New-York tribune. [volume], January 09, 1912, Page 3, Image 3

About New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924

Image provided by: Library of Congress, Washington, DC

                
A TU O ROO G H i- V
matured, .-?oft flav?
ored whiskey of sin
gulnr purity and excep?
tional Ii.ffh qnality.
John Jameson
Whiskey
TIlOsE who know its
goodness would
prefer to go with?
out a drink rather than
take any other.
SLAYER DIES IN CHAIR
Harburger, a Witness. Converted
to Electric System.
S he'IT ' imbu-per returned to hl? nfhYe
?ejrterday morning: from an early m
visit to Sing Pine prison, where he saw
Ma?*srano. convicted In New York
??r filling his dsughter, put to death in
1nP ?leetrie chair. Sheriff Harburger wit
?KSBSd an execution ?n the chair for the
S/st time, and before had some doubt
about the humaneness of the system of
putting criminals to death In dm in this
Mate
I >? Spitzka explained the scientific feat?
ure? te the. Sheriff, so that, when he came
awav. Mr. Harburger was firmly convinced
of the wisdom of using electricity lnst-ead
ef the callows.
Mengano VrSS an Interpreter in the mar
r|a?*e license bureau in City Hall. His
- , Ihter, Miss Anna A. Mangano. was
- hool teacher. Mangano shot bis
-daughter while in a flt of temper over her
jip-iHi-tence In marrv????- ?i man to whom
btfi ?'?- was opposed Mangano went to
? H-.r weeping.
Albec Wolter, slaver of Ruth Wheeler,
?:!! be the next to expiate his crime In the
chair, the Court of Appeals having fixed
the week beginning January Cs as th?- dite.
Letters have been received by Qovei*nor
Dix written by pe??plc in various parts ol
the country. '??? Woher** behalf, but it is
Bet considered probable that the Gov<
will interfere.
FAMOUS "SWAMP" SITE SOLD
Former Headquarters of "Old
Cronies* Club" Changes Hands.
There Used to be an "Old frontes' club"
In the famous "Swamp.'' better known as
the lea'her district -ea.-t of ?William
and north of Fulton Mr. et ? In the t
ffg It met son ' No. ft Spruce
- ? ? ? and frequently at No. ::i Bpruce
g This last named popular no?
Place was sol.I yesterday by William H.
Whiting &? Co. for Walter O. Walsh, as
? xeentor.
ft Is a five story structure ofl a ?plot %.f_
Till feet. This Is the first BSla "f the
propertv- in about ?eventy-flve years an l
the fou?-tti sal?- of the land in the lust thrt a
hundred years,
funeral ?'rant was a familiar figure a1
thla meeting place before be b-acame Pi -t
dent. Robert EL Bonner, owner of the fs
moua trotting horse Maud S . was also a
Isltor 'Tl ? N? sr York ?Ledger,"
of w> . ' hi w.-is the own. r. had Its home
by, on the site now oecupted by the
? ?at ag ts-Zeitung."
The property sold yrsterdsy on? f<?rmed
I | t of the .1 . i? tannery
property. Roosevelt bought some s
ir, |7M for tMA The acres est?
Iren William Street to within a short dis?
tance of ("lift Street He divided the land
fty purl- end eetabllShed eight tan?
tanes on it Before be improved the land
"Beekman swamp."
The narce continue? to cling to It.
In the year Ro< levell ?got title to the
property the city Hsll Psrk was known a*
the "flat'' and was the public place of exe
rutlon. Ihe gallows being n?esr where th?
' -il of H?--'"
In 17T?" thla pa?t of the city wai
t<-<- |ta dwelling -'--ptember -1
Of that year h fire which extended from
shall to Barcia) street destroyed m
RIVERSIDE CLUB HEARS HAYWARD
William Hsywsrd, se<*retsi7 of the Pe
n National ?'onimlttee, defended
IminlStrstlon of President Taft last
Sighl before the Riverside Repu bl les n
Club, No 117 West i'Tth street Other
speakers nt the meeting were ?"-ongresa
? .Mer. of Brooklyn, end es-Coi |
?? an B?-nne'
T<?tlaG?en??
TECLA PEARLS
Mciunted with genuine dia?
monds in platinum and gold
setting* of rare individuality.
We ere at present showing
some reperc? workmanship in
original and beautiful creations
desi??n>*d by our Paris artists.
Tecla Pearls possess that
rare sheen and delicate tone
found in those from the Orient.
1 ecla Rubies, Emeralds
and Sapphires are now
?o well Imown that further
comment is superfluous.
TECLA
NEW YORK PARIS
398 Futl Aveo.i? 1 n R,Jt ?f u P.;?
LONDON NICE
701dBo-JStr,* I6Ave.Ms.aVr?
AGENCIES
PU-J.I-A...W.I?,,, St. .t 16tlu
Wm4W.oo.DC F S?, at 1 lltt
St. Lou,?. 621 Lorn.! Strftt.
B?rl,a, 15 t'nt.r ira Lra-n.
V-tata?, 2 KlrotWiatr.?? .
So Other Braarha or Agent?.
1
The World's
Greatest Condiment
Known the world over.
LEA I PERRINS'
8AUCE
? Mi oaioiNtL woscreTt?-?aMi-?r
;--rior flavorine fur fmh. B?t I
fiW MeaH. Smp>. ?tea? SPA 9Atts
An Appetizer
?Ion? DmcaV? Som, Agrti.t-?- N.T.
Mrhk
Second in Series of Auctions
Robert Hoe Library Begins
LONDOM DEALER'S REVEN
Bernard Quaritch, Outbid at L
Spring's Sale, Carries Off
Many Choice Volumes.
Bernard Quaritch. the London I
dealer, pot 1,|S rov.ni?. lost night at
second session r,t p;irt z of fhf. Kobe-rt
library ?.air. a( .,,? Andprson AllPtJon ,
Madison avenue an.l ?/?th street,
the many time* lam spring when he
anxious to M a ehoice volume and
outbid by fame American rol lector. Ou
fourteen ?hooka, valued bj the aaaembl:
nor?- than | .... ,.???:,. ,,, , arr1p(1 a
twelve, among them th.- pich o? the c.
Ing. an edition of Thomas A Kerni
? ? lion of rjhrlst," print*?! in .?ait
u . bound by Monnier In old Ftp
Citron ?nororro. Inlaid with nirious peri
ape? In Chinese costume 1* eosl
K5.1G8 to take it ??ay from .1 F T?r.?k.
lor of this city, who wanted it to
r-t.nt of ? BOO The total for the day
186,8
The MK-ond pari of the salo ..f th?* rr
Inc press manufacturer's librar, ope
yesterday afternoon, and will extend
two weeks, with ?-.?-??ions fach aft?*?
and evening from Monday to Friday.
elusive. Morr> than nineteen hundred
tut* disposed of at a similar sale 1
sprint: I .? In S total of nearly |1,(
0?v?. considerably more than anv previ
book s ? er netted l? a
two mor?- series of auction? bef?>re the
library is finally dlspost- if. on"
them ?being scheduled for II Is spring i
the other for n?"\t falL
it was thought Ihe weather yeptori
? | ? dampen the en' Of '.he Y
ders who followed ib.* aale closely i
sprinp. bul ii?- evening aeaalon ?
to be a falsely founded feo?*. Mi Dri
Coroed .Mr. Quaritch to the limit on iif-a
tvi re book for which the .?unis ran hii
although It ha?pi>en"d that <>n ?everal <>??<
slons the Knplish buyer was so anxious
capture his choice that tie ? laced his b.
where nono dared folio* i? waa said
several who knew him well and have ?
lowed the booh market with great ea
that he was doubtless buying to a lar
extent tor j. Pterponl Morgan.
Mr. Quarit. h's second plunge was to t
extent of fi.'fo for a volume of Thf
phraatus from the library <>f Henry II a
I>iana of Hoi.-tiers Th- third book was
finely bound volume entitled "Re?u
?enera! dea Caqueta de 1'Acourhee." t
- being No. is of the twenty?.?
by Trauta*Baluaonnot, c
edited in 1871
Mr Drake took away the fourth book
1-espect to prie., from the 'englishman,
volume of J'ontanus from the library
Oroller, as demonsfrat.-?* by an autogra]
re on one of the leaves. The oth
man who managed to capture one of t
Jl.?'??'-.i?!d-mor.- variety wa? M. Hondheli
r? preset ting J. Haer & Co., of Krankfor
on-thf-Maln. on?- of who?? memtiers que
tiered the authenticity of an edition
Ovid purchased by Qeorge D. Smith, of th
city, the largest buyer at the sale la
? _. He took one of Fierre Dor?!
works, rrln?er] in Farls In li.40, In a roi
temporary landing of brown laoroeeo dec
with the arms of King Francis I
other books going to Mr. Quaritch wei
"De Bello P?rsico," I y Procopius. f<
? and a copy of Hygtnus*s "Fabularui
Liber" In old Italian brown morocco, f?
81,260. This nan one of those for whl<
.Mr. Quaritch opened with th?; only bl<
The total hid at the evening session w*
The opening session in the afternoon gai
little promise of the spirited round? of bk
wi i< h the .\et;iriK seaatun brougl
! of,k ?old for inore than ft,***
and only twenty landed on th? further si?.
UDO mark.
Arthur Hoe, .?on of the collector, atart?
the aooond pari of the sale of the enormoi
libran by capturing ?'?i-'-rt Abbott'a"Coo
i? History of Kriglsrid." London. lWT-'fi
with a bid of ?-'.. after th<- bidding ha
t>een opened by Arthur Swann. who kc<?
ta-ib on th? purehasara for the Anderso
company, at $V>. The interest was lax the
a complete file of "The Spectator," i
originally Issued bj St. ele and Addlsoi
with urn ?i? pagaa waa put up- Mr Swan
? d the ar_ument with a bid of $.A b'
* et\ under by rjenrg* I
Smith, the N'W York dealer, v. ho bougt
the famous Ginenherp Bible for Henry 1
Huntington last sprlnK; Walter M. HII
of Chicago, and Dr. Vf. A. Ros-snbach, ?
Philadelphia, bom extensive buyers a? th
farmer sale who carried the price up ?
The two volumes of gr<i*<n vellui
ln?o which th? papers are hound flnall
????r>t ?o Dr. Rosenbach. Besides th*. con
?ions of Addison and Bteele, the vo|
contain Pope.? *"Tbe Messiah." pub
? ?hen for the first time
The next fr^" of the sfterr.oo:, ses: io
v. SS -Hen f i a VOtmiM of .Ksop's Fabl*
probably printed by the prln?er of the im
jordanus de Quedlinburg at Strasburg
and rebcir.d by the c"ltih Blnd-ry. in whl<!
Robert Ho? was interested. It wen? to Mr
for H00 its price at the Huth sal
fome vears asro hiving been 877V Anothe
volume of a-Esop. from the press of Jacoi
de Fhortzhelm, 1V>1. was obtained hv Mr
Smith for ?4y> Richard Arnolds *'<*hronl
cle of I-r>ndon " catalogued asa peffOC
copv of the first edition, and notable fo
containing ?he first appearance in Engll--l
of tlM famous ballad. "The Nut Browi
Maid." was captured by Mr. Smith for th.
sum Of IMS, srmewhaf lo the surprise o
many In the audienc-, as the Huth ?*op;
sold for less tha-n ?1?V?.
John .lame? Audubon'i "The Birds o
Amerka." With five hundred colored plates
Jr. seven volumes, was sold for 1RS, whll?
Scribner paid $.*Tf? for a book .-ontalnlni
the plans of manv Of France's faSBOU
chateaus. published in Paris In IMH-lt
The total for the afternoon was $1<"?.??-3.
? ?i
WON'T DISMISS WILL CONTEST
Surrogate Wants Mere Proof in Case
of Miss Maria L. Campbell.
Surrogate Fowler refused yesterday to
dismiss the cont.?st of the will of Miss
Maria ?> Campbell and said that unless
proof was offered to offset the testimony
offered for the sixteeen contestants of the
will he WOUM have to take the case under
advisement. The Surrogate also intimated
that the burden of proof rested on the
relatives o," Miss ?"ampbeii, who offered the
will for probate.
jllss Campbell, whose home was at No.
:: Fifth avenue, left an estate valued at
la.'.?V?0,?X?i? to four first cousin?. The conten?
tion of the contestants is that Miss f?mp
bell, w?o was eighty-one years old when
,i . .1 ' ad long been la a weakened
condition snd was of unsound mind and
under undue Influence when she made her
will Howard Townsend. a lawyer, was
named as executor of the will, and his
mother r?**oeived a one-fourth ehare of the
p.t?te An affidavit was Introduced yes
, w hlch Townsend made In l'??4 in the
matter of 'nP transfer tax appraisal of
i?. ?--t;?i?- of Mi,*s '"??therlne B. ?"ampbeii.
u ?ister ?>. Ih'' *1?f4,?"rl*-. Wit? died at the
?.?re of seventy-eight. Townsend said in
th-i affidavit that Mias Maria L. Campbell
mum "mo feeble that she could neither dis
?i__ nor tranaact he^business."
HUNTER KILLS HIS OWN SON.
Ithaca. N. T ? J*in 8 --Michael Sheridan
shot hi? fourteen-year-old son. Martin F?l
ward through the right lung, killing lilm
Instantly, while hunting rabbits to-day. The
v?w who was starting the game from
?-?u_h heapsT ran U-tween the Klln and a
ra bit and the father's heavllv ?loved hand
? iu Vi?? change- the direction of the barrel
in Un?a.
PRISONER HELD HERE FOR $375,000 BANK ROBBERY.
JOHN M ?AMARA. DETECTIVE REILLT,
Said lo be head of gao?; whl.h rubbed the Wh" mide the ?rr.-t
Bank of Montreal
? nui.nurd from Aral pea'.
cards When he deposited th<?m with hi?
lunik they were conflsi ated, as they bore
the serial numbers of p<?me of the st"l>-n
?urreii-v
When Mi Nnm.ir.? was arrested lie de>
mandetl that his captor? show their
?bielda This ?lone, he asked If th.\
a warrant for his arrest. Assured they
had, be ask?-<! ?artist he was charged
with. Being told, he exclaimed:
"Is that ell? I thought it wa? son?
thing mor?- Mrious."
When Ml ?amara was searched et l'o.
Ilos Headquarters 11,100 in American
money was found In his pocket!
one r?-nt In Canadian monev was dis?
covered. <?r a tingle scrap of inerlmi
natinn svtdenca
Aftei lie gsve his piare of birth hs
Melbourne. Australia, his iifte as fort/
riin?-. aii.i said he cams to this country
twenty-live yean sgo, he whs ??skid
what he did for s living.
"I am a manager and a traveller,'" t> -
pli?d McNamara.
"Wbere ursre yof on tin- mgin of B ;
tember 14, when the bank w?*a robbed?"
asked Deputy Commissioner Dougherty.
His Defence an Alibi.
"1 was in Hi?- Strand Hotel,
couver, British Columbia," ?sold M -
?amar.t.
Th-- tWO fine? i,te sboul twsnt)
mibs apart.
"What were you d? in? there?" asked
Dough? rty.
"Haven'i i ? right i? travel? The
country la big. if you want to know
badly. I'll tell yoo I wsa looking for a
f-iiitabl?? hotel .? t<
MoNargara'a onl3 known hot?i expe?
rience was ?acquired m running ? notori?
ous resotl In Bsi Fi ncisco known si
"The 7'irtle" during tlie Bchmitl Ruef
regime, when beei lei favors.
Later, in partnership ?Mth "Billy" <'?nl
lagher. be conducted another ?Jive called
"The Log Cabin," m 'Frisco's Tender?
loin.
_\n nr?<r\ as McNanars wa.i behind the
bars the ?poll?* searched his home in
Fort Leo, 1."ping to Und a cache of the
stolen currency there, but without SUC?
cess
The ?robbery of the New Westnainster
branch of the Montreal Hunk was the
most daring and one of the biggest rob?
beries In North Amerb-a There was
only one hlgpri r-n this continent that
Of th* old Ocean Bonk, at Fulton and
Greenwich ptreets, In this city, during
the early dags of Inspector Byrnes. AI
that time about {"?tgi/iiwi was stolen,
wrecking the institution. The robbers
were bead?! by the notorious Qsorgl
Bllsa
Most of the money stolen from the New
?Westminster Bank was In $."< and $1<>
notes. Some $'_',">, $.V? and $100 notes
were also stolen, and ? considerable
quantity of gold.
The hank had received a large con
signnient of notes of the smaller denomi?
nation that dav. These did not bear the
signature- of the bank officials when
stolon.
F?ur Men Did the Job.
The robbery itself showed expert work
Four men, two believed to be a i off/man
and McNamara. entered the bank, evi?
dently liy means of a duplicate key.
They first went t?> a room on the M
Door, wlorg s clsrk usually slept. Bui
h>- was out for I he evening.
Then they went to work with picks
and crC-1 ars until they had made a hole
through the brick wall surrounding the
vault, sud with the name tools broke
through a thin cast Iron lining that etoo.l
hetweei them and the ?aie.
Next they drilled holes In the safe,
which they filled with nitroglycerine.
This was exploded by charging the safe
with an electric current from one of the
electric lights in the p|a<?e.
The gang had worked so carefully and
had so deadened the explosion by cover?
ing the safe with rugs taken from the
bank officers" rooms that a ?policeman
who lived next door heard nothing.
They worked uninterruptedly until 4
o'clock In the morning. Then the Chi?
nar, watchman ?ame in to clean up.
They seized him, bound and gagged
him and tied him to a post In the base?
ment. After an hour he wriggled out of
! his bfinds and Kave ?he alarm.
The gold and currency they packed
Into ticking, sheeting and pillow slips
taken from the clerks bed.
Th?y stob' an^-?uiomc'blle from a gar?
age of a nearby houiie, but it broke
down with them after they had gone
two blocks It waa supposed they then
carried the gold ar.d currency tu a
launch they had.waiting In the Fri
River, and made their ?scape.
Some Money Recovered.
The robber.?- fourni it nocoaear.
cn<h<- til,????!? of the stolen money ui
a wooden sidewalk in New Westmln:
whl? h was recovered ?>n Novembei
, last. Twelve days earlier the pollc
jtiiat city fourni $3r..??-??0. one-third in f*
hlddcn und.-r the bridge spanning
?Yas.-r I'lv?-r.
Three days after the robbery a 1
was found In the Chinese quarter of \
.ouver. having the time of his life, sp*
Ing money right and left. He bad ?
? when arraatod. All of the mo
was r??rt of th?- proceeds of the ?
Westminster Hank robbery. He
j Found It ??ti the road, not far from
j hank, whore th?- robbora dropped It.
The Plnkertona who were retained
the Canadian representattvea >.f l?nn
Lloyds, who had injured the bank aga
robbery, eenl braa?k*_at ?.v?-r the w<
descriptions of ih?* stolen currency v
? ?-rial number. A rewar?l "f |i>
olTe-red for information lending
the arrest of th.- guilty parties snd
j , r cent Of ?he value of th?. notes
ihelr r?
Baatdea his two arrests In this e
McNamara ha* also i-'.-n arre '"d
Booten, Cleveland. I^ulsville and tw
In San Franrls.-o. When arrested
laOiilsvllle he was In Ih.? Insurau<??? Ba
accompanied bj two w?-u known ba
sn?-ik thi.\es. Herman D?iehm i
i'eorge Carton, in McNamara'a pock
I he iH)lt<e t>> ind two wire prongs, in
In r ?Clin*, money through the wire m?
.shi'-r's cape
M? ?aman is listed as a bank sue
1 thief and profeasdonal burglar by poi
h.-r?- Deputy <'ommls.-|.>n<-r Doughei
I said McNamara COUld a's?. probably t
[something about the numeroua ??_
blowings In this city during the last ?
weeka In each Instance the Mr
method was used as In the lowing
: the New Westminst? r vault.
The other man arrested in the case,
F. Hoffman, has served several terms
prison for bank robberies. ?>n Novemb
11. 1.?i7. he was in a park in Reatt
With Homer .T. Mlnot and Edward Rat
gan. two notorious hank robbers, wh?
the "soup," as nitroglycerine is known
the underworld. e:.ploded in th? leathi
lag in which Ratlgnn rnrrien. it. Rat
gan was instantly killed.
Ta?->s Ange|e?. .tan I?A man who said I
was ?'. H Howard was arrested by d<
te,-fives here to-day for alleped compile!!
in the robbery of the Bank of .Montreal, i
N'.w Westminster.
a
WAIVES EXTRADITION RIGHTS.
Winnipeg. Man, Jan. S?Charles Ros?
who was arrested here with bonds to tf
value of $.*V),??a in his possession and wr
' has been missing since the robbery of A. .
Bancroft. In New York, on March 2 las
when charged In police court to-day wit
the theft, admitted he was the man wante
In New York and declared he would fores
extradition formalities. Consul ?Jener
Jones asked that the prisoner he remande
for one week, pending the arrival of Ir
strurtlons from New York. H- said officer
would arrive to take Rn?, back to Stan
trial.
WOMEN CLUBBED TO DEATf
Planter Murderously Aasaulted
Wife and Her Mother Slain.
Memphis, Jan. ".?Mrs. Kate Carpente;
and her mother. Mm. Davln, were killen*
and M. P. Carpenter, a wealthy planter
was probably fatally injured, by a band oi
five or six white men, who beat the womer
to death and left the man for dead at th?
Carpenter home, near Blythevllle, Ark., last
night.
There was a knock for admittance at thf
front door of the Carpenter home shortly
?"?afore midnight '"arpenter answered It.
and as he opened the door he was felled by
the man presumed to have led the hand.
The two women were the next objects of
attack. It appeared they made desp?.rat?>
resistance before being clubbed to death.
Furniture was demolish?-, window hang?
ings were torn Into shreds and glass and
bric-ft-brac wer? smashed m If a terrirle
hand-to-hand encounter had ptaeedei the
deaths of the two women.
Neighbors chanced to vlalt the planters
home to-day, and discovered the bodies of
the two women and Carpenter in a serious
condition, rhyslclsns were summoned, and
Carpenter was revived long enough to gasp
out detalla of the attack. Iaater he lapsed
Into unconsciousness, and his death !a mo?
mentarily expected.
Reporta from Blythevllle say the attack
against the Carpenters 1b due to the en?
mity borne Can-enter by certain amall
farmers in the neighborhood.
_?
PRIVATE DETECTIVE CONVICTED.
Oeorge King, a private detective, of No.
tV- West 151st street, who was Indicted for
attempting tu extort $5,?XX> from Mrs. Fay
Lewi? Tysen. wife of ^?bcn F Tysen. a
rich broker, was convicted by a Jury be?
fore Justice Davis. In the Crlrnlnal Branch
of the Supreme Court, yesterday. The Jury I
??.us out fifteen minutes? __
c.
Philanthropist Is Guest of the
Sphinx Club at Dinner.
LETTER FROM PRESIDENT
Praised for His Work for the Up?
lift of Negro and Education
in the South.
Dr. Robert C. '>gden, who was resident
member of the firm of John Wanamaker
during the organization of Us business in
this city, and who ha.-? been one of the most
ardent and successful workers for the up?
lift of the negro race and the educational
advancement of th?- South, was honored
in an unusual manner last night hy the
Sphinx i"lub at a dinner given at the Wal?
dorf. Three hundred men, representing
every phase of th?- successful ouslness
of the metropolis, joined ir, paying tribute
to th?- man whose work has stampe?! itself
upon present dav philanthropy and busi?
ness development. Many letters were re?
ceived from all parts of the country ex?
pressing the high regard in which Dr.
0?gden is held everywhere.
President Tsft, In a letter, said he had
more than an ordinary regret In not being
able to attend the ?linner. The President
then wrote:
It would have been a pleasure to have
Joined you In ?paying tribute to the work
of Rob'-rt Curtll Ogden, In Whose honor
I understand the .?inner Is giv.-ri. Hks
?UCCeBI as s man of business, followed by
I sai personal interest which he has
shown in philanthropic and educational
affair?*, gives him a hit-b rank as a helpful
American citizen.
There Is no man whose self-sacrificing
efforts In behalf of th.- humble and helpless
of his fellow men deserve as much
stinted praise a? Robert Ogden. I know
what 1 am talking about, and I am ?glad
to say this
1 '?? "re B Van Cleve, president of the
Sphinx Club, presided at th.? dinner, and
Job K Hedges wielded the gavel of the
tosstmsster. The tributes to in-, ogden
were opened with an appreciative t?Mresa
delivered bj the Rev Dr. lb Ills B Frls
sell, who spoke on "Robert c Ogden,
i of White and Flack. Who Has
Brought from the North Peace and flood
Will Into the Southland."
Dr Frl.-s. II reviewed the career of Dr.
. gden, and gave an ac? ount ?if the actlvi
i ? lp extended by the guest of honor toward
the work Of the Hampton Instituts and
the Educational Alliance.
Dr. Walter H. Page was then introduced
te [?resent to Dr. ?>gden the beautifully en?
grossed resolutions of the Sphinx t'luh,
which made him ut? honorary member Of
the club for life in appreciation of his
many achievements.
"I can say about the guest of honor,
whom I will Introduce now." said Mr.
Hedges, (Then the turn came for Mr. OgdSS
to respond, "that he Is so normal that he
bas not to be peculiar In order to attract
the attention ?>f his fellow men."
Dr. <)gtl?-n ??xprssssd his thanks for the
honors received, and spoke briefly about
advertising as the topic uppermost In the
minds of th? members of the sphinx Club.
He then turned te social and political ?jues
t'.ons. an?I said:
With US a period of ?nd striai <lvll war
? .-ms to exist. Politics are seething with
? on?*ernlng big business, the
"money trust," whatever that may mean,
itlons of big corporations, legisla?
tive Investigations, regulutlon of railroads
and other agitations. Much confusion Is in
the uir and some Of our friends would, in
tl.??'.r utixl- ty for reform, utterly ruin and
destroy th? ?goose that lays the golden egg
nu.I would leave us with only Che broken
empty shell of success and prosperity.
All thts conduct!, us t?i one leading QUOS
thal commands the attention of all
'. the much talked of. per
? commonplace, question of the reia
Hon ol capital and labor. The time has
! when a slngl? man. alone In his of
ttle what his workmen shall be
paid for their labor The workman has
som-thlng to s?iy about that. He Is not ai
A , reasonable and Just, but he hns a
Itlon ami must be heard.
Has labor any moral rigtus in a success
?ful business over and at ove the market
rr|.?e of Its service, which we assume has
sei paid?
I believe il has such a right?a moral
equity In the net prurits-and I do n
thai the full application of the Golden
Rule will have ! een made until that obli?
gat!?.n lias been re.-ogntzed and paid
How Is this condition to be met" Pimply
hv the conscience of the man. or the men.
In control <>f the results. Put the whole
sum In a tr tat fun?l Let each participant
have Ins bank b"?.k showing th? amount to
his credit ?'reate a board of tr'ist.-es and
let the money of each participant be sub
J. ? to draft at a certain age.
fou will find that ownership, absolute
and pure, with delayed t?o-?ess!on. will
rrove a character buildlntr influence of the
BIMt conservative sort To own and care
for money Is th? '?????on our work?
ing people need to learn
Other speakers were Artem.is Ward,
Manlev I. fJillam. Pr. brick J. Gibson. W.
R. Hotehkin. H B Harding ?nd James
O'Flaherty Seated at the guest table also
were Borough President M<\\neny. Dr. Al?
bert Shaw. Wilton Merle Smith. William .T
Schieffeitn. fJoorge a Wilson, Herben r,
Brldgman. Willis D. Wood and w J
Ifatheson
Among those present were rolone) Willis
L Ogden, Arthur C. .Tsmes. F S Dellen
ha ugh. Frederick Trevor HUI, Jach H
Schiff Prend! t? Hlne, Stephen Baker,
Isaac N. Sellgm.'in, Collin Armstrong.
Sereno s Pratt, n. L, Btoddard, George
P Sheffield. Preston P T.vnn, Robert
Nixon. B J Green hut. J. I, Kesner. W. H
Putnam, Adolph S Ochs. Arthur Oreives.
Bernard F. ?Umbel, Charles J Brooks.
Charles Schultz, Robert W, de Forest.
James YersencS, ?Bogene Delann, George
J. Benjamin, H A. L, Hogtiot, O J Gude.
Louis S. Glmbel, Samuel Brill. John N.
Crulkshnnk, Charles H Green. Franklin
Simon and S. H. Hollander
TO NAME CENSOR OF SKATING
Alleged Experts, with Permits to Use
Conservatory Lake, Can't Stand Up.
A censor of skating Is to be appointed by
Park Commissioner St.iver. This step Is
made necessary because the Commissioner
has opened the Conservatory lake to expert
skaters, who must get permits to skate on
Its surface. So far fifty or more permits
have been granted, supposedly to experts.
Put Captain ?arson, of the park police,
went to see the Park Commissioner yester?
day because he said some of those who had
permits were not able to skate.
On Sunday when all the other lakes were
closed, hundreds of skaters noticed the
chosen few using the ?.'onservatory lake. All
with a rush put on their skates and were
soon on th?? ice. Captain Carson ordered
the police to clear all the skaters off. There
were so many demonstrations of poor skat?
ing, the captain said yesterday, that he put
It up to the Commissioner to find a means
of determining whether those who got
permits were experts. One of the officials
of the department will have the Job of
censor.
There was skating on all the lakes in
Central Park, as well as In Van Cortlaudt
Park and Prospert Park.
e
KILLED BY FALL OF THREE FEET
Driver Tossed from Truck When Foot
Is Caught in Loop of Rope.
Henry Gaygell. a driver, was killed yes?
terday by falling from his truck, a distance
of three feet, his head striking the paving
blocks with force sufficient to fracture his
skull, while he was engaged in unloading
freight at Canal street and the Hudson
River. He died before the arrival of an
ambulance from the Hudson Street Hos?
pital.
The driver got his foot caught In a loop
of rope used to hoist freight and was j
dragged from his truck and tossed head- j
down against the pavement. He weighed I
200 pounds, was forty-five years old and
lived at No I02u Jamaica avenue. Long ?
inland City. ......_? -, ___ '___ - *1
SUES CITY FOR $50,000
Woman Charges Husband Was
Slain in Bellevue.
Mrs Catherine Monihan. of No. M?*? West I
Houston street, has tiled a eult for "_?).Oa0
against the city of New York for the death
of her husband, John Monihan. who, she
allog' a, was killed by one of the orderlies:
lr, the psychopathic ward of Bellevue Hos?
pital in IS*-. Mrs. Mon"?_n was examined
ye.-terday before trial.
She testified that Moniha.l vsas a dock
laborer employed by the Cly^ Steamship
Company. In November, 190.. h.., "**?ind be?
came affected, and he was sent to the psy?
chopathic ward. He escaped and returned
home, saying that he cculd not sleep on
his bed because it had no springs and that
the attendants had tried to strap him ??own.
Monihan was sent back to the hospital.
Mrs. Monihan said she visited her husband
on November 21 and found him covered
with bruisf?. He died six hours after the
\islt of his wife.
JoJ;n Foley was a patient in the wavl.
and when he came out he told Mrs. Moni?
han what he had seen and heard. He de
clared he saw an orderly washing >o;ne
blood from his hands and heard him sa\.
with an oath, to tne cook, "I fixed him.
Frley told her, Mrs. Monihan said, that
the orderly had broken his wrist giving to
Monihan the beating that, it Is alleged
caused his death.
9\ ley will be a witness for Mrs. Monihan.
The city has made a general denial, and
saya further that it is not responsible, be
on use the board of trustees of Bellevut
took charge of the hospital in 1902.
CAN'T DEFINE INSANITY
.Alienist Says No Two States
Have the Same Views.
At the annual meeting of the New York
Society of Medical Jurisprudence, at the
Academy of Medicine, last night. Dr. Smith
Buy Jelllffe, who was an alienist in the
Thaw trial, read a paper on "Paranoia an?}
the Law."
"We should shake off these symbols in
medicine." said the doctor, "for they retard
rather than help advance the science of
medicine. The symbol that I am going to
attack to-night is that one of insanity. To
the medical profession there Is no ?ucli
thing as Insanity. In one state It is de
fined one way. and In another state an?
other way. .No two states define It th?
same. How can any one have a reasonabl?
Id a of what Insanity really la with auch t
difference of opinion?"
Dr. Jelllffe then said that there used t.
THE
VANDERBILT
HOTEL
34th St. E. at Park Ave.
NEW YORK
Opens January 10,1912
In Residenti- dismct on
Murray Hill. Four minui?*
from NY. Cent.. NY.. N. H.
y H. and Pt-nna. Stations, in
the heart of the theatre and
shopping di*trict Surjway aa
ticn adtoir.tng the hotel.
Singl. Ro-m ??Ih both?$3.$4.
85 and $6 per dav.
Doulale Room with beth ? $5.
$6. $7 ar- 58 per dev
DouMe Bedroom wilh boudoir
or drev.inp-room and t?*tb?$7.
$8.8-.. ?IO andSI. p?*f day.
Suite?.?5-1 on. IJedroorri and
jiS.i?r> 110. $12. $13 and $?9
be a time when all diseases of the brain
were labelled Insanity. One that figured
for some time was paranoia. Borne years
ago. he said. 80 per cent of Insanity case?
were called paranoia.
To-day less than 1 per cent of insanity
cases were bo called. A new disease, so
called "dementia Precox," had become to
the medical world what parsnola used to be.
DENY INTERBOROUGH DEAL
Settlement Not Near Solution, 8ay
Prendergast and McAneny.
In regard to a report from Wall Street
yesterday that the city was about on the
point of coming to terms with the Inter
borough and would agre? to guatrantee thst
company more than 8 per cent on the total
amount of its Invested capital, both Con?
troller Prendergast and Borough President
McAneny said the problem waa no nearer
solution that It waa last wreck.
There are several pointa of difference be?
tween what the Interborough wants and
what the city repr?sentatives feel would be
fair and these matters will be thrajihed
out further at a conference, nrobably with?
in a day or two.
SUNDAY'S NEW-YORK TRIBUNE
Mailed snywhsre in the United States
for $2.50 a yesr. _ ..
Bin.;JI^^^m?^r^^TTT^^.^?rr^![!fm??H^m^^m^i^T?rTT/T7TTmTr^^ffmI:!
S
p ?
Flints Fine ?^?mture
PRICE REDUCTIONS.
In order to gain room for our new Spring
and Summer Furniture, we have made material
reductions in our several departments on single
pieces and suites which we shall discontinue.
During the month of JANUARY patrons
may secure "Flint Quality" Furniture at from
10% to 50% below regular prices.
Every piece is guaranteed by the Flint
Trademark and
r :
.- 1
E
A COMPARISON OF PRICES
IS INVITED
GeqCFLintCo ?
We*t ?*??$? I
IJTjn?itU?^iMf?M ' .n!!I!:!?f!!!?I?!!?lf;ii]
We New
Jjocomotile
Little Six
A Little Six with 60 Horse Power
and
Equipped with 10-inch Upholstery
Ready for demonstration and dtv
livery. Brand New Model. On exhibi?
tion this week at Madison Square
'Jarden Automobile Show.
A large portion of the output of thig
Model has already been sold, without
a single deinoti?tration having beea
made.
The Locomobile Company of America
Broadway and 76th Sir?**, New York
Norton N. J. Dette*
GREENE MOTOR CAR CO
SS .Vulilaf ton St..
Newark. S. J.
B-wkt-f-n DstVtn.
I. A. REIISON MFG. OOj
WO AcAtort Ata,
Brookiym. N. T.
Yoakrr?. N. T. D?i: ?OSS a HIBBARD.
WHIM riaatn. X. T, niilm OOM MOTOR CO.