Newspaper Page Text
, Jto'i *m ftxibunt Vw LXXIII.N0 24,418. To-d-j>. lair nnd . tmlrr. Tomiimm, 1.1. rnixnc , Innilnf... NEW-YORK, TUESDAY, SEPTEMBEB 23, L913.-16 PAGES. * * Vork. Jeraer Tit? anel Hoboken. PRICE OM'e l b> I KI/?r.BHF.RK TflO CF.NT* OF BY 51 IO 1 VOTE Court Decides in Secret Session That Assembly Had Right to Prefer Charges at Extra Session. MUST NOW STAND TRIAL President Cullen Leads Way in Long Opinion Sustaining Con ter.tion of Prosecution That Action Was Entirely Legal. WENDE VOTES BY HIMSELF Buffalo Democrat Only One to Raisc His Voire in Governor'R Favor? Louis Marshall's Argumrnt for Defencc Anpwered hy Parker and Brackett. . \- ? Bept. 22 By i 3. tbe Hlgn Courl of Impeacbaaeni nor Sulze-r ha,'. ? cnlly. The only VOl rii-i ? ? ca.-t by Benator ? - taken b"/ th- l " lagtatativf rnveatlgatlng comm Zr- ? priaaary <ampaign commil - .. ? | v ... . b taken in executh i uring ?i n1 by ihe Bulaer dafcnce. The rakfi the ronstitution from Ft.-m to ir trying to prove that tha A - 4 lOrtty in adoptmr ? ? ? irdlnan aet : ich a**tlon waa recomtnei ? HaaahalL ff the Bulaer did not coaataa himself excl 'iia: argnrn'T* I I '???' ihe frST ??.. BBOBB uf :. e?-ho of the 'i' - fcnce before the t~ mply the \ ietim of Tam | that dellvery ? ?f impaachaai nrt I the Praai-laail of the Be ? BOt legal ? -' " top nf hli ? ? -? -. ? - nient i OUld i ? be> pres'-nted to the ' on 14 a Yr.rk or at the throne ? Tielnionlee, s and make thal ? D hment."' Judge Cullen Leads the Way. B ? neitber the conatl I irgi m<r--- for Bulaer nor this allusion to Tammany weigh*d with tha OBUil ti* for> tht- rxfuiive Beaakm Praaldent n announeed that he had made up his rr.ind aad was quite wUltag I noun^?? his opinion if any body a :?. -:iO'igh he did BOt wlah to rule ?'ti the rjuestion. hut would rafer it I t Apparently his hrother ju'ig- - i with him even befora baa "pin u>r waa ezpreased, '?r in the eaecutlve sest-.on the rollcall showed each oif-ni '?r-nc "n< " nri the BSOtiOn tO Jla rnlBs tha impeachment proceedmk--. Judge Oillen w; tha d ? -. ' r of tha eaurt to d Ihe questloa at alL When hlfl ti'im. waa <<;i<h<>!l oa the rollcall lie said lhat oa had to be Inten r'a- nata aad that u would i. raaaonabla to bald. aj= did the E aade, that the Xaaarnbl*/ convenad In extraordlnary session waa dabarr**d from .n.j eaehintr th?- Qavemor, .1! be probably one further ?" rg .nu-nt of the samf- nature preserited. lt ia on the BChadule that i>. i.'adv H?rr.ck will ask the court to rule all thf- nrtlcles of impeachment charg ing Bulaer with aarjurjr and thefi of eampnign conttlbutloofl r-n tho ground that an official la not liabh- le> im lunent for acta commltted before f nntlnncl on Bi?.tt. pagr. Hflh ruluinn. This Morning's Sews Z.OCAX. Ma '-4 f.-jrney to Orave ln Bunahlae 1 : t Trj te Boaa < on- ai tion . l p ii Balllvan. . i .ra\e Mark-* QajTBOl Blllial. 2 ? I un> ral llalts City s Pulae. 3 i.Hiid gwlndla. 3 Bot* in I'.Hho.-ifi Arbitration 3 i Mooae In l illemma .. 6 I iddish Bard Uead ? 7 Lafi vnnulty foi Hla Bhoemaker, ..11 Three Kllled In Long laland Ifc'reel 16 16 OENERAL Held Valld.. - Kamlly al l oaoord. 3 1 Noi to Haar Baakei 4 1 ?"?? hllej Ac. UM.^ Mulhall of Hold-UP 4 mie Tax Adopti ?' 4 Coloaibtan Oranl. 6 te Trata; Klll i-im o L-aboi i nloni 6 raal Kariai 7 FOKEION !' ,.'!* i ??ni I >n,? nlOB ... 1 ?-' li'iol .... 6 MISCELEABTEOUeJ. W??tet*-I> . 7 MA i I ? . 8 ?eelaty . 9 Dhttttary. 9 l . 9 . io and ii Bhipplng . ll . ll .11 *1t*an< ial aad . a, 13 and 14 r't*J Eatata. m j 1.500 PUPILS ON STRIKL j Syracuse Girls Climb Out Win dows to Join Movement. By Telee*aph i I ? Byraetiae, sept '_"j. ?? ? ',.en hundred atudeata of the thre- hisrh jerhoota hert marched oW during and were Indefinltely auapended. There were many iz;H< among them, aad al] are atrtking on aecounl of the lonp hours, short lun?h ? "r mtermiaaion and |m> r luncheoo accommodationa The dally Beaaton formerlj ended al 1 p. m., bal was rhanged to 2:80 p. m bj Buperin* tenden' Hughea j The strikcr* parad'-d th^ | latraeta wlth horna blowlng. a'i n mg Thi leadera aay thej wlll nol re? turn to-morrow and are , if petltlon in preaem i>. tha Board of Educa ? The majortty nf atudenta Btru ... bul at th.- Technlcal Hlgh Bchool more than half refuaed ln th.- atrll Thii^,- that Btrock there had t-. break !" c-' oul and man; i limhed out of th-- wlndo ? ? MOURNS GAYNOR: SUICIDE | Mayor's Friend Hangs Himsclf at Time of Funeral. Griel ? ? nw a y ii- .-!? h. i ? . ommIt i fternoon Hla i" ? found nglng fn ? i n a barn li ? ., \ ? nui v haiw ? waa i 1- a j : frotii a beam aa Metaf a atam man f'-.m \)if ? ? flral rai ? ; and occaeionallj found tj Hall oi intry home. w hi n thi Mi ? ? lo lay pli . when - Mi ? . I thi n' ? ... of in thlng \. almoal thi ra the Q ? ' ? liurn and AUTO PLAY KILLS A CHILD ? Boys Start Truck While the Chauffeur Is Away. ? ? tr)e aeat v the drlvei ? a di Ing a ge, ran di wn and kllle l threa -year-old Herberl Feli u | ln em . al No. 1050 i al nlght. The d off aad dlaappeared. aad ...- dltcbed Iteetf h ? ' iffeura i n m ga tbe drtver lefi and began t" work th<- gi ? i .... moka from ? ? bi th< I iined mo ?proup of "h'.idi- ii B do/.- n away. The Pelnburg bo: mn '-ni of its path and the car knocked him down ik- r ? fracture of the *kuii and hla ne< k broken. .\ hook and ladklei - omi ar ? ,a him tr, ii. 11,? gUlly. Th' tre looktai foi the two bo knov. thi name f otu. MACMILLAN WRITES PEARY Crocker Land Explorer Says Esquimaus Prosper. Portiand Ma, iept. 22.*-Proap< - I among 11 ? Eaqulraaua thua far ? i re|,ort.-.l by ' ? leader of the Croker Land ezploratlon iarty. In a letti formei i blef, Rear Adralral Rob< rt i:. Pean ? The letter recelved lo di Etah, the wlnter beedquarti i rl L'.v ??The Beqalou.ua ar?- all bapp: ? ? tly proaperoua, plent) of food and ga MacMlllan wrote, "ll ai gettlng ia?e BOa and fM-./.mc Blgbta." hi ad j "and wa bava wahrua ta bJlL II i oound (Smith) bri gka out, i ahal to run oi ? ' lha powei ; to < ape Babini, I egpecl to lub fl ; dog teams ir. th. aprlng " ;too late to' SEE FATHLR - 1 Asserablyman Escapes from Legislature as Parent Dies. Aaaemblyman TJtotnaa Lane, of thi :;:;,; Dlatrlct, la Tba Bretfi home from Alban: yeaterday m ai ? jfort to aea bia fathei ? bo ? akull had ? ?., ? : .-.J in an ai cldent, bul 81 - rlved al tha Ltncoln Hoepltal a few Imlnutea after hib father'a death ?'' ,. . ..; .i t.-i< gram on Pi kda . whlle in tha Aaaembly i hambei Inforni Ing him of tnt- aoddenl and he applied to sp. gaai Bmltb for a leavi aence, bul it '.'as refuaed owlng to bllla i baarlag on tha bnpeav hmt nl of Oov. Bulaer belng before tbe Ai aem* Ibly. ; On fhinday, boweyer, Aaaemblyman i..,,,. mapaged to break awaj from tbe chaaibar. Ha bM """ '" ,a" through th< atreeta lo tb< lUttan aued bj aevi ral eergeanta al arme, and oaught a traln for Nea k*orl futber, .loiin Lane, who ??^ Bf ly.twn ye*n old, waa loreman ln the ,? ,.... v'crgne Iron Worke, al UMtli ? Bnd L-oeaai avenue. H? , ?? the head bj an Iron beam Th funeral wlll be held to-morron at Jt Rochea Chureh. al 180th atreel and Robbma avenue._ RIVER STEAMER HITS A DEER. Nvwbargh. N- v. iepl , |; odell on her up IrlP ??*< evanln* ?truck a buckdeei wlth epreadtag antien intbe .laon Rlvei oH I. ' ?'"" lh ,,..,.. waanotbadl) han " "wntotbe and dlaappeared la tbe a. PHOTOGRAPH ol GAYNOR FUNERAL SERVICKS IN TRINITY GHURCH. u ry ?SES HIS FISIS Senator Fitzgerald's Men D>. feat "Larry" Mu'lifjan for One of "Bicj TimV Placcs. FIGHT FOLLOWS THE VOTE Tcst Oomei When "Unknowr" Is Put Up for Oommitl Job?FaVil to Pick Con gresi Candidate. i of Tll ' ? ? I two I ? in thi ' i ? ? .; . d of th,- I ?? . John ' ? Tlm i??' ??'?' '-? and now the n overlord of the "Sull ']-,i. -.. the Iroubli ? betwi en "Paddj " B illlvaui and Fitsgi r mentaily ;,,, onopi tenl \ ? '?' the 'i ammap Hall 3d gonl; ? ihe 13th ' l ? >,'?-. toi ' Bla Tim ;? ? The ? andidi bowi ver. ? ' .. agree ? Bu1 a ?< I-'' ' '' '' la* t,, the narnlng ot th didati ounced thi ,vould l?e UKi n t" ."" "' lill ??(?..| T ' '" "" """- ' "'' loroml tee-o Wlth Al< ' : . hlp, the in- Ui alled ,, 0reli ? and a ouoi im ? Id l ,, th. ruJl ol the rommlttei * ' ??'"" '" '"""' ' ,.(,H w, re th. niin ' lha Pullivan rfian I '?" r; ? Ul|l ... Tlm'B" hall brothei , |I.!'T V-, '"' "lil"1' ,!..,- i.. i, ? ii'1 aJdara nny" w rilte. '"'"' ' '?'' " '" confi ? ""' ,h"" Ihe Blate * ??- Pr< P ir"'1- '" ,?,i,,,i, v. i. mi b Bdherenta o1 the ,...,. ,.,,, apparenth the pro rlin -tii ainl dried. t ?Ltlaard aa riath aaaaa. aaiaad aadaaaa. PUCCINI NARROWLY ESCAPES DROWNING I omposer Rescued from Motor Boat After It ls Badly Damaged in Collision >n Lakc Ncar His Villa I -. n h ? og hia i a not her motor ng ""? ? ? ? 1 and hia fan II . luly, ln ? H of the i ra ?' ... But> .. :i> . hia | .? II.I. Wli.. known foi THE SOUTH SHIVERS Yestcrday Was FJorida s Cool est Beptember Day. Kla.. flepl d i... thla ?n?. i. mperature dropped to ? im the day, thi ool -. ,,,i,. i .1 , I.-.,-. i. the toi . \ ., Bepl 52. Th< Bl H ' ? ????'' ntornlng. . lorted KyiLSQW in 50-cirvr seat Prcfers Place in Balcony to Prcsidcntial Box. V., , , . ., b) hla brother-ln .., Btockton Axaon, and Dr. , g. x vaudevlll. i-'"'".' thl _.T from a ,0 rt-nl ??>< I" "" '"?-, !,il,,""t"i> WHaon doea no, U ,, ?i.,,,,..v. ?'hl .....up,... b M. ...??I-? .nnli| 4-, | HO U"?nl -I \ l* v- "' ia from H ?? ""'",."lr"1 , ?,. ln tbe -ircheatra or hajcony. ' \,, rhm-lv. Ke.mewhal to the dl ma s.-,., Hervtee .n alioae duty puarel him. ho inaiata >mlHV ordinarj aeal and taktng hla ??oundedbj Btrangera although ,.,,i, ha? a frtend on ctthei aioa. ANGOSTURA BlTTERSl'.v.n'- IB **f ? ,.,,. ,,., i aaUag.- Ailu. ' . in th.- l'nlted Htal ? t and Inl had rathi ? ? ? not t .;.-!! it arhi ni. n." x ' ' and kindi WOMAN LEAVES MAN DEAD Pohce Tliink Slayer Was "White Slave' Victim. Thi * "in1 ti ^ 'i in runntng through !. i l I Ti I. atreet, on m a Ith ? * ? ? - volver in her hand, guided u\>> ;,,i i. men t" the i 01 m r of rhli i ? niKhi Tbei ? . i>-*?ar_i downward in ihe mudd) gu tbi i.I ? li.ii.. blood Bowing :i.in. lila in ad The polli ? mi n ? alled an ambul i, um i>. Ilei ue, and ti..- aurgeon made .i hi 1.1' i tamlnal lon of tha bod;, Pha man waa di ad from h large ua.HI i let, which entered his moutfa and ? .uu" .1 the neck al the baae of tbe ikulL Tbe j'oii' i r. in.>\ .-,i tbe body to lha ' i&ai t -"-'<i lon .' nd ad to * ,; ii uu thi ? lea of lh? flei Ing woman. iietecilv< ? Ih.u ii'..- ? . ii.<- "white alave" varletj and that tbe man mel hli di ath uI thi handa ol a . um or aome woman a hom ha made Jeeloue. alng madi l an i arlj houi thla mornlng lo i lear up th. ktentlty "f th? dead m...;. Tbe .had man waa about 3 foel ,"i : i - * li. ? uii hla, k bair and . j ea, and B'l i in a bbich Bhtrt and cheap hia. k ckHhing. In hla ahlrtfronl lepin wlth tha Inltlabi "11. H.." and m a DjOCkel was a ranl.?i*.o with the carda of Andrew Laaruerto, No. 208 Baai 7th atreet, and Moaea T Barrowa, a lawyar, at No, o-" Broad* v\a>. 1: ni boss cmrffiKinN Leader Persuaded to Give Up klea of Dominatmrj State G. 0. P. Session To-day. WERNER FOR CHIEF JUDGE Hi.s Nomination Secms Sure? Platform Will Approve Fusion and May Call for National Republican Meeting. William Barnee, Jr., chairman oi th*" i:. publican Btata Cotnmlttee, erill uol ... ,,, ,| m|| te the Btata convanUon .,, be held In Carnagie Hall lo day. After .-, ponfi " i,??? ai the Union Laague Club yeaterdaj afternoon aU diffaren aa . were amoothed ?? '. .,,,, N|. | t,, abando-i bl* pian to featura Aaaemblymaa Harold j. Hinman hia Albany lieuti nant, aa chairman of th. comratttee on reaolu tlana oi i" rmanenl , h.unu.u XI.ueal indldatea to bu< - .,.. ,| chlef Judge Culh n and U - ,;. Judge Oraj of the Coun of Ap ,,, ai.. m iii be foughl oul ni op*sn roii ? ventlon ln the avening. The chief ;, w||| be a eonteal between William i- W< rner, of Rochea ter, and Bi n i ? Bdgar Truman , ti , k.-n. "i Baratoga. There aeema to ;?. ,,,, doubi that W'.-rner wiii wln . B ? margln. Juatice Frank H. Hlacoca., of ?lyra , Bn<] Juatl. - r"n deriek i:. . *am. ,.t Brooklyn, wtll be tbe princtpal eon tendera for the aaaociate JusUcesluu. I,,,,,, ; ii, ndricka, the leader of Onon daga County, aaa been moal actlvt t ir His, ock, and II looked 1 fot nlght as though h< would laad his in.ui Want National Convantion. Apati from the platform, a. raaolu? tlon wtll be Introduced aaking the Re? publican Natioii.il < oinniitt.-.' to meet _t ,n .-.ni' date to make pfovtaaon for :,n . Ktraordlnary national convantkm. -fh? reaolutlon will adveeata thut aueh -, national convention noi only chaage th.- baala of repreaentaUon m tha >,.iiiherii atatea ln national conven tiona, bul alao chan*p tha vottag baata in tha national committoe. lt will he auggeated that membara ot tha na? tional .oinniitt.'e have irotaa acsardlag t,. the vobai caal by then- raapacUve atataa for lha laal Republican caadl clate for Prealdent, Chalrman Barnea la atrongl) oppoaed ( onllniir.l on lltiril paffr, fourth < olumn. J 10 GRAVE IS IN THE SUNSHINE Nature's Beneficent Mood Per mits New York City to Bury lts Executive with Im pressive Ceremonies. 15,000 IN LINE AT FUNERAL Rufus Gaynor Supports Mothci at Trinity Chureh. as He Did Hi3 Father in the Hours Before His Death?All of Family There. EX-PRESIDENT PALLBEARER Mr. Taft and Many Other Distin guished Men of the Nation Hear Bishop Greer Read Servicc? Bared Heads Along the Routc to Greenwood. The pilhlie of New Vork City PBld lts last trlbute to Mayor Oaynor n Q \\ blle fewer than a thousand om trould attend the funeral ln Trmity Chureh, bacaaae of the ihnlted Bpaca, hundreds of th< hore Bllent testimony tq the dead along ol march i f the funeral i ? The earlj morniag a-eal threatealag, bul Nature, ln beneficent mood inaad the akiea to i i aod the march to lha neve waa aaeTer H brlgbt aun, Th.- pleture wlthln tbe "'R'1 erched walia of Trinity. arbara urom'n- nl Bteri from all walka 11 Hfe - I ??*?* membera of the Oaynor family to ie I onor to the Mujor. araa bapreai The loa Intonatlon of the I lemnit) tbe ? omm tmertl. the muak of the greal orgaa tba chaata aad hymaa of lha etartT and . aridoa aad chll puactuated the atllmaea at totarvad in the bour and a nuarb r that the aer \ I.-. la The chajreb waa dhnlj Ibjhted. Bia tail .aiidies baraed on tha alur. three ,,n m-H'T aide of the Jewell Tha; onlj Hgh1 in the chu but ? ? ' - ' ? lou-h. d aad brfehtgndB tha blgb banks of rlcb Bow ran rn thi aaany Boral niaeea artdeb ,, ranati d ttv Bpa< e Mi-o-ind thi i oerrn. i.i ,,, the Mayor'a Bag. wlthoot a -angaa uud or hiossom. the beavy bron* cotBn lay at tbe oatraace of tba IchancaL The taega wraath of oreMtfa, the th.ral tributi I v.oor-s taBBib/a which has been wlth taa body ron ountly, reated al Iht Blde. The Aaaarl . .,? and Brttlah Baga, crosaed on a. . of areen, and tha broken columo I ......... baartag tha hv Bcriptaoa "Our rhicf." aent by the at tachea or the aVUyofa oface, occvpled ,,?. piacea of lionor at the head of the ... Back m the Bjaadkvwa wera tlie Uark ClOthad inouniera. Fifteen Thousand in Line. Plfteen UKrunand pereoaa ware ia the ? ? the City Hall la :.. Ten thousand "f them formed after tha Bervtce and a - campanled the bods back througn taa .treeta and over Brooklya Brtdga, h larga number of tbe organlsatkaaa m ,1b, dlabaaded at Borough Hall. bu? ,!?. i ooo plcked polit araaa la the aa* .,??; of honor. tha C:ti,cu?' CeaaaelttBt ?f loo the heada of cltj departm th,. honorary |?Ubearera aad ? hundred other laouraera Miiowed tna body to tha jrava ta Oreenwood Cetna lary I a - ow aarrlni i ortega araa three ' ura la golng from the ch'irrh to tha ci tM't.-r Th. Mayor'a bods waa takea thi i Hja Ih< Btreeu on a hbjh intfatfalQua draa i bj aisteea btaek hotaea, led by ? pottcemen and etght nr-tnea An r,000 pollcemen. Includlng the ea art,or haif the Btreaurth of the whoh ?.,.. concentrated along Hr.la - ,,,.?, Chambera atreet lo Bowliag ,-,,,??. and along Part Row, the roaw over whi'h the ptuieaalon paaaed ? Manhatun. Tha unlforraed men t.,o.i along tha garb wlthln arms' reach of one another. They atood rlgtdly al at teatlon aralla lha caUfaJque peaawd. Never befero, lt araa aaid eacepl ta I ? aaanal pollee pamde. was auch a bady of iM.ii'-.men Baeaaahlrd ta pubiic Th,- acbadala of the ctaamlttae of arraagemaata provtded far the traaafer joi the cegan from the Cltj MaJI. where .,,.. body tay ta Btate untll mldolgbl ea Sunday, al IOJ0 a m. it waa Bftaea mlnutea aiter that bour when the cot? Bn was borne dowg taa Clt3 Hall atefaj and Dlaced On UM .atafahiue. The police eaeort arrtvad at the rhnrch Bva mtnatee later. Thej ware ta formatlon ln Broadway for aeveral j biocka bekvn th.- City Hall plaaa bafore I the -t.nt. The privOeged rraoewnera <n tared Ihe chureh, aad the r.-st ?.t the inarcheraeamUaaaal on doara Broaelutajr. Marct to the Grave. The proi.e8si.inal at tlie chureh atarted at ll:**- a'caoegj, and the body waa carned down the centre atale, wlth tl?- , oiiKi'.^ation Btandlng. The si nuc ,-i.ded at l-:40 o'clock. but it was n.'.n |y an bour later when the head of tha proceeelon startt-d over the Brooklya Hri.Ui. The police ln.es were thrown aroun-l City Hall Park at an early hour. A large, crowd gatlured in that vlcin.tv 1,1-foie | o'clock. Bhortly afier 9 traf t!<- way Btoppad in Hroadway. betWeOB Chambera atrft-t und Trinity fhurch. The oara were permitted to run aa far