Newspaper Page Text
6 Amusements. MEMT OF MUSlC— s:ls—The K*«ie»t IVay. A 1.11 AM BRA — — Vaudeville. .ASTOR— 2:ls— S:ls— Seven Days. ♦ BELASCO— 2:iri — S:1S — I* Matrimony a Failure? PUOU- 2:ls— s:ls— Tlie LMtcry Man. BROADWAY— 2:IS— The Jolly Bachelor*. *>KI.VN ACADEMY OF JHTSlC—B:ls—Con cert. -•* • CASINO— 2:IS— S:I&— The Chocolate Soldier. COLONIAL — 2—2 — B—Vaudeville.8 — Vaudeville. «rtMEDT— Z-J3O— tins Affinltr- , , CRITERION -3 15 S -20— The BacT>*lor> Baby. DAW'S — 2:15 — S:ls— Tlie B«»n« of Brittany. EDFK MCSEE — World in Wax. I 13IPIR-E— 2:ls— S:ls— VT.at Bvery Weman • OAirTT— 2:ls— S:ls— The Fortune Hunter. GARlUCK— 3:lft— *:l*— Tww Humble Servant. . HACKKTT— 2:I5 — 8:15 — Cameo Ktrby. HAMMERS EIN"S— 2 - v vi I' < *- HERALP SQUARE— 2:IS— £:15— Old Dutch. HIPPODROME— 2— »— A Trip to Japan; In *Jd> thf rarth: the Ballet or Jewels. HrpSOX— 2:l6— B:tS— Th« Next of Kin. IRVING PLACE— 2:I8 — Per Zugeunerbaron — S:ls T>*r Floh im Ohr. KNICKERBOCKER— «— Th« Dollar Princess. 1 fBERTY— 2:IS— SMS— The Fires of Fate. I.TCEfM— 2:2O— *:»*— Penelope. I.YRIC— 2:JT»— The City. MADISON SQUARE GARDEN— S— Automobile MANHATTAN OPERA HOUSE— 2— Thais— S— MAXINE ELLIOTT"? THEATRE— 2 :3n— S:3o— T^* rmsslnj: of th» Third Floor Back. METROPOLITAN OPERA HOUSE— !:»»— WaI- Ijaer* — & — Butterfly. XATIONAI- ACADEMY OF DESIGN— *• to «— * to 1<» — Exhibition _^ SEW AMSTERDAM — 2:15 — *:»» — The Silver Pt sr XPTW THFATRFr- 2:SfV— Don— S:3(V— The Nirc*'. jCEtr YORK— 2:IS— SMS— The Man Who Owns Rrfiad«"*r' SAVOY— 2I.V- *:Js— The Cotntnandincr officer. FT NICHOLAS RINK— Ice Hockey. PTUTVB£ANT~ 2:IS— «:15— Th- t.l'\. WAI-UCK'S- 2:15— A Uttla Brother of TTEBEB'S— S:IS B:IS The Coddera of Liberty. WEST END — S:15 — The Midnight Son*. Index 1o Advertisements. Vzte.C'V, Pag" .'■--' Anujemenrs ...1« «-7 Ix>f> Bankbook*.. l3 « Jk*:tomobll«>s .10 1-7 Marriaees » v. a _ tankers and I Dwiths . « r - ' Krottern 14 l'M»*'ta«* lj l PoanJ i- RoorrF :r. 7 '. Misc«!llan«ru» ...II « Tlookt and Pub- ! Notice of Bam ltostlons m 6-7 ' mons '- ' ITmIM Chsnres.l3 V Public Notices. -.13 « C»rp«>t CJc-aulnr.lS Real Estate 13 • City Hotels .12 7 Recover** Bale.'.]* « Op»rtn*r sh ! p ißelißioas Xotlcee.ll 1-4 Node** 14 li Resorts «* •_' PfFkn and Oa<-« Ravine* BMllW...l|| <► « Vurnjture 13 M School AS»nei«s. 2 7>tv:deod No- [Special Notices . . < 7 fires 14 1 Tim. Table* ..IS «-« T^Tv.Pf.ti Sits. To Iy»t for Bu»J- _ antM 18 5 ness Purpose*. -IX 6 ■ J^uropcai A4vts.ll <»; Tribune Subecrip- _ rmar.cial ......14 6-7! tJon Rates .• 7 ' F«r*£ate IS 7 1 Trust Company Foreign n«rort*.ll 6-7 Report* ]* 1 7~ur. Rooms to Typf* rltinp • •*• » t^-t .it. 7 L'nfurn'd Apart- HHp "Wanted . .U 3-4! tn»nts to Let.. l 2 7 Instruction 1" 2|TVorJi Wani*-3- IS 4 3TeRj-|]orJ\ JTtilJtmf. SATI'RDAY. .TANTARY 8. 1910. This newspaper £3 owned and pub lished hy The Tribune Association, «i Veto York corporation; office and prin cipal place of business. Tribune Build ing.n g. "So. 154 Nassau street, Yew York; Off dm Mills, president; Henry W. Saei-^tt, secretary: James If. Barrett, treasurer. The address of the officers is the office of this newspaper. j . i __ .. THE NEWS THIS HORSING CONGRESS. — The Senate was not in pension. -— - - House: The President's Fp«^ial message on tho interstate com merce find anti-trust laws was received; the resolution providing for an investi gation of the Ballingcr-Pinchot contro versy was adopted. FOREIGN. — special dispatch from London says that the activity of the British peers has practically ■nil, as the election ■writs issue on Monday and after that event they cannot interfere. 1 ■ "La Barricade," a new play by Paul Bourget, was produced at the Vaudeville Theatre, Paris, for th« first time: it deals with socialism in its most violent form. -, : . ' Karl Hau. formerly a profesor in George Washington Uni versity. Washington, under a life sen tence for the murder of his mother-in law, mi.oe an unsuccessful attempt to < -<•:[• from the prison at Brochsal, Baden. Germany: his hiding place was discovered by a dog. — . — France and Great Britain are still considering Sec retary Knox's note proposing an exten t-ion of the International Prize Court. DOMESTIC. — President Taft removed Gifford Pinchot. the chief of the Forest Service, from office, the cause being the letter written by Mr. Plncbot to Senator Dolliver. — -^^ Supremo Court Justice Ia Boeuf notified Attorney General O'Malley at Albany that he had ruled that the Jamaica Water Company, which ■was recently involved in a test of the special franchise tax law, must pay ♦; per cent interest on the franchise taxes from the company for 1907. - — The municipal campaign at Boston became exceeding warm, with charges and countercharges between the candidates; *x-Mayor Fitzgerald spoke twenty-four t'mes and James J. Storrow more than a dozen. ===== Attorney General O'Malley at Albany named three deputy attorneys general. CITY. — Stocks were active, closing «-Tr.>ngr. ■ . ■ . Buildings Department em- Pioyes reached the body of the man who was buried 1n a tunnel of his own dig pingr under Ludlow street. =^=^ Several persons were injured when an automo bile ran into a streetcar in Central Park. -j—=^ The Board of Estimate and Apportionment took steps looking to an investigation of the Catskill water proj «■-.». . ■_ It was announced that the National Sugar Refining; Company and the Federal company would contest the BStrcraSßSßtTs ?SOO.OOO claims. -, The President's special message was well re ceived in Wall Street. .. ■ •■ . George J. Gould filed a petition in a friendly suit *f-kin£ for a partition of the Gould es tate. utt^^^ An order to examine Cleo fODte Campaninl before trial was issued In the Supreme Court in the suit of Oscar Kammerstein against Mrs. Clar *nc* H. Mackay THE WEATHER.— lndications for to <•.»;••: Fair. The temperature yesterday: Highest, 35 degrees; lowest, 26. EASE XAVAL REFORM. In its January number "The En ginecrinp Magazine" editorially reviews Secretary Meyer's plan for the reor ganization of the navy, giving special prominence to its opinions by placing them ahead of the contributed articles printed in the same issue. As will be remembered by these who recall a *hort extract from an advance proof which. The Tribune recently used, "The Knsineering Magazine" has criticised Mr. Newberrys programme as having l>een tastily forme*! and unfortunate la the effects which it threatened. On the Other hand, to the deliberation with which Mr. Meyer has proceeded and to the sanity of the recommendations made by the Swift board its gives the hearti ««t approval. "The Engineering Magazine*' lays stveip on the fact that in selecting four aids ho are to act in an advisory ca pacity and who are to be members of the General Boa rd the Secretary makes no attempt to establish a general staff. Th^se men are clothed with no execu tive authority whatever. They are tnrrely ' officers who by long experience and by freedom from the hampering routine of other duties will be excep tionally qualified to give valuable coun eel. Besides, it is understood that the head? of bureaus v.ill still have access to the bead of the department. Washington dispatches to The Trib une indicate that in the Hou:»e Com mittee on Naval Affairs Secretary Meyer's plan ris now being regarded with more favor than it received at first Do— C of the doubts previously entertained concerning its effects are disappearing in consequence of patient inquiry and intelligent response. For instance. it is becoming evident that the constructors will not, as tome of them feared, be little more than drafts men, but will have increased responsi bility. Perhaps" a similar change will occur in that stronghold of conserva tism, the Senate Naval Committee, after the House has finished its work. In any case, tho views of "The Engi neering Magazine," a technical publica tion of the highest standing, deserve the careful consideration of members of both houses of Congress. The American people take an Immense pride in their navy and heartily sympathize with every effort to Increase its efficiency by improved methods of administration. They will note with peculiar satisfac tion the forecast of "The Engineering Magazine" that Mr. Meyer's "name will "go down as that of one of the great "secretaries and great administrators "in the history of the United States "navy." ith'. I AfT AXD THE RAILROADS. President Taft's proposals in regard to amending the interstate commerce act had been foreshadowed In his speeches and those of his Attorney Gen eral, and upon some of them wo have already commented in referring to the recent report of the Interstate Com merce Commission. The most impor tant recommendation of the message sent to Congress yesterday is that for the creation of an Interstate Commerce Court, to which nil appeals from the Interstate Commerce Commission's de cisions shall go. *r..e object of the establishment of such a court, is to hasten the disposal of railroad oases— to reduce "the law's delay." That is so laudable an end that public opinion is likely to he enlisted in its support. The railroads are said to object to an Inter state Commerce Court on the ground that it would be only a "second com mission." that it would take different views of the- law from those tnk«n by the courts to which they now have ac cess and tb;*t those views would be likely to be favorable to the Interstate Commission and unfavorable to the railroads. But. inasmuch as appeals from the decisions of the proposed court would go to the Supreme Court and it would have to he guided by the law as laid down by that court, tins objection Las no great force. The particular increase in the author ity of the Interstate Commerce Com mission recommended by Mr. Tuft which will meet with tbe greatest op position will be the conferring upon thai body of the right to initiate Investiga tions into individual rates without the complaint of a shipper and to initiate inquiries into changes in rates and clas sification of rates on notice of such ehangee. The former extension of au thority appears reasonable enough and can hardly be of great practical im portance, for there surely can be no lack of prompt complaints regarding excessive or discriminatory rates. The latter doubtless aims both at expediting tbe determination of the justice of changes ami at further protecting the shipper. As it is now. thp railroads can tile several thousand changes in rates at one time. The cotumissiou must wait for them to go into effect, and can in vestigate each change separately only as a complaint is made upon each in dividual rate. Obviously, it is difficult to see bow the determination of the jus tice of rates can keep pace with rate making. As The Tribune once said, the railroads can make rates by the whole sale, while tbe commission can investi gate only at retail. To meet this situa tion it has been proposed that tho com mission have authority to suspend the operation of such general changes in schedules until it has investigated and determined their justice or decided what rates are just. But this avoids one difficulty only by creating another— the placing upon the commission of a task beyond its powers, namely, that of de termining the justice and propriety of a prodigious number of rates in a rea sonably brief time. Mr. Taft sees the force of this objec tion to conferring what would virtually be rate making power on the commis sion, and concludes that the authority to suspend changes in rates should be granted only In "a very limited and re stricted form." He therefore would have the commission empowered to in vestigate at once upon notice of change Of rates, and at its discretion to post pone for sixty days the date on which the proposed rates would go into effect, the changes to beeotue effective then if the investigation is incomplete. This may be ■ practicable compromise, though it? advantages to the public can hardly bo judged without an actual test. The difficulties in the way of a single body of regulators confronted by the possibility of s change of two hun dred thousand rates at once are evi dently inherent. As to the other changes in the railroad law recommended by Mr. Taft. we have at other times suf ficiently indicated r<ir opinion. AS TO THE TRUSTS. President Taft's opinion in regard to the Sherman anti-trust act has under gone some change in the last year. In a Speech made a year ago be declared that modification of that act would be re quired, but he has now come to the con clusion that, as defined by the courts in various cases, it does not interfere with the legitimate development of business. He writes : It is possible for the owners of a busi ness of manufacturing and selling: use ful articles of merchandise so to conduct their business as not to violate the. in hibitions of the anti-trust law and yet to secure to themselves the benefit of the economies of management and of pro duction due to the concentration under one control of large capital and many plants. If they us« no other Inducement than the constant low price of their product and its good quality to attract custom, and their business Is a profitable one, they violate no lav. If this is true, certainly no amend ment is required. The law should not bar this country from the advantages to be gained by industrial concentration, nor should it permit the great power that resides in a centralized industry to be abused. Mr. Taft says the Sherman act meets those requirements. At any rate, it is perhaps well to wait until the Su preme Court has rendered a decision which will be a bar to the benefits of combination in business before making any change iv a law which is being gradually clarified by judicial decisions. 1 With regard to the President's sug gestion of a national incorporation law for industrial companies opinion will be Blow in Coming. The message is neces sarily much too general to permit of the formation of an intelligent opinion with out study of the text of the proposed law. Such a phrase as "protecting them "[the corporations] from undue inter ference by the states," natural and suit able in a message, is an example of gen eral instead of specific language upon a point in which the states will feel vitally interested. The aim of federal incorpora *»SV-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE. SATURDAY. JANUARY 8, 1910. tlon is highly desirable By this process tuo federal regulation of corporations In interstate trade might be systematized n "d extended. The abuse Of excessive, issues of stock and bonds l>r Industrial companies, which the state* ive done little or nothing to chec" . might be stopped by Mr. T;ift's plan. The publicity for which it calls might also prove some check upon excessive charges for their products by the corporations, and from the point of view of the corporations themselves uniformity of- regulation in place of the multifarious requirements of state laws would be a desirable object. But the subject is full of 'difficulties, as Mr. Taft himself concedes In his mes sage. It bristles with constitutional questions. For example, in the Knight ease the Supreme Court decided that manufacturing was not Interstate trade, even though the manufactured product entered Into interstate trade. Can Con gress, then, under the interstate com merce section of the Constitution, charter a manufacturing corporation? Mr. Tafr alludes to this constitutional difficulty, but adds that "under ■ recent decision" Congress apparently has the power. The inducement that would operate to make corporations take out these volun tary charters would be a desire to escape state regulation. But it is impossible to see without further elucidation than Mr. Taft. affords in his message how federal incorporation would alter the states* au thority in the premises. The boundaries between state and federal authority are constitutional and would not bo affected by the proposed device. ".I LIVING EXAMPLE. The death of the pastor of the. Brick Presbyterian Church, yesterday, ended a life of much sweetness and beauty and a public career of more than ordi nary usefulness to the community. There are probably other ministers in this city who are better known to the general public, but it may be doubted if there is one -who has labored more earnestly or more efficiently to do the real work of the pastor of a numerous, needful and exact ing congregation. The church which was his is one of the his toric churches of New York, and it is one which has not declined with age but rather has continued to increase in numbers and influence, in the variety and scope of its activities, and therefore in the demands which it makes upon its pastor's time and (strength. How well Dr. Richards served it. as spiritual exhorter and guide, as intellectual in structor, as administrator of practical affairs and in the tender and intimate personal relationships of sympathy and consolation, cannot he told but must he deeply realized by those who had the privilege of association with him. The example of his life affords what should be a convincing answer to those who are quaveringly inquiring how the churches are to be filled and how the people are to bo interested in them. Here was a preacher who sought no adventitious aids to attract attention, yet who never lacked a great and deeply interested congregation. Here was a pastor who never indulged in exploits outside the limits of pastoral duty, yet who never was distressed by desertions from his parish. Here was a religious teacher who sought no new fantasies of faith and who discarded none of the vital and robust doctrines of bis belief, and yet who never had occasion to lament the decline of faith or the failure of Christianity to lay hold upon the hearts and lives of men and women. His was a living example of the way In which to . make the churches prosperous and Christianity a triumphant force in the world: and it will remain a living and potent exam ple in his death as it was in his life. NEUTRALIZING MA\CHVRIA\ RAIL ROADS. The neutralizing of the Mauchuriaii raUroads, which were built and are now owned and controlled by alien powers, would l»c a taking "t" those controlling and sometimes contending powers at their word. Both Russia and Japan have repeatedly and earnestly declared that they have no tilierior designs of military strategy In retaining control of their respective paits of the system. They want to protect their pecuniary Investments and also to guard against the employment of the roads t<> their harm. That is all. We may give them credit for sincerity, and we must con cede that the designs and desires thus expressed are reasonable and void of offence. But it is apparent that the cuds in view could probably be reached and maintained through the plan Just broached more surely and securely than through a continuation of the sys tem of separate and alien ownership which now prevails. There seems to be no good reason why the new plan should'not be accepted by the interested powers. Turning to the affirmative side, thelfe are several strong reasons why sucb a chance of ownership and control is Ho sirable. It would remove from the in ternational relations of the Fax East r. potential and menacing source of fric tion. Already there have been com plaints of Japanese aggression and in vidious discrimination on the Japanese part of the system, and of similar action by Russia on the Russian part. AVith out attempting to determine what ground in fact there is for these com plaints, it may bo observed that it is practically inevitable that they will be made from time to time as long as the present control prevails. If it is not human nature for the Japanese a;id Russian proprietors respectively to favor their own people — we are in clined to think that it is. unconsciously, if not, consciously— it certainly it for others to suspect them of it; and it is obvious that the practice or even the suspicion of it must militate against the faithful fulfilment <n' that "open door" policy to which the nntious are commit ted. The proposed arrangement, under which China would become at least the titular owner of the roads, would also accord with the wise and rational pol icy of respect for the sovereignty and integrity of that empire. China has en tered, sincerely and earnestly, upon a new era of constitutional government, in which equity certainly, and we be lieve the general Interest of the world, will demand that she shall have the en couragement and support of her neigh bors. She has already reacquired vari ous important concessions »nd proper* tie& which had been granted to foreign ers, and it is desirable, for her own self respsct. that she shall do go a* widely and as generally as possible. There is probably nothing which would more confirm her in her sense of sovereignty or which would more assure her of the sincerity of the powers in their talk about respecting her sovereignty and territorial integrity than to permit her to purchase the Manchuriaa railroads, ■which under alien ownership have been and gre a constant menaco to her and which have been and might again be n cause of war. If "China for the Chi nese.'* is to be realized, and If the "open door and equal opportunities" are to prevail, Chinese proprietorship of Chi nese railroads will need to be estab lished. OTHEI! EXEMPTIONS DESIRABLE. Governor Hughes has fixed the ntten tion of the country 0B one serious defect in the income tax amendment — that it fiiils to exempt from the taxing power of Congress iin-ome from the bonds of states, counties and municipalities. It has been decided by the Supreme Court that Interest received on such securities ought not to be included in income ta* alilc by the general government. Ratifi cation of the amendment. In its present form, would remove n salutary restric tion on the federal authority and reverse a condition from which the states have greatly benefited. It has been suggosled that the amend ment might be made acceptable by % a change of language which would exempt, returns from state, municipal and county bonds from federal taxation. Such a change would cure tie one defect which Governor Hughes emphasized. But there axe other defects of a similar character which ought to be cured In any redraft of the amendment. It would be well, we think, to extend the exemptions so that Congress would tind itself debarred, fia it is now. from taxing the salary of the President, of any federal judge or of any State officer. It might be advisable also to safeguard income from interest on United States bonds, now exempt "<l by statute from taxation. The Supreme Court has ruled in several cases that it is derogatory to the sovereignty of the state, and in violation of the relations of mutual support which should exist between the states and the nation, that Congress should interfere in any way with the compensation allowed by the states to their own officers. If the pending amendment is faulty in sub jecting the securities of the states to federal taxation, it is also faulty in per mitting Congress to diminish th*» salaries of state officers, now protected by con stitutional construction. The Constitu tion says that the President's compensa tion shall not be increased or reduced during his term of office and that the compensation of federal judges shall not. be decreased during their terms. The income tax law of 1883 apparently In cluded The salaries of federal judges among thos*» subject to a .*» per eeut deduction at the hands of the Treasury Department, and Chief Justice Taney felt called upon to write a letter to Secretary chase declaring that such a penalization was in his opinion unconsti tutional. He explained that an informal protest was necessary, be-^ause the judges. being all concerned, could not property hear or determine in their official capac ity the question of constitutionality. Tlv income tax section of the Wilson-Gorman law of 1894 specifically exempted the compensation received by the President. the federal judges and officers of states. Had it not done so the Supreme Court wruld undoubtedly hare found three mure counts against it. Why should nor the proposed amendment recognize the propriety of these established exemp tion*, which everybody concedes to be reasonable and desirable? It may be said that Congress will never care to levy a tax on interest de rived from United States securities. Yet thfl income tax laws of the Civil War period did impose such a tax. Since the refunding act, interest on the govern ment's bonds, except on its Pacific Rail road bonds, has been exempted by con tract with the holder. But that contract would be at least potentially invalidated by the ratification of an amendment to the Constitution giving Congress power to tax income from any source whatever. The government would be only taxing itself if it imposed a tax to be collected on the interest of bonds still to l>e float ed. It would l»e breaking a solemn pledge if it taxed interest on the bonds which it had previously Issued with a promise Of immunity from all taxation. The Mississippi Legislature is about to elect a I'nited States Senator, and eight candidates for the place engaged yester day In an oratorical contest before the Democratic caucus. Each spoke for thirty minutes. This looks like Intro ducing th»: merit system with a ven geance in a hitherto exempt field. But B pass mark in oratory is not the cer tification it is often bold to bo of fertil ity in thought and proriciency in states manship. No one until yesterday ever went up 3,600 feet in the air with an aeroplane, but until Latham made bis attempt no one seems to have cared to. "Oh for just on« hour of Tilden!" exclaims Colonel Watterson. Say, Marse Henry, how would it do to have just one hour of W. .T. B.? Eternity would then be robbed of some of its terrors, wouldn't it?— Hou ston Post. "The Post" is inviting Just one hour of attention from the catapult which not long ago landed its dear frirnd and co heretic, Major J. C Hemphill, outside the Jeffersonian breastworks. The n^w Fire Commissioner ought to feel highly complimented by Mayor Gay nor's confidence "that you will carry out "my intention of banishing all political "and outside influence and favoritism in "that department immediately and once "for all." It would take an Augean broom, wield' d by a Hercules, to clean up the traces of political influence and favorit ism in any of the city departments, the broom working 363 days a year and twenty-four hours each day. What a Titan Mr. Waldo will show himself if the purification is effected "immediate ly," as well as "once for all"! THE TALK OF THE DAY. "Behind a candy counter Is a great place to s-ee things," said an observing young woman who sells sweets in a downtown Store. "That man who just went out used to buy a big box of candy every Wednes day. We know ho was engaged by the way ho bought. Then li« stayed away two weeks. We know that was when he got married. Then he came regularly onco every two weeks, but got cheaper candy. Now he comes once in a great while and takes homo th* "old-fashioned, broken* kind. They're all that way, but take a lit tlo fresh start when thsy becomo inter ested in chocolate cigarettes." Madge — How do you know she thinks she's pretty? Marjorle— bho is always suggesting to the girls that they havo their pictures taken in a group.— Puck. "The national sport of Norway hat, never flourished us It does this year," saya * writer from Chrlstlanla In the. "Hamburger jrachrlchtcn." "Tb* Norwegians, are always glad to see a foreigner on skis, and take pains to explain the ■pert and to tell of its advantage* as a healthful exercise. King llaakon Is a convert. With the Queen and the little Crown Prince. Oiaf. h» rpakea long eki tours, unaccompanied except Sf a valet and a rnald. A good portion of his popularity, it Is saM, in *scrib»d to his interest and expertnesa in the national recreation. " Johnny— The medicine ain't so nasty as Jt useter be. memmrr. I'm gettln" used to It. , , Moinmer— Do you take a who!© spoontui every hour? Johnny— No'm. I couldn't find * spoon, so I'm ustn' a fork.— Cleveland leader. William Seltgrman. the venerable banker, who died in Paris on Thursday, whs for many years a conspicuous figure at the Fourth of July celebrations In thit city, ■where he was th« dean of the. American C%SSIMr of Commerce. A few days before the celebration In 1905 a member of the Tribune staff called on him. He was en gaged in writing his Fourth of July ad dross—actually writing tt. refusing the aid of a stenographer, despite hl« eighty-three years. "I like this." he said, handing to the newspaper man a closely written sheet on which he had marked this paragraph: "The time is approaching: when there will exist but one religion, namely. th<- religion of justice, truth and charity, having as its foundation tho Golden Rule." On account of the death of John Hay the celebration did not take place, but Mr. Sellgman's ad dress was printed and circulated by his admirers. "What's the matter?" exc'aimed Sap phira with wifely solicitude. "You seem utterly dejected." "I am," replied Ananias. "I can't help thinking of the opportunities I miss by having been born too soon to go out and lecture as a North Pole discoverer."—Wash ington Star. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR. OPERA UNDER OTHER NAMES. To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: Kindly Kive mo information in re gard to theatrlrrO matters that will enable me to obtain com» relief from a much dis puted question. If a book or novel Is produced on the stage in the form of a play it is expressed as dramatized or a dramatization of a book. What terra will express the same idea when a drama is set to music and produced as an opera? For example, such plays as "Othello," "La Toeca," "Carmen" and other similar plays. Can it be expressed as operatlcatlon, or as a musical adaptation, or as an operatic adaptation? What is the proper term that expresses the subject In question? Kindly let me know as soon hs po<ciiiie. and oblige. SYLVAN" BCHBNTHAI* Baltimore, Dec. 2S, IMS. [If It were allowable^© follow the rule of construction which has given us such words as "dramatize" and "dramatiza tion" the terms which the correspondent is looking: for would no doubt be "opera tize" and "operatization." Fortunately, we have- been spared such abominations. As it is. such a circumlocution «*s th*? correspondent suggests is better than the Words? which might bf> made by rule; and for this reason: "Opera," as a term indi cating: a play that Is sung, is Itself an abbreviation. When the term came into musical literature it was "opera in musica," that Is, "a musical work." Other terms were "opera per musica," (a work for music), "scenlca per musica" (scene for music), "regia rd esemplo per musica" (rule and example for music), "drama per nni!*lca." "tragedia per musica" and "melodramnia." Modern composers, both French and Italian, have shown a disposition to get back to early designations under the leadership of Wagner, who invented the term "musik drama" as an equivalent for the German "Oper." Thus, Verdi called "Alda" an "Opera in quattro Atti"; but his "Otello" he designates as a "Dramma lirico" and his "Falstaff" as a "Commedia lirica." Puccini calls "Tosca" a "Melodramma" and "Madama Butterfly" a 'Tragedia Giapponese." Cilea found a long cir cumlocution necessary to describe his "Adriana Lecouvreur." It is a "Com medla-drarnma di E. Scribe ed E. Lo gouvc. ridotta in quattro Atti per la tcena lirica da A. Colautti, musica di Francesco Cilea." — Ed.l COMMENDATION AND WARNING. To tho Editor of The Tribune. Sir: The absence from your columns of any commendatory letters from your sub scribers on the exposure of conditions here tofore locked In official flies of our late administration places the general public In a strangely lnappreciative position. In so ber language, devoid of all sensationalism, you are showing them where the money la going and where it has gone. Highly paid, if not heavily oathed. offi cials sit supine and defer action, because action might not be looked on with favor by the corporation concerned. The tax payers smilingly pay their taxes— and their railroad fares— and read publicity agents' statements of the great good that is to follow further expenditures of municipal money« for railroad Improvements'. In the mean while the public official to whom we are indebted that tills money In dispute has not yet been spent is out of oftVe. uncommended; also another, and un regrettably so, as one who aligned with an adverse interest. Let a greater public spirit arouse and commend the one (and the paper that strayed from local newspaper routine to give the public the facts) to the extent that a new era may be developed — the era of non-sensational publicity, in commendation and warning to the two classes of public officials your Interesting researches have developed! More power to your pen! Svn Yorfc. Jan. *>. 1910. TAXPAYER. ZIONISM. To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: As one who has been Identified with the Jewish-Palestinian colonization move ment—and Zionism, its child— from its start at the gathering of the best elements of continental European Jewry at Kattowltz, Silesia, in J««3. to its climax reached with the advent and death of Dr. Herzl (1897 190l>, I fully agree with what you have to say on the subject of Zionism in your yes terday's leader, entitled "Not Persuaded." Zionism shares the fate of all idealist causes whose, official organizations are captured by materialist selr-seekcrs. They serve tho latter as stepping stones toward the attainment of their own petty and sor did ambitions, and the ensuing demoraliza tion of such movements, naturally, repels the very elements that have fathered them and brought them to life. You are also perfectly right in disabusing the mind of your unnamed correspondent as to his exaggerated idea of the Impor tance and popularity of Zionism even among the Jewish masses at present. These masses instinctively, if not intelligently, feel that there is something rotten in th© state of official Zionism to-day, and, there fore, Justly remain indifferent, if not hos tile. In short, Zionism, swayed as it is under its present administration by a mer cenary materialist spirit, is bound to i,,. fast losing Us power of moral suasion for both Jew and Gentile alike. The title of your leader, "Not Persuaded," Is indeed very apropos In the premises. ADAM Rosen New York. Jan. 4. 1910. rr ' KU THREE WORDS WOULD DO. From The Philadelphia North American Taft took five thousand words to answer the. question "What is whiskey?" »£ might have answered it in three by adapt ing General Sherman's definition of war PROVED. From The Elnira Advertiser. ••Women." ** >ii a Harvard professor "have no more emotional »enM than a Persian cat. Its dollars to doughnut that the professor is a chronic bachelor. People and Social Incident* AT THE WHITE HOUSE. (From The Tribune Bureau.] Washington. Jan. 7. — The President »»r. c a letter of dismissal to Gifford Pinchot, the Chief Forester, thi3 afternoon. The Bal- Hnger-Plnrhot controversy was the princi pal topic of discussion at the regular Cab inet meeting this morning, and again at a special meeting at 3 o'clock. The Cabinet adjourned at 7 o'clock. The Secretary of State, the Secretary of th«» Treasury, the Attorney General, the Postmaster General, the Secretary of the Navy and the Secre tary of Agriculture wero present. President Taft sent to Congress his spe cial message on the Interstate commerce and anti-trost laws. Representative Town send was with the President some time to day, and said he would introduce In the House next week the administration Inter state commerce bill, drafted by the Attor ney General. ' The President's callers included Repre sentatives Martin, Townsend. Tawney. Ben net. Perkins and Calder. and State Senator Armstrong and John A. Stewart, of New York. THE DIPLOMATIC CORPS. [From Th» Tribune Bureau! Washington. Jan. 7.— The- Italian Em bassy was open this afternoon to the diplo mats and people in society generally, who took occasion to call on the "first day at home" of Baroness Mayor d? 3 Planch*?. The members of the embassy staff assisted the ambassador and the baroness In the reception. The Russian Ambassador and Baroness Rcsen entertained th» members of the em bsssy staff at a Christmas dinner at the embassy to-night, the only outside guest being Baron Schlippenbar.h. Russian Con sul General In New York. It was said to day that Baron Rosen was rapidly recov ering from his recent Indisposition. Mr. and Mrs. Prothero arrived hem to night, and Mill be the guests of the British Ambassador and Mrs. Brye* for several days. They will be constantly entertained while at the embassy. Baroness Luise Alexandra yon Birnstorff went to Philadelphia to attend the Assem bly ball to-night. She will return here, to morrow. IN WASHINGTON SOCIETY. rfrom Th» Trib'jn" Bureau ] Washington. Jan. 7— The Vice- President left here to-day for Ttica to remain over Sunday. Mre. Sherman entertained s num ber of ycr.g people at dinner to-night hi compliment to her hous^ guest. sfPBS MSO Baker, of T.'tica. and afterward took them to the National Theatre. The Secretary of the Navy and Mr:-. Meyer were the guests of honor at a dinntr to-night, with Rear Admiral and Mrs-. Leutze as hosts. To meet them were in vited the Assistant Secretary of the Navy and Mrs. Beekman Winthrop. Captain and Mrs. McLean. General and Mrs. John A. Johnston, Mr. and Mrs. Richard Harlow. Paymaster General Rogers and Miss Marion Leutze. Senator and Mr?. Burrows gave a dinner to-night, having as aruests the Postmaster General, tlie Secretary of the Interior and Mrs. Ballinger. the British Ambassador and Mrs. Bryce. Senator and Mrs. Depew, ex-Justice and Mrs. Brown, Mr. and Mr?. Lars Anderson and Mrs. La Crone, cf Michigan, who is spending the winter in Washington. Mrs. Potter Palmer, who has been the guest of the Secretary of the Treasury and Mrs. MacVeagh, has gone to New York. She will return here later for a series of visits. Mrs. Wirt Dexter, of Boston, who has also been the guest of the Secretary an Mrs. MacVeagh. has gone to the Arlington as the guest of Mr. and Mr? James M. Clark, of Chicago, who are spending the winter there. ... Colonel and Mrs. Robert. Roosevelt enter tained at dinner to-night for their daugh ter, Miss Ol»ca Roosevelt, preceding the ••small and early"' dance. Their guests were Mi;>s Ruth Pilling. Miss Marguerite Bar tour, Miss Laura Merriam. Miss Hinckley, lieutenant Long. Lieutenant Osterhaus, Lieutenant Palmer and Franklin Ellis. The "small and early" dance given at Rauscher's to-night for the debutantes of this season was under the direction of. Mrs. Richardscn Clover. Mr?. McLean, Mr.-. James Morris Johnston. Mrs. Robert Chew, Mrs. Frank B. Noyes and Mr?. Archibald Hopkins, chairman of the committee. The hours for dancing were from 9 to 1 o'clock, and supper was served early. Th. were fifty young girls, including the debutantes of this reason, and as many men were iii vited by their mothers. There was a dance at the Washington Barracks to-night for the officers and their friends. - . Mrs. Charles Maria t entertained guests at luncheon to-day for Mr?. McCormick* 1 1 New York, who Is the guest of Mrs. Stan ley Matthews. Mrs. John McGovan entertained fourteen young people at luncheon to-day, and Mrs. Yrooman entertained guests at luncheon to Bet) Miss Marth>na. Harrison. NEW YORK SOCIETY. Mrs. Robert Kndicott gave a dance- at Sherry's last night for her debutante daughter. Mis- Lillian Endicott. Instead of the usual seated supper there was an old-fashioned buffet luncheon served in the CLARKE ESTATE TO CHILDREN. Hackensack, N. J . Jar. 7.— The will of Dumont Clarke, the- New York banker, who died at his home at Dumont several weeks ago, was filed for probate in Surrogate Hes ter's office to-day. The estate is estimated at from $2,000,000 to nXlsMsft The will, which is dated May % 150 C. pro vides that «t trust fund shall be created and the income derived from it divided equally among his six children, •with the exception of E. Stanley Clarke, whose wife Shares his portion. The will further pro vides that at the end of five years the en tire estate shall be divided equally among the six children. A codicil to the will. dated January JJ I . IMS, gives all the house hold furniture, jewelry, silverware, build ings, carriages, horses, etc.. to sUn Corlnne Clarke. th<* daughter. She also gets the use of the estate for five years. M. Stanley Clarke and George V. Case, a son in-law, are executor*. SENATOR PERKINS BETTER. Washington. Jan. T.— Senator Perkins, of California, who yesterday -.lipped on the icy sidewalk and wrenched his spine, was re ported to-day as somewhat improved. His physician announced, however, that th« Senator would be obliged' to remain in bed several days. TOKIOS GIFT TO WASHINGTON. Washington. Jan. 7— Two thousand Jap anese cherry tree?, th« gift of the cor poration of Tokio to Mrs. Taft and th« city of Washington, arrived her« to-day. As soon as the weather is favorable these trees will lie set out along the drive In Potomac Park. It was in this park that band concerts were arranged by Mrs. Taft The trees represent i.»n varieties, with that number of different kinds of bloom. A few of them will be- planted in the- White House grounds and in public parks. ■ ■ »■■- » SENATOR CLAYS CONDITION. Atlanta. Jan. 7.— Physicians attending United States Senator A. S. Clay, who Is in a sanatorium recuperating, said to night: -The. Senator is suffering from ute stomach trouble and is absolutely •deluded from his relative and friends. "* is not permitted to receive mail, to Mrtte letters or to read newspapers. ' II« 43 resting comfortably this evening and «*> v s he hopes to be in Washington on * ebruary t Th« Senator Mil remain here * l 'cast until that time." foyer hall. Mrs. Endicott and h»r das^s> t«T received th« g'.i**sT<« r»ar th» entrance to the grand ballroom and in the MoaQ r#. crptlon room adjoining. Alexander M. Har den led the cotillon, dancing with 3fJs» Endicott, and the favors included parasols, tells and halls trimmed with ribbons, £anc7 flower headdresses for the girls, and is to* figure th*>- received astral favors, consist. Ing of suns, moons and stars, mad* sf gold paper, v trimmed with ribbons. Th» men received canes, orders and ctgarett* cases. Among tho guests were Miss Vir ginia Alexandra. Miss Beatrice Flaarg. Jtk, Jean Roo«evelt. Mis» Lesley Fretfertca Pearson. Miss Char lot to Le R>y Olover. Miss Kathertne O. Chapin. Ml«s WSTtrc<si Mortimer. Miss Helen Montgomery Las*, don. Ml!«!» Rose O'Nell Kane. Miss Jeaniwi King, Miss Charlotte G. Wyeth. Miss Jo. anna. Auchinclos3. Miss Marie Seton. Miss Lc>clM Munroc, Miss I»v© Godwin. Misa Catherine L. Hamer«ley. Miss M- Clvills* Al?xan«lre. Miss Katharine Steward, Miss Lisa Suydam. Miss Virginia Hunt, Mlsi Zellna Clark. Miss Joan Tuckarman. ii\z\ Katherine Auerbach. Ml»3 Eleanor Btirria. Mi3S Laura Emmet. Miss Katharine K. Tilford. Miss Elizabeth Fowler. M;s=» KatherJn* Green*. Miss Anl»a lag»rs<-ii;. Miss Julia Nourse. J. Harry Alexandra, jr.. Marshall R. Kernochan. M. Taylor Pjne. Jr.. Percy R. Pyne, M. M- QSSSS vVtison, jr.. R. Thornton Wilson. Frederick E. Alexandra. William A. Drayton. Howard Potter, Arden Robbins. Gallatln Pell. Joh:i R. Surdam, Jr.. Stephen Van Rensselayr. Francis H- Markoe. George- Endicott. Campbell Steward. John Egmont Schernier horn, • Amos C . Schermerhorri. Phcenix In graham, Courtlandt >.*.■ oil. William Manlca. Stanley G. Mortimer and Cforge Ttiacher. Frederick Town-end Martin garsalnnea eon at Sherry's yesterday for Miss Mar 4*4 * Tempest. Among hi* guests were ex-Gov error and Mr.- H^rrick, of Ob!-->; General Horace Porter. Colonel John Jacob Astor. Mr?. Edmund L. Baylies. Mrs. '"haries H. Marshall, Mrs. Gouvernour KorTrig Mrs. William Post. Mrs. James Speycr. Mrs. E. N. Breitung. Mr. and Mrs. Harry S. L«hr. Mr. and Mrs. Reginald de Keren, General Edward Winslow. Mr?. William F. Sheehan, Mrs. Henry d« la Pasteur. Mr. and Mrs. Martin W. Littleton. Daniel Frohmaa. Les lie Cotton. Mr. Clark and E. CtSSSBs] Jones. Mrs. Robert Goelet gave a dinner, fol lowed b- a small dane«», :ast ni?ht at fcer house, in Fifth avenue. Announcement 13 made of the OBSSSS> tnent of Mis.«» Charlotte Irving Grinns!?. daughter of Mr. and Mr?. E. Morgan Grtn nell. to Alexander Forbes, of Ml'-Ton. Mas*, son of Mr«. William Hathaway Forbe3 and a brother of Waldo and William Cam eron Forbe?. He H a graduate or Harvard of the class of '04. Francis L- V. Hoppin, who is to marrr Miss Mary Gurn*e on February 8. -win nave Robert P. Huntington for Ma best man. and his ushers will be Henry Rc??T3 Wlnthrop. P>.oenix Ingraham. Muuivs Robinson. Percy R. Pyne. C-i . Walter. S. Gumee. jr.; Robert L> Livingston. Charles K. Beekman and Elisha Dyer, a cousin of Mr. Hoppin. Miss Gurnee's attendants will be Miss .Olivia Thorndike. of Boston: Miss Pauline Riggs. Ml?* Pauline Robin pon and Miss Sydney Henop. Th« wedding will take place at the home of the bride - parents. Mr. and Mrs. Walter S. Gnmee, in Fifth avenue. The Motor Car Touring Society will riv* a dinner at the Union Club this evening for Commander Peary. U. S- N. Mr. and Mrs. H. Forbes MeCreery will sail for Europe to-day to spend the re mainder of the winter ; in Egypt. " MbM Harriet Robb also goes abroad to-day. Mr. and Mr?. Anson Phelps Stokes w'.. leave town for Palm Beach at the end of next w«ek- Mr. and Mrs. Pierre Lorillard Bonalds have: returned to town from Tuxedo. Mrs. »"ii«-irn:r de Rham Moore will- jtva a dinner on January 14. SOCIAL NOTES FROM NEWPORT. [By Tolas* • to The Tril>un».T >Tewport, Jan. 7. — The BIS! of I series of assemblies, of Which th» officers of I.*:? second naval defence district are II fcost?. was given this evening in the lecture room of the United States Naval War College. Several hundred were present, including the army and navy officers, tkeir families and the members of the ▼.inter colony of cottager?. The Ttives of Rear Admiral Raymond Perry Rodger?. Commander F. W. Hourigan. Commander Mark L. Bris tol, Captain Roy C. Smith and Medic;' Director James C. Byrnes received. Corr mander Hourisan. Assistant Paymaster Tl.T 1 . B. Walnw right, jr. Commander FrauS Marble. Lieutenant Commander W. W". Phelps. Lieutenant K. 6. Casrleman. Ma jor John Russe'l and Surgeon G?orjs T. Smith were the committee. . Mr. and Mrs. T. S ;f?o-n TsUSf are at Newport arranging for the tniproveir.erit o' the Collard Villa on the cliffs, which thfr recently purchased and which they Trill occupy next season. DR. APPLE IN OFFICE. Lancaster, Fenn.. Jan. 7.— Dr. Henry Harbaugh Appl* beam- president of Franklin and Marshall CoCegt to-day. TTi* exercises in Fulton Oj^era House her* w«r« attended by Governor Stuart and delegates from thlrty-flve universities, colleges an! other educational institutions. GERMANS HONOR AMBASSADOR. Count Johann yon Bernstorf. GsjSSSB Ambassador, was the gu?sr of honor at » private dinner given last ni^ht by th- mem bers of the Gersssa Club, at No. EC West I9th street. TRANSATLANTIC TRAVELLERS. Among; the passengers who will saC to flay for Europe are: TUP CAUEDOXIA. worn GLASGOW. " Gustav Bania, Jr. Mr. anJ Mr*. J. 9) Mr and Mr*. I>avtd S ! Kamscy. Humcr. '.William L Rig*. Miss Mary Troeter. j Mrs. T*ooe*3 S. TaCocJ*. THE NEW TORK. FOR SOUTHAMPTON. Mt«s Vern. Beresford. ; Dr. and Mrs. F. s5. x mx- Captain A. T. Cole. i son. Mr. ana Mrs. J. M Mrs. Julia Paul Smith. Dunn. w T. "V\>>- burn- Mr, aud Mrs. E. P. 'Mr. and Mrs. Jay W*«te» Hardy. f. W. Spring. ■Walter Ptki \ THE BARBARA.- \. FOR NAPLES. Bear Admiral and Mrs.! Mr • and Mrs. Adas Theodore >\ .lrw«»!L 1 »irot.^. Charles L. ttarstcm-. r>r and Mr?. C«ors« Mrs. Thomas Purltas-I R«ed. , ham. : Paul Sc&rwber. Mr. and Mm. TV. M John C. Wilson. ■SS*tt I THE PENNSYLVANIA. FOR HAMBITUI H. « Andersen. I John H. t>orn. Hfnry Bruck. IWU'Urn Haaa. Mi»« Laura. Lindsay! Mrs. Malvin* fiiisf Carter. i THE MINXCWASKA. FOR LONTON. T. D Ayr*ard. !MuiV A. Into* Mr and Mil. t«- 800-!i;«ors» L. Robiasax nam Bird. Carl "Vvynccop. Miss Sybil Burton. [ THE CARONIA. FOR NAPLES J>r. Sophta Morimn- Mr and Mrs. Ffcfl!> thaler. I Shears. Major and Mr». Wi!!-.Mr». U. A. Stone»tr««t. Urn J. P»rd*e. Mrs. John i»«|i»> J. H. Ladcw. l H«atoa. Mr. and Mrs. William; Mr and Mrs Frank W. A. Irving. I Grtftln. Charl*« F. K«nt. iMlsa Ida May Swift. Major J. V. Tost. , Dr. and Mrs. C J. T«ar*. Travellers who arrived yesterday fre» abroad were: THE ADRIATIC. FROM SOCTHAMTTOK. Mr »n I Mrs. John H. Mr and Mr*. Fran* f, Allen. | Mitchell. Mrs. \N I> C. Eiddle. t Mr*. Herbtrt B. Tors*?. T. D. M- Cardeja. iMonsJenor O Kara. Mr. and Mrs. C. A. ; Mr. and Mrs R. * Grtscora. | Cravtard. Mr snd Mr». H -» * - «a. M MSSI I •