Newspaper Page Text
I Broader Power President’s Aim Wants Justices to Write Decision Amending Constitution. BY DAVID LAWRENCE. PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT has been good-naturedly taunting some ol his opponents who were so cocksure a year or so ago that the Wagner national labor relations act would be declared un constitutional by the Supreme Court. He has Deen won dering, moreover, why one New York newspaper, critical of his pol icies, hailed the court’s pro nouncement last Monday as “a great decision.” What Mr. Roosevelt doesn’t take into consid eration is that many of his crit ics have been ed ucated into reali ties which did David Lawrence. not exist last year, and the implica tion of which even Mr. Roosevelt himself has thus far declined to rec ognize. Up to a few weeks ago hardly any lawyer of consequence who had fol lowed Supreme Court decisions would have hesitated a moment to predict that the court would invalidate the Wagner act on the ground that “pro duction is not commerce,” and that employer-employe relations are not subject to Federal regulation. But this was before John L. Lewis gave a sensational demonstration of his power. This w7as before any na tional labor organization had suc ceeded in paralyzing interstate com merce in a major industry, and before that same national organization had begun to issue threats to tie up other major Industries as well. Openly Boastful Xow. Prior to the time the “sit-dow7n” strike technique was developed, labor leaders never ventured to stop inter state commerce and boast about it openly. They avoided any such ac knowledgment of purpose. But to day Mr. Lewis, with his dictatorship over government, and particularly with the influence of his organization over White House policies, has ac tually proved how Interstate com merce can be stopped and how his political power can keep the head of the Federal Government from daring to speak out against his tactics. So skillful is Mr. Lewis and so suc cessfully has he maneuvered White House policy into passive acquiescence that when Congress, pressed by public opinion to denounce "sit-down” strikes, drafts a resolution it is so \ handled by the President’s agents I in Congress as to spare Mr. Boose- ' velt the necessity of approving or disapproving it. A "concurrent” reso lution was the method chosen, be cause, unlike a joint resolution, it doesn't require presidential signature. Saw Ominous Realities. In the face of such power and in fluence exercised by a national labor organization to tie up interstate com merce the Supreme Court saw the ominous realities. Whatever theoreti cal limitations It might have dis cussed In the past in ruling that pro duction Is not commerce were of academic value compared to the plain evidence that commerce itself was actually being interrupted by physical violence or threats of vio lence and that restraining orders of a State court were proving futile. It was a lesson in "obstruction” to in terstate commerce more realistic than J any precedent of words or theory. The White House, incidentally, would prefer to discuss other phases of the latest decisions of the Supreme Court. It is logically asserted by the President's spokesmen that the Su preme Court has done nothing which affirms the power of Congress to enact a minimum wage law or a law to fix maximum hours. Indeed, the President is represented as somewhat doubtful as to whether or not the decision invalidating the Guffey act last year has been overruled. No Overriding of Guffey Case. A careful study of the latest de cision will reveal that there has been no overriding of the Guffey case. In that instance a scheme for regu lation of wages and hours was pro mulgated by Federal statute, and this was by a virtually unanimous court brushed aside as invalid. The minority in that case did not defend the labor provisions. Today the Su preme Court has limited itself in the Wagner act cases to the simple ques tion of compulsory negotiation and collective bargaining. Nothing else has been touched by the cases just decided. There is no Federal power to regulate wages and hours. The Federal power, according to the court, extends to the right of Con gress to set up a machinery to adjust labor disputes. For these reasons it is natural that Mr. Roosevelt, considering his point of view on the need for reorganiza tion of the Supreme Court, will con tend that he has not yet obtained what he wants. What he desires is not simply five justices who will de cide things even partially in his di rection, but nine justices who will go the whole way—giving to Congress which nowadays means the President, the power to regulate hours and fix wages in all industries engaged in or affected by interstate commerce. Prefers Short Cut. The President wants the justices to write decisions which will amend the Constitution. He prefers this as • short cut to the supposedly round about process by which amendments have hitherto been written into the Constitution, namely, by letting the people vote on specific issues. He has chosen to place his entire reliance on judicial Interpretation as a means of changing the fundamental rules of constitutional law in America. And since he alone is to pick the new Justices, and since he controls a ma jority of the Senate, which has to confirm his appointments, it may be assumed that he will pick justices whose attitude and views correspond to his own, namely, that the Con stitution should be amended here after by judicial interpretation. In other words, the oft-twisted words of Charles Evans Hughes, ut tered 30 years ago, before he be came a Supreme Court justice, name ly, that “the Constitution is what the judges say it is,” will have as a eequel now a new slogan or motto: “The Constitution is what the Presi dent tells the justice* to say it is." fCoprrltht, 1037.) A News Behind the News Education Subsidy Bill Opposed By Roosevelt—New Tax Provisions Reported Drafted. BY PAUL MALLON. SPECTATORS nearly fell out of the Senate gallery when Floor Leader Robinson fought against Finance Leader Harrison’s bill for a $300, 000,000 annual Federal education, subsidy. It was as if Damon had struck Pythias. Administration Senators could not ascertain which leader to follow, as both are supposed to represent whatever President Roosevelt wants. The answer is Mr. Roosevelt will veto the Harrison bill if it ever gets to him in its original form. Senator Harrison had so^e private advice from the White House to that effect. The President’s strongest objection to the bill is that it allocates the money to States automatically on the basis of their relative popu lation, giving Mr. Roosevelt no say-so whatever in the distribution of the funds. He may not mention it in his veto message, but if any spending is to be done, Mr. Roosevelt wants to do it. After all, the people might just as well elect a Republican President if they are going to get their share of the Federal loot automatically and not from the presidential hand. Note—An amusing angle of the Harrison perpetual subsidy bill is that Senator Harrison is a lead ing advocate of economy, balancing the budget and an ardent opponent of increased taxes. So much in consistency has developed here lately, however, no one takes the J /'.PONT'' RJ j BRING HIM i\l* VtWL.'y pl/T.HEb HAkMIL5> | /t I trouble to mention suen tnings any more. * * * * Mr. Morgenthau’s facile tax-maker, Herman Oliphant, counsel to the Treasury, is supposed to have drafts of several new tax law provisions hidden somewhere about his person, probably in the sole of his shoe. The ideas were taken out and discussed at a secret meeting of certain congressional leaders and Treasury authorities, but they failed to arouse any enthusiasm whatsoever. The Congressmen were almost violently opposed to any tax legislation of a general character. One leader is supposed to have informed the Treasury that, if it wanted a tax bill, it would have to get another congressional leader to handle it. That threat will not be carried out, but it reflects the deep bitterness of all congressional leaders to the thought of additional taxation. They ivant to pass a resolution continuing excise taxes which expire soon, and let it go at that. The warmth of their opposition and other considerations have delayed a decision as to whether there is to be a tax bill. The decision will be made around May 15. * * * * The only one who had an unkind word to say immediately about the Wagner decisions was John Lewis, who made his workers sit down and the Nation sit up. No one in the know considered it strange that the leader of labor thus denounced labor's great victory in the courts. If the decision is fairly enforced by the Labor Relations Board. Mr. Lewis will become a mere agent of labor. He will lose his power to call sit-down strikes, his power to dictate hours and wages. His political prestige will wane. The board will become the dictator, not Mr. Lewis. * * * * Many a politico on Capitol Hill is surmising that the mam reason for continuance of the President’s court fight is to pack it for future White House generations. They know of only one other legitimate reason for pursuing the issue. If the court is packed, the A. A. A. crowd might be able to revive a stronger production control program. The truth is A. A. A.-ers probably have enough power now. to effect their purposes, although they would ■ juSta k minute Jnio/ coy*T sooner die than admit it while the President is using that as an argument justifying his court program. Nothing is now pending in the court to make packing advisable from a White House standpoint. The only case yet to be decided is the processing tax case, which might cost the Treasury a billion dollars if decided against it. An other is the Alabama unemploy ment insurance tax, but indications are the court will certainly uphold that by a 5-to-4 opinion. The court was divided, 4-to-4, on the same question in the New York case when Justice Stone was absent. Mr. Stone clearly hinted, in his questioning of counsel during recent arguments, that he believes the tax should be upheld. Pev; accept seriously the suggestion that the court might change its mind again, or that wage and hour legislation might be declared uncon stitutional, if carefully drawn. * * * * Justice Roberts has been working in his office at night frequently. The watchman noticed him plodding out rather late and suggested to the justice that things were coming to a pretty pass when a Supreme Court had no maximum hours law. "Yes,” ruled Mr. Roberts, “no sit-downs for us.” A leading Government attorney beamed at the Wagner victory. Particularly he liked the dissenting opinion of Justice McReynolds be cause it appeared to give some substance to the President's contention that the court was illiberal. Said the Government attorney: “Justice Hughes saved the court and McReynolds saved the President.” (Copyright, 1937.) NURSE HELD SUICIDE AFTER LONG ILLNESS Miss Agnes Campbell Found Hanged in Home of Mrs. John C. Letts. A suicide certificate was issued to day by Coroner A. Magruder Mac Donald following an investigation into the death of Miss Agnes Campbell, 47, companion and nurse to Mrs. John C. Letts, widow of the founder of the Sanitary Grocery Co. Miss Campbell hanged herself with a dog ! leash in the Letts' home, 3200 Ellicott street, late yesterday. Dr. MacDonald said he was unable to establish any motive for the act. Miss Campbell had been employed by Mi's. Letts 11 years. Her body was found by a housekeeper. F. S. Milberg, official reporter of debate in the House, a brother-in law of Miss Campbell, said she had been in ill health suffering from heart trouble six months. Unemployment In Germany has dropped 667,119 to 1,853,000 in the last year. BEAUTY that will set her Jieart “a-flutter”* 12-Diamond Bridal Ensemble Really An Unusual Value! . The beauty ot the mm gag white or yellow gold a t ■% mountings la only sur- ” ■ • w passed by the bril liant diamonds. The engagement ring shows seven diamonds and the wedding band _ . ,,v* Pay 75c Weekly! CJ^HE opinions of the writers on this page are their own, not necessarily The Star’s. Such opinions are presented in The Star’s effort to give all sides of questions of interest to its readers, although such opinions may be contradictory among themselves and directly opposed to The Star’s. Only the Beginning Supreme Court Decisions Momentous, But Roosevelt Wants More Than Power to Regulate Labor. BV MARK SULLIVAN. BECAUSE the Supreme Court last Monday gave Mr. Roose velt a decision he desired, it was supposed that he might abandon his fight to change the court. That supposition misjudged the factor of human psychology and Mr. Roose velt’s variety of human nature is exceptionally hu man. Also the supposition un derestimated what Mr R o o s e v elt wants from the court and why he wants a court that will reflect his wishes. What the court did on Monday is momentous. But compared to what Mr. Roosevelt wants, it is only Mark Sullivan. a beginning. Mr. Roosevelt s program, If he can carry it out, will take Amer ica on a long path. The revealed part of it is long enough. The part that is unrevealed is longer yet. Not all the later steps are known yet even to Mr. Roosevelt himself. The longest part of the path is the more distant part—the steps which Mr. Roosevelt does not yet realize he will take but which will be forced upon him as inevitable consequences of his first steps. Even for the immediate steps he already has in mind, last Monday’s decision is only a faint franchise of power. Mr. Roosevelt wants more, much more, than right of the Federal Government to regulate labor every where. Pressing on With Vigor. And so, far from abandoning the fight to change the court, the admin istration is pressing it with the vigor of an army which has won a prelim inary skirmish and now drives forward with heightened mora'e to the major battle. Not from the administration1 side comes any talk of relaxing the fight. So far as any such sentiment' has emerged, it comes from the op ponents of the President’s proposal. With a manner of expectations out raged they say, in effect: “Now that the President has got so much that he wanted, why does he press for more?" Yet it is true that in the Senate the opposition to the President’s court proposal is a little stronger than it was before last Mondays’ decision. There are in the Senate men who hate to! take a position. These are the un knowns whose going one way or the other will decide the outcome. Their hearts are strongly opposed to chang ing the Supreme Court, but their sense of political expediency makes them hesitate to oppose a popular President. Some of these now have an alibi which will permit them to follow their hearts. To the headlong partisans of the President in their constituencies, they can say that the President has now got much that he wanted. With this Justification they can now join the opponents of the President’s court proposal. Perhaps the opposition, as a result of the court's recent decision, will acquire two or three recruits. Chance for Compromise. Also, last Monday’s yielding of the court has created an atmosphere in which some uncomfortable senatorial followers of the President have the opportunity for compromise. Com promise would at once salve their consciences, partially placate both groups of partisans among their con stituencies and save face all around. A compromise that is beginning to emerge in quiet conversations would give the President power to appoint two Justices instead of six. The figure two is arrived at in an ingenious way. There are in the country 10 so-called ‘‘circuits.’’ Historically, there 1s sup posed to be one Supreme Court justice for each circuit. Historically each Supreme Court justice had a direct relation to his circuit. In the ancient days, he used to "ride circuit” on horseback. Practically all this relation between a Justice and his circuit has disappeared: but enough remains to form the basis of a compromise now. The compromise would add one new Justice to the court's present nine, in order to have one Justice for each circuit. This would cure the situation in which, at present, one justice, Mr. Van Devan ter, has two circuits. Then the compromise would say that the Chief Justice ought to be freed from responsibility for a circuit—he should be supervisor over all the circuits. Thus the compromise would add yet one more justice. It would result in two new justices in all, and a Supreme Court of 11 justices instead of 9. Pass "Buck” to Congress. One consequence of last Monday's Supreme Court decision will take time to sink into the minds of those most affected. The Supreme Court, in a sense, has passed back to Congress a "buck’’ which Congress has long been passing to the court. In effect, we can imagine the court saying to Con gress something like this: For years you have been writing laws which were unconstiftitionai and which you knew to be unconstitutional. You have been voting for these meas ures because they seemed to be popu lar, or because a popular President demanded them. In one recent case, the original Guffey coal bill, you voted for It because the President told you that he hoped you would vote for it in spite of any doubt you might have about its constitutionality. That was an improper thing for a President to ask and an improper thing for you to do. Both the President and Congress are supposed to have just as much responsibility and regard for the Con stitution as we on the Supreme Court. You have been passing laws which you knew to be unconstitutional, and other laws which you knew to be badly written and in other respects undesir able. You have voted for these measures, saying to yourselves, Oh, well, anyhow the Supreme Court won’t let it stand.’ You have said to your selves that the justices of the court didn't have to go before constituencies for re-election and therefore the court could afford to be the goat. Well, for the time being, the court is not going to be the goat. You mem bers of Congress have got to live up to your responsibility.” Congress Is Going to Wake Up. When Congress realizes that the court, in part at least, takes this posi tion, much of Congress is going to wake up. It is going to wake up about the Wagner law. The court only held the Wagner law to be within the Constitution. The court didn’t say whether it Is a good law or a bad one. Much of Congress, and many out of Congress, know it to be badly inspired, badly written, and generally unwork able. It was Mr. Walter Lippmann, I think, who called it, at the time it was enacted two years ago, "a legis lative monstrosity.’’ It is now up to Congress to perform several surgical operations on the act. The awakening in Congress will be explosive when the Southern Demo crats, who now compose the New Deal leadership in Congress, realize how far the Wagner act, which the court has upheld, involves State rights. Since last Monday, there is doubt whether enough is left of States' rights to pro tect the South in its cherished pre rogative of conducting its own elections without interference lrom Washington. (Copyright. 19X7.1 Railway and navigation companies in China report gains in revenue in the last year. CASTELBERGS famous Watches STYLED to every taste! PRICED for every purse! (1) A smart and de pendable lady’s GOTHAM—it’* only $12.95 50c Weekly! (2) “The Medallion,” a stunning BULOVA for the ladies. $24.75 50c Weekly! (3) An ELGIN for gentlemen who de mand quality. $25 SOc Weekly! (4) HAMILTON 1? Jewels—the watch of railroad accuracy. $37.50 7Sc Weekly! No extra charge for Credit! We, the People Vote in Congress on Sit-Down Strike Seen Tip-Off As to Support for Court Bill. BY JAY FRANKUN. THE vote* In the Senate and the Home of Representatives on the sit down strike situation provide a pretty reliable tip-off as to the support the President’s judiciary reform bill will get when it is reported to Congress. On the whole, the same group with the same backers who are fight ing the reform bill are also anxious to have the Government “do some thing" about the sit-down situation. Party lines are broken on both questions and neither problem was directly involved in the commitments “£5*1 of the 1936 campaign. The Senate voted down the Byrnes amendment to the Gulley coal bill, condemning slt-downlng, by 48 to 36, with 12 Senators absent or paired. This result flts in with the New Deal estimate of a Senate victory on the court-packing plan by at least 10 votes. In the House, the question came up in the form of a proposal for an Inquiry to Investigate the Mi-aown prooiem. « was introduced by Representative Martin Die* dle w d ? member 01 powerful Rule* Committee, which still is headed by Mr. John J. O'Connor, Tammany die-hard from New York. The Dies proposal was eagerly supplied by the Republicans— and was interpreted as a plan to embarrass and weaken the Presi dent. The vote against the resolution was 21) to tally which recalls Maury Maverick’s estimate that the Rootes;eit plan would pass the House with about 100 votes to spare For all practical purposes and barring a mira/ > the court fight ha* been pretty well won by the administration, thank* to the support of the people whose sovereign power has been challenged by trie Federal courts * * * * By a happy accident, a biography of the late arch-Republican Elihu Rooj,' hps, Just been written by pb>lip C. Jessup and fa;, been running ii°n the, day the H0U8e gav* Martln DlP» thp well-known works, the following letter from Root to a friend, at the time i- was reported that Theodore Roosevelt had offered him the chief Justiceship of the Supreme Court, appeared: ,p "The President offered me,” wrote Root, who was then aged 63 "the , “Sr" jUStiC€ 10 1111 1116 vacancy to which Moodv was appointed and I told him I was too old and would not take it. I am inclined to think that I should say the same thing about the chief Justice ship. I shall never have occasion to, however, because Fuller will gtav indefinitely, and, as Vest said about old Senator Morrill, they will have to shoot him on the day of judgment. He will cling to the bench with his last expiring ray of intelligence, and when that is gone he will be incompetent to resign or retire.” "Incompetent to resign or retire” expresses the feelings of the New Dealers toward some of the overage members of the present Supreme Court. * * * * And here's something which the strike news crowded out of many papers. Two Lutheran ministers recently appeared before the Senate Judiciary Committee in opposition to the Judiciary reform bill which *hev assailed as "dangerous to religious freedom.” „ v‘ j: .Y' Behnken of Oak Park. 111., president of the Missouri Svnod a Nation-wide organization representing over 1.000,000 members of the Lutheran Church, one-fourth of all American Lutherans, then issued a statement which is regarded as a masterly rebuke to clergymen whn meddle in politics. It is also an assurance'that the two SKLvS Pf- Theodor* Graebner of Missouri and Dr. Gould Wicky of New York, the latter being general secretary of the Council of Church Boards of Education—do not speak for the Lutheran Church For Dr Behnken said: ^ appearance of two Lutheran ministers before the Judiciary Committee in opposition to President Roosevelt’s court proposal, the impression has been created that the Lutheran Church is engaged in political activities, I would like to state emphatically that such is by no means the case. the Tntharm0t A^aV0r 811 Lutheran bodies, but the Missouri Synod of the Lutheran Church, a national body numbering more than 1,000,000 members, does not meddle in poll- . _ ucs, nor does it attempt to influ ence or dictate in the political opin ions or affiliations of its members. "The church's work is spir itual, not political. It is concerned about converting men, changing the hearts of men, making Christians of men by gospel preaching. “Such work, as history shows, thrives under all forms of govern ment. Such work also trains law jf Ujthepa v 3 Church does ? NOT EHOA0e l ,N POimcAL l ACr/v'T/fs ^ abiding citirens who are loyal to their country. "As for the court proposal, this is a political matter which must be settled conscientiously and to the best interest of our citizenry. As church people, we pray that God may grant proper wisdom to those who are intrusted with these responsibilities, that they may truly seek the welfare of the Nation." In this connection it is interesting to note that the anti-Roosevelt group seems to have dropped the plan to have a prominent Catholic priest testify against Mr. Roosevelt’s reform bill. The New Dealers had so many Catholic prelates of far greater influence than the priest under considera tion who were aching for the chance to support the court plan if their church were dragged into the question, that the whole scheme was put in moth balls. * * * * The most eloquent proof that the administration is winning its fight is the loud silence of Senator Bennett Clark of Missouri, who led the first headlong attack against the reform bill but who now is letting others do the talking. (Copyright, 1937.) An American You Should Know Alexander Dye Strong Asset to Bureau of Commerce. BY DELIA PYNCHON. THE Bureau of Foreign and Do mestic Commerce reaches great tentacles around the world like a giant octopus, it sucks in commercial information that enables the American importer and exporter to function. Alexander Dye, director since 1936, Alexander D»e. brings to the bu reau ft contribu tion of world un derstanding and experience that should add greatly to world commerce devel opment. The bureau is 25 years old this year. Imports show an Increase due to drought and prosperiti. Exports show a 52 per cent in crease over 1932. aignincantly due partly to prosperity and partly to rearmament in Europe. Twenty divisions, with a total per sonnel of 1,100, keep commerce wheels running. Thirty-four foreign and 25 domestic offices keep wires hum ming. One hundred and fifty reports are received daily on world trade con ditions.. Here you will find basic statistics that are used by all gov ernmental departments that deal m commercial matters. Varied in Activities. Mr. Dye is a personable and friendly man, with an appreciative smile and a steely glint in his blue eyes that mean •'business.” His life runs a gamut of philosopher, professor, busi ness man, cowboy, traveler. They have brought him many posts of responsi bility in Government service and have kept him abroad most of his life. A native of Flora. Illinois, Dye started his education at William Jewel College, Liberty, Mo., graduating in 1901. He continued his academic career at the' University of Leipzig, Germany, where he was made a doc tor of philosophy in 1904. Returning to his alma mater, he taught lan guages five years. Suddenly Dye said, "I revolted against the academic life. I wanted action, and I sure got it.” In 1909, as American Consul at No gales, Mexico, for four years, he saw plenty of action. The revolution against Diaz was under way. Pancho Villa was on the rampage. Obregon and Calles were then revolutionary generals, with whom Dye often dined. Mining Work in Arizona. In Arizona he saw action in a four year association with the Phelps Dodge Oorp., a mining venture "It was a troublous period of many strikes,” Dye says. In 1917 he went to Norway as rep resentative of the War Trade Board. For his services he was decorated with the Order of St. Olaf. He associated himself with the In ternational Associational Corp., which led him all over Europe. In 1921 he entered the Commerce Department, became trade commissioner in Lon don, commercial attache at Mexico City and Buenos Aires. He did much to further American foreign trade. Once Dye’s train was derailed in an Argentine swamp, pinning the fire man under the boiler. Dye rescued the man. Current newspapers called it “a typical bit of Yankee heroism.” Russia’s Exhibits. Russia's exhibits at the Paris Ex position will include mechanical mod els of the port of Leningrad, the loco motive works in Voroshilovgrade, the new- Socialist agricultural city in Kabardino-Balkaria and the Moscow Volga Canal. IIAIIN 14th & G • 7th & K • 3212 14th features Florsheim Shoes GOLF SHOES Endorsed by the j PGA STYLES 51350 REGULAR STYLES | : - Borsheim presents die shoes officially endorsed and recoin* mended to all golfers hy & the Professional Golfers ' Assodadon of America. Boik on exciasiye golf lasts, of finest leathers, " with "Keep-Dri** soils, and patentedremovable steel calks. HAHN TRU-MOCS Golf or sports shoes with spiked leather or crepe soles. Genuine moccasin construction in which you walk on a smooth piece of soft upper leather that extends completely around your foot. A truly "7 IT American outdoor shoe giving utmost comfort_ ^