Newspaper Page Text
SNA ICAN AH INDEPENDENT PROGRESSIVE JOURNAL THIRTIETH YEAR 28 PAGES PHOENIX, ARIZONA, SUNDAY MORNING, JULY 13, 1919 US PAGES VOL. XXX., NO. 77 TB ARIZO KEPXJBL WOULD MAKE ALL 1LI1S INTO IE LIS Consolidation of Many Sys tems Into a Few Big Ones Urged by Expert to Solve the Railroad Problem Big Lines Absorb Small Ones NEW YORK, July 12. Consolidation . of all the railroads of the T'nited States into a few large systems from 12 to 25 as a possible solution of the nation's roalroad problem, is opposed by Robert 8. Lovett, former president of the T-'nion Pacific railway in a memoran dum to congress made public here to day. Judge Lovett for a time was di rector of the division of capital ex penditures of the government railroad administration under William G. Mc A4oo as director general. The effect of the proposed consoli dation would be in his opinion "to im pair the credit of the strong roads, in- stead of improving the credit of the weak road. Inevitable effect would be 1 to reduce the average of credit of all the railroads- "Congress," he asserted, "has no right to compel one railroad to con- ; solidate with another. It may give one the right to acquire the poperty of the other by condemnation but it must pay for it, and here is the difficulty, pay for it In cash. Need Fabulous Sums "The underwriting of a fabulous : amount must be provided. Will con gress appropriate the billions neces- i sary? Have we bankers enough to pro vide the money except through a series of years? And what will happen to the welfare of the country n the mean time? "My judgment is against the con solidation of all the railroads of the , country Into a few companies, because ; I believe the companies will be too large and too unwieldy for efficient and - economical management. "I believe that the absorption of some of the weak lines by some of the strong lines, upon fair terms, should he promoted but competition in service and facilities should not only be pre served but should be extended." Judge Lovett also opposed the plan which has been discussed for pooling the next earnings of railroads by divid ing them Into groups and establishing rates sufficient to yield six per cent or some other specified return on the book value of each group. Earnings in excess of the average, he pointed out .would be set aside for the unprof itable roads that earn less. One Scheme Impracticable Suggestion put forward bv many financiers and railroad men "that the government should guarantee fair divi dends on the full value of the railroads and leave the management in the hands of the railroad owners, was character ized by Judge Lovett as impracticable because he did not believe the govern ment would take all the risk and none of the profits. If a small return of two, three' or four per cent were guaranteed, he said, this- would not be sufficient to pay the interest on bonds already outstanding. "It would make doubly sure what is already abundantly secured," he con tinued, "but it could afford no colla teral nor new issues nor secure new loans. "The importance of re-establishing railroad credit cannot be overestimat- ed," said Judge Lovett. "but neverthe less, I am persuaded that no guaranty short of a retrn upon the full value of the railroad property will be helpful to that end, and that a guaranty of full "value is not practicable without gov ernment operation, which I regard as beyond present discussion." after Brokers who Republican A. P. Leased Wire N'EW YORK. July 12. Internal rev enue officers who yesterday launched a campaign in this city against stock brokers who have evaded payment of income taxes, tonight turned their at tention to theater ticket speculators, arresting five on charges of defrauding the goverrfment by failing to pay war taxes on tickets sold by them. More than a. score of ticket broker age offices vere visited, and the agents had expected to make about 40 arrests. It was believed that the brokers had been "tipped off," however, as only four offices were found open. The complaints on which the arrests were made charged that the brokers had violated a section of the revenue act which provided that "whoever sells an admission ticket or card on which the name of the vendor and the price i not printed, stamped or written, or at a price in excess of the price so printed, stamped or written, is guilty of a misdemeanor. NEWS EPfirOfVIE 70REIGN Orangemen warn United States not to interfere in government of Ire land. Secretary Lansing leaves Paris on first leg of homeward voyage. British dirigible R-34 ends homeward voyage, alighting at Pulham early this morning. DOMESTIC I Townsley and Gilbert, non-partisan league members, are found guilty of disloyalty; stay of execution . granted. rVoposal made to make all railroads of U. S- into few great systems. LOCAL Hotel blocking ease to be argued be- fore Judge Stanford 9:30 Monday morning. , President Matthews of Tempe Nor mal reelected treasurerwf National ' Eduational association. More than one-half inch of rain fell. Work on three new school buildings . to start in a few days. . EVADED INCOME TAX MartialLaw Likely Result Of New Clash LONGVIEW, Texas, July 13. The situation here in connection with Friday's clash between whites and blacks was revived late last night when a negro named Eurch, father-in-law of S. L. Jones, al leged negro ringleader, fired upon a party of officers who visited his home. Martial law will be de clared today, according to an nouncement by Mayor G. A. Boden heim at 1 o'clock this morning. Mayor Bodenheim said he talked with Governor W. H. Hobby at Austin over the telephone at 1 o'clock and the governor said he would order ZOO additional national guardsmen to come here probably from Dallas. Martial law, the mayor said, would be declared upon the arrival of these men. County officers went to Burch's ' home and asked admittance. The negro, according to the officers, fired five shots, none of which struck the officers. The negro es caped in the darkness and blood hounds were put on his trail. He was captured at 2 a. m. gitSible lands safely st NUWIUL LONDON, July 13. (Sunday) The British dirigible R-34 landed safely at Pulham at 7:02 o'clock this morning, Greenwich Mean. Time. LONDON". July 12. The British dir igible R-34 passed over Clifden, Ireland at 20:10 Greenwich Mean Time (4:10 p. m. New York time.) After passing the Irish coast Major Scott, in command of the dirigible, did not communicate with the ministry for hours. His last report was that the R-34 was crossing Ireland high up in a clear sky, with a following wind. The Pulham airdome has received a wireless mesage from the R-34 saying that she expected to attempt a landing at about 6 o'clock Greenwich Mean Time, Sunday morning. The air ministry calculated at mid night that the R-34's landing time would be about 8 o'clock Sunday morn ing. The British dirigible R-34 is proceed ing to England under none too fav orable circumstances and Major Scott, her commander, protested tonight against landing at Pulham. He re ported that a second motor of the craft ia working badly which leaves only three in good working order. Major Scott has asked the air min istry to rescind trie order changing the dirigible's destination, but without avail. COSHiSEMIhlESSHOW BISBEE. July 1. Reports compiled by Cochise County Treasurer Guy C. Welch for the board of supervisors, covering the period from September, 1918, to May, 1919, show a total amount of city and county taxes collected to be $1,919,279.52. Of this amount, total taxes of corporations of Cochise coun ty were $1,475,481.77. City taxes paid equalled $239,438.02. Taxes that were delniquent in May equalled $31,000. Total taxes paid by smaller taxpayers were $443,817.85. Under the present law, the county treasurer of Cochise county collects the taxes for the different cities in the county which are unincorporated at the same time that the county and state taxes are collected. The total net assessed valuation of Cochise county for the year 1919 for the producing mines is $113,258,170, "an increase of over $3,000,000 since 1918. The Phelps-Dodg&'corporation Copper Queen branch, ranks second in the entre state with a valuation of $72, 050,407. IDE BILLY DIES FROM INJURIES SUSTAINED IN FALL FROM HORSE WASHINGTON', July 12. News of the death of Edouard de Billy, former deputy French high commissioner to the United States, who was thrown from his horse in France, was con-, tained in a cablegram received today at the French embassy. No details were given. Mr. de Billy came to this country with the French high commission after America entered the war and remained until a short time ago: He acted as head of the mission for several months after Andre Tradieu returned to Paris. WHITE REPRESENTS U.S. ON "COUNCIL OF FIVE" PARIS. July 12. Henry White rep resented the United States at the af ternoon session of the council of five. Secretary Lansing called to say good bye. The Italian request that the Austrian concessions at Tien Tsing, China, be transferred to Italy, was referred to a commission for consideration. It was decided by the council to send a message to the Czechs and Poles, declaring that if no agreement is reached regarding the contested Teschen coal situation within 10 days the council will decide the question itself. INVESTIGATING BUREAU IS REORGANIZED NEW YORK, July 12. The national investigating bureau organized by the war chest committees of various states during the war to investigate war charities, announced today its re-organization as the national information bureau to investigate social and wel fare organizations national in scope. Barry C. Smith of this city will con tinue as director, with Gustavus D. Pope, Detroit, president, Hln "GIDDAP, m OH OOR. OLD fctUABL AIRSHIP LINE ran - I ' loV.TAMVATlAHT.C GROOKBS 3k NON-PARTISAN LEAGUE HEADS FIIOJITI Jury Finds They Conspired To Teach Disloyalty A. C. Townley and Joe Gil bert, Defendants Wanted To Argue ' Own Cases JACKSON, Minn., July 12. The jury in the trial of President A. C. Townley and Joseph Gilbert of the Non-Partisan League, late to night found the defendants guilty of the charge of conspiracy to teach disloyalty, in violation of the Minnesota law. When Prosecutor E. H. Nicholas completed his argument tonight in the case of A. C. Townley and Joseph Gil bert, charged with conspiracy to teach disloyalty, Townley made a personal plea to the court that he be permitted to argue his own case to the jury- Townley told the judge he had dis missed his attorneys and that the co defendant, Gilbert, had waived the right of further representation by counsel and that Townley asked the privilege of speaking on the ground that he left the Non-Partisan league was on trial. Judge Dean denied Townley's re quest to address the jury. Townley, after conferring with his attorneys, announced he had decided to rest his case without argument. Judge Dean then began his charge to the jury at 8:55 a. m. Prosecutor Nicholas, in his address to the jury charged that the state hart proved its conspiracy charge against the two Non-Partisan league leaders through the testimony of witnesses who had heard various speeches made by the defendants, through evidence in the form of league literature and through the testimony of the state's leading witnesses, one of whom was F. A. Teigen, a former member of the league, who declared that Townley told him in 1917: "We are against this war, but can't afford to advertise it." After Nicholas closed his argument, Townley stepped before the court. , "Tour honor," said he. "I have dis charged my counsel. I feel that I and the organization are on trial and that I can handle this defense better than my attorneys. I do not know what Mr. Gilbert is going to do about it." Defendants Wanted to Argue At this point, George Hoke, who has been chief counsel for the defendants, announced that Gilbert had waived his right to be represented by counsel. "I ask your honor that I may be per mitted to make my own plea to the Jury. The attitude of more than 250,000 farmers and a million of people throughout this northwest will depend upon the decision of the jury." Judge Dean questioned whether the law would permit one of the defen dants to try his own case in an action of this kind without legally repre senting the other defendant. Townley is not a lawyer. Assistant Attorney General J. E. Markham, objected, holding that the court could not prpperly grant the de fendant's request. Judge Dean then asked the attorneys to submit authori ties on the issue, and Townley took his chair while the lawyers argued. The case went to the jury at 9:45 p. m. Much of Judge Dean's charge related to the question of conspiracy and the fact that the guilt of one de fendant in a conspiracy action is con sidered the guilt Of both defendants. WILLARD REACHES HOME LAWRENCE. Kan., July 12. Jess Willard and his wife slipped quietly into Lawrence last night and were resting at their home west of town to day. Mrs. Willard told today how she went from her home to Toledo without being recognized until after the fight. Willard plans to leave here shortly on a business trijto .ihe-Teaa&.-oil-fields., FANNIE! HEH, HEH, HEH!" - ttrviulLtl jv nwfC MOVE TO BLOCK THE TREATY ENDORSE! WASHINGTON, July 12. Plans for preventing unreserved ratification of the peace treaty were discussed today at conferences of senate .opponents of the league of nations, but it was said no decision was reached on the ques tion whether President Wilson should be invited before the foreign relations committee when it takes up the treaty monday. The subject of the president's ap pearance will be taken up tomorrow when it is said opposition members of the committee will endeavor to agree on united action. Some of them are understood to favor inviting the presi dent to sit with the committee daily, while others oppose it on the ground that the treaty now is out of his hands and the senate alone is responsible. Mr. Wilson's supporters were pri vately predicting tonight that the first motion to be passed at Monday's meet ing of the committee would be one in viting him to be present at subsequent sessions. proiitSebite concluded i house Republican A. P. Leased Wire WASHINGTON. July 12. General debate on the prohibition enforcement hill twelve hours of it was concluded today in the house, and advocates and opponents of the measure made ready for the real battle that will begin Mon day when it is taken up for amend ment. Prohibition leaders admitted tonight that it was doubtful whether a vote would be reached before Saturday. "There will be a fight in every line of the printed text." they said, first of which will be over an attempt to split the three part bill so as to take up separately a straight measure for enforcement of the war-time law. Representative Igoe, democrat. Mis souri, startled some of the prohibition advocates by suggesting that they raise no point of order against a pro Dosal to let the house vote on an amendment to repeal the war time law. This action has been expected and half a dozen were known to be ready with the contention that such an amendment was not in order. o BIG DECREASE IK Dili VALUATION GLOBE, Arizona, July 12. The total net, assessed valuation of Gila county for the year 1919 is $158,524, 234.11, ac cording to figures recently compiled by Frank Gates, clerk of the board of su pervisors. This amount is $5,594,663.37 less than the total net assessed valua tion for the year 1918. The producing mines of Gila county are assessed at $119,654,096.21, the In spiration ranking first with a vauation of 173,444,184. Clerk Gates, Chairman Rose, of the supervisors, and Assessor Duncan leave early next week for the Grand Canyon, where they will meet with the state tax commission, scheduled to convene on July 21. GERMANS PUNISH SOVIETS BERLIN', July 12. A court martial at Munich which is trying the com munist leaders today, sentenced Erich Muehsam, who was one of the mem bers of the Bavarian soviet cabinet to 15 years imprisonment for high trea son, with extenuating circumstances. Herr Wadler was given eight- years penal servitude as as accessory. Ay"rt nxvx , p rWwm ORANGEMEN GIVE HlMMIIlIC HOT TO miiimisu iu u HELP IN FOB Ulster Leader Has Hard Words for American Mis sion It Stirred Up Trou ble Irish Republic, He Says, Backed by Church and Germans BELFAST. Ireland, July 12. The twelfth of July celebrations were car ried out today in Ulster on a large scale. Sir Edward Carson, the Irish unionist leader, speaking at the Orange demonstration at Holywood, Belfast, said : "There is a campaign going on in America foistered by the Catholic church which will soon be joined by the Germans, and their funds, in order to create a great anti-British feeling. "Heaven knows I want good reeling between America and this country. I believe the whole future of the world probably depends upon the relations between the United States of America and ourselves, but I am not going to submit to- this kind of a campaign, whether for friendship or for any other purpose. "I seriously say to America today you attend to your own affairs; we will attend to ours. You look after your own questions at home; we will look after ours. We will brook no in terference in our own affairs by any country, however powerful. . It is not for that we waged the great war of independence which has just been con cluded. " What right had an American, mission to come to this country come here in a breach of hospitality of one nation towards another to attempt to stir up strife in matters in which they were not connected? "The encouragement those men gave the Sinn Fein has created for the Brit ish ' government far more difficulties than ever before. I believe that the visit of these men and the encourage ment they gave to lawlessness, which is being preached throughout the land, has added greatly to the campaign of assassination of innocent policemen who were only doing their duty to their king and country and who were foully murdered on the roadside, with men looking on, who had not the courage to arrest life assassins or give such information as would bring them to justice." Sir Edward Carson denounced Sir Horace Plunkett, who, he said, was elected chairman of the Irish conven tion because he was "thoroughly hated and distrusted by both sides," "and," added the speaker, "a nice mess he made of it." CHEER wm OF IRISH REPUBLIC" AT Republican A. P. Leased Wire CHICAGO, July 12. A ,15-minute demonstration greeted Emmon de Valera, "president of the Irish repub lic," when he arose to speak at a luncheon in his honor today. He was borne on the shoulders of his guests and carried around the room as he waved an Irish flag in one hand and an American flag in the other. Mr. de Valera came to Chicago this morning and was received by a com mittee of 1,500 and a large crowd. - (ContinjuediOn Pager Twelve), CHECAGQ SPEECH I BSIitaieaEi(b Republican A. P. Leased Wire WASHINGTON, July 12. The right of congress to deflnte intoxi cating beverages was denied to day by Samuel Untermyer, a New York lawyer, in testifying before the senate judiciary sub-committee which is considering prohibition enforcement legislation. Mr. Untermyer told the commit tee that neither under the war time prohibition act nor the constitu-. tlonal amendment could congress say that any particular percentage of alcohol content constituted an intoxicating liquor. Both the act and the amendment, he argued, left this as a question of fact which could be determined only before a jury. o El E STATE HEADQUARTERS OF AMERICAN LEGION Resolutions Condemning I. W. W. and Demanding Congress to Investigate Conscientious Objectors are Passed TUCSON, July 12. The first con vention of the Arizona division of the American Legion closed here tonight with a home coming celebration for all service men, at which Dr. R. B. von KlejnSmid, president of the Uni versity of Arizona, was the chief speaker. At the concluding session of the con vention, Walter Sandberg of Yuma was elected state vice commander of the legion, and the following were elected ; members of the executive committee: George H. Myers, Flagstaff; A. J. Detloff, Bisbee; George W.. Nilsson, Prescott; R. M. Aiton, Clifton; Oscar Ruggles, Phoenix. The following were elected delegates to the national convention: John C. Greenway, Warren; E. M. Robinson, Flagstarf; Cliff Faires, Globe; Lewis S. - Douglas, Jerome; Power Conway, Phoenix; Gerald Jones, Tucson. The next state' convention will be held at Globe, Arizona, on the second Monday in August, 1920. Thoenix was selected as state head quarters of the legion, over the oppo sition of the Cochise delegation, Ira B. Joralemon declaring that the head quarters should be at the home of the legion commander and further, that the establishing of headquarters at Phoenix would make the legion sus ceptible to state politics. The legion passed resolutions con demning those responsible for the al leged protection of conscientious ob jectors and demanded an investigation by congress; denouncing the I. W. W. international socialists and anarchists: denouncing the misuse of the flag and uniform in business; endorsing the so called Lane soldier settlement plan; demanding re-employment of returned soldiers; for the protection of service men's rights under the war risk insur ance act: favoring equal suffrage, and condemning the use of military titles by civilians and others. o DAYLIGHT SAVINGS IE Republican A. P. Leased Wire WASHINGTON, July 12. The day light saving law was rescued from re peal today by President Wilson's veto of the agricultural appropriation bill. The president also vetoed the sundry civil appropriation bill because, he said, by restriction of funds it crippled the work of rehabilitating and restoring disabled soldiers and sailors to civil life. The latter veto was accepted without contest by congress and the sundry civil bill went back to committee to be reframed. Veto of daylight saving repeal wag not accented so readilv olthm.o-h h prevailing opinion was that a necessary iwo-tmrna vote to repass it over the president's veto probably would not be mustered. The first test will come in the house Monday, when, according to announce ment, republican Leader Mondell or Chairman Haughen of the agricultural committee will move the re-passage of the bill with the daylight saving repeal intact, over the presidential veto. Both bills provide funds for which agencies of the government long have been waiting. They are already months behind schedule because they failed of passage in the last congress. COIER WTTO SELL R . WASHINGTON, July 12. Prices at which surplus stocks of canned and cured meats held by the war depart ment will be sold to municipalities were announced today as follows: Corn beef, from $3.60 per dozen cans to S24. Roast beef, from $3.48 per dozen cans of one pound each to $26.40 for six pound cans. Corned beef hash, $2.76 per dozen cans of one pound each and $4.80 for two pound cans. Bacon in crates, 34 cents a pound in twelve pound tins, 36 a pound. These prices are bout 20 per cent less than the cost of the government Pro posals must be for a minimum of one carload. . WILSON SAVES THE MEASUF 81 PLUS MEAT STOCK LANSING MAKES LOT STATED! ON PEACE MEET A Farewell Speech to Press As He Sails for Home Pleased But Not Over Complacent at Treaty Sees Many Crises Ahead Republican A. P. Leased Wire PARIS. July 12 Before leaving Paris' tonight Secretary Lansing aSdressed a message to the French people acknowl edging the courtesies extended to him during his sojourn. H exrpessed re gret that he was obliged to leave Paris on the eve of the fete in honor of vic tory, in spite of the great temptation to remain. Before leaving for the United States tonight. Secretary Lansing made tha following statement to the American correspondents : "Many thoughts rush to mind on leaving the peace conference after six months of effort. Never before haf such an international gathering been held, for here has been the meeting ground of twenty-seven nations to li quidate a world war and establish a new order and a laboratory where al ready a system of world co-operation has been born, out of necessity. "Out of it all has come the most im portant international document ever drawn the treaty of peace with Ger many, a document which not onls meets the issue of the present war, but also lays down new agreements of the most helpful and most hopeful character. The nations are bound to gether to avert another world catas trophe backward peoples are given a new hope for their future; several ra cial entities are liberated to form new states a beginning is made toward re moving unjust economic restrictions, and the great military autocracies of Central Europe, are destroyed as the first step in a general disarmament. "The treaty is. of course, not all that we had hoped for. It could hardly be expected to be. Too many conflicting interests were involved as well as too many legitimate documents which would tax the most perfectly balanced mind. Nearly every one will find in it weaknesses both of omission and com mission, provisions inserted which might better have been left out. and provisions left out which might better have been inserted. Treaty a Stepping Stone "Such a document, must, however, be examined both against the back ground of its creation and in the large sweep of its spirit. From that point of view, we may call it a stepping stone from the old international methods to the new. If it still holds some of the distrusts and hatreds of the war which Germany has full well earned for her self if its construction has been hin dered by memories of secret pacts and promises, it must be borne in mind that it carries with it the evident pur pose to throw off the old methods of international intrigue and plotting. "But the present treaties are but the starting point of world reconstruction. Now that the general principles have been laid down it remains to execute them. And by that I mean not so much retributive action against nations which have recently run amuck in the world, but rather the cleansing and healing processes that shall really make good our hopes and aspirations. "Undoubtedly there is a great danger m the world today. Many people have thought that the mere signing of the treaty with Germany marks the ending or the world peril. Public opinion seems to have breathed a sigh of re lief and relapsed into apathy. Concen tration of thought on world problems is weakening now when it is most es sential, and the forces of disintegra tion and reaction have been given a freedom of action far greater than when the world was on its guard. Situation Serious "The situation today is serious, Western civilization is still dazed b? the shock of four and a half years of destruction. Industry and commerce are not yet restored. All of Europe is impoverished; parts of it are starv ing, Its whole political fibre has been shot through. Russia and Hungary are gripped by subversive political trou bles, Austro-Hungary and Turkev as empires, have ceased to be; Poland and Czechoslovakia are struggling to their feet as members of the family of na tions. All that complicated machinery of society which took decades to elabo rate and a world war to tear down cannot be replaced over night by a wholly different machinery. "Many problems remain unsettled. Territorial adjustments to secure the rights of peoples to live under their own flag as far as possible in the tangled skein of European nationali ties may be made effective. Attain ment of the Polish frontiers on all sides, particularly in East Prussia, is very difficult. The Teschen coal fields are still a source of contention be tween Eoland and Czecho-Slavia, Hun gary is Interrupting the trade of all central Europe. The Adriatic problem is still unsolved, as well as the fate of those large territories formerlv un der the Turk, including especially Asia Minor and Armenia. Statesmen Will Be Sorely Tried "World statesmanship will be sorely tried in the next few years. Two things are essential: First, arf alert, intel ligent, interested public opinion and, second, co-operation of the nations. The former is needed both as a check on any sinister purposes that may crop up and as the great support for com mon action. The second is essential, unless the nations are to return to a selfish particularism which can only breed the most dangerous disputes. "The peace conference has been his tory's greatest instance of a unified world statesmanship directing the moral and material resources of the world's family of nations. To allow the spirit behind it to disintegrate at this moment of emergency, when united action is imperative, would be fatal to all the hopes of permanent peace with which we entered the war. "If it is true that one nation can destroy the equilibrium of all, it is all the more true that each nation Is bound by its own law of self-preservation to co-operate with the others to chefk troubles before they get their headway. "So. I leave for home tonight pleased but not over-complacent with the out come of the past six months and hope ful, but not in the least unmindful, of the problems of the next few years." i i