Newspaper Page Text
ALL THE NEWS PRICE: ?Jb c!.0*?12 40 CENTS' f'OL. XXXVI. NUMBER 100. COUNTY'S AUTO BILL IS $26,000 IN 16 MONTHS AUDITOR BLAMES DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE DOW SANS HE GETS LITTLE AID IN SAVING PUBLIC MONEY Court Rules That Taxpayers Shall Not Be Assessed for Motoring Coats, Caps and Goggles HERRBERT G. DOW, county audit- i or, won yesterday in his conten-! tion that the county treasury should not be called upon to pay for the automobile clothing of county offi- • cials. Judge Monroe, before whom the ■ hearing on the application for a writ of j mandate to compel the payment of the ' bill was heard, refused to order the auditor to pay for accessories, the price j of which aggregated $79.50. "I'd like to know what authority | there is to make the county pay for these things," said the court. "There! is no more right in making the county | pay for such items than for a silk hat and a frock coat to be worn at a funeral." The auditor won in spite of lukewarm counsel. An hour before the hearing began Deputy Ristrict Attorney Shaw, according to Mr. Dow, tried to prevail upon him to pass the bill and have the case dismissed. Even District Attor ney Fredericks, it is said, tried to have the bill settled in full. On behalf of Mr. Dow, Deputy Shaw prepared an anrver to the writ of man date filed by the Los Angeles Motor Car company. The answer noted only a part of the exceptions taken by the auditor to the coroner's bill. These were as follows: One automobile ci it, $28; another coat, $35; two pairs of automobile gloves, $9; two pairs of automobile goggles, $5.50; one racin,-* cap. $1; one regular automobile cap, $1; two blue robes, $28. Other Items Omitted Why other things were not included in the answer is a mystery. It certain ly was not due to any wish on Mr. Dow's part to keep them out. There was the $95 speedometer and clock, and the excess price for the automobile over the list price as shown in the catalogue. "You need not issue a warrant for the coats, gloves, goggles and caps," (Continued on Page Two) THE NEWS SUMMARY FORECAST For Los Angeles and vicinity: Rain Saturday, brisk south winds. Maxi mum temperature yesterday, 63 de grees; minimum, 45 degrees. LOCAL Exposure of vice by Los Angeles Herald pro duces consternation; Mayor Harper explains his visit to Venice Twenty-four young men at county court house arraigned at one time on criminal charges. Post and Woman's Relief corps hold Joint Installation of officers. Court rules that Auditor Dow need not pay ' bills for unnecessary auto accessories presented *by county \ officials. Anti-racetrack Gambling league issues com munication calling on citizens to contribute money with which to fight the betting evil. I Neighborhood row leads to arrest of wln«i dealer who is alleged to have caused disturb ance. Negro is held to superior court on charge of having robbed aged woman of $1500, which sum the had accumulated by saving for a lifetime. Grand jury busy with getting ready to render report of its findings in its recent inquiry Into I alleged vice protection. Woman accuses detective in employ of board of trade of defrauding her of money given him to purchase land for her. Man who managed McCabe's campaign for membership on board of county supervisors is elated for steward at county hospital. Marriage which was celebrated on high seas is annulled, wife alleging officiating clergy man was ignorant of laws concerning matri mony. Police commission hold secret meeting in which members say they discussed "new po licemen." Jud R. Rush addresses Jefferson club mem bers at their observance of Jackson day, and talks on modern graft. Churches ask council to enact ordinance which shall prohibit dice shaking at cigar stands. COAST Northern California and Oregon cities cut off from telegraph service and trains de layed by storms; 100 inches of snow falls in day at Summit; freezing weather at Port land; California rivers badly swollen. Great quantity of oil leaks out into San Joaquin river, killing vast numbers of fish and fowl and badly polluting waters. " Over three hundred bills introduced by solons of house and senate at California legislature; two measures presented to abol ish race track gambling and lobby is split into many factions; lively battle expected. Wheelwright who killed his wife in San Francisco because she deserted him is hanged at San Quentin with prayer on his lips; shows no sign of nervousness. Man arrested in Oakland on charge of forging over $800,000 of notes must face grand jury which is called to hear evidenco against him. San Diegans plan big celebration at open , ing of two big water conduits just com pleted. «. Coast artilleryman accused of having shot police sergeant in San Francisco while lat ter attempted to aid provost guard in sub duing him; officer dies on way to hospital. Fight in the state legislature on the race track issue is begun and it is claimed that the gamblers themselves are in division on . the question. EASTERN ,* President Roosevelt alleges that Senator / Tillman used his influence to obtain timber grant in Oregon for relatives and these ac cusations are embodied in the president's report to the senate. Lower house of congress passes resolution censuring the president for the language he used in his message and in future it will refuse to receive messages in which the acts of members are denounced. Culberson reso lution asking for president's authority in instructing the attorney general not to prosecute the steel trust for absorption of the Virginia Iron and Coal company passed by the senate by a big majority. Teeth found in the church stove at St. Clair, Mich., have been identified by a den tist as belonging to a carpenter named -Browning, who is known to have been seen 'with the clergyman, who Is also missing and who is supposed to have been murdered Belief *is now extant that the Rev. Car michael is alive. J* FOREIGN Chinese reformer, Rang Tv Wei, : accuses dismissed member of the grand . council of China of being instrumental in the death of emperor and predicts that the deposed of ficial will be placed on trial for his connec tion, with the matter. V v LOS ANGELES HERALD RULERS WHO MOURN FOR QUAKE VICTIMS y *** c!^s-4^*--, QUEEN REFUSES TO OBSERVE BIRTHDAY BECAUSE OF QUAKE Another Shock Causes Great Panic at Messina—Unite-! States Gunboat Arrives—All of Injured Housed ROME, Jan. B.—Following the de- j sires expressed by Queen Helena, the anniversary of her birth, which was ob served here today, was not attended by any of the usual festivities. Her majesty, as well as the king, said that this year she wished to cele brate the day by working doubly hard for the Calabrian and Sicilian earth quake sufferers, whose sufferings she cannot drive from her mind. The United States supply ship Cul goa arrived this morning from Port Said. A detail Of bluejackets from the Scorpion constructed an Anglo-Ameri can station this afternoon upon a space adjoining the ruined building ln which the American consulate was located. Dr. George C. Rhoades, surgeon of the Scorpion, has assumed charge. An undulatory earthquake shock caused a great panic last night. All of the injured have been removed from Reggio and housed. One thousand bodies have been dug from the ruins of fallen buildings and buried in improvised cemeteries. Among those who escaped uninjured when the shock came were three chil-, dren, who, after being buried in the debris of their home for seven days, got out unaided, burrowing like mice. The safe of the Bank of Italy, con taining $3,000,000, has been found. Fresh earthquake shocks are being felt here at Branca Tofe and Messina each night. They are preceded by ex plosions, and buildings that -were not totally destroyed in the big shock are being further damaged. COUNT AND PRETTY STENOGRAPHER WED; AGAIN DISAPPEAR Yon Horst and Helen Kukulski, Who Eloped from Los Angeles, Mar ried by Minister in San Bernardino SAN BERNARDINO, Jan. B.—Count Yon Horst and pretty Helen Kukulski, who were reported to have eloped from Los Angeles a few days ago, were mar ried here this afternoon by Rev. E. H. Fessenden, pastor of the First Presby terian church. They disappeared im mediately after the ceremony. The girl gave her age as 19 years, and the count gave his name as Jonu : Koenigwarter and declared Russia is his native land. The couple did not give any account of their whereabouts since they left Los Angeles, but it is believed they have been traveling to gether and when they learned their actions were being Investigated by the police decided to have a marriage cere mony performed. Helen Kukulski's mother was found at her home, 1360 Myrtle street, by a Herald reporter last night and in formed ' that her daughter was mar ried. Mrs. Kukulski said she received a letter from Helen the day before from San Diego saying they were happy and would be home soon. The letter was signed "Helen Koenigwarter." Mrs. Kukulski was unable to under stand why her daughter was married yesterday when she had been informed the couple had been married several days ago at Santa Ana. But mother like, she has faith in her child and de clares all will end well. Solon Dies in Nordhoff PHILADELPHIA, Jan. Word has been received here of the death in Nord hoff, Cal., of State Senator Algernon B. Roberts, a son of the late President George B. Roberts of the Pennsylvania Railroad company. SATURDAY MORNING, JANUARY 9, 1909. EXPOSURE OF VICE PRODUCES CONSTERNATION HARPER TRIES TO EXPLAIN TRIP TO VENICE POLICE COMMISSIONER AGENT FOR NOTORIOUS RESORT Respectable Citizens Everywhere De mand Full Investigation of Awful Conditions in Infamous Girl Traps * IN many other places besides Mayor Harper's office The Herald's state ment yesterday concerning the reign of vice in Los Angeles and the story of the excutive's night trip to Venice were the leading topics of dis cussion. The consternation that fol lowed' The Herald's first announcement was increased when the story was made public of the mayor's attempt to dictate to the people of the seaside city. Everywhere the Interest was as great. In business offices, In hotel lobbies, at the court house, on the street cars, at public gatherings— fact everywhere that men came together The Herald's question was repeatedly asked: "IS VICE PROTECTED IN LOS AN GELES?" Everywhere were heard such ex pressions as: "Good! I hope the matter will be followed to the end." "I am glad to see The. Herald go after this so vigorously. The thing should be thoroughly probed." "If vice is NOT protected, why do we witness such scenes in the cafes. I have heard in restaurants supposed to cater to the best element conversations which were positively indecent, and they indicated a freedom which would not exist if everything was strictly su pervised in an honest manner. There is something wrong, and I am glad to see The Herald go after it." Approve Herald's Action The tenor of the average citizen's conversation was in approval of The Herald's attitude. Not only was thi3 apparent in conversations, but it was evidenced to the management by many letters, telephone and personal calls, and messages showing the intense in terest in the question. "That's the question." said one man, "IS VICE PROTECTED IN LOS AN GELES? And decent taxpayers and citizens look for a full answer from The Herald." The position of the city's executive acting as an intermediary for the "in terests" at Venice and a special pleader for retention of the all-night policy in another city was a topic that called forth much Indignant comment. Many business men looked upon it as an affront to the city of Los Angeles, to say nothing of the Indignity offered Ocean Park through the official sug gestion regarding that city's moral con duct. - _, The exposure of Mayor Harper's er rand fell like a bomb at the city hall yesterday morning, and there were im mediate consultations. Mayor Eakins is said to have been hurriedly sum moned to Los Angeles, and lt was re ported that Harper and he were closeted in an office of the Los Angeles aque duct at the Central building. A statement purporting to have been Issued by Mayor Eakins, but which was signed on the typewriter as "H. B. Eakins, mayor of Venice," was handed out yesterday afternoon by Herbert Kennedy, Mayor Harper's secretary. In the statement Mr. Eakins' reason for restricting the liquor business along the beach was attributed to his desire to prevent the beach towns going for prohibition. If the statement is what it purports to be no doubt the wholesale liquor men used the comic opera ex pression, "Well, that's fair enough." The statement which Private Secre tary Kennedy handed out as coming from the mayor of Ocean Park is as follows :* In justice to Mayor A. C. Harper, * who has been unjustly criticised and placed in a false light, I make this explanation of his visit to Venice Wednesday evening. I have known the mayor a great many years and the bond of friend ship between us has been very close. Since becoming mayor of Venice I 'have frequently called on him in his office and he has called on me at Venice, and we have ex changed views on municipal affairs. If he had called on me at Venice Wednesday night, as reported, there would have been nothing strange nor unusual about it. But the truth of the matter is he did not do so. Mayor Harper came to Venice with his friend, Mr. Sawyer, in the lat ter's car for a ride. While at the Ship hotel James Morley took ad vantage of his presence to send a car for me and ask that I call on Mayor Harper at the ship. In the course of conversation the subject of the proposed early clos ing of the Ship restaurant on ac count of the disgraceful "Brownies" ball at Venice New Year's eve came up, and Mayor Harper expressed himself that an injustice would be done the proprietors of the Ship "restaurant should they be put out of business on account of it, as he had always heard of the good order that prevailed at the restaurant. I explained to Mr. Morley that be cause of the sentiment of the peo ple along the beach the liquor busi ness must be restricted or the beach towns would go prohibition. That ended the discussion. Mayor Harper made no request of me concerning a "wide open" town; In fact the subject was not broached. The mayor congratulated me on closing the "Brownies" ball, say ing while he was not at the ball he had seen the program and con sidered it the most disgraceful ever - heard of in California. "H. B. EAKINS, "Mayor of Venice." 'Liquor Men Shown Up Commendation of The Herald's searchlight, turned upon vice, was not by any means confined to any one class. Proprietors of cigar stands and saloons, who as taxpayers and business men are entitled _j to protection from exploitation, freely commended The Herald. Several did not hesitate to express the hope that "the thing would be shown up." *-.■>.'■":•'--.-" \ The conservative membership of the liquor element has resented approaches which have been made by representa tives of city officials at various times to secure investment in stock con cerns. "We want no club held over (Continued on Pajte Three.) IS VICE PROTECTED IN LOS ANGELES?=III How Police Commissioner Sam Schenck Suc ceeded in Placing with Liquor Dealers Stock of Corporations in Which Mayor Harper and Majority of His First Police Commission Were Interested If! considering the efforts of Samuel Schenck, Police Commissioner, to place the 0N stock of the the efforts of Samuel with persons interested in liquor dealing in the stock of the Sugar Corporations with persons interested in liquor dealing in the j city of Los Angeles, it is worth while to remember the power possessed by the ®km Police Commission, a majority of whom, together with the Chief of Police, were interested in the Corporations in whose stock Mr. Schenck was dealing. Under the provisions of the city charter and ordinances, the Police Commission has di rect and absolute control of the liquor business of the city. It has the power to cause to be issued liquor licenses to saloons, restaurants, hotels and wholesale liquor houses, and it has the right to cancel such licenses. Controlling, as the Commission does, the Police force of the city, it is also within the power of the majority of its members in association with the Chief of Police to virtually accord special privileges to any liquor dealer or dealers whom this majority may desire to favor by causing the Police force of the city to wink at violations of the law govern ing the sale of liquors, time of closing, etc. • These -facts may or may not have been a contributing influence in inducing the per sons and firms interested in the liquor business in the city to become stockholders of the Pacific Sugar Corporation, the Pacific Sugar Company and the Pacific Securities Company. Certain it is that a good many of them purchased such stock. The lists of stockholders of these corporations in the possession of The Herald show that George Zobelein, President of the Los Angeles Brewing Company, is the owner of 200 shares of the stock of the Pacific Sugar Corporation of thenar value of $20,000, and that, John Graft Zobelein, also an official o: the same corporation, owns forty shares in the same corporation. While' the lists of stockholders above mentioned do not show that any of the stock in either one of the Sugar corporations is owned by either one of the Maier Brothers, who, with other members of the Maier family, are the owners of the Maier Brewing' Com pany, the largest brewery in the city, yet The Herald is informed, and it believes correct ly, that the Maier brothers actually own $25,000 of the stock of the Pacific Sugar Corp oration. ..-.-•.■ -v X . - . ■ • i The Herald has also imformation which it believes reliable to the effect that the Los Angeles Brewing Company and The Maier Brewing Company own or control 120 of the 200 retail liquor licenses now in force in the city of Los Angeles. If this is true, then it means that by the Zobeleins and Maier brothers owning sugar stock which they now hold, 120 of the 200 saloons in the city of Los Angeles were, by such ownership, brought into business association and mutuality of business interest with the majority of Mayor Harper's first Police Commission and the Chief of Police of the city. The lists of stockholders show J. Henry Zitt, President of the San Diego Brewing Company, to own 250 shares of the par value of $25,000 of the stock of the Pacific Sugar Corporation. It is a well known fact that the beer of the San Diego Brewing Company is sold in the city Los Angeles. As to whether or not that Company has acquired con trol of any saloons in the city The Herald is not informed, but it is extremely probable that such is the case, judging from the fact that brewing companies always find it con duces to the handling of their output to control as many retail liquor establishments as possible. There are also a number of independent liquor dealers in the city of Los Angeles whom the stockholders lists above referred to show to have acquired' considerable inter ests in the sugar corporations. Darmody & Schaeffer running a saloon on the corner of Fifth and Main streets are shown to own 625 shares of the Pacific Sugar Corporation of a par value of $62,500. John Koster and J. J. Lonergan of Koster & Lonergan, who run the Imperial Cafe, are shown to be owners of 37 and 38 shares respectively of the Pacific Sugar Corporation. Alexander Aikman, who conducts a saloon on First street, east of the Salt Lake System, is shown to be the owner of 50 shares of the stock of the Pacific Sugar Company. R. F. Goings, who conducts a saloon on Seventh and San Pedro streets, is shown to own 125 shares of the par value of $12,500 of the stock of the Pacific Sugar Company and 500 shares of the par value of $50,000 of the stock of the Pacific Securities Company. Mr. Goings * establishment will be referred to again in these articles. J. E. Dunne, commonly called "Chowder House Jim" Dunne, who was connected with the Manhattan Hotel, of which The Herald shall have something further to say, is also, according to information in the possession of The Herald, the owner of a consid erable amount of stock in one or more of the sugar corporations, although, as in the case of the Maier brothers, his name is not shown upon the lists of stockholders in the pos session of The Herald. There is also no doubt that a number of other liquor dealers in the city whose names are not shown upon the stockholders' lists in the possession of The Herald, are interested in one or more of the sugar corporations; thus associating them in a mutuality of busi ness interest with the Mayor and the majority of his first Police Commission and Chief of Police Kern. The sum total of the foregoing is that parties interested in liquor dealing in the city of Los Angeles and whose businesses were, therefore, under the direct control and practically at the mercy of the Police Commission and the Police Department are shown to have be come the owners of 2115 shares of stock of the par value of $211,500 in corporations in which the Mayor, with the majority of his first Police Commission and Chief of Police Kern, were also stockholders. As these figures do not include the stock owned by J. E. Dunne, the amount of which is unknown to The Herald, and the probable stock ownership of several other liquor dealers, the probabilities are that at least a quarter of a million of dollars of the stock of these corporations, in which the majority of Mayor Harper* first Police Commission and Chief of Police Kern were inter ested, is held by persons engaged in the business of selling liquor in the city of Los Angeles. Including the saloons owned and controlled by the breweries whose own ers are interested in the stock of the sugar corporations with other saloons whose individual owners have subscribed for this stock, it appears extremely probable that at least 150 of the 200 retail liquor establishments in the city of Los Angeles were connected by mutuality of business interest with a ma jority of Mayor Harper's first Police Commission and Chief of Police Kern. One, and indeed the principal official duty of this Police Commission and the Chief of Police was to regulate and control these liquor dealing establishments. Upon the care and faithfulness with which that duty was performed depended the enforcement of ''-* laws and the existence or non-existence in&he city of Los Angeles of the evils ss&r'£i? spring from uncontrolled or loosely controlled liquor selling. .'« -"k- >) - , The amount of stock in the sugar corporations placed in the hands of persons interest ed in liquor selling in the city would seem to indicate that the influence*'wielded by Mr. Schenck as a member of the Police Commission in his efforts to place this stock was very effective. Indeed, so effective was it that it seems to have inspired Mayor Harper with a desire to further extend the operation of this influence in financing corporations. For some time after Mr. Schenck undertook his financial campaign among the liquor dealers, Mayor Harper and Mr. Schenck became parties to the organization of another corporation known as the Los Angeles-Utah Oil Company, of which the Mayor became President, and which was also extensively financed among Los Angeles liquor men. The story of this feat in what might be called "Municipal official finance" will be told in tomorrow's Herald. „.-. CENTS SINGLE COPTF.S- -*-»*-«-*- 2 <* : ron».T. » kJAX-l \JTJ_-»XJ \j\Ji: _LJ_jO . OX TRAINS. 5 CENTS TILLMAN FACES SERIOUS CHARGE BY ROOSEVELT ACCUSED OF ATTEMPT TO "GRAB" OREGON LANDS PRESIDENT MAKES ACCUSATIONS IN REPORT TO SENATE Chief Executive Declares Solon Used Influence in Conspiracy to Ob tain Timber Grant for Relatives WASHINGTON, Jan. 8.-President Roosevelt made public tonight details of an investigation by postofflce inspectors and secret service agents of Senator Tillman's connection with an alleged "land grab" in Oregon. As he presents the evidence to Sena tor Hale, in response to the latter's re quest to the heads of the various ex ecutive departments for a statement of the operations of the secret service, the president undertakes to show: That Mr. Tillman used his influence as a senator in an effort to force the government to compel a railroad cor poration to relinquish its control of land grants from the United States in order that he and his family and his secretary. J. B. Knight, might profit through the purchase of some of the land, and also that the senator used his government franking privilege in nu merous instances for the conduct of private business. Senator Tillman did not permit the fact that President Roosevelt was giv ing out the charges against him to alter his determination to make no statement until Monday. Does Not Deny Effort No effort was made by him to con ceal that when he had learned the facts concerning the railroad grant ho made an effort to obtain portions of the land in the names of his family and himself, but he declared that, as at the most he could have got possession of only a few hundred acres, his efforts were, after all, in behalf of the public and not especially in his own interest. Immediately, after the conclusion of the chaplain's prayer Monday Mr. Till man will ask the recognition of the chair on a question of personal priv ilege. Departing from his custom of extemporaneous speaking, he will read his statement. . The communication to Senator Hale is nearly 3000 words long, and in addi tion there are appended numerous ex hibits, including copies of letters writ ten by Senator Tillman and his agent. William E. Lee, showing that they did make an effort to secure several quar ter sections of the Oregon land, and the report of the postofflce inspectors who investigated the transaction of the land agents. It was through this investiga tion that the alleged interest of Senator Tillman was brought to light, and. fatefully, it appears that it was at his instigation that the inquiry was begun. Substance of Charges The substance of the president's com munication to Senator Hale follows: "I have requested the different de partments of the government to give me all the information about the use of special attorneys, special agents, in spectors, etc., in their departments, which will enable me to put before you all the facts which, as I take it, your committee desires to have. "Let me at the outset express my ocrdial agreement with the view that it is not only the right but the duty of congress to investigate the workings of the secret service or detective agents by which alone the government can effectually safeguard itself against wrongdoing, punish crime and bring to Justice criminals. I am well aware of the liability to abuse inherent in any effective detective system or secret service system. "It nevertheless remains true that this system is absolutely Indispensiblo if the popular interest is to be ade quately safeguarded and wrogdoers continue to fear the law. "I would like to state here that very frequently accusations have been mad? to me privately by members of the two houses to the effect that the secret ser vice had been used as a 'police of mor als' or to shadow senators, congress men and other public officials. Detectives Baffled "Hitherto the effort to discover the basis for such allegations has always been fruitless. : "I should be greatly obliged if any information could be furnished me tending to show any instance where this has been done in times past. "Of course, in the investigation of specific frauds we sometimes come 1 across wholly unexpected cases of mis conduct. The frauds in the postal de partment which were unearthed some six years ago, for instance, offer a case in point. "My suspicions were first aroused by a report made as to the very extrava gant and debauched manner of life of - a certain postal employe, the report be ing made by an official of the secret service In connection with another transaction at which he was at work. "So it was with the cases of the abuse of the franking privileges. The post office never of sea purpose inspects any printing sent through the mails by a senator or congressman, but sometimes through the accidental breaking of such package the contents are exposed, and if they are of a character which makes their transmission by franking privilege illegal steps are taken by the postofflce authorities to collect the full postage. ' Ignorance or Carelessness "Some of these instances are due to carelessness or ignorance, and very of ten doubtless are entirely unknown to the congressmen themselves and no good purpose would be served by any publicity in the matter. "But a case has just arisen of a dif ferent kind, which it seems to me I should put before you as illustrating in striking fashion the way 'in which in vestigation begun by. any of these agents in the line of their duty may develop facts of high Importance, -which the investigators would not in the first instance have so ight to discover, and which, when dlscofigred, ought not to be hidden or suppressed, but the de velopment of which may tend to create an erroneous impression that the agents in question were being .used for. pur poses not within the line c" their law ful duties. "On the 19th of February, 1908, (see exhibit A) Senator Tillman called the attention of the senate to a circular of a syndicate firm for the sale of land in Oregon, particularly in Coos and Doug las counties, which had been granted to corporations by the government, the; (Continue*! on Page Two)