Newspaper Page Text
Wem $ork tribune First to Last?the Truth: Newa?Editorials ?Advertisements Member of the Audit Bureau of Ct/cul atlor.a > WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 19^ Owned ?id PUbMOied dally t? New Torfc Tribune Ine^, , N>w Tork Corporation ' Oiden Reld, Preeldent : O Vemor Rogers. Vice-Preeldent: Richard H \r*. "f'ret,,7,: r. A. Sitter. Treasurer. Address. Tribu:-.' Building. 154 Nassau Btr**t. New Turk. Telephone, Brekman -0W. BUBSCBrPTTON BATES?By Hall, Including Postage/ I i.V. TUB UNITED STATES r.irTSIDK OK GREATER NEW YORK FIRST AM) SECOND ZONES?Within 150 Mile? of New Yc-k City. , . _0 1 yr. ? m.>. 8 mo. i rao. P?li, md sund?, .Iio.oo *5-22 HU, ,l?S Daily mil, . . 8.00 4.?0 2 00 .75 fcWs* only . 3.00 1.B6 -75 .88 TMK? TO EIGHTH ZONE. INCLT'SITO?Mora ttiau !Sr Mlies from New York Clt? Dall? .nd Sunday .?11.00 ?8.00 88.00 8100 Del:; Jill, . 9.00 ?50 2.25 .80 frujida, on by. J.00 1.75 -80 .00 CANADIAN KATES r>al)> and Sunday ......?UM 1*00 fS.OO 81.?0 ?all, only. ?00 4.50 2.25 .80 fcunda, Mil, . 5.00 2.75 1.40 ?0 FOBKION KATES Ball? and Sunday .12400 $1S.50 86.50 IC.M Daft only . 1800 9.50 5.00 l.JJ ?und?, onlT . 7.00 4.00 2.25 .85 Cnt?red ?t the PostofflVe ?t New Tork ?? Second Cists Mali Matter GUARANTEE feu #?n purchase merchandise advartlsei' Is THE TRIBUNE with absoluto safety?for If dissatisfaction re ?ulia In any cat? THE TRIBUNE guarantees to pay your money baok upon request. No red tap?. No quibbling. We ma?? feed promptly If the ?dvertlaor d??a net. MEMBKB OP" TUE ASSOCIATED PRESS The Assm-laitd Preen I? excluslwl, entitled to th? n#e tor renulil'raticn of .ill new? dispatches credited to it or not otherwise (red!ted lu this panor and also the local ; r,e-*a of spontaneous origin published herein. All right? oi ?publication of all other matter herein art also lejcrtcil. A German Threat The German government's note to President Wilson is a despicable mixture of whine, wheedle and threat. That is to say, it is familiarly and character? istically German. The German government requests tlie President of the United States to arrange for the opening of peace ne? gotiations. The German government, for the purpose of acceleration, proposes first of all a preliminary peace. The German government is particu* larly anxious for the negotiations to begin immediately. The German government has ac? cepted the terms of the arm.istice be? cause it had to do so, but it disap? proves of them and most solemnly calls the attention of the President of the United States to the fact that they are likely to produce feelings in the Ger? man people which will make it impos? sible for them to subscribe to a just and durable peace. The German government is afraid that if it fulfils the terms of the ar? mistice millions of German men, wom? en and children will starve. The German people therefore re (piest the President to use his influ? ence to mitigate these fearful condi? tions. That is the note, It remarkably con? firms the fear expressed by Herr Dr. Muehlon, formerly of Krupps, who was disillusioned about his own people, pub? lished his opinion of them and then went into exile. He said: "The peril of the hour is that the Allies may become kind and humane and extend the hand of sympathy before Germany is ready to confess the wrongs she has done and make restitution." Obviously Germany understands nei? ther her own position nor ours. She is a prisoner among nations?a criminal prisoner. Her life was spared because she put up her hands. The act of physical surrender was one of self-preservation. She acquired there? by neither merit nor virtue. Her fate remains to be decided. In the mean time she will not starve. She is in the hands of people who do not starve or torture prisoners. A little humility would become her as much as anything could. To set up her wishes and preferences, to propose means of accelerating negotiations, to prepare beforehand the ground of alibi by serving notice that the German peo? ple at heart reject an armistice on which the ink is not yet dry?this is truly German. So far we have spoken of ourselves and our allies collectively. We wish to say one thing more for ourselves?for the American people alone. We are not the keepers of Germany's pride or dignity or stomach. We are not Germany's advocate among the Allies. We resent the implication of her solicit? ing the President to procure a mitigation of conditions. If she wishes to make representations of that character let her make them to the authors of the armis? tice. Already we recognize the signs of a German propaganda to be addressed to the maudlin sentimentality of the Amer? ican people. It is a dangerous gas. It is the beginning of an organized effort to produce separate emotion? among the Allies. Therein lies the only hope of escape from what Germany fears to her heart's core. We call It JUSTICE. A Certain Yellowness in Kings Piain, common murderers have often ehowed complete pluck and sportsman? ship. Having done their deed, they have given tbemselveJ up and taken the contcquenccii. Apparently another rule holds for kings and emperors. They beat it while the beating is good. We can think of nothing so calculated to do harm to the king business as the j Kaiser's scuttling like a scared rabbit from the just wrath of his people. Did he leave the Kaiserin behind, by the way? Even we, as Americans, may hopa not. If a king cannot be courageous j he at least need not be a deserter of his womenfolk. According to report, Hindenburg has shown himself better stuff. If he has, indeed, stood by his job and cooperated to saye his nation from chaos, he will have justified much of the popular trust in him. And the people will have proved themselves better pickers of true majes? ty than all the divinities that preside at ! the crowning of kings. A Good Crowd When the lid comes off you see what is underneath. What this old town and its suburbanites, from goodness knows how many miles around, and its visit? ing soldiers and sailors did in its cele? bration gave a pretty clear view into the character and essential stuff of New Yorkers and Americans. That view is of as decent and cheerful and well-behaved a crowd of humans as ever cut loose. Every one who was in the human whirlpool on Broadway Mon? day night bears the same testimony. Drunkenness was the rare exception among civilians, as among men in uni? form. Roughness was almost always good natured and amusing. The police stood about grinning cheerfully and stepping in with a word of warning only in the exceptional cases when jokes were carried too far. There was no need to make arrests, and almost none were made. The police showed admirable tact and sense. They were as typically American in their self-control and good nature as the crowds themselves. Altogether the city did itself proud. Our Last Armed Enemy Germany is out of the war. So are all the other regular members of the Quadruple Alliance. But there is one Teutonized power which has not laid down its arms. That is the Bolshevik government of Russia?a creation of the German corruption fund?which for the last ten months or more has been an irregular but exceedingly useful Ger? man ally. L?nine and Trotzky are at war with the Allied powers. Bolshevist troops are fighting British, French and American forces in Northern Russia. In Siberia they have been fighting Japanese, Brit? ish, French, Italian and American con? tingents. Both in Siberia and on the Volga front in European Russia they are still fighting the Czecho-Slovaks, whose armies have been recognized by the Allied powers as co-belligerent. Red Russia stands, therefore, as the sole sur? viving combatant of the Teuton group? the only organized government standing out against an Allied peace of justice. L?nine and Trotzky have recently be? come aware of their hopeless predica? ment. Not long ago they impudently made a demand on the Allied powers for an evacuation of all occupied Russian | territory?parodying President Wilson's I demand on the government of Prince Max of Baden for the evacuation of alien soil as a preliminary to the dis? cussion of terms of peace with Germany. j Since then they have changed their tune. '] Now they are pleading for any sort of ! peace which will carry with it a recog ; nition of their bloodthirsty and inhuman despotism. L?nine and Trotzky have nowhere to I flee to escape the retribution which , awaits them. The whole world has pro ! tested against their murderous travesty | of government. The Allied powers have ' dealt with the Sultan of Turkey. But : they cannot stain their hands by dealing ; with the impostors, bought and paid for by the German secret service, who se i duced Russia from the Allied cause and ' revived and multiplied in Petrograd and ! Moscow the horrors of Robespierre's Reign of Terror. By the terms of the armistice with Germany the Allies have obtained free access to the Baltic Sea. Their fleets | can approach Cronstadt, the key to | Petrograd. Neither Cronstadt nor Petro? grad can be defended. Poland and all I the Baltic provinces seized by Germany are to come under Allied protection, | awaiting the readjustments of peace. j The Ukraine has also been freed from German control. It can be reached by | the Allied military forces by way of the ! Black Sea. An iron ring can therefore be speed | ily drawn about that part of Russia ! which L?nine and Trotzky still control. ! At the height of their power the Bol? shevists, backed by German money and : troops, could not check the steady progress of the Czecho-Slovaks west from Omsk to the Urals, and thence to ! the line of the Volga. What can they do now, standing alone, against the ; urniies which the Allied powers can ' start toward Moscow from every point of the compass? Winter is near in Russia. But the ? original Russian revolution was carried | through in winter. L?nine and Trotzky's I counter revolution was also carried ; through in winter. There is urgent | need now of a military demonstration | which will pave the way for a third ' revolution and the disappearance of i the present outlaw r?gime in Moscow. If Russia is to be represented in the ! coming peace conference L?nine and I Trotzky must go the way of their kind ?the way of Marat, Danton and Robes? pierre. A civilized government must replace theirs. Otherwise Russia must j lose forever tin? territories of which Germany stripped her and must revert ? to the status of an isolated third class j power. I It is also important that the Czecho Slovaks should be brought home as quickly as possible. They engaged in the wastes of Siberia in one of the most romantic and heroic adventures of the war. They renewed Allied hope? at a period of deepest gloom. They won freedom for Slovakia, fighting 1,000 mileB outside its borders. They should participate in the creation of the new Czecho-Slovak state, whose emergence has been due largely to their almost legendary exploits and sacrifices. The proper climax to the Czecho-Slovak drama in Russia would be a march west through delivered Russia and Galicia to that recreated Slovakia whose national redemption its peoples have dreamed of for hundreds of years. The Great Slump A stale, flat world we live in? No news worth reading, nothing worth do? ing except celebrating what is past and dead? Well, what else could any one ex? pect? We have been living on romance and adventure, the greatest adventure in the history of the world, for four years now. The morning's cup of coffee has been drunk to a daily accompaniment of colossal deeds that packed a newspaper's front page with headlines and crowded ordinary American local doings off the stage altogether. Such has been our scale of life and diet of excitement. Now, with a few strokes of a pen it is all withdrawn. We may see trouble and messes and more lighting. But it will never be the same. The curtain has been rung down on the greatest of all human dramas and we are left with little save to put on our coats and hats and wander aimlessly and pop-eyed out into the old familiar world, now so far away and forgotten and alien and?dull. It is a great slump we are going through, and we shall not gain anything by blinking our eyes to it. We have all of us done hard and disagreeable tasks gladly and well. Our soldiers have done dangerous and deadly tasks as well. The general spirit has been one of enthusiasm and glad sacrifice. Now a very different set of motives, a wholly changed frame of mind, uprises. Wo find ourselves back in our old 1914 grooves?and we do not fit them?or if we do fit them they seem very shallow and straight and dull. Anything that comes now is an anti- I climax. However blood may run in the streets of Berlin, the news will never have the thrill of that vast duel on the fields of France, the greatest tourney in the annals of combat. The slump for soldiers and sailors will be worse than for plain civilians. The old William James quest for a moral equivalent for war will face them in a quest for an equivalent for the advent? ure of war. There are plenty of ad? ventures left. There is the sea, neg? lected by Americans for many decades. There is overseas trade. There is the world of international politics, now at our gate. There is the whole tangled web of reconstruction, social, political, economic. But it is a gloomy, boring outlook by comparison, at best. Lucky for the old human machine that it possesses such amazing powers of ad? justment to environment! It found it? self in a great war and enjoyed it. It will undoubtedly make something of plain, dull peace before long! When the folding trench cap replaced the American campaign hat for overseas wear hundreds of thousands of felt hats were checked in to army supply ser? geants. Now a use has been found for them. With felt from the hats and cloth from torn uniforms the salvagers are making soft slippers for wear in hospi? tals. In Illinois prisoners are helping win the war. More than six hundred have been paroled from the state's peniten? tiaries and put to work in the Rock Island arsenal. Most of the money they ?>arn is sent to relatives and dependents. To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: For five generations no citizenship for a German in any other country? Very moderate your proposal. Shall we let any of them visit our shores?even visit them? for the same period of time? Is the Ger? man "reservist" who "chucked his job" in a West End Coney Island saloon to go over there and agonize our boys with poison gas to come blithely buck when Coney opens its season in the spring? Ye gods! We excluded the Mongolian for the comfort of such as these! la a complete loathing for the German beast consistent with one's faith and hope and charity? I think so. I think the peo? ple of America feel so. They couldn't buy the toys wrought by a people who cut off tho hands of little Belgian children. Words and phrases pall upon us to-day. Who tells us to sing no "hymn of hate" is out of tune. This week the printing house which is conducted in connection with "The Araltyville Record" turned away some orders for printing in the German language. Intolerant? Maybe. Tolera? tion of the beast of mankind must be about. as contracted as you propose this morning in your editorial headed "Sentence." Only more so. CHARLES F. DELANO, Editor "The Amltyv'lte Record." Amityville. N*. Y., Nov. 8, 1918. How to Restore Louvain To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: I notice a call for aid to restore Louvain University. There is only one rea .--onable nay to restore it. That \a to trans? fer to Louvain the equipment und library of a Prussian university, preferably Berlin. New York, Nov. 12, 1918. LEO STEIN. - ?".msvmsMmk^mmWmmmswmm THE LAST FRENCH LOAN A poster designed by Abel Faivre for the Fourth "Loan of Liberation" of the French Republic in the Great War.?from L'Illustration. SHOES & SHIPS & SEALING WAX "MIKE SCOTT?NO ADDRESS." (American Casualty List.) Just a homeless, roving sort of chap, Gayly knocking round about the earth, Into any decent kind of scrap So it were but big enough of girth; Glad to get his chance to mix it rough, Fight for freedom on the fields of France, Show himself of Scottish-Yankee stuff, Teach the Huns a lively back-step dance. First and foremost where the light was hot? Just Mike Scott! Mike, who cared to give them no address: Named nor friend nor any kith or kin, No acknowledged old home town to bless, No loved hearts to spur him on to win: Leaving not an eye to scan the list, Recognize his well beloved name, And be sure the jolly Mike they missed Played so well this last and greatest game; Yet we know he fought most soldier-like: Right there, Mike! Though no record stand of whence he came, He has made his record with the rest; Played his part out on the fields of fame, Been nmong the men who backward pressed All the flower of the German line, Taught the Boche respect for Yankee blows: Where Mike hailed from needs no special sign Mike himself knew, and the Kaiser knows! Knows and trembles! Whence? Enough to say U. S. A. WALSTON SOUTHWICK. The Kaiser, the Croivn Prince and the whole General Staff have fled to the I Netherlajids, and we wouldn't blame the i good Dutch burghers a bit if they raised I a howl for a protective tariff on imported cheese. There are just about 2,000.000 rea? sons why you should give every nickel you can to this war fund drive, folks. They are in France, and several thou I sand more reasons have been arriving on ! each transport. You blew yourself to Liberty bonds. i You weren't doing any one a favor by | buying them. Let's see how genero.us we are when we aren't getting anything out of it ourselves. Every show you deny yourself this j week can be made a spree for the men i who have been doing your fighting for you. Every box of candy you don't buy when you want it can be made a gift to those who really need sweets. Let's go over the top for those who have been going over the top for us! The Kaiser has deserted his country, ; thereby beating the country to it by a few short hours. * ? ? SEVERAL TUTS! Mary has a Hule calf And with this fact before v.* We plainly nee tha reason whj *he can't go In the chorus. JOHN DOH. Those Guys Would Do Anything F. F. V.?Might the Hohenzollerns not refer to the present cessation of ! hostilities as a "disarmistice"? "VEGETABLE." Apart from a mild case of shell shock, I caused by exploding auto mufflers, And three new corns born of the ! march of thousands across our feet, And a twinge of regret that those who ; held the world safe for democracy ; couldn't hold their liquor a little less os? tentatiously. Ami a little weariness when regarding ' the civilian of draft age who now de? mands blood thirstily to be led against the Germans, We'll admit that this waa one of the pleasantest armistice signings we ever celebrated. The Bolsheviki, Chester, are the peo? ple noto engaged in kicking Mitteleuropa right in the mittel. F. F. V. I Lucifer Isaiah xiv; 9-21 9. Hell from beneath is moved for thee to meet thee ?it thy coming: it stirreth up the dead for thee, even all the chief ones of the earth; it had raised up from their thrones all the kings of the nations. 10 All they shall speak and say unto thee, Art thou also become weak ?as we? art thou become like unto us? 11. Thy pomp is brought down to the grave, and the noise of thy viols: the worm is spread under thee, and the worms cover thee. 12. How art thou fallen from heaven O Lucifer, son of the morning! How art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations! 13. For thou hast said in thine heart, I will ascend into heaven, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God: I will ait also upon the m<-unt of the congregation, in the sides of the north: 14. I will ascend above the heights of the clouds; I will be like the most High. IB. Yet thou shalt be brought down to hell, to the sides of the pit. 16. They that see thee shall narrowly look upon thee, and consider thee, saying, Is this the man that made the earth to tremble, that did shake kingdoms; 17. That made the world as a wilderness, and destroyed the cities thereof; that opened not the house of dis prisoners? 18. All the kin^s of the nations, even all of them, lie in glory, every one in his own house. ! 19. But thou art cast out of thv grave like j an abominable branch, and as the raiment i of those that are slain, thrust through with j a sword, that go down to the stones of the j pit; as a carcase trodden under feet. 20. Thou shalt .lot be joined w.th them in burial, because thou hast destroyed thy land and slain thy people: the seed of evil I doers shall never be renowned 21. Prepare slaughter for his children for the iniquity of their fathers; that they do not rise, nor possess the land, nor all the face of the world with cities. The Kaiser's Trial i To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: After reading your article in The Sunday Tribune, "Lauzanne Wants Kaiser Put on Trial," I sincerely hope I am only one of the many who feel that their own sentiments have been precisely expressed. i Cannot something be done to promote j such a trial as St?phane Lauzanne speaks of? The Tribune has done so much along lines of taking up and promoting things of importance. Certainly a movement to ' punish the Kaiser and his officials is a | thing of world-wide interest and should be heartily indorsed. (Mrs. Joseph H.) EDNA V. GREEN. Passaic, N. J., Nov. 10, 1918. Why Not Try This First? (From Ufe) The Peace League of more or less bel? ligerent nations suggests that we might have, just for practice, a peace league on j a smaller scale right here at home. How ; would a peace league composed of Theo ! dore Roosevelt, Henry Ford. Robert La Follette, George Creel, W. R. Hearst, Ogden 1 Keid, Henry Cabot Lodge, W. H. Hays and : Joseph Tumulty do for a starter? The rules could be catch-as-catch-can, three-ounce gloves, with ample police pro? tection. If among these gentlemen harmony could be established, then a permanent peace j basis for the world at large need not be considered impossible. Peace Problems By Frank H. Simonds (Copyright, 1918, New York Tribune Inc.) THE actual signing of the armistice i opens the way to that peace con gress of which the world has been talking for the past four years. In that ? period there has been a growing appreci | ation of the fact, that a general settle [ ment, comparable in its magnitude to that of Vienna in 1815, was inevitable l when at last the time came to liquidate [ the present struggle. What has never been properly per I ceived in this country is the magnitude of the task and the obstacles which make it almost inevitable that many, many months will elapse before the signatures are written under the definitive docu ! ment, the reasons why a settlement even | within the limits of next year are slight ! in the extreme. After the first abdication of Napoleon [ the victorious Allies met in Vienna in i November to reconstruct Europe. They I were still in session when Naprleon re | turned from Elba in the following I March, and they lingered until June 9 j before they signed the final treaty. Nor would this settlement have come had it not been because of the pressure of events. It was Napoleon who in reality ? made any agreement possible at Vienna, by restoring unity of purpose to his ene : mies, who were bee nn:nrr to be sepa ? rated by connecting ambitions. Thus, in the case of the last general i settlement in Europe much more than I a year divides the actual ending of the | hostilities from the signing of the final I settlement. Tn the interim there had \ been sicned a treaty between France and her enemies, the Treaty of Paris, exe cuted promptly after Napoleon's first abdication, but a second Treaty of Paris, following the -econd abdication, was not ?igned until November 30. Thu-* the settlement hung fire over all the per:od from April 7, 1814, to November 30, j 1815. In the present case we have to face certain conditions which recall those of 1814-'!5. First of all it is necessary to ! find a German government with which to negotiate. In 1814 this was supplied by the return of Louis XVIII. Thanks to the aid of his brother sovereigns Louis was able to take over French adminis? tration with relatively small difficulty. : both in 1814 and again in 1815. The ; fabric of government was not destroyed, there was merely a change in the sover? eign, the executive. But in the case of Germany we have something approaching a genuine revo? lution already, and there is good reason to believe that the disorder may extend in the following weeks. In any event no government c'hn be more than provi? sional until there has been a German election, a submission of the new order I to the people. With any other govern ? ment the Allies must hesitate to do busi I ness lest it be repudiated later by the j people. But an election can hardly come before demobilization, before evacuation of the regions to be occupied by the Al I lies, least of all can it come before the German chaos has settled into some form of order. We may then conclude that any real peace conference in the present year is out of the question. We may suspect ! that any gathering early next year is : unlikely, given the existing situation of chaos, not merely in Germany, but in i Austria and in Turkey. Peace can only be made with governments, and for the . moment there is no government in Aus? tria or Germany and no handy substi : tute such as Louis XVIII constituted in 1814. Nor is this the sole difficulty. We are not merely to deal with Germany in making the new peace, but wc have to reconstruct the maps of Europe, Asia and Africa and reorder the relations be? tween the nations of the world. We have to or?ate new countries and we have to rewrite the international law governing countries in their dealings hereafter. In a word, we have to free the smaller peoples and to construct t league of nations. Looking to the task of liberating the smaller peoples, it is apparent instantly that the problem is colossal. The con? flict between various claims is b-und to be sharp. We have already the pro? tests of the Jugo-Slavs against Italian claims in the Adriatic. Greek protests against Italian claims in Albania, Rtf thenian prcte-ts against Polish policy in Eastern Galicia. The German minority in Czecho-Slovakia is already becoming vocal and the racial problems of Russia are manifold. It may be that the victorious Allies will follow the course of their predeces? sors in 1814 and promptly ?ign a treaty with Germany, always providing that Germany can in the meantime achieve a national government. But this would be but a minor detail in the pe?era! set? tlement, as the Treaty of Paris was wholly subordinate to that of Vienna. And the problem of time would remain in the matter of the larger task. Measuring by past precedent, it seem? to me almost inevitable that the wf8" tiations for restoring peace now mu occupy most if not al! A next year, end may easily extend into ?020. There may be separate treaties closing the war as between Germany an i the A.lies, Turkey and the Allies and Bulgaria and the Ailes, but the?e will not collectively or severally dispose of the even greater questions of race and of international relations. And even if Germany find3 herself, there remains Russia, without which no general settlement can be made and concerning which all that we know precludes hope of ?peedy sanity. In a word, the making of peace may spread over years, as in the case o? Westphal?a an'! Utrecht: u '?ccunv less t*me than the settlement of the Napoleonic period, which occupied more than twenty month-:, punctusted by the Hundred Day. o. ...., The Clearest Voice (November Elei'enih) THE golden voices of the bells break witb sudden laughter; t Leap the sirens, golden-voic? d, the peeks o. autumn sky' There are voices everywhere, -mging, S; S ing, singing, "Jesu. Saviour, peace is come, Thy blessed p'-ace is come. ? The dark hills break into singing. And the broken valley placet; The wind-strewn seas, white with gol'"- a in deep voice, ? And there is singing in the invisible l?n of sky. ... Yet clearer than all the?? In the full streets of great cities, | On the hushed front of the gray battle tt? ? . Up the lonely forest passes And in the rocking breast of the it*r~ ? Ah! the clearest voice sings unheard In the heart of One, alone, Of One who walks with bended heal Unseen of all th8 throng. "Jesu. Saviour, peace is com?? 1 hy blessed peace is tome." FLORENCE RIPLEY