Newspaper Page Text
All the News voi,. xxxv. ni'muf.k 21s PRICE: S£r ca,To iSJK 40 CENTS HENEY USES 'IMMUNITY BATH' TO OBTAIN TESTIMONY AGAINST RUEF FLEET AT MONTEREY BATTLESHIPS ARE NEARING SAN FRANCISCO MAGNIFICENT NAVAL PAGEANT ARRANGED Forty-ilx War Vessels Will Enter Bay City Harbor to Pass In Review Before Secretary Metcalf By Associated Preaa. MONTEREY, May I.—The Atlantic flcvt of battleships sailed tn here today to give the Monterey peninsula of Cal ifornia a place in the history of the American navy's record-breaking cruise around the world. The residents of Monterey and Pa cific Grov« and all the other settle ments of the near vicinity made the occasion of the arrival a holiday. They lined the water front when the fleet dropped anchor at 6 o'clock this morn ing, and lingered long to view the mag nificent marine spectacle of the sixteen ships drawn up In divisional formation —four lines of four ships each, with the flagships Connecticut, Georgia. Alabama anil Missouri at the head of each column. Throughout the day the streets and the decks of the battleships were thronged with visitors. A gale which swept away the heavy clouds of the anchoring hour and transformed the usually placid waters of the bay into a choppy sea did not deter the hun dreds upon hundreds who desired to see the ships at close range. The HUe power launches used by the excursionists bobbed about in lively fashion, and the wind-blown spray of the breaking waves sent many of the visitors home thoroughly wet, but did not mar their enjoyment of the day. Entertainment for All A sreat many of the entertainments ashore, both for the men and officers of the fleet, marked the first day of the battleships' stay, and the visit of the squadrons promises to be a thoroughly enjoyable one. New orders were Issued today cov ering the entry of the fleet through the Golden Gate Into San Francisco bay on Wednesday next. The revised plans provide for the most formidable and picturesque naval display in the history of the nation. It is now ordered that all of the ves ■els of the Pacific fleet shall Join the Atlantic battleships outside the Golden Gate and steam with them through the harbor entrance to the anchorage In the bay where the review of May 8 la to be held. Practically the entire fighting force of the navy, with the exception of a few newly commissioned ships In the east and a few gunboats in Philippine waters, will be in the great column of white and buff vessels that thread their wav between the headlands of the Katewav —Point Bonlta on the north and Point Lobos on the south. Forty-six vessels will be in line and the long column will stretch as far out to sea as the eye can reach. The vari ety of fighting craft will range from the massive 16.000-ton Connecticut down to the little destroyer Fox of only 154 tons displacement. Battle ships, armored cruisers, protected cruisers, gunboats, destroyers, torpedo boats and auxiliaries—«n fact, every class of vessel in the navy save the obsolete /iionitors—will be represented In this fiinarkable parade through the famous port entry. The steaming of the ships through the Golden Gate will be a far more im pressive and enduring picture than the review at anchor, which is to be held two days after the arrival, or on Friday next. Rear Admiral Robley T>. Evans will be either on the bridge of the Con necticut or in the emeregncy cabin, where he commands a full view of the fleet, In entering San Francisco bay. Strict orders for a fair way for the host of naval vessels have been issued by \he department of commerce and labor at Washington, and the scores of excursion steamers that 'V»111 take crowds out to Angel inland and be yond to view the spectacle will be un der close federal supervision. Revenue cutters and naval launches will patrol the pathway and keep excursion and pleasure craft out of danger. Hour of Rendezvous The hour of rendezvous outside the Golden Gate—probably at tne San Francisco lightship--has been fixed for 9 a. m. on Wednesday next, May 6. Three hours later, or as near noon as the calculations ot the navigators can compute, the broad white bows of the will appear within the gateway. The flagship will he followed by the fifteen other veterans of the South I American cruise and hy two additional battleships acquired outside the har bor entrance—the Nebraska and the Wisconsin —making eighteen battle ships in all, the largest number ever brought in one command, Next will come the two divisions of ««E.agniflcent armored crullers of the West Virginia type—l3.ooo and 14,000 tonned fliers —eight ln.all. an* the other crulserß of the Pacific fleet. Following these will be the torpedo boat destroy er flotilla which made the trip through the Straits of Magellan and the flo tilla of the Pacific fleet, and at the end of the line will come the auxiliaries, alx In number. The poor, old, Wack h til led, soot-begrlmed colliers »hich did so much to make the recent cruise a success alone will be lacking. The Atlantic destroyer flotilla, which last saw the battleships at the western "Vnd of Magdalena, wli: rejoin the fleet at Santa Cruz on Monday next. Today was the tenth anniversary of the battle of Manila bay, but there were no ceremonies commemorative of the event on any of the ships. Rear Admiral W. "I. Emory of the second division cr j j6r'tained his fellow flag officers anij the captains of the fleet at luncheon at the Hotel del Monte, and tonight there was a dinner to the ad mirals, captains, Governor Gillett and staff at the Del Monte, with Mayor Jacks of Monterey as host. A Mug raising In Monterey attended by a number of detailed officers, (Cnntlnued on Page Three) i LOS ANGELES HERALD JOHN D. BALKS AT PAYING $500 FOR OLD ENGLISH SWORD Oil Trust Magnate Says "I Am a Man of Peace," and Declines to Buy Ancient Weapon By Araoeiated Press. NEW YORK, May 1.-John D. Rocke feller has refused to buy for $500 a sword sent by a young woman In Eng land with the information that the weapon was carried by a soldier in Cromwell's famous "Ironsides" troopers and had been buried 150 years near a church. The writer said thn sword was dug un 150 years ago. The ancient: relic did not appeal to Mr. Rockefeller, who de clined It with the remark: "I am a man of peace and have no use for a sword." Annie Parry sent the relic over. As Mr. Rockefeller refused to accept the sword It was sent to the seizure room of the customs service. The sword is about three feet long, has a curved blade and has apparently had rough usage. If the sender doe* not endeavor to have It returned it will be sold next fall with other unclaimed merchandise. _ 12 PRISONERS BREAK JAIL AT ENSENADA RURALES ARE IN PURSUIT OF FUGITIVES William Walker, Absconding Banker, Who Has Been Held In Lower Call fornia, Reported to Have Made No Attempt to Escape By Associated Frraa. ' ' . SAN DIEGO, May Rather meager reports; were received here today of a Jail ••■ break :at Ensenada, Lower Cali fornia. According to the best advices a dozen prisoners, among them several Americans, made their escape. Among those who r got .-; away are Crossthwaite, an alleged cattle thief, and Alex Smith, the latter accused of the murder ■ of, C. , V. Young at , San .Qulntln, L. C. a few weeks ago. '- sa : William F. Walker, the New Britain absconder, who is making a determined fight Ito resist extradition, , Is/reported not to have been one of those who got away.: The fugitives fled to the moun tains and rurales are In.pursuit.-y*^* •;: The report of the break Is not a sur prise |to persons I who have • seen the. Ensenada Jail. It Is by no means a modern structure.- 1 It Is constructed of adobe stucco and an experienced crook would not have great difficulty In get ting out ■if he | managed .to secure the right kind of Implements. There Is al ways a large guard of soldiers on hand. The guards are armed: with rifles and have barracks In Cuaretel.,; , , ■, ' Madame Gould and Prince at Rome By AMoclated Press. ROME, May I.—Madame Gould and Prince de Sagan, who arrived here yes terday from Naples, are spending their time sightseeing. They continue to deny themselves to Interviewers. Summary of the News FORECAST > v For Los ■: Angeles and vicinity: Showers Saturday; fresh southwest winds. Maximum temperature yes. terday, 68 degrees; minimum, 55 degrees. '-.•.."■"'' '. -■ '■* ■-•'■' ' '■• ■'.-.'.r,: : '>■•'■ LOCAL ; ' ■ ".■ Robbers make: desperate attempt to enter Monrovia postoffice; when seen fight duel with constable, t; '■*<;■ : - '■■ "•' Police Justice Frederlckson arrested charged with breaking , law , forbidding use of auto on road. ' --•■'■ t Wife claims mother-in-law's actions make It Impossible for her to live with husband. '- ' - Sawtelle , veteran claims comrade robbed him of years' savings. ~ ■ Children arraigned on charge of being horse thieves. . . >' ': f Attorney Wldaman, charged with as sault. Is held under $7500 bonds.' Grandfather says children are cruelly treated by father. ' . ."■.■• .eastern, .'' '■ .•Orover -.ieveland suffering from fatal Illness, according to report < current in Now. York. v ■'■*•* '• ■; ;■-"■"; ' ■ .' , " ' if. Senator j Davis 'of f Arkansas makes bitter attack, on i trusts ' and subsidized newspapers. .' ■". -■ ' f-.'-^ - ■ John tD. '■ 'Rockefeller refuses to . pay $500 for a-. oK sword sent to him from Frig-land. •-: -•'•-.. ■ : Few strikes reported in east on May day, which is usual time for labor dis turbances. •: -.'■■. : .'-. J -'.''■' '•" ■-" '- ; Express i robbers : secure large ' sum from train 'on Pennsylvania road. ; ■ S Vicious dog aids his master in Penn sylvania to commit suicide. - *-■ ' •"". COAST ;■ Immunit.- '■', is . promised * another ; de fendant in San Francisco graft case to obtain his testimony against Abe Ruef. p Battleship fleet anchors at Monterey; plans completed for great naval review in " San 1 Francisco, xt '^^Hj^SmtHSf^^fii Twelve prisoners escape from Jail in Ensenada, Lower California. "; <•: ' »,' Fate ;; of Tlrey -L. ; Ford will \be in hands of Jury today. /; : ' :•.';, - ■■:..•; ".*' Wells-Farco •;" Express > company re ports 'robbery, of. $63,000 from train in Mexico. <; J.';.' ;">-.;: ■'\ -rr. ".'.,■-'■•. t 1.;; ;.i ■ t -'*i, .." Admiral \ Evans > continues. rapid im provement at Paso Robles, where he is being treated for rheumatism. 1-*-"' : '•j'y.i Force at Mare island navy yard busy repairing. war vessels."'; '. ( '.■','• ', .. !l:1l 'OBlH<fj» t V^ \- -■ ,''.".-;',. i Two hundred s men": perish *In naval disaster/, caused tby explosion lon ," Jap anese fcrulser.v.'/.A.^.Si/C-i,?;' %,'ip\.\ ft^ :i •'■■l Winston Clvirchlll, defeated t for par liament lin . Manchester, seeks ■ election from Dundee.. ' .'V <'-:'r'-< SBMW SATURDAY MORNING, MAY 2, 1908. FLOTILLA ANCHORS TORPEDO BOATS STEAM INTO SAN PEDRO HARBOR BLUEJACKET BHOWS GREAT BRAVERY i Jumps Into Ocean to Rescue Little Girl Who Fell Overboard. Officers and Men En. tertained &■, ,- :-. • — • ♦ ■•> Automobile* are wanted badly for <•■ <•> the entertainment of the officer* and ■•.> <£> men .of the torpedo | bunt flotilla. A <•> >r> large parade In planned for 10 o'clock '» <;■ tbls morning;. All who can npare the <$> ■';'■ auto* are urgently requtwted to bring •$> '«> them - to the Chamber of Commerce <$> 4> building before 10 o'clock thin morn- <$> <•> Ing - and report to Secretary ■ Frank &> v«. WlggUi* of the chamber of commerce* 'v &,,, • , -!.. 4> A half dozen deadly demons of de struction poked their long, slim noses into San Pedro harbor yesterday after noon and were soon peaceably tied up to the wharves, and instead of the huge clouds of inky smoke that they had been belching a few minutes be fore, long gray filaments slowly rising from their stacks and an occasional puff of white vapor were the only in dications of the power that lay caged within their holds. At 5 o'clock yesterday morning the torpedo boat flotilla left San Diego, and at 2 o'clock yesterday afternoon they were tied up in the channel of San Pedro harbor alongside the piers. While the long allm boats, with their coats of dark green paint and funnels aslant, did not look so majestic as the ships of the great white fleet that came into the same waters a few days ago, the impression of enormous strength and speed was conveyed very strongly to those who watched their arrival. In single file, just as the warships paraded the coast, the line of six de stroyers headed straight for the mouth of the harbor, and with the government pilot aboard the Whipple they slid up to their moorings at slow speed. So smoothly did they go through the water that it was difficult to tell at times that they were moving. Two of the boats, the Whipple and the Stewart, tied up to the Banning pier on the San Pedro side of the chan nel, and lay there side by side. Within twenty minutes after their arrival the Sunset Telephone company had a tele phone In commission on the Whipple. Hardly had the boat reached the pier before the reception committees from San Pedro and Los Angeles went aboard to pay their respects to Com mander H. I. Cone of the flagship Whipple. Personnel of Committee J. W. Walton, mayor; John T. Gaf fey, president of the chamber of com merce; W. Blckenbaugh, W. C. Miller, R. Angel, W. J. Wood, Hadley Gross and B. M. Scott were the reception committee of San Pedro. Mayor Arthur C. Harper and Frank Wiggins represented Los Angeles. Af ter a short chat with the commander arrangements were made as to the time that the officers and men would be entertained in Los Angeles. Only sixteen of the twenty-four of ficers of the flotilla could be spared at one time, but 250 of the enlisted men will be given shore leave and will be on hand this morning at, 10 o'clock to take advantage of the automobile trip that has been arranged for them. The cars will start from the chamber of commerce building and after the ride lunch will be served the enlisted men and some form of entertainment provided for them at Chutes park in the afternoon. The theaters will be attended In the evening. The officers were entertained at dinner last evening at the Jonathan club, where they stopped over night. This morning they will be given an automobile trip in dependent of the men, which will prob ably include a stop at Hollywood to see the festivities during the after noon. The great hospitality of Los Angeles has been advertised among all of the men of the flotilla, and they were all anxious to get ashore and see for them selves the city that has won such a warm place in the hearts of their asso ciates on the big fleet. Girl Fall* Overboard The small boy at San Pedro was highly pleased when the destroyers tied up alongside the piers, and he did not wait for gangplanks or Invitation, but Jumped aboard with a flying leap. Lit tle 9-yearlold Katharine Calllaud es sayed to do the same feat that she had seen the boys accomplish successfully, but she failed and in an Instant she was In the water between the side of the Whlpple and the piling. It seemed for an instant that she would be crushed as the boat swayed with the tide, but only for an instant, for like a flash Fireman W. A. Coffman dived as the little girl struck the water, and when she came to the surface he grabbed her and held her head above water while several of the sailors climbed down the side of the ship and pulled them up on deck again. Little Katharine was taken home no worse oft thaa for the wetting, and a half hour later was romping with her playmates with nothing more than her wet hair to indicate that she had been so near a fatality. Coffman modestly disclaimed any credit for his manly act, saying that any of the boys would have gone overboard after her, but he happened to be the nearest. He tried to beg off from having his picture taken for The Herald, and it was only when he was told that It would speak well for the sailor boys to have the story printed that he would consent to have a snapshot made. The ease with which the boats could be boarded soon had the effect of mak ing them appear like a sardine tin with the inmates still wiggling. B'inally the officers had to call a halt on the num ber going aboard and only let them cross the gang plank to the boat as left who had seen all there was to see. Engine room, bridge, officers' quar- IfiSgß : (CootVmrd on rage Three) :■; ?«| I Bluejacket Rescues Girl from Drowning FIREMAN W. A. COFFMAN KATHERINE CAILLAUD —From photos taken hy HeraM Start Photographer a few minutes after the arrlrtcnt. FIGHTS DUEL WITH DARING ROBBERS CONSTABLE NARROWLY ES CAPES DEATH BANDITS TRY TO ROB POST OFFICE Attempt to Enter Federal Building at Monrovia a Failure, Owing to Watchfulness of Officer Special to The Herald MONROVIA. May I.—A desperate at tempt of two armed and daring high waymen to rob the postoffice at this place early this morning was frustrated by the sudden arrival of Constable John Thomas, who fought a pistol duel with the robbers and escaped death by a narrow margin. The robbers, chased by a hastily formed posse of citizens, escaped to the foothills and all efforts to overtake and capture them were unsuccessful. The police of the surrounding cities have been notlfed of the attempt and given a slight description of the robbers, and it is thoug'it probable the men will be apprehended. Word has been sent that the bandits are desperate and have shown they prefer de:.th to capture, and all offi cers in this district have been warned to use caution while attempting to effect their capture. The men evidently laid their plans for robbing the postoffice with the greatest care. At 2 o'clock in the morn ing the streets of Monrovia are prac tically deserted, and so they were this morning when the attempt to rob the postoffice was made. At that time Constable Thomas p. ssed the building on his rounds. The flicker of a light In an inner office caused him tv halt, and a second later he was startled by seeing a shadow pass from behind a tree a short dis tance from the front of the building. Connect!- g the two things, Thomas decided that two men were endeavor ing to rob the place. One of them was evidently acti lg as lookout while an other did the actual work. Fire at Officer Hoping to summon aid, Thomas Jumped behind, a tree, but as he did so a bullet whizzed by his face and buried Itself In a front room of the lodging houu opposite. Dropping on his stomach, Thomas drew .His revolver and opened fire on the ' hdit. The robber replied and bul le fere exchanged in quick succes | Suddenly a whistle sounded from ■L.t. .Jar of the building and Thomas' opponent dashed from behind the tree whore he was hiding, around the side of the building and joined his com panion. Thomaa waited long enough to in form several men who had been at tracted by the shots of what had trans pired and then started In pursuit of the robbers. Word was sent to other offi cers here and soon several parties on horseback were scouring the country. The men are supposed to be a couple of tough looking tramps who had been hanging around the poatoffice for sev eral days and whose actions have been noticed by the police. LARGE SUM STOLEN FROM EXPRESS CAR IN MEXICO By Associated Press. LAREDO, Tex., May I.—The Wells Fargo Express company has reported to the officials of Torreon, Mexico, a. loss of $63,000 In Mexican currency, which they claim was taken from a through safe on their City of Mexico car. The money was consigned to one of the banks of Chihuahua. Two ar rests have been made in Torreon, al though It is believed by the officers here that the men received th money. It appars that one of the agents of company boarded the express train at a station between the City of Mexico and Torreon, afterward leaving the train. It is said he was the only man who wad In the car who knew the com bination of the safe. He has not yet been arrested. CHURCHILL AGAIN SEEKS ELECTION TO PARLIAMENT Defeated in Manchester, New Presi dent of English Board of Trade Will Try Luck at Dundee By Associated Press. DUNDEE, May I.—Winston Spencer Churchill, president of the board of trade, whose recent failure to be re turned to parliament from the north western division of Manchester has forced him to seek a "safe" seat, ar rived here this morning to contest the vacancy caused by the elevation to the peorage of Edmund Robertson. Mr. Churchill has a well organized opposition to fight, but it will require an enormous turn of votes to defeat The unionist candidate, Sir George Baxter, has a powerful local influence, and the labor candidate, C. H. Stuart, while a novelty in this country, is an out and out prohibitionist. B Scrymgour of the United Irish league is urgine- the Irish voters to give their complete support to Mr. Churchill in the ground that Prater Asqulth has adopted Mr. Churchill s pledges at Manchester regarding home rule for Ireland as representing the policy of the government BIG FOUR MASTER IS BLOWN ASHORE HUGE GERMAN SHIP IN SORRY PLIGHT In Terrific Sea Ship Runs Aground Near New York —Ineffectual Ef. forts Made by Life Savers to Rescue Crew By Associated Pres».' NEW YORK. May - The great four-masted . German ship,. Peter Rlck mers, which left New York yesterday for Rangoon loaded with case oil, was driven ashore on ' the south coast of Long Island \ last night In a terrific gale, and was still ashore today with life saving crews unable to aid her. ; The'high wind which prevailed dur ing the day prevented the ship from gaining sea room yesterday, and early In the evening It Increased to a gale against which ■ the stout vessel could not hold her own, and she was thrown ashore about ten miles west of Fire island. • ■ i A tremendous sea was pounding on the beach and amid the blinding rain squalls.which swept across the ocean only the flaring rockets sent up from the deck of the steamer In appeal _f or assistance gave information of the dis aster From the shore the outline of the ship's riggings could be dimly discerned from the flame of the rockets, but the vessel lay beyond the reach of the Lyle gun used by the life saving crews to throw a line to the wrecked vessel. ■ Ineffectual efforts were made by the life savers to launch their boat in a terrific sea. .' " '■• ,'.'''.!. CThe Rickmers was loaded with 117,000 cases of oil from the Standard Oil com pany worth $80,000. The vessel Is valued at $60,000. She carried a crew of thirty or thirty-flve men. Before daybreak the gale veered to the northwest, blowing diagonally oft shore, and the sails of the big vessel were set again In the hope that ; the wind would drive her off shore as the tide rose.' Signals of distress were fly ing in her rigging, and with <k the smoothing of the sea the life savers again essayed to reach the vessel,: but without success for several ! hours. .' A revenue cutter and a wrecking tug were sent from New York to Zachs inlet and this afternoon the tug was seen stand ing by the ship, but apparently, unable to. render any assistance, as. the wind and sea were still too high. </ : Daughter of Revolution Dead By Associated Press. WOODBURY, Conn., ]>tay I.—Mrs. Roda Augusta Thompson, the last real daughter of the American Revolu tion, died at her home heri. today fol lowing a paralytic stroke. Her father was a drummer boy In the Revolution ary war. SINGLE COPIES: Sff^Tc^V BEULAH HAWKINS AWAKES AT LAST SLEEPS THROUGH EIGHTY SEVENTH DAY WOMAN APPEARS TO BE IN GOOD HEALTH Strange Case at the County Hospital Which Has Attracted Worldwide Attention Ends When Sleeper Recovers Consciousness Mrs. Beulah Hawkins, "the myster ious sleeper," who was taken to the county hospital February 5, eighty seven days ago, while in a sound slum ber and who has since remained in that condition, awoke at 12; 30 o'clock this morning. Miss Stevens, one of the nurses of the hospital and one who has been in constant attendance on the sleeping womaji, while passing down the hall way of the ward in which Mrs. Haw kins was a patient heard a knocking at the door of the sleeping woman's room. The nurse stopped, opened the door and was surprised to see Mrs. Hawkins standing by it. The patient appeared natural, and not in the least excited. Mrs. Hawkins said quietly: "I just wanted to let you know that I have awoke." She then turned and sat in a chair near her bed. Drs. Barber and Wright oi the hospital start were summoned Immediately and questioned the patient. "Please give me a glass of milk," said Mrs. Hawkins. "I have thirsted for one for several days." "Do you mean to say that you have had knowledge of what food and drink has been given you and have had an appetite for certain fluids and foods?" asked Dr. Barber. Watches Events Asleep "Why, certainly," said Mrs. Haw kins. "I have at all times been con scious of what was going on around me, and have closely followed events as they passed in my room. "It Is true that I have been unable to announce my wishes, but why this was I am unable to explain. I have frequently tried to speak, but appeared to have no control of my muscles or organs. The nurses and physicians have treated me with the utmost con sideration and kindness. I appreciate this and wish now to thank them for their acts." "Do you remember the acts of any persons who have visited you while you have been asleep?" asked Dr. Barber. Why, yes,' 1 said Mrs. Hawkins. "I remember on« man who held a bottle of ammonia under my nose," replied Mrs. Hawkins. "I also remember physicians discuss ing my case tonight and felt very ner vous for fear they should try to awaken me." "I think you had better lie down." said Dr. Barber. "No, I have been in bed long enough," said Mrs. Hawkins with a wan smile. "If you will tell me your address I will send a messenger for your daugh ter," said the physician. "Why, I am sure I can't remember where I live. Haven't you my ad dress here?" replied the woman. "We have in the office," said the physician. "Let me put this blanket around your shoulders so you will be comfortable." "I am plenty warm enough," was the response. This case has attracted the attention of the most noted specialists and physi cians In all parts of the world, and re ports of Mrs. Hawkins' condition have been telegraphed from day to day to the most noted medical societies in this and foreign countries. Specialists claim the woman has been suffering from a disease known as cat aleptic insanity. Others claim the wo man was in a trance, but all efforts of hypnotists to awaken here were un successi . Taft Sails for Panama CHARLESTON, S. C., May I.—Secre tary of War Taft ?nd party sailed for Panama on the naval transport Prairie today. The party expects to reach Panama on the morning of May 6. Q CENTS GRAFTERS ALARMED GREEN WILL TELL STORY OF BRIBERY PARKSIDE DEAL TO BE RELATED BY ONE OF PRINCIPALS Attorney for Former Boss Protests Against Prosecution's Strategy, but the Court Decide* Against Him W By Associated Trent. SAN FRANCISCO. May I.—The pros ecution sprung its first surprise In the case of Abraham Ruef, the former po litical dictator of San Francisco, >on trial for bribery, when Assistant i Dis- ! trict Attorney Francis J. Heney late this afternoon moved the dismissal of; fourteen indictments against J. K. Green, president of the Parksid« Real ty company, a co-defendant of Ruef in the case now being tried, In order that Green might testify against the former political boss. Green had been called to the stand by the prosecution despite ' the | ob jection of his attorney. Judge Dooling directed that he be sworn, and after some preliminary questions the assistant district attor ney asked what steps he had . taken to get the committee of the board of supervisors, which had held up a fran chise, to take some action. Refuses to Answer Green, upon advice of his counset, refused to answer and started to read a statement setting: forth his reasons. Heney objected to the reading of the statement, was sustained by the court, and Green then, upon advice of coun sel, refused to answer on the ground that he would be testifying against himself. "Then, on behalf of the people, I move that all indictments against the witnesses, fourteen in number, be dis missed that he may give his testimony In this case," said the assistant district attorney, rising to his feet. This unexpected move on the part of the prosecution came as a surprise to the defense and created something of a. sensation In the crowded court room. A whispered consultation between Ruef and his attorneys quickly fol lowed. Henry Ach, chief counsel for Ruef, strongly objected to the move of the prosecution on the ground that such an application could only be made upon a joint trial of the trial of the co defendants. Indictments Dismissed Judge Doollng overruled the objec tion of the defense, dismissed, the . In dictments against the witness and or dered his discharge therefrom.. ■ til. Green visibly showed his relief and pleasure at the sudden turn of pro ceedings and smilingly acknowledged his willingness to testify. . ._ At this point an adjournment was taken until Monday. •_ .. :_'. . "Walter B. Cope, president of the , san Francisco Bar association, formerly superior judge of Santa Barbara county and for four yean Ruef's classmate In college, testified against Ruef this morning. Cope Is a member of the firm or at torneys for the Parkside Realty com pany, in which he also was a ; stock holder, and told of Ruef s demand for a fee of $40,000 or $50,900 If employed by the company to get the desired trolley franchise through the board of super- V Cope was followed by "W. I. Brobeck, who also was Jointly Indicted with Ruef. Brobeck was questioned about his knowledge of the trolley appll- CaAfter Green took the oath, under tho After Green took the oath, under th., interrogation of Heney he told of the preliminary steps taken toward filing an application for the sale of a fran chise, the application having beenj.re pared by Judgo Cope and filed with the clerk of the board of supervisors by, Green said he attended all the meet- Ings of the committee to which the ap plication was referred and told of his efforts to get some action upon It and his conversation with Mayor Schmitz, who declared himself heartily In favor "Did you. do anything else to get It out of committee besides speaking to the mayor?" asked Assistant District Attorney Heney. ' Declines to Answer Prank D. Nichol. Green's attorney, arose at this point and Interposed an objection, advising the witness he hart a right to decline to answer the ques tion. Green took r typewritten paper from his pocket and began to read a state ment setting forth his position In the case and his reasons for refusing to answer. He had read but a few lines when Veney objected, declaring the witness should state upon what ground ho refused to answer. Henry Ach Jumped up and contended that Green was within his rights in reading the statement, and for a few moments counsel for the defense and the state" both talked at the same time and so rapidly that the court reporter was unable to follow them. Judge Doollng asked the witness to IU him see tiu paper, which was done, despite a vigorous objection from Ach to the court's reading the paper. "The court will not permit the wit ness to read any statement," ruled Judge Dooling. "There are certain statutory grounds upon which the wit ness can decline to answer which are well known and need no enlargement. If he bases his refusal upon those grounds the court will not compel him to testify." "My advice to the witness," here in terposed Nichol, "Is that he cannot con stitutionally be compelled to testify against himself, being a co-defendant, and that he refuse to answer upon the ground thai it might Incriminate him self." "I refuse upon tho«e grounds," said Green. There was intense silence for a mtc ment in the crowded court room and (Continued oa P««o I»«)