Newspaper Page Text
THE AGE-HERALD E. \V. UAKKETT.Krilto* Etnerud al tne Birmingham. Ala.. ! Eostoffice a» second class matter un der act of Congress March 3, 13<y. Baiiy and Sunday Age-Herald, year . ^.IX | Bally without Sunday . 4.0* ; Baily and Sunday, per month. uaiiy and Sunday, tnree months.. 1.30 3 Weekly Ago-Herald. per annum.. .50 fcvr.aay Age-Heralu, pei annum.. 2.00 O. E. Young. R L>. Griffis and VV. i>. - Brumbelue are tne only authorized trav ** cling representatives of Tne Age-Herald » in ns circulation department. 2 No communication will be punlianed without its author's name. Rejected manuscript will not be leturned un less stamps are enclosed fur that pur pose. Remittances can be made at current 2ate of exchange, lne Age-Herald wjli Slot be responsible lor money seal Plrrough the mails. Address, THE AGE-HERAHD. Birmingham, Ala. Washington bureau, 20? Hlbbs build ing. European bureau, 6 Henrietta street, Covent Garden, Roudon. Eastern business olfice, Rooms 48 to 60, inclusive. Tribune building, New York city; western business office. Tribune building, Chicago. The S. C. Beckwith Special Agency, agents for eign advertising. TELEPHONE Bell (private exchange connecting departments) Main 41X10. O the difference of man and man! —King Lear. BEGINNING THE DAY— O Goil, help me to remember today that those who serve me on street curs, aat telephones, In shops, sre not ma chines, but people. Give me a quick sense of tltelr need of the human touch. Give me a due appreciation of the abiding value and high dignity of their work. For Christ's sake. Amen.—H. M. E. Uncle Sam's Sailors Formerly a sailor’s life in the United States navy was a hard one and it was made particularly so by poor food. There were no provisions for keeping fresh meats in the days of wooden ships, so that “salt horse’’ was aften the only kind of meat re ceived while on a voyage. This was supplemented with black coffee and hard tack. Today the American “tar” is better fed than the sailor of any other nation. There are about 66,000 enlisted men in the navy at present and it costs the government about $7,400,000 a year to feed them. A writer in the New York Sun, who discusses the work being done by Ad- : miral McGowan, chief of the bureau of supplies and accounts, says that the navy’s efficiency and the content ment of the men are largely due to the generous and varied food allot- | ment. No matter where a ship may j be, an elaborate system of provis ioning makes it possible for the “jackies” to have an abundance of the best food, and even luxuries. Canned meats are still extensively used in the navy, also canned fruit and vegetables, 1 but refrigerating plants on board the battleships supply^ the sailors with plenty of fresh meats, vegetables and ' fruits. On the Wyoming, the prize ship of the navy, a sample menu is as follows: Breakfast—Fried eggs, fried bologna, fried potatoes, bananas, bread, butter and coffee. Dinner—Grilled sirloin steak, fried onions, mashed potatoes, cocoanut custard, bread and coffee. Supper—Beef a la mode, hashed potatoes, corn fritters, bread, butter and tea. Also many tons of candy and thousands of packages of salted pea nuts are bought by the government every year and consumed by the sail ore. It can be seen that Uncle Sam takes exceptional care of his “tars,” and if those attractive posters in front of recruiting stations bore more extended reference to the bill of fare in the navy there would doubtless be a larger in crease in the number of recruits. Vacant Lot Gardening The school and vacant lot garden Idea has met with such remarkable ■uccess in those places where it has been given a thorough trial, that it j seems incomprehensible that the plan has not spread to every city and vil- , lage in the country. As an example of what may be done in the way of small gardening, attention is called to the accomplish ment of William Tompkins, an 11 year-old gardener of Corpus Christi. William has only 25x40 feet in his “back yard” garden, but he cultivates that with system and intelligent care; in fact he makes a study of scientific gardening. This year he won the prize for the best cultivated piece of land in Nueces county, Texas, and netted a profit of $55, including the prize, from his little plot of ground. The following is a list of the vegetables he produced: Foryt-six pounds of beets, 24 gal lons of snap beans, one and one-half ~ gallons of English peas, 197 bunches of lettuce, 15 bunches of parsley, two bunches of onions and one gallon of Strawberries. In addition to the $55 cash pro ceeds from his garden, William sup plied the family table with early veg etables. Nothing is so unsightly as a weed patch, 'it is a menace to health, an eyesore in a neighborhood and de preciates property value. There is no better way of eliminating the weed ' patch than by converting it into a garden spot. All that is necessary is to give the small boy the right incentive and he j will remove the weed patch problem, j At the same time, he will be learning | valuable lessons in soil culture. His | study of plant growth and his near J ness to Mother Earth is bound to have a good effect upon him—he will not have time to cultivate a weed patch in his soul. The Women Will Help The drastic retrenchment in the city’s annual expenses, which the lack of adequate revenue has made neces sary, will be sorely felt by the pub lic, and until the tax rate is increased there will be no permanent relief. It behooves the people of Birming ham, therefore, to unite in an effort to induce the legislature to submit t.o the voters of the state a tax amend ment authorizing the qualified elec tors of this city to raise the rate. This important measure is being opposed by two members of the Jefferson county delegation, but if local senti ment is thoroughly aroused favorable action should be expected. In the meantime the city comniis-' sion will be glad to receive sugges tions from citizens touching certain departments of the municipal govern ment that will be seriously crippled when the new budget becomes opera tive, with a view of minimizing to some extent the effect of the present rigorous policy. The counsel of the public-spirited | women of Birmingham is earnestly sought by the commission, and the Equal Suffrage association and the women’s civic board have responded with characteristic enthusiasm. The women can do especially good work in connection with the school depart ment and the health department, and they may be counted upon to render all the aid possible All honor to the women who are ready to volunteer their services for the emergency. But no matter how much aid free of cost may be rendered the city in its straitened condition, Birmingham will never be in proper shape until its income is on a par with the revenues of growing and ambitious the revenues of other growing and am bitious cities. And as the tax amend ment legislation is the first thing necessary let no effort be spared to secure it. Higher Price for Iron Expected The pig iron market has been ac tive for sometime past and, as a prominent man connected with the trade remarked the other day, “it is hard to see what holds the price of iron down.” He expressed the opinion that iron was “due for an expansion in price of from $3 to $4 a ton.” So hrisk has been the demand for pig metal recently that many blast furnaces long idle are being “blown in.” In the Birmingham district sev eral more furnaces are in operation now than was the case a few weeks ago and the number will be still further increased in August. Some large tonnage sales have been made this week and it is pointed out as a notable barometer of the trade that consumers are already beginning to make inquiry for 1917 delivery. The steel industry continues to boom. Every steel renter, including the Birmingham district., is the scene of unusual activity, and the best of it is the steel manufacturers are get ting satisfactory prices. If Birmingham iron can be ad vanced to $12 or $13, as some brokers think quite probable, and if the coal trade revives, there would be a greater degree of prosperity hereabouts than has been known in several years. The eugenics law in Wisconsin has de creased marriages 20 per cent. A great many people continue to believe that mar riage is a game ot chance with which science has nothing to do. In claiming that Thaw was trying to hypnotize him, old "Doc” Flint strength ened Thaw's case considerably with people who don't take much stock In courtroom | alienists. Mr. Bryan is blamed for the unsatisfac- j tory tone of the last German note. The ] eminent Nebraskan would feel lonesome if he couldn't hear the anvil chorus. With Champ Clark, Colonel Roosevelt and Mr. Bryan guests at the same time. California has more than her share of national celebrities. Within the past week or two summer has made her conquest of the country complete, but she hasn't been able to route summer furs. A New York man made more than 51,- j 000,00) last month by tfie rise in Electric j Boa' stock. Not bad for a summer | month. European war is not an unmitigated evil to the man who holds a few shares of stock in an American munitions faetury. The Cossacks are probably the most un popular soldiers in Europe. They do not specialize in deportment. General Huerta's vacation has been made a hollow mockery by the solicitude of Uncle Sam. Charging wire fences with electricity is also proving beneficial to the fatherland. In the meantime, it seems a long, long way to Constantinople. What Mexico needs first of all is three Bquure meals a day. Dentistry is one of the oldest profes sions. Martial, 2000 years ago. wrote of false teeth and as far back as 1300 B. the physician Asklepios recommended the extraction of teeth for certain maladies. In 400 B. C. Hippocrates prescribed dill, anise seed and myrrh dissolved in white wine for the treatment of unhealthy gums. After 2400 years myrrh is still pre scribed by dentists everj'where. Hippo crates also recommended chalk for clean ing the teeth, although it is true he ad vised that it be mixed with “the head of a hare” and the “intestines’’ of a mouse. Chalk is the basis of tooth powders used at the present time. Ancient dentists had i few instruments, but they did remark ! ably good work. Roman dentists had a pair of tweezers, corresponding to the modern forceps; phizagra, to extract loots; vulsellum, for removing bits of bone and tooth, and the specillum, a sort r>f probe. In the museums of Greece and Rome are many specimens of crown and bridge work, while pre-Columbian skulls from Ecuador and Mexico have teeth In laid with gold and precious stones. Orville Wright says it would take two years to equip the army and navy with necessary aerial craft. It is hardly prob able that any European power wil 1 be in a position to tackle us before the expira tion of that time. The Germans are said to be negotiating With Roumania on the assumption that Constantinople will be able to hold out at least another month. In the long run, however, the Turk will be the goat. THAT BAGGAGE LAW From the Pittsburg Dispatch. The amendment to the interstate com merce law which has been responsible for the new regulations requiring the Insur ance of baggage about which so much complaint has been made, has usually been referred to as proposed by Senator Cum mins of Iowa. This Mr. Cummins indig nantly denies. He acknowledges that he introduced an amendment designed to re store the principle which, prior to 1906, had always been in force in a greater part of the I nited States, that common carriers should not be permitted to limit theii liability for loss or damage sus tained in the carriage of ordinary freight below the basis of actual value. But this amendment contained a provision except ing property concealed by wrapping, box ing or otherwise. The irritating clause which has so annoyed the public, and particularly the commercial travelers, was, he says, the product of the states manship of Senator Reed of Missouri. Reed struck out the Cummins exception and inserted the amendment now In the* law which empowers the carrier to require the shipper to state the value of tin goods, and limits the liability to that statement. i Senator Cummins, moreover, contends that tlie theory that a misstatement of value by the shipper makes the owner liable to a heavy penalty cannot be sus tained. He believes that the statement is merely part of an agreement between this carrier and the shipper limiting liability and has presented that opinion to the interstate commerce commission, which he hopes will recall the ruling. This, at least, is a common sense view of it. BEC KER DOOMED From the Pittsburg Post. It appeared a doubtful business to attempt engaging the United States supreme court in a consideration of the case of former Police Lieutenant Beck er. Justice Hughes’ denial of the ap plication for a writ of error is no more than was expected by those who saw nothing in the New' York police of ficial's case that presented any con troversy dealing with his position un der the constitution and laws of the United States. By granting the reprieve which en abled counsel to try this last chance for the condemned man held responsi ble for Rosenthal's murder, Governor Whitman w'ent as far ns he consci entiously could go. The federal justice finding no error affecting the proceed ings in the New York courts adds vo the legal certainty that there is no in justice/to be corrected. This eliminates the principal consideration under w’hich the governor’s pardoning power could be rightfully exercised. No other consideration involving either public policy or exceptional circumstances in tervenes to save Becker from the elec tric chair in Sing Sing the week July 2G. BADGERING JANE ADDAMS From the New Republic. It is a little hard to see why editors should continue to scold Miss Jane Ad dams If the chancelories of Europe from Dowling street to the Vatican were willing to receive her. if the harassed statesmen of practically every warring country were willing to play with the idea of her mission, then surely the do mestic creed of manliness and red blood need not assert itself by deriding her. Had her trip been purely Quixotic it would st 11 not have been markedly insane in this insane world. As a matter of fact, Miss Addams did not go to stop the war”—she went to find out what peo ple and governments were thinking about the possibilities of peace, to recall to statesmen, if only a little bit, the fact that tliis slaughter must end sometime. The utmost practical end for the moment is that she may have started in some of ficial mind some disposition to think again in terms of human adjustment. Miss Addams was peculiarly the person j to do this. She has stood to all the world , for the intensive cultivation of human life, j She herself is tHe very antithesis of those ; military ideas that dominate the world. ! There is a side of human nature pitably : starved by the war, and Jane Addams speaks for it with a strange purity. With no trace of pride in any of her opinions, she could not be humiliated because she had left herself so completely out of ac count . She wields a power, weak perhaps at tills time but a power nevertheless, , w hich silences the scoffer and disarms the i pugnacious. The too-too manly man may . even feel a bit silly in her presence. -- IRIHITE TO THE SEA From Farm and Fireside. Eleven tons of soil is carried into the | Gulf of Mexico every second by the Mis- \ sissippi river from its immense drainage ! district. This material amounts to 310,- ! 000,OOu tons every year and is equal to i the surface soil, 6 l!-3 inches deep, of 346.000 ! acres. STRICTLY NEUTRAL From the Topeka State Capital. The American concerns that are send- j ing inferior supplies to the allies are show ing their strict neutrality. They would have done the same thing to their own country. 1 IN HOTEL LOBBIES j nunlupsK ('oiHItlnnn In Alabama "I have tiavefed over the state recently] and have found considerable Improvement in business,” said Buford D. Chenoweth. 1 “In northern Alabama, where crop diver j sJfication has been in practice for years past, thrift is the general rule. The faim ! ers raised some cotton, but more of other j CI°PS. Consequently the northern A!a ; liama merchants as well as the farmers in that part of the state are in ex- j cel lent shape. “Down in the cotton belt where I had j (expected to find business dull, I vas in j | many instances agreeably surprised. Much ! .attention is being given to the raising of j live stock in counties that formerly pre I dweed little else than cotton, j *n nil, Alabama is far better off ! ^lan I had any idea it would be. Nearly | all the merchants 1 met were optimistic.” In the .Mimic Trade “If business in sheet music and musical goods has been comparatively quiet tlii = summer, good times are ahead and I con fidently expect to see a great rush in all mercantile lines in the coming autumn,” said Oliver Chalifoux. “There are already indications of im provement in the near future, and as for the last quarter of the year/ it will wit ness a large measure of solid prosperity. T have never felt more buoyant when look ing forward than I do now.” Curtailment Regretted “It will indeed be a sad day for Bir | mingham if a'l of the proposed cuts in municipal expenditure are put into effect as butlined recently by the city commis sion,” remarked Percy Brower. “The fire department, the police depart ment and the health department are of great importance to the community and their efficiency should not be impaired or any of the offices abolished if it can be found practicable to avoid doing so; but what must be has to be, I suppose. “Perhaps the most deplorable feature in this connection, however, is the scheduled reduction in the length of the term of the city’s schools. Seven months is not enough for a child to attend school, and even country schools average a longer term than tills. Some means should be found to remedy this state of affairs. Tin schools should be financed in some man ner, and no doubt it could be done if suf ficient ingenuity w'ere brought into play by those at the helm." A Pine Railroad Record “More than 16.500.000 passengers—a num her greater than the combined population of Virginia, North Carolina, South Caro lina. Georgia, Alabama. Tennessee and Kentucky—were transported by the South ern railway during the year ended June 30, with only one fatal Injury to a passen ger while on a train, and that one was standing on a car platform in direct vio lation of the company's rules,’’ said ,L. Sevier. “Of thiB grpat number of passengers, not one was killed in a train accident. “This excellent record was shown in the official figures given out today, indicat ing the high degree of safety that has been attained in the handling of Southern railway passenger trains. “in marked contrast are figures re cently given out by President Fairfax Harrison of the Southern railway, show ing that during the same period 12 per sons riding in automobiles were idled In accidents at public highway crossings, every one of which accidents could have been prevented had the driver of the car observed the familiar warning. ‘Stop, look j and listen.’ ” Improved Local Conditions "The best sign of improved business conditions and the general prosperity of the people, is the fact that collections are better than they have been for the past 1 six months," said J. D. Baugh. "This, in my opinion, is the surest sign of returning confidence and a feeling of prosperity that cannot be downed. The people of the i'nited States seem to have adjusted themselves to the conditions caused by the European war. The result is that every one realizes that things are not half so bad as have been pictured in the past. Nearly all of the big Industries in and about Birmingham are putting on men and I understand that they have ample orders to keep the plants operating at capacity for sometime to come. When Birmingham people see the stacks sending forth smoke in great volume, they natur ally have a sense of security in the fu ture. "For my part, I expect Birmingham, and. In fact, the whole country to im prove at a rapid rate during the next few months. Everyone realizes that there is no telling when the slaughter in Eu rope wil cease, accordingly they have commenced to pay more attention to their business and less to the war. In other words, we have commenced to realize that our country can live and prosper re gardless of all the strife in foreign lands. The natural result is. a vast improve inent in business conditions, and cheaper money in the future.’’ The Chicago Wheat Market "Conditions in Chicago are very much improved." remarked I. (J. Cohen, rep resenting a brokerage concern of the lake ! metropolis, who passed through Binning- j ham en route to Meridian. "A great number of the idle men who j were in Chicago have gone to the wheat - Ik Ids to help harvest the crops. The farm ! ers In the northwest pay a good price I for these men and this enables them to 1 lay by enough money to tide them over until they can find other work at the end of the harvest season. Money throughout j : the west is loosening up, and I confident- j I ly expect things to resume their normal ! condition in the next six months." In speaking of the effect the attempt- j i ed assassination of J. Pierpont Morgan i had upon the Chicago exchange. Mr. Cohen - [said: "As soon as it became known that I 1 Mr. Morgan had been shot, the entire mar- 1 ket broke sharply and pandemonium | I reigned throughout the rest of the ses- j ; sion. The following day when it was j ! positively ascertained that the great finan- • ; cier’s condition was not serious, the mar- 1 ket resumed its normal condition. The: | slightest event or well grounded ru^nor | ; during these times has a tendency to j i completely demoralize the market. The i result is that the traders in the pit are j ! at a loss to understand how bad the i • market will break. j "The wheat crop this year is the big ! gest that has ever been raised in the his | lory of the world. Had it not been for | the present conflict in Europe, 1 doubt if i the farmer would get anything like the ! pric* that is offered for his product to day. The corn crop breaks all records. • and the best thing about it is that the j , farmer will be enabled to get a good ( price for his grain when it is ready to | j market. Good times are coming—there is j | no doubt about that. Those who forget > to knock and stick to hard work are 'bound to reap their harvest of prosper-) ity.” ! Greene County Democrat: We under stand there is considerable home raised, home ground flour in the county, but the owners are so well pleased with it, ^ they are not offering it for sale, but . re keeping it for home consumption. I'alksville News: One hundred cars of Alabama hay received in Birmingham during the past few days. This sounds j well, but there were perhaps another i iOO cars gone to waste. We lose as , much as we save. Conocuh Record: Industrial activity | and old general prosperity throughout ihe United States are greater today than they have been for 10 years, and the tide is still rising. Gadsden Daily Times-News: We admit that the weather is hot in Gadsden, but Alaska, Denver and other pleasure re ports are much warmer. Mobile Register: The Kaiser expects to win by October. He doesn't put it that way. He says the war will end in October; but he does not expect it to end until he wins. ANTHONY COMES HACK From the St. Louis Republic. A few brief days ago the editorial columns of newspapers scattered throughout the country contained more or less extended appreciations of the life and labors of Anthony Comstock. An thony was not dead, nut it was sup posed that he had been removed from his position as postoffice inspector and it was assumed that he was officially defunct. It appeared that Inspector Comstock had run his course and that all that remained for him was an ob scure old age in which he would never more impose upon the public the con sequences of his supersensitive discrim ination between nice and naughty. Therefore it behooved the sympathetic commentator to remember that the in spector had not always been merely a hypercritical nuisance and to admit the value of his public services. To be sure, there was audible in every word of praise a sigh of relief at the departure. The commendation was enforced by the unalterable demands of fair play. The “Thank heaven lie is gone!" came from the heart, but the postoffice depart ment does not seem to have seen the thing in this light. Inspector Comsto* k recently visited the Postmaster General and perhaps lie carried some of those ! very editorials with him and underlined the acknowlengments of his worth and zeal. Anyway, it is announced that he is to be retained in the service, and all of those who sped the parting inspector will have a chance to open the door and bow him out again. Comparisons be tween the next set of farewells and those which were just said may prove interestin g. A FUTILE PEACE PILGRIMAGE From the St. Louis Post Dispatch. Returning1 with her American com panions from the Woman’s Peace con gress at The Hague and peace pilgrim age to foreign capitals, Jane Addams wonders that "in England there was a spirit of indifference in the press" to her errand. Probably British editors were not polite enough to conceal their opinion of futile effort. Their government-placed obstacles in the way of the congress, which was only by chance attended by two or three scarcely representative British women. French women were not present; they 'disclaimed all interest in peace while an invader's foot remains on French soil. Belgian women came to fight successfully any call for peace that did not add "with justice.” The prepon derant groups were those of the great war power and the chief neutral na tion. of Germany and the United States Germany’s interest in peace is natural. As the war stands, she has won. Hav ing Belgium, her main object, more of Poland than she probably cares to keep | and a rich slice of France, she can consent to compromises. The allies, beaten thus far, but still short of their maximum strength and still hopeful of' Roumanian and Bulgarian assistance, are in no mood to stop. One nation may make war. War, one made, is not checked until both siac-s find some ground of agreement. The mission of the peace delegates expressed a humane aspiration. As a practical step toward peace now, it had all the weight of a feather fluttering in the vortex of a tornado. GOOD EXAMPLE From the Milwaukee Sentinel. There was a time when it was not an unusual thing for merchants, manufactur ers and other employers of men who be longed to the national guard to say to I members who desired to spend a week in camp of instruction, “If you go you need not return,” or words to that unpatriotic effect. But that time has passed, apparently. Several large business firms in Boston I have notified their employes who belong ■ I to the militia that leaves will be granted ! | them for the usual military instruction.' I and also that while so engaged their I | pay by the Arms will be doubled, j Several large banking houses in New j York and Brooklyn have made the same generous and patriotic arrangement with j their soldier employes. It is further evidence that, in spite of j the paid and other service of the “peace at j any price" people, the public is awaken ing to the importance of military training and preparedness in this country, that has never been ready for any of the wars that it has been forced to engage in. A BYWAY I By Margaret Lee Ashley. ! The highway marches sturdily to market town and mill, | But I would And a little road that loiters up a hill— A lit He vagrant, woodland road, gray- I ribboned through the green, Whose berry brambles bar the way and orchard eiders lean. The highway is the world’s way, but 1 would drop behind To follow little luring paths that only lag- ; Sards And; i i he challenge of the bandit weeds, the' tilt with startled bees— ! "'hat can the dusty highways give for j tournevings like these? • j The highway is the sun'B way, and follows ; east to west, I But there are yelllow, vagrant beams that ' love my road the best— | That linger down the weedy ways where , lady's lace is spread, ! Or slant through shady orchard paths | and tint the tree trunks red. * ^ j The highway, the highway!—you follow where it calls; j I watch you through a leafy screen from crumbling orchard walls;— j I wait and smile among the green and j know that by and by 1 We’ll lure you back through dust and dew—my little road and II —From the Washington Evening Star. ■••••••••••••••••••••••(•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••I••••••••••••tl•••«••«••••••>#asaav ADRIFT WITH THE TIMES SARTORIALLY IMPRESSIVE. "I notice that Mr. Buffkins always oc cupies a seat on the platform when there Is a public meeting.” “Yes. He’s been doing that for 20 years.” “He must be a man of some importance in the community.” “No. He’s not at all Important and I don’t believe be was ever invited to sit on a platform, but he puts on a silk hat and a frock coat and nobody has the cour age to snub him.” HELPING CONSIDERABLY. “I suppose you are willing to do your share to lessen the horrors of war?” said the inquisitive person. “Not only willing, but I’m doing my share.” said the quiet man. “How so?” “With people I know I argue about it as little as possible and with strangers not at all.” ’TIS INDEED. “It’s a good plan to think twice before speaking.” “No doubt that’s true in some cases, but not in others.” “For instance?” “When I'm talking over the long dis tance telephone at 50 cents a minute, stopping to think seems like a waste of money.” THE RULING PASSION. “What’s all that racket in your dinin' room, Hiram?” , “That's my hired man doing a clog •••••••••••••••••••••••••«••••••*■••••••■••••••••••• dance. We’ve got a couple o’ city boarJf- * ers here who’s so used to them cabarets : that they can’t eat unless some sort o’ ! show Is goin' on.” s NO BEAUTY. ? "I guess Muggson will die a bachelor.? J "What makes you think so?” I ’’He says he's not going to marry until i| he finds a girl who will take him at his |l face value.” j SOMEWHAT SKEPTICAL. \ "I would like to know what Abraham ? Lincoln would do in the emergency which confronts Woodrow Wilson,” said the first citizen. { "So would I,” replied the second citi- • i zen, "although I turned down the offer of » a man who said he would tell me for $2.” J "You must be joking.” | "Not at all. He was a spiritualist and • I informed him that if he thought he could really get into communication with Abraham Lincoln, he had considerably more confidence in his powers than X * had.” HOW IT WORKS. The critics said a movie show Was one we should not see I And held if anyone should go, i ’Twould most imprudent be. ! The papers then took up the cause, j Expressing pained surprise, And running on with -tittle pause, They served to advertise The naughty film to such extent, With virtue's fond pretense, That nearly everybody went And profits were immense. »••••••••••••••••••••••«>••••••••••••••••••••••••••••< THE MODERN SHORT STORY From the New York Evening Post. IT is not often that a critic can fire both right and left, but whereas Henry Canby registers in the Atlantic his belief that the American magazine story is a weak, stereotyped product, j the same Mr. Canby points out in Har- 1 per's that tlie public emphatically shares j his opinion. He is convinced that college teacher, business man and artisan alike think of most periodical fiction as trash, j In Boston, a critic who had read 00* short stories of the twelve-month recently un dertook to pass judgment upon them. Mr. O’Brien's appraisal was generous enough, at least as to the writers—Mary Wilkins Freeman, Katherine Fullerton Oerould, Conrad Richter—whom he rates first. But from the Portland Oregonian the re view elicits a discouraging comment. “The American short story,’’ it remarks, “has long since fulfilled all the artistic prom ise it ever had, and is now In senile decay. Nor is there any doubt that its ending should be speedy. When an art form comes to the point where it is produced by the bushel, according to a mathemat ical formula* its demise is not far away.’’ The short story is a form, and nothing more, and it totters through the pages of the magazines “as a pale, utterly dis embodied specter.” It must be remembered that it is the average that is spoken of; the mediocre background against which and without reference to which writers of genius may still bring out distinguished work. Upon the short story we Americans have lav ished pains and pride. It is the one department in which we have excelled, the one of which the public is by temper ament most fond, and the one which our addiction to periodicals most stimulates. It is still much better than the English short story, quite equal to the French, and not far short of the Russian. In ex planation of its recent deficiencies we have had a contradictory variety of theT ories. Magazines imitate each other in one prevailing craze; editors are timidly unwilling to risk anything beyond three or four modes established by years of usage; there is the worship of formulas, and the belief of writers that by abject obser\ance of rules alone can they reach commercial success; besides the require ment of inventiveness and constant “punch.” But these explanations are not so contradictory that they do not all ad mit or imply one thing; the heavy em phasis upon form and technique, as against character, emotion, atmosphere. This is put forward by defenders of the short story as well as its assailants. The stories are as “well made" as a piay; they show consummate dexterity, and be speak a masterly sense of narrative. But those who read many of them know how quickly this superficial merit palls, and the faults Involved in an exaggerated at tention to structural niceties obtrude un til they are offensive. The preoccupation with form shows its blighting effect upon plot. Quietness is our first element to go—half of the modern short stories must start with a whiaz, tilt sharply over f descend through some nerve nt to a conclusion w • ***" than 10 per cent c ! amined by one enterprising writer of a new short story handbook began with conversation, and twice as many more gave us conversation introduced by only a few words to indicate speaker, time and place. Thus interest is “caught at the start." The situation conceived the writer must contrive exactly the retrospective narrative, the train of machine-made in cident revealing character and unfolding plot, and all-satisfying conclusion. Since j O. Henry, there has been a wearying re- ! ! currchce of the ending that, quick and j unsuspected as a lightning flash, throws ! a searchlight back through the proces sion of events to reveal how much more clever the narrator is than the reader/ Gouverneur Morris, successful from the big check standpoint, has just told us how overrated and antiquated is Wash ington Irving, from his mere quality of leisureliness. As for the latitude allowed * the short story, it is unthinkable that America could have anything like either* | the simple French notes or the German , novellen—even such novellen as Conrad ! often writes. We have spoken of the 'part Masefieldian verse like Robert Frost s ' ha.: played as a substitute for the bare 1500-word tale of Europe, and Mr. Canby speaks of Tchekoff’s ^eries, which wobld be rejected, not because they lack pic tuiesqueness, or narrative suspense, or vivid characterization, but because they do not seem to move rapidly, and lack a vigorous climax. Such forms do not satis fy our demand for technique. But the dfeper effect of the preoccupation is upon character treatment. A machine-made plot argues machine-made characters, mold | ed to fit the exigencies of opening, crisis land titillating end. There is an unneces ! sary temptation to use a “type”—the ath- ' | lwtic young man, the pretty girl, the neu rotic wife, the vulgarian wage-earner—as emphasized by externals. It thus seems that a writer can pro duce a clever story nowadays without en ! terir.g into the personality of characters who are not like himself. It is easy for him to obtain a reputation even for vlvla originality by making his own the people of some new’ environment, as the Portu guese fishers of Cape Cod, the modern business woman, without actually poss#;s ing himself of their spiritual traits. Henry* James has left us somewhere a descrip tion of Turgenieff s method. The first form in which a tale appeared to him was as an individual or combination of indi viduals whom lie wished to see in action, being sure that such people must do some thing ver^ special and interesting. They stood before him definite, vivid, and he wished to know ar.d to show as rmyfa as | possible of their nature; lie used to write a whole preliminary dossier or biography of each. But in not five American short | stories in 100 is it possible to believe that anything but the plot has been conceived | first, and conceived so that problem, j contrast, surprise, mystery predominate, while mood, emotion and symbolism, call ing for special deftness in character de lineation, fall into the remote background. This is the natural result of a straining after form, and of a want of psycholog ical penetration. BY CONTRARIES From the Memphis Commercial-Appeal^ Things go ny contraries. King Georg*. > after all these long years, has bestowed1,’ *"■ « wnman—oiiri