Newspaper Page Text
builder indicted for perjury in onnec tion with his testimony before tho LockwocV. committee, pleaded not guilty yesterday. His bail of $25 000 was continued. Edmund L. Moouey, his counsel, will appear before Judge Mulqueen this morning to argue on the . date for the triai. Robert S. John stone, prosecuting the c;.se, announced .. he would ask that the case be placed I on the preferred calendar, yo that the . tri-*' mnv bo speedily disposed of, Brindell \v?s indicted on three counts. He is accused of attempting I to exto?t "$7.500 from Jacob Fradus, a r.eral contractor, on April 10 last. the first count charges that Brindell attempted to obtain the money by dis? rupting an operation of Fradus's at 8 Seven h Avenu Thirty-sixth, Thirty Sseventh and Thirty-eighth streets. The ? second churls that he attempted to ,! i m ?ney by threaten ing to cull a strike and prevent Fradus's carrying * out a contract he had o do the work he sum? operation, while the third ? charges that Brindell threatened to pu . it i-r dus from obtaining compc ; tent iaoorera to do the work. ?* The v.i.-i. . m . n h in cor.nec-, . ti?,,, with 7!i? indie - ' ? ? George H. Claike, an engineer employed by the fbui ding tirm oi HolbiuCK, Cabot & ? Rollins; Saul Singer, owner of the ?building for whom the particular job '.', . ? ?- do i ; Samuel >'>. Donnelly, Franklin Nevius, attorney for Fradus, ? ami Fradus himself. . The circumstances surrounding the ? <*rime charged in the indictment were' nearly ail disclosed ?-t the hearing of ?J the committee on November 28. At Mi at tmi.e Fradus declared that his ..- ? .?. had been ruined by Brindell and that he eventually was di i ven into bankruptcy. He said that Brindell demanded $25,000, and when he refased to give up he could get no I mor?; wrecking contracts ?rom the larg construction ccmnanies because the.. informed him they could not do busi ?< ness with any one who did n -t sign an .igreoment with Brindell as to the em? ployment of men agreeable to the labor I? ad or. He testified that he at last gave Brindell $1,000 for the agreement ro 1 erred to. $7,500 Deal Cited The $7,500 controversy, he said, grew out of a contisct he had drawn up on February 13 to do demolition and'excavation work on a building for the Garment Center Realty Company j.t the Seventh Avenue address. He ^i.id he had t,fty steam shovels nt work ard had purchased numerous trucks, v hen suddenly all the engineers were called off by "Brinde!!. He went to see the labor leader at 12 St. Mark s Place. Brindell, he said, in? sisted on seeing h,s contract When Fradus refused to show it Brinde! ?id, according to testimony, "Well, you wiil never do this job" "I asked him," continued Fradus, "what was the troub e, and he said: 'You know this organization is not run on eha k. 1 want you to produce $'25.000 if you went to go ahead with this job.-' Fradus said he saw he "was up against it" and he went to see Frank? lin Nevius. his attorney, who was un able to help matters. Fradus said he then went *o C'ark. ? f the Holbrook, Cabot & Rollins ? :? firm, with whom he vas acquainted ami '; ??m t-e thought had c nsidcrable in? n{?,fluence in the labor worid. C.a k said he made an ? ppointment \y. wit':. Brindell over the t"Iephone and .'* later m I him at his office. The tes tim i.v < f Clark runs as follows: y. Did he make any prono Pion to Hi you as to the terms on which he would .allow Fradus to go ahead? A.?He did. It was a cash proposition. t> 1 km '.v t ; t. hut ho\v much ? A.? ',['. $7,"00, to tiie bist of my recpllection. <4. Is that the best you eon!;! do ?!; v ...i . A.-- 1 did not try to jew him li'Avn. t?. Did he tell von why he wanted }',? $7 500 ? A He said he wanted it for himse f. One reason he gave ?vas that '?J there was no general contractor on the bui ding. He meant by that, I suppose, that there we're no intermediate profits >j\ and lie might as we!! be the intcr ? '?':? mediary. ': y. What was his next reason? A. Tha he wanted the money. He thought '; he o.:; ht t'i have a rake-off on it. ''\'. Q. He was perfectly brazen about il n A. 1 never knew of a situation Pke that before; 1 never heari.' of u p. or saw it. Tells of Faying $1,000 The circumstances surrounding the | alleged payment of $1,000 to Brendel) '' are told by Fradus as follows: Q.~ You say you found you were up against it? A.?1 found I was up against it. 1 had a big organization, fifty automobiles, ana everything was taken away from me: I had to pay bills and notes came due; I was not ?ihie to pay. 1 had to sell out my stuff t?< make everything good, and 1 found n ysi If up against it, seeing that 1 : cculd not get any work in New York to pay anything. t?. Did you tell him you were up against it ? A. 1 did. Q. -What did he say? A.?I said: ""What did I ever do to you that y u threw me out of business?" He said: "You know this place has got to get a little money, and you have to he a good leP.ow to get anything out of here, rait of this office." 1 was figuring on a job in Sixty-fourth Street for the Fradus font i acting Company. After I get through and lost everything my son went into a little business for himself, and he formed a little company in New York, and 1 am working for him, trying p i, ale a living. I went to Brindell, and ne did not know anything about that. So I said: "1 am figuring en n job with the Underpinning Foundation Company, Will you classify me to do : ? kind -if work?" He .--aid: "What do you mean?" I said: "I want the excavating down there.'' tj. lin-, big a j"ii was that? A. -- About $30.000. He say-: "Yes, pro? vided you will produce" i said: "What do you mean'." He said: "Give me a thousand dollars and 1 will give you a le te?." Q. Hid you pay the thousand dol? lars? A. -1 did; 1 paid in one-hun dred-dollnr bills the;- and r.o;-e. Q. When and where was this? A. T?i ht in St. Mark's Place, right in his Oil ce. 'I he Brindell indictment had been he d off, it was explained, because of the committee's great cat? in the prep? aration of his cas? and the desire to c'.uso up the charges,against ?very ave? nue of attack. It was also necessary so to cordato the thirty-odd charcos against the labor lender that in effect they would support each ?Plier. $.?1 i.021 in Alleged Bribes According to figures gathered from the testimony at the heari >i atora of the committee, Bvindcll and : he Building , i t???e? ... re? ceived at leas: $514 021 within the last year 'rom various sourr \ i to their calculations, $93 021 is 1 a\ o been ha nded ov?; r i- a agents by witn? - who b? '"i the comn ittec I unsel for tin? Lnckwood c tee ave intimate I that h I gh with Cet ? on charges against '' tl ' th? nu. i?---. !?;. t '??? of ! ibute paid to the labor lead ? been brou 1 to thcii att - ?? ; i| : ous ruli M - - test mony of t i- nature, t v/ss said would be brought out it t is moi ?ng's ! ; of t! e c ?mm ttee. tn in- argument in conneccion with ti o B.'icker case Mr "tonnes-, his attor? ney, insist ?1 that his client committed no crime for tvgo reasons. First, the p ! had to da onh with hous ing cond :: ns and that the indictment ag inst Back,-: mentions a mercant l< structure- second, that the Lcckwood ??i mmittce was not c instituted to ferrot o; t ? rimes 1 ul U' investigate the hous i ?tuat^on, and that therefore the : to whom B tCkor paid the $25,000 pimntarial to the purpose; of th.e com- littoe. He said the defendant had aiv,;, s -.'-- ntained ho " i- the money i ? i i i not hear ? money for a definite object," continued Mr. Mooney. "He is mot a professional briber or bribe taker. He was one of the first to expose the tiue conditions j as to the building situation." Judge M'tlqucen argticd that the I identity of the person to whom Backer paid $?"?,000 to have a strike called was j material, He refused to allow the de- j murrcr on this point, whereupon Mooney entered a plea of not guilty. Argument on the d^to of the trial was ? fixed for this morning. The Mayor in his letter to Unter-' rayer yesterday pointed out that the 1 Board of Estimate investigation was authorized after the Lockwood com? mittee had announced its inability to go ahead with the inquiry into all city contracts. He asserted that the new inquiry would be "most rigid and starching," and that "if collusion or: fraud should be shown in the award? ing of any contract, no matter where the trail might lead, the fullest jnstice would be meted to the guilty man or men." Newest Hylan Letter The Mayor's letter reads: "Your letter to me under date of .November 16, 1071Q, is the meanest col? lection of insincere expressions that have thus far been presented by you to me. " You know it, I know it and sooner or later the whole public will thor? oughly understand what is moving you to such despicable attacks on me. "You cannot have forgotten that at the joint conference of the Board of Es? timate and Apportionment and the Lock wood committee on Monday P-st. No? vember 15, when you staleu: 'The Lock wood committee has neither the power nor the wish to undertake the duties that devolve upon the officials of the City of New York.' a resolution was adopted by the Board of Estimate and Apportionment, without objection from you or the committee, that the Hoard -,f Estimate would proceed to make its own investigations into the letting >f any city conttr.ets that might be under any possib e suspicion of fraud. "You cannot pretend to have ?for? gotten that the Board of Estimate and Apportionment inv ted you tj conduct tais investigation in person. Y?.u can? not pretend to ! ave forgotten that you declined this "invitation. Committee Volunteered Aid "You must remember that you also pave us a reason that the Lockwood committee's investigation into the questions of labor and material com? binat ons was of more immediate im? portance, and that you volunteered to aid the Board of Estimate and Appor? tionment in its invest gation by sub? mitting to it all ?lata in your posses? sion relating to city contracts or such other information that would come to yo'i from t:me to time. "Now, suddenly, without the letst. justification in the world, you turn around and attack the good faith of the entire Board of Estimate and Ap? portionment and the Law Department of the city. Of course, very shrewdly, all of your attacks are by inference on'y, but you try to create the false mpression that the Law Department of this city will not conduct an open nnd fearless examination as to whether there was fraud or* collusion in the granting of contracts by the city. ? i e people o- au Cuy o? .- a' York rightfully have the fullest confidence in the law department of the city by reason particularly of its suce?. ?sriP conduct against the traction interests f the 5 cent fare litigation, through every court Up to and including the Court of Appea's; the legal battles to ; rotect the 80-cent gas rat" status; the telephone rate inquiry now in prog? ress; the litigation involving the New York Cent-al Railroad's occupation of ? city property on the West Side of Man hattan; the investigation before the ? Hoard of Estimate and Apportionment : of street railways and -T.pid transit conditions and thi* successful conduct ? ' f many other complex lawsuits ana ? proceedings. "No one has so far made any attach | on the honest. ? and loyalty of the law department of this city under this i administration. Ever you do not dare ! do :t except by the mean but carefully ; guarded inferences carried in your j letter. "Irrespective of anything you have f:aid, I '-o, mnly declare that the Cor? poration Counsel will conduct a mos I rigid nnd searching investijration. and j if collusion or fraud .shoul* be show; i in the awarding of any contract, i.o ' matter where the trail may lend, th-' i fullest justice will be meted to thj i guilt man or men. "The next time you? start to write a vicious letter to me try to keep in mind some idea of fair play and decency. ? You know very well that 1 am and al | ways have been ready to appear before , your committee and testify without reservation. Your intimation that you are 'waiting on me' is U2> false as the - rest of your inferences concerning me." School Board Will Aid City in Fraud Inquiry Compl"te cooperation with the Board ?f Estimate in its separate investiga? tion of building; and equipment con? tracts was pledged last night by the Board of Education in so far as the in ouiiy will take in school building con? struction and re'ated matters. At the same time the board directed that all future payments on account of contracts for school buildings and e?iulpment should be paid only upon the approval and upon the order of the Corporation Counsel and that all rec ords, books, files, proposals, contracts iind other data be furnished the Cor? poration Counsel >r the Board of Es? timate upon request. A list of all bills received fr^m un? successful as well as successful bidders < n school woik since January 1, 1918, or since the present Board of Education assumed office, together with the names of all genera! and subcontract? ors, the c)i; racier and amount of their contracts and unpaid balances, will b. suoplicd by the Department of Educa? tion. Harding Still Uncertain on Mexican Visit Senator Will Decide To-day Whether He Will Accept Obregon's Invitation to Stop Over at Vera Cruz Creager Urged as Envoy Texans Confident Host of President-Elect Will Be Ambassador to Mexico From a Staff Correspondent BAY CITY, Tex., Kov 17 (On Board .Senator Harding's special train bound for New Orleans).--Traveling along the Gulf Coast railroad, sometimes in sight of the waters of the Gulf of Mexico upon which he will be afloat to-morrow, Senator Harding had plenty of opportunity to-day to reflect on his forthcoming visit to Mexico to call upon his recently discovered amigos, Don Alvaro Obrcgon and Provisional President de la Huerta. If the Presi? dent-elect of the United States wanted to utter his reflections aloud or at least whisper them into sympathetic ears there were available those of R. B. Creager, host of the Hardings during their visit to the magic valley of the Kid Grande, where the natives know t. i eager as the Red Fox. These same natives have convinced themselves that Creagfer is going to be the next Am? bassador to Mexico as a reward for his preconvention work on behalf of Sen? ator Harding. However that may be, Mr. and Mrs. Creager were aboard the train, having accepted an invitation to go to Panama, an invitation extended a few days ago as if to prove that there were no hard feelings for the unadvertised mosqui? toes that bit the ankles of the next President and the next first lady of the land; nor chill memories of the biting cold of the norther that sent the *ip.n away from Point Isabel and ma? rooned the vacationists for three days il a villfige of discomfort and unpala? table food. Cattle Herds Mark Route There was nothing along the route to distract Senator Harding if he cared .1 nev?te itis thoughts to Mexico. Through the windows of the private car his eyes roved over a vast expanse of level grazing land desolate except or beef cattle, Texas longhorns that lad outgrown the markings of their white-faced Hereford sires. Governor and Mrs. W. P. Hobby and members of the Governor's staff left ae special train at Kingsville, Tex., for a visit to the King ranch and a .?ste of a side of Texas life that the eoplc of Texas regret that Senator '' vding was not permitted to see dur? ing his present visit. The King ranch, i . example, embraces more than a miliion acres of land and countless head of horses and cattle. but to re.urn to the proposed visit to old Mexico: It was said to-day by uoorge ij. Christian jr., Secretary to Pena: m- Harding, that it wolHtl be known definitely to-morrow when the patty reached Baton Rouge, La., whether it will be possible for Sen r Harding to stop over in Vera Cruz It is understood that the directors of United Fruit Eine have been re? quested to make arrangements tor the steamship Parismina, on which Senator Harding will travel to the canal zone to add Vera Cruz to the list of the hip's ports of call, for this voyage. and as the request comes from th 'resident-elect of the United States, t is net like y to b<: refused. Obregon Sends Special Invitation It is now understood that Elias Tor .-.-, secretary to the Minister of For? eign Affairs, who brought the invitation to Senator Harding to attend the in uguration of General Obregon, handed the American President-elect a letter '':?-"?-. ?he Mexican President-elect urg? ing him to accept the invitation, a letter that Senator Harding probably will an swer immediately. ? "p-a' in New Orleans to? morrow morning Senator Harding will . ,-.? ui, . -, to the Hotel Grune? wald. He will deliver an address be? fore the Association of Commerce, at? tend a reception at the Elks lodg? and then go aboard his ship. The speech he will deliver in Nev Orleans was written during those col days when he was unable to go out ii ; to the Pass-Brazos de Santiago aft. : tarpon. Howells LcfTs 199.923 An appraisal of the estate of Willi;1. Dean Howells, which was filed yestc day in the Surregates' Court, sho' i tl nt the author, who died Mny 11, 191 I left total assets of $190,923 and a n I estate of $192,432. His real esP hoi lings are valued at $'<G,500; his en assets aggregate $9,5S3. There i securities, including $25,000 in Liber ? m Is, aggregating $81,942, and $10,6C in royalties from his books. .Jehu Mead Ilowe'.ls, of 3f>7 Lcxinrt Avenue, his son, and Mildred Howe!', of ISO West Fifty-seventh Street, 1. daughter, are to receive $95,1131 eac' tlis grandscn, William W. Howells, 0 lias: Fifty-eighth Street, 13 to r ? ive $1,200. There are small beque "or hi? brother, Samuel Mead Howe-: 1 nd his s'sters, Amelia H. Howells ai .' nne T. Frechette. ____ " I L a F A YE T T E All La Fayette enclosed models urc now on view at our show? room, 1763 Broadway? at 57th Street. You are invited to in? spect them at vour convenience. _1_._?_. Porter- La F a y e tt e Company, Inc. Hugh T. Porter, President ? Telephone, Circle 3757 fdi\ 'Irish Inquiry ? To Open To-day In Washington ! Acting Mayor of Balbriggan and Dudley Field Malone Among First To Be Heard by Commission of Seven -_ New Association in U. S. British Embassy Declines Invitation for Representa? tion at the Hearings -. ? WASHINGTON, Nov. 17.?Irish lead ; ers from over the country to-day com i pleted organization of "the American ? Association for the recognition of the Irish Republic." At the same time the [ commission of seven from the com "niitteo of 100 investigating the Irish ! cuesti?n laid plans for opening its ; hearings to-morrow, with two witnesses ' direct from Ireland on the stand. i The hearings of the commission were I to have started to-day, but receipt of 1 information that John Durham, Acting i Mayor of Balbriggan, and Dennis Mor i pan, of Thurles, would be ready to tes I tify to-morrow, resulted in the post I ponement. Dudley Field Malone, for I mer customs collector at New York, j also is on the list of witnesses for to | morrow, and after his appearance on the stand he is expected to sit at the ? hearings as the attorney for the Amer? ican commission on Irbh independence. Britain Won't Re Represented The Bri ish Embassy will not be rep? resented at the commission's hearings foimal dec: ?valion of the c mmission's | invitation hnving ! een forwarded b ? ? the embassy to-day to O.-awaid Garrison : Villard, of New York, editor of The i Nation, who appointed the committee l of 100. In declining to send a repre 1 si ntative to the hearings, the embassy ' declared it could not approve the pur ! poses of the inquiry and expressed the j Leiief that the only result would be the : spreading of propaganda. The embassy also informed the com ? mittee, through Mr. Villard, that, while 'the British government would not with j hold passports from any person wish < in^c to appear^before the committee, it \ must be understood that the British gov? ernment could not undertake to guar ! antee the safety of witnesses from ! personal attacks ami violence at the hands of Sinn F?iners or loyalists upon i their return to England and Ireland. Doubts Benefits of Inquiry The embassy added its conviction i that it would ( be impossible for the committee to gather any evidence of value that could not be more readily obtained through "the. ordinary agen? cies of publicity which operate unob? structed in England and Ireland." The organization formed by Irish ; sympathizers after a conference with Eamon de Va'era, president of the provisional Irish republic, was said to be designed to supplant tie Friends of Irish Freedom as the leading Irish independence organization in the country. I It is the purpose to form affiliated organizations in every state in the Union, and directors to head these organizations were elected. Edward L. Doheny, of Los Angeles, who presente?! the minority resolution for recognition of Ireland at the Democratic National Convention at. San Francisco last June, was elected president of tho new organization. ! Tho vice-presidents are Judge John j j W. Goff, of New York; John J. S Castolline, of Cincinnati,, and Major; ' Eugene Kinkead, of Jersey City; John j J. Hearn, of Westiield, Mass., is treas ! urer, and Daniel C. O'Flaherty, of Richmond, Va., secretary. The oflice- of tho Irish inquiry com-. I niission announced to-night that plans ' had been perfected to send a sub I committee to Ireland soon to make a first hand investigation. The person I nel of the committee will be unnounced | later. The project resulted, it was said, from invitations to send such a j commission received by the commis? sion in a round robin signed by British labor party leaders, including Arthur Henderson. Robert Smillie, William Anderson and others, and similar pro? posals from the Irish Catholic hier? archy and numerous persons prominent in Protestant Ireland. British Labor Manifesto Urges Peace in Ireland LONDON, Nov. 17.?The executive committee of the Parliamentary Labor party has issued a manifesto signed by Arthur Henderson, William C. Adam son and John R. Clynes, calling upon the Labor party throughout the coun? try to take more active steps to secure the withdrawal of all the armed ' forces from Ireland and the election I by proportional representation of a constituent assembly charged with the task of working out whatever consti I tution the Irish people desire in order | to settle their own affairs, provided I proper protection is accorded to minor j ?ties and Ireland is prevented from be? coming a military or naval menace to Great Britain. The manifesto explains that this action is taken b-ca :se of the hope? lessness of "expecting anything from | n Parliament dominated by a mechan i ical government majority." It an? nounces that the party lias decided to conduct a great national campaign t) : enlighten the British public on what j s happening*in Ireland, and also to - appoint, a commission to visit Ireland and investigate the government's I policy and methods. DURE Tasteless Ice A ?Food Insurance ? You know what care you take to ! keep salt from getting into the home freezer. Knickerbocker | Ice is made with far more ; scrupulous care. Four-tim^s ! filtered water is put into ; sanitary containers?practically j sealed in. Through the brine surrounding the containers run the pipes containing ammonia The ammonia can no more get into the ice than the gas can get from the pipes to the food cocked in your gas range. : And remembei Knickerbocker Ice In ' sur anee not only means pure, tasteless ice?but ice enough to preserve tht purity o) your hod. Knickerbocker ICE Company TTir" ,?fciMM i??i mcn?i >SCIiAN2L MEN'S TAILORS Clothes tailored by Schanz are built to emphasize the best lines of one's figure. Made ~to-Me asure and Ready-for-Wear Chesterfield Overcoats, Ulsters, and Business Suits?Ready-for-wear 14 EAST 40tm STREET NEW YORK r.zrrrjvmxrancum-ruimv stanKOMiV FRANKJ^I^K SIMON ?iCE^'S SHOPS 2 it U ll'EST 3Slli STREET A substantial saving in London Aquascutum Winter Overcoats For Men $95 Due to the low price of sterling exchange Worn by the Prince of Wales But an Aquascutum is a coat that doesn't have to he sold on the basis of a conces? sion. The low price is simply an added attraction, but it is a world-wide custom to ask for an Aquascutum first, and for the price afterwards. The fabrics are Homespuns, Cheviots, Saxonys, Shet? lands, and Fleeces. The models are typically English. The style is inimita? ble. The workmanship is superb. Single and Double Breasted Box Coats, Ches? terfields, Raglans, Great Coats and Ulsters Exclusive New York Agents for Aquascutum, Ltd. FIFTH AVENUE ?y- Red Cross Roll Call?Join Now -j" A Tower #v of Strength Back of "tour Business In handling any banking matter that may arise the Bankers Trust Company is pre? pared to place back of its customers the full facilities of the Company and the ex? perience of its staff. We offer you not only the working equip? ment of an institution that does business of worldwide dimensions, but also the per? sonal interest and co-operation of an organization whose constant effort is to obtain the best results for its customers. Let this Company stand as a "Tower of Strength " back of your business. Backers Trust Company Member Federal Reserve System Paris Office: 16 Place Vend?me Aster Trost Offltse.. WtAwjnue at 42nd Stiett A Plain Statement of Facts * Because of our consistently revised prices and the offering of our most beautiful Fashions at Replacement Figures our various salons have been filled daily with New York's most critical buyers. We are now going still further in our desire to meet the new economic con? ditions with a still greater revision of prices. , The savings which can be taken advantage of by purchasing now range from fifty dollars to several hundred,.according to the price of the article desired. Our entire extensive selection of Rich Afiparelhzve been included in these revisions and embrace Fur-Trimmed Suits?Day Coats and Wraps Handsome Day Dresses Beautiful Dinner and Evening Gowns Luxurious Fur-trimmed Wraps Blouses?Hats?Accessories and Exquisite Furs Wraps?Neck Scarfs and Separate Pieces