Newspaper Page Text
mrmrnxm i; SPORTS FINAL SPORTS JL JLA NJra.JL imtut t VOL. I NO. 8 tf PHILADEIiPHIiSrR 1AY, DECEMBER 21, 1014. pmom one oBm: ConmonT, 10H,r tn rcstio Ltoou CouriNt. GERMAN LINE FLUSfi BACK BY ADVANCE ON RODLERS Flanders' Town Menaced by Furious Drive From Ypres Vigorous Offensive on River Somme Makes Notable Progress Toward Peronne German Guns Wrecked by Heavy bombardment and Trench Lines Taken by Infantry Attack Dix mude Reported Evacuated by Invaders 100th Day of Great Battle. , Reports from he Franco-Belgian battle line indicate that, from the sea to the River Somme, the Allies' of fensive is being pressed steadily and that some important gains have been made at strategic points. The ad vance against Roulers is being main tained with such determination that that Flemish city, which has been one of the chief objectives of the Allies' drive, is now being bombarded by the heaviest Anglo-French artillery. Farther south, in the vicinity of Lens, the Allies announce important gains, their lines being now but 2yi miles northwest of that town. On the Somme also' the advance is making progress, German trenches having been captured and German guns dismounted east of Alhcrt, in the drive on Peronne. The capture of trenches from the Allies and the taking of a number of prisoners near La Bassee is reported in today's official report from Berlin. The report also announces' the re pulse of a desperate charge by the French northeast of Chalons and the taking of an important position at four-de-Fans. in the Argonne. French attacks northwest of Verdun have failed completely, the German General Staff announces. " The great battle in France and Bel gium, which began as the Battle of the Ajsne, has now been in progress just 100 days without any decisive ad vantage having been gained by either side Pounding at the Russian centre in i Concluded on race Four THE WEATHER Gosb. what a day! How In tho world can one be peace ful on earth and practlc rood will to men when on Is slopping around tba office on 'a pair of sponges tied to "each foot end with the bade of one's collar ilka a wet bath towel. And Christmas shopping on a day like this I The leas said about that the better. FORECAST For Philadelphia 'and vicinity Clouds and unsettled tonight, fallout, ed by fair and colder Tuesday; wtpaV erate variable, winds becoming fresh, westerly. , For details, see page, Observations at Philadelphia JSJ"1 - ...KwtS.lO t Minimum tjprtu . , . ,'" ,, .. . Sor& Almanac of the Dav ffKytsiw;;;;;" ; :;;: fSfs-g- 7&"r.zr.::z:z2&tit 2- Lamps to B XJglitVd tatsraad olhTrijUUi..., Jp., Win KT RJUHMONn fWC k. H U H aV l22JS-. -.s:- CNwntUT m&aanr dbim ?. a.ssia. h. Mar uota irovi il.: - WHMliMaim, OFFICIAL WAR REPORTS FBENCH During tha dnv or December 50 there was nothing Important to report In Belgium except some process in tha region of Lombnertzyde-St. Gcorgca and to the southeast of Korteker Intl (Southeast of Dlxsclloote), the occui potion of romg houses nt Sownrtclcm (south of Zlllebekc) and tho bombard ment by the enemy of tho hospital nt Ypres Between the Ls nnd the Alsne wo captured a forest near the road of Alx-Noulcttes-Souchez and occupied nlso nil the first line of the Herman trenches between that road nnd the first houses of Notre Dame de Lorctto (southwest of Loos). Tho enemy bombarded Arras. Our hea,vy artillery silenced that at the enemy In fecrnl combats. To the north of Carney (east of Albert) It wrecked tho German trenches nnd overthrew two pieces of a bnttery placed near Horn (southeast of Car hey). It likewise gained the advan tage on tho Alsne nnd In tho sector of Rhelms. In the Champagne region In the region of Prosnos, of Perthes and of Beausejour. ns well as In the Argpnne, we have made appreciable gains on our whole front. This Is practically true to the northeast of Beausejour, where we have taken 1200 yards of tho enemy's trenches. In the forest of Grurie wo blew up four sapping mines and hnve es tablished ourselves In tho excava tions. Between the Argonno and tho Jleuso we havd made progress on nil tho front, notably In the region of Vorlennes, where wo have advanced BOO metres beyond the heights nnd In the roglon 'of Oercourt-Bcthlncourt. On the right bank of the Mouse wo have gained ground upon the heights two kilometres (1U mllra), west of Brabant and In tha forest of Consen voe. In conclusion, wo have made slight progress on tho heights' of the Meuse, and In the forest of Chevaliers to the northeast of Fort de Cojon. 1 GERMAN French attacks at Nleuport were re pulsed jesterday. They were also re pulsed between tho mnal and La Bassee. We nttacked the positions of the Anglo-Indian troops. We stormed and captured their trenches and dis lodged them from their positions with heavy losses. f ' We captured one cannon, five ma chine guns, two mine throwers and 272 English and Indian prisoners, In cluding 10 officers, Tho trenches which were lost to the enemy on December 18 near Notre Dame de Lorretta, were recaptured, In the neighborhood of Sllppes, north east of Chalops. the French attacked rlcrcely yesterday, and In one place penetrated as far as the outer trench es. Their attacks broke down under our fire. We captured four French olllcers and 310 men. A large number of dead Frenchmen were left lying In front of our positions. In, tho Argonno wo captured an lm ptrtant wooded hill at Four-de-Parls, taking three machine ,cun, one re volver sun and 275 prisoners. Fierce French attacks northwest of Verdun failed completely,'. y ' , In Cast and West Prussia the situa tion Ja unchanged. In Poland we con tinue to make attacks agajnst the enemy's positions AUSTRIAN In the Carpathians the enemy's ad vanced troops in the district of tha Latorcia (In northern HiinBary, north of Munkacs) were repulsed yesterday. To the northwest of Lupkow Pass (east of the Dukla Pass) a great bat tle Is developing. Our attack on the front, comprising Krosno and Zakll czyn (In Gallcla, between Cracow and Przenysl), has gained ground every where. In the Blala Valley our troops have advanced to Tuchow (south of Tarnow). The battle along the lower Dunajec (southwest of Tarnow) con tinues. The Russians recently appeared with strong forces In Qallcla. In south Poland they have reached the Nlda River. RUSSIAN On the left bank of the Vistula, on tho front of the Bsura and Raw a Rivers, a number of encounters, some of them of a very fierce description, took place on the 10th Instant. Two German companies which crossed the Bsura, near the village of Dakhova, qn a half-burned bridge were Immediately attacked by our troops and annihilated. Of this force only W men remained. These we made prisoners. Fighting also la reported in the , region of Opoczno, 25 miles to the east of Plotrkow. In Gallcla the situation Is without Important change. At certain points we have made counter-attacks and captured some prisoners and machine guns. GERMAN CRUISER-REPORTED SUNK OFF SCOTLAND liondon Also Bears of Damage to Two British Destroyers. LONDON, Deo. SI. Rumors, entirely unconfirmed from an official source, wero-ln circulation here this afternoon that a German cruiser had been "sunki off th coast of Scotland, It Is reported further that two British destroyers' have arrived at Lelth badly damaged. , ( 'in ' i PANIC IN N. Y. SUBWAY Trifling-Blaze Causes Passengers to. , Stampede. NJIW YORJ, jrfec. H.-Two tralnload of passengers w thrown Into a pan! In the subway today aa the reauit of a small Wae, caused by water rti tha rails, whlsh ruled the Kd stmt station with smoke. Flame bc$aa pretplny up the ! side 9f one or the- car and the pa$. sengers Immediately stampeded far the pjatfora. Sevwal women fainted at tho ixlls. When thorst xHemat seemed to be passln a second train pujisd In and Its pissencer MUrgtd out to th jat form. JimmlJi: the aock. M&aita wra slla and quhkly quet)fc4 tU blase, HIP1-I ISIJSJI I MWIIJ IIS SfSSJSSW scat xmim BAKT SIA-ag ' 'IIP '" 'p'WB Wouoaa Sfctpwtfci to Glv SntBd Jury Important CIum. MWr TOSK. Dec. .-! fuAtehwf I tiw Ur at Br&.Ht BMC inmy &sssstt AstsMAssM4 IlLsB sfllf nsftllW a i M tre-- i i j l ill M i I MUST RETURN TO NEW fRK FOR TRIAL ON i i 1 1 i ii i &i .a&iBmmt&"m . . m rmmm: "A'T"tr nssmmsmims W'iW s ' -ft 4K"K2 mJ. ,1 " - 'Wv-ggra? -" s v x . .Ak '', ')L i .i-- t!slsBBVissBWJBVsBBBbtS. , - J?.3mB1bMBssmb wsm' - , . .mmL'. v ' . . , . jMg&SBM : ' ' jsHsHHUBsStliiBSsk VS.. " ' '' S'lW:SS." 4 .SsssssssslslssHvsflK T ' ' "" ' 1 fKiL 1 iissssBHK;ti:Ss5i PL ' k iSsjssf lBsssssBHHHiXMf5i T ; iv-Y fsHi 1 lysBsSsnsiHizKBsHssssssHB 7K'MJ - iafe IK ai 1 UslBBSBBSssPQKsa&BLBScWPV jSR9BsbIHsbbbbbbbbsbbbbbbbHsbbbbS 11 1 IBsslsmHsBSBsvV JHHiHMHI IRS H ssssssssssssssssssssHsssssHsHsinBssssssssHsssssssisss 'liio o.. .w uiJies ttuprcne Court decides case unpiecedenteu in legal annais ov ruling that the slayer of Stanford White may be extradited from New Hampshire, thus reversing the United States Court in that State, which granted the fugitive a writ of habeas corpus. P. R. R. SUBMITTED HEW RATES 8 DAYS PRIOR TO DECISION Schedules Allowed by State Show Collusion Between Railroads and Commis sioners, Commuters Say. NEW CHARGE AGAINST PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Public hearing held In Philadelphia, December 10 and 11. Decision by Pennsylvania Commls. slon on December 12. Changes ordered by the Commission In Its decision December 12 sent to the Interstate Commerce Commission by -the- Pennsylvania Railroad Com pany on December 4.. v Interstate Commerce Commission approved; new rates on December 10, the day the hearing began In Phila delphia. Charges of collusion between the Pennsylvania Public Service Commis sioners and the railroads to be based upon this new evidence. Proof that the new passenger tariff schedules for the three railroads enter In? Philadelphia, approved by the Penn sylvania Public Service Commission on December 12. were submitted to the Inter state Commerce Commission at Washing ton almost a week before even the hear ing on the rate case began In Philadel phia was obtained today by attorneys for the commuters. On December 1 the Pennsylvania Hall road Company tiled with the Commission at Washington an application to make the very rate changes ordered by the Pennsylvania Commission on (Decem ber n. On December 10. the date on which the publls hearing began before the Com mission In this city, the Commission in Washington put Its stamp of approval on the changes proposed by the Penn sylvania Railroad. Whlla Commissioner Emory It. Johnson admitted last week that the commlsstcn had given the railroads an advance Up on their decision and that a conference had been held even prior to the public hearing In the City Hall, It was not known until today that the railroads had been advised even before the hearing what the new rates would-be. On December 1 the commission ani nounced from Harrlsburs that it would, hear the compjahits of the commuters in this city on December 10. From the evi dence gathered by the attorneys today a. secret conference must have been held, with the railroad officials immediately; after It was decided to grant a hearing,, they declare, The Pennsylvania Commission, however,. In Its effort to exact justice for tha peo ple; decided to grant the railroads even! more than was asked. In the request filed with- the Insterstate Board the Pennsylvania Railroad signified Its wlN Ingness to continue the 100-trlp tickets at an Increased rate to be good for a yar from the data of issue. The Penn- s)lvan!a Commission In its decision ruled that the tickets should be good for six months only. In this respect alone does tha order of the Pennsylvania Board differ from tho tariffs tiled at Washington a week earlier by tho Pennsylvania Railroad. COMMUTERS ALLKQB COLLUSION This evidence jhowing the course fol lowed by the Pennsylvania Board In Ha attempt to adjust the controversy be tween the commuters and the railroads same to life today In a letter from 0orge B. Mairjty, secretary of the Interstate Gommajrco Commission, to, Edwin M. Abbott, attorney for the com routers. T rtVlth this pew paroof $f alleged col-. Concluded tua Vaj Two BtSASB'S SCMAS PARDONS ii in up ii mu - Many Erlsoaws i& Soufh. Caroliaa. Jaila to Be yrd. dCARLSfOK. & a, Deo. .0ovj--moe Cate Bisais today 4w op bis iUt of cswtsAfAM sumacs, a4 & a reautt were io a sf 9t saati who hav baea oonvlctsd at artatafwUI eat Ualr CtrUi- inw at taaM. T afjgr bmb- pMSBtiriktatitMyrtitfj I ui Mt bx mm-4- " - llssfssssssssK T' ' , ilK "Billy" Sunday Page The story of Evangelist Sun day's life and work, and all the plans arid organization, for his Philadelphia campaign will be told in special articles, with illustrations, to be published tomorrow. Boy Scouts' Activities Beginning tomorrow special de partments will be devoted to the man-building Boy Scout movement in Philadelphia in the Evening. Ledger. All scout activities will be reported regularly in this depart ment Watch for both these big fea tures in the Evening Ledger Tomorrow "$1,000,000 BRIDE" CAUSES ARREST OF MOTHER-IMAlin Mrs. William F. Donaldson and Her Maid Accused of Assault Counter Charge of False Arrest. Another chapter In the Donaldson do mestic controversy was enacted late this afternoon when Mrs. Evelyn Donaldson swore out a arrant for the arrest of her mother-in-law, Mrs. William I'. Don aldson, 2003 Chestnut street, and Miss Fanny Blanc, her maid, charging assault and battery. The warrant was Issued by Magistrate Beaton and was accepted by M. Hampton Todd, counsel for Mrs. William Donald son, after Constable Duffy, of the Magis trate's court, failed to gain admittance to the Chestnut street home. The hear ing Is set for tomorrow at 12 o'clock. A summons was also Issued In behalf of Mrs. William Ddnaldson by Judge Brown, of the Municipal Court, charging false arrest by the young Mrs. Donald son. The amount of damages desired will be named later. A writ of habeas corpus was allowed by Judge Brown to show cause why the elder Mrs. Donaldson should not turn the child over to Mrs. Evelyn Donaldson. The latter, when seen In the office of her attorney, John R. K. Scott, this afternoon, said she did not want to cause her mother-in-law trouble, but simply wanted possession of her child. "I have a right to the custody of my little girl six months out of the year, and I came all the way from London to see her. It almost breaks my heart to have her kept front me, and I shall not stop until I once more clasp her In my arms." The younger Mrs. Donaldson was an rested on Saturday afternoon when she called at the Donaldson home for tho child. Little Dorothy, 7 years old, has been staying with her grandmother for, some time and her mother has been spending most of her time- In Europe. ' Mrs. Donaldson obtained a divorce fremi Keith Donaldson at Reno, but the little daughter It was agreed, was to live with her for only six months of tho year and with Mr. Donaldson the other six months. Aa the time has arrived for her to take charge cf the ohlld, she went to the Donaldson residence, on Chestnut street, Saturday, for her daughter When a French maid refused her ad rolttance, It was charged that she forced her way In and struck and scratched the maid, Mrs. W. "T. Donaldson called In a policeman and Mrs. Hvelyn Donaldson was taken to City Halt She denied tba charges and was released after she had signed a bond for tM to keep the peae. EducatiQji and the Lawmakers J" i n si j ii ii In tomorrow" Evening Ladgcr will be prated a notable article on the prapcU of acttaft by tbe aw Legislature af Pennsylvania oa Vo-artpK-l NtHt$9, It is from tfee pee of N. C. SCHAjEFFKR State Supritn4at of Public In struction, than wfeesn no man in die 0awmtk if better ijiwli" M4 to m&m tit topic uader feagWy fcffld with authority EaJJturtal fae. CONSPIRACY CHARGE ii I, HARRY THAW LOSES IN HIGHEST COURT; MUST STAND TRIAL d Supreme Bench Decides He Is a Fugitive From Justice and Orders Extradition to New-York State. PROGRESS OF EVENTS IN THE THAW CASE June 25, 1906-AStanford White shot by Thaw In Madison Square Roof Garden. January 23, 1907 Thaw's trial be nun. April 5, 1907 Commission appoint ed to.examlno Thaw's sanity, April 12 1807 Thaw " Jury dls-' agreed, seven to flva In favor of con viction. January 6, 1908 Second trial beaun. February 1, 1908 Verdict "not oullty" on account of Insanity. Auoust 17, 1913 Thaw escaped from, Matteawan Asylum. Auoust 18, 1915 Captured at Cotl cook, Canada. September 10, 1913 Deported from Canada, as "undesirable alien," to Colebrook, N. H. September 13, 1913 Thaw not writ of habeas corpus to avoid being re turned to New York. April 14, 1149 Thaw won habeas corpus suit In New Hampshire, but was denied ball. May 8, 1914 New Hampshire Fed. eral Court brdered Thaw released In custody of Sheriff pendlno appeal to Supreme Court. June 15, 1914 Supreme Court de nled application for ball pending ap peal. December 21, 1914 Supreme Court orders Thaw extradited to New York for trial on conspiracy charge. Estimated total of Thaw's expenses to date, 5063,000. WASHINGTON'. Dec. 21.-Harry K. Thaw, slayer of Stanford White, has lost hla fight for liberty In the United States Supreme Court. Ills extradition to New York State frotn Now Hampshire waa ordered by the court today. Thaw must stand trial on the charge of conspiracy to escape from tho Matteawan Asylum, on which ha was Indicted In New York, following his sensational night to Canada and thence to New Hampshire on August 17, 1913. He may stay in New Hampshire for 30 days unless his at torneys consent to his removal sooner, Tho Supreme Court reversed the decision of Federal District Judge Aldrlch, of New Hampshire, who granted Thaw a writ of habeas corpus. "Whether Thaw is re turned to Matteawan depends 'upon tho New Tork authorities. His attorneys de clare that If he Is not tried on the con spiracy charge, or should attempts bo made to hold him aa a lunatlo In the asylum, another application for a writ of habeas corpus will be made. Nearly all tho points made by Thaw's counsel, former Secretary of. State Phil ander C. Knox and former Governor Stone, of Pennsylvania, ere overruled In the opinion, which was handed dawn by Justice Holmes. "Thaw was a fugitive from justice; be was charged with a real srime, and it Is for a Jury of tho State of New York, after consideration of the law of tha State of Kw York. t determine whether or sot he waa tnasne at the time of hla act. and whether he la guilty of a crime against tha laws of New York," said Jus tice Holmea "Thaw l not ot trial hare." DBCLARBD HKHTIVB FROM JUSTICE "It baa been allaged la the arguments of the attorneys f of, Thaw thtt it waa no ofiaaa far a matt in an Insane usyjua in tho State of New York t walk out if ha could do so." oattwM4 JwMaa ltolwsa. TtaaMlore.-it waa coatenAed. it waa bo erima to conspire to de tfeM (Mag, But tfeat 4aa ut Bacaaaariiy foUaw. "It la as a uriuie for a twaoa to watU hoM Ma sres frasa a eariate stag, but If a sMimfear of pajaesa aaBaplra Uy K&aar to wKhtaald tbatr patresage. froca that shop it becomes a ooaapUacy rnsri able by taw "Tharefore wa are obliged to hold that tfe wUbdwi of Thaw fro aa ia aaaa iiftm, luaawuUi aa It 414 otrujt tha law. waa a eocapkacy tor that pu. uaa, s4 tsMtacttuaaUy ife Htoffnum as yktaa tkg tt f He Tor WWJlti W Mmt Thaw Wi. ta Jw York EXPLOSION OF DYNAMITE DESTROYS SIGHT OF BOY Blaekhandcra Blamed "for Wrecking Catharine Street Tenement. An explosion of dynamlto destroyed the eyes of a evcn-year-old boy and wrecked a tenement at 810 Catharine street today. Six other sticks of dynamite found under tho eves started the police on a. search for the block banders believed to havo set the explosive. The Injured boy Is Morris Dlcecco, whoso parents live In the house Mrs. George Azemoro, his nunt, who also re sides there, believes tho dynamite was planted by men who are hostile to her husband because he refused to sell them tho house. The boy was playing with his sister nnd cousin on tho fourth floor when tho djnnmlte exploded. Tho force of It threw him down a flight of stairs. The lad was taken to the Pennsylvania Hospital. Tho other children were merely bruised. A great crowd gathered outside In tho street. rollccmen Fitzmaurleo and Peter Cohen ran into the house. On the fourth floor they found tho greater part of the roof blown nway nnd tho stairs choked with debris Fltzmaurice, who nas digging about In tho ruins, suddenly drew out an unexploded stick of dynamite. Investiga tion brought five moro to light. They uero all damp and harmless from the rain v,hlch had leaked through the roof. 1'ollco believe the black handers cut a hole through the roof and then dropped dynamite Into tho eaves. BRITISH AND JAPANESE LAND ON PANAMA COAST Say Thoy Seek German Station, But May Bo Taking on War Supplies. PANAMA, Dee. 21. American officials of the Panama Canal today received In formation that shoro parties had been landed by a British and Japanese cruiser In the vicinity of San Miguel Bay, on the Pacific coast of Panama. The landing parties said they were looking for a German signal station. It was suggested, however, that supplies were being taken on board the warships. ORDERED BY COURT TO PAY HIS WIFE $60 A WEEK "Keely Cure" Agent Protests Because of Effect of "Billy" Sunday's Work. The largest order for wife maintenance on record In the local courts was Issued today by Judge B.rown In the marital relations branch pf the Municipal Court, requlrlnx the payment of $60 a week, by Jnmes'Nelsonnuraon f'Ils-wlfa-fqr her support. Burson Is exclusive Pennsyl vania agent for tho "Keely cure" for Inebriety. Burson protested against the order, saying since. "Billy" Sunday's visit to Pittsburgh the Keely institution In that city had not been paying expenses. He said a "sobriety wave" had resulted a .poor business for his concern all over the State. Witnesses called by Congressman-elect John n. K. Scott, representing Mrs. Burson, said Sunday had boomed the "cure" business, as many of his con verts took the treatment. The Bursoiis were married 13 years ago. They disagreed from the, beginning, it was Bald, and 1907 rhey separated. Mrs. Burson said her husband carried econ omy too far. Thirty minutes nfter they were wed, she said, he berated her for wasting Boap by leaving It In the water after she had washed her hands. He was generally Irritating, she maintained. Her allowance was systematically re duced under various pretenses, Mrs. Bur son said. After giving her testimony she collapsed In court. SET MOTHER'S BEDS AFIRE First Drive Aged Woman Prom Her Home. Philip Heavy, of 430T Ludlow street, waa taken from the University Hospital late this afternoon to the 3A1 and Woodland avenue police station to answer for his actions of last night, when he la said to havo forced hla TO-year-old mother to leave her home and then set fire to two beds, two chairs, a couch and a settee. According to the police, the man was intoxicated and threatened to kill any one who attempted to enter the building after he had set lire to it. Battalion Chief Michael Walsh and Lieutenant Sweeney, of trust No. 6, broke into the building and found him overcome by smoke. Mrs. Harriet Iteavey Bald today she would not appear to testify against her son. FRANK LOSES AGAIN Denied Certificate of "Reasonable Doubt" for Appeal. ATLANTA. Go,, Dee. zt.-Federal Judge William T Newman, before whom the latest move In the Leo M Frank caee waa made Saturday, today declined to grant a certificate stating that In his opinion there was probable cause for an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States In the habeas corpus proceedings. Justice Newman refused the applica tion for the writ Saturday, COAL SUITS DISMISSED ii isp-nm pi s i U, S. Judge Deoldes No Cause of Ac tion Against Iiehlgh Valley. NBW YORK. Deo. M. Federal Judge Hough this afternoon dismissed the Gov ernment'.! Sherman law monopoly suit against tha Lehigh. Valley Railroad Cam jkany and a number of other defendants etigagsd la the raining and transportation oft hard eeal "No rnooapely of interstate corameroe is shown nor any attempt to monopolize, the option says. "Blase tha railroad.' dissolution coatret th caal earners nave B9 means of reatrahai." MAW KIHiED BY PLY WHHBL A fait agalast a Sir wheal U the Uj rtsoe Cbaateai Warka, t Mth uat aa Gray's Ferry Raad. aa&d tha tUt death at Xtofco-Vie Huta, X ya aR wfcaaa adsttaaa la uaksvawR- BtapaVii head waa araahsa. He wu pmruwnetil dead by yayeioNMaa at thtstvrtty Hos pital PesnnTtYawie1!' sstftiijMs a Tmil ABHINOTON. &a -Tht tteuae lu of yawtfcei wstto ' t-msimss, D ,' ta (i4viuQUttt iaibi, m isaiwi-eatU ; . tivt lite 0HMa! Umm a Gunloii iAVo. $10,000,00 SOTS MAY BROUGHT BY COALMEN Reparation Under Act Creating Public Service Commision May Be Sought From Pennsyl vania and Philadelphia and Reading Loeb .Delays City Bid. Feared Mining Companies and Retail Dealers May Reach Out for Benefits of Anthracite Rate Cut. Decision Causes Rr R. Stock Drop. FACTS OP COAIi BATE' DECISION IN BMEF ...Ne.w York' vvn,ch "o nearer to the Pennsylvania hard coal fields than it '! cJiy' '" netting Its coal from Z5 to 50 cents a ton cheaper. Stove and egoi coal there sell for 7 a ton. Chestnut for iris. Pea for $8.25. Prices here aret Stove coal, $7.23. Ego coal, $7, Nut coal, $7.50. Pea coal, $5.50. Direct saving of $1,500,000 to con sumer If coal dealers cut retail price by 40 cents a inn. .J?1 y .b.8 u9d r "MM J t.",w,vw, uj, acaiera as reparation for present rate, covering period jof c'y holds up bids for 81,00000,1 "!' v ooiain oenent or lower rates under tho decision. FlDht for cut In rates took more," than two years, Harry E. Dellls, Harold's. .Bhertt-and Ward VWPler' son, tho latter two attorneys,, con ducted it, with four business men's organizations. Sults for nearly $10,000,000 may he started against the Pennsylvania and Pblladel phla and Heading Railway Companies tor reparation covering a period of six years, when the decision of the State Public Service Commission ordering a cut of 40 cents per ton on the hard coal rata to this city goes Into effect. The act creating the Public Service Commission makes It clear that when any decision of the commission shows an over charge or an unjust discriminatory charge has been made, the sufferer may fU action for reparation, from the time the commission was created. The common law, according to attorneys, equally Is plain In providing six years as the period for which reparatlon'foc a discriminatory charge may be sought Statements to this effect by coal dealers and attorneys were the Jstest develop ments today In the decision of the com mission after the two-year fight waged against the high coal rates from tha Pennsylvania anthracite fields to this city. IiATV MAT NOT BE ATTACKED. Strong intimations that no action to attack the constitutionality of the act creating the State Public Service Com mission would ba taken either by the Phil. adelphla and Reading or the Pennsylvania Railroads were given today by counsel for the companies. George Stuart Pat terson, general solicitor for the PcnnSyt. vanla, said he had heard of no movement along that Una and said ha doubted that such action would be taken. A similar statement was made by Charles Heebner, general counsel for tha Beading. Neither would say any fight would bs made, but coal men and others Interested expect (he railroads to contest the ordr of the commission, which Is to be isyii today or tomorrow. The two attorneys named said that If action ware taken H probably would be along the Una of as) appeal against the order of the ooaiwW sion. Tha Immediate effect of the dsaiatoN upon the stock market today waa Ubs. Pennsylvania waa quoted at WU. wtoeti la U off Saturday's quotation, 11A Valley fell on one and a quarter to Uth Heading oeoimea one ana a quarter to !&. Tba deoMa had mora Jfct oa tha general list than tha Jataratate Owis tserea 5 per oant. Increase decision, HITS BIS COAL DEALERS It also waa painted out today by ooat deaaf that th smaller &rm will gm. a dUU advaatag over their brsr eompetltafB unless asm adntant i made. Sosae of the big daalera hy ftssu qoaJadd e H " HpmiiUHtragr is )-.& Airs W . Sf F JV Mr si, t&t & HjJt tula M, t VhUj.- i iii t iU a 4 ke Wh&$z. &p If w- US i s4 tf sn assSgSBSSsamiri i -rnila, XQ8T AND iDma YiitlyM s wLanwa VfcIi- sfBdi S Wisf In p IJteT LUSVF Pi i nr- mc aarifjg qe.& Ii i ft m -t i 1 ajr wzi a&ms p's'WigfiWP fiSsBt tvutic4 traa f I si Attay rf "v jf stadia '- " J. IM. --