Newspaper Page Text
THE BIRMINGHAM AGE-HERAEt) VOLUME XXXXIII BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA; THURSDAY, AUGUST 14. 1913 12 RAGES /_ NUMBER 100 NAMING OF CLA YTON CONTINUES SUBJECT OF MUCH DISCUSSION - I - Senators Still Firm in Belief That Clayton’s Appoint ment Was Made Without Authority CLAIM ALABAMA MAY BE WITHOUT FULL QUOTA IN SENATE Officials Charge That Governor O'Neal's Action May ltender Futile Struggle of Democraic Party for Past Sixteen Years By C. K. STEWART Washington, August 18.—(Special.! The oppolnlmcnt of Henry l>. Clay ton to succeed Senator Johnston Is u popular one so fnr as Mr. f'la> ton is concerned personally, but In view of the fact that Governor 0*0 en I mnde the appointment without the consent of the legislature It la the consensus of opinion aiming the democratic sen ators here that Mr. Clayton will not be seated. Senators will not talk for direct quo tation now In view of the fact that they must act in a Judicial capacity. But privately they unanimuusly ex jfiens the opinion that there is not a chance for the judiciary committee »to b© reversed and Mr. Clayton allowed to take his seat In the Senate. ALABAMA MAY BE WITHOUT FULL QUOTA As the matter Htands the general opinion is that Alabama will be with out its full quota in the Senate unless the governor will acceed to pressure and public demand and call the leg islature in a special session and get its authority for the appointment al ready made. With Senator Culberson dangerously ill at a sanitarium In Connecticut, wljere oven if he recovers—the most sanguine do not expect him to do so in time to vote on the tariff bill— it is freely observed here today that llovernor U‘Neal in not following the unanimous advice of the democrats in the Senate as expressed to him by Sen ator Overman, has endangered the tar iff bill and may render the struggle j □f ihe democratic party for the past lb years futile. 0 Q\’.Y ONE COURSE REMAINS If Governor O’Neal refuses to call the legislature together so as to make ills appointment of Mr. Clayton legal, tind It becomes certain as It now seems to be that Senator Culberson cannot' be present to vote upon the taiiff bill, ihere will be only one course open fori the democrats in the .Senate, suggested t une senator today, and that will be to take recess until such time as a senator from Alabama can be legally appointed or Senator Culberson can I return to his post. In the meantime I the opinion is that if O’Neal stands] pat Alabama will be represented in the .Senate is in a fever of excite- I Hit election is held. Senator Clayton is wanted in the | Senate. Governor O'Neal's appointment i IS highly approved as to the man. Also the fcjenate is in a feve rof excite ment over tile situation, but not a single senator will admit that as pop ular as Clayton is, and as expedient as it may be that lie be seated, that there is a ghost of a show for them to dl> SO. Even should the democrats reverso themselves on the proposition, the re publicans would liglit it tooth and nail. In their tight alone would delay the' seating of the senator even iJ the democrats lined up solidly for doing so for at least a month and rndkn him useless to this party in its hof.r of need. -•._ Stock Subscribed For New York, August 13.—Members of the syndicate organized to dispose of the $88,000,000 of Southern Pacific stock owned by the I’nion Pacific Railroad company, announced today that the entire amount had been more than twice subscribed for. ..... | TODAY’S AGE-HERALD 1—Naming of Clayton continues to be subject of much discussion. Alfalfa movement proving great suc cess. .Sulier and Glynn both claim gover norship. f—public willing to give railroads fair treatment. 8—Cower Peachtree committee makes report. 4—Editorial comment. B— Commission hears ftarber and Percy. Clayton here yesterday en route to Washington. Press club rooms to lie spacious. A 4nistaken action. <1— Society. v 7— Sports. 8— Miss Warrington continues story. •—Capital shocked by revelations in Sul zer case. 11— Markets. 12— Marion ready for alfalfa meet. »•••••••••••••••••••*■•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• Johnston’s Successor Leaves for Washington to Present Credentials Before jjjpe-' Committee " c 1 O’NEAL CONFIDENT THAT APPOINTEE j WILL BE SEATED l _ Anticipate That Election Will Be Contested, But State Capitol Of ficials Agree That Governor Acted With Authority BY L S. BETTY Montgomery, August 13.—(Special.) Henry D. Clayton, member of Congress from the Third Alabama district and chairman of the judiciary committee of the House of Representatives, who was appointed, yesterday afternoon to fill the unexpired term of the late Senator Jospeh F. Johnston of Birmingham, left j tills morning for Washington by way of Birmingham, and will reach the na tional capital*by Thursday afternoon. Senator Clayton bears with him his commission which the governor con ferred upon him when he appointed him to the vacant senatorial seat, and he will present his credentials imme diately upon his arrival in Washing ton. It is understood that no contest will be entered against Senator Clay ton until the Senate committee on privi leges and elections has investigated his credentials. Carefully Investigated The impression obtains very gener ally in official circles here that the new appointee will be seated, although it is anticipated that his election will be contested. The question of the right of the governor to name the late Sen ator Johnston's successor was carefully investigated by practically all of the constitutional lawyers in Montgomery, and they all agreed that the governor had this right. Among the able consti tutional lawyers who investigated the question and gave the governor an un official opinion was Maj. William A. Gunter, who declared that in his mind there was little doubt of the govern or's authority to appoint. Major Gun ter is considered one of the most bril liant constitutional lawyers in the state, and his opinions alwrays carry exceptional weight. The question was also investigated by practically «J1 of the members Of twa supreme and appellate courts who are in Montgomery, and they too agreed that the governor could appoint. in the opinion of Goveronor O'Neal there was absilutely no doubt of his right to appoint a successor to Sena tor Johnston, and, he believes the ap pointment will he confirmed. Tlie appointment of Congressman Clayton to the vacant seat in the United States Senate has given univer sal satisfaction in Montgomery, and the governor is believed to have made a wise selection. Receives Many Telegrams Since the appointment of Congressman eft vton was announced the governor has received scores of telegrams from va rious parts of the state complimenting him on a ctfoice of a successor to Sen ator Johnston, and all reports that have reached the capitol have been to the ef fect that the appointment has given most general satisfaction. The governor has not received any word from Washington since he announced the j appointment, nor did lie receive any tele grams from the national capital yester day. So far the governor knows the report that Sena ten Kern had telegraphed him on Tuesday urging him to call a spe cial session of the legislature to grant him authority to name a senator ad in terim was untrue. The governor was in formed immediately after he announced the appointment that a second telegram had been sent him from Washington, but the executive declared he bad not re ceived it. Will Call Election in Third District Governor O'Neal announced today that he would call a special election in the Third congressional district to elect a suc cessor to Congressman Clayton just as soon as the latter has been seated in the Senate. He anticipates that there will probably be a delay of 10 days or two weeks before the situation is adjusted in Washington, but believes that ultimate- j ly the appointment will be confirmed. The governor will then immediately or der a special election in the Third district to be held some time In September or October, or as soon thereafter us one can be legally called. Already there are several candidates in the field. Among those most prominently mentioned are Henry M. Stegall of Ozark, solicitor of the Third judicial circuit; Byrd G. Farmer of Dothan, also men tioned as a probable candidate for gov ernor: Charles S. McDowell of Eufaula and Judge Mike Sollic of Ozark, judge of the Third circuit. There seems to be considerable doubt In official circles as to Judge Sollie s eligibility to run for Congress. Inasmuch as there is a constitutional Inhibition against a judicial officer running for a public office, except a judicial one, dur ing the term for which he hail been elected judge. It was pretty generally agreed among lawyers at the capitol (Continued on Pnge Twelve) MOTHER OF LEO FRANK CAUSES COMMOTION Attempts to Defend Son From Attacks of the Prosecution. Leaves Court Room Much Agitated^-Story .of Tragedy Re-enacted. Atlanta. August 13.—Mrs. Roe Frank, Mother of the defendant, caused a corn notion during the trial of Leo Frank ate today when she attempted to defend ter son from the attacks of the prosecu lon. Solicitor General Dorsey, cross ex irrining J. A. Jones, a character witness, Lsked whether the witness had heard that “rank had conducted himself Improperly rith women in his office. Mrs. Frank urned to the solicitor general and ex claimed: "No, and you didn’t, either."*' Attorneys for the defense admonished Mrs. Fiank that if she remained In court she must expect to hear accusations against the character of her son. 8he thin left tiie court room, apparently much agitated. I taring the afternoon session Judge Koan permitted witnesses for the defense who re-enacted the story of the tragedy as told by the negro Conley to tell how j long It took them. This testimony was • introduced with the Intention of showing I that Conley could not have done all lie I paid he did In the time claimed. A “FUTURIST” PICTURE IN ALABAMA * ( ~rt/£LL t1ANG ^ ( /£ 77//G /f/A/'r GO'* ' ? I 4 x/rr*t£ y'Go J ( w/r" r/") r ^ 'Art'TG^'Sr'^D ■'.' ) \-=z: ALABAMA ALLALLA MOVEMENT PROVING A GREAT SUCCESS Experts Well Received in Demopolis, Faunsdale and Uniontown BARBECUE AT MARION TODAY A FEATURE "Alfalfa King" Wing and Professor Holden of Iowa Tell Perry Farm ers How to Raise Alfalfa. At (ireensboro Tonight n? HA I,PH H. SILVER | i’niontown, August lit.-—(Special.t The Alabama alfalfa movement Is on the move anil landed tonight full grown and very active In this little black belt prairie town. Here tonight "Alfalfa King” Joe Wing and Prof. P. G. Holden of Iowa told a large crowd of Perry county farmers how to raise alfalfa and hereby enrlgh themselves and their lands. After tlie speaking there was a barbecue supper In the open air at 10 o’clock and the crowd then broke up for the night. The hospitality of the citizens of I’nlontown and surrounding neighbor hood was so great that they ordered tlie hotel closed up when the automo bile train arrived. Each guest was reg istered and they were alloted to dif ferent homes to spend the night. The automobile train will form again at 7 o'clock tomorrow morning and leave for Marion. An Enormous Success The Alabama alfalfa movement was launched at Demopolis tills morning and proved an enormous success. After the first auto trip through the plan tations of half a dozen of the biggest farmers surrounding Demopolis ' the speaking was held on an alfalfa plat form in the public square. The entire town of Demopolis was decorated with alfalfa hut the platform In the square was decidedly unique, it being made completely of hales of alfalfa, the seats were made of alfalfa, Bteps leading up to the platform were of alfalfa and tlie entire park of a couple of acres was carpeted with a soft layer of new mown alfalfa. Experts Roach Faunsdale After the barbecue at Demopolis the automohile train got under way again at 2 o'clock and headed east for Fauns dale. A feature of the trip this after noon from Demopolis to tills town wap the "Governor's special,” a car driven by John Webb, one of the biggest land owners and alfalfa growers of the Demopolis district, anil containing Commissioner of Agriculture Ft. E. Kolb, Marengo County Commissioner Wilson and Sam Fowlkes of Birmlng hpm. The special left Demopolis the last car and pulled Into both Fauns dale and,. Fnlontown the first car, pass ing everir car on the road. Mr. Webb itwns three cars but he was driving a Fdtti anil he Is "some chauffeur." At F&uBsilale Captain Kolb and A. F. Grout, an Illipols alfalfa grower, made tlie two speeches. Captain Kolb told about the value rtf Alabama land, what It would tin if properly treated and cul tivated and some of the things It ha.l done, saying that Alabama had pro duced more corn to the acre than any of the states from which the northern expertpwere from, but that tlie trou ble here was that st* h tilings were (Cpatlsoed «■ Page Twelve) rK&blU&LM l HU&K I A Ai\D ENVOY LIND MAY HOLD A CONFERENCE TODAY Mexico City, August 13.—A stack of call ing cards on the table In the apartment of John Lind, President Wilson's personal representative in Mexico, beats testimony i.f the efforts thaj are bring made o give advice to Mr. Lind or get from him ad vance information as to the character of the much discussed message he bears to President Huerta. Mr. IJnd receives the advice offered by his callers, but they go away without any Information aud usually with the Impression that their ad vice will be pigeon holed. Mr. Lind is not talking. He saw no Mexican officials today aud If progress has been made ir^ the negotiations be tween the two countries no news of it became public, as the Alexiin officials are tv<n more secretive than those at Washington, or Mr. Lind, Mr. Wilson’s representative did noth ing more today than visit rhe American embassy and talk with X- ison O'Shaugh nessy. the charge c’afTW'*. aside from replying to messagt s from tiie state de partment. The importance of these mes sages or of the conference at the embassy is ’unknown. There is a feeling tonight that Presi dent Huerta and Mr. Idnd may meet to morrow'. If th^y do there is every rea son to believe an attempt will be made 1 to keep the fact a secret. ....... RELEASE OF BRITO CLEARS ANOTHER ,,,_. . ^,r., i _ . | Former Governor of Cam peche Released on $10,000 Bond — Explains Position New Orleans, August 13.—What was considered a delicate situation between the Unietd States and Mexico was somewhat cleared here today when Em manuel C. Brito, former governor of the Mexican state of Campeche, ar rested on charges of murder and rob bery In Mexico, was released on bond of |10,000. It was stipulated that Brito was to report every day to the United States marshal here for 40 days, the time given in a treaty with Mexico for that government to produce proof of guilt. Brito does not deny that he Hilled one of Huerta’s men when he came to arrest him, but argues that as it was done In time of war, it is a political of fense and not extradictable. He was arrested on instructions of Attorney General McReynolds several days ago. The federal district attorney liere today received a message from Mr. McRey nolds advising that Brito be allowed bond. Iwoath to Give Bail United States Commissioner Arthur Browne was not Inclined at first to allow bail, saying he would be gov erned entirely by his interpretation of law. After the attorneys for Brito hau argued that the Mexican was arrested on instructions from the Attorney Gen eral when the Huerta government was not formally recognised by the United States and that Mr. McReynoAds had in turn advised allowing boftd, the com missioner agreed to accept the bond. Brito’s release came soon after he had learned that Mexican fed-3rals had raided his ranch in Campeche and de stroyed all buildings and drove off his live stock. He also learned that the federal? had taken his daughter by his first wife a prisoner. His second wife is with him here. Brito says his arrest was not in good faith and charges that the Huerta government did not intend to try to prove him guil ty but that it was done to keep him from joining Carranzo in nortntffn Mex ico. New Interpretation * Washington. August 13.—A new inter pretation of the extradition treaty with Mexico was established today by Attorney General McReynolds in ordering the re lease under $10,000 ball of Emanuel C. Brito, provisional governor of PHmpeche, Mexico, who was being held at New Or 4C«bUb«M mi Paso 7Vlaa»jL I " “ TAKE EFFECT AT ONCE President Is Incensed Over Statement Given Out by Former Ambassador to Mexico Washington. August f3.—The United States government has informally sounded the powers and learned that for eign governments generally will do nothing to embarrass the, peace policy of President Wilson toward Mexico and are inclined to support it. Henry Lane Wilson, whose resignation as ambassador to Mexico recently was accepted to take effect October ]4. is sued a statement today attacking the reported statement of the Briish for eign office that recognition of the Huerta government had been extended after he ivd made “a congratulatory speech” to the provisional president. President Wilson read the ambassador's statement and was so incensed at its tone and contents that lie promptly requested Secretary Bryan to ascertain through tho British embassy here whether the utter ance of the British foreign office as reported was correct, and tonight the dis missal of Ambassador Wilson by sum mary acceptance of his resignation to take effect Immediately was under con sideration by the administration. ^ These were the developments of the day here in the Mexican situation, while dis patches from John Lind, personal repre sentative in Mexico of President Wilson, indicated that he was in personal touch with Prederico (iamhoa, Mexican minister of foreign affairs, and was preparing to submit the representation* of the United States on the restoration of peace in Mexico. Chief interest centered tonight in the administration attitude toward Ambassa dor Wilson's remarks concerning the British government and the information that European governments were dis posed to lend their moral support to President Wilson s policy. It was learned that many of the for eign governments feel the Mexican prob lem to be peculiarly within the province of American diplomacy and though they may take no affirmative action, they will not Interfere with the peace programme f.»* a constitutionally established govern ment through which President Wilson be lieves all foreign interests ultimately can best he conserved. The American government has learned I some of these things only fiy indirection. tContlBued on Page Mae) 4 SULZER/AND GLYNN BOTH /CLAIM TO BE NEW \rORK GOVERNOR Impeachment of Governor by thg General Assembly Causes Serious Legal Con troversy CLAIM EXECUTIVE NOW INELIGIBLE TO HOLD OFFICE Clash Expected Today When Both Men Attempt to Assume Authority. Both Factions Cite Constitution to Uphold Claims * ♦ • UO\ KHNORS WHO HAVE 4 4 FACED IMPEACHMENT 4 4 ♦ 4 In all the United States only • 4 seven governors, besides Gover- 4 4 nor Sulzer of New York, have * * faced impeachment proceedings. 4 4 These men and the results that 4 4 followed were: 4 4 Charles Robinson, Kansas, 4 4 1862, acquitted: Harrison Reed, 4 4 Florida, 1862, charges dropped; 4 4 William W. Holden, North Car- * 4 olina, 1870, removed; Powell 4 4 Clayton, Arkansas, 1871, charges 4 4 suspended; David Butler, Ne- 4 4 hraska, 1871, removed: Henry C. 4 4 Warmeth, Louisiana, 1872, term • 4 expired and proceedings were 4 4 dropped; Adelbert Ames, Missis- 4 4 aippl, 1876. resigned. 4 4 4 A Ilian,v. August 13.—With Governor I Sulner Impeached by the assembly and | the date of IiIm trial before die senate and tlie Judge" of the court of appeal* lived for September IS, n "peetnole w-hn presented tonight of two %n»cii elnlni ing to be governor of the "tnte of New \ ork. As soon as the articles of Impeachment adopted at an early hour this morning by the democratic majority in the assem bly were presented to the Senate, shortly after 3 o’clock this afternoon, Lieuten ant Governor Martin H. Glynn announced hie intention of occupying the executive chamber. Friends of Governor Sulzer declared that the governor intended to continue in of fice and would use every weapon in his power to maintain his position on the ground that the assembly had no consti tutional right to consider 4mpeachment at its extraordinary session. MAY SUMMON MILITARY PROTECTION Some asserted that the governor would go so far as to summon military protec tion if necessary to prevent the lieuten ant governor from occupying tlie execu tive chamber. Judge D. Cady Herrick, who will act as chief counsel for tlie governor at his trial, said tonight that "talk of resort to force Is the merest rot." "He will meet the charges against him in an orderly and dignified way,” said Judge Herrick, "and will do nothing un becoming the dignity of the state, lit* will engage in no physical scramble to assert Ills rights to discharge the func tions of tlie office governor." The governor himself was silent. When at t> o’clock tonight he left Ids office in the capitol where lie had been closeted the entire day and he was asked If he expected to return tomorrow. "Yes, si'ree,’’ he replied in ungry tones. So far as could be learned, no attempt was made by IJeutenant Governor Glynn in any way to exercise tlie functions of chief executive today, but there was every indications that timre would lie a dash of authority tomorrow when both men appear at the caplto). The lieutenant governor would not indi cate tonight what action lie proposed to take except to say that there would be "no circus or military maneuvers about occupying the executive chamber; the law is supreme.” The inaction of i deuterium Governor Glynn in the matter was in tlie face of HTgumehtH given expression both in tho Senate and in tlie assembly today that at the moment the articles of impeach ment were presented to the Seriate nov el nor tlulzer automatically ceased to be the chief executive. This contention was based on an article in the constitution, which says that "In j j case of impeachment of the governor the J powers and duties of tlie office shall de | volve upon the lieutenant governor." It was held by tlie majority leaders that the word "impeachment’’ corres ponded with the word "indictment’’ In a criminal trial and that therefore, in the meaning of the constitution, the goyernor already stodd impeached even though not yet convicted, and was, therefore, not now eligible to hold his office. GOVERNOR SULZER NOT MOLESTED These arguments were placed before the lieutenant governor by the demo cratic leaders early In the afternoon. l*nt. nevertheless. Governor Sulser was ! not molested. A few minutes after tlie governor left Ids office Patrick H. Mc Cabe. clerk of tlie senate, appeared at the executive chamber with n copy of the articles of impeachment and a summons and complaint which he in tended to serve upon the governor. When informed by the governor's sec tion tinned on Page Nine* Reports That Mrs. Sulzer Would Give Out State ment Yesterday Fails to Materialize MAY BE CALLED ON STAND AS WITNESS FOR THE DEFENSE Claimed That Her Testimony Will Go Far Toward Clearing the Gov ernor of Charges Preferred—Policy of Silence Albany, N. Y., August 13.—Reports that Mrs. Sulzer would give out a statement setting forth the derails of her alleged, use of Governor Sulzer's campaign check* for stock speculation unknown to the governor, did not materialize today. Friends intimated that In view of the fact that Mrs. Sulzer probably will be called as a witness for the defense at the trial what she may have to say will be reserved until she takes the* witness stand. It was said her testimony will go far toward clearing the governor of the charges of misuse of campaign funds for ■deck speculation. Mrs. Sulzer was In the care of physicians tonight and was ^aid to he in a complete state of collapse f^om the strain to which she has been se lected. > Mrs. Sulzer’s condition became so se rious tonight that Governor Sulzer wired to New York for a specialist on nervous diseases. The governor then told his ad visers, it was said by those who claimed to have knowledge of what transpired at the riight's'conference, that under no cir cumstances would he allow Mrs. Sulzer to testify at the trial. It was said, on the other hand, that Mrs. Sulzer insisted, hysterically, that she he allowed to testify in her husband’s behalf. MLE.NCE WILL BE SULZER’S POLICY Silence also will be tfle policy of the governor until he appears at the bar, of [he court of Impeachment. "Counsel for Governor Sulzer," said Judge Herrick tonight, "have no desire Lo be Interviewed or try his case in the newspapers, or to make statements in his behalf. They have advised tlioyov*" 8*nor to retrain from making any slate m*nt at present, likewise ids wife, Wo have engaged in his defense not for Wil liam Sulzer, but as a professional duly to the governor of the state ami to pre serve so far as it can now be preserved the good name and fame of the state. After an examination of Mr. Sulzer in relation to the transactions disclosed by the Frawley committee, we are satisfied that there has been only a partial revela tion of the facts so far and we are satis fied that he has been guilty of no wilful wrong doing. We ask the public In his behalf for a suspension of judgment until all the facts can be disclosed before the proper tribunal and in an orderly way." WILL TAKE STAND IF SHE HAS OPTION It is said that Mrs. Sillier will take the stand if Mho has no other option. It is now Claimed that she besought the gover nor a week ago to permit her to tell her story to the public. What attitude Governor Sillier would lake in this matter as well as toward the ipiestion of vacating his office when the senate should receive the articles of Im peachment brought forth widespread di vergencies of views among ills friends and opponents. The majority leaders were reasonably ertain, they said, that he would not at tempt to continue to hold office but would recognize what they asserted was the law tnd give way to Lieutenant Governor Glynn. Louis Marshall, the governor's counsel, Is quoted as placing a different interpreta tion on the law. According to the quoted expression of Mr. Marshall’s views, the language of the constitution is not clear on this point, a.nd Governor Sulzer could give himself the benefit of the doubt by refusing to vacate the office. LIFE PROLONGED BY OVERSIGHT Sentenced to Hang: in 1906, Man Liven in Penitentiary While Case Is Forgotten San Francisco. August 13.—An over sight has prolonged the life of August Jobber two years. In 1908, just before the big San Francisco fire, Geber was convicted of the murder of Charles Hartman and sentenced to be hanged. Then came the holocaust which de stroyed the records of Geber’s trial. Geber had taken an appeal and he was sent to San Quentin penitentiary to n wait the outcome. The appeal was dismissed In 1911, hut for some reason nobody bothered about the resentencing of Geber, so he has remained in San Quentin. T<idav George Hartman, whose son was Geber’s victim, called th“ atten tion of Superior Judge Dunn to the slayer’s protracted tenure of life. Geber was ordered to appear In court Saturday and be resentenced to death. | DOCTOR TRIES TO PERFORM VIVISECTION ON PATIENT — i Skillfully Opened Face of Wealthy Farmer and Makes Incisions on Throat—Frightened Nurse Brings Aid and Physician Is Subdued. i - Marietta, O., August 13.—With the commitment of Dr. R. D. Dabney to an asylum today there came to light the remarkable story that the sur - , geo$'b mental disorder was first re vealed when he undertook to perform vivisection upon a patient who has sub mitted to his knife. Jacob P. Schaad, a wealthy farmer, was the patient. Schaad had a growth on his face which Dabney had assured him could be removed by a minor op eration for the abscess. Soon after the surgeon began to wield the knife, ac cording to the story of the attending nurse, he skillfully laid open both sides of Schaad's face and made incisions in his throat. The nurse, horrified, ran from the room shrieking that Dr. Dabney was killing his patient. Other doctors w ho previously Dabney had sent from the operating theatre responded to find Dabney brandishing Ids scalpel over his subject. After a desperate struggle the sur geou was subdued.