Newspaper Page Text
4 THE WEATHER FORECAST. Fair to-day and to-morrow; light variable winds. Detailed weather reports wilt be found on page 15. tm. VOL. LXXIX. NO. 297. NEW YORK, SUNDAY, JUNE 23, 1912. Copyright, llt, fe Sun rrMtltii; mid VuWtMng Asaoclallon. 68 PAGES. PRICE FIVE CENTS. ROOSEVELT NOMINATED ACCEPTS AND DECREES THE BIRTH OP A ApprnlK to Ernst, West, North nnd South to Support His "Principles." "HKIRS OF LINCOLN" Nominators Say They Rep resent Majority of Republicans. "SHALT NOT STEAL" First Principle Laid Down by the Colonel for His New Platform. nxns a victors circle Convontion Makes Committee; Committee Makes Conven tion: Fraud Goes On. Chicaoo, June 22. The Roosevelt dele gates and alternates to the Republican convention, meeting at Orchestra Hall to-nlaht nftcr the regular Republican ccmentlon rind adjourned nnmlnntetl Theodore Roosevel: for President of the United States. At the name time they declared that they represented the majority of the delegates nnd alternntes "tonally elected to the Republican national convention." The convention was called to order by fiov John on of California and Moses K, Clapp of Minnesota was made chair man. Orchestra Hall waft filled, platform nnd galleries, nnd o great crowd In the street struggled to got in. Mayor Harrison had ordered tho police from the Coliseum to Orchestra Hall and there wo a big force outside. Fire mn were scattered in tho audience and en the platform. After the crowd In the galleries had been waiting for an hour James R. Gar field Mood up in his place on the platform and announced that they were waiting for some more delegates from tho Coli seum. Those delegates came almost Im mediately and entered the hall while th band played "The Star Spangled Bannr " The crowd got up and yeltod. Amung the newcomers were ex-Oov. Fort of New Jersey and the Minnesota delegation, the leader carrying his stand ard taken from tho.Collsoum. Th'.'nppearanco of tho standard brought the crowd to Its feet and it was cheered a sain and again. Cecil I.yon of Texas came In with some of his fallow delegates and a few men from Massachusetts arrived. Both States were cheered. Mrs. Porter, the Cali fornia woman dologate, was recognised hy the crowd and cheered. The s'.spensa did not lessen the in r"t o! th crowd. As tho Roosevelt iwidrr i ntne In they seemed to take it as a premonition that tho Colonel himself would be along in a minute. Meanwhile, they shouted again "We want Teddy. " While all hands wero waiting a letter fmmCi T Taylor, treasurer of Tennessee, a lifelong Republican, made its appear ance Hh declared himself heart and MUl in the progressive ramp and ob htsv that the old order was passing and that ( ol Roosevelt was "leading on tii great'"-' revolution in history." George v Perkins came in Juit as a man from Ohio jumped up and waved his donation placard. Tho crowd oheered more Vf" Jeraes'a Chant. Then the delegates began sending up neert ns though they were at a football Kanu Now Jersey, as though tho con wero not over nnd dono for. vntn ii jel! I We are ready. JuM you wait Wf( HvoTetfcly 'twenty-eight straight. At Hint Massachusetts got to its feet led 1-y Albert Hushnell Hart the Hnrvard hi.' riun, nudKredcrick Fosdick.ndele ea'n at Inrge. They rlp)ed out a cheer me. t.-jti the Jersey men's. G v Johnson got to hid feet at pro ' 'i 1 1 o'clock. He said It was his task ' what the meeting wus called for, 1 i" always n pleasure to fight n fraud," f" k I and tho crowd let out a whoop, 'fc' Oklahoma, delegation coming in m.;ttinile shouted: "Wo want Toddy! We wi Teddy!" while, tho audience U. .r.llered w the delegates from all parts of the 1 n.t -I states," went on Gov. Johnson, '"l,ii..nijK(l majority of legally elected delegites to the Republican convention, K re to do liero and now what they ' I invented from doing thore," v " yelled the crowd, picking up 'mson's words, "Now,, now, nowl" tho Cnllfornlan went on to nay tU' thiM meeting had bran called to glvo ih'-t.-n lioosevelt "that nomination ' ' i. n ho won roblied." This waa the '-t '.Kllng that the orowd had of tho purpiiM. ()f (ho meeting. It Jumped up -rid veiled. I he ihr subsided tiickjy and Gov. fu.rton went on to doolaro California's aWuinii. to n principle which w' nreigu to tho understanding of be u,r. d Now Vork. dar kest America ry "Hrut-Cates" "a ii t ., .,..'..1!'in,Jtn" 'or a rill At, wl:vfN3CO.,lrilllt 11 u. Fulton Strett.N.Y. BY RUMP MB ! . Ct-IMEDtNiH President Taft. Tho principle thnt tho coplu are above the bosses," Ho (.poko of the "pntriotism" that would build a now party oat he ruins of tho Republican party. Senator Clapp of .Minnesota then ross and offered tho resolutl v, he made no sproch, but naked immediately for its adoption. . , I'rruttprKilst's Srrunil. William A. Prenrlergr.it of New York rose to second the resolution. Coin cident ly n golden California bear was placed ujion tho tablo in front of him. William Flinn of Pittsburg came in and sat down behind the Comptroller Mr. Prendergast said that party name, and party allegiance do not tneui as much ai they did, but. he was Burprlf,el to find that the break hml come no soon. There was tremendous enthusiasm when Roosevelt's name was put In nom ination. Col. Roosevelt, who cam" int'i the lint! after the nominating rcnlntlon had been adopted, thank'-d them for the nomination, said th.it he iec.snl.ted them it luwfully elected iMegntes rep resenting an overwhelmin : i-ii.ji rity if the voters nt the prlmarUs, and said he would nccept tho nomination subject to ! the formation und approval of u new party. He told them to go home. Hnd out the sentiment of their people and then met In "masii convention to nominate for tho Presidency a pri:;re?dve candidate on a progressive platform, n candidate mid a platform thnt will enable us to appeal to Vwa VnHlu.pnpr iiwl Kniithemor. Kast- emer und Westerner, Republican utid Democrat alike, In the name of our com mon American citizenship." Col. Roosevelt referred to President Taft. the newH of whose renomlnallon by the conentlun he bad Just lieiird, as "tho man who Inspired and profited by the fraud." He made this reference to the President after he had declared the essential part of the majority as constituted In the convention to have been fraudulently seated. It onset fit oiulnated. The resolution placing Col. Roosevelt's name In nomination woh as followHi "We, delegates nnd alternates to the Republican convention, representing u clear majority of the voters of tho Re publican party In the nation, nnd rep resenting n clear majority of the dele gates nnd alternates legally elected to the convention, In meeting assembled, make tho following declaration: "We were delegated by n majority of the Republican voters of our respective districts and Htutes to nominate Theo dore Roosevelt In the Republlcnn na tional convention us tho candidate of our party for President, und thereby carry out the will of the voters as ex pressed nt tho primaries. Wo have earnestly nnd conscientiously striven to execute tho commission Intrusted to ua by the party voters. Tor five days we have been denied Justice In the national convention. This result lias been accomplished by the ac tion of the now defunct National Com mittee In placing upon tho preliminary roll of the convention and thereby seat ing upon tho floor of the convention n sulllclent number of the fraudulently elected delegates to control the proceed- j Ings of the convention. i "These fraudulent delegates, once soated, have, by concerted action with one another, put themselves upon tho permanent roll, where- they constitute an Influence sulllclent to control tlif convention and defeat the will of the party ua expressed at tho primaries. IbkirUCtlllUk, "Wo have exhausted every known The New Moaat Klneo Ilostr. On Uooichead I-skt. Maine. LOCO feet above the tea. Opeos June nth. Management Dicker Hotel Co. Information at 171 llroadway. Ait, , CONVENTION NEW PART! means to head off this conspiracy and to prevent this fraud upon the popular will, but without success. "Wu were sent to this convention bearing the most specific Instructions to place Theodore Roosevelt In nomination ns the candidate of our party for Presi dent, nnd we therefore deem It to be our "duty to eorrv nut thniso Instructions In the only practical and feasible way ru m.Vnlnc: open to us. ! "Therefore, be It resolvid. Hint we representing the majority of the voters of the Repkih;icnti pari'- end of the dele ,:iHes and alternates h -.rally dieted to the national Republican conventem. In compliance with our Pistr ictlonn from the patty oter.s, hereb) nor.iln-it Theo dore Renevet IIS the lamlldllte of our party for the olttre of PreMdent of the t'nlted States, and we will call upon him to accept such nomination In com pliance Willi the vvlll of the party voters. "And, be It further resolved, that a I committee be appointed by the chair to forthwith notify Col. Roosevelt ot the action here taken nnd request him to appear befori us In this hall as soon as coim ulent." The delegates nnd alternates and the large audience of Roosevelt shouters adopted tile resolution with a tremen dous outburst. It cnine a a complete surprise,. Noth ing hud b.'cn n.tld In ndwince about the nominating resolutions. The audience was bulled merely to attend a meeting which the Colonel would address. The people were still cheering when Col. Roosevelt wmi brought Into the ball. Ills nppi nrauce was the signal fur n fresli outburst, which drowned his efforts to speak for many minutes. The Colonel waved his arms nt the audience In his familiar fashion. When n moment of silence came ho began. His speech was frequently Interrupted with shouts of "Teddy, we're with you!" "Keep your hat In the ring!" nnd tho old cries of "Klght "em, fight 'em. fight 'em!" Ills announcement of the birth of tin) new party was the signal for even greater outcries. He said; Itniiaevelt' ftpeevli. (if.NTl.tMTN I tlinuk you for' your nomination, anil In you I recognize the lawfully elected delegates to tho Itepubllcuu convention who represent the overwhelm ing majority of the voters who took part In the rtcjmhliwiii primaries prior to the convention, and who represent the wish of s majority of the lawfully elei ted mem bers of the convention. 1 accept the nomination subject to but nno condition, '1 his has now hoootne a contest which cannot be settled merely along the old party lines. 'Die principles (lint are at stake arc as broad and as deep ns the foundations of our democracy itcelf. 'lhey nro In no seinu sectional. They should appeal to nil honest citizens, Kuxt nnd Went, North and South, they should appeal to nil right thinking men, whether Itopiiblicans or Democrats, without regurd to their previous party aflllintlons. I feel Hint the time has mine when not only nil men who belleie In progressive principles but all men who believe In those elementary ninxitus of public and private morality which must underlie eery form of successful fren government should Join in one movement. 'I lierefore J ask you to go to your several homes to find out the sentiment of the people at home, and then nuuin to come together, I suggest In nnihs convention, to nominate for the Presidency u progressive candidate on a progressive platform, a candidate and a platform that will enable us to appeal to Northerner and Southerner, easterner and Wostornor, Iteptibllcan and Democrat alike, In the name of our common American citizenship, "I'll Make (he Fight." If you wish me to makn tho fight wilt timke it even if onlv one Sliite should support mo, Tho only condition I Impose Is that you shall feel entirely fren when you come together to substitute nny other man In my pluco If you deem it better for tho move- Continued on Third Page, . f WOODRUFF QUITS AS BOSS. Tim Korimilly Retires an Lender of KIiiks County orgnnUatlon. CntrAOO, June 22.--Timothy 1,. Wood ruff of HrooUlyti sent the following letter to Reuben h, Haskell, secretary of tho Kings county Republican organization, to-night: Mr DrAii Stts, 1 hereby notify you as sec retary of tho Itcpublican county committee utid oxecutlvn eominlttce of Kings county that I can no longer serve as the lender or tho ltepulillcnn organluUon of Brooklyn. The utterly ruthless subversion. of the popular will cxpicsed by our fellow llepuhlicalis of the great ltopubllcun States by the National Committee, the committee on credentials nnd by tho fraudulently constituted con vention, whereby the destruction (r the ltepulillcnn paity !, in my political Judg ment. Inevitable, us I told my fellow Brooklyn delegates when they nrrlvod here after 1 had cure full v Informed myself re garding tho situation, compels mo to take this course. Timoiiiv U WoonnurH. Alfred K. Vns Is chairman of tho Re publican county committee of Kings and Ib a delegate to this convention. "The executive committee of the county .nn..,.lii..u nocciwl n resolution last soring 1 to appoint a leader or the organization," j ho said to-night "I declined to vote for that resolution as there is no such oflloe. Mr. Woodruffs resignation will be simply filed away. No uction will be take;, on it." Mr Woodruff attended the meeting of the'Roosevelt delegates in Orchestra, Hall. He has thrown in hts fortunes with Col. Roosevelt. SENATOR LODGE VERY STILL. Snys He's Krpt Out of the I'lstht, but Mar ' fninrthlnat Soon. Boston. June 22. -Senator Ixdgo U ut his Nnhant homo, where ho will spend the week's recess which Congress has taken His smile when ho was naked about the future of tho ltepulillcnn pirty gave tho questioner to undcr-tAiid that the breaking of waves over tho rocks of Nahant was much more pleasant than the uproar which has marked tie' convention. "Don't ask nu anything about polities." he said. "Do you think that aft-r keep ing out of thU fight four months 1 am liable to get Into it now? 1 may havn something to sav when the convention is over and a candidate Is named but for the present I intend to keep silent "1 have had no Inside Information of the convention since it started, getting all ray information from the newspapers " JOY IN DEMOCRATIC CAMP. Ilnlllmnre Itogiinls llrlinmlnotlon of Tnft as Fasorable. ( IlAt-TiMonr. Juno 22. The news of ' Taft'? rcnominutlon wns hailed with joy 'in tho Democratic ranks. Democrats . ! generally believe victory will Ito theirs ' in Novomtier. ! The naming of Tnft was regarded hs ' favorable to th Wilson tsjom and in creased the likelihood of tho Democratio platform and candidate being progressive. i HUGHES REMAINS SILENT. Ins) lee Only I'olllrlj- i'nrlims Ibrr llrsnlt at C'hleaKii. I.akf. Pi.ACtu. N. V.. June 22 -Not even the announcement that President Tnft had been nominated upon the first ballot w.is able to elicit from Justice Charles K. Hughes any comment what soever on the later news of Col. Iloose. volt's Independent nomination by his wing of the inrty. The Supreme Court Justice was politely curious, nut lie nu ! hered to his decision that he could not with propriety discuss the situation. I The man who might have hud the nomination if he had shown anv willing. ness to tnke it appeared to the news ! paper men who gathered on the porch of 1 his Adirondack cainti to tnke little interest in what waa even tnen happening In tho 1 convention hall His only concession w as a long distance telephone connection bv means of which his former secretary , Robert Puller, kept him informed from New York city That the convention was over was offered as an excuse for some comment, but to Justice Hughes that seemed an additional reason for silence "Not since I went on the bench have I talki-d politics," said he, "and this isnot ' the time to begin." NEW NATIONAL COMMITTEE. All lUreteil Kserpt 'e Vork nnd Massachusetts lllllea Chairman f Cllli'AC.o, June 22.-Tho makeup of the.. new National Committee wns announced this evening. Tho Massachusetts and , New York delegations huve not selected their representatives. Monator v. .aim- rav Crane declines reelection in Massa-, chusetts and William Barnes, Jr., of New York can elected to succeed vwuinm L. Ward if ho wants tho post. It is estimated that the Taft men have- about thirty representatives on tho com-! mlttee Soon ufter this convention ad- tl., i.o in4,Tiiv inornVmra of ii .ifi.o- consultation with President Taft, will i select a chairman to succeed Uctor Rose- Mr It was said to-night that riecre-' tary Hllles Is to lie the chairman. Kol lowing nro tho members of the corn mlttee: State. Ala. Arti Ark Cat. Col. Conn, Pel . l'la. (In Idaho .Name. Prelate tl. Parker llallih II Cameron, I'uuvll Clayton. . Ilosa .rry Simon (iugirnhelm. Charles T. Ilreulirr. . T. Colerran .In I'onl . Ilrnry S, Chnliti. Jr. Henry N. Jscknon. .icihn W. Hart. Itnv I). WVt Heisldoni'e. Mohllc. I'lagMalT. Knreka Springs, I xix Angeles. Pener. Annonla. Ullnilnif Ion. Winter Park, Atlanta. Mrnan. I'lili ago. Wlnihesier, liutiuiine, Cmporla. Owenaboro. New (irlcmm. Portland, ballttniry, Detroit, Si Paul, Jaikkon, Si, l.mi, Helena, Omaha, Keno. .Nanhtia. Newark I.hh I. unas Illinois indlniia .lanio I' Cooilrlrh, lna John T Attains . Kansas Ullllnm Allen White Ity J. W, McCnlliiugh.. Iji . Victor lii.lsrl , Maine I'rederli k llnle. . Mil w iiu.-im l jui'Ksiin tn-fcrrf it. Charii'H Wnrrcn. I. A. Caswell, . I, . II, tlosely. 'I'liiis, K. NelilrliutlmuB T A, Marlow, II. II. Ilouell. Musk Mich. Minn Mlm Mo Mim . .Neti XelAfla 11 11. Maxnn. .New II Ilea V. I'.mahrook N, .1. tlnnlen U. Whiting. . .V, M Sulmium I. una N. William lla lies. Jr Aiiiuny, .No. C. Illcliinunil Pearson Ashevlll 'Hie, I) Thuinan I . Marahaii .iiakek. Ohio. . Walter I'. Hrnwn,, . Toledo Okla. , (ieorge C. Priestly llartleavtlle, iJri'gun..ltalnli Wllllamt The Dalles. I'enna . ii. ii. waasiin I'linniirg, It. 1 William '. Mlienielil . .Newport. .Imeph W. llnlliriHik, (Ireenwooii, Tlumiaa ThoniMin Cnnton. Newall Sanders. Chattanooga, II, I' Magregor. Himmon, i;. r IsioKe. . Provo, John I. Uw. North Troy, Alvah H, Martin N'erfnlk H. A. Perklna. . Tacnma. William C. H. r.dwanl. Charleiton. Alfred T. lingers . Madison. Oeorge a. Haatoa raaimton. W, H. Daylea Juneau. Chanln Uruwn Uaililnelon. So. C, So. D, 'I'elin, Teaaa Utah Vl . Vn. . Wash. W. V. Wli. . Wo. . Alaska I. c nawaii..!,-. a. itieo. . . i.anina, V. UI.. ..Henry M, McCoy Manila. Porto It. Sucl.emaj fleha... San Juan. TAFT AND SHERMAN RENOMINATED ON FIRST BALLOT: 344 OF ROOSEVELT'S FOLLOWERS REFUSE TO VOTE President ficts 5G1 Votes, or 21 More Than a Majority. TWO CAST FOR HUGHES La Follette Receives 41 in the Dakotas and Wisconsin. ONLY 17 FOR CUMMINS Galleries Rock With Cheers When 34 Ohioans Refuse to Vote ai All. 5.(7 THROWN TO SHKRMAX Ko Motion Is Offered to Make the Nominations T'liimi- tnoiiH. as Usual. C'HIiWio, June 22. The Republican na tional convention this evening renom inated President Tnft nnd Vlce-Presl- dent Sherman. I Only one ballot was tnltcn on each i nomination. Kor President, Taft received ,"fil ' votes; Roosevelt, 107; Cummins, 17: 'i.u Kollette. -11; Hugh.s, 2. Six dole- W ,rSW Vice-President Sherman. Ktrp wcrp absent nnd 344 refused to ; voto i . , l r Mee-I resident, Sherman received 1 f,p7 votes, many of the Ui Kollette and i . i..i v,t, .i i Cummins men giving him thel Ir sup- port. ri"n was no motion to make, nomination of Taft unanimous, an , , . . , , . precedented Incident. the iiu- Senator Root was made chairman of, ,. ,, , , ,, ,, ,, ' thp committee to notify the President of his nomination, und Thomas II. De vlne of the committee to notify Sher man. The convention adjourned nt 10:30 P. M. The Roosovelt programme as deter mined upon lust night wus curried out at to-day's session of the convention after the convention had received tiie last of the credentials committee's report and had become permanently organized. There was no bolt, but in accordance avltli tho programme no roll cull was demanded to-dny nnd after tho per manent organisation was completed tho Roosevelt men didn't voto. This wus in obedience to tho request of tho Colonol contained in a statement read to the convention ut 3:15 o'clock this afternoon, In this ho usked the Roosovelt delegates not to vote on any matter after the report of the credentials committee, on the ground that tho convention did not repre sent tho reul Republican psrty, The Colonel's statement wus rend by Henry J. Allen of Kansas. Mr. Allen sup plemented it with a statement of his own which he said represented tho views of a majority of tho Roosevelt delegates The convention hr.d been in session 1 DALT1MORK AMI ItlCTCHN. HOVAI. lll.li: LINK. Democratic Convention. Tickets on tale June U to 27: limited to July 3d. Ilaltlmore k Ohio. Heading, Jersey Central. Adr, four hours mid a half when Mr. Allen got up to rend Mr. Roosevelt's statement right after tho report of tho committee on permanent organlrutlon lutd been received nnd adopted and Mr. Root had become ernianeiit chalrmon. The an nouncement by Mr. Allen that ho hud a statement to make from Tlieodoro Roose velt led to u noisy demonstration by tho Roosevelt, men lusting twenty minutes and In which tho scenes of Wednesday's session wcro repeated to some extent. It did not hnvc great lasting power, how over; for one thing the delegates, par ticularly tho Roosevelt ones, were utterly worn out. Itonsevelt Mtsttement. Hero U tho Roosovelt statement: A clear majority of tho delegate honestly elected to this convention wero chosen by tho people to nominate me. Vndcr the direction nnd with tho encouragement of Mr. Tart (lie majority ot tho National Committee hy the so-enlled "stenm roller" methods nnd with scandalous disregard of every principle of elementary honesty and decency stole eighty or ninety delegates, putting on the temporary roll cnll a sufficient number of fraudulent delegate to defeat the legally expressed will of the people and to substitute ii dishonest for an honest majority. Tho convention has now declined to purge tho roll of the fraudulent detonates placed thereon by tho defunct National Committee and the majority which thus Indorsed fraud was made a majority only because It In cluded the fraudulent delegates them helves, who nil sat as Judges on one another's I cases. If these fraudulent voles had not i thus been cust mid counted the convention I would h.ivo been pursed of their presence. 'This action makes the convention In no ' proper seice any 4onger a ItepubllcHii con tention representing the real Kepubllcati party. 'I lierefore I hopo tho men elected , ns Itonsevelt delegates will now decline to vole on nny matter before the conven tion. I do not release any delegate from ' his honorable obligation to voto for mo If he votes at nil. but under the actual condl- tions I hopo that he will not vote at nil. The convention as now composed has no claim to represent the voters of the Kepubllean party. It represents nothing hut successful fraud in overriding the will i of the rank ami lite of the party. Any man nominated by the convention as now con- 1 stHnted will be merely the bcneftelnry of this smcessful fraud. It would bo deeply discreditable to any man to nccept the con- j veutlon's nomination under theso clrcum- ' stances, and any iiiau thus accepting " "Id have no claim to the support of any Hepubllcanon party groundsnnd would have forfeited tho right to ask the support oi any nonesi man or any party on moral grounds Tnnopoiir. Hookkvei.t. Hops for Order. Hunt To-day's session of the convention began at 10:45 o'clock, when Senator Root's gavel whncked the table. The convention had been adjourned to meet ut 10 o'clock, but at that hour enly a few delegates wero in their seats. It was ii weary and faded looking lot that i came slowly into the Coliseum. Not only I huvo they lieen getting llttlo sleep, but the long sessions have meant sandwiches for sustenance until well along in tho evening, There were few vacant scuts in tho gullery when the day's proceedings le gan and few left their scats through tho long session, Tho Bcsslon was oiencd with prayer by John Wesley Hill, He is a close friend of President Tnft and has lieen stumping j for him, He prayed fervently for the I President und thai the country might Ixi spared from revolution, . The Mississippi contests wero taken up and the Tnft delegates, as usual, seated with a viva voce vote: this viva voce vote began soon to provoke hoots and yells. First would come tho "ayca" hi a great volume oi sound ami then the "noes" in what seemed to be oven greater vol UlinuoLWAY. I The All-die-nay.bv-Vtater War 1 to lloston and points Down Kast. In Maine and the Maritime Provinces, Mleamshtps Massachu setts and Hunker lllll. See advt. Ait. '-f5- ' ume, and when Senator Root would an nounce that the ayes had It tho Itoosovelt men yelled derisively. Even It not Una I.niiKh. When the Washington delegates nt large wero reached a Roosevelt delegate interrupted tho proceedings with a point of order. Asked to stnto It, hn said: "Our com plaint Is that the steam roller Is exceed ing tho eis-ed limit." ' Kven Chairman Root had to latfgh. "The chnlr will rule the point of order Is sustulned-the Justification is that w have some hopo or getting homo on Sun. duy," he said. The Washington contests involved a Presidential primary. Tho Roosovelt men in tho Pennsylvania delegation liegan singing "John Brown's Body." Tho'ro were fow raps of tho gavel, and fsenator Root and others on tho platform sat and smiled throughout u great deal of tho noise. Whistles and tootH imitating a eteani roller camo from sorno of the dele gates. A rolling pin was lifted high on a pole, provoking more laughter. H. T. Hnlbort defended tho minority report on tho Washington case and said that he had a statement to mako on be half of the minority members of the com mittee. Mr. Hatliert said: "When tho minority members or the credentials oommittco took up the work of considering the contest they wero confroutcsl with a set or rules which they lielieve were arranged uon a wrong theory, the theory that no contest could be hoard unless an appeal had been made from the Notional Committee. Tho minor ity believe that the committee on cre dentials was u court of original juris diction, and they further believe that the only court of lust nnd final resort was this convention itself. They lieljevo. therefore, that all contestsshould be heard upon their merits. The rules originally presented to them excluded any dis cussion. They believe that every con test should lie discussed nnd their vlewa presented." Moral Issue luvoltpil. The issue in the Washington case, Mr. Hnlbert said, was ono of simplo morality. "The acceptance of the report of tho majority," ho added, "will put before this convention one nf is-,, iiii.n ,.i..u ... , ,,,,, ttiaiitu", defeat or Theodore Itoosovelt." There was laughter from tha Taft forces and cheers rrom the Roosevelt men. Nobell, the Washington member of tho committee, started to sjs.-ak. but Gov. Port of Xow Jersey obiected on I bo tfrnlllul that Ills vote was in question. .Senator Hoot decided that Nobell could state his case. He concluded that the primaries had Iwen illegally culled. It was ex pected that them would U a roll call on Washington, but the Roosovelt men did not usk for one und went on with their fun making. "Merrily wo roll along," thev sang, the chorus filling the convention hall. John ;C. Dight, u Pennsylvania limn, got up i on his chair and shrieked through u mega phone: "One more stiff for tho under I taker!" j "Pennsylvania nominates Jim Wntson of Indiana for Coroner," canio u minute I mier uiroiign mo megaphone, i Thn galleries wero laughing and cheer- ing in turns. Chuirmati Ilosewater hap , Kncd to isis by the Pennsvlvnnians. One or Flinn 's biggest henchmen picked him up like u liaby. "Now wo got Rosewnterl" camo the cry. A bie Texan sltlinrr nrnvnlin imiu Ilosewater nnd held him up in tho air in return. It was nil dono in a spirit of run. but little .Ilosewater did not seem to enjoy it greatly, l.idly, a Californlnn man for itoosovelt, sturtrd the "Wo want I Teddy" cry, but the delegates wcie too tirrcj to keep it going very long. At lti.Vi o'clock a recess was taken to' awuit the next ruinm. 1. 'ustctl until 1:37 o'clock. There Was H irraoit ,lnl j disorder for a while. Up in iho gallerv just below tho band a man hung a banner rending; . "What Hoot said uliout Penrose, 'They are a crimluul und corrupt organization masquerading under tho numo of the Re publican party.'" Assistant Chief Schuettler hnd . man and his banner thrown out. Final,. Miss Flo Jacobson, a professional singer, got up in the bund gallery und sang "My Country, 'Tis of Thee " All the delegates got up nnd for a while things quieted down. It started up with the resumption of business. The session wns clearly tho most disorderly yet. "We'll hang Boise Penrose on a sour apple tree," sang the Pennsylvania men. The Now Yorkers sitting next to them trial to keep them quiet. "You tend to your own business and we'll tend to ours," said Flinn. After the Virginia cases had been acted upon a ntimlier of other con tested cases wcro accepted. Itnosevelt Miilriiirnt Sent In, At 3 P. M. a printed statement from Col. Roosevelt wus circulated among the Pennsylvania delegates. Several of them stated that under instructions from Sena tor Flinn they must refuse to givo a copy or allow it to bo seen. Senator Flinn him self would not givo a copy to the press, Mr. Mayo of tho Pennsylvania (tele, gal ion seized a megaphone and niadu ready to make an announcement when tipped off not to do so by Senator Flinn. Tho minority report on North Carolina was read at 2-..VJ to keep tho attention oi tho delegates. It was 2:10 o'clock when tho credentials committer reported on the Texas con tests. Tho. lew minutes wall had length ened out to nearly three-quarters of an hour, during which the weary delegates circulated around the hall and discussed the chances of getting away this evening. Tho majority and minority reports wore read and Mr. Cady of Wisconsin argued for the minority report. "Tho Texas rase," he said, "was the one cuso in which expediency was con spicuousty thi reason for the decision of the committee," . Tho usual motions were put and carried ' J 2 ; i