Newspaper Page Text
f THE SUN, SUNDAY, OCTOBER 18, 1914. OLD MEN COMMAND EUROPE'S WARRING ARMIES- Heaviest Responsibilities Have Been Placed on Men of Fifty Years of Age or More A STRIKING feature of the war ZA In Europe In the mature yenrs of the lullle lenders. Youth, perhaps, may h at n premium on the firing line, hut ago with mllllnry experience; Is sccmlnfrty showing Us strategic, worth. History Is both re penting anil reversing Itself In thin par ticular, nnd this adds something to the psychological ptizzln which the present situation offers for consideration. If It ago that makes n general, or l the military tnlent n nntle gift rather thnn the cumulative fruit of flelt experience.? Nesrly nil of the ltr!tlh gcner.ils nretury service. Twelve months of his 50 years old nnd over. The heaviest burden of nrtlve responsibility In the field hus been placed by Krntirp upon mn In the sl.xtlof. Germany apparently hit looked wl men :iltanee at any ireneral of less than threescore years. Austria has seeniliiKl piaci-d u mlum upon men Hint have pnss-d by a fondly margin the half cent.irv mark. ........ .... , and this Is equally true of I! issM nnd Servla. And yet the luttle annuls of CP rm.iny iave shown old age to be .in objection- hie element In Its military loaders and the overennftdence of advanced years probably placed Prussia In Its most critical position as n nation and brought upon It the grave-' hi'm''isMor? It his ever suffered- this rlrht In the wa'.ie of ' well et secure upon his sueresf:il brllltnnt exploits nf Frederick the Clreat. , etToru in reorganizing the Prussian When Napoleon Invaded Prussia ir. 1 armv for Its memorable campaign .. , , i ncnlnst the Inst nf the French Km- lor. he nnd nv." f M-imUHs ( , wnrn , ,. M , ranpd between 35 and 37 ye.n-4 old, i rmles ln:o Franco .;is 7.1 years old, yet Poultney H'.uclow snvs: "On the hut he showed that he cou'd share the Prussian side tho Klni: nlore was within ! ripors of field service with hi soldiers, thete years. His commander In chief. (len. WlnflcM Scott was madu C'om wns not fit to he mi horseback. mander In Chief of the Cnlted Stntcn Out of eixty-slx colonel,, In the Infantry ' :nny In IS II At tha.i time h was of the. lino twenty-clqht were ovc r BO years; or zi majors eipntv-sit were. over Rl, nr.l 130 more thnn 50 years ta old." Tho Duko of ilrunMvlck. then head of the army, wr.s 70 yeais old. In one caaa tha commandant of an Important fortr.i was moro than 80. and what , rtrfg'ht bi termed exasperated inn- turlty was characteristic of subs:an-l tlally all of the commandants of thej Prussian fortress c)tle. I In tha Thirty Year War It tool: a I slffre of seven months to capture the) aironshold of .Mapdeburp, and yet the Prussian commander, u count of 73 yars. .surrendered tho city In 18'Jt! to a handful of French troops without tiring a single shot. True, he called n coun cil of wnr before he capltulat'd, but, PKz, a German chronicler, tn JCucInw i telli us, "says that tho n'.r.-'.een mem bare of this mllltnry round ngprfyctrd 1,400 yesrs of life, wh - h pivrs a pretty hlph averas-o for the individual." But all of th"e furnvr pupils of1 Frederick the Orrat were not faint hearted. One of the Oncn's present, a man nf Vi, dared to prott-st npalnst tha aurrender nnd urccd that there wtro plenty of niiiltary storis nnd troop.s cnouph to put up a pood and long flpht. "The rominnndant promptly called him to order In these words: 'You aro the younpest hub here. You will plve your opinion when It Is ashed.' And then they proceeded to plpn the contract of Hhnme," On the evo of the bnttln nf .Tena, fought October 14, 1S06. Klnp Frederick William It I. rested at Auerstadt and there called n council of war, composed of the Duke of Hrunswlelc. Field Mnr- of he Uuke or urunswieK. ! em Mnr- :tr'" frrn",a" ' :i generals and a cnupla of colonels. Those men represented the highest military nuthorlty then In the kingdom. They wasted hours In np!ess talk while the comparatively Juvenile Na poleon pushed his army within cannon range. There was, however, one officer on the alert Hlueher, relatively a boy of 64 years. He knew the datifT threaten ing and sought to reach his royal mas ter, hut the King was asleep and had given orders that ho Miould not be dis turbed. However, Frederick William III, was rudely nrnuced sumo hours later by the booming of Napoleon's guns and the noisy retreat of his own troops, who, rtirampi'd and asleep, had been stumbled upon In the fog by the onrushlm: French, Napoleon was h better Judgo of gen erals than Frederick William III., and recognizing In Hlueher a formidable enemy ordered tho King of Prussia to dismiss the old soldier from his service In 1811. This was done. Three years later, when fortune smiled upon the efforts of the Prussian nrmy. Hlueher was able to retaliate and he drovo Na poleon beyond tho Rhine and defeated him at Laon. Again, at Wnterhio, upon that fateful June 18, 181.V It was the tlmly nrrlval of Hlueher nnd his men that spoiled Honnparto's plans nnd turned the tide of battle In Wellingtons r.ivor. Ills 73 years hnil not hulted Hlucher's "auda cious activity," ns one of his French military critics described the character of his services upon thnt day. Tho Marshals of France nt Water- loo were all nhout Napoleon's nge, nnd Wellington was lesw than four months older than his Imperial antagonist, hav ing been horn In April, 170. Grouchy, whose lardy arrival on the battlefield TRANSPORTS CARRYING DOMINION TROOPS TO and failure tu prevent Mueller's Juno turn with Wellington had rrlppled Nn poleon, vn the oldest of the French Marshals, nnd he had the advantage nf his Imperial master only liy nhout three years. Whs It his age, 48 years, that hampered his efficient)-? At the fame time there was Gen. Gtii'lscnnu of Mueller' army, a man of nearly 5(1, and It was upon him that fell the responsible task of pursuing In lelenlless Prussian fashion the French as they retreated fiom Water loo. It wit the splendidly aggressive manner in which he did his work that made it possible for the allies to march with ease nml speed t, P.uis. Here also was a man of ,n1de and varied mill- career hud been spent In tile pay or George. lit. ntoitnnt the American Colo nists, and he had learned there the value of skirmishing tactics and quick ness of action. What of that splendid military trlum vliate of King William I.. Iloon nnd pie-,.Moltke, whose united M'rvlces put the Merman Umpire upon Its llrm fotindn- '"'"7 W"'" "" yn" ,M"''ke "!!Z from Koniggrnl. after the Austrian ,.,,,, of m6 ,. wlu, yft.lr ilt. Hn yrf heavier duties were to be placed ; up ii hm In behalf nf the fatherland I He t wa who planned the campaign I aRnlnst France, and by his mainly I grasp or neiaii nnci resources ni.iiin u possible to muster the force's that car ried all before them In 1S70-7I. (len. tan Itnon wa.s but threo years Von M ltiie's lunlor. and h!s fame may trooH ,, m(.;:v0 , irown. d his j work ti,r t)ll. i.ap.ur 0f the capl bilny of military action In 1SCI. hut he was ton old to gi to the trout and wn retired from active service n tho u it. aim of cn.it year. GEN. T2ADUMIL. PUTNIK-I Itroiidly speaking, the civil wnr lead ers were principally young men, as age goes In military careers. Gen. Grant was fifteen years younger thnn Gen. I.ee nnd Gen. George Gordon Meade was eight years the Junior of "I,cc being some months1 chort of 48 when he won his memorable victory nt Gettys burg. It was I-ee's training nnd ripe years that helped him to light so brill iantly against odd ami his rich r . U -.n,, the overpowering forces of Grant gathered nhout beleaguered Rich mond. Gen, William T. Hherman was only 41 yenrs old when the civil war bgan. When Kngland had the Hoer war nn her hands she found It necessary In battling with the burghers to call to her service In the field the most experienced of her soldiers, Gen. Itoberts, tho rann Tommy Atkins admiringly nnd lovingly called "Htns." In 1!00 Gen, Itoberts wa.s (IS years old, nnd his long service In India had made him Just tho man to copo with the resourceful Hoers nnd their manner of fighting. Ge,n. Roberts had lino men under him, hut even so he had to draw upon tho wholn of his forty-eight years of military experience to win In South Africa, Kmpcrnr Wllllum II, properly esti mated Lord Roherts'.s soldierly fitness, and ns a seeming compliment Invited him to be present at the grand manreu vres of the German army In 1902, The fact Is he wanted the Kngllsh Genernl to see his troop In simulated buttle nction, not for the 5:1 lie of tho spectacle, ns might havo appeared, but in order thnt ho might reap the benefit of any criticism coming from ho competent a source. Tho Kaiser was bent upon profiting by Lord Roberts's campaign tn Knuth Afrlcn, and he had a profound respect for ago whero military Judg ment was concerned. So apparently havo the Hrltlsh, for Karl Roberts, now 82 yenrs old, has his placo upon Kng land's war council to-day. When Japan went to war with Russia In 1001 she laid the burdens of mllltnry and of naval responsibility upon her oldest men In the services. The taciturn Togo was then r 7. but a man of Iron despite his age. Field Marshal Prlnco I.-pon him fell the first rcaponsl- .O mM JJJJJJJJ) t Off Gen. Alexander. .w Kluck:: lwno Oyama was at that time CO years t old. Ho had served as n military at tache on tho French side during the I'rnnco-Prusslnn war, had fought through the Hatsuma rebellion of 1S77, playing n conspicuous pnrt In subduing that revolt, and was very much In evidence In Jnpan's war with China In ISiM-Sfi. Tho part he played during tho lttrsso-.lnpnncse conflict Is well known. Field Marshal Mlchltsura Nodr.ti wis born In 1841, nnd yet his sixty-three years did not keep him from thn hnrdest kind of campaigning in Manchuria against tho Russians. Field Marshal Arltomo Yamagata wan three years older than Nodzu, and his was the onerous task of Chief of the General .Staff of tho Japanese army during the Mikado's war with Russia. Gen. Kurokl was iMirn In IS 11 nnd nt threescoro ho carried his armies to victory on the Ynlu and ut Ltaoyang. Hut thn heaviest task fell to that grim old warrior Gen, Nogl, who entered the campaign ugnlnst Russia with the winters of fifty-five years be hind him, Against him was opposed Gen. Anatoli Mikhullovltch Htoessel, a year older, and Intrenched behind the most formidable nrray of defences at that time devised. We know the story of Port Arthur, nnd we know nlso of thn stubborn nnd relentless way In which Nogl ntuck at his work until tho opposing defences were well nigh wrecked and tho garrison was reduced nearly to starvation. Tho soldier spirit never died In that wonderful old Japa nese, and in his devotion to his Imperial master ho took his own llfo when the Kmperor died. The Russian Generals were commonly much younger than their Japanese rlvnls, nnd tho Czar's mllltnry lender, Alexel Nlcholnlvltch Kuropatkln, was but Gfi years old when he measured forces with the Mikado's armies. Gen, Kuropatkln's career hod been varied und apparently successful, for ho was simply littered with decorations because of his military activities. Hut ho was no match for his .Japanese antagonists of riper yenra nnd less spectacular careers. True, Kuropatkln was hnm pered by the remoteness of the theatre of war ns well as the disorganization of tho mllltnry bureaus nt fit, IVters- i i ill cWJUkHWfmwi t imi ii mm iimmbm in i i I 111 lBt'ilrH HAH m MMJJLLJ I I I I I i 1 mmStt cMMmrxtii 1 ' COUNT rftjDlrJAND HW ZEPPELIN to JP&W I f fT (V71 IV 7 M 111 I P " m My ryArM J Count Gottlieb von haeseler.:. Gen. sir. John French kji mm mm mm mm mm GEN. HELLMUTH LUDWIG WM0LTKE GEN..P0N DER. GOL.TZ-. burg, but the fact remains that older men won tho day. Tho problem of Kngland's battles on land rests to-day In tho hand- of Horntlo Herbert Kitchener, Karl Kitchener of Khartum, a man of three scoro years nnd four, whose years of maturity have been spent either 'n warfnro or In responsible mllltnry posi tions of administration. Kitchener Is the samo hard driving soldier to-day that he was when ho tirelessly blazed his wny ngalnst grave physical ob stacles In Kgypt and never rested until ho drove the enejny out of his strong hold of Khartum. As a military orgnn Izer Kitchener now Is n greater man thnn ho was then, nnd his hns been the responsibility of picking tho leaders whom Great Hrltaln hns sent nnd Is sending to the front In France. On thn field Kngland's supremo In command is (ren, Sir John Denton Plnkstonn French, born sixty-two yenrs ago, nnd one. of Knglnnd's most strik ing military figures. Much wa.s heard about French In tho Hoer war. Hncce seemed to crown nil of his efforts, nnd desplto tho beleaguering .burghers he helped to hold Iindysmlth until It be came necessary for him to reach thn Capo. Then, under the seat of a Becond ENGLAND FROM THE SECRET GEN. MofclTZ. you AllFFENDERG class carriage In n train supposedly, carrying only women and children out of the way of tho Hoers' bombarding puns, ho got through the enemy's line and south to tho llrltlsh colonial seat of Government at Capo Town. Thero he was given the command of S.000 cavalrymen, ami that wqnderful rnce to, the north stands to-day as an unsurpassed exnmple of daring nnd de termination. Gen. French nnd his men kept ever 011 dny and night and reached their goal, Klmberley, Just In time to save It from surrender. Gen. French Is both brilliant and per sistent. He exemplified these traits when Gen. von Kluck, after days of bat tling and sacrifice, asked for an nrmis tlco in which to bury his dead. Gen. French suspected a ruso and promptly and curtly refused tho request, saying, ns ho hammered aay nt tho enemy's yielding lines, "I never hnlt a Job until the work i.s done." This Is the man who I.s leading what Kmperor William Is said tn hnvo described ns "that con temptible little llrltlsh nrmy." Gen. French has Imbued IiIh entlro fighting force with his relentlessly aggressive spirit. Nearly all of the men who are his division lenders aro tried soldiers of moro than fifty years of age; some of thrm nre even older. Gen. Joseph JofTrc, tho French com mander in chief, Is 62, and until about a yer ago ho was virtually unknown to the military world, Then ho shocked the Parisian public, after tho annual ninno-uvred, by bru.sqnely dismissing n number of tho most popular of the French genernls, nnd he was Instru mental in Inaugurating the threo year period of active service with tho colors. JofTro Is not n man of many wordsj In fact, conversation may be termed his short suit, but ho Is abundantly actlvp. His mllltnry cwvlco has been long and laborious laborious Inasmuch as ho has always taken tho work cut out for him seriously and has dono It thor oughly nnd well. Moro than nny othor man, ho has prepared the French nrmy for Us present struggle, nnd is lending It lo-day ns ho planned nnd with consum mato strategy. Mnjor-Gcn. lentil Mario Cesar Jerald Pau Is a ono armed veteran of tho Frnnco-Prttsslnn wnr; ho numbers threescore years nnd six Ho is n Interesting Psychological Situation Offered by Men Holding Reins in Con flictWhat Makes Great Generals? natural bom fighter; Indeed, like some of Ills llrltlsh allien. It has In-eu said ho would not know It If he wero whipped. It was in this spirit that ho fought In 1870-71, and his aggressive ness Is. not diminished to-day desplto the Withered ycjirs. (len. l'ntt Is ex- . tremely popular with the French public .unci the French soldier, nnd he wnH railed back from his retirement to take I tho Held as .loffre's second in command. Wo know what he hua been doing on 'tho right of the French front In Alsace, l nnd the grip ho him upon that lost ' provlnci) he Is not likely to loosen unless , utterly overwhelmed by a auperlor force. Gen. de Curleres do CsMelnau of , tho General HtHff Is tho third of the I oommnndtng trio of the French nrmy I and is well up In the sixties. Gon. Gal- llenl, in chnrgo of the defences of Paris, Is in tho neighborhood nf 70, Old ugo in the German urmy might almost be said to bo tho hallmark of military aggressiveness, for one of tho most active men in tho field Is Count Gottlieb von HueUen-IIaescler. Despite hLs seventy-eight yearn thla gallant old soldier hnH displayed his energies beside those of men many years younger and has not suffered by the test. Indeed the story is told of htm that recently In thn cnmpulpn agnlnst tho allien ho ! took a Frenchman prisoner with his own hands. Tho enemy wero routed, hut Instend of leaving it to his Juniors to lead tn tho pursuit he took that dangerous duty upon his own shoulders, sending his subordinates to the rear nnd to nafoty. Then It was that he made, the capturo reported. Certulnly this Is going Komo In a man of nearly fourscoro years! Field Marshal Kotmar von der Ooltr. is the Heeond oldest penernl, being 71, that the Kaiser has sent to the western war zone. Von der Ooltr. became Inter nationally conspicuous when the Turk ish nrmy, which he had reorganized, was bentun by the ilulgars and their allies. The Turks would probably have suffered worao bad It not been for tho manner of their training under this splendid teacher. For more thnn half a century Field Marshal Kolmar von i der Goltz hns been writing on military Vubjecta and fighting betimes. His usefulness us nn adviser has not been I Impaired by his fathering years, and his GEN. .PAUL Wt fcENNEMKAMFT (7ZUSStAj position nt Brussels calls for Just tho rare qualities which are his. Gen Alejcnnder von Kluck Is thn Knlser's main reliance against the allies, nnd when stnrting out upon tho present campnlgn tho Instructions of his lmperlnl master aro said to have been that ho should take Paris or die. Von Kluck sot about his task with characterise vigor, making light of Ills sixty-eight yenrs; and the worlds mows now ciobo no came to niH goal. Probably but for Uhn impetuosity of thn Crown Prlnco ho wjuld havo fulfilled the Knlser's Injunction to tho letter. That he has not given up hope of Kluck'a desperate and persistently ag gressive battling with the allies I.s am ple proof, Gen. von Kluck comes from the people, nnd by sheer merit reached tho rank of colonel ero tho Kaiser saw fit to bestow upon him the ''von" of nobility. This soldier of few words nnd much nction Is extremely popular with his men, nnd besides being nn Ideal lender ho has marked academic quail ties, for his works upon strategy nro recognized by military critics as being of tho highest order. Gen. Otto von Kmmlch, who had the task of carrying tho defences of Liege, is HG, Gen. Karl von liuelow, who has worked shoulder to shoulder with Von Kluck In tho centre nnd in supporting hla brother general on tho right wing, U CS years and Gen. Max von Koehn Is but three years younger. Gen. Paul von Hlndenburg, tho Kalsci's hope against thn Russians, is one of Germany's mos pleturesquq figures. Though 07, h,s lmperlnl master has given him a task that might stagger tho physical and mental vigor of a much younger man. Dut Von Hlndenburg Is a man of iron In will and strength of body nnd sin gularly calm In tho face of the greatest difficulties. lllndenburg's strategy resulted In .the capturo of 70,000 Russians In tho early stages of tho Czar's campnlgn In Knst Prussia, nnd he has gono now to Gall rla to supersede tho Austrlnn com mander In .chief and tn tako up tho most difficult task confronting the Ger man nation In tho enstern theatre of war. Von Hlndenburg began his career of nudaclous dieds In tho wnr with Aumrln In 1806, und upon every oc RENDEZVOUS casion iflnoo he hns shone. This ex plains why he has thrico won th Iron Cross. inero is no neeu or mentioning m de lull tho rest of the Knlser's fighting lenders. Most of them nre what nre com monly recognized ns old men, and they hnvo txittla records dating from n Franco-Prussian war nnd upon ciMer earlier occasions. Years and exper. tic aro nt n premium in tho Kaiser r.. . mate. Perhaps the most picturesque tlgnrs among t)if German forces is c ont Ferdinand Zeppelin, who hns gnun to tho front to direct tho operations ,f tho great dirigibles. Although 75 years old this wonderfully a.'tUe o'd man Is still full of the fighting sphlt Tho Kaiser already owes much to tho genius of this undaunted tn ventor, -who hns given to tho fnth"r land its notable superiority In the mat ter of nlrshlps. Tho debt will he n bigger one If Cour.t Ferdinand succeed In humiliating F.n. land by an aerial nttnek upon I.indm. Ho announced the other day that ti llrltlsh would hear from him n cliis senson, nnd there was something gr m In tho Implied threat. No wond. r fin German soldiers nr battling as thy nre when men of such advanced yean enn cet an example both In rt ,r.ig und In nction, . 1 . . . , , 1 ... ... . . . . 1 iu iviirniiwi ira.ier, ine tirnrm iu Nicholas, I.s ns, Ho hm had tne lir.p. fill advice of Gen. .SukhomllnofT a w-; tried soldier, verging upon 70 v Together these two mti hnw n rrj hard nnd earnestly In bringing :; ths Russian army to Its present mi o ,,f elllclency, and the manner of,lt m.ih . izatlon, the speed of thnt work iiimI t h success In battle of the troops '.. ii0 brilliantly they have tevcdittl inz-,1 ths fervlce since the war with Japan Among the picturesque figutes of th Russlnn nrmy nonn looms up mors vividly than Gen. Paul von Hrnnnn. knmpff Th! brilliant invnlr.- leader has worried the Germans in Knf l'ni sla nnd when seemingly trapped br the Knlser's troops his ciutn.tig ,M fox of slMy-four doubled on Ins tnvks nmld morasses and achieved an n, tnnt victory. Gen. von Rcnnonkanipff was one nf the shining figures d'ir'ng tho war with Japan, nnd hail m.re of his associates been of thn rami' s'rlpe the outcome would probably have Wn very different. Oen. Ruzsky. the hero of Lumber and tho commander of the Russlnn army In Gallcln, Is well up in the fifties nnd an olllcer who has had much dis tinguished service to his credit The Archduke Fiederick of Austria Is uS, nnd Itfo Ills keeping th Kmperor has placed the respons'hilltr of Austria's battle honorrt, In Galleia Gen. Morltz von Auffcnberg, r,2 yearn oil, and Gen. Viktor Ilankl, Just short of 40, have felt the brunt of the Russian at tack nnd have been pushed befnie it Hoth nro soldiers of experience. Von AufTenherg's enreer being one of un usual hrlllianne. Kcrvla turned to Gen. Radmn'.l Putnlk in thn present crisis, and at commander in chief of the Servian firrcoH he hns shown tho fitness of the choice. Gen. Putnlk wr b orn la 1819, and though from southern Aus tria Is Servian in every fibre, I'nl.ka t.o many nf the Balkan generals. I'ir nlk Is a man averse to parade, and d llberately wears tho simplest sor o! uniform. His work during the Hilk.in war showed tho Muff of wh!i li he ,s made, nnd as a leader of men and a strategist he easily mounted tn pre eminence. Without going into further rlnh 'ra tion, It Is clear that the men itcnr.nj the brunt of lendershlp to-day :n f 1 wnr offices and on thn battle ,.ms nf Kuropo are elderly; indeed, are unit tho world is pleased ordlunr 1 . 1 all old men. Youth, broadly. Is bearing the f,r, k .f attack on thn firing line, and luniib needed to meet the tax levied tn-ilny bv mnchlno made wnr, but stinig n these hardships nre thn gentinl oltloe-s of fifty years and upward, ai.d. 1 addition to this physical stress, th' i nre carrying the grnve burdens nf leadership. The bodily drains of wir to-dny nre far greater than the ev" wero before. Troop.s move at n p.iea that was undreamed of 11 feu yiirs hack. The strnteglo and menul pi ' lems nro increased accordingly I''" splto these conditions that would seem logically to call for men of vouneT years nnd physical prime, tl.n kittlliu nations roll nlph with complete unanim ity haW asked tho most of their oMtst men, Ac ?. psyc.hetiglcnl study the itu.v tlon lr of deep Interest. Measur d by the enormity of the duties Impost a, tV generals to-day nro cnlled upon ,0 nchlnvo now what staggered the agi leaders of Frederick William III 1" yenrs ago. They are living thrmifh well nigh continuous warfare tot twenty-four hours of every dav, an! yet they are succeeding despite their years. I.s it posslhlo that thn battle V.idiT cannot bo Judged by the ninmon standards of a, physical prime" Pee' the spirit of the natural born ."iillr make him a sort of reversion to tvpe. thus giving to him a primitive indiffer ence to suffering und prlvntr n r '1. 8t the samo time, endowing him with an enduring robustness? In short, is the true mllltnry genius n sort of s irvlval of thn savago with a veneer of irpff resting upon nntlvo cunning" ("''' wlsn why should old men hold th reins to-day' ON CASPE COAST