Newspaper Page Text
Burned at the Stake as a "Relapsed Heretic" bv Her Mis guided Age J JOAN OF ARC, who was burned at the stake as a "relapsed heretic" and who was described by sober historians as a witch in league with the fiends of 11, will bo proclaimed to-daj as a saint ? . the Roman Catholic Church. Cope Bene? dict has ordered her formal canonization, ceremony, coming nearly 500 years after her death, marks the conclusion of half a century of formal effort to clear her memory. From to-day, in Roman Catholic practice, there can be no dispute. The Supreme Pontiff will have spoken ex cathe? dra. From his dictum there can he no ap? peal. The name of Joan of Arc takes its placo wjth martyrs and confessors, and venera 'i of her name becomes an obligation upon Roman Catholics everywhere. Ten rs ago, by order of Pope Pius, .??>an of \rc was beatified. This meant that her mory had been formally pronounced "blessed" and that local veneration was rmittod, The sanctions of today's ceri mony ;?i<? not merely permissive; they are 11 .1 II'I.'1 til IV. rhcy represent the ultimate effort of the Koman Catholic Church to remove a stigma which it long sinco repudiated. They ri ont il"' oporations of a long and in volvcd process which, in the eyes of the Church, can permit of no mistakes. Re? viewing her historj meant the appointment of .; devil's advocan*, whose effort it was, il order that the Church might, be safo uarded, to combat every effort looking ? ?ward to-day's ceremony. Twenty-four years after the ?pndemna tion of Joan of Arc, a revision of her trial, the "proc?s de rehabilitation," was begun in Paris, with the consent of the Holy Sec. The proceedings of the trial were reviewed exhaustively; witnesses were rc?xamined, and finally the judgment was reversed and technically annulled. But Joan's body was then in ashes and the waters of the Seine had carried those ashes where they would. Even before the trial there had been many adherents of the Maid of Orleans who Liad believed lier divinely inspired. With the repudiation of the findings of the court many began to feel that the mere reversal and annulment of the judgment could not atone for what had formally been declared an error. But not until 1?69 were the opi r tops taken for her beatification and ultimate canonization. In that year Mon signor Dupanloup, Bishop of Orleans, made fin appeal to the Pope. His action culmi? nated, on April 11, 1909, in the publication of a decree of beatification by the Pope, Pius X. A mass and office for the Blessed s) ?'".-?il wa latei approved for use in the ! I oc< " of O? lea ir". Burned At Stake To-day's ceremony will again focus the ;. tention of the world upon this peasant girl who shaped the course of history. The part she played in the destinies of France; the legend that has grown about her per.-on; the years of controversy over the steps in the canonization, have made :? . mory of the Maid of Orleans one of ? ? high lights of history. In the minds j of the French Joan of Arc is not only a tradition, but an ever-present guardian of the national destinies. To them it was the spirit pf Joan that stopped the Huns at tin- .Marne. born of a well-to-do peasant family in Domremy, a small village in the Vosges, partly in Champagne and partly in Lor? raine, she emerged, unlettered, to advise a Kine; and to take command of his army. She appeared as if in fulfilment of prophecy. She spoke of her divine inspiration, of the leadership of heavenly voices. At first she '. was corned. But she triumphed over each succeeding rebuff, and finally, in the mo? ment of testing, penetrated a King's dis guise and commanded liis attention and con? fidence. Her military genius placed a crown upon the brow of an uncrowned Dauphin. She won wild acclaim. Then came a reverse. Wjth it came n loss of popula? favor and of tho King's confidence, intimately those !h" had believed in ner heavenly guidance looked upon her as a witch. She was sold by those whom she- had served, She was tried by an ecclesiastical court; sentenco was suspended; a retrial was or? dered or, rather, a trial for relapsing into heresy. That heresy consisted merely in tho wearing of man's apparel. Sho was burned at the, stake. Her ashes -were scat? tered into tho Seine because of a super? stitious fear that the machinations of the devil would begin in the vicinity of her remains. To-day she triumphs over and in the Church that condemned her, and millions?millions that owe nothing to her by any national tradition.will venerate her as a saint. ? Some historians have tried to ascribe her leadership to successful priestcraft. But it has been shown that the only instruc? tion sho ever received upon ecclesiastical subjects was at her own mother's knee. She learned the "Pater Noster," the "Ave Maria" and the "Credo." She knew nothing of reading or writing. She was brought up in ignorance even of the prophecy which, it was Inter held, she emerged to fulfil. Bidden by "Voices'* The Maid of Orleans was pictured bj early historians as a shepherdess. But from her own lips there is a denial of this. She tended her father's flocks occasionally Yet her chief occupation was that of i maid-of-all-work. She was an excellen cook. Sho was proficient in the use of th< needle. She was noted for her physica energy, which is often a complement of ! highly nervous temperament. None could possibly have been more sur prised than her nearest neighbors when sh? came forward with claims that were lookei upon by all as fantastic and fanatical. Per haps a few of her girlhood friends wer not. amazed, for they had watched he gradually withdraw frtim their society an give her time to solitary brooding and t fervent prayer. Her father was a peasant owner, whic means a freeholder. His circurtistance were easy, so Joan wanted nothing. Hi name was Jacques Dare and the rightful name of the new saint was Jeancttor? Uure. Her mother was unusually devout, even for that early day. She had made a pilgrimage . to Rome and was rigorous in her observance | of church customs. It was when Joan was about thirteen and ! a half years old, according to the best at j tested statements, that ?'he became con ! scious of "hearing supernatural voices." I From her own words it is assumed that she I believed these manifestations to be accom | panied by a blaze of light. She declared | she recognized the voices as those of St. Michael, St. Margaret and St. Catherine. To her confessor she said nothing about these voices, .and, at her trial, she refused to testify further about the appearances to her except to say: "I saw them with these very eyes, as well as I .see you." By May, 1428, .she had no doubts as to the messages that were Iransmitted through these "voices." She felt that she was bid? den to go to the assistance of the King. She presented her plea to Robert Baudri court, who commanded the King's armies in the neighboring town of Vaucouleurs? "The Catholic Encyclopaedia" has it that Baudri court rebuffed her with the statement, "Take her home to her father and give her a good whipping." In the next few days the,situation of the i Dauphin, afterward Charles VII, became more desperate. Orleans was invested, and | it seemed as if the King must face a com ! plete defeat. ; Rebuffed \ By King Because of the rebuff she had suffered at i the hands of Baudricourt, Joan, according - to her own testimony, made an effort to rc ' sist the voices. But they became threaten ! in?. Jn January of 1429 she again appeared before Baudricourt. Again he refused to receive her statements seriously. Joan rc ? mained in the vicinity and won over a num \ ber of his advisers. On February 17 she ? told of a great defeat of the armies of the Kintr at Orleans. A few days later the ofFi ? cial reports of this engagement were re ceived and those that had been skeptical now turned to Joan for advice. With Baudricourt's expresa sanction and attend ? ed by six men-at-arms, she sought an au ? dience with the Dauphin at (,'hinon. Joan I was in male attire, which she adopted as a I protection while in the company of the sol? diers. The King was just as skeptical as Baudricourt had been. He assumed a dis? guise. But Joan singled him out of a I larger proup and conveyed to him a message I that made him realize that she was no or i diiiary person. It is reported by most his? torians that this message set at rest his fears as to his own legitimacy. Other writers say she repeated to him a prayer which, he said, could have been known only to himself and God. Before the Dauphin would permit Joan to take any part in the military operations [ under his command he ordered that she be scut to Poitiers to be examined by a com : mittee of bishops and doctors. & The minutes of this examination disap? peared, and were not available .at the time of Joan's trial, although she frequently ap? pealed for their production. Nothing could be found against her. She was declared to be a girl of simple faith and the ecclesi? astics could lind nothing heretical in her claims to heavenly guidance. The report of the examination did not pass upon the ? validity of her claims. It merely replie?! to the negative accus?t ion;., ami said that nothing actionable could be found. Used an Ancient Sword Upon being permitted to return to Chi non Joan made immediate preparations for the campaign. She was proffered a sword by the Dauphin, but she declined it, saying an ancient sword would be found buried To-day Acknowledged as a Saint With Fitting Ecclesias? tical Honors i behind the altar in the chapel of Ste. Cath erine-de-Fierbois. A sword was found as she had indicated. ' At the same time it was decided that she should have her own standard. This was made for her with the words, "Jesus, Maria,"* and with a picture, reported to be of God the Father, one of the very few ever attempted. Kneeling before the image of i the Deity were figures of angels presenting a fleur-de-lis. On April 22, 1429, a letter was written I by Sire de Rotslaer. This letter, now pre? served in the original manuscript, says: "She would save Orleans and would compel the English to raise the siege; that sho herself in a battle before Orleans would be wounded by a shaft, but would not die of it, and that the King, in the course of the com | ing summer, would be crowned at Rheims, together with other things which the King I keeps secret." I Joan's entrance into the field of military operations was as audacious as her presen? tation of herself to Baudricourt. She sum? moned the King of England "to withdraw his troops from French Boil.'f This demand was indignantly rejected, as of course she ex? pected it would be. Joan then effected her own entrance to Orleans. Her mere pres? ence heartened the soldiers in the be? leaguered place. Nine days after her arri? val, on May 8, all the forts encircling the city had been captured and the siege raised. On the preceding day Joan had been wound? ed by an arrow. Wins Big Victory She was not. mortally hurt and was eager to push her success, because, she insisted, she had been warned by her "voices" that she had only a year to live. The Dauphin and his advisers delayed their offensive. But Joan persisted and en ? couraged the troops to many new successes. t On June 18 these preliminary engagements l culminated in a great victory at Patay. The : English forces, together with great rein I forcements under Sir John Fastolf, were ! routed. This victory opened the path to Rheims and to the fulfilment of the proph ] ccy that the Dauphin should be crowned. Again all the energy and enthusiasm of the Maid of Orleans were needed, for the I King's advisers urged a retirement before ? Troyes, where a sharp resistance was en? countered. Joan led the troops in an at j tack on the town and i? fell. Then she compelled the advance to Rheims, where, ! on July 17, 1429, the Dauphin was formally ; proclaimed King and where he received his crown. She shared the honors of the great cere? mony and stood beside the King. She in , sisted that her own standard be displayed conspicuously, saying, "as it had shared the toil it was just that it should share in the ] victory." Wounded In Thigh Joan here felt that her mission had been , acccomplished in the main and sought to withdraw from the King's armies. But she was not permitted to leave. Toward the end of August it whs decided to attempt an assault upon Pans, tk forces, led)by Joan, occupied St. Denis On September 8 Joan, while cheering the men onward, was shot through the thigh *ith a bolt from a crossbow. The Due d'Alencon removed her from the battlefield and the assault was abandoned. Joan felt keenly the failure to attain the objective. She knew that her prestige was in danger, that she no longer inspired the men as once she had done. When the truce was signed with the Duke of Burgundy, JMB laid -down her arms on the altar of St Denis. On December 29, in the midst of a season of military inactivity, the King ennobled the maid and her family, who, hencefor? ward, were known as Du Lis, from the fleur-de-lis on her standard. In April Joan again took the field. Her "voices" had represented to her that she would be taken prisoner before midsum? mer's day. On May 24 she had thrown herself into the defence of Compi?gno, menaced by the Burgundians. During the evening she r??! lied 500 of the troops to attempt a sortir. They encountered a vastly superior force and attempted to withdraw to the city. Faced Death Calmly The commander at, Compicgne, evidently in a panic as the noise of the lighting drew nearer, raised the drawbridge. Joan and many of those with her in the sortie were left outside. She was taken prisoner. Joan was held captive for many months. No effort was made by the King to ex? change or ransom her. In the mean time she was a problem to lier captors. They could only cite her before an ecclesiastical court for heresy. There, was no military ground upon which they could condemn her, for she had merely beaten them. Ultimately this was the fate she offered, and there has been much written upon the subject of her trial and its legality. She faced her accusers fearlessly and re? sisted all efforts to confuse her. On Marcii 1 Joan stated that "within seven years' space the English would have to forfeit a bigger prize than Orleans." Less than ' ven years later Paris was lost to Henry VI. Eventually she was sentenced to deat? but this sentence, after many appeal an?! many efforts to involve others in ?ti rape sition, was suspended. Then Joan - back to prison after being prepare?l fur the stake. This so aroused the Burgundians and the English that they laid a new trap for her and placed men's clothing in her way. She adopted male attire again, this time as a protection from her jailers, and was cited as a "relapsed heretic." She was tried on May 21, 1431, and the sentence was carried out the next day. By George S. Edgecombe HETHER prohibition will or will not result in a great increase in th'e use of habit forming drugs i*? a question on which even the experts in drug traffic do not agree. One of the arguments of thos*e who believe j' will not is that one of the causes of drug using is the relief which it affords to persons sutTering from the effects of over ?ndu.Kt-nce in alcohol. While the experts are debating the outcome the public gener? ally realizes, in an indifferent way, that ilruj; ad'licts are increasing alarmingly every .'?car. It does not, however, realize that ??'.'.? York state now lias a new "Narcotic ch went into effect. March 1, and which most experts believe will cope with the evil, present and future, better than any statute heretofore enacted iri any - of the Union. Under this new law the Department of Xarcotic Drug Control, headed by Com? missioner Frank Richardson at Albany, di? vides the state into four administration dis? tricts. All persons or corporations hand ling cocaine or opium or their derivatives must register with this board. The manu? facturers and wholesalers, down through the druggists and physicians, must file one of triplicate order blanks, giving dates and ?g the amount of drugs purchased, prescribed or ?licensed by them. Even den ' and hospitals are included in the law. Violation of the law is a miiukmeanor and of th'- penalties i:; the revocation of "ties. The Federa! Harri on law and the original Boytan state lav/, enacted in 19! 1, although ded to curb the evil, had the unex ?! effect of causing physician i to fight ? t treating drug addict?. The result was 'hat the traffic was drrven into the. the underworld venders again. ? '? ged the various hoi pita!? and tation houne** were crowd? ?1 with i pplieants for reh.'f. Thia went on until 1917, when the Whitney bill went into effect. 'I htt nnw law encouraged the treatment of xid/Os by physicians. This brought about mi u irinclpled physicians took advantage Of tO d pt ? ?-?ry.t: tin:,: ., "rf.. pestera' in their office?, and thus reaped unconscionable profit-. That abuse of their power* became no great that Federal au tnorii ? recently obliged to ."?* over ific beads of otate ai police to tari many ??tabliehmente which .were ?ell W ing to long lines of supposed addicts in waiting, who in turn were selling the drug to soldier:, -.viso' carried it right into the military cantonments themselves. It Hinges on The Physician For the past two years the problem of drug control has centred on the physi? cians. Justice Cornelius F. Collins, of Spe? cial Sessions, chairman of the consolidated committee on the drug evil, however, is authority for the statement that not more than 100 physicians, out of several thou i sand in greater New York, have been "un? conscionable" violators of the law. Th? details of how the new law enables the Department of Narcotic Drug Control to keep tabs on a given quantity of opium, morphine, cocaine or heroin as it passes from manufacturer to the ultimate con? sumer are too many and devious for the purposes of this article. The supporters of the bill admit that under existing condi? tions of imperfect national and interna? tional control it is at best imperfect, but they believe that it is a forward step in the solution of the difficulty. Dr. James A. Hamilton, Commissioner of Correction, says the new law will not pre? vent physicians from issuing several pre? scriptions to the same addict or patient in one day. Supporters of the bill point out that the Department of Drug Control un? der the law has means at hand to discover that abuse, and when discovered it, is ex? tremely likely that the offending physician will lose his license to obtain the drug. Ore of the grounds for anticipating a f great increase in drug addicts is the war. | Morphine and, in many cases, heroin have ] been largely used in surgical cases where soldiers have been gassed. It is feared that I sufficient quantities have been absorbed in i this manner to form habits among many of ! the returning troops. The War Department is trying to guard against this by careful medical examination at discharge of troops, and embryo addicts will be treated in gov? ernment hospitals. The Number Of Addicts The number of addicts in New York City has been conservatively estimated by Jus? tice Collins at 1 per cent of the population, or about 100,000. Causes of acquired habits are mainly these: Extensive surgical treat ! ment, protracted medication for bodily ail? ments and disease, persistent taking of patent medicines containing an appreciable quantity of the drug, seceking relief from alcoholic excesses, to association, environ? ment, gang influence and foolish curiosity, ! and last, but not least, to the interchange of the drug in jails and prisons, where it is i indulged in furiously by felons in a frenzied attempt to overcome mental anguish. The addicts are found in all walks of life, the rich and the poor; all professions and business callings. The use of the drug by the "underworld" and criminal classes ren? ders more sinister their power and greatly I hampers their chances for reform. Opium using and morphine taking seem to be waning. Cocaine, and particularly ! heroin, are most, in demand. The hero ' in habit is growing at an appalling rate ' and strikes particularly at the youth of 1 America. Between the ages of seventeen - and twenty-two there are so many heroin i users that the average age of its victims is easily set at twenty years. What the Courts Know "We men of the courts," says Justice Col I lins, "know the horrible examples. We see young men almost destroyed, absolute shad j ows of their former selves, with will, mem , cry and understanding impaired, 'the pale I youth* descrioed by Edwin Markham in j frenzied fancy, their 'phantoms that fling ! wild laughter and wild tears into the crater of the wasted years,' with no normal sense : of right or wrong, with a pronounced in ITHIN a few weeks Paris has wit? nessed two sensational trials for acts of political terrorism. In the one case Cottin, the crazy young Kiiarchist who attempted to kill Clemenceau, the "grand young man" of France, was sentenced to death by court martial. In the other Raoul Villain, the ? !;?\<r of .lean Jaur?s, leader of French So? cialists and anti-militarists, was acquitted by a jury after a trial which lasted only five ?lay-. The acquittal of Villain leads us back into the last days of July, 1914, when humanity watched in breathless suspense for the fall of the blow destined to ?'bake the whole world m it-' foundations. Nothing shows more clearly the terrible tension of those days than the fact, teslitie? to by contem? porary newspapers, that the assassination of Jaur?s, in ordinary times a firnt rate world en ation, was panned over almost unnoticed. It. was completely overshadowed by the new? of ultimatums, dvclaratioua of war and gi W gantic army moves, which were just usher- f ing in the greatest war of history. It was on the evening of July 81, 1914 - the last evening of peace that Jean Jaur?s, most powerful anti-militarist agitator in Europe and leader of trie French Unified Socialists, then just triumphantly emerging : from a hot election light, was shot by a youngish man as he was dining with a frii n i behind a window at the caf? du Croissant, near the Bourse. The assassin, standing on the sidewalk, fired several shots through the window-, two of which hit the victim, who expired in a few minutes. A crow?! seized the assailant, who was first believed to be an Austrian, and nearly lynched him before he was res? cued by the police. He gave his namo as Raoul Villain and said Tie was the son of a court clerk in Rheims. He admitted that before shooting the Socialist leader he had first telephoned to the restaurant to make sure whether he was there. When examined by the magistrate, Villain snid that he acted of his own accord and did not belong to any organization, reaction? ary or otherwise. He Raid: "If I have commute?, this net, it is because Jaur?s betrayed my country by leading the campaign against the throe-year militar;,' service bill. I believe one must punish trai? tors, and if I give up my life in such a cause I shall feel my duty is accomplished." He said his mother had been in an insane asy? lum for twenty years, which confirmed the suspicion on the part of the police that he was mentally unbalanced. Only on the preceding Tuesday (the mur der occurred on Saturday) Jaur?s headed a (lepufiition of Socialist members of the Chamber, nho protested to M. Bienvenu Martin, the acting premier in the absence of Vivianj, against France participating in the Aust ro- Serbian imbroglio or taking any stej: for the recovery of Alsace and Lorraine from Germany, after more than forty years of peace. Since the breaking of the wai cloud he had been working night and da*, to make war impossible, and had night!) braved the anger i f war-excited mobs win yelled in the streets after him, callinf him "Traitor!" and "Prussian!" an cpithc which in a Frenchman's mouth just thei and since meant something worse thai traitor. It was not the first timo Jaur?s bai braved the anger of the nation in the sam cause. When the bill to increase the terr of compulsory military service from two t throe yeui'B first came up, in March, 101? ? Jaur?s's opposition to what he called "crim ? inal folly" led to violent scenes in the ! Chamber and the streets. Advocates of the ? measure denounced the Socialist deputies as a band of scoundrels and the public in ? the galleries joined in the ?lemonstration, ! crying 'Down with the traitors!" "Down i with the Prussians!" and "Why don't you ! go to the Reichstag?" This last taunt, uttered in the heat, of patriotic, passion, might, in quieter times, ; have recalled the fact that Jaur?s once tried to go to Berlin, but was prevented from doing so by the German government. , !t was in July, 1905, just nine years before ? his death, that Jaur?s was scheduled to . speak before a Socialist meeting in the i German capital, His appearance there, i however, was forbidden by Prince Biilow, tln-n Imperial Chancellor. This in spue of ' the fact that it was Jaur?s who only shortly before ha?! marshalled tin opposition which forced out M. Delcass? from the French Foreign Office for what Jaur?s denounced j as a chauvinistic and imperialistic policy ! boiiinl t?> bring about a European con? flagration. For the moment Delcaas?'a re ! Lin-merit seemed to benefit the German gov j eminent; however, Biilow diaoerned that [ Jaur?s's policy, if adopted by tho German i Socialists, might thwart imperialistic plans nearer home. After spending fifty-six months in jail ? pending trial Kaoul Villain, Jaur?s's slay ; er, was brought before a jury on Monday March 24, 1919. Witnesses testified that Jaur?s, while opposed to regaining Alsace i Lorraine by force of arms, was in favor ol a peaceful reunion. Pierre Renaudel, whi succeeded Jaur?s in the leadership of th< Socialists, said that Jaur?s had decided t< make a personal appeal to President Wilsoi on August 2, 1914, in an endeavor to havi the President intervene and avert wai Witnesses for the defance depicted Villaii as thoroughly sincere, but ultra-sensitive lacking in will power and given to despon dency. Men like Ribot, Viviani and Pain lev?, former premiers, and Generals Re gnault and Sarrnil testified to the lovait and patriotism of Jaur?s. The judge advc cate declared that he? did not ask for th death penalty, but only for a prison scr tenet*. The verdict, was for acquittal, and thu before the law of France the slayer < Jaur?s will be regarded on having paid i full for his deed with the lifty-nix montll spent in jail between now and Augui , 1, 1014. - \-* clination to embrace the wrong, even though contrary to the nature of the youth." Justice Collins's experience ?a Special Sessions shows that the heroin habit is the most quickly acquired, and is now recruit? ing the largest share of addicts. Vet heroin was unknown until a few years ago, and on its introduction it was claimed to be a non habit formi.ig drug. Many medical men have declared that its manufacture could be dis? continued entirely without injury to their practice. All drug control experts recognize the necessity of treatment of addicts by gradual withdrawal. There, is, however, no known specific remedy for the cure of drug addic? tion. In fact, the whole tr ?s at seh on the subject, so much so, that Health Commissioner Dr. Royal S. Cope land has just announced that the Health Department of New York will conduct a re? search into the subject among the patients on North Brother Island. The cocaine user is the more susceptible to treatment. Perils After A Cure Temporary cure of all narcotic addict? is not so difficult. It is the exercise of the free will of the patient after he is dis? charged that cannot be. controlled. A period of convalescence and recupera: ion is abso? lutely necessary. Plenty of fresh air an? proper physical exercise while the patient is under careful surveillance are most df " sirable. The Warwick and Harts Island farms are to be thrown open soon for tin? purpose. It is generally agreed that no permanent ' or adequate relief from the growing druf i evil will be had until tne attempt ?i 'V'rt ! national control, interrupted by the war in 1914, is resumed. Conditions in the Phil ; ippines in 1909 compelled the United States i to take the initiative in this international consideration of the evil. -Shutting off ?' the opium traffic with China served onlv to stimulate the morphine and cocaine bvr ] ness, with a consequent loss of $l0o.00i. S 000 aggregate annual opium revenue to th? great nations which had voluntarily sncr1' , (iced the traffic only to see their subjects ? pressing two other deadly druir? int? th* hands of the Far Eastern people who h?d ; heroically determined to abandon W* [ "opium vice.'* l