Newspaper Page Text
Defense Witnesses Tell of Seeing Bearded Highwaym? by anybody to look for a second blood ' ?pot'.'" "No. air." "Had you heard about this second blood spot on Wednesday?" "I don't remember." "Hud you heurd about It on Th?rs- j flay?" "I don't remember." "Did your cousin mention It to you before you found It?" ; "No." i "Who discovered it first?" "He did" "Was ho looking for It?" |"l don't know." "Was 'it as plain ns the other big one further up the road?" "Showing as much blood ns the other?" "No, I don't think it was. The firs. 01. didn't look like It was sprinkled. kThe second did." Juror Asks Questions. " Juror Hancock spoke up with tho j first question that has come from the ' Jury bos to a witness. "Judgo, I would liko to ask the wit- \ ness a question: Could tno spot bo ? seen from each side of tho road?" "Any one going up in a wagon or ' buggy could soo it. It was Just in the middle of the road," said tho witness. "How were you traveling?" "1 was on a bicycle." Eugene Henshaw was called. His home is about one and a half miles above lion Air. .-?o you know J. C. Talley?" asked Mr. Smith "Yes." "A^-e you acquainted with his repu- : tatlon?" "Yes." "What was It?" "Pretty bad " "You mean his reputation for truth and veracity?" "Yes " Saw Man Wltb Beard. Tld you travel this Midlothian Tike Shortly before this murder?" "I go over it every day except Sun teys " "Did you see any stranger on the piKo that attracted your attention, and If so. more than once, and when and where was It?" "I think you should show some rele? vancy'."' said Mr. Wendenburg, in pro? test against the question. "Did you seo any auch stranger as I havo described on this plko within forty-eight hours previous ts the mur? der?" persisted Mr Smith. "I did see a strange looking man," answered the witness. "I mot him as I was going to Manchester about three-quurters of a mllo from Where the crime was committed about 9 o'clock A M. rte look:d strange. I thought ho was a lunatic." Mr. Wendenburg protested that the witness was not an insanity expert, and the remark was stricken out. Tho witness continued: "On Thursday I went back and didn't sec him. On Friday when 1 started home. ,1 saw him sitting down on tho roadside about 300 yards down the plko towards Manchester. He wus a man about tlfty years old. very strange looking, with a gray beard that hadn't been -.iaved for weeks, i don't trnvol the road on Sunday, but on Monday morning he was slttlnp on tho left band side of the road auout seventy or seventy-live yards from the arch on the same road nearly two miles from where the crimo was committed. I haven't seen him since that Monday morning" Every Day but Suoar. "How often do you travel that road?" "Every day except Sunday." "You saw tbla man throe limes?" "Yes." "The first time was on the Wednes? day before the aiurder?" "Yes." "And the next time was on Friday?" "Yes." {'And the next on Monday?" ?'SYeu-V VJill preceding the murder?" "Yes"-.- ? ' "He had a beard of two weeks' "Yes." "Why did you tlx upon two?" Mr Smith asked Mr. Wendenburg; "the witness hasn't said so" "He was a pretty good stout built man," persisted Mr- Smith. "Yes, he must havo weighed about 170 or I.-.Ci pounds." "How ?all was o?" "1 couldn't guess at his tallncss. He was something taller than I urn He was sitting down two of the times 1 taw him. "Had you ever seen him before?" "Since?" "Ar* you - ?well acquainted in the ilght/orhood?" rYes." Kir Wendcnburg began his cross j_jnlnaf.on with a sudden turn. K'ou are a Mormon, are you not?" K, arn a Latter Day Saint " Hb there any distinction?" HVeli. I don't know " 9& I, tified here with re g& Toiley. Have you ever had s?n ' with him?" -? m ShoHfd nitternoss. ?'. fin you lick him or did he lick DkH tried to ;..;;^H\v was it?" HVY ?'?'? ? years ago " M \ ' ? iUEi' you Insulted his "?'??'-' sw \ ' ''" something to ? against sucr. questions." Hv :.hs ,1 li.-iit to show Hn the whnoss." ruled (SmMeI colored?" ?S ^ KS ? t.e white." 5 Hi rd on about a week?" Bra veeks," ir.'.orootcd Mr fl Sat "pt*,, h,n-i" saot back Sgajjtf ^?'?'M each other." dt / HjV ' "It leads only to pbk s'e h:m on Krl ./i??^;'^- - '^?t V'lley's." - HjS? 1'ing there?" ff ?V4'L * h<trs?" 5& V .??'.-it into a yffieg9j9@I^B HlU:* Murn>' Epps. ?S^Sr'^^^ & Clements." Some of the Newspaper Reporters IVho Are Handling: fteattte Irtal Gathered In a llttlo spaco In Chcs terflold Courthouse aro no? only a round dozen newspaper men from Rich? mond, but an ovon larger number of men from the great news associations and the larger metropolitan papers. Fifteen of tho outsiders gathered yes? terday for a group photograph as a souvenir of the trial. Several men wore missing, however. The call of the wire?the exigencies ot early copy ?prevented their taking even the brief "What time did you leave Manches? ter?" "J don't know." Saw II im lu MortifiiK. "What Urne dltl you see- the man on Monday V" - "In the morning about 9 o'clock." "What time do you generally come to town with the milk'.'" "1 generally start from home about S or a little after," "Where was he when you saw him on Monday?" "About seventy-live yards from tho arch." "How far Is that from the spot of j blood?" j "About two miles west of the scene of the crime." "Where did you meet him on Wed? nesday ?" "About three-quarters of a mile west of the scene of the crime. I vAss going to town and met him. On Fri? day I saw him about 300 yards nearer to the scene than on Wednesday." "What sort of hat did he wear?" "Slouch." "Was his coat on his arm7" "Each time." "What sort of clothei7" "Dark." "Did he wear a collar?" "I don't think he did." "Which way was he going when you met him?" "The lirst time he was going west. The other two times he was sitting down besldo tho road. I don't know which way he was going then " "Who did you see when you came to town on Wednesday?" "I don't know." "Who whs the first person you told of this?" "A young follow named John Ford. He'lives at Mr. Jervross's." "Have you seen th? gun exhibited here with which the killing was done?" "Yes." "Did you see this man walking) around with that gun?" '. "This man didn't have any gun. I am sure 1 didn't see him with a gun." W. it. Holland, a quarry man, living at 1019 Floyd Avenue, and employed In a quarry on the Southern Railway Just below the Belt Line bridge on the southern shore of the river, was i sworn. "How far is the quarry from the Midlothian Turnpike?" "About u mile." "Do you remember seeing any per? son on the track of the Belt Lino sb?ui the date of this murder?" "It was not on the Bell Line?on '.lie track of the Southern." corrected the witness. "He was fciottg toward the Belt Line." "What so.'t of a man was he?" "He was Q man about live feet ten nr eleven Inches tall." "When was this"" "tin July 18, between 6:20 and 5:30 P. M." "Thai was the day of Die murder?" "Yes." . "Wh< re did you sec hiinv" ' 1 -,iw him on the Southern Railway, about one-fourth of a mils from the Belt Line." "What was he carrying?" had a single-barreled shotgun over his shoulder." "Is there anythng to hunt at this time of the year?" "Nothing that I know of?-it is not the hunting season." "What age man was he?" "I should my about thirty-eight or forty." I '"Did ho have a beard?" "lie looked like he usually wont shaved, but at the time hadn't shaved j for a week or ten days" "How large u man was he?" "He looked to me as though ho' Weighed from ISO to 175 pounds." "Would you know the man again If1 he were shown to you?" "I think I would." "What color h*lr did he havo1" ! "Sandy. I d'dY.t notice the hair ex- j cept by the C/dlor Of hi* hoard." \\'/r,- n Slouch Ifnt. "What ?ort <?! a hat was he wear-i moment the photographer required. The press associations have private wires in various outbuildings noar the courthouse. The Western Union has opened a general ofilco In the rear of a store just at iho edge of the grounds. Skilled operators aro on the ground, and a relay of messenger boys is kept going between the wire tables and the side entrance to the courthouse. When tlie Commonwealth rested Its case yes- j terday at 12:15 o'clock, the bulletin I scene of the homicide?" | "I have never been to the scene of the homicide It Is about a mile along the Belt Line from the Southern Hall? way to tho Midlothian Turnpiko; thu man was going up the rivor?going West" "Did you sec any other men around?" "Thoro was another. A brakeman on the Southern Hallway was stand? ing on the traok by mo. 1 don't know his name." Tnller Than Witness. "The man you saw with the gun was larger thai, you uro?" "Yes, taller and stouter." "Have you seen him since?" "No.' , "Before?" "Maybo once." "When was that?" "A year or so age." "He was a stranger?" "Yes." "How much do you weigh, about 132? And did you say he was taller and stouter?" "Yes." "When did you set, blm beforo?" "Ac the station house In Manches? ter. I was called to Identify some men charged with stealing railroad brass. He was there then to aid in the identification?he wae not ohurg cd with any crlmo. I thought 1 had seen him beforo." "Did you see one of your men speak to him?" "No, sir." "How long ago was It that you saw htm at the station house?" "About a year." "Who was charged with the steal? ing?" "A man named Anderson and two I others." Mr. Wendonburg strove hard to got the date of the trial In which tho two men appearod as witnesses, but the witness was uncertain whether it took place In tho magistrate's court or before tho Hustings Court, part 2. Walter C. Moore, a farmer who al? so keeps a storo on the Midolthlan Turnpike about three miles from the scene of the homlcldo. waB called. "Do you know J. C. (Sam) Talley?" ho was asked. "1 have heard of him and seen him." "What is his genera] rcputution for truth and veracity?" A sharp legal tilt followed between Messrs. Smith and Wendenburg, which at last got beyond the even temper of the judge. "Walt a minute," suld Judge Wat? son. "I don'f think that sort of thing Is proper. You gentlemen must stop." Mr. Smith stated to tho court what he had proposed to ask the witness. "That la a proper question." ruled the court. "Then the Interruption of my frlond was Improper," asserted Mr. Smith in triumph. "Thero was no occasion for the In? terruption." said the judge. The stenographer repeated the ques? tion as to whether Mr. Moore, knew of Tallcy's general reputation for truth and veracity. "I don't know of Mr. Talley except what I have heard," said Mr. Moore with hosltatlon. "That's Just what we wanr," said Mr. Smith, "not your opinion, but his genera) reputation In the community. "Well, I hear people talk at my store." said .Mr. Moo>-e. "I have heard some of them speak poorly of Mr. Talley, but I have urovo doubts of their veracity." "Who were they?" "I wouldn't like to answer that question." Took Smith by Surprise. Attorney Smith stated that the de? fense had been completely taken by surprise at tho attitude of the wit? ness with whom he had talked during tho dinner hour. "Didn't I nsk you out on the lawn what- was the general reputation of Sinn Talley." he asked, claiming his right to oross-examlno his own wit? ness. "Yes, and I told yr^^J didn't know only what I hod linu/ft?t announcing the fact was posted on the front of The Times-Dispntch office hefore 12:20. Out-of-town newspaper men and wo? men In the group picture are Mrs. A. Ii. Sperry, Washington Times; Miss Annabel Sharpe, Cleveland Leader; Charles Somervllle. New York World: Hoben Richie. New York Sun; Juan A. Moro3o. Now York Kvcnlng Journal; Davis Lawrence, the Associated press, Harry Q. Proctor, Philadelphia Bulle "1 said It was bad." "Did you suggest to me that tho source of your Information was also bad?" "You didn't ask me. I said that by hearsay It was bad. 1 don't know my? self." "Isn't it tho truth." asked Mr. Smith, "that Sam Is a little fearod In his sec? tion, and nobody wants to say any? thing against hirn?" "That Is not a proper question," said Judge Watson. "His lighting ability is not In question. It is his truth and veracity." "I am not afraid to tell you what 1 1 know," Bold the w'tness resenting the suggestion that ho was awed by Tal icy's reputation as a fighter. "1 hppo it will not bo Improper for me," said Judge Watson, to make a suggestion.. It seems to be n mis? apprehension. I have personal ac? quaintance with Mr. Moore and am quite sure ho would not intentionally misinform you." "Under those circumstances," said Mr. Smith at. once, "I accept tho alt j uatlon as an entlro misunderstanding. 1 I did think that tho witness had not treatod me Just right, but I hope I have said nothing that was offensive." "I should llko to tako this occa? sion." said Judge Watson, "to make | my acknowledgment of having spoken hastily a few moments ago to the at? torneys In thl6 case. I have received only courtosy at your hands." The at? torneys bowed their acknowledgments, and In view of the statement of tho court, Mr. Moore was excused, as he was called us a witness in reference to the character of Sam Tulley ap? parently through mistake. Wlllinm Pemberton was called and testified that ho had known J. C. (Sam) Talloy for years. "What is his general reputation for truth and veracity?" "asked Mr. Smith. "I don't know. I nover had no deal ' ings with the man." "What do people In the neighbor? hood say about him?" i "Pooplo don't talk well of him, but I don't know, as I don't have dealings with him." Tho witness went to Mr. Wonden burg for cross-examination "Didn't you live for some time with? out paying rent on land belonging to Major Walker " "Yes." "You Just squatted there?" "Yes." I "Did you raise a family of nine chil? dren there In one room?" "No; In three rooms." "Whcro do "you work?" "At Belle Isle when at work. The mill has not been running since last June." 1 "Don't you have slops sometimes?" "Yes." "You are all right mentally, aren't you?" j "I/Ook here, young man. you don't I know what you are talking about." I shouted the outraged witness. "Isn't it a fact." persisted Mr. Wen 1 denbur,?. "that when living at Major I Walker's place you chained the cats, and pictures were taken of thorn I chained?" "1 don't remember. I have had strings on them." "Don't you thresh your wheat by laying It down on the floor and all of you treading about on It?" "That's good Biblical fashion," re? marked Mr. Smith Told Lawyer He Was Crosy. "Say. man. you're crazy," replied tho witness. "I didn't come here to talk about nothing like that. You're be? ginning to cross-question me, ain't you?" Even the culm dignity of the court was shaken. The prisoner and his counsel laughed, anja the presiding judge found it convenient to pick up a paper to hide a twitching face. "Isn't it a foot." went on Mr. Wen. denburg. prompted by Mr. Scherer, who sat noxt, "that you claim to know two women who say ?hat they saw Beattlo lift his wlfets dead body into his motor car?" ) "I said Charlie Trirockmorton and Socrates told mo that) two women had I tin; James E. Bready. Washington Times; J. K. Costello, Philadelphia Evening Telegraph; Everett Ewlng. Petersburg Index-Appeal; W. B. Os norne, National News Service; Harry farllsle. New York Evening Sun; J. Q. Long, New York Globe; E. H. Sart wcll, the United Press; J. K. Walker, statt photographer New York Journal. One of tho best known of the news? paper men, J. J. O'Neill, of the New York American, missed the picture to discussed the voracity of Sam Talley?" Tho witness began a long-winded and involved account of hiring a ne? gro. "Stop, stop," said Mr. Carter. "Stop, sir, this Isn't evIdoncO," said Judge Watson, but the witness went straight on. "Stop the witness, Mr. Sheriff," call? ed the court sharply, and Sheriff Gill and Deputy Goode moved to his side. The witness subsided. "Can you give me the nnme ot any one who has discussed Mr. Talley's reputation for truthfulness?" Never Dealt with lilm. "No, I never said nothing. I never had no dealings with him. I heard Air. Hcnshaw say something; about hint once." "Do you know Roland Sydnor?" "Yes." "Did you ever hear him any anything about Sum Talley?" "He talked to a neighbor?not to me." "Didn't you hear ItT" "No. It was something about a horse trado, but 1 don't know the de? tails." "Do you know Mr. Moore?" "Yes." "Did you ever hear neorde !r. his store talk about Mr. Talley?" "I never heard Mr. Moore say any? thing." Mr. Carter objected to the form of the question. "Keep the witness quiet fo.- one min? ute," said Judge Watson. "I can't hear." The question was ruled out and the witness was excused. Deputy City Sergeant John Q. Soun? ders was called. He was In the automobile with Luther Wells. Henry and Douglas Beattie. when the conversation was had with Sum Talley. Ho hod been In the car and got out and didn't hear what Henry Beattie said, but heard Talley reply: "I hoard a shot, and heard you shouting and honking your machine, but there Is so much shoot? ing and hollering on the turnpike I didn't pay any attention to it." Did he say anything about having heard a woman scream?" "That was all." "You would have heard If he had said It?" "Yes, If I was there," "Do you know whether anything Is tasty and wholesome and it is made under absolutely sanitary con? ditions. Baking good Bread has been our business in Richmond for fifty years. We're proud of the fact without undue boast? ing, that in all these years we've been leaders in our own line. We've always used the best materials, the latest appliances, and employed people that "know how." Photos by W> \V. Foster. talk to hl* office on the wire Virginia newspaper men who have spent several (lays at tho trial were J. L. Lindsay, of the Charlottesvllle Progress, and Walter Scott Cop< land, of the Newport News Times-Herald. A number of other men have come and gone from day to day representing the New York Herald, the Washington Post, and a half dozen other papers. Magazine men and photographers for Illustrated weeklies have been on tho ground. was said when you were not there as to the shot and noises?" "I do not. When I aaw them talk? ing Mr. Heuttlc was talking and I didn't hear him." "Are you acquainted with the gon oral reputation of Henry C. Benttle Jr., for truth and voracity In tho neighborhood in which he resides?" "Yes, It is of tho best." "What is his reputation for pence ami good order, kindliness and affec? tionate disposition?" "So for as 1 know, good." "Do you know anything about Sar.l Talley ?" "I do not." Luthor Wells was recalled and told of being In the car with Henry Owen. John Saundero, Henry and Douglas Seattle on the morning after tho shooting, when they had a conversa I tlon with Sam Talley. Henry asked Talloy If he lived In the neighbor? hood. Talley pointed to a house In the woods as his ho.-r.c. Henry said: "You must have heard the shot." Tal? ley said: "Yes." Henry said: "You must havo heard mo holler and the auto horn." Talley Bald yes, he heard tho holler and the horn. "Did he say anything about hearing a woman scream"*" "I didn't hear him." "You would have heard him If he had said it?" "Yes." ( "What reason did Talley give for not Investigating?" "Ho said he never paid any atten? tion to tho noise. He thought It was a crowd of negroes going along the road hollering and shooting." "Did he aay anything about negro women screaming?" "I don't think so." Judge Watson asked: "Did Mr. Talley say anything about the order of the hollering, tl o gun shot and the horn?" "No. sir. He didn't say how they followed, but tho order in which he mentioned them was gun shot, holler? ing and horn." Did Not Pass Benttle. William Galnes, colored, said he vas on the Midlothian Pike the even? ing preceding the murder with an? other negro. Dr. Blackwell, starting from Manchester In a buggy. They went .up to within one block of tho Belt Lino crossing, turned around, and came back. Two or three automo? biles passed them. "Do you know Henry C. Beattlo?" "Yes, I know him." "Did ho pass you In a mdtor car?" "Not to my knowing of. If I had seen him I would have known him. but I wasn't paying attention to who was passing." Herbert Richardson, a chauffeur for tho Poster Motor Company, was sworn. "Have you ever been hold up In Chesterfield county," asked Mr. Smith, "ijcar Manchester, or within a few miles, hy a man with a shotgun, and, If so. state whoro and when and under whnt circumstances?" "We object," said Mr. Wendenburg. i "We propose," said Mr. Smith, "to: prove that it Is not unusual for auto-, mobiles to be held up." "And women killed?" supplemented Mr. Wendenburg. "That's your theory'." said Mr. Smith. "I will bo frank to state to the court," said Mr. Smith, "that wo can? not bring this Inoldent closer than a year or within several miles of tho spot We do not even propose to Show that it was the same man, but merely to show that thero Is a prejudice and animosity against motor cars, and that tlmn nnd time again cars havo beon held up and shot at with women in them." "Will there be several such in? stances?" asked the court. "I expected to bring another chauf? feur here," said Mr. Smith, "but I find that ho is dead. I expect to show at least three such Instances." "The counsel are familiar with re? cent rulings In England." said Judge Watson. "You can present evidence to show that the highways are beset tvlth dangerous characters, but unless enough Instances are presented to al ?hMialfte JUT t0 term a conclusion on jj?i?J^hjeot ths ooutr will rulo man?" asked Judge Gregory. "I think you would bo on| show in roply that it was occurrence." Itullna; by Court. "You cannot convict one mat crime of another," said Mr. burg. "We cannot convict thf of having hilled his wife becaus mon have killed their wives. IJ It as irrelevant. The particular different. The chauffeur may case have angered the mat* or 1 cause for provocation.' "If sufficient Incidents are pre| to show that tho highways county nre beset and lifo cndal it Is evidence, otherwise not,"| the court "We do not Intend " said Mr. to show that the same man he!] automobiles In other instances, ably they were different men." "It is not a questljn of Idenff ruled tho court, "it Is merely a possible motive on tho other person tha? bar. The <iui to the identltl mit ted a mu| poses to shov on the part "Wo object vant," satd Mrl Mr. Smith r>!\ tlie witness: "Have you heil "Yes. on .the this side of the lng Creek, betws ot night last sut.| "Was It dark: "Yes, sir." "Held up with fr\ "Yes. sir." "Who was In the I "Two other younl "Who stopped Hli(Uwa>mun U "A man stood In road and forced us out and took his nun away from ll end took the shells out of the gun a| threw them away " "Where were you going?" "Mr. Carroll Montague's car broken down and I w"s K"tng to fix Mr. Lyons and two ladles were w'| him. We made the highwaymar in our car and took him abou' miles, then we threw the cartridf away. He got out and we gavt his gwn back." "You didn't have him arrested! "No." "Did vou look on It as a Jc "We took It pretty serlouslj "Why didn't you turn him j an officer when you had him disj In your car?" ??We hud this other car to knew there were ladles In t" car and didn't want to scare ??What happen-d coming ba<] "We came by as fast as W The two ladies got down In and wu ran by about thirty hour." Carrol; Montague, of Ly< taguu, was called. "Do you remember on occt young men coming to your held up?" he was assicd. "Yes, I remember It dlf was in July a year ago. bringing me gasolene from Motor Company In a relief! "WSTe the yoyng men| when they came or wcrs and scared?" Kneed by llnuger "I wasn't tbtre when thi I had gono to Chester IJ When I returned In consell Information I received fl took the precaution to hi *nd my partner's wife lies bottom of the car and I rl as I could by what I ha<lr was the danger point." "How fast?" "About forty-five or hour." "Do you know of youj edge" whether Lewis was once held up?" "No." "How far was It frol the Midlothian turnpllj blood was foVlnd to the r tersburg Turnpike polr as tho danger spot?" Gregory. "About thirteen or fourteen miles. "Have you seen the Beattlo machln ?hown to the Jury the other day?" "Yes. I have seen lt. I did not ex amlne It closely." "You are experienced with auto mobiles?" "Yes. somewhat so. I lave two." "You are familiar with the Bulok?' "I have driven one Tor a time." "Is it a rough cur with a lir '?? weight on the back seat?" "Yes, that model Is not as easy rid lng as the more modern Buick can which have ellpttcal springs." Mr. Montague was closely questions os an expert on the bouncing qualltlo of the Bulck car. He thought I would bounce more when light thai when weighted down. The wltnes knew the Belt Line crossing of tn Midlothian Road, and aai<! that " swerving far to one side a car wouj get a sharp bounce. ."Did you notice the first clear t| not covered with dirt?" ? , "Yes." / "How far was It from the road' "N'ot more than five feet from edge of the road." "Do you think It unreasonable unnatural for a gun to bounce t{ far from a car with no doors?" Question of Bumps. "No. If a gun dropped from n mov| car on one en<i tho momentum throw I: at least five feet." "Would you consider it or unreasonable If it had gci that distance." "No. From a car run* miles an hour an object tnf fifteen feet or more." "Don't you think," asked denburg, "that because of tt turn the object would bounce direction the car was going? "It depends on how It struct momentum wotild carry it for! a certain extent." J. Preston Carson, one of In Mr. Montague's car the n$ relief party claims to have 1 up, had little to add to the he left the party before the was reported. Mr Carson sale with Mr. Montague and Attorn| Smith, Jr. on last Sunday i nt the Bolt line crossing of asked REMOVING HER (From the Feminine We The quickest and surest way a good complexion out,of a to actually remove thG thlr faded or discolored outer the face. This can be dor safely and privately by The process Is one of gi vj.l<] tlon. Get nn ounce of pure wax from your druggist and at night like cold cream,., wa^ off In the morning. In- a the mcrcoljde In tho wax absorbed the disfiguring ci veallng the fresh young neath; you will have a bj natural complexion. Tl pleasant and harmless, face look brilliantly atl youthful. It also effectual such blemishes as freoklett patches, liver spots, Kvery woman should keep coiizod wax on hand, ,as ?W-fA3h!or.ev'jcmedyjjlil tt