you tell your next
audience that there was a deal by lending Republicans with the liquor interests and if you do what new brand of logic will you conceive to support your
assertion f It seems to be pretty theroughly < up to you Mr Roberts
You have used that telegram Avhich you secured somewhere nobody knows how > because it i was apparently a private telegram and from that you have
builded a tissue of something that yo milder term than falsehood will fit and one certainly would justified in using the shorter and uglier word You
have builded that tissue of falsehood arguing from the premise that these men did not answer the telegram and therefore they must be guilty
Now Mr Roberts since ypu have the word of these three reputable men these prominent citizens these three men who stand high in the Mormon
church that they did receive oft answer to that telegram will you retract what you have said Will you topple over the structure of falsehood which rests
upon a basis that does not heist You know what the manly stand would be for you to take Will you take it1
We will quote you a little more Mr Roberts
I
Now then I hold thrA these considerations the charges that are made by the Republicans in the legislature and outside of it the SILENCE OF
THESE GENTLEMEN REFERENCE TO THAT DISPATCH FIXED THE FACT of this immoral deal with representatives of the worst element of
society It fixes it beyond any question
Now since the hence of these gentlemen Senators Smoot and Sutherland and Congressman Howell fixed the fact of this famous immoral
deal I where do you gfit off Mr Roberts now that it is shown that these gentlemen were not silent r Where does it put you now that it is shown on the
word of three of the 1cading citizens of Utah that these gentlemen were not silent but that they answered that famous telegram Are you not willing
now to t < stop that talk r of a deal since the foundation of your argument is blown to atoms by 1 Bishop Nibley Apostle Smith and President Morris f
Dont you > mow that whoever got that telegram iu < the first place mid passed it to you was committing a most despicable piece of work I Did the
t
r r Contra Jed on Page Two
1
T
I r4
L < c
ClUB WOMN id
TAKE A HAND jg o r j
Crowds of Striking Garment
Workers Led by Dames of 1
Wealth and Fashion in Tai t
loring District of Ohioago n > +
5
SOME ARRESTED AND
CLUBBED BY POLICE t It
4
Engraved Calling Cards Pro t
duced at the Station Houses t
in Lieu of Bail Bonds a d i
Fair Ones Quickly Released
CONFUSION OF OFFICERS
r
t
a
CHIC C il Nov 1M HBte < i pellet
ineii charged ItirrJilpBluK muti ef P
ftlrlkluj garment M rLrr and
I made nmuerouH arrests IB three see
lion of tlileaco tuda > euly lu be dum 4
founded when met hr obdurate rsp
or trellknutin dull I and Aeellty women
who priiilurnl vallliiK earrts at police
Station In lieu ef hall httfld It nan
a neiv experlenee for the police and
plainly confused them t seere ut these
omen champion at the
garment t
worLer who faced tedeys rioting were
tk rlj Into custody They were Imnie t
dlatcly released however when their
Iilrntlt hreume kuairn la the police
One of them Mat injured w hn s jck d a
by a policeman I club but her name Hd
not become known UK el I i xt i z
rledly placed in an auunoh ai 1 i
taken to her nome
Moat of the women uf prominence i
Involved In today s l monetrati 1 ns
were garbed as working Kill and fr 3r
this reason the poliit ecuH not <
ttltfriiisb them froia strikers until rtfir
arrests had been made 1
Riotous and 1 h
f tctacultr riu Lae
eloped In the I jrntunn litrin n
the north Hide anti on the Laet H d N
More than five h in ired mn and w r in
engaged in a 4tollft i niontraM > i i r
which was brjkep up by I Ilr
after considerable trouble 4 <
left their headquarters in la M aCT I
street the ntrik r s and t fir i tr
thiser flanged iH i 1 B blew r ni ot
tooted horn
Led l > A inrii D l
1
The downtown Inc He u ar t
ceeded into the wi ole ale dtr tst < v
the river paasiin before r Ping
ergo + rt r
Inp eBtabllahineniK ih > r nn > i
were beckoned to join ih < r nkers 1t
J ore than ZMo took pan in sans of HI iii S i
seal demonstrauuns 1
damonstrati on n t trte
1111 each matinee women iitald t fr > r
4 e Jr la r Alun sad wear intake n w
would i
take bath that vr ur
ins g t y ty1y 1O tonJ L9
ta sliliMiss 1i1I parr me of hn t 1 I
dull w jgg who ha becme a strike E l
I pJeket TIae oILy persona who > csc i
Yl9laUag the maw were the t ilicem 1
I who treated III roughly and hurt dread 4
fully with their dubs worn of the i jr I
boys who were lealliiK pea f ia Iii
the shops If thre had et Ii rr t I
riot this mom UK and it i MDIII 1
nave taken much i have malt me t 1S
would have been lr < lted altogether I r tE
the police
Miss 8 M Franklin an ithn t f 1 1 A i
volunteer j uket iva nui jsnart t I r
cause of the mannr in whim MK I had Ott
been treated to t > i poliri f
I kilo the v Id toi hair i sat i l
go if I hart noi relltntd ny and u
said Mis Fiankl Tee er mrd o
think that I IId aruruUrlv danger 11
one character I rlapi i oJld Lne t
been a gaud plan T II ut Ihm ak ne a ct
to Jail and I rove III ih > m I lr
little legal f nUtlon the hate tJo C
stand 1
on S
it
Hume riiruiTn Open
Promi fro u Hto il > a nirn ro I l
n their hun I t dextntitf n k ng it
iE volunteer f r r pu kt > be
om among worn e well known s
ctal and dub 1ddr l i and i rdKr 1 f J 1 s =
any assistance ui u n their pau r fern +
many other worn r were r t roj i i rs 1 9I
Mrs Raymond Kolinn preident < d tie r
Womens Trade lnton 1 leagu l tuck a ce
Helen M Todd a deput tart vI in
Spector who addressed a meeting f
strikers today oiuteered to addre = t J l
Meeting of Cntver lly of tiiPigo xirg +
tomorrow night Mrs Hot n v i 1
speak on the subject of rte Ink to
the members of the fhitagfo kln1Pr a J
Karten Institute In 1 this manner n i < i a
expected to earn the fight of the strik
ing garment workers Into ever I ar f
ter of the cit > and to secure valiioliis
aid for the cause 4
i
Mr Robins l < Bred Uat t at lest
fifty volunteer pu kts frcii i < mns f
Club and other ourte itMdt i It ss 1 if
working girls wit > be actiel ly sane r I
tomorrow w hen f nher demon irati WB a
are expected
We cannot g v their nam at i II h i
time said lr > Robins tle f > nH it <
advisable In trw l York and I arc sre f e
we will here to keep the police gn e i4
Inc aa to who our picket are
i
Meeting This Morning
Striking girls club women and had
ore in the Womans Trade Union league tli
it
will meet at a breakfvst at a i s al rest r
taarant tomorrow to discus the stride t 4f
Among those who will be p < iial
Kneete la Mica Catherine Toman for
mer professor of history at is ct i > etey
college >
Although several tailoring estaJtiUH
mente where strikebreakers are tttinn e
employed were stoned today only s
few person were Insured and there s
were no fatalities r
0
BlACK RECORD FOR YEAR i n 1
nail road Iteiiponslble far Drcih af
tOM TerMons and Injury of f L I
2371 In ISieUe Mouths t f
1
Washington Nov 1 Kil ed t t
Injured 82174 1 > 0
This If the casual i re ord < f oe
railr ada in the United late dur UK
the jnaar ended June 30 last according u
to the interstate commerce romn i > hn
It la I an Increase of lou in tin number
killed and 4A4 In the number tnJur d
over the previous year fiirure
There were 5861 collUion k1Jlg
433 people and injuring 785 and dam
aging railroad t i > perty 44Sau < in
the S9l < j Jerailmem 440
years J per
sons were killed and 48M injurr 1
During the latH Tee month ul t e
year the total ir red was v 650
COWS Pith TUB IIITF HOI SE
I aphlnpton Not Il 1 Ia + ne
Va > ne the prize uainr i fm
Senator Isaac l Sienbei nr > = nk I t n 0
in V i ronsn is I at la i i sad rr
the fthite noose f f r
the Ire = inl < tab > n IT
telegram from sna ve 1 r 5
re rr eg 8taTi a < w g j
J cGlppC + 1 from K 1L a ay
J
t
t
D J