New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, August 08, 1876, Image 2

Search America's historic newspaper pages from 1770-1963 or use the U.S. Newspaper Directory to find information about American newspapers published between 1690-present. Chronicling America is sponsored jointly by the National Endowment for the Humanities external link and the Library of Congress. Learn more

{
                  title: 'New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, August 08, 1876, Page 2, Image 2',
                  download_links: [
                  {
                   link: 'https://www.loc.gov/rss/ndnp/ndnp.xml',
                   label: 'application/rss+xml',
                   meta: 'News about Chronicling America - RSS Feed',
                  },
                  
{
    link: '/lccn/sn83030214/1876-08-08/ed-1/seq-2.jp2',
    label: 'image/jp2',
    meta: '',
},
{
    link: '/lccn/sn83030214/1876-08-08/ed-1/seq-2.pdf',
    label: 'application/pdf',
    meta: '',
},
{
    link: '/lccn/sn83030214/1876-08-08/ed-1/seq-2/ocr.xml',
    label: 'application/xml',
    meta: '',
},
{
    link: '/lccn/sn83030214/1876-08-08/ed-1/seq-2/ocr.txt',
    label: 'text/plain',
    meta: '',
},

                  ]
                }

New-York tribune. [volume], August 08, 1876, Page 2, Image 2
About New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924

Image provided by: Library of Congress, Washington, DC

Image: of 8.

Page

All Pages

Issues

All Issues Text | PDF | JP2 (6.3 MB)

New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]), 08 Aug. 1876. Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers. Lib. of Congress. <https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030214/1876-08-08/ed-1/seq-2/>

Newspaper Page Text

THE SILVER CONTROVE
LRTKB FBOM TiiiriJLOW wkki
TUS VAILK DP Ml.. UK COIN 1IXKC??sb?Y r??N
Till: PRB8CR1 i f.? t'l.i.t' IHK RRROL1 I
SU. VI. a Ail OP 1873?A RR"**R_J, ?'I' Tl
ai'Vci'Al'i :i?.
f? I lit Bailer of Tht Tribune.
lint My last letter to iHF"I-HRCRR ?fdOB
an e\??re--i "i of saM-im itton that one lead;:
Hi tWaOgXliaei "f...? "sVdsg to the -il?.: ?,
1 have l.o-.v ??? '.'? _r. I that the i!i*>cii-.-v"ii and
opinent, tho*a**b go full and elearaetoaati
n'retagte m.ad, ?I-? ant ? hanga et laodif* the ?
leatiiuia' R? pnbli? a;, ioarnala. 1 reajn t t!. - fi
he. gase these journal-- ?an likely t? pn
publu ?ill KM mini- ' I I oils-'
?jahreeia tarer of ths lepaal ?of ths
Inwwhich ?i.-.'-.in.s theQoTsni i I
gag "- re '..?"i -m ?
Tke Utter . ;' yoni We hingtos e
tvlio Is ? -titled to gl
folu-.i-:??.: .,. hag ?' lal? ?la::
| Isti
si ?,.* . -.
anil | S
, v i|e t'.. \. D * -???'-> l^:
ami ' ' ihe p
Uli..!
Inthe Conatit "
1*.7:> r?. i - ? be rece
41.-- ..?.?,- - * .'??l sir
ooa ths est - ? ? - n aiy l.tt r.
m?-?'- ; 1*>7;'>,
eq aa I t i der, ai i
th? Is -?s autl _ Ihe If ? ury D
I ? -, i ? - . ??? ?,.io?!,..ii)?? plsda ?
faul) of the ' foe the i<*?'?.:
of ths "A of it*1
i:, | i. i'- a he the Ul-ai
u, - . '. 873 on eo itiou of ?i
x, . , AH- that reu
t ration it bo t lbs a. t ol
at: - itsof e it peophi sntl :
onnHy? Tn? ? IT? et, ?t not iln- obji et, o
it?, t aras t?? depreci to silver and appreciate
'I landb on gold coueequ utlj hss beem
?atolj m i - ?'. ;- i enrolla] ?. demon.
Bilror snffers a ts ?-. depreciation in i
\v;,.i: ? d be the atb el ? I the rep? ??'
Ian; of 187! .' Would not the pnce ?al |
and .li.it ?. - ...?ii'?ie tip OutU, |g lolUlell..,
relati??- ratot - sppitmmati ?'. t
It ?\ ?li A .'.*k.?1 that the ?diver Ai llar i- aot i
in valu?' 1v the gold d< liar. 1 !.? buswi ;
?teasis directed by the Constitution ol thel
Mates to fix and reflate the vain inf l?oth a?
neither bungs gal b ??1? r withonl sm h n
tion. ! m nth ?n tii fo
it.? . ? ? -tra. : fr?.:,, B irni :
a:?!: t- but * rtsmp,
'i. e :.- r a' that "
WHht**at ? ttaitip, diver and goU tronld
their places ? itfa baser metal?, telling iu the mi
f... .?'oat they wi re practically worth. Their es
?leTaina la imparted i?>* t!io Goveminenl stant
hare deplored, in ov.iiuni with <'t;?er ?
la?-kof statesmanship at Washington. With!
enH| hteii ! nd pal i iotii men i?? Congr? as tl
of 1873, depriving ths ?people end the eonni
on? of tb. :. tw. !? ....-:. -,?i. r coinages, would
found little .a-.i'v in either Hon ?? of Co ig ? ut.
anhappily Webster, Clay, (toward, Slangum, 1.
Whittkesy, John Scrgoana, Many, W
A?'., lui.. I. leaving nfl sacre
c'i.i.? to an etnergency wl*i?th the reh
? .?in!. Hence ?the passage of s Ian which
cau*.- psneral - rprise, and trill*, wheat its mi
iutli,.-: ? at are 1? ttet anden t.
?lii;t:;iti>n. fog ?? bea it ??'?i
that by striking silver out of the It-gal-tendei
tagte} a ?l??i-t:>?u.44. mjoa truck at the indus
of the eoi.it;,, so ft. at -.'. \ re.
tie;,'ly eiidur-''. ?O-tMigroes i? supposedtorepr?
the InttrmRt ul th.* wh le p ople ? bnl in tas
pol?', a':.! cold only, .->. legal tend. i. . ?
small clats only was couanlted. The ?
gol.l is porpetuated by a law of I
in? aint-.'.s are ?sjaeeaed, ?Imp bj drop, froa
Iti'W of labor. Now I take leave
nah Brpreaeiitatives atul Benatnrg hon
in their 'U.'t-i e*,T th:? IWeatillg ?ui'i-i -.
... d sgainsl lab
; 1 The i itizt !?- ???: I ? Western SI
? ??I :? repealoi t.'i.- wrong law. They op
tet - --ion li?
t ? ? . itesth. ? ??.:- h ? n w !.i< h wt
al! *ain"i ? ' .-. i re ? d B - ?t ('??-,
? i in I B70, w itb-out h n
?
i* the " mat ??my" ? : '?
t -. i 1:. art ot !*-7.'?. de
?? ?. i : h. itit great)?.
? ? ing tb. l? iitleiis, !??- ?? -,
en ? ::i : - la), mini ifact m i i : ? an i
?Meann Li)? lb. bond] old? . eigner*? ii
trnoni we purchase luxurit t pi itil largely.
If tboae ?.?-'m urged tl .? i bs B
<t? ? bad ? ? . r inter.
-? ? ? ?: i\ ?i repeal ol
tu ' : bat ii -in al ...
i ? . ?: I;.:. - d found 0
apa i ':? -.?-?tii sn np u .??:?et t
iption ?*.ui! ?uo.-i ??. ?t
kew-i'oric. Au., s, i-??;.
sn.vr.n has FALLEN.
?XC!l iN'.i '?:;: i tXn MARKET V\;l!S 09 I ?"
KKA1. V.tl.l'K .?! Ill ? 1M I III ?' ??V Uli: I "M'
RURRR1 I ". ti. '? win: MCP1 gl
tu? I-.m?! i 1*1) \\D .?N UCUISLATIOM?El>l
OK DIX'.im: 1*4 Til?*. VALUS 01 -n.vi.i:.
To the ?: A : i u rat ?he T r ? i> u m i.
Bnl Y??ur i ..:iev;.( tuii-nt, "<'..,"??' ? -?? i ? .'
Henatothe ilbcti ironol the si!?.r question I
ways read with great inters I, although I - uietin
?lis-.iit from bit e ?u< Insiotu, tahoa si the texl .?l l
last lettii thesaserttua that**Silver Cannot I'al
and ?Mnstrnets a very ingenioui argument to pro
it. lie says thai " u is not shown that the pin.-h.
ii)C |x)\ver i.l -,.':?.-r In*? .1. i-lnif?! :'' that " \n ?it
(oi?iti.v whi re it baa not iie.*ii by governmental i
t. -rf.-reiu-e ?? Inlly or pa.-tiillv detuotietised, it W
bu? nearlj t ? mnch ?>f ti:?- pro -t buuian lah
? tally aa it 4-.ou.il tour ytaan age.*- Andagaii
"Tin pan ihasfi g power of stirer cannot fall j?it
out a total ?-?..itiiri in those ?at regions whei
cl.at ce is ]??? .,? ilnn an?: ?iii?ieti?t. Therefore, if tl
iil.iiion of tbe metala ebangea, Ihe resnltninst l
tvee.i m the Idvanea of the porctusiiigt power <
gold."
1 shall mat attempt to follow "(;.' through the a,
(ruinent by which he reaches these Important, n
ciii.-ioiis, bnl will point ?ant what I eoneeirs tob
He fatal ?defect. Ami Iret, in onfor to avoid ?Minft
sinn, ht uu- toy a weed aboot the tue of tbe ten
" vain?-." Applied to S?TSS in ths ??r? lent di
it is the sajnivaleal of lbs ii It ? of thai metal ui th
iii.-iik * at Ihe world, tai that pries maj be ei
prraaaed m ths uni;.- of any othss sl?andard eommod
ity at tn...?- bs steel eeasrt aient, it .s i. mal to i,, *_<h
tUanriea in gold, bnl a- t-'.i'i Itn If, Uhe ewsn otbs
coiuiiuxiiit. Hi.final.? hi Taina thongh la leasde
ur?11; .m inosi of ih,m, i hangai ia tbe rat*ie of tin
valiusof tin- two |)i,i ions nmtAtim lue.uh may hi
? ?1 by ? haasna in ths valu.-1 f eJtln r ..,? both <-i
tl.ein. It ?s il,.i,.f,,K. mACetetgy, in onhr lo.lfter
inine ??h? th. i f.?.er sfthsat ssetals hyabsolutely
risen or faitea te Tains, to tabs hito aeooant anme*
thii.i,.-!?.- bssidsths limpia ? bangs ?>t tbe relation
Wind! "f:" hCRIRtg the otln | m tin- gMlbl tsof the
v..il?l. We must know ?nlwther the metal, by the
Uliitmf which the price of the ntiu-r is m. asiin .1,
hiis channsdia aetaal?*alni araoi Ithiah thees
pro]>o.-ii:ot'-s Will he uni? ersitlly .?,,.j,?,.,!_
I have-ai'l ll at ?he value of r-ilv, r i- I1-|?il,i,. ii,
the mark? i?, o? th.- ??.?rid, .iml I ?fish |? [;,y ^.?.,??
stresasoii the last sll ?vordsof this pggMoaltion. 'liie
local valu.- af an <?ui:re o? sil?er in ?adia ,? (Jbino
t?r Franee, ??hen it is PAWt in .l.ui..-tn- tra.!??, muy )*.
afi't-etMl by a lORSR local ciruim--taii?e-., which may
not c ban i-i' ll?<- real value of tbe in? ?al in the leant.
The Frein h sil? er live-franc |Mn I? exa.tlv ?s-iiiva
lt-nt in WStghtRggJ hiuness to two half-?l??Hars of i,?r
pMrnaaommry (-??itiage, and was worth in th<- market?
of the world M?6* cents in Amen? an ?.'"?'1 lagt I ha?
day. The same ?lay it ?l>as worth iu li anee the
?eqn?TB'ent of gSmy cent, in American gol... Of
two, t?o* former was it-s real v-tlue. au.l tlio Uttei
an :?i-ei,l,)it.il va'uo ?gNsS. to the ail?*
?t_*.iv.-rii?!'i"it.il nel -whti-h makee ?OH ?
the va':?e o? ! -..> fi.in.? m ?gsM? k
lir.l!:. ' ' i ' ? - - un 'U'.'t v?r
?i? ll-e Hit Man'- ? '' ?*?*"
-
A _ i
?.??-?
':--'? ?? l
' :
I? iff
? .. 50,<000,000
ItH?.?).' - ? ?ni -ulf tin#
..??- "i the a
uittl l?y
. ". i; ?? ? : a.-: ?trop i?!'i-|?,?, ?ta ??
?!>? Im- .ii-h* they intlirate
? - - ? .1 m. v ?be ?aspect?
furnished by ?ill
ti ,-- in the worM ?may " l
V ,,','i,' ,'f vv!?e?it WOUld
? ? ? me t ?un' local eso - -
tnatiaas ta ?i angla to intrj o
rannte Mtible regions of tbe same eoon
order to ?determine whether wheat Ian
wotthmon ?or .lesa during a ?given yearthandni
another, it fa nreesearj to compare i.- prl ei ol
?ferenl tunea, nol ?mi tin" lanns in ??nr \V??at?tro 8t?
or on tin- thant >?f ihe Blai k ?Sea, i?nt la Liverp
or in some other net ?gni-cd markel noon which
?apply sn.l demand of tin whole world it free to
Now, to apply these ?principles to the direr qi
lion: If we wish t<? ascertain whether til? r
artually tint u or fallen in valne, we mu il compon
;? ? ' .i- . power with tbal ? ? <?: her commtalitie
:!,, ,- cd market '??? it, ind thai is ? ?real ih it:
If ?any one in any part of the world baa silver 1
lion i ?sell, betakeeil to London, or, what ieeqi
aient tot - . . ? ,1 h-i bis pi ? ?? si ?i sn
ta?je ..i.,?v?' or below th I idoo price, act*,
in:::., the i ourae of exch tnge Ob tin
,.-,-* v hod - '? e i" ''?i? til ? i ?' dlion ;??'
?London, or, il he ii- I ? :i itiv k f' ; - li '
else, hi ii the price he onght to ?pa ? : i il
the ] I
i ,? I ? 'on povernt its rain? in
it corner ol the world ; in 1
ill ,?r ! - the ?le ?it idnrd snd Ihe exclu
snrrency,..- w? Im I ?e which h re r donld?
n sinfflc -"?.111 -; iiiilnrd. h - ?ot ithe .!. er roint1
is in ;?'?'!! ?i ' r 'nlation in any eonntrj
?real ?..?' ? "i silver in the n Un* v..
-o loug ? ? ? thai < ",:::;:;. : bul v. !
the eon* ? of trade or legislation t.'.- a i i ? I
min ont of the country, ?mid thi .? It i lo the ?m
i'i? 'i the ?mi; " bich '
fen I dot?exert fin nee un tbe ?real vnlne, i
only of the i : mm ki t, i nf of ill the il
?in the world. The world, stuck of -ii ?.??!? ?va- :
-i ?I i,',? OUI , ? 1?> lb? ' ? ? n "i 9 :.'? i1' '
by Germany, bnt the amonnl thom rl
waa ?? . V? :? -. .I. and wehavi ?ceu the efleel ..f ii i
only in i bia coun in Ind ? ;,
t he 1?.- ;. I ,,? .?I' tural caua,
ignoi bul ;?? op] ?.'?'?? nlty olacorni ? it
? i - ,? ?,' i: 11',,? ronn t is]
tbe same country, ?may canse the nomit i lo
? rain? of t! i -:!?, r tutea ? ? enrn ? ? ? lo n
chai ??? ! vv . : I? .; :. : 1 v nine . ....
?i? : ? :!. Iin! if tbe real raine la pci
'!. iniah? ?i. it will grad ? ?? ; ?
nominal value to a level with itself, unkt? tbia
1 | ?? \. nt? ii I ?> I . ? I Mi ?, Inlei ?'??.-??.. ? ? ? tb< ? ?
?>t I'l'iit,?. Ircady cited, fliia pre?
many J ote ?;.?1 ball I ronntt i
the? re to? on ?at last. ! 1?m ? -
?- foi : ? ? ? i ? >?: _
I :l'l-.'i! I ? ViIV ???'!:?'
'r mmines, ?to '.i.c eitsfnllefl'ecl ? t-n in Lui
?i?..I tli , ouutrv.
I have no doubl that "G." is right in s (?jx-ei
,ii.it the
tranaactioi ? beta ?
: II I. u ? ,:
. .:? il. but, ?,. I have al tempted I
.?i ?-,I rer bas not < J ? ?
.,? d ?Chin : ; we lo detenni I ' I
! ?
? i thoai roniit
.?t the Ic.tdin
?liei-lii; ?-,? i-i the i? lation ? loe ; > thai
I . :.,? ?before - '?' . '?
d in The I ?
last, -I.???'-tag il: who ',??,?
pain Man?
aiy of each yeai since t -:; , and
of t it h tie ?i ? :?? . ?I t
? . - l - t i : ?
live The chic!
j ?'?alie,! :?? I
? 1 -.7 l, atiton itine. In nun
a, of tin ? t , ? .
I ,:.i from ?:'.'?? ? ?? i il: n -. Sow, co the pri
t i? ?? ? e 1st of Jsui
: . ? i
1870,1 I
... ?cent
? 1 -73, ! ;
l-*7 I. I-.-, ?? i in? ? '.
conf? - ' i. ??i, * 1 .,'? ? il
? ??!? I.
:. ' ol
the Isd ??: J- : u ?. 1870, with tba
i?,!':-'] ?ii the '???? im g ol ??ii
1 --7 A. we find nn actual adva i lead ?
of I: '-?? -' ' ?> BO per.? ? i. Hy yean it - .
follows : Sine? l * 71, i : ? ? i ?
4o*_ ??m * ? ,-t.i : ?since 1871 ,?????
since 1873, ll-iorer cent <fe line; since 1874
i)?-r eenl d 1 **"?"?. I ? '. pel
i hi ..i the high i-i ice <A iron i . ?
gland in 1^7:? ?n?<l 187-1 is *. *. - -11 l . otn ; it ?
? u chango in the rain? "t oith? mi Ihe pi iou
tn? tais. Taking th? av? roge pnci -1 ; (he .'? srticl?
of win ?li tbe v ?iin?'-* in?' given in tbe I ibles rcfeire
to, and we find that tbore im- been an sctnal ad
ranee <?t' i'.-, j? i , enl iin?, i -,71, 1ml a d? i line ,>f
pel ei'.it -im e 1 373, when ! ! ? avcrag? .. lehetl i:
higheatpoinl irince i>,i7. The prices here givei
?m i i oonrse, _- ?,l prices, ?and the
r-intw une ,.i iiiie. things: I. Tbal tbe purrhasini
power of Kold baa increaaed. _". Tbul the aetna
v.11 m of i.ti!?? I ii i'-?* has decreaacd since I ^7'.'. ; o
(3) thai '?"tli "I these propositi ins are true. I tbinl
?there i-. nodonbl tlnii the ?last ??! tli,-??, _p] m ??
i- ?the true one. Thevslneoi ?.*iiiil ?bas di litlyad
vanned on seeonnl "f ?sn Increased demau?
ooopled with a ilecressed production; and tin
?mine of eommodities has decreaaed as a coucotni
tant of the prevalent depreasion of bueiniMs, I l,.
luve that the decline in the prfaes ,,! g.!-, ,.
?greater than the inereaae in the vnlm? ,,f ?gold) bnt
if mi ?suppose tbal the two ?art BQaal, ire con? In I?
thai the ?actual rise in tbe valu? of gold lias ?bees
lour !>? i et nt. Buj the n ?lation of ?the \?,!u< - ?,l gold
aud surer to each other has in tli? same tiun
? bang? 'i m iirhood ?,: 20 per cent, t?np
posing font ?per ?eentoi this to he doe to tbe tun ?i
?gold, it leaves lOpereenl as tbe actual decline ?ul
tiie ralae of silver.
I utderstaud v,r> i\,ll thai tbeae conclusion??,
though baaed on the ?beat attainable data, cannot,
from tbe ver. nature ol il?- ? ?i*,-*, l??- ?perfect
??u i,-it,-, bat I think.it is entirely sals to saj tl, it tbe
decline In tbe value of all ver bat been nt Ittxtt two
nr thrss timri a. grrat as the Inrrsaao in tin- ralas
of gold,and t!,,-? belief is suatained l>.v s careful
si inly of tbeesuaes ?ffe* ting tba raines ?>i tbeae t ?n
metala trapee lively. The intlaeneeg ?? h,Ii?ik i<> iIih
tmii the v.i'ii? of silver bave bean at least thins <n
.??ni ihnen as great aa those which liave effected the
value of gold. India having nothing bat silver t?i
Bse aa currency Buffers iuteusely on Bcetgittt "f tin
deprecia! ion in tba valaa of it. nmoey. The Oov
i-iiiiiniit ia alai-ted at the prqspecl of baakrnptcy
ami ill?? i? ?.,,!,? m, it, i'ljii dl treaa, 'l'ho revenues
of the tonally an paid m silver and ths pturcbasing
l?,.wi?r of tl.iit m, tul bas ?N iiiikiIi deelioed
that it ?All? nut IT?,? un* th< BUBS am,mi.I
of lioveiiiiiuTii supplies ai:?! servies i<*
foiiinrly. ?PlSSjSM ih.i?.ihk ?snrcltBBSS in
r.uiui??* are i,,|.iii,,i to pay froat3ft to85perotsd
ineniiiini for balls of s_sBa__8ja, Bseot-ttag lo ?lbs
auioitnt tliiiwn for, an we wem b__?___) ?by Ihe
?aiihloalcw day? u(j<? ; and to-diiy n di-pati li from
l'i U* 1 \>t?.m ?_??--_^, -
I.o'ul'ii ivports a resolution ti the Vieerny in Conn?
iv? iksKtibinf tin? ?l.-i'loiahln ??nulit.i?.>t? of all'air?
there and ????????u_ with the .lee!?ration that "the
ti.iuiilal dlso-dei U solely ?lite t?) the rapi'l fall ?n
? ? . ? at s.l.er." l'liev ?vill be gbr*d to loam
? ,i ? tte-|H?iiilent "(;." Unit " silver eainu.t
fall*" Tut it is all a mi.-t.ikc that the r?-v?Reg of
i i! i hare htsenrate ed by any iR?h eanee, ami thai
: ii ?..-?? ha- thngatM pu:?thaaing POWI r to-day
had thine yean age, bnl I leu ihaty.?uj*c<>r
reapondent's theories would most the fate ol tboss
unanswerable arguments once adramred loproTS
thai the world oouhl uol mqvei while il waadifOonll
toorerthron the argumenta, the] wereauaa end hy
tbe tacto
I do not propose n this letter to dise?as the t>t <?p
osition t?? ?fa? tii" principal and Interest of out
National debl In slltrer, bul will simplj my thai I
lu.util-, loiniir with "G." when he says that
" i-i | n 11 i i. ?milis 11 ..I ??.?? -I i.tthl |? i . I he -a n m value
In purchasing powei aa to commodities generally."
thai we borrowed. We cannot do thai sith silrer
dollars at the old standard, rated al their par rains.
RsiglagStw, /< i v. ?a. 9, i-iiv /. u w.
Tin: CONGKESSIONAL INVF-STIOATIOB.
i" n I ', e /. n' .lor of ! ? r It, h une.
Sii?: Politicians on both siib-s an in m general g
? i m .. ?. ; cover up this simple question ol peeis
resumption in s fug of >\?.'!-, thai ?t icetnt in h,
hopeless to eudestor to pul it in a imple form bo
fore the people. Wh- n it ?\a at lii-I pniposod to
.i ? ol sIItci ami gold, sud of ingls
ami ?!? i.. ;. ? ? imai llee lo report ??? t
Win!, i. i ? a- ? \p.. ???'! thai ?ni h i omraittce would
be s ' > 'I'm Itoe ? ?: ? lerts outside of Con
' an In foil I ? ..i'.''. li nl !?i d. si
nit! >1 ind odifllrnlt s ? v ?. s hl? h ought
to In? m?? titrate?) '?.? a tribunal ei I relj impartial.
I tu i m ...k? u. it an*
? ? ; . ? ? ,-t- is t" be :? ' ?? .'.????!
politi. i.iu- only, end Ihe rep ut it is to
?t'-r ?. ritoia in fors ? ? pcrid on .-. i
? ' ' ful, ? i-.., v. :,.'!.? t the berg oi
imitt. ? -iiali i 9 i... n. il Mr. Raylei or by
!.'!..- . I i ? ?'.i tho '
por! : ? ly 5 if
In neither ? ase shall we
. t'. ' aiu'i and
[ mon? or of tbe is i?t .-'?' to
: ?on of a igleoi du ildc stautLird ol ,
i ? ?? nblc standard In t !.. roto
prcvail '
I
- I .' '? ::.
.n ilit- n ?aimu bare ,
re bad la n
fo ir or Uve mu h i ' r re would d ?
been a ip ailrupl ". n ?: int pie it? ... ,..,*
mdardb i ? ? .1.
II he. II.
rk, log. ?? i -"?;.
MB. ill."' '? - .'./ ii UlTIGS El.AX.
mi WAY TD llkKlMK li ! ?IK.
re II t ? ' " ??.
.-n.: 1! ? ? ?? i ! recle V *...?.'' ay toi
ia tor. ?uu ?." ! Mr. 1 ildi n
. :!.. \ Bj to 104*. 'J Bl I
?...
it? ?I a . . i
annot lie sal ? Il bava
i niilliu of gi Id m the
ai r hml t ? ??! tbe
Ihe I.? ut
i ?-... ? i ' ? : : . .
ah? ol
?
u
I WOllbl . ? . : .
* %
- i
'
!..
present?
? '
tb !??*. i?
I * . ? ? ' :
D I
I
luidis, the put
' (mm th?
:..'.'?.
Ill I'M
! f th.
...
*
? II .1.
Il?
Till - -. '.i I / THE I'll
?. . R| ', '? RI ??::?" I? i.?
i .?:?*-..,. i, ;.:?im, ?.
.
?? ? mi ;?. - -' ?ps ?i?
. : ? , tit til li
.
either by I ii? I
.!...!??.?.: I. ? ? ? ?
i '??...:, ai?! :.l 1 |i. Bl. B nun, ? r ? I
n.. m - a? i" i".-. t '
'.- lilt -:... I
St. (???:..!. ul le French Liu II ? itittonal
i a.. . nil < lit my, were al
: . ? . .?,.?. Ri i'erlual, tb.
mi. :? i ?nl of n.?- ?'? I. ?? Star | i. ? . ?i ia! th rk ..i.
? ' - ? Il wi ii de , ker*.
net v. fu I: I ?in; Ins Is .
, i : . m i , o., i!., -.. . ? :u tin- ,,|,t
l'iorcuietl. 'I ' am. i'i i. Uli an o ...?;.'! iii.,l:i j
,i .?.., bnl was rapt. ... - ?
portloiro! the.imp ay? ?i ? n t. ?A bite J tar plei tit
.. i i !n;.!i..M ?i i?.\ t'.? C'ouipanj at i - a iry ol , i.. _
w. i \-, tin-1. ii in lug paid i ? u." !i..iir.
i: n.nt been reported i ?' anatlaek waatabamadt
. i pon the men a! ?? . :
? a i a- <?? ; m line. Ro Mm 'i ,n . m. . -. | i ?
? ? n eaiphatl..i that aaj ? .
li.-i.n nal ration aas thought of. Torendei an/dlstun)
we. impo ill t Uaallls bad bR m t la re ??!!
? ?.? all lb? ' rlki i tu iif beek -in-, i an ;
',.?' ,1. "I. I ?l| m |e eoll.l : .ll 'II ?' ? I ? ? ?, '.. ill. \
. , ?? ?r tali : in- n i,a .. . Ri.!-in ia R?kly t :
toitii don Was! t., between Ota - I I rrow-sta. pn
? ; ten ?. 'i'ln u ten lo *, bower! i.
.i.
','! .:? ??!? .i>l r- ? at ?! >.i r managerssar thatal ',.?
ral ? tl?? '.mrla ? ? : lagon t ??? Ihei i* uol th. si
du ;,i : :?.i' .-'.?i ? ? i? ... er will Im- read/ In util ut 1
|...'i ? .1 ' n.;: . an ! l!i? > :.! n i. . ! ',. ? I in-.. \M:I lot , I i,
uv of the stt pri?e if Ihejf .:?? i ? ?nj
i..' Ul..? . i.. Su . . I.- lbs Bien .-?ill ??i rat
vere in tii Ir tl u unis.
Wille Win. ?V< '??? i-? ilkl t quietly thron****, t'hrtsto
phn -i , 11 mi i tii ? (forts River, t .i m ? n -rrsterd*
.- - ? upon bj neVi rai lutiK? on un a snd I ? i ? ? i :
i. ,? i.'i.i -t ;. ,. -i ud? ' ?i
. t Un .? ms i ' i Hiiwi ?? nwtted In .???I
,, i r.,i, . ..r ? . sin li Pn elnel lie ?. - I
fore Jll lies .-:??: .ii..?-I PvniillS al Wasblll I?ii I'l.n-e
I'n le. ? ouil un.i beb? .?i * u ? li ill Un tl ? ipp ? ?!
I Mili llg fill ?? Oll Kl till- pit ,0. I.l'. ?ID
....I. . ,. ?
I bal '?
?al.lt? ? In? il.llt i
inch i,i ?. ? n.
A DRRIAL HY .ioiin KBRjjTSLIai
Tn the Pdtlor nt I I. e I r i 1, u n e .
Biri An ?ulule published in ???.ii- pRper t<?
Utl , | ,1 |??i'llll< lu lit- U slid tuent, lillt Hut ll!l 1, 1 u.illi,
earns wltk fraudulently ronreylng. An., property
uin? ii t in i.i ia i tn ,i. t t ..ni. i -taie thai si no 111 m- bars
i f.?! in m anK propertj la trat! iw Mr. Jan? vaj ? et for
o . ?a;, i Is?-, m my lite, and Un- l?ateme nt in nl.. i? :?
i.?...i i,r faiaiii,,., i team begtnalag ??. end, gallea ap, n.?
?lo'iiii, for Um '?in JIO-.1 .?f niiii kmalRaa. Hsapactfnlly.
?ri? i.,;?-, kng. 7,187R. J.?ii*. kiNMii..
( I he statements oomplaintsl ?if appear in the oonrt
n-coriis sabmltted to i h-iu.-ellor Buoyim hi Newarh
aa chin (????? inailn aaninal Mr. K? amll ami Tliiuiia--.
Carey j??mtly. Korwhal parnom ?ahoy aiw?nade ws
do not itiio??. We should I.,, ?-hol tu pnblish Mr.
KeiiueH's ilefeiise, ?thieb ?vat entered in ttin snino
court; itml if he pWrRS an ul tempt nt Ida? I.mail Wo
??hall he paitn iilallf dcliglil.il lu puh'iiili Uu- sell
t? mi- inflict.?I.- Ed.]
ANSWER BY GOV. TILDEN.
THE TF._H.I_ HAUT* RAILWAY TRANSAC
non
mil t.Y r,r Tria WBBBIItBIB TO TH? rit.vi.OES OF
IHK (?i.VII'I.AI.V* ? KVKKY I I.I JM A i IOS, Of IN ?Al It
i>i:vii.<; it.nu*.i- -ins ?noOKB")iM?I iN-riKKi)
117 BQD?Tf ?UIB -VKM MHr.HAl.ITY?litlV. TIL?
dk.n'.. i BOA1 fBMftCBB.
In tin toil by tdTBixy in-gun ln tlio United
Slut, - ( in ,ut Cuitrt ?oi,i?j unie ui.'". by t'i?* ?"?'? I-onl?, Al
ta.ii .u,ii ierra ?Hants ftsllieart f?omraaj against ?Chartas
Bauer ?ud etbeva, ?lavrbleb ?Bsssael J lUdsn ?? ?ne of
t'?? .i. tt ndaato, ?i irarltal saairi i ?hat i?< in ?liai i>_ Jmlgo
Blatiott "? i"iiii??-l fur ?i!?v. li..l<-ii.
'Iin? i-'.tiii.l.-iiiit _et? fiirtU tbal on IMi. 1-1, 1-.".,., tht
'i,rre Beats sad altea I ompaay ?sad ?tbe ?BelleyUle ami
nilaoiitoara Usuread Ooaipany ?-, rt ,?? -, mAlAated ?Basan
tin- uiieiif lbs Tern? Etante, Alton ?tad Mb. ?Louis ?___?
i,.,,,i i -,,i,i?, in?,. labseanantly tbe neu lenipaaybeeasss
.-ml. in., ?ei mu? SBShlS to P iv tin* lut' rest mi eilln r It?
,.?', Mortgagee at those 'if ihe <>i?l eesapaatss. Altar
iti.inu btlcathia the rand ?ras seid ?t aaettoa f,,r ??-')".
?000, i-iPiHii : j. rudea, Chattel Butler, lt'ii!, rt Bayard,
ji,.-e'.!i i 1,'it', i,? in, and J'.iin B? Richardson beeotnlns
pnrcbaseri sad bworj raton. Tbs aeweoa.paay wuh
??nn -.v? 11- .1 !?,., mum ?tat ?ttabllit :? * ,?f tbe obi company,
and ?'? i) *?? ttb ii" iii-?. nalng for that porp.i sew It tea
??r noel and boada A _aeetlag ?,f H"' ?teaspanj was ?held
m tl?: ? ? :t) on .In??i? '_'-. 1 -i.'J^iiinl UM ' -ii" '?f ?-'''. I''1,
?ni?) ?.i atoek ami iitiiiii.i ama ordered, Mr. nidea sa
oenaert eft be aoaipanj iteeoauaendiag tbe raeoluUoa i.?
tli.?!, ::.?,*.
* The et.'iiipl.iiiit avr? t!ii?.f In ?addtttSB to ?hi? SmOttBt
Ibe I'.ii? .iii-.ui!. ?'..n i,.??tee lamed ta them
000tat DotaawB a*?-., ?Uta Issna of ?rblcb was never an?
ll? ?::.'?' I li.v ?iii.l. ???I.V. Til" lefWrt O- "-? t'?' :??'? tintai
il i of tbe i',.:.!!.!i'i? In ettlli
?bad I ?? m Hit Ir bai 1,259 DO ?of Iti Bra) mort
?.toada, : l::i.:."" I f ?tbe , ?- , ??:-!.? t'?l 11
in et i.?m???i -i??, k ii'i aa b un al 11 '???',"?"?. 1 he rep , I
? dlrectort >>n Jaa. I, i -Tt. ?h,.??-? ebelaaeoe. !
1110,493 i ? m :i?l.l'!."ii I'.ii "?.' ?.??i ? ?? ol --'-'".
000 above referred lo. . *. : ? i ? ? - : ?a- tbe Ito-te in ttte eoni
i. -i !?> ti,?? ?mat ' t - ??'?.ii.-.. ti la have baas
lb] <?"-.. , : - 11 ' -?
X_s i ? : admin tbe _ neral
? ?
: fit.; . ?1 It.'. '
1 .1 :, 1 iieli?. i?!n il ? I tal ? ? I eu
aol * i li for l ., i :
aere it ? ????? ? I ?
In tbe obi coi pom .
? | : ... ? ??-..??: nor ol
I. V. Ill, ?... I, t
an. ?-i > n. nt ; aoi - i ? Ibe pn I ? ?
tl,,n, i , i au ? -. ? uto ?
?m.11?- ' ?
; . . . ?
tie thletot ? ' '
and nt- ? '.?? .?t ???!?! il to tb, ,
... il ... .! ,1 ?
In legs rd to t lie I
?tu!, ibe ai that
, '
?itli ue
.... ;
I ici ven J
: ?
.
r -,
I ? .
? ! ? . ?
Tbe ? la furl
? | ? l - !...(
? :.... ... , l lo til
-
-
?
I two
I ' ?
' . t; lilla
.
? :.,
'
i
'
? '
I -
:
?
? ?
*
'
?
?
?
?
- .
ii ; iii .i
....
?
.
et
C,. ,r
i
. . .' i . al ..ml I
t? ? ? ? .
? '? . . ..-:???
: . ??
to all,
. ,.
i tlu
?
i
!
?
i .. . ... had j
>?. i 1.1, ill ? ; m,? nla . . iiaiill
?t tin
? i ? Ibe ? ???!?. in m.
.,1 n ?? ?? , en ? .* !??i tlefei ' . . Ill? in. for
?
I nation to auch nic-ubere of tbe committee . I ol
i live, la the DompU atad, ?
i lim.... ? ? h h ? i prt ,i? ..
,Ki.l profitable (?? ?ill ?pai h? i Intereated I ?
?- -. the ? in jffl.i ? ?? ii li ??? lil ? ?
dlatilie.linn i-??iiieiiiiii.it il bj i.i . teei ?,.'!.,.' .i.'..ii
ii . ? ! I ? ? -;;?'?. ttiiit if tin? ?tat, i
la tbe I lof? ??i.?- .?:,:.
?,, n.i. ,,., ii n, .??'>., mi i, . ai I allotment! ui
aptatbe Ibne ?of tbe remen ?i, add Mil an .-:???.,. ?i ,?:
A/ u i iii c. ii.i..', tin -t eand receiver, in tbe y? i i-?:i,
and ' kamaHlai aforeanlil oi tbe eloee of th I year
were complete, tbe preeeat a i el all the re
> ? at Ibe i.e ratee wbteb make tbe whole
i--m* v..nil -,;..-.,. ?.'.??? ,-. .??',! mount i?, ml] about
??:!!..,Di-i,, and that the .?.t.:? ?? ta, or each of them
? ? .."nui at tbal data la tba kaadi of Us ?id com*
i, i. ?. i.?', .titi.'e.i t!.?.?.r v. in ',? rasantes tat iademalty
?i-.':,i,-i i, .t : ?. i .i !??_ aad lltlgatl ?, ei - ,.: ,?, _,
. md ? ipei latlott f"t ?ill ier? Ice?, ?, ? ?? II
. farthereeltlei.i?* "?- allotments in third i> U-e,
wldebnu il ?? u ? time thereafter i> cc-mewjul
prop? i,.,, ? ? i?? ? ? '?:.
lu regard to thi receiver- i?'!".rt. tbs ai iwer ,tM?rt
?tbal 11 did ?i.?i ?state all Iba aperaUoaa ol the pun using
.??"?;? ?;?:,.;. lau, aad tta it tl era ? rei ii aol author*
?/.-.i m ?i? ?u i.ir tiieni. Ula report I therefor, aaaertcd
; I? wholly Irrelevant, ti ?lealao maini-Uncd that tbe
i "'" ' leport waa not ad pled la behalf of the ?i
, ??r ? .? i
rhe defendants deny that ear ef tba ?sonda or ?stocka
i? ??ii' ??? ?I m n?? WH ni ?rumplalnl bar, I m u uni iwfulii
Malii 'I ?'.'. '?!??:.* i?It ?I u.!?; tbe .|, r? n?i,,.;i.., , Utnuetl ...
?Ii'i"'-' 'I "? b) t'.'i'i. m v i... ..mu , r their .1 it) ai mem*
I?. I ? ,?! .,!,'.' ' ":. !,.i-.,, ; , .?i.ii?,,, ?,?,?, ,,i ?a 11,. - ; ? ? i -. r -, ,.; -.?:,|
l:.,.ml ui i'l:e, t". 1, ?ur ni v i.ti.t; i,.ii ,,f au/trimt or t oud
dri '? :e?"?-.'.i In then?.oi in ani mannte vhataoever
? ??"i il?? ? -?' ?'? ii? iii ?' by ??-i? .i.'ii-iii or failure ?n. tin ir
i?-?'' '!? ' li "'?li.' li ?i?i?-ii? ol tl.? .? -,.),! ihi?ni Huye
ii.-i-u uuju Ur ?i uin,..?-, mil m, ,, i?..| k, u,,. ui|,,,,UJl
ol u.11 ? 1.1 n .. i.?n ???),? ? m. oi toanj amouul almtever.
?i ml tbe j lurther iay. tuuchliiK the ?tat?-uteiii ,:i-ii,i
bill of t ?iintiiiiiiit ii? In l!i? -i-i 11.1.? nf tbed teiuliilit,
??iiiiuifl .1. I ??.I? n. it?:it he bad, loag prior t??f aud at the
Unie of the ?coiuiueut-eiuenl ot the loreeloame mit In
..el billitf ? ?iiii'tjii'it i,i, nti .ii.,1, t.. .-n th.ttuael for
II I ???I "iil.l .It. ??_-.* In?l,?lt,,il,l, ,?,, lu v? I.??, e lieb .11 Hllell
lult waaltwtilul it,and 11?.?t i? ? an ? ouu , alaofurlhe
in.?i.t?<?! aanltoeoml in?" i..?.-. . i.ii.iu ?,,ii re. and I? "i
t? i- n 11 "?i. tome time lo the fear l -,..,', ?to w tuun tbe i .?l
ruada of the Torn Haute, Altnnatul s,. i.: i.,i!,,..,,i
,.|i:|..i:i> \? re ?lil ?'?Iiilei??,!, :iinl v\ Ii.i ?,,, ,, .?,. t|tu*ntlj
in.i.ii* rt-eeiveri thereof i and waa ?'.:.,, the .. i n-i i.,V
u.l i, e,vt m. ami ih.it i,e ?il-.i acted aa tli i.iu ipal
? - -i... i i.ii u.,- r.ii.i Ural i?i,,it,:?t_e .idhbldera, in teta*
ti. m ta Hie [?r?, i, m?i, [in.I:i:_. hereinbefore men
Kiiieil, aad ,'iiei |ti'iii?ei, Hi, K? t'.iiine, t,,i ?therewith, and
ii.it Mi.'ii ei rteea bad -?'1111111 ueed prior to tbe year 18&0.
1 ii< 1 a -i?'? n adere I. from ihn ? to time, durtiia ?"1 pertod ,,f
i>iv.,1.1 of 1 in? i- v,?.,,-. .lien?.liter ; tin,t ?for _.ii"i m ?rvlcea
?.i a. . in ...1 nMsa uitvit* Baaaigsaf |lu??oooagalast
laid teeon.l mortgage bondholders, and the said char/re
was i'.iil, by or on behalf of said second mortgage bond?
holders, on the 17th of October, 186'-, out of a fund con?
tributed by ?aid second mortgage bondholders, under an
sgrertnent between themselves, dated Nov. 1,1859; that
the defendant Til,leu. for a part of his services afore
Sal J. also turulo a c!.ar?o of the like sum of $10,000,
sn aeeount of prnfeeeloaa] terrteea r( adates ??>
Ibe first mortirnire bondtmMeta and tiio reeelvera, which
was i?al(l t?. lit in by tito said Azariah ('. Vistee, sur
vivinif receiver as afore-anl, out of money? In his bar.d?,
aa sum receiver, derived from the earning! of tald rail?
road, aad stated by said Flagg tn hie aeeond report to
bars ben remitted for ths purpose of paylag " the costs
sad chargea of f<?recle?sliig the trust mortitsge under the
decn ? I of tlie- courts of IiIiiio?h and lii'iuna," and wliu h
payment appears ander ?latu of Rot. 7, l MS, ?n a ?tate
uiffit annexed to the fir-t report tfoi-reatd, aa havm?.
been receipted lor by the said Tildea, "on aoeouat
of prnfnasfontl lerrkae-." And tln-se defendanta
(tenv that cither of the ttvo claims of the
ib fendant lust sforesald were ?lor, or were
arer stated by liim as forelaunt agalntt the rcorgan ?ta?
lion, or that it was resolved by the purenuingcommit?
tee last aforesaid that any claim of the defendant laat
aforesaid n-r flo,0o? niroinat the reomnlsation bo
allowed as in laid Mil of eomplainl mentioned ; ami iIu-m)
d?fendants deny that anyanm of |20,000. or any sum
Wb i te ver, ?a* eveifpaJd to tho defcndai.t 'Ii!il<*u. in full
for, or m bu* way on aoeoant of, any. arrices of Hid
last named <i .'.miaut at a member of the miweaalag
co : i?,ut? e last aforesaid, or as i ount? i thereof.
??ad tbe ?rid defendant, Samuel J. Tilden, further
aoswertng, taya, for himself, Unit during all tin*
|..-nw?i tlnee July, I8C2, a? - ell at i?e*?,ri that tune, and
until tome lime in .lut!?'. 1873, the mid Tildes acted, ut
tbe Instance and r*M|u<*sl .?r tbe san' purebailug eommlt
i.,,..? their i -ouii-ei, iu divert important matters, and
th i r?.; ...... . he has re? it. tl no a mpeaaatJoa
ns such whatever ? thai during all the. I years between
tbe said dates, the tabl Tildeu.at the Inatanee and re?
quest of tbe ootuplaiuant, ai -v*. < * i as at tbe instance of
said eommittea, was aceuatomed to rentier, professional
ea aa counsel f"?- tbe complainant, which was In
ft*, nut m an i almost constant m eu or professional adviee
.u, | ther pi ?? ; that such services bave
. ? .n ! .a.,! ?us, protra. ?< ?!. aud dll" cult, ?? -
. .Mil :?: I ; ? aliar -i III and abilitl? t. and ?rers
?ii _??? .t ami :i.-u?i..-.\ :? ??i.-? i u- lulnest and talon ??? tie
complainaut, among th frail ot wnichilni no luttsneet,
liability i lo :? i.\ ?jil r
?. morl '-'? ' ?ml avert t fn ?li
that f???- i Mm- "f those m rices bai fio said Tilden re
, ... ?an? ?iiiaii. ..-.'ti'oi I tola thi ? . Which,
Ii. :.i Itl . ? 111 i ', : i- !? ? !
compensan u ? r any pi ??'??? ?usual ?ervice, nor bas h n
? i ?vil any cuiupeiiaatfon themlot from tas --a.u pureRae*
lu ?f committee.
And theae dc.endants furth i i my. touching
, i ounei i ? ??! ? I stocks to I
.. ,a ! ?'.? ,? ? ???! ii asked lor In snd by tbe i
bill of complain! herein. In r?-*-? ii to all andeveryof ?
: ,,.i i? Ion . of i ? ? i and thing
dun ? ooucei ulng th? ? . thai the tal ! tmmi i
? |n nutuner, most of which wi re ?: u i md I
. mu rted 1" i - eacd and ? ? n I these
::,.. tbe time thereof, duly closed and
ut. ?! 'o-, all persons !:.i? in
I rat I nod by each
, -;???.U hi i.n-1. lal?uu "/ ]uin- I
i l|ial ' ? ec ; that the said
purel ting commit I lid not have und i lal ? - ?
I riiliicuii a busiui ss, u tbeir nghti aad ob*
lignliii.ret ft to ?i i ". m :. !.. ' uol ? eu care
full) d? fined, qu iUll?*d, ai r a wrlttei
nn nt, or If *
trun-a et.-xt, by of I lie thou
Int. i
i.\ M . u) |i, i.-nii or corporation claln
w ,, . - |.. ? ,. -? . . i say,thai so n stlt n of
. - -: -: ??!. (?1 III
* ? sud (
uy ot tb? i in tbe
t] com
.. I . ? : ?.t? rest, le> .
- i
lant? lo i.. ;i?.i? . a-.!i_
?. i .-,,.-? i -. .i- . -. . ? .. tgbi or
i . ? , : of I i . t ?. \?' ,.ny
.? . I tO MU I I?"inis
-
:?-!?- ?-.>? i r. - i' fewlanta
ti. g ?it, l'. r. .'-i.: ..:. ... ,!j:... i < . Carter, <<:
( ii-? !.
SALARIES I*. RING* CO! MY.
J.'ii'S li.i.x?, ii ..!-(?;- it A .;?_-(? of
: a spproTsl
I by I .. : I . -? - ?'?<
tlie salaries
.U sub
II
sent of s
? o le, i- to
?
ose. I lu opt ???<? I I?? nn
?
.1
naomy. It Is mo? I I bj
? . - ? -,
. ? ?
:
? nl; all
M
-
o entinte.lud
Of ? I?
....
i ? ? ?? : i n..i ,i
- . ?I .
- 0 ' ! a - ..
I
I - oh I I
: . that th :, I.? or
? a '.n aid
? . illumines of
'.?. ??:? uf a . except,
i ol pay, which .VLu'.aaa'ocr
. ..
THE COLTETS.
?:. niMi'si. ?? ::? i\ ?.???.
r.iltKB I : .. D gtTRa
liRDI s i .,: s, II.
'I ' ' . fiien .?t ?>! . d ???
a .
?stead
? . II a,
? ? , ? till
' , - o|,
liter i City ?if :
?a the \
'
Kaicr to Its inbabil
b ti :
. ?
: ? ? '
?i tin i ? i,! of W itef CommU itoncrs, In
1-7!. t?> ? . pro
u of a f. .:?: | nil- bol ?a | i.
? . - . ' r liter, i |
i ? ?
I lie II
ilared on the enUr. ? I iving It
: ? ' ? twelve teat In exp nditun*
? ? :
itiaUfUtl . ' ' 1 V. l-.lt
tip ?."'?. !"!??? st ' Itj R'orki
. 11 til tll.lt ..!,.? I a | ?!,t ,lf
Ihecl! ?? t! f ('.?'iiie.iili ('..'!?.. ?t t.. a will
of maudamus to romp, l ob. Henee Is tbe , u ?tl. n pre
Tbe.!. cisi?n tin.
Thi ' ??ti- itioa te be d ?? run ? ?> :?
n t 'ouu( u i: '. e the
, - ?' i ? ??'.- ? - ti. ? fee ot '!:,? i 'Ml. inn!
i ii.- ? Dim ion Conu.- t.:" dutte ??f a M ist ??? In
? fen ' . ill. s
ilutti ? ? ? a ',, press ? ,
for the pm i ? ?-? - for ?
? u i - ? is it is, bst been
ti.;?.?. :.n t..iu ' The I. ?-?
! i def. m?' pi called the
I'einiitueiit liourd ot Water und ?????.? i.? ???
to .-ai .m -i loo,noo upon ?t. Tu?t baa ".n done.
: Me.'.-i im,- )...v,i. li ? n.-, n -iv, ti to the city to
? ? u-?.? nt. Itj refi i? h? ? - to i !;<? la i - it
? n i ?i. -1 i in ? v. . .n m r--. Works cant?o! execute
the dut] litt).?I upon II ol ho menacing th waters
.. .- .,?< t.? obtain ii.i ? r mi which tin ire con
. o . i.. ? i Cou I order* tlie
work u.'fs-i.i? in iiefotuplisb that end Upon auch or
n? r tbe Itoard i- ! er n? li mud lo "?? ) No ilia, rotl u ??i
m .i.? n u in wbiuh it can preveut the <.uon
(' u.nai n.lolng its duty, 'i !?.? util .'-i,.'! that tbe ?to
fi ndunta are a?'? ?ni t .rol of t.,.- I'lniitnoti Council
as to lands outside t. city I? not of weight i e priuci '
? ?I - ' '--: i' ' o wi ?mi ter w..- Uu -u'oi i lion ol
the I?. i*attun al of tbe fill Works to the Coinmon Court- ?
ell. There is no reaaon any the reservoir mould Im left I
out of the application <?f the principle, mil tbe I.? Isla
ture in this tfrsl ??ciiou liave made dtfemUuts'control
'? Im Inn < intl ? "-i ? Hi eonneetei] witli the water*
lork .?:'.?: to :'.?? ?litiit mi i?r the Common Council,
i ,e ileiio-.i.i.l IK,.,;? m., ant ,?, n, i?s?l from th-? domin?
ion of th l i'ouuril uor frotu ti.< D?partaient of
tii) Work? from Its control thercol r. e ulij . ?'.?.. thai
there are ?so fttiala wtlh whtoh to do tl..- work i? declared '
1.1.1. '?Uni. -d.
BIODT o?' DUMPING BTKEET I?IKT.
Miltl. lll;?'C:.KIi|Mi.'i IAKKN I1Y I HI. It, lAKl) Of
POLK?! i?? ?7RRTKR1 DTI gRPRRRRCR*.
'I'll.. Cit?of N'l-w - Vi?ik lias ;;?ilirij?att'il any
Bl ' a of Hi?- "-Inga County oflcb**B tS i?-<tf.?Ui ttie dum;>
iiio ?it tin? street lint i ?r i m,ey Island Id brtagtag salt
aa-aliint Wlttelies:? r RrtttOB tai ttht I Kta^'S tiuinty ofll
rials te i'ieveiii tin-ill frotn interfering wttb the New
Torb dirt M-.i-.is. laths eetuptslat prepared by ?Ctariss
t?'. ?ta ?! ?-.m, sennsst "f u??' Board nf Polli a, tiie elty sets
tatth Unit Wtticliister l!illt?ui I? tin- I ?I -t t t.t- Mtnrney of
kiiik? County, thai Jaasss Jeatttaa. Mm Pyb?am, and
?'. lo.atn R, Rudars Poltos Oontsslssto?JMrs. aad Patnsfe
I'aiiii'l'ell, I'oiiee lupW lttti intuit .?f Urooltlyu. und Cor?
nelius t*-rgttSStt, MM lad liai!!??t i!? fen?! nit, Is Shore In
?peetnr of the cuiiutns uf New-York, y.ie. ns, Wcal
thattat, and Kteliiniiii.l, uinli r tin? law of ltT.Y The
?'?unl.laiiit ibon states that tin* ?nanl of Health i, charged
wiiti ti.eiiutj of laaratrtag from ths tlseetoel this city
??iirion and offal, and tini Hoard of I'nliee with the duly
of reinntiii- nrdiii iry street dirt, ashes, Ac, through tho
MMSt ?'leiitlltlK lluroail of the l'nllci? Di p u ?nielli ; that
tin? Hoard of I'nlhe has i?eit?in|)U)rily forlildileti the pla
?Rag of any carrion on Its scows, and ha? placed lusiiet-t
oi? to cuforco this luoliibiiloit at the loadlo, of tbe
.cows which carry Urn stre.'t dirt to the ocean. The
complaint dec ?ares that this UKihnil of n-iu ?m_ the
.afreet dirt la the only poMible way of Itftfly fulnillnr
duty moat easentlnl to tfco health of the cltv th?,
Police Departnieut ha? only a limited ?um't. d,,
work and cannot _fr?,rd ledo it m ?my otlier w-.
eomptabrt chargea that Ferguwm aa ?-iiore taw?m,
ttinea to allow the dumping of tun dirt -cowVrf
abare except on eendltlona wile. wOA involve rrai_t__aai
tion.ilexiM-iise.aiiilil?it in m. i?, sin? smli ,?,, ?ui.,?"?1"
Uexreed UKtlio authority ,?..?V.-rr.,. on lu.n b/ft?
en atiag in? office, iu?l that lu ,. ? nt . i,? i,a.. i, ,,. ?, .*
led and rapported by the otber defendant* S_S____
..?*...? I. ? that tl,.* defendants be n_etrmit_ed from Su?
ferina; with the pr?sent met hod of di-poting of tho ?"reel
?iin tirs complaint and antninpanjlng -SBsatlu _.-.
in* ebeolutely that ai.-v oarrion ?>r garbage ha. ?_??
placed on the not i, Judge Weatbrook granted ?mo---??
?retnrnabla yeitenlay, to ?itn-w .?.u?*. wi,yan liiiiiu,?n?_
fthuuld not ia-tue aa rri|U<-?tod in tin; ?.ompluiuL in,-!?
the mean time, ,i..,l until the decl-lou of ?tbei_ot_K,?
it.- ordertoabow eauae.eatoined ttie ?defoadaaja '-from
Interfering with, obatnu Ihik or in-vi-ntu:?.; tueiila'Miir
or lut u?ioer?, agent -, t inuloy?*?, and ?servante, tin? l:.,?v>_
of Police of the Police Department ??-f the cuvnf n?V
York, (ho ?Burean nt Btreet-cleanina. ?,f uld 1 ?,Ho. rw
nartment, or their offii era, meen t?, employ??, andurr?-,.
In retaovlag tba autterial by the ?said ?6_r?__ rf tti__.
Cleaning to tie ?removed ?fnaa ?the Cltj <?f New-York in th.
mannet beretofbre doae."
Tiie motion wii?. H?lj..iirne<l reeterday, oti the re?_-..t __
the lll?i li,?.,l.lr, to lie_l .VI?,,,, i, . ? ""?
OHIO ANI> IU88I6S1PP1 BUTT.
?nOCBBR-MI BBOtm BY AMMlKW J. HIKF.H AGAIXgl
Tu?: mmn
A 1 ?i 1 i in tquity baa been ?filed in tin* offie?
of tho dark of tlie ?'?ii ?I *-t,it,-.a? t, nil c?,.;rt, tij Aa
?Irew j. ?Blkat ?at N? ? j.amay sgalaal Joeaph W. AUon,
Allan, Ciiiiiiil" 11, ?Prilltaa W_ltt---.iI/l:t, ?.n.i Kredetlek
ehardl of Kew-Yurk, and William ii <ii .?wold of
Mi--..'ni, hi their sa peart* aa tmateeeof Ute c?hio tat
Miaataatpi-I RaUread, la reeovec oa iii coaatraeflM
bands "f the read. Tlic ??lit t,-:-,,?.?- out .?i tlit..-ier?*eiiitBI
\,y which lbs asaapaay aras ? ? ?? ? ted ha 1807, ?ad
tbs i" d tras transferted ?to a new p. >*-?*?.??.
non. The eompLaiat charges thai tbe defen-daaH
bran tat ?saeat t?i- foteeloaaie ?tale ot the r?_d
?,f vviii,?:i they thenHSh ? beoame tba pnrebaaata
.?mil bave ever tlaee bald the preaei ty aa l dr ewa? ?but
tbe new corpora m bee no property except that !!_?
t.v.-i-el to them, and tbal '?''? ?Id inu-tre? were rae
.:.:,: .t.ii kbuldi -. and ;?:i r tbe ?11 ? ?:- :l ;?.s
i.,???- i ,.i-|.,,riiio,i : that the only payment nude tor m
property of ll.Id corporation wim by -? otstotk
lo tin- li", lil. i- o. ti'-': t.-?-.' ???? VI? it?-- i - ? . i ; ? i r* ut
further -??' - bal '?.* the , ? m ?'??? f? tb? rt' ? ??? rj>< ?,- ?
- - nr : v ol lb? reiidue Ind? '-. ?ai t..?
object .?i the ag-re? n waa d?i ><-?t, and tl ?* <-. ?u.
i.'?,i.,!,! ?..i- , ft wit].t nnj
lion i,?,!.,!-.. I . ..-.I
i-oiiii?-i,?'itioii for their - r.to conti ? '?,;??
meut to tin aiiioanl ,?? .-liT...,". B. W. Uuntmgtaa B
, oa#t,1 f?i tho e? n-i?..iiii?tijl.
OEVKB U -i ?-8101*1 00?K !:<">0 ?:<??.
Tlic- Angnnt b*tn <>r ?the ?Court of ?Gemnil
_,?i.-it-?. Pari I., ti;,'-!i, ?! reatenI.i-.-. /:??? ?lerBadMi
pretlding. Tbs tshndsr i n besvy one,sad taita
pea afthebnatnea an band v,!ii lake ih. greater earl
of en ?month. Tbe ?Keeerdar, labia? ?sarga t?? thi ?a?al
/?ry. Baals referredto the condition of the ( u'-..?.__,
: . r, |an ?! ?? be. ,i nn Mace?. ?Bol ? ??
h ?..;. - hi ?i '?? m "i,- -:- i-, i-:- th - f"'i- ah a I fllth, aal
:?-'.' til !
? I ? -.1 foi ? v pom Is lea ??? ? ?'i :?i !:.?
.?? hrinii. ou account of the effect? ,f I .- '?. t v< o
t?i:ii.,,:. i-r i ? ' ?on?. Me ? re? ..'. :? tld,abouldbssn>
vni.il for this ( .??. _
Tnr. ' '"ikinvkm. r.iN''; HTfT.
in tho --'lit of xbt 'People ?aga___i J?*hn
(??'1)1,1!*!-:i for m tor lampa aad atber i:_-'.ir:ng
, .?..,??I lllii;; ruh*, amounting to
.:'?,,::t .???.'.? I
,)-i>. i ?- ?: ?? ,i ? . led ?)i a j ?_ fan
.-',-7 02,wl ? ',ii?:.!""i bad r?aoveaed ?i alaat t^i
ntv, under ? tbe ? wool I ' ?va ?"Il
th.* City H ; - for tbe enu 1 ?*
. . 1 in ibe ?suit ?against *
plot on ? ? - ' ' ' -'-*t
.-....:.,,,,. ? ..? ?imi feel."? it ;.?- deal.
in vv.j.'aij j_)'L)..ii?;i-i! i- ?i.iiii, -l to bava sa in;.. i.
civil. N"'n:-.
T?. tlie -'lit ?b-rongbl by Jemni ib V. Bnadar agaiasl
? ? ? ?
m rr ?nt . f '
-..-....': - .
II* ..!. ".Lil
lot .i vvi: ??f ?hats m Borpai ^?is
:
hen '?? ' ...??? , ? ?. ?m i it.,? -Ti.i
? . ' ,' !!.? .. ?.
t
. tl
'..
?
l
then
. 8. Si'iith'v : tb, ?receiver et tl.e Bhteckee
Btmat Bi ? ? '
l ... . ? . i ? ?
?
tn. ? '? ? Ihe _
- ? ??. .1
. ?. ? ? ? -ll
a
? l ? ? -?
. o i : ??? : . it I . ? <?
,7719?, _
pirt-lONS-Air-,. -
? ' ; , i . I _? ? \v - ? ' ?__?_
-
'.--? ?? ? - - . i ' r
: I ?.?.-?
? .
?
? ? ;>.-?.?
. . ?
"?
I'l.l -
r
.... ' I ? . ? : y
.
M ?'...?
.u
Mit . : ?
n
-
a
, , . ? . .n
?? .?-..
?
CA? l'vr.
I ? v -OUtTE. J.
173..'
I
17t..0 ? i '??_
'?
1- ?..v??: '? ri >lt _et. ln__*
?
; ; ?
: ? ? - r
?
?-'.'i. i-jr i ? i ? -, r
? ' . ?:.!.
'- ? '? L'ait
? '.
<
11.r-.
?
?
t i i . ? ,
v ' ! '?
M. : , i
.
?.
? y -n
?
?ji ..?:-n?-?i.? n igt
- i agt.
? t ??
"- '
?::ieL
:.i ? i ,. ... ?
1-,| ? .
107 ! ? *? I.om.
i '.:... \ .. . igt. Wart.
* :i . \'i ? act ,\ul
i ??'.I1, ...,.?.. l_l. : Ha: .i ! j.,., n... ?? ,?.. i ?-J
:.?i ???i. ,?.?:.
?Il - Ml'C'lt. 1 ?* 1
, ? ? 1. ?.::?..,,, ..?. ?_. .' . ?| . . . :- >l,y
I
? \ K :i.v -?.r.,
?
' ?. ?
; '
?, prill ! n? - f M ..i i i:t K-iil:.r, , , ?V .lo,
f ; Murria H. mai .: . ta Cran?.
KTNIATORB A!.M\v\r
aanttaaa .... B-oa -?:.-??-. .1,7 _teoe !.*?? ? ?i
III, .' ? ? ? 1? VI V Vt
-aiiilv ii.H.'_ :< ? lala l l(?:i:ll 11,110. Ferry !__?
iiitin >?? vii u n a n*i r. ?1
sandy lia air m B .,-..?...? ?? 1 ? \,.. u. ?."an. ..Il -?
SHIPPING ISliA.I.IOESCR.
r,,uT D? NKv.* voiiK.ana 7.
. ! ' IRKTJ.
st.?'Di-i.if T?-? ?i,v ?in i, ii.iii-iin!, ifvatpeaSj Raaaaanfl
'?':.- -?? i? ? net ??. v.'.ii.ii: ?tan, i??-!., a. ebbest,
Ht?..:..- 1 ?? 1 i.. mua. Braga l .?rt .,, 1 .' r '
' S?. .ma! 1; V - *-! -M' ,?. W ,,!;? I .. .!.??. Il-Illt
Rai ? 1 ? rren liai - t. Jan, Heart 1
Bar a Pale A .t", J?v.??tti-?, MaraatUea D. ft, 4* S. mxBatkw
man,
, vin"?? (!?.?'.?. Farta? Be i.'- I ? .- ?rer.
Pari -.-i.i!-..:,' i -??..', redan-?. Oil alta t, So ?.y. Kin.cl,
I .Iv.-.. I ?'.
1.?i. -.ii.i 1? iBr.l, ?.mir, i"mi..i. 1 . .?.;,,??? w .te*
al ' ?L
?Brig l,i?uisi? 1 Hr.). Hobt)?, st. Jo'itiii. M. ?'?? Kattea, w.'.oon
I.ii? I.l?a?ttioi (Nor.), An.tr.A_t? n. i,?..,it r i ???r*.C. l"b'.as
A ? ?>. ?
.-,, M- I'?. 1! , -r:,,.?..'!. I'rl.!:*??;.??:t. c nn . 15 il.CUrt?.
>. i,' J?-??nii i-.ii.t.i. aii.:.i?.iii, ?._:?,?,(,.,,.... i? iinr'-?ta
?Oa .1
-.!.; o.x H.iiiira, BTrigbt, WndrtHebt MttatMttwthfm
?. I'?Vie.
..in Sarah W. Hint, CaMaaaa, sl juh:.?. Anti.-j?. n-*t
\\'. H ?' lia A ?'??.
buiit?, BaattaaMts, MeCaa, __tla_ei_Ma> J?ta Hind.
taint t v - -
rtt? *im?hlp Htn.teo Hi ?. M.ll_ I I'll. I .?iv -.?.'.?:.! S-injU-P*
I.i:? .'l.t., -?.!:, Ill, tue Iitul ;,:,-.? t'.Vl?.?V?. U W tight S
YachtMrvrtaa ,ot c_e?aeara_ i???? tt?a?_t_al_na._-'
pbia 11 Say*?
.Still, I.IV.IliiKil I.?:.'"t. 1..I.1.1..I. II ???HI. v?ti !'"'??* ___.
i; ui. B_i___af (ol ?;?iati,ii). tmdy, Berdeaas ft i*>?_ m ''?*?
I C!:irU (?Bi W-iMelH.-o, M ? >, -?Util, IV, n.in,lin? I ityt,
?ill? I li?.Ihm. ... ,._.
I.i i< t .?nil???.?:? (nt !.<"??l.ii.leir?., V.S I. KM?, Ot?oi-to Jt? ,Ay*i
vu li, lawar? Hreakaratar, In :.?:i..-t. ^^^^
Brta aauaowea, i--.iti.'g.u. fainaaai io ?i-r?-*""- ,u*i?
mill in.it,.???!?? _ _,.._. ?t
brig ?K-elera --tAr (of Nt-wHaven). Ko.?.tet, Pem?-?- "
Jay?, with-ugai ^u-l ", ?U-.ie?. __ v ?
ii i_ Imilie.i. ?l.riU, ot .ml _ liny? fi-oiii Win4??r. ?-? ?_?
s, i.i i>,? Mmr nrav (of l-art Ja_s?raaa_, Waubha\naWm
nan 14 il.ty?. wuli luiiiie-. er,u_.
.-.!,i. Ueorgal iiuieiuuau vof riuUJoiainal, (truoy. i,n-^
?wi? k. (..A , 11,1av?. w it li lamber. .
t4.hr M?rv l-.Arnolil, Arn,,id. n?Jltni,)rt). with ?USA
.?-, !,r. Kva, Wu-Nly, Vlrginl-. -Uli fin
?s_Ur J li. Hup?, i ol?. Viriiiui? ?un e<??\.
Mi.r CUarlel liaalta Molen, Vlrgimn, ??in mtiune
m, in a. V. cianaier. !.-_._ _-ii_u,_- niih conL

New-York tribune. [volume], August 08, 1876, Page 2, Image 2
About New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924

Connect with the Library

Find Us On

Subscribe & Comment

Download & Play

Questions

New-York tribune. [volume], August 08, 1876, Page 2, Image 2 About New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924

Connect with the Library

Find Us On

Subscribe & Comment

Download & Play

Questions

New-York tribune. [volume], August 08, 1876, Page 2, Image 2
About New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924