Newspaper Page Text
V- LXX....N-; 23.285. - To-morrow. n » r n, rloudv PRESIDENT MONTT OP CHILI DEAD The Shooting of Mayor Gaynor Regarded as Hastening the End. HE ART DISEASE THE CAUSE Sailed on the Kaiser Wilhelm, August 9. in Search of Health Abroad — Anarchist Re ported on Board. Lc-drn. Aug. 16— President Pedro ".. of Chili, died at Bremen, after •^arrival --. the steamship Kaiser WO beto> der Gros^e this morning. His death £jsn*d at -.-.. o'clock t- -night. It ££~due to a recurrence of heart trouble. jjajpwlnS a recor.t attack of angina .. r . from which he suffered. President Montt sailed from this city ts the yearns 1 Kaiser Wilhe'.m der Gr: .«cp on August 9 tad was to be a •>!]pw passenger of Mayor Gaynor. 'He Jtc nn ' his way to Bad Kaahefm for -edical treatment for heart trouble. wttch was the cause of his sudden jeEifc. "fi"n ile tbe Chilian Chief Execu- Bfre was - ■• a witness to the attempt* II S^ssmation of Mayor Gaynor. he was ...... of the attack before his de- Mrtnr£ all d it was said by a member of the official party which went on board the steamer to say gnodby that he was -r-jch affected by the occurrence. Al tfconsi under the constant care of his physician, who accompanied htai from Santiago, it is known that "neither his wife, who was with him. nor his "friends [tared his death while he rasinthfe city. During his stay of six flays here President Montt avoided all exertion and entertainment. He made ♦no . r three short trips out of New v ... including 3 visit to President taS at Beverly, who entertained him inferably- When the Kaiser Wilhelm der Grosse asslbi second ••'■ on her voyage. Presi c«:t y ■■- Fent a wireless message to this city inquiring about Mayor Gay — = condition. c--.- reports of the scenes on board .v. c Kaiser Wilheim der Grosse. when Xayor Gaynor was shot. said that President •• ntt had witnessed the shooting, but these were erroneous and •-. American and Chilian officials who •nere there were pleased that he did sot aM it. fearing that he might suffer -■ even greater shock than he did when be vsj informed of it. Affected by Attempt to Kill. . SeScr Ricardo Sanchez Cruz. Chilian Crrs-dl General in this city, who was »;•- ; ■■'-• ■■ the time, said |a<r to a Tribune reporter: "President Merit and Mayor Gaynor exchanged gratings, and after a few moments of | conversation Befior Montt withdrew and accompanied hi? 1 arty to the saloon. The shooting occurred a minute later. it - we -■ Are toastine the health of President Montt, and we did not hear •-. shots Bred The first news brought to us »•£? that some one had committed e-lcide. A little later we learned the truth. The President was much af !fct«-d by the unfortunate occurrence. •• may now be told that President .Jtott'E frlendK feared that some harm ,ri:fhi come to him at the hands of anar chists -w-hile >-<=■ was in this country, and •■;• he -was continually under close Tuard. This fear of possible violence to &4or Montt was shown on the steamer just before he ■lied He stood with his party on the leek of th" Kaiser when cse of the bitter, a Chilian official. ca-^ht fisht of ■ black bearded man. Bagging one of his countrymen the offi cial -w-hiFpered : "That man is an anar chist." a close watch was kept on the eospected man. President Montt v, as sixty-four years til " He was a lawyer. His family was "' of the- best known In Chili, and his lather servr-d as President of the repub lic from l*v>l to IBSI. •-'■ Montt became President of Chill <*■ September IS. lIM6. and his term of t^ce extended to 1911. He succeeded htaiu Riesco as Chief Executive. He "i? elected by an enormous majority. IBS -was supported by a really national party. He was chosen as member of ■ l£e forcer house s«x>n after his admis- Eoa to the bar, in IS*>S. and held his : »»«t for any years, being afterward , "'"-" Senator for one of the southern j provinces, and later for the Province of i Eajitis-g-r,. During ttroan years he was a ; — err;b*r of the Cabinet, and was more j once Premier. j The Career of the President. It ■■-_-- . times Eeftor Mont* was '-■-■- r* the Chamber of Deputies and * OotmcUlor of Ftate, and during a brief bat trying period was Minister Pleni *""" ■ •-.• Washington. In all the '-Sew? wrhich he held he was dlstln pisb«*3 f., r his conciliatory and well de saeej policy. His avowed ambition as --"«Kk:r* iv 3!i i o return the country to •U former high position in the financial *orid, to govern the nation with the *"'"■• economy compatible with *-m ci *st public service, and to live at peace *Ilh an j ts neighbors. Be was the tampion of a Bound financial stem, 2a va^pj unceasing war against the Jolicy of prodigal expenditure. In debate on foreign polk he urged !J*ateful and honorable settlement of In the years between 1889 pad V.*»J '.•!,.,, the frontier dispute *p3t tie Argentine Republic brought ~ i-*i -* Dear war, when practically every ?s<s was ready and waiting orders to a '^r>'h, Sefior Uoon untiringly poured *? on th«- troubled waters. iif: vii, s defeated ri<-«- for the Presl *-i«.T. iiv<' amra i>« (me his election, * D <J on that occasion )j«- returned to the +nat '- and continued his daily occupa ">ri as if ihe defeat had been only a occurrence In his life. President lr -r.ttd«-vot.-d considerable of his time to £ £v <?l and while in the United States. - c tland, France. Germany and Italy **^- much attention to the technical Cachet of education, public service. 9 \l \^ *40PS^=^r^- '■ ■ -'^^^T^^SBBBP^Bi^L^^ia^B m^^^SCl^ *g^j LE BLANC WINS RACE. Arrives at Issy After Covering 485 Miles. Paris. Aug. .17.— Le Blanc arrived at Easy. In the suburbs of Paris, at 6:45 this morning, and is the winner of the 'cross-country flight which started on August 7. The distance of the race was? approximately 186 miles. The priz^ contested for was $2<\f>oo, offered by a Paris newspaper. AIRSHIPS DEFEAT BIRDS Carrier Pigeons Distanced in Flight to Amiens. Amiens. France. Aug. 16.— The first aeria' race between the birds of nature and man's production was held yester day in the course of the great aerial "cross-country competition. and was •ABOy won by man. Forty-seven car rier pigeons were released at Douai at thr same instant that Le Blanc, in his Parman biplane, started from the mark on his fifty -mile flight to Amiens. Rushing without a tremor through the calm air. the biplane soon outdistanced the birds, and nrhen Le Blanc reached Amiens the flock was not yet in sight, the first pitreon arriving six minutes and twenty seconds after T>e Blanc. PARIS-LONDON AIR RACE Latham and Moissant in Contest — Latter at Amiens. Amiens. France. Aug. 10—. n aero phUM race between Paris and London Started to-day, when Hubert Latham and Moissarst left Issy. a suburb of Paris, announcing that they intended to fly to I^ondon with stops. Latham as cended first, and drove through the air at great speed, but motor trouble forced him to land in a field near La Faloise. X ■ spects to resume his flight to-mor row. Moissant reached Amiens in two hours and started for Calais at 5:09. This race between Paris and London has caused great interest, as it begins on the eve <>f the conclusion of the great 'cross-country competition, in which Le Blanc and Aubrun are the survivors. Latham and Moissant concealed their intentions until the last moment, wish- Ing to forestall each other, and the an nouncement was made by Latham that he was going to Amiens in order to make the return trip with the 'cross-country fliers. Amiens. Aug. 17. — Le Blanc started at 53Q8 o'clock this morning from here on •the last stag-p of the "cross-country flight to Paris. Aubrun left the ground at o:10 and Legagneux at 5:15. Le Blanc has a considerable advantage in the race, as his elapsed time so far is less than that of Aubrun by more than an hour, and The 1201,000 will go to the man who covers the circuit of 2.*^ miles in the shortest elapsed time. Legagneux is not a contestant Moissant started for Calais at s:<~>9. ELKINS GOING TO VICHY Duke of the Abruzzi Expected to Pay Visit There. Vichy, France. Aue. If. --Miss Kath enne Elkins and her mother have en gagr-d rooms at a hotel here, and are expected to arrive to-morrow by auto mobile, from Baden-Baden. It is un derstood that the Duke of th* Abruzzi will also come here for a brief stay. HUGHES GETS NEW HOME He Has Leased a House in Washington. [From Th» Tribune Bureau.) Washington, Aug. 16. — Governor Hughes has selected the home which he will occupy in Washington during his first years as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He has leased for a 'term of years, with an option to purchase, a house at No. 2401 Massachusetts avenue, belonging to Mrs. Florence R. Boyd. The house is just west of Sheridan Circle, and in its neighborhood are some of the finest homes in Washington. It Id a brown stone and brick structure, with a tower, and is surrounded by large grounds. AH the rooms are large and attractive, the drawing room, li brary and dining room b«ing particu larly spacious. Some improvements and alterations are now being made on the house, which will be ready for oc cupancy by the New York Governor and Mrs. Hughes by October 1. CHILDREN SEE DEATH LEAP Mother Grieving for Only Child Jumps from Window. As the two hundred children attend ing the vacation school at Public School 147, in Havemeyer street. Williamsburg, were dismissed yesterday afternoon, they were horror stricken to s* r - Mrs. Philo mena Bfncott jump from the window of her home across . the way at No. 32. While Miss Harper, the principal, urged them back Into the inctosare of the building. Patrolman Ferguson ran to the bod- lying on the sidewalk. Up to three weeks ago Mrs. Bincott had sent her five-year-old daughter Rosie, her only child, to the playground across the way. Every afternoon when the children came out the mother was at the window and Rosie and her play mate waved to her. Th^p weeks ago Rosfe died Mrs Bin , . tt continued to sit n\ the window tho igh wtth ■ Md smile- and receive th* greetings of 'he children. Yesterday she scnamed "Boate!" and then lumped al ntosl among th«-m. in IfcAHster. <-f tbe Wflßamsburg li(is|;it:i!. Mild Mr.-. Bincott ii;t<l broken i,<r ij« k, and pronounced death to have been Instaatmneous. Bhe leaves ■ bus l,;;;i'i. Who was <>\ «-i <■< mil- ;i! luis th< tuta.l loss of hia family. ASSESS ROCKEFELLER $300,000. Although- the assessment on John V- Rockefeller^ awjnslnoeni borne at I'ocan tico Hills was increased from 12W.4N <° $3</j,<."tO by ' i ■•- assessors, he made no com plaint resterde when the assessors -•>' to hear grievances in Tan -.11 In fact. M' Rockefeller sent word that he was perfectly satisfied 10 pay the additional assessment. Th* assessors had the unusual experience of not having a complaint made aiuirist '■-<- NEW- YORK, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 17, 1910.— TWELVE PAGES.** MAY OPERATE ON MAYOR TO-DAY OR TO-MORROW "General Improvement in His Symptoms." Bulletin Says — Temperature Decreases. PATIENT IS IN FINE SPIRITS Is Propped in Bed, Allowed to Read for First Time, Jokes with Surgeons, Hears from Little Folk. MAYOR SHOWS IMPROVEMENT. The bulletin issued at 9:30 o'clock last night by the surgeons attending Mayor Gaynor at St. Mary's Hospi tal. Hoboken. follows: "Mayor Gaynor has passed a very comfortable day. There has been a general improvement in his symp tomr. "ARLITZ. •DOWD. 1 STEWART. "PARRISH." A bulletin was issued at midnight as follows: "There has been no change in the Mayor's condition since the evening bulletin. The Mayor is sleeping quietly. "ARLITZ, "DOWD." The bulletins issued by the physicians in attendance) on Mayor Gaynor at St. Mary's Hospital yesterday were uni formly favorable. The Mayor was re gaining his str*npth so rapidly, one of the attending physicians said last night, that it may be decided to operate and extract the bullet to-day or to-morrow. When this physician left the hospital, late yesterday afternoon, he said a pre liminary survey of the wound would probably be made at the usual nightly consultation of the surgeons to prepare the way for the more serious operation. Xone of the other physicians would say later that an operation was immi nent. When Dr. Arlitz. house physician at St_ Mary's, was asked about it. he denied that th e surgeons intended to extract the bullet soon. "The Mayor is getting- along swim mingly." he said, "and we are not going to operate for the present." The 9:30 o'clock bulletin last night ! was rather colorless. It was issued after the usual nightly consultation of the attending physicians. It was said the patient's throat had been examined, but nothing could be learned as to the prob ability of an operation. The bulletin read: "Mayor Gaynor has passed a very com fortable day. There has been general improvement In his symptoms." Temperature Decreases. The bulletin was signed by Drs. Ar litz, Dowd, Stewart and Parrish. Dr. Brewer did not return to the hospital last night. One of the attending physi cians supplemented the bulletin by giv ing the Mayor's temperature as 99. the lowest it has been yet. and nearest to the normal mark of 98 3-5. The Mayor's pulse was TO and his respiration 17, he said. Robert Adamson. secretary to the Mayor, was less emphatic in speaking of the Mayor's condition yesterday. "The Mayor appears to be better to-day than he was yesterday." said Mr. Adam son. "He took more nourishment and swallowed easier than on any previous day. and I believe he Is going to re cover. Of course, it is wholly specula tive as to when he will be able to leave the hospital, but with conditions as favorable as they have been so far I think he will start on his belated vaca tion to recuperate within two or three weeks." Mr. Adamson said he understood that the physicians were discussing the pos sibilities of an operation for secondary hemorrhage which might arise from the "sloughing" of some of the affected tis sues on the walls of the arteries in the region of the wound. Surh an operation could be accom plished by incisions in the neck, he said, and not directly through the mouth, as •would be the case if the bullet was re moved. He paid he had not heard the Burgeons diFcuselng a more serious op eration to extract the bullet. Dr. Brewer, the surgeon who would be railed upon to perform whatever operations wore necessary, was with the patient all Monday night. A report was current about the hospital last night that an operation had a!r<*adv been performer], but this was denied The hacking rough which has bothered the Mayor considerably for the past few days still han s on, it was said, but he found much relief from it by ly ing for a good part of th<=- time on his right fid^. He does not sit up in bed. A Book at Last. For the first time yesterday the pa tient was propped up with pillows into a reclining position, and was allowed to read a little. He had asked his wife to prevail upon the physicians to let him read Mrs. Gaynor told the doc tors h^r husband practically lived with a hook in his hands at home, and that unless his condition would not permit, it, the deprivation for so long a time was a hardship They decided to grant i)i(. request, and a copy Of "Happy Haw kins' and "Marcus AurHtus." the only available literature in the hospital. were given '<• the Mayor. !!■• glanced through ""■ books for s little while, Secretary Adamaon said, bui didn't n ,. 1( j mi;, h He was not •allowed to read tbe newspapers. •ji,,- Mayor slepl Beven hours dining the night, and awoke much refreshed ,,,) in hi* usual good liv r yesterday tnorning. ••When 1 went Into his room early this morning," Mr. Adamson said yes terday, "the Mayor greeted me cheer fll Hv with the remark: "Hello, I*"' 1 ' ' ■*• >' ou have beaten the doctors this morning. None <>f them has town up • ' Th* Mayor rani be hadn't talktd much CuutUiut-U ps fourth i-\c- LLOYD C. GRISCOM AND TIMOTHY L. WOODRUFF. At R*t>ublican State Committee meeting: yesterday. VICE-PRESIDENT SHERMAN. Who was selected as temporary chairman of State Convention (Photo copyright by Pach Bros., x. y.. 1908.. WRECK DELAYS COMMUTERS Pennsylvania Freight Off Track, • Causing 1 Long Blockade. A -freight- train on , the 'Pennsylvania. Railroad was wrecked yesterday after noon near Perth Amboy junction. A tramp who was stealing- a ride had his arm "badly crushed; but there ' were no other casualties. Traffic was suspended for twelve hours while the wreckage was being removed and the tracks repaired. Ail the passengers on the Pennsylvania lines were compelled to transfer to the jersey Central lines. The freight was going east, and had twelve freight car?, loaded with coal. As it reached the point where the tracks of the Long Branch line converge into those of the main line a truck frame on one of the freight car? broke, causing it to leave the track and derailing all the other eleven cars, scattering coal and wreckage over three tracks, only th 3 fourth track, westbound, being open. Wreck trains were rushed out from Jersey City and New -Brunswick and began at once the work of clearing away the wreckage and replacing the track, which had been torn up for over four hundred feet The work was completed in time to bring into the city the com muters who had been compelled to take the Jersey Central out the night before. RUNS WITH CHILD ABLAZE Mother and Baby Badly Burned Patrolman Puts Out Fire. With the clothing- of both aflame, Mrs. Sarah Finkel. of No. 902 Riverdale ave nue Brooklyn, race,: with her three year-old daughter Elsie in her arms from her home last evening to -a drug store two blocks away. Mother and child screamed with agony. • Patrolman Burton overtook the woman and pulling off his coat, wrapped it around her and the child, partly extin guishing the flames. He beat the rest of the fire out with hi? hands, and was slightly burned. The child was taken to St Mary's Hospital, where it was said she would probably, die. Although suf fering greatly herself, the mother insist ed on helping the policeman and others in treating her child with oils, pending the arrival of an ambulance surgeon. Mrs. Finkel was cooking on an oil etove when the little girl knocked against it in her play. The stove was upset and in an instant her clothing was afire. Seizing her, the mother dashed from the house with the child Her own clothing was Ignited while she sought to tear off the baby's flaming garments; AUTOMOBILE HITS BEAR. Both New Yorkers ' and Bruin Badly Frightened in Maine. Ban^or, Me.. Aug. lfi.— Colliding with a large black bear In the highway in the town of L.acran«e to-day, a motor car In which were Mr. and Mrs. Edward 1- Hopkins and John P. Fassett. all of New York, and Miss Marlon Gordon, of Philadelphia, was ditched by the roadside. The tourist* es caped uninjured and the bear disappeared in the woods. The car was. running at high speed -when the bear rose tip on its haunches directly In the middle at the road. There was not room to pass, and the car struck the sur prised animal squarely, carrying It [along growling on th.» hood of the car until a bad place In the road bounced it off. In falling the lx'sr went under the wheels and thr car was ditched. Ah soon as the party discovered that the hoar was as frightened as they were and was making tracks for the woods they righted the car and proceeded to this city on their way '" 'NVw York. ■•Uikit." th« stylish 'eyeglass. . Bisisht or torlc Pebbles- Spencers, 31 Maiden Lane. ■— Advt FLOOD'S DAMAGE IN JAPAN Hundred Thousand Homeless — —Rice Loss $4,500,000. Washington Aug. I«.— Mr. OBrien. the American Ambassador at Toldo. re ported to the State Department to-day that the city of Tokio was supporting: one hundred thousand refugee? from the flooded districts of Japan. The damage to the rice crop was great. According to the ambassador it is estimated at $4, £OO,OOO. More than one hundred and fifty thousand houses were damaged by the floods. Tokio, Aug. 16.— The suffering among more than half a million people here is indescribable. The local relief funds are large, the resident foreigners assisting generously in the relief work and with money. Among those drowned was the tecond son of Rempei Kendo, president of the Japanese Mail Steamship Com pany. No casualties among foreigners are reported. Ambassador O'Brien has remained in Tokio throughout the floods, and is doing everything possible to assist the suffer ers. All the visitors at the summer re sorts are safe. FEARS HUNCHAKIST THREAT Applies for Protection on Eve of Martoogessian's Release. On the eve of the release from Sing Ping- of Levalt M. Martoogessian, the Armenian priest whose activities in connection with the Hunchakists caused his imprisonment two years ago. a man who refused to disclose his identity, brat who. it was said, was active, in the prosecution of Martoogessian, called yesterday upon Acting District Attorney Moss and said his life had been threat ened. Although Mr. Moss and Daniel F. Cohalan, who accompanied the man, de clined to discuss the object of the call, it leaked out. Martoogessian was formerly pastor of the Gregorian and Armenian Church, in this city. He was charged with being the leader of a society of Hunchakists. and with pending: threatening letters to wealthy Armenian business men de manding sums of money. He was convicted on February 27. ITHkK, of attempted extortion, and sen tenced to two years and six months in state prison. His sentence will expire August 27. NO CURFEW YET FOR YONKERS Oldest Alderman Objects to Ordinance '■ Proposed by Youngest Colleague. Alderman Thomas W. Tobin. the young est member of the Yonkers Common Coun cil, says he has been shocked to find many • girls and boys in the parks, and by the. waywardness of children who loiter in the streets at night. Ho has Introduced an ordinance in th« Council making it .un lawful for boys and girl? under sixteen to be In the streets after 10 o'clock nt Blghi unless accompanied by parent or guardian. Alderman . William Corballs, the oldest member of tlie Council.** objected to the ordinance He 1.4 the father of ti large family, and thought It would be a sham* to keep the children • Indoors on summer nights, Under Mr. CorbaUs's objection se t-on on the proposed ordinance was post poned. ■_ SAYS ROOSEVELT WILL FLY Hannon, the Aviator, Makes Announce ment at Boston. [liv T< Ipprarli to The TribuiM ' Boston, Aug. IG.— Mr. . Hannon, .the avi ator, announces that Theodore Roosevelt i,,. promised to make an aeroplane trip with him next mouth at the aviation meet here. 'T\' r-v-v-T-. i^TT'-VT' In City of N«tt York. J*rwrr C«T and HobokMi. PRICE CXNE CL*JN 1 KISKMHKRE TWO CE>T3. "chinaman crosses "dead line" and is Tong Feud Responsible for Four Shots That Entered Chu Him'sSkuN. SEVENTH VICTIM THIS YEAR Police Make Two Arrests and Have Two Witnesses Who Swear Prisoners Did the Shooting. When Chu Him. of No. 11 Dryers street, a. member of the Four Brothers Society, was shot to death last night, in front of his home by alleged members of the On Leonar Ton?, he was the seventh Chinaman to fall a victim in the tens war in Chinatown thi? year. Chu Him has been a "marked man" for many months— he knew it: that Is why he kept to the little cubby-hole in the wall at N'o.ll Dover? street, where he ran a restaurant and made his home.'. This restaurant is "No. 5 in an arcade which runs from Dover?; street to No. 2O Mbtt street. The arcade is dimly lighted in the daytime by what rays of the sun can edge, their way there. and at night not at all. The arcade is about seventy-five feet in length and • about twenty-five , in width. It starts from Xo. 11 Doyers street and runs straight for about three quarters of its length, then turns slight ly to the north and ends at No. 20 Mott street. At the turn there are four steps, the Mott street end being lower than th<? other. These steps mark the boundary line between the Four Brothers Society and the On Leongs' territory, and few men venture beyond that spot, known as the "dead line." Shortly before 7 o'clock last night Chu Him arP p »r^d at the door of No. 11 Poyprs street and glanced keenly up and down the length of the darkened alley. Haying satisfied himself that no enfmy lurked within the shelter of the arcade he shuffled toward Mott street Chu Him had gone seventy feet or more, and no sound broke the stillness until he reached the top step and was preparing to descend to the next, when there was a Minding flash and a deafen ing roar. So fast were the shots tired. five in all. that they sounded almost like one continuous report. Chu Him leaped into the air and fell crashing to the ground with four bullets in the base of his skull. Following the shooting there was a scampering of slippered feet through the alley, and then all was still. Standing at Mott street and the Bowery were Ser geant Stevenson and Patrolman Young, of the Elizabeth street station, and as soon as they heard the report of the re volvers they ran to the arcade, and 1 found the body of Chu Him lying half way down the steps. The noise of the shooting and the gathering of excited Chinamen on the scene had caused a panic among sight reers in the district, and they poured out into the streets from nearby restaurants, adding to the excitement and confusion. Sergeant Stevenson sent in a call for an ambulance, and while waiting for its arrival started to investigate. As he was trying to find witnesses to the murder of Chu Him. he felt some body plucking at his sleeve, and turned around to find Lav Wing, of No 23 Pel! street Wing said he was a member of the Four Brothers, and had been an eye witness of the shooting. He toM the police that he could Identify the mur derers if he were given protection. His offer being accepted, ho led the police down Mott street until he came to No. 14 where he pointed out two men from among a group at the doorway. The men were arrested and gave their names as Tom Yuen and Lee Fat. No revolvers were found on either prisoner, but ■ charge of homicide was made against them and I-.au Wing was held as a material witness. The police obtained another witness to the shooting i'> the person of Chu Yuen, of No. 22 Pell street,' who said 1,,. was a cousin Of the dead man and a waiter in his restaurant. He said that wh*;u he heard the .shots he ran OUt of the restaurant and saw two men shooting at his cousin. He was taken to Police Headquarters, where he posi tively Identified both prisoners us the men "who had done the .shooting. COPPER TRANSMUTED TO IRON. Ottawa, Aug. 16.— L. R Keogb, or the Ot tawa Collegiate Institute staff, announces that hi* has succeeded in transmuting cop per into iron. He say* that the discovery m of no commercial value REJECT ROOSEVELT; SHERMAN SELECTED oHIKIhIaN otLtbltu Old Guard Wins in Fight for Temporary Chairman of the State Convention. WOODRUFF FULL OF ELATION Head of Committee Declares Yesterday's Meeting Shows Where Control of Or ganization Lie 3. MR. ROOSEVELT'S STAND. "To the various persons who asked mo whether I would accept the posi tion of temporary chairman of th* state convention I said that 1 would do so only if tHey w«'! sure, after knowing my attitude, aasl they de sired me. because ry scaeci wouid be of such a character t iat it might help if the convention norr-rated the right kind of a man on a ciean cut. progressive platform; but that it would hurt if neither the right kind of man were nominated nor the right kind of platform adopted." Members of the -old guard" showed conclusively that they were in control of the Republican State Committee yester day when they succeeded in puttin? through a resolution recommending Vice* .President Sherman as temporary chair man of the state convention. Lloyd C- Griscomf president of the New York County Committee, one of the leaders off the riQJiewilM element in the organiza tion, offered the name of Theodore Roose velt as a substitute, but the "old guard." purely for personal reasons and to ?V '" V their "strength, defeated the substitute by a vot^ of 20 to IS. State Chairman Woodruff, elated at the result, said after the meeting that It showed clearly who was in control of the organization, and that any attempt to change the control would be futile. H*» said there had been no intention of af fronting Mr. Roosevelt, but the latter's name had been lugged in for a football and had been kicked all over the field. Thf» members of the "old truard" were absolutely defiant last night, and de riare.l that no trace of the principles of Governor Hughes would appear either in the platform or the ticket to be nominated at Saratoga, which was named yester day as the place for the convention. The time selected is Tuesday and Wednes day, September 27 and 23. Progressives to Keep Up Fight. The Progressives declare that theywil! take their fight for progressive policies right into the convention. The conven tion must ratify the choice of the state committee for temporary chairman, but Mr. Griscom was not prepared to say last night that any fight would be mad« there to substitute the name of Mr. Roosevelt for that of the Vice-Pre.=idenr. After the meeting, which lasted not much more than half an boar, in the Republican Club. William L. Ward, of West Chester, and William Barnes, jr.. of Albany, had a talk with Mr IbJUM vent and later Mr. Griscom saw him. When he had heard both sides of th« story Mr. Roosevelt gave out the fol lowing statement: "To the various persons who asked me whether I would accept the posi tion of temporary chairman of the *tat« convention I said that I would do so only if they were sure, after knowin? my attitude, that they desired me, be cause my speech would be of such a character that it might help If the con vention nominated the right kind of n.an on a clean-cut,, progressive plat form, but that it would hurt if neither ♦.he right kind of man were nominated r.ur the right kind of platform adopted." Attention was called last night to the use by Mr. Roosevelt of the term "pro gressive platf€»rm." They said it showed clearly that Mr. Roosevelt's prestige could not be used as an asset in the campaign if the "old guard" persisted in carrying out their reactionary plat form. Will Roosevelt Be Delegate? Mr Roosevelt would not say that he expected to be a delegate to the conven tion, but Mr. Griscom said he was sur© that the ex-President's district would not refuse to send him to the conven- Gen. Fearin? the activity of the Progres sives, the "old guard" deliberately planned the test of strength for the meeting yesterday. They knew that Mr. Griscom had seen President Tart and had talked with Mr. Roosevelt. They knew that the proposition that Mr. Roosevelt be temporary chairman had been mentioned to him. They saw a chance to rebuff both the ex-President and the Progressives, and at the same time display their control of the star* convention. They went about their plans secretly. Not ■ stiggestion that Vice- President Sherman be named as temporary chair man was made to Mr. Roosevelt or to Mr. Griscom or any of his friends. Mr. Woodruff saw the Vice-President at th-> Hotel Manhattan on Monday night, but he was careful that their meeting should not become known. Mr. Woodruff said yesterday that he had the unqualified consent of the Vice-- President to present his name as temporary chairman. TIM Vice- President left town at midnight. Mr. Griscom at Oyster Kay on Mon day had obtained the consent of Mr. Roosevelt to allow his BMM to lie pre si>nt»'d to the committee m temporary chairman of the convention, but the un derstanding was that the selection of this officer would not come up until the meet ing of the committee the night beforo the convention. Early yesterday mornins one of Mr. Griscbm'a friends heard of the plan of the "old guard" to present the '[>■•■■- President's name it the meeting at noon. As soon as Mr GriMM was informed of the plan he got in communication with Mr. Roosevelt over the telephone and told him what he had learned. Hi asked Mr. Roosevelt whether he was still will-