Newspaper Page Text
Congress Veto of Courts Is Fateful Step Justice Stone Told of Drastic Changes That Could Result. BY DAVID LAWRENCE. Proposals that congress be given the right by two-thirds vote to override the decisions of the Supreme Court are be ing advanced as a compromise In the controversy over enlarging the size of the court. But such proposals, while on the •urface a basis of compromise, probably would he fought more vehemently when analyzed as con stituting a more fundamental change in our system of gov ernment than the attempt to change the judges by altering the size of the court. The best ex position of the argument against David Lawrence. the idea of giving the legislative branch increased powers was made by Justice Harlan Stone In a speech delivered while he was a member of the Supreme Court bench. The occa sion was the meeting of the American Bar Association in Seattle in July. 1928 Justice Stone pointed out that he was not discussing whether the power to override decision-, should or should not be given, but he was out lining "in a gathering of lawyers” the effect of the suggested limitations on the judicial power. He said in part: “It has been suggested that a stat ute might be made to prevail over constitutional objections if it were passed by the legislative body twice. It has also been suggested that if a statute whose constitutionality was contested were upheld by a minority of two or three of the members of the court, it should become law de spite all constitutional objections. State and National Questions. “When any such device is applied to the function which the court exercises as the arbiter between the rival claims of governments or the separate branches of the National Government, the question at once arises: Shall it be applied equally to statutes passed by Congress and to statutes passed by State legislatures, or shall it be ap plied to only one. the acts of Con gress? If applicable only to one, it ii apparent that the sovereign State and the National Government no longer can stand on a plane of equality in matters of constitutional right or immunity, but the way is opened for the gradual curtailment of the constitutional powers granted to or reserved by one through the enactment of statutes by the other, which, whenever their constitution ality Is assailed, have greater weight before the court than the Constitution 1 itself. “But If the device of the weighted statute were to be supplied both to the acts of Congress and to State statutes in the field of conflict of powers of government under our dual system, then each would be given the ©pportumty to extend its constitu tional power in particular fields at the expense of the other by the enactment of statutes which, before the Supreme Court, must be given weight greater than is given to other forms of gov ernmental action or to the provisions of the Constitution itself. Problem Becomes Involved. "But governments do not always ex ercise their eovereign powers through the enactment of statutes. Under our system they may aet with equal com petency through the executive or the judicial ipower, and such action when it is supported by the Constitution is as authoritative as if the Government spoke through legislation alone. The consequences '' these proposals, there for*, would be to give a weight and effect to legislative action which would not attach to other forms of govern mental action when it is asserted that both are sanctioned by the Con stitution. "In a controversy between States, founded upon diverse claims of con stitutional right, greater weight must needs be given to the statute of one than to the executive action of the other, merely because governmental action In one case has found expres sion In a statute, rather than through some other equally competent agency. "The same inequality between the different types of responsible govern mental action would occur with respect to the three branches of the National Government. Under such a scheme, the executive action of the President of the United States or the judicial action of courts, each founded upon a claim of constitutional rights, would have less weight than the action of the legislative branch. In prac tice the device of the weighted statutes eould only operate to effect a gradual transfer of constitutional powers from the sxecutive and judicial branches ef the Government to the legislative. Would Bring Redistribution. “These are but illustrations in some what elementary fashion of the truth that under our system of the distri bution of constitutional powers, the power vested in one branch or agency of the Government cannot be sub tracted from one litigant without add ing to that of the other, and that giv ing artificial weight to one form of governmental action wherever it comes into conflict with the other forms, or with the Constitution itself, can only result in an inevitable shifting of gov ernmental powers as they have been distributed by the Constitution. And that redistribution of power would take place, not as a result of judicial action based on the provisions of the great document itself but by increas ing the power of one at the expense of the other by resort to its own leg islative action.” Already, of course, what Justice Btone foresaw nine years ago has come to paas in the demand for greater and greater legislative power or greater executive power, both at the expense of the judicial power. The plan to override decisions of the Supreme Court by act of Congress voted upon by two-thirds will lead to a proposal lor majority vote.' Indeed, it is being sponsored already as a compromise in the event that the administration objeats to a two-thirds vote as a means of overriding the Supreme Court. Political Oligarchy Might Result. Such plans mean only that their sponsors want to make the legislative power supreme and that 531 politically elected persons would be asked not only to make the laws but sit as judges on their own acts in interpreting the Constitution. A simple act to take News Behind the News Secret Agreement Seen as Blocking Court Proposal Vote Until U. S. Speaks. BY PAUL MALLOW. PPOSINO court factions in Congress say it ian’t so. but they have a private agreement to hold off consideration of President Roose velt's repacking legislation until the country Is heard from. In other word#, both sides are agreed to let the country, rather than the Congress, decide the Aght. it appears Mr. Roosevelt’s leaders have been telling him the project cannot be jammed through without heavy casualties. The first run of incoming moil teas against him. He mutt build up popu lar sentiment behind his move, or a lot of congressional gore will be spilled, they say. This is all right with the opposition. They have insufficient votes signed, sealed and delivered today. They must build up a majority by stir ring up popular opinion. The White House is miles ahead of the opposition on Inside organisa tion. Mr. Roosevelt had his whole campaign set-up ready to shoot, with the lamed publicist, Charles Michelson, called back: from a Florida vacation to sight the guns. Facts and figures for speeches are being systematically furnished to Oovernment officials and sym pathetic Congressmen. Radio spots are being arranged for them. Propagandists are being prompted with the proper arguments. The whole presidential campaign plant ing machine Is sowing as smoothly CAN YOU MAT ' TUJkT.' i WHY I JUST fi GOTWfM. Y VtSTtHPAY^ as it did last October. The opposition has nothing like that. Most or ita radio work so far has been developed by radio program directors. The broadcasting companies are flooded with administration speakers and must go out and snag a few oppositionists now and then to create an appear ance of evening things up. Senators Borah. Johnson. Van Nuys, Bailey and a few others are getting their heads together occasionally, but they have nothing like an organization. Nevertheless, they have had an advantage. With caustic tongues like that of Senator Glass ready to ad lib a devastating answer to Attorney General Cummings, they do not seem to have suffered much. * * * * Recurring rumors about an allied credit loan to Germany have pierced the skins of State Department officials. The highest authority has told friends it is • unthinkable" that this country should join in a loan. He attributes the rumors to financial authoritiea anxious to get their money back from Germany. An influential economist of the new order says Germany could not possibly meet the exchange requirements to pay interest on a large loan, so it would mean giving the mcney away. More than one presidential arranger it talking about thifting the leadership of the President's fight from Senator Minton of Indiana before the Senate starts. It seems that Minton had good reasons to expect an appointment to a circuit judgeship vacancy in his locality before this. In fact, there has been a lot of talk that he would have been appointed except for the opposition of Democratic National Chairman Parley. When asked about it, Minton proclaim his candidacy for the job by saying, ‘'Barkis is willin'." Many a Roosevelt friend suspects it would be wiser to have his court fight led by some one who is not a candidate for judicial appointment. Note—It may be hard for Mr. Roosevelt to find a Senate leader with out the toga itch. Nearly all who are lawyers have it. and the rest have law partners who have it. * * * * If you will look hard at those new Joe Robinson half dollars you may 'I see a slight touch of crimson arts* on the cheek of the handsome silver visage. The coins bearing the counte nance of the renowned Democratic leader of the Senate are to com memorate the Arkansas centennial. The choice of physiognomy was made by Treasury Secretary Morgenthau, who must have in advertently overlooked the fact that the legislation authoring the coin was not fathered by Senator Robinson, but mothered by his col league, Senator Hattie Caraway, former friend at Huey Long, whose face appears at no place on it. The power of any governing authority to reward ita friends or punish its opponents is limited only by ita imagination. An attorney nominally connected with, the New York Com modifies Exchange has been in toum lately with an idea for opening the silver market. A bill to do it will be introduced shortly, but , its fate is decidedly uncertain. Statesman, returning from Florida, was surprised to learn that Mr. Roosevelt had proposed to get his social legislation by packing the Supreme Court. The only unsettled questions he heard discussed in Miami were the prospective winners at Hialeah in the afternoon and at four dog tracks at night. (Copyright, 19S7.) away power from the States would, under the proposal, supersede any right a State might possess. The pos sibilities that a political oligarchy, possessing all the funds and the pow ers of issuance of money, would su persede any other agency of authority are considered by opponents of the plan to be by no means fantastic. The only real compromise on the President’s plan to enlarge the court is to shelve it while the new retire ment bill is passed and a couple Judges retire. This would give the country an opportunity to appraise the type of justice Mr. Roosevelt has In mind for the Supreme Court and the basic issues would be clarified. (Copyright. 1937.) — -• — Book Affected People. ‘ Robinson Crusoe,” when first pub lished. had the effect of inspiring manliness in solitude apd of pouring healing on the artificialities of the bewigged and powdered social life of that day. There was a regular factory .of "Robinsonaden” in Germany. Its prototype, the "Swiss Family Robin son,” almost rivaled its popularity, and one edition of "Robinson Crusoe” for juvenile consumption passed through 120 editions in 20 years. PARKING FACILITIES PROVISION IS URGED Sixteenth Street Highlands Citi zens Wonld Require Space With Hew Buildings. As a partial aolution to the Capital's parking problem, the Sixteenth Street Highlands Cltiaens’ Association last night adopted a resolution caUlng for a regulation that would prohibit the issuance of a building permit for office building or apartment purposes unless garage or parking space be provided for the occupants. Havlland Hobbs, chairman of the Public Utilities Committee of the as sociation, introduced the measure. As the result of an accident to one of Its members and the death of a policeman not long ago. the group also voted that the Commissioners and superintendent of parks be requested to do something about the “dangerous bottleneck’’ at the point where Blag den avenue enters Rock Creek Park. Increased street car service to Fourteenth and Colorado avenue waa asked in a resolution. nrHE opinions of the writers on this page are their own, not necessarily The Star's. Such opinions are presented in The Star's effort to give all sides of questions of interest to its readers, although such opinions may be contradictory among themselves and directly opposed to The Star’s. States Rights Path Open Recent Supreme Court Decision Permits Progressive Laws Without Shakeups. BY MARK SULLIVAN. THE surprise attending Mr. Roose velt’s action about the Supreme Court was of a double kind. It was a surprise in the sense that Mr. Roosevelt had with great pains kept it secret until the moment he read it to the newspaper men. His success at keeping it secret gave him pleasure. Callers who talked with him after he had put the sensation forth, found him more interested in the success of his secrecy than in otner phases of the momentous step he had taken; he said, with much pride, that only three people had known of it. It was a sur prise also In the sense that no body expected It, or anything like it. On the con trary nearly every we 11 - Informed person expected, so to speak, the Mark SalllTaa. absence of any sensational step by the President. Everybody supposed the President had turned his face in the direction of calm and healing. Immediately after the election, sources close to him gsve out the notion that his second term was to be a period of quiet, and of forgiveness of oppo nents—an "era of good feeling,” said a confident of the President, Dr. Stan ley High, in a January isaue of Liberty. The tame spirit emanated from the President's circle through many chan nels. Intimates reported the Presi dent as feeling that there should be an end to agitation, commotion and public nervousness, that the country must be led into a period of repose and tolerance. This impression per- | meated the Washington atmosphere. A dispatch from Washington, writ- I ten by me November 18. reported Democratic party leaders as feeling assurance that Mr. Roosevelt’s sec ond term would be more calm than the first, and that Mr. Roosevelt's whole eight years would be teen in history as merely a period of neces sary and wholesome Democratic Jack sonian reform. Why Mr. Roosevelt should have blasted this atmosphere of quiet with one of the moat sensational and pro vocative actions in American history is a question, of which the answer lies in the mysteries of human per sonality. Mr. Roosevelt's personality is not only a part of the Washington scene in the ordinary sense. Because he has already been given such great powers by Oongrekl, and because of the prestige of his overwhelming elec tion. bis temperament is an eaeentlal factor in government. The general expectation of serenity was confirmed when the Supreme Court on January 4 handed down a decision in which the court seemed to accommodate itself to Mr. Roosevelt, seemed indeed almost to make a con* sciously amiable gesture toward him. This decision of January 4 made it possible for Mr. Roosevelt’s objectives to be attained without necessity of constitutional amendment or of any change in the court or curb of it. The January 4 decision in the con vict-made-goods case, was immediately recognised by lawyers and students as having far-reaching importance. Sev eral States had passed statutes forbid ding the sale within their borders of goods made by convict labor. There* after, Oongress, in order to aid the States in making such statutes effec tive. passed the Ashurst-Sumners act. This statute forbade shipment of con vict-made goods into any 8tate which outlaws such goods. The decision upholding the Ashurst* Sumners act seemed to break the jam caused by the court's invalidation of N. R. A. and other New Deal legisla* tion. It seemed to ease the tension be* COUNSEL CIRCLE "CARLETTA" Printt Interrlews—tm Inrreu Circle Readlnft Deilr 34 yean an Fourteenth Street. Spiritual adylce by ‘'Cerletta” Appointments by a rlelt or telephone. 922 14th St. N.W. MEt. 4993 i for ihe best name for our Wa ml a am hailpliw a *4 >Hmlin UM (*( aat mm Abb tbraa •Mi) iar Ibis HniM-ulU tba Mat raralatiaaary WaMan) *a Ik racaat kMMf af Aaasatia baatiag. Tba ariaaar aaa baas aay AariraA aiaa af bard aaal . . . iaaadiaUlr, ar aa AaairaA tbraagbaat tba 7aaa. Tba aaa tail is liaftsA to garaeaa saw baraiag bar* ar saft aaal I'M la A# aaagak balsas. writing aAAitisSal aaa as aa a sagarato ibaaS. I • _ Consolidated TERMINAL Corporation.* Hon U mtnano for tom* now Conjlolo Hoot lo»>lw _ _ _ Addrow_ Phono_to Kind of Co<d Ui»4*» T*»r___ An You Usina A StokofT (Chock}: Yoo_No_ I i_ _ _ _ Revolutionary New Complete Hoot aAfVlCe Am*singly simple and complete, this new de velopment of research experts enable* yon to enjoy just tho temperature you like beat—from fall to spring—without ao much a* a lift of your Anger, except to turn the thermostat. Even no ashes to bother with. The installation of all-automatic equipment, as well as the fueling, sab-removing, and inspection service is arranged on easy period payments. These pay for fuel and service a* well as the equipment. The latter becomes your prop erty at the end of five yean. Consolidated TERMINAL Corp. lllh and E STREETS. S. W. For further details listen to SINGINQ VIOLINS oe<*r Station TVRC, every Sunday from 1 to 1:30 tween the President and the Supreme Court. The path aeemed wide and clear for the attainment of Mr. Roose velt’* objective*, without change In the Constitution or change in the court. The situation created by the Ashurst Sumners decision remains. The path opened by this decision remains an easily available and abundantly satis factory way to attain Mr. Roosevelt’s objectives. It is free of the disad vantages of the other ways proposed, whether the President's way, or the way of constitutional amendment, or the way of limiting the court's func tion. Besides, the Ashurst-Sumners way has one immense advantage; It achieves the desired objectives—but at the same time preserves States' rights. The way opened by the Ashurst Sumners decision consists of a combi nation of State and Federal legisla tion; it conforms to what Mr. Roose velt himself suggested in his January 6 message to Congress, “Federal laws supplementing State laws.” Any State that wants to can, and probably all would, pass statutes for bidding the manufacture or sale of goods made by child labor or made with labor receiving less than a mini mum wage, or made under other dis approved conditions. These local laws will, of course, protect the States against the making of such goods, or the violation of such standards, with in their own borders. Thereafter, Congress can pass a law, analogous to the Ashurst Sumners one—a law forbidding the shipment of goods made under disap proved conditions into any State that outlaws such goods. By this Pederal law, the State would be protected against disapproved goods coming in from other States. By its own local statute it would be protected against the making of such goods within its own borders. By the combination of the two, the Pederal law supplement ing the State one, the Slate would be protected completely. Obstacle Remains. True, this path depends upon get ting rid of one obstacle that still : remains. The Supreme Court must yet bold tbat States bave tbe right ' to pass lawa forbidding child labor, or wages below a minimum. At present, the Court is on record, as late as last May, with a decision that a minimum wage law enacted by New York State was unconstitutional. But competent opinion believes the obstacle presented by that decision wi'" soon disappear. Competent opinion believes that with a relatively alight change in phrase ology. the New York minimum wage law would be found valid. The adverse decision last May was a 5-to-t one A switch by one Justice would uphold the law. The court d a not exist In a vacuum—it knows what is taking place In the world. Throughout the country's history, the list of articles defined to be deleterious, and therefore banned, has always been growing. In the Ashurst—Sumners decision last month < Chief Justice Hughes read a list of articles which have already been barred from Interstate transportation, We, the People Murphy’s Handling of Strike Crisis Uncovers Another 1940 Possibility. BY MY FRANKLIN. JOHN L. LEWIS has created another "Crown Prince” for the New Deal presidential nomination of 1940: Gov. Prank Murphy of Michigan. The sit-down strike settlement is, on the surface, a compromise between General Motors and the Committee on Industrial Organisa tion, everybody's face is saved, but Lewis walks off with a good-sited chunk of the bacon and a civic explosion has been prevented. This it due to the remarkable labor statesmanship of Gov. Murphy himself and to hit peculiar use of the armed forces of the State of Michigan. Tor, if the sit-down strike is s new and baffling "tactic” in labor con troversies, Murphy has introduced a new and important element into the settlement of Industrial disputes: The principle that life as well as property is entitled to protection. He did not Invent this system. It was originated on a large scale by the late Gov. Pioyd Olson of Minnesota in the Minneapolis teamsters’ strike of 1934. The Idea is that when a labor dispute threatens loss of life, the militia shall be used to picket plants against all workers as well as the strikers. The oourte, of course, work time and overtime in protecting what they know as “property” and it is no trick for a judge to issue an order, the execution rff which calls for violence, bloodshed and the general jeopardy of life and limb. This Is known as “law and order,” though it frequently destroys much of the physical property it assumes to protect And what property Is more precious than a man's own life? * Tt Is Gov. Murphy’s peculiar glory that he sent in the troops and handled them so well that no man lost his life after their arrival, and that one of the bitterest industrial strikes on record passed off without the usual dreary lists of killed and wounded in the conventional struggle. He seems to have done this by the relatively simple device of throwing a cordon of troops around the sit-downers, by occupying other plants by the military, and, while permitting food, etc., to go to the strikers, by preventing contact between them and the private automotive army known as the Flint Alliance and the special police. Just as the French discovered 15 years ago in the Ruhr, that you cannot mine coal with bayonets, so Messrs. Sloan and Knudsen learned that militia don’t manufacture automobiles, and that the most drastic court orders their attorneys can wrangle are useless with out the will of the public authorities. in otner words, human rights have been placed on the same plane with property right* by the Governor of Michigan and the principle has been established that even if the court* consider it their duty to hand out dangerous in junctions, it is the duty of the State to prevent bloodshed. This is so important a contribution to the technique -of American self government that Prank Murphy of Michigan must now be counted along with Henry Wallace of Iowa and George Earle of Pennsylvania among the leading contenders for the next presidency. * * * * Of the strike settlement itself, it appears that the union won every thing worth having—collective bargaining with G M. a pledge by G. M. not to negotiate with other groups without the Governor's permission, the right to unionize General Motors (provided "outside'’ organizers keep out of O. M. plants), an immediate pay increase and promise of a general negotiation on wages, houn and labor conditions. Oeneral Motors got back its physical property and will be permitted to resume production, and the court injunction will be dropped. The next move by John L. Lems and the C. 1. O. is said to be the unionization of steel, although there is a chance that the United Automobile Workers will mop up Ford and Chrysler, too and then we shall see whether Gov. Karle of Pennsylvania has learned the Murphy trick of handling the militia arut whether the steel magnates have learned anything from G. M.'s experience with the sit-down situation. As for Gov. Murphy, his presidential stock is already being bought for the rise by far-sighted Washington speculators and he must now be rated as one of the New Deal's coming men for the 1940s. (Copyright. 1937.) by laws which the Supreme Court has sustained. They include diseased live stock, lottery tickets, adulterated and misbranded articles, kidnaped persons, women transported for immoral pur poses, intoxicating liquors, diseased plants, stolen automobiles—and now convict-made goods. To add to this list, now. goods made I ! by child labor, goods made by labor at less than a minimum wage, and goods made under other undesirable conditions—to do that would be a small matter. And it would be a natural evolution, of the kind through which the oourt's lines of decision are constantly passing. (Copyright, 1037.1 An American You Should Know Mrs. Lucille Mann Has Followed Husband as Naturalist. BY DELIA PYNCHONT. TO BE a naturalist you must overcome natural inhibitions. In addition, you must have a sportsman's Indifference to personal comfort and a scientist’* real for research. Mrs. Lucille Quarry Mann has these qualities. She is the wife of Dr. Wil Mrs. Mann. 11am M. Mann, director of the Washington Zoo. She has stated that "being mar ried to a general all-around natu ralist Is a better education than passing A in zo ology.’’ Mrs. Mann has bug hunted, bird hunted, snake hunted and big animal hunted. In fact, she has hunted mot everything that crawls, flies or stalks through remote jungle forests. She and Dr. Mann bring them bark alive, so that we cushioned Washingtonians may gape at them in the Zoo. To look at Mrs. Mann, so slender, almost frail, it is to wonder at the secret of her strength to travel the explorer’s road. Strength and vitality surround her somehow, and experience demonstrates she can ‘ take it." Came Here in 1918. A graduate of the University of Michigan, Lucille Quarry came to Washington in 1918. She had a po sition in the Bureau of Entomology, Department of of Agriculture. She married Dr. Mann in 1926. Lucille Mann does not shine by reflected glory from her famous husband. She is a writer and .■’oologist in her own right and executive secretary of the International Women Geographers. Her enthusiasm for animals, their capture and care came as a result of her husband's enthusiasm. Dr. Mann's interest in animals came as a by product of his exploration for buss • though that appears to put the cart before the horse j. Snakes are admittedly a cultivated taste with Lucille Mann. Once she would not go into a snake house and observe them in cages. Dr. Mann absent-mindedly misplaced her jor hours in a snowstorm by an ice-locked seal pond while he went to see a man about a snake in the tropical snake house. Mrs. Mann decided that even snakes were preferable to freezing. By easy stages one snake led to another, until Mrs. Mann found herself hunt ing them with Dr. Mann on their trip to South America. Later she kept two as pets at home. Lion Cub Brought Home. Mrs. Mann declares that ‘ nothing from ants to elephants is too small or too large to arouse enthusiasm " Once Dr. Mann brought her in a candy box a day-old lion cub weighing two and a half pounds. The cub had a bottlp for a while night and day, and is the only recorded case of a lion cub ever to be •‘house-broken.” FIXED* FLAVOR GOODNESS IN EVERY SLICE I HOUSEWIVES the country over are ecking for Armour'* Star Bacon. It’a America'* favorite for top-notch quality and smooth, full flavor. And there’* a reaeon for it* astro goodne**. Fir*t, Sur Bacon come* front choice Mock, impacted by U. Armour’* Star Bacon today. You’ll too why it’* the ttnxUrd io million* of home*. Aod while you’re chopping, a*k your dealer for the" Meal of the Month Recipe Folder. If he ano’t aupply you, write to Marie Gifford, care of S. Government expert*. Second, an ex clusive Armour proce**...Fixed-Flavor curing... give* it a sweet, mild-smoke tastiness unrivalled by other brands. Third, careful inspection assure* uni form quality in every pound. Buy ■ , ANNIVERSARY Armour sad Company, Chicago, lor your free oopy. It gives full directions lor preparing the delicious Star Bacon and Chopped Steak Grill, as well as several other tempting recipes to whet your family’s appetite! For convenience buy Armour’s Star Bacon in the half-pound Cel lophane or the pound or half-pound Nu Pack cartons.