Newspaper Page Text
PS .?k v. *ts- •1 t:- KNOWLEDGE IS MANKINDSGreateU Benefactor False Teaching Is Civiliza tion's Greatest Handicap, VOL. 30. NO. 16. The fight against the ship'sub sldy is- concentrating* in the senate. Labor is turning all its guns agaiAst the measure. Protests are coming into Washington from heads of trades unions and they were this week presented .to the senate. IT. S. Against Subsidy. J. L. Cpulter, secretary of "the In ternational Association of Oil Field, G-as Well and Refinery Workers of America sent in th« following: "President Harding and his col leagues plainly see from the reflec tion in the mirror of our last gen eral election that the people of the United States do not want such a law enacted. Therefore the reason for calling a special session of con gress to arbitrarily force this bill through, if possible, before the Wall Street puppets must relinquish tHeir seats to their progressive successors. The people of the United States do not want individual, group or class legislation, and every effort should be put forth to prevent such being arbitrarily forced upon them. "The Amef ?can.pepole to an sjcigijt are losing confidence in fconstitu tional government as maneuvered as it has been by Bij Business, and such legislation as proposed by. our president in the ship subsidy bill only adds fuel to the revolutionary propaganda thft is already falling on attentive ears." A Cost-Plus Plan. G. W. Perkins, president ^Gf the International. Cigarmakers' union, declares the proposal a coat plus plan and is uneconomic and un sound. He protested as follows: "If we subsidize the so-called ship marine for the purpose as stated, of enabling our ships to compete with the ships of foreign nations, the for eign nations would'immediately sub sidize their ship owners, reduce wages or otherwise cheapen the cost of shipping by water. We, in that event, being bound by a twenty-year contract on the cost plus plan, would have to increase our subsidy to the American ships. Such a sys tem leads nowhere, except to piling up taxes on the innocent, burden bearing masses. "Some are bold enough to say that the question of subsidizing our ships originated in foreign countries. The idea is that if America subsi dizes its ships it would give these foreign ship owners an excuse to go to their own government and de mand an equal subsidy for their ships. "The whole system of subsidizing or anything else is economically and (financially unsound and pernicious ly vicious and should under no cir cumstances be tolerated." Repeal Impossible. "It is a 'steal' and should be beat n," says J. J. Hanley, secretary of he Wisconsin State Federatidn of Labor. He put in this protest: The ship subsidy "steal,'' known as a bill now before congress, is a most brazen attempt to fleece the Amerig^n people. It means selling the government-owned ships to a monopoly at 10 per cent on the dol lar and then pay a subsidy^of $75, 000,000 a year to operate them. Their attempt to hoodwink the peo le of the Northwest by attaching amendment purporting to favor the deep water-power interest, pur rting to favor thv deep water-way plan from the Great Lakes to th£ Gulf should not. b? tolerated. Labor would not feel so keen about this legislation were it possible to repeal the law after this session, when the people would have realized what had happened, but because of the con tracts it carries, Its repeal will %be Impossible for "many years. Organized labor of Wisconsin is opposed to the ship subsidy, and W^rns against any scheme in putting it across, be it the d6ep water-way of anything else, because it practic ally gives to a private shipping mo nopoly our gover'nmeift's ships and t]i»Jt requires onr government (the jpeople) to pay an enormous sum t,o this private ship monopoly for op erating Public Must Pay. •"The' transfer of ships j^nd ship ping from government t6 private in-' terestfft"will yjt INTO FIGHT TO DEFEAT SUBSIDY Union Officials Call on Senate to Veto Plan to Loot President Would Strike Out Important Amendment. Washington, Dec. 14.— Special to The Labor World from the International Labor News Service.)—Admiral Harding, Capt. "Kidd" Lasker and their mates sailed their ship subsidy through the House of Representatives shallows with more or less succesp, but they collected so many barnaclcs that the piratical crew is hard at work repairing the hull in preparation for the senate storm and plotting their voyage so as to circumvent, if possible, the Progres sive men-of-waT who are intent upon sending .the skujj and'bones of Davy Jones* locker. Senator La Follette will lead, the fight against the big treasujy loot. Against 20-Year Contract. President Harding is intent upon eliminating: the Madden amendment which was fastened on in the house and which provides foi* annual ap propriations for ship subsidy. The administration measure permitted the subsidies, their subsidiaries, and* beneficiaries to feed indefinitely at the U. S. treasury trough without future supervision by congrcss. The proponents of the bill know that congress would repudiate the 'scheme after a year's trial: and they want nobody to interfere with their little grame. t,remove the burden HCohtjjhGed Oil? p*ige 2) H1*'- STRENGTH Treasury CONVENTION OF FARMER-LABOR PARTY PLANNED Central Committee Wants Par ley Held in Twin Cities. St. Paul, Dec. 14.—A state con vention of the Farmers' Nonpartisan league and the Working People's Political league, to be held in the Twin Cities in January, was urged at a meeting of the state central com mittee of the farmer-labor party Saturday afternoon in the office of F. A. Pike, state chairman, St. Paul. This action was taken after con siderable discussion in which Will iam Mahoney of St. Paul expressed himself in favor of tha organization of the farmer-labor party on a dues paying basis. The final action taken by the committee instructed the chairman to confer with members of the state committees of the farm ers' league and the working people's league and urge that state conven tions of their respective organizations be called to be held in the Twin Cities in January tQ effect a closer affiliation with the farmer-labor party. After -declining to send' delegates to the national conference of .pro gressives being held in Cleveland this week tho committee indorsed the ac tion of Chairman Pike in sending a letter to the conference outlining the position of the farmer-labor party of Minnesota. The letter gave a brief history of the organization of the farmer-labor party of Minnesota! and expressed the hope that the national conference would adopt a policy that would make it possible for co-oper ation wtth Jhe Minnesota organiza tion. No mention was made,in the letter of the organization of a na tional third party. EVICTEOlNERS AT WHITE HOUSE Tell President Harding Story of Their Hardship. Representatives of evicted coal miners in the Somerset county (Pa.) field are in Washington to see Presi dent Harding. They called at the capitol, where lawmakers assured them that ,in case the president failed to act resolutions will be in troduced in congress caUing on the administration to sponsor a settle ment conference. The miners say that from 40,000 to 50,000 men are still on strike, including fellow work ers in the Somerset fields. "The companies which are evict ing miners the worst and hounding them with armed guards have their headquarters in Pittsburgh. A direct or of one of these companies is R. B. Mellon, brother of the secretary, of the treasury. These companies privately say that their policy of attempting to break, up the miners' organizations has the support of the Washington administration. We want, to ask President Harding about that. "In Somerset over 1,200 families have !been evicted and we have re cently rhoved the last of them from tent colonies into winter barracks. These men merely ^want the same conditions that 500,000 union min ers in the country-got last August." Among the companies that are re sisting a settlement fs the consoli dation coal company, in which the Rockefeller family is interested. Re cently John D. Rockefeller, Jr., pu» licly stated that "the underlying grievances' t)f the miners are *ell founded," but he 'couljl do nothing as he is "a small stockholder." Rockefeller is on the company's board of directors. NEW TEXTILE COMBINE. The woolen trust, known as the American "woolen: company, and the biggest distributor of cotton textiles, known as the consolidated textile corporation, are getting together. The official announcement defies that the combine is a trust, but tlrat the relations are. "only jpersonaV and that they have directors, in com mon. NEGRO SUPPORT ON RACE ISSUt Third International Decides to Concentrate on II. S. The Third International at Mos cow has adopted a resolution declar ing that the United States is des tined to play an important part in the struggle of the African race for liberty and that inasmuch as Amer ica today is the center of the Negro culture of the .world, it is in that country that the Communist cam paign to bring freedom to' the Ne groes of all countries shorild be con centrated. The resolution was drawn up by a special commission, of the' Inter national appointed to consider the Negro question. One m'^nber of the commission was an "American Negro who has been very active in cham pioning the cause of Ms race. He has beeri'aided by several whites in the United States. The resolution, which was adopted without a dissenting vote, declares that the Ne^ro question has become a live issue in connection with ef forts toward a world revolution and that the communist International recognizing it as such, coils atten tion to- it as a problem which must be dealt with. The resolution pledges the mem bers of the International to strive for the equality of negroes and whites and for the full political and social freedom of the African race. "The ftommunists will use all their power and influence with^ trade unions," the resolutioh continues, "to admif^Negroes as members, and if necessary the Internationals will un dertake a special campaign to achieve this aim. If these* efforts fail, the Internationalists will organ ize special Negro unions to further the cause." Detailing the history of Negroes in the United States, the.resolution as serts that the Civil war, was merely a struggle between the capitalists of the north and south for domination. Ruling Reduces Chicago, Dec. 14.—At the request of ithe railroads the United States railroqii labor board has handed down a decision cutting off about $1,500,000 a year from the pay of telegraphers on 14 western railroads. The decision was accomp&nted*»by a dissenting opinion by O. A. Whar ton, labor member of the board, in which he favored distributing the aggregate amount of the wages in dispute among the employes in suck a way as to eliminate inequalities^ Accompanying^ the decision was a* resolution interpreted in railroad circles as marking the end to wage reductions for railroad employes un til' there is an appreciable change in economic conditions. The roads effected by the decision aref^Chlca go & Northwestern, Chicago, Burl ington & Quincy, Chicago, Milwau kee &. St. Paul, Chicago, Rock Isl and & Pacific, Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis & Omaha, Great North ern, Illinois Central, Minneapolis & St. Louis, ftfinneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Ste. Marie, Northern- Pacific and Southern Pacific. WANT ANTI-UNION SHOP. The Dannenbaum cloak company of Baltimore locked out its union garment workers and established the anti-union shop. Now it has a fight on its H&nds. International Labdr News Service. Washington, D. C., Dec. i.4.-^Wil lie Lyons, an elevator operator in the Congress hotel in this city,T^as been the means of bringing forth some of the strangest reasoning that ever issued from a court! Miss Lyons was operating an ele vator at a wage of $35 per month and two meals per day when the Minimum Wage Board issued a® or der forbidding hotel keepers to em ploy w.omen or minor girls at a rate of wages of less than 34cents per hour, $16.50 per week, o^ $71.50 per month. After Having gone through the-supreme court of the District of (Columbia, the- case finally came to the court of apgeals where it was .decided by a 2 to 1 decision, Justice Van O.rsdel delivering the. majority opini6n with Chief Justice Smyth dissenting. Because the case is ah attack on minimum wage legislation for wo men and because the city of Wash ington, wh.ere the legislation at pres ent in question applies, is under the control of the United States con gress, the case ft of decidedly na tional: in tertest. Foj: the first time an Aiherican uourf iHta* #whole 4&jjLred- .lh so many words that ks between the protection of life, liberty, and prop erty "the chief of th^se is property.'! AMERICAN LABOR WILL NOT Bti OUTLAWED OR ENSLAVED DULUTH, ^V"NESOTA, DEC. 16, 1922. Have Its Own Sweet Way "The object of the secretary of the treasury in opening this field anMn requiring the pipe line may have been to produce competition if SO, he has accomplished no more than the dog that bays the moon," says Mr. Bell. "'The Standard Oil interests had-in view exactly an opposite purpose, which was to absolutely eliminate any chance to competition. Aside from the Naval Reserve, Standard Oil, through the Midwest Refining company and the Ohio Oil company,: controls practically every acre known valuable oil land in Wyoming. If the reserve had gone to an inde pendent, there might have been com petition but with this field in the hands of ^another member of- the Standard group, there is no danger. "If the pipe line is -constructed in accordance with the terms of the lease, it will' not serve the purpose, intended, 'because it will' not have sufficient capacity It is hot required until 20,00& barrels daily, production has been developed on the Naval Re serve. The government, royalties from, the Salt Creek field, if the wells were operated to capacity, would amount to 25,000 barrels per day, and more than ope hundred new wells are be ing drilled. Such a' line would not carry more than half the oil to be transported. The government, there fore, will not be in a position to de mand its Salt Creek royalties in kind (if it il not* satisfied with Salt Creek prices) and transport them through this line to other markets and at the same time leave room. for the oil from the reserve. ''The proposition i« a nasty mes3 and in such *hape that these oil.companies wfll Just US# their"owh sweet will about anything they please to do or not toThey will get tho off and the' contln&e to get 'skinned.' "Undoubtedly the profit on the en terprise soon will net the lessee a sufficient stim to build such a pipe line. "Permit us to suggest what might have been done, if the government desired\a pipe line from the Wyom-r WOll WILL HEAD LEGAL BUREAU OF INFORMATION Washington, D. C., Dec. 14.—Mat- thew Woll, vice president of the Ai. F. of L. and president of. the Inter national Photo Engravers' union, has been, chosen director of the new A. F. of L. Legal Information bureau. The Cincinnati convention directed the executive council to create sucli a bureau. Director Woll announces th^t he hopes soon to haye the bureau func tioning. He believes it should be made clear, however, that the bu reau is not to furnish counsel in any case, but that it is to serve as a clear ing house for information relating to law and to legal contests Involv ing labor's interests. SCIENCE WARS ON DUST. The United States bureau of mines and ihe public health service are .conducting studies on dust in mine and factory air for the purpose of combatting pulmonary disease. A new instrument for samping aerial dust has been devised by Leonard Greenburg, assistant sanitary engi neer, retired, United States health service, and George W. Smith, jun ior physical chemist of the bureau of mines. „ConcludesBell, The Teapot Dome oil lease deal is a nasty mess and in such shape that these oil cohipaiifee will just' use their own sweet will about anything, they please to do or not to do. They1 will get the oil and the government will Continue to get skinned,'' concludes Robert C. Bell, formerly a**&*nt to, the attorney general in the Wyoming oil land lease cas«t in his^summing up the case for the International Labor Newa»SeirVice. ing fields to eastern markets and wanted to catch thei alleged drainage from the Naval,, Reserve. The Salt Creek: field covers 15,000 acres the government's royalties now would amount to 25,000 barrels daily if the wells were operate^ to capacity more than 100\new wells -are being drilled at this time 'the field is not one-third drilled and it &' believed that large quantities, of oil will be produced in this field for at least a quarter /of a century. The govern ment has a right to demand its rojre alties in kind, which, with the oi|£ from, a row of offset, wells.along the. northwestern end of the reserve, would be enough to justify the build ing of refinery in Wyoming, or a pipe line from the field to' connect with pipe lines to the east "An offer by. the government to deliver its available'supply of oil, at Mid-Continent market prices* to a refinery or a pipe line company, would have been ample inducement to many responsible concerns to have QBgaged in such an undertaking. The government has a great asset in its royalty oil a* was in a position to drive a real bargain. "Had a contract of this character been made with a purely independent' company, the Naval. Reserve would have bein saved and conserved to future generations there would have beensome actual competition in the Wyoming fields the government perhaps would have received Mid Continent prices for its royalties and would not have heen trading crude worth j|2.50 "for fuel worth 6 3c the Standard Oil. interests would not have had a complete monopoly on every hrahch of the oil industry ini Wyoming, but independents, would have had a chance neither 'Would Sinclair havehad a monopoly on the ^privilege of building stgragejaiid fur nishing the navy, fuel oil,. kgrpaettia^ £a*oline, lubricants, et#'- ^urtherr more,, such a contract, would have been a credit to the administration and an honor to the secretary of the interior and the secretary of the' navy ahd not a shameful disgrace as is the deal which has been made.' 'It might have been.'" NO RBHITABLE ENGINEERS Trade union opposition to. the long work day has recently secured many recruits among metallurgical engineers: Dean Mortimer E. Coo ley of the University of Michigan, said, this opposition, refresented "a tendency prevailing throughout the world," and that the\United States is falling in line with Europe and Asia. Several notable .engineers have de clared for the eight-hour system. No reputable engineer how stands for the long work day. They say the advantages of the eight-hour day compensate for any apparent extra' cost. HOW LABOR BENEFITS. "I would like to know if. seamen will get the benefit of this ship sub-, sidy, bill in the same way pottery, workers who are now on strike are getting the benefit of the Fordney McCumber tariff bill?" asked Con gressman Crisp on the floor of the house. Mr. Crisp showed that the tariff bill raised pottery rates from 30 per cent to 60 per cent, yet the, workers in that industry were forced o'n strike to resist a wage. put. UFE, LIBERTY AND PROPERTY, AM CHIEF OF THESE IS PR0PE8TY. SAYS OOIRT While the decision was l/anded down on Nov. 6 complete copies have just been made available and those who have thus far read the ma jority opinion are amazed-at the po sition taken by the court The de cision states, impressively as might be expected, "the, sacredness of the right of the citizen to freely contract his labor" and in that connection several court decisions are cited, jn ciuding a decision written by Justices Harlan of the United States supreme court. The reasoning of the court, of .ap peals in this case' is well illustrated by the following paragraph from the decision: "We -/are of the opinion that" the act cannot be upheld-^upon the theory that the contracting for" labor be tween private Individuals Ms a busi ness impressed'with a public Inter est. Unlike tfye operation of fin ele vator to handle indiscriminately the grain of the pubUc, and t|ie rates* to be charged for such service (Muon vs. Illinois, .94. U. 8., 118), or the trust relation arising from the de positing of funds In- banks, (Noble State Bank vs. Haskell, 219 U. S„ 104), or the rates to be charged the public by insurance companies /Ger- deallng with a private business, con ducted between private individuals, in which the public? has' no. direct economic interest.- it follows, there^ fore, that if the dcAtrine of" 'public interest' is to be extended. to the point of fixing by law the drate it which the individual citizen' may con tract his labor, by placing a limi tation upon the freedom.' of private contract between employer and em ploye, It is difficult to understand just where the limitations of. the ex tension of police jiower may be reached. It amounts to converting the police power into a convenient experimental agency for distinguish^ ing, extending or Abrogating express limitations of the Constitution." The court coiild hot forego the op portunity to indulge in a bit of phil osophical' dissertation and as a' re sult we find the following in the, de cision:/ "Coming now to the consideration of the vindication of the act as a proper exercise. of the police', power, we, are of the opinion, that it can not be upheld. High wagef do not necessarily tend to good morals, or .the promotion of the general*# wel^ fare. Th« s^ndi*4 ... of virtue and among the man Ailtence Insurance Cmnpany vs, |ttuisiieVdU)i than aniiong the poor. Kansa*,5M U. S., 389K &**** btre lllxdr worgi caB n^t be measured.liT •Vr 12-HOUR SHIFTS Must Give Way to New. The 12-hour, workday has outlived its usefulness and could be elimin ated vwithoVit either economic or fi nancial disturbance to,*the progress of Amcrftan industry," President Harding declares in a st^fement in corporated as part of the Federated American Engineering Societies' re port. just made public. The statement Comments oh the report of a Committee q|!.,$he organ ization of more-than forty "continu ous industries, including steel and iron, in which the engineers conclud-. ed 1 si-hour day was not an. eco nomic .-^necessity. The? 'president's statement follows: 'It is-a matter of very much grati fication! to me that- the Federated American Engineering Societies, our foremost organisation of American industrial skill,, should have given two years of diligent inquiry, under coxnpewnt experts, to a subject which 14 of very deep interest to me, and important to the country, "I rejoice to note the conclusions of this rgreat body of experts are identical with those which I have' reached from a purely social view point. It has seemed to me for "a long time, that the 12-rhour" day and the type of worker it produces have out lived their, usefulness and their part in American life in the-, interests of good citizenship, of good business, and of economic stability. The old order of the 12-hour day must give way to a better and- wiser form of organization for" the productive forces of the Nation, so that proper family life ahd citizenship may be enjoyed suitably by all of our people. "This clear and convincing report of the engineers must prove exceed injgly helpful in showing that this much-to-be-desired' result, can be achieved without either economic or financial disturbance to the. progress of American-industry." State Federation Several weeks ago the state fed eration of labb'r telegraphed a re-? Quest to: :the interstate. commerce commission that unsafe railroad equipment operating out of the Everett yards.be.Inspects^ The com mission replied that inspectors were being ordered to Everett at the ear liest. possible opportunity. Shortly, afterwards a wreck oc curred north of Everett, qn the Great Northern //ailroad, in which three lives were lo'sit. Officers of the state federatlo^- pf laJor agaift called the c.ommissions fatten tipnv to conditions that maOti travel unsafe and the need to"compel the Great' Northern, Northern Pacific, and other roads operatirig out of Everett to comply with safety Jaws and rules. The unionist? suggested to the commission, that the law might be enforced "against these roads, in view of tlte claim by public officials that the interests of the public are para mount to all other interests. The commission was also reminded that the administration attempted to compel^ labor employed on the roads to accept. wages'* and conditions. URGE FIRE PROTECTION". A ^survey of -all laws for ~the pro tection i6f life and property against fire Wasp agreed to at a conference of labor, civic and industrial organ ization sin New York. dollars and cents, ar promoted by a. legal subsidy. ,Never have wages beeni.se high as since the outbreak of the late war, and never in the history of the republic has crime been souiniversal and this condition, it must be conceded, has made a like unfavorable iotpression upon the morals of thte people." A wage based upon compietitive ability Is just, and leads to frugality and hon est, industry, and inspires an- ambi tion to attain the Jiighest possible efficiency, while the equal wage paralyzes, ambition and promotes prodigality and Indolence. It takes away the strongest Incentive to hu man labor, thrift and efficiency, and work# injustice to employe.and em tloyeir alike, thus affecting injuri ously the whole social' and lndus trial^'ftebric. Experience has demon stfat^i that a fixed minimum -ifragte meAns, in the last analysis, a. fixed wagers since the employer, being compelled to advance "some to a wage higher than their- earning', capacity, equalize th$ cosjt of opera tMn, fewjBir ither jllgkt4qn P% wage of .the more cpjriftfnt tp^he common- basis." •. i"TWr#iit^toeil(t-- bit' of express ton in the ^entlrel ide^ision, however, Is found iit- ihe cjouift'^ triumphant vin- supremacy of prbp- (poQtiniicd on ^age -i* mm .... ..... Thmtght in thduth Be Patron Worlds BY LA FOUETTE Senate Passes Resolution for Branding the. proposed merger of two of the "big five" Chicago pack ers as a "flagrant violation ofvthe law," Senator La Follette, republi can, of Wisconsin, charged in the senate that officials of the."Armour and Morris companies were''frankly bargaining with the government'for permission to do an unlawful act." La Follette as"kfed the senate to pass- his resolution demanding a gov ernment investigation of the pro posed merger.' As a result of. Senator La Follette's appeal,, the senate passed the reso lution without a dissenting vote. It authorized the secretary of agricul ture to inform the senate, what steps had been taken. In the-merger. .La Folletite. condemned the ^action of President Harding in voicing a tentative approval of the. deal, life declared thiera was "no' law', ^rhieh authorizes the' president: to sell- ln dulgenec to lawbreakers." r. "The history pf the packing cor porations is a ,shameful history of defiance of the law and of tjie courts," said La Follette. "It ig a warning of the length to which cor porate greed -will go in robbing the public, oppressing Its employes and defying the Jaws. "Why are the'great packing houses frankly bargaining with- government officials for permission.to.do an un lawful act? It, is because the great packing houses are in financia.1 diffi culties. "The trouble is that, they ate:.meat packers no longer. With-the.ntfllions, they extorted from- the' people, they have reached .out into other lines of business and the losses. connefeted with these Other dines must event ually be paid for by cnhancing the meat products." .. Frank Morrison and W. J. Spoor Visit hi Twin Gittes. Minneapolis, Dec. 14,—Organized labor will concentrate its efforts dur ing the coming fsession of congress to prevent the repeal of the present immigration laws, Frank^ Morrison, secretary of the American Federation of Labor, declared in an interview in4 .the Twin Cities Friday Sight. Mr. Morrison and W. J. Spencer, president of the. metal trades of Washington, were in the twin. Cities for a few hour's-Friday en poute to Portland^ Ore., where the^are go ing to arrange'for the next national cohyehtlon of the American Federa tion of- Labor, which will b§ held in that city in June, 1923^ "There' is" no scarcity^of 'labor in the United' States, but there' Is a scarcity of men-^who work for starvation wages,". Mr. j^orrison" said, mployers who want chekp foreign or are carrying. on an intensive campaign'to- let down^the imttiigra tion bars. I hope th^y will npt be successful." !'En laoc In commenting upon ..the appoint ment of Pierce Butles- to ,the supreme bench, Ur. Morrison expressed ..hope ths.t the nomination vrould' hot be .confirmed by the senate^ "I am pleased *dt the tt&rrtw being made by the progressive people of Minnesota to hlook the^t^olntniehjt of Butler and hdpe" they^ .irni suc ceed,". lie- said. He stated that "the reft&kttipk pe-Ho nored k. F. of Policy. Formation of a ne^r party to represent the progresnve thought of liberal parties, labor organizations and progressive faii mer organizations Was frowned upon^ki the report of the commit tee ort organization, headed by Morris Hilquit, New York, at die conference for progressive political action being'.'1^ Cleveland this week. The committee recommended the continuance of the method which proved so successful in the last campaign oiF going into the primaries of the old parties dnd nominating men friendly to the progressive caiise/V It wis provided, however, that in case the candidates sp favored v%re not ^omiriated then independent nominations should be tnadis 61 reactionaries will oontinUar lft hMh local and national elet^ons beM|K of the dissatiftfabti^n of the :pe^pl« with the' representation mt^a been. receiving. He .expressed ieU^ ure at th^ farn^i^a^rjS^toi^^ri Minjiesota hut said Ipat could see ino need for a Rational third •party. v-- 1V' W* Approves A. P. of L. Polljy. The recommendation7 of the com mittee is an. endorsement of th« stand, taken by the American Fed eration- of Labor: for more than 40 years and is a vlndication.' of the-pa ction of Samuel Gompers oh polite ical action. It is also aiv endorse^ ment of the 'position takefc' by Mr. Townley, former president of \the Farmers' National Nonpartisan leagufe, who one year agp" upon lils release from jail declared for a pp^ litical course by farmers aftd work ers that would give them the ^bal ance of power in government, which they will have in Washington after March 4 next. The chairman of the committee to back the time-hoinored ahd time-* proven policy of the American Fed eration of Labor is Morris Hilquft, former member of the Socjfclist pari ty apd. one of the. -leading figures in Socialist politics and literature. Tho surprise of the conference is in the -change of heart of Mr. Hilquit. Scores "Workers' p«rty.»' The conference was further mark^ ed by its constructive and practical wisdom when it Refused recognition to the "Workers' party,V the defer gates from .which -sought sqpts in the meeting. Edward Keating of Colorado^ editor, of "Labor' 'at Wash ington,-ledt he fight against seating delegates from, that party. Mir. Keat ing- la a former member of -Congress. "The 'Workers' party' has-jio place where honest, trade unloiaiata are represented,'' said Mn Keating^ in Jiis1»eekrh to the conference. He declared ttie, party un-Ainerl'can and anti-labor. "This conference stands for the flag and the constitution," continue^ Mr. .Keating, "and the reason we are going to- kick the. delegates from the 'Workers' party out is because they neither, stand for this country or its labor organizations. Unfriendly to Unions. "Its ^officers are managed by im? friendly Interests," he-charged. "Its leaders know they receive money from anti-labor employers tp- com* into labor's ranks and disrupt labor oganlzations. They are out to de stroy the unions* They are- relative-* ly'in the time position as the citi zens' alliance." Minnesota was represented at the conference by A. E. Bowen and D. C. Dorman,. representing the Farm ers' Nonpartisan league H. D. Crar. mer, Minneapolis Trades and Labor assembly .6 W. Lawson, Minnesota State Federation- of Labor Thos. "Van Lear, Working Peoples' Non.? •partisan.league, and W W. Royate^ railroad, brotherhoods. The, railroad brotherhoods took a leading hand in. the big confei^ ^nce, following their successful pais, ticipation iii. the. political battles !g a score of states this. year. The president of the conference is Will iam'P. Johnston of. tha,Inte*nationai Association of Machinists. Minnesota Was Divided. "T While the. Minnesota delegation divided upon the question ofc estab lishment. of a national thiird party at this' time, they agreed upon 'a "har?nohy plan" which'was in part adopted by. the conference. This plan according to one of, the. delegates, provides fqr leaving the entire mat* ter to the progressive forces of the various states. R. p. Cramer, representing the Minneapolis Trades- and Labor as^ sembly, was under instructions in-f« far of the formation pf a. third party vrklle A. E. fiow6h :and D. C. Soc man, as repreMntatl^es of the Na tional .. Nonpartisan league,.. are- opro posed to thirds party-action, at this time. W.^W. Royster. while favoring a third party, advocated thaj^ th* question be left to the several .states to ideclde. George .W. Lawson,. rep^ resenting die Minnesota State. Fed- eration of Labqr, -also urged that the question "be left to the states to'de cide. Thomas Van Lear wasunder in-r structions from ,the .- Working Peo ple's league to urge the formation of a national third party. Mak£-iip .of* Conference, ., The Cleveland Conference was the result of a move initiated about a year ago by the International As sociation of Machinists and, was' ^at tended by delegates from the.' If railroad ^organisations, tlMsNatlpnal Nonpartisan league, tho Working Pepple's Political league of Mlnnfr sota, .i.the United (Mine Workera Of America, central labor .iinipiifl throughout the United States, greMVe^fSirnvBrs.''. or^nisatioiKS,^ thie i^ational' farmer-labor party and" tha national j^cMiist party, the c6j^e^ence was b|ld' inrChl^4tft^ ^^^h*t a rMgJ^latlv« pro* '^g^.»was. :.ai(^^d:.uffbji. 'v-v- f#GoatIiiiied .on-'-'paga^S-)'^ .tiiSS