A mn si went ss.
B.CADKMI OF MUSIC — S:1j — The Return of
AUB A XI im A—?— K— Vaudeville.
AHTOn— S;ir» — The Jtan from Horn*.
BKI_ASOO— 6:15 — Is Matrimony a Failure?
BIJOU — — Klol*.
BROADWAY— S:IS— The Midnight Sons.
J.IIO.VX— 2— S— Vnud*viU«-.
CARXKGIB UAIX — >:I.". — Concert.
CASINO— 8: 15 — <lirl and t*i<" Wizard.
COI^OMAI 2— S — Vaudeville.
'COMEDY— S:l3— The Meltiiu: Pot.
CRITERION— 8:15— I iraej.
DALY'S— S:J 55 — The Wh!t« Sister.
EDEN MI'SEE — Th« World In Wax.
Kit PI RE — 15 — Inconstant George
OATETJ S:l.'.— The Fortune Hunter.
GA':::; X I ".The Harvest Moon.
HACKETT — 3JS — B:ls— Socti a Little Queen.
HERALD SQUARE— S:I5 — The chocolate Sol
HIPPODJtOME — 2—2 — «« — A Trip to Japan; In
•i«l« the Earth: the Itallet of Jewel*.
H' ' PON — v •_.<« -I!-..- Builder of Bridges.
IRVIXO l*l.At'E— S:l.*.— lv.r a™<> Jonathan.
KN!«-Kr:UD<viCER— S— The I>ol!ar Princess.
LIBRKTY— <!:irt— ?prinrtime.
X.Vi.EITM— 2:IS— s I.", — Ar«. :»• Lupin.
I.TRic- fi:l&— Herod.
MAJKSTIC — 8:16 — Mr I.ode of Km!.
MAM.VK EI.MOTTS THBATRE- S:so— The
Pnssine of th« Third Floor Hark.
Iff [>Rl.t«m>HX mi.l. :S — Fang Recital, c
m " AMSTERDAM— «:I«— The .Silver Star.
NEW YORK— S:IS— Tho Man Who Own
BAVOV— 2;IS— S:I3 — The Atvakenin; or Helena
PTUVVKHAN'T— r:IS— <:IS— The r.a.:-*t Way.
FT. >!<-M«H.A- ni.VK — 10-e Skating.
VS\M.I.A«~K'S— •; IS The Fourth Estate.
"U'nnKns— <s:ir.— The ri r tax
.TVEST END— S:ir»— Havana.
index to Advertuemtnt*.
Paire.Col.i Pace. Col.
Ae*nt% "Wanted. ll 4iH<"lr> W*nt«d II •»
Ar ,fments ...14 5-7 1 Instruct . ... 11 3
■Auction f=aie«...n i,-« Bankbooks. ll &
*• obil«« .. . S 7 M»rr!ac<*s and
Banko's and I Daatiia " 6 -ft
Brokers 12 liM^tinK* 14 7
Board & nnomi<.ll ft Proposal* 11 «
Boarders Wantedil ' .-> 1 Public Notice*... ll «
Carpet Cleaning.ll ."• Real Estate 10 6 7
City Ilotela 10 7in»sorts 11 «
Dividend No- School Aiwnciet .11 '■'•
tlcen 12 I: Special Notice*.. 7 6
T>omestlc Sltn« - ISurrOKate's No
tion* Wanted. ll 4-5] tires 11 «
r>r«»sFrnak!ns: ...11 6, The Turf 8 7
Employment Ttm« Tables 11 6-7
• .'■ i»b 11 * To I^et for liusl-
T -..r-rißl 12 5-7! ness Purpcsps. .10 7
Financial Me^t- (Tribune Fubocrlp
!ng« 12 1| tlon nates 7 «
F-- Me 11 6iTyp<'*"'"l«inK 11 6
Pal 1 ■ h *> d (Unfurnished
Roorsa 11 r> Apartments ...10 7
- Fur* 11 f. Work Wanted. . .11 4
TinnSDAY. KOVEMBEB 4. 1909.
This newspaper is oicncd and pub
lished hp The Tribune Association, a
Cesp York corporation; office and prin
cipal place of business. Tribune Build
ing, No. 151 Nassau street, Xcw York;
Or/dm Mill*, president; Henry W.
Backctt, secretary; James M. Barrett,
tuaxurcr. The address of the officers is
ti>c office of this ncirspapcr.
THE SEWS THIS HORyrSQ.
FOREIGN. — The Tribunes corre
spondent gives an Interesting descrip
tion of scenes at the trial of Mine.
Stoinlt'l] in Paris; Bb« strenuously de
nied th<> charges of murdcrine her hus
band :ti<l stepmother. . Henri Far
man yon the Michclin Cop Jit Hour-
Jiiolon. breaking 1 all aeroplane records for
duration and distance; he covered about
144 miles in 4 boors 6 minutes and 55
seconds. - ■ - Porto Rican police seized
?.7f>o lottery tickets which had boon
shipped from Santo Domingo. —
Dominican insurgents dispersed the gov
ernment forces near Guayubin and re
filtered the city. ■ Four ringleaders
In the recent revolt In Greece have been
captured near Thebes; Lieutenant Ti
haldop and a few followers are reported
to be surrounded near fcfesara.
DOMESTIC.— President Taft left Bir
mingham, Ala., :ift< r greeting Union and
Confederate veterans, for Macon. Ga.
■■ *4 '■ The National Geographic Society
Id Washington approved the records of
Commander Robert EL Peary Knowing
iiiat be had Found the North" Pole, aim
"■•<*•! hljn a gold medaL zr.T-rrr The i-iiT
Board's most difficult task, according to
<"::-!■ .it. lies rr»tn Washington^ will be the.
application of maximum mid minimum
rates to CanadaJ ■ Pellagra and the
hookworm »re often coexistent, according
io a paper by Dr. p. m. Landwith. of
i -l-ii. read ;<t th<=- International Con
ference «>n Pellagra. held in Columbia,
S C. - The Carnegie Hero Fund
CommiKrion. in session -it Pittsburg, di=?
trilrutPd (33.000 and awarded fifty medals
for acts of bravery- : The* funeral
of si.nt.- Controller Charles H. Gnus wan
held at Albany: Governor Hughes wan
an honorary fallbearer. ._ = No-license
rains v.ei-e . 'ported in a number if
town? upstate. ===== Mine. Lillian Nor
dics was present nt th • opening of the
<-..iit'>st over the will of her aunt, In Hos
ton. - "A copy of Hums' s poems was
.«• i(i for } 1.025 at Boston.
CITY. — Stocks were firm and dull.
~=^= The police took charge of th<>
Criminal Courts Building, <.rderins all
the tenants out. - Mayer McClellan
appointed three women as commlssioriera
of the Board of Education. - : Charles
F. Murphy paid he had no intention of
resigning the leadership of Tammany
Hall. = Judge Gavnor Issued a state
ment complimenting the newspaper men,
received callers and prepared for a brief
vacation, r r Otto T. Bannard spent
thA day at hip desk in the New York
Trust Company, happy that bis asso
ciates had been elected and not at all
cast Sown over Jil« defeat. ?■■' ' "■" ■ Tam
many's control of th" Board nt Aldermen
meant the retention in office of City
Clerk Scully and his deputy, Prcnd#rga 3 t.
THE WEATHER.— Indications for to
day: ; Showers. The temperature yes- 1
terday: Highest, CO degree*; lowest, 52.
VOTERS AND PARTIES.
. ".Something dropped" on Tuesday up
the state as well as in the city. The
Republican leaders of the "Old Guard"
stripe who have been trying 'to block
<;overnor Bughesfts plans for giving me
voters a larger share of power i.i party
management have been almost .-!< sis-
I'iticantly rebuked as have our discred
ited Tammany autocrats. It is impos
sible to interpret the defeat of several
Republican Assemblymen conspicuous
in opposing direct nominations legisla
tion and the dwindling away of the
pluralities given to other anti-Hughes
candidates except as a notice that the
public is intensely interest" d iii the
Hughes programme of popular sov
ereignty in parties and intends to see
that ,he Governor's reforms hare a fair
cZnnve. Senator Uaines and Speaker
'Wads worth have been especially out
spoken in their opposition to the popu
larization of party methods. The .Sena
tor's Assemblyman lias been defeated in
Hits Strong Hei-tiblican county of Onta
rio. Speaker WadswortU had a narrow
escape from defeat, and in Orleans.
Niagara. Onondaga and Warren counties
candidates hostile to direct nominations
Lave been left at home.
There is nothing clearer from the re
sults <.; Tuesday's voting In" this city
::md ■aie than that the public is dissatis
fied with the existing narrow methods of
parly organization and management.
Here the voters struck everywhere at
the authority of managers who were try
,ing to interpret their wishes without suf
ficient, information, and, therefore, with
only partial success. The Tammany or
ganization B| crushed, polling one of
the smallest votes polled by it in 'many
rear)?. The tic-- of party will continue
"lo reH lisbtly on both :. • licaus and
I <en... • Lx unless, a change in methods
of party government is made which will
•give, a dearer ■■•- mi t« the ides i
... .1 wishes of. th" voter*.
i» < ,<>'. >-:\" \- Hughes wants to make that
tiLau^v bccauVu .1 will repair an obvious
weakness in the party system. He
favors a rrlnvtgoratioii of party spirit.
■while hi* opponents are working—
haps without realizing ii -- to enfeeble
parties still further by widening the gap
between the leaders and the voters. No
party <:in accomplish its proper pur
poses unless it strives to represent the
ideas and wishes of its members and
succeeds in a fair measure in represent
in;; thorn. Apparently what Is most
needed to attain that object is a wider
distribution of political power.
of B COMPLI VENTS.
S<> far as Mayor-elect Gsvnor's cOfjp
pUments to newspaper editors are a<l
dres>e.l to us. we wish to return them.
t>» felicitate him and to express onr
unbounded admiration of liis achieve
Justice Gajuor iaagbs only once,
biughs last :ui<l laughs best, if the acrid
smile with which he views the discom
fiture he has brought upon the myrmi
dons of predatory journalism may In
deed be called s laugh. But h» should
Ik* temperate in his triumph, for in this
unequal contest just dosed he has been
handicapped by no sense of. humor, and
that fortunate circumstance has created
an IrrefragiMe bond of sympathy be
tween himself and bis public.
It is a familiar observation that the
man who laughs much and easily is
doomed to the lower rungs on the lad
der of public life, but it has remained
for the Christian jurist to prove that the
corollary of this proposition is true to
its logical extreme, that solemn linea
ments are an adequate support for sol
emn pretensions, that unwinking self
assertion tiuds unhesitating acceptance,
and that the man who laughs not at all
holds ihe public faith in fee simple. Tho
guile, cynicism and sophistication of the
metropolitan multitude are less than
skin deep. A man with Ingrowing re
ligiosity who can solemnly worship him
self as a fetich can Ret that fetich a< -
cepted by the subliminal chiidlikeness of
Our compliments to the Christian ju
rist. We wish to record our profound
conviction that if Ih> had chosen to stand
iii Madison Square Garden, not <m his
metaphorical but on his physical head,
maintaining the while his prophetic
gravity, the people would still have
voted for him with unabated unction.
Through Mr. Barnard's campaign the
people of New 'fork are richer in the
knowledge of one more "best citizen."
HiR modesty, his unselfish willingness
to serve the public, his unfailing cour
tesy, his pre-eminent prood sense have
been impressed upon the public in .1
campaign in Which his candidacy af
forded a refreshing contrast, nnd lp
takes with him a degree of popular
esteem that has seldom been the lot
of s badly defeated nominee.
Mr. Bannard is an ornament to busi
ness life, but the majority seem to feel
that political !ife when unadorned 18
adorned the most. ,He talked shop on
the stump aud tried to impress the
electorate with the relevancy of Intelli
gence and enlightened self-interest >«>
the problems of civic life. He goes
back into private life a man whom
every one would be eager to have at
the bead of an enterprise in which he
bad invested bis money, and whom less
than one-third <>f the people desired to
have at the head of the civic enterprise
in which are Involved their nearest pub
lic interests. The voters 'am evidently
determined not to mix business with
pleasure, and self-government remains
bti unadulterated joy.
XO PATENT OX ANCESTRY.
Maryland is to be congratulated on
the rejection of the proposed, dis
franehjseinenf amendment to its consti
tution. For the second time the peoplo
of that state have repudiated a dishonest
scheme to limit the franchise, not by
imposing tests intended to bear on the
ignorant and the undesirable as such, but
by creating artificial and unjust distinc
tions and establishing a fantastic claim
of eligibility based on ''descent." The
original roc-Gorman amendment, sub
;i.ined four years ago, was rejected by
a majority of 34.039. It was so glar
ingly Illogical that Senator Rayner and
Governor Wsrfleld both opposed it and
helped to defeat it. The revised amend
ment of 1«mk» was more plausibly drawn
and Senator Kayner consented to support
it. although in order to do so be had to
applaud an application of the principles
oi hlnow-Xothingism which lie had for
merly denounced as abhorrent and de.
prayed. In spite of his recantation, th"
new "ancestor" scheme has been de
feated by a majority of til teen thousand
This pernicious agitation in Maryland
should now end. it has been insincere
ami narrowly partisan in motive from
the start. There is no excuse for a
"grandfather clause" in a state like
Maryland, when- the race issue is not
acute. The Democratic leaders who
have favored restricting the suffrage
have never had any intention of sup
porting a bona Me restriction scheme.
They are not trying to penalize defects
which should disqualify an elector with
out regard to rare, nativity or ancestry
but only to play on racial and nnti-\
foreign prejudices for partisan advan
tage. Their hypocrisy has been twice re
buked. They ought to realize now that
they cannot intimidate or humbug the
THE CLAIM AGAINST CHILI.
The Alsop claim, of which after many
years there is now a prospect of settle
ment, may be described as a by-product
of Chili's war with Bolivia and Peru
and of her conquest and annexation at
the rich sea coast provinces of Cobija
and Atacainn, belonging to the former,
: , and Hoquegua, belonging to the bitter.
[ It also affords an Illustration of chili's
practice of procrastination, which has
been the cause of much complaint by
I'eru in connection with the settlement
of the Issues of the same war.
The claim in question, of the validity
of which there appears to be no dispute,
was originally against Bolivia and took
the form Of a lien upon the guano and
nitrate deposits of her coast provinces
[lad it remained in that status it would
doubtless long ago have been satisfied
from the proceeds of the guano and Mi
trate works. But Chill waged war
against Bolivia and rent, and seized the
whole vast region which now forms
her four provinces of Taens (I nil tiding
Aries), Tarapaca, Antofagasta and Ata
c.nia. Bolivia, thus deprived of the
property '" : '''" development of which
ii.c claim upon her had been incurred,
and also of the means of paying -'. ih
claim,. protested that >.he should be re
MvroOHK DAl*.* rnfBIM:, TTUHSDAY, XOVKMBEH I. 1009.
leased and that tho dalm should he an
(ucambrauce npon the property which
chili had seised.
This contentfbn of Bolivia's was well
founded. The American principle In
such cases was laid down by John
Quincy Adams In 1818, to the effect
that "the conqueror who redsjees s na
"tion to his subjection receives it sub^
••jei't to all its engagements and duties
"toward others, tho fulfilment of which
"then becomes his own duty." Mr. Fre-
Ungfauysen also, in 188&, referring to
cases identical with and closely con«
nocted with this very claim, declared
ll'at "the foreign, obligations of ivru,
"incurred in good f.-iiih before the war,
"rested upon and were secured by the
"products of her guano deposits. Chill
"whs under n mural obligation not to
"appropriate that security without recog
"niziiiK the lien existing thereon." For
"Peru" road "Bolivia." and Mr. l're
linghuysen's words exactly apply to the
case now in hand.
This view was Indeed regarded si rea
sonable and oquitablo by Chill liorsoU'.
Hut then began those processes of pro
crastination and delay which Chili has
practised not only ia ibis matter, but
also in avoiding futilmont of tho Angon
treaty with Peru. At fir^t it was do
dared that the claim could not be paW
until Chilian tinnneo-: had boon read
justed after the war. When that plea
was no longer available others were
found, and, jis a result, now. after twen
ty-four years, the claim is still unset
tled. It is gratifying to have a good
prospect that the delayed settlement will
soon be effected, and that in the way
in which each matters should always
bo settled — by direct diplomatic dealings
between tho two nations, it is also grat
ifying to know that the alternative, in
case sucii dealings should not prove
effective, is an appeal to the tribunal ay
The Hague. But we have no idea that
the latter course will be necessary. Chili
is notably prosperous and well able to
pay all legitimate claims against her.
Mr. Bannard, with characteristic mag
nanimity, ignores his own misfortune
fit the polls to acknowledge the indebt
edness of the fusion movement to Mr.
I-lFarst for the support of the fusion
ticket except himself. No doubt Mr.
Hearst, did in a sense cause, or at least
permit, the election of the anti-Tamm
any candidates who were elected •
that is to say, if he had chosen to sup
port Gaynor's associates or had put up
nominees of his own the fusion candi
dates would have been defeated. The
Hearst newspapers are prompt in claim
ing the credit of the victory and In
representing the editor as running dis
interestedly and against his Inclinations
for Mayor in order to accomplish the
very purposes and only the purposes
which were accomplished.
Perhaps the Hearst newspapers are
only doing their editor justice, or even
scant justice, in praising his disinter
estedness. Hut the question arises,
when the 7CMXK) pluralities received by
Mr. Mitchel and Mr. Prendergast are
taken into consideration, whet had
Mr. Hearst boon loss self-sacrificing, de
clined to run himself and given hearty
support to the fusion candidate for
Mayor, that fusion candidate could not
also have been elected just as Mr. Mitehel
and Mr. Prendergasi wore elected.
We admit this question is impossible to
answer definitely. Hut the majorities
of Messrs. Mitchel and Prendergast are
large, and they suggest that Mr. Hearst,
in keeping himself before the voters,
may not. have done the utmost possible
to give this city better government.
We have do desire to do anything
but justice to Mr. Hearst. But perhaps
we can hotter judge his disinterested
ness and his earnestness in the cause of
good government by watching what ho
does with the personal strength which
this election proves to be his. If he
uses it to serve his ambitions, making
alliance.-; hither and yon according to
his opportunities and without regard to
consistency -in short, it* he behaves
again as lie did after he learned four
years ago that he had a great following
— the public will lie able to make up Its
mind about his disinterestedness and
sincerity. if. on the other hand, be
plays a part perfectly consistent with
the part his newspapers say he played
in his campaign and remains an oar
nest opponent of Tammany Hall, thorp
will be a disposition to revise the ver
dict, and Mr. Hearst may become an
important factor for bettor government
in Now York.
TRESPASSING OS RAILROADS.
Comment, not favorable to ihis coun
try, was recently made upon the vastly
greater number of casualties through
railroad accidents in the United states
i ban in Great Britain, despite the much
greater number of passengers carried in
the latter country. A similar contrast.
greatly to our discredit, is presented in
the statistics of persons killed or in
jured on railroads not through accidents
to Mains, but while they were trespass
ing on the rails.
in Great Britain, as is well known,
railroads are generally fenced in so as
to make trespassing lew easy. Never
theless many persons do gft upon tho
lines, and in the year lt><»7 no fewer
than 278 were killed and 113 injured
from that cause, or more than twice as
many killed as the number of passen
gers killed from all other causes. Thai
was a heavy roll. Hut it was Insignifi
cant when contrasted with the corre
sponding roll in the United States. For
here in that same year no fewer thai;
.*;,i;r_' persons were killed while thustrei
passing, or more than fifteen a <l-iv. '■>
ten years the number thus killed was
47.4 Ki. while a still larger number were
more or less seriously Injured. The vic
tims are not only tramps, who notorious
ly trespass on railroads, hut also w,, r k-
Ingmen and thoir wives and children aud
all sorts of people, who often consider a
railroad a convenient "short cut" to
Generally those deaths are charged
against the railroads, as though they
were to be blamed for them, when in
fact the companies not only are not at
fault, but actually have striven hard to
prevent trespassing and to protect tres
passers from their folly. Tims the Penn
sylvania Bailroad reports that In spite
Of Its fences and warning signs in I<VJ7
no tower than :»ir. tivsp:i->ers were
killed nn its various linos. In au heroic
effort to suppress the evil it caused last
year Hie arrest of mote than Il,<X'<> tres
passers, but that did not altogether dis
coorage the others, for In the first six
mouths of the present rear 285 were
There surely ought to l>e some iraj Oi
■bating so gross aa evil, some of tho
railroads wsejn to '»»■ doing about all thsj
can io stop it. imt <oin|.iain thai thej do
MM IMVS Hi* CO-OpentUOU and support
of. the local magistrates, who refuse or
fail to impose deterrent penalties upon
the trespassers who are arrested. In
MMM places there actually seems to be
popular resentment against the railroads
for trying to keep people from •' walking
on the tracks. Such an attitude of mind
is little better than inhuman. There
ought instead to be ■ hearty co-operation
of companies, magistrates and people for
the suppression this dangerous prac
PEARY AND the POLK.
The value of the verdict rendered by
the National Geoajmajhic Society in
favor of Commander Peary is derived
from the experience and standing of the
men on whose advice that body has
acted. These men are not only mem
bers of the society, but also public ser
vants, whoso duties peculiarly tit them
to pass judgment on the trustworthi
ness of observations to determine lati
tude. Professor Gannett, long the geog
rapher of. the. Geological Survey, and
Mr. Tlttman. at the head of the Coast
and Geodetic Surrey, are experts in
geographical surveying. Admiral Colby
not only has the familiarity which every
naval officer possesses with tho proper
methods of ascertaining a ship's posi
tion at sea. but enjoys the further ad
vantage of having for several years been
in charge of the Naval Observatory, in
Washington, where the chronometer*)
used on war vessels are rated. It is
incredible that these men could bo de
ceived by the evidence submitted to
them or that prejudice could have blind
ed them to any defects in the testimony.
While in our Judgment no reasonable
doubt can hereafter be entertained about
Commander Peary's success, the deci
sion of the National Geographic Society
docs not help the public to determine
whether or not he was the first explorer
to reach the pole. It is unfortunate
that Dr. Cook did not see his way clear
to submitting his case to the same tribu
nal or to some other having an equal
claim to the confidence of Americana.
The prompt settlement of the merits of
his pretensions would have been a re
lief to millions of persons in this coun
try and Europe who seek to be dispas
sionate and are eager only to learn the
truth in this matter. The question hav
ing arisen which Of the two explorers is
entitled to the distinction belonging to
priority of discovery, it was nothing
short of si duty to assist the world to
reach a just conclusion. Whatever ex
cuses Dr. Cook has for his delay, it
puts him at a serious disadvantage.
Where, oil, where is the Katzenjamnier
man in this hour of triumph: Let him
come forth. Tho new administration
will require a comic- supplement.
The hour has struck, and it hit a num
ber of persons xcry hard.
What Mr. Murphy calls "tho inagnifi
"cent triumph of the Democratic candi
'■<i;iW> for .Mayor" was the triumph of
250,678 Tammany voters over 331,605
anti-Tammany voters, divided between
two candidates. Its demonstration of
the loosening of Tammany's stranelo
hold on tho city is the most "magnifi
cent" thing about it.
Script iir-- seems not to have l>e<Mi so
successful up in Central Now York as it
was down here.
Cracks like those which have appeared
in the Criminal Courts Building, are
now likely to show themselves in Tam
Even If, as is highly probable, the tests
about to be hold at Sandy Hook demon
strata that an effective attack cannot
be made on balloon- with ordinary can
tion, they will not be without value. In
that case tlu>y would show the wisdom
of employing another sort of weapon for
the purpose, and the sooner the. lesson
Is learned the so;. tier the army can profit
There is something to be said in sup
port of tho theory of the Chicagjp Jury
commissioners that waiter;: ami other.;
who jive largely through accepting
"tips" are not desirable jurors. The
habit of mind which is almost Inevitably
Inseparable from th<> cultivation of such
sources of income may he held not to
comport with just judgment. The waiter
who discriminates among those whom h-»
Berves, according to their giving of
gratuities, might be suspected of specu
lating, perhaps Involuntarily, as to which
party to a tii;il wpuld ffivo him the
bigger "tip." and of shaping his verdict
That a few Southerners should be irri
tated by Mr. Rockefeller's offer of help
i:i the (suppression <>r th^ bookworm is
not surprising, l»u it is unfortunate. Had
they first consulted medical exports in
their o\mi neighborhood they might have
had their eyes opened t<, thj renlity and
extent of the e\i] againsi which it is
proposed to wnu^ war. Mr. Rockefeller
i\;is not greatly mistaken, it now ap
pears, mi believing thai a campaign of
education might do much Rood.
THE TALK (U l U i: DAY
"Speaking of thr nerve displayed by
Finail h0y.«.," .said a man who had jiitst re
turned from a trip through the Southwest.
"reminds me of an incident that occurred
a few months ago in the Santa Ana Moun
tains, in Southern California. An eleven
year-old boy, a member of a family mak
ing their way to the Coast, left the camp
e;irly one morning to stalk deer. He found
trackr, and had followed tlum until he was
five or six miles from camp. In rwsrhlus.
up on a rock he disturbed a huge rattle
snake that was sunning himself, and the
snake, without warning, struck, wounding
the boy on the middle lin^T of his right
hand. Knowing that unless prompt action
was taken the wound would prove fatal,
the youth placed the flnKfr over the muzzle
of the gun and pulled the trigßer. Mak
ing a ligature above the wound to stop the
flow of blood, he killed the snake and
walked back to camp, where he fainted.
The finger was Mown off close to his hand,
but he recovered."
"So the jury returned a verdict without
leaving the courtroom." said tht visitor
"Yep," answered Bronco Bob. "That's
the way Crimson <Julch Juries always do
nowadays. The hoys have bad he, much
trouble that they stay where they are in-
Me- ( < lof taking ehan.-fs on gettlnc ser
ar;.i*-d lrom their hats and overeoits "—
There is no limit to the uses of adver
tising. A novelty in that line comes from
•way out in Crete. Neb., where the city
marshal has recently made a hit with tax
payers by his ingenuity. The town had
for months far too many "hoboes" on Its
mess roster tO suit the people who foot
the bills, so the marshal decided on ad
vwtlstog as a remedy. In Baaars In near
by towns ho Inserted this brief card:
"Wanted— Seventeen -hoboes, for. stone
crushing. Kens but bona fide hoboes need
apply." Not a "bo" has been *een-iu"tb«
neighborhood slnco the "ad" appeared.
Stone piles and sledge hammers are not
attractive to men who are always "look in'
Tea'c'ier — What are. th*» duties of the
VI ri*»lll*al of 111* United States?
Vouiif America — He has to play golf in
the absence of tho President. — Puck.
At the exercises commemorative of th«!
one hundredth anniversary of the birth at
the late Dr. David Klnhorn. which will I*JH
plare on November 10, under the auspices
of the Central Conference of American
Ilabbls. there will probably bo present two
sons-in-law of Dr. ninhorn— Dr. Kauf
mann Kohlor and Dr. Emll G. Illrsch.
nr.e i«: the president of the Hebrew Union
College and the. other Is pastor of the
Slral Temple, Chicago, where services are
conducted only on Sunday.
"I thought," said the Inspector, "yon re
ported that this building was provided
with a fire escape?"
"It is. There's a room on the nineteenth
floor that is used by a very devout littl*
land of people as a church."— Chicagu
Th<» Supreme Court chamber nt Albany
is ailnrno.l with an oil painting of the
lati« Rufus V,'. IV'-Uham. father of Jus
tiro Rufus \\". Peckhain. of the T'nited
States Supreme Court, wbo died at hia
home, near Albany, last week. It is a
ttrikiny UkcneM of tlio elder of the two
distinguished jurists, who looked so much
alike that the picture was frequently mis
takm for a portrait of the MOB. The elder
jud.^e, liko his son, was tall, slender, erect
of carriage, quick of ■pprctl. -mr! wh^n last
seen in Albany, before he stilted on the
trip to Kurope from which he never re
turned, wore a high stock and ruffled front
.shirt, a stylo which he had cultivated for
Missionary (a little nervotiPly)— l do hope
that we shall agree.
Cannibal King— Oh. I don't think there
is any douht about thai. My digestion is
excellent. — Illustrated Bits.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.
A TRIBUNE 35 YEARS OLD.
To the Kditor of The Tribune.
Sir: For fifty years the form an.l varied
ccr. tents of the great journal founded by
Horace Greeley havo held my admiration.
Its six wide columns' to the page were espe
cially interesting, but your enlargement to
seven does not seem to impair its facial
quality, v lnle adding space of value to
readers, as well as advertisers. May the
paper's prosperity and influence be extend
eii sevenfold! Your prerle.-s Sunday issue
comprise! the best of features in its usual
size of fifty-eight to sixty pages.
If convenient, please publish the date of
The I>aily Tribune deposited with other
memorabilia in the cornerstone of the new
building some time during th~ ycara IST3
to 1873. HARRISON.
Marion, Ind., Oct. L'S, 1909.
[The cornerstone of the present Tribune
Building— that is, the part «t it com
pleted in IST~» — was laid on January I*4,
187t, and The Tribune of that date was
A FRATERNAL JEALOUoY.
! To the Kditor of Th»» Tribuiif.
Sir: It will surprise me very much if,
you do not find out, late-- on, that the
' "Englishmen" who recently lost thoir
| lives in the South Sea Islinds belonged to
"thi 1 land north of the Tweed," and not
to that country "south i>t the Cheviot
hills." which seems, in the I'nited States,
| to get credit for everything Great Britain
L does. The northern r>art of Albion has paid
; far more respect to the last Bra TCfSM
of Matthew's gospel than ever the south
ern did or doea R. M A.
I Brooklyn, Nov. 3, IfOO.
THE STATUS OF BYGONES.
To the Editor of The Tribune.
Sir: Just a word in answer to your cor
respondent-"Let t's Have Peace'"— who
•wants ■ Confederate, statues in the Capi
tol building at Washington. ' Lee stands
there In the uniform of the caus»: that
nought to destroy the Capitol. Ills private.
chaiatttr and the honor of his motives arc
not In the ojnestion. If he was wrong
then, politically and legally, he is wrong
The erection of such monuments at tht>
Capitol is audacity and a raroroal of his
tciy. <.;<>d knows we have no bitterness,
but we have memory and loyalty to the
nation. YVII.MAM HKMSTRKKT.
Formerly Captain ix'h Missouri Infantry.
Brooklyn, Nov. :'.. I*'--
MORE IIUI.NPS THAN KVP.R.
From The Brooklyn standard Union.
i >u«> T. Bannard lias more friends than
h»- ever had before. And he can congratu
late himself that he certainly belped some.
IN FUTURE TEARS.
From The Xew York Globe.
Whether or no! h** desiroa :'. Mr. Ban*
nard need iT>t b« surprised if on future
occasions pood citizens k" to Mm and ask
him to enlist again In iin>ir cause. The
time of Governor Hughes expires In a
year, and stranger tilings hare happened
than tho summoning of Mr. Bannard to
"WELL WORTH FINDING."
From The New York World.
Mi. Bannard was well worth finding,
and tin- <"■ \hit>iiioti <>f sane, honest leader
ship which lie made should compensate
him even for defeat, if he continues to
play an active part in city politics \m> shall
hereafter reckon him among New York's
most valuable assets i>t' citizenship.
From The New York Evening Post.
The deep impression made l>y Mr. Ban
nard leaves us with regret that a luckier
political star did not mako him our Mayor,
yet strengthens iij In the conviction that
he Is hut a typo of that unused talent in
our public life upon which we may draw
when Seeds arises.
"REGRETS OURS, NOT HIS."
From The New York Mail.
The prooeaa of becoming better acquaint
ed with this strong, modesr man and most
useful Citizen has beon a pleasant and
even Inspiring one to fin community, al
though n<>t hint; to ..ur immediate "good
comes of it. The only regrets are ours
not his. and they will ho somewhat tem
pered by the reflection that New York has
su>'ii a rr:nn as h.\ in call, it may be for
other needs under more favoring circum
EQUAL TO THE TEST
From The New York Times.
It is sufficient to say that on the record
unfolded from <lav to day his [Bannard'a]
character and ability were distinctly and
fully equal to the test. We are sorry
that he Is not to be the Mayor lor the
next four years, but we ar- gfad t!,..t his
name has been added to the list of citi
zens of New York of proved fitness when
a happier opportunity comes for the city
to avail Itself of their services J
BKXUSB AND lIETTKR.
Froa Tin- N>nv York Sun.
We take off our hat to Mr. Otto T Rnn
nurd and we offer him no condolences ' H»ta
a blggt-r and a better man to-day than la
ever was. and the people of this 'town will
never forget it. Re has to be reckoned
with he.. alt, -r; an.l many who v.!t.-d v^
terday tor his rival will bp among * ih«
first to recall the hon.st and v- 1 onoken
gentleman whom a wave uf vi r-as
resentment . ■■•u,'.*u.,i to unmerit.' I def ,i
Ho i« the redeemtng figure of a revolUna
and an unworthy campaign, and the die!
j.iiy. the manliness an, i toe temper of lhfs
THINGS HAVE CHANGED
From The Buffalo Express.
Governor Curry of New Mexico whn
once served In the Rough Riders has
reined Hero's a ■ fine job op",, for ■ S
good golf player. . .- < or a
AT HALF PRICE.
From, The Cleveland Plain Dealer.
It- cost » schoolteacher $3) i,, ank i
pupil, But. of course, it may ha?e don*
the pupil $10 worth of good. In which VJlt
the parents should remit tho Uifrei-enc*.
People and Social Incident*
IN WASHINGTON SOCIETY.
[From Th* Tr!bun» Korean. J
Washington. Nov.' 3.-Mrs. Wckersham
has returned "tt> V/ashlngton from a visit
of a re>v days in New York. The Attorney
General is expected Is Join her here to
Miss lli;d.-Bar.|. Nagel. daughter of th*
Hill IBBJ of Commerce and Labor and
Mis. NageJ. who lias been spoken of •- a
debutante of this reason, was presented to
society In St. I#bJS three -winters ago.
She will assist her mother in her official
social duties this season and will meet
th»* younger people In society.
The Italian Ambassador ' and Baron» > :
Mayor das Planches returned to »i>- em
bassy to-night from New York, where the
baron went to meet his wife upon her ar
rival from Italy yesterday. They have
Opened the embassy for the. winter.
The Counsellor and Charge d' Affaires of
the Japanese Embassy celebrated the birth
day of the Emprror by entertaining at th*
embassy this afternoon the members of the
honorary commerce commlssloa from Ja
pan and a number of prominent officials
of the State Department and officials of
the United States and District of Columbia
government and others. To-niKht Ml
Matsut again entertained his countrymen
by giving a dinner at th« New WiUard.
when again a number of officials were
Several hundred persons prominent in SO
ciety filled St. John's Church' at noon to
day to witness the marriage of Miss Fred
erica Morgan, daughter of Mr. an.l Mrs.
James Morris Morgan, and Evan Sinclair
Cameron, of Baltimore, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Angus Cameron, at which the Rev.
Roland Cotton Smith officiated. The church
was handsomely decorated with green as
a background, and rich autumn foliage and
yellow chrysanthemums, which decorations
also obtained at Rauscher's. where a re
ception was later held. The bride's gown
was a trained princess of white satin with
the bodice almost covered with pearl em
broidery and duchess lace. She wore a
veil of tulle with a coronet of orange blos
soms, and carried liltes-of-the-valley. Miss
Marion Cameron, sister of the bridegroom
and maid of honor, wore a striking cos
tume of deep corn colored chiffon over satin
of the same color, the drapery of the prin
cess being held in place with a large black
velvet buckle. Her hat was of black lace
and net, with Ion? black plumes and gold
lace. The bridesmaids were Miss Lillian
Chew. Miss Constancy Hoyt. Miss Mary
Scott and Miss Helen Hlbbs. of ' Washing
ton; Miss Dorothy Hayden. of New York,
and Miss Dolly Lynch, of I^akewood, all
of whom wore yellow gowns designed after
that or the maid of honor and moo caps
of black tulle with gold roses at the side,
and they all carried yellow chrysanthe
mums and autumn foliage. Mr. Cameron
had as best man Dr. Frank Dickson. of
Philadelphia, and the ushers v.ere Herbert
Dillon and Frenvillc Abernathy, of New
York; Donald McKaip. of Plttsburg; Craig
Mitchell, of Philadelphia; Lowell Brown, of
East Orange, and Clark Matthai. of Balti
more. A reception followed the ceremony,
and later in the afternoon Mr. Cameron
and his i>rlde started upon an automobile
trip which will last for some days. They
have taken a house here for the winter,
which is now ready for occupancy. With
the official and resident members or so
ciety present at tho ceremony and recep
tion there were from out of town: Mr.
and Mrs. Angus Cameron, of Baltimore;
Frederick. Flncke, or UUca, N. V., undo
of th« bride: Mr. and Mr". Jasper Lynch,
of Lakfwood. N. J. : Dr. ana Mrs. Hayden.
of New York; Miss Marjory Brown and
Archer Brown, of East Orange. N. J.: Mr.
and Mrs. R. W. Downing. Mr. and Mrs.
Kugono Caldwell and Mrs. T. l.an:iing
Smith, of Philadelphia, r.nd W. H. 1.. Lee
and Guy Cary, of Blow York.
The Bachelors' committee has decided
to give their gerinana for the coming sea
son on January 3. January 1!) and February
2. The members of the committee are Gist
Blair, president: Montgomery M. Macomb.
vice-president; Frederick H. Brooke, secre
tary: Franklin 11. Ellis, treasurer, and
Commander Cleland Davis. James Mauds
ville. Carnal*, William F. Hilt and captain
Sherwood a. Cheney, a White Boms* aM,
The dates for the germans are. anxiously
watched for ny the younger members of
society, who greatly esteem invitations to
the cotillons after making their debuts.
NEW YORK SOCIETY.
Miss Olive Sc-hley. , daughter of Mr. and
Mrs. William T. Schley. was married In
St. Bartholomew's - Church yesterday
afternoon to William Moore Sbackford.
son of the late Commodore William G.
Shackford, V. 8. N. The bride, who was
given away By her lather, was in a gown
of White satin, embroidered, and wore a
tulle veil fastened with orange blossoms
Her flowers consisted of lilies-of-the-valley
and white orchids. Her sister-in-law.
Mrs. Reeve Schley. and her cousin. Mrs.
Max Behr, were the matrons of honor,
and Mi-- Anas Shackford, sister of the
bridegroom, and Miss Margaret 1* Hub
bell, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Charles
Bulkley Hitbbell. were the bridesmaids
They were «<ll dressed alik^j in pink chif
fon, trimmed with pink satin, and wore
satin hats with ptol tulle tops. They
carried pink roses tied with pink ribbon.
Lieutenant Chauncey siiacktord. r. 8 N.,
war. his brother's best man. and the ushers
comprised Arnold L'Honimedieu, Lawrence
Slade, Gardner B. Parry, Benjamin Hotch
kiss, Arthur H. EMsjesaeyer, Augustus
Skillin. Reeve Bchloy, brother of the bride,
and Norris 11. Mundy. The ceremony was
performed by the Rev. Dr. l^eighton
Parka and a reception followed at the
home of the brides parents, in West jl'd
NEWS FROM COL. ROOSEVELT.
He Is Distressed at Accusation of
Slaughter, Says Chicago Man.
Chicago. Nov. 3.— v: M. Newman, a Chi
.l- i publisher, who has completed a six.
months" tour In Africa, on which he met
tho Roosevelt party, returned her» to-day.
Mr. Newman's second meeting with thd
former President occurred in July.
Even then reports had reached Colonel
Roosevelt of his alleged "slaughter" of
came, and lie appeared to be much dis
tressed in consequence.
•!!•■ shoots only such specimens as are
desired by the Smithsonian Institution."
said Mr. Newman, "in addition to the lion's,
which the natives regard as a menace and
a pest." BPW
"I am not a good shot, but I shoot
often." is a quotation Mr. Newman brings
from _the former President.
"The natives and colonists of Africa in
Colonel Roosevelt's path expressed great
astonishment at the distinguished hunter's
enerßy." said Mr. Newman. "Members of
the Roosevelt party in July were -nearly
tired out and wished to shorten the trip.
They had been marched to exhaustion."
SINGERS SAIL FOR AMERICA.
Southampton. Nov. Mine. Emmy Dea
tir.n and Alessandro Bond, of the Metro
politan Opera company, and John U
Riddle, who has just retired from Is* post
of American Ambassador to Russia wer*
passengers on the steamer George Wash
ington, which sailed for the United States
PLANETARY NEWS FROM LOWELL
Flagstaff. Ariz.. Nov. 3,-Dr. rerctvai
Lowell, of Lowell Observatory. issued no .
tie* to observatories of v,.. ,..; . ...,,. r .,"
that by an arrangement with the* Ccntra'e
"""• at Kiel. Germany, the Low*] Ob
servatory. Instead of Harvard, hereafter
•ill be tb* dUtrlbuUnj ctau* - i>lanetar >-
news In Aim-lie*.
Mrs. 11. Ilolbroofc Curtis and Ills* Mar
jori»> Curtis have ju.=t return»d to :;*y
York from Europe.
Miss ■■■'::■■■ Pcuslas UoblnsATi. danghtn
of .Mr. and Mrs. PougTa* Robinson, mii
h* mnrrJed to-day to State Senator : w«pti
TV. .Alsop. ■•.' Avon. Conn. Th* c»rrm r >n7
will h>- performed by Bishop Greer. a*
slstrd by tli» Rev. Dr. L'lshton Parks, at
th«" horn" "' IS* bride's brother and Muter-
In-law, Air. ami Mrs. Theodora I>MD(las
Robinson. So. »50 Park avenue. Mi.»»
Robinson *111 have no attendant* nor wii;
thorp be any iwb«rs. John AIBSSJ will act
as his brother's b«*»t man.
Mr?. P. Hserton vr«M an«l m> f3tb»r.
FT'ITT I I>. Randolph.- SSB bonk'fl to «ali
from Eneland for .N>w York 10-day.
l''re«l*rlck Towns'inl MartSn. W%B has
be«»n aliroH'l nil »«nini<»r. *p»nrtins: most of
his tinr- In Fn«cl«n<l ;>n<i Scotland, has fan
returned to New York and "ill make his
headquarters at the Plaza this winter as
usual. He will rive a brtc!«<* th*r«» on
December 7 for the benefit of the tube-cu
lOSSI fund. Prizes wUI bo Riven 1.-- Mr».
OSBSSBBBS Vanderbllt and Mrs. Frederic*
J. Arthur Barratt. forrr:er!y of this r\t r
but now living In London, is in New Tor*
for a ?hort time and 13 stairin^ at t?i»
l'laza. Mrs. Ha r ran in In London con
valescing from her recent injury.
Mr. and Mrs. .var«i Spencer !;ave ar
rived in town from J>r.o:.. where they oc
cupied the Piters cottage for the fall, and
are at No. 11 W>st Htl street. They will
remain here until late in December, whta
they will return to Ch<*riaston Park, their
place in Gloucestershire. England.
.\j:.'. Aavaadsf sVbwb wl
town to-morr. \v from Baltimore a: :
be the guest d- ring horse shoxv WSJSB] v»t
her daughter. Mrs. T SufT :n Taiier.
SSI Lucy Blair, daughter of Mr. and
Mrs. Edward Bl^lr. of ChlL-a^o. will at
tend Miss France* MacdonaM on tba oc
casion of th» latter s marriage to Henry
J. Whigham. at ItosSyn. Lore Island, oa
November 21. Miss Macdonald is a daugh
ter of Mr. and Mrs. Charles Blair Mac
Mr. and Mrs. Cortlandt FMd Bishop, - 1 "-!
have just arrived from Europe, • M I<-^-.^
town .'■•.- Lenox to-day, to remain until
ths end si r.?xt month.
Mr. and Mrs. Oaklei^ii Thorn*, who !iav»
been BBCndtaSj the fall at their country
place at .\ri!t*-O'>k. N. V-, sailed r>r Ku
Mr. and Mi William Douglas Shun*,
who arrived from I#nox on Monday, left
town yestTday for Madison. N. J.. wh^r-»
tli«y will be tlie SjSMStS over xtw we«"Jc cwl
of Mr. and Mrs. H. McK. Twombly.
Mr. and Mrs. Stuyvesant Fish will re
turn to town at the end of the month
from their country place at Garrison, N. V..
and open their house in Ka^r 75th street
for tits winter.
M.r. and Mrs. Herbert I* Satterl<?» ar
rived in town yesterday from their loun'ry
place at Highland Kails. N. V.
IN THE BERKSHIRES.
IRy T >5r.-.; h to The Tnhiw*. I
li— Nov. 3.— Mrs. Reginald >'- Vanii<>r
bilt. with her dauehter and Mi^ Madeline
O'Brien, has son*" to N«"\v York, after thre^
wo<»ks at the Curtis BoMli
Mr. and - " '. Edvtari Spet:<-*r -»■ cl r> ?^
the Quinsy villa to-morrow.
a large Eatherinsr for roller sstatsa] jras
the affair of lac afterntjon. Mr?. Harris
Fiilinesto.-?*. Mrs. Frederic S. Delan>M.
Mi's Anita DelaCeld. Mirs «'onstari'-«
FofsomJ Miss Ros-iinond r'ix«>;-. MXi
Eleanor Crcsby aSd tin** SBSBSS PristM.
Turn"r^ and Fairfax wero on the flr»or.
CllSJlltH MStSi Pri.-r.-rl. Mrs. QSSSBJI W.
Folsom and Mrs. Joseph Whistler wer»
arnons: th©s»» present.
Mrs. Joseph W. Burden. Mr. and Mr
Frederic Bull and Mis* Georgian* tfarser.c
have.olo?»d their country p?ac«-s.
Mr. aiid Sim. G*a*a« Westinshotise. Sir.
arid Mrs. G«ors* TTritlni.amwt. jr.. ?.T:-s
Sylvia Krockle'oank. of London, and Al\
and<»r •;. I i>t<>;:rafi will =.• la N-.\ York
Friday for two weeks. Mr. and Mr- \V*-st
iitghbuse and th««ir guests will return it*
ti-skine Park. in Lencx. f«>r the eariy
Misa Cornelia Barnes will sja to New
Mr. and Mrs. George Paty Blake .«.e
at The Needles for a .*!ir>rt stny.
Robb Do lVyst»T Tyttjs has b*rn r<»
elected to the Massachusetts Ilium of
pi «s»ntatr««9 from t!i«- Tth Berkshire
District, and Frank run of Sheffleli.
I i the Sth District.
SOCIAL NOTES FROM NEWPORT.
18, T.>^,«!, ... The Tr,b..n-.|
Newport. Nov. .".—Robert Ives Gamnicll.
who has a summer home on the Cliffs.
is to become a legalized cttizen of tiu*
Samuel F. Parser, with Mit=s VA-\\
Barger. Mrs. Itarger-Walla^h. Miss Ji>arnii
Wallaea and Miss Mary Appleton departel
for New- York to-day for the winter.
Mr. and Mrs. n. Livingston Be-knua
started to-day for a visit at Hot Spring*.
Va.. before SjSlsaj to Providence for th*
Mrs. John Nicholas Brown has so»» l»
New York for a short visit.
FINDS LABRADOR WATERFALL.
Returned Explorer Confident It Is
Highest on This Continent.
Oshkosh. -Wisi.. Nov. 3.— Edvrard Falci
Barr. of Oshko?h. an explorer, who has
Just returned from Labrador, reports the.
discovery in the wilderness of that coun
try of a lutge waterfall, which he SI con
fident will prove the highest waterfall ©a
the Western Hemisphere.
The discovery was made while Barr
with his party was travelling by canoa «0>
the Caster River. This fall i* said to M
larger than Grand Fall, in Labrador, whlca
is StJS feet high. >
MR. WHITE SAILS FOR HOME.
Taris, Nov. 3.— Prominent' • -:-. . -% of
the American colony. A. Mollard. person*!
representative of President Failures: M.
Plchon. the Foreign Minister, and other
members si the Cabinet; M. PallaJn. gov
ernor of the Bank of France: Prince vo»
Radolin. German Ambassador to France,
and other diplomats of Europe and South
America bade farewell at tho railway sta
tion here to-day to Henry White, the re
tiring American Ambassador, who starts
for Cherbourg, whence he sailed for New
York. Mrs. White, who accompanied th*
ambassador, shared with him the senti
ments of good will expressed.
. STEEL MAIL CARS. " •
From The Boston Post.
The United States postal department ••
■ '■ - i ■ .. - - . ro**»
throughout the country built of »teeU Th*
reason for this new method of car bultdis*.
Ja to protect th* mail and tha clerK* I"
train wrecks or In other accidents where
f£Tr. '■,..■-.. to conic together and »veßt
uauy tako flrv.
. i \rst.-r.la\ 1... new , .| mail cars »r* |
.•I ■■" the Boat & Albany workshop* m .
AUdton. and were the admiration of h '*'*•
jhron X of people. The cam are built ««* >|
ttrely of utteel. no woodwork b*ins used ** ;S
•!i. From .the steps on the ends of th«e««*Mj
to the framework holding th« largo tavi
cf $ «-i* * tV#rj !hiw * Uof th * ** 1 «uaUß§|
xml | txt