Newspaper Page Text
". i j &s '&n iS s ! U.J. .' "- rfs - ., 'Ass- .$ ii?j2J . " r . J, '4- r ' A- L n '1 . -? . i-r - At- ' li ""fr mat an me Last" Edition Showers This Afternoon; Warmer Tonight. ' NUMBER 7207. Yesterday's Circulation, 60,111 WASHINGTON, FRIDAY .EVENING, SEPTEMBER 15, 1911. Twenty Pages PRICE ONE CENT. vrdM:- WILEY WINS; FATE OF CONSPIRATORS HELD IN BALANCE President Exonerates Pure Food Expert, But Defers Judgment in Case of Doctor's Foes. COMPANY F FEEBLE CLE Food Expert Who Has Won His Fight T TO POSTOFFICE IS MRS. HUTCHINS SUES TO OUST TRUSTEE DANTE t am t HANDICAP RANSFER SUIT Declares Court Has No Jurisdiction In The Matter. ASKS FOR DISMISSAL OF PENDING ACTION , Capital Traction Attorneys Claim Law Of 1894 Does Not Affect Charter. Opposing the campalng for uni versal transfers the Capital Traction Company this afternoon in the Dis trict Supreme Court moved to dis miss the suit of the Baltimore and Washington Transit Company for interchange of transfers at Four teenth street and Kennedy street northwest. Jurisdiction of the court to hear the suit Is denied. The right of the Justices to sit as traction commis sioners is also denied. This move by the traction com pany was made by its attorneys, R. Ross Perry & Sons, and G. Thomas Dunlop. The motion is sworn to by President George E. Hamilton. He says it Is not made to delay the pro ceedings. Avoids Formal Answer. By moving to dismiss the petition of the suburban company for trans fer privileges the Capital Traction Company avoids filing any formal answer to the suit. Its motion goes on the regular court calendar for hearing In the October trm of court. A complete exposition of its defence to the suit is made, however. In ad dition, to denying the Jurisdiction of the court the traction company saya Its charter, approved .Tune 23, 1888, gives it a contract right to receive fares at the rate of six tickets for a quarter. "This provision of law constitutes a contract between the Capital Trac tion Company and the United States. Any attempt by Congress to lmpare the obligation is a violation of the Constitution." Cannot Compel Transfers. In this manner ths Capital Traction Company declares the provision of the old law, of 1S91, cannot Impose any ob ligation to give transfers to passengers of any other lines It is also alleged by the traction com pany that the old law of 1894 refers to street car lines having actual physical connections. The tracks of the Mary land company at Fourteenth and Ken nedy streets don't physically connect with those of the Capital Traction Com pany Referring to section 5 of the act of 1894, said to confer power upon the Su preme Court of the District, the trac tion company says in its motion "it cannot be considered as an authoriza tion to the justices of the court to ex ercise power thereunder in the character of commissioners or otherwise It at tempts to impose a non-judicial func tion upon the court." Attacks Court's Jurisdiction. Specifically attacking the Jurisdiction Of the court the traction company says: "The court has no Jurisdiction to en ttrtain the petition unless by virtue of Statutes cited, because, first, the act constitutes t no recognized grounds for general relief; second, because the peti tion does not constitute a species of relief recognized in a court of equity. The act of 1S94 does not confer Juris diction." The reference is then made to Con gress' amendment to the charter of the Metropolitan Railway of" 1893, provid ing for tho receipt of 25 cents for six tickets, and a penalty for refusal to sell tickets at that rate. Provision for Transfers. "None of the acts," the motion of tho traction company states, "contains any provision authorizing free transfers between the Baltimore and Wushington TranMt Company and any other com pany In the District." The position of the traction company Is that Congress has passed no law requiring interchange of transfers be tween any traction companies. Declaring the Justices have no author ity the Capital Traction Company saya the law of 1894 authorizing the Metro politan RAilroad Company to yhange its motive power attempts to confer powers not Judicial. WEATHER REPORT FORECAST FOR THE DISTRICT. Showers this afternoon, cloudy and wanner tonight and Saturday. TEMPERATURES. TJ. S. BUREAU. 8 a. m 5? 9 a. m 58 JO a. m 59 11 a. m 59 12 noon 62 1 p. m G6 2 p. m 67 AFFLECK'S. 8 a. m 61 9 a. m C3 30 a. m. ... 65 11 a. m 55 12 noon 7 1 p. rn 0) 2 p. ra 2 TIDE TABLE. Today High tide, 12:31 a. m. and 12:59 p. m. Low tide. 7:21 a. m. and 7:10 p. m. , Tomorrow High tide. 1:30 a. m. and 2:01 p. m. Low tide, 8:26 a. m. and 8:23 p. m. SUN TABLE. Sun rises 5:3S.Sun sets 6:lt Thirty In Washington Serv ice Should Be Retired, Says Robinson. PENSION SYSTEM IS STRONGLY URGED Would Be Humanitarian And In crease Speed Of Mails, Act ing Postmaster Avers. Emphasizing the statement of Postmaster General Frank M. Hitch cock that the expeditious handling of the United States mr.lls demands the pensioning of superannuated postal employes. L. J. Robinson, who, in the absence of N. A. Merritt, Is acting as Postmaster, today de clared that there are thirty men In the Washington Postoffice alone who should be retired. "The Washington office, like all the large offices of the country, is encumbered by employes who no longer are of service," said Mr. Rob inson. "They clog the workings of a machine that must of necessity work rapidly. Expeditious handling of the malls cannot be accomplished when old men who are employed be cause of humanitarian consideration, are given the work to do. Positions Are Made. "We take care of the men who have given the best years of their life to the service of tho Government when they are no longer able to stand," continued Mr. Robinson. "For in stance, we place them In the basement to exercise a restraining Influence over the boys who carry special de livery lotters. We place them at doors to see that no unauthorized people pass We make work for them In places where such work is not really required. We .do this because to turn them out would be to drive them to a pauper's grave. Oftentimes when these men finally do go, no one is put in to do the work they were assigned to, so it Is apparent they really are unnecessary to the service. "After a time these superannuated employes accumulate, and It becomes Impossible to find work which they can do. "With a pension system it would be possible to retire them and fill the vacancies with new men who could do milch more work. The Government would be the winner by such a sys tem." Mr Robinson sighted many Instances where men had worked the best years of their lives for $1,200 and $1,400 a year. hen old age crept upon them and they were no longer able to handle their reg ular work with dispatch, they were put to work looking up names In directories or some other work requiring little physical effort. When their minds cea&ed to be active enough for that, they were given a chair at some door as watchmen with salaries of $700 or 5&00 a year. Speed a Necessity. "Of course there are many bills deal ing with pensions of civil service em ployes in Congress," said Mr. Robinson, "and because they vary so widely In their provisions. It is impossible to tell Just how many would be affected. There are at least a dozen aged men here who would come under the provisions of any pension measure that Congress might enact and I could make up a list of thirty that could be retired to advan tage to the service. "If there Is any branch of the Gov ernment's business that reulres rapid ity. It is the Postoffice Department. It may be possible to care for the old soldiers and soldiers' widows in the pension office, by gqlvlng them em ployment, but in the Postoffice De partment, everything depends on speed. The people of the country are constantly demanding Improvements and more rapidly In the handling of the mall, and business demands it. IS DEATH FROM SHOT Suffers Great Pain, And Is Partly Paralyzed Assailant To Hang. KIEFF, Russia, Sept 15. The condi tion of Premier P. A. Stolypin, shot by Lawyer Bogrof at a gala performance at the opera given in the Czar's honor, is critical today. After four hours sleep the premier was slightly Improved. He dictated a message to the Czar and ordered a re assuring telegram sent to. his wife and daughters. The premier is so weak that hi phy sician decided an operation would provo Immediately fatal, and will delay a re sort to the knife at least until the ar rival of Dr. Zldler, an expert in- the treatment of gunshot wounds, who has been summoned from St. Petersburg. Beyond the fact that he is safely locked up, nothing: has been heard con cerning Bogrof n since the moment that the police rescued him from the at tempt the audience made to lynch him immediately following his attack on the premier. Whatever may be the outcome ot his victim's Injuries. It Is safe to assume that the lawyer wlU be banged. ST0LYP1N E Charges Breach Of Trust In Management Of Million aire's Estate. IS CLIMAX OF FIGHT FOR BIG ALLOWANCE Court Refuses To Hear Her Appli cation For Thirty Thou sand Yearly. Summary removal for alleged breach of trust of William J. Dante, trustee of the $3,000,000 estate of Stllson Hutchlns, was asked this morning by Mrs. Rose Keeling Hutchlns in an ouster suit filed In the District Supreme Court A rule was secured from Justice Gould re quiring Dante to show cause next Tuesday, September 19, why he should not be ousted and trustees appointed by the court In his place. This sensational move of Mrs. Hutchlns came as the climax this morning in her fight for a monthly allowar"o of $2,500 from her aged husband s estate, as recommended by Auditor Dent, of the District Su preme Court An offer to take $2,000a month as a temporary compromise was made and turned down. Attorneys Git tings and Chamberlain then filed the ouster suit against Dante and got tho rule for his appearance Tues day. Refuses a Hearing. Tho flUrn? of the le.noval 9iil -ol-lowed Justice Gould's refusal this morn ing to hear Mrs. Hutchlns application for a formal order glWng her $2,500 per month. Justice Gould refused to hear the case, declaring it was contested and must go over under the rules during the present vacation term. Justice Gould advised Trustee Dante to pay Immediate pressing bills of Mrs. Hutchlns, but made no formal order. An offer to take $2,00) per month tem porarily then was made to the trustee by Attornejs Glttings . Chamberlln. holding a heated conference In the hall of the courthouse. 'Not a cent more than $1,000 per month," was the reply of Attorney Brandenburg, counsel for Dante. Attorney Chamberlln at once hurried Into the clerk's office and filed the suit to oust the trustee. Gifts of $35,000 to Lee Hutchlns, a son of the Washington millionaire, by Trus tee Dante are charged In the suit. Fail ure of the trustee to render an account of his trusteeship and misstatements as to debts of the estate also are charged. The petlUon to oust Trustee Dante - auj i. nco iTtitnhfn nn the "next friend" of her husband. She also is a plaintiff on her own behalf, the peti tion being preparea oepiemuer , m " TTntrhlns summer cottage at Narragan- sett Pier, R. I. . , . To remove uxusiee j-rame anu upumi. other trustees; to enjoin his payment of funds In his t-ossesslon except u authorized by the ded of trust; to make a fixed allowance for Mrs. Hutchlns and to assume Jurisdiction of the en tire Hutchlns estate is osked of tre court in the petition. Husband Brought In. Justice Gould was asked after filing rt tho suit to immediately make temporary allowance for the Hutchlns household. He declined to do this, but issued the rule to show cause against Trustee Dante. By naming her husband as a plalnun in the suit as his "next friend," Mrs. Hutchlns has brought her husband Into court ThU is said to cure the defect of former proceedings, in which no subpoena was served upon the Washington millionaire. In the petition, Mrs. Hutchlns de clares she "has lost confidence in the trustee and does not believe he is a proper party to eb trustee." Referring to specific charges of maladministra tion against Trustee Dante, she says she Is informed they " "constitute grounds for the removal of the trus tee and that said trust should be ad ministered under the order of court by trustees appointed by It" That (Continued on Second Page.) Last Minute News Told in Brief KILLED IN WRECK. ALBANY, N. T., Sept 15. In a wreck on the New York Central one man was killed. The crash occurred near this city, tha crews of both trains being in jured when an express train sldeswiped a freight. CANADA BANK ROBBED." NEW WESTMINSTER. British Co luknbla, Sept. 15. Three men robbed the Bank of Montreal here of a large sum, estimated at $250,000.' The robbers es caped. RATE INCREASE HELD UP. l Proposed Increases In freight rates by the Burlington and the Chicago and Great Western .railroads on traffic ba- oen the Mississippi and Missouri - Evirate' "VfflmkS v. ,ir v, 5a,v ' 1 - ''CsW TA iT , & afSr Jk. nj tjfggjjggfggffggfigjjj DR. HARVEY MACHINISTS NOT TO MOVE HEAD OFFICES i-rtua iht uAfrlAL National Headquarters To Stay Here Despite Efforts Of Indianjans. The national headanartcrs of tho In ternational Association at Machinists, for a number of year located in Wash ington, is not to be n-moved. despite eforts being made by members of that organization in the Central States. The assertion was made at headquar ters today that efforts of Indiana ma chinists to .ve the national officers locate in yjorte. Ind . have been re newed; but that the number of lodges favoring this transfer is so small as to cavse but little concern. For some time machinists of the Cen tral States have endeavored to have headquarters removed from this city. lWth the election of William H. John ston, formerly of Rock Island, 111., as president, the lodges of the Central States believed he would throw his sup port toward them. On reliable authority it is stated that Mr. Johnston has no intentions of favoring such a move. On the contrary, it is said, he repeatedly has stated that to secure the proper legislation from Congress, it is neces sary for the national officers to be lo cated in Washington, where constant contact with the legislators may be had. Game Postponed on Ac count of Wet Grounds, The opening game of the series between the St Lonls and Wash ington ball teams, scheduled for todar, was late this afternoon postponed because of irt ground. The team will play a double-header tomorrow. rivers, were suspended by the Inter state Commerce Commission until De Camber 30. GENERAL BOGGS DEAD. SALEM, N. C, Sept 15. Death re moved another of the few remaining generals of the Confederate army. Gen. William R. Boggs, eighty-three years old. The end came suddenly. Ho was a native of Augusta, Ga., and a gradu ate of West Point GOVERNORS SELECT RICHMOND. , SPRING XiAKE, .N. J., Sapt 15. The house of governors selected Richmond, Vs., as the scene of the next conference, which -will, begin the 'first Tuesday in December, -2S1J. " -up right, American Ptms Association. W. WILEY. DENIAL BY GIWBELS OFTHEIR NTENTION TO LUb'nlt hEUE Despite Statement, Rumor Is Confirmed In The Capiatl. PHILADELPHIA. September -Unqualified denial of the report that Gim bel Brothers are to establish a depart ment store in Washington was made to day by Ellis GImbel. one of the direc tors of the company. Mr. Gimbel asserted that his company had purchased no property in Washing ton and had no Intention of going Into business her. Story Is Confirmed Here That Gimbels Will Erect Store Confirmation of the report that a large department sore is to be erected on the western third of the square, bounded by F. Twelfth, Thirteenth, and G streets nrthwest, and that the store Is to be built by Gimbel Brothers was had today While denial is made by ownres of some of the property said to be involved, it Is admitted that negotia tions have been started on pieces not ulready inquired. All of the Thirteenth street frontage, and a part of the F and O street frontages have already been acquired. Ella C. McCarthy, proprietress of the California Fruit Store, 1220 G street, denied today that she had sold her property. An offer had been made, she -said, but it had been refused and she had no intention of vacating her property. Tho price of the corner property at G street is said to have been '110,000. The prico of the inside property. K15. and 1217 was JLO9,O0O. Well over $50 a square foot Is reported to be the prica paid for the F street corner. The tenant of the one-story store is reported to havo received $7,500 to vacate before the expiration of his lease and another, whose lease runs for only two years to have received $6,000 and a year's rent. HELD AS DYNAMITER. CHICAGO, Sept 15. Otto Qulnte was arrested by the police In connection with the dynamltlngs that for three months have been directed against the Edison Commonwealth Electric Company of Chicago. Qulnte, tho police say, has been connected with the dynamiting, and knows others who perpetrated them. STEAMER AGROUND. A report has been received bjr the Revenue Cutter Service that the British steamer Kyleaktn, bound' from Phila delphia to Vera Cruz and Tamplco, has been stranded near Key West on Mar quesas -Key. Wreckers are trying to save the vessel. EFFORT TO SMASH FOOD LAW ENDS IN A FIZZLE President Taft's Findings REGARDING DR. WILEY: That he was Justified In all that he did, and Ehould command the sympathy of everyone for his earnest ef forts to maintain the pure food laws. REGARDING DR. RUSBY: That he was not advised at all as to the legal difficulty of his employment, and was only scheming for additional compensation which he thought to be adequate, and 1 recommend his retention In office. REGARDING ATTORNEY GENERAL WICKERSHAM: That he was given only a part of the actual evidence on which to form his opinion. REGARDING DR. KEBLER: That he be reprimanded for "dlslngen ous conduct" as shown by letters he wrote in connection with the employment of Dr. Rusby. REGARDING DR. BIGLOW: I find the use of disingenuous methods in arranging for Dr. Rusby's employ, and direct that he be repri manded. REGARDING THE CONSPIRATORS: "Th broader Issues raised by the Investigation may require much more radical action than the question I have here considered, and decided." By JDDSON C. WELLIVER. Dr. Harvey W. Wiley wins. The pure food champion will remain at his post President Taft today de cided the famous case, and his ver dict is sweeping and complete, not only in favor of Dr. Wiley, but also in favor of Dr. H. H. Rusby, expert The McCabe-Dunlap conspiracy against Wiley collapses at every point Years of plotting, planning. scheming and devious efforts to- frame up a record on which Wiley could be forced out of the Govern ment service end in a cqmplete fiasco. More important by far than the vindication of Wiley and the de struction of the conspiracy against him, is the salvation of the pure food law. Vague Threat Of Trouble. Throughout the President's letter is carried a strong suggestion portentous nf doings that may later take place in the Department of Agriculture. Cryptic and vague, these Intimations seem to suggest that somebody may lose his Job when the final determination is reached. Presumably, this means that Solicitor McCabe and Associate Chemist Dunlop are on the doubtful list But the Presi dent leaves the matter so uncertain that the event may easily leave these gentlemen as firm as ever In their posi tions. Written with a Janus-headed look in both directions, the President's letter leaves him free hereafter either to dis miss and disgrace Messrs. McCabe and Dunlop, or to sustain and vindicate them. . Beyond and underlying the effort to undo Dr. Wiley, was the yet more sin ister and menacing purpose to break down the pure food law; to put its administration Into the hands of its enemies rather than its friends; to make sure that it should be con strued narrowly Instead of broadly; that it should be made to give the least possible embarrassment to- the food fixers and the smallest measure of protection to the public. It is not yet possible to Judge con clusively whether there will be a Cabinet crisis as a result of the action of President Taft In effect he has rejected the administrative ad vice of Secretary Wilson, and the legal WILEY GLAD WHEN TIMES TELLS Hints He Will Keep Right On En forcing Pure Food Law. Doctor Wiley received his first no tlflcatlon of President Taffa decision when The Washington Times called him an the long-distance telephon'e -at his farm at Biuemont, Va., this mora lag "That's fine; of course I am. glad to hear if he said. "Have you any statement you want to make for the public?" he was ask ed "No; without more detailed infor mation of what the President has written, it' would be impossible for me to say more than that I am very much pleased and gratified." "But anyhow," was suggested, "the food law -will be administered by you, and with a pretty definite understanding- that the people expect it to be administered up to the handle." "The people have acted as if they liked this law, haVen't theyT" retort ed the doetor, quizzically. Then the connection was broken. 1 counsel of Attorney General Wicker sham Both these members of the Cabinet had given the full weight of their influence to the anti-Wiley cabaL Secretary Wilson not only cast his In fluence for years in the scale against Dr. Wiley, but. when the time seemed at last propitious for destroying Dr. Wiley, indorsed the recommendation that he be "permitted to resign," that Rusby be removed, and that Dr. KeWer should go. The Attorney General did more. He had befor hin an opinion by ? cslstant j. mat the Kenwen Lniri In chemical "Up . peals as illegal, and another by So licitor Jiccabe. or the Agricultural. De partment, that it was legal. He sus tained the McCabe and rejected the Fowler opinion. After that when the legal questions concerning the employment of Dr. Rusby were submitted to him, the Attorney General held that the law had been violated, and declared that "con dign punishment" should be visited upon Wiley. Acute for Wickersham. The Issue between the President and his Attorney General Is made particu larly acute. In his decision, which is in the form of a letter to Secretary Wilson, the President declares that Dr. Wiley was Justified in all he did in con nection with employment of Dr. Rusby as an expert chemist; that Dr. Wiley was not a party to the correspondence in the matter, and that in any event Dr. Wiley acted in accordance with numerous precedents. Finally, the President gratuitously observes as If he were willing to rub it Into the people who so long and bitterly fought the chief chemist that Dr. Wiley cannot but command the sympathy of everyone for his earnest efforts to main tain tue pure food law. It may be a day or two before the possible political results of the Presi dent's decision will be clear. Secretary Wilson is in the West on his vacation; Attorney General Wickersham Is- at his Long Island summer home; Solicitor McCabe Is in Utah, where he maintains his political residence. Dr. Wiley is spending a fortnight at his farm at Biuemont, Va., getting in his crops and not permitting political cares to disturb him. Here are the people whose tenure of positions in the Government becomes exceedingly dubious by reason of the President's decision: James Wih-on. , Secretary of Agricul ture for almost fifteen years. George W. Wickersham, Attorney General. George V. McCabe, solicitor of the Department of Agriculture, chief of the anti-Wiley cabal. Dr. L. F. Dunlap, associate chemist amd persistent enemy of his chief. Dr. Wiley. C. C. Clark, chief clerk of the De partment of Agriculture and member of the committee on personnel. Assistant Secretary Wlllet M. H&yt is chairman of the committee on per sonnel, but his Indisposition to sympa thize and co-operate with the plans and purposes of the antl-Wiley conspirator. brought him Into the bad graces of So licitor McCabe, and there is every rea son for the belief that his persistent friendliness for Dr. Wiley throughout the long period of the effort to oust the latter, will stand him in excellent stead now. There has even been Intimation that Dr. Hays might be found at the head of the department before pie end of the Taft Administration. To Strengthen Law. No matter what political results may come, one thing Is assured. The pure food and drug act will hereafter be ad ministered by Dr. Wiley with a firmer hand and more confident assurance of his position than ever before. He has been vindicated in a manner that few gubllc servants hav,e ever been able to oast The whole country has risen as one man In demand that no harm should come to Dr. Wiley, that the conspiracy .against "him should be foiled, and that the pure food act be left in bis cnarge. Almost from the day that the food law passed, Dr. Wiley's power as the nominal chief of its administration has been steadily pruned down until latterly It has been but a shadow, a mockery. The real power has been wielded by Solicitor McCabe, working In close conjunction with Associate Chemist Dunlap, who has been his ever ready aide In the management of the elaborate program for the undoing of wiley Dr. Wiley made his policy perfectly clear In his testimony recently before the moss committee of the House of Representatives, which was Investigat ing the Wllev affair. "It has always been Jny policy," he said, to give the (Continued ob Secoaa PajeJ T I -ft -.(I t . , . r?"3B t&P&z.jszMzh V " J. .. 3fcfc M. .,ii ,i- -t j "V1- . ?s8&t to:c.i v- jTf . i&ya. .-.vk