Newspaper Page Text
o H 1 1 P BRIDGEPORT, CONN., WEDNESDAY, JAN. 5, 1&16 VOL. 52 NO. 4 PRICE TWO CENTS nEMIH6T0Hv GOmOLS B. GO Litisration in New York ; Qotcrfe? .Discloses Lodge Interests of Marcellas Hartley Dodge m Another Bridgeport Corporation. "War Boom Has Relieved Financial Strain of Plant, WhicLiNow is Directed By- Interests That Control Big Arms Plants. .., (Special to The Farmer.) New. York, Jan. 5 That the Amari6an & British Manufac turing ; Cck ' of i Bridgeport , has X . Jueexi xuetue it ua,i t ui me great Remington interests and that Marcelms Hartley Dodge, who. controls most of the Remington stock, has also hecome.one- of the largest stockholders of the American & British Co. became known,! yesterday through re- . cords Hied with the bupreme The Bethlehem Steel Co., Mr. Dodge,' Charles R. Flint, Allan A. Ryan ancTChaiiiicey N. De pew are. recorded as the largest stockholders of the Bridgeport ' concern. ;; ' , The profits from business stimulated by the war ha-v-e en abled ' the American & British Co. to pay off; a $60,000 mort gage, add $125,000 to the value of its real estate holdings and to increase its assets $700,000 : further became known, , , Justjce , Ford directed Charles- H. Tildder, receiver for the' International Power Co, of -which the Bridgeport plant is a subsidiary, to -vote the stock of the. American & British Co,' forv tie re-election - of the , present ;offlcersf tie Park Qty conoern. .''.' - , ' . ' . The plant of the American & British ; Co. la i mrpiwhing ' parts-K5. Buna send ' shells to the Bethlehem Steel Co, the United States army and many mnni-s tlon factories , in. this . country and Canada.1'' t.---' A . ... ' About $5,000,000 worth of stocks of ' the American & British Co. -was pledg ed several years ago' to the Interna ; tlonal Power Co. for. $150,000. Since the European -war began the Bridge port factory has been .operated night " and -day on -war orders, and in the v first-, few . months of the war, the " papers filed in court show the profits were so large that the company pros pered. , ... ; ;i The owners of the : pledged stock recently attempted to obtain a share of these profits by means of an action brought by the New J ersey receiver . , of , the , International Power -Co.. Ed win Sadler, of Trenton. The American f& British Co. thereupon brought, an action against the New York receiver to account, but Justice Whitfatker de nied ,the ; petition. The plaintiff then began ah action before Justice Ford to "instruct the receiver in regard to . . certain stock transactions." - In these papers, filed in the county clerk's office, it is stated that efforts . were being made to influence the In -, ternational Power ; receivers to vote the business out of the hands of the ! controlling members, and Justice Ford was asked to direct Mr. Bidder to vote to keep i the present management in control. V . - To indicate that a new" management night upset the business, . the affida vits recite that the company, is ne gotiating ; for new orders embracing hundreds- of thousands of shells for . the- Allies, and that at the present . time : It has .in process of manufac ture these -orders: 100,000 3-inch shrapnel case f orgings for the United States army; ' 900,000 .7 high explo sive shells I for the Bethlehem Steel i Co., 250 breech mechanism for 3rinch guns for the Bethlehem Steel Co., be sides breech rings for guns, lathes, - automobile trucks and other materials used In war. v; In his decision Justice Ford said: - . "I can see no valid objection to the present , management of the plaintiff erganizatioiu' There are strong argu ments why the existing board should be continued in control of its now flourishing business. The receiver, " Charles It Kidder, is instructed to vote the stock of the plaintiff cor- - poration for the re-election of the present directors at the next meet- .-, ing." :: Although Karl T. Frederick, of No. I '4 Wall street, the attorney for the International Power receiver is con nected with the firm which conducts the legal business for J. P. Morgan & Co., he has denied that - he is acting in behalf of the munition agents of the Allies In an effort fto obtain con trol of the Bridgeport- works. The attorney who represented the Amer ican' and British .company is George S. Graham, a representative in Con gress from Philadelphia, who has a law office at No. 42 Broadway. ? SHEMPP WILL GIVE ' , HIS DEPUTIES DINNER S County Sheriff Simeon Pease Will - give a dinner to his Ceputies Saturday afternoon at the county Jail. It has "been an annual custom for the coun ty sheriff to act as host to his deputies .and this year the event will be more elaborate than usual. There will be informal speeches and a group picture of the guests will be taken. THE WEATHER . Xl&ln tonight! Thursday rain or Cnow and colder. gton FURTHER OE J Washington, Jan. 5-President Wilson conferred with Sec retary Lansing for an hour today over the submarine crisis. No additional facts, beyond the definite knowledge that only two Americans were aboard the liner Persia, had been received by the state department over night field at Vienna, Ambassador Gerard at Berlin or American Con sul agents along the shores pf Such Information as had already been received, however, wad carefully reviewed by both the President and Wr. Lansing. There still was every indication that no action would be taken pending the receipt of fuller ad vices. Whether the status of the Per sia was changed - from a'n unarmed ltner to that of a vessel which might technically be classified . as armed by the fact that she mounted one gun, is a point -which United States navy ex perts will be called upon to help de- miv FfOIDEMT TO SENATE P - Washington, Jan. ,5 Charges circu lated during the last session of, Con gress that administration officials act ed in the interest of foreign business firms in urging the passage of the government ship purchase bill were held to be : baseless . in majority and minority reports filed today , by the Senate committee appointed to investi gate them. Both .reports also found the shipping interests blameless, of il legal activity in opposition to the measure. - V The majority derfounced Theodore Kobsevelt for failing to appear before the committee to testify concerning bis published assertion that President Wilson and Secretary. Bryan "had en deavored in the interest of certain foreign business firms' to secure the United States the power to purchase the; interned ships of one f, the beK ligerent : .,,.., The charge. -..fh report said, had its origin In fthat ungenerous trait of the; human mind which makes it prone to promote unworthy motives to re doubtaibte xifala and particularly po litical, antagonists." 00S1 STRIKERS MERIDEN SILVER SHOPS AND LEADERS OF UNION FACE COMPANY'S DAMAGE SUIT New Haven, Jan. 6 The petition of J the International Silver Company for J an injunction against former employes I who are now on , strike restraining them from aUeged interference with other .employes, was heard by Judge James Webb, of the superior court today. . More than a hundred per sons came down from Meriden, many of them under subpoena, and as a committee room assigned -for the mat ter was not large enough, a superior court room was used and well filled. At the outset C. J. Danaher for the respondents . waived he reading of the complaint and filed in writ ing his formal appearance for the Met al Workers, Buffers, Polishers, Platers, Brass and Silver Workers Interna tional Union, the locals of that body, the- confederation of labor, the Fed eral Union which is made up of -women, other organizations and the many individuals- named in the complaint. The International Silver Company also brings a suit alleging damages of $6, 000. The petitioners were represented by Ralph O. Wells and Roger H. Davis, MUNITIONS KEY TO VICTORY OF BRITISH ARMS Lloyd George, In Solemn Speech. Reminds Work ingmen of Their Duty London, Jan. 5-The House x ol Commons today passed a bill design ed to facilitate the output of muni- ... rrv.A win 4a tw fnrm of an UUU9. J. io pj. w ... amendment to the munitions act. In appealing for the passages of the measure. David Lloyd George; minis ter of munitions, saia: ("I hope the commons will not ren it ti task of turning UVl v - out munitions- a task more serious than I dare tell. Everything de- ntnM uDon it. The length or tne war depends upon it. Everything depends upon wnetner we turn uui munitions inx sufficient quantities to bring the campaign ' to J an end , this year. wrh.t dnM not denend upon tnfe u; havo Anna 1 their tass BUiuici e, . - - - heroically. It depends entirely upon I gay it in ail solemnity i-ne w.- men of this country doing what thji m-nrkmen of France have done: frankly, setting aside conditions, throwing themselves Into" the work and sticking to their workshops. Un less they tio that i cannot . xeu wna the result will be." . v await: TAILS OM from either Ambassador Pen the, Mediterranean. termlne. They will be asked for ad vice on how the liner's one gun' might have been used. Meagre despatches have failed to Indicate whether the gun was mounted for defense or offense. Official despatches received, today established that only one American is - among the missing ' passengers, Robert N. McNeely, newly appointed American consul at Aden. Charles H. Grant, the American passenger, was rescued; -' - i " "The writer," added the report, "whose eminence was. naturally calcu lated to give weight to his utterance, finding himself . without any - -basis, even of - a hearsay character, for his slanderous attack upon -the highest officer of his government, . simply re sorted to a palpable sophistry to es cape the responsibility for the asser tion he had made." While the committee found no evi dence to indicate that the President or Secretary Bryan harbored any purpose to bjiy interned ships the ma jority held that It was' not difficult to conceive of ' reasons - consistent with the most exalted motives that might induce the 'declaration that .the.- bel ligerents -ships would not 'be bought. . "Such" an action," said the report, "would " rightly ; be construed as an abandonment of our right, which our nation, has vigorously maintained to acquire merchant ships by 'bona 'fide purchase, though -a state of war ex ists Involving the. natlonxuridW .whose Sag they previously : sailed." : .Senator Sutherland signed the min ority report for himself and Senator Penrose. , : of Hartford. - After entering his appearance, w;hicli he! explained to the court Was to protect the rights of all those named in the complaint, Mr. Danaher entered a general denial to all the allegation. Judge Webb I said that the case was' not In court at this time, this belng simply a . hearing upon a petition for an Injunction, the burden of proof beirlg upon the peti tioners, I However, he said that Mr. Danalier could file his papers with the record in the clerk's hands. Mr. Wells " asked permission to amend the complaint as some names in it were not complete-and some of those named had not yet been served with notice. John Fitzgerald, a vice president of the metal polishers' union, was called. He said the international union was a voluntary association of men in the trades mentioned. The first knowl edge of these proceedings he had was (Continued, on Pag 7.) TIDE UNUSUALLY HIGH, SUBMARINE G-3 IS LAUNCHED Leaves Ways at Lake Co.'s Yards in Tow of Tug Rob ert McAllister. The submarine ' G-3 was launched at the Lake Torpedo Boat Co. ship yards this morning. The undersea boat went off the ways and into the water without a mishap. Lieut. Fred Xerxes Gygax, officer in command of the ship,' was in charge of the launching. Officials of the Lake Co. and others witnessed the sliding of the ship into tle harbor. The tug Robert McAllister towed the submersible. The launching was made easy by an unusually high tide that prevailed at the time. The G-8 now lies in the Bridgeport harbor and the offioer in command is awaiting orders from Washington. . VETERAIf KILLED BY GAS Hartford, Jan.' 5..- Edward- O'Reilly, 78, was found dead in- his room at No. 113 Pearl street today and gas was es caping from an- open fixture. He was a native of Ireland and came to Hartford from Wallingford- ie was a Civil war Teteran, A S ATTACIi OK g DEiJOUiyGED JUROR'S LETTER CAUSES ABRUPT ENDING OF TRIAL Suit Against Manufacturer For $10,000 Must Be Heard Aneyr. v MISTRIAL DECLARED AND COURT ADJOURNS William H. Wessels of Greenwich Unwittingly Violated Juror's Oath. The writing of a letter by a Juror to a lawyer in the case resulted in Judge Gager this morning declaring a mis trial In the $10,000 action brought by Benjamin ,Feinman, administrator, against Casper D. Wallace of this city. The Juror, William H. Wessel3 of Greenwich, ; violated his oath in writ-, ing the note and Judge Gager ruled that there was nothing else to do but discharge the Jury and order a new trial.' As no other cases were ready for trial it was necessary to adjourn court until mext Tuesday. On the jury which was chosen yes terday to hear the evidence were for mer Director of Public Works John H. Colgan and Isaac P. Turney of this city. Juror 'Wessels learned after the trial was almost over that these two men were Bridgeport residents. The automobile aecldent, which was- the cause of the present suit, happened in this city and Wessels had an idea that ( Juror was disqualified from acting in a case which concerned an affair in his own city. He therefore wrote a note to Judge A.- B. v Beers, counsel for Wallace, in which he stated that, although Judge Beers might not be afarare of the fact, there were two Bridgeporters on the jury. . Wessels" said he thought Judge Beers should know this. Judge Beers was aware that Colgan and Turney live in this city. The mere fact that they are Bridgeporters would not dis emality them from acting in a local trial. ' Nevertheless Judge Beers felt it his duty to inform Judge Gager that he had received the note from Juror Wes sels. The court remarked that the Juror had made an . innocent mistake by , writing: the ;note. He had un wittingly violated his oathby talking about the case with a person outside the Jury during the progress of the trial, .. Julge. Gager was not disposed to censure Jurolr Wessels but said Tie- hiust declare a mistflah ? Fein was suing for $10,000 , as ad ministration f6t his son Samuel who was fatally injured by Wallace's auto mobile In Congress . street in April, 1914.' - - ' : V;: Mr. Wallace," Whd-lives at 178 Arc tic . street, haa- been connected in an executive capacity wth the Lake Tor pedo Boat Co. He was for many years superintendent or tne xost Typewriter works in the West End. -He has several times occupied posi tions of - national prominence in the Grand Army of the Republic. TWEIIlY Pf R CENT OF POLICE FORCE UNABLE TO WORK Nearly 20 per cent, of the local po lice f orce are' absent from duty today, the larger proportion of the absentees being on the sick list. Spencer R. Gordon, head of the charities depart ment also is severely ill at his home, with the grip. Among the local policemen afflicted iwth colds and grip are : Detective Sergeant Peter Hall, Charles Lush, John 'McPadden, Jr., and -John Mc Padden, Sr., Dennis Keboe, John Glennon, John MoGlrr, Daniel Poland, Christopher Finne'gan,. J. T. Coughlin, Simon ?McCuIlough. Michael Quilty, John Dwyer, ; Patrick Corrigan, Pat rick Sheen ( and John Kelly. Others granted absence for various personal reasons are Patrick Boland, Andrew Mraiik, John Fox, John Smallwood. and J. J. Lavln. ' . Widow Appeals When Court Denies Share In ilusband's Estate Claiming that she received-no no tice of her husband's death or of the probating of his estate, and therefore was denied her rightful share, Mae Butler, of Minneapolis, Minn., filed a petition In the probate court for a redistribution of the estate. Judge Miller today denied the petition on the ground that every ; legal require ment had been compiled with and the only heir at law to make claim for the estate was Luch Washington, mother of Mr, Butler. She lives at Roxbury, Conn. - ' AH the parties In interest are col ored people and Mrs. Butler was rep resented - by a colored lawyer, George Branford, of New Haven. Mrs. Butler, who was Mae J. Seames, presented evidence that she was married to Butler in Minneapolis on Dec. 15, 1909. He afterward left her and came to Bridgeport, where he, died In 1913. Whether the couple saw each other or communicated with each oth er from the time Butler left until is death does hot appear In the papers at the probate court. Henry E. Bishop was the adminis trator of the estate which consisted of $500 equity in a piece of real es tate and $508.63 in cash in banks., After Mr. Butler's bills, the cost of settlement of the estate, funeral ex penses, etc., had been paid, there was left $154.61, which his mother inher ited as sole heir at law. Since she received the money nearly two years ago and after every leeral requirement had been complied with, Judge Miller denied the petition. At torney Branford served notice at once of ' Intention to appeal. CHOATE ASSERTS RAILROAD TRIAL HAS BEEN UNFAIR Counsel For Directors of New Haven Declares New England Repudiates Case WOULD PROTECT NAME OF OUR GOVERNORS Says Government didn't Dare Try Case in Any of New England States. New York, Jan. ' 5. Charles F. Choate, of Boston, told the jury today while summing up the case for the de fense at . the trial of the 11 former di rectors of the New Haven road on charges of violating the Sherman law, that the people of Nev England , were opposed to the prosecution and had re pudiated it. , ' ' "New England repudiates this pros ecution," he asserted. "They will have none of it. The government put these men on trial where they were not known. Tu probably heard of none of them before they were brought into this , court. The government did not dare' to try them in the courts of New England. ' "And I say that the men . who would dare 'to insinuate in New England, as has ' been done here, against the fair name of Governor Draper well, I daren't tell you what would happen to him. And the man who would, say that Robert Winsor is n'ot an honest man would receive the contempt he justly deserves. , , Mr. . Cnoate said that the govern ment, with all its experts and its se cret service had not been able "to produce one witness from New Eng land who would testify to a single act of oppression on the part of the New, Haven." '-. The lawyer dwelt at length upon the improvements in service which the New Haven had furnished to New England, citing in particular the ter minals at Boston. . Speaking of the New Haven's fights with,-.rival steamboat lines, Mr. Choate asked: . , "Are you to sit defenseless and let others tsfke your property from you? ."What is the logical outcome of competition ? There is a weaker and a stronger. And the govFnment says If you- fight your competitor till he succumbs then you are violating the law. And if you give him chance to live and Work along with him then you are also violating he law." WON'T ALLOW PERSONALITIES IN BIG DEBATE Suffragists and, "Antis" Must Be Ladies When They battle (Tonight Special precautions have been tak en to keep the big suffrage battle scheduled for tonight within . the bounds of logical argument. The com mittee in charge of the affair have issued Instructions to Referee Ernest Berger, appointed by the Bridgeport Philosophical society, that in the open debate only, written questions may be proposed to the chairman." This meth od has been taken in order to assure that personalities and irrelevancies may be avoided in the heated argu ments between suffragists and "an tis." Another feature of the affair which is open to all women interested in either cause is a newly formed wom en's orchestra. Under the leadership of Mrs. John J. Llndholm, Mrs. Cora Van Yorx, Miss Carrie Whitney, Miss Elizabeth Spelcer and Miss Margaret Casey will combine to offer orches tral selections. Miss Vida Stearns will be heard .in vocal solos. i Another novel feature that has been ordered is the taking of secret ballots both before and after the debate to see what effect the 'speaking has up on the audience present and wheth er, suffrage or anti-suffrage gains-'by the argument. The affair will be held in Knights of Pythias hall, 102 5. Main, street the atfirmative forces arguing "Woman's Suffrage is Desirable" will be led by Mrs.. Katherine Houghton Hepburn, chairman of the Connecticut Worn ens' Suffrage association, of Hart ford. The negative will be led by Mrs. Grace Duffiels Goodwin, of the Anti-Suffrage association, Hartford. Noble Estate Heirs Claim More Damages Than Allowed Them Henrietta M. Noble and Fanny S. Dupuy, heirs of the John F. Noble es tate on the north side .of Stratford avenue, have notified the city clerk of their intention to sue for greater land damages in connection with the wid ening of Stratford avenue. The Noble estate heirs claim that their property will be damaged to the extent of $16,000. They reside in Jenkinstown, Pa. They were awarded $317 in dam ages for the property, which it is pro posed to take from them in widening the street for the approach to the pro posed,, new Stratford avenue bridge. Attorney Samuel C.Shaw appeared at a hearing before the common council a short time ago and said that his clients will claim large land damages if their property is disturbed. The common council at its meeting Mon day night acceted the report of the board of appraisal of benefits and damages on he awards made e.xch property oner. - Maior-General Nicholas Bosboom, Dutch minister of war, has resigned. ' COMPULSORY BILL BRITISH SAmi Many Members Get Permission to Return From Battle ; Front to Vote On Measure Earl of Derby, Who Con ducted Campaign for Recruits, in Gallery Tells of Handicaps Met With In His Work. London, Jan. 5 The bill providing for compulsory military ; service was introduced in the House of Commons today by Pre-1 mier Asquith. The largest assemblage of members since the war began; faced the Premier. "Many members had obtained leave to re-1 turn from the (front so that they might be able to vote on theT compulsion bill. . The Ear of Derby, who conducted the recruiting campaign, , was in the peers' gallery. Under the terms of he bill all males between the ages of 18 j and 41 who-are bachelors or widowers without children depend ent on them are liable for military service. Ireland is excluded from the terms of the measure. Loqs Battle Cost British 60,000 Lives London, Jan. 6 rThe British casu alties in the battle of Loos, France, last September, totalled 2,378- officers and 57,288 men, .according to an an nouncement , made in the House of Commons this afternoon by Harold Ji Tennant. parliamentary under sec retary for war. Berlin, Jan.. 5 -Fighting with artil lery and mines at several points on the Franco-Belgian front is reported in the war office statement of today. London, Jan. 5 The sinking of the White Star liner Arabic, the destruc tion of a British submarine by a Ger man destroyer ' on the Danish'" coast arid the submarine attack on the Brit ish steamer Ruel- are. .-the--three inci dents that Sir- Edward, Grey;- the Brit ish foreign secretary, suggests for sub mission to some impartial tribunal for investigation, together with the case of the- Borelong. , - ! PUTS REVOLVER IN MOUTH AND PULLS TRIGGER Unknown Man Found With Head Shattered in West End Circus Lot. An unknowns manj. evidently a pros perous foreigner, was found dead to day in the. circus lot at Fairfield avenue,-' and Auburn ., street - of a pistol wound in the roof of his mouth. From the position of the body It would ap pear the man committed suicide. Be side the body .was .a 32-calibre five- shot .revolver with one of the shell empty. " ....... . The body was found at 1:10 "this afternoon by John Magra of 118 Pine street, who was ' crossing the -- lot. From ' the appearance ' of the corpse it is believed that the man had been dead only a short time. Young Magra at once notified Ser geant Sanger at the Third precinct station. Sergeant O'Oonnell and a po liceman went to the scene and the body was taken to, Cullinan & Mullins" morgue. , The man Was well built, of about five feet five inches in height and , weighed in the neighborhood .of 155 pounds. He had darK Drown nair and mustache. He wore a brown -mixed cap, light brown trousers and -a- black overcoat over . a dark coat, new red sweater and starched stiff shirt with collar and a black necktie. He wore black congress gaiters. From the condition of the man s hands and his body it Is believed he had. formerly been engaged in some kind of clerical employment. No money was found on his person. Medical Examiner Garlick took charge 'of the revolver and some let ters written In Hungarian, which were fonud In his pockets. The police at press hour were endeavoring to find some resident of the West End who could identify the man. ' , HE LIGHTED A BOMB, INSURANCE HELD UP, ADMINISTRATOR SUES Hartford, Jan. 5 President Morgan G. Bulkeley; of the Aetna Life Insur ance Co., as administrator of the es tate of Oscar Johnson, his late gar dener, has brought a suit for" $809 damages against the Brqtherhood Ac cident Insurance Co. of Boston. The suit has been returned to the superior court In this city. Johnson had a pol icy with the company. It is the con tention that Johnson was told to cart away some bombs which were on the Bulkeley premises at Fenwick but ha voluntarily lit the fuse of one of them and that it exploded and blew off part of the chin, producing a fatal wound. -The company takes theJ ground that Johnson voluntarily j ex posed himself to danger and that the company is therefore not liable. SERVICE IS PRESENTED 111 The House of Commons reassembled today in an anxious mood, uncertain as to how far the injection of compul sion Into the British, military system might have jbroken or weakened the cabinet. This point presumably was settled definitely at the cabinet which sat prior- tp the opening of parliament and adopted in its final form the com- : pulsion bill. '-. . ! The only absentee from the cabinet meeting today was Sir John Simon, home secretary, .who has resigned. : As Reginald McKenna, chancellor of j the exchequer, was present and an swered as usual, the members con- eluded there had been no further with- . drawals from the cabinet.' LACK OF CLERKS DELAYS DERBY'S! RECRUITING PLAfj' LORD DERBY TELLS I OF HANDICAPS TO RECRUIJTIN'G PLANS London, Jan.' 5. the. government's -The operating of plan was hand!- : capped and ' delayed by the impossi bility of obtaining a sufficient number ; of medical examiners and experienced clerks, says . Lord Derby today in a : report answering criticism of inade- quate arrangements during the abnor- -mal flow of . recruits at - the eleventh hour. Hence- wh'le gross numbers aro J available up to the end of the period. Dec. 11, details of groups are forth- , coming only up to 'Nov. 30 before the 1 tremendous rush began. . In the latter days of the canvass, j says Lord Derby, especially in country i districts, the starred - lists proved un satisfactory . and recruits were incor- j rectiy aescnoea.- - this win - can ; ior , further Investigation. - v ' . Lord Derby declares - the canvass i shows that-it is not lack- of "courage which keeps men from" enlisting. Many i who are willing to go. find themselvea j barred by domestic, financial and bus- i iness' obligation and by- the lnade-,-quacy of the separation "allowances. J This applies especially to professional.! and commercial men. - ' ' The total' number of men ready to j bear arms obtained from enlistments for the period between October 23 and. (Dec. 15 is -estimated .in- Lord- Derby's t report at 1,046,493. - After deductions from the total number of attested men j of the various classes indispensable fori i civil occupations, the numbers - avails j able for military service - are' 343,383 ; single men and 487,765. married. : Adding those who enlisted for Jm- ; mediate service gives a total ready to bear arms of 446,386 single and 600,107: ', married. ; " : - "An obstacle -to recruiting," says the report, '"has been the unequal treat- lent o Individuals. Parents and re-! , lations, especially, cannot understand ' why their sons, husbands or brothers should Join while ' other young men : hold back and secure lucrative, em- ', ployment at home. ' Apart from the j number of men who have, actually en listed and attested there are many ) who have promised to enlist when "so , and so" has also promised to go.' ; There may, of course, be a number of men who make this answer as an ex- cuse. But that it is genuine in very ; large number of cases Is accentuated I by bad starring there is no reason to doubt. . ,. - "The canvass shows very distinctly that it is not want of courage that Is keeping men back, but that the coun- try as a whole is determined to sup- j port the prime minister in his pledga made at the Guild Hall on November . i 9, 1914 (regarding the calling out of i married men) as it was when the ' pledge was made. There is an abund- ' ance of evidence of determination to see the war through to a successful' conclusion." . This report was made on - Dec. 12. In a supplementary report made on Dec. 20, the E;arl of Derby says: ' "Large as are the figures, I am ' afraid that on analysis do not prove ' as satisfactory as I could have wished. Owing to the great rush of recruits it was impossible in many cases to have ' more than the most perfunctory med- j leal examination, and the number of ' men who will be rejected when the various groups are called up and sub- ; Jected to proper examination must be i very large; the number of men ac tually examined both starred and un- tsarred, being 925,455." The Earl points out also that many ; must be reduced as the sole support of j dependent . relatives. He says there i are 651,160 unstarred single men un accounted for. "This is far from being' a pegligibla quantity," the report contiaike--.