OCR Interpretation


The evening world. [volume] (New York, N.Y.) 1887-1931, April 10, 1907, Evening Edition, Image 1

Image and text provided by The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundation

Persistent link: https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030193/1907-04-10/ed-1/seq-1/

What is OCR?


Thumbnail for

i y f U rr J1Jt bit I ITI t I
cO
r
i OO 0 > > OO I > >
f BEST SPORTI G FEATURE FTHE DAY l l
I Full Details Relating to the Form of ALL the Horses Running at
F 1 Bennings ToMorrow on Page 12 t
w Ct O U e J M IJieJ
l
n
r ou IIVTIinit nntr and frrriltiB Thursi r nlr
WCATHBIl Snnrr nn 1 frerilnm Tlmrilnj fnlr I t
l Gbt r Y of THAW VERDICT I
L U 1 EXTRA
I 1 ei Circulation Books Open to AIL I I i Circulation Books Open to AIL
0
PRICE ONE CENT NEW YORK WEDNESDAY APRIL 1011907 PRICE ONE CENT T
C n = 0 cC = = c 0 = c n = C =
THAW JURY IN A DEADthCK t c I
I
1j II l 1 I r I W FOR MANY HOURS
1 J
k lVENING WORLD RACE CHART
FIFT ENTU DAY AI6ENNINGS1
APRIL 10 CLEAR TRACK GOOD
85 1nsT hAClrataldea thrrr rear otde iqd upward 1100 added flv Jurloon Co
a4nutibla oour >
111 Ifhcdcoclt lirlvlajr T1mw I OR M winner br L by PUudll Th Rot
erT II lebCO < k r
tdu jjLart Uggr w U 81 U tTh FBI Jock r r HlchClo H nh
t Sho a 110M y6 1 I I I Hinlth Jo a
1 1 IS Ill 10 I
How Atout IOU 112 a et t U 41 1Ilamlth III SO 4
a C lr on inVI a 7 o 3e KMtlnc 11 log joi 40 Jl
lId Chtlh VI n St Lt to 4 j Jlntfir logB joiH 3 b6
IJ Situ Cat la VIM b 14 li > 1 61 jliuo Ii 911 2M 3b 4
Wt t 1I hM it 3V > aV 5 Siounttln 7 v Ivf 73 S3 K
sa IUCT hinnn jj U W ti AIrdUeott IvfrS J
Mud totl iS
rS
utk lukg III I 311 It 1CCarthy H 0 f JS H
M AcrumuUt p 4
I u kx 1ft e
111 Hall + nd Pepper iflf 13T1k 10 I 0 10 tS 2u J5MI v S II
ja Uwk b is iJ n 1 = Ii 1wrr r MI a 5 W
Hnrlrtill I nJ l 12 Oollneln w I
u 18 J Ia 11 f1 la York A tw too 20 I
= lttella hJ a 12 J4 4 fljmmnni IV > 1rI rtl 02
i l tlmt 340 i off i U rrmcvviTu4lMiiuct UutlusunC
nkltj
a and llAviru
V tl L aaOed tw > ju aa 4uui lajasurm i
2I hose tat the ul and lUll 11M < dratten tl mol tron l1uw About You
aanlro +
I
I S6 It old t cuun 1AC17Itn tKOJTMrollll r iwJ dJM four and a halt Nr ore
Afar good Won drlTlnjr TlnoOo ZS mener b c by TMilnittcm Cornea
o n r I Iowri
Htruri T ta a4yt CS iTlrt Joule rK Op ItlahlIh 1k
1 t J IIhlUSo nllll s 3 n y 4W < fJr HtroiTur O1IUJ Ijr jin 4
Si fcSJfvWii S 5 K s si a onry I 5 Ji > J i i
j n a I
I frj e ot auadu 1 rf I u 4 i tei 6 II 3 I
is
I ffiasif IIf 7 1 tl tJ II wryer n si t4
Itle F1d1 taw k 1lY 1 a y tlt T n III ry fill S fl 1 tl
E J s i µ l1tr f 13 i tle f
° an1td
1 llJJ l o i = l 10 Kl nll I e J
1aillm a2A nrt Fnt s4I ltldw
llllfll w het r or Anahw qlt IM lstk dl bed iDer1
B7 T1U1N JtACThTArla oJ dolJ IL and a hU u loon C m tii
tars rq1 lion ill out TImI 1Slnnerb c by reeTonn Owar
n a Ptatlr u tS aNt 3 Nn
PII JorbraOnnlHan loc1
e 9ili o II t 1T iftnI1
II
11
2 16 I
1
T
J lkh IIMI I I 111 r t
tulr 3 7101 111
Y r
70 1 r II ell 011 01 1 4 j 3 f lountalny II 0 8 6t I y
aN dtIn ti I 1 =
u g
F ht AWd ftJi t t J rJltl V 16
e J non 20 3U M 6
tt 11m 35I ort 337 =
nnna we rt bolt hail llre4 tdlI Lallr clod tronrOthar DUlrtaud
b itllIITII ItACFour rearol1a 1 ujard awiIjJ =
pwud AdeJ ray
r 0 Mt mane turlonrr Celum
111I wane cowl iJ won + t jl eulL Udmnt Tme1tA2 3 Wlene11 c br 1IlIt ot S ararr
t Index Nnrrfn Wto Rt J k TT
o YeY + p + a I IrnClw ftF a
it fb a VIU or I awn 111 x I ol yi y 1i NII r ill 615 r J3T 13
n rr Irom 10 1 5 t 3 teltiwl u 3 I
t
RI 1 fcttm a l t n tI II ell 1
I a It r > 7 n 4htw 1 t Itlnlth io t to 4 1s
iJ tlnnarAor I 61 6 Ate Its 1w UJ III II
1 oJ
Pfd nwtln L ld 1f1 u T 1 t I U 2 t a
= = J lukltwn III U It 4 Tw
Iat Urn 2off 111
l 1 TH >
Ion plro aI y Mal a rote rile
pJ a Ihwhiundr wTak 1W ete eM lr opivnr urlY r ed own bbl core q opMd In the last fur On
8Urlr ItACLiultlArinrrarda glair and up + nd Jw aSSr VVn car ono
n < if eta Qwntr 1 > vSmdrlYlnc j C rr TlmIal 1a WlBer t t tr armirvnluAptdl
o4 n tltrten Vl HI la = ti7
Jula kE
7
11II rcty u4 11 t I t I Ir N
+ 1i t
3 N91ah Uun a t a fl I film i I i2 74
fv nbo na Tn N tlddu D G j HI
r v
n I ttarntn 2 4 zt t nt J Jhnwn 3 it 111 al
i IVlbUlvfll mt JJliaili 4I J Nrutinr 1 II s
° mar P i Y + t LJlanl 1p J1 I Ji t
T i loTCiiif n unolI f I M I 7
avno y pad bowed lmpror m nl irwl huni
uni on Food and
M no nm Wtou Qu fn nn
O p n 1t r dgld 1 P 1hnaJ arold and upward ldUddwf nl teal
II 10 dhI Tlm 1u
r < 0 i errran t7nrtdrHlrlF I9Id Wlnn r tf e tor IAplllttPl1n
1 iliArl ii iil
M ctk l I t 1SV A a lilt I
t M 1 r 14 fJiit mronte hells 1101 7 Ii J lit t S C gwJIt404 n B s I It V 4 7jT = I
too IYIIIrDo ht J A1 aS tai u
t r A t I5 iou 10 Q 1
I i o IIrn A It ort r n Krarh < < 1 Mf t1h r J i 3 11
IflOfl waa bell UI ran his no 0nnI 1II1lt t j ad The TSuiH
j jj pelted wwt nIIY on w Inflows tatMnt the
I 8L ACK STORM IN
11
dawn tin over minutia JoI1I1 the Inland itorm lud the blown mow I
ud Ihky brJlhLonll A drizzling j I
AN GR SWIRLS hUlln rn the dlscoinfort nlnuo i ptoiil bound for ot the B homeward I me to add tired to I I
NEW ORLEANS RESULTS
OVER THE CIT Jlns HACKOne mllOold 1uka
m to place < to i 1 HcAIIIiler n to1
3 Ilti place i t1letlJlrulll I terItn o
L J
u
Cor nAPBBurn furlonri
CablOrm I 10 G and Dill t Bt JAlOn
Snow Rain and Sleet So t tr to Lx for p KM L Vie 7ar11rr I Tim I
I 1lIInD ItACt kills and qUArlrr i
Thick You Could Cut CI naVlIny In I fir plaid 1 10 37 t and Hanna DUll 1 J Tlmeos 8L NH I
I Fouling IIACE Half muleIglu I
It with a Knife Ixo G to I and to Jl 1 iiislek Uurr
CIlo I tor plan J True I Timer
r i 0 ijrs I
IIKTIt AfBOn mile Uclc
Abram h to 1 and I In h I
j I Allonb
A feUck squill of snow nun and slttt
is t > tor ptae t QUIU I Tlmn
hat struck Itit oily t 4 oIOk title 1
flUrnt waCam itrgge A lhenCHUNII
of lhlrmtets car Unriimcn are JIIl EVA BOOTH STRICKEN
mllt < toN It cint up IIh alum I I
mar itoroi and posed over Ilkn on AFTER BIG RALLY I
liut the wind thus sucomptlllx It torn
cold and tilt snow and let thai rod on I
the wind wsl painfully teil C IroN O Mill tvs Ilooth ram
Ubtirviri Inthe all oRU bultdlRCl mndf of tl H4h still Army Ira
doirntown noilt i Ih sky turntni gray poke at the Auditorium hire lust night
Whlnd the Jirny hllle a > out SX9 Neon to four UMwn n < 1 poG was aHull
all of Jersey City and llobek n ours br a ludrlt Ulntu alter Ult addrtu
hidden In what leaked 10 t i a thluk hI eeitiilllof waae lyloui Ulat ibi u
1 foe itretchlni out ova the river JlI ellil In fire hand Qt a pliyilclsn m U
nlevl on New York Ilk a eluwd Tell tIOnln hold l and Is uoibli 10 leave
tllinule u tur It stuck the lowir thi Bltt
lertlud at MtnttstUM a bllxiard HBS 4n MaKlnl hM arr + aod to ft I
I < < Jt04 rlilll11i 1M lIarl stir hrr 41 hor eoae toder 1
A low nn InsUla fur ihn storm Uruk r q of nfr IeMeiese waa tint tot la
sky iruMrs boss Iowan ar II M 11r1Inly heal Mn Joltlelr had
The lskts wars turned h eyed b kintt o1b Iroraa etYm
fhlIJIIU w 11M Ii e + ply aw Of 411a1 ingplrl
ran und I tNiAtt HlII In lit J
l
try t6 1 UtlWIIP illru1 IIUI i
Qa yrlpall
t L riMa wlN U 4 1a11 ° DUL Anil aisl feats Iieeaetew LX1 1a 1 yyy Ae rt iiYl
r f 1 c v
1
1
i t 11 rlilu HfJj 4
COURT IN HIS CHARGE R1vIEWEDI
L TESTIMONY IN AN EXHAUSTIVE WAY
I
Justice Fitzgerald Finished His I
Charge to the Jury at oClock
He Defined Every Phase of the
Law and Told the Twelve Men
They Must Weigh the Story Told
on the Stand by Evelyn Xesbit
Thaw >
Justice Eiizreratd finished his charge to the Thaw jury at 51 1
oclock The jury then retired to consider the verdict Justice r
aId decided to remain within call in case a decision ireaehed tonight
DistrictAttorney Jerome finished his address to the jury at 347
oclock He had spoken more than four hours Jerome talked in hit
thebullseye fashion He assailed Thaw and Evelyn Nesbit Thaw He
said that Thaw was sane before and after the shooting Thaw and the
m mbers of his family remained unmoved during Jeromes speech but
they all showed nervousness when th ordeal was over They all re
mained in court in the hope that a verdict would be quickly rendered
Justice Fitzgerald started his charge to the jury at 420 oclock He
began by asking their close attention saying he desired to define to them
thelaws anJ the legal wisdom by which they must be governed in reach
ing an agreement He complimented them upon the fact that they were
selected out of 337 talesmen before either side had xhausteJ Its peremp
tory challenges We impressed upon them the importance of the task
before them
You must take the law absolutely from the Court Of the facts
you are the sole judges he said Then he proceeded to make the fol
lowing points
DEFINES TIlE LAW TO TIlE JURY >
That ibo defendant Is presumed to br Innocent until proven guilty
That ho must have the benefit of every reasonable doubt
That murder In the first degree ii premeditated and deliberate boml
clde
Thnt murder In the second decree U homhvMe committed without pre
meditation
That manslaughter In the nut degree la murder committed without
the intent to cause death
That homicides which are not criminal are claned aa juiUflabte and
excusable homicides where life U taken In self defense or In proper defense
of another
That homicide II alo excuaable when committed by accident and
without unlawful Intent
That In this lLthe defense being Insanity U la governed by certain
eotlona of the Penal Code
That a person la not excused from criminal liability aa Idiot Imbecile
lunatic or Insane person unless he labor under such a detect of reason
I aa not to know the nature and quality of bla act or not to know the I
net wai Krone
Hut alIbI characters and acts of individuals rary the Jury must
not undertake to Judge tliU case by other cane
That if from the ertdence the jury was aatlafltd that the deed was
committed with deliberation and premeditation by a sane parson they
must nod the defendant guilty of murder In the first degree
TVIIS OJf MfItDISK SECOND DEGREE
That If the Jury found It was committed by a acne person but with
out deliberation or premeditation they must find the defendant jruJty of
mtrrrtei In the aecond degree
lh of the victim furnished neither
That the crjpmcter Juatincatlon or ex
cuse A private avenger at private or public wrong I i < not rccoBnlted b >
the Ian The character of the victim must not nlr Into yourl dellberatlong
In arrltlns at a verdict
That evidence cf communication claimed to hare been made to the de
pendant had been admitted only tending to haw the effect of lUch com
munleatlon upon his canlty
I
Tha the law Irllllmea unity as that U the normal condition of mgn
kin L and thin the burden of the proof of IAMnll YOU upon the defense
That ft wfftV or Reordered mind Will not In Itself an excuse and that
a delusion In the dtfendauta mind was not rxcusaQ1e for a homlcld
unlen th dtluiloB If true would bay pQnttltu ad a proper XCUM
f T1stilia 7 ry J i k cktUe trlietlet naw 1twK i tkl w 7 t
M y w r
T III 1 Ii ftf r
f q
i h
lhJij
1t7 I
and flrlnp r revotrer at hla enemy was liable to caiiae death and It he
know the act was forbidden by law
That the Btory of the defendant wife wa not gIven In evidence with
regard to Its truth or falsity but In order that the Jury might decide
what effect tbo telllnR of It had upon the defendants mind
HAD RJGHT TO PROVE MORAL PURPOSE
That the defendant had a right to prove a moral purpose which might
to
have had an effect upon the mind
That the defendant had a right to ahow that after a certain Um the
condition of hla mind underwent a change
That he had right to ahow that earlier Influences might have had an
effect upon hla mind
That Uio defendant muat prove to the satlsjcctiop of the Jury that at
J theTltne bf hla act he waa not sane within the legal meaning of the word
That the story of the defendants wife with all Its phases and the
latitude given the croMeiamlner should be weighed In their entirety
< Here Jerome murmured an exception
That the deep Interest which the wife had In the outcome of the ease
and the fact of her husbands peril should be given due consideration
That the clalnl had been that the credibility of Hummel might be Im
peached because of his conviction and because of hla record and the Jury
I was allowed to consider thin claim
That the legal presumption was that tbe defendant waa aane at the
time of the killing but that any reasonable doubt us to hla sanity must bs
given to the defendant
That testimony regarding the defendants alleged Insanity as ahown In
his examination by expert after the crime might bo considered aa tending
to show the probable condition of the defendants mind nt the time of the
tragedy i
That the Jury mlKhJacept or reject the testimony of any expert and that
the jury must take into consideration the standing reputation and ex
perience of the experts
That the opinions of the experU must be connldered In connection
with all the facts
MUST HAVE BENEFIT OP THE DOUBT
That it must not bo taken aa granted that the statement embodied
In the hypothetical questions were true
Tha a reasonable doubt waa not a possible doubt
That the prosecution was not called upon to provo tho guilt beyond a
jiosslble doubt but that guilt must bit proven beyond a reaaonable doubt
That If the fJry had a reasonable doubt of the defendants guilt In the
fltaU degree and had no reasonable doubt of murder or manslaughter In a
leaser degree they must glee him the benefit of tho doubt aU Awl dbim
guilty III the lesser decree
That the Jury must consider only the fac tOt evidence and to disre
gard all statemrnta of counsel except such as were pertinent and proper
That the Jury should reach lu verdict In the light of the law and In
wisdom and fairness and honesty
That It the defendant were acquitted on the ground of Insanity the
Jury must so state In Its verdict
Justice Fitzgerald finished at 611 Jerome asked that the Jndg charge
the jurors also that If after a discussion one 6f the Jurors stillfelt a rea
sonable doubt all of the Juror must vote to find the defendant guilty In a
lesser degree Justice Fitzgerald mad this addition
The Court then followed the banal formality of entering an exception
In the name of the defense on thn ground that thecharge to the jury offered
by the defense liaJ not been used by th Judge
HARRY THAW WAS NOTICEABLY NERVOUS
At exactly f5 he sent the jurors to their room to ballot for the guilt
or Innocence of Harry Tham Thaw wbo had Ncom noticeably nervous
while His Honor was delivering the charge gated bard Into the race of
each Juror as tbe twelve men brushed by him on their way out of the Jury
box Not one of Jhera looked at him
The prisoner was at once returned to his cell and his campy went to
the anteroom which they have used since the trial began to1 wait for the
summons which would man so much to them It was stated that all of
the Thaw party would remain In the courthouse building until he jury
reported no matter what tbe hour might be
Evelyn Nesbit Thaw mid to an Evening World reporter AI she left the
room We ore all still confident that Harry will be acquitted W a do
not believe that Mr Jerome speech bas Injured ills chances and I for one
am quite certain that we will hear the good news In a little while
The young wife did not appear to be In the lent agitated The grip
of her gloved hand al kite hook bands was perfectly steady Old 4lra
Than looked worn and haggard but there were no Indications that the
UOIIIIMHC mother would break down
AltliwuKh Thaws Iaayerp jtrttfesiMi liism lvfi as loving amply ratUflpd
with the Instructions It was acraontl + tHillmnt among the lawyers In thw
courtroom that tIlt ln + < i actions hail been rather advent to the cause of
the df n >
P3JI 9J ATTOlf1fYJ Jtl S SPEECH T < f ON FilGf2
+
p
G
Jury Began Deliberations Upon Facts 1 1
in Greatest Murder Trial After t
<
Brief Charge on the Law by
t
Justice Fitzgerald
I t
JEROME SUMMED UP IN i
HAMMERANDTONGS STYLE
it
t
Dementia Americana Ridiculed by District
i
Attorney After Bitter Attack on Evelyn i
Nesbit and Her Storyr Which He
if wWM + J J FT I J I I ULlT
Denied as Concocted Lie
J u r
>
f r r
The jury trying Harry K Thaw balorc Justice < Kitzgcraid in
t
the Criminal Branch of the Supreme Court was deadlocked aJ
k
11 oclock tonight All Indications from the jury room polntej t
to fln iltarrght session r u 7 >
n
T <
f
The jury had not been lacked up an hour when th r < flgdlca
lions of a long session induced them to take a races 3 for
dinner Under a strong guard of court flews they proceeded
ceeded lo the Broadway Central Hotel at 640 P M ThaI
1
I
jurors woro given a good big dinner I over which they remain
4
cd thebast part of two hoursx returning It the Jury reel tat t u i
I
at 855 oclock t
i k
Harry Thaw gave expression to apprehension 1 t1owa
5 I
interpreted as fear for the worst waon e the jurors filed duly J
Ha was heard to say to a deputy Well thank God w 4
hpe enough exceptions
Forth first time since his Incarceration he was Icn <
Alone in the oourt prison pcn with hU wife Evelyn Naab t
ThAW who had gone toa lunch at Pontlns restaurant as soen
I
V
a 6 the jury went out They rwnainod alone thro a ft8rr r
of airiwur tafetafl over the devilopmwli ol lhtdayand IhjL
t i
s z
stinging iraignment ol OistnctAttornay Jerome
Altar a Lima they wore joined by Josiah Thaw and Mr ann
t t
j
Mrs George Carnegie The others of tho Thaw paty went tpl
I
the Lorraine for dirut W r 1nd rest alter the Inu ttriw i
r > j
eaiot
wrItrlJUrYhldbenonvened for Uvtir nfghl s eul0 fl >
JIJ > tICf FiUo r3ld lent word that he wed remain witHin teln
hear call ready to come tp the Criminal Cuerts Building ai
son 25 tho jury came in
n aftcj 10 oclooV word trioklad out from the jury roof
hat the Urori had not even oomu tp the point of inking thi
It < t H fii thtt the doh bora one had rHt ohci iw oolinj uJ
i 9 r COOl I
tJ i > j 7f < t 4

xml | txt