Newspaper Page Text
1 mU " ; W7Tnot often Jr m SLl&fr' A A tf M1WTfli 1 we want another -sig man- ' 'H jMBj wiiK.?." anything I . 4 1 ri 1 vf 1 rcaF NT M TO fill a big JOD, Tmeo TO B ., ,.n nf.pn H - - few . fflL fl A. .a. A v , 1 a , a. a y a. Is the tlrr-t r-cntence In n f j l-vnr- nder- tcIvt,Hfd""0r'r o man "hS I 4k 1 BP 1 y&W M rflA tisemcnt In lho current Issue or ah eni.- MwiSh Prclll?''"sVe i nn t roallv M 1 IB 1 33, 1' 1 8 lavm 1 ir lkN W7 nVffl fl era periodical. This la one of fc.ir M.ntlnr PAVJ HEitlcien"" 1 n,lv,,cn aHve Umt he Is JJP 11 fr jjW-l I I 1 Fffi Ij-W lX ll I 1 III 1 I i 11 MS ajlvertlaemonls -In tho one Issue. I tfrter Swltl ..JjtlefH'to t J 1 I 1 7& lm 11 11 (k ffl Bll VL 1 11111 11 i throughout ViS'landfor w"jo1L ''tiI' ' ffcjou KnoWwViiVs hto prln" fcM WJ V-WllL ft UltL "li B .1 ll wL mT g 11 SLllEL 1 IIM . ft- IIL A. biggest Jobs the rommcrehU world 'h:. 1. up and success is" the )9 yN TVV f V sK 7 ever k(nyn and at the biggest salarl. :, T JhHc tnw-s it ui' tt V y I y I l What an Inspiration to the young loiter HI imyy1"'' ' . x - V V. no barrier hut the limit of lite Indttatry. 1 -rl ' ' H yniNO 113. weather today Gcnoraiiy fair. , SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH, TUESDAY MORNINQ-, FEBRUARY 9, 1909. 12 PAGES FIVE CENTS. H piTAGl . Kres to Be Fair With the Test, but Not to Irritate K Japanese Nation. RE64TI0N OF STUDENTS would violate the ait Lis That People 'of Cali Smia Leave Problem to flic M Federal Government. I I- 'Fobi .sr"Tbc ,f tho administration is to com 10 mnximum of efficiency m iZ tho real object Tvh.cl. the of the Pacific slope have at rill! tho minimum of friction nblo, whilo tlio miscuided men dvocaie such action as this ,Thich I protest arc following TThich combines the very mini t efficiency with the maximum H, ami -which, ivhilo .totally to' acWovo any Teal result for et niifbt accomplish au infinity lis lanRuaKO President oosc hr, in a long tcleKrani to . p A. Stanton ol tho - Cah i.jcmblv. sot orlh ilio govern view ot' the Japanese- school Cause of Complaint, president, states that the ibll it cause for irritation, and that eminent would be oblipcd nn lr to lako net ion in the I ed its in lest such legislation bc ; is held to bo clearly a viola thc treaty obligations of the States. The telegram to Speaker was sent onlv after a confer ith Senator Flint, and Repre o Kahn of California and P. e o the Interstate Commerce pcaker Stanton the president ! following: nst there will bo no misumler ; of the federal government's ! Wo arc zealously endeavor ;iiard the interest of California tho entire west in aceordanco s desires of our western people, udlr agreement- with .lajmn wo r carrying out a policy vhich, ecting tho interests and desires Pacific slope, is yet coinpat t niorcly with mutual selt-re-ut witli mutual estoeni and ad i between tlio Americans and 4w iEC3 the Japanese. ilh Japanese covernmeut is loyally ;ja poad faith doing its pnrt to f. ont this policy, precisely as the intan Roveruraent is doing. Tho f nims at mutuality and obligation isbavinr. (accordance with it the purpose is , tno Japanese shall como lioro cx F as Aincricaus po to Japan, is, in cfTect. that travolern, stu persons engaged iu international Jte, men who sojourn for pleasure or, and tho like, shall have the. access from one country to a li ft and shall bo sure of the best wart, hut that there shall ho no mcnt in mass by tho pcoplo of country in the other, pi""? the last six months under iPHcr, more Japanese havo loft tcmilry than have como in and the "rawer in the United States has mta by ovor two thousnnd. These F"0 .absolutory accurato and not he impeached. Tu other words, i present policy is consistently WW and works as well iu th fu Wl 18 uow working, all difficul .m causes for friction will disap nt,tuo same time each na & I5.t.a,n its Bolf respect and Sv. Ti!" o,tho othor- ut such Si?5S 8cho1 accomplishes SlV-01?111? whatever in tho lino o object aimed at and givcH inst e causo for iritatiou; while, Kini 110 F,niterl States govorn P Wold bo obliged immediately to LinAi08.1? -the fotleml courts to Jdr ,Pi3lxR.t,on' aa wo hold it to bo 'Jit' a violation of tho treatv. dKu SoferB to Decisions. lXnnl Pinfc 1 rofcr 5Tou to the wpwions of tho United States OThvjniol11 " 7eK;iTfl t0 stato laws W 0 trej.ty obligations of tho iWSm w J''6 KIation would nW'h nothing boneficial, and SHidpf - y causo Homo mischiof Mfif 5i,an8?. Vor Pr,lVQ ""schicf. 'm$il pol,.cy of tho administra 9Bcan JomP?no. tl"J maximum of HXk'. Kr nn10 tho rofl1 object L"10 .? lho Pncific 8 opo MS S1 tbo minimum of ,2,!wh af?Ycato such action JBffiir T ini- wl15, 1 Protest, are SKn&m.r.0110? wJ,Ich combines tho um?mi of, efficiency witli tho 1!K a;nL1"8u,t., "d which, whilo w' oSR ac ,x.ey a,iy roal rc- im fnC4Lafld0'lt 0f Eosult- fro what V? Kvninent fails lo Wfi tho Wv5 now achieving, then, tM MS it ' sro that tho Will III ,nrl nC,0P, f Cali' f effo f?'01 f,?;0"- Ir- Speaker, wish to I . 10 ,,CI,, nf ft'lone S ,i,llU'r wlli"h thi i3 .fArra, if Lt " good and may of iinir.xt ynp nr two the lifrwnt wSl lh" Prnve.that tho ar- vCrtoi " S r P"ovanoo, and for itf hs nreni. v,mt'0".'H ' govcrn- iKBSt o? i"iiWOr.ni-T well and riijm f. 1P t0 chnngo it, atul MRS. LEf SWEARS HUSOANDJEAT HER Double Divorce Suit of Promi nent St. Louis People At tracting Attention. LBMP'S SIDE APPEARS ON CROSS-EXAMINATION Wife Admits She Wrote Letter . That DiH Not Express Devotion. ST. LOUIS, "eb. " Tho divorce suits which Lillian Handlan Lcmp and her husbaiul, "William K. Lomp, .'Jr., son of tho millionaire grower, filed against each othor, camo to t vial iu the St. Louis circuit court today beforo Judgo Hitchcock. ' Tho case has at tracted wido attention, and when tho proceedings began a largo audience of fashionably attired men and women was present. Tho suit for divorce, for alimony and for custody of J. G. Lomp Ut was filed by Mrs. Lcmp, but immediately thereafter Mr. Lemp filed a cross bill, also asking for divorce and tho cus tody of tho child. Mrs. Lemp nsks no stipulated sum in alimony, Sho says her husband is worth $1,500,000 and lias an income of $50,000 a vcar, and sho asks enough to support herself and. licr child com-fortablv. i Alleged Acts of Cruelty. Mrs. Lemp was tho first witness. She told how Lemp beat her in the bath room of thoir homo until sho had to barricade herself in her room. She de clared ho derided her when she told their son thero was a God. Mrs. Lemp also told how her husband had often threatened her with a re volver; how ho had a dotcctivc trail her; how ho had locked her out of her home, and how once he had moved out to furnituro whilo she was absent. On cross-examination Mrs. Lcmp said that her husband had taught her to smoke cigarettes after their marriage. Tlio religious education of the bo' was ono of tho main causes of differ ence., according to Mrs. Lemp's testi mony. She asserted that sho had had the boy baptized in-tho "Roman Catholic phurcli, despite his father's wishes to tho contrary, but added that she had told Mr Lemp of her intontion to have this ceremony performed. Quarrel Over Religion. It was brought out that two ante nuptial agreements, had been entered into. Ono bound Mrs. Lcmp not to interfere in tho religious training of an3 child until ho was 7 years old, and the othor, signed in the presence of an archbishop, bound Mr. Lemp not to ob icct to tho Catholic baptism of a child. Both documents bear the same date, and it is tho contentions of Mr. Lemp's attorneys that Mrs. Letnp's agreement was subsequent to the. other, and super seded it. A lotter was introduced in evidence which was found by Mr. Lemp among his wifo's private papers. It was ad dressed to "My Dour Little Pal," and contained this sontonco: "Ilo is going hunting next week, nnd I wish to hoaveu ho never would return.' ' Mrs, Lomp acknowledged that nho had written tho letter, but explained that sho had done so in an effort to find out who had been tampering with hor private papors. Sho said that tho lotter was a decoy, and had been so placod that her husband wjould sco it if ho searched her desk. Sho acknowl edged that tho "ho" referred to in the letter was her husband. STEEL TRUST' SEEKING VANADIUM IN UTAH. Special to Tho Tribune. 2sTEW YORK, Fob. '8. 1909. A Colo rado mining company closed a contract with tho United States Steol Corpora tion subsidiary companies on Friday for all the vanadium oreB which tho pro ducers can 6hip during tho current 3oar Tho first shipment is to bo mado in April. Tho only occurrences of vana dium ores in commercially workablo quantities in this country aro in Colo rado, Utah nnd Wyoming. In Utah tlio vanadium occurs as roscoelito, tho vanadium mica, sandstone. The principal uso for vanadium is in connection with chronium, to increase tho tensilo strength of stool. Vanadium steol is becoming more and moro in de mand for railroad and automobile axles and high speed machinery parts. The United States Steel corporation is on the outlook for tho good vanadium yielding properties, as tho uso of forro-vanad-diuin is being specified in many steel consuming trades. HEADY FOR TESTIMONY IN TRIAL OF COFFEY SAN FRANCISCO. Feb. S- A. jury haviu" been secured last weok, tho actual" trial of formor Supervisor M. "W. Coffey, charged with accepting a bribe of $'1000 to voto for a trolloy franchise for the United Railroads, was begun today in Judgo Dnnno's depart ment of tho Superior court. District Attorney Cook mado tho opening statement for the prosecution, outlining the facts the state proposed to prove, which substantially aro tho snmo as are allccd in tho caso of Patrick Cal hourn, president of the United Kail roads, accused of offering bribes to tlio Sehmitz board of supervisors, now on trial before Judgo Lnwlor. Prominent Printer Dies. BUTTE. TUonl.. Feb. .S. Robert .Shields, for many years organizer for this district of tlio International Typo graphical union, and known to the print ing cruris throughout tho Rocky moun tain mates, died yesterday In &t. Joseph. yU)., used 38. of pneumonia. , ' WILL THE VACCINATION TAKE? '""'1 ELKS HF SALT LAKE BEACH US MuElES AH Members of Big Party Well and Happy, Having Time of Their Lives. .Special to The Tribune. LOS ANGELES, Cal., Feb. S.- With ove.o' ono in tho best; of spirits and health, tho" big excursion of Elks ar rived in Los Angeles this evening from Salt Lako City. No. So, Salt Lake, is tho guest of No. 00, Los Angeles, and for a week tho an tiered folk from Utah will bo the object of all tho at tention thoir brothers and sisters here can bestow. There wero four trainloads in the excursion in all, and when i In? hotel proprietors saw tho number they wore at their wits end. Late tonight, how ever, all had been accommodated, and unless the rain, which began falling this evening, interferes with outdoor events, the visitors will sec pretty much all of southoru California. Next Sun day the guests will go to San Diego, and crossing the bonder into Mexico, will witness a bull tight at Tia Juana. With tho ostrich farms, the citrus fruit groves. Mount Lowe and a trip on tlio briny to Cajalina Island they will not lack for sight-seeing, whilo tho hospitality that is dispouscd at the rooms of the local lodge is warranted to euro homo sickness and tho blues A. J. Daavis, exalted ruler of tho Salt Lake lodge, was the spokesman in tho presentation of a beautiful loving "cup to the Los Angeles lodge. Davis saw to it that the token was ovcrtlow ing with German champagne. BOULDER WRECKS TRAIN AND TIES UP TRAFFIC GRAND JUNCTION, Colo, Feb. S. A wost-bound extra freight train which loft hero at 5 p. m. vestordav ran into a rock slido between Rubv; and "Wcstwatcr, Utah, thirty miles west of here, last night. Brakcman Orou Spencer was instantly killed and Fire man C. R. McLeod seriously scalded and bruised. Tho others of the train crow escaped uninjured. Thirteen froight cars wero demolished. It was slated this morning that tho main line will probably bo blockod for two days as a result of the wreck. Hast bouud and west-bound passenger trains arc meeting at tho wreck-, where passengers, mail and baggage are transferred. The boulder which dropped on tho track weighed several tons, and had it dropped an hour earlier east bound passenger train No. (" would probably havo been wreckod. Railroad men havo been expecting this particular boulder to fall for years. BUSINESS MEN DEFEND THE SLAYER OF WALTON MTSSOULA, Mont., Fob. S. A spe cial to tho Missoulinn from Wallace, Idaho, says: Asking that tho court deal with len der mercy toward .lohn 11. Crndlobntich of Wallace, who shot and killed Fred Walton, also of Wallace, on tho street of Denver, Colo., last weok, members of tho -city council, tho count offi cials and local business men have signed a lengthy petition which will bo ad dressed io tho prosecuting attorney at Denver. After giving a history of tho affairs leading up to tho killing and speaking in turms of pnuso of Cradle baugh's steady habits and devotion to his family, the, petition declares that Crndlobaugh did only what "any other man would have done under tho cir cumstances, in trying to right, the wrongs done him in tlio breaking up of his home and family.-" Index to Today's Tribune I ! r Departments. Page -I-, -j. Editorial 1 -j- -! Society . :- Minus G -I' v- JnlCTinounlaln : S v Markets U I- .?. ! Domestic. 4- - President outlines policy on anil- -! Japanese legislation 1 -I- Prexldent uigi'fi congress to re- v qulri wlroli'.ss telegraphy for ! v ocean hi on mens 1 Elks of Salt Lake roach L.os An- 1' gele.s, well and happy I -2 Mrs. I.enip tells on stand story -r ot alleged cruelly of husband.. 1 I- Tlaco war situation In Pittsburg grows more serious 1 4 President says lie prefers to Ig- J. noru ninny charges made v against him 1 : v Local. Council Is after Salt l.ako clubs. 1 Dr. Albert I'enck, nolcd scientist, -I- visits city 2 Utah TJghl and Railway com- - puny wants fninchlso extended In county 12 -I- j. Penilng is given live years moro. 12 V Saloonkeepers to bo called on - J- carpet 12 v Prohibition discussion Is hot one 12 County board up against it 12 j v Sporting News. ' v I Baseball league Is assured 0 Jeffries and Johnson create much v -. talk 0 Lamv la considered ice chain- 4 pion 0 v Emervvllle favorites are beaten. . ') n Valuable wild-animal lantern slides are stolen from Shields.. 0 ' PRESIDENT PREFERS 10 IGNORE CHARGES Says Story of His Striking Horse of Young Woman Was Too Absurd. LOS ANGELES, Feb. S. Mrs. A. W. Rhodes of this city, whoso daughter was mentioned in the Washington story which was widely circulated to tho offect that Prosidcnt Roosevelt had struck tho young lady's horse while riding past her in the road, has re ceived tho following letter from the president nn the subject: My Dear Mrs. Rhodes: r thank you for "your leltor or the L'Jtth ultimo, and urn glad to hear from you that your daugh ter denied the story that 1 struck her horse. Of course, I never struck her horse or any other lady's horse. Tbo whole story wus so absurd as not to bo worth denial. Numerous stories of this kind arc started from times to llnio by foolish or malicious people, Occasion ally I au obliged to deny them, but as a Viilo I find It best simply lo Ignore them, because denying thom calls atten tion to thorn and gives n cbanco to mls-ehlef-mukors to mislead well inclining people by further repolltlons of the stories. Sincerely yours, THEODORE ROOSEVELT. K-:-rW-HK-HI-W'KW'H' I- GIRL OF EIGHT YEARS TAKES HER OWN LIFE .i. jt, .. VITTSBURG. Feb. S.At Bolivar Saturday, May Estella, -J-I eight years old, committed sui- v cide. She grieved over the -I I- denth of lior mother. "Papa. I r -I- am going to shoot, " sho said, ; -I- nnd before he had time to v -I realize tho meaning of tho r words, the. girl fired a bullet ! into her tcmplo. j RAGE- SITUATION II P1TTSBUHB SERIOUS Judge Who Has Sentenced Negro Assailants of Women Is Threatened. PITTSBURG. Fob. 8. Many persons gathered in the vicinity of tho oast end police station this morning, believing that, .lames Dickson, a negro arrested Saturday night for insulting a white woman and who narrowly escaped being lynched by an infuriated crowd, would be given a hearing. Owing to tho ina bility of tho young woman to appear against the negro until tomorrow tho case- was postponed. When an attempt was mado Saturday night by a plain clothes officer to ar rest. Dickson, the negro knocked tho officer down and fought so desperately that the policeman's clothes wore al most torn oil". The fight attracted a largo crowd which becamo threaten ing when it was learned that Dickson had itisultcd a whilo woman. Throw ing the negro to tlio ground the officer drew his revolver and held tho crowd off until a, squad of police camo to the rescue. Magistrate Brady, who has sentenced a number of negroes to long terms in the workhouse during tho past week, today received an anonymous letter ad vising him to be more leniont in deal ing with negroes or ho would meet with violence. Notwithstanding tho stringent meas ures taken by the authorities, a ma jority of tho negro population is de fiant and there is apparentb no abate ment Of assaults against whito women. CHARGED WITH STEALING FROM THE INDIANS Gl'TIITE, Okla., Feb. 8. Samuel Mc Gowan of Degraff, Kan., ono of tho best known Indian authorities in the country, was arrested 'hero today on a federal grand jury indictment, charg ing him with cmbozzlemont and misap propriation of federal funds while su perintendent of tho Indian school at Chiloeco. Okln., from 1901 to 1908. lie was released on bond. Tho indictmonts, which woro re turned Friday last, consist, of nine counts alleging emblezxlement and five for making alleged false vouchers. The charges allege that McGowan con verted money belonging to tho Indians to his own uso and also took grain and livestock, nnd that ho mado false vouchers, thereby securing money from tlio United States subtroasiiry "at St. Louis. There. is an alleged shortage of i?lf00, nnd tho indictmetns intimate that an additional sum was wrongfully secured. , Agents of the. federal government have been working on the McGowan accounts for almost a year, and the in dictments were based on their report. McGowan was superintendent of the fovornmcnt's Indian exhibit at tlio jouisiana Purchase exposition at St. Louis, and at the timo of his arrest was preparing to go to Seattle to take charge of a similar exhibit during the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific exposition. WILL INVESTIGATE WHY CRIMINAL WAS RELEASED BUTTE, Feb. S Tho police commis sion today set Thursdny as tho dato for lho investigation of tho illegal release of Jean Dubois, a notorious "whito slave" dealer. Dubois was under son tonco of the local courts and in addi tion was being held for the fcdoral au thorities, who wished to prosecute un der that act which prohibits bringing women into America for immoral pur poses. City Detective Batos last week gavo Dubois his freedom without au thority and tlio Frenchman disappeared and cannot be located. PRESIBEHT gIVES WI8ELESSA BOOST Urges -Congress to Pass Law Re quiring Proper Equipment of Ocean Steamers. POINTS OUT VALUE IN PRESERVATION OF LIFE Compliments American Inven tors Upon Great Progress in Practical Workings. WASHINGTON, Feb. S. To prevent the loss of life by catastrophes at sea, such as so nearly happened when tho liner Republic went down recently, tho president today sent to congress a mes sage, urging the passage of a bill simi lnr to that, introduced by "Representa tive Burke of Pennsylvania, requiring the equipment of ocean-going vessels with a wireless telegraph apparatus. Before sending tho mcssago, tho president conferred with Mr. Burke on the subject. The president had been advised hy the commissioner of navi gation that, in hiu opinion, such legis lation was most urgently demanded, and he argued in strong language tho passage of this or a similar bill. The message follows: Text of Message. , To tho Senate and House of Representa tives: Your attention 13 Invited to re cent events which havo conclusively demonstrated the. great value of radio telegraphy, popularly known as 'vIrolcso telegraphy," as an Instrumentality for the preservation of life at sea. While the honor of the first practical application of the scientific principles in volved iiiav belong to another country. It Is gratifying to know lliat our Invent ors have been quick to seize upon and de velop tho idea, and that several systems of approved scientific merit and practi cability have been put into operation in the 1'nltoil States. Furthermore, through the liberality of congress and the intelligence and Indus try of the navy department, our Atlan tic, Gulf and Pacific coasts are equipped with a chain of shore stations, designed primarily for the national defense, but capable of receiving and transmitting messages by any of tho systems of wlre Ji'KK telegraphy now In general use. Even our distant Insular territories and Alaska are. so equipped. So far as our own country Is concerned, steps have thus been taken effectually to prevent the establishment of a mo nopoly in tho practical uso of the new applied art. Purpose of Application. 1 doom It highly desirable that tho con gress before adjournment should enact a law requiring within reasonable limita tions, as determined by what the govern ment of the United States has already done and by what prudent and progres sive shipowners have already found prac ticable, that all ocean-going steamships, carrying a considerable number of pas songors, on routes where wireless Instal lations would bo useful, should be required to carry sufficient radio-telegraph instal lations nnd competent operators. The subject Is now under consideration bv the congress and 1 am advised legis lation to effect the same general pur pose Is under consideration abroad. Our interest in its enactment Is keen, on account of the great number of steer age as well as cabin passengers who an nually arrive at and depart from our ports. What wo havo already done along practical business lines warrants tbo United Slates In being first among the nations to enact a staute requiring the use of this safeguard of human life, use oi u",in,:DOlK ROOSEVELT. HOUSE BUSY WITH ITS COLUMBIAN AFFAIRS - WASHINGTON". Feb. 8. Tho house gavo practically the entire session over to the consideration of bills pertaining to the District. .of Columbia. A message from the president was rend recommending a law rcquir tig ocean going vessels to be equipped with wireless telegraph apparatus- At 5:.11 p. m. tho house adjourned. Opposes Fulton Bill. WASHINGTON, Feb. S. Senator 121 klns. chairman of the senate committee on Interstate commerce, presented a re port to tho senate today in support or the committee's adverse action on tiic Fulton bill, which would authorize a sus pension by the Interstate commerce com mission of a proposed change of rates by a railroad upon protest from a shipper. Senato Session Secret. WASHINGTON. Feb. fi.- After a very brief legislative session today tho senate closed its doors and devoted the day to a further consideration of tho nomina tion of William 15. Crnm to be collector of tho customs for tho port of Charles ton, S. C At 5.03 p. in. tho sonato adjourned. CHARGED WITH SECURING FORTUNE BY FORGERY DAVTON, Ohio. Feb. S. ,T. E Smith, colored! who has been in tho custody of the police for a week, was arraigned today on a chargo of criminal assault on Margaret Zcbrist on January 3. At that timo sho was nearly choked to deatli and on Sunday she identified Smith as the culprit. The finding of a blody skirt in Smith's room leads tho police to suspect him in connection with tho Mary Farschncr murdor. He pleaded not guilt v and his bond was placed at $1000. Ilo is still locked up. BELIEVE TRAIN WAS DELIBERATELY WRECKED COLDWATEP, Miss., Feb. 8. Fol lowing an investigation of today's wreck of an Illinois Central train -which resulted in tho death of ono man and tho injury of more than a scoro of tho crew and passongors. Superintend ent II. McCourt of tlio Illinois Central railroad, declared the. train was delib erately wreckod. Into a "cockod" switch which had uot been used since Saturday, tho fast Chicago flyer from Now Orleans rushed at headlong speed early this morning. Veteran Actor 111. WEST SWANS 12V, N. II., Feb. S. Den man Thompson, tbo veteran actor, Is dangerously ill with pneumonia at his homo .here. Mr, Thompson Is 70 years of age'. ' SALTJM US I Resolution Is Adopted Rcquir ing Such Organiation to y Secure Licenses. ' PRIMARILY AIMED AT H THE COMMERCIAL CLUB1 H After Introduction of ResoIuV tion, All Clubs in City Arc Included. If a resolution adopted by the city council Monday evening is constitu tional, every club in Salt Lako City selling liquor under a government li- censo will be required to take out a city liquor license.' The resolution wns introduced by, fl F. S. Fcmstrom, councilman from this. Third ward, and adopted with but one: jH dissenting vote. It was primarily! jH .aimed at the Commercial club, but was H amended to include every other simila club in the city, all of which aro operat ing under a government liquor liconso which costs only $2,' a year. A city( liquor license costs $.1200 a year. 1 Immediately upon tho reading of tha resolution Mr. Pernstrom moved its adoption.' Mr. Hall seconded the. mo3 ion. Ilio. amendment to include alt gH other similar clubs in tho city w.-H made upon Mr. Black's motion. Tim , IH vote on the amendment tho chair for-? IH got to call for lho voto on tho original' motion was as follows: Ayes -Black, Cowburn. Fernstrom Hodgson. HoJlcy, Hall, Murdock, Bay, bonld, Rcodall and Wood 10. N ays Ma rt i u 1 . Mr. Forry, Mr. Stewart and President Davis wero absent. Tho resolution is as follows: 1 ThatRcsolution. Whoroas, Tho board of governors of Hit Commercial club passed a resolution las .Saturday. February C. 100ft. a portion oft 0 vhlch reads as follows: "Hcartllv favor the most stringent regulations of th liquor traffic of this city nnd stato"; and Whereas. The board of governors ol the Commercial club are now. and havo been for many years, operating a llquoi? business in their club and havo failed to procure a license from the city, although they have alwaj's paid a government li cense, and as such they are now con ducting a liquor business In defiance nt tho present rules nnd regulations of tho quor traffic of this cltv. both as far aa license is concerned and also as far as the Sunday closing law Is concerned therefore, be It Resolved. That the license collector bo, and ho Is hereby, instructed to notify said club lo procuro a llccnso at once: and If they neglect to procuro such II cense that he then notify the chief of police, that tho .chief mav proceed to at once close up the Illegal liquor traffic of said club. Mr. Elack's View. In speaking to his amendment, Mr. jH Black said that the possession of a gov eminent license is prima facie evidence that liquor is being sold and that all clubs in tho city Hmits are amenable, to the city ordinances. , Mr. Martin argued that a man's elnb is the same- as his home, and thoroforo cannot be brought under tho city liquor ordinance. "Tho Comnicrcia'l club buffet is not run for profit, but for tho convenience of its members. I'm non a member and I can't got a drink at; tho Commercial club, neither could tho chief of police get into the Elks' club' buffet without a warrant if ho weren't a member," declared Mr. Martin. "Tho Commercial club is not organized for profits to its members, but for tho up building of tho city. And its club ia its homo, and you" can't molest it in this matter ns lohg as it complies with tlio law in ever' respect." Black Conies Back. Mr. Black thought it just ns harmv ful to sell liquor in tho high places as in tho low. "Is tho rich man who sells liquor in his club without, a license; for convenience sake any better than the poor man who sells with a license for a living?" asked Mr. Black. "T am a member of the Commercial club myself and tho Commercial club, ad nuttcdly, is organized for tho upbuild ing of the citj. but I am in favor oi tho resolution, if made, to apply to all othor similar clubs." ' Similar legislation has been attempt ed in eastern states, but held un constitutional by tho higher courts on tho grounds that a man's club is his homo and that ho is entitled to drink. ns little or ns much as ho pleases, so long as ho keeps within the law thero. OFFICIALS OF CLUB EH DISOUSS THE ACTIO W. .7. llallorau, president of the Commercial club, when informed of tho action of tho city council Monday ovening, stated that ho could not say what action would bu taken by tho club at the prcsont time, as it would bo necessary to call a meeting of tho board of governors in order lo deter mine tho intontion of tho club in tho "Wo aro not conducting a publio saloon in any sense of the word." said. Mr. Halloran, "but a buffet bar. nnd tho intention is to sell liquors only to IH members of the club. The club is lho home of many of the members and tho bar is a private affair. I think that clubs which sell liquors under such circumstances are generally regarded as private institutions, and I cannot seo how they can require the club to take out a license or close the bar. "The small buffet bar which we con duct in the club presents only a littlo figure in the life of the club. We aro working hard every day of the year to build up the state and to better com inercial conditions hore. Cerlaiuly if t-ho club is violating any law by keep ing a buffet bar it. will be closed, or. at least, a license will bo taken out. flH It is surprising to mo that it. should bo necessary to havo a license, but it is the intention of tho club o keep within tho law on all occasious and, Continued on Page Two,