Newspaper Page Text
Elmer Oliphant Now Takes Hi? 1Niche in l-bot^a Hall of Fai-iaj Comment and Gossip On Sports of the Day r>y ii_!._*??_?, J\ 1 ?.i *maamammm*wmms wssassa **msa CORNELL, Columpia and Pittsburgh are the unbeaten football elevens In the Last. One year ago it was Harvard, West Point and Union. Cornell, the conquemr of Harvard, Michigan and Pennsylvan a among others, ha. now reach?',! the same place in football that it has hel 1 bo long in rowing, ant! from time to time on track and field. This piaco i? at the top. There are those- Charley Brickie]* Is one? who set aside thai 10 to 0 victory over the Crimson and give Harvard the preference on lato season form. This is not fair to a team which showed such consisten'. power from end to er.l of the season. It is true that Harvard gave ?M impression of greater finish against a Yn!e team that was falling apart than Cornell did against a Pennsylvania team which, no matter what it-; failing through the season, was mighty strong defensively last Thurs lay. But there is no reason to believe 'hat the eleven from Ithaca would not have 6hown this fame finish against a team so weak as Ynle or that it would not have 1 eaten Harvard on N'ovem!?er 20, as it did on October 28. Harvard's attack was based lar-rely on deception, Cornell's largely on driv? ing power. Harvard'* looked prettier, but it does not follow that it ?roul . have been the more effective againat the same kiml of ? defence. Cornell met every te-?t. To Um victor belongs the spoil?. Credit to Columbia. ONE can say without teat of contradiction that a'new spirit has been born to Colombia, or, in any case, ? reawakened spirit. Football did it. Superlatives would not be wasted in giving credit to Nei eon Metcaif, who face,! the task two short months ago of building a fooc lall team fr?'m a lot of green and mure or less untried material. Superla* tives also would not be wasted in giving credit to the eleven, individuall/ ami collectively. A gridiron miracle almost was worked on South Field this fall, and Trinity must share with Columbia the honor of having the loading e'even in what may be called the second division. To beat Wo.v leyan this year, even withotft Deotjen, was romething of which to boast. Footballs Newest Star. THE newest star of the gridiron would never have risen if football had not been restored to Columbia. Howard Miller, at quarterback, is sure to be found in the seats of the gridiron mighty if he goes along as he has bogan. It is quite possible that he deserves a seat, even now. Miller is a drop kicker extraordinary, but his prowess does not end there. He is a capable fielt! general and a brilliant runner in a broken laid. Seven goals from the field in three pames puts him in the Charley Prickley class. He may rise to equal height! with the same amount of study and practice that the Harvard captain of a year ago gave to the art of kicking. . , ; A Loyal "Princeton" Man. B!'"s HILL EDWARDS tells a good story about Johnny Knox, one of Percy D. Ilaughton's most valued scouts. They were riding ?lown together to one of the late Princeton games, and a friend, seeing Mr. Edwards, later remarked: "Who is that loyal Princeton man I saw you talking with on thfetraiB. He never misses a gome." Pitt Pill smiled. "That was Johnnv Knnx," he said. "He scouts for Harvard." One of these days, perhaps, Willie Hoppe will be beaten, but for the present no reasonable handicap can bold him in check. His record ron of 308 at 18.2 balk-line billiards last week once more proved him the master. What Football Teaches. FOOTBALL and the rigors of football training leave an Impress for good on many players after they get out of college. The g.nme teaches many things?self-denial, fearlessness, quick thinking, moderatkn, control and dependability, among others. It also teaches, and at an Impressionable time, care of the body, and a striking illustration of this was furnished on the Yale gridiron this fall. Nine of the ten coaches who were asked at the last minute to aid in pulling the eleven to? gether after a disastrous early season responded to the call. They were Tom Shevlin, Jack Owslcy, Johnny Field, Ray Bigelow, Ted Lilley, Johnny Kilpatrick, Purr Chamberlain, Guy Hutchinson and Howard Jones. Raflferty was the only one who was not able to go back. Of these nine, seven do not smoke, and of these nine six do not drink anything stronger than White Pock and coffee. And the Greatest of These? IN all my journeys this fall or.e subject could always be counted on to arouse quick response and much argument. It had to do with the merits of Eddie Mahan as compared with Charley Parrett, of Cor? nell, Jim Thorpe, ?if the Carlisle Indians, ai I Ted '?v. of Yale, as the greatest barks of recent years. Parrett had supports, and so had Coy, but, as a rule, it quickly narrowed down to Thorpe and Mahan, and opin? ion seemed about evenly divided Occasionally Tack Hanlwick's name was mentioned, while Andy Smith, once of Pennsylvania, was referred to several times as the ?greatest defensive back of all time. Jim Mc-Cor mack, of Princeton, too, was mentioned as the peer of all phmging barks, not excepting Maulbetsch, of Michigan, while some insisted that Walter Eckersall, of Chicago, was a better quarterback than Parrett. But, on the whole, the four first named were conceded as the stars of all stars the brightest. The greatness of Heston was recognized, but not so much by the newer school. For all-around efficiency on the offence as well as on the defence, in running, plunging, kicking, and even passing, it would be hard to find four better exponents of the game than Mahan, Thorpe, Par? rett and Coy. An Abuse in Football. //"?" T occurs to me," writes W. L. Richter, "that the practice of putting I In subst,4 ' y ai Oled Al an example, Team A has the ball ****?" SB Team B's (-yard line. The signal la given, the men are sei for the play, but before the ball can be snapjx?<! the coach of Team B rushes a substitute on the field. The whistle blows, * me ?s taken out, the men straighten up. Then- is a delay, and Anally the signal arain is given, but the continuity of the attacking side may be effected. The practice seems unfair. Why not a rule that prohibits a rabetitote going in after the teams are set for a play?" THF criticism is a Just one. The attack has been held up a number of times this year by Just such methods, and no doubt advantr.f**. has been taken f?f the faet that oftentimes an offence is weaken.d by checking it momentarily or ? defence strengthened by even a short breathing space. It Blight be hard to frame a rule to cover the point without working a hardship, but it certainly is worthy of consideration. Case for the Courts. . .r-spHF discussion in The Tribune of the amateur rule." writes E. J. S., "reminds me of a most serious point that I have Deen In* * tending to put before you. As you doubtless know, wo have fery excellent broiled lobsters at the Staten Island Cricket Club, and or.e Sunday nevera! years ago, when my son wanted to go to church, I per ?l_aded him not to, but to go to the cricket club and play tennis with m-*, by offering him th<- bribe of a Motor luncheon. Now, the questi-.'i II whether this does not make him a professional, and whether he ought not to turn hack the various medals 'i.a4 be has since won on the track at col Icge and a number of ?nips that he has w?,n at tennis." This is a case for the courts, not for the amateur rule framers. Bribery is a serious crime. King William IV. VOP Scotch Whisky Rtcttetd ktfluft arcara of merit end told eudel et San ?aaci.ee When a Feller Needs a Friend By BRIGGS West Point Gives Army Eleven Rousing Welcome Six Hundred CadeL? Drag 01* Si age Coiich Carrying Vic? torious Team Up Kill to Academy. .-??; b ? ? IB* Whoa* ] West Point, N. Y., Nov. t*\t Th victorious Army team returned to th post at noon to-day. All the ol "?r-fries ai-rompanyirt)* euch occasion Voie ri ? nacted arni if possible wit more eathoaiaaai *hnn ever. The anci'-nt staj-e couch which ha done duty fur alir.ovt ? iinarter of i century dragged th?. members of th team up the lull. Six hundred willin) eodeti manned the rope? and partie Ipi 'rd In the loti?- hnu! The ehee leadera, Martin and H i v.l.?-, ?-?ia nto| the aatiajuated vehicle and led the bat talion iti its rooting, which bej-nn ai th? ferryboat loft the east ?h?re o the river and continued until the mer were drawn Into the barrack yard or the parad?- cr? und?. The paru ? ?! '? th? arad emy bead and the ' ?'?' Navy, ' ?o? itor? Speecnei We; nd, the Armi i ? u "t, the hero of the ga '?' ? ?? and p - v.' re I '??' 'y to com? b a* ai un le?.?, the Army ladl WOl Cheer? for Lieoteaaal Charlea D I)a!y, the Army'i bead eoach; Harry Tuth o? the eleven, and in? dividual mei ? ? ' h? te-i?r. fe Ob the trip home the Army squad ?looted <adet John J. IfcEwan a? It? eaptiin tot next y ?r. MeEwsa la a member of the present sei ami in the roving centre rash who has played ?ucb woaderfu! football foi th? Army doi Ii g the t tl He a . Hil iriag the season just i ? even more eoaaiatsnt and apectacaat th.-.n in previoai pears, and h.? il ?- r?-il : t ? .I iritfa knowing more real football than any man on the Army squad. McEwen waa ar pointed to West Point from the State of Miasmata in .1 IB? 1918, and ?rill craduate with the class of 1917. !' . . ? I in stature, itandiai six feel two. Is tweaty-twe ; M round.?. The ' ? * " will lose m Ij fo-ir player? <-: thii itjp team by errada Jbbo, They ate Cap le; (i'H?ii-, i- ?.''. ; i I, end, H'-i ' ..lui;, full bacVi. ting, a?id with the rii ? ? : playera ami coma m the in JOB? th'' Army con-aider!? the proa re.t. for a BtrOBf team next year a ! n o?t favorable. YALE HOCKEY SCHEDULE Nine Came* Arranged To Play. Prlne-v ton Team Mere. New Bavea, Nov. 2H. Joseph E. Oti., Jr.. manaj-er of the Tale * eanoui <?' .1 th? lehedale tor the i! two game? to he played m ca?e of a tie, are Ion mav be lei ,?. -. i ? ? ?ul** ?' N? ? i ?'??*?? l! . a- : |i,r'm-?iih a- \? I'??" r? -i*rr II. II..??/?! a- I? ? a I - # ? ' S'a* n -.. ? ? , m .- I ? rets "f a I i -- .--.. I .. 4. ll?J.eaI. ax L? ?.. HI. ?-?#? Vt * tl?) ? QUIET HOMECOMING FOR NAVY ELEVEN Middies? However, Give Defeat? ed Tean a Hearty Welcome. 'P. IWt*jr?a*l to Tii? T." MM 1 An- St Tl .- defeat by the Army team yi aterdny Bad the fact that it was Bands? combined to make a quiet homecoming for the Naval Academy eleven to-day. The midship? men gave their gridiron warriori a hearty welcome, however, ?rid would have made a great deal more noise ex? cept for the desire of the playera to get back to their rooms at Haticroft FTall with a? little ?tir a? possible. The football men were pulled through the streets of Ar.nepo'i? by mid-hip men, who tagged a* the ropei of the ; 'buses. At the academy a ?.-rent BOB' fire was 111 in froal of Bancroft Hall, I and the cheer leaden raennted to the and called f-ir fell? for the The?; ended arlth -? year," ladleatiag that H i t begun at oBce to turn ? oh \ FIV? T*PT,~*>TT> 5F?_ TARS PLAY FOOTBALL Elevefl from the Wyoming De? feats the South Carolina Team. Five thotiscnd sailors, officers Rnd civilians saw th? eleven of the ?. S. S. Wyoming, Brat division champions, de ' si tha team of the D. s s Booth ? ! division eham] ia a play-oil af a tie game yesterday at the Ilrooklyn Athletic Field. The score was 19 to 0. By their victory the Wyoming boys won the right to play the U. B & Mew Hampshire el"vn. the third division ehampiOBS, for the Atlantic fleet cham ; ion-hip, next Wednesday afternoon at the SHtiii. ; After five rrvnu'es of play In the first ! th? W] omii | team made its ? ' ? I, CM if the i in (.in.-i backs, fumbled the bail ?..?ii ; .?i .1 i from a ' ' ? ko-1' . n-, aad Luseoa b for a touchdown. The r.?'?? r ?rai a Bip aad toed affair, but la th" fo ? pel lod W) eming - agaii. a foi ??...: -1 paaa from De ? to Mollinski, ahiefa netted ii yards paving the way for a touch? ai ??? n. The next fouehdown rame In the !a?t q'lui'i-r when Beech irtereepted a for? ward pas? anil tlasl.ed seventy-five yards across the goal lin?. Tin? lineup feile - ?.?aj'l, ramllne ? ' - . ' ? ... ? il .I? T . Tainn-non :. . ? . Th . ? I .........I : M , ? rr .......... Da In a II. II ft-AT? . ' , a fr.-re , ' > i fo? llalfj i ? i- far fu I - ??II? ? a. II*. ? -, . ? ' ?a - - mm? na.uuiee. all-western football team ! being selected Voting So Far Gives Three Places to Players from Minnesota Eleven. Chicago, IM., Nov. _R. Good backs wer?, plentiful, but (food linemen ??carca In the central states, according to critic? who assuma the t? sk of picking All Western football teams. The nama All-Western lUelf la a misnomer, for only the limited territory from Ohio to Nebraska, inelusire, la covered In the . search for tulent. In the aaiacttona armilabl?*, the fol lowine have received the greatest num? ber of votes: li I hiimhcrlaln, Nebraska, and Pn-ton, Minne: ota. Tackles: Muck, Wisconsin, and Shall, I'hicairo. Goardai Pi-Sjtereld, Notre Dama, and I? iota. ? ? ? s? , : . Illinois .! l'u sel!. Chicago. Halfbacl Maulbetsch, Michigan, with Ratherford, Nebraska, and Ma r. Illinois, tied I i! backi Biennaa, Minnesota. A tendency to pick players on tho more loeCMBfal teams was manifest, but there wai little difference of ??pinion on tii-- i :nl? _a_S.d over Xquier, Illinois; Menrrs, Wisconsin; Staverum, Wisconsin; Flward. Notre Dam?; Quist, '.,-Ti; Ils nninp, Michigan Aeries, a- .1 Don a i nd Beaten, Michigan. All of these received favura!,!?' mention. Hick's choice for tackle was prac nnaniinons. an?l Shell bad a l'a.r majority. Other tackle? gaining pi?ii>.p ?ran Smith. Michigan Antes; Booghtnn, Ohle Suite; Barron, Iowa; Bnecnner, Pardee: Randolph', North? ? ; Berey, Nebraska, and Petty, I.'inols. At guards, Fit7?er*ld gained the place on his ability to punch holes in opponents' lines, and Abbott, of Neb? raska, was slightly outvoted in favor of Dunnigan. (?ther nam?s wer? Stramberg, Northwestern j '"ochran, Michigan; Keefe, Notre P?me; Sinclair, M ne ota, and Redmen, Insiiana. Blocher, of Purdue, who played on offeree and loose centre on defence, i'* variously chosen for e?*ntre, i'unrd and tackla 1 Bt not a cr:?;c left him out entirely. Watson of Illinois, was nearly the unanimous choice for ? ?. outranking Hnnsun. Mianesota; r. Chicago; Voss, Indiana: Knoll, Ohio .Vate, and Smith, Northwestern.' Rus?ell r'.eanlv carried quurterback, his irreat generalship and the fact that he played his three years without once ??king time out for an Injury giving him the place over Clark, of Illinoia. Other quarters pieked included I'n coll, Nerthveeterni (?rosa, Iowa; WThitaker, Indiana] Long, Minnesota; Pfohl. Wahash, and Moss, Ames. Th< critiei vers widely at variance rsgardlag the halves Maolbetseh, oho made ?? ?ral all-Amsrieaa teams la?< ?*. .1 *o ha\" improved 50 ? ? r cent i'i sls'fs'iisive work, though his ?ads ivi* ys'ar behlad a weak liae, ??.?I not show ii[i ?o well. Ruther finl's all around ability in carrying 'he hall and Macomber's goal? kicking i.srnnl ?hem 'he next place, with Co fall, No're Pame; Porue. Illinois; ilyer?, Wisconsin; Rlake Miller, Michl- ? na AggleS, arsi Rergman, Notra Dame, I high up in ranking. I CELTICS DEFEAT CONTINENTALS IN SOCCER CUP TIE Brooklyn Eleven Has All ? the Better of It Through? out the Contest. WEST HUDSONS BOW TO CLAN MDONALDS Rooters on Sidelines Take a Hand in Contest to the Sorrow of the Visiting Team. The Brooklyn Celtics defeated th? Continentals ;n a cup tie of the Ameri? can Football Association, at Harlem Oval, yesterday, by a ?core of 3 goals to 1. B i faf 11 si-orliijf went, "he SBBBBploBB had the better of Ouch h.ilf, taking tue B the first by 1! to 1 and aiso ?hooting the only goal credited to either ..Ke in the second. Darlas* tha latter part of the game, the CoBtil u Une eshibitioa of ?tubbora attack, but their ?hooting for goal was not always accurate. Th.? (Cities took the len?l, 10 minutes from the itart, arhea Bills worked through, iind sent in a hard drive. which ?' liman atoaped. Ellia recovered the ball on the rebo'ind and score,l on a spectacular play. A loiag shot by Van den Bynden, the Contiaeatal'i cent.-" half, tied the .?.core riv?.? minutes later. It lacked quarter of an hour of half time, when CrOBO, on the right win)- of the Celtic . took a im^r? from O'Halli pliired the champion? once moro in the ' .. L .. breaking through on the -. oread i rner tot tin Celtic? 20 minutes aller the restart. Fiom the i Kick by McGreevey, Ellis he in the last goal of the ?,'""?"? llay?? nid Puxty worked hard to br. ak ?i.i ugh the champions' defi?7ice, and had l?verai openlnca, but ju ?t. fell hhort of tallying each time. The line-up, follows: ?' . : n. CajMlr.-nta'a '!' Duffy .?'.. : Kelly .H fi. I-'rI?l .L. ;:. MctVt?lam? ? .I'.. It. M?*l-^?s .C, H_Van den I ? .I. II. McLean .O. R. 1H.R -'i 0 UnUoran .t. It. 1. la .C. R? - l^n-.on .I. I.. Pnxty ? vev .'i L . 7 i, . . . . .--..... \-in , . ' I- M gvttj ,. T'.-.n 11 a.;rea of ".?a minutas. The replay he?ween the West Rod? "in?, of Newark, end the * la Donalde, of Brooklyn, la the firat round ci the United State? Football Aaooeia ?ion serie? for tl ? -.fi7ionp.l ch:. trophy at Harri.,,in, .'-,'. ,J., ye? ?d in. victory for the former by a Rcoro of 2 goals to * in one of the hnr?>st fought and roughe?t games ?eeeri here this Ee;??on. The tWO teauu, which had met twies ! before without reaching n ! ? aere well matched, ?.nd r.ei?hrr lid? ?cored throughout the first play Fifteen minute:-, after the ? \ Whl ton, a new r.'a- er foi tl i v,.- it Hudaona at eutatde left, ?hut tv goal nfter a misktek by Rob?, the Clan Marl1 ? back. Three minute.? trota tweaty-ftve yards out, V.'i: iton got I '??!. From a cross by MeChesnle, Maddea scored a goal ' for the Clan "?laeDoiinlds fifteen min? ute? from the etui. The line-up follow?: Weit ateSm? CSS. I'o.l'Jnn Cleo MarlVna' fa : rirney .Q . Wlloon Harr .P. O. Lavort) Murray . I. I? . Itos? Muir .H il. I^nnoi . C II. M **f .la- H . LOW? .'. R. |(l un* .I It. ?'. -l .'?. ? .I I. i:.!-. U'l.ia'on.O I. Ha ., Ua W] laten w ?-. ll.iJ..-.? M, ' n run WarD I i Mneeraee !t Marl arid Letttl ? Hare? of forty live Mtf****tf Sunday Soccer Games Results a. r. a. cup Tica Braa-tyn Csitlcs. 9? Casdnaatals *,. I Bt-oafclyn . ??I. R. T. Strallsrs... 0 u. a r. a. cup ties. Wat Hu.sass. 2?Clan McDonalds .. I N. y. a. L. Unter* .?V-B?? Rl'ia. I Cvnsrons . I?Our B?y*i. I Columbia Oral. 0?Clan McOuffs. a WMts Rssa. ?? Huijarians . 0 Lontisilo.s .0?-Clan fkott. 0 Sul.ays .... 4?Ossriaas . I Grsansolnt . 8? Mand.sstsr Unity... 0 METROPOLITAN LEAGUE. Ba> Rldga. -? Vliltatlsn . 0 Grssntllls .14?Si. Uaorta. I Fulton Ca-aroni... S? Jsrsoy Blusa. 2 Whirs Rasa . 0? Gsrmsni . 0 Vonssrs Tflhttss ... I?Human Usttsd. I 8c.nl? h Amarloans 4? Ksarny Athletlos- I BROOKLYNS WIN IN REPLAY OF CUP TIE Spicer a Factor in Victory Over I. R. T. Strollers Eleven. The Brooklyn soccer oleven defeat.*.! the I. R. T. Strollers by the BOOl 3 goals to 0, in the replay of the cup tie at Jersey City, yesterday. The Brooklyna In the first haif established . a lead of 2 goals to 0. Spicer, tho centre halfback, shot the : first goal frsjm a free kick outside of ; tho penalty area. He nlso figured in ; the play \vH:h yielilesl the second ; point, the result of his rass to Shan '. the out?!?!, left. A corner kick by Shanholt gave spicer his next op? portunity to score in the second hnlf. The lino-up followSI l_ (Ss 1' . I H T BtNl . '. I T .an . i. , . .I. fi. . ? .R II.?A . ? ' II . ? 1. II. II. linn/ ks-r.?J R. It. II.iu Ksr.I It . . ' IT. I I .UanbaH 0 I. Safares \ Monti Ins . I -r ? : Greenrills rolled "n the record score of 'he season against St, '?? '? ? ..".nte at M a* comb', l?.i:n l'urk yesterday, d ing ths St, George eleven by it 10 1. At hnlf time the plavcrs from .1er Fey hal a lead of 8 to 0. K > was the most prolific of tho goal get? ters, being creslited with eight. Me? Loughlin a ?- i two jroals nnsi 3, He* , Knight, J. Lowe, Schund and S. |_e? K ?tight one each. Hitchcock was re <nonsihle for the lone tally in St. George's column. Fultons-Camerons Hold Soccer Lead The Fulton-Cameron?, maintained ?heir lead In the Metropolitan I i !>y winning a close game by the ?core of 8 goal*, to 2 from the Jersey Blues, at Hobekon yesterday. T i Jersey Bines took the lead half an hour after tho Start when their centre, Ilaughey, scored with a final shot. Two minutes later, IT. Shaw, ttt m a leffflUMge, r-!:i?,'''i the Jersey ? 'J points un. Braca then ' for the Pulton-Cameroni and ?-hot by liai ? I the leers. Exciting play marked the entire second ps :?r.d i.u* fortune fm:l. .1 * upon the '?easier*, w-io obtained the deciding point, when Click shot the fifth goal of the same from a pass by Reid. The lineup follows: Peatearn. J?*--7 niu cirapfr .Q . Keaaoa .n. 14. ala .i- m. H ' .It. IH. i? Ral ! .C, Il. Rosran ? all .I? It. O i_y .O. R. , . I ? : .I. it. Ml .1 Bnaoe .?.C. Hi oiic_ .i. r.1 ".?rml . ? . I, . H Ro ,..v n si.si?. Jetees 11 nr?, i ?.'??,, s' . si, ! Malili,?. H ?t'.t .J fs.tty r;?s, mlnuies. The State League '.-ame between the ami White Rose at II llted in favor of the White Rose team by 1 goal to 0. Official Fielding Averages of the National League The offldal fielding average? of Na? tional League players who played In 'fifteen or more champ'or.-h Ip games , during the se.i-.on ot Ifll follow: F.risT i?asi toot. o r n a I Ht Mar?? n~t?. ;: IT1 11 ? 1*4* M??; -'lv Ctnrtnn?!!. . I$1 154" "? - Dtubert Bmekli -. r 14 M Lud?rui, I'hMa.le'pMa III 111 II II I Miller. St. I -4 Hyatt B( I.'- ? m lia. New Yor? 111 71 H-a|- ?M Saw V. r-i 1 II alo?. 127 l.-l ? ' 17 HI ! .?. - Chleaco . 1.19 1341 -1 Melaawir, CM?** 1- l?f 7 ? :?;< BEI ONO HA-- m?a Grnii ClaeBwatl . H SI 11 ? ITI ? ? a . . ;?.? ? . Mi ?r. St I.- .1? 71 : ?. Pitt* I ?!lfo . I] ? < 1 Wagner Clnetouatl. M I ten Best . II If? - ' HiiMlr? Bl IaO.Ha. mi |.| ' i?o. -1 II <- ? vi..i Pluaburfb '.. : -i I ? Ml IS ?51 riirlaii. fi.Laio. :? II -l D-..I?. Nn? i i-r* . 14f .1!. KM 4') 111 le:??-, ClndnnaiJ . Sri M 170 11 B41 ?.l-,.f. I'M.i.Ir pi.la. 144 Ml 111 41 Im nan. IM, e?-o. IM .11 M? I- ... M a - j rt (,,_? Olson. Cincinnati ir?!?, ?i ?? IM n IM Tlllltli BASKM-H M.-Car'.h? I'l'-.a fntfaBB II !" I? ? ; ?11 Ptillade.phla flrant. See York. ?Iron. I'ln. Iii.ail. 1 1 ll.ri.? P : ? 1*1] l.l*. . . 1 ??.?ir.. Rr.-.K.? ?. 1 -.1 Lntwft N?w York. II Kmltli. It.?.t.*i . M .' Balrd, Plttabitrit?. 1- . Htielan. liilra*"). ?1 Br'rel. Hi. l??ile. 10' P.?. at. Ht. !?*ll? . >,. .-??i K.v 1-7, i'|- .-lr.nat! . If la?-?^?r. I'itul?iir?h. i.laon, Clnri h .it . 1", , III, Oil avi,. TM ,1 11 Ml BcbulU, I'??"??--? . ...... 11 4 ?I 10 ??. Bralsard, N< ? Tart n If 33 anon**a*fos*s Warier I'l'r?hurih ..... Ul 2"* M M ' II-- o* i Inri al ..151 Ml ill ? lierai ?Uli .... 14'' Ml 4- ? i I - : ? ? ii i i ? ! I . . I?'. . 7 ? I '1 .? I . mfl I- i ? .- phi? ...151 ... i. - .. ;< a- i? 1 - Lout* - S4J 53 ?M . 0 Jl.ue. H- - ... . M 111 4.11 It .906 di ftnumn Fltrpatrl.-I,. Be?ton. 29 ?1 I ? 1 ?0? T-...I-I r. Oil I .r-a-1 . .'4 M 2 0 1 000 Brooklyn. i-i 27 oil ooo Wllauri. Ht Ixiula. 1*5 r? 10 4 .?a? I I'arry. Pl'i.rmrih . 1 I Ml 21 I .Mil Batr.t. I'l'tahurgli. M IS 5 1 I1..'? Ma*-?*, II... on ,. IM ?4-1 1* f 911 ' Whitud riiaiaiimiL.. it? im ; ? Mil R?an. B?>atmi. M M 2 1 -4 \l?rk'?. N?w Tork . SI M ? J Ml! Ban.y. ruialwirfti . M M 2 2 ?72' i -? Ri I a-uta . IM 1ST 11 S .?T| ' . i . '." 151 I? i i. pu? II..Mil .I M I | | . Kllllfer, i -. ... .-I IM IT I l-l. ..t- i- ,1a 1- 1 ' . I'.it.l.un : 17 o - ? 4M lain i . a? ? III l? I? I i.- -. . I . n ?? i Boaton l -i IM 17 7. r i -. i :.' a? ? 14- - ? . I lil.-M'. . 147 IM 74 1 Veta \ ,a . IT? II l: I' ? :l . i.H IM H !?' " ' ly?e- li < '.'..-I I ..II . t"i 20.1 t? Srw York 1 ? .. '? II 11 M4 . lar? llrmhlyn 1?< .'?3 II II flrimih. On li.t ail . IM IM 11 11 Wt lain? (1:.. i: i ail .... ?1 HT 11 I M i ... i, !? i ..:- i .1* ... 1?* : i 3? 15 ?i-- i 1 ? a II'. ?I.?- ? .... ?I ?2J II I? .??? Becker. I'uiilrj I?. It Iff I 11 Mil a I r.iuvrt. Boaton. XT K. .ri?? ?"i.: ?uro. v? I.ajiini.o I'lliAturfh... . '.? sao IM ?. ?' *" H ?? . . -? Louis Se* Tor*. i i B_ ! ? ', . I. l'I father, I' ?? ;i ? sTCHXBB tie ? si ct I k . M ?.. ? .: ? ? - I ' - I' 1 . ?. \ ' . ?* . ... 114 ? I 1.101 Mr? R t. s . . ? 'i I ri-vnt.ns. A'lani?, Ptttsl ilffR. 4<> ? ? ?1 : ? ? s ? i. Phi s ? M Tj st. Bssrto . : i . ? ? ?.irs!?s n ? ? . s ..I, Mayor. I'M ? I P-la. ? l?..sk, St ?Loi b....... ? I ?0 Muslo p I. ?4 .? s s Pi dtW, . I . > < Mamaus. I i . . .?.r Vrsr York. ? ? ., ': 1*. I . .... I ... Ill . ? s ? . -I M?*ssli/#?. St ____,... I .5. . .3* * . : - McQ.lI!?- . i lia Adams Chi .. ? Dalo, Cil . ?". ... 4* Ne. rock. _ sa I'M s (In . I . ? ' titira?. . . n Riser. PI Hs I i-ni.. -?? Uar Clisrlm.all . 40 c?.l_'. PI?tsi irslt. SS j i ? ...SI s ' i ?? s Hr.- i; v, ? s ! n i B.lyt ? suit?. ? I ? .41 rt.i. s..s i.; . IV-lyn... .in ?? Mehaus. SI. !.. il? . . If l'rrrllt. Ns? *i. i I 4 14 1? - 1 3 ? 9 1 3 ?.? ;? s . ? : i ri ? ' i? :? 1) M ?XI H Firi.KING ?', r <? ?.?i tese n-*?isvi . m stt. lrf?, ?.?| :uo lltul.iirfh . ? . 1.1 n? ? " riii.art? phta . i*.? ?i*-? last sie - Uwk . isi 4i?o mu ttt smiis . IM ai,**? I1XI4 IM I s. '.' ?131 19TI 134 ?3M GIANTS AS GOOD FIELDERS THIS YEAR AS LAST Braves and Reds Had , Close Battle for Lead* ?ng Honors. HANS WAGNER SHOWS WAY TO SHORSTOPS Chief Meyers Heads Catchen, ?with Frank Sn>?_er, of Cardinals, Second. The N'e? YorV Giant?, who flnliluJ last In the National I<s,.? pentm OWE is _ :o th? sf. ?? '?? ?/eateries br league. The .? ln ?^ '.TSJIT, '< \\\m f Ma enth this year, v . in last position. But t! <? ?gures emee 1 Mi*t nt a .9 ?'. c.:p, ? : ?j their 1913 . ?rk, ? *ar jj,? turned In ? c?r,i i ? or j3 in r un?l tii/ure?. ' ? terril)? battle ?vith the i . , ?.ors, ami ,,f*_r ^ averages had i SS to ?y? I?luces. Th<> cnrsla show ,. t-j ,9to_7 : . * arere fourth ? ? Shsm the lioit?? r>ris'.^-.. i? the nominal leaiit-r of tk* drat baaemen, but he played in ..]? twenty ^lollwtt^ of ths I 'ore ttk? first honors. Jake Daubert, of tW \ of A? ire tied i ._ p!^ ; ,,,, rhile Vu* S ilar, the atar of ths ' h.'?;,.:<> Cubs, raiik-,1 last amone the re? . That von.1er of tha dit* raond, Hani ? . his fimt Uni U forty-one years of .' he ?i stilt the only Wagner. Chi? ; M, yen, et the Giants? ?r of the catchers. Fr , o:' the Car_U nais, was righl on :> * heeli with u average of I - ,'..rni_ FOURTEEN MEN FACE MAHHASSET TRAPS Several Shoot*? :is Rt quired to Determine \ arfotis Wi-ners. t'n.le- Id? sl etr. rata facesj the ? -*t 1)?? Yacht t.'luh -. ? | toi asNp lent sc< ? wat tha best slay of the aeaaon thu? far for ths ?port, ?uiii so ci so were the leortt la the shoot for the msir.t't . __d yearly that severa. ihoot-eA ottt requireil to deterrr'r.e the wlnnar. Eight men t ! *a11h full scorn a( 2.1 in the shoo' .'sir tho month!* cup. an.l in the ahoot Oil If _. Besdcll the srinner The 'Am* numb? of men I - lie yearly cup. The* vere T I! Lewia, IT. Otoit, W. !.. Bilkworth. I? I Ss?th, C. L Thompson, L A N. ? ?- . D '1 Looral| !.r.?l II. L I!. ? loll It re?! ..r*?l thm fhoot-olTs to decide the victor, .ho ?ai Waldo Q In the l(i() bird hand'rap ihoot Cf. Hy.ie, W Grose, D F. Smith. C. L Thompson, I) Ci 1.1 .ni? ai ?? L A.. Nie* man tied, each returning full ?.?*ort_ l'arkre-rs ]irs ? shoot-off Is this mat?*h It * '. be held neit wMk. I! L Bssstsa ? ? .'? . :? ? \ Vi.ais ? ? T I! la?*? III. .? I W A I M ' . TI'' ti .? ?. .? : * c t ?*?<-? ' C l*ta* > I. Battis .i ?' (S), 1? I.? < ? ? . | ,.. -sl'-T 1 I-.?r!s ("??-i .? ? r K s |. ^> :j_|M, *. ??rois. IJ--I0 I?* D T. Ami., ?.?- -*-lH.?lJ? a . ?? --iwni d. o i i - i >m'#t **? ? <>? ? ;: i su - rr?a-*i, il _ _?___ 9i~t?t* ? w _.-?. tt?a??l II C 9mm ra?is?to TV? u '? ih?*i >_ tn\ w**t Larchmont Yacht Club Shout Thf- Larehmant Yacht Cleh opettel ?tn trapshosstin?/ mi ? rdef ?Itk fonr ?venta ' ? off#ri4 1 y the i te. tai T. J. UeCab'll aroi -wo too* He also p r r. v^s 1 hlgl ?' or after a II A B ?' I? wi i i '???. ? ?? Something new's ?B town! Irish worsted., urovtt ? Jj County Cork and made into Ro<?crs Peet suits. . They're a distinct no\elty. and can be had in New Kork only at our stores. The patterns are quiet ?I -*??* tinctive. and the fabric gives ex? cellent wear. Something new in 'Scotts Mists." Rainproofed coatl oi doubl^ texture cloth?the inside an ??** thentic Scotch Tart.tn Ro?m ?Pbct CoMfeXt Broadway Broad??? at 13th St. ? "he at34tbbi Four . Broadway Coiner*" Fifth A?* at Warren at 41st i*