Newspaper Page Text
2 The honor was Indeed thrust upon l me, contrary to my own will. Now, how ever, I am a candidate and desire to be elected. And I promise you that If elect ed my office shall not be a political one. (Applause.) It shall not be a home for broken-down politicians or broken down lawyers. "It Is now my pleasure and' honor to Introduce the next governor of Califor nia—a man who can speak for himself, and has no need of employing anyone else to make his speeches for him. (Great applause.) The Hon. James G. Magulre." As the "Little G'lant" stepped to the front of the platform the Immense au dience rose and cheered themselves hoarse, while the ladles waved their handkerchiefs, and for several minutes a scene of intense enthusiasm prevailed. Mr. Maguire's speech was as follows: The Opening Gun Ladles and Gentlemen—l am pleased to meet this second sreat gathering of citizens of Los AiiKeles. and to witness tfie Interest which you, in common with your fellow citizens of the state in every county through which I have traveled in the pres ent campaign, show in the issues for which we are contending. * The chairman has called attention to the occupation of my early life, and the com mittee has brought an emblem of the trade which I learned when a boy. I was raised on a farm ln Santa Ortiz county, and after leaving school my father determined that lt would be well for me to le.trn a trade. It was rather against my own opinion of what ought to be done at that time. I served my apprenticeship, became a Jour neyman, worked for six weeks at the trade and left tt for a profession which I must say I rather like better, but 1 have never in all my life since doubted the wis dom of my father's choice. I am proud to have been raised among the people as one of them in the occupation cf farming, the fundamental occupation of God's people (applause), and to have learned a trade, and from association and sharing In the hopes and fears and aspi rations of my fellow craftsmen to have had Imbedded In my soul a sympathy for the struggling, tolling masses of my coun try. (Applause.) I have never lost my love for their fellowship nor my sympa thy for them in their trials, and in every station to which I have risen since that time one of my chief alms has ever been to try to better their condition and to widen the opportunities for their happi ness and for their advancement. (Ap plause.) Lincoln and Jefferson It taught me, too, perhaps more fully than I might ever otherwise have learned, the truth and Justice of the fundamental principles of Jeffersonlan Democracy, that In rights all men are equal; that spe cial privilege Is an injustice; that a privi leged class cannot co-exist safely with free Institutions; that the danger to free Institutions, the danger to the republic, is the growth of special privileges; that equal rlghis to all. special privileges to none, is the Very safety of free institutions, as It Is the foundation of true Democracy. (Ap plause.) Tonight I witnessed a see.no that was very Impressive. 1 saw a body of colored fellow citizens enter this hall with a ban ner proclaiming themselves to be Lincoln Republicans not Hanna R< publicans. (Applause.) There is a mighty meaning ln the contrast presented by that simple motto The Republicanism of Lincoln was nlmost identical with the Democracy of Jefferson. (Applause.) Jefferson believed ln the people and insisted that ultimate power should always rest with the peo ple; that the peoplo should control their Institutions: that equality of rights was not only Just, but the only just condition which could exist. In a republic. Abraham Lincoln taught in his World-famed and Immortal Gettysburg speech that he. too. believed in the people. His memorahle declaration that he stood for a govern ment of the people by the people and for the people placed him with Jefferson; and the followers of Jefferson and the follow ers of Abraham Lincoln are today united In the reform parties that are contending for a government of the people by the peo ple and for the people. (Applause.) Hanna Republicanism What 1s Hanna Republicanism? (A voice: Rot.) Marcus A. Hanna represents more truly than any man who has ever reared his head In the public affairs of this country the domination of centralised and concentrated wealth. His faith is not in men but In money: his belief Is not ln a government of the people by the peo ple and for the people, but In a govern ment of monopoly for monopoly end by monopoly. (Applause.) The difference Is marked and on these very lines the people of this country are di vided today. The representatives of monop oly are aggressive .bold and confident, have thrown down the gauntlet to the masses of the people. The Republican candidate for congress In this district, who In on unfortunate phrase or sentence, defined his view of the character of this union and of the people, who compose It, was not merely giving forth an accidental or spon taneous thought. S Among the modern representatives • S of the Republican party opposition to • S monopoly Is not regarded as respects- • S bio. Opposition to monopoly is to • S them aherchy. Tt Is hostile'to what c c they understand to be the most per. * c fc-ct social organization, with a class • c controlling society, nnd the masses c c of the people hewers of wood and c c drawers of water for thoso enjoying c S special privileges. (Applause.) o Special Privileges to None Tho fight that Is on today Is but a new development of tho old fight against the ddvlne right of kings, and the superiority of privileged classes, who ruled by virtue of birth and family station. The founders and fathers of our republic relegated theso claims to tho continents of Europe and. Asia, when they dedicated this land to freedom, to equal rights, to Justice, to popular sovereignty. Thomas Jefferson warned tho people of this country that the power nominally stricken down by the success of the American revolution, would insidiously advance ami stealthily gain puhllc power, public authority, and use ft against the people, unless by eternal vigi lance the people should guard against its encroachments. (Applause.) The people of this country have been too confident that mere popular suffrage, universal suffrage, the sheet anchor nnd safety of our Institutions, made our Insti tutions automatically safe, nnd that the government would always run Itself safe- ly. While they have been divided In pur pose, while they have been unheeding of danger, keen, intelligent, unscrupulous rcpri-sentatlves of the new aristocracy, the oligarchy of wealth, have been working their way to dominion, working their way ■ o power, concentrating theCr power, and at last have come to feel that with those who arc dependent upon them, more or less under rheir control, though I believe not so much under their control as thoy think (applause), with the masses of the people ever divided on collateral and com paratively Insignificant questions, they mlKht. by keeping the people divided, dom inate their interests and exercise the pub lic powers given them to their unlimited enrichment and the corresponding oppres sion of the masses. Majority Must Rule We have accepted the challenge. Wenp peal to the masses of the people today to rise up, not In violent opposition—the turn for that passed with the foundation o! this great republic. (Applause.) It Is n< longer necessary for men lv our eountrs who are oppressed to resort to violence ir order to secure their rights. While the; remain in the minority they have no right to rule. As soon as their demand for Just- Ice shall bring to them a majority they have no need for violence to establish their rights. (Applause.) Gradually and through the course of years the oppressed cried out variously against various things, which to each seemed to be the cause of his oppression—of his unhnppl ncss. Discordant voices cried out foi different and often antagonistic rellefF Their want of clear knowledge divided them. At last thoy were united. They are uniting and their common cry, the cry that rallies the forces of reform today nnd that strikes terror into rhe beneficiaries and supporters of special privilege. Is tho cry of the union forces, "Give us Justice; we arp men." (Applause.) We want justice, equal rights, the aboli tion, the extirpation of special privilege or Its subordination to legal control. Southern Pacific Barnes It has been my custom to proceed to dis cuss the issues of the campaign affirma tively, but as I have spoken here recently, covering many of the Issues, perhaps 1 may as well take up the Issues tonight aa they have bee n discussed by our opponents, replying to their arguments and crlticls and at the same lime presenting affirma tively our own position. Until a week ago last Saturday night we had under stood that the keynote for the Republican campaign had ben given forth ln a speech delivered by my distinguished opponent in this hall some ten days before. Many of you doubtless heard that speech. We Were answering It as best we could, when, suddenly, a few days ago, we were ad vised through the leading Republican pa- pers that a new keynote was to be- sound ed. It seems that the» old keynote did not suit. c By whom was the keynote to c c bo sounded? Why, by Gen. W. H. L. c c Barnes, a great, able and distln- c c gulehed lawyer; a man whom, person- c c ally. I like and admire. I have no c c criticism to pass upon the choice of o * him as the leader of the Republican c 0 campaign, if it was determined in ad- c o vence that the campaign, was to be c c led by an attorney of the Southern • O Pacific (Cheers.) Ho is most cer- a c talnly the ablest and most eloquent * LOS ANGELES HERALD: TUESDAY MORNING. SEPTEMBER 27, 1898 c of all the regular attorneys of that c c company. (Applause.) c The first keynote which was sounded here by my distinguished opponent was | very like a G sharp. The new keynote was very much like alt flat. My dlsitjin guished opponent at Ventura, on Friday evening, stated that we might wait for a third keynote, and it came to us this morning in a speech by Morris M. Bister, the distinguished candidate of the Repub lican party for governor In the last cam paign. The Railroad in Politics Gen. Barnes, who struck the second key note, hay been going over the state pooh poohing the railroad issue in the campaign. Why shouldn't he? llow could he lead a Campaign If he didn't get that Issue out of tho way? (Laughter.) flow could Judge Carpenter make speeches If the railroad question was in issue? tlen. Barnes critl isos us very severely for dragging the railroad question into the present contest. He Is a little unfortunate In having his position so thoroughly overthrown by what the railroad company Itself has been doing and declaring. A few weeks atro. just after the adoption of the Democratic state ■ platform, the livening Tost of San Francisco, a news paper owned by tho Southern Pacific, nnd edited by its agents, declared that because jf certain planks In that platform the Southern Pacific company would be obliged :o remain In polities for the present cam paign. It was too bad that they were not emitted to exerclso their choice and foi- low their earnest desire Jo get out of poll tics. But I fear that if the popular inter ests represented by those plnnks hnd been ignored (nnd they should not have been ignored) the Southern Pacific company would still have been In politics. It has been assuring us for twenty years that It was out of politics, but lt never has been. In addition to General Barnes, other Re publican speakers have been going about over the state declaring that the Southern Pacific was not in polities: that the issues concerning the relations of the. railroad to the people were dead Issues. Mr. Estee, an honest man. n good man, n personal friend of mine of twenty-five years' standing, a man whom t honor as a man, but whose political judgment I doubt very seriously because, notwith standing the statements that he unequivo cally makes ln a speech, he remnins in the campaign ns a suppovter of the railroad ticket. Lot us sec how Estee answers General Barnes on this question. Estee's Speech Dissected Mr. Estee Is willing to contend for what he calls Republican principles, willing to contend for the election of the Republican ticket on other grounds, but be Is not will ing to go over this state saying that the railroad question Is not a burning issue. He is net willing to go over this state say ing that the railroad company Is out cf polities. I will read from the report of Mr. F.stee's speech delivered in San Francisco on Saturday evening last, as reported In the San Francisco Call, a leading Repub lican newspaper on Sunday, September 35th. The report from which I read pur ports to be a full stenographic report of the speech: "It is known," says Mr. Kstee, "to every public man, Democrat or Re publican, that the Southern Pacific Railroad company has for many years tried to control the polities of this state. Its vast influence and unlimited capital is used in politics full as much as in business. It places money ahead of men. and its own greed In advance, of public morals. If this thing Is longer permitted to continue It will Imperil alike the rights of liberty and prop erty. It Is a menace fo the republic and good men of ai! parties should unite ln defeating Its Influence." (Applause.) Now that Is an exact statement of our opinions, nnd that Is what we have done. (Applause.) Why doesn't Mr. Estee bring his party Into our combination against that monopoly dominion and make the opposl- THE CLUBS MARCHING TO MAGUIRE'S HEADUARTERS Lion unanimous? (Applause.) But that wai not all he said on this question. Continuing ho says: "The political power of the Southern Pacific railroad corporation Increases as new and additional favor* are ex tended to lt. 'With all Its railroad mileage and Its vast business Interests it is a political machine. It Is a power within the government greater than the government itself. It Is now entering upon both state and national politics." A Vast Political Machine How is it er terlng? With whom Is It en tering? What represents lt ln state poll tics? Behind what party does It stand In state politics, which/ It Is unquestionably entering, as Mr. Kstee says? He proceeds: it Is now entering upon bothststesnd national politics amy all parries should unltu In opposition to Its nefarious boss rule. It aspires to elect United States senators and) congressmen. So open are Its acts that disinterested people attending political conventions intui tively ask "How does the railroad com pany like the ticket?" (That question was not necessary after the nomination of the Republican ticket.) (Applause.) "rather than 'how are the people pleased with it?' " Candidates for of fice look furtively up, tq: the; yellow building. Do you know what the yellow building is? The yellow building is the Southern Pacific building at the comer of Market md Montgomery streets ln San Fran cisco, the political asPwell as the business headquarters of the Southern Pacific com pany. Candidates for office look furtively up to the yellow building and wonder whether they will be beaten or elected. If it Is for Qstge lt Is because it hates some one else more. (Applause.) If for Magulre, because lt prefers Magulre for governor rather than for congress man or for senator. In any event its friendship or enmity is controlled by self-interests. He who will do the most for the railroad will gain Its support, and the last and best bidder gets the office. (A voice: "And the whistle") The whistle, my friend, goes with the of fice, or rather with the nomination for the office. "The Fight Is On" "The fight Is on. Let Republicans lire up for the great contest." (Laughter.) Now I would like to know where he wants them to line up for a contest of that kind. They had better line up under the Silver Republican banner If they are going to line up on the side of the people. (Applause.) "The light Is on. Let Republicans line up for the great contest. Tou cannot serve the Lord and please the devil at the same time." (Laughter.) That seems to be what Brother Estee Is trying to do .though. I am inclined to think that instead of serv ing the Lord and pleasing the devil, he Is putting himself ln the attltudo of serving the devil and trying to serve the Lord (Laughter and applause) ln this particular matter. "You must choose sides," he con cludes. How Mr. Estee, after making that speech—and lt certainly represents his hon est convictions and his honest sentiments— oould get behind the Republican ticket ln the present campaign Is a thlrrg that amazes and puzzles me. (A voice: "He changed on the silver question suddenly.") Yes, he charged his position from being a leading advocate ot silver In 189t and down to the meeting of the Republican state convention ln ISM, and then went over to gold standard, but he says now ln Jus tification of that course that the silver question Is dead. Mr. Barnes says It Is dead, Mr. Gage says lt Is dead. But if lt were not, Mr. Gage says he is for the gold standard anyhow, so it does not make any difference whether the silver question is dead or not. (Laughter and applause.) But I cannot ente-r tonight into a discus sion of the money question. I dealt with that question very largely ln my last ad dress here. General names' second keynote ot tha campaign of WuMjJi I have spoken fills some twelve columns of the Son. Francisco Call. I read the first six columns without discovering anything that seemed to me to even remotely touch upon the real Issues of the campaign, and it seemed to me from the reading of the speech and consid ering lt as a keynote to guide the Repub lican speakers In the campaign, that the purpose was to try to evade the Issues and to go through the campaign seeking success upon entirely Irrelevant ques tions. The first part of his speech Is a very beautiful, rhetorical and oratorical essay on the war with Spain. At the conclusion of his essay on that subject he draws tho conclusion that because this country had a war with Spain, which is over, therefore the Republican party Is irr its atom? on the domestic Issue now before the peo ple (Laughter); therefore the Republican party ought to succeed In the present cam paign. I really cannot see any logical connection between his major premise nnd his con clusion. I studied logic a little when I wns a boy, and one of the things that the books and the teachers condemned was a syllo gism with an ambiguous middle. General Barnes' syllogism, which commences with the major premise that there was a war with Spain and ends with the conclusion —"ergo: The Republican, state ticket should be elected ln California this year." must be a conclusion drawn from an am biguous or Irrelevant middle ln his syllo gism, for certainly tho syllogism as It presents Itself to me, could have no such conclusion. Sectionalism Is Dead 1 had OCCSStcn when I last spoke here to call attention to the evident intent cf the Republican party to try again to draw sec tional lines; tc wipe out the glorious bene fit that came to our country from the ce menting cf north and south and east and west in common bends of fr.iternal patriotism through the mlng'.ing indiscrim inately cf the blood of their sons nn all the battlefields of the*wnr and tho leudershp of our forces for our flag and our country by gallant soldiers who in the civil war wore the blue and the gray, and by as gal lant leaders like old Joe Wheo.ier\who in the civil strife wore the gray tPrc ! longed applause), and It seems to me that my prediction has beer, verified, that for partisan purposes for mere personal advantage, cr tor tem porary ends, there are men in our country wtii are willirg again to draw invidious lines between cur people; to revive the old and burled prejudices and heartburnings (Bat for more than a generation followed the civil war. They arcr all burled; they are all hurled beneath the glerious wreaths of honor and sacrifice furnished by the people of all sections and of all parties on the fields :f Santiago, Guatanamo and Manila and on the decks of our warships during the re cent armed conflict. •fr These sectional issues cannot he re- »fr •fr vived. and I believe that the peo- -fr ■fr pie are more ready to rebuke than to + .fr accept any Pharasalo.il claim cf su- .fr •fr perlor patriotism on the part cf any + •fr party or of any section. Our people >fr •fr are all patriotic, regardless cf party. -fr •fr and domestic issues shall not be + •fr clouded, shall not be Obscured ncr the .fr •fr people deceived by any appeal to pre- -fr •fr judlce or by any clnim of superior -fr •fr patriotism on the part of any party, .fr •fr (Applause.) .fr A Common Heritage The gl°rles of the war constitute our common heritage. But all was net glory in the conduct cf the war. There was in the conduct -f the war much that we cannot call glorious. More of the gallant sons of our country died of neglect in the camps of peace thm perished on the lields of battle, Including all the battles cf the war and including the • AMUSEMENTS «Tk rnhaiim TONIGHT— Los Angeles' Society Vaudeville Theater. ■ ■rifllCUni k« -Fetched and Famous Stars from Vaudeville's Topmost Plnnaelaa. "— row-ZOONMN Arabs—7. lIAHBAN BEN ALl'B Oraatast Novelty, SOW ARD v. FAVOR and Kill 11, SINCLAIR, character comedy sketches. HINES and RKMINOTOM, ln th* "Road Queen." Ore wlioimlng success of tua operatic atara. SIGNOR PASQUALI, tenor; oIGNORA l-AKjCALI. soprano; bIGNOR ABKAMOFF. baaso. CHAB. KARON, introducing the mat danes. CARPOs BROS., tho (lad latorial gymnasts. Petite IRENE FRANKLIN. MR. BARNEY FAUAN and MISS HENRIETTA BYRON; hear Mr. Fagan slug for the first lime his latest sona, 'Hold Pern Pbilinplnaa. MoKtnley " Come to the Matlneo Tomorrow and get a SOUVENIR PHOTOGRAPH of that FAMOUS '>KWRY MATINEE API'IENCK FKKE You were In It. £anta Catallna Island at.. HOURS RIDE FROM LOS ANOKLES. The Greatest Resort, the Loveliest Basses of the year HOTEL MEfROPOLE Reduced Rates. Tito Beat Golf Unka. Phenomenal Flshlag and Hunting The Great Stage Ride. The Famed Marine Gardeaa, Glaaa Bottom Boats, eto. Unique, exclusive attraotlona. Round trip dally from Los Angeles. SUNDAY EXCURSIONS, Three hours oaths Island. See railroad time tables. For lull Information, illustrated pamphrcts and rates, apply to ITot - M " n SSanniny Company, g jg&gg |{ night's Templar Limited to Pittsburgh jCeauing jCos Jtngelos October S AT 1:10 p *»■ The CALIFORNIA LIMITED Equipment of the SANTA FE, including Dining Car, Barber Shop, Composite Car, will run through on a fast schedule. Only a «*o / Q/t limited number of berths left. Round trip rate *PO/» £?(/ Limit for return 60 days. See about it at 200 SOUTH SPRING ST. plater Schedule—Terminal Railway, Sept. 28 *f» . /} For San Pedro, Long Beach, Terminal Island—B:4o am, limine -J. nfr DO l:»s v m.. ;.:IS p.m. Sundaya, 8:4 j a m., 10:8* a.m., 1:35 XSSUt/t* caWCrMtver p m ~,: ISp. m - Saturdays only, 11:80 pm. For Catallna —8:10 a.m., dally. Only route giving first choice stenmcr accommodations. FOR PASADENA—7:O3 a-ra., 8:30 a.m., 12:20 p.m , i::»p.ra., 5:20 p.m., dally. FOR OLiNDALE-7:04 a.m., 1:3.1 p m., 4:25 p.m.. weekdays. Sundays, 7:M a.m., .1:25 p.m. CITY TICKET OFFICE, 230 SOUTH SPRING STREET Deduced Rates to Pittsburg Z&%k H Stfsh a,>ii ' n f-r\ f> Los Angeles Ticket Office OOUthorn J"aCiftC CO. 229 South Spring St. as ■ n . n l filunmnss Newly (Hied aud newly furnished throughout. Free baths. HOIBI SJICIIIIIVMC Artificial heat. Take oara at door lor depots and all points *■ M hi nuere.t 131',i Moiuli llroailwsy. destruction of the Maine and her gnllan* crew. Somebody Is responsible for this. But we have made no partisan claim based upon that chapter of negligence and In competency. The Republicans ought to bo very willing, as we permit that scandal o* tho war to remain the common sorrow cf our whole people, to let tho glory of the war remain the common heritage of all. And let me say here I do not know wno was responsible for the neglect cf our sol diers, and therefore 1 do not attempt to place the blame; I do not attempt to pass Judgment upon the secretary cf war. But this I de know, that Republicans, Populists, Silver Repub l.cans, without any distinction as to party made ample appropriations for all the pur poses of the war and placed those appro priations under the control of the present Republican administration. Here let me say that the statement of my opponent that I had voted against any of such bills is an error, based, I huvo no doubt, upon misin formation. lt may be that the fault does not lie with the secretary of war. He say* it lies wdth the officers below him. They point to each other ln succession, shifting responsibility. Judge, the leading Republican conrlc pa per of the Union, caricaturing this shifting of responsibility ln a recent Issue has a long lino commencing with the secretary of war and ending wdth tho army mule, all trying to shift the responsibility and the mule stolidly bearing lt. (Laughter and applause.) If, then, they olalm credit for what the soldiers and sailors did, not am partisans but as Americans, they must accept re sponsibility for what those who neg!octe<l the soldiers havo done nnd left undone. I do not ask that they accept even tho lat ter, but 1 say to them that they have much loss claim to the former than they have responsibility for the latter. (Applause.) If the responsibility were placed U|>oni them for tho neglect of our soldiers and for their suffering and death, they could expect. Instead of eredlfaml election, only repudiation and utter defeat. (Applause.) But I do not ask that. I ask that they put tho war. Its glories and Its scandal aside as a matter common to all the people, re gardless of party, and let us discuss the ■ lomesitlc issues to which the people have now turnel their minds. (Applause.) Barnes' Platform Criticisms The next three columns of (Sen. Barnes' opening speech are devoted to an essay on the South Sea Islands, apparently taken very largely from the travels of Captain Cook and the "Cruise o." the Challenger," liased upon those, at least doubtful, sources of Information, tho general tells us that he Is prepared to say now what are tthe interests of our country in the mat ter; that he has determined Infallibly where our country's interests He. He condemns the platform of the Democratic party of California on that question be cause It leaves the matter open to be de termined when Investigation shall put us in possession of all the facts and of all the conditions necessary to make an intelligent determination of the question. Let him not condemn the platform. Let him remember, If he has forgotten it, or learn it if he does not know it. that the Democratic! platform on that subject was simply a tacit approval of the course tak en by the present Republican president of the United States on that question. (Applause.) I 'happened) to be in Sacra- To Cure a Cold In One Itay Take Laxative Bromo Quinine Tablets. AH druggists refund the money If lt fails to cure. 250. The genuine has L. B. Q. on each tablet. mento at the time of tho drawing ofitha Democratic platform and the sub-com mittee having that matter ln charge asked my view concerning lt. I said then, and I say now. President McKlnley took the only course that ln my opinion was possible to be taken safely at the time; thai we were almost abso lutely without Information; that the In formation we hadrwas so meager, so doubt ful as to Its accairacy, that lt would be folly, worse than folly, for the President to attempt to take a definite and final course without getting full Information on the subject. That was his decision, and for that purpose he held those questions open. I said then, as I say now, that for my part I would never consent to have a Republican president or any other Re publican officer criticised or condemned for having done what I would have done had I been ln his place. (Applause.) Let the general then contend with the president of the United Staites, his own president— perhaps not his own president, because I think he Is representing an organized force outsldo of the Republican party more than he Is the Republican party ln this cam paign. (Applause.) So much for that question. The Funding Bill j On the Pacific railroad question Gen. Barnes and the Republican party platform both declare that the matter was settled by the present congress at Its laept session. The Republican pla/form declares that a bill for the enforcement and collection of the debt was passed. I discussed that matter somewhat though rather Indefinite ly here before. But I say now that the bill passed Is not for the enforcement of tho debt at all. It Is merely a measure delaying foreclosure for a year with a view to presenting a proposition for settlement to the Central Pacific Railroad company, to Huntington and his associates, who are ln control, and they have a right to accept or reject the proposition as they please. That Is not a bill for the settlement and collection of the debt. The Republican, platform evades that question entirely. My distinguished opponent, commenting upon my former speech here, made a very seirlous accusation against me. He said In this hall that I was largely responsible for tho passage of the blllof which I speak. Ho said ln this presence that my reputa tion rested largely upon my fight ln con gress against the funding bill. He ex plained, and very property, that he had never had an opportunity to vote against the funding bill, but he sold that when that measure came up, if Judge Magulre had simply stood up In the house of repre isentatlves and said. "Mr. Chairman, I oWeet to the consideration of that bill," it never could have been considered. He is reported stenographioally to that effect, and I understand tha>t was his language here. If that be trues then, I displayed either great Ignorance of my duty ln con gress or great carelessness in executing It. If he Is not right somebody has deceived him lnbo a very unfortunate position, for no man occupying his posttlon should make a charge of that kind against his opponent unless ho Is very certain about his facts. Gage's Bad Break Now lot us soe. What was the proposi tion as lt f ime to the house? The funding measure had peon Incorporated by the sen ate In a general deficiency bill and was a part of that bill when lt came back to the house. His Idea is that if I had arisen ln the house and simply said: "Mr. Chairman, I object to the consideration of that bill," It never could have been considered. The deficiency bill of which the funding mea sure had been made a part by the senate, cnrrled two hundred and twenty million dollars appropriation for the support of the army and navy in the war with Spain, In time of actual war. Now, his idea Is that If I had arisen In my pta.ee and simply said, "Mr. Chairman, I object to the considera tion of that bill," that the other three hun dred and fifty-nine representatives, and delegates ln congress would have been obliged to fold their hands, open their mouths and look at each other In perfeot helplessness and say: "Too bad, too bad, the war with Spain must stop. We can't make any appropriations for the army and navy. We can't even appropriate money enough for transports to take our soldiers back from the positions of danger to which we have sent them, because that fellow from California, Mr. Magulre, ob jects." (Applause.) Now the house of rep resentatives Is not such an Imbecile body as that. Whatever may be said against It, It Is not a body of fools. It Is not helpless In such an emergency. If fifty, If a hun dred objections to the consideration of that bill had been made. lt would not have taken twenty minutes to "dispose of them all, by a rule from the committee on rules, de signed by a general rule of the house to prevent obstruction ln such coses. Somebody deceived my distinguished op ponent In that matter, nnd somebody should have told him that It was a mistake, r think lt was unkind of my friend, en- Governor Markham, and Mr. MeT.aehlan, both of whom have served ln congress, to sit behind him and let him make a state ment of that kind without correcting him. (Applause.) A Reporter's Blunder My distinguished opponent. In oonneo*