The sun. [volume], October 27, 1915, Page 10, Image 10

About The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916

Image provided by: The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundation

                
THE SUN, WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 27, 1915.
George Brickley of T Hnity Eleven Protested by N. Y. U. Murray of California to Play His Tennis Here
H. Y. U. WRITES TO ROBERT LINDLEY MURRAY, TENNIS S TAR YALE MEN BEWAIL COLUMBIA TELLS WHY IT
tt Amnnm nniflwi n C I AM All F? n ATI t I m s r ri r m r , w w r r nir ama mbm I r i 4 r a r y-v y m r-s nr i r r at r r
OPEN MEETING TO
CONSIDER APPEAL
Board of ManAjrcrs to II, null,.
Kiviat-Smith Case No Mnn
Action by Com mi If or.
PROTEST BRICKLEY FflOAf CALIFORNIA, MOVES TO NEW YORK
LOSS OF ATHLETES HASN0 GAME WITH N. Y. U.
Left IrtmdPd Wondpr to Join
West Sidn Clnb and Pity
on Its Court.
RuprjrrHfs Trinity DirMlIfy
Frnfrssiniial for (.mil"
ElMtlOII Hay.
Blames Bucknell, Which Refused to Cancel Its Date
With Violet Eleven Teams Arranging Series
With Fordham and Stevens Next Year.
Disqualification of Fivp Stars
Still Is Fruitful Topic
of THucn union.
10
4
I
OMITS IKFTMTK THKK ATS i EMPLOYED FN BAYONNE
PWIvirlns; ths pnll'V nrlnntiMl ty Will
lams las writ. t!ii New York Tnlver
Ity Athlrtlc OBMMll MMMMMi yestsr
ilay aftrriuxin Unit n s ml-fcrmnl pro
tsatf ins hpoji iriit U) llis Trinity Col-
i ftu'tiity oofnmUtM on sYthsKm
mifBoptlnir llie rllsiiualinVntlnn of Ueorsja
Brloltrry, b layrr M THlUty"! NW
Tho oonraimiloatloii h prttoot rails
attention to tru, loiiir rxistinic ruatom
of holdliiK nil minimi fOOtbaJl Kama be
MWMI tho two Institutions on elrs'tlon
flar. Ak tlio next (..tnie on 1h- siheclnla
in with Trinity, nvw vork, nltbouah not
thrsatMiiiiK any rlrflnlta action for the
violation of Ih Intrn ollri-iiitr rut
which fnrl'lils thl i1m iiiK of man who
has received any remuneration for hie
athletic abllltli'K makes mention of
the fart that the faculty at the Height
liaa enfoteeil thin rule Strictly at ell
time and often lias debarred men from
rnmrsntlns. In col lew rt beianse they
were InollglblO ;u a rrsult of title regu
lation. At the same time New York l.'niver-
afty rlaurly Intimates that It la not
only Iras plnylntr of Brtekley on Tuesday
to which then' Is'an objection, hut also1
Trinity failure to comply with Iho rulM
laid down for tlm reaulatlon of amati ur
athletic teams. The note also showed
the unequal basis! upon which the inme
would ! ptayod If yruff lotla.ll were al
lowed on one tram and not the other.
It further requests that If any men on
th team are ineligible according to the
reeruiattoiiH of the Intcrcolle-rlate Ath
letic AeeiM'latlon they be removed before
NMwnbtr -
The signatures affixed to the protest
erere T. K. JOfteO, chairman of the fao
tttt committee on student orsanixations,
.antl Martin While, Hrat trie PfOOldOnl
ft the athfitic nesoclatlon.
COLUMBIA CREW IMPROVES.
Kllnrrr or I Hunch a e V hkIIt
la i. "Inn Too last.
After a layoff of three d.is. tlue to the I
.:horpy condition Of the HUdOOAi the Co
lumbia v.iixity crews ronintod practice
yeaterdnv in piopuatton for the Yale,
race oti .NovcmlaT 13. COOCtl Kice tKMited
two crews and sent .them l the river
lor nve milt. It WM the brut exhibi
tion of rowing the varsity has etiown I
since it took to tle river three weeks
mro Hill Mvers. the engineer of the
eoachlnt; launch It 00, said the flrat crew
la ffetUtie. so fast that he will have to
Uave a speedier enejlni installed.
The .lumhia Rowlnej t'lub eeint an
anawer to the propOMJ of Yale thai
both OOHoejW row two crows In the rare
on New Maeu harbor, It was decided
that in tflOW of tin trouble COaoJl Uice
has bad in ojettlnej a junior boat to work
t.wx days runnUll with the same per
sonnel It would 1 la-tter to row one
orww aajalnst the other. Columbia doee
not favor Yale entering two crews to her
one. although Vale can do tt If she
wante to.
The rnnka of the Eaatern tennis
players will receive considerable strength
ening this year 'by the addition of Robert
Llndley Murray, the ynunc Oallfomla
loft bander who made such a wonderful
record In the East In 1914. Murray,
who was graduated from the school of
chemical engineering In Leland Sanford
I'nlverelty Jut before his memorable
invasion of the Hast, has left hie home
In I'alo Alto and Is now a chemist In
the 1'aclBc Coast Borax Company works
In Bayonne, N. J. The youngster will
do his tennis playing an a member of
the 'West Side Tennis Club at Korest
Hills, I.. I , although It Is more than
likely he will not Join that organization
until the spring.
The great little left hander has been
in the Kast for the last couple of weeks
but has been kept so busy In his new
duties that he has had no it foi
tennis. As a matter of fact only a
few close followers of lawn tenuis knew
that the Palo Alto boy had made his
home in the Kast
Murray made such a brilliant allowing
en his trip here in 1914 that he. was
ranked fourth In the national list, trailing
only McLoushlln, Williams and Behr.
Hie position on the list waa two notches
above William M. Johnston, who car
ried back tho national championship
this year. The championship cups that
were inscribed with Murray's name on
his successful trip were those repsesent
Ing the New England and Metropolitan
titles.
Besides these tournaments (Murray
WDti the Sleepy Hollow Country Club
Invitation singles. In which he defeated
K..il H. Behr handily In the seml-nnal
round the Meadow Club Invitation
singles at Southampton, I Ll the l)ela-
WW . ll.-
: - -
... -..,.,. .
i
PRINCETON ALSO TALKS
IHiRKRT MNDf.KY Ml RIMY.
ware Ut ile i lamplonahlp s1ng... In
which lie hei the challenge round to
Qeoiie m Church and was rannerup
to McLoughlln for the New York Krate
ohamptonHhip.
He also competed In the national
championship at Newport, where he was
defeated by Karl Bohr after Mve hard i
sets on a terribly hot day. and In the
Seabnght Lawn renins and Cricket
i (Tub invitation singles, where he col
lapsed because of the heat In a match i
! with Williams in the round In-fore the '
; seml-nnal with the score tied at S 4. '
4 tt, & all. lie also was nmnerup to
McLoughlln In the LongWOOd ClHb in
vitation elnglos.
His record therefore shows only six
' defeats, two by Mcl.ougtiltn, ranked
number one . a technical defeat by Will4
I lams, ranked second ; an isy victory
Over Behr and a lose decision lost to
the same man, who was ranked third.
Tho only men ranked belli nd him who
succeeded In checking Ids rush were
Johnston, tho present champion, and
ileorge M. I'hurch, who lat year de
feated the champion, Williams, for the
Intercollegiate title, t'hurch heat Mur
ray on turf early 1n July before the
young California!! had a chance to get
acquaint' d with the peculiarities of play
on the grass.
Murray had little time to do any
playing 1r. California during the 191.".
season, but bn Is In good shape and
should prove a hard man to beat next
summer. It Is more than likely that he
will have a national title annexed be
fore the limner conies around, for if he
can make arrangements he will go after
tin- IndOOr CrOWn at the Seventh Begi-
ment Armory in the tournament which
begin.- February ID.
LACK OF MANAGERS
HAMPERS COLUMBIA
TO ROX FOR SIJLLTVAJJ FUND. MOTOR BOAT MEN TO MEET.
Kntrlea for rrnrrat A. ' Half of '
Several Tennis Arc Getting
Alomr as Best They Can
olf Is Dropped.
LAUREL RACING RESULTS.
LAtTRKL. Md . Oct - Tli following
r Hi; reMittf "f to4ayi rc i
Flrnt Jt.n -For mal ign t vn- mir-olils .
Mllltic; purnc I'on, Rv (urlonm May
McOee. (Rlc, trattTtl1 HO. pUe
14. Tt, ihOW 4. CO, wuni San-l Light, 109
Bil'n i:i, plftCg t 0. h'iw $.', 40 necnri'l;
Mrv Bluckwood, 1 0 4 (Hayetn, sintw f 5 4.
Wrd Tim, 1"! I ' Lctfettl. K!iiri'r.
Friar NttUffhl M uw iphon . Taitanu. BllC
of thf Kitchen. Jerry, Jr. S ml I at, Danotfifl
Moon tone and itot-niink o ran.
efecon.i Race Fnr t ere -jraar Hilda : pur
ISO1 . ix furlonga Jeorga Hmih, 121
Byrne- itralghl $: T", plire $: ;.o. ehnw
tt l", wti. Ann t. 10; ( BuxtOB , piare
J I I ahn l.'j't necond; '"'l Vennlf. 1 09
Turner' fh v. fa 1". ihlrM Time. 1.12 4-0.
Broonifctr U . Jafquetta -i tfi rernrock alo
ran
Third Rnr Handicap ; a'l ag'i ; $400
adde'l . ene mile and a Jlxtfnth Short
)ntes. 1:0 iHn'vlli straight 13 40, plae
42 40. ihow 1. won Water Hasa. 117
Rlc". place 130, show IS 40, nemnd;
Dtatant simrt. 67 (Waracher), show ft so.
Third. Tlnif t I" Koureddlni Wnoilen
Shoes a ti i ,' Bkn nv ulau ran
Fniinh Haci -The (Itrneiown Hlgh
weifriu Hand 1 1 ip; I n ell eyce; i.oo0 added 1
aiu furlongs llr i" it n- 1 1 0 (8myth)i
etralgli' I71M0 p 1 40, ehosv $11 50.
won Htfh Noon, 1 a J (Turner), place is so,
ehow l.t9, eecond; Ha neon I .'.( (Loftua),
Hho- ti.ho imm Tim.-. 1:11 lt,ik..,
AhHrei. 8tarl Ing i.ii Barbary, Tea
Caddy, Kieeeaa, lle r Pryne, Tin- and
iflupertnteiidf'ni ; 10 : m. HJarmen entry,
taddf'l ptitr:. r.
Fifth it.i" . T)ireeyear-oldi wiling;
pure oo. .me mile and twenty vardi
S'orue, 110 (Turner), r.ught s place
$4.70. ahnw $3 In. w .n , 1M rrot 1 M ink .
piac $5.ro. linvv n bo, eooond ; "n pt.
Parr, luo (Mlleyi nhow 11. third Time,
ijil l-.v rt. -i Piper, lnd plrltuelle,
Mabel Duerebar, Hurgeon, Lignte "njt Star
Bird, Bamboo idonue. Deviltry, Primary
etnd HoBHilt Orme alio ran
9x th Hat e Thrae 1 rtr r nml upD ard .
oelUnCi pursrt $ 0u . one mtl and a ls
teatitn Volant, 16)1 ia -n- itratffbt f t4,l4)(
pleoe llb.f-o. ghon 4.$fl won; Itoneheage,
ot (MtfDermoto, plaee $ ,how 4UI
fcond; Ambraati Ids 1 Mink how $4
hlrd Tlim. 1:44 n ynlnre ltrn 1
i'unardr, Iledg. 7es Ir, Bugg Around.
Hrlan Horu and DciTri etopaa ao ran
LAT0NIA RACING RESULTS.
1' S JIarier. tt, manager of the
Columbia fencing team, wae appointed
M-etenlay by the manage elections
commute,, to All a etmtlar position on
the tennirt team because of the rexlg.
nation of K. W. MoCracketl. Several
ussisiani manage falleil 10 return to
college tail fall with the reiult that
Some of the minor teaine are without
echedule make.
No one haa been appointed n yet to
rill the vacancy of crew tiunaKir Will
iam V. Walker wae elated for the honor,
nut beeairae of Ml failure to keep up
to the eeholamhlp etandard the faculty
tapandad him from participating In ex-tra-urricular
activities. Aeeietant
Manager Scofleld cannot be elected man
ager until next year so the poeltlon will
go unfilled, a state of affaire which
existed latrt year when Manager P. K.
Cobden left college.
It wan decided to drop golf from the
list of sports became of lack of inter
est in the game. Mnwr.gcr Craxen was
transferred to the hockey team. Oivlnc
to the abort age of supply of eligible men
no assistant ha been appointed to Man
ager B. V. Constant of the gymnastic
tenm.
I.A.TOWla, Ky.. Oot. . Th following
ern tii ryeulte .f u6m.r'u re-.
letrvt Hare -MtMei two-year eJda een.
tag, puree oo: fnr',ong M:ke Mul
Un, 108 (Hohlnaoni, etratght 431 no. plar.
n? Be, ahnne flr.-rt: Buay Joe, lij:, Klan
?), p' fio. shw 45 io, Moond; '.
"lr. Its? Metoalf ) , shmv 4', 0, third
Ttme, i 1 4. faeltatlAn, itunnlni Queen
Queen of the Mint. lin k West. Circulate
Jsmes Oakley and Bayenarra
Also TWII
Hmri Haer- Three ear nMa and up
ward; selling, purse 4,-en; six furlong,
lluntreas, 107 (M. Cluroneri, slralalc 4i 7n
place 44 so. aiimv ? ' tirst: Carrie Orm
17 (jeteartibi pUce u y, show $!.,(. .
eoo; Mias ieriAre. 1 is- (,ientii, anew
4, W, third. Time, 1:1! 4-1 I'haemeuae
Hoonlr, ,xnnsui;ht. ITnela Hat t. Matei
Tale Bearer, Itoadrnaetsf aaa itnUel also
ran
Thtrrl Race--Twn var nlds: purse 4-;nn
dee ssi a half furlongs satnis of pieae
.ire. I o r nuoina..ni, straight 4! in, phi,.
44.4, 4BOw 43,.r0, firm. Rig rellnw, 1 1 :
vaa T)ueT,. piaxe (4. anow 4.t 10 e
'nd: Alex OaHS, Ul (flOjrb elo.vs 41
hlrd. Time. i:07 1-4. Htiiv Cumertavn
laiehla, Tndtistn. Muriel s Pet. Paulaon,
Walch, . - . inltig. Oiuntesa Wllinnt and
Jerry nine ran,
r'ourth lia.ja Mandh.111. thrae-year-elil
and upward; purse 4D0; six furlongs -Othello,
IO Mfott), stralglit 41 1,0. i.la...
r. 4. ah. -a 44, flrei, K.i C'riunn, rja ft
,irner, pla-e 4t sh.ea 13 ."a, socon.l,
' "untliiftliaflii. JOn t Itul.lt, son 1 show tl.oO
lilrtt Time. I 12 I. use, Srlaghuret
und Uncle Jnnmle ft!so run
I'lfih Ituce Tlir.-.. yeat rdda and tin
a ard : purse 40o; one tulh- 4mafioBi 108
ill Garner), niwlgfci 47, place 11.70. iho
IL' 40. flrat; i.1uiste, 105 (Clentry), place
ti 10 show s ew aroond; UeAdoo, 10
!.. Palllei, ghow 11.10, third Time, 1
Harry I., Money Maker .nil. Hltyer Hi;:
and flrumpy ale., ran.
sixth Ilac 'rhree-yenrolda and up
t a 1 t jasllliig; ptlSM 4'."0 ; one mile and
(hiea-atxteidilhs Dude, 0l llui PidjTel,
asra.1ght 111 lix pla4-e 186. ahnw 21 80
flnat, TrHiisp.ii't. 101 f Kreblneori I. plaee
110 70, eh'rw .S, eri'nnd, Aprlsa 101
tal Oarnw). show ll.H, third Time.
14 l l MUui i). ild. Juries ,ioehal, II
inuda, OeMy, tit. rejtarlotie, "Iga Htar. Jexi
nle Oeddeea, iuci Poet nd Alston also
ran.
eleventh Rare One and thrae alitaentha
gtlleel for (bras yaar olds anil upward;
aalHBgl purta 04 Hbyaeee. 'i ' Morris I.
etiaight lio.io. plara tio. show 1,80.
ril'L B"7'"'anig in, (Rablnoen), place
,12 " J1" OOBdi lleno. 04
(awaaenai. .i.ott , In hlrd Time, 1 :.',8 4 C.
'"'"i' 1 ''' fly Hoin... teatnode.
attain .,' '"-"Se. MoWiory. Joe
Lealle Hobs Faet Half Mile.
Running from scratch Sid Leslie or
the tlfth company won the S40 yard tun
which featured the first monthly games
nf the Thirteenth Regiment last night In
the Brooklyn armory His brother W.tl
ter who had 36 yards handicap, was 10
yards behind when he reached the tape
in 1 minute Bit eeconds. The fifth com
..., 17 Dolnts on the season team
prila ami the tint company .is next
with 10.
Mone Heale Sraalon. no to IO,
The fifth game In New York city of
the Interstate Three Cushion Billiard
League was played last night at ThUm .
John Si-anlon, representing Cleveland,
played Joseph Htone. who represents
New Yolk, and Stone won 50 to I" The
score: Htone. 50; high run. 5; innings.
75 Scanlon, 40 : high run, 3 Innings, . 4
Klitynlnlfe ele Work.
The new atthlatlc oomrrdltee selected t
hv OoL Cxmley to manage the traca aim
tleld aporta In tha Wrty-nlnth nr)nient
tssan work on Monday, and with MeJ
Hhejppard In ciharg of the tnax team
an eventful eeaaon la expected. Sliep
najrd expeole to obtatn recruita from the
maxTubere of the Irlah County Socletlea.
In whtoh he hollet-eo are many unde
velrpd athlotea of merit.
TO-DAY'S LAUREL ENTRIES
Tonrnev iimhiiik nl.
The) ooinfnHtaa in i-hurn of the Suiu-
an iiK'ii m ir U-x.n-r tou i lutiiu'ht an-
rioiuioai) yeaterday i lie rramaa of tha
;iin.t!i uts who vrtll box in th olaaan to
Ih- held al t : CrtWJenl A 4'. on l-'nday
n'mlit. in t!i. .-a uii nl'lit fuiir other
l.iMcMjs Ih- pal i. n at the .New Yvrk
A. C, Th Ixixern who quajlfy at tho
t'u,.4.,iit A i" 01, Prktajf will RpiK-ar
in th finaU at the New Vork A. - on
SHt'jrJa night and those who qualify Hit
tho N'W Yurlts will k-i on at the t'tee--4i-nt
ftr the nnul on S.tuila. Thon
ranlt'd for tho Cr!Ti! .. . follow:
Mi I'nui 't i:m. i Johnston PHtabafa;;
William r. CMevoland; Tonv Vatlan,
Ii.4nt4.il. Matte Herbori and Charlie Pinker
ton. Union Vettletnent a r . Morris,
Ki't i-ni- Uouie ' m lehor, Kdacatleiial
lUanae; .1 Shields, Mnriiins-ui a. ' .
J. Co rail I aa, 9t. jiMph Ltyueuiu. a Qraaeo.
j Kleedemo and a Cbadwlck
13;. Pound Claes -Mike Sullivan, Houton.
v PokornC Clveland; u 11. ftleaaon,
Hamilton Lyceum; v Beroth, rnmn Set
tlement ; t j. .hirkiay, norcester; T 1.
fi dpli ton. Pnt rrf'n . J. Mullshi St M I
ch4?iaj toeutn; l. Pranien, Nwrk, .
Kit-in. Union Settlomenl C.i V Ryan,
Mornmselde a c j .1 Arbour, W, Mc
Ii4ii and .t Pylnn.
r.una t Qaddl, St narthoin
men a c r, Povonka, rievoland A ,
A Kaufman. Trlnlt) CI 1 1 . IahiIh Pes .
Hamilton lyeeum ; J Tu'iv. saw VTeet
Si i a , Thomae (Tbarlee und a Nelson
DRAG HUNTING RESUMED.
Long lelnnd Healalenta to I'nllnn
lloiimla Nearly Faery Kay.
Hfmpsti ap, I. I , 1 ict. 2 -I'rag hunt-in-:
h.s heeti llarlllllart oat la-nie. Inland,
and three tltnes a week, on days when
there Is to fox himtltiK. the js.ok of Bng
llsh (oshounda w-tii be us.i t.. Follow the
drag whS-h will be !n:.l over some of the
lent bunting country on lsmar leland
The fox hunting sti!! cnntlntice to lie the
m"st poimlar aport with those who atay
41 their country pines nil winter.
Inter. '.it In polo Drag renewed to-day
When .1 e-wd of Inn men started t"
woiK on the new field whi. h tin- Meadow
Ilrraik Club is to DUUd west of the later.
naUonal Raid it gag laarnnd iimt the
property was purchaaed by ciuvlaa
OoDhran, who is now in Biivopa, and
turned over to the Mindow Brook Hunt
tlub. Th.- Held will iie laJd out parallel
with the InternMlonal field. The top
soil Wae taken off to-duy and the .vork
ot imtklllK" 1r one of the "newt ticlds. in thla
country wlU b otMttpleted by snowfall.
when It will Ve covered with etruw, and
planted. By sprint it le hoped that work
can he dnni on the turf and It made to
pool so as to be played on by iat. sum
mer 1' will he called the COOftrafl
11 aid.
Innaal I onelave al Waldorf to!
Mettle Mans I'rolilema.
Tiie annual mHt:tiB of the American
I'ower Boat Vesooiatlon will he held at
the Waldorf-Astoria to-day . The dele-j
tnit.-a will meet at -' :3' o'clock this af-1
tamoon and the eeeeton will lagg through I
the a-f ternoon and evetiing. with a abort J
internnewloti for dinner
Among the ,Uertions to be discueaed I
Which hay, been aiigg-ceted b) the coun
cil aie :
The r.-per; ef the cemtnlttee t-, prepare
a plan f"r bruadeiimf the Mope md in- !
Rttenee of the ass.. flatten.
Plani t" In era aaa th. rnembershlp and
In. Dim of the .... . . ,t t'in.
shaii thr goetponenieai of the Qald 'ur
on.- mile . hampionshlp gad ether Impor j
taut races i.h al.owe.t In future, and under !
aha, elrcaaietaacee?
M.nll the meuih.-t -hip nf tl,- eouacll t.ft i
lacraaeed by Including tin- members f '
the racing commission, with vote, ami h ;
the addition of the meiuts-rs of an i I-
isory ttrnnlcal aemmrtiee. to t.e composed
of an igptri timer, th.- president of th
Assoclatl-ui of Itoat and KtiKt-ie M.inttf...
turers and a deslcner, aho shall also t.e I
ri-aular nn nihers of the council, eith vote? I
Hew can .merest in mm r mattera net
lolnlng In mo-or hoatlnn oslda from ra. -
Ina t.e stimulated?
thengei In ra Ing ru !f any
There are 111 c.i ibs In Hie MJgO .
Uon ami e4idi club le allowed lo 1 os
one repreaonfatlvs for each 1 on mam-
bent. H T. Kierner is prealdent and
Aiiert i.. Jiidem .s aoc rotary, iieie-
ir:,tes are comma from all parts -! ;he
oountry.
Nnw Havrn, Oct. !. In reply to the
criticism levelled at the Yale DOttf .Vetrs
for refusing to print comtntitilciitlons
from the undergraduates on the eligi
bility mayor, the Kne iiimouiiced to
day Hint they now were proyldcd with
shotguns and ready to defend them
etdvee. Thereupon they pointed out that
tha Invading army, composed of thoee
armed with disregarded communications,
coneleted up to thin morning of Just two
men, eo that they felt fairly optimistic
s to the outcome.
After quoting the open letter that was
posted on the Yulo campus on Sunday
and then torn down. In which tho rVetr
waa taken to task for Its f.ulure to
print communication! on the eligibility
matter from the undet graduate and
calling on tha undergraduates to Wits
tiees that In this) way the paper was
violating n Yale unwritten law, 1 no
.Vrtr rephed :
"To the section of tho student body
who have IhUg Warned us. many thanks.
Ye Bdg uo now provided with shot
guns, and, though we still need u little
practice in trench warfare, we feel on
the Whole fairly optimistic, so optimistic.
In fact, that we notice with regret that
the 'Open Letter' Is unsigned. Since
our hands are thus tied, we are Kmng
to take the privilege of addressing these
unknown gentlcnnm In thin column.
"In tho first place, we have received
JuM four rotnmunlcatioiis to date 're
lating to the eligibility episode.' One
of theso npissars this morning, find a
aecond wae suppressed at the written
request of the original writer. We have
d. tii.-d, therefor,-, 'means of expression'
to Just two men. As to our having 'vio.
l'.ited a Yale unwritten law,' we have
acted on the contrary in a, rdajiog with
a written law, a law which we took
pain.- to make dear last year. We quote
below the editorial In which wu ex
plain. si our attitude In regard to com-
munloatlone i
"'We lnite communication and nat
urally we tl.. not assume resioiisibilit)
for the sentiments Which they exprcse,
but we also reserve the right of ceifsnr
Rhlp, This grg bellevg nnriaiagijt for
two reasons. The .Yr ics is a public
nawapaper, its circulation is not limited
to members of the unlaw rally, and nc
rordlngly these problemi and affairs,
wiii.ii concern Yale only and winch are
subject to mielntorp relation and misun
derstandings on tho part of Individuals
ami newspapers who know nothing about
them are hotter left out of our col
umn. Then then is another type of
letter, uaually written thouffhtlesely and
regretted latfr, which merely gtlra the
college up and doee more harm than
good With th.--,- two eg captions we will
gladly ptinl tin- cnmmutiic! Ions which
are - tit In.' "
The conwniint, atixMl which appean
till.- luonilju; in the .Vena and i- srirnel
by three alUmnl calls for the exercise
of some common sense In this cllgihilltv
matter atul asks that If. as the official
statement of the matter by the Tale
Athletic Assoelntlon states, the Violation
of rules wae dug to "the cafateaafteagg
The fact that Columbia and New York
University will not meet In a regularly
scheduled football game this year Is
blamed on Ituckncll College, According
to the Columbia verelon, which became
public yesterday. Hue knell, say the
Columbia authorities, stoutly refused to
cancel Its game with New York Uni
versity this fall when New York Uni
versity and Columbia both asked for It
ho that they could play a game as an
outgrowth of the resumption of foot
ball at Columbia after ten years in exile.
It was said that New York Univer
sity was willing to cate-d the game and
help Columbia perform the titanic task
of building a echedulo after most of
tho colleges already bad announced
their cards for the year, but Ituckncll
held on to Iho contract and refused to
MWtd a helping hand to the badly handi
capped ,'olumbla team. It Is said that
three colleges, the name of which were
not annOUnOgd, were w illing to take New
York University's pln-e on tho Bucknell
schedule, but all were turned tlown.
In order to prevent a elmilar occurrence
next year, plans aro now under way to
arrange a series of framem among Co
lumbia. New' York University, Fordham
and Me Vang, The New York University
game Is nlready contracted for. although
no Official announcement to the effect has
been made as yet.
The practice echelon between Columbia
and New York University will ! plnye.1
of Its offloers and oommltteeay tfhat tho
officers and ,otnmltteea confseaae,lly
guilty should have been rsu'rlflced and
not the players; that It was up to therm
to withdraw and let the players remain.
The communication was as follows:
"iVivt able Yale athletes of otherwise
Unblemished reinrtatlon have been led
to withdraw from competition In Ititer
OoUogsate athletics on account of brief
And Inadvertent violation of n rule of
doubtful value This violation was due,
according to tho chairman and treas
urer of tho Y'ule University Athletic As
sociation, to the 'carelessness of Its of
fice tw and committees.'
"It seotno to us that thla punishment,
while It may lit the crime, has missed
the criminal The action taken sug
gests an almost hysterica! and perhaps
even vaimclnrious martyrdom, with mis
choice of martyrs. The officers and
OommltteeS confessedly guilty should
have Withdrawn' If any one had to be
Sacrificed and not the athletes unless,
after full OOrafeaeksn of the morally jrullt-
less braaofi of m: gome coiiteat&A! hav
ing n right to obJOOt (If there are nny
su. in had objected something which
s-erne very ampfOtsable.
The matntenanoa of high standards
of armvtaur athletics does not nooaagarlty
require the abandonment of common
sense Tttagl ammxi.
I'yr.MlNOTON. Oonn . 1 '.-toher II, lf)H."
Thursday at Ohio Kiebl. Both Coaoh
Mctitalf and Coach Itellly are anxious
to sec how much their teams hates im
proved or declined since their liust meal
ing The Columbia coaches be 1 1 ewe that
I lie New York University lost to Haver
lord Sal unlay lasausc of overwork, and
feel tlsu In bringing tho Violet team
tlown to Mouth Field they helped bring on
tills condition, especially since Kordham
played Hetlly's clan the next day.
Hulwinkin mid Kornsund. two men
who have been on the hospital list for
weeks, appeared III uniform yesterday.
lJulwinkol was the Columbia varsity
centre until he fractures! Ids shoulder.
Cat. Knuirts .SliiMmds treld out his
liijuicd leg, and It trcetned as good as
ever. The , .... ilrllled tho nuui
mostly in lax-kllng. The hacks took the
ball and had to run t. t five tacklcm
lliusl up one aehiikl the other In ordeir
lo speed up fdsefr dislging tucXlcs. An
hour was dovirtcd to covering punts.
Since Theodore Witlilngton, Harvard
191, 'i, has been wnrklng on the lino It lias
la-en IniprovtiiK every day. Witlilngton
has been teaching tho 1 la ughton tricks in
tho Columns ay, Mad. He was urged to vol
unteer his eorvloew by Charley Hann.
another former Harvard Hnetnan, wan ,s
a law Mtu. lent at Columbia. It was stibl
that as soon as he Is through with Ids
campaign spas oh eg HaatnMt4B Fisth, tho
star of all Harvard tackleav will coins
dOWII from I'utntun county AJid tadp
whip iho Columbia team Into shafie lr
the Trinity rtnd Wesleyan gatissa
of Wednesday morning, sehlch print
below.
Here is 'he categorical editorial from Hie
JaJe Neva, entitled "Abstdut'ly I'n-
foun.le,t" :
"tit the gossip of the campus. In the
prs-a f yoeter.lav. It wae rumored that
Princeton seas responsible for the investi
gation of the eligibility .f Mllhurn. Kaaton,
le-eore. Pumpe..' and Hhett. that Prince
ll brought the faOXS to the attention of
th V I'nlverelty AUlletl. ASM, latlon.
and even that the net ion of these live men
in withdrawing from the ajUrerelti teama
wae .I.e. to pressure brought o, bear hv
Prlncston Tlm rumor Is absolutely un
founded Wo p..k. with authority, for
An. I see ,ir glad to be able to print
this niornlDg th ofMal statement from
Princeton made b Lsean M th ,n thai
1 ale t.s-.g action on her own Inltkaalve and
without any suggestion from ua. a a s
Prlneeton has mad" no protest of any eort 1
"The dleoovery that the men had broken
the eligibility rule aaa made by a, ale
man. The facta of the ease whl'fi were
given out v eater. lay a ere brought before
th Tele authorities hy the men tatemeolvos
under no preesuie from Princeton or any
one else. To credit this rumor is to deny
the facts It l. moreover, unjust to
Princeton ind to Vn.ie. and. most impor
tant of a.l. i- -,,hs the Ave man concerned
of the ere, lit they d-eerve for the splendid
way t bey hte a led throughout."
T ie Prln. . ton tindergnadunre ,la1!y
; i eg apgpai hits pirtdlehed an eslttonal dls
I claiming all I'SaponalbilMry on the part of
I Princeton or I'rlnceton nen "or tha up
heaval at Yale The editorial saya:
UtSOM'TKI.Y CVieot-VDED''
PrtnostoS Will be graufled at the stand
k-ii ! the rale v'e-vs in their erli-orta'
Cliff Haven Oolfera al Oakland.
Thirty-five members of the CHfT Ha
ven Golf Club partu-'iiated yeeterday
lh a tournament at the Oakland Oolf
Club. I'. J. O'leeary won the low thirty
six hole net prlxo with a card of 207
I'l, 1 (ienrgw J. OlllesplA was sec
ond with 19s 1. 1ST. The low net
morning prize was won by I. 8. Mas
tersen, with !'.' 4, M, Thomas J. Corbett
being second with 10. 20, . In the
afternoon the elghte n hole net prize
was won by .1 H. Murphy, with 111
24. 91, Thomas Kagan being second with
9.1 1. 2.
MATHEWS TELLS Ills sK
Tliere is llltle chance thai the rsgia.
trstlon committee of the MetropuHtag
Association of the A. A. V, :ll -a-open
the cases of Abel I!. KlVlal km
Harry J. Smith, so that 1f these athlettl
want vdndlcntlon they will have t ,.
pend on the appeal to the board nf
managers of the association f
verdict of the committee whi. I ,e i,,-:
them Ineligible from further romp,. .
tion as amateurs.
Under tho A. A. V rules the glhlstes
sra entitled to be heajd oti arial
and Frederick W. Itublen president nf
the Metropolitan Asuocintion, said ya
terdy that the apptiratbsi thai
appeal be Ireard In open meeting f ,,,,
board of managers would be aranted
The data for the ffsMtltal wii he
lected as soon as It Is post- I1, to , tVB
the proceedings at the reglstralion o.rn
mitteo's Investigation lypawrlllen, Th
rulsi call for ten days notice f tha
meeting lo be given, go that In nil
probability It will be at leaM to oval,,
before the appeal Is beard
ileorge I'. Mathews, chairman of tha
registration committee said that he nag
preparing a statement In reply to thn;
Issued by the Irish American A. C, and
meantime gave his personal Views sa
to the futility of asking the o min e'.,
for reopening the cases. He s.-iid that
matter would haws to be decided I 1
the committee, but that he for nna mu
against It. As a matter nf fa-t tVt
committee lmd practically derided
it on the second right of the Invest,
gation, when It voted ndverseiv ,- H
ouestlon of leaving the ease ,an f r
further Inquiry.
The oil airman called attention Is
fait that Klvlat and Smith had every
opportunity to explain the . . .. .'
stances which led to their cards he,
cancelled. Mathews's statement in, r
gard to the adjournment is Mt variance
with that of John T. I tooling. Nfio
tains that he Infoiiie.i that ejen-, ';,,
that he would be busy on most i Is
up to NcAettiher I, Mathews m
other hand says tha: Itsding loW httg
any night would h,. lallSfactor) lo hha
and the s,oiier the .et , r.
The chaJnnan Insisted 'hat Klvlat ,- I
Smith had been treated With every oens
Mderation. that under the rul, I the 01
mittee could .have SUgpended them on
Die first night of the lfivestlea,tlon for
rifuslng to answer questions, put to
them, on the second night they eo-. J
have boon suspended ftar net sppearirig
and that doitens of athletes had be. a
eo suspended In the pag . Instead the
committee decided ;o mike the ll
ligation thorough and get af t . v. -a.
before taking action, He also called
attention to the presence of Murray
bert. one of the counsel for the athletic,
on the second niht. Mr. Hul atrt was
conversant with the testimony SAlblTrKtsd
on the opening night and had he tlim
srlshed to cross-examine Campbell and
the other witnesses be had the ercer
tunlty to do no.
MEN ON ARKANSAS EXCEL.
In. U Tars of Wynmlnii antl '!
0tla.ri In Trark Med.
The atJilt4a if the V. S S Aikian-
.-; far 1 off the tej.ni trophy In the
it initial haniplon-jhlp Inti-rnhlp athlerlr
met of th Kirt rlvlnlon of th At
lantlc flf-et hi-Ul In thfl KymnaMiutn of
t in Sa ntin a-itrert Navy v M C, a,
Brooklyili "trrilav. Tim moii of thll
m.in-o'-war ti:i1 llttl dlfflculty Wfnnlllf
th teant prlM witii tin larff total of
4.t points. Tha V, s. s Wyomlnj and
I" S S Te'xa Anlahad atCOnd and thlnl
raapaotlvelyi with 11 and 10 point each
The Victorious tram made a clean
iWeap in the ion and 2-U yurd '1a.'hts,
won nix of the I'itii' event h and wax
p la COd In all wive one K I lenyey of
the Arhnnia.1 provad ths itar parformar,
trlumphtiui ttirtoa. Ha won tha half
and one mile ninn ami llandlni hroal
jump
ennnuv
UUUUIIJI
eao.u.s pat orr ;4f
inuiuii
BASOIINI
'OIL C0J
STANDARD OlLCO.ST NY.
VirS
lonre:
Kn.lle Henry
dancer
s.i.'onr
I.aity Atkln
Altaillr ,
Wmslalone
1 .'ii;, ...
t'liurehlll
Rae Purse two year olds
III Wenonah
Ht.Vlrstnla M. ...
Ill Sehoolhor ....
Itsi Fratiklin
ltw WlrarCI
11: Seyilbsn
11; lldiku
110
St .siii.l Kace purse; two jiir si
..ne half flurlOIWS:
..I lit Ranibl
it, iiot I4S Hroomaaie
Ilari Idl Lord Hnekvale.
Favour l(W Lorac
Ihtlil'itl nil neniamin
Tuilaii Hi immune
Fairwaaiaas ... hbi
Third Rave -Handicap: for all sgea:
f uridines I
Hie Wats. i Back Hay
in. ttanaoii m.
113 Water I.ectr
IM lurawlntendent ....
in? l.uekhorn
liiu lairnae
Ill Keiiillinlae
I'n.k
1 auliite Notions..
lafontreaof
ll'ixy
t'npra
Iteyhiiiirn
Iliiuacuiatd
tWIlSOn entry
Fntirth Race Purer: for aJI ages: one mile
Surpriauiif HE. Knakaakia 108
K ..hi.. 1114 Ktmer Qorden
Push wussg NiMlar star
Ilia, k Coffee l sandman ll
Ilnlierl Bradley . II! St Rock
r n h Rasas IslUng; ail aiea . fllllea
iiiiireH; one mile anil twenty yards:
VI patience
101 In.
tia'r.'iirlavrrocg
as l.aura
H" Mlaa Sherwood ...
1": snrinama
i'ir fiimelha
nil
Suth Uses-tlelb rut ; tor three year olda ami
iipwurtl: one mile and a quarter:
O M Mlllsr U4lPsrth Rock
ady Hryn
Tirl
Koae Juliette
Life
Sinai
Tiars
iiuaina ,,
Jewel nf Alls
Jawbone
apatty Kegaa...
Sul. her
Healer
Mlaa Sherwood
(Vnteurl
The Romp
s A tap rent Ice
olaimsd
lOtiisTom HaiK-oek
Hi2,sHarry Lauder.
... lOOI'NaijIer
.... Kill Hutchison..
.... Ill Cordie P
. ... 104 saawan
.... lool
allots sues ef Bts
ail tirr- asa-amf,
w ml
tea i l
lit; a
115 mmmmm
110
via '
,.....
.re and
m
)S4 ' II
ion i II
18 I
'"'
all
111
l"ti II
let I l
I
and III
mi III
r i I
R L
Get Spring Delivery Now
At The Present Price
Months ago Chalmers foresaw the big demand for
touring cars and an advance in raw material prices.
The demand developed and Chalmers production in
creased 300 per cent.
Now here's the present situation the price of the
Chalmers Six-40 Touring car is based on previous
prices of raw material.
The same car mads from material bought in to-day's market would
cost nssrly $100.00 mors -and materials ars still advancing.
It seems to tie the sensible thing to do Is to buy your touring car
now rsther than wsit until Spring when prices may advanca.
You csn use the csr through iho bssutiful Kail months and get
in sonis Ane trips bsfors snow Miss.
Come in end ssa this car then drive it yourself
inai it is a wondertul car at ths prlts.
Chalmers Motor Co. of New York, Inc.
Broadway and 50th Sir sot 'Phono 2980 Circle
Braafclra-Bedford Asa. and Felloe Si.
'Panne 370O Bedford
Jeroos Cils 2S2T Bealssatd
'Phase 1543 alorsea
tseerse Slows, General Masaser
pound
""""'rft.imi
you II admit II
1 1
The Sign ofa
Reliable Dealer
andtheWorld
Best Gasoline
caution
The Red, White and
Blue SOCONV sign is
displayed hy all deal
ers authorized to sell
SOCONV Moior Gas
oline. beware of mis
representation. If it
isn't SOCONV it isn't
the Standard Oil Com
pany of New Vork's
Casoline. I .ook for the
weekly Bulletins con
taininillistofSOCONY dealers.
GasologueNo. 7
"Do you believe in signs?"
"Sometimes. Why?"
"Because I've watched you on
this tour and whenever you
want gasoline you always look
for a sign. Isn't that so?"
"Yes, it's the SOCONY Sign."
"An advertisement?"
"Yes, and a guide post, too. It
means safety first when it
comes to gasoline buying."
"Then you're always sure of
getting good gasoline if you look
for the SOCONY Sign?"
"You're sure of getting not only good
gasoline, but the same? gasoline wherever
you go. That saves carburetor adjust
ments, carbon and other troubles.
SOCONY Motor Gasoline is a straight
distilled product, absolutely uniform,
every drop like every other drop. It's a
clean fuel, powerful and quick starting."
"But I never heard of SOCONY before."
"You've heard of the Standard Oil
Company of New York, haven't you?
Well, SOCONY is the name of the
Standard Oil Company of New York's
gasoline and it's the only name that
their gasoline product is now sold
under. '
STANDARD OIL CO. OF NFW VORK
Principal office
New York Buffalo Albany Boston
... a il r.n
stab