Newspaper Page Text
?JBB DIBPATOH FOUNDED ISM. HB TntBS FOUND I'D UM WHOLE NUMBER 18,621._ RICHMOND, VAM TUESDAY, MAY 16 miT" TUB WBJATHEU TO-DAY?Filr. PRICE TWO CENTS. NO TERMS IN JAIL WILL BE IMPOSED ON LABOR LEADERS SAMUEL GOMPERS. I'llAMC MOHHISO.V. COURT SETS THEIR SENTENCE ASIDE G?nipcfs. Mitchell and Morrison Win Victory in Contempt Litigation. CASE HELD CIVIL ONE Uccisiori of Justices. Handed Down by Lamar, Is Unanimous. No Further Action; Case Now Is Closed St. Louis, Mo., May IB.?The Uuckn Stove and Hange Company will imt Inntltnte civil notion ngatnnt Samuel Ciompera, John Mitchell and FrnnU Morrison, according to F. D. Gardner, chnlminn of the hoard, to-day. He said the comiiiui.T nnd the American Federation of I.nhur are on friendly terms. The cane decided by the Su? preme Court of the United States Iran prosecuted by the American An? ti-Boycott Association, of which the Bucks Stove and Range Company In no looser a member. Washington, D. C, May 15.?Samuel Gompera, John Mitchell and Frank Morrison, president, vlce-prealdent and ?ecretary of the American Federation of Labor, respectively, stepped from without the shadow of the Jail to-day irhcn the Supreme Court of the Unltrd States aet aalde their sentencen of Im? prisonment for contempt growing out of, the I'tifratlon between the Buck* Stove and Hange Compnuy nnd the federation. The highest tribunal In the laud has left with the lower court, however, the right to reopen the contempt proceed? ings. This grant of power probably will not be accepted nnd the case prac? tically is ended with to-day's decision. The basis of the court's decision was that thir proceedings brought against the lnhor oftlcors were for civil con? tempt, which could be punished only by the imposition of a tine. The sentence of the lower court to Imprisonment was the penalty for the criminal con? tempt, and in Iho premises It was, therefore, not u legal punishment. Tho case, which grew "out of the so. called boycott of tho stove corporation by the A nu t Iran Kode) fit Ion of Labor, three yoara ago. Is one of tho greatest Importance nliko to union labor and to the employers of union labor. No Itiuivtdnni Bights. The Supreme Court holds that the published or spoken utterances of or? ganized lnhor can bo enjoined or at? tacked legally because organized labor Is a combination, and as such, relin? quishes the rights of Individuals. It also establishes tho fact that legal prosecution can be levelled not only at tho union Itself, hut at Its officers as well. ^ ? In handing down Us unanimous opinion, read by Justice Lamar, tho court reviewed the caao brought by the Buck's Sovo and Range Company against Oompers, M!t?hell and Morri? son, Booking to enjoin them from plac? ing'the company on Its "unfair" nnd "tfe don't patronize" lists published rog ularly in tho American Federatlonlst, the official publication of the fodera POLICE BATTLE WITH STRIKERS Score of Officers Injured in Desperate Fight at Cjrand Rapids. MANY WOMEN TAKE PART Xot Until Arrival of Fire De? partment Is Angry Mob Quelled. Grand Rapids. Mich.. May IS.?At j least a score of policemen were In-. I lured and many members of a mol> of i:,000 striking furniture workers and sympathisers were hurt in a riot at tiie plant of the Wlddiooinb Furnitur? Company to-night. Several of the in? jured may die. After a" fierce battle with revolvers, cluhs. stones and missiles, in which | the police were badly beaten, a fire en? gine company attacked the mob with streams of water, and succeeded In quelling the disturbance to a consid? erable extent. Many women were ac? tive among the. rioters. The trouble started when a mob of about 300 men, women and boys at? tacked a closed automobile driven by Ralph' Wlddleomb, of the furniture company, who was taking several strike-breakers from the faotory. One of the policemen on guard at the plant attempted to make an arrest, and the mob closed In on him. Other police? men, with drawn revolvers, quickly arrived, but were overwhelmed. A squad of reserves was rushod to the scene, and soon began firing, and the I fire was returned by the rioters. Sev? eral of the police officers were knocked senseless by missiles hurled or swung by women. Mayor Bills made a fruitless attempt to quell the riot before the fire depart? ment was summonod. A terrific battle ensued as the firemen began to lay their lines, in which the mob was finally overcome and broken up. The strike-breakers were spirited away, and while comparative quiet now reigns, a force of officers will patrol the district all night. MRS. TAFT BETTER She Will Dp Able to nelurn to Wn?Ii . lugten Thuroilay. ? , Washington. May 15.?President Taft.' received assurances from New York I late this afternoon that the condition of Mis. Tnft had Improved so much that she would be. able to return to [ Washington Thursday. The President felt so much relieved at the news thai \ he went to a local theatre to-night Announcement was made at the Whlti) House that the social program which I Mrs. Taft had mapped out for . the spring will he adhered to. The dinner to tho *Fur Real Commissioners on Thursday night and tho garden party, which Is on tho program for Frldav, will be glvon. Miss Helen Tcft will act' as ' mistress of the White House on both occasions. TAFT IS CENSURED Ministers Regret III? "Desecration" of." Snbhnth Day. i Harrlsburg. Pa., May ir>.?Resolu? tions expressing regret that President Tnft traveled to this city yesterday to address, the big Surjday meeting of rnllroad trainmen were adopted to-day by the Methodist Ministerial Associa? tion of Harrlsburg and vicinity. Tho resolutions, in addition to voic? ing sorrow at the occurrence, expressed the hope that there may be no repeti? tion of what. Is termed "desecration" of tho day. Tho Governor of Pennsylvania, t.ie Mayor und the former Mayor of tho city and the clergymen who partici? pated in the oxerclsOR yesterday aro also mentioned in the resolutions. PEACE PARLEYS m BRING END OF HOSTILITIES Madero Believes War Will Be Over in Short Time. CONFERS WITH. ENVOY OF DIAZ Federal Government Inclined to Accept Latest Propositions Submitted by Rebels?Chi? huahua in Fear of Attack, and Desperate Condition Prevails in That City. Juarez, Mexico, May 1G.?Provisional j President Kruuclnco I. .Mmicro, Jr., nl the cuncluHlon of a conference ?Hb Judge Carbnjul, tin- Federal uetiee eti- ' vuy, to-night announced (hut there wait j n hlniin; probability that pence would I he restored In Mexico ulthlo a short ! time. < "Judge Carbajal brought some pro? positions," said .Sonor Madero to an As? sociated Press reporter, "arid I made some modifications In our original pro? positions. In lact, these concessions; slight though they may be, were made to show our willingness to meet tho government half way; and, after our military triumphs, n more than indi? cates our good disposition to treat fori peace." Senor Madero said thru the next move on the peace checkerboard should; be made by tho Diaz government, but he talked as If to-morrow there would be a favorable reply from the govern- i Intnl. This, immediately would end the revolution. There was evident, on the other hand, a determination to prosecute the war > should the government refuse to ae- | cede. 1-i.c gave the Impression llinl the affair had reached (he point of an ulti? matum, and that the die would be ?rast to-morrow. To-day, preparations for a vigorous pushing of the revolution, at a stand? still for the time being, because of the victory of Juarez, and the first serious efforts to make the provisional govern? ment of Mexico something more than a name, were grimly evident. The war Situation may be epitomized us follows: On to Chihuahua and then Mexico City. This plan is not admit? ted or even discussed in public by the revolutionists, but It Is In the air. Pence Seems Xenr. Mexico City. May 16.?Peace again loomed big on the horizon of Mexico'.' internal affairs to-day, and led Foreigr Minister de la Barra to remark: "We believe that we are making i great progress towards peace." .Negotiations ItFHiitned. The end of tho revolution In Mexico | iccins near. Judge Carbajal,' Federal peace commissioner, this morning re teiyed ' telegraphic instructions from Mexico City to proceed with peace ne? gotiations along the line proposed by Itai'ael Hernandez yesterday, carried in last night's' Associated Press dispatch? es, and based upon Madero's demands. To Krorgnnt/.c Cabinet. Juarez, Mexico, May 15.?Indirect as? surances that the Federal government is inclined to accept the propositions' submitted unofficially within the last two days by the lnsurrectos for the establishment of peace were received here to-day by Rafael Hernandez, one of the go-betweens In the negotiations Tho government Is believed to be ready to reorganize the cabinet and glvo the lnsurrectos four members out of eight and to allow the revolution? ists to namj , autrlght fourtoen Gov? ernors of twenty-seven states, and by mutual agreement select the remain? ing sixteen Governors. More definite ad/Ices giving the atti? tude of the government were expected later In the day. Optimum of the probable success of the peace parleys now taking place by telegraph with Mexico City prevailed to-dnv. Not l.lkoly to Attncfc. It was not believed that Colonel Rabago, who last night was reported to he marching on Juarez, would pro voke any engagement at this time, though the insurroctos took no chances and prepnred to meet him. Some reports had It that Rabago Villas nnd Tcrrazas were not far from Chihuahua, and a wek's march from here, awaiting orders. The bellet exists that the Federal government will not in thai case send hltn march? ing orders In view of tho probable suc? cess of the present negotiations. In Fenr of Attack. Chihuahua, Mexico, May 13?(via El Paso. Tex., May 15),?Chlhua'hua now stands In fear of an attack, and many people feel that any resistance is hope? less. The ".000 lnsurrectos who are approaching from the south, to-day reached Kscalon, a fow miles below .limine;:. As they proceed, tho lnsur? rectos are tying tip the National Kail road line not protected by Federal troops. The Federal troops south of hero arc all rotrcatlng to Chihuahua, having found It Impossible to stem the onward march of the lnsurrectos. An armored train, filled with Federal troops, which went south to open the. railroad, soon returned with the re? port that tho enemy was In over? whelming numbers, and an attack from the train would have meant annihila? tion. The belief 13 that the lnsurrectos Roon will take Jtmlnez. togethor with the branch railroad running to Par ral. and then will encamp around Chi? huahua to attack the city In con? junction with part of Madero's force? from Juarez. The Federal troops are reginrdcd as effectively bottled up Only 1,500 Federals are In Chihuahua oity. Gonoral Rnhago's 1,200 men, who started to Juarez, are cut oft fron; return by an insurrocto band, which enmc In behind them. Tho situation in tho city Is becoming dally more des? perate. Supplier are scarce. ' All train and telegraph communication has boon cut off for two weeks. Governor Ahumada to-day Issued an 1 (Continued on Second Page.) SUPREME COURT ORDERS DISSOLUTION OF STANDARD OIL COMPANY, DECLARING IT MONOPOLY IN RESTRAINT OF TRADE Tremendous Legal Struggle of Years Finally Is Ended. EPOCH-MAKING IN ITS IMPORT Sherman Anti-Trust Law Up? held, but Its Application is Limited to Acts of "Undue Restraint," and Thus Pray? ers of Business World Are Answered. What Court Holds in Standard Case The Supreme Court boldsi 'I'llin the Standard Oil Company la u monopoly In rctttrnlnt or trade. 1 hut thin ;;lnn< corporation must Ue dissolved vtltbln six month*. Corporation!! whose cnnlrncfii are "not mi reiinonnhl y restrictive ol compel It Ion" are not afTccted. Oilier ^rent corporation* uhase nrln mny hr called Into f|tiestlon will he clinit with according (o the mer? lin of (kclr particular cases. The court was unnnlmoiiH an to the mi ill n fcnturcK of i In- dcclnlou. Jus? tice llnrlnn dissenting only as to a 11 n il n i in a nf the application of the Sherman nuli-trunt law. President Tnft and hin Cabinet ?III consider I mniedlniely the en? tire trust pit nnt Inn and tbr ndvlsn blllty of prfhulnc for h Frdernl In? corporation act. A dcrlnlou In the Tohncco Trust i'/mp, vthlch ?11? expected simultane? ously, was not announced to-day nail may he handed down on Mny -U. Washington, D. C, May IS.?The .Standard Oil Company of New Jerney and Itn nineteen subsidiary corporatlonn vi ere declared to-dny by the Supreme Court of the Lulled Stntc* to be a con nplracy and cmnhlnntlnn In restrulnt ol trade. It also ?nn held to be monopo IizIiior Interstate commerce, In violation of the Sherman anti-trust law. The dissolution of the combination was or? dered to take place within nix mouths. Thus ended the tremendous struggle of years on the part of the government to put down by authority of law a com? bination which It claimed was a men? ace to the industrial and economic ad? vancement of the entire country. At the samo time the court interpreted the .Sherman anli-irust law so as ^to limit Its application to acts of "unduo re? straint" of trade, and not "every" re? straint of trade. It was on this point that the only discordant note was heard In the court. Justice Harlan dissented, claiming that c^ses already decided by the court had determined once tor all Hint the word "undue" or "unreason? able" or similar words were not In tho statute. He declared that the reason? ing of the court In arriving at its find? ing was In effect legislation which be? longed in every Instance to Congress and not to the courts. ' "Business World" Pleased. Ever since the decree In this case In the lower court, the United States Cir? cuit Court for the Eastern District of Missouri, was announced, hope had been expressed by the "business world" that the law would be modified so as not to Interfere with what was deslgn&ted as honest business. To-night that section of the opinion calling for the use of Ihe "rule of reason" in applying the] law is regarded In many quarters ns un answer to the prnycrs of the "bus? iness world." The opinion of tho court was an? nounced by Chief Justice White. In printed form, It contained mo'ro than "0,000 words. For nearly tin hour th< Chief Justice discussed the case fron the bench, going over most of thi points In the printed opinion, but no! oiu'e referring to It In order to refresh his memory. Before him sat a distin? guished audience of the most famou? mon of the country. Senators and Hep resentntlvl8 loft tholr respective cham? bers In the Capitol to listen to thr epoch-making decision of the court Most oager to hear wore Attorney-Gen? eral Wlckersham and Frank B, Kellogg special counsel of the government, who had conducted the groat tight against Ihe Standard Oil. None of the brilliant array of counsel for the corporations or Individual defendants was present In Ihe court during the reading of the opinion. To-day, as on previous decision day" for months past, rival brokers" agents with messengers In line to the various telephone and telegrnph Instruments throughout the. Capitol, were on hand but to their dismay the announcement Uncle Sam and Farmers In an article prepared for next Suuday's Tlmes-Dlspntch by Frank G. Carpenter, that well-known writer discusses some new schemes of the Agricultural Department, ns outlined by Secretary Wilson. In? teresting stories of little corn rais? ers are relntcd, nnd he discusses farming with goals mid calves, de? claring thin to he it movement which will revolution I re the South, Chler Justice White, who rendered decision, ?nd Fr??k Kcllojr (smnll iilc" cure), who hnudled the ense for the Rovcrnmcnt. of the decision was not begun until an hour ufter the closing of the stock markets. Tobacco Case Next. Many expected that the decision of tho court In the dissolution suit against the tobacco corporation would be hand? ed down Immediately after the decislor In the Standard Oil case. This was not done, however, but the decision 1b ex? pected on May 'JO, the last decision day of the .court until next October. The opinion of the court to-day wa3 I construed to mean that the tobacco case, like every other case In which re? straints of trade are alleged, must be subjected to the new tost of reasona? bleness of tho restraint, aa laid down In tho Stnndurd OH decision. By far tile greater portion of tho opinion of tho Chief Justice was de? voted to the Justification of the court In requiring that the "rule of reason" j be applied to restraints In trade beforo they were hold to be violations of tho I Sherman anti-trust law. The court RAILROADS ORDERED TO COMPLY WITH ACTS Their Absolute Duty to Keep Safety Appliances in Repair. SUPREME COURT RULES Hereafter Mere "Reasonable Diligence" on Their Part Will Not Suffice. Washington. May 16.?Railroads coming within tho torma ot the safety appliance acts of Congress in 1S03 and 1903 arc under an absolute duty to Keep In repair automatic couplers and other appliances prescribed by law, and not merely a duty to exercise reasonable diligence In repairing. Such was the decision to-day of tho Supremo Court of tho United States. Vital Uuestlons. By an odd coincidence, a number of vital questions concerning the scope of the safety appliance acts of Con? gress enme beforo the Supreme Court of the United States about the same tlmo and were hoard together. One of these arose in tho suit of F. M. Deik, a bralieman on the St. Louis and San Francisco Railroad Company, for Injuries suft'erod while attempting to manipulate a defective coupler of a cur on a switch In Memphis, Tonn. The United States Circuit Court of Ap? peals for the Sixth Circuit finally de? cided against Deik, on the ground that while tho railroad was under an ab? solute duty to oqulp cars with auto? matic couplers and othor appliances ro. quired h>' the safoty appliance acts, yet it was only under the common law duty to exercise reasonable diligence when It came to repairing the ap? pliances. Dalk had contended that tho acts changed tlio common law duty so as to make tho railroad absolutely liable for. not ropalrlng appliances re? quired by the statutes, as well hs for not equipping cars with tho ap pllancos. The direct reverse of this holding was announced by tho United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, when the United Slates sought to recovor from tho Chicago, Burling? ton and Qulncy Railway Company $100 for each of four alleged violations of the acts. Thoro It was held that the railway coinpanj' was under an abso? lute obligation to Iteop the safety ap? pliances with which their cars must bo equipped In repair. Tho rullrond claimed that the court hold them liable, notwithstanding the company did not know Its cors were out of repair and had no Intention to violutc the law. Cose In Colorado. Another question was passed upon by the United Slates District Court of Colorado, when It held that the Colo? rado and Northwestern Railroad Com? pany, a narrow gauge ra'iroad entirely within Boulder county. Col., and said to be using locomotives and cars equipped with '.ho old link and piii couplers was liable to the govornmont for a violation of the law. In so doing the court held that it was not neces? sary to order or bring a connecting carrier within the safety appliance nets for It to have an arrangement for a (Continued on Second Pago.) Ii BATHTUB GASE Supreme Court May Be Called On to Interpret Immunity Statutes. . Washington, May 15.?Tho govern? ment's case against tho so-called Dathtub Trust took a twist to? day, which may Involve an interpreta? tion of tho Immunity statutes by the Supreme Court of the United StateB, and mny possibly thoreby affect near? ly every anti-trust prosecution now under way. The ColweU Lead Company, one ot the defendants In the government's civil suit asked the Supremo Court to review Judge Howlnnd'e recent de? cision In the United States Circuit Court in - nlladelphla, that ono de fondant In the case, when called by another as a witness, could not claim the protection of the Immunity statutes. Thc Department of Justice holds that Congross Intcndod the im? munity stattjtcs to protoct witnesses testifying for tho govornmont. Judge Howland so ruled. Uopartmont of Jus? tice olllclals declare that to nllow Im? munity to one defendant i mm anti? trust suit becauso ho Is called as a witness by'a co-defendant would prac? tically emasculate tho Sherman law. Dignity liaised n Notch. The dignity of assistant secretaries In the government departments hero was raised a notch or so to-day when the.Supreme Court hold that notice by Assistant Secretary of War Oliver to the Hannibal nrldgo Company to alter Its bridge across thc Mississippi Itlvor was oqulvnlont to notice by the Secretary of War. President Taft was Secretary of War when tha notice was issued. The bridge company failed to make the alterations. U'lien the govornmont proceeded against it and the Wabfish Hull road Company, which uses I lie bridge, tho point was raised that thc law roqulrlng the ".Secretary of War" to give notice was not satisfied by the act of an "assistant secretary." Victory for Gils Company. Natural giui mny be transported out of Oklahoma In pipe linos and tho State cannot prevent It, according to a de? cision to-day by the Supreme Court. Tho court In effect approved an In? junction to prevent thu Oklahoma oili clals from Interfering with tho Kansas Natural Gas Company laying n pipe line into Oklahomn. Tho court hold that ihe State officials in so doing were Interfering with Interstate, com? merce. Ah Oklahoma statute authoriz? ing tho acts of the officials was hold to hn unconstitutional nnd void. Appeul Dismissed. Tho Supreme Court dismissed for wnnt of jurisdiction the appeal from the sentence of contempt recently Im? posed by Judge Uioomhii in the Unltod States Circuit Court at Now York on United Stales District Attorney Henry A. Wise. The attorney had refused to ribev tho order of tho court to return to Lawrence It. Mills and associated I'Importers tholr books seized when limy I wore urroslod on charges o? violating tho customs laws. Giant Corporation Must Be Dissolved Within Six .Months. COURT'S OPINION IS UNANIMOUS Government Wins Sweeping Victory in Bitterly Fought Litigation, Decree of Lower Tribunal Being Upheld. Decision Announced by Chief Justice Whito. Take Up Solution of "Trust Question Washington, n. i\, liny in.?Presi? dent Tuft ami his Cabinet tn-inorrriiv will take lip tin- solution of the "trust question," hmughf sharply: before Ibom liy (lie Stnnrturil Oii de? cision. Art mtnl?triitlnii iiII'.cIiiIm Uncvi absolutely nothing us In hnw the Supreme Court would determine the <?ii.se, hut n decision In fiiviir irt the government nna not unlimited for especially hy the President, Atlof ne>-ticnernl Wlckcrsluim, Secretary Knut nnrt ?Iber lawyers hi Iii? <.'"?> Inet. I.nst fnll. Ions before Hie fluni nr gunifiilH In Hie eiiHe were minie, Mr. Wlckcrshuui, ?villi the approval of the President, I'riiiuert n ??l-'eilcrnl in eorporntlon lilll," desliTncd to per? mit Hie existence of legitimate c?in tiluutloiiN of eupltnl, hut su Worded ns to prohibit monopolies, ami Hltll Jeettng corporations to governuient supervision. Thnt measure vvim never presset! lu Congress, although it wits Introduced. Its rrlnt ruiluc lion In this Congress Is n possibility. The President lind nothing to nay nlinut the decision to-night. lie wished, he tolrt enllcrs, tlrst to rend It enrefully, to illseu.su It with the Cabinet ami to dissect tt with Mr. WlekcrHhnm. found this justification In the common law of the forefathers, and in the gen? eral law of thc country at the time tho Shorman anti-trust law jyss passed, In short, the court held that the tech? nical words of the statute were to be given the moaning which these wordc had In the common law, and In the law of tho country at the tlmo of the en? actment. This moaning of thc words, according to thc court, called for tho oxerclso' of reason in determlng what restraint of trade were prohibited. Chief Justice's Opinion. Chief Justice White, In his opinion, first reviewed the preliminary ptooeed Ings In the case in tho Circuit Court of the United States for the Kastern District of Missouri. Ho restated tho essential points In the bill of the gov? ernment asking for the dissolution of the Standard Oil .and tho answer ques? tioning the Jurisdiction of. the court and denying tho claims of the govern? ment. He dismissed the objection to the Jurisdiction In a few words, by holding that It was not well founded. Ho then camo to the arguments as to tho law and tho facts in the case, say? ing that out of the "Jungle" of law and facts both aides wore agreed only on one thing, and that was that the de? termination of the controversy rested upon the proper construction nnd ap? plication of the first and second sec? tions of the anti-trust act. The views of tho two sldos,- as to tha law, the Chief Justice said, were as wide apart as the poles. Tho same ho said was true ns to tho facts. "Thus, on the one hand, with relent? less pertinacity and minuteness of analysis," said tho Chief Justice, "it Is Insisted that the facts cutnbllshed that tho assailed combination took Us birth In a purpose to unlawfully ac? quire wealth by oppressing the public nnd destroying the Ju3t lights of oth? ers, and that Its ontlro career exem? plifies an Inexorable carrying out ol such wrongful Intents, since, It 1? as Bcrtcd, tho pathway of the combination from the beginning of tho tlmo of the filing of the bill Is marked with oon stant proofs of wrong inflicted upon the public, and Is strown with tha wrecks resulting from crushing out. without regard to law, tho Indlvlduui rights of others. ? ? ? Cnlled Enduring Menace. "It is asserted that the existence, of the principal eorporato defendiuit, the Standard OH Company, of New Jersey, with Its vast p.ccumulatlon of property, because of Its potency for harm and the dangorous example which Its con? tinued existence affords, Is an open and enduring menace to all freedom of trade and a byword and reproach to all modern economic, methods. "On the other hand, In a powerful analysis of tho facts. It is Insisted that they demonstrate that tho origin and development of the vast business which the defendants control was hut the re? sult of lawful competitive methods, guided by economic, genius of the high? est order, sustained by courage, by it keen Insight Into the commercial posi? tion, resulting In tho acquisition of great wealth, hut at tho fame lima .serving to stimulate nn Increased pro? duction, to widely extend the distri? bution of the products of petroleum at a cost largely below that which would otherwiso have prevailed, thiia proving to be at one and the same time a benefaction to tho general public as well as an enormous advantage to In? dividuals." Tn this state of affairs, the Chief justice seized upon the single point of concord, namoly, Ihe application of tho two section* of tho Sherman anti? trust law, as tho Initial basin of an examination of the contention. Tim rest of his opinion divided Itsulf into n consideration of tho meaning <?> th? Sherman anti-trust law In the lighter the common law and the law of the ' "(Continued ^on "Third Page.) !