- -.':-- "' : -4 3 '
; f irwa:
HONOLULU STAU-BULLETIN, MONDAY, XOV. 10, 1913.
yy'.-'y-r, ' - -
(Special JStar-BalUUn Correspondence
f?--y-n - -!
Janes n. Love
i i?nfnnnnrii unnnr
i v WASHINGTON: , J), a Oct. ZB.
,1 7 r.;
C ales, accompanied by heavy seas,
retarded the progress of. the Oceanic
liner Sierra in the voyage from San
Fracclsco -to Honolulu. The veEsel
err cared off ;the; : quarantine '.JIne
tLcrtiy after 9 o'clock - this morning
and te fore II o'clock was moored at
; a Icrth at the Oceanic wharf. , ':,'.
, Ceveral hundred' tonspf navy and
, crruy equipment carried on the after
deck was a prey of a succession of
mountainous seas that swept the yes
. r. tl.- Wtile vast quantities of water
were el ipped, no material . damage
.was done to the cargo
4 - Friday, and 'Saturday .were rather
strenuous days for passengers on the
Sierra. The v weather; conditions: we ce
r uch that the travelers ' were obliged
to remain within doors. -7,':7777-v
That the season for employes in
orchards and vineyards on the coast
Lea crai a to a clase was'"borne out
by the large number of Spanish', and
Portuguese who returned to ' the
islands as steerage passengers In the
Sierra. The vessel brought 85 cabin
and 43 steerage travelers. s
A Email percentage of the ; cabin
I zz senders are listed as tourists. The
majority cf the passengers are kaa
mianas who have been spending the
tv.mmer months on the mainland and
alar.g-the Pacific coast v-;1v' "'
One of, tne largest consignments of
mail to be received here in avnum
her cf months arrived in the Sierra in
the 475 sacks delivered to , the local
postal authorities. 7 -'""
Work was begun on the discharge
cf ICG3 tons of general cargo as soon
as -the vessel came to a berth at the
wharf. In the shipment, are eight au-
The Sierra will be disnatched for'
San Francisco at noon on Saturday, f
The bookings at the Oceanic ofiice In
dicate that a fair-sized list' or passen
gers will depart fo? the mainland in
the vessel - -" .;
Miller May Take Hand at Salvage. ;
Capt. Frederick Miller, veteran
fckipper and salvage expert,' has de
cided to take a hand In the refloating
cf the distressed bark S. C. Allen,
ftranded off. Diamond Head. K. Mat
tumoto, who recently purchased . the
wTeck for $4600, has succeeded in sav
ing a considerable portion of the lum
ber Stowed below decks. It is esti
mated that, about 110,000 Xeet cf ma
terial have been ' rafted ashore. , It
ig-planned to fill the space formerly
occupied by. the lumber with empty
cascline drums, 'ttese to befastened
to the bottom, with ' the expectation
that the vessel may be raised from
IS inches to two feet with .the rise of
the tide- Two five thousand ton an
chors are - to be planted, to which
cables will be attached, and upon
these a constant and powerful strain
Is "to be maintained. "Captain Miller
lias expressed confidence. In the pos
fvlbility of 'removing the bark . from
the berth on the, coral to a place of
safety within . the harbor.
- .t-. ' ' :' - ' fa -r r'-i-. -::
; Stevedore Met "Death In Alaskan. ;:v
' Falling' to a considerable distance
; Into the hold of the American-Hawaiian
freighter Alaskan, Ciciaro Valder--itiaii;
a 'stevedore In the employ t
McCabe, Hamilton & Renny, received
Injuries late Saturday evening ; which
resulted In his death..- While engaged
in replacing a hatch, .Vaidennan lost
; hl3 balancei and .dropped to the bot
ftcra cf the hold.,. The Alaskan was
about to sail for 3an Francisco by
the war of island ports when the ac-
cldent occurred.'- i::- .
To Call for Bunker Coal. . y ' v J .
- The Inter-Island has beenadvlsed
that the British freighter rEccIesia,
with lumber, in .transit from .the Co
lumbia .river to Australia, may be ex
pected tocai; at Honolulu tomorrow,
for the purpose of taking on t about
: S00 tons of bunker coal. -The. Ecclesia
' ias been here on ' several occasions
fcrineine xarcoes of coal for local inv
". porters! . The vessel will be given a
uick dispatch for the coiomes. :
i : ' Ea I ' y .
.All Inter-Island steamers returning
to the port yesterday brought, small
vJ!sts of-passengers. -: V
7:7-777.-- , 777n 7 Kk
A Are which threatened to destroy
the entire valuable, cargo carried In
the Pacific Mail liner Manchuria, dute
to arrive at Honolulu this afternoon,
required the combined efforts of offi
cers and crew tc subdue before it ;was
completely extinguished. . The fire Is
reported through ad vices -received to
day to t have . occurred ; while ' the big
steamer ,was' proceeding through : the
Inland Sea of Japan,' from Kobe to
Nagasaki . v v--- '; ' y
A 'relessly thrown ( cigarette ; tSy
one of the members of the crew Is re
ported to have started the blaze,' that
was finally; confined to one compart
ment of the ' spacious hold. A portion
cf "the,- freight stored ; In one ; large
ccTmpartment -. was thoroughly soaked
by water- A watchman is said' to
have heen. attracted , by the smell of
I smoke and , quickly sounded a general
alarm,? which, brought'- officers ""rand
crew - to ' immediate' attention. The
Manchuria is supplied with a com
plete fire fighting equipment, ;which.
in the recent trouble Is declared to
have proven very satisfactory. s I , f
Per O. S. S. Sierra from San Fran
cisco For Honolulu: . Warren E. ' Al
ston,' Mrs. , Alston; Mrs, 'Edna 'JDeau
mont, . Miss Dorothy Beaiimoht, "Miss
M,' J4 Blake, F. K Bolton, ' Jas. E.
Boyle, Mrs. Chas. A. Brown, Rer.
Collins G. , Burnham, Mrs.- Burnham,
H. Cushman Carter, ' Mrs. R, S. Chap
man, ThosCcllins.V; W. Croxton,
Mrs. F., N. Dalton, -.; Miss Dalton, F E.
Davis, Mrs. Davis, D. W." Donald,
M- Dowsett, H. Dusang. Rev.' A.
A. Ebersole, 'Mrs. J. Ellas and.Infant,
IL ;D. Elliott, "A; J. Elmes. ' J P. Far
ley, ; Mrs. Farley, Miss Farm, " Mrs.
W, U Frazee, E. H. Hamakau, A. S.
Hey ward, V E. : Humboldt, T. - T.
Hughes, v Airs.1 Hughes,. ;-MIssV.- A.
Hughes, ; J. M. Johnson, b Mrs. John
son, M. G. - Johnson, T. C, Johnston,
Mrs. Jcflnston, , C H.-Jorgeson,, Henry
Koch,' Mrs. Kpch, :. G.A-McDermott,
H, -L.;MfcLain," .Mrs. M; E. Maddern,
J. Marino. Mrs. Marino, Master Geo.
Marino, Miss ' Lena . Marino, : Miss
Mary.; Marino, - Mfss' Rose - Marino,
Master Tom Marino, H. B.'Marlner, T.
CV Manlowe, Mrs. Marlowe, - Miss il.
Marlowe, 'J.Medeiros, R.- R. 'Morse,
E. Mcses, Mrs. Moses, MissM. H.
Moses, - J. E. Nicholson, . J. R. Parker,
R. E. Parkinson, Miss Edith Peacock,
R.' Poehlmann," A. ' Randall, Miss S.
Robertson, G. B. Robinson.'.1'" Mrs. E.
Rosa, L. Rosa, Miss M. Rosa, - Miss
Clara Schafer, Antone Schnerr, ;"W.
Searby, Mrs. C. r A. Simmons, 1 1. J.
Smith, f Mrs. Smith, D, F. Sullivan,
Douglas Swan, Mrs. Swap, Mrs.M.
Tavares and Infant, J. E. Thornton,
Dr. St D. G. Walters, u Miss Merced
Walton, C. W. .: Welckel, i. A; N.
Wayne, C Weissman, - Mr. Williams,
A. H. Yoder, Mrs. Yoder. v ;
s Per Claudine; Nov. 9.- T Cockett,
A, CR. . Warner and wife," Mrs. Gal
bralth, E. E. Brunei F. E, Howes,' C.
ET Willing. Y.' rwataj Baba' Mrs. ,Car
borge and 1G deck,'-' ' .';'-':- ! ';
- Per W. G.' Hall, Nov. 9.Mra.: J.
Davis and child," Henry Ho, Mrs. F.
Delaert, F. C. Lyser, E. Lorell, George
Haggarty and 25 deck., v 4 : : ; - T :.
Per Mikahala, Nov. 9. Lee Ping,
Salkl, Mrs! M. Poaha and Infant, Y..U.
Hing, A. ftSmythe,' TameKIochea 'and
12 deck. ' ; :: :i yMyy::
4- - "' - i'
Sunday, November 9." ' x
Maul, Molokal and - Lanai J ports
Mikahala, sUv a. rh. ; V P ' ?v
j- Ivaual ports WV Q."iU, str., a, m.
I i Monday, November 10, '
San Francisco Sierra, O. S.r S.t
a, m. ' ; ; ' . -
. , , .RING UP 24 LORRIN.K,' SMITH
FURNITURE AND PIANO
iThe veteran bark 'Albert, for years
a familiar figure ; in island shipping
in the 'transportation, of 4 sugar, and
later In the carrying of lumber car
goes from the, S6und to the island . of
Hawaii.; is reported today as soon to
pass' from' the control of H.Hacls-
feld & Company to the Charles Nel
son Company.--.';? f w?A'fykJ
: . The transfer of ; the' bark, built In
the year 1890, to the' coast: shipping
cenjpany, probably ; means, that the
vessel iwlll be peraJanently withdrawn
from the island : service to enter Jnto
another class of. trade.. -';';' "' -"',
The. Albert Is now Jon the' Sound,
where the bark has been given a gen
eral overhauling. . Of late years v the
Albert : has been confined .to? a route
that : included frequent , voyages' be
tween Puget, Sound; and- Kaihia, Ha
waii, j It has ; been, some time since
the-windjahimer-made -anj appearance
at iionoiuju, l ne . AiDert.- is : a rpri.
Biakeley - built vessel and the predic
tion Is made that the bark - Is yet
good ; for; many years of service. It
is understood .that the kelson com
pany ' will ' employ the vessel In v the
foreign lumber trade, ' While tha deal
has not been closed, representatives t)f
H. Hackfeld & Constated this mornlhg
that the vessel was likely to ' change
hands within a few ,weeks. ' Whether
the Charles Nelson Company ; on ,i the
coast will become the new owners of
the. bark yer remains - to ., be; , deter
mined. -., ' '' . ;: ' ' '
:.y y .. ;':
Helene Here With Lumber.
1 Twentyrnlnet 'days-from Port Blake
ley." with a shipment " of lumber , to the
order of Allen I &! Robinson, the
schooner :: Helene is an arrival : at the
port today. ;The vessel met with faif
weather' after clearing the Straits of
ucat The Helene? was . given . a
prompt' pratique : and was sent to
the Allen & Robinson , wharf to dls-
- 'Arrangements may be, made where
by a mall .will be dispatched from the
Islands to Australian picrta i In ) the
British steamer. Ecclesia, due to ar
rive here tomorrow for the purpose of
taking on J bunker coal. '
y ln departing i for - Maui ports this
evening an animal s show in which a
number of horses, dogs, monkej's and
cats will take part, will proceed . to
the Valley Island In the steamer Clau
dine. Sam Weller, the theatrical im
presaricvwin play the attraction over
the "rattoon circuit.", ' : . - y k v
The steamer X) . G. Hall completed
a special trip from Kauai ports yester-dar-1
The '.vessel returned with 'a few
passengers and ' a general cargo.
VESSELS TO AND - V:
V C FROM THE ISLANDS
Special Cable to STerdianto
v . --Exchange - ;'
' ' " ' ' Mondav, Not.. 10. . : I'
PORT HARFORD' Arrived, Nov. 9,
S.S. W. F..Herrin, from Kaanapa
- II Nov. l. - .
SAN FRANCISCO Arrived. Nov. 10,
I p. m., S.S. China, hence Nov.? 4.;
PUGET SOUND Arrived. Novr iO.
U.S: str. Ringold. hence Oct 31.
HILO Sailed, or.I8,i S.S. Seiyo
Maru. f or Manzanillo. .
YOKOHAMA 'Sailed. Nov. 10, S.S;
PIle;'f6r Honblulu'(2-days late).
SEATJLEf Uf, Sailed, Nov.-8 S!S. Hy
t. ades, for Honolulu. v. ; -
MOVING A SPEClALtY.
: Nuuxna and "Quaen.. 8trits
Two ' charming- r women, - representa
tives of former' administrations, are
In Washington lust 'now. and a third
will be here within a tew days. , JMri.
Franklin MacVeagh, who 'is in Dub
lin; Is : expected at her 4 home in - the
Avenue of the Presidents shortly, and
Mrs. George Vonr L. - Meyer,, and,, her
daughter. Misa ' Julia Meyer) are
spending a ' 'week i at " the - Shoreham.
While here. : they will see Lieutenant
Christopher . Raymond P Rodgers,. U.
S. N.- and Mrs. 4 Rodgers, Settled 1 In
their tew home at 1619 Nineteenth
Mrs. Truman iH. : 1 KewbertyM left
Washington at -tioon . today after hav
ing" spent several days, at .he Ner
Wmard.'rv With heir.. Is Mrs." Thomas
thatcher : ot .New - York; and ; they are
en route .front!; the Virginia; Hot
Springs - to their respective 1 homes;
Mr. ; and Mrs. Newberry, ; win agaTn
leave Detroit next month," and. en No
vember 29, will call from . New; York
on the Adriatic to spend the winter
Irt Egypt ' Their daughter. Mrs! Frank
W. Brocks.: Jr.,' of Detroit formerly
Miss iCarol Newberryy Will no accom
pany . them, 'i being detained y In this
country, by " her six-months-old t "daugh
ter, who requires, .her, care. .. ,
.' .The retiring 'military attache of the
French embassy. Count de Chambrun,
with the Countess de Chambrun and
their children, who have" been for the
last; month In ..Cincinnati: wlthMrs.
Susan ' Loagwofth,;"are saIIIng '.'. this
week on - La Provence, for France.
Count de Bertier de Batmghy, who will
succeetx ,uount ae ijnamDrun, win oe
here taa few weeks!i ':'". '.. ,' -::
rs. Lbhgworth gate a' large recep.
Uoii.Frldav last at Rookwood, herein
cinhati home, for - the" benefit" Tof lier
soa-in-iaw and daughter. Count, and
Countess '.de Chambrun, v-v v j t v
rMrsHenry F Dimock is having the
Scott, circle residence" which she has
leased put In order 7 for occupancy.
i ne nouse,. originally buiw. by former
Senator 'Cameron, has aybollroom and
has' had jas tenants Mrs.: Stuyveant
Pish of New York and. mere lattely
ex-Secretary Meyer and family. ? V X
" Miss . Frands , Moore. will i not-; be a
aeDutante here pe coming winter, as
she had ' anticipated, aa Mrs.1 Clarence
Mbore lllTnbt ' ,opea Vtcer: JTassaehu
setts, a venire resld.ence- and will Tspend
the ; wlntf r..in Euro; traveling with
her: vounar ' famllv: - y'.y y : -fA I
-Lieut: Coif Stepheu ,llL;siociimU.
S.; A!, an4 . MraiJalocum" entertained
MaJ. Gen.' Lebierd - Wood. v TJ. S. A-
Lveut C6L Sir 'Alfred f E. Coddringtoa
qt therttJshrtH J, lady:Coddrngton
and Miss. Coddiiyigton and Capt-'J. It
U Phillips' of ihe Coldstream Guardi,
and others at dinner.; ; .V ; : 4 1-
senator -Henry ?n Lippitt ; and his
son, Mr. Henryj Llppitt and daughter,
Miss J ranees , Llppitt have returned
from a short trip to Europe', They are
at 'their farnr In' Cumberland for t a
time before coming here for the winter.;-
V''i :- ;
' . i-i V 'fc f . -'
--,,- ." - , '" ' "; -c
y The; commandant qt? the " marine
corps and Mrs. BIddle ; gave a dinner
at the Chevy; hase, Club In complt
rae'nt to MrsU Baileyr' wife of Naval
Constructor Bajey of . New York, , who
la now their, guest - Major Low, Mr.
and Mrs." Power ot, New - York-; and
AlaJor.PaSsqn Were other guests, v
; -' ' r;"- ' .':..-,.-'-" :-;y ''-. v--.-.-'-'
.The Secretary of War and Mrs. Gar
rison. Walter C. Pedlgo and Mrs Ped-
Igo and Brig. Gen. Weaver cf the coast'
defense "corps left for New York and
win sail from there 'for Panama, and
will be away 'unUl November 10. T
-vv-X :J 'Jyh 4e : -; 4 ' ;v yyyyy.
Mrs.' Robert ,W. Patterson, who re
cently returned, from V a .-short trip
abroad,' haa returned to Chicago.' Mrs.
Patterson will come, as nsual:to this
city. 'later in, the season to open her
heme on-Dupont circle. ' '-'
:; ;v.-ir-;,5":.'.' '
Mrs. Robert Wallach, wife of Capt
Wallach, . U. . S. A-. who was (the guest
of her, mother-in-law; Mrs. -Wallach, In
I street, has igone to Hamilton, Mass,
to, visit her mother, Mrs. Henry Cleve
land PerkInsC!f??v f : -rK
y'Vif.- --' y- ' " -rU
Mr. ' David Jayne " Hill is in New
York,- having arrived from Europe this
week. It Is unaerstood that the for
mer ambassador and Mrs. Hill and
Miss HIII wll spend the coming winter
in this city. y - -. '
The Assistant Secretary of War and
Mrs. Breckinridge have taken an apart
mem on Wyoming avenue and are es
tablished there. : ' t ' .
I 's --':: : 'r: ' ,;i .
Mrs. iUalnbndge-Hoff, formerly of
Washington, is visiting her son. Com
mander Batatridge-HoIT, at the Naval
:'" -w : .
Mrs. Thomas F.Walsh is a gues of
the Secretary of War and Mrs. Garri
son on' their tftp to Panama,
-. 4 a.. . : . .
Much, rough Weather was !met by the
Inter-Island steamer Claudine in re-
tu rhing from the Mani " ports yester
day.' ; . - .-
Oahu fell off half a point in a sale
of . 5 shares at 11.50 on this morning's
board, ' where no other sugar stock
was in evidence. - Brewery maintained
21.50 for two lots of 50 shares each.
Cv R. & L. fives held at nar for
$1000. Altogether it was a hardly
worth while session, but rather por- would "properly be submitted. Like
tended atfother week of depression, wise as to the, statements attributed
i - B II I III II IIIBI I. I M it II J
(Continued trom age one)
organke' "his 4 department : Several
considerations, quite ulterior ; to; the
investigation itself, -such ? as a res;-catlon-
already acted on that of Detective-
Manuel 4 Olsen rand another
resignation now submitted that bl
Detective Robert SWiden have made
a' reorganization necessary. : But the
iwilnt is; McDuf fie says . he Is hot 'go
ing to attempt to drive' from the de
partment the men who sought his Tm
dclng. v-; ' ' , '-: i:Kv y-. y,
'All the persons officially concerned
In the: investigation by : which, Is
meant Sheriff Jarrett, Deputy Attorney-General
Smith, Captain of detect
ives McDuffle and tils attorney, E,' C
Peters'expressed ; themselves this
morning as glad that the matter had
ccme to an end. The sheriff and. the
deputy attorney general believe the
Course they ; have taken Is the only
fair one." :'--;
' The next 'case to be taken up will
be .that of Detective , John R. KeUett,
also represented by Attorney Peters.
Smith is of the opinion that the evi
dence, "against him 13, much stronger
than was the evidence against McDut
fle, and: consequently he ; expects to
proceed t with It ; before the - commis-sion.-
An appeal for & hearing before
that ' body has already -been noted.
Sheriff Jarrett is Glad, f 'U f I i : V v
7 Sheriff Jarrett was all smiles - this
nibrhrng.'andZ didn't" hesitate to say
that he was glad that the Investiga
tion had come to ltjs conclusion with
the entire thing, so far as McDuffle
is concerned, settled He was pres
ent yesterday morning during the en
tire 1 conference; j and.- v according to
Peters, he acted . fairly . throughout
answering whatever ? questions t were
put to" him with candor. " . ' , ' Z1-
. "I am glad it Is all over.. said Jar
rett I reinstated McDuffle - this
morning .'on the recommendation of
Smith. . -There are no hard feelings
between us. I still look to McDuffle
as my. friend. C I. allowed .the investi
gation to proceed because the charges
had been made and because I felt that
It .was the, only proper thing under
the circumstances. But I never took
an active part in the investigation.
,Now that it .Is all over and McDuf-.
tie is back on the job," we will have a
talk together "and : a few changes in
his department 'may be piade. I have
promised Detective Swaden to place
of lnspectcr of weights and measures,
a position made" vacant ' by ; the death
of Officer AbreuA It will be necesslry
for him to take a 'civil service, exam
ination. 'V i Ho will, however,- tak the
posi tion at once and the- examination
later." 'V-rZ-'-' '--h; v-.-. -
McDuf fie on . the Jobw i - f ,X
; ' Jarrett - was , asked If the complete
authority t over - the V detective depart
ment, vested ; by him In McDuffle,
Vlll be withdrawn. 5 He said:. ''
I have no such plan- It may, be,
as we1 talk tilings over: we will see
rt .nf vi,nv nf anv PTrpnf the fib
mentioned. s?r r..--
': McDuffle appeared a few minutes
refore 9 o'clock at the' office cf the
sheriff and was simply; told ' that? he
was rclnstat'ed. Word- to this effect
had been sent to the civil service cbn
mlssloners so "that no meeting ;for a
hearing; was - necessary." V . " ' : ''
- MI am glad the thing is over " said
McDuffle. , "It came out Just as I
predicted.: Yesterday, when Mr. Smith
met us, he gave; me ' the opportunity
I- wanted to explain away the charges.
Mr. Smith was very fair; the same
was true of the sheriff. .? Mr. Smith
took up ohe'eharge after another; and
I" simply fold him my side "of them."
Attorney Asks Fair Play. , 4
v vCoramentlnff on the outcome of the
case, Attorney E. C. Peters made the
following statement: V v . - -;
-4 The. decision of Sheriff Jarrett to
reinstate Chief McDuffle was not un
expected. The evidence disclosed by
the investigation admitted of no other
coriclilslon. . Deputy Attorney-General
Arthur, G. Smith in his dual capacity
of linvestigator. and 'advisor secured
and submitted to the'sherif f such evi
dence as was; procurable and gave it
as, his opinion that it was not suffi
cient Justification, for McDuf fie's sus
pension; Hencei: the decision of the
sheriff. - '. ';,'' ; y? '; ' " '-'; - ;
. .'rThe attitude of the Advertiser,
however, as discibsed by its morning
columns, is to be: regretted, lit places
Itself In the position of appealing to
Its readers from the decision of the
deputy attorney-general and imputing,
to' say 'the least,: rank error of : Judg
ment on the part 'of that officer In
advising; Sheriff Jarrett that the evi
dence was Insufficient to place before
the Honolulu: Civil Service CommIs-4
sion. .:- ;.;v'.- ., ,. .' :;,; --'-.
The 'evidence 5 submitted by ;the
Advertiser . this morning wasknown
both to it and to Mr. Smith. Mr.
Smith "decided 'Hhat it was 'Insuffi-
cfent, . It might appeal to the gossiperJ
or slanderer, but certainly not to Aim
who understands that evidence In the
main roust be within the knowledge
of the vWitness and worthy of belief.
Evidence 'which is unworthy of be
lief is : of no greatef value" than no
evidence at all. And the considera
tions of the deputy attorney-general
vrere necessarily and could only be
based ; upon "evidence within the
knowledge of th9 witness and worthy
of belief, When he decided that there
was not soiiicient evidence to place
cation of McDuffie's suspension, his
Dtiore me comiB lasioners bs juswii-
decision amounted to the statement
that assuming all the evidence to be
true there1 was not sufficient, or such
evidence as was worthy of belief was
insufficient. Because, for instance, if
Mr. Smith " believed the evidence of
the Korean spy as to the facts related
t then the Korean s evidence
In which U, combined h HAWAIIAN STAR, established 1S3J. and the
EVENING BULLETIN. esUbilshed J8S2. Issued' Dally and Seal-V. eekly fcy
- :vf Published Com
.": 'v :: i-a -v Photo-Engravers. . .;;. ' ""vJa
WALLACE R. PAERINGTON. . . .General Business Manager
2JE3IBER ASSOCIATED l2irS3.
FLAT" RATE, DISPLAY ADVERTISING OVER 20Ci INCHES.........
(Preferred PoslUoo 20) .......... .. ................ .2Qc PER INCH
' ( . LEGAL AND TRANSIENT RATE, l Hrst Insertion .
, " CLASSIFIED, One Cent per word 33 eetts Ter line rer weeic '. v
MAIN OFTICES . . . . . 1059 ALAKEX STREET
Telcphone Editorial Booms SISSjr Sisacn C.lre :.,:3
: v. Telephone 2ZZ
. SUE5CEJPTI0X KATE3I
: t- ' ' ' , DAILT STAR-CULLLTIN :.
Per Month, 'ajsywhera la tlalted States
Per Quarter, anywhere la United States
Per Year, .anywhere la United States..
Per Year, postpaid, foreign ...
:'U,yp- 7yy SEMI-WEEKLY- STAR-BULLETIN ; f c . -.. '
Per Six Montlxs l.O
Per Year, anywhere. In United States.". . ....... ...............
Pex Year, anywhere la Canada S.C3
Per Year; postpaid. areiga ...... . . , . ... . . . ....... .C )
Auircss all CcsastlcaCons to IlcrI-'.a
to Swaden and Apana. But If 3mithUuch a: thing, that I hJ rever told
did not believe the statements of the, him anything to lead him to believe
Korean or Swaden or Apana, then
the evidence of those gentlemen was
of no greater Value than no evidence
at all- -'.-.:: . -;: f -: ' J -
Mr. Smith was agreeable to the
Advertiser as an Investigator. It had
his confidence and he had the back
ing and support of Its columns. .The
fact that It presumed to: publish all
the evidence that'was submitted yes
terday behind 'dosed doors" shows
that It knew or was informed of the
ftvidpncA nrpHPntpd to Mr. v Smith.
Furthermore, It was accorded every 5 proceedings I propose to institute."
faculty .in presenting to him the evi- That was all ha had to say, but it
dence which it claimed through It3.6eei3 to be very signlucant
aifnrtal oolntnna n nnet - Tho In.I ChLlIngWOrth Saidr
vestlgator of , its iChoice decided that
the evidence was insufficient . v .The
parties to that decision were . the
sheriff and McDuffle. y And in the
spirit of fair play aud substantial Jus
tce. Is not McDufflee entitled to that
decision ,'and that the .Advertiser
abide by.it?" : ... ,-'?.: ;r" -
, - Attorney Smith made the follow
ing statement . to the . Star-Bulletia
this morning: ? - - ,r - - -"I
tried to put myself In the posi
tion of the civil , service commission
hearing the : case, .- and came to
the conclusion;: that; I . had . not
sufficient evidence When met. by Mc
Duffle's explanation thereof to make
me .'. certain that . the commission,
a full hearing, would sanction a
discharge or a reduction in rank of
McDuffle. - The ' explanations made by
the captain , of : detectives were not
wholly . satisfactory,; for' the jfact re
mained that during McDuSe's admin
istration these : large gambling games
did run. And some ; games . would
start up .again Immediately after be
ing raided by McDuffle. , ; ;
,As soon as Deputy Sheriff Rose
took charge and "started to close up
these games,-the remarkable thing
about' It all was that: those games
.which were impossible to raid,- such
as the Ah Hoo game, closed down and
have remained closed ever since.
"There was not-a bit of direct evi
dence which would Justify .anything
in the way of a criminal . charge
against : McDuffle. " The - whole thing
resolved . Itself down: lhto a ' question
of competency. I was'perhaps influ
enced in my position; by the fact that
McDuffle - will now have to - see that
these games : frotn which - he Is al
leged to have received money, remain
closed, or explain. .why they are nqi
closed. Mt has been shown that the
larger - games can" be stopped in; Ho
nolulu and ' that a wholesome fear of
the-detective department has a good
deal to do with the question of wheth
er the games shall run or not. . Mc
Duffle .will have a chance to keep up
the: record set by Mr.' Rose or explain
why he does not.'
; There Is some i question whether
all, the large gambling games"; have
been1' suppressed. ... Statements have
been made that there are a 'number
of them : now : running full blast , m
the city., The Star-Bulletin has been
tofti that a number of games have not
been raided. .: .:;:'; . . : ;
(Continued from page oner"
was responsible for bis suspension on
a charge cf drunkenness. -"And then
again,"; he 'added, "I wanted to get
my Job back, and a reporter on' the
Advertiser gave me to understand
that If I made such an affidavit my
1ob would be given back to me. .Ac
cordingly, a day. or two after J was
reinstated I swore to the affidavit
Before I did so I saw that ' It con
tained ' statements which I knew
nothing aboutsuch as the one that
A. M,; Brown, Charles r ChlllingwoTth
and McDuffie were ; getting money
from the gambling games. I told fhe
reporter that I knew nothing about
i ovn?- mil r; 'tvt
k . . . MERCHANT- STREET
.... .....$ .75
J. .................... 2.C3
rZzzil Zl:zlz. 7. II.
any such thing; but he tdi ne it
was all risht, tsli na to go ahc i and
sign it, which I did. I never real the
affidavit all through. I enly read the
'leading lineal cn the pc?s.T
Just what action Is bing ccntem
plated by Brown and Chlillnrsvcrth U
not. disclosed today. But that seme
action U to be taken la lnilcted by
Brown's few word3, which were:
Court , Procseiins Intimated.
"1 prefer not to make any stats-,
ment at. this 'time in view cf future
""This is the ' greatest ploca cf unfairness-1
'have ever known."
Ohsen. satJ today
he had signed the
was executed in the attcrr.ey- :z or
al's oce, he called en Dc;uty A:tor
ney'general Smith and cs'ci that it
be returned to him. The reazen ha
gave was that many of the Elata-
re'Eats lir- U' c-rtTiiati o?Ll that he
fe.ired ft wou'.! go hard v.Ith t'.r.i if
he did not recover tha a.T.avit. Al.ir
Smith 'had stricken out tha r '3 cf
the aidavlt which --C.-tn .':rcl
were' fatee, he 'returned ll to C!.;cn.
The latter says ha toc'x It to a Chi
nese restaurant and de:trcyed IL
Olsen Tel! About A.';:: ult
The appearance tLli rzcrzlzz in the
Advertlser.of this affidavit which tad
been returned to him by :r.ith camo
without warning to Ol3en. Ha Elys
that whon he, denied, the truth cf
many portions of the Instrument, and
one copy,wa3 returned to him, he de
stroyed it and believed that that ended
the - matter.
7 "I took the" affidavit to a Chinese
restaurant and burned it up." ha said.
' "1 was suspended from duty about
September 17, and socn after that I
was met by a reporter cn the Adver
tiser," said Ol3en; thIs' mornL-.?, la
explaining why he'slzned the Li3trt
ment. "He talked with me about the
charges against McDuffle, asked me
what I knew about the ring, etc - .
-.'"T-jtoldv him I didn't want to make
a statement, and he replied that I
didn't have to. But soon after I met
him and, we talked some more abcut
the charges. It was understood then
that I was to "make a statement and t
be' reinstated. I think It was the day
following this that I met the 'reporter
5 nd he told tne fhatl was to go to
rork. . I also met Detective Swaden,
who; was working with, the reporter,
and he told me t was to report for
work.' 7'; -7 ,-7 , 7 7 ? . 7 )., ; ; . 1
""After' this they ' took me to an at
torney's: office and the attorney In
formed the reporter tht they had al-;
ready beea sent 1 We then went to
the Advertiser oifice, and I belleve.lt
was there, the affidavit was -foundV I
did not see it, however, until we reach-
ed-the attorney-general's office. 7 -' -.-Didn't
;Read Document Through. ' " .
; '"There,' ia the. presence of Attorney-general
Thayer, I was given the
affidavit, v There -were three copies.
I was handed one to read, but only
tead tue leading lines. ; I thonght.lt
was all i- rlght-that .the facts in It
were as I had given them to the re--porter.-1
Once, however, I saw; some-,
thing which ; I knew I had not said,
and I called the reporter's attention
to; it, but he replied, saying: 'It's all '
right; go ahead and sign It.' So ;I
signedlt and swore to JtT 7 7
He goes jpa to state that a may or
two later he called on: smith and
asked that the affidavit be given back
to htm,, '?SmIth surrendered tthe three
cdpies, he says. '-.- 7-7-; - '7"ir -
y: ' 1 '
The new frontage tax law will form
the discussion at the"" meeting of'the
KalmakI Improvemehf - Club "fn-the.
Liliuokalani; school, Kafmukl, at 7:S0
o'clock this evening. T.' M. "Church.
president -of the organisttion, S. Ss
Paxson, and Senator A. P. Judd :wfll .
read papers, dealing with the subject. ,
and a general discussion by the 'mean .
bers of the club win follow. .
Affur. remninin for 'a 4 number of
months at Hilo and along the coast of
Hawaii, the steamer Kaiulanl . ls an
arrival at Honolulu with a small ship
ment of cattle, 30 cords "of firewood
and 40.000 paving blocks. The Kalu-
lani will go. into drydock before ; re
turning to Hllo.. 77 , 7 7 7
-. -' .-
xml | txt