Newspaper Page Text
DEATH HATE CUT Health Officer Responsibility Cited in Issue on Hospital Control. This is the third of a scries dis cussing principles involved in the proposal for transfer to the Health Department of control over the hospitalization and medical care of the indigent, now vested with the Board of Public Welfare. BY DON S. WARREN. “Since the health officer carries re sponsibility over public health con ditions, and must meet criticisms against prevailing mortality rates and the incidence of disease, he should be given direct control over municipal hospital services.” This is one of the arguments moet frequently offered in support of the plan to transfer to the Health De partment the jurisdiction over Gal linger Hospital, the Tuberculosis Sana toria and the medical charities. Advocates of the change predict there would be greater continuity of medical services, fewer delays and more efficiency in public health and hospitalization programs if Health Officer George C. Ruhland were given command over the whole situation, acting under the Commissioners, in stead of but part of it. Those holding this view argue that the change would eliminate oppor tunities for "buck passing,” which they say exist under a system which leaves the health officer as the "po licing” power in public health but places the control of operation of the hospitals In the hands of super intendents who report to the Board of Public Welfare. Collin* Upheld Charge. Chairman Collins of the House subcommittee in charge of the 1938 District supply bill, subscribed to this view during the appropriation hear ings when he stated: “All of the Army hospitals are under the medical de partment of the Army, and all of the naval hospitals are under the medical department of the Navy, and the Vet erans’ Administration medical facili ties are under the Medical Corps. All the other Government agencies have their hospitals under the medical di visions of those agencies, except the District of Columbia. In the District they are under civilian heads, and it seems to me the medical associa tion could more properly run the hos pitals." Ross Garrett, director of the Central Admitting Bureau for Hospitals, an agency set up by the Community Chest, several years ago to facilitate handling of applicants for free care or part-payment care at the hospitals, is one of the active sponsors of the change. While discussing the merits of the proposal itself, he interjected: *'Dr. Ruhland probably will find him self in an embarrassing situation next year or later if the situation as to in fant mortality, the death rate for tu berculosis and the prevalence of com municable disease is not improved, for he is being given larger funds for the public nursing service, for labora tory work and for the first of the pro posed medical centers.” Hospitals Added. Garrett adds: “When the municipal hospital set-up was placed under the jurisdiction of j the Board of Public Welfare, the now j existing, augmented facilities of Gal lmger Hospital, the Communicable Disease Hospital as an extension of Gallinger, the Children's Tuberculosis Sanatorium at Glenn Dale, and the soon-to-be-opened Adult Tuberculosis Hospital at Glenn Dale, were not in existence. "Likewise, the population of Wash ington was not at its present level; likewise a progressive and modern Health Department did not exist. The Health Department, now equipped to do an active job, might better handle the specific problems of health and hospitalization than the Department of Public Welfare, with its added re sponsibility over relief, old-age as sistance. foundlings, penal institutions, home for feeble minded and so forth.” Advocates of the change point to the 1928 report of the late Dr. Paul j Preble, a surgeon in the United States | Public Health Service, for support. I This study proposed creation of a Department of Health and Hospitals, with a director of health in charge. There would be a Bureau of Health, which would have an advisory board, but the current proposal does not pro vide for this advisory agency. The Preble plan also proposed designation of a Bureau of Hospitals to operate under the director of health, and this bureau likewise would have an ad visory board. Many of the proposals in the Preble plan, such as development of a public health nursing bureau and construc tion of a contagious disease unit at Gallinger Hospital, have come into existence. Communicable Disease Care Vital. ‘'Responsibility for the control of communicable diseases is logically the function of the Health Department,” the Preble report stated. "The care and treatment of those who have contracted communicable diseases be comes equally as important as meas ures Intended to prevent the spread of infection. * • * If additional fa cilities for the treatment of com municable disease are provided at the municipal hospital under the ad ministrative control of the director of public welfare, this divided responsi bility over patients afflicted with com municable diseases—under the health officer if treated at their homes, and under the director of welfare if given hospital treatment—should not be permitted to jeopardize municipal ef forts to control these diseases." Advocates of the change also point to the suggestion of Dr. Preble that some economies might be achieved In the consolidated operation of the ambulance services of the welfare agencies and the Health Department. The Preble report also stated: "This hospital division would assume re sponsibility for all medical relief pro vided under municipal auspices. It would provide hospital care to all per sons entitled to the same, whether re ferred by the Health Department proper, the Board of Public Welfare or other city agency. The proposal undoubtedly will meet with opposition on the part of those who contend that all medical charities are proper func tions of the welfare authorities, on the ground that indigency is the de termining factor. Under the plan, the Board of Public Welfare, of course, would continue its non-medical re sponsibilities, referriiK all who re quire medical relief the hospital authorities, and by (¥olIig *° ^is board would fulfill its obligations.” Win in Divorce Case Mrs. Eleanor Wilson McAdoo (right), former wife of Senator William G. McAdoo and daughter of President Wilson, pictured in Los Angeles court yesterday with her daughter, Mrs. Ellen McAdoo De Onate, at the latter’s divorce suit against Rafael Lopez De Onate, actor. Mrs. De Onate was granted an interlocutory decree on grounds of non-support.—Copyright. A. P. Wirephoto. M’ADOO’S DAUGHTER GRANTED DIVORCE De Onate Admits Senator Pro vided Money for Their Support. fcfv the Associated Press. LOS ANGELES. April 3.—Ellen McAdoo de Onate, 21, daughter of United States Senator William Gibbs McAdoo and granddaughter of the late President Woodrow Wilson, ob tained a divorce yesterday from Rafael de Onate. 40, an actor, on a charge of non-support. She and her husband both testified in her contested divorce action that they were supported during their mar ried life by Senator McAdoo. To Mrs. De Onate's charge of neglect and non-support. De Onate countered that McAdoo induced them to go to Europe after their marriage in 1934, preventing him from obtaining film employment. The young wife testified her husband often left her alone at night and that when he returned he ''usually was slightly intoxicated'' and ‘‘used abusive language.” Wilson's daughter. Mrs. William G, McAdoo, divorced wife of the Senator and Ellen's mother, denied she in fluenced the De Onates to go to Eu rope. Asked if the Senator objected to the marriage, Mrs. McAdoo said: "The Senator told me that if she loved him (De Onate) he would not prevent their marriage.” "It was Ellen's idea to go to Europe,” Mrs. McAdoo testified, "and I thought it was a good idea. too. because of the newspaper publicity, which was very annoying.” "It seems to me the defendant is an able-bodied man.” said Supreior Judge I. W. Bull in granting the decree, "who could have found work of some kind during his nearly three years of mar riage.” Mrs. De Onate did not ask and was given no alimony, but De Onate was ordered to pay *25 a month toward support of their son, Robert, 2 years old. Deaths Reported. Marv H. Lincoln 90 3014 N st. Jessie A. Mellis. 89. 616 Maryland ave n e Joseph A Gaston, 80. the Westmoreland Apartments. Annie E. Pritchard. 79. 26 9th st. n.». Henry Lowry. 77. 4*.’1 1st st. s.e. Marion Kearns. 76. 1031 P st. I,aura P. Weaver. 75 1069 Jefferson st. Ann E Huett. 7.1, 1401 Girard st. William B Newman 70. 712 Whittier st. Joseph D. Bradley. 65. 5402 Kansas ave Margaret C Smith, 6o. National Homeo pathic Hospital. Mary A Cullianno. 58. 4906 W'estwav dr. George E Lescure. 56. Sibley Hospital. Howard A. Shry. 47. Tuberculosis Hos pital. Constant W. Dommitt. 46. 514 D st. i t Lee T Bowen. 45. United States Naval Hospital. Ethel M. Hamm. 42. 217 8th st s e. John Grassi. 40. Casualty Hospital. Katie Seabrook. 85. Galllnger Hospital. Luvenia M. Harris. 67. 818 11th st. n.e. Samuel Crawford. 65. Galllnger Hospital. Dr. Livingston. 51. Garfield Hospital. Fred Thomas. 46, Galllnger Hospital Willie M, Reeder. 41. 1412 Hopkins st. John Taylor, 28. Gallinger Hospital. Infant Elum. Freedmen's Hospital. -_-• Births Reported. Frank and Katherine Davis, girl. Thomas and Mae Thomas, twin girls. Alexander and Mary Meloy. boy. James and Grace De Witt. boy. Richard and Dora Brown, boy. John and Josephine Porirsky. girl. Doras and Angela Orusaeau. boy. John and Kathleen Atwell, boy. Lucius and Jane Wilmerdlng. boy. Oscar and Eleanor Suserud. boy. James and Mary McCarron. girl. Edw’ard and Margaret Kelly, girl. Louis and Alice Dieterich. girl. Conrad and Leita Boterweg. 1r., girl. Martin and Frances Ryan. girl. Sol and Ada Sorkin. girl. James and Caroline MacKenzie, boy. Alton and Nell Cates, boy. Alvin and Barbara Hanes, girl. William and Mary Bebedict. boy. Elwoori and Rose Zupnik. boy. Howard and Irene Slachter, boy. Raymond and Ruth Spaeth, boy. Oliver and Dorothy Holmes, boy. Timothy and Sarah O’Keefe, girl. Michael and Nellie Marcopulos. girl. Douglas and Ida Long. girl. Frederick and Katheryn Mulvey. girl. George and Juliette Foreman, girl. i CITY NEWS IN BRIEF. TODAY. Meeting. Biological Society of Wash ington, Cosmos Club, 8 p.m. Dance and card party, Joppa Lodge Chapter, No. 27, O. E. S„ 2400 Six teenth street northwest, 8:30 p.m. Dance, Social Security Board Union, Pythian Temple, 1012 Ninth street, 8 p.m. Dance, Thomas Marshall Club, Broadmoor Hotel, 10 p.m. j Dance, Sigma Kappa Sorority, j Carlton Hotel, 7:30 p.m. Dance. Forty and Eight Club, Ward man Park Hotel, 10 p.m. Dance, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Wardman Park Hotel, 10 p m. Dance, Credit Union, Mayflower Hotel, 9 p.m. Dinner, Society of Colonial Wars, | Mayflower Hotel, 7 p.m. j Dinner, Continental Bakers' Relief ! Association, Mayflower Hotel, 7 p.m. Dinner, Kappa Phi I*gal Sorority, Shoreham Hotel, 7 p.m. Dinner, Johns Hopkins University Cotillion Board, Shoreham Hotel, 7:30 p.m. tomorrow. I Meeting. Bartenders’ Union, Old Local No. 75. 720 Fifth street, 3 p.m. i Meeting, Irish History Study Club, 1500 Newton street northeast, 8 p.m. Marriage Licenses. 1 jt;KL -Airtf: ! w^aVm 3220 Grace st and Doris Grayson. 20. 14.>1 Corcoran mi., Rev. W. Jones. Wilbur T. Townsend 2.. 030 F st. n j;. KWKCTJ!: ?" I WKdf?r A2flSlboth of Baltimore. Judge VlrRl jfl'u^H'““Goodman 21 Richmond and Jane A. Goode. 18. Dumbarton. Va„ JoMi't Street7 17th st. n e.. and Ida R Krause, 22. 1440 Newton st. n.e.; Rev. J. E Malloy. , James J. Drew. '!ti■„ 1?,llaI)/tS?Jiska1naa« and Jessie E Hurt. 25. .1905 Kansas ave.: Rev. F J. Kelly Clarence A Ravnall 21. 313 O st. s w.. 1 C and Bernice Harris. 18 1130 New Jersey ave s.e.. Rev. Solomon Jackson. O\TeMa^lnB^rhb0Uth of ffiP^nyM Pressly RLL Stevenson 33 Chicago, and Florence M Palmer. 34. Miami. Fla., Robert SMR'Metcalfe. 30. and Ida O. Johnson. 22. both of Baltimore. Rev. A. F. Poore. . w IV^neW74HaboTh&nof^opeielia^aIr'!iaudVe Edward ^RtHenneberry. 32 5435 Connec ticut ave.. and Norma L. Hughes 38. Chevy Chase Md.; Rev. T. G. Smyth. Leland C McCallum. 27. 1.101 Massa chusetts ave. and Helen L. Thornton. 23. 3622 Norton pi; Rev. W. R. John°Ld)Harry. 24. and Virginia L. Balder son 19. both of 2022 North Capitol ft., Robsnd "^8** Young. 22. and Pauline O Replogle 19, both of 1900 Maryland ave. n.e.': Rev. R. D. Bowman. Robert Taylor. 66 1611 Swann st.. and Lulu Roland. 46 1440 Chapman st.. Rev. C. T. Murray. James E. Jones. 21 and Pauline Floyd. 18. both of Richmond; Judge R E. W Ullamn *Rand. 26. 1741 8th st and Alberta Richardson. 25. !61b Covington st.; Judge R. E. Mattingly. John Sponsal. 3^. and Gladys Minor. 32. both of Baltimore: Rev. A. F Poore. Cloyd C. Peterson. Jr, 22. Pittsburgh. Pa and Janet E Reich. 22. 1523 16th st : Rev. P. B Harris. „ . Frederick W. Curtis. 26. Palmyra. N. J.. and Nancy C. Brunner. 24. 1226 Lawrence st. n.e.; Rev. A. L. Wills. Charles T. Andrews. 46. Richmond Hill. N. Y.. and Lydia Williams. 30. Brooklyn. N Y : Rev. C S. Biggs. Constantine J Nichols. 25. 219 H st.. and Mary Sarkis. 22. 151 Carroll st. s.e.; Rev. W. H. Hoffman. Bernard R. Raum. 23. 2236 Prout st. s.e.. and Zilphia F Norton, 22. Capitol Heights Md ; Rev. J. V. Buckley. Harvey W, King 30. 3401 22nd st. n.e.. and Mary L. Smith 24. 1912 Jackson st. n.e.: Rev. T. L. Coyle. Charles H. Jackson. Jr.. 31. San Antonio. Tex., and Ruth Warren. 25. Chevy Chase. Md : Rev. H. H. D Sterret. Charleg E. Briscoe. 23. and Beulah E. Lee. 18. both of Alexandria. Va.; Rev. P. A. Poore. Joseph Brazitis. .33. Smithton. Pa., and Kathryn Slavena. 32. Chicago; Rev. J. H. Dunham. -1 Young Washington When the goldfish in the second grade of the Takoma School have to be fed, they could not ask for a more charming person to do the job than this little miss. She is Nancy Harrison, 7, daughter of Mt^and Mrs. Louis Harrison of A? Ethan Allen avenue, Takomti Park, Md. Monday: Rene ward, son of Mr. Raymond E. Ward, at the J. R. Keene School. —Star Staff Photo. HUGHES DEFENDED BY DR. WALSH * G. U. Vice President Cites “Mutilation” of Text of Court Comment. A defense and explanation of Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes’ now famous remark that “the Constitu tion is what the judges say it is” was made by Dr. Edmund A. Walsh, S. J„ vice president of Georgetown University last night in his weekly lecture on the Supreme Court. Dr. Walsh had declared that the Supreme Court has an “inescapable duty” of interpreting the constitu tionality of enacted statutes and, without power to nullify, it would be no more than a "debating society.” “The Constitution cannot talk,” the Georgetown educator said. “I wish it could at present, for I suspect we should hear much revealing commen tary. “The voice of the Constitution has been committed to the judiciary, not to the legislative or executive depart ments of government. Every attempt to impersonate that voice is ventrilo quism, which is usually booked as a vaudeville act not worthy of the legiti mate stage. Remark Often Misapplied. “Hence it follows that the law Is what the Judges say it is,” he added. "That remark of Chief Justice Hughes, who was only repeating John Mar shall, has frequently been distorted and misapplied. It has recently been invoked as a flippant expression of arbitrary power residing in opinion ated Judges.” Dr. Walsh declares that the phrase has gone the rounds among "high personages who, I hope, were unaware of the flagrant misuse of a truncated and incomplete sentence, torn bleed ing from the body of its context and mangled into an alleged criticism of the Judicial function." What the Chief Justice actually said in a speech at Elmira, May 3, 1807, when Governor of New York, was quoted as: “I have the highest regard for the courts. My whole life has been spent in work conditioned upon respect for the courts. I reckon him one of the worst enemies of the community who will talk lightly of the dignity of the bench. We are under a Consti tution, but the Constitution is what the judges say it is, and the judiciary is the safeguard of our liberty and of our property under the Consti stution. I do not want to see any direct assault upon the courts nor do I want to see any Indirect assault upon the courts.” Cites Deceptive Censoring. By putting a period after the cita tion where none was before. Dr. I Walsh said, an entirely deceptive : interpretation is given of Chief Jus tice Hughes’ argument. The frequent use made of the mutilated text, he said, "has done much to lessen public confidence jn the reasons alleged in support of the present proposals to remake the Judiciary in a more recognized image and likeness.” While the Supreme Court is not at liberty to surrender or waive the "inescapable obligation” imposed upon it by the Constitution. Dr. Walsh said, “it has no mandate to inquire into the motives, good or bad, under lying an act of Congress. "Both the knowledge and the good faith of legislators must be assumed and their intentions are not open to investigation by the court,” he re minded. "Nor can the wisdom or the expediency of congressional enact ments be questioned by the Supreme Court * * * Remedy for unsound legis lation lies in the Legislature, not with the court.” Dr. Walsh will speak again next Friday evening in Memorial Conti- j nental Hall. __< Traffic Convictions SECOND-OFFENSE SPEEDING. James B. Graham. Maryland. $10. William P. Prank, 2714 Twelfth street northeast. $10. Clarence M. Chandler, Virginia, $10. Rodney C. Shull, 4925 Conduit Road, $5. Iowa Rankin, 1423 Fifth street, $10. Andrew 8. Boarman, 307 O street southwest, $25. FIRST-OFFENSE SPEEDING. Katherine Broening, Maryland, $5. Walter D. Brookings, Virginia, $5. Burch Smith, Virginia, $5. Otis H. Lester, Virginia, $5. Ernest K. Strempel, Maryland, $5. William R. Lockhart, 5310 Reno road. $5. Everett* D. Murphy, Maryland. $5. Norman W. Wilson, Maryland. $10. Martin S. Myers, 3915 Kansas ave nue, $5. Dorothy M. Agnew, 3818 Fifth street, $5. John F. Moran. jr„ 2715 Thirteenth street northeast, $5. Earl F. Sodeman, Maryland, $5. Coleman Johnson, 4717 Foote street northeast,, $5. Allen G Stern, 3022 Wisconsin ave nue, $5. Prince E. Williams, 118 Florida ave nue, $5. Joseph B. Herbert, Maryland, $5. Roger W. Curtis, Maryland, $5. William E. Branford, 1903 Seventh street, $5. Harold E. Carter, 7100 Connecticut avenue, $5. Arthur B. Belfleld, Virginia, $5. Norman L. Davis, 4918 Albemarle street, $5. Joseph A. Micker, 1348 Oak street, 15. Don Newberry Bent, Maryland, $5. Edmund B. Benser, Maryland, $5. Edwin W. Hill, Maryland, $5. George Jackson, 1640 Hobart street, *10. V William J. Pruneau, 6309 Dorset! place, $10. Obrient Hill, 1312 Fourth street, $5. SUSPENDED PERMITS. » The following is a list of the oper ators’ permits suspended or revoked by the board as of March 31, 1937: Herman! E. Ford, 2413 E street northeast, revoked. James J. McQuade, 224 S street northeast, revoked. William 8. E. Pieresma, 1657 Good Hope road southeast, revoked. John T. Wilson, jr„ 114 Florida ave nue, revoked. James B. Fox, 4817 Blagden avenue, revoked. Denis Moss, 1314 Sixth street, re voked. Harry R. Ober, 5718 Third street, revoked. Garnett K. Potts, 521 F street north east, revoked. John Riggs. Rockville, Md., revoked. Willie Rhodes, 1526 Tenth street, revoked. Harry dj-Poole, Fairlawn, Md., sus pended. Drinkers on Relief Tagged H NoiMfoop' Angered when four men working for W. P. A. appeared in Police Court on charges of drunkenness, Mayor Frank H. Wheeler of Clifton Forge. Va., who is also judge of the City Police Court, city relief administrator and president of the Virginia State Firemen's Association, ordered that henceforth any person on relief who is convicted of using relief funds to buy liquor will wear one of these signs on his back while working out his fine. Since the Mayor made this ruling no relief workers have been brought into his court on charges of drunkenness. —Wide World Photo. WODEHOUSE DISOWNS “JEEVES” AT COLUMBIA It's Another “Gentleman's Gentle man" Who Goes Through For tune Racket Experiences. rpWENTIETH CENTURY-FOX is fooling the people. This is not a particularly harsh indictment, how ever, for such tactics represent nothing more than a time-honored Hollywood custom, do not constitute a cardinal sin. and are affable chicanery. Up at the Columbia, the men in the booth are unreeling several times each day a celluloid item entitled. “Step Lively. Jeeves." It’s about a pair of confidence men who decide to put a new twist on the old Sir Francis Drake fortune gag by producing a made-to order heir, and Jeeves. English "gen tleman's gentleman," is chosen as the favored one. The catch Is, as some put It, that people are being led to believe that this Jeeves is Mr. Wode I I house's Jeeves, which he isn't—being j Just another valet named Jeeves. To be sure, Arthur Treacher is the perfect Jeeves—even the perfect Wode house Jeeves—but Mr. W. had nothing to do with the story. The “con" gentry bring the masquerading ex-servant to ! the U. S. A . tackle an ex-beer baron I gone “society” with “shake-down” in j their eyes, find ready response to their j suggestion that a small outlay for establishing title to the Drake fortune would reap amazing returns. A girl reporter and boy friend expose the scheme, but their threat to print the story helps “con" men and Jeeves out of a ticklish situation, because Mrs. Ex-Beer Baron doesn't want to lose \ her new' social standing. Treacher. Patricia Ellis, Robert Kent, Allen Dinehart and George Givot per form capably. There is enough fun for any one except the Wodehouse addict 1 —he'll wonder what it's all about— this "Jeeves" business. —C. A. M. -. Blimp Carries Many. A privately owned blimp in Califor nia has carried 21,000 persons without an accident. Woodward & lothrop I0™ll™r a*h G Street* Phot* Dinner 510# I Eat the Correct Foods for Health—Visit the Food Shops Battle Creek Foods Demonstration Miss Ethel Barnes, nutritionist of the Battle Creek Diet System Foods, is to be here next week. Consult with her—she will be glad to aid you with your diet problems and tell you what foods can help you. Foods Specially Priced for the Demonstration LACTO DEXTRIN, a colon food; with travel QCc size KA8A, a laxative food. Special, both for JO FIG & BRAN and ZO. nrc Special, both for-_ ^^ Ti« Food Shop, Fifth Flook ^ ADDRESS TONIGHT Senator Johnson to Speak at Swedish Society’s Fete. Senator E. C. Johnson of Colorado will make the principal address at a meeting commemorating the 27th anniversary of the Swedish Society of Washington at the Lee House at 8:30 o'clock tonight. It was erroneously announced in The Star yesterday that the meeting was scheduled for last night. Radio Meows Upset Cat. SYRACUSE, Kans. yP).—Mrs. Jo seph Kucera’s cat, a lover of music, sat on her lap to enjoy a radio dance orchestra. When an entertainer in terjected an imitation of a cat, th« Kucera pet went crazy, bit Mrs. Ku cera, scratched Mr. Kucera and tore down the living room curtain*. WOODWARD & LOTHROP I0"ll«r*» C Streets Phone Dlmicr #300 Demure little rows of daisies bloom orr a And the daisy print is just one reason you who wear sizes 16l/2 to 24V2 will rejoice in this frock. The squared neckline, with brilliant clip, is young—the fagoted be low-the-elbow sleeves and soft front drap ing are flattering—the chiffon is pure-dye silk—the whole, refreshing and very smart, indeed. Woman's Dresses, Third Floor. News about Kleinert's Sturdi-Flex Reducer, s3'50 Better than ever—with its adjustable "bra" and firm, lightweight batiste panel for added abdominal control. In Sturdi Flex with perforations for body breathing, the back low for day or evening, the gar ters flat and "bumpless." Notions, Aisle 22, First ^{[loor.