Newspaper Page Text
THE SUN, THURSDAY, MARCH 18, 1915. m I'll 1 I nival warfare, particularly In the use of rlie HUbtnarlne for both drfentvve nnd offensive operations, may make the former means of maintaining u blockade a physical impossibility." Thin In precisely one of the points put forward by the Allirs In Justlllea tlon of their extraordinary programme. It In asserted also by both France and Oreat Britain that they stoppeJ short of Imposing a blockade In the urcrptrd legal sense of the term out of considers tlon for neutr.ils and a desire to mini mise the Inconvenience to which neutral Interests will be subjected. It Is their claim thnt, by not oonllscatlng either vessels or cargoes, which may be deter, mined In the enforcement of the new policy, the effects upon neutrals will be much less Irksome and Injurious than would be those of a full blockade. The I'nltol (States Is Invited by both Gov ernmentn to compare the act of consld eratlon for neutrals with what Is termed the barbarous policy of Ger many In exposing neutrals to destruc tion of life and property by Herman sub marines, Cnn Asi'Mlnti Omitted, The difference between the Anglo French programme, s set forth In their notes, and the regularly accepted blockade Is that they apparently In tend to operate on a longer radius than Is usual and that they are to omit con fiscation. Moth Prance and Great lirltaln like wise display a tendency to And a large measure of justification for their policy in the alleged Iniquitous character of the German operations, Orc.it Britain particularly, In replying to the Amerl ojui Joint proposals to herself and Ger many, Indulges In a general indictment of the German conduct of the war on nix or eight count", maintaining at the name time that the Brit lob have ad hered scrupulously to the rules of war fare. These harangue-.', as they are regarded here, will not be taken Into considera tion by the Administration, which re quires that the belligerents deal with the United States on the basis of their obligations o this Government and not with regard to what one of the belllg. I rents may be doing to Its enemies. The most extended and what Is be. lteved to be the ablest defence of the Allies' policy Is contained In the Brit ten reply to the American Joint pro. posals to Germany and Great Britain, By quoting from Oerman precedents ment Is preparrfl to aiianuoti tne prac and German wrltets the British etablish ! lice of sinking British merchant vessels something of a case In defence of at 1 by submarines " policy of cuttlnc off an eneny from hlsl "Upply of foodstuffs, even If such a Emplnlne In I'srt, policy affects the civil population. 1'ur- ,. . , , hv the fsct thermore, It Is said the Germans -auk two snips iaoen wun rooasturrs con signed to unfortified ports In Great Brit ain even before the Inauguration of the submarine programme. ilnth llavr game Object. The Oerman etibmarlne policy and the I This, it Is understood, the British In Allies blockade policy both have the 1 tM1ireird mean that British vessels wvmo objective, the British declare, that nIlll noutrals carrying contraband would rj LiiiiiuK mi an Mippiies troTll lim rntii the the po I : i a Ui . shin, n" ' on lieu-ilnto enemy, the difference between oles being "hut "we ptopoe to It without sacrificing neutral si non-combatant live,, or Irtllctlng on neu-1 irais tne damage in. must ne -n.aneii when a vessel and Its cargo are sunk .i,i . i ... ...i-i.. IIIIUUI Atl til. 111k I It'll lir 111.11 Though :he corre.pondence regarding e American joint propo-als is legarded , the row iih dead Issue, one curious con flict of Hlafement was -inted in the Brit- lsh and German repl'r to thr Cnlted TEXT OF AMERICAN NOTES fr rj f ' I f f T7 - IX IB fX r, I jj t k Germany Willing to Accept Warfare, but Allies Insist on Blockade, Which They Define and Explain. WvstiiNOTON. March 17. The corrrspondencr brtween the t'mte.l Sta-rs and Grrmany, Grtat Britain and Kn.nie mrnt to-day. First is thr Identic notr of thr Britain, .suggesting mutual concessions of the safetv of neutrai xhlppmc and is Invited to ncrmlt foodstuffs to re.ich American supervision In return for marine programme, and both ate askid The Secretary of State to the Amer.3 ican Ambassador at Ixindon. Telegram Department of State Wahhinutk.s'. l-Vb I'n. Ton will please deliver to Sir Kdwaid Gn-y the following Identic note which we are sending Ihigland and Germany; In view of the correspondence which has passed between this Government and Great Britain arid Germany resprc. lively relative to the declaration of a war zone liy the German Admiralty and tlie us-e of neutral tbigs by British mer chant vessels this Governnn nt ventures tO express the hope that tile two bel ilgcrent Governments may through re ciprocal concessions Ilnd a basis for agreement which will relieve neutral ships engaged In peareful commerce croui tho gre.it danger which they will incur Hi the high ea adjacent to the masts of the belligerents. i-be Uoi-VrnniTm ..f th' I'nlted Stntes . remectfullv suggests that an agreement In terms like the following might lw entered Into. Tills suggestion Is not to bo regarded as In any sense, a proposal made by this Government, for It of course fully recognizes that it is not its privilege to propose terms of agree ment between Great Britain and Ger many, even though the matter be onr In which It and the rplr of th 1,'nlted Htntes arr directly anil deeply Inter ested. It Is merely venturing to take the liberty which It hopes may be ar. corded a slncerr friend desirous of em. barrii.ssInK neither nation Involved and of serving. If it may, the common in terests of humanity. The course out lined Is offered III the hope that It may draw forth the views and elicit the sug gestions of the .British and German Governments on a mattrr of Intrrest to the whole world. Gerniniiy mill Grrnt Rrltnln to sitreel 1. That neither will sow any floating mines, whether upon the hiarh seas or In territorial waters, that neither will plant on the high neu anchored mines except within cannon range of harbors for defensive purposes only and that all mines shall bear the stamp of the nation planting them and h so con structed as to beeoma harmless If sep arated from their moorings. S That neither will use submarines 10 attnik tneichant vessels of any na tionality, except to enforce the right of visit and search. I. That each will require thrlr rr pectlve merchant vessels not to use. neutral tings for the purpose of dbeulse or ruse dn guerre. (irrmmiF lo Aureei Thai all Importations of food or food tuffs from tint United States (nnd from mich other neiiirnl countries may uskf tho belligerent Powers In n.e use or il) into Germany shall be consigned . their menns of warfare, arr iquulU to agencies to be designated b.v the i r0nslderatr of thr Interests of nnitrnls l.'nie.l States Government: that the-e I)n,i the d1ctntxs of humanity Conse. Amerlcin agencies shall buve entlie , ,pty, t wiis liitlmiite'l In the German charge and conlrol without Interferi nee ,, f the ltlth nstant thnt observa. on the part of Hie iierin.in "loverninent Importations and shull distribute them Noblv lo ii'tuil doaleis bcirlug licenses fiom the Ib niaii Government entitling them I,, receive nnd furnish such food rnd foodstuffs t" iinii-combalatits only; llui' a violation of ih Itrms of the retuili's licviifes shall work a forfeit 'tie of their rights fo receive such food iit.d fovdstuffa fur this purpose and MAIN POINTS IN NOTES EXCHANGED BY THE U. S. AND THE BELLIGERENTS Note Su, T.tnlted Stales to Great llritain and Germany suggests restricted use of mines, abandonment of submarine attacks on merchant men and passagr of foodsttins to Germany by Great Britain, on condition that such foodstuffs be distributed t" the civil population under American supervision. Note No. It. --Germany's reply to No, 1, accepts conditionally mot of the American suggestions. Note No, 11 1. llritLsh reply to No. I, rejects all the American sugges tlons because of Germany's alleged non-acceptance nnd niso' because of Germany's alleged Improper and bat bat mis conduct of the war, the par ticulars of which are cited. The llrltlsh defend their foodstuff policy by German precedents; declare the HtltHh blockade nnd German sub marine policy "fok the Mine ends, but the Knitllsh programme protects the lives and properties of neutrals umt non-combatants. Note No. IV 1,'nlted States ask" France and Great Hrtl.iln how neutral owned goods are to be tteatid when detained and how blockade rlifhts are assumed without the declaration of ,i blockade: recognizes that changed conditions of vvarfato affect blockade, but as!:s what radius the operations will have. Note. No. V. Hritlsh reply to IV. asserts fiat the bloikade will be maintained, hut without confiscation nnd penalties, and therefore Is less Irk some to neutrals than a regttlnr blockade. Assurances are given that operations will be conllned to Huropean and Mediterranean waters. Note No. VI. Prance In teply IV. Invites a comparison between the "Inhuman practice'' of Germany and the "considerate" policy of the Allies. She justifies the blockade on .he ground of chanced conditions of naval warfare and the German suhniutlne programme. States note, whlrh officials here are . ,h..ii., nn.,1.1. m i.vtiiii'11. The I'nlted States asked both nelllg-jine practical sortition ot me inn-uou- ererts to agree that neither would "use which have arisen. nubmarlnes to attack merchant vessels) With regard to the various points of of any nationality except to enforce the rlRht of visit and searen. The neriium Government replied that the German Government would unuet take, not to use their submarines to at- tuck merrantdrs of any flag except when . necessary to enforce the right of visit and search." In the British reply, however, is this statement "It Is nut understood from the tir- man) reply that the German leiveni- ... ..' . ' t followed by thr statement that In case visit and search should establish the em my na tionality or the presence of contraband on board a vesel, thr submarines would proceed in accordance with International , . , . .. ... . - i ,t.. ...1. 1,-il i eiiin inrr. .iiiiur .iii.-i.iiu limn uir u.- mk forthwith, under t he rule that) of MMiA ,M"'h a,c,''n ,",.,P'rn,,,,,,lhI r.Mored ! -Ib-tinctlve mark-. It would appear to ! ' n" a p""Ul0n i?h nntter of course that such mer- ,",r' a ' r c"urf'' ,l" Cl"e 'canllle also abstain f ro n .irniiug them- '" ' , - KHMfral Impre.slon in Washinr- , . ', " ,.. (-,.-. itriialn ton Is that the notes or i.reat iintain ... . , . , , ,n. "-"'1 have -ucceeded the bb. kad- policy in a better llKht. al- inou'40 tnis v.iiiv eriiiie-in i- u"i pare.! to ais-ept an ti e reatures ol uir new polcy without a nrm protest O P Dl IJ IP W ' J k 1 y VV " J ' L I Suggestions to Modify waf mad public at the State Depart- in ... if. r ... United States to Grrmanv anu ureal . by both belligerents in tne interest neutral rlirhts. In it oreat nriinin the civil population of Germany under . v nn abandonment of Germany's sua- to lessen the menace from mints. that such food and foodstuffs will not be reo,ulMtiimed by the German Gov ernment foi any purpose whatsoever or he diverted to the use of the turned turves of Getnuny. lirrnt llrltnln to nreei That food and foodstuffs will not be placed upon the absolute contiaband list and that shipments of such cuiiiiiodl. . ties vv-ll not be interfered with or dr- talneil by British autboritlos if con- igne.l to agencies designated by the . I'nlted States Government in Germany , for the rece pts and distribution of .uch , cargoes to licensed German retailers for; ..i.-i.ili.l.,.ii nwi.-i. 1 . ii.,..-v., population 111 submitting this propose) basis of agreement thi- Government does not wish to be understood as .nlmitting or, -l-njlw nnv .V'J"'. r "',:'!' established by the prlticlpbs of Interna-1 tlon.il law, but would consider the agree- ment. If acceptable to thr Interested Powers, a modus Vivendi based upon ex pediency rather than legal right and :us not binding upon the l,'nltei States either In its present form or In a modi fied form until accepted by this Gov rrnmrm. Hrtan. GERMAN REPLY. Next Is. ClermanyVi reply to thn Joint suggestions of the L'nlted States, ac cepting conditionally most of thr American suggestions: The American Ambassador at Berlin to the Seorrtary of State, Telegram : American Kmbassy Behmm. March I. 1015 Fallowing Is translation of German repl". : Thr unrirr-4gnd has the honor to In form his Kieelleney James W. Gerard. Ambassador of thr I'nlted States of America. Ill reply to the note of tho J'-'d instairt, that the Imperial German Government have taken note with great Intel est of the suggestion of the Ameri can Government that certain principles for the conduct of maritime war on the part of Germany and Kngland be agreed upon for the prote-tloii of neutral ship , R,an oV T o"1" ?! "'''""T f the friendly fis-llngs of the American Govermnrjit toward the German Govern- ment A' 1 rll arr ftillv- r.clt.eo,.:. I..1 he metit, which are fully reciprocated by Germany. It is In accordance with Germany's! wlhes also to have maritime war con ducted according to rules which, without dlscrlnilnatelv restrlrllntr one nr IV.. olh.e . f ,hp )e,-n ration of London on the part of Germany's adversaries would create a new situation fiom which Ihe iii'lliiiili iiovfrume.il! would gladly draw the piopcr conclusion. llesls for "olotlon. Proceeding from this view the Ger man Government havo carefully exam. Ined the austestlon of the American Government and believe th.it they can actually see In It a su table b.i'.s for the American note, they beg to m ike the following temarks t. With regard to the sowing of mines the German Government would be willing to aKree as suggested not to us.- Moating mines and to have anchored mines constructed ax Indicated. Mote- over, they agree to put the stamp of the Government on all mine to lie planted. tin the other band :t does not uppiMr to them to be feasible for the belligerents wholly to forego the use of anchored mines for offensive pur pose 2. The German Government would un dertake not to use tlolr submarines to attack mercantile of any Mag except sary to enforce the right of o. i.i . ..... when neeess visit and sear L 11IK1 i-rai. n. .iii'uni ,-iirni,, ,i- tlonallty allty of the vessel or the pr.et..e of"""";" ''. ", ", .'V irab ind be ascertalne I submarines an ev, eptlmi-the general rtile to whirl lid proceed in ccord inoe with the I ,"" 1!r '"I""""""' contraband would proi general rules of lnternatlon.il law I'se of .Nentrl I'lnus. ti. .-ir ,,i ,,i-,i in uir .Tinrii, nil ii. tills restriction of the use of the sub. marines Is contingent on the fact that enemy mercantile abstain from the use .selves and from all resist, uae by fori e. since such procedure contrar to Inter I national law would tender Impossible an action of the submarines In accord ance with International l.w 4. The regulation of legitimate Im portations of fooJ Into Germany sug gested by the American Government ippears to be In general acceptable f-iii-u rKiiiaiiuu uuin, ui iiMiisi-, .lonllned to Impiirtatloiis b sea, but that would on the other hand Include 'indirect Importations by way of neu-, trai pons. The tierm.in Government n'""1'1 therefore lie willing to make the "r0'''r'ulon nature provider! in have the importation of other raw ma 'tnl.il usnl by thr economic system of i non-combatants Including forage, prr- mltted. To that end the enemy Govern- menfs would have to permit thr free lenrry Into Germsnv of the raw ma - terlal mentioned In the free list of the ''laratlon of l.ondon and to treit ma- , llon;, rontrai,ami according to thr sann- ...!- III. lilii,. 111 111." ll?l ill .irillll- I principle! a rood ano roofiFttiui. , ulrl (r Breemeni. Thp (Tmin 0ovrrnm,nt nope that the agreement I A'nlMti Gov'ernm'nt in.i i". rencnen at on of the remarks , iii.il in this- way i shipping and trade suiter hiiv more than In .1.. ... ' i. ' L " """"" ' ". i-.i.iie,, ...11 ,0 111" i.eininn nme 01 toe inn in- slant, some vvav could be found to e. dude the shipping or munitions of wr , fiom neutral oountri to liu,;-rents iDll Mhilm of auv tiiiflfinnlftv The German Gov -r' rtieni must of rourse ies..,Ve a delli lt- statement of their pos'tlon until su. h time a they ,m,y revelve furthe,' information from the American Govermn. r.t enabling them , s wh;,t obligations the British Gov- ernment are on their part willing to assume. The undersigned avail- hlm-lf of thr occaiivin, ivt .igr.eii. von .i.igovc i GKturm Dated l'orelgti Oillce, Berlin, I'ehru.ir)' 1 2, jpi,-, (Apparent umission 1 l" 1 . BRITISH REPLY " ; , " ' , y , I , V ' . i. . i. V - character of the proposed operations, """is't.' can oe i-orininien to ne a i the mported fotl and foodstuffs sole y of British vessels and a number of non- -pn.M inouirv wis sent soon after Great blockade It would ceitalnlv create a by the non-combatant population would combatant and Innocent lives on Hrlt- ' n's nI'ulr 1 ' " ' ' ,."i.ms -state of affairs If for anude . Con be guaranteed. The Imperial Govern- in vec-ei,,, unarm.-d and drfenseles., oruai.i s , , ...,,,..u, ... .... . ... ,in ,er!c.in vef!.el laden with a cargo "J-" i ment. must, howrver. In addition ' have been dastrovrd In this vvav her Intention to shut oil all foodstuffs , .., ,,.,. .,,,,,, ..... Third Is the reply of Great Britain.!1'' '"Imltted If 01 effective "conlo-." con-1 sfan-dard hy which to measure tblr 1 with the ti.ule of neutrals in such 111.111 The Urltlh Government accepts none 1 tr'1"'"s '"fcrcourse wif the eneiw Is 1 ights or to avoid danger to theli ships tier is may In the circumstances be of thr sniri-estlona reltemiine- ,,. I ll' 'l'n, nniiouncd and ma.ntalned More- and cargoes. The paradoxical situation , deemed Just, and that full provision is .,."' '. ',' , "plover. Independently of rights arising thus creited should be changed and the made to t icllli.it.. ' Urns bv persons In.' "'"'" ........ .... 1 of l.ennnny. This note also contains vvhnt Is regarded 11s Kngland'n hft derrncr of nrw blockadr policy, an fol- ' lows: The American Ambassador nt Lon don to the Secretary of State Telegram American Hmb.issy lyiNnoN, March 15. lslf. Tollowing Is the full text of u memo, random dated March 13. which Giey handed mr to-day ; On the ::,1 of February lnt I rr. crlved a communication from your ll crllrncy of thr Idrntlc note ii,Mrried to his Majesty's Government and tn Gi. many respecting an agreement on err tain potnts as to thr conduct of thr war at sra. The reply of thr German Gov. ernmrnt to this note has been pub lished and it Is not understood trom thr reply that the German Government are prepared to abandon the practlor of sinking British merchant vessels by sub marines, and It Is evident linm their reply that thy will not abandon the use of mines for offensive punsises on the high seas as contrasted with the f "'I"" for defensive purposes only ,Vlhln cannon range of their own hi- .Kir as suggentesl hy the Govenrment 1 . . ... ... of the I'nlteil States, Slnlemrnl nf I'osltlnn, This being so, It nilp.ht appeal necessary for the BiIIIhIi Itoiemtnem lo make iiny furthrr t'pb than lo take I note of the German answer We de. ! sire, howrver, to take the opportunity of , irinklng a fuller statement of the whole ' position arid of our feeling with ree-ard I fo It We recognize with svmn.ilhv the desire of the Govi'illtnent of the I'nlted States to see the European war coniiucieii In accordance with the pre vioiiBly recogtil.eii rubs of lritrrniition.il law and the dictates of humanity. It ' Is thus that the British forces have con-' niii'teu ine war, aim we are riot aware that these forces, either naval nr mili tary, hnve laid lo their charge any Im- pioper procredlngs either In the conduct of hostllltiee or in the treatment of ptlomrs or wounded. On the Oerman' side It has been veiy different. i l. nie treatment or civilian in ami ! t ii tit h In IbOg-ium anil the north of fiance has been m.idu public by the. IMglati .mil Flench Governments and' ' by rlioso who have had experience of It I at first hand. .Modern history affords no precedent for the sufferings that have j been mulcted on the defenceless and j non-combatant population In the terri tory that has been In German military I occupation. Uvea the food of the popu Hat inn was confiscated until In Belgium in international commission largely In fluenced by American geiieroslt and conducted under American auspices came ' to the relief iif the population and ' secuted fiom the German Government a i promise to spare what food that was ; left In the country, though the Germans 1 coiitlniix to make lev es In monr.v upon the defenceless population for the sup port of the German army. Tells of Atrocities. " We have Horn time to time I reeved most terrible uei-nuntn of the barba 'oils treatment to vvhl"h British ntlicnrs and soldiers hale been exposed after they have been taken prisoner while being conveyed to Get man prison camps, tine or two nstntices have already been given to the 1'nltrd States Government founded upon authentic and tlist hand evidence which Is beyond doubt Some evidence has been received of the hard ships tn which British prisoners of win aie subjected in the prison e,intp, .oi. trusting, we believe, most unfavorably vvlii the 1 1 raiment of Grimm prisoners In this country. We have promred wit the i'onent of the fnlted States Gov ernment that j conim ssiou of I'n cl States ufllcers should In per ltt-i' ,n o'h country to inspect the trr.,t. no t 0f pr( (invent oners of war The I'nlted St lies nment have hepn unable to obtain any reply from trie Merman le-iyerum n to this priipos.il and we temaln in ioi'- tlnu.ng anxlet .ind appi c'.ieiisio' .is to the treatment of British pi Nonet war ,n German' M At the very outset of the wa. a Gentian mine laver was discovered lav Ing ,i mine Held on the high seas Pur thei mine fields have been laid froir time tn tlm without warning and. so far as we know, ate still belt ? laid Mi the high sr. is and many neutral as well as British vexels have been suni, b.v them. I nnrineil ,, mi,. t At various times during ih war G, .1111:111 sllhtnrithiev Ii im vliil,n,l r.n.l sunk British merchant vts'sK thus I m lM" the sinking ,.r merchant ves-,... . a K'ilei.il practice, though It .id. . , . .. . , , ,. hlch hung that merchant vessels if ..iptun d , ,!lf. bj. i t of the importance of In must be taken b'for. a prize court. In ,,r..,tioiiiil piote, tlon for private prop one ,-ai.f. already i.iole, in ., note to ,.rn llt ,rt,(. t f'wlng state. . mini ,-i.iir- ,- ii iii.'ui. .1 I J II inn ,--,-.-i i,iii;iii,; i ihiii.i nil s in ail unfortified tnvvn in Great Britain h.-is Ik en sunk Another ..! Is now rf- purled m which -i GeMtia-i m nasi i niis.-r ipi.i i-,i in imiu ii i i ,r-iii.i-i u nisi r I n-; lm( inK A,.r...lM XHVV, th u. . la.i, I'. 1'rye. c.u.vmg go of w.at from S.attle to (Jtieensnnvn 1 t.i i'Jes the cargoes were pie.uinablv des- tinel for the civ.! population I.'v.-n th argoes in sir-h rlrcumst.im slMulil nut have been con 'eiuned wit' out t'li" decision of ,1 lll7e court lunch less should tile VeH.el h.lVe heel sunk It 1 to be Dlltril lh.1t both ttle-e t.isrs 01 curl ed befii. t'le dUetitiull bv tile Brit ish authorities f the AVIIheimina and lier cargo o! fisidstutfs, wht'Mi the Get. i.i.. ii i". -i iiuiiii UU.-KI' is J"S"i'CO- 'i ion ror tneir own action The Ger-! , mans have announced their in'.ntlon if sinking British merchant ves-,s by i rorpeuo witnout notice and without any provision for the safety of the erevv - i oev nave aircaiiy cnrri-it out this tn llefenrelesa Tunni Hliellrd. I'nfortlfled. olieii nnd ilefncl. 10 Scarls.rough. ar mouth , 411 vvnltbv. b.ivo been ibd berately and' 'wantonly lsmb.irde. hv German ships' 'towns, sue, as Scarlsirough. Var mouth of w.i! c.msn g ,. rorne i ases ciir.sld - r:ible loss of civilian life. Ir-clurtlmr wom,V i,n;1 fldldrn , nmx umjipra , where there were mi rn'llt.irj or strate. i - ..4 ii,mi'i ....isi.uc.eii uiai iney woiiiu ne Harmless ir the.v went hi r ft urii, i niv.u .minorities till many vveel.s ..fler thr Germ m '...1 ... ..1. reiriil .ir iit..i'tii 1. of li.-ii.t' tt.i.i.u .... .1,. lileh -.'.im do It Is ni thnt the UntiKh 3ov- ..-t,.....n. ........ ,..... . ' lnteinatlon.il law which th... dpre. v,oulv maintained that foodstuffs ,e. I tin. d for the ovll tH.puI.tlon should be 1 never mterfeied with, this .ling. hePi? founded on the Mibmisslon to .1 nn? j . out t of the .-.rgo of the Wilheluurm The cousi.leintlons nfT.vtlng this cirgo ,1V .llrKllh. rwnt '., onnidnm to the Tinted st.,t, i:,,.r,,. 1 ment and I rued not lepeat them ueio I illisciiiciice of lllocl.llilf . Ill ISMUI ll US t ,f stoppage of a. foo.l. Mutfs s an ii.Imutiil c'luinifii i' of lilo. k.t'ie ,t s obvious t.iat lh'e . all lie no unreis.il rule b.L-eil on cic s.lt.i,i lions of inorallti and 'Miin.itiitv which H ennr.-.ir to this practice The right to stop rooiistutT.s destined for the evil populat on must, therefore. In ai.v case j rroru i.eiugerent action ;n ttie nature of 1 blockade some other nations dllTerinir from the opinion of the Government of the 1'clted States and Great Britain hnve held that to stop the food of the civil population H 11 natural and Ugit - mite method of bringing piessure to bear oil an enemy ixuintrv as It Is tinoi the defence of a besieged town It Is nlsr. upheld on the autrorltv of both rrince nismarcit and f ount t'.iprlv and therefore presum.iblv Is not repugnant to Germ 111 morality, rollowlng .ire the iiuotntlont from I'r'nce Bismarck and Count Ciprlvl on this point: HUmnrcl. Qnoletl, Prince Bismarck, in nnsweting in ls" an application from tho Kiel Cham ber of Comiuerie for a statement of the view of the German Government on the question of the right to declare as con traband foodstuffs lb.it were not In tended for military foires, said. "I ie ply to the I'hamlier of Commerce th.it any illeailviintage of our commercial nnd c irrvlng Interests may sijifer bv the tieatnient f rlco as cuitrabainl of win does tint Justify our opposing n measuie , " ,,1luKht ' "'ike in '',,r';"l"K ", " "'ir vv ;tr calamity entails evil consequences not onlv lurnlshes quiiik, convenient and re liable transportation tn section contalnlni? the most desirable linmev neir New Vork, I. Ive where your family cm enjoy life, Send for list of Real hstute Agents to room So. I, I4J Lib erty St., New York. , , , '"' J'"" aiiHcueu i mi ine wner Uti'jints upon commerce with Germanv 'llfy i accompanied bv the olllclal ventuie to hand I am aware of but two criticisms - i ...i.i. .t, n.. i. . .i fo, ! ..I, th.. tv ... 1, ,. i . , , luci.r cuiiiiiiviiuv, in- ..i- i.-v in 1.1 ill mis ,11 l-iiuiicil. lev vvp ci- the that have ben made in British net on i- rveti.... ... .i,. ...... foMowini- . have ,,ave. t : , ., ,.....' respects T r lit Itv of ileteimU ing action ... "J;. "V""" 'V.VCT " I-on,lon me- ,. con-iuer- ,. , undei-stoisl t .at the Br tlsh ,,n the Brltlsn and l'r'ti.'li declut - wru" ' " ""lr in the .ils.ve an, ,K(vi authorities also have laid ""inn ' o tntendnl retaliation upon coin- '"'egiam peaceable neutral anchored mines on the high s,.,, Thwv I 0 , 'r"1,, , J! , nature American Kmbassy will not have to have doi.e s... but the .. w.e. ..... I ."- !.'!:........ . ....... ..i,. London. March IS, HI.., i ul.snlotelv ...ces. .1 : ... . .. .. I OI "" l'r,lI" I i"-a-i-" " lolowinir IS the full tevt of .1 not. 9 Burglaries During the year 1914 there were many more burglaries than fires in the City of New York. It is, therefore, just as essential to carry Burg lary Insurance in this great City as it is to carry Fire Insurance. We received a greater number of burglar claims during 1914 than during any other year in the history of the Company. If you want the Best Burglary Policy in the Best Company - ask your broker to get a policy from, or apply direct to National Surety Company 115 Broadway, New York nit BROKERS' BRANCH! 71 WILLIAM STREET REMEMBER THIS: than any other surety RESOURCES OVER SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS. on 'ho combatants but ,ilo on the neu. :,ils These evils tnav easily be In i teamed by tile Inierfeten.v of a uelltial l'ovvef vvlt the was ii vvli.'H a third ,r. es oi tne war ti no ii.'.iiiv.iiH.ige if the subjeits of tin ..-rfi' li.g Power .Hid b) this means lie iit.iti commerce iiitf it be we ghteil w.th f.ti heavier iiisnis Hi. i. a tr.ins. torv P' ohitntion of H'e rue trade in Ch'ne-e w.it" The measure In iiuestinii oas fur It- objeet tlieshiirteiiiiigiiftliew.il l.v iini easing t ie ilflctlltle'' .,1 the enemy and ' Justifiable step in w.ii tfltnp.iMi.ill en- loned agaliist all neutral mps .llislltleil ll I lllll'lv I. ount I'.iptiv;. dunn a dlcuj"lon in I it... I!,.ini..n lt..1..lw!it' fi, M .ri.ll 4. 1VIL1. t .,.... , V . ountrv in.iv h dependent for her' t.iod oi fc lor raw ptoduets upon he? trade In fact It m.iv be .i i olui : v n. esai v to destlov tlie euem.v's tl.ule ' The pllV.lte IllMOiluctlO'i of jiiovjsioi- i-.t.i Paris ..rt pruli.li.te.l In ng the 'i;' and .' ti iiii' vvav i lation would he Jiist'.llei! m p-ev n:- "BLOCKADE" IS BY ENGLAND I'mirth .s the American identic note if inijulry aitdressed v the I'nlted , I.N-mr.. 'iii.l I'reit Britain , ""Klni; a more drtlnii- statement o. Just what ipe.illmu ate lntend-d In enforcement or tin- Allies policy u rutting olf all tlade with Germany and culling attention to the extralegal Urorn Germany and befoie the almvc reply to the Joint suggestions of the I'nlted States had been received. The j f10"1 reads: notr n.u The Se lean A mh Secretary of cUn to the vmei- Ambassador at Iondon ' Telegram : i j wHitisnTos. Mm U PI- I iri ffcurd to th recent wmmunua- t rm si riMifi i rnni imp iiri : .iiiii ,lrll ,j0veriimetif concernltig re' ; Uon to commerce ' While It ant-ears that the intuition i .11 i.ir.- hoth ..t,.,,i.,r ..ml lr.com. m- ti.idmg with Germanv. which is in er- fe.-t .1 blockade of German pints, tli- 1 u. of blockade that a ship atteri'.ptit g to enter or leave .1 Girman port, regard les.. of the char.ut.r of i's cargo. ina In- condemned, Is not asserted. I.iiliunnuc of tlecliiinlloii. The language 01 the declaration is "the British at.d l'rench Governments will theiefore hob. the H'eives fre to detain and take into port ships carry ing goods of niesiiiiied eiicmv destina tion, ownership or origin It i no: In. tended to cont.se ue such veswls or 1 'irgoes unless they would otheiwi-e hp. liable to condemnation " The tit st sentence el .mis 1. gilt per tain, ng on'v to .1 state o. nioi u.iue 1 ne I.I -it s. llte'Ci' pi Opoes .1 tleatlll. llt of hips and c .rgoe as if no bio. ka.le ex isted Tne two together present a pro- nosed course of action previously un known to International law As h consequence nriitrals have no declaring rowers ought to assert ' whether thev relv unon the rules rnv- rnlng a blockade or the rules appllcn hie when no blockade exists. The declaration presents other per- plexltles. Tlielnstsentenceiiuotedindiratesth.it the rules of rontraban 1 nr" to be ap. idled to cargoes detained The rill" ' covering contraband attlcles .arned In, i.eutisl bottotnsisth.it the cargoes shall. be released nnd the ships allowed to I pioceej This rule cannot under the I Hist sentence quoted be applied as to I destlnatlon What, then, is to be done with a cargo of contrabae ! goods di- talneil unde- the declaration'' The same iiieslon maj- he asked as to conditional cnntnibind citFOfs Other Com til len I Ions. Tne foregoing comments appb to ciigoe. dest ned for Germain C.ngoe- routing out of German pints ptrseni ..: other i.i-oblem under the terms of the declaration 1'nder the rules governing enrmj exports, only goods owned In - 113 I.l'l' 1 rt. enem.v suh.le-ls In eneni iKitloius are Moms olh, lals and executive committees subject to seizure and condemn. itlor, .' si t" ne, will impress upon them the Vet b tl,., dts'larallon It Is purposed to'.lutv of acting nl' Uic now mid take Into port all goods of on.stetu with the ,ec oncmv "owneishlp and origin" The . of "how ng u, ev erv . ,is , , .i..i..i.. ... . . word "origin" e imrtleiilaily slgnlllc.int .lion Im leutr.ils nH n,,,j ,e compatible The orlgi" of goods destined to neutral' with that obj. c which is sin 'iriitlv territory on neutral snips is not and stated, In establish blockade to prevent never him been a ground ror forfeltuie vessels from cum Ing goods for or isim exci.pt In case a blockade is declared Ing fio'n Germanv. nnd ma ntaiiied. What, then, would the' . Ills .Majesty's! Government have seizure amount to In the present c.is.i ex-1 felt most reluctant at tho moment of cejit to delay the delivery of the goods , Initiating a policy of blockade to exact Tlie ileclnr.it on does not Indicate what from neutral ships all f' e pen.ilt es ut iilsmstlnh would be made of such car-1 tnch'ng to a breach of blockade I., toes If owned by a neutral or If owned their desire to alleviate tho burden hy an enemy subject Would a different I vv hlch the existence of ,i state of wir rule be applied accoiding to ownership" nt set must 'ncvltably impose on neu If so, upon what principles of Interna- iral seaborne cuniineice. thev de. laie tlonnl law would il rest" And upon tl Int. ntimi lo lefrain altogether I' om what tllle, If ho blockade Is decl.iie.r the ex. r, Is,. ,,r the right lo cnnllsciite and m.iltita tied, could the eaigo of a n ns or cnigoi-s which belligerents have iieiiir.u eiiip n.uiiiig out or a i ierni.in port ne connemneu" ir It Is not con demned, vv'i nt other legal course Is there but to release It? While this Government Is fully alive to the possibility that the methods of kg - vs - Fires HV bond more people company in the world. Ing lbs ,mport o' foil and raw produ- e ' The Government of Gie.v Br tain havt fr.viM ileilated in '-on rt w.th the i.overmnetit or I'ra'i e th.r i itention to i:..ct ii ijerma'i attemp: to stop all supplies of even kind from leaving ,,i viitent.g British or Pie'irh pints by I tii,.mselves stopping o.ppl es gome to ,,, f,(,m (;,.r n.... i,,r n, ,.. , Tlir 1 Mrlllsh tlift has Instttnteil a lilnrkmle 1 , tfe rtl ell i-iiiilrollliiir hv irtil.er "eor- dim" all pii.siige In umt (nun lirriiiiiiiT ii sen. The diff letu e between the two i .Indies ,t, however, that while our oh Je't is the same as that of Germany, iiropnse to obtain it without sacrl- tl-uir tiruT.il shltis or nor.-romb.itatit i ves ,n lnniri hi, upon neuirais tne oam .ige that oust l,e entailed when a vessel and ,ts raryo ate sunk without notice, exam, nation or trial I must emphasize .ig.nu that this measuie onseiiieri' a natural a. id ne'eseary if the unprecedented meth ods repug' .ii t to all law and nmraliiy w lu b have been des. ribid above, which i 'ii.i hv neg.m to adopt at the verv out se of tlie w.ii aid 'be effe'ts of which ' -iv let i coiist.intiv a umiilalui Vine i an Ambassador lVntdoti EXPLAINED AND FRANCE inivlern nua! waif.ite. p.irtlciilatly In the I'nltisi states of t: submarine for botn defensive .mil oflet sive operations in.iv make the foi mer means of main taining a lilo, k.ole i physical impossi bility. It feejs th it it can he urged with great force that there should be also somi- limit to "the radius of activity." .mil especially so If this action by th' isji patrol In Etuopeati waters only to be hebl up by a cruiser otf New Vorlt and taken Into Halifax Bnr vN'. A similar Paris. cablegtarn was sent to ENGLAND'S REPLY. j The British rep'y to this note of In I 'le.l to-dav. and an order in council I have Just i.cf.ved from Gtey. I Ills .Majrstv s Government have bil under cnefiil consideration the In .iii"iis which, tindfi instruction" from out 1 iov ei mil, nt, voill' K. elletli'V ad .I'cs.'d to me on the vth instant regard ing t'le s, ....' and mode of application o! the measures foreshadowed m the Untie 1 and .-'tench drclnrat Ions of the 1st of M.i-ch to- restricting the trade ot Grim my Voill i:cellency explained and illustrated b .efeiir., e to certain .'optingencles the dinicultv of the I'nite.1 St ites Govertitnent lii adopting a definite attitude toward tliee measures l.y rea son of uncertainty regarding their bear- J ing upon the coiumrn of neutral cnun- tries i.' I ran at once assure vour llxcej lency tnat. siilije. t to the paramount i'eivssii,v of test' ctoig German com ic t.-e. his M iji'.'v f 1 love! iinicnt have made 11 their trsi am to minim;?.' in. oliv enti ru p t.. lent'al eo'iiipt..e l-'rolll the 111 . oiup.iii.v ing cop.v of the older i'i council, w hich Is 10 be publish, d to-. lav ou will oh-erve that a wide discretion Is afloidrd to tl.e nnze couit In itenlno? reresreu in an-, goons pi.iie.i In the 1 us ody 01 the marshal of the prize court undr th order I apprehend that the perplexities tn which voiti Kxrellency lefers will for the most .nt be .lis. -lp.it. 'd by the perusal of this document and thai it Is only necessary for me to ad 1 expl.in.itor.v observations Purpose of the Order. , ' 1 '"" effect of the order In cnutn.! ,B lo confer certain powers upon th" evecut ,v .. nMlcers of his Majesty's Gov- ' r""" 1 extent to vvh.ch those 1 !'ow '"rH wl" '" -icttMllv exerc se.l ,i. 1 degree of severlf. w th wh h tie '" '', 11 '" or I'lo. kade authorized will oe put mm operation me matters win, h i will depend on the orders iss-ied In I the Gover-ineiit and the decisions of the i Humoru es speuaiiv charged with t duty of deillnp with Indlvidiia ships and cargoes according to the merits of rich case The Cnltr.l States Govern. ment mav test .msnc,! ti. ,t .... i.. Mmotio'is to be Issued bv his Miijestv s ' Government to the fleet ami m' ti.. Utmost despatch ct In view ami SO. h enininlnr . - . ulw avn claimed m respect . ,,f bu achrs of blockade Thev restrict their claim to tho stopping of cirit es destined for or ruining fioni tho eiuniv territory. f., As regards cotton, full particulars of the arroJiKcmenUj contemplated have nlrfxidy 1 ,n explained It will be admitted that cvct.v possible tegurd lies been hud to the legitimate Interests of inerlcan cotton trade il, Finally, In teply to the penultimate paragraph of your Excellency's note, 1 have the honor to statn that It Is not Intended to Interfere with neutral ves. sets carrying enemy cargo of noncwn traljand nature outside European waters, Including the Mediterranean. American Ambassador, London. Here followed the order In council, the text of which hns already been published b.v Tut: Sr.v FRENCH REPLY. The. l'rench reply to tho American nole of Inquiry gives nn additional ex planation of Intended operations: The AmeilcHX Ambassador at Paris to the Secretary of State. Tclegtam American Embassy I'ahis. March 14, 1915. 1'ieneli Government teplles as fol .ovvs lo i letter dald March 7 your Ex. i ellency was good enough to draw my attention to the views of the Government of the I'nlted States regarding the re lent communications from the Krench and British Governments concerning a restriction to be laid upon commerce I with Germany AecoidlnR to your Ex irilency's letter the declaration made by liie allied Governments presents some iriceitalnty as legardi Its application ontiifernlng which the Government of ths . I t.lte,. .states desires to be enlightened' i'i oixler 'i determine what attitude it 1 :lou!il tui.e At the same time your Excellency . itltled me t'a.it. vv.-.ile granting the pos- , bll tv of u--!nr iiw methods of retail- it'on against the new- use to wh eh suli marinfs '.ave been mit, the Government of t.ie I'nlted States was someiV'wt np- ' prehensfve. thot the allied belligerents 1 m ght (If thei- si tiori is to be construed ar i onst.tjt tig a blockade) capture in waters near America atiy ships which, might have escaped the cruisers patrol-. ling European waters In acknowledging ' recpt of vour Excellency's communi cation, I have the l.nnor to Inform you that the Government of the republic, has lot failed to consider this po nt as1 presented by thi Government of (he I'tnted ,t..tes and I beg to specify clearly the conditions of application as fat as nr Government is concerned of tlie declaration of the m tits allied Govern- lll.l Vtelbods Discarded. As well s-t forth b.v the I'ederal Gov ernment, the old methods of blockade 1 cannot be entirely adhered to In view of thr ue Grrmanv his mule of her sub marines and also b reason of the geograph cal m tuatiou of that coti'itry In nnswe' to the challenge to the neu trals, as well as to Its own adver s.ities, contaireil in the dei taratlon by whl' h the German Inipetml Government stite.l t1 at It ro-sldired the seas sur louudlng Great Britain and the l'rench coast on the ohanriel us a mil t.ir.. zon and warned 11etur.il vesaen not to enter the same on account of th danger they would run, the allied Governments have been obliged to exam. lie what measures they could adopt to interrupt all mam tune i oirimip.. cation with the German llmpiir and 1 litis, he.), t blockaded by. th" ncval piwer of rhe two allies, at! the same time, however, safeguarding' as much us H.ssbl the legitimate In-, terrsts of neutral powers and respecting, the laws of humanity, which no crime of their enemy will indiue thern to violate. The Government of r,e republic, trerefote, reserves to itself the right of bringing into a Kretu h or allied port any ship carry ng a cargo presumed to be of German origin, deet ination nr own ership, but it will not go to th- length of seeing sny neutral ship, except m case of contraband The discharged . cargo shall not Ite. conflscatrd 1 In thr event of a neutral proving his lawful ownership of merchandise des- tined to Germany he shall be entirely free to dispose of same subject to cer- ' tain conditions In case th owner of the goods is a Germvn they shall simply be sequestrated durlne the war 1 Will .Not I oliHsi'nle. Meiohandlse of enemy origin shall onlv be sequestrated when It Is ut the same time the property of an enemy. ' Merchan ,ise belong. ng to neutrals shall be held at th- disposal of its owner to' be returned to the port of departure. As jour Kxeellency will observe, these measures, while depriving the enemy of important resources, icspect the rights of neutrals and will not In anv wav Jeopardise, private property, as even the ' enemy owner will only surfer from the 1 suspension 0f the enjov mem of bis nghrs dur'ng the term of hostilities Tlie Government of the republic being desirous of allowing neutrals every f... lilt v to enforce tlieii claims give the prize court inn independent tri bunal 1 cognizance of these questions and in onler to give the neutrals as In tie tumble as possible it has spe. tiled that th" pti?e court shall -Ive sentence I within eight 'avs, counting from the I date on which the case shall have been In ought befoie it 1 1 do not doubt. Mr. Ambassador, that ' the I'ederal Government, comparing on the one hand the unspeakable violence with which the German military Govern ment threatens neutrals, the criminal ' actions unknown in maritime annals ,ii. read pe-petr.ited against neutral prop er! v and sh.ps and even against the I ves of murals' subjects or citixen-, .11.1 ,,n 'he ot'ier hand the measures adopted bv the allle.l Governments of Trance and Greit Britain tcspecting tho laws of hu tn.inlt anil the rights of individual", w II re.ulilv prcive that the latter have not overteppe, their strict rights as bel.lg. erents 1 rinally, I am anxious to assure you ' that It Is not nnd it has never been the I Intention of the Government ot the re public to extend the action of Its crutsera against enrmv merchandise beyond Ku lopean seas, the Mediterranean Included 1 SliAnp Tndei'iphernhlei I'ode I'uhlee lo I'rrnch Colonies, The Western I non Telegraph Com pii'v announces that the codes at ntesent available fir messages to and from Trance mav be used In messages 'o and from IVench .-olonles IHILIP.C M0RRL3 tmf RLD'S OLDEST s "rfjPLAiNTL OR ' . '. CORKH iti Zf' ,4 "THE I BROWN 11 OX" (JJ i If you manufacture any thing which is sold princi pally to women arc you sure that your advertising appeals to the women folks? No "mere man" can know. That's why we have long had a capable woman on our writing staff. Gisorge Batten Company Advetl!$ing 381 4th Ave, at 27th St Boston NEW YORK Our-aw GREEN STRIPE SCOTCH Ask for the Non-refillable Bottle with the Green Stripe. ANDREW USHER A CO., Edinburgh AT A STANDSTILL No Ship Lrnvinsr V. S. for (v-. man Porls Sinco HritMi Blockndc Order. NEW CLAUSE IN POLICIF. WAsltts-rjTo.v. March 17 Bus -es ar a complete standstill in the ievf merit war risk Insurance bu-ea i . result of the Issuance of the oler council of tlie Brltlh Govtrm-e.t 1 Ing In effecr the bits kade .m.i -t many Otllcals of The hu-e. i , day thnt the reison fo" the ,na, v " that no applications for .ne'irir being made. t was undei-si ,00 Mu1ll.11 statt of atr.i.rs p-rv.i .- a marine insurance companies The fact Is, according 10 ,,'1 , -the bureau, tr.it sh.pp'ng ts. . standstill, no sii.ps an :. ivms ', man ports and none ;s 1 ';. 'v '.i . until a solution h ..1 I" . 1 . situation bioncht on hv th. B blockade orders Assist vnt Seclel.u ) ..f "1 1 Peters conferred vv- in tit" I ", - olllcl .Is to-dav w"h re'-, it . . Interests of the Will t elv I'll e 'I ' are ..fleeter! bv 1 e 1 '. 1, , .. 1 learned latei r in i ., . mi . . made in the p..' . v .. ti. i n.e that the scale .1' "ates h fier'.. , if. will be adhered to fieepite 1 ,k ingnSs Of the hill, atl to issue IPsiir however. It Is not anticipated th.r ness will improve to any exter t nil the diplomatic situation ee.n It was polnte-i out to-day thr ,k' reau never has done anv .c-.i,. volume of business 011 ship: -.k i for British ports That bus re... ti-en handled bv the mnitie ...int., most of which are lnco'poi.ite.i 1 land, and the hulk of -he hu-ice. .1 by the Government ha. been In i -si ships aid cargoes liurd fo- Genna' neutral ports ,.uch as Hotter. un I ness with German ports t,..sed tnat!'-a tv with the puhlH.i- . ' Bi.tl-b or, it rs ester.lav oe. nt-r so-called "blockin'e Inns, ,,' ., age policy issued b the buiea.i 1". beo.lllle kllinv 11 to-da thai 1 ,r lowing new provision has '.e In the foirn of policy issued . ti r s'k bureau with the vi.c .. mg anv attempt to 11. i. tie 1. , Ii. v lotatlon of neutral. t v "U aniiiittd thai t i - ir he voided If the Vest I si 1 ,e ,, s vllv U'ldertaK.-i w 1 , the triiispo" ot Indiv ..I.i 1 1. . . who aie f-mbodied In t' . .n'ceo , belligerents, or w.th tile '. transmission of int'll'st' e es of t.etllKet ent - or 1 ' lo !. e.lge of either 'lie owi.". . or the mister -he is tr. .pur, . tarv ilot.i 'htne; i of ..'.' j, t." O" mole J.ersoi s vv ho '.1'ie 111. f ' vovacr direct!' ass st th' i "i .' belligerents .1. t s'le .1- - to war Ki'c ot iiUcr" i orvv eit III ii sili ll.'lliinleil l.ospov. M.n i; I , s M.arnshlp I'mg'.-.. fron. '. . v I'operh.-igt"- wh.'h w.-i' llleir.ore, S'or'i' 1. ., h. r '. has reiched her lesim.it.,.. i .sh steamship yn P.lcar ,. ' Arthur for Cngl.md. is s' '! -A thousand t"ns .f cpg 1 , Jett'fcOne.l Plaids and checks are the tendency in this season's suit patterns. Wood-brown and blue-gray ovn plaids of subdued contrasting tone-., are some of t h r novel color design's we are featuring. Spring Suits JiS t-j til ii A 1 J45- Spring Ovcicoat i6 to $40. BrokawBrotiii. Astor naa'cVloiui!) cv" Sllbw.iV St.ttHIII .It IXtK V I. Bttrm i I -..." V. AKHfc-W ft t