Newspaper Page Text
Vo1? ??\..??0? 17,7S:j NEW-YORK *n:i)M.Sl>AY, J! ?? 24, IW?W.-TWKIA? PAGES. PRICE THREE CENTS. HOKE SMITH ON SILVER. UIS SOUND MONEY CAMPAIGN -.R CLEVSLANCS REPRESENTATIVE EX THU8IA8TICALLY RECEIVED. ?j/nTc-y not sufficient final payment, .-?n?' the ap re< . i?ion of g^i^..^. ... ???? everything ?'lee. G??? the??? ?trWy-rv'ltk^nn their cntir?? Arguments ere base). Tha Secretary met these {?repositions by clalmf-is, Jlrst, thlt the aliened contrapon ?f money of final peymenl hai not taken place; second, that :he j- iposed remely ?would, in reality, drive one-half of the money now in n?.? out if circulation, and ; ' IC a Mltrarthni rainons In its results He said it was Immaterial, so far a* the pr, pose . Vzislntlon w?? concerner), how th?? a?'t of 1171 was j ed. "Il would )??? fou?? to bring on dlsastr is corserjuen^es. for tbe simple satisfaction of repeal in? ? Ihw Improperi) ; ?'? continue: The a'M of 1V7.1 did not remove one-half ol II mo; ? ? of fina: Daymen only ellvi ir. ?.-.. 'iii?.?: State? ,ns.?-t??,! of subaldlary silver amounting to $17.000.000, which was nui * paym.-: ? of debt? m smounts beyond V?. The coined , Stati then amoui ? l : il . ??? th- I'nlted Bist? ? '?'??? while the standard sil? ver amourus :o U~' :?.?>\ and the subetdlarj - to ???*.,". ?? The total - I Bllver, therefore. In 1S7X was I.' .? ..? ? | ,?.? ;- fl.23?--.???., ? -7.:. Th?? |.aiM-r n, .? '? . es. In 1873 ? about tuai to the amoaf :s.. t?,? ; ? ? espita ,if ,-.r ilei ? tr. Jt73 s i- ? seen tl? at. 1 <!'? The ? now Is bet a? ? ? ? ind $24. MORE HOLD AN!? SILVER THAN' EVER. Th* claim, therel re, thai ??? money o' ?nal |?yment has been ? by de. ?giving the ] 'a sufficient volume, is simply puundlesfl \\ ?? Btlll us?? gold and silver both, and have ? ?,. ?,?? ?. . ?,. r hsd prior to the passane m tue act ol Th? . . ina? the curren? \? haa contracted, thereby appr? it ? .? the value ?' Bold, is shown to h? ?... ???,. . ?, vai,,11?-' output of ?ril'l last year: It - i- irgea he history, and emounte ' ??, | > ". Tl >? ?a rld'e coinage ?f gold lr. 18P3 ? .ml that ol r 1 ? $'.?.',.W?.M ? making ?/>?? large?? yearly ?? ???.-???? in the ?'Orili'? history, ?a ;:. ??Ibi) ?ne exception ih?, ??? thai Bold has appreciated, thereby de? predating ih? value <?? producte, .s based upon the theorv ? .,? ? ? In the value of sllvei nnd In tbe valu? of prod u isbas I en ontemporeneouB A car?-' ?] examination of the facta scows this ? to b? ? Tli? sveragi ? res ?? of commo ? since]?"', nas been ah? it ?"'l per ceni t?.? heaviest 'Inline has been In the line of tl,,?-<- th.in.-s arhlch tbsiu*?? ' ' people buy. All these reductions '?a price? are parti) sttrlbuti i ." a lessened cost of pro' partly to the r?-.ent pani??. While the comn, ? ii'i??? ha??? fal'en -'? I'-t ??'?<,t, silver han fallen :>< -ter cent. GOLD IS THE MEASURE OF VALUE The bullion In a silver ?ioilar is worth or.;?? |] cents; ?,: grams of Standard gold ?re worth MO e?ntv h ....; ??)] for th it all over the world. 11 Bow ronti t ites a measure of valu?? In the United ??tea, an.l ar a nv-asur?- of values is worth, bsr __s_,?h? ' na??, in rouml number?, tsrlce as much as eilv, naKe, in round number?, olne ? into a dollar. Th? ?? exchange products for a silver <i?.iiar sa readily a? for , ?old dollar? It la because ih?? Govern? ""*rit bavins stsrted stamping *!-'? grains of slrver ?"e ooi.ar. an i having pul th?-m inr<? immerce as *_>rth ,, hiindrrd cents, has fell responsible to keep ?? coiner] dollar at an exchangeable valtu equal " lbs stamp pul on II to keep ?t up to the ?madard of ?, ? ?rains of gold. without Qovernmenl support 412". grains of sti? ver an.l the ,.,..v ,;;Ver Mollar would I??? ol tbe seme ??changeable value The question, therefore, is: "hat effect would ftee eotnege have on silver l.ull pni Woui.? iijt ginina of silver become worth s* rn.i'ii ?,, *B.t? (rains of gold? Would free coin \ m give ? ?,? exchangeable value equal to our *?,'? ni dollar in the markets of the world? If ?ne value of s?ve- |i r,ot double.! by free '?ilnai,?.-, inen the exchar.geai.le value of our n?-w silver ?ollar must drjj, to the actuel velue ol the sllv.r Pui into it. We would not have bimetallism, but a ?oil dol? er worth twice as much an the silver dollar. ??"J ?'? silver lollar would become the standard -"??asure Gf value, ilrlvlng the gold ?lollar out of h_?. *"?" w'" would reduce <??p standard one nl\j?nM ,h" ""r r,f '"'?'2 Wi'* passed, Jefferson and ,?7 l;'"1 both determined to make the new gold ??o silver ollar equal m vai,.?? to the then stand mo. m-aaurements, which wsa a dollar semel tw * ?''?>?"? of gold. They recognised Ihe fa : g?" the exchangeable vaine of a coined dollar gJ*M?e controlle,! t,y t),e .?rnn.er ial vain.- of Hie Wllon r'ir into Und how man ? Commercially ..,,,, They dfl , . Therefore, Ihe) indertoob :" giains of silver, uncoined, were 1 In value to 9? ?rains of gol,I. tlfteen ma-,? . '* ' !h*?' '? re<4inre.| fifteen times ?? of ?iK ? ,nu>?iHying 24\ by It pia.e.i 371'/ grains th. ?VT f '' ''""?r. 'ihis undervalued ?:old. For ?he nr sju ?*? ? limit ?nt tk Huicw""?'?.""? ??**1"*- ow'iiig largely ?K international thi lach ??f i'ommimii ation, it circulated ?eni :??.'.'", "x;""', ?nd then, long la-fore l?vM. tk. ,?G lv '"" "' circulation, and we were on toter, ?? ",an,,1.!,nl '" I?! Js.-kson sought to chan? ,.'""?"'11"?"' but he was unwilling to ?e4nlf.il. ",??;;,|??':? ?'lion which buslnesB was then mer** "..:_. recognised the danger to com r-siu, '?at ui,,|*r Ihi. ,,-v '????,??G.?' "-'"<,G!'?? ?ne etan.lard H??, iheiefore, the amo-iM of ?old j.ut Into the dollar, so koth ?,??? th'" It* ,0,n?KC the bullion value of '1 U?.^i,T *?i?y\ *"? iu?1 ?'inai lo the dollar then ?si, V, '?.??. Wei Inataiiee a new ratio of II to 1 ?"?tlo ???.G_1. J ^a!' l,f,on ?"'?'?il that this n?? ?'rol,! Ill *,n, ,0 '"' K0,,) standard-?I grains *l?h? th. .1 ''oll,,r;*-"' ha?, been on it ever since, n ?ne exception of th?? time lacld. ni to the war. ^ A PRKI-tSTKItors CLAW. ?Mmi?:I?"*!*ht V""r" of "?r-'rience ?Uh free and fr?? anrt r0'r,a*'> of no,h ?t?????? showed that by ? ?-ad unlimited coinage we were unable to af fB? Fin>T OF THE gRCRETART r>y TllK IN* TERIOR'I gPEECHBg AOJUNBT FREE G????? AGE A REFEREN?CE TO Tin: i-iiKsi l'KNT ORXBTKD with TU. lll'LTVOUi .\ri-i.\fSK. Gainesville, Ge., July B.?Northeeet Georgia ?.-,.-? B? retery Hoke Smitii a splf-n?iii reception this m? rnlng. The presence of hundrelp of cov trp] wagons aurroundlng th-^ public s.iu.ir?? de jintpd the inte.-?M that tlie fermera feeil in the geancial discussion now going on. Early It lie cam?? apparent that the laruc county courthouse, ^ : seats more than one thousand, would be ?pia le t ? hold all the country i?<-?pie who had come from a distance. Tho c??mtnit?"P requested, in view of thir? fact. th.i? the ladle? and city G'<*" ?> would ? ? atteri. Th.? bull ling was trrowded to ? ?? ?cation, many being tinable to i,bt.\in ed? fission. The Becretary ?,?.?<? for two hours and a lmlf, Heelvlng the cloeegt attention fr??m his auditors. jn ? r he refeired eloquenti) to President (je\?-'lnn1. who?.? name was received with m giultuou? applause Al the con? hisi.-n ..G iil< ?peech the aiidi>Tr??^ pave Secretary Pmlth s ris? ing vote of thanks. m?t one auditor failing to risi? lo hla feet Secretary Smith said in mihstance: 1 am here in response t?? your invitation to ilsciiss the finan -lai problem. 1 shall support the fiaterai Democratic j,lHtf,irm and oppose the Na? tional platform of the G puliste. At Chicago, 'n ???? ? hi i?????? ? u party, by Its representstlves for ihe entln I'nlon, voted down, overwhelmingly, the ? r position of a delega*,? from Colorado to lu? ne?? in the platform the word "free" (which would r- made the platform declare for frei coinage ?f s'her) The platform adopted, when honestly <??.., lemned the free coinage ol silver at 16 to 1, and rh<> delegates, on the lirst ballot, r a'.eii by a two-thirds vote, as Ihi standard bear r ?f the party, one who. in 1883 by a message to congress, had i*h th?? free coinag? of B'.Urr -n ? the Blsnd-Alllson a.-t. and who, Ister, in February*, UM. m? a private i ?????. in s public je-ter. declared the "experiment of free, unlimited anJ Independent coinage of j!i?.-<r" to he "danger? ous and reckless " This nomination emphasised the r-: .?a-.ion. by the convention, of I ?? tree coinage of silver SATURAL RE8ULT OF A PANIC *Vc have been through a panie. Times have im priv?? I, Without stopping to account for the pani,?, It ik iul 1 be borne in mind that panics have oe aam : about every twenty years, usually acc?>m MBied with distrust of the kind of money used. Every panic ha? devel ?ped s party In favor of hai money, but ?srlth returning prosperity the party tas died. Reib ' from panics hss always come through restoration of confidence, not through ha,l ; I ,r.ey. :i ry teaches that a Md-raonev scheme should , Yr? e\;.? ;<?? now. It comes In the form of a propo- | ? ? ? for the free, uni mlted ar,] Independent coin- ? , ? silver at i? to l. Coinage ai la to ? means sixteen times as much silvr as gold hi a dollar. tins ? ' si in lard e ?Id, fW? grains of standard | silver. Free coinage means, without charge to the ? : holder, bul at the ?-xiiense of the taxpayer, unlimited means, to coin all that is offered; inde pendenl mear?^. within? reference to tl.*? course of I ?r.r.-r nations. In the language of "G.???" Hill: "l ? o; ; ise this proponed legislation ? aus? 1 favor all ; of its professi ? objects, ind oppose all its real | fa ???." THE V.'"T OF 187?. T:?,. free-silver advocates claim, firs', that the ? ii ? of -?;? was surreptitiously passed, and robbed i?-.e reiple of one-half the money of final payment; record, that for this reason there i: fe.", first, Ihe vaino of silver, to make it equal to gold nt ihr? ratio of 15 to I, or. second, the value Of sold to make It er?iial to .?liver at 1? to 1, when Ihe different?? in their buHlon .eine eras onlv 5 ??"' cent, la li noi preposterous tn ? lain thai free and unlimited coinage now ?rill ao Increase ? lie value of allear, when the dlacrepancr is U pei eggtt? It cannot lie i-laloie ?: lhat the l?gislation by the ? nlted states In 1S73 aerlousl) affected th?? commer? cial value of silver, for aim?? that tlm.? we have furnished a market for ???,???.??? of silver, very much more In proportion ?.r Increaelng om mine than areni through our minta during the ''**}'" of free and unlimited coinage ol allver The fall in ihe price of alivi r ran easily be ac? counted for. in 1873 the arorld'a produci of allver at coinage value ?rag ISl.lOO.Oi'lO; ;n IMS, n ?.vas $1:*?. 4?O,000; in ISSS. l2W.leo.0uu, and In ISM, $j;i.t?l.ftOO This enormoua Increase In ihe production ??: silver ' took |.la<?e despite ih?? faci thai allver had fallen In value ??, ? .??? rent. My legislation passed in ?v7: Tj. Norway and Hare, den an,i Uermany suspended :h,? coinage of sliver In 1873 M Germany demonetised allvei ami pul fW>. 000.090 of bullion upon ihe market? of Rurop Denmark. Holland, Russia, Austria, Hurgar) each suspended the coinage of demone) .?.? ? sil? ver. The Latin 1'nlon. rompni??! of Prance, Belgium, Switzerland, Italy ??.] Greece, ?a? forced la ?hf i.eii.l the coinage of allver because II sa? found Impossible, by free coinage, lo sustain Ihe value of alh'er bullion, Thin was done by ?^u?-; ???.si,,n for tweh'e months at a time from i??i io Itil when Hi.? auapenalon arai made without limitation aa lo tho Mm.? of continuance, Since then India Mr,17, A rmtlne Republic and Chill have suspende??] ir??.'? coinage Th" value of ?llvrr bullion has fallen since 1873 on account of th?? lessened cosi of production, on account of the enormoua Ine res se li- production and on account of the dei rea seni demand. .Ml of these .-lenient* entered Into and helped to the reduction of the vain.? of allver. To restore the price of allver io Ita value in 1S7.1 .voi. must remove all th" ? .11...?- which heve re? duced Ita val le, Concede for th?? ask? of argument thf?t the action or the (Tnlti , Stati ?. ?. 1 tho?-e .anses, it Ii Illogical to claim that ?? rooval of Uns one Is to remo4*e the effect of -ili ; the others THESE WERE PRACTICA!. TESTS. We were unable to keep Ihe value of ?liver up m | gold under th? Pree Coinage a I of IT?. ?Ve rei nnat.;?. to Keep gold up to allver under the Pree Coinaga net ,,f ist prance and hei associate? In th" Latin G???? found themaelvei unable to keen si.ver up to ??foLI In '.?.: ' radure of these practical tests, under far mor- favorable clr urn? ?tances than those of thi ;,?? ?em dem u.?? 1 ? how ridiculous Is the claim nf the silver .1 ?%?? ite The Imme.Hat.? err.??? of tha election of Pn dent committed to such a nolle* would be thi separation of th- gold and silver dollar thi dollar going tc a premium ..f nb .- ? ... The currency constating of check* and bill? of .v ??nani,?'?, amounting ?a at pei rency, arould an oui of use m conaequence .?' , of confidence an.l credit, and thi resoli arould he the withdrawal of I??1, per ?? ? of >ui entire cur? rency an.l the paralyala of business would Imme? diately follow. NO PRESIDENT WOITI.P APPROVE IT. 1 do not believe that 1 President ?.?..,u'l pvei sp? prove auch legislation, if elected 111 in .1 platform with a Congresa pledged t.. pasa It The ItOUa effects following SUCh nn ele-Mot? would to them the pray era of the verj ? ? who ? them, appealing for the defeat ol at* h ? ?1 la t k? ? Inatead of fr.?.? silver al 14 10 I, which mssna sil? ver monometallism, a contraction of Ihe urren ? ani ? temporary and permanent Injury to business whl h had t..'?? described, the Secreter? necessity f,.r a Bound mone) currency, consisting of gold, sliver ani paper, bui evi r> dollai kept ns good ?s any oth"r dollar ThU would the coinage of all silver which could bi held exchangeable value silk gold? Thi? could el?os the Improvemeni of Hie larking ayalem evet to tha extent of repealling th.? '..? upon ??tate imnks under stell prepared provision? regulating ihe is? 1 of not"s an.l giving safety to t'a olllholderi BLAND*8 PRESIDENTIAL BOOM IT II ?.?G?????. AT A MVSETtNO OF M IS.-?'it-It! PRU I1LVCR ????' ?ft? Bedatla, Mo., July ? Th- Miami Presidential boom certainly wn? launched here to-daj bj 0 1 ernor Stone himself in a t-i??? ?' re about fifty ] Missouri Democratic editora from all over the State The mention of Bland'? name and ihe r : nectloa in which it wh? itsied brought forth a ; storm of applauae an,I shout.?.. Th?? liovernor hai depleted th? general distress ''til hurl time? In , the rec-ent pnnl??. ant "losed In his most Imi r? a? ?Ive ami elirr.itW-ant st\ le by savin?; "And I things will ?1 continue uollea a man Ilka honest 'lii"k' Miami I? nominal? 1 for It? In spue of .Mr Rland'a Beaming Indifference to the mention "f bla run?? as a Mr. ildenl 1 Milt/ It Is not r|"nle,l h'-r- 10 night b) hi? ' that "Hiiv-r in.k'' ma) attempt to come the next National Democrat!? Convention e hope to lead the hoata la thi batt?i m l< free-silver banner SILVER DEMOCRATS WIN IN' MIIW>ITR1 I ?I-HET DEPRAT Tin: m >V*D M< ?RET MEN OS TH? ST ATE fOSTVEKTIOS QUESTION. It. !.. ..ns. Julv 0. I'-sptte ,,|,|, thai met them at every etep m agitating for ? Bl ? tlon. the fre"-silv?r wing of the Democrac? in? triumphed at -v-rv point. Th.- State convi will be held al Pertle Spring? on A igual I ?fti th?? call for the convention wsa lasue ? by ? e Bl it Committee, the aound-money Dem?crata r.iis? ? the point thai th?? convention ?,.,p? ??? onlj ? maaa meeting end could noi bind the party. .1 conventtona to elt?t?oee delegate? eould be held for ., k ,,f tlm??. This hint waa eccepii I by tha allver men, and conventions were called In even counly ?n the sta?.? 10 choose delegates. Severs! have ah.?,,? been held. The siiv.-r men ?a* that th? nvehtlon, which la certain to declare f??? fre< ?liver, u:li be regular The Bound-monej p ersta ?re divided Some favor delay at evei while others favor an earl?, convention believing thai the ellver mon will thua expend Iheli em ??usui and the sooner return to ?Almi the) terra <?? Ihodoi principle? THE RAI TIMORE ASD omo BLOCKED DWTRl'CTIVS WORK OP A PLOl DHfRSI \ MAN KILLED Bl UOHTSIHa Connellavtlle, Pen?., -Mil?? H The .1 ? ?? . tloi In this ragion wrought by the cloudburst last night is worse than waa at Mr;' reported Both the Hill Parra and Perguson mines ar?? full of ?rater. The latter cannot i? pul In operation roi months The Malumore and Ohio Railroad Company has a large force of men at work between Dun bai nnd Mount Brsddock, but the wreckage all! not be cleared up ao that trains -an ?-t through tn fore ihe last of ih?? week, The pa aenger ira.n? are being transferred 10 Ihe Pennaylvania ? ill r?\t L'-senrlng 1*0. I, Krank McClory stepped ., aide his door to gel som.? wood, arhen ha a 1 < struck by lightning and killed Instantly. ,-??> ? MISIC AS AS All? lo BOBBERS. A MAN P1.AT? ?11? PIANO IN ? ROADHOITBE WHILE Mis COMPANION RANSACK? TI IK I? 1. ?MS nn" of ih?? moil prominent rosdhouaei on Mr? Patersoa Plank Mon, 1*. Dankhoff*? Hotel, ?? large fram? ?truriui?? al.i.ut midway between Rutberfoi I and Massai", ?. .? . and. In common with other simi? lar reeorts M has slscred i" ibe prosperity brought by the ?w-Jersey Blectrle RsUwsy, which cai thousands of people pas? the ?.? ,.,r even aa; The recent opeslsg of Ihe Usa to Hoboken baa large:) augmented ihe bttstness, Two pleasant, well?4?reeeed raen from Hoboken rode on the troll'-y 10 Dankhoff. Hotel 0? Monday afternoon, and .iitere.i the barroom Afiei ? h one of them looked around, and, seeing ? handaom plan, just Inside th?? parlor, aal down and. begs ? running hi? finger? o\.-r the keya it ? ?? evident lhat he was no novice, and he Boon ha i ? ?????- an I appreciative aii'ibnce. Bojourneri in ihe barroom Kather???! around the door; servants i<-ft theli arork, and the bsartender deserted iha b?r and i.in.i iha Ibrong- The musician'? companion sai fi ? ,tten. Kor perhaps a half boui everybody In Ihe ???1???? l...rho,?I was charmed with th?- beautiful melodies, and, as th.- Btrangei ar,.-, from Ih? In ti ?.,,? t, a baisi of applauae ma:k.-.i ti ? ,? ,?. of the impromptu concert Tna servanti returned :?? iheh ?.-' and mosi of' th? muslc-loven went luck to th i"t room, whl!?? the bsrleader arai k< ;,i bus) ?-rving drinks for several minutes. A irolley-car can along snd th?? Hoboken men. jumping on board, waved a farewell to the hotel Some little time sflerward a visit to the ?e,?oinl story of Ike hotel revested Ihe fad that whi:?? the muwc was in progresa the skilful player's companion had carefully ransacked the upper room!? for Basali artici??? of value He took two gold satchel tnd various other minor 11s-f.1l ani ..rnam'-tital t'-.!n?s ami ha'l aptiarxnth mad? a ihoroueli and taklni; sean-h An ?larm was sent out, bui the tblevea hs4 ? ??.,,? ?tart and were not ?p??? ? -?. snilifFRS' ORATRS T?FSF.CU?TI Ii Marshallnwn. i.,wa .inly 24 Oresti ascltemenl pre? vails river an an of vsndailsm ??< ininlit???) las: ?>???,? The oemetery at the Iowa Soilbrs' Home wa?? en tcrel by an unknown ml^r-'ant, who with a s|et)?e hammer deferivi ami broke off at the aiuuni furur six maride Biaba re t. 1 by the Government over the soldiers' groves. Threats sgalnst the life of the guilty person are male by veterans at the Home A discharged Inmate, who has disappeared, Is suspe b ' ?. ? BA NNOi *?'.? ON 77/ ? WA RPA TH. A MAS8ACRE OF WHITE PEOPLE FEARED IN THE JACKSON?? HOLE REGION. THE IND1AX8 BAIO ?? > BE BEKKlKfl BEVENOE ?TOH Tilg ???.?.??; OF PRIMMfERi Bt WHIT1 VI ? Till: RRPORTS BB1J1 VtSD IS WAPH? INOTOK TO I'K BXAOOEBATBD Ball i. dte, July 8 >Advl es from Jerkson's Hols Ind ate 'in tbe position ol the Bettlers is becom Ina critical, an,I unless the troops nrr,?e there quickly Ii is probable thai ?? general masaacre ?>f white people will take pisca Thlrtj Uve men lefl Jackson'a Hole r,,r n hack Canyon lo arrest In? dians f,.r killing elk ? ?wi and otherwise l" the rune laws They took seventeen Indian? prisoner* On th?? way bach the Indians a.npi to e>. *?,e. an?) a fighi ensued, in which all tbe In . ex,?, j,? one pappoose, were killed. Bevefal of the ??iite men ??.??? severelj wounded, bui none fatali;. The Rannodi wsrriors are sssembimg In for?* tm the Hobsck River, snd ar.? sending away their squswa and children, which indiostes tliat ibey m< m t?? tinbi The Indians are greatly hseeneed al tbe killing of the prisoners and the rttuatlon la M ci Iti ?! that a g? nevai ri-mg max ? moment. The Benno k? an seid lo he ?", atrong. The cavalry are pushing t?> th?? scena of :. t ? s with a'i posait ? peed In Iba mean time Ihe ????'?? an entreneheo snd swsltrng an atta k b) ? e li Hans Reports from i'- itello. Idsbo, lui received, >?n noun ? - ' raen In Hans ? ? settU ?- near .? ? ,. - Hole. Wyogtleg, p which three white men end Is Ii lien? arer? kill? I. .?...? ne, \\ ?,. . .id? X The (irsi .? :??? es ol ? authentic net in from the scene "? the Indian trou? ble in ih? Jsckson Hole region r. .?? ? ? Qovernoi Kl herds to-day In the sbaj.t telegrams seni bj r from Marysvsle, Wjrp.. lo Market bake. Idaho, from Adjutant-General Btltser, of tbe Uot . Btsfl who .?,? seni Into the regten to Inves? tigati the troubl? between the lad'sns snd wl < me ?. ? from Mgrysvale, i- s ? .? S?,,uts who have ? t me n fr.?ra Ihe m luntalni ... ,,. ... .. , ek and Rlvei Ail passe? bv ill ? de ' ? in? Captain Hm prospector ? ? im? In, wounded In th?? right br? ,-? b? In Hai ? ?th? ? pr? epe, t ir? ai m th? n u ? -'" ?*- >?"? ' nounl pass? ?? gbt Fon ? . ? ; - , r , i foi march snd everyh ? ,, : ::.? I A ih .ni message seni yesterdsj ??? i*tita.r from th? Teton Basin, near th.? Idsbo-Wyomibg lmr. Arrived here on return trp Bettlers in rhe-Jtasln i ? -, . !,? r that mam ind' m? from Fon Hall sn leaving t., |oln ties.? in ti -, ? era r? ie?l joining them ?.???????? and rouriera ha? b? -u aent iul t -, t-i ? ' ? ? il !; ? foi lid. sn?! ' ?'. ho h.??' -.?r go : ? ? the mounts ? meet il t ? r t, ? ? r r ? ?.? S ttlrr? bevi given Up ?!? hopes ,,f rops , ? ' ire preparlni to t_k- ail w omen . ? . :. . .1 ? ? ?ut if thi ? ? . .; ernoi Birbanti states that no movemeni ?' FU m troops Into th Jackson's II ?le oun a b : mtil further Informati in Is recarvi ? Washington, ? ?? ? it ?m? ?aid al the Indian .it .?, , ?.? ? - ha :???? ? ? ? ? ? t?,. t. esistei ? of trouble wifh the lian noch In ? Hans ,,t Jackson'? Hob si mm!? ? ? I ? ?> ? . ??.r? --? - ?? Increduli!) respect ma reports h< ?? bole?sile of In -???|e?? ?'.??? t... . I.'t ?Un bad sent to Investigati ihe situ?t lot hss besa in -? .'?!?.. ? - j? ,r '.um * ,' a ?? tu ?,,1.???? ?rhtch , mualcatlon to the Barese, ?ini the . ?? p? m? ?Ioni thsl nothing I ? ? ? days Ills lit??? reporta ? ? ,?,. Buch In , S usi la "r ? w.. It ?il pul ronuastoni r ? . I ? lei ?A .,- be) .? I it.- ? f ? , ; ? Usa si ? fot ?..s ?n? WORD FROM THE PRINCETON STl'DENTS : ?? ?? ?\ r.i.i. in ? p Kl ????????. 1??? Phil idelphts luly lu ses I > Da is t?:,- ? ? noon ????,????! ,, telegram from '(.e Pi ?. who, it ? .-? feared ? . ? hi ih?? Hanno? k ?? lattng that th? ?if,? it. , ha ? arrived in the Veil, , l-ark ? . : ? ? ? ? ia been I i?, - .? -.' .. . ' ??,,? prlnn Irai ? ?. pe im?.n rbe entli pari ol ? ?? ? ? ? ?.moretti arai Uuboii ? - the s. ...... of ihe Indian minina fishing and hui memi ? ?? uBiwoi rmatlon waa ri eli ?? ! In thi? ????::, from two sources _ ? ? , . ,. ;.r?rt\ of Prtncetoi si idei te, > ?m? ? ? -. geological ?urvej part) seni ? ? ? from Princetoi College, hsd passed thr,,ugh the ? Wyoming made langerons bj the depre ? if thi Bam ck Indiana, nd waa now safe within th? boundaries of Ibe feltowstonf Perk ?.? n,, time ime li been sbsolutely ?-ertsin 'ha? the si?i d? i?i? erere In ??? ?!? but the lack a ? ? f:, m it,,- party h.??? cause?! much snslet) ? ,? ?* hi. h there ? m ; >?? be no ?r?>?ni.| A .1 Mill! si ... of No 7: Hudson Bt and ? Foi ayth Ut tie, of No, U Wsll-si ? ??.? l yesterdsy? ? 'owing telegram fr.,ni Captain \ S Andel eon, w bo commands the 8th ? nlti : Rtates < ' 11 ?ili ? ir, y>| owstoi ? l'ark Founts In fleyser, Hv?. Jul) :*". k-? Princeton pert) sil righi No trouble, uni ? bod) hen and perfe il) well Fountsln (ieyeei is In the southwestern pali ol Ihe National Park, no- more than twenty miles fron the Idaho State .in.?. (?? receiving th?? message, Mr. Little sen! ? nt , Major Krsmer, a? Fori Wsshakts, \\'\?>. .is fol ?,?* Princeton pert) al Fountain Oeysei to-dsj No trouble Ail w?:,. Thsnka foi your s'Ire. ?? v. Oarrett, of Biberon, N. .1 . is a brother of John Oarrett, Princeton. !?.'.. of Baltimore, anotbei member .,?" the par*] yesterday he receive?! ? telegram f:,.m ii1.? brother In Wyoming, snd h<- itn m? Ha?? -. lelegruhped 10 F W, Otbeman, of No -? White st . this city, Ihe Father of Edward It. Ol he man, Princeton, '.?'. who is also a member of the ? . ? ? as foil? s ? Biberon, ?. .1 . July ? Telegram from John says all well in Park. No trouble A, I.. P. Dennis, Princeton, ''*',. also telegraphed | lo his father, the It' \ .1 S li? nuls, of ??? PU Lexington ave., who Is now al Norfolk, Conn., : staimi; Ib.?) tbe pail? Was Well alci eaf<?. - ? -ay /?/v. UASIEI i.mis its PBEsimsi - ? a \i:v?. ?.on?: PHTSK IAN AV tiik iii:\t, or thi: STATE ? itti!) OF BKAt.TB ttbany, luly I \> .? meeting of the State Board j of Health held here to-day l>r Danisl l.ewls, .?/ ? New York, was unsnlmously elected president to ? ? ? ? Floret ce ? ? ? ?onohtie ? ?-. ? ?ewla '? ? an r\ presiden ? of Ihe Htate Medical go? ?i?-t\ :u Fred erlch w Smith, of Syracuse, appoint.? ? by Got .or Morton as successor lo Dr, Donohue, sai 1 ??iti. tbe Board. Il? arili probablj succeed to the , placea on the rommltteea ,-f Ihe Board formeriy : h? id by Dr, Doaohui Th?? Board lecelved an opinion form th. tttot no) Oenersl holding tbai Dr. Donobus coni.? con til?n? sa a member of the Tuberculosis Commit? ' tee for ih? vea ?, although his term of ..III.?.? as . member of lbs Board had expired At this sftsi ; north's session I >r. Moti oh ?it was in attendant*?, and I ii.? announced thai h?? was willing t., stand on tha M torne* Oeneral'a Interpretation of th.? lew ree? I tinning him as a member of the Tuberculosis rommlttee, ? it ?vas announced thai ?- John reust, of , /Oughk.-epale; ?,? Matthew Henderson of S?ra cuse, nnd Dr Austin, of .-? henectady. had been eelecti 1 as attle Insp? toi "r i.ewis who lives ai No ?:? Madison-eve., In Ibis rity, is one of the prominent physician* ??G Now York Me Is a member of the .'..unty Me,|,. ,1 ?Ta! ".'.".' eCe!E?*-lL._!fc!-' meni?ai organisations DONALDSON SNOWED UNDER. PLATT'S MAN ? ? ? ? ? N IN Tifi". SARATOGA SENATE O INVENTION. BOOAR ? BRACKETT, THE ???? MACHINE i'AM'1 DATE, ORTS THK DELEOATION AND is PRAC? TICALLY BURE OP THE ROMINA? TTON ? VP TORT TOR f* >' ?? OOVERNMENT., [ht t??.??p??? T'? Tiir. rStStTNg | Saratoga, July tt. ?Harvey .1. Donaldson, of I Ballston, is th?? first of IRS group o? I'latt Sens! t* vho ?!? Red Republican sentiment In am am laut winter snd openly obstructed the progress of p form legislation to find himself repudlsted by ? discriminating constituency. By ? vote of more thsn two lo one, Ihe Bars togs County Republican Convention, which met tn-dny in Ballston spa. rejected hla sp? osai fir ? renomlnstlon and Instructed the eounty'a oight dslegntes to the Senate Con? vention 'n thi? district, the row XXVIIIth, to support his energetic and popular rival. Edgar T. Preckett, who, In Ihe Interest of better government -?t Athen) and ? more llbersl le.||c\ in G'.?-???.???mi management, hna headed the movement in this county to retire Mr Donaldson lo pr?vete life. Mr. Bracket fa victory is ns aignlfk-snl sa it la ?weeping, for, eoupled with Mr CoggeshsU'a Impending de? feat in Oneida County, it will be a.pted everywhere as an emphatic assurance that the rank snd file nf the Republican party In the Stat" are not disposed to overlook les! winter's aoandsla ani shortcomings si Ihe Btste Cap Itnl. noi t.. return lo power Ihe rahservlenl lefxwlstlve sgenta who for four mont he de tinntiv aacriflced party principles arni part.? welfare si the dictation of an Irresponsible "brass " NO one wh? more surprised, perhsps, timn Mr Donsldson si Ihe overwhelming chars, ei of lili defest The resuH of Issi Saturday's ? au. il?.??.??, rntlflnl nnd ronflnrtcd b) Hi" a. tl'.n ?if the convention to-day, leaves him with,ut a t-ingl?? delegate In Ihe Benste Convention, which I- t?. meed In Ballston on August ? Hla reeoi I and p? reo nail t y are, therefor??, lutely and aommaiily eliminated from the canvass h"re, mil he ind bis ms< bine aup porters will have to lie conten? with thi rather novel aenaatlofl of beine ' >n at the windtip of perhaps Ihe moel exciting Senate contest fn this aecttofl of the State for twenty pears. DON iLDSt ?N'S REO IRD TI -.'HI? ?? of th? Btrugg??' r?"t?.,. ??-? Mr Dot ildsm and Mr Bracket! f r the control of Bsrsl ?-1 Count) and, with Ita ? te, the Senate nomtnatlcn it. this district ar.lai iratel) de? ?ctitx-d in ? re ?!.? lettei M Th?? Tribune. Mi Donaldson, ss wi ??? ? served ,l" ? terms In Albany aa ? Btati Senat ? ?? i two as gn Amenti .,??.??' ? it Ion lhs?i Ihsl of : ?.?. II Ing pii| I In Mr. ? ' .?? ' ? ind personal \m " bettor of ill th- private legislative ici nf the R ? and m re than auape ted of underhanded a Kling ll ? ? with the ? immani ? ' ? ?? ? ? ?? - ?: ?, ? ? ? for a foui th lei m In the ?, ? a ns turali! ft tv l up >n the ?. ?? ti ?? ? th?? dlatri ? ?? ? . ' ap rg or "oivl? inning th.? questionable pnllHss! ?? ? hi !.. undei Mr. ? I Inued ? ve crept m? ?? | ind ? Al tati ini kly rallied ? the M ... ... ; . . ... gg|p f ... both ?'?.?,? u ? ? ' ihe t local pal ? the ', ind ? of Prank Jones, I , ? r ? ni s-a ? freel. it his dlap < '? the fai m< re lm ? portan! patmnsge f ih? Bri;? and t'hamplaln C insla w ?- g|a io h m ! ? ? ? leni Aldrldi u Superlntet.denl ? ??? ?? ? Th( ? . m mala tr iwrre t ? ? ? lei ? in?! s nit hem poi lion of ti. whole strength ' " ? ?' was put forth ?? ? irrj ti ? ?? . . s in Iha eastei town for ?? ? U ? igenl p \ PR? in \..?: I ?11 ?? G .'?'". The result f thi iturda sirat.-l cleat ly that t wer of pan mple, n is of little ivsll tgslnal u ar >uv ? l ?nd Indignant public s miment V.netj dele gatea were t?? be chosen to it.uni) e ? Hon, i4ni when Ihe smoke if the ba|l ? cleared awii\- U ?as found lhat Mi Bra keti had slxt) thi.?"legates t , Mi '. ? nnldrion'a twentj seven Of the towns on Ihe Champlaln Canal. Water ford, the home f Mi P< k. a <- th nl) one of .m, mai qui nu r ? Bupp ? ' Ihi lifting S n itoi Half Moon, Beret ga ap I Btlllwster, It east .lion were all carried t?j tin Ann Machine ' ? it??, a hile ? ? Ine aouthi rn d??t mlj ?'lift ,n Park an 1 Ballston sci ? ai i mu ' the wreck ..f ihe Donaldson csnvi??e I'"?? Sen.itor'i own town, Milton, -spped the cjtmax >) electing tin .? Bl ackett delegates it of a total of eight Mr Bracken's home, Pai il -, Mm the hands m? c >mpllm< nt ul ? solid d > lion uf a! ? teen \t the convention this aftern m the Bracket! men h?? I thtt ga ill ihe ? ?wn ??? iy, the su eas ful candidate and his chief backer, ?>? Bherlfl W VY Worden, of thla village, bellt? on Im;..I to Bee that none of the fruita ??.' Saturday's vlctorj should slip ,i ara) The ? tonal Is? p man igena were ? ? ? liicrln.-?? that they made ? ? m ilei lai ppoal lion to the Bra ke?t programme, and, sfti r nom! n?es for county officer? had ?.p chosen and Va semblyman Donald M Saught?>n had been nomi? nated )??. acclamati in. Mr Brack??tl ?.?..is all ? I t ? name, practical!) without ? contest, thi Benste lelegatee sho ere t? ?.t ?1th elghl others from Washington Count) and ti?.?? fr>>:.i Bchenectsdy Count) t" m ik?? a no ninstlon f ir the XXVIIIth District. MR BRACKETT ? PROBPKCTrl Mr. Brackett'a nomination is practlcslly as? aured, now thai li?? haa captured Barstoga'a eight delegates lo the Senate Convention Washington County rhoae its delegates near!) ? month sgu and Instructed them to vote for !.. M Howland, of Po-I Bdward. This action wan. taker- chlefl) t. encourage tha opposition In ih?? ?.??,-r iw.i counties to Mr Donaldson'a candidacy, the Washington Count) Convention having beVn csrrletl by the ?.nt! Machine ele lu-ut under the leadership uf llenr) ?'. Bui lelgh. An attempt had been made b) Ballroad Commlasloner Bskei t. sectiri a delegation friendly ?? Donaldson, hut ihe convention re pudlsled ? hla programme and declared In Favor of Mi Howl? id. n is not probable, hos ?ver, that Mr Howland'a nomination will be pressed upon th.nventlun beyond the point of a parsons! compliment. In Bchenectsdy Count) Ihe ?? legstlon '>f five chosen on Baturds) in hesded bj Edward Kills h haa been Instructed to support a Bchenectsdy <',.utit\ candidasti If Mr ?>?.?.??? f ?? ii.ni carried hi? own county, Bchenectad) would probabl] base given him the three addi tlonsl votea neceaasr) to secure his nomina? tion, it is undersl.I thai Mr. Billa is alao willing t.. help Mr. Bracheti out. on the ground that tin? vntc of the iwo counties, which have long In-en Intimately aascdated In pnrfv poll tics, ahould ultlmstely ??? <*?lst as a unit. Mr. Brackett'a friend? srs. therefore, confident that ths convention of August t win promptly ratify the action of to-day's convention In Ralhrton rKBTRRDAT'l NOMINATIONR 'iti?? Saratoga Count) Senate delegate?, whom, mi tnotlon of Bsnator Donaldson, u wns I'-fr to Mt. Itriukett to elsooge, ur?? W W. Wur? den, ?, w. Neiisiin. Franklin Carpenter, C I?. Sheffcr, VY. B. t'onsalus, OsorgS W. Huirln-s, W. C. Crombl? and Mntthew Armer. These delcgatea were nanu.! to go to tbe state Convention: w. w. Worden, D. w. .M.ild.?. M D. Hardner. P. C. Curtis. Ezra Bayre, J. p. Sherman, K. EL Strange and O. W. Keveneugh. Mr. Worden will control the delegation. The county nominees were: For Surrogate, K. II. Peters, of Saratoga Springs; District Attorney, John Persons, of Ballston; Coroners. Mr. Miles ??; Varney, of Saratoga Springs, and Mr. Ovorge Hudson, of Stlllwater. .1 TRAIN RUNS WILD. IT DASHES THROUGH FAR ROCKAWAT AT A I?CII RATE. THE G????.???,? BAKOU! OP TUR tlNOOfg gggagl AND Till?: ??????? IXStVKA CONTIIOt. BROtTOHT TO A staS'Iistim. TMP.F.F. MILtn BBTOKD THK VTATION. Th?? Long Island train due at Fat U?.? ka way at io.'.; p. m. became unmenegeable ?it the Boulevard croaalng last night and rnn wild through Far Rockaway end three miles beyond It, before the engineer succeeded In g?Mtlnt- the train under ? optrol. The train was being pulle.l by Knptne V,, ill. in charge if William Planagee. <>n neeting th? crossing at th.? Bouleverd, Flanagan att?-mpte<l to slow down in eecofdatice with the mtea Aa he pulled the throttle, the han?]|.? br??ke ,,ff, and lite engine lashed ahead at full speed, with the train behind swaying from Kid?? to side. Th?? train sp???! through the t tern l!k?> an "ex press" and lused mil -h excitement. Flanagan stu l< f , bis post and after running almost three miles beyoi i ?-'ir R? kaway succeeded In bring Ing ih.? cars to a standstill with the air brakes. Th?? passengers w.-r?? Kreativ frightened and son,? of them ?vaIked bach to the station. An engine fr..m the r-'nr Rockaway roundhouse towed the train back t ? Kar R ckawey. RAILWAY MEN IN SESSION. IMPORTANT CONPBRRNCBfl AT MANHAT? TAN BRACH. ? imi TiKKN TO CARRY OIT TBB AOggB ? r FtBAl BED 80MR TIMB AOO ?? Till?: PRESIDENTS ? ??'?MMissi? ,\ ?.????.? TO in-: APPOIMTKD. ? conference of railroad ofllclala r?'pr*?*<ent Ing Ihe principal trunk lines east of the Missis? sippi and north of the Ohio, the outcome of which Is reasonably certain to have far-reaoh i . Iferts, waa begun at tbe Oriental Hotel. Manhattan Beech, yestevdey morning, and win be continued to-day. Two aesalone were held yesterday, presided over by M B, Ingnlls. ? leni of the Chesapeake and Ohio Rail Reporters were not admitted and those. nl refused '" tell what was done. It Is doubtful If the broad verandas of the tal have ever held a larger gathering of trunk line magnates than is Hureniblod tfiere, and the fee! thai the representation is so large and that plenty of time is going to be taken l> Ihe ofllclala Is lobked upon as an ln dlcatlon that unuaually Importent metter? are the programme for s?-ttl"ment. Present yesterday at the two conferencee, epe of which b"gan at 11 and th?? other ?it 2. were 1. .1 Beargeent, W .! Bptcer and <l R. Reave, ,,f the Chicago and Grand Trunk Railroad; 11. .f !!.?? len, aecond ? lee? pr?sident .?f the Near? i Y..rk Cutral. M. A. lleg~man and A. Fell, of the Delaware, Leckavrenna and Western; W m Themes, ?president, ?;. ? Coehren nnd D. I. Roberts, of the New-York. Lek?? Krle and West? ern; Krank Thomson, first vie?* presiden?. W. i, Joyo general freight agant. an?i F. ? Klngsbury, ??: the Pennsylvenia; i ? Oeirett p ?. Klni the Lehtgh Vail? y. C. i' Mayer, president Prank Harriott, and C. L. Bkull, nf the Baltimore and Ohio; M. K. In galls, W P. Walker, h , and ? <i Troup. ??f the ? 'h? ?.!?? ike and Ohio; William Duncan, tecond vice presiden! und general manager of the Baltimore end Ohio Southwestern; A. H. M< I,.i. of the Cincinnati, Hamilton and Mav? >n: Oscar I Murray nnd Mr McCormlck. ?f the 'Rig Four;" Mr McDowell, of the Motion; S ? Callawa) of the Nickel Plate; D W CaMwell, president, A ?' Bmlth general pasaenger agent, and ? .1 Ora-nmer, of the Lake Shore end Mil hlgan Bouthern; D. ? Orar, representing the Pennsylvania evstem weel of Pttteburg; Charles R, Hives, president, and Milton Knight. 1 general freight agent, of the Wabeeh. Hest.les these were a number who did not register, and I others arrived late last nigh! Oeorga m. Pull? man was prea ?nl unoffl? ? illy. WHAT WAtl IK1NR YKSTKRMAY Tu- work yeaterday wan largely preliminary. and the feeling waa apparently harmonious If ?m? one was there to eh ?xrlevencea .?r settle oM IgalnSl bl ???',*?. outsiders did n-u learn G t crop pr ?ap?ete In the \\,-?. together with thi ' -: revival in bust? eenied I bave a geo J effect upon the freight carriers, ami tho Ils -us ?slon would ? >w and than turn upon the millions if bushels of ?-.,rn and ii .? that would be carried within the next six ? ? The meeting war? pursuant ;? a call Issued by the ? ? ' trunk lines, who on .lum? 21 met in tli:s city an I ree lived t ? make a well-di? rected effort to pu l issues and effect an agreo iii.-ut relative ti? frelghl tariffa and classification between the trunk linen eaat if the Mississippi an l north of the Ohio, which would, If faithfully idhered t .. reaull Ip a le resse of "throat-cut? ting ' ? nmpetitlon, mul th?- tli lUsand and one wor? ries Incident il I > li Aa near as could be learn???! yesterday, a committee will be appointed to-day or to-morrow t.) nominate a permanent commit? tee, with voting power, which shall have th.? ad? justment of ail questiona relating to freight tar? if, and classifications The committee to make up this commission will, :t is said, submit their rep irl ? , the presidents of the roads represented in the prop?? agreement, who In turn will sub I to their -v utlve boards. While this looks on lis face to be something of a long-drawn? oui procedure, it is believed thai it will be put through in sinnt order. It Is believed that Og ae ,- mt of its representative character the conclu? ei ms of the ?inferen ??? ? ?w in session will not be reversed .-r materiali) changed. THE MAKE-UP OP THR COMMIMION ? good deal will depend, according to one uf the presidenta with whom the Tribune'? repre? sentative conversed yealerdejr, upon th?? make ? ? of the commis?!? n, Ita head and managen. Whether Mr Ingalla will be at its heed remains ;,, i,.? seen. II- 's regerded by a greet many of the relimad men aa acceptable, but th?? selection Will ? ii be made In a hurry. .lust how much conalderatton passengar rates will receive bus noi developed as yet. There does noi s.-eni to be ani disposition t,< reduce in.-:n The most of the talk up ti the present tir???- ??.is ??>????? relative to ? strict maintenance of the taiiiTs and cleaetfleet lone and the eatab II hineilt of a BySteig for th>> roads represented .m tli.nference thai shall be "burglar proof" againsl ihe attecka ,,f rate-brokera This arould mean en Immense suing In commissioni t?? mld illciiien and Would do away largely wllll r? num? ber "f bad feeturee which at present make the uf.? ,,i' tin- freight and psseenger agent and bis superior*) a burden. President tngells wss retloenl wh-'ti ask??! what had been done or was t>. be <i ne. "We hsven'l anyihliiu ''? ulve ??tit," said he, "at present We do noi deny that we expect that the conference win be far reaching In its resulta nnd Mr. Ooddard, secretary of the cog? fe renco, will to-morrow give out a statement of all mult?is of public Int-reat." "Will provision under Ihe new plan he made for Imposing penelttes for violations of the pr\? posed Bgreement, which will work any more satisfactorily than they have In the past?" he whs asked. We neve not Consl?Tlered anything of that kind yet." said hi? "Shall you begin a new war upon the ticket scalpers?" "The pubi!?? will know all that is Interesting about the conference before it adjourns," said ? -?J. BLOW AND COUNTER-BLOW. HORR AND HARVEY EXCITED. HARD KNOCKS EXCHAXGRD IN THEIR GREAT SILVER DEBATE. ?? HORRS Et/JQfENT OfTHfRSTS AND TVtTTT II.I.I-STRATION.S gUCR G.???? APPUAfKE AND I.AtT.MTEK - HARVEY AI.so I/unLT ? ?IEEft KD HY THE ADVOCATM OK mag OOfNAOB THE LIVE? LIEST MMsHOS YET. Chicago, July 23.?No evidence of farle;???? was apparent In either of th<? principals In the Horr Karvey debate when time was callo?! for the sixth round to-day. The discussion was more lively and exciting than an?? which preceded It. and the ?pealtsraf hits wer.? greeted with great applauae. an ? laughter, Mr. Harvey Uf^nn with a vindication of the im portane? of the deba:??, which, he said, rested upon five historical tea?? >ns: First, for 2-0 year?? prior to the dentonettsation o? silver in 1873, silver ana? seeking the mints of th" World for coinage Into money. Second, for 200 years prior to 1S7I there was no variati?.? betWOSB the commercial and legal ratio of l-Vj t ? 1. During the twenty two years since 1873, gOWever, the two ratios hai ?eparated widely, and r"n? from IS?Uj to 1 to about 32 to I. Third, for 338 years prior to 1873 the quan? tity ratio between sllwr and add ranged from 5<i of silver to 1 of g..ld to 4 of silver to I Of foM, but. notwithstanding this wide variation, the commercial ratio had clung t"i;ac|,.usly to the legal ratio Fourth, the prie?? of ?liver In the London market, as measured In gold, up to 1.873 was practically stoa ly, while since that date ?li? ver had declined fr m ? pene* an ?unce to 2*7 penco an ounce. Fifth, that this violent fluctua? tion In th?? price of diver had been g. ing .?? ?sines Its demonotizati?!!!, and If? going on to-day. Mr, Horr did not reply directly t > this, hut took up Mr. Harvey's FtiUement of yesterday that only one error had been found In his ?a irk. sav? ing that there Brere mvr'.a Is of mlsstate r.ients, not In expr?s? statements of facts, but by false implicati..n, which any man Of senee would r?pudi?t" on sight. At this point Mr. Horr created great laughter st the tapeoM of Mr. Harvev by saying that h<? did not deny that hi? opp Dent r.-lieved all he hail written. As a matter of fact, it was impoaatble for him to tell whr-.t a man in Hr. Harvey's siate of mind might bScspsblool hcileving Th?? ??tatem? nt In Coin's rfnaneta? School" that every ounce of silver produced up to the present time had c .st pro? ducers $2 an ounce was scouted by Mr. Horr. If the mine.owners had h vn producing silver at this cost and selling It as th.-v bad been ?loin*", at $1 2d to ?7 cent? an ounce, th"v had lost by the transact! <n during th?? ?ast tnre?? years some Bje.OOO.OOO. The next point of attack was the statement on pat;.? SI Of Harvey*? b ? 'k that th?? people of this count?") ?"-" annually paying to England $2?>0.0<)0,i?00 in Interest on national and private bonds. Mr, Horr lenlcd ll - ; ; rtttou flatly, and challenged any one t ? produce evidence that th? Indebtnesa of the people of thla country ?> i.ll the nations of Fur p.? involved anything like su? h an amount of Interest Th?? dehnte was adjourn.??,! until 1 o'clock on Thursday af'? rnoon. THK DSBATE IN' DBTAIL. Mr H?rr's opening statement was a? follows* "'???f?'. Mask ?v ?:? >. uauh ? Yesrerdav Mr Rsrvsg stated that I had found >.??? ...?.,. error In the .-tat?.?.neata .f hi? .???>??-'?:, and !?e defied me to cell attention to ani other mistak? that he had ma !e. The mistakes that are mal? in Mr Harvey'l b..,,k .ir?-, many of them, not mi-cak??? as ? ? the wir ??? he uses, i.ut misleading inferences fr..rn p. sltlonr -vhIch h ? takes, and which, giving him credit f?>r th- ordinary sesee of ar-? ordinary man, t? must hn\. kno.vn wtici he r>rtp:-?.l md published luch ?tat?menla, in your hoik. Mr. Har vey, roti aay ; "It Is estimai?! by all men of jU'lgmcnt Who gave mention to mining that th?? silver now In existence he? coal not lasa than H per ounce, and many put it much higher." I deny that men of judgment and ??; cla m an?, such thing, ? aasen that ?very man of an) common sens?? who has studied this question kn wa instantly that that statement is noi true; know? .listanti) that silver haa not cost that much for production, because sliver has bean constantly Increasing in predite? lion at a 1 ?w price, running from 11 2'? p-?r ounce down ? .*?" cents an ounce, and the p-op!e ,,f th? world never keep constantly pt*oduclsg ?n article hi so much leaa thai II costa th-m to produce it. Bualneaa men are not such idiots a* that. According to thla statement, th? silver mm-? owners ani men engaged In producing allver lost in ?he \"ar UK m??'.'*-? Th.?y Increased th??r produci in lass, ao thai tbej w..ui,i have loot thai v.ar IT"???"?1" Again, In 1*74, the Increase was ? ? large thai th-?v lost ?tW.OOO, ",, ? total Ics? in three \,-.ir- if CM.000.(IO0 ? iw, th? ? I? an old rule sosas? where th.it "a burnt child dn Ida the Ur??." I think there is some truth in that, and whenever silver mining srets so that th?? m-n lose at the rats of almost 00,000,000 a year th??y will stop ?diver mining. THK rACTfl ALL tOAIXaYT HAKVKY. Again, Mr. Harvey says in hi? book: "There is In the world now. according te the report of Um De rector of our Mint. U.VtMii,M la fold and HIM,? RUM in silver." The Mini l'Ite, tor didn't ?i ve that as the amount of 'Iver and go!?! in tlie world at nil. The Director of the Mint gave simply the amount Of coin supposed to be then in ?StStenca Mullhall, whom you refer to aa good authority, ????.e* the Block or gold coin and bullion It, 1S80 t>,?..,^?!,. ? ;,?,] th,. amount of silver at about ??,. ???? "i-'oln" relis na: "We h.i?.?? in iha ? nlted State? In round figures ??.???,???.??? of ill kinds of money " The statistical Abstract of the Fnlted St.it. s wyi "The total arnouot Is ffl.t!??.. OnO.OijO." That give* one amount, von give another. You tell us ??.?,?? n.? paying Bngland f)C4)M0.O0t annually In gold In tiie payment of interest oli our bonds. National and private bond.?, owned by her people. 1 denj ll and defy any proof that win ?how thai we owe all the countries of Europe combined that much; lhat I?, the bonds that would require that nvieh of interest to be s.-n: abroad, Tes ?tat?? that th" indebtedneae of the t'nlted states li ttx>.000,000,000. That is. that the people of this coun trv. If lhat be true, owe nearly two-thirds as much as all th- property tn the I'nlted States Is worth. 1 brand su. h a statement limply as false. I doni say that Mr. Hsrvej loean'i believe it. bacana? ti is Impossible for me to r ?? 11 what a man in hi| state of mind may believe, (Laughter.) Hut I aay the fact ? contrary to his statement. Pltotu'iTloN OT OOLO AMD stt-V-RR. Mr. Karvej Wh-.i Mr, HO rr refers to tb? amount of gold and silver in the world he orniti to ?ay that m\ statistic? gSVe the amount of gold, | and silver available for us? as money. Ita quallti for use as mone) is the subject uv are uueresred In. 1 now distribute among you a tibie ahowlsj th?? world's production of silver and gold from 17?>| t > la?t taken from in?? book la?: referred to. "Th< Officiai ?On,hi;. Lawa and Statistics'' Issued by thi Treasury Department at Washington. H.?re wi H.?e that from IT?! 10 UN there was $3 2? In sl'.vei produced to 11 In gold, or a quantity ratio, ounce f.ir ounce, of s bou I fifty ..f silver to one of geld. ani yet there was m> fluctuation of the commercial with' the legal ratio. For the ilrst fifty years oj th s century there was produced In the w.iri i $1 71 of Bllver to $1 of gold, a quantity ratio ,,f abou| twenty-eight ounce? of allver to one ounce of gold The world Is now producing about 11 10 In s.lvei to |l in gold. In ISTit, when the mints were closed the world waa producing ab<*Jt Sn cents in silvci to |l In gold In ?? rh" world waa producing about II In silver to 1? In gold, four times as much gold as allver. For am reara prior to Ita, as fai ? back as w.? have atatlattca thai ara undisputed, thai ! all writer? agre?? on as substantially correct th? , ckang? In the relative quantity of relative produci 1 tlon bad no effect on their relative commercial value But In twenty-two \-.irs lemonetlzatlor ', has revolutionized th?? ni-taille currency of th? ; world. And there .? so longer a par of eichaag? , between th?? two metal? at the legal ratio which | ratio Is now only retained to govern th? coins? of silver luto token money to represent gold They aaslgn no other reason than overproduction f,?r th? I.reak In the commercial parity of the two metas \ If tney assign any other reason, .\fr HoTT wl'i surely state it, for the gold standard tow hi? s chance lo lay its claims before the Int?llarenc*? o? th.? country. w m Mi ).\KY AM) CON'THAi'T.?' I began by detlnlng scleniitic bimetallism, and ? lb.? second clause of its leflnition I emph.-??|z,.| ;h? lmp.ii'ianiv of the unit. ^^^^ Imixirtance of the unit As that has already been discussed. It is not necessary to add anything to what has been sail. Hoth should be U>g.i'-tend>?i In the payment of all d-bte. This assist? In main? tslnung the ?quality of the two metals. You Inter? fere with tbe unlimited demand for their u?e ai money when you limit their full use a* money Excepting In the unit there should be no discrimi? ni money, ??? suen contracts, when made pavabia In money, should call for lawful money What 1 good for one cltlsen la good for another. To permit a raid to be made upon either gold or allver la li 1 permit Individual* er combinations of men to til?