Newspaper Page Text
Conducted by Samuel Hopkins Adams. Thi? department ia devoted to ?eparating the ?heep of i etivertising from the goat??and hanging a bell on tht> goat?, it deal? with a very ?eriou? topic in a way that i? not too ?eriou?. It? honeit endeavor will be to ?n?\ver with fairne??, either in print, or, where that it inexpedient, by private letter, ??11 fair question? about advertisement?, while reserving the right to plead igno-ance* when that i? the right answer. It a?k? nothing for it? ?ervice? except the confidence of its corre?pondenl? in giving their name? and nddrette?, r confidence which will never be vio? lated. Please ;t??.e clearly whether you pr?ter to have your name ???ithheld from antwert printed here. No unsigned comm?jnic?tion? will he read. Addre??: Tho Ad-Vi?nr. The Tribune. New York. The letter pObltshsd In your Ad-Yi?or column of The Tribune of October 16 criticising certain practice? and eonditieoi in the moving !v?n ntid storage business in thi? city ia particularly interesting. I write Uili letter to you sa a reputable mov?as van concern of thi? city, and I wiah to present lone obvioo 'ai-i? which have appar? ently escaped Mr Morgan and yoarself It is a fact thai the public often have opportunitv for criticism of some mov?. 1 would ' t?te, however, that in mr.ny r. ?och cri?;r ? thl peopl? who make 11 are themselves te Man? people who, waat Bg sad ? oi-.-?> 1er. to . I po b -. half a doses or more mo** ? | van and ? Ii the idea of ?^?mg thl Work den? .-? ,l-?; lowest i their pri? ? i h ich Mr. .'*; learch for a asoving van concern, 1 ? ? ti t thei nothing in ?he way of integre! .- ? hieb ii = a rula cannot be ox] ?1 the price and who neglect th? ? e in 1 learch for chtnpnr. a. If Mr. Morgan, or any user of moving van lervleo, instead of shopj ing around promlacuoualy among a variety sf eooeerai without icgaru to their credit or their reipi or their capacity to do ?he work well, would eonaider who can do this Job the beet, then ho would get a moving van concern which would give him good .-er?, ice at .?? reasonable prie and which co-jlri be relied upon to give him satis? faction. The pub?i- are often in fault for allowing themselve? to be gov erned entirely by the pri??* of the lowest bidder. If Mr. Morgan wants good moving lerviei hs pick out one of the many reputable concerns in this city who "ill j7?vr hits a I.sb BOd a fair price If, however, he reports to the usual procedure of matching price?, he i? bound to have trouble and probably cause for complaint, for 'he motto uf the low?-t biddci usually Ii "I.< t the Buyer Beware.11 A Ii. VF.TTKR. To this the Ail-Visor has nothing to ad'i. Common sonso, clearly sot forth, nr-'di- no commentary. Isn't Robinson's ad. ?he best example of multum ?4? parto in foolish and dishoBSSt advertising ?hat you over MB 1 H. A Just aho'it. Hero ii tin' advertisement: ROBINSON'S PATENT BARLEY The Only Infant Food ? an any reader produce another example which so thoroughly com? biner hrevitv. mendaritv, and ineffecti*ven?*?M. I have been reading your column with a great deal of Interest an?l t" a great extent agree with your campaign to eliminate the bad ad? vertising from the columns of the daily press. Hut why not apply the same iule to all? Why not (to chaags around the old adage i east out ? he mote, so there would be no comeback in getting rid of the henin ? The theatrical sd thai was an freelj discusses sad to whose elaborate BtateSBOBta there *?'i'n:? t.. hav, been considerable exception taken, probably did make : have been proved to be over sxaggc rated. Bal I'* ' - torn to page 9 ?*f the ?ame edition of The '1 rihune and lock over the sd of the W. I,. Douglai Shoe Company. In one of the paragraph? this advortiaemeal itatea thai MW. L Douglai M*00 shoe? ?re ju.?t bi good for ityle, tit ami wear ai other Btakei eosting %SM to I*.ou. Th- ealj perceptible ditTer?nce ii the price." I'll admit the part i fie and the lit for the first few weeks, but I'll be banged if any one can cran, down my throat the fact that a ?4.00 ?hoc of any firm'? make will out-last or wear BI long as an $8.00 shoe Now, candidly, which pair of shoes would you bet on if a test were to be made? Would you lie willing to place your money on the |4.<N pan or a pair of the |8.00 OBSI from s good, icputable concern? W. W. JOHNSTON. This criticism was forwarded to the W. La Douplas Shoe Company for comment, and the folkraring reply was received from one of the diie??tor?'. Mr. Adam:-'- corresp? ndent ? little unfair in thai hs ssyi "W, I.. Li.ugla-i 14.00 -iuie- Bra Jual bi good," etc, By referring to to-day'i ?dvertiaement ? : pe? yon will not?- thai the paragraph reads ' W. L Dougl ? ? 50 and fB 00 e just aa good tor atyle, ht and wear ,? other makes coating 16.00 to 18.00. Th>* only percep tibie ditTerei.ee ia the price." Thil statemenl il tha result of compari? son ?if w. L Dougla price with other shoes at tha higher price.?, and I am willing to pal w. 1. Douglas Si 00 ahoea agaiast any $C>.(i(i shoe on the market for . I d wear, ju.-t as the advi tifcenunt Baya, or ai?> K6.00 average SS.00 shoe for atyle, fit and wear. It is true there II Bometitnei a ditt'eietice in work maaabip and Aaiah. Any experienced ?hoc man will tell you that tin;.?h, however, eoven a multitude of sins. FRANK I. ER8KINC It has lonj*, been a pet theory <?f the Ad-Visor's that ?-10 y-old pieces are seldom to OS had for 15. Nor are |8 shoe values ordinarily obtainable at $4.00, or even *?.">, to adopt Mr. Brakino's interpretation of the advertis? ing. To the poblk this- advertising sayi by implication, "When you pay ?<C.OO or $8,00 for another firm' hooi you are arasting jrour money and '.ettin-' the ? o? you." Further, llie advertisoment -ays "The '?ill?, p cptible i iff? encc Mr. Erskine admits thai "?here i- "ii.el (Terence in workmanship and finish." Porbapi workman ship and finish arc not perceptible, it so, it is difficult t<> per i-uvi the value o? tin m. The fac? is thai th? Douglas advertising man. in nut beim: content to tick to his last and offer B lii ?t-c!ass four dollar shoe value for four dollar.-, which is all that the public has any right to expert. has fallen into the Inars of the comparative. He is attempt in*,? to jter suade the publil that tin y are either getting more than they are entitled to when they deal with Douglas, or loss than they are entitled to when they deal with sotoe <*ii?> else. In so doing he ?s a little less than fair both to hi? public ;i7 ?1 t 1it competitors. ' ' e tumi your attention to ' ' ?' i U ? ? on? n ? ? etti ' ? .**'..> I u?M ?aal? la. \ ociation. It i? with the graoteot satisfaction that Mr. Zagat's ?'traij-rit-from the-shouider l?*tter to th? patenl medicine maker, who have sought to in? duce N?w York droggi ore ''< Board of Health regulationi is reprodu? ?<i : s""', ' - et, Phil id? Ips a. Ps ? - I and. w ? of your kii t efforl public bould be li ?ate, ii. ? . toobeyiagDr ing over ?- ? "?/''", ??"' ?????' '?'?" ?a oppoaed to hand "-.,r;,-i??A VJlVr ;*. . , , ? ??fWdiSBts Of ? dencethVu, . , ,""?! * ' L "?? T3U?n* '" ara1 ? ?- ar? ' --..,. **}? f'\r ?*ese prep fraparatieni U year eompi . ' ";;*'K ,h" "?tars of ? cannot b. J1*-? '" no P?*?P*??? ' I ? ia The sale of """? aasoasa .... ?dvi-rt.s,,,,. ?no i,..'i . , ,, '.Iher' ourao^; of ??'' and thai ? Mag m thii i?.. ? ?? ? OACh ! - ill.Ml? AI. ? ?i k I Zagal Wh?.? i Lruo o? ti.'- Smith, Kin.?-a- i- ranch Co.' ?,.-,,.t n-rsroojaUooj |g true of practiea?1j i ?? neairum , The socrac. i? bul ? pratoi ? ? ''Muff." I' i redoeed ??. the lourael lonai of alwurdity bj tho cleo? lesji? O? Ml Z ./.al and expert knowledge. MORGAN BARRE AD) FOR MORS SAYS MELL1 Forced New Haven to 1 fuse Half of Steamboa Stock, He Asserts. BREAK WITH HIM, BANKER'S ORD Railroad's Policy of Buy Trolley Lines Urged by Hii self, Ex-President Testifies Judge and lawyer? confessed fti 1 day in so many words, and the j' men hy look?, that the evidence in N'ew Havea case was getting so com rs.ted they were at a lost to know t> it waa nil ahout or where II ing .his situation herum? BO SI that Judge Hun' called a bait, aa< v. as derided !" pripR'?" written Stl ment?, of pnrt of tl'- I id? ' of a 'url!,er attempt t., r?i?ike it ?*? prehenaible to the iorj presentation. Eve? Charles S. Mellen, of unfai! memory a? to all New Kngland tra portation history, ??aid: "1 BBS twisted ahout thi.? matter." The evidence yesterday hy which government sought to make pood Charge that the eleven former N Havea directors conspire?! to build an unlawful monopoly of New Kngli transportation had to do with the de involving live different Metropolit steamship companies. The intern tion came as the government attorn? wore atraggliag to present an inte gent story of these transaction?. "The magnitude of this case is t mendous," exclaimed Judge Hunt. " iatrieadea seem to multiply. Ni gentlemen, let us see if we can't coi to some better understanding of tl Metronolitan situation, some betl way to know the differenrr bctwe these t'y*.'r companies.'' There followed a conference as what should be dono, and finally was agreed that both sides ge' t gether on a written explanation. Aid to Morse Refused. A few facts stood out fairly pis in the presentation by R. L Bat chief government attorney, of the M? ropolitan matter, while he was allow. to go on with it. He showed '.hat t! particular Metropolitan line over whii Charles W. Morse had control we into the hands of a rec? ivcr and th J. PierpOB. Morgan ordered Mellen refuse Morse's plea tor aid. "Don't you have anything to da wi him," Mollea said Morgan 'old hii He explained to Morgan that Mor was ofT-ring them half the Met ropo tan stock ir" they would take up tl job of rehabilitating the line. "'Well,' Mr. Morgan ?aid to m? Mellen testified, "'you leave him e tirais alone. Either break with him i break with me.' " Mellen broke with Morse, who I that time was in the Tombs facing tl trial which resulted in sending him Atlanta prison. Passiag from thi? Metropoliti ateamahip natter, evidence wai pu' -bowing, by the minute? of a direc'or meeting April 19, 1-912, aOthoriziog I the purchass of the New York Tran portatioa company, the Bastera Steal ship Corporation and the Maine Stean ?hip Company bonds. This act brought the steamship O] erations of the New Haven within tl period covered by the indictment, ju as the I'oughkeepsie Bridge transa tion, brought out last week, carried tl expanding railroa?! operations of tl New Haven within the statute of lim tatio'v. Mr. But;?; then offered to put in ti the government evidence of reb?tis by the United States Tran.-portatlo Company eont roll?-?! by the Ne Haven, bat the court rated agaiast it admii libility. "I- : - merely eumulsl .-.ant t.. ran;, the ci-.- any furth? t- ramifleations than those ?? orth m the bill of particular-." Judg Hunt said. I'unliased ?S"? Trolley Line?. From the ateamahip aeqaiaitioni c the New Havea the government ev deaee passed to the buying by it o ?\ty-live trolley lines. It is the cor tention of the government that the? WO!, bought up to obtain control ovr street franchises in New Knglan towns for the purpose of blocking tii potting tin?. ;gl, of any competir, steam lines. The defenee argaed n_:. n.-t the ad misaibilit; of thi ? ? idenee - ground thai thi -, the bordei ? of tl > respeeti? tes in whirii they were leeated, am th?- parehase ai them in ?volved r?1 ' "' it BI of the Sherman lav which applies to interstate c.imm.TCf Mr. Hat'? argaed that the ultimate ef and parpase of the purchase? wa the pomt t.. be coneiderea. In ruling, the court said: "It woul? ? ? s ?i?> t.. allow in a criminal cas. that the law I?, misunderstood as per nutting a conviction because of thii gathering together of these intra-?ta!< ties of traffic to be usn within thi ? of ?fie ?t?te. I at the ex] tion of tl , -. idenes r,..th lag ii -i "??? n bat the aggregal Ich ol * bese troll? lii u I I not i howi that thi .i directly in mter ' i '??,? ; m i ; I,, It must be hown ?i ? t.. ? iolate ?. ..?. ' With th? in that tba evi deacc Ix i ; ? oa this has- ? ti,r government sttoraeys were allowed to begin putting in the trolley line ?avi* deaee, starting with the ecaeisitiea of the Fair Haven ?V Westvilfs Railroad Company. When n?ked if he recalled the ??ireetor?' meeting at which it was breached, Mellen said: "I remember II distinctly because Mr. Millet Mid that be did not object I ?to the acquisition of thai particular .. t, i* ha -i ?I obji el *?. tiie ..i of a policy of trolley llac . ? ? "I '..Id them then that it .sa? th." im.." to Bettle tli?. question, tl.at era ? ?,, Lu., th? bei t thsri troll? ) line bi I oal rhat we had it wa? my judgment '?>? ? Havea ?Railroad ibeald furnish all ?,? traBsportatien demanded by ; the punlie I wh? in favor of taking ?n?. trolleyi I recemmeaded t? ? i" ? | thai We either ought t<> adopt a compraheaaivs scheme to give all kind? of ? r...i -portal ion or get ou' and Confine ournelve? to the railroad bus; I negs." | PREPAREDNESS.'' AT THF. MILITARY LEAGUE TOURNAMENT. asawsssjBB*??*^^ ;;?. armv an(1 jMkis astride ? sVWtahead t?.rpo?lo, on? of th? exhibits at the demonstration in faroi ol i itronftr army and navy in Madiaon S?qaare Garden,___^ 25 CENTS TO WHEEL BAB. I.iterative Job Wails Barnard '??r ?alio Wants in Kam Kduration. Twenty-live cents a day for wheelini a seven-months-old baby about th? streets an?! park? of New York i? th? wage offeri-d to anv strong, willing an? capable Barnar?! girl ?lesirou? of work? ing her way through college. A pro ?pective employer yesterday sent i postal to Pan! C. Ilolter. secretary el the Students' Employment Bureau, at Colombia, Baking for an applicant. Many students are on the lookmi for winter work of 01 S kind or another and manv are already occupied wltl variooa form? of seasonal occupations Two students recently qoalined M hOBSS painters, vvhil? two others sue cessful.y decorated the interior of t church. A greater number are cleanin?, furnaces, while more are tending fur naces in conjunction with waiting a' table in many apartment?. HE HIrI?DALIENIST, SO DID HIS WIFE Phinneys Parted and Reconciled Thaw Trial Experts Called. They Quit Again. I,ove may laugh at locksmith?, if he still finds those respectable craftsmen so ludicrous. When, however, two Thaw alienists obtrude themselves into one marital squabble his sense ot humor deserts him and he resigns at once. Mr. and Mrs, Y.. G. Phinney hired the alienists, lost their love and are now suing each other. Mr. I'hinney, who v president of the K. G. I'hinney Company and the An^'e', Forwarding Company, thought his wife was mentally unbalanced and hired Dr. Menas S. Gregory, present head of the Bellevue psrhopathic ward and one? time Jerome witness in the Thaw trial , to make sure that she was. Where upon Mrs. I'hinney engaged Dr. Carlos Jv Macdonald, another state witness in the Thaw trial, to make sure that she wasn't. Then love resigned, and Mr. I'hinney re?igne?l and so did Mrs Phinney. On ?December _:;, 1914, Mr. I'hinney had added hi tai I nasas t.. the already euphonious title of Miss Willis I'earl bussey. Oa Navamber i">. 1915, which era? ;.. terday, Mrs. Willis Pearl Bas* PI .. y left bei home at MO Rivsrs.de Drivs an.i started for Jack? sonville, Fla., there to defend the final stanza ot bei title is the divorce suit brought hy her husband. But before she left lbs tiled B suit for ?eparation in the Supreme Court here, charging desertion and cruelty. Between the two ?lates the Thaw alienists got in their rhilling work. According to Mr?. I'hinney, who is the daughter of a physician in Augusta, Ca.. the Aral of the m inv- flaws in their wedded existence OCCUITSd when her husband wandered home one night, staggering under a load of liquor, BBS? v. .1 iaternally. sin- was la the mi?ist of a temperance leetare to bim when be left the boasc laddealj and ia the ..! direction Of Maine. When he reached there he seat her a telegram. She fallowed him t.. New England, and there the pan were reconciled. Twentv-lour hours after their return to New York, according to her, Mr. I'hinney announced that he was going out "on business," an?l went so far that he never came back, sending her, in? stead, a meaaa?ga announcing that she wa? mentally deranged. Later he called upon her in company with a man who ?he found out later was I*r. Gregory. Immediately thereafter she engaged Dr. McDonald to testily that she wbbbI erasy. She might have saved herself ths money, for Dr (ireg orv ?admitted this h mi elf. In August Mr. Phinney began sction for separation in l ?i city. Later lie went to Florida and filed sail for di* - ? t bei >. According to hi i tion? the nearest approach to cele??ial influence in hi? !.f?- eras furnished by the Angel Forwarding Compaay. His description of his wife i? far from seraphic. He speaks of her "austerity of temper" and "violent sallies of pas ?ion." According to him. she also t'| atened him with a weapon on July 5 last, and had him followed about the country by detectives. His wife, on the other baad, exhibits letters in wh'ih ha ?':**? her Ml "?lar?mg | i!" and "precious" anil "sweet." whether theae epistles were written befara at after I ? ad enl of the alic?tate de* ponen! lyetl nal JUDGE LINDSEY HELD GUILTY OF CONTEMPT rined $500 for Refusal to Dis? close Information at Trial. Denver. Nov. 1.. Judge Ben B. Lmd j ?ey, of Denver'? Juvenile Court, was , held guilty of contempt of court and ; fined f.">00 and costs by Judge John A. : Terry in the District Court here lo 1 day. Thirt] days WO!, allowed for an appeal The BBSS fttM out of JadgO ? ? :..-tn". tion in the tria! ? ??. ?g , .. | t on a chargi ??: murder. J-sdgs I..' ? | the iaferaa? Vion cam?- to 'mm iM a privileged man ' ??' through tl.. , oafassion af Neal Wright, twslvs years eld, during the trial. An kaforaaatiefl charging the boy with the murder of hii father he cause of an alleged confess ,,n made at hi? mother'? fru? .mi ?g pending in the Juvenile Cauri Mi?. Wright was acquitted. i ROAR OF GUNS FILLS GARDEN Tournament of Military Athletic League Opens at Madison ?Square. "Is America ready for war"'' This' la .. gaeStion which a military tourna? ment, continuing all the ?reek at Msidi son Square Garden, under ?he BBBpicei of the Military Athletic ?League, pro pose., to answer. The opening ?" tion last night wr.s extremely inter? esting, an?l wa.? convincing at lea one of the '.',.i present, who was over h'-ard to r-nmrk: 'After seeing :'.' : am posit"-.? r? ;.r.- prepared for war. - Had toi iuar Garden!" Twelve events were o i the pro gramme for she opening night, and reg ulara aad militia from ever, branch of the service helped to make the en? tertainment diversified. Without ex? ception 'he event? were run off wi'h precision, and to judge from the ap plau4* the programme was well re? ceived. In the absence of Mayor Mitchel, who was to have opened ths tournament, the drills were reviewed bv I'oiice Commiaaioaer Arthur Woods. The number which apparently arouse?! the most enthusiasm was a saddle drill by Troop K, _th Cavalry, U. S. A., a detachment of ?fifty men from Fort Myer, Va., under command of Captain Frederick D. Kilgore. ?Thifl troop of highly trained regulars moved about the tanbark in a maze of intricate figures with astonishing rapidity an?l ???curacy, and the educated animals displayed a grade of intelligence which seemed to the audience nothing less than extraordinary. They wheeled and circled with precision, and when they Anally "dressed" in four lines before 1 the reviewing stand, while the strains ' of the bund completed '.he martial ef? fect, BVea ?ths MidiON from other con. mands brake late an enthusia?tic up lield (?un Drill. A 1-pounder tield gun drill by the _?i Battalioo, New York Naval Militia, ex-, cited much interest. Four groups of sixteen men each hauled in a gun and manoeuvred them about on foot. Clad in white, the militiamen nevertheless did not hesitate a moment when the order came to advance flat on their stomachs, a? small boys on sleds. This detail of preparedness waj quick to be noted by the crowd, and each addi? tional flop in the tanbark was giaalad by a round of cheers. Company <i, Tl.t Infantry, N. G. N. Y., with Captaia Heary Maalia com m.-in?imi?, gave an i steaded order drill, the men being exceedingly deft at <!i* charging their rifles ahile reclining on their stomachs. Lj. :ng thus in the soft tanbark, suddenly a whistle would blow, and they would ?ret up and a?l vance ten yards, only to lie down again. In the course of several minute? they traversed the entire arena in thi? fash? ion, and seemed none the worse for he experieace. A military athletic contest between two men not occupied the attention of th ? spectator? Ths contest coi m removing rifles, insaeadera, costs, leggings, then hoes, then hats, ami placing thi in apart at distances ... lei, yard?. At this point several women in the audience were BOOB to become agi? tated, but evidently the requirements ? f the coates! were fulfilled, for they did not remove anything more. At the report of a gun the men started to r?; clothe themselves, aad I'rivate Faugh nsn, of the "1st Regiment, won as the speemest dre ISer. To wind up the evening'? entertain? ment, the 22d Corps of Kriginers, Na? tional Guard <>t New York, constructed a pon'.,.on bridge and th. n demolished it with tin- " ..me sort <.f stuff we found ..\er in Jersey," according to Owea K. an. Inspector si ? ombustibls . ?vl-,,. aras e* hsad '. 'hat no gol ... i i ?-.?-. k ? d ? tat tiie gunaowdei. In < I.I..H.I - lioner w ood a box a i ? a First Deputy ?Leon <). Godle-j end Mr?. v .. ? ., ? 'o?.cei Georgs Wingete. ? ola* nel hrank Norton and Captain Hewitt C. Weld, jr. A detail of fwenty-nir,e officers and men of the Old Guard, commanded by Colonel Ardolph L. Kline, acted as BBO* .?al escort to the officers of the Mil itary Athletic League and their gue-ts of the army, the navy and the national guard. There will be a detail of the ?>ld l.uard pre?ent every night during the snow. An arm-ired motor truck, with a wicked little gun on top. stand* in the middle ot' the room, wit: several ?r tlllery bait? i ? ? aras d Than li al*o a .amp1.' of "i ?? ird whale boat sf the United State? v ?. ??. ou ned bj i!,. I ? i.,.",,i...r.. ?a?... '. ?t?a FRIENDS OF SHUT-INS TO MEET S?niel> I.? Hold Tliirtv-lnurth \nnu.il (lathering in lirick I burrh. The thirty-fourth annual meeting of the Shut-in Baeiot? Brill ?be held ??? Hl?rTOR'. lal.arrl I llr,,?|?_, III,. lUll g ommoaamlmi HBh _*. morrow, at \0-.W a. ?a?, in the lecture room of the Brick Presbyterian Church, Fifth Avenu.? and Thirty-seventh Street Miss MaeKeasis, of the ?*e cicty for Improving the Condition of the Poor, will make an address. A luncheon will he served at noon, end daring the afternoon ^residents of the various branche? will report on the advancement of th? work in the last ?/ear. All frisada of the society will he welcomed a? :**? meeting. -? FIND NAKED ADAM IN BASEMENT EDEN Girl Theatre Ushers Hide Fares While F ?remen and P?)lice Overpower Intruder. "Halt!" ihooted Fireman Patrick J. Rnrry to the young women ushers at ihe New York Theatre, Broadway and Forty-fourth Street, who were dearend ing to ?I;?ill dressing rooiai in the cel? lar to don their BBlfomi at ti:45 o'cloch last evening. "There'.? a man naked as Adam over ?here near the furnace. Sure, I just discovered him in making my round? to see if the building is ?afe." Busi? ness of BShsrg running back upstairs and Fireman Barry searching for a blanket. "Perhaps It's the bass fiddle player taking a shower," he mused as h?* aaveloped the ?tranger and yelled to 'he girls that they could come on down. The man in the blanket became vio? lent as BOOB as he was presented to John Joaes, engineer of the building. He insiste?! that .lories had taken his clothes. While Barry tan outside to blow his police whistle, the stranger mixed it up with Joseph M. George, the electrician, and several other at? tendants. Not until Patrolman Will? iam I.oeb, ?m duty at Broadway and Forty-third Street, came with his hand? cuffs di,I the fight cease. In a daz<*?l, incoherent manner the man said that he was Percival B. Fas kally, of 70 Fast Sixty-sixth Street. He would tell nothing more about him? self dr his predicament, but ?aid that he would like to telephone to his wife and daughter. Dr. Glynn, of Polyclmie Hospital, sai?1 that raskally appeared to be coining sal from the effects of -iime powerful drug. He was taken to ?hat hospital and placed under the care ? if Ins private physician. Paskally i-; ?aid to be an Eaglishsiafl of cons.,i?i ahl" wealth, who ha? '.pen aaaociated with Flint & Chester, Inc., dealers in railroad supplies at 237 La fayetta Street. Prior to last Septem? ber he and his family lived at 1 West Sixty-eighth Street. They plan to re? turn to England in a few months, .Mrs. Paakally said. METROPOLITAN ??y?* **foa?atl i??.i i. i.iniiiiu.1?. Ober. Oolaaaola: Dldur, Altheiwe, Rothler. Cond. R?>ia?-,o. Th ir. ..* 7 II ?...r-n.-r.liif nun, ? nut; Kurt. Ifatsenaucr, Helarles Idebat) I riu?. in . n ?? ?II ? on : h .i o. ,<.-.- id? bat I Kri. .* ???? Hiili-me. A Ida, < n?gttl i.Iebut ? ; ? - ? M i', ??noil . .?!? flit) Hat. Mail ' 1'iiseiikamlirr. Ober, llem ;?? III . ???.in ' . OorltZ. U ,i. Mih?ius?. Bodaask) ?sal. m ?. 7 7. toll), \l.l-i. 1 i p.; I. Mafien. ,?ii,r Ifartlnelll. ?mato rond. BavacaolL v??i Men. .? ? ? Iris. :.? i Del lunola; Boi .. .?. olil Dldur Coad 1-. HAIil'M \.\ PIANO ISED . SECOND BILTMORE I It?!> V . MllltMMi MUSIC.*!?! HOThl. Mil THOSE, NOV? m. at 11. LOI 'IM. f ANNA HOMER FITZIU Ml?*< HA ( lARKMT. ELMAN BIRD i- ! r ... . ? I Mow an .?]? ?? BHUMf? B'*i "~ ?? Man?? I. H Ko. ? t?t?i a t SYMPHONY C0M.Ei.TS ? I ??It rot NG PBOPLK ? Saturday Aft., Nov. 20, at 2:30 ? I IIIMI.IK II ?I.I.. ? N V SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA 9 ?\ITJIl IIWIKOMH (on.luctor ; '??,,?,, GRAINGER ? TI keti al etm ?, R?wni ISSI, A"?a?n ? B tig an.i H.,i i iffl, ,.. Carncfl? Halt PHILHARMONIC BOCIETT OP m:w rORK .li'Slil-' KTRAN8KT. CONDUCTOR ' ?Tmi ?.: ?i - '? i- i : an ?? . ?? '?"I l??l Mtl. II-/T. M Itlil.MlKRl.. i r- ..-..- , ? m. ., ? Br.t i a . . si \l\ l -?.\i.n-. KIMNKI kill'*. Xhlil I, EMMY D-STINN ?IR? III ?III V IM I R loo I'lKKiltMIK** . '- > "" - ' ?'? *???? . !?- , .* AIOLIA?. HALL VIOLIN frltlar l.g. s... ? at 8 15. RECITAL. HOCHSTEIN ????is. ?i) (S| to ?7. H ?al* a*, f, i BO ? CCMELLINGM jd? f < a?eaefte Hall, To-morr???*. : Bjn ?L M la', it? ItaVl. S??l? '? ? H \_\ WSW ?|<- ataj I. ?? * i- - ? . , i ? gafj ? McCORMACK f. a . Ans??,II I. All. \i V I M \ AKT al ? Ti. ??<? *"??? ?' 11- . "?*? ?-_ ?s nui. ru-Muht \r mis. M HEGEOUS 1 ? ""? ? M ..- ? A ' a ?ai.ifr CARNK.I? MALL THIS AI TI BnJOIIiV AT I. BL0?MFIELD ZEISLER H SI WW AS MASO iMa B b '? *i ? n*ir??u ? ?aBOLIAN II ?all. Ont. W?.. No?. SS, tat 3. BAUER-^CASALS Mji. L'lu.luQ Cbaii: n. lia? il A llamllu l'ianu. SING SING LEAGUE NIPS GRAFT PLOT Convict Head of Clothes Store Accused by Wel? fare Court Judge. INMATES ABOUT TO QUIT, SCHEME'S PREY Victim Says He Paid $2 To Be Fitted Out in Stylo When Term Rxpire-*. Theodore Grant, a ten-year convict at Sing Sing, who until a day or two ago was in charge of the State Shop at the prison, will be plsced on trial this morning before the Mutual Wel? fare League Court, charged with ex? torting $2 from Robert Gray, another convict, on the promise that he would fit l?ray out in an expensive suit of clothes when ("ray leaves the prison at the expiration of his term on Fri? day. Last night when Spencer Miller, sec? retar? to Warden O.sbornc, was told that the facts had become public, he sa?d a prisoner bad been detected by a judge of the Mutual Welfare League Court in grafting from prisoners about to be released. Mr Miller added that the convict would be called to account this morning. Grant hag been sus? pended from the league and Its privi? leges and returned to the unemployed company. The State Shop is the prison de? partment in which are stored the clothe? worn by men when they reach ! the prison to begin term?. The shop. i like several other prison department?, is in charge of a convict, supervised by ! a keeper. There are well made and up-to-date , suits of good material in the shop, as well as the shoddy and cheaply made clothes of the men from the under? world. When a prisoner arrives at the institution his clothes are taken from him and ufter disinfection, dry clean? ing and pressing are sent to the S'ate Shop, to be useia by prisoners a? terms expire. Therefore, a man wearing a cheap aait may, on release, be found to he the same size as a grafting poli? tician or bank defaulter, an?l will get the high grade suit of such convict. Several month? ago, the shop was in charge of a prisoner who has ??pre been released. Persistent rumors of graft by this inmnte resulted In an investigation which, while not disclos? ing anything in the way of conclusive proof, caused the removal of the con? vict and the transfer of the supervis? ing keeper. Gray Tells of Deal. Following that action. Grant was placed in charge. For n time the graft rumors ceased, but in the last two weeks they again became current. A close watch was kept on the depart? ment and the grafting from Gray dis? covered. The story told by Gray when callad Grand Jury Sing Sing Inquiry Nearing End So fast has the We?tchi??ter Coot?, (.rand Jury* *t White Plains been wt, ducting its inquiry into di?cip!ing, f,j, onies and the g?rerai condition, ., Sing Sing ?Ptisan dnriag the lut ? months that it is bel seed it will g. ready to report it? rlndlBgfl ?? B^ court within the BBBt ten day?. District AfforiKV Weeks had ?'i wit. nes?es before the '?''r?)n Warden Osborne did net ?ppear it t>.g prosecutor's office, but I'nnripgl ..... er Dorner was in the jury room f?r more than half an hour The conrity ?Sailed were Ge?.rge Evans, Peter Oil. len, John Jasper and a myaterii.. h. called "John Doe," an inmate of Sir.? Sing, but whose name the lliatrict At? torney refused to reveal. It :i ?g. pected that during the 1 .?t 0f ?, week the grand Jury will go In g body to Sing Sing to make a thot*i_|! inspection of every department an. ti talk with some of the Inmate?. Euchre for Holy Name Minio., The Holy Name MissiOB, of 319 Bo?. ery, is to hold a euchre and reetotl.i Saturday evening a* the *".'*h Rijimir.1 Armory, Lexington Avenue and Tw?. ty-sixth Street. The Re? Willig? 1 Rafter, Its director, l??u<-?i gn gpagj yesterday to all Catholics in tht dtl to help. The proceed? will be ttt\ for pressing need? of tha mi?ilsn, | larger chapel, a.reeeptton room, dens!? tories and a restauran*. 5TARW00D MEN OF GOOD f/T TASTE AND UFINEMENT WILL WEAR NEW YllKK'H I.KUHN?. THKATHI.s AMI ?.I??!?*! .?PIRE. It'-aiy, ?O'fi ft Mi'a T" m' WM. GILLETTE _? LAST ; Tl ^^^^^^^^^ "SECRET SERVICE. LYCEUM. W 15th s? Matlneei T-uia and Sat. ETHEL BARRYMORE ggaKk r.AIFTY I'."i.i?i>'- ?*> St F.rsilr.gi ?jo. Unit. II \| ... To-m'w i rep i A s?t .' 20. "YOUNG AMERICA" _??- rOHAN?. H-?> 4 1 St (?' ' .0 BEGINNING rO-NIOHT AT I 20. "BACKr_B-__-wl?**a mes NEW AMSTERDAM AKOUNDmMAP KLAW A ERLAM.ER PRISENT Bonk by ? Ms M I. a M KP? -S ?VtaSTiN W. 44 S IV. FROM IRVIN COBB 8 "JUD?E PRIEST "STORIES. HUDSui? ?^JKSLJ?-S'l COHAN 4 HARRIS PRI8ENT LEO UITR1CHSTEIN "THE GREAT LOVER" L?__I______HI___i HAMOS Stfea feT^i? [____II___________ ASTOR B*W?T, ? ?T. En ? M). Bryant alt. O?. M. Coria?. Graat Amartcan fane _ HIT.THE-TRA.L HOLLIDAY TUC Pf f IViFR ANG ?nth num Minx) u "BiLi.r uoyupor- lllL Evl \J 1tILI\/_1i*J CANDLER a_?A6^Se*S ELTINGE w-? ? XUIC unncr _-??- ".. ?i.?- -aiaiiisuc M... a". ? i: i ? * ? Till'!: DAltl IN?!.. ?LM Lait 2 Weeb .'w-rmri GIGANTIC PHOTO IPECTACU K? S ?Sa? Ma' B '0 *S M _ i.'i.T .i.-. ..?-. :?_ * Ua. BELASCO W*V.*...? r;ir,f:?.s. ..??. -.nrl?? Ht ?- a su I ' ??^?V?oJ2_S*^ "FAR __"1_W ?>.ui Miry m ?an a V.? iff???* A . Arnrr n < aa* . ? ? Orch. |a. 11 50 IBS Sea*. I-t Hi., .0- 7V $1 ' _? r?""" '"'.'?????>' '?"*'?? " A"rT H?HW-*?i CANDLER THEATRE. SPECIAL MATINEE. REPUBLIC *1 TO-DAY I ini m '"'-At-T'.MIMI. AT 1 I AU A l?AM?. aa,:?"..| I SI J- a.ra??*r? RTM.HONY OBTH globe "-"^?'vr-rr.'^.i? MONTGOMERY & STONE it IB * I ______________t_3 CHIN N'g CHIN M , . r.? assl Europe's .?iii tin mza M-s'm': Ci.?!?-, Iiiii-j'a-., Mat. T?-day, |3c SA 7 fl.OO. I ? A Sat. Mal.. U *.n H?l i*i?A|I.J0 ?,".K,AS5T HIP HIP HOORAY 1 i?\> ?:ST 10 MlMfcsJ ?i.mf.il?*? I'RII'RB !" Hi.?- -I*)'?'? Hfot;.?. 80USA ANO HIS BAND. SENSATIONAL ICE BALLET ? i i ; a) NOVELTIES s*?i?1 hy R II. It'ir: ? ???? HI M'AIS ?ni SA A. ? Hip" s-?r IVatiir?? r (i u i m-?* ??? ' p"s a '?? IMiTPMIB8M ili ELEANOR PAINTER. LtAllNtl I UP? MADAME P?TROVA Ma* I ? I?| Sc.AMl in *'THE REVOLT." jirtiiunau '*KICK?IN" * 11 I' KEITH'? NAT. C. GOODWIN ?a? PA I 4 I* D ,'?'*1 Armslr.ii*?'? "la a KLAVC n s?? -? <;;..?-," mm if?E R-WAT ?'ST lilAMNil. T!?s It'll? Dill) MM 7?. ?? 11 I ?J?P " ' ?' COLONIAL i-?*.? Halts Mat IS loll | Sl,..p " "Cr?Jlbrrrl??."Ar GRACE LA RUE. '?..?*?. A Ce . & M.s.rs. Br> TRIANGLE PLAYS This Heek: Kath.rlns Kaelrrd II T ? WI-rM i :??-... ? ;??-? i ?.yd I ??oi.-i I? - 1*1 ' a II.. .i Doreth? GUh. H it s pri -. i'" . ?i,-. I ... M i-- Jl . : I KNICKERBOCKER THEATRE. II.? a ram NEO fmm WAYBURNS Town Topics WEBER'S TWILIGHT SLEEP M.-l;n*. i*i ?tant A la-tur? 1\\ me "? - ? a ? r ?i Mi " t I l ? i' M M\l)l?x?N Mil \kk ?.AKIlKV. Nu, I.?-?0. MiLllARY ? ?? ??? ??A ...m::?i..n TOURNAMENT nt?KN I ? ? .'..ii VITAGRAPH *\ ; W I .. .V A, *? , * - H, THE BATTLE CRY OF PEACE f.Ofw's American Roof ';.* ,*,."? *7, WEITON i LfON ?ARROW. ALL SEAT! KISfRVlli 144. tit 10a WAIHINGTON SO PLAYERS IIA ? I'll. 'X ? i! A 1.1 A? flam III !.. ? ?. liai ?. m T.? a n i.. ?..?i- ??..? i..r??.ti?? h*, lr t? N.l Ml II, II...... . II...I.a. I COLUMBIA I.a? 1 I' | IT?. ? I I. ... *i . , I i.o I?.let MAJESTIC*. ? 11th Ct T..? ...il' U .'n ??? r'_Wi?****. ???Hl, 01. v,. I IM K.a ? 30 M? ?U HARRYLAIIDER W A COMPAVT ??K INT? ?_N VI SAL tW*. PLAYHOUSES... '?'.'Jrl'm) GRACE GEORGE in THE LIARS un i.V.; iir.> BNbb? IBS Um THE NEW YORK I0IA. comedy. *:.?? i-s mut ? -.* *r,^if ,';? . , HOBSONSCHOICE 48TH ST. ThT.'. " sSgS THE ETERNAL MAGDALENE a '. 1ULIA ARTHLS LYRIC _ _".? ___anp_H33!-9 "POTASH AND PE H^MlTTE*-" SHUBERT K.a a l?, M ? '*T.*ri'_ ALONE AT LAS l MAXINE ELLIOTT S M ?AL*1**"!' flS QUINNEYS* t. TH ST I?, s !" vu . . - *JT;i'?,/i THE UNCHASTENED WOMAN BOOTH. ..g? ?i I' II. " *, '-'aJ ? SOT HERN .?btV CAbiNO. i >?? ? Ui r kl cr?n, THE BLUE PARADIS-. PRINCESS , FOB TWO WllKS sau GERALDINE PARRAR CARMEN ".-, MANHATTAN ??1 TOFALOS v? ABERO LINOW vs CUTU* TO A FINISH WEONES.?AY NII.hT *?*?,_.? TOFALOS vs HEVONPAA TO A FINISH \roll_n Hall. TIM- M IMiMi^** *f l ?...\?. i ELIZ-XBfcTH KKIIItl { M TV?.: . -. t; Mg v THfATR?" FRAN?AIS ' ' ? | HlMi?' **Z GUTMAI Via a I?' ' WvP - L?*i Marlaaall?! *?*"" I - Mal Ma . i i ball* I- i ? ' IRVING PUCE THEATRE , II ? i., ? m.m it rastn v> * oirana silla oobb? ?S?. Hi. ?-.u-i J?l ?i? is? l ___n_? I a.Mae Ui* ??