Newspaper Page Text
Weather Forecast Cloudy, cool, occasional rain today, high thla aftemon in lower 70s, low tonight about 6*. Tomorrow- cloudy, humid, chance of show ers. (Pull report on Page A-2.) Midnight, 71 6 ajn. ---68 11 am. 69 2 a.m. 70 8 ajn. ---67 Noon_70 4 a m. -__69 10 ajn. ..-67 1 p.m. _-_70 Lote New York Morkets, Pogt A-13. Quid* for Ktadari % ?» DmhM CtstRif* f I* II t&urMl % • Itffwirl ft nr In %•* Flaam* % • l J A- Akkx «s •(•€ Rr-j**! i t OteiffcaM"? * t* R*4*> C 11 Apart* fit W anwtt » #Kftj«5 I I • 97th Year. No. 175. Phone ST. 5000 irk S WASHINGTON, D. CM WEDNESDAY, JUNE, 29. 1949— FIFTY-TWO PAGES, cvi» wiw n»r» ».«««• » t* » mm «k * m i'ry Tfl •»:•«*?% *5 .JM »*♦« f*» ** >M *: W **,# * • *»* MmM • V *• •’ * * JUDITH COPLON'S FATE IN HANDS OF JURY Judge Corrects His Charge After Defense Protest Jurors Ask for Full FBI Reports, Purse And Its Contents By James J. Cullinane and W. H. Shippen, Jr. The fate of Judith Coplon, first Justice Department employe ever accused of espionage, was placed in the hands of a jury of four women and eight men at 11:12 a m. today. In a 25-minute charge to the Jury Judge Albert L. Reeves said the brunette 28-year-old defend ant should be acquitted on the first count in the indictment against her if the jury believed her story that she was in love with her alleged Russian confederate, Valentine A. Gubitchev, and never intended to transmit information about this country's national de fense to a foreign power. Judge Reeves told the jury there is no question but that the de fendant removed documents deal ing with the national defense from Justice Department files and had them in her purse when she was arrested on March 4. In considering the second count of the indictment, which charges merely that she unlawfully re moved the documents from Justice Department flies, Judge Reeves said the jury should determine whether she was following ac cepted practice. To Consider “All Circumstances." If they believed she took the documents merely to prepare for a civil service examination or to aid her in writing a book, as she testified, then Miss Coplon should be acquitted on the second count, Judge Reeves told the jury. Judge Reeves told the jury It should consider all circumstances In connection with Miss Coplon’s “clandestine and secret” meetings in New York with Gubitchev, a Soviet engineer employed by the United Nations. In addition to the trial here, Miss Coplon faces trial with Gu bitchev in New York on charges of conspiring to violate espionage statutes. Defense Attorney Archibald Palmer took emphatic exception to Jutfge Reeves’ charge after the jury left the courtroom. He in sisted there was nothing “clan destine or secret” about the meet ing of Miss Coplon and Gubitchev on January 14, the first occasion on which the pair were trailed by FBI agents. Judge Corrects Error. Judge Reeves recalled the jury and told them he had made one error in his charge. He said there was nothing "clandestine or secretive” about the January 14 meeting of Gubitchev and Miss Coplon. The white - haired 75 year-old jurist then told the jurors to go to their room and elect a foreman and begin their delibera tions. Opposing attorneys were 6till arguing a technicality an hour after the jury received the case. .The jury had asked for the se cret FBI reports on which the data slips found in Miss Coplon s pocketbook were based. Objects to Marked Copies. Mr. Palmer objected to the jury seeing copies of the voluminous reports which had been lined in red pencil by prosecution attor neys in the early stages of the trial. There were technical leasons, it was said, why neither the steno graphic record of the reports nor photostatic copies in the FBI flies would be acceptable to both sides for the study by the jury. Judge Reeves declined to return to the bench to discuss the matter and it was debated informally in the courtroom. Miss Coplon tried to get into the argument at one stage, and her counsel told her: "Sit still, Judy, for just a min ute, can’t you? Maybe you went (Continued on Page A-7^Col. 1.), Two Killed, 100 Hurt In Shanghai Bombing ■y th# Atsociatcd Pro* SHANGHAI. June 29.—Low flying Nationalist bombers blasted the crowded Chapei district of Shanghai today, killing at least two persons and injuring upward of 100. Police and rescue workers dug the injured out of blasted build ings hours after the planes com pleted their mission. The raid lasted for more than an hour. Machine guns blasted away at the leisurely flying bombers but had no effect. Reports of the number of raiders varied from two to six planes. Chapel is a densly populated Chinese residential section. One stick of bombs fell in a rice paddy near the Lunghwa Airport. Other bombs reportedly hit the Bubbling Well Cemetery. Hospitals reported at least 70 •eriously injured had been re ceived. 1 ARRIVING FOR TRIAL WINDUP—Judith Coplon and her attor ney, Archibald Palmer, are shown entering District Court this [ morning shortly before Judge Albert K. Reeves instructed the j jury in the espionage ease against the former Justice Depart- ' ment worker. —8tar Staff Photo. Former D. C. Teacher Refuses to Answer In D. C. Red Probe No Stool Pigeon, He Says; Husband of Pharmaey Proprietor Also Silent (Pictures on Page B-l.) By Chris Mathisen Pasquale L. J. Branch, former Eliot Junior High School teacher, j ! refused to tell the House Com- j mittee on Un-American Activities today whether he ever held mem bership in the Communist Party. 1 The same attitude was taken by John P. Anderson, husband of Mrs. Rose Anderson, proprietor of j the Investment Building Phar macy. Mrs. Anderson testified j yesterday and also refused to reply, to queries about possible Commu nist associations. The committee is attempting to establish that prosperous business people here have provided flnan- i cial backing for the Communist Party. Mr. Branca, who gave his ad dress as 833 Allison street N.W., said he now is employed as a salesman by the District Whole sale Drug Corp. In addition to teaching, he said he also worked for a time as a cab driver. When Frank Tavenner, com mittee counsel, asked him if he knew Mrs. Anderson, he replied: •'I object and I refuse to an swer the question because the an swer might tend to incriminate me and also because I refuse to j be used as a stool pigeon by this ; committee.” Repeated Refusals to Answer. Chairman Wood said, sharply: “The committee is not interest ed in using anybody as a stool pigeon.” Mr. Branca, however, used the phrase again when Mr. Tavenner asked him if he was a member of the Thomas Jefferson Club of the Communist Party in 1945. The witness, who said he was born here October 8, 1914, gave his repeated refusals in a loud voice and cocky manner. When Mr. Tavenner began asking him whether he knew any of a number of piersons, Mr. Branca declared he did not intend “to become part of a plan to build a blacklist in this city and deprive people of their economic means of liveli hood.1' In response to other questions, he said he had served in the Marine Corps and had taken an oath of allegiance to the United States at that time. Representa tive Case. Repubfican, of South Dakota, asked if he didn’t feel he had some obligation under that (See~UN-AMERICANT^PagrA^.) Showdown Diie Today! For Britain on Trade In ERP Conference Deadlock Over Bilateral Pacts Still Unbroken After Finance Talks iy the Associated Press PARIS, June 29.—Britain faceb a showdown today with other Marshall Plan nations on how trade should be conducted among the nations of Europe. The seven-member Consultative j Committee of the Organization for European Economic Co-operation met for a little more than half an hour this morning and decided to (urn the whole problem over to the full 19-nation organization later in the day. A spokesman described the morning meeting as "just a formal gathering" and said: “The real debate will begin now. and it will probably go on tomorrow." W. Averell Harriman. American Ambassador at large for the Mar shall Plan, attended the Consulta tive Committee session. A spokes man for him denied reports pub lished in London that Mr. Harri man had threatened to cut Marshall Plan aid to Britain un less the British agreed to Amer ican proposals. The stakes in national prestige and perhaps even national eco nomic stability seem large in com parison with the immediate dollar stakes. Last week the top economic ex perts of Britain, France and Bel guifn met in Brussels but could not resolve their differences. It was a question of the others not being able to reach an agreement with Sir Stafford Cripps. Britain's iron-willed Chancellor of the Ex chequer. Mr. Harriman has been sitting in as observer at the meetings. The question is whether each (See MARSHALL PLAN, Pg. A-3.7 20 Sait Lake City Firemen Hurt in Ice Plant Blaze By th# Associated Pross SALT LAKE CITT, June 29 - More than 20 firemen were re ported Injured or overcome by smoke during a 10-hour fire which destroyed the Utah Ice & Stor age plant early today. Flames still crackled in the five- j story buildmg more than 10 hours after the fire was discovered. The loss was estimated at be-; tween $500,000 and $1,000,000. Charles P. Rudd, manager of the poultry division. Utah Poultry and Farmers} Co-operative, said his firm had $500,000 worth of dressed poultry in the building. Large quantities of candy also were stored in the warehouse. Baruch Misinformed on Plans For Defense, White House Says Bernard Baruch's criticism of President Truman for what he termed his failure to have a stand by war 'mobilization plan drew a tart rejoinder from the White* House today that Mr. Baruch "ap pears to have some pretty bad information.” A spokesman who preferred to remain unidentified said specifi cally that Mr. Baruch was wrong in stating that the National Se curity Resources Board had draft ed a plan which had been rejected by the President. The spokesman; added the board had had no formal plan and that consequent ly Mr. Truman could not have rejected It. Mr. Baruch ir. an address yes terday at the Armed Forces In dustrial College graduation, said: that though the cold war is going; into its fourth year, this Govern ment lacks an effective plan for swift mobilization, and added that additional delay is a “gamble” with national security. The White House authority stressed that the fact that no blueprint of a mobilization plan has been made public “or shown to Mr. Baruch” doesn't mean that no planning has been underway, j Actually, the spokesman said, planning is continuous and any government which was not con stantly looking to the future “would be derelict in Its duty.” Mrs. Hiss Denies Membership in Socialist Party Voted for Thomas Once, She Testifies At Husband's Trial >Partial Hiss Trial Transcript on Pag* A-4.> By Newbold Noyes, Jr., ond Robert K. Wolsh Star SloH Coir*ipond*nt» NEW YORK. June 29 —Govern ment cross-examination of Mrs Alger Hiss at the perjury frial of her husband began today after she categorically denied accusa tions by Whittaker Chambers that she typed stolen State Depart ment documents which Mr. Chambers says she got from Mr. Hiss. Early in the cross-examination Thomas F. Murphy, assistant United States attorney, attempted to establish that Mrs. Hiss was a member of the Socialist Party in j 1932. She denied this, although she admitted voting for Norman Thomas in that year. The prosecutor produced New York City voting records showing Mrs. Hiss registered as a Socialist. He asked her if she knew the records of the party's Morning side branch for 1932 list her as a' Socialist. ‘‘I certainly do not know it.” she replied. Disputes Chamber’s Testimony. The witness, prim in a green cotton dress and white straw hat, under direct examination disputed much of the testimony of Mr. and Mrs. Chambers concerning furnishings of the Hiss homes in Georgetown and the association between the two families in the 1930s. Declaring that Mr. and Mrs. Chambers never visited them at their Volta place house where they moved in late December, 1937, or at the Thirtieth street house whpre they previously lived since July. 1936. Mrs. Hiss told of having lost a pocket book containing the key to the Volta place house in 1938. She added that she never found the pocketbook and sometime later had the locks changed oif the house. Mr. Chambers, former Com munist courier, has testified that he saw Mr. Hiss well into 1938 and got Government confidential information from him on many occasions for transfer to Soviet spies. Mr. Hiss is being tried in Federal Court here on charges ■ that he committed perjury last De cember in telling a Federal grand jury that he never gave secret documents to Mr. Chambers and never saw him after 1936, until last summer. Corrects Typewriter Statement. Overcoming the nervousness she showed on taking the stand late yesterday, Mr. Hiss corrected a statement she made before the grand jury last year concerning an old Woodstock typewriter. She had told the grand jury, she said, that she thought she had dis posed of that machine by giving it to the Salvation Army or selling it to a second-hand dealer in 1938. She explained that later dis closures, including the finding of the typewriter by defense counsel last April, convinced her she had given it to the sons of a former maid in late 1937. She added that she had confused the Wood stock typewriter with a portable typewriter she disposed of later (Continued on Page A-4, Col. 6.) Late News Bulletins Milk Price to Increase The Virginia Milk Commis- 1 sion this afternoon authorised | an increase of half a cent a quart hi the retail price of milk for the Arlington-Alexandria area, effective Friday. Wash ington dairies indicated they will increase the price by the same amount here. This will bring the home delivered price in the Metropolitan Area to ff'4 cents a quart. Schroeder to Face Drobny LONDON <A*>.—Jareslav Drob ny of Chechoslovakia defeated John Bromwich of Australia, 6—1, 6—3, 6—2, today to enter the final of the Wimbledon tennis championships Friday against Ted Schroeder of La Crescents. Calif. (Earlier Story on Fage C-L) Sheriff Closes Coal Mine MADISONVDLLE, Ey. (A*>— A few hours after an esti mated 4,666 members of the . United Mine Workers marched on the East Diamood Coal Mine in a union organising demonstration today, the mine was eloeed at the request of Has Gilliland. Hopkins County Sheriff. The sheriff said there j was no violence. (Earlier Story so Fage A-5.) ' 1 please; make: MC5T0P Hoover Sees Peril in Proposal For Chairman of Joint Chiefs Would Moke Office Too Powerful, He Soys, But Indorses General Purposes of Bill ty Atiooo'ttj Herbert Hoover said today it would be "dangerous to the country" to create a chairman for the Joint Chiefs of Staff of the Armed services as proposed by the Truman administration. Such an office, the former Presi dent declared, would "place too much power in any military officer." Mr. Hoover testified before the House Armed Services Committee on legislation to amend the Armed Services Unification Act of 1947. Generally, the measure is aimed to give more power to the Secretary of Defense and iron out "bugs' in the 2-year-old law. Backers have contended the proposed revisions will permK savings of many millions of dol lars. The Senate passed the legis lation May 26. Mr. Hoover indorsed the general purposes of the bill but strongly opposed a section which would create a chairman for the Joint, Chiefs. Each of the armed services is represented on the Joint Chiefs by its chief of staff. Under the present arrangement, each is equal in theory and they try to reach their decisions by mutual agree ment. The proposal to create a chair man was advanced by the late Secretary of Defense Forrests 1 and has the specific indorsement of President Truman. Under the plan, the chairman would act as chief military advisor to the Presi dent and the Secretary of Defense Chairman Vinson said he agreed with Mr. Hoover that the proposed chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff might become, in effect, a single chief of staff for all the armed forces. Mr. Vinson added' •'I want to put something in this bill so that it can't happen." Representative Short. Republi can. of Missouri said he is "a little alarmed about the tremendous powers" proposed in the bill for the Secretary of Defense. Mr. Hoover told Mr. Short: *T believe Secretary Forrestal's iSee”UHIFICATiON. Page A-4_> U. y Bars Recognition Of Legality of China's Order Closing Ports Effective Blockade Held Necessary to Change Rights of Americans By Garnett D. Horner The United States today an nounced its refusal to recognise legality of a Chinese government declaration closing Chinese ports held by the Communists to foreign vessels unless China maintains an effective blockade of those ports. Secretary of 8tate Ache son told a news conference that this action does not mean that the American Government is going to try to run the so-called blockade, but merely reserves the rights of American citizens. The Chinese government was informed of the decision in a note delivered by the American Embassy at Canton yesterday. Mr. Acheson made the note public here today. v British Position More Extreme. Orest Britain has taken a more extreme position in regard to the matter. Mr. Acheson said he un derstood. He told reporters that the ques tion of possible recognition of a Chinese Communist government has not arisen because there is no such government seeking recogni tion. The Chinese government noti fied the United States and other powers on June 20 that ports in a large coast area under Com munist control "shall be tempo rarily closed and entry therein of foreign vessels shall be strictly forbidden." The Chinese declara tion added that foreign vessels violating this decision would be responsible for any resulting danger. Effective Blockade Held Essential. The American reply said: "Despite the friendliest feelings toward the Chinese government, the United States Government cannot admit the legality of any action on the part of the Chinese government in declaring such ports and the territorial waters adjacent thereto closed to foreign vessels unless the Chinese govern (See CHINA, Page A-4J 1 Vatican Car Reported Entered Forcibly by Czechoslovak Police Action Was 'Rudt and Violent/ Diplomatic Source in Prague Says fty IK* AtiMMIld PfMI PRAGUE. June 20—A diplo matic source said today that Czechoslovak police had forcibly entered the automobile of a Vati can diplomatic representative at Kosice, in Slovakia. The Informant, who is close to Vatican representatives here, said the incident occurred last night. The source described the police action as "rude and violent'' and said a protest had been lodged with the Foreign Ministry against "this violation of the rights of a Diplomat." 'An informed source in Vatican City said the Vatican expects its diplomatic links with ™«See CZECH. Page A-6 * Home Rule Could Cost Jobs of 2,000 Here, McMillan Declares Transfer of Voting Rights To District Would Change State Quotas, He Soys By Don S. Worren The possibility that some 2 OOO Government worker* here might lose their jobs if Washington gets home rule was raised today by Chairman McMillan of the House District Committee, s suffrage op ponent He Mid he understood thst District residents now sre about 2.000 over the city's quota for Federal Jobs, under the civil service apportionment rule, divid ing Jobs among residents of the States and the District ‘They could lose their jobs If the Civil Service Commission in sisted on the apportionment.' Mr McMillan declared today during a hearing on the home rule pro posal Might Change Classification Mr. McMillan s suggestion was related to the question whether persons voting here might loae any voting privilege* they mav have been maintaining in a State Observers Interpreted the re mark to suggest that if voting in Washington established a per son » legal residence here Federal work ers exercising the ballot privilege locally might be classified in the Districts quota of Oovernment Job* and thus add u> any eiceas now existing An immediate challenge wa* made by Senator-Kefauver, Dem ocrat. of Tennessee, author of the home rule bill passed May 31 by the Senate. On the witness stand when Mr McMillan raised the point, Fma tor Kefauver replied 'T dor t think any one would lose his Job for this reason. The bill speci fically recognises that a resident of the District and otherwise qualified as an elector could vote in etty election* here although he continued to maintain his voting rights in the State of his legal domicile." This is the so-called dual vot ing" provision which has been made a point of controversy by House committee opponents of lo cal suffrage. Today s hearing was brief rrnce the House met 11 11 a m Chairman McW.llan an nor need Continued on Page A-3. Col i.» Bob Barnett Found Unconscious In Chevy Chase Club Golf Shop Popular Prof 51, In Undetermined State at Hospital Robert T. (dob) Barnett. 51. golf profession*! at the Chevy Chase Club for the last 21 yean, was found unconscious in the club golf shop early today, ap parently having barn there in a coma all night. He is in unde termined condition at George town Hospital. Club Manager R. J. Roper said the last employe reported leaving the golf shop at about 5:50 o clock last night while Mr. Barnett was still there. William Hardy, as sistant pro at the dub. found Mr. Barnett at about • o'clock this morning, stumped la a chair. The door to the shop was locked { Dr. J, Lawn Thompson jr.. per sonal physician to the well-known golfer, mid Mr. Barnett was to s coma when he esammad him. but added that ha could not yet say what had eauaed the soils pm. At the Barnett beam, 458) Ridge BOB BABMWTT ! —Stmr Stef rhoto i itnrt. Carry Char* Md Immiij nambrr* aud they did ta* *»•» rhat had erad, thr eoUapM. tat rtad teen taid at th» hMpttal that ~uST iuawrr, rm Xi» Final SenateVote On Labor Bill Due Tomorrow Approvol of All Toft'* Amendments Likely; Lucos Predicts Veto •UUITIN The Berate a#r»«d today M* vote at 1 p m inrBWTtm or t.ha remainder of the Taft subati tute for the admtmaira troth* labor bill This may remit tn a final Senate vote on the la hoe bill before !<wmn#i r.ifhi eith mdrranom that the enure Taft pfoaram ail! pa** But Mt .tort tv leader !**<-*» predicted flails Oat President Truman a mild veto the bill *y J A 0 Leore Thr Tail-Hartley labor Art ap pealed destined todav to remain on the book* at least another sear, and become a major t**ue in Uw 1950 ccsnyre** tonal election* Administration leader* had lit tle hope left of carrym* out *t thl* WMion ihelt promise to re peal the la a in ue* of Renata adoption of trie Taft Plan for handlin# national erne:fancy strike* By a sole of M) to 40 the Ohm Republican Sena to* with South ern IVeniociatlr help arote into (he administration » mild nee la bel bill hi* plan rropoaeun* the President to u*e plant »ei»uie or injunction* cm both to present Natuuvaide industrial tie-up* Senator Taft predicted similar victory for the rest of hi* amend ment*. tic untied to presets# oilier essentia! feature* of the present la a I un< Heck* v ale 1 »»w«*etww Th* Taft amendment# diop some provision* of the present la* but not enough to aaliafy th® admini*tration The general be lief at the Capiioi i» that any bill that toea through both house® now probably would be vetoed, and the Taft-Hartley barker* would not be an on* enough t® override Senate Majority Leader Lueai planned to try thU afternoon to get an agreement for a final vm# on the labor bill tomorrow befor# the Senate begin# a Fourth of July rerea* Senator Jvea Republican of New York who prevlouaiy had op posed a quick final vote treeauwa he wanted to offer further amend ment*. told reporter# he would not objert to the Luca# requeat today. If the agreement I* made all Indication* are the Senate will adopt the remainder of the Taft amendment* in which caae ad ministration forces are eaperted to lose interest in trying to put through a new labor la* at thta aeaaion (lawk Mhwp Raw ftwwght. William Oreen of the American Federation of Labor wrote Senator l ait a# today aupportmg hit re queat to vote immediately on th# T*ft gubatltute becauae "We feel that amendment* rte signed to make the Taft bill mor® palatable would be uaeleaa and a waste of time aa the aetion yeater - day tn the Senate * * • make it absolutely unacceptable * Other amendment* nought by Senator Taft include The ban on closed shop con tract# although continuing to permit the union shop Th# independence of the Fed eral Mediation Service, which th® administration want* under th® Labor Department The ban on maa# picketing and • See LABOR Rage A-l i D. C. Enjoys Cool Day; Tomorrow to Be Warm W ash in f ton are* resident* e«» joyed cooi weather again today but the intermittent rains w«l end tome line tonight and warm, humul weather it predicted for to morrow. The cold front that brought Washington relief from the heat was a more serious proposition in nrtohbortng Mate* Mesry ra.na aent owiu out of their ban**, causing minor repeat flood* ua Petersburg and Romney W Vs. usd Cumberland Md As aoob a* the rams stopped late last night the waters began to recede tn both area* the Asso ciated Press reported A diaastrou* flash flood tiiied a* least nine persons a the Peters burg area has than two wastes ago (been inches of water courted through the southern part of Petersburg iate yesterday cut ting S OOO telephone Itnea A two hour cloudburst struct Cumber land with >43 inches of water, street* and Knocking out telephone lams * The forecaster said today » high temperature will bo tt degreeo with o lorn of it day ram tagoctad tonight