OCR Interpretation


The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, September 04, 1872, Image 2

Image and text provided by The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundation

Persistent link: https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030272/1872-09-04/ed-1/seq-2/

What is OCR?


Thumbnail for

WWW
f THE Stttf, WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 4, 1872.
II ' .
"- 11 Milm. r.r VII.
WI'l.NT.s.Y, SI ' "It t, IW.
1 A inil-rmrn .'....),
tj ' Tts-itiVs Tlnnlri TV P
l j llnwrrj' Iki-Blre r... -.
uH Hon llrjuil'. Mln. IrrP. r ; . n ,i.
IT. . t' a-rsnn' ('utlHirnU tlln.(rp,-l.u Brs,i.7,
n 1 I'liHi tvenur theatre . . . I..
V ' l-'ran) drier llnuvf . rt 'i.
I Tirwart Itidn.lrtitl I- .1. I.lll.-.V,, 1, 1 ..
i, IMymilf Tin 'r I tin
Si HI. J:ir. Ihonlrc . I .M011-.1.
d" ""Iki-slrr ('..mintie l - ' It.
jy M II lm ks 1 In Hire I
1 Wlill lth.n.ii -
K ilu.,.)' Mn-n ni -K i . Ir. .. d.-.V V.I
Tho Wreck uf I he Meti.
Admit n lili'lttli upo nno uf ottr ivpni tirj
',)' ti III ll.lljl l. II U HlMlllll .-ti'IHIH't' lltltl II I'OII-
Mj l.l-.ltllll Willi IH'I'Mill supposed to do
;l ' in l ug n n lonlioiit. Tlic ni"lit win ilnrk,
f t nnil Hip f.'rin ml uspctl if t1. tvrnthi r
J trlimniy mid tliri'iit"iiiiiT. The lookout, in-
i hi. ml of in i ii.vlniri imsttioii rrnin ti hidi liu
i. y (ihi1i1m.'i'ii ik I'liilicml, Viii-ui liiiiuguiiili r
IE1,, the cuve of I In- ill." n. When iiestiniiol
jj.li by the rrpni'tcr, In- Mrklti'V lulcul that ho
' t.-us wl 1 1 Kill I n.jil t frl i-.rs, 1 tint hi-1 onliln'L
kf J ri ttvn left hi c Ml tile bows of till-tes-
V 'rl, mill Unit I..' il in- nit-Hi liiiuin
, f tin1 law ri i. ttil ii Ir iki nt. I'm- nil pur- I
j.''' piwix ir i i. tli' i'. -i I'uf i nr i lit ii '
Jlj III' IM'l. il l-U.' h:'i.' I li II -imi in,r in till) J
11 i.il mi. I
s T
V 'J in r .iii i' I ii i i In litis ii:i Hick nt oottl-
l, 1 inA tt iili tin low i but too prevalent
?' '. iimmiR tlio i)urou who tiu initio uurrnn-t-
' v l-c uti'niiH'n, mill it is a mutter of tvnmler
Hull iirrhli'lll like that tiiili li.T.'l tlio
l An tin tin not on ur mote frct'tieiiHy. If
tfi' ' Hit- law i licit sufficiently sti inpciit, if It j
terms flinily i .'"iu.ro mi mitnti'iitir com-
'tj,i vUiiiiip ivllli f.itnin foim, tlifii let It lm
tf'l Hini'iiilril n. Mum iii Oiiijjrp nlmil lmvf an !
iiioitiinit to tu t mon it. If tliflinv to- !
I'jt i;ln iiHii-c limn tlii, tluni let it di eit-
jij fi'ic.'il im miiiii ii- a lull in tlio riiiiiiinlgn
Si, 1 ' hull ffivi' (iuvNT's tinvclilnc Vim tiry
iijiV I ii'in rt tiiciit mi oipm tunity in nMiiitlto
I'ij lriiillnuitf biihim -w.
' j A notkwililo luiiili nt in the ivh k 'f Ilii
' tU i- tl'i-ui; :u il Lift tlintnni'of tlif two
1,7,1 nr.- ir-'p wnrt inltn inw f l.w llvo
i ' ilcrk diinil mm n .liriw i r if tlic pI imii
dent . 1 1 iiii y. A. f. (Jai.i.i i'. Win n It H
'., )? r. nii tiil . ii t ili.it tlic i-- n;n r li-t in-,
J, ili.'li'liH I.- i .'.I I .i'v . i... i mninriit on
tyi tliislm ! i.i in i.' i .11' --. 'I In' i ijlmn if
' tin' M. t.- im. ii. .1 t lm..' niiM th.it
j:' , f i tn- iij '. i ..i of tli' m.ii.'1 i-t.-nm-
y tmiit v ; ',i a i ut i. ,h ;,i tii,' i. in
I .n mill i :1 lil irulil ) i ,i or.ni ft
,'i nt. i r. i. .i . in i .i i i r : 1 1 ; i. i.i. u
' l Uf m.. i ii r-'fr.rs v. f" av 1 t ll.il
i?,h ullnriM .f tt'c -liip; dm mi. li a iicia-
,j liiirlty oiii'lit iii. i :o liarr N,f.l. A Mm
ii). per pari of tin- venl itt. the pliucln
wlileli dotli ecliin nn.l "tiit.'i .'i.ni pn-'jet'ti'i i
'.'1 flipt, n luiivy wnvf in n tiiin i-iiili ni I11.1
deen kiiinvn on tlic Soinnl luliilit Iibid
''; m-ept Hie upper pnrtiuti of tin doat nviiy
j1 J" iirnl onirieit every pn nper Into etirnlty.
X "f ('apt. IIittov ffitalnly iKyerve? irwllt
. f"i' ene thine. If lie Ini kul preJonco of '
i ininil in I he lionr of pull, lit Mmvptl inan-
'' ' , ly lonnige in reinnliilntotnl;oliHi;liunrf!S 1
k' , with the pnn-cnpeis mi tn- iimuinu .iu.1., ;
' I'li-tfilil of jiiiiipiiis into n life doat with tlie ',
:' v ilin etor mill id k li.imN.
" The Ftory of the Mu! wi'.l point two '
nomlii: Mint In a 'tnirpd- fur life dout.',
'i ilffk hiindu nnil htfimitmut otHi-lnN xtnnil a
5 in ilt'ti In tti r ehaiiff tlinii iiiiM-i'iincr-. e i n
I when half the pa'iigi"" am women anil
j rhililren; nml that tliiielj Minieililiip: null-
j, rally ilefiflivo In the fteaindnnt rrsnhi-
t ' Hiiim. that tlioso reiiliitiun nro nut pro-
, r peily enfoieeil.
IN ' J nlpe l,irww Dext, tirntlier-ln-law to
i. I I,r-liint Ohint. allnrkptl on Jlunday. In ffj- !- '
'J Irctoii, Mr. IIkniiy I!kku. on of the ciiH.iN "f '
A (, ' tlio (VipfnJ ncwp.iif r. Mr. Htin Ii an ulderty
I Ri'ntleiimn, nml n.it stmni;. The asuult wui j
I , , ' ri'tiimltii'il without warnln.T, with n hloknir
'f. c.inf, nn.l Mr. Hiim, who rveeltml ninny Mows I
' i''' Injured about fio tii'iJ. j
I' Ii Tlic oci'iMuii d r t hi limt.il n'.t.-H'k w,i tli
I .i i li i-t t ii In the I'iijiimI uf nome of tlio f .i t n
y r.'-i.f tliiif llio .ilo ly tli I)Krs to V. II. I'ii
li livsn tlio iippolnt tiii-rit r CiHiil nt Callnn.
l .v:. .vm p.il.l lli two lirothflr'. f).rjil, of whl. h
j ' L.:vi? 1).M' nvvdcj f.'.So). tml r.cn. V. T.
I , Dk.st tl,')i. mill ili. ii UiiAM nu'lo tin upn.liit-
i oii-nt Ju-t after tho a.lj(i:ir-ncnt nf Conttei'i.
I " TIiN lie iIIJ on tlm Hollelt itl.iu of Juili;e IlE.vr'i
( -lfo. Hut aftfrivard Senator Oot.RefOnllfiirtila
, ' objected to the appointment of finonni: f)RVT,
I. -- i Ooiu'icrat, nnutlier ineuiiier of thU liiU'retlnnr
hv family, rw AjipMiicr f ('iinoini nt Sin rriuiol.
I,', f . unit tn apnoujo i.'olb anil maka all eay fur
v (lEtniOE, the apNilnlm:it of Kaiiiumi wm not
rontlrme.t liy tho Sn.it. nnd ono I). J. W'u
; MAVtMiA, ii friend of I'oi'i, nppolntod liy
I . the I'lHiMnnt In lm nl i r H-ln-n ronercM ni 't
rt'. r Riln; and thin Okoiioc Dl'Nr lircnme
ffv prnlsiT.
,j N-xt I'MiHiii ImrifMneil with the Hi.vt fur
k', tho npiMilntiiH ht of ,1. A. WiTiiar nt I'urt liy.
I "i. S. V., an n C uniiilnxloner to etih clnlitM
kt, J 1-ilnst I'unt ; ml for thU M.U') 'i' pnld at the
Actor If oil-Mi In thltrlty, fie nmney ln-ln a dr.nvn
Ljf for llio p.ii'fioa frmn tho 8lue and heatln-r
Uuik. WtTntv did not it tho nppol'itraent
M na tli j I) 'NTS had cngased i lint when Judo
1)k.t did imt return n cent of tlio mmicy, nml
when K Il in. mi compla'iicd of the f.illuro to
jj i i. kocp tho harKiiln. Hunt ddd hl.n it would lie
i butter to nay imthlns on thu m ijeit, and that
, j thoy would niaUe It rluht In viino other way.
i Theiic ar mne of tho m:iln facts In lhl eaie.
i, ii They imniitUiito 11 hhIu of appointment.) by tho
J'renldent'ii brothent-lii-InT, and in oiu can h
H-iS Unlivery of tho nppnlntiiient by the I'renldent
'' after the inoncv had boon paid.
;,. i' Tho lesal erldvnce on till whole matter In
j - 1 earlly attalimblo.
i', Juiiu- iivwn jn.iii (in tr Itrn.1 In a eor.
"L , , fotalun tli.il tlioo'i. ,iif .10.
It '; I The I- if k Mnu of F.tifopo U for frota lillli
jj' ni'.rll iiiiu. In llio oplu on ol llurupemi capital-
, j ! 'J no i'ui lull U... eminent mcuntly U.uml
S( t BOino iilim pi r cent Ifeanuijr bnnils. will h were
j1 1 pruuiptly mibsi rlbed f.u. Tuike) keciim to Imvo
ll jj tlon a new lnwe of 1 fo nnder Anm-t. An?,
I ,f t.ud, like inoi't timiital countrlei.it ln.i nuer
'. ,.1 b.'i II half li dead u It toen.cd to be,
i I :i. .
1 Tin-re inn In: no doubt that tli" .l;ip-ineno
'jS' cm 10.1II) makiot proicr' In iiiuitorn ll. in, fur
' !.' wi- iiutl. otl at .)a;i.i ut 1,. ik.fl.liiu tin Jnima.
i can llu,-, 111 uiiiej b. J -pumvi! nuihu'j, ami car. y-
,'iVI - liuacu ouf luu, iiir.ve I ut Hjii rrtuuliii'o on.'
1 'k', il.iy .it Wtuik. Thin In mild to bo tho tlrut arrival
I ,1 ut a Jupaneiiu v.'cl on .1 ivjuhir coiiiniorcUl
U ; oy; ibcil liai ever been rupurtod ut mi A moil-
cm lrt. Tim .I.ipanejo uru .K.'rt and adveo-
H i.pjj tiiiuiia Hallirn, liuw.iiur, mid liuvo rrom tlnin
H 'I j! Iniiiiuinorlttl rurild 011 .tn iixteimlvti cuuiiiu r-e
Wl with Cbliiu nml . .iber Anl.jlic eiiuntrieii. (If Into
H , ill let-in tl.i'y Imvo I, in lot luducluM NGsiela of
H ' liuropeaii IihuUIh Into then In it and huun,r-
H S li. ehaeod htomii.ihliw In llun.jio vihlc-h tbry Imvu
k V puttogotlier In ihelr "wny.irds. ItUpuMiblo
. thai o iniiy yuUi.o tho tluni when .U, jtt.,ailuw
i,f will luonopollju tho .-arrjliiB timlo bi tween our
'Jl ljl I'.udllo vvmI mid Aal.it In pint, foi our na,Un.i.
7 F tbu U uro mi fruiued v to fdor eer uinin-
A k try but our own, and inero 1. no nation whtih
H j -aa U'ttcr facllltli'M fur ntrurdliii.' cheap drluhu
H 1 ii!' than tlio oh 1 ovi it mid calcuhitlni; Jnii, ltlouk,
H -fj (jj. too, a If tin y Intended to mnUo the uion ut
Hk J U'lradraiitiuea.
THE KING OP ntAUDS.
Ointiii'iC'1 fiom l'lrst Page.
rontrnet wn nomlnall nifpended. I'll it con
tract V.H liori.liii'lll nt nil end. Hu nk-h bv Mile it
wnn continued even beyond Hie luufii nieriuUti ;
at lenit It wn nimle no tube. Tho w rk .11
K'llni: mi utiili r (hri iiii.ii nt Inn. n'.
Mr. McMuttrle-I think mi nr. Mrueit III ny
Iti5 It wanttelnc f 11 under any out Mule. I think
It -in trolnu on wait In. f"f c titrictn In be iinulu
Mlilrh Mould net lie II nil.
A.-No idr. It .. ' i Inn mi um'.-r tin llootm r
rontriirt. The II' ml 1 r c. til mi t and (.111 r . ..n
trnctinirolnesli.il m eat 1 be t. ine. T'u ' lll'ifn-.
eiintriii t w.11 ni.ii..'. nml inn re In i xbleo. e
nt the time llili eoiiiii.ltiio unit to inite I lit
IKIltl.l.'t.
Q. Von liii" Bon-i nn and i-tmken of lb- uplll s
now oii nr.' ronil' it lion 11 tothu V llll"iii eon
ten. II A. .N'o.rlr; 1 111:1 coming d.iivii to tho
Am, 1 c '.iir.n t. 11 '11k. Am J
I,'. 'Mu 11 juil p i..hoi'rtheilii'rof the Wi'llnnm
l iu,' nn if A. I hen already told iibi.ut that.
II III till)' Villi ULl it II,
Q. Von i'iU lit ; fl In. ion in . p.'inrUf.ne inor'i
of tie Willi.. tii ! .mr.i.'t 1 A. V.".hlr. .Nuwlhefu
Imvr been Allnv. Ann, nnil llnry t'.Ornni', n ho
I11111 1n-in nnliii'd n n piniv t. tnke 11 rent mi t
f'.rthe Imnotllui 1 tic I rrd'tMob.llirof Aim rie.i,
but union 1.1 miiiio dlfk"..;tv I'li'int It tri.iiblu
with .Mr. AIIhv about nit Iiik tlii'in niidi'i-ti. nl
fnltly t lint win in-.i'd mcr. nml the whole in.it
ti r viii tiiudlv unniireil eailyln Aucutt, I tlilnl:,
erllmlHKi of July. IniT, Hint n 1 ontriict nboul'l
lie made In ihe name nf ()nk.. Aine :i tni't".'.
A )Wt of the iii ople, Hi it U to eay, Allev, mid
bit. frlend-(. T Shennnn. who wrote II, i iiuiv
.liulee of the I'lilteil r"tm- Court III llhlo- them
were the pnrtlrn who nljiiied. C. T. Slierni.ni
iirn. the then ti. -.rnieent Director of llio rnlmt
l'nclfli' llnllro.id t'otni-nny. There win n ehnin
In tin drtift of eoiiti-n, t ivl lrh nm partlruUily
olije. il'imible to the-.' Ilox'.oii t'iinlr, nod that
wthit Tun ut lmi.l. bo iiindo llio Ki'iienil
ntfetit f the '..ii pnv .
(,'. TI1.1t Hiii nii w.i' the in. 11 loony th 11.
tru-'ioinV A. '.itonnt -.1. 'o 1 a i Hie cc. r. 1 1
out.
Q V011 ".e 11 build "i ro.nl? A.-Ve. lr,
ni'b-"i Mi nt .'lid 'ipii'-rnt Agent. Thlswu
tnril. eliiii 1 - Hoi b in Alei mid hUcon-l.'.-n
. I.i.uu Allr) i. u.itl.0 rnuleiiiau of till
r.r nl".
U. Now you nay It was particularly objection
able In .'in' e Mr. lo'innt v to lie llenend
.j.nt of nl' t llh I "ini .ui v do you nienn
; when )oit e.i llio compnuyr A.-Tho (ien.'iul
A Kent to execute the contract.
t.- (Jcneral Aitcnt of whom? A.-Oererul
Aki ill ot the Prt.'lUe Itnllroiid (niipntiy. Thli
, wna ii contrail pin p. 'd. Any nun met Hint
w.. 1 ont ni lated, or ever contemplated fro'i
the I'.'i-lniilhL- ot the ervMuntloii ot the Cnulil
I Miil.lil.r. nn, eoleninly mid nlwobit.lv iiiiib-i'-
I Mo.Klt ' hcr.rthebincr.t . f the Credit Jtoblller
of Ami lei end nobody 1 le; Hint all tboillvl-
j dettil an I the pmnt niwltn; under any "ontia. t
j b idt by the I nlon l'jclfe Itatlri-ml wee to c
to the Mm kr older of 1 lie t'irdtt Moblller of
! Anietlr.i and nibi.dy el. And ai an eildeneo
1 of that no mnu irlin ivm a -torkholrier nf iho
I nb.n I'arillc limit, ml. ami not In the Credit
Mob Her of Ami ri. a. eer fit a dithr or a dbno
of dividend. 'I tier .an. while It all ill
t id. d to on the lo. k that eer iudlvluunl held
In 1 ( i- ( r. d t .Mi blllef nf Am. rl.-ii In-ni the be-
1 (..niiliii: until the en.'.
I The 3lcc m!io 1114 II.
C- AVIiii were the 1 at tie tmrllcuhirly uctlio
lu iiiak.utf tin c.nliii, t ..:,,rrt.iul Known n t..o
.1. 1. t;iil.nill, tnke Am.-. jTn 11. Mic-,
l.bi.'i Ii :..ii, J11U11 llutf, I'.iru. ton IIuhIhk II, C.
I'. vl i' 11 111. 1 ml II. .-. M. 1 oiuh.
I.il bavo Hat"d Mho were the par.
tt. i.. .-o'liiMiitf thin . n'r.'ct. 1 think oii tmi j
iii. 1 .1' Ira i.iIh'I .1". in ilu name of ih"in
I i.: .'i-l-i -led. I tr u iluallv au e-1.
tl .11 . for 1. 1.1 il'u. -all lei. .ml tin 11
iiiii.inii, 1..; nil I tb ik. oiu. ltd. tinic to I'd
I i i.i i.ti.L'i . to m tl.. .if 1I1 in,-, i.ii. 11 w -1-
1 w 10 1 o no ti.se n't- w I '1 i .al - A no
' ne I ' v..'. Ai law.' I ,1 .'p. .,inl luiw It .uui
t" 1 " 1 . . m I : 1 . i 1 1 .1 ,-',ilo il. - -
. .'. V 1. V",U- An ' - w.i til. Ill Hi Int. I?
A .1. !v 1 1 .'- . t.i .1I1 -,'li .'led. nnd oii..
, "I l). pi "i If waiii.'U a . i.tiiia. I made. All, y
( wn, .n "I il'. in. hi.'I li.dd the inpi 1-ir, x use.
1 mil ii... li.' una 1 If 11 m. .r i u. n I nu tu..o
abi ut i. "l'ie dlilli'iil. y 'nut Ind to be oiei--I
1 0 me u k Alley u.i.l A:mi. and tl.elr f'ien.N
I van ed the 1 ontriu't t" iru illicit to III ( red It
)!' 1 ilier of Ainericn; that . Hk,, Ame -hould
be III.' truitf' for tl 1. Cieilit Moblher. Ilil.ttit
i v mild ti 't rotient to that at all or bin fn.ml-.
1 li, 1, i'e (leojile Hint weie theeieciilii.i . 10.
I riiitee of the Credit Mobiher wi'io obn, xloii- t.
. 1. ill i' ell to Iluraiit ti'lelidn, mid they Old
I 11. -l ibink Ilia tiny had ih.'ir rlu.it or U...I
Hi. '.r rl;.hl would bo fnlrlv directed un.'er tt.
Y icy thoinrlit lhat It Would bo nlilii' to
th. 111 a jKiwer which they, who wero
not their .pee'al frlond, wero n.li-ero
t thtlrliiiliik'. After 1 conflict of a iiiiiiiIkt of
dn; the t.'-titt hinged nn acotitr.n I Ih'Iii iniiibi
llimllv with Oikrn Ame, pruiuled be would
name before 1 tie emu.,, t .'bout.t t. made tho
iru tec of the I redlt Mobiller. nnd who rhoit'd
oe 1 lie ri','r,','iila:Ui of tlm Credit .Moblllei',
The" men were 1 lllver Ame. .I..I111 II. Alley,
l.t iijamln E. It..tn. II. s Mi C, nib. C. S. Ilu-h-iK'il.
and S. J lilili.ii ; the) were the ,'o lii.an.l
the e aie tho niiiutuie ol the ianle npiMMii2
Hi.it t iper. '1 hi- e men weie tl.elru-tei under
the Ante ennlni.'t, to pn.toct tho rl.'hu ot the
L'ndlt b blller of America, and tlio coiitrm t
wiw exi'i ii. d ul.i ii tin i rovlsli 11 for the trial
; wa finally tie. !dcd upon, and the appointee,
and tnoi wore nil mnile uine month prei...iH.
I ,'. Illi'i.l all been itr. ed tipnn Home time ,
tirlour A. It wa utireed upon lu Auu-t '
unnllr, and not e-l.-ned until the fuliuwlu;
October.
lli.w lliry Tlrd the Mnrbluilild-.
O. Then the exc -ntion of the Ames mnlr-vt
w 1 iiieiiip..r.ine iii Willi llio ex'iitiori l
tl tnitvei if. V A.-Yi. ir;llie Ann cjii
tr.nt w.i ex. 'i uteil Hlii"i.iau. mi-lv witnathiN
tram , lnp. And II mi c-loll with tlll.l tlitte
w-a a later onpar.d bv which the holder of
tho t nl. .11 I'm Ulc t:.,i., i,i:i tink. U-t( ulb of ,
tliem. app' .nted 11 tnujorltv t the-e tiume. .:
nml Ilin v,n that n u.l. rfereiice rbi.t.bl be .
1 i.i.le ulili lb- Atne '-entiait iiiuil It wa coin- I
plel.d. I
I. 'IH't b. tin r .nib 'tired tli':i to vote their 1
Ho. k ill the t nl ... I'a.'in-.' ltndroad Cnnipuri I
A. Vi. lr. and keep the i-mnr lloanl of ,
Hire. tori, mi im not to intetteie with the A'mh i
c.iiira. t. and p reiei. t ,uiv adiepe "crntf 11 on
j the i.irt . f the Cre Ut Mol.ilnr ttoiMioliterm.il
nc . ui.t of the '.n .jl.nn. .-. null Inn of ih. mi
three men; r.ud that lod to the lluid exeiutliiu
of thlii c 'iiirti '. 1
(,'. 'I hen. w hen the On lie Ame contract was
executed, It Mipi. de.l and uimiilled Hie pio
Tiou exIitliiL coiurni tr A. Ve. ir It wan
one ol the c uillll us with the IIimiuiit tin- j
tfiiit Hut tho protlt nrllnr tinier It hnuld
belunctothe Credit Mobllier of America, and
the llezner nhonld be merged i and that tho
Ame contra. l .I'Hiimed everjtldnc. and t mlc
th road from tho 1'mth innrlUiati to bi
miles nt. with tho rlifht of cxteudlutf under
th.. '.imo triialte,
(j.-Wa I; es. r rtinpo. d at any time il urine '
tho ll'-f-ollntlom win h e .(. mule iindrr tho
r-e iittrui nl thl Ame 1 1 11 1. 1 Hint the Atne 1
I ontia' t wa the lndtv 1I.11.I pri'i oily of Hiko
Aim-' A.- Xi ur, to th. extent of ,1 dnUar. I
1.1 '.''!mly i'ier thoiml.t nf any ".-li th'tiL-'r
A.- Sol, ody fir r itreaie. .1 nf nuili a illn.'.anv
nil!, 111010 tb ti you that It wan jour Indlild al
C'.ul.mt, that did not know .iiijthiin; 111. rj
ab mi II. lleli.. I id ltneret lu the Lrid.t M i
blller of Amirb u, nod nothing mm.', ,
Q. I'or whom wa the c ti'ru. t bi.liu: mado '
A. 'Hie contract w.i made f r I' o Cmllt t-.
bllltr of An ei 1 ,1 ; f..r II. to. kh ndi r, and fur ,
II body else; tn-idn to exclude the pn. ino ulm
were kii inn . - I'e l.ic ll'.lr .ad mck holder and
nut Ciidli Mob.i.vr f Ameilca im-Mioldr ru.
The -(Dill oflbe Job,
0. Tht)-tcm of trnteet:ln w,v to jirevent
th, pr 'ii froiu k"lnii Into Hit hand- of tho l!i
oeutlic Cotiitnittce, that w-ire ribnoxloit lu tho
Hto.kholdcrar A. -Yen, lr; that wa the oh
J.ict Tnted of the dlvtdnd belnc dd Idrd by
tho reuulur 1 lUcri. tbi.j l.onl.l lm ill.-lded t y
till liinrd? A. -Vr. lr. Ihethlnir If elf iuii
that tt rhi.ll lo diMde.1 to the holder of tho
Uie.lit Mobbler Moik after Hi it dale. 'lbtw
the ai.. in. I Intention; thatwa the c rluinal no
tion of thl mutter, nml thl. tniateeiihlp wiu .ui
original notion of Duriitil'H to elu cktilMe the
tiM'.'iitl.o (Joinmlttee of the Credit Miibdler of
A.... .1. 4 to in. i-.-.it tlirin naabody from h.tiliu
tttyili 111-' to .fo wiih It.
V.- Il.it for unit nl Jictlon It w-.n.li liavo beim
Juil ll.u II... II. .sit niii.rji'U A.-V.i... -Ir. If
thc l'irdllM ' Ilu r people I1..1I been ae -epia'dn
to Dur.iiit uuii I.i fiuniU timro never would
have bi.in an Ai.iea contract. The Hollo uon
tinet tti.iild liilie li. en .'Mended clear tliMiiuh
l; the enu ..I tho llif'uit for tiuue wrun.'lc s
that wa-v !. it bioimht all lhco Bubi.-niioir.
tl.iiil.' up. .voI. Iiik i l-e ever did ii.
y. -'('he pruUl.i of ihei-e c.inira.'li all fltiully
to k the 1 1 1. lie 01 dlMileiul on t .e Ciodit Mo
liiUtU'Ktock A.- .', all. alliie. . ,-i.
y. '.hey nil went thro'iiih funnel or
Hpuiit f A.- Ve. air. ulio.-e.r.cr.
O. -Mute II jou uui int. profit that wa
loabin.d by the i-rrKtit MobllUr ol Amoil. alu
tlievhnpe ol' ill Ul. iil. in iho l'.it t lnii'i. II
wtiat dtudeiul . ni.ii' p id. rui'l what yuiium in
I lie Cndli Jlil.lli.r. Yin to. otlur 'loca ftoni
the bi",'llllllli'' a, 1 lull. i.i.,n 11 lu lllVulllle-
II . nt here. I: W 11 m v,uo, I ihluU, up to that
ti.nu.
its Mr. lllack ftnte what tho road rout. A.
8ouie of ilu- iilieelor ..tfcri'U to lmli.l Hie ronil
and oimlp it (or fa jam a inllo. and lliul wa . lei
than Hie n..ri;e.f ii'0 hiit iitoitinu.1' b .nil
KiM'ii b) tho UoM'ii.u.ont. I wa looking for a
p.ter lure In wl.li h Mr. Dutf hud urine an In
k de coiiir .i ' to tali, il ut y; . M . I think III. to
I a (liiiUei.il 111 nm k docUred lie In,'.', ills
uii.d ndvin de. l.Ti d mi c.odlt Mnb'lior ioiii
ud w p..;, al.l.' in l'i l.,n I'm ulc hi.,, :;.
AdJouuiuU to Tuuday, Juno i-.l.
Tlll-nHAV, Dec. 11. lUTI.-Mot III piirkiiaui 0 or
notl.e. l'riioiit : .buiiia II. (Joweu, and tUiiuul
(1. Tli'iiniwon, li , forcotupl dii'int i and llcnrj
M. Coml , I'omplulnaut. Mr. Mi'Murtilo, loun
el for il.feudaiita belli a- Ini-ourt uu..lilo tu ut
tend, and Kilcu to Monday, Dec, li, Wl, ut I
1'. M.
Moniut, Don. 18, 1871. Present t Jn. H. flnw
euunU a, (i, ThoiuiMon, fur lomplaltiaiiti
and Henry H. IlrCoiub, oompluluaiit. Mr. Mo
Mnrlrlo. Ku for defeudautaiaud Hunl.H.Ueru.
tcln and Geo. Crawford, Usip, for Henry 0,
1 ant.
The Onken A rue Conlrnri Aunlu,
K-nnilnntlon of Heiity R. Mct' itnl reitineil !
(.'-When irm the eotitrtiet known 111 tho
Hnke Aiiim enntrnet "Tented t A. H took
et'icct on tho l.'u It or halt of Ori'.ber, 1hi7,
liii'.ill.innou with tho appointment of tho
i-eieti witne. e, to rxeiulo It, I think It benn
date enrl lu An "iit.
1 Whowiii' the trniteen? A. -Oilier Ame,
.1.11. Allei. I'. I. Htiiuiitill. 11. IJaliWi II. t. Mu
c.uili, r. S Ilu dint II, 111 (1 fliiin-y filllon.
y. H hen wn the (Hike An.e contraei hrncd?
V. It ii n not ollii lull) Hlcned and delivered 11I1
tll ticiober, but It wn fiibjeut to Hieniium.'.'
tm.nt for n trut, not. belmr rlien lo Amu
iiiuiiltliiidlv at nil. Tiio detiiery ot the conllHi't
w o be 1 'iiitempornueou Willi 111 -( xccutloit
' f l'.e triiil. (inkeaAine w.i not ..ppimi "I to
be the man III ivIkmc iiuiiic llio contract would
t.itiiii.iti ly bo uin.le.
(,'. When did tno neeotit.tlen for (Iii con
tract begin A. nn the lt of March. IW.a
Co.,! r.'irt wnsioied to be made by the HlTclor
f the I nlon l'.ie,i;e Itellroad with .1. M. S MI
I .u:i In 1 o t the b"lli!lnic of tlic road fiom ih.
Inul'i HK-!dIan tu l," Chw Cre"k cro(tl'ii!. Jii7
toll . .v'th Hie dl tl'ict tinih rsiandlm; that It
huid be u.'Kimd to the Credit Moblller. Tii .
coimiiitwa tube executed with V!lll.in., mid
klinull.in. i'i:ly tr.insferted to the Credit Mo
blller on the pith of July, IMT. Thomn C. Ibi
rtn. VI e Vrr ildent of the I'li'iti rnelllc Itnll
rouil. li ii ifcri il by Inl-jri. tluii, i.uil def, iile.i tho
aunt . metit. Tlio lfiinid ot Idnctor of th
Noniu 111 I'B.'Iflc llnllroul Co'iitmny met on th..
IS,d of May, ap ulntod a euinmiiloo t" audit and
ett'eih, account of the Credit .Moblltur with
the I nlon I'licllli- l(aljroadC.uiiinnyii.iil pfm-cd
r. i.'solutbin dltectttn.' the opi olnttueiitof acein.
mlttee nf tlio ii ron to iret up a contmot. mid
out of which 'ho contract .1 ultimately made
came. Ttico paper wero drawn up by C. T.
Shei 'uai. tl .-ti 11 tloveriit'ieii! Director, and after
1 ' ' r.il month of w-ratitftlni! mid dlciiion nl
tlcn.ul) ntibKiaiitlKlly ntfueil lo
The (Jcnilil ullh lliiliuit.
O. IVIm wn to be the other 1 riiTtielhif pmty
- 1 11 .it i. I m. -an. wlinii-ii t.. be Hie re.l a .
I iri1an'! d .ii t - the nno that wn to do I''
I work called for bv till contrail? A Vli. 11
1 thl c iilracl wa llrt drafted the ( ir l t Mo
blller wn to be the enntnie.itiu party. 111 "d t
Dm 'lit. Vlce-1'l. flilent of the t'liloii I'lieilic
Ih.llioad, a tdn'tHl iwetit.
V. - Do ton mean that when tl e contract w.i 1
Unified flrel II at It wa to be cxeetit'il b 111.'
Credit Moblller and the Cnlt ti l'aclile lb llro.ul .'
A.- 'I Ml wa all knoi ked 111 tho head by Intuitu ,
Hiirntit out of the I're-ldenei of thet'ri.bt
Moblllirlieeaii-e .f hi objectfoii 10 Allev nlel .
lleianl.wlioia.no liiaelluee or.. I the (V III
M11I til- r.
y. ho v it" Hi 1 uui itIiii nh'-v'te-t to iinitn
tho contra. 1 xlt- J 1.) the Civdll M il'llt. r r A.
Dr D.irnnt.
y. What wahl teeth ti A It ' .1 t-l
have ft. Hi in He lal.liv and d -1 .'..n.r
Mr. llHXnnl and Mr. Alo-y to do iu:u iitb,
1 tiiatiaiieiu. nt of llic (.rouit ..iob.li. .
, f.- What U..I It. -UitL. t ' A . I'.ti. tt. of
f even, and (lint ia;'ir itvi'v.I f. miiie p.,r
1 marked A. W. N. (i.e. II. '-.1. n. 1.
y. IWiat did Hie -"ttii.nl . a d Wl.i.twa
I the re ult of the i.'t.iit A. Nolhln . fuilh r
than tl.U .-i.-ri eineiil at that time. I 111011 the
1 pa ei wiil.li I t.ow prid'tie. iI'iiiht mai'-
. i d A. W. X., No. ,111,1 4, Dc. en b. 1 I , l7l.)
And from wi tell the Mial pamnwh II weie
nxeeuted by (lke Am. were .le.li.i .1. I .ioii't
remeinber when tho puni r win .Ma in. .Ni .
liX',11 and 4, bu. 1 think It was to la-t ol Mai
or In llio nn l.:li of June. Il iiiuy po.- ut huio
, lieen III .lulv.
, U.-lbI..nli C e I re;vir:it. "i .f t'"' pal el
marked 1. !. -1. 1 ti I 4 find ibeOni.l itebv ry an 1
I- fi 111111 1 1. 'Il 1 , 1 he I I.Ik Ate. . .ill' rn. 1 all 1
' the iippolii. iitetil i f I lie tiuxce. what wa.doiio
b Iho j arlle In t-p ted lo iwtliin.' op t'u .n
tr .t f r the cNt.'iirlnn of the I'n oii I'r.'ltJ.'
CUliond fp in ihe loth ii'.-ridl u .- A.-ili.i
rout w.' In i n' r. nlilly built iw. . i.e I in.,
i ".h ii ll ,'. in. ir.ilei- a e u'ra.-i wio li s i-. -
. I i -Id. nt li'irant had in.ulo wl.lt I.. II. II. on , r
In 11 .' i , . ' ,
y. V. in. re Hie -'iirl c, t that . I l - f
In 1 ',r..i t m li'e I ill., l '.!',,,, t viM.iJ
Ct. .t . .(.:. r nnil 'I e-ir I.I. 'i of t."
1 ni n PaclMc l!allri.ad Cn.epuni . -laieu ! y
. bltn. for the lienetlt of the C.odlt Moblller.
i y. -IMio I in in .led the l.n-an to b'.nl.I t'"
r .ad in, tier Ihe llooiner cm. trai l ' A. 'in..
I nlon I'nolne Kalln ndl i.inimii), a they i...l all
I me eoiitr.ii t thu wen-made. ,
i.-Throui-h hat iron.'! re the filed- f ir
nU.ied ? A 111 draft uud . hocl.aoii thu I lie it
I'.n Itie Itadioad. '
here the Credit JtaMller ('net" f u.
'i. M hut .11. 1 tho Cridlt Mi bl'ler have to .! 1
wl.h It ': A - Al thl lime notion .-; that I to av :
at Ho lltne the.' pam r-.v re I.e'W i reiin-e.l I
that I to ny Se .teiub' r. loT. I ut n w . -ta'.e.l
b) Duialit that Ihe llooiiior inntr.tel had In en
ma l with the iiinlemiandlnii with htm. II
t, that the pn.it und.r II and Ii'.j nine t
were to I liorbcd by an) k J MS i,nt c .ntra. t 1
limdo by the I'nl n I'acil'c lUiilroad C..in...iiy.
O. -Vi a lli.ni... r Uto real iwrty intereted in
Ihf coutmctr A. 1 Uuu'l kuow. Ho id-tied
the paper.
y Wl i w the Cre.ll; Moblller orrml7d
for A. I idw.i) uiiu. 11. d ii I. ton I
thrmu-h whl.li tin' dlilib nd riiBhl I .-. mold
tin: iniiiiidiinl babil.ti ; 1 lueiui .lie l -;,-. i
the i ontrui t.on tuid otb, r c.ntra. mii-t,, t. ,
10 the to, kl.i'lder ot the Ci ',1't X.., , r.
y. Hud uny prollt I om th. -f e. nl i... t . 1,,-cri
dliidcd mill tii the flock l.li i .,1 the I niiltM... .
blllerprl. r to the fall ..f sd. - A. Y. -. li-; Api 1
P.'. teOn, ftipereiiit.iiito, kof the I nlon P.i. me
llallroad; July. lMitk niiolhi r M pet cent.; N't t.
INfi, 11) pen cut. I nioti I'aeifli Itil'nwil t,n 1, ;
IW .11. lt'k liu r ertil. l id. Il l'aclile lia.lroiui
etoik; Apr, I I. IwT. So per i.i . ft I. u I'n llio
Unit mortirnjo bou. I ; tii.tt i .dl up lu Auk-i:.i,
IKllo I
i,i. Had any profit ben p' dl.'e.l opto the
remtinii of In.T fi n .1 , iru.-tl ii.tittai., .
of tho I iiiuil I';,, in" Itnllroud .' A. Yi the
book In. weil Urt-e profiu. i
y. Wlia. "ontriil piece.h'd tie II oi.iereeti- '
trie l? A.- r'.ei, ifr . oiiii.v t. '' nil nub.
st i'itl.il one I i .'..re C tt wa, too lluxle i ouir.n t. i
(j.--ft hat io.iti.i. t w.a. xitin whin Ihe i
Ci dlt Mubiller w.i. i ri.-aiiized.' A. The Hone
i nua.-t. lhat wa.-in.ide. 1 :.i. nil, fur lUltii.j,,
and exleii.l. .1 lr..in nine f , tlu.e I
i). - ho wa lloxie r A.-It. .xle w.", an . in- '
.h yen "f a rail." id .or;. ml of ll.. r,',,- n-l-
I.ibiy. He a u c . 'o Ilii'.i" ..ett-l. i
y. Wlen the Ci u't y, b.P. r wa ermidred, ,
what a'.ioi.iil of i up I..I wn nil .-. nl,d A. I
(l.il.0.
y. NMiat wa.'..! e ill. it ? A. -It n .iaiu 'bd
to I Hilda ll. i ,i I.
I. Del llic tin . . i p ll i.,.it:i the tlinhnry
of ll.v Colon I'j. .. K.lnnd.' A. 1 1 run toy
re.el.ed from Hie -to. I.i.nlrl, r of V Cr.on
Mobiller wn applied to butldtna the mini am
to .ylm; the ilel.t and to purehuet. material
In builtllnK tho I'lilmi PaeiU.; IUilroa.1 undLr 1
Ihe Hullo contract, which cofitrnct bad both
iii-almuil I" the Ciedtl Molullor. I
y.- Did tho Hoxle com : act expire by It own
limitation .- A. The lloxie contract iui tn
ceptible of Indelluito exttulon by r.iniclil of
botli imrtiof-thut I. by tho Union l'aclilo Hall- ,
load mid ( r.-illl Moblller. ,
y. u It not uper( tied, theiich, by tlin i
Geztier contract? A. -No. I utuwer that in ,
name it w ti. but not In reMlty. The eanio an- .
awer :i,.plii'i to Hie llooiner coiiiract. .
W here the I'rntti Went, I
t. To wl oi.i did t.ll the profit an under all '
tu. se .- intra. I? A.-The Cn-dlt Mol.ilh r.
y I lid. r wh1. h . f these tltreo l oull.u I wa
t'.i ik bolmr done ..I Ihe price l.vululed
win li the (hike Am,. coilrn'twa beltudli. I
i i'nl In tho n'l-uner of lb ? A. - It wa not
dilii.ilely leaulati d under i llher. nml )et It wa I
rek'nlutod umler all. Tho railroad fiom tin- III ih
in : d. n tic It V to the t'toiv Cretl; crnln?, '
J,l i. d mid inlle sirt of the Jlnth
lueildlaii. win pr.tde.l, and oier HO mile I
liullt at the time of tho An:e cotitrnet, ivhicb '
the Atne itra t wa m-iile to cover. There
were about ulJ mill- of r. ad from Omaha to Hie
Cn,w ( re. k Cr"- n.--the bun. of tho Ibuky
Moiiniel'i, - and thl wa all done, except ) lm I
l.bont 1111 iiilie of rond, w hen the Ante coin met
iiai itii.de. Henor and II " nier w ere only llt'iirc
Itcnd. I 'eloie; llooiner wn a men of morn
ieionibil b.y, but niuy put up like the othrn..
I he . leii. ii work .. id I n direct Inn nf the clerl
tal iv. rl- In the out e, und the ere. Hon of tho
li; 'I c.. n .a r fm nl1 '.hi work and for nil lheo
i ..litre, t -. n made by Henry C. Crane, tin
Aral' nm Treasurer of the Credit Moblller. who
wu alwi ii eretitry tor tho TruMnc under the
Ame contrui't. Ill liiei fnll ol W, he cow l lo ,
be Tr.'iomier of the ( ...lit M .blller, t til w.t.
bupi r. (lid by II. I'. Hi d. 1 d n't I' nk tie I
de.ticr enntr ie' ami 11 iter cuti i t It id . i. ,
Leon in -i n, ed to llic Cp'd i lo' t . ei-
y-iii.ii ilu i-iipi.al 'i l o I llm In. lit
Moblber w. .nci. a-, d w 1 al ,,'u lite it, noun t uf
ni.jt.i.j I a.d lii'i A.- tin the ::t'h ,lnv of Junil
nry, lNii, Ihey deir.it to murw. Hie ettriital
aux kor theCiinlit ib '.illr to two mid n i..f
million, and u v. ti',1 b) ih"lr l.naPl. At tlio
tlmeoftl- a. I, ,.n i e riii'lLiI wan not (illicit If
nny mot two uoli om. t w.i only n mum In
ire, e, V lietliet tliey e .rrleil till out I don't
kn ov. Salve,!.,, ii to in.u Until titoy illd in
ere.ie the . iiiitud Hoek nf the (Jredil Milliliter
Mi v per in . I l.iiow mat at lhat Hue tin.
n ick w.i- not opto t...'i,u.n. ihmk y,aiu,n.,i.
I know Hint t..e Iii.to.i-h .I'd m.t yi. la mor
tl .jii.iui. i na ,i.i, ami n tr ,.n.
y.-l llllt bee.iuie ol the lllulie)' p.dd III? A.-
11 w.i laud in.o tuu (:r.oiu of H i. I'n, oil
l'a. ic It illrn...l. Tin. iiodllloinU ubcrit.tiiiu
wan math, to i.cllwllt the I nlon Pacific ItttlliiMtil.
y. -i'h tio '.a lulu tno ao irco lioin will li
Hie uinin y u il to b.olU Hie l ul .ii I'ltciko Ua I-r-
ud wu dtrtuil ? A. I'iuiu the Cioiilt Mi.bl
Ihr. The (nicrmtit'ni KnlaUdy I'.ivlmi f.ir the
1(01. d.
Q.- There wa (.ioierument mibldy. Tell u
It.oi lac iv i. wu done uud too Ittoiii') I ,.iu in .
A.-I ue lo.ioanui i.i Lino thu l ntoii l'liiuli
lo.di .ad lioiu i ni, aha lo thu i .in.nt baao ol
t'o I" kl Mo nil, .tux hi, Kill I 'IT lil.le of (io, oi ti
ll,, in b.iu ' a i. ut mc y. I". Hie I.Vi mil, h m;
ilio l.o. .'!. .nl d:n li.iitl in r until hi ulitul"?
bund, ami (.t,.iui per nolo fin llio b il.in. i nf llio
w iy. Die i U.-I i i n l lain UlvUlnn wn jliliklo ,, r
in dot the ii.i.at.iaiiieoiipotiiinHr'(s,liUiMi.jrmilv.
an. I the itoatcrn plain tlK.urn per mile. Too
I nlon Pa. itle llallioHtl Con, puny Ikhid.i It nun
IU-.I nioiiyu.uliohilH "iii'ii. hiliioluiiHt lliemuno
rito Iho llovernineiit luul dono. hlelt Ininil
were ojd mid thu money expended nn tlio rond,
aiiddliltled I'luiuii; the stockholders of Hie
tiiilll M .blller, a piolltH or ilUiitimU on tho
wink and for iho lrcaplt.il Inieeted.
y. -How wu It donor' What wa the mrvdji
o iyiiuK of biiliiirtlie(lovirnmeiit ImiiiiI? I
liienii, wltiit Wa tiecchwiry lo show to tho liny.
.Ttiui.int befoto tho l.otidi, were obtained A.
The Uuuiutuiut Coiiiiulasluhcr icrtlUoU fur
I J l.il LX1JJL-1 I I 'B-!iJ 1 1 ULJ -Cg
every twentjr mile done t Uion upon th tjt
neera' rertlflcato backed by the Commiselocera
the ItalltuaU Company, wn allow cU to !:su
bonds at so ranch per mile for a hundred mile",
and they could also Issuo rcrllfkutc, fur tlio
Um eminent bond in ndrmice.
Q. Ato you abio lu say what proportion of tho
money ndiui"id by the Cicdlt Molill'er, ntel of
the tlt'Ternmint and Itallnts 1 Coini-.tij' bonds
iu leii-ct! In l.iiihi.n -tli. r-. i ', -u.d w i it pr por
tion w-j dcolfircd In dividend-i A. The I'nioti
l'u. Iflc llullr nil c. t to build nml ei"li
from Omaha to their terminal point not exc. od-
lllt; .-..IIIU III .11.111'' I lie I i.il crtl'llt 111 n.tbiidj
wa aulllclritt to build the entire work.
y. The (lenicr mid llooiner contract bad
they been inane by dr H"innt ib.iie.or throtiirh
tho committee? A. lb Ml. Di rnnt tilonc, and
not bv the committee, a I iili.. ritlid It.
y. What b tl 'o lliiiiiil.oi'ilmcnt uf a "iniittilt-
tro to in.ike a Heir . tiii.i, i in tl prln and
ailiuciernf IhTT? A. Tlieilbndi-. eiii 'it betwe it
Hiniliiilln iret ninoiu the .lire, lorn of llio
I'lilou l'i" II!'- Iti.lln.Hil mid Iho ItoUiHk.T of tlio
C'edlt Moblller.
i). Win t'lere nei prirtbiibir poln' tobecaln
ed bv mi Mow a ir v iniitr.l A. Ve-, tho
po'nt ot icettlinr a i. ry tn.i.-li Iili her prl' " fortho
work.
linni iiiuii till liteii.l.
).- Wn there anv Inlrriiirdlnle stnm-of reiru
tall n or .irr.iutieiiieiit between the piopioiillon
o f Iho pnier alnnd) referied lo and the tlnal
delivery of the Aim i contract In 1hI7 r A. -H
wn eoiiiempl ted to put It into n .ommlltiiii
who i.ete tobo of tho Itiruiut stocklioldei lu
place of tho corporation tlio Credit Moblllir
and this to t reventtheliitetfrrenionml tiianlpu.
I itioii of Alley nml llatud.M ho wete the uxeotl
tlio comti'lllee of the Credit Moblller mid par
ticularly oboxloit to 11. mint. Hut finally tho
matter wn rononnmatcd by the delliery of tlio
Amu. contract mid the creiilioli of lliotrutee.
h p. The tiiMl, im were tl" -'im1 IndiliduiiU
ii'iio had prelloiifly been n lined a Ihe com
mittee. y. Wlin' Mi hletiil wii'deelftred on the Credit
Moblller Kto.-k after Hi. deliver) "f the Aim
rmilrai't? A.-My book- uow t b.it 1 to .lied
Ihii. I. II.. ml ier c.nt. I'niou I'a.'iric Ihulio.id
-link, :tl , per nl. I nioti I'.n lUc liallioiil
Moek, lit per cent. I ul.ii. I'ai'llle Unllroad l-otiU.
Above dlildeml w.i on ",'iU fihan . I'eb. H I pa
tiom II In dividend Nl -li.m of kIo -I, of I ri ilit
Moi.tll.T. June 11 I reeeiied 10 p.Toiiiit.ln i'lilou
l ii' llic l.iillrontl 'lock, w lib iki per ct lit. In i if
( n s-O nhnte. .lull .1, 1-.. A per cent. Ill mock
iiml '. percent. In ruloti t'u. lUc 11 illio .il bond
i n .)eluin. "-ept. II, i.i per. ent. In bond and lo)
percent. In toel:. Dee. 1". -m per cent. In tork.
In nddlHon to thl thete wn. 11 M per cent, in
Cold paid In .liinif.ry, 'a'. I'nillt Moiillier stuck,
and I-' tier , ur in ai.ld for tv-Ii dlildelids.
(,'. What no .nut ..f Hick, dli'ltleiids rcpre-f.-nleil
profit e re tl pre r to Ihe tlite of Iho
deliiervnt the Ann lotit-act? A.- Ileforelhs
dnt.'flhe Vni'-c titra. t -here wa about SJO
prr cent, of ibildeml ileclnretl on the Credit
Mol llier ! '; I ut then wn i-arned nil of
another l"l p.-. rn! en-h befn n the Atne ifii
t i"t took elf. et. and hl.-ii In inv oiiilou wa
d i. Il l' -.t h tl Ho '" ai.d -o Included In Ilu
Uiitdeitd oi July I, I" .
Hun .Mi'CiiniliV Mihic Here llltrttiineit,
(,'. Do ymi tif.w what ha beeniuo nf the i50
h n of oilj-n'il t ok nd the li" li ilea ..( In-et-e.K
i ,t, en that i"U claim In thl ene of thu
CW'iiit Mobli vr.- A. -It wn put under thu
ion i.. . f . 'ik- Ani.-.Trctee-An fharenof It -"I
or i..'iell.liK like I'int, went to a Mr.
N-II ii ; ". - i.tr. of It we ( hail. M. Nod-on,
broker. New otli.
',' - What .1 'flrtiiutlon . ( It nm mad by Mr.
Ai.e. A.- ItHjr.iie , t i in- uber ,, Cotiitre,
Sr.. ''..I- alt l Met !.. tna.lu f
t,i. I v wa paid nt.. ihe . r.llt Moblller for
tha. ". ' nhlen Mr. An-e .l.-,r.l n'e.l In tho
w v i..ii mention r i', ' mock whle'i Mr.
Am. - to- a i.i iru tee h .d pa I I.. It all t no llil
ilcnd . f lie eofii-inv troio il... il.- of th
-,-i. Ir .Con ..f tl . '."nvani d"ini to lb t ni
when lhat tto. I wa .1, lit"'.', I lo bi n. an l none
f'f the e pro e.n hp.. un"M ; t . rernl h to
dP il c r rent, lu per inb.e wer. paid In. I he par
value mil i" aid In.
i,'. U' 'lua'tl .-1 viiPie of thl '..'k i"
he tl'ii" .1 " i tu d ' .- II would ell Pi Hi..
ipi-k. t ni fvi per 'h ire erli tuple, nn.l lery
I ie culd i I. 'id ai that more buyer t'ni.i
. I'. r- a i o.., .1 -il. I w-w ofr. -ed O tier shuro
lor mine lm: lit ifter th it tp
y.-Win.t lm I n the hii-iiet value retched
I. ) te C e.llt Moblller tu.'kl A.- I wn oboe. I
" "r hare for mine. 'I hi wn lu Ink loin;
bef re till ult benui. I refused to ell nt that
tin '. I coti-ldercil ll worth SI. Kit p-r ilii.re,
mi. I it would ham been i.'Hillly worth that,
In :i ally and fairly tuanntied at that time.
Cp..exa'iiitiei by Mr. McMurtrle Ib-When
).ui elected n Ilin. 'lor "f (he Ctvillt Mobl.
Ilerr A.- I tiner wa a lbr,M'lorat all.
y. Y. mi were una of Ihe Trustee under Iho
Ame imiintcw A. Vie, air; uud am )ct. I
ftllppOM.
The Wuv Ihr ltnIue- nn Hone,
y. -After the tuie cunt met trust wa er atedi
who wa the iilviiI or man of Lu.lii" of lhat
tnitr A. Iiiiinedmtet nfter the kiIui: ol His
p ,r-nml the ImvIoiiIu of Ihe a. tile o ra
ti ui of tbi work under It, Tie .tun C. D tranr.
He w. nt nut on to the line of the road, and re
mained thfe some time r.- Vleo-P h nl arid
II, -n. r., Air. ut ..I the t nioii Pa. ,u,' i:.dlro..d
t'o'i i,,.i. iiireiiliiii tho bi.ll.lln-' f tl,.. r ail,
I. en. i.. M. D' il liebiL- Ciu, f l.ii.'ine.r, and
( Oil T A in, ( h it. man i f l ie Pru!. i'-. lie Mill
tinned " i'or in., lime, tin; 11 '-.in.- of the
lie. lit M bill, r p ople cr at ill a iiiuipusby Iriv.
In; ull.er tine- lu.erfere with the rJ.r of
'I l.otuu. C. Dura'it ...ton lite line of th nail.
f..r liie w.-rk of Ihe loa.l. the Chief lii.di.e. r
I eliiit ut Ho time lit Vt ,ililiit:tli a a ao'tubcr
ol Cotup' -. and not being- in 'ch on thr lino of
Hi" r. ad- ib lnir Id w. rk by proxy. Tn led ''
tli" arM'Ui'ii'i.i.t of a commlltiw, coif Mlnit. I
Hi. nk. of John Dutr. Sidney Dill. n. and 1 hotii i
c. Duraiit. who thir.aftir were uniiiiiully the
ui.iiitwcr. John DulT peiNotutltii; a Trustee in
the pbu-e of John II. Allen.
y. - You ea) Hi ) beemne nominally the niiin.
airer. Who were the Imltvid.ril w lm were a .
tlvelt ItiteteMed in "to utiiu- Hit Attn aeuntra. t
In tlio wa of buylmr ni ut.l.il r coitlriiiiluj
I. r work done ' A. - The auten trustees.
y. Who ws their tnaiirer? A. - l'-'njamln
II. Hate nouiliiall.'. Iletil) C. Crane ie i'Iv.
y. - Did you tak any part In the ciciuuoii of
!h,ttrui? A. Y".
y.- Did youeur ee a cot.trai t In writing for
the pun hao of boa or other materials, ur for
viaditii: ,.r for other work dune on the road?
A.- i.e; sen ral.
i). Can't y. it recall who slcnetl llese eon
traits, or any of Hum. nn tne pan uf the
trutrct' A. Hen-) C. Cr,,ne sillied some a
r-. ret-iry. D.irani and Dtibm sinned others, and
I think iilii.r Ami. DulT, mid D.lhi.i sUnvil
ollitl.
y. Where was the eflleo of the tmttee In
which their buln. wa done and their bnoka
kept I A. 1'nit ol the lime al ai Nii'nut street,
.New York, and uheout'iiHy in ll..i. u.
I.-1 lm wa lle-ir tiookk. 'per; A.-Mr.
(V ine. I iltlnk. II. I'. II uid w a., tit" nuditor of
thl I nl..n I'ailfle and Treasurer uf tin i relit
Moblller.
y. Hid yon when yon were triitee ever look
tit any of the bunk of Hie mnt ? A.-V. lr.
y.-Wb.it bonk did they keep? A.- Crane
kept the bonk nf niitrn.'l fur material ami a
rec. rd "f the amount of work done at e itract
prl. e. Ti e d. tall nf the absolute expenditure
were iiioro e:.pll itly under the auditor' dlicc-
tlotl.
y. Ilnw many btnk aeenunt were kept by
thfstrii.tr A.-1 wo. 1 think.
y In whin ban I.- A.- I think tho l'mirth
NuHon.d and thei ..ntlneutnl.
(.- lu wha' names or stiles were lhee ae
count opened or kenl ? A I can't sav. That
wn left under the direction of the Iren-urrr.
y. a tho c.ih eier veillt.'.l or examlneil by
the trustee or anybody by their direction. A -
1 teuueiit exhibit were made nf the tlnr.ti. I n I
eoiitlltloii nf the trust by Mr. Cinne. the Treas
urer and Secretary, but never by tlio trutlee or
a ' .'iiiinlttee of their number.
Where Ihe Money ('nine from,
y.-Wheii money for the expense . f hulldinir
tie. road wa raised, It wn done liy ale of bond
oflbe I'nited Male or of tho road, whs it not I
A.-It wa done ty selllnj bond and stock
wiilcli hjloniroil In art to tho Credit Mubiller.
be. ituse their debts due them had nut been pel. I
and their iai.iti.1 had not him rclunud, . uui
even not pa . I to tli'stlay. so f.irn I know.
y. W If. 'Id ihcohond uf Hie I'ltlteil Slate
nml or Hie rudroud. A. Mr. Ilium wnalhepr'n
clpul sell. r. He win Hie Awlnanl Treuter of
the i re II Mob. Her.
y W I., m did lie pay tho proceed to? A.-To
diiei lersotia. Tl.n holdei a of I e olillfalliin
of tlio I nlon I 'a ' llic Hailf.iad and Credit Mobil,
lev both, mj endttui tint lu'loinilnrf lo either
I ntllpnilV.
y.- I ,. whom did ho pa) Ihe debt Incurred In
tlio work afler II. n trurucrs us-ui.t 1 '.letmin.
iii'i nient ? A. (letter .It) lo the creditor ot tlio
II ilroud Coin pauv, the h.ddi I of I., oik hi
y. 1 1 "tu w i out did l.o iu.. i. utile ."ecuilti'
which ho Hut sold ami applied the
proceeiHr A. lie iniiierally recoiled them fiom
Cie limp of thol'ndil .iloi.tll. t mill the I' uh.it
1 ticlHc l.i Ir. .id Company. 'Ihe) wero both 111
the -ame room. ..ti 1 tin iu wo no ,KI-I:i lu Iho
liiaii .elin iit of lin lr biislne n far n tlio
n lilh c)! ...uid mo or mi) Individual tloln;
busiii.' -u w nh tliem.
Another llniiils.oiie III blend.
0- Cua ' ,. n "f Ciedlt Mobllier sio. k you
rec'liml as iiu ilend I. no sh n .l I l, ton pa
eliii' Utibioau it. ch , a. t e. sir, t ibiuK o,
y. I he p. Ice ol ihi i tuilroad lock w.tn rr Hit..
(KK iu il oi' he t ied I M. billet .st,Ur.'. A. , , .
y-Wbal wk Hie net mil market value In April,
IN ., of the I'm. ut .'.ul'ic Il.illru.id stock? A.
A ... I Kl" per shun uiaiiit lupei coiit.-porluii,
not it, at leiieh
i.i. Vi hatwa' Its mir,-.t valuo In July, isnd ?
A. .,.t tun i It, tl imi, mi ie.
y.-lu S , tin... , i r r A. About Hie name.
y. lu Uu.emb. r? A. .lb n. i tnch.uiirle
fore the I is' dlildin.l of I-ul ; lilt, r tlial it io
pi... laleil -. uiio.
Dili jou, or any on., for ynti, lmi receipts
lor tho ildei'il mttilA In lusi i A. I think
en, an. ('ratio, I think, wa lite ninn In it hum I
i". e.pted. 1 think I f.celjit.d lor eieoihliic
i ra.cly eier lead u receipt fslifiied.
(.'.- V il did then sl.'u reeeipia for the divi
dend mud., duiini.' pj.,8? A.- I think so. air.
That I my reeolloeilon.
. Who p.iul or dellverod loyoit tho money
or seeuritlCM ivlueli coneiiinted those UiilUfiiUaf
A.-Mr. l.'nuio.
O Vim have said tlint Ic the nut turn of li7
f r. ( riino, who had been treustirer d Hie Credit
Moblller, w.i supiTseded by Mr. Iliiud? A.
i es, air.
y.-What oftlco In the Credit Moblller did Mr.
Ciuno h.dd lu it, A Not tui) tlint I know of.
y.-lou huvo atdd that In Juno, 1N, uu r.
ii J-l
elvcil a ca.ih tllvIJcuU of 00 per ccnt.f A.-I
did.
'. 1)1-1 you not In Hen of that rnsh receive.
$51,01)0 In botulsof Ihn I'nlnn i'aciac llallronil
Conipaiiy? A. I don't think X did. I think I
sot It in a click ( ti the bank. ....
y. You bate sMtetl theo fact relative to
tlir-.i illiidcml. from n memoiaiiiluui tuadu by
yntir j-lcrk irotn your own bjeka, hate you not
y. Doe not Hint nicmornmluui rend (V) ncr
i out cttli on jjUaUatc, fil.uJJ boi.dw A. es,
that toniUBu.
Whnt ho Dono with Ihn .11 tier.
y. llxplaln what that margin or carr)liiit out
Into hnmjh mean I A.-II means of cour.e tlio
nt. me). I ill-Hi, etly remomber to liaio (lol'eu
n 'beck on the bank for thl dividend nod
think It not unlikely Hint I bomrlit b. ltd to that
etli nt from t,.e company, and k'avo my own
diet k for thai .iiuouut. If this I mil so 1 will
notlf) mui.
y. iVh it .in the mnrket vnltle In Hie open
mark' f nt lhat time of I'niott I'nelflo bomlsi
A. I In y ni re aboie l.nr IS to 'i per cent. I
tl.iii', lue.mup.uiy offered mo Ihn ill otint or
a. mu Illd' icement u spend tho nit.uoy iu tho
purclimo ol bond.
(,'. It was on the .Til of March, IrWrt, that, von
snl. 'crib cd for IVsl share of Hie Credit Moblller
Block for 11. (I. Kant? A.- Ye, lr.
y. on drew n draft mi l'titit fur tho sub
scription ("".'.."io y A. I old.
y - WIihii did ).,ti fir I I. now that ralilhad re
fusi'il to uc.'epl or pu) that iliaft? A. I tbi.ik In
May,
I y. Who told )oit of tint fact' A.-I think
Fun f Icli'ifniphnil tne. and ('nine, tho AiItuni
Ttetisurer, adil-ed mo about the name time.
0. Wits Crniio' cominiinlcallon teil.nl nr
, writ ten ' A. Verbal. I think. I wa fieqiunlly
. In Now York and In tho ollb-e
y.- What did lie say when lie eonimiin'ente.l
the fact ? A.- lln wanted tno to pa, my draff
, for the stock, and coiuratiilate l tlio comnany
and hlni-elf that ho l.al mv ilmft u n rant In
ti"id of hi own n Al"ttit Treasurer, u ho
e.iid he k'e iv my draft wuuld be ).-ild.
y. What wa the itflt" of this communica
tion? A. About the tnlddlo nf Muv.
y.-Whenw.n tho dr ft presented to rant?
A.- Not until call) In Ma), 1 think.
y.-ilniey it ever f.ild that draft? A.-N'oj 1
hue neier paid It, but I bale lend, red il.
, y. - when id. I ou tender It? A.- (Jn tho I1.'.!
day .f Mai, In.).
(J. To v Ie .in? A.-Mr. Crme.
t).- Whnt In? A.-Cerlilled check,
(j. Wa the inoney leftiscd? A. Ve;ltwa
nckiionlcdi:.-.! to bo u kouiI tendor, but tho
power of attorney of l.int wa not liht.
t y - At the Huio of thu tunder did )ou rcqulro
nnv.hiiik' to be done u a cundltlou for your uy
Itulhe money? A. Iteiulrud tho stock to bu
, truisfefred to me.
y. Did Mr. Cr ino sny hn could not iilve tho
Mock I A.- I did not .end! r tlio money peraun
ally, but through mi iu:eiit.
i y. -Did )ou Instruct ) ..ur ncent to r.'ii'lrntho
' stock i.ii puymetit of tnone) ? A. I did, he
cause that w.u tuo ustoiii.tr) wuv.
y. -How ninny shnr-" had mm then In the
company? A. - l'tto hun.lteil sli.ins perhaps
more.
c.-IIow inmiy share had then been lucd
wt .oi )oti iiiade thi lilidel .' A. About $1,'.M),
; Hi,- Iv.tMl shsi j about.
. (,'. At what lime we-e all the -Inn Issued,
nm .iicluditi'i Ihe no per coin. Ihn In. nasfil i-ap-I
lial ttiailo ut a sub'e.ileut date A. -I luu't bo
1 exact n to date.
I Illd. 11 Wlllll TH.) VI IMC.
(). After Mm. IMA. w i tho eotnpiny sollrlt
IliK new o- n.blliloiisl sulis -rib, r lo llietr stock I
i ,. Not that I know of - u t neiv ub '.Tiber.
1 y.- In May. I-I, w hat ve n the solllnu price of
tint stock lu the lien k t I . - I dotl't klloiv of
I imysil-.! i lto. Ie.- ,, it i.i M.v. I. l.
y. - lia l it ai inar..et ,ti. e d ir.iiit lM? A.
.
(,. Olve the pi lee? A. -It wa worth over
par. 1 sold port i. ui of my -lock, wltli It Be
rn'! on, il .r to .1" in I,. Klini of Sprln Held,
Ma- , i pe. lint: to be reimbursed by tho trans
it r to in.' "f this I'm t tm-k.
(.'.- '.Mien? A.-poin.i llnio In tho rummer of
thit)i.ir. Tl. . I would not hate dotiu but for
the I toinl-e nl relmnorseiiient, and because Mr.
Klin: wa my tier-on il friend and expressed ci.ii.
i sbler.ible aiixiely to net s.uu.. ..f the stock I hail
1 taken for l-'niit. which w.t protnl-ed to I jiteti
; to mo by the President ami Asliant tecrelaiy
of Hie company.
y. When the 5fl per cent. Inererjin ofrnpll.il
wn re,. bed on, what botiu wa otlere.t and
. paid to tho.' w lm wo uid takelt? A. Iho pa.-il-s
In lnten't. Hi. . tnmn.'iiin people In tho
C -e.llt Moi.tller. pnipoe.l an Inerease of Cn (lit
Mooiller i tork. tliat nhotibl come to the liolde. l
thereof In the form of a dividend. Tocarrvout
t'.l Hie i, Mr. C. Iiamhert propoed to give to
' the-t.'.-kl' 'liters of th" Credit Moblller li J l.o D
t I'lilon l'u. Iflc lint mortcur bond for every ti n
I shure of t..ck subscribed for up to fsl r cent.
I i t esclt linhler' lnieret In thu stork of Ht.it
compntiv. A cno. tunny nf the -Inikllolileri
takuu Hit dlildeml III thi form kept their
I iH.nd and .ld the toel at pal, making neaily
tlio r hole bond as protlt.
I y.- Did )nu take your jOpereenl.? A. I took
wliHt wa-allotted lo me nn the rtoek reirl-terd
In mv nam,' nl the time. Tin whole In mo
hnd been t'ladu In my nbetice ami wlih.uii my
knowledge, and nhli the fact w.i itoiclopcd lo
' me It was bv ihe A l-t ml lien-iir. r. Ih tiry t'.
' Crane. li'Minlou to tu a pa. kru.-e with the boitdn
' nut -t ek-. w ull h wu nut examined by tne mull
I ntterit lind been returned to tnyhuine unit en
l tend Into my honk by my seeretar). It wan
then Hist I reuteitibered my ott-etpn (ed wish
to et my ntleincnt of Ihe Kant stock, a 1 w.u
cutl' led. ami n hud been a-ieed tiin by the
I ollleersi.f the coiii.anv with me.
I y. Tld. Iheti, was while Crane was AsUttit
I Tieitsiiri-r of the com) any, ami before the au
tumn of P-17? A.- Yes. -nr.
y. Did t.ni enter Hi.--.' bond iu voitr books
v hen ic. ear. I r A. -I think my eierk did.
Wmita In Pee Ihe llueks.
Mr. MeMiirtrie called for b.ik eotitalnlni; en
try of the 'e bniid
The witness will produce book at next tneet
, Inc.
1, ' C.i:t y nt ny whether the tlfty r cent, of
I the lioinK recehed Anrll I. IMT7, sunken of by
I ton In )nur "xainlnatl.in In cnlef wire Hum)
I, "lid A - 1 eii'iuot, but I think they wore,
for I liaie treated them as a dltliUnd.
I y --Nuiiioallucrsousthatt .il say von know
1 kei t ihn In. ml Ihu alb. tied and sold thul:
i slock ut hour 1 1 par.' A.-C. M. Ilushnell sold f.u
himself ami Durant. nml 1 think scleral othcrt,
wln-e name I will give jou hereafler.
Adjourned to tneel iiikhi nntlcc.
Mtttttw ixt. ai, li!.
Mot In pursuance of notlre.
I'n unit James K. How en nml S. J. Thnnip
son, i;.iir of ci.iitnel for cotnpltlnnnt , II. s.
MrCouihe, complainant, and It, C. McMurtrle,
li-q . f. r d.-femlatit.
Cros-exainlii.itlon nf II. 8. Midmbc by Mr.
M. Mui trie continued .
Thnt' the ((nesltnn.
y. Who cot the ftoek you say b"lnnjed to
you under the Kant subscription? A. leant
tell juil posltliely ai to who cot tho Identical
sto. k.
y. -I mean to whom w-tusthestnekliicdbyllii.
rorporitlon? A. -When the K.tnt subscription
wo made there was a cre it abundance of stock
to bo ulspo.'d of, that I, a crcat abundance uf
stoi k muter tho control of the comp iny. When
I wa ohlhicd to take lentil prorccdliiK to have
ni) tlht re. ncnlzed liy the then controller of
tho corpnrnti 'ii Iho stock of the Credit Moblller
niiioi.ntlnc to i,1,7VI,O0 hail been t'.'sposed of to
other panic, without my l.m.wli dje. to within
to I or .sO share of that amount ut capital. Ihe
slot k duo to tne me iimlertlie Kant sub-u-rlpM ui
not haiittc been Issued to tue, there wa not a
siifth'ii'tit iriioiuit left to make good my clulin,
without In, iiidlnc Hie stock to (lake Ame-.
Trustee, it lib Ii was ubout belnc dono under my
protest.
y. Do I understand you to say that the stonli
winch y.ui were colli led t . recetie iindor the
1 alio ubcrti thin w.i Imici by tlte company to
somebody? A. -It had not been Issued when
I tu claim iva niadi umler lea.il prnceedlnc in
stltuted June in, p-iih, in New Vork, which were
I stopped liy an imrceinent for a reference by mu
tual rnnicnt to, I think, Oilier Atne. .1. an
Dull and 'ihomas C. Ditrnut, unless some 'M
thare had been luod to Hake Ames.
(.- Has thu stock )ou iltltn ever been lsue.
yi in.-. iit.ipnii) luiiii) uuu r .v.-jiy unucrsiaiiu
Ine I that ll Ii ix.
y. To whom? A.-Soineot the offlcer tahl
It wn lo Atne, and tome to other parties.
y. Who n!d It was Issued to Ames? A.--Slr.
Alley -n d so.
(. Who were Hie eMicr It wn raid to bo
Issued to? A No nr.ii.es civ. n.
(,'. Who sahl till- A. All-v. 1 don't re.
member anv other. Ho said soinetlin . Hie nno
uud si it'.iet 1 me the oilier. At first llc siod It
wal-iied to Ames, and tlie.i altertvu'il, w lieu
we not Into Hie lltlcall'in lu re, lie aid It laid
been Is-ited to Ames with my 'on ent. Afur
he first said that it hail been l -icd to (i.i(.
Auich ho told ine It had been bailed to othir
pailie.
Ame Winn ii Ciiiriimlnii run. I.
y. H.ve smi eior asre.-tulneU to whom tho
lock vmi lulni w.t I-iifil - A. Mi tiOakiH
Ames, tlirouitli Alley end Siilnov Dillon, nt u
inietltu: or the trul0H presented u nuper lo
ine for u.y l tiatuiii as n stockholder ill thu
( fill Mobllier to nllow Ame to take -JM shine
..' ihe eapl'ul slock of V Credit Moblller fur o
I u I which at the time of imklirj f r n.y s c-
na mio was not cxiiiaiiied. .ut'y ho bu-n to v
tbul ll wonl 1 lio bleed by Hake .Vine In a w iv
(o beitellt tin. Ci'tiitmny, I refused iK.remploiilv
to Hhtn tho paper ciiili I had itouooi. r utv da tt
for tho Kant stock for about the one huudr mtii
lliiiii, niid re. elicd f.om "-Idli 'y Dillon. Jolin 11.
AI.ey, ijuko-Ames, Jo.hdi llmlwell, nod lien-Jt-niin
I. Ilatei Iho uiir,ineo th it iilhmuu this
el. ok j.. vti t,i Ainu :ioii,d imi in nny wav
luej iillce my 1 1 i.n but lb ii tin stork ahoiild
be 1,'iuin. d io i,i- ,r 11. ore iua not , 'uuii.u I It
to ui .1 my claim .-...oil. After thl i phid. tho i
mid theti. Kli. n to mo, I s'liiciI tho paper. Mr.
Ddlnti had nut nt that Huio U;n. d the paper
iiuil pnsliitel) .ol-soa to tiyii until 1 luul dino
It nr Utfrecd to do it.
('nun. I biriiuiiplnlniint nsk rounx l forile
fondant'' to proiluc' ho oriirlual p hut.
(.' lloiv mail) slum's of Credit Moblller stock
remained nniu.;d neu tu,. piper w t si ;ned ?
iit'oks '""""t f"r ' " l" "'0
(,- Did you liiiiilri'? A Yes.
-..Tut tEKcSl'All. A'Mi uw Bcmlon,cn ,,rc-
They Would .MuUe ll All Itltht.
,,?.'To'"ltlmV",ul.l"l,.,ll'. 'u" ""'lv on tho
H it rw.oir.rt i ii1 ril':,u"1 H'K. "'h.tinailou, Hut
If It ri milred tho return of Atnea s stock initio
should bo undo uuud. mid that mitlnlleU uie- In
other wotUb tlint they would u.ako gootl tny oo
oount. Q. -riien was thl.? A. T can't fix the date,
other than It was tlio day I Hcneil that paper.
y.- In tvhnt )ear wn that paper sliiicd I A.
f don't tctnember tho yctir. I think It wn In
ii77 or 1". 1 relied upon tho paper lo fix tlio
1 y. ' Wan It before or after tho Increjso of capi
tal on which ti) per cent, bom' were reeeiied?
A I think It wa tnibsciiteiit to that time, but,
a before aid. I relied upon Hie p iper nml tlio
correlative fact to nmko plain tin dale.
y If the paper contain no il do, what nre llm
eonelatlvo f ict to wlileli you can now refer n
fixlnir the d.tio? A. - Thu Issue uf Iho atoik lu
oaks Amu trustee. ... . ,. ,
y. -Wan H.I paper slened boforo tho divi
dend mad.' In I.-. wero declared nml peld ?
A. Yon, II wn befuie sumo of them, but befuro
wltlclilcirtt.il.
y Nsino nnvntie or more of tho dividend
mnde In INW Hint w. re paid afler Hint naper w.i
-h'lird' A. I think tin' Hi" diil.lenili nlier
Kebriinry and perh-tp th.. o of Jtm.iary iiml
i'. l.ril it -v I. '.I t' d b en n ui.
y.-l)ld vol" during l i' '.v nny dividend
on thoaeli'Kl lit 'e u- the C". I "h- prnportloti
of Hi-' inei.M o. .'.'ft...
tVbn !..' Ihe Dill ' ' , .
Q.-To wlioiu weie the .lb i. .1 oil tlm'o T, i
eharo paid? A.-I prelum, to Oaken or his
leprcentallvi a i trustee.
y. -When )o'i lectin d tl." .Ilv'.letid. that
wero rnldyoiiln lrW'l.Mdi ei lin.nire who wn
t--.Ht liu; Iho illv.deii'l't on those I, .a rliums, or any
of llioill? A.- e, air. 1 did.
y.-Wlu.iii from ? A.-D. I'. Hand, As.dstnnt
Treie.iirer Crrdlt Moblller.
y. -Wltiit did ho tell you? A Oaken Atne
wn I'cillni them, nml I think a mnu ntmod
Kent "tb , to wh m AtiuMli id trunf.jiied totiiii
of the t-lo, k us trustee. That 1-1 wn.t Hand told
tun.
y. Wltnt elfort did loti t lie it in.tko to cet the
st. k nr dividend ? A. Ile,ntt lecnl proceed
In:: In I'rnnMlviinl.-i- that I the on sent suit. I
bixati procoedlmf III New York by retaining
conn. el, S. I.. II. Harlow, T. M. Ilamr , ami
let. ml. ih P. Hind; of I'enn-i Ivnnl.-t. I think I did
not actimllv Issiio n writ then', n tny counsel
h id ntlii-ed luo to cotnineiic.. proreedlliR" In
l'cntiaylvntd.i.Hiey bnvlticexhuiMtod itllromi'dlu
for an amicable settlement.
( Y"it hate snld Hint li pwviyou received cer
ium h in' of the Colon I'uc, lb- Unllroad stoi tr,
nml that ' here wa n tlivldcnd .f thei redit Mo
blller. D d urn ub" a receipt for tliem A.
Ib u't renii"i.i"T ; think I did to tho Alaiaut
Tieiiauret . i . Crane.
y. Uid) i peyunytlilnc fnrthat ..took? A.
N'u, lr, tif t" my recollection.
y. I Hi. nk ) .u said thnstock at tint time tvni
about ID pn t ? A. Ve, I think I did.
y.- Wa' ii"t that stock tranferrcd to you nnil
otht. stoi khol.ler ut7l ? A. -Yrs.that Wat tho
cab illation 'nidoon the book, but no money
was paid by tho stoclihuldir. I paid nuthln
fur it, I know.
(). What booki do vou refer to? A. Tlio
hook on which tlte stock wn reck .nod at 71. I
utter nw any book entrlo.i of it :.t all.
y.-lt wa after thl tlte capital of tho Credit
Moblller wna Increased -I mean Hie Incrcnxo
tvlih.li you tookorot In April, Ist)7, beinctbo
smi o for which tho fitly per cent, bond wero
r'len.wu It nut? A. l es, Iftlieiniestlon refer
lo what you bavo snld In icferetno to tho llrst
Ulildends In lPud.
y. What wa the nh'ert of Hint lnereao of
stock or the Credit Moblller? A.-Not heini;
consulted by tlio psttlei who inrulo It, I cannot
nnwer wlint the itiuilio wn. It wn. ail dono
without my ki.imluuco until after it h id been
pet foiled.
y. Wa not the HV per cent, fur Interest ac
cruing to you before, paynblo In Jauuarv. ImI',
tiald lo eip.allre stibscrloet to thl stock lor tho
I IneioassU tock for Ihe different tune tltcy had
i paid in their siihcrl.tln.i ? A. That was the .
pretex. It wa (o evi.du a dlililcn.1. So stated
to me i.y Mr. John II. Alle) nt tho tint. . ,
y. Wa bo then a it ho. tor or oill.er of tho
I'.id.i Mobllier? A.-Yi. he wn one of IL"
. 1 teeutlie CoiittulC.eo. He wa chief iun on
. mat cnmniltti ..
1 y.--Vlil.-b officer of Ihe cointinnv told ynti
I thnt this wan the oo.t've fur iiisklriK th l pa.-
mint? A.-I can't recollect any one ii o but
I Mr Alley.
I y. l.'l.o ei-e? A.-I Uni.k John Hand, tho
Altanl Tp'i-iirer. I wn bavlnc triiu"iimls-
I eus-loti with Mr. aIIot on tbio suiijeel. and
1 tho freiiueiiey of thl precluded any luutleular
I Ideniltl. alloii a tn tunes, and Identification if
nirii ns ns-oclated with an ollkl.d c;,iucliy lu
llm com pan).
I y,-In your examination In chief you sny that
the .175 r nil,' weie put umler thu c.ntnil of
(lake Ame. and that ho nam I lie into nietiiliiri
of ('.uurr-.-. Where d,. vou obtain )our liifornia-
tliinlomakoth.it aacnioii? A. Fiom Oakei
I Ames.
I y.-Vorballrnr In writing? A.-Ilutli.
I Cnniln in (lie Palm,
y. Have you the prtpcr here? A. I have not,
hut cm produce It.
I y. -You asserted n' the l.is( meetlns tint you
I hntt Mich n paper and would produce It. A. I
I did.
y.- Why do you n"t produce It ? A.-lleewif e
I thoiicht the nicetiti' on W edursiiuy iustcntl uf
' 'Jhurd iy.
(. Do vmi menn by citlnc. tint the-o fhnrca
I wire clft In Hie m;ure of pre-nt-': A. -I do.
' (,.- Vmi until rtnnd, then, r. Ame tu tnenn
that II..'.' hal ,'k si'is t.i li. t.re-enteil wlthuttt
. value paid to in. int.. r- of c.nuii -; A I un
derstood from Mr. Oaken Ainet limy tvereau'v.
. atatithilly u cllb Hie panic lo whom the stock
. wu -old to be npproprlaied rerelilnc tltroiich
' him u their triMteo more tiinn sut'.ictent avail
' nblor."et a dlildeml to pav tor tho same. I
I and lhat he, out of their asset, paid Into tt.u ,
Trea-niry tho imr value. d the stock.
y. Do you iiieHii to ruy that Hi iernnhnd
not prut..iily aurred to riibseiile t .rthestoil. .
a ot tier bad done? A. I had im t.ilu.-tualloii
on li.tit piilut.
y.-Did y.ui understand Mr. Ame to mnn I
that tliesu person were not iiititicd to tin- e
' slum' as sitbsi rib, r or persoiu. w h" had -ur. ed
;tiisubeii. i A. I ui.der-t'."d no siii-b tbiiic. I
l y. Did you iitidrrst.mil fiom Mr. Aiiioj what
I wa the in. nl o tor allow, nc the o p '.nn a.
t.ke thl stock at par wh.-ii It wa so .tu,thb i
Hint part of the dir. den Is utliivd lo pit. tne par
villi"? A. Tin mollis. undi ttoo.t. wa to
; ru-eiire the liiiliience and sittipoit in enures
I o the turn to w l. on the -to. k wa elicit.
if. -ll, tlueiue nml support fur what? A. I'or !
1 at )Xhlnc uilectlHir the L'lilun l'aclile Hallruad I
Company In I'tncres.
y. Whenweio these verbal commuuleutl'int,
ch a )ou halo mentioned, made to you r A.
pun-e.neiil tu Iho sli-nliu; of tho paper kcruto
fon referred to.
y. How tnnir after? A.-I can't remomticr,
as l met It i i:i n number of times In Now York .it
Ihe e tiip.ni) ' oilicc, where ho mado statiiuciit-i
similar to this .t number of limes.
y. t any oilier plseo Iban the roinpany'a
onlr ? A. -Ye. In Wblnctiui.
y. WUeie In Washington r A. -In tho Capitol.
.... Coilldu'l lln Anttli'm;.
Q.- Wlnt step did )oit lake to pretvnt sued
act n you say he pnipoed tf do Willi thl
stock? A.-I took n" step, feellnr myself
powerless, a ho and hi fncnd (it that time
ru.ed auprctnely the a Hal is of tho Credit Mubi
ller. (,'. Vou sthl nit the flr-t day ) mi wero exam
ined Hint )"n iiticrnl and were ready tn pay
Cr. me I r this stork, uud wero onli preientoil by
hi not belnu able lo uic "u a i ertltl. ato. I
1 tl.lso? A. -'Iho statement, at you make lt.lt
not in curate. 1 said elii n t.io uione) wu pro.
dii.'ed to Mr. Crane, ho ncknowledccd for Ilia
Payment nf thl slock, but declined tn trnnfer
be. aiiseMr. Kant' power of attorney wa not
n proper one, ho iMr. Crane) on that day tlllliiif
up a new-power of attorney fur Mr. Kant' siji-
l tituie, piiunlslni; to deliver tho rertitlcnie.
When thu new power wa returned to htiti duiy
signed, mid the money, and when by tne sub,,
ipientlynfleied to hlinwltn th" tnonev.the 1'ies.
blent had pone Wed, unit left no ceitlUcule
s.giied I.) him.
y. us tt because ton could not art a cr'lfi.
ate for the shun that too declined pa) Inline
liiotlt.y? A.- I'liiit w.t the o . uui d cnii-e.
y. What wn the n-al ci.ioe? A.- Mr. Alley
nml Mr Ante had m.i I.- me iieileie tint Dura. it
wa unly a tldef, and Hist nil tho money ho got
hold or lie would inKniprnprlutc. Thatnindo
j toe helliite about ileilienii r my power of at
torney nml monev without haling tuy oertldcate
duly attthuuticu.ed.
, , , Durant All Ittshl.
It Is due to Mr. Durant here to av that thu
statement of All. y ami Ames with n fe.eii, e to
misappl.c itlon ol IuiiiIh wn. Hiibi4...nlly ex
nimne.l ti l" b) a .'"iiiinlttee nf w ilcn 1 ivn one,
und it w.u found thai theie t.itoinouta iviro
oiet ve hi re false.
y. -Am I i ..ric. t, then, that your objection to
itctunlly (i.i) inn In Hie uione) wa tin want .., a
i "tttllcntu lor Hie aiiai-o and tlio-,.. Injuriou
sttetiieiii BiMinst Mr. Durant' ciioraciorr A.
t cs, uitiini) mi.
!.- Male "iv other ftct or reauin for not pav
liu the so .ripllon b.r tin so ,.aro.i i A.-'l
rcolloet ii . . tin, r.
y. Aft. r I. n Dlrectora and other utU-iera of
the Credit M miller were ehiinu d In ll.e .pring
oflsu7, st.te when and lo wh on the nt appli
cation wa iil i'l" by you for liieae sb'ir l A -It
wua llladc io cncli uue of llio l.'ie. uilvc Coin,
milieu, w n, eii c,in-,i-ted of Shine) lillhui, I'rcal
ib nt of the ('oiiii..iny..lnhn II. Alley, and llo.and
II. U.U.U-.I. I can 1 reiri'inlN-r the exail tl'itin,
but ver) oon uf.er tlioy beeuiuo oftieer of tuo
COIIlpO 1).
y. 1 e It prior to the 'nerau.te nf stork on
wine., i o tut i per taut. bond., won Ktvoiii' A.
I . tut i t. nn iiibnrthe pat'lcnlu- lime.
y. Did )ou lorn teudrr thu A,,isi'i aiilmrrlp.
lion? A.-i lonJeied tWXxl iu l uuod .-;.i i
lej 1 lender j that was to cover Hie lie mute
tuid liitiTc.i.
y. l.'iin ) ut explain who of tho com ii.uiy were
cbiuc.iel.u.10 I in. in I'.i dl.' limit.. ad b'n.l to
eve y man who wo .1,1 take leu h uv ol uiuk
mid pay tlio partaluor llie-e hum refused to
CH" ion Ihese slnlll at par wl.hoiit am MiU'll
botiu nrauUitbut A. Iil-noiti e tliu Iheao
s uii-cs would n.it liau, i.irri.'tl tho boi,u..ind
liu uddlllon. They should huio curried Ih.'
h.illr.ild tillotllieilU of slock pr vlullsl) luode,
und tlmt i- tuo icatnn, ibiu!., wh) th, would
nut lot nm have tne ioc. uud tuku my money.
y. . in huio Ilu. dlvbb.iid that had been
preilou., mado? A. Not n uv belitK able to
Ui the prect..u date uf this Ut tender, I 'annul
i:.tu the Uiildend that had buuil pro.iuiul)
inailc. ' '
y. Had tiny nf the dltidoml paid lu ItsVi been
M-alhdr A. -1 caniiot now teiuoiiibei, fo,- Ihu
reason cliou In the piuvious ittiswir.
"'"I tlio Aiiiuii comiai't luiiili made? A.-I
think so, but of tin I am nut p .inu.,
Adjourned to ineel on Tucmlat, tho id day of
Juuuajy, utdj'. M. '
. .V'(fn, .if.ttfSl, IfC!.
Mot In punuiauce uf uulicw, 'i'htru wore pwur .
- - - -r-i
ent at tho meetlnc Pntnucl O. Thompson and
Jaoie I.. Ooweii, I,i., for the complainant,
at'. I ltd hard C. MuMurtiie, Eii lur tho defend
at I.
Mr. MeCouib fnllin to nppcar, ndjoitrned to
i' eet upon notice.
Mctltno, June 9.
Met In piirsuatieo of nottco. I'reent, fur eoni
plilnnnt, H. O. Thompson and Tliom.n Hart,
Jr., Hsu.; mui for dulelidants, Ulc.hordC.Mj.
Mu.-ttle. I-iar . . .
Cross-eMiiitlnallon of Col, McCoinh by Mr,
McMurtrle.
i:nliilnlmr llie Honk,
Q. T umlCMtiitid the en'rle on pace I'M ot
your book r ill id IOdcer tiro the cnlrle from a
copy of w ith h you spol e whn Vou cave thu
st dement uf Hi" illildend )oit Iiad r. . Uc
A. - I belii'ti' s .. II i i.tii I neier huvo esatulii d
them III comparison w It h the p in 'r.
(J, Thr entry nt the toll of that pvo. I in
fer, I a stnlcnetit in regard lo y...ir ttlii el ,t I m
to the Cnloti I'.u Ifio H i lio.nlatoi i. A. I.'-eit
understand ant ftirh thine.
(J.-State, IT to i pie".', ivtft H'-it ne-oimt re.
fero? A. I do not knoa. 1 in ter ha'," ,. ..
nuillii i) Hu "' lio'ia-'.
Coniiel lor e . u.d .In ml !!, 't to nny . ; i .'.
nation wlileli Ivl ite hi nny n count nr ni I ,s
oth. r than th ,i) hi -he it.itoinout refer.c.l ti
by Mr. McComli.
(,'.- I he nerotiiit I lieadul I'nlnn 1'nelP H ill.
rond Coiiip.iiiv'a stock Dr., .Inn. I, lHflit, t . 'i,
pnld Hept. at.lsM. r.-r 1 pT r?nt of my '.ti "na
tion. What sub i.p'loti do )ou suppo ,e
refer J to?
Comi lalnniit' cunn. 1 ol.Je I.
A. I'but refers lu tho a ilw. riptloii tin,!.. i,
tne to Hie CnintiilMpiiieM named in the oh nor
Wanton by ('.lucre, for my oi i 'lii.l sn' , ..
Hon to the Cnlon l'aelllc llalll a I Ci in; I;,,
Tho oopy of Hie pace IKI, with loo unti ,, . I.
ludod to therein, is a loll uv :
UNI'lV PAOIHC iEAib'.OAll CoMl'A vV-' U ' If.
tin.
lv-,.
April t3..To8Mhire stn,-ke, If (lit .tlv'.i
l.yi r. leS. ,.f abiuI n.atfl '). f ?. 1 1, (t
.Inly ..Tn wt.' sures Hues ictf oiii.vd
h r. tun. oi Aim n. v. m ni. ; i
Sept, 53.. Tn tn sluno unci r. til .Kl mv'd
by I r. ll.l. ut Atiiericii nt II'". ., C
Dec. M..T.I .vniM i.iuc.'i urn's iii .nil
.l.t .1 lo ( r. Mull, uf Ajicti a)
at JUJ 6t .. il
Tutsi til ifiui
IK?.
Jin. I..Tobaktneel,07Stbsretock at tt'W timjkv t
lau. ' 4. .To cr. MnMHi-r illv'd, IV) slurct
tuik a'ti'l (ten j)
.tan, I. .To I r. Moi.lll. r clbM, l Hurts
, . ituckst tmeii.,,. ,ti)(yj
Feb. J..To (.r. M.iMller .llv'.i, i rlnrra
. ateclcsttltD.Kli , S,:X)10
Feb. 8..T1. Cr, "li.t.UKr .ht'd, is stiirea
ittKkstllJMiEitl 4A)N
June 17.. To 1 r. M.u.dler it'.v'd, 3d) sl.src
ttoi't at IU) 511 Sl.eO r,j
July 3.. To cr. sloMllsr ilwM, UT!!( aluirct
atuc't at JtuJ isub i.',r-ij
Total fo... Mil
Cl.
wa
rept. iw.. liy Jul.n S. niic, !3 tlmres liana-
fenv.i tirrff I. ll ti '! 01
Uy l.sk.ULe csrre J dou, l,uia
sharis atu.k 1' i.'W
Tolal ."lll'VrOM
On ftge IM t.'c fllowlnjt (Jn lead peitell 1
Tn Cr. Mob'r uit f "'
(WtihrirM by i nnsi.
fept.n,'-l)ii'dlti,.ri 111. -on.
Imc. I idt M Mi p. e ceoi .. l.'.iW.
.Mr. Jlc.M.trttlo fir a to ptge ;5I of bW. anl
a)-; "I Hint now to urt iffil.and i enpy ol
tkut la a follows. Thai ptrtuf puol adai t
tud Is as lullows :"
lm. li..:ill MuULIF.n nf WfFI'ICA.
1
1'eb. 7. .To tibui-ica (rrksincd
f rum ..1 ji . . . .. ..fti,tt80t
l ed. tt .T.i . .- mi ' r lu II. ( .
1 . iu-. iic-uiir sit rs tmis vQ
Mar. ?n. .To alsee,t ilu aiwr ae.
ii. .11 .a ip-s.ui r . ... 39! M
Msr. !fi. .T.. . ' .'!.'. 1, lr' '. .. 1,'U'D
I.' sr. w..fii"r.'i 11 isKi ..( ucM.
isv-i ui CO- . . ;
1M I""' ' ( .i
I'eo. ' 1J..T0 ftpsese frttlng teslivltlre on
cro iit "ti.unl. p
Dlh, !.'., ; 1 I1.7..I1 llth, I. Wi 1 Il(i,2.il
lh..l',llh,.UtlWS, lllal,.9t
., t ll.l,l.Wi viu, .U. r.ta. I.'.u 13 "t
fit). lS..Turri-ck i.ii i sraittra', Hotel hill, Ac, )
Witlnnti.n Mb)
tee. ir,,.Tu can 1.11 .urlli Aiueri. u, ll'JUi
1 ash. 15) ...... i-vt
tab. H..T. ro.li-ixpeus-l lu I'Mialitlpkla,
.Ae :i in
var. 3..1oe-h-esp. u.- tu New Y'.r .. .. Kjoj
Kar. 3..10 cash pu.a Juiljzu J.o. buuil, lur
vpiillUU 1"0)
ru luUI lrtT
1
Ke. '?3..ny Crmtlt Moblller uf Amrrlrw sto-k
--cn. NO.M.'.HU shuns; (tr. N'u.1,
HOstiap i.U laiui,., tit) S'.'ICJ
Lej-t. 34.. II) 1 re.nt Mukt.ler it America stock
i sYires. 1 1.11 5.00(11
j.u.si.ieUiisu
TutJl ti. i-TTJ
Tiaaf, rr U to page 311 Il.-mji
y.-Tho en'rle nf pngefiuiff (hit bc.nk. )i,u
SB), refer to wltut lr..ti-a. Holt. I oii;ii:..i...,nf
cutiuiel ooJvcU.J A. 'iliuy reler lo.n."ral
tratianetloii.
y. With whom? A. They look like transac
tion with tho Lulon 1'i.ol.K Uuilr.wd Cou.fUuy.
line book sirtts lo sliuw tiuti-.u lluu lm n.ai.t
of in -in. y, ixpensKs. uiatciiiil 1 aiii.pn, I th.)
I nl'.n P.ulllit luiir.k.d (..unnnnv, b.uliit no
beurlnir tttuituver upon thu subjucl at .0 lu
tins c -e.
y. 1 urn now to the Hrst ent rv In tour book
lu teltitiun to the Credit Muidilcr of A'ni.-r.cii. I
wua.t a top) 01 thai pane il.. iin.du I.) ,l.e 1U
umlner. A. Vou can mite It.
y. -('.in I lo..'; at It A. Vo'tcan.
Mr. Al Comb h,ru band Mr. McMurtr e tlia 1
In ok fl, 1 red to. The loll., lull" I a . .,) of
page Hi), al... to icfrru'd to.
II. fUl.DIT MUUll.tl.lt OF AMKIUCt
I ol.
ill.. 73. Tn ( r. il. Jtoh. of Am. f. r t o aUres
no V at tl'O f.'tt cl
fept. SS..Tu 1 nil. Muti of Aui. tur .i,re. ,
1,7.
April 1. To ra.h paid tor VSJiharts stork st
1 2SrtH 10
r.,. r. O.nkua7'slwre.tockatr.sr....t.5,liliu
Dec t7..Cni'h 1 all lint. II. Msi-y .t iimu'i 1'.
I, iuarr U Uo.i ru (tuire stuck ut
lAVsudiuurul !f,tV9M
trb. '..Tork.nnPirk.paM lUnb
. urn lur lln n... tJ.771 83
1'ib. 7..Tock-.euPrk,paiilllrd-
c.l fur Uulua Sll H
nh. ..T,T.,i M:'Vy.,.u.. 7HUI-
.'.nn" '..'..a;." -'."Wl C..
if 60. Ml,lK' r,.::
Hie. SI. Ily tllvl l"nr'i rhir'nn th rr p.
I. 4t IMi iliar.a itati t-jo imu c ut,
1u1iuu.il 1 tlw 'B M
A.r,l l..Uydlv.nU.P. IUI. bobds.fiVJ il 0
pirnui. on .".."OOQ
J.U.' I. .11 .llr.ai C. P. Ill:, bonna, tl.u.0 .so
11 r . . .1 . ' r A i. . . i. 1 cu
Jin. I. ,Ilv alt. 4,'ii ares I I' lilt, itucks 00
p. i i"..l. un u'.ii, . Ij 111 n
Jan. I.. I)) utv Srm .ilures f. P. ..I'.. -to k.
0-1 fert. ui. ilii. 1 P. 1 l siuioa
Jan. lu. Py 1,. iMh il. i.oi.i il I'sr , ii-uk, P.
II. . . n
lib. 7. .liy .Itv. C. P. t.'Ii. "uuii', 4.O., i),n r
.. . . v. ni tin .1 P. ii '. . .. ,oDl"J
Irb. 1..P) uit. -!, si slurs V. r. Ml.
sn.ikim. per in ui.iuv.it. u L.... ,jui -C
I Mi. 7. .11) . I1.1 lik.li..uu A 1. ...
, s.ii.,iii,iiib to .f.j ct oil U
let'. 7 P) J... l.i.r. , . jii.c a . ....
.. ,. si'ieiuiti'ii-- ,. 5 97.. t;7!
June 17. It) .lit. lu , .- ., to , r i.m. unnfs)
iisr. -,i.-i 51 XJU IC
June 17 .lo .10. tn si el, io pir ism. uu uvu
liar. s, p.. I ijaui 00
July J. .1) illv. 111 sti'ik, 73 .r .oat.ouist" .
"iin-s, P. I. . j w j I
July 3.. by bt. 111 loads, IS per .. ut. uu tuil j
l...r-,P. L... St.:- - "5
Tlio fulluw in.' apieura In lead ikjucII 011 p.i'ii
P. pi. I. .Ity.llv. '.a lo'ilt, rsjier ceot ... ; w 1 !J
ri'l'i. it. .p.y .ni . tu stoi-.. im p. r in i ,
IJec. 1J. I ) 1 It. in st. ili.'.Ui'i ire. nt .
y. -Aruthcru any other e.r.iie. In In a 1... 'k
in relntl "i to the Credit Mobiliar ..r At 1 .
A. 'ihu. are 110 ontno. oxropiHu on 1 1 ,.o
w lileli nave been aheadt producoa nn.l 1 X
to.
y. -Tut 11 lo Ihe llrst piiife In that bo .1, 1
tat,, n t.. tr.ii . iii-t 1011.- ititi. 1 ... 1 p. 1 1
lt.ibi-o.idsii.iU A. I l.ai Is on i' ii.' I ..1,1
l,ir 01 . it .Jii.a.1) pi-oUn, ed uitt. . . ' r
i.ielhiiie out oilier en; 1 bis in 1! 1 I, . 1, 1
Bitdlo Hie I'm. ut l'a Iflc li.tlin.ul c . i
luik o.l, rr th'iu Hioee produced .111, 1 r .. '
Where ine the I., lit inf
Q - On n ft ruier day of y.nir cmiih.ii " '
rjfem'il to .1 letter or lo'iu ml ten
Ait.os. 1 UBie never i en . 1. 11,11 of tli i
or tiny such bu ler. I It ive b, .ut li...t 1 r
purportliia to ue u cot y of om . 11 . 1 .. t
loose Ictler hero t A. Tn vwill in" n. 11
few mlllUIUS. Mv llel'k hor Uil'ill en . . ,
tne Intrt.ci bin to benn i'. ,., ... '
and is due hetu it nv. Hcwinoe h . 1 '
H lOllleH He Iiiirs. ,1 Hie tic i::i 11 . .1 ..l.U
lure uu llm nest, wluci 11... ,iue.
Mr. "'..il proluci - tl 'IIP.
Aittea'a leitur ol , inn. .ui s..s 1 -'.. ...
bend I Ki'iul ! Iie.ni !
W 1 -ih;, . 1 .1, .P. 1 1 1.
. .'. il. emit .'
Hutu 'tu ) 1 cn- f Ci v-'ii ry
nf h'tfr ' 1.1 ..r r.l'ic-1.1 Mi 1 I
I'lVcslUmien b.Hse. Vfaat a 1.11 .1 " .
Btuy ilu In N-Vorll ctu'i W 1111111. .
laluty. Von .1 1 ni l nnil, r-t .a 1 1'. 1. .r 1 1 1 1
have dnn-and am to do will, a v I s .f t k
say inure lu Sen Y"rK I I..,-. 1 '.. e I ,. i ' '
York, ur ami' in .ml 1.1. Yuu must r. 1 . nt' 1
a neuri) all .lrn d n ).'ti m 11,. 1
York, auU tin iv ..'ns but 6 nr tl li.r in' u. 1 1
ciiul.ln.it ge e ul itie) wante.1 ur tlio uu -la v."' '
lint. 1 uu unuld nm uaut me tn ult. r I. 1 '
iliuiituad tMi lu su) uuu We ailnsi'il inirut 1 "' a
t ,uu tu ktuiie tiiuw ur luiir uf his trl. " '
lilnisi'ir, I knot a.frt 1A1, Hicie . u'. J"sl. it -' 1
yeul (.1 tut I lui.l, I
WtNT-l .1 H1VVT.
Ill view if King's leu, r .11 ,1 1 tsiiliurn- in." ' ''' I
-o lu lm ...vi,. uue l.uuil illviJi'UU iu iu.1. 1 - -J
I
!

xml | txt