Newspaper Page Text
2 It r • ... - • — . ..I । Iffl wr fit you— n [New Fall Shoes Men’s DANXOM Alamo | Outfitters Plax L n TII FT DEFENDS DECISIONS OF SUPREME COURT (Continued from Page 1.' ficiently broad and indefinite to re quire Judicial construction to settle their meaning. The early decisions under the law can not be said to have been fortunate. The decision in what was known as the sugar trust case — the Knight case —was really a retro grade step and one which seemed to limit much the operation of the sta tute. It encouraged the organization of combinations which the same court has since found violate the statute. Indeed, some law officers of the gov ernment did not hesitate to say that under this decision there was little hqpe of reaching the evil aimed at through federal action. It has re quired twenty years of litigation to make the statute clear. But now it is clear. What Decision Means. “I shall not attempt to give it a close, lawyer-like interpretation, but 1 think it Is not departing from the declaration of the court to say that they find any contract in restraint of trade, made for the purpose of ex cluding competition, controlling ■ prices, or of maintaining a monopoly, in part or in whole, is contrary to the statute and is subject to Injunction and Indictment under thia statute in the federal courts where It affects in terstate trade. “I repeat again that in spite of all the denunciations that we have heard of the decisions of the Supreme court in the Standard Oil and the Tobacco cases, there is not one who has criti cised them that can formulate a con tract in restraint of trade that ought to come within the statute that does not come within it under the decision of the Supreme court. Changod the Statute. "It is said that the Supreme court has read something into the statute that w-s not that it has Inserted the word “reasonable” be- POSITIVELY BELIEVES WOULD HAVE DIED Fortunate Experience of Lady Who Obtained Relief From Serious Trouble by Taking a Woman's Tonic WILDOMAR, Cal.—Says Mrs. F. S. Mills, of this place: "I had a mishap, which was followed by inflammation and I suffered with intense pain for more than a week. I positively believe I would have died had it not been for Cardul, the woman’s tonic. I don’t think any one can recom mend a medicine more highly than I can Cardul. I never saw a remedy which strengthens one so rapidly. “When I began to take Cardul I could not stand on my feet. After taking two bottles, I was cured, and now I weigh 165 pounds. I am glad to recommend a medicine with so much merit” If womanly troubles have worn vou out, made you feel weak, sick and miserable, and able to see only the dark side of things, brighten up by getting back your health. Take Cardul, the woman's tonic. This well known woman’s medicine has brought health and happiness to many thousands of weak and ailing women. Why not to you? Get a bottle - today, at the drug store. NOTE—The Cardul Home Treatment for Women consists of Cardul (SI), Thedford’s Black-Draught (25c), or Velvo (50c), for the liver, and Cardul Antiseptic (50c). These remedies may ' be taken singly, by themselves, If de sired. or three together, as a complete treatment for women's ills. Write to: Ladies' Advisory Dept.. Chattanooga Medicine Co., Chattanooga. Tenn., for Special Instructions, and 64-page book, “Home Treatment for Women," sent in plain wrapper, on request. L. T. WATERS UNDERTAKER 431 E. Caanint St. Phones20&0 11 OK DAY, Regal— I $3-45 to $5 85 I ' li French-Shriner | & Umer | $6 to $10 I We show many styles | you will be unable to see I elsewhere. fore restrainta of trade, when the same court had said that this could not be properly done, because con gress had evidently not Intended to Include such a limiting word In the statute. This Is not fair to the court. It 1s true that the court, in the early days of the construction of the stat ute. had said that It could not limit the statute in effect by exoluding from Its operation what was deemed rea sonable at common law. But as other cases arose it found It necessary to make exceptions to the literal opera tion of the words “restraint of trade,” and It did so by excepting what was minor, or Incidental, or indirect, and Including only those case where the chief object of the contract or com bination was the restraint. In doing so the courLsald that It must give the statute a reasonable construction and not one leading to absurd or ridicu lous results. What combinations or arrange ments can escape under this inter pretation that any sensible man would wish to have condemned? Did the court not condemn the standard Oil Co., the father of all trusts. In the history of which every form of crim inal Illegality was practiced? Did It not, on the other hand, condemn the tobacco trust, of much later origin and framed under the advice of cun ning counsel tor the very purposees of evading the condemnation of the statute and at the same time securing and enjoying the monopoly the fram ers of the statute intended to prevent and punish? "Let me renew against the Invita tion to any of the vociferous critics of the decision of the supreme court to use their legal imaginations and state the facts of a case not con demned within the rule of construc tion put upon the statute by the su preme court, but included within theli construction of it, which reasonable men would think it wise or proper to make criminal. “The decision of the supreme court as it grows to be understood In the near future will be a signal for the voluntary breaking up of all combi nations In restraint of trade within the inhibition of the statute, and will. I hApe, lead to a complete revulsion of feeling on the part of business mtn of this country and to a clear under standing by them of the limitations that must be Imposed by them upon anv business combinations made by them in the future. The operation of the statute has illustrated the slow ness of judicial procedure, and of this I have often made complaint; but in the settlement of issues of this impor tance two decades are no great length of time, and if in that period we shall have stamped out an evil which would certainly have carried us to socialism as a reaction from the vicious control of the few, the time spent, the effort, and the litigation are worth the cost. There have been Umes when among others I have thought that the en forcement of the law might have been facilitated had the courts visited its breach with severer punishment, but "Though the mills of the gods grind slowly, yet they grind exceeding small,” and without the severity that some of us urged and would have been glad to see used, a revolution in business methods where they have heretofore been violative of the sta tute will be accomplished, and with least disturbance to business which is lawful. I wish to repeat now, and to say further that the attorney general has instituted investigations into all the industrial companies above described, and that these are in various stages of completion. x,' Opnosed to Amendment. Under these conditions, I am en tirely opposed to an amendment of the anti-trust law. It is now a val uable government asset and instru ment. Tested and brought into prac tical and beneficial' use by twenty years of litigation and construction by the highest court, why should we Im peril its usefulness by experiments? The outcry sought to be raised tn some quarters, followed by proposals of amendments prepared without a real understanding of the law or the court’s decisions, may serve the pur pose of promoting unreasonable and unreasoning discontent, but certainly ought not to be considered seriously. When an amendment Is proposed let the proponent state the defect in the s atute the amendment Is to rem edy, and how it will, effect It. If the avowed purpose is to make 1t impossible to use reason In the con struction of the statute as the su preme court did, let the mover of the amendment formulate a case of re straint of interstate trade not con demned under the supreme court’s construction of the statute, which ought to be condemned. Let us avoid general expressions. Let us avoid charges of improper motives. Let us come down to concrete cases and facts and make a showing for an amendment that a lawyer and a leg islator can understand and weigh, and not be content with mere rhetoric and language useful only for declama tlon. । (BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS.) FORT WORTH, Tex., Sept. 18.—It was announced today that Dr. F. E. Kershner of Princeton will be elected president of Texas Christian univer sity at the meeting of the board of trustees Tuesday. He succeeds Dr. Clinton Lockhart, who resigned last fall. Will Break Up Combinations. Elected University President, C. P. RODGERS IS INJURED WHEN BIPLANEFALLS Just After Starting Machine Strikes Tree and Drops to the Ground. INJURIES ARE NOT Repairs Can Be Quickly Made and Flight Will Be Con tinued Tomorrow. (BY THE AR8OCTATED PRESS.) MIDDLETOWN. N. T.. 8*P« 1« — In to resume his flight to the Pacific coast this morning. C. P. Rodgers crashed Into a tree and fell with hts aeroplane thirty-five to the ground. The airman received scalp wounds not serious, but his machine was wrecked so badly that ho probably will be unable to Dy until tomorrow. Baa Narrow Escape. Rodgers stuck to his scat during the plunge, but was thrown out when the machine hit the ground. He was pinned beneath one of the wings, just escaping being crushed to death by the heavy engine. At first it was thought he was fatally hurt, but after physicians had dressed his wounds he went back to the accident acene and worked with his helpers to ascertain the amount of damage. After the first Inspection he said that the engine could be repaired after the other broken parts could be supplied from duplicates in his special train. If obliged to send back to New York for another engine, he did not know how long he might be delayed. In any event he had no expectation of getting away again before tomorrow. The trans-continental racer arose before daylight today intending. If possible, to create a new distance record for one day’s flight. He left the ground at 6:16. Although there was little wind) he failed to get a good start and nearly striwk the four-foot stone wall surrounding the pleasure grounds from where he took ofh Then at a height of 20 feet one of his planes struck the limb of a willow tree. This threw him out of his course and he crashed full speed Into a hlg hickory just beyond. Fall Is Broken by Trees. The branches of the tree partly broke the force of his fall, but the machine came down so hard, headon. that the engine was partly buried in the soft ground. Rodgers was pulled from beneath hl’ plane still smoking a cigar he lighted just before the start. He was assisted to hfs special train which stood wait ing nearby with steam up. ready to accompany him on today’s journey,' over the Erle railroad. Rodgers landed here at 6:18 o'clock yesterday evening after making hie first day's flight from Sheepshead bay. about SO miles, In one hour and fifty three minutes. If all had gone well today he had hoped by Tuesday to pass his competitor. James J. Ward, who was delayed at Oswego, N. Y., by an accident last Saturday. Rodgers said that Investigation showed that the machine is practi cally ruined. Rodgers will return to New York this afternoon and make another a new aeroplane. t Ii T I Th ere is an uncommon ■Il |Lw R LU/w J |. soda cracker packed in I ■ I j I an uncommon way, I ■ I O'! I Uneeda Ifi I ■■■ ‘ ■ I ? i ■ H , H ■ S ===' ■ moisture-proof B EEEE | I /aYaa ■ I = ■ package ■ = I I Wxy/ I I I — I zzzzzz I I Xva ~' ■ I ~~ I I I 5® I = I I [ Uneeda . l = I | Never sold in bulk J . vpEEEE ''K I*' * V Biscuit 4| M I ■ W national biscuit a g I 1=3 I Always fresh— I । R W W COMPANY |= I crisp—good— J = I J IVW I c ' ean * Always ■ , HvJ ■ J ■ R wholesome. I I ImI 5c ' Iffl I iFil I. NATIONAL R I '*1R biscuit ■I 1 — ■ ■■■■ company THE SAN ANTONIO LIGHT in il m phia bamk SUSPfNOS BUSINESS My* Will Pay Dollar for Dollar Hut Ixiaaa on Real tkrtMo Cannot Be HeaUaed Now. (BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS.) PHILADELPHIA. Sept. II. — The Tradesmen Trust company, with a capital of 1*0,000 and deposits, when the last report was made of *1,>2*.000. dosed Its doors this morning. Peter Boyd, a well known attorney. 1s pres ident, having succeeded the late Mayor Samuel H. Ash bridge In the of fice when the latter died. The trust company Issued the fol lowing statementi "To the public: SERIOUS "The board of directors of the Tradesmen's Trust company have de cided to close the doors of the institu tion In order to protect the depoeltore, who, In the judgment of the directors, will receive dollar for dollar. "The Institution la Insolvent Its as sets, properly administered, will pay Its entire Indebtedness and leave a surplus for Its stockholders. The as sets are largely In the shape nf mort gages and advances on real estate, and while well secured, cannot be realised at once. Therefore, as a precaution ary measure In the Interests primarily of the depositors, the above action of the board was decided upon.” SCHAEFER —Carl Schaefer, aged 86 years, who came to San Antonio in 1*66. died yesterday afternoon nt the home of his daughter. Mrs. Jo seph Hierholzer, Alamo Heights, of old age. Mr. ti haefrr. before hla re tirement several years ago, was en gaged in both farming and dairying He was a widower, hla wife preceding him to the grave three months ago and had lived in the city sixty-seven years. The funeral will be held this afternoon. Rev. August Dldzun of the German Methodist church will of ficiate. and interment will be made in the family burial ground on the Salado. GRAY —The funeral services for Dr. Nettle G. Gray, wife of Dr. R. II. Gray, were held In the late residence. 310 Carson street. Sunday afternoon at 6 o'clock. Rev. J. H. Groseclose. pastor of the Government Hill Metho dist church, and Rev. V. A. Godbe.', pastor of the Travis Park Methodbt church, officiated. Services at the grave In the Mission Burial park wore conducted by the Royal Neighbors, of which Mrs. Gray was a member. The pall bearers were Drs. G. W. Johnson. J. D. Bell, A. R. Beal. L. K. Beck. W. C. Hirxel and M. J. BUem. KOZBOY —Mrs. Ethel Kozboy, aged 30 year?, died this morning at * o’clock, at her residence. 195 Rehmun street. The -funeral Sendees will be held from the home at 10 o'clock Tuesday morning. Interment will be made in the Orthodox Jewish ceme tery. We remodel ladles' suits. Abrams & Koenigheim, Conroy Bldg. Major Dickman at Post. Major Joseph T. Dickman. Inspector general of army posts in the Central division, arrived at Fort Sam Houston this morning. His visit is for the pur pose of making the tri-annual routine Inspection of money and property of the post quartermaster departments. Major Dickman will remain here for five or six days, following which be will return to Chicago, stopping at Galveston and at Intermediate points. OBITUARY A.SANTLEBEN, IN OLD PIONEER, passes my Injuries Sustained In Fall From Gallery Last Thursday Prove Fatal to the Aged Man, WAS WELL-KNOWN HERE Came to Texas Nearly Seventy Years Ago and Has Resided In the State Ever Since, August Santleben. 66 years old, a pioneer of Texas, died at his home, 1110 North Flores street, at 11:30- o'clock this morning. Injuries he re ceived when he fell from the second story gallery of his home Thursday night, the shock of the fall and ex posure are believed responsible for his death. Mr. Santleben fell while searching for some coins that had fallen to the gallery floor from one of hla pockets. He lay on the ground three hours be fore his groans attracted the attention of members of the family. An exam ination disclosed the fact that no bones had been broken, although Mr. Santleben had numerous cuts and bruises about the head and body. It was not believed hla Injuries were serious, but his condition rapidly grew worse until death came this morning. Wns Well-Known Cltlsen. There was possibly no better known citizen of Han Antonio than Mr. Hen- Heben. Born in Germany, he came with his parents when one year old -.o Texas. The family settled near Caa troville and Mr. Santleben waa a reel lent of Texas continuously from that :imc until his death. He took an active part In the af airs of the southwest during his youth ind ear'-y manhood and established a freight and stage Une from San Anto nio Into Mexico. The line extended as (ar as Monterey and Mexico City. In iddltlon to his activity In the commer cial life of San Antonio he became identified with the development of the entire state and assisted materially In its progresa. Fought in Civil War. When the Civil War began Mr. Santleben enlisted in the Third Texas cavalry and served In various cam paigns. At the end of the war he re turned to San Antonio and resumed his activity in the affairs of the city. He inaugurated the first mall service from San Antonio Into Mexico in 1866 and 1867. Mr. Santleben Is survived by seven 'sons and two daughters. The sons are Fred Santleben of Yoakum, Texas, Ferdinand, Henry, August, Carlos, Graves and Alfred, all of 8an Antonio. The daughters are Miss Ella Santle ben and Mrs. E. D. McAllister of San Antonio. He is survived by only seven grandchildren. Wrote “A Texas Pioneer.” In his later years Mr. Santleben found time to Incorporate Into a book a number of his experiences as a pi oneer of Texas. The book is entitled "A Texas Pioneer" and in It is to be found a vast amount of information concerning the development of the state and the men and women Instru mental in its progress. The date of the funeral has not been announced, but it will be h*ld within the next two days. Mr. Sant leben was a member of the Odd Fel lows and that organization will have charge of the services, which will be conducted by Rev. Arthur Jones of the First Presbyterian church. Tn- IS YOUR NAME UN OUR RUUKS YETf Hundreds are taking advantage of our exceptional values and unapproached service. We are specialists in our line of work. ’ Whatever we undertake we try to do exactly right. > 'BlagarSro&z tfumUXire Cor 301 EAST HOUSTON STREET terment will ba in the Odd Fellows Ce The* T p*H bearers will be Marshall Hicks. Selig l, « ut,chmani ?' Devine. Cilrlee Shiner. Albert Mejer and W»lter Napier. A. Collman. plumber. 616 Main Avs. Abrams T~Koenlghelm do high grade tailoring only ; Conroy Bldg. MIsh Hocmpke Out of Danger. Mis. Ruth Roempke. one of the vic tims of the auto-street car collision at Garden and Madison stroeU last Thursday night, and one of the most seriously wounded, was today reported by Dr T. T. Jackson, the attending nhyslclan. to be entirely out of danger Her rapid recovery is anticipated. Her sister. Miss Alfreds, who suffered a sprained back and several body bruises, was removed from the Santa Rosa hospital to the home of her father. A. I. Roempke. 822 Ogden street, yesterday. L. J. Kelly. Injured in the accident, is still at the Lee Surgical institute, but is much Im proved. Royal orchestra plays at the Sara toga restaurant dally. New -and exclusive weaves for la dles' tailoring shown at Abrams & Koenigheim. Conroy Bldg. Washington to Tour State. Under the auspices of the State Ne gro Business league. Booker T. Waah ington will begin at El Paso on Sep tember 25 a tour of the principal cities of Texas. He will reach San Antonio on September 26, and will speak to a mixed audience of both races on the evening of that date at Beethoven hall. It is the negro educator's purpose to Impress upon the members of his race the vastness of the opportunities of fered by the south and the south west and to promote harmony be tween them and the members of the ■white race. incinerator Agent Here. R. S. Waggoner, representing the Winn & Co. Sanitary company of Waco, arrived in the city this morn ing. He will endeavor to confer with Mayor Callaghan, some of the aider men and members of the board of health this afternoon relative to the establishment of a garbage Inciner ator here. SEPT. 18, 1811. • «' MW 'HUI A UMI Store Bas Been Remodeled and Show Room la Filled With BeaMtlful De signs In Fashionable Hata. One of the prettiest displays of tall and winter millinery which will be shown In San Antonio is on exhibition at the Edwards Millinery company on Commerce street today. The store has through the summer, been re modeled and enlarged, and the second floor is used exclusively for the trimmed hats. A pretty feature of the opening. Is the advance showing of hand bags to match the hats. These are ex tremely stylish In coloring and de sign. In the muff and hat sets, a scarf, muff and hat of pink, uncut velvet, covered tn chiffon, and trim med with fringe of gold cord and white kid was among the handsomest shown. A Paris model in black velvet, trimmed in chenile fringe and a bird of paradise, waa the prettiest of the Queen Mary style. A Georgette model was designed In a theater cap of silk tapestry, with a drape of Russian laoa and trimmed In mink fur and hand made, pink rose buds. A Kurzman Tam pattern was beautifully made In black and white, with trimmings of white chenile fringe, and an osprey of white aigrettes. A New York model by Madame Josse. was made of black velvet faced with blue, covered in hand-made white lace, and shaded with blue and plum colored plumes. The first floor shows the children's hats in every color and style, many of which are bonnet shape with high trimming, like the models for womep. French plumes, fur, lace and velvet are the most fashionable trimmings, and roses will be the favorite flower. The fitting rooms are furnished in white and gold and finished in pea cock colors. The store is decorated in palms and is thronged with admir ing women.