Newspaper Page Text
2 Heney Ignores Delmas' Challenge to Submit Case Without Argument | Continue! trom Pasfe 1, Col». 1, 2, 3 Steias had scarcely arisen from the witness chair when Heney turned to the court. • "That' is ' our"case. your I honor." ho said. ' , \u25a0 -..-»., ,; , "It is ours." returned Delmas so quickly that hie words sounded like aa echo of Heney's. S3SSS - There 'was i a sudden stllliiesß In -the t'ourtroom, broken, by . Judge;, L.svwlor*R order to proceed --to argument. ,Botb sides demurred, however.'because.ofth'o surprising tufn i» the case which had left 'them,- they declared,' unprepami. The court acceded to. the request' for ati.udjoiirnrnent and a recess was taken until . 2 o'clock, the requests -for in-, ptfuctions being filed beforft. th«> case was resumed. " Before adjournment was takSn Del mas .turned a 'neat point against the state by flinging an open challenge to Heney to submit the« caae-;;"withont argument. Unwilling to allow it to go to" 4 |hejury without a thorough sum ming, UP °' evidence Heney was forced to sweep aside his plans for the sec ond time and undertake the opening argument himself instead^of leaving it to Assistant District Attorney O'Gara and saving his own endeavors for the rebuttal, as -ho a .had intended- Fearing that should C'Gara address/ the -jury first, confining 'himself j, to" a logical discussion of the evidence, Delmas would utill' refuse to argue and^ so avoid the danger of Hexiex's power of damaging Abuttal, the chief attorney for the prosecution took the only; way oat of th«rpositlon he wan forcsd^lnto and elected to handle. both opening^and closing addresses himself. niCKEIUVKLL DRAWX IN Through the testimony given by Stelss In the morning the name of Man ager Pickernell, assistant to.thepresii' dent of the American Bell telephone company of Boston, the- parent com pany of the Pacific States, was -drawn into the case for the first" time; and it was apparent that the defejise;x as en " deavoring to throw the responsibility for Halsey's acts on his shoulders, at least fey implication. It "-^a^-- shown that his power extended over offl ctalg of the local company," anU, al though Heney attempted to -'establish that this authority was concerned^only with the physical management 'of the company's affairs, Coogan, in .his-"ad dress to the jury, made a strong', pblnto of Pickernell's presence In the city at j the time the telephone bribes were paidr'j The auditorium of the Temple Israel was crowded to the doors when the af ternoon session was called, and again in the evening the seating capacity of the big courtroom was taxed. -In the throng were scores of women, and neither they nor the men who composed the audience -were of the class from •which the usual court loungers are drawn. Xot only were, there prominent attorneys and professional men by the dozen in the vast audience, but there were society men, clubmen and repre sentatives almost in legion of the wealth and social life of the city, drawn to the place as much on account of the prominence of tbe defendant at the bar as because of the fame of the opposing attorneys. The balconies of the.audi torium as well as the. main floor -were tilled with listeners, but' the audience was quiet and undemonstrative. ?. GLASS SITS "WITH BOWED HEAD t 1 In the pew in the rear of his attor- ' neys. Glass sat bowed as though pray ing while he was in turn excoriated by Heney and lauded by Coogan. . W^Ui bis arms outstretched over the rear of the seat in front of him, and his -head buried in his hands, he gave indication feut once or twice during the whole day that his being was steeped in the battle progressing; between the attor neys a few yards away from him.,Onc<v jrnen Coogan referred feelingly to his friendship. for his client, \u25a0declaring that n'e hoped to fight for the latter's vin dlcation until every taint; of had been removed from his name, Glass raised his head and touched his hand kerchief to his eyes, in which tears were glistening. ;--\u25a0? Heney opened, his address with a low- Tolced, calm, deliberate statement to the Jury of the duty devolving on the prosecution .to seek out . and punish crime and a concise explanation of the facts to be decided In determining the question of guilt. Then, with a sudden burst of indignation as he turned tbe attention of the jury from the abstract to' the detail of the facts presented by the events of the trial and the sub stance of the testimony "Introduced, he threw every atom of his power of ter rible denunciation into his words, hurl ing invective after Invective at \u25a0 wit nesses, -attorneys and defendant. Hia face flushed with . the fervor of his ut terances, perspiration dripping from his forehead, his hands clenched an'l his whole body trembling with the tension -of thought and. expression, he .was the personification of earnestness There was.no attempt at polished rhet oric no elusive . appeals to sentiment or sympathy, but driving, forceful pre sentation of fact built on fact, of con clusions logically drawn from the-tes timony \u25a0 adduced during the trial, and contemptuous flings vat the tactics of the men whom he charged with de bauching Ban \ Francisco and debasing the courts of justice.. From virulent attack Heney lapsed, to &xci us i v :t e No Branch Etorei. Xo Agents. WE STUDY INDIVIDUAL: FORM IN THE TREATMENT OrFITTjNG; TWENTY DiSTINCT: MODELS USED IN STYLING OUR f CLOTHES; THE, JFABBICS/ARE jfODUCTS FROM THE WORLD'S BEST LOOMS, THE MOST EXCLUSIVE TO BE HAD. HALL-WINTER SERIESARE READY SHOWING UNDENIABLE MERIT. • - ; \u25a0' ; - -, " '-'I We nue et* ry facility, attmla» bl « '.| ?^ to s*ll \u25a0 tl># ' best : ni«ii'i clothes mad? . J\Here yen .fifid' brain and . quality ' mrrped. v/'Gwkl, taet^ful dressers . \u25a0will apprw-Ute .that \u0084; i^our *Mttlon«thi« eeaaoc.were eitraordlnar^. y Erery patteria and ' model U entirely "new, "'.-: fontalolnp a "GoldCrtd; 'of Style,*' f_obllteraUo« frcait aod-frillg of ; '»ll kinds. oa the cl»the« qnwtlon,' try ours. ii - ' King Sol6mon ? s Hall Fiyimore St. near Sutter Sta n Franciscoi quiet sarcasm, picturing the super vißors groveling: at' Halsey'a ' feet, ac ceptlngr his invitations to} wine idinners and 'opening the "way for' the, advances i which Halsoy was but , too - ; anxious Jto j make,-. There was no; vociferation "in this : part of the , address; but the con^ tempttious sneers were ; plain, and once a ' laugh, 1 : joined : In by some of . the y jur ors,' rippled , over;, the courtroom '". in ' ref eponse to -his' sugrgestive- references; to 1 the motives and plans of the telephone company and Its officials. \u25a0 .Zimmer's action in.refusing: to testify waß stigmatized by' Heney in th^most. violent terms, and he' laid the:reß)ponsi billty for, the act directly at 5 the door of tHe defendant's"; attorney. In summing: up the case, after a logical drawing/of the points in. evidence, he declared' that : the only defence advanced; from begin ning to end in Glass' behalf, was "based by the attorneys.. on" "the belief that \u25a0 without Zimmer's f testimony it;' would be .impossible", for v -the. prosecution ,to ( prove beyond a reasonable; doubt that 1 Glass ordered Halsey ; to pay the money, I j to the supervisors, and that in case this failed, the defense relied upon the pos sibility of error committed during the ! progress of the tial. / : ' Delmas did : not* even, appear in the courtroom during ' Heney's; argument, nor while - his . associate, ?Coogan, . was i making .the opening argument for j the ! def ense, y , ljut Attorney ",McPlke stated j that Delinas was ill and that ; no dis- '] respect .was intended? by his absence.] Judge Lawlorv BUggc jied. that an ab sence to "prepare for the closing ad drees .would be. a* matter •of "course and > would not be censured by^the court. STATE'S CASE COMPI.ETE3 That one-hoyr of Delmas'; eloquence ! must save Glass if anything Is to do no is attributable; solely, to the sound- j ness of the state's circumstantial case j at^very point,' utld | not to any lack of | logical argument; by Attorney Coogan. ; The latter handled the case smoothly l and directly, but with little, on which ! to base an open- attack* and with no j loophqlejoff erlng^itaelf x he did : not suc-^ ceed impenetrating ! the complete armor of corroboratlon' with whtlch Heney has established ev^ry * essential fact in connection with the. charge. ' Coogan-rnade_no effort Ho refute the ] testimony -of -the .supervisors, and vlr- j tually t admitted 7 the 'payment of the . bribes tij. them. by. Halsey, for his every i argumsnt;;presupposed . « such ; ' bribery, I and {only - direct .Words ,of admission were; lacking. His contention; in*l>rlef, jwai^that as long ': as . a 'possibility re mained of Glass' innocence, the jury, couid not convict, and all the stress of his logic was. brought Into play to con vince the Jurors that,; at least from a technical standpoint, a reasonable doubt of " the defendant's guilt must survive the _ prosecution's case. i : Coogan's delivery was quiet and in strong "contrast to the flre-of ;Hertey's preceding argument. He referred: to Glass* long 'business life, to his . own friendship " for the defendant, and ' he appealed to the Jurors individually, calling, them by name, to search their own* hearts for any trace of "doubt be fore returning a verdict "of conviction. When Coogan concluded after an hour's argument in the afternoon and 30 min utes In the evening, given to a rebuttal o£ Heney*^ contentions/Assistant Dis trict Attorney O'Gara ' petitioned . the court to be allowed to answer '. him ; at once. Both Coogan and McPike ob jected to allowing the, prosecution^ an Intermediate argument, and after a short examination :* of the' statutes Judge Lawlor ruled that the final re buttal only would be allowed. HEXEY'S WORDS TO JURY In' his opening argument Heney talked an hour and forty minutes. He said: Gentlemen of the Jury: Yon probably. all wish that ;i; had accepted " Mr. Delmas' proposal .. aad •abmttted' this case to you without argument, and I ' would have • done jso except , that ; I . feel '.It my \ duty as : the ; attorney ? for i the . people I to ; present this case \u25bato \u25a0 yon In - Ita .'fullest vform. -. H'ou 'are here cs citizens - under -a i republican form gof government,"' doiug 'yonr^daly as • yon ; are 'called' opW to do it, though 'four own time'; has been sacrificed and ; taken i up. 5 You * are hero r , to pee justice done, : to see : that uo . man ia ; rallroad</d, and that this defendant is accorded his rights. On the other hand yon niv here to see that the law which demands | the punishment of criminals Is upheld, and 'that it canuot be ' debased ; nor owned by .this defendant or anybody else.,., . It is the duty of the attorneys to "aU yon in recalling ; the evidence that has been : presented and assist yon in connecting the integral' parts of the testimony that yen have^ heard." In a long trial * like this,' which has extended over several days; it is easy to forget a part of the testimony produced, and it is my duty to assist yon In summing it up " end - seeing this case as a' whole." ..'-.-.\u25a0\u25a0'-.. .-. -, : s', - \u25a0.-/-..\u25a0:„ \u25a0 The question before you to decide" Is whether or not the > defendant. Glass, bribed the \u25a0 super visor," Charles Boston, by: paying him $5,000 to Influence bis .vote 5 In : a matter then and th*re pending before . the board \u25a0 of supervisors,: which was ; concerning ; the . application \u25a0\u25a0' of the Home telephone company for the sale: of a franchise. Now, did Glass pay Boxton that money? M a matter of - course, u\ I - outlined •- to , you ; In > toy opening statement, \u25a0• we J did : not Intend \u25a0to i show that U lass 'banded Bex ton that money. But if Glass aided or ; « betted ' Halsey : in paying . that moneyxbe, is Just «s ruilty as Halsey Is; if lie <irdcred or directed': liitlsey'. to': pay it his 'guilt Is equal to that of: Halsey. And that: Glass d'.tj so aid and direct does 'not have to be proved 'to yeni by > direct testimony, alone, .; but c*n ;; b* proved with i the nld o£ clwjin's Lantla I evidence. This is. true because; as yea can sec by the'ac lion. Of Mr. , Zlmmer^ in this case, It is no dl f ficolt' thing ' to \ torn . a 1 i^nltenilary < off rim» ; Into a mere: misdemeanor, the >, extreme? panls'inU-nt for which ia a flight term of six months in jail, and so defeat the. ve/y. foundation or jLstlcf. ; "~ -.:. HONZBT MEJT SHOULD -BLUSH : \ When a man of « wealth and position 'cka % Mr« a • clerk or— an anderllng in , his i office— a man willing to give up bis liberty and go to Jail to serve bira— when be can hire nuch a man. to. do this 'tWnk; Tt would sot ! be hard |to defeat f Ju«-" Uce ' if it were allowed \ that . his act should be passed over ' unnoticed : and }, that .-; the i evidence which thta < witness ; alone y could \ gite ) directly should i sot be • secured : through 1 other channels. If ench . a spectacle ! of ! the degradation * of i a court is permitted,' lf such a thing can b« done with im munlty i when -It amounts, • as does < this thing,, to * anarchy, then I cay /that ': a ma n can go Into the • streets and j com mit, murder : and fbe unpunished. . :; If \u25a0 attorneys ; can > Instruct ' a;.; wlt» ness to do as Zlmmer has done," then t attorneys can not only allow, but aid a man who has com mitted a foul murder to go from this. courtroom free. ; ..- ,- '\u25a0.'.-\u25a0.';\u25a0 / : -. . .-: ' ,'-; *• y. : ; It oopht to bring the Mush of shame to every honest fare that ' a man : licensed , to practice; the profession of • the - law ; and sworn •to support * tbe constitution ' of his . nation . and - the \ laws , of \u25a0' his state : should order, a' witness , to do such | a thing as this— to tell him that be can refuse to answer a , question ; because * he ; fears what' the effect •of I that witness*: answer will be. t As algnlflcant as any ' circumstantial .- fact * that * I shall \ bring ,; to your ; attention ' was ; this action of ;tne \ witness Zimmer in refnsing;to testify;:.' I -called; him to the stand -and he refused to answer; my ques tions.-- >v:, «.:''.'- ~-~" : , : - ..;"."\u25a0.".\u25a0. \u25a0 - :\u25a0;•<\u25a0 Does Mr. , Zimmer refuse to" testify upon . the ground that \ his evidence would ' tend .. to subject him to prosecution 'for afelony? No. He said that . his evidence . would \u25a0: not f incrlminat* i him. -Why. did not thedefense show. that fact? ; There is only one Inference : possible. * fils i testimony I would . tend *to Incriminate ; Louis r , Olass.' r < There I Is ' no other Inference possible. Who s bad a mo- 1 tlv« .to ; make 1 Zlmmer :\u25a0 commit ; a ;. misdemeanor j tnat : has \u25a0 «<nt : him ', to j Jail? "% When s a* crime Xls committed. thTe is always a. motlTe;:' r We ? M>6k in : Tain \u25a0- for ' a motive , for; Zlmmer' s ' offensn until we " enwranter " the ;' flgure •• of ,-; Ixrais c* Glass. ; slf Zlmmer ; had , answered , yes ; to 'our .'question \ about Glass ' tbe . def endao t < would * have \u25a0 been . convicted directly ion f direct ? eridence. ;^, But ',., Zimmer j pre ferred,to go to Jail. v. Who/; In, God's name fit* { by ; Zimmer's ;\u25a0 silence t a Loul* { Olass;v;2 2im- ! mer ; Is . Trilling ,' to go ; to ? Jkil ; for. flve? days ; twloe ! and oncefiforone'day. and'pay'a'nnefot $500 for I Glass. It is loyalty > to l tbe? man* lh i the i corpora tion where Zlmmer worked his way up ward from \ oftceboy. to auditor, and flnairy,vtee'presldentr*-*| -V- : \u25a0 wiTKEsaES^AaB }. evasive ;; ; . : ; : T--(: : ] ... What other; inducement , Zlmmer. may have} to* I copsole " him ..for i bla" imprisonment \u25a0 I , ; , doV not i know, ; but ' yon •' can \u25a0: imagine. ;. ; You ; : can :. lnfer from - your i knowledge of ., men = and life end : . hu- 1 man nature, . Why,j was t It? imperative -to , have Zlmmer ; refuse : to .testify ? \u25a0' Because t aa ! you • have seen • from clrcnmstan tial (evidence,*? the ; link I be^ tween * Haleey s 1 and the „; supervisors might kbe missing •In 5 the . chain I which i surrounds \u25a0 this i de fendant. But we have the date* upon which the cheeks were draws ' and 'we have the 'date* I upon which i the ''money ? was ! paid by j Hal sey >to the supervisors.', *\u25a0 Sanderson has : testified howl he | was told to go to the office r In the ; MI1U ; bnllding , to get his share of the booty ' and , that » fact ; will -THE SAN FRAIS^ISCO CALL^ FRIDAY, JULY 26, 1907. account for the ' disbursement ; of the ; entire . $50, "- 1 000, T whlcb - was > ; drawn .* out % of j: the .bank ? by j checks • signed * by) Louis ; Class.'^TA S ' long; as . Zlm-' j nierfdld \u25a0; not f testify * the'- prosecution c would :"- be \ forced ' to i f ely S upon ' circumstantial ?• etldence." f i - { ~- j .. HasUhero :beenVa|ningleiwltneßßifor.;the*de- j fense ". who : baa \u25a0 appeared j; on/s the "\u25a0 stand I and Tan^ | swered * promptly : and i frankly | the i question J put ? ! No. - : \u25a0 ETaslon.V forpetfulnesS t and I more;; evasion j has? characterized: all «thelr4 testimony; one; has j eren | gone | so' far, as ! to commit perjury, k but ; of a nature j that cannot i be- proven, ;• 1 1 4 ls <a ; matter | of memory; and who '. shall' say ; what that - wit netw*.reallyf,thinks?'.- . , - . •\u25a0-::. \u25a0"- •-;.";"'\u25a0 - : " ; ,W* have seen " from Uhe r testimony, how : Cashier Kennedy ' started i ont ' by. 1 saying I he? couldn't < re member. , Then '\ he ; fixed .' the ; sum f- at i J50.000, but ' he: tried to ring; In stock itaxes;to^fllltlt! up.' Fortunately •, there ijwas to : show that tills 1 was;not!"so.*?The transaction; in 'sjtock was ' simply .; a , hook j a ffalr, < a . mere transfer; from onei account ;to;«oother.': .*;>;' >5 f.' When \u25a0 we. forced Kennedy, ; pressed fand I pressed him— -pressed hard-— he > admitted ! that ! there | were four!- 510.000 -checks r and :k: k two ;. : $3.000 ; checks. There, was' no stock t4x '\u25a0\u25a0 In It' after all. J; But yon see * how,;Kennedy,f too,"; tried :to' - - squirm r^V He J wanted Ho protect : . Glnss^. and > his > memoty '.was j bad. fy He * »ald-.he believed"; those-; checks \u25a0. were i drawn in March.'- -Why • March ?.' ? l • ' j "BAYS i KENNEDY \u25a0IS ''\u25a0 A": PERJURER ' - y J I - asked him t who he talked to after tfivtng ! his i testimony . before the •' grand \u25a0 jury.' ' *He ' said -< Kreuseand Sinlth.*Ci'~; . :,\u25a0 Z; ' r ; ,'; Do yon. want to know. who this Kreuse is? He [ was Halney'D assistant in tliat room In the Mills bulldlntr." where .they stw the supervinors. ; \u25a0..': \u25a0'. " | ..And this man Smith. ' Who is he? Why. Olass*. j prltate secretary.* ;~* : ; -^. •V ; .:-V '. J These are ; the : two men 'Kennedy admitted hay- \ lag ' talked -to after : the Indictment. ;j He '< talked \ to " no ; others, : according '; to s his " own 5 testimony." . That's -whyi'hV: remembered -that* that $50,0Q0 j worth ' of checks were drawn ' lu March.; Why ' did j he ? do: it?." 'Because . those " bribes .were Riven; In I February.' . ' " J jffliH T |jj\^Vj!i T ~ij ilh l ">. " " " ' " " i ' : ""' : -;','.! ' j a : And "' to A save : Glass ? he" deliberately perjured j himself— committed ; perjury, • perjury \u25a0• he % cannot -; b« punished : for because -he\\» -' careful to < make it only^bell*f-^to>save his'chle,f. "\u25a0'"/ -. He Ua<l been told aud knew ' that this i case had-.to be butlt. upon rclrctlmotantiar evldonce. after- Zlmmer. was .corrupted,*, and. hc J :do liberately chose •to neck ; tUe i degtruction : of one of the -Important! links,:: the ,\ date 'of \ those chccfeK. . The same influence ' unclertook 'to cor rupt • him ;that ; corrupted \u25a0 Zlrnmer and r Krauae. : '; . We have i>een trying • to ', fix I the Mates ; when the \u25a0\u25a0\u25a0 money s was , paid T to " the t supervisors ,' in the Mills building-.* i TUe '\u25a0\u25a0 defense '- does " not < want \to help in this little matter. : " Why ; did they at tempt to' show that the ;-. occupancy of the offices In ; the Mills i building .; was .at i : some other time than 5 that which | It* really; was?J The reason is that | the ;bank account |of the- Pacific telephone company cannot be erased ', nor - ; wiped out. "'.The T books : of \u25a0' ttie . bank '\u25a0 are ; aTailable and show with damning , accuracy when s four check? of 110.000 : were \u25a0\u25a0- paid .to g. the company and two of 15,000. .' , 1>" •_' BBIBES PAH) IN CTXEItENCY 'This was the . money ' that v the ' supervisors got and " they - got -it when '•> the ' rooms •\u25a0 in '\u25a0- the Mills " building i had ," been .-. rented by *. the com pany and the rooms •ft&e Mills were rented when the checks were drawn. 1 That vls why. the " witness • failed • to _ remember..* whether It was January or "February that. "the :' Mills building apartments were : taken by . the r tele phone company. ' But /Kennedy,^ after- ho -had squirmed 'and sweat, Vflnnlly,* remembered - that it was some" time " in : February when > $10,000 returned money .was ; placed " on tags. :; This was the ' money \u0084 that , some : of : the . supervisors ;" re turned * because -.-' they - could . not '\u25a0:-. deliver '\u25a0- the goods ; to the Pacific company.: But ' does ; Ken-" nedy. : remember whether c the . money :\ was \u25a0, cur rency or^ coin ? No. - •He ', forgets v that detail." Why? , Because he does'; not want;,, it . to" be made of - record that the : money ; came back .In the denom inations and kind of coin that . we hare shown was .; pild : to ; the .eupervißors.',"".;•\u25a0:. eupervißors.', "".;•\u25a0: Why did Kennedy =-- avoid f. an answer? Be cause he i knew only too ; well i that ? the ' $10,000 was a ' part ' ooff f the ; $50,000 ; that , had | been •- paid to the supervisors? to . keep T< them -"friendly. 'V Then i after . Kennedy had ~ read ;". the testimony jhe : had - Ki^en • before'" the. ; rrarnl ;* jury •he V re- I called after all- that it ; wes currency. s ; -_;; .: ; Let's 'go l back ' a moment. _'! Did . Boston s get money * from the room" in : the : Mills "\u25a0 building? Was< fit « paid to him : for- the ; purpose '< of f lnflu-^ enclng his vote? . -* This \u25a0 seems ;so ;> thoroughly apparent that ; it is;; hardly ..necessary ;' to * take up the time going o ver \u25a0 it. But let us look. #%\u25a0"\u25a0 In June,; 1903, a : number ; of , people Installed a . competing • telephone \u25a0; plant, in •; Los \u25a0 Angeles. They gave; such improved: service*! that the - old. monopoly ' company \u25a0- was ;• alarmed. '..-.Then i they, came to San Francisco I with ': an J application jto the supervisors for^a* franchise. \u25a0• \u25a0\u25a0• ,-v.-,. '\u25a0;..: '.' .-' The ; law provides : that ' when % the '\u25a0 supervisors are, asked for a ; public : privilege ; the , board shall advertise -it for . sale ' and [ . then ; sell \u25a0 it to :\u25a0 the highest ;;bldder; : ,v .- --~"";7; ..;;.\u25a0/;\u25a0 BOSTON PUT ON . BALARY/HOIX^ i" ; ; Sir. Pillslniry, -'bn»-|-ot : tbu": largest - stock -hold ers ,of ;fhe?old . eorporatlon-fnndj'a'r member* of I ts i executlre \u25a0 committee, ; told 'i you *on ?, the""- 1 stand that .'he> went t to\the';> officers \ them I that sunless - : ; the service Vpf \u25a0 the c Pacific ; States ! telephone company . was^' Improred \u25a0; competition would be ,! sure >to come ia : and " cut * down i its pro&tS. ; \u25a0 : . \u25a0 • . \u25a0 ' ..' r» '".; \u25a0 ;','\u25a0'- \u25a0 '-,\u25a0 '. ; \u25a0' ', ~ . '\u25a0 \. . t i The : service was so poor ; and '.its /improver ment ; so remote that-; Pillsbury -; feared ;,; a > com-, pcting ;• company would I come , in I and I its | services would be so ; gladly .. welcomed that . the , old«com pany. • would •• receive '•; a i tremendous r- blow. ;', ". He advised \u25a0> improvement ; at : cflceV- in ' the ™ serrice,'* which the people •of San - Francisco were ; forced toput up' With. \.- .. \u25a0 -•\u25a0; .; : . \u25a0\u25a0'\u25a0' ',;_' . . \u0084' | - But what ? did they do? They took Boston I and put him " on ' salary ; to be friendly, to ; them- \ i to see. that, no measure passed * the boards which* would hurt .;. them. • \u25a0'\u25a0\u25a0 That 'A was - bribery. ; '. They began - bribing '• far back fin • 1&05 to keep put competition.. \u25a0\u25a0-..\u25a0: .-.; \u25a0.' • ; ". ;\u25a0: Do : ; yon .suppose .that;* Mr/.,' Glass,' the -;-,Tice president '; and V» 1 general /. manager of ; the ; company, did not - know i that • moneys was being : paid ; out . for ; tb Is purpose,'- did not ; know what was common' knowledge- among the :"citi zens of; tliiK \u25a0. city, ; people ? whol were m ot; at ull Interested, that . there -was I money . for;-; the' mv-" niclpal officials 'Jn I keeping \ competition | out ?I'\ I .-\u25a0 San ~ Francisco ~t ltt\ the; center, |the ' keynote,"" of the '\u25a0\u25a0 telephone " situation > on ? the * coast.»<,We z'all know; where •\u25a0 the big \u25a0; profits tof i the"; telephone business ; come from. \u25a0\u25a0 :. Those ', ; who =»-;, pay exorbitant ; tolls r on ' long '\u25a0. distance;:; messages know • their.', source. -^ It _ Is ; ImpossibltV ' that \u25a0; Mr. Glass."., the ; general < manager >'\u25a0 of '\u25a0 the '£ company," its % responsible " head,; did - not know.- what $ was being done: to keep' hold !of the" tremendous buftlnegg. •-\u25a0\u25a0-\u25a0\u25a0;\u25a0... \u25a0\u25a0 ' .-' . \u25a0 \u25a0.»-\u25a0.' ;\u25a0 ;.. .'-., . \u25a0 :- - .r .\u25a0;\u25a0 :"•\u25a0;• The defense is v that he didn't, c. Yet ho 'was the i only man ; that could sign s those : checks jor authorize C their r Issue. Is it i possible s that -'• 11 that S money could hare' gone , to - Halsoy ; without his kbOwledgC? .-'\u25a0\u25a0\u25a0' ;..,•; * : • :;-.; CHECKB a TEACED TO \u25a0.GLASS.; : , Was ' Glass ' asleep . that he did \ not ' know what was going on ; In San Francisco? ',; As manager iof a s great "; telephone 5 system f. In I this I center, from which so ; much \u25a0 business I radiates,; Is It likely- he did not know, every move of Importance that was made? ; • Mr. | Plllsbury ils I injected ! In i \u25a0: this i case a* '. thel last ; resort ,to ( divide \u25a0 responsibility, ni But who was general manager? The answer Is I»uls Glass.; 1 DM s he haye \u25a0»\u25a0 assiatanti? Q. Yea ? he s had assistants.*^ PiUsbury was atked ; these ' questions. He t was * also • asked '\u25a0'; If > he ; knew > Halsey. v Cer tainly: he j knew>Halg*y, jbut j Haleey was subject to Glass.; Instruct Ions ; anfl I formerly^ to the ! orders of \u25a0 S«bln. ; Mr. Halsey >. was i under. Glass ; and > was looking , after I the? polities iof - the J company. ,'\u25a0\u25a0> He was the political ' agent, V and was i taking ' care ! of the opposition ;\u25a0; which T might ) : be?' brought V in^ by rival \ corpora tioM.-, i'^i T \u25a0 • ---vA' • . -.* '• ' ; :-.'.;•:'• -•- ?•'\u25a0 Was * Halsey ian \u25a0 Independent .; man ? -.-\u25a0 Was *he taing ' care 'of \u25a0 bin I" owo> lnterests? '".Was ; he Jex pending his c»fn: money ?i- N0.%~ Halsey could^not get \ one P dollar^ without ; Louis 1 Glass' -. signature. Glass,'' by; the process of elimination, could have been V the ' onJy^ man J who * could y bate ;'slgned 5 the' checks » that \ produced I the I currency i wl th >1 which the superTisore j. were] bribed."^ If j Zlmmfer signed for ; the i president,"! he 'signed ; for • Glaßs,l but > the defense '.will mot!r not ! put , Zlmmer, on 'the f stand.*^, Zlm mer! could 5 sign ifor | the | president.;^. Who ', imag lnes / that '\u25a0: Zimmer Jauthorlred i'Hilsey.i 1 to J ppend this ' $50,000 ? S Would f. Zlmmer » do '; such <a^ th Ing without \u25a0;. consulting J his C Superior, ? Glass ? x<m know,;Be"|couldsnot.VVj^",jv-; -.-y ;: i ; ..'.;->•:'". "'." '. '•-;: '-.-\u25a0 Now;, what *doiwe /. find sin { the s; testimony of Henryi!Klng?BWesfind*thi*:;v- - ' ; ;-; '_ VQuestion-^-Wbat ' officers s besiflei • Eaton could Sign * checks? ' ?V", :: ; ?#%;\u25a0\u25a0• - i ' I *«."* • : '"-\;?'''"f .•'\u25a0/. '"\u25a0 : : - -..'v:: ' f 7 •"Answer—The president; and rice president." I:i Does he ; say,; Zimmer? '; Its never ? occurred \u25a0to hlm,toAay; Zlmmer. .\u25a0''*/\u25a0' \u25a0 - \u25a0 * Kow," who : was president* ig that ?,: Louis GltMi* : Vie* i President J Scott' «ai4j flat * footedly i that t he never ;' signed * those t checks. v? X ing n asked 4 him : x "Dld . you i authofije » any.; one] to : sign | them JfA.'-v '**: I'No, V - he -replled^-i'not I until i after ; the \u25a0 fire. '•/?-. iS Lf ' that ' were j not i true j they] emild i have ! put ~> a witness 5 on T; the T etond | to s prove g itfef But p they didn't do | tbat-*|iThey i couldn't,*t{So S that 'sso,ooo conld j only | have | been ' taken ' out f of ' the 1 telephone treasury/ byj authority| of I Glass: X Back* ml 1605] th'eyi learned (ot jthe plan of '• the Home * telephone ! company ,5 to i cofne « up ' here ; and compete.^ Theyjknewithat|thetpeople| who* had been compelled', to accept their; inefficient i service would : welcome I !t,li that the Home ; wns |at means of releasing ;,thl» f city ; from Sits X helpless! position *\u25a0 and:iknowmg:that;;iwhat did£thty;do? , " ;'. There \ has| been :-. talk of - blood houndafc^^r ' YOSBMITBJg VALLEY Is t now .• reached \ byj the I Yosemlte Valley railroad.*? No f and; du«ty^ eta«- ing.T; spend j&your&vacatjonl among 4 the cliffs, crags | and! lovely waterfalls, now at i thelri beatrronlyii a Kew^ hours s f rom San > Francisco.?* Sixty,; miles ! of ;the i wild ; Merced j? (Cal.) S river s canyon £ ens route." $ 18.50 if orithei round; trip, from Merced. Cal.T Write i 0.t W.1 Lehmer," traffic ' man- ager, Merced.iCal. • • , extortion, rof ..'greedy city officials;, holding up j and - shaking \u25a0 down : the -telephone ' company.'"-. Were .they A held s up-^-held 5 up * from 'i keeping | all 1 the business i and ? going f on s giving ; bad'^serviee ? V Yes ; but .that Sis | all. I??; The J evidence i shows i that i they .went deliberately "• into?, the" i field -", to c debauch, corrupt J and ? undermine I the ; government jof |this City.', to disgrace It and Jiold ; 1 1 ' up ' to ; shame and to > the i horrified ? d isgust of? com ing . generations as the i mbst s defiled ? city: in * lilstory.;;^-:'. 'V* .";'.' J**°At ', whose door ' can 1 - you' lay ' the'dlsgrace' of . the graft 5 revelations?^ kot i at : the j door -of .\u25a0 those . pobr.t weak fsupervisors \ who sold ; their, souls," and who ; are, now,; paying; the ' price Vof dishonor.; in j the "contempt 1 " of i those s who s'once :,were ' thelr| friends and, the life long distrust of itheir fellow^cltlzens* . you? cannot f^layj It » at-< their "doors,*|* but v at 'those; of Ithe 5. riches cpnscieneelesß,* greedy ra tlons£which'ii p'aldf punyj^prices <to > grafters ; for Rinnethlng i to i which '..they } knew| they 4 were \ not entitled;nThey,j invited * the ? ; poor^ fellows i out %to lunch \ and % bought %. sauierne ,- to J wash %It f down.". Then ! they ; got ! them, 11 - and ' disgraced f them 1 ana our city. *!:-,vv "-.*;-. v ---'"• .".' ; '.'. " \u25a0; i "' ; '' "'\u25a0 ::. r \u25a0\u25a0-:.""'"' '.isThere are. 100,000 ' men in, this. city .who might prove ; as "weak :j as » these siipervisoM/ who took bribe ; money 5 and l^ in • whom": these \u25a0 corporations^" public < service ! corporations— created a .- greed • for money.^;-:.; : '> : 'x-i"i\ r ,>:: ;\u25a0\u25a0"\u25a0\u25a0\u25a0\u25a0 ' \u0084 \: . : ;;" ; : f .> They -wlli" be j elected to [office, and ,the , same ] "corrupting V. agent '.that - dishonored ' the y present \ I city : government s win " seek ; to » dcstrOr them.* It < i will 'f approach r them « In , tlie * same '; subtle ": way,"/ ! steal -\u25a0; their?;: souls*, arid .. defile ; their i clean r- con- V [ sciences."".- They.; talk *. about : being J held \ up " by. • !•' grafting -supervisors, t For what , did ; they ; Buy i i their * votes 1-j For 'what ; did :\u25a0 this .- despoiled 7cor- I j poration^ buy^each*',: vote, 'make : the | supervisors | I "friends',* » one \ by • one ? ,- <l t ; bought : them \ so ;. that j the |5,Q00 ; it * paid i to ' each ! mtent ; be \u25a0 sloubied \or I trebled^ or : quadrupled '] and go into ' its own;pock !:ets, "/> It *• bought-, and -paid;- for; the • supervisors for.'no' other i purpose. :'" "- ' '^" : :; ' i ; ".^y'' : GEEED^PHOMPTS BRIBERY \u25a0•'\u25a0'" " j : ,Whov was f the". president' in ; fact? ! There She I Sits.. >; There . kv the "man. Glass: •/ .\u25a0.-.'• ;/: !,; If; the, t supervisors 'were /bought y for $5.,000 ; apiece/ ; why *; did ~ that ' man ;"buy;,them?j"- For \ God's ; Sake \u25a0 why: did ihe "do i t ? * I" II " tell you^ \»h y, he ; those ; poor > fellows. -, He : bought- them because ,w for; every -j £5.000 he : paid lie espeo.t'ed to .make j f or . his ; company $500,000. .Then ; with • a portion. of this money /Jingling in his pocket*; he could Igo j his : ; fellows \in \ broadcloth ; « be could live Jat j the clubs ; |he could ; wine \ and ! dine ; he could^posejbeforeubesocial'world as a leader and as ' a ; representativen ta tive of good citizenship,' \u25a0; He could , assume ", this'! attitude ' successfully and be a general .> In / the 5 forces ,of :j "good A government'!: whenever some political boss got in his way. and would > ; not ". give ;:him ». the ,: things *;\u25a0 he "wanted.- I : These 'conditions would ; fill ' my soul with \u25a0\u25a0 disgust I at democracy ; if ; l: did not believe.'in the'ulti- I mate .;• triumph ;• of >. right ; and I would -", have I vomlt ! ln!reply,tothe contentions of the defense lin s this matter; ; > is ;\u25a0 These ;' poor ., fellows i who have passed ?to -, the witness ; ; chair fare "confessed .:' criminals ; '£\u25a0 Louis Glass;; is Van, unconfessed criminal. ?He ;is ;" the, greateV : felon. ' Who was'it that. made,Boston r a criminal ? •./« Who - Was ';-, it , that V made V* Furey.-t a i criminal ? > -And 2 Lonergan and . each - and '\u25a0 all ; of | these -wretched', men?. -There", he sits! .- . ; ;: ! ... .Who ; made these 'men criminals and fed them \ with J» for a money ? \u25a0\u25a0•"> Who T was * it .\u25a0 that i created : an \ appetite 'In them for : filthy - coin and . : then j led : them ; on and on and on until " they .sold your, city, and mine ; when she sat In ashes.deso-' late?. Who was it that brought these poor men to ; the 'heights 5 and showed: them ' wealth "and ; ; made I I them crazy iuntlliiß-theJrlust;forgain:theyßold : ! theirlcityiandtyotar.'city in'the overhead trolley. j Bteal? for f s4oo,ooo?^' \u25a0.•\u25a0 • ;-\u25a0; . '": : .' |Si Assuming f that '.tbe' : city needed ;. the, overhead I I trolley J and *\u25a0 that |it j was ;a ; good , thing 4 for i all !. concerned ;t to > permit ?- ; the ;! stringing L- of T- these j wires "along; our streets; .why: not ;glve the money | to^ the j city,; which • needed ."lt^ao \u25a0 sorely ; -. why^' de,-* . I baiich/San-;; Francisco* befdre t 'the".'eyes i: ;of a the ; civlllßed world?until we are'branded as harbor-^ ; Ing; the :, tnO3.t ' corrupt i administration i that 'ever was known in the history of "municipal! govern j ment? .?/:;. ;\u25a0 ;-- ; " \u25a0\u25a0.;.-', \u25a0. .;'\u25a0_ "• \u25a0 '. ;"'-;' : .:^, \u25a0"-:"\u25a0/ } -'The. telephone "steal, the gas bribery;-; the | trolleys steal and" the .flphb trnst boodlers ; are ; a' \u25a0 I part ", of \u25a0 the,"record- commenced' { and \u25a0 encouraged " ! by ithls \ defendant. "{- Thej . are : all"- in" the : same ; box; "- they ':. all ? debauch . us. /These .men sof 'the telephone s company), with no > excuse*" whateter j say the ; love - of i filthy ; money _ tempted t the { poor supervisors.™ ;\ There ' was ; no occasion ! to 'pay,' over the : money . »,;- The : sflp'trvisors f ne ver t held *. them . up. >\u25a0; The '. crime p> was ji wanton,;: gratuitous: and \u25a0' vicious. The ; Pacific? telephone company; wanted I to I stamp); out X competition. ;V They ;; were '; giving j us ' wretched i service." "; Everybody ' knows * this; ! and : they, did \u25a0 not.; want to ' be ' forced » to J Improve ', It.' * So "they,' proceeded ito kill competition. ;• And ' : how did they, proceed to. kill competition?';" Why; I by s paying -, the I supervisors ; to : refuse ;" a franchise to a rival * corporation.'; j : : "' APPROACH] THE LAW ; MAKERS ; ;' ; I ,-"-A« • soon? as ; it was ; whispered that the Homo ', telephone < company^.was fa;, possible .competitor; the >Paclflc = telephone < rponipanyi proceeds ; : to : make i i friends iwith.^ the. snjiervlsors '. who have the power. i to | grant % tho'| franchise? ;CThey S take i Boxton S to | dinner J and X buyj him J'Crinka.'j:-; This 5 Is ) shown -. in I the *evldence,3.andScaonot ; iibe--refuted.'e-. Finally they- place him • onf the payroll and; he Is 'given a ! salary; ? i What for? S,Why;^ to -be 5 friendlyJ;; He I has no duties save this: be friendly to us. -1' Then ! he'isgiven; $l,000;fcr; election /expenses. / What : for?': : To keep out the: Home .telephone company: : Then I they igos to i Nicholas ' who ; is •at ;\u25a0 work at his.tradej^hejla a carpenter. rjThey say: '\u25a0\u25a0'\u25a0 j',lj ',l: /.'Nicholas, 1'?1 '? will ;\u25a0 you • condescend ' to: Join •us In ! a;' drink?" does. .They ask .him how ; he ;; is ; feeling;,- He \u25a0 feels - in ;\u25a0 need ,of money; of course. ;'\u25a0" '> r ": '.•../\u25a0 -\u25a0- ">"' ;. '« ; ;; ; ;-\;". '\u25a0\u25a0 \u25a0',-. I:/- 1 ' I How about Zlmmer? 'Is Zlmmer ; going 4 to Jail I for ; Pickernell ? ; No. ;If ; Pickernell ' gave the money j to.* Halsey, .why- doesn't Halsey say.'; so. Halsey : is . sitting back > there. »; He iis not ; speech less.; He knows whotgave -it to]hltnC;: If; Glass, i;the defendant, : did not,; why, does ho not pay; so? ' ' Heicannot.'beiworse^offlthaniheils'and Is in,a j position jto • make .Tils "brother in '.law,- Very 1 much \u25a0 ; better i off."/ 1 This • pretense * about •* Pickernell T ; Is j , what tit appears to * be-^nere I pretext I and % pre | tense.-: It was suggefited Uhat 'Plekernelltwasn't i her«sln N inos'atthe.'tlme*of.;tho?empl6yment'of : i Boxton;,* That ; Is true.. , ; Who»waS'it that.'BU | thorizod; thps engagement*. of . ; Boxton? \ .That ; was j a:bribe. Pickernell «mild l not have been respon-" j j s lble i f or tha t ' liecauselh'e *,Va 8 • ridt\ h'ere.'ii When ; Halsey gave Coleman h!a election-expenses;Pick | erncll \u25a0 , was ' not j here;; Neither jwas he ' here' when ! Boxton • gof, hi?.' . .•>\u25a0 ."> ;\u25a0-- •• . :,'. ' ." ; ; ; .,: V^""i; "L" L .:\u25a0\u25a0:\u25a0 . .;; iS Mr. ( s Halsey/ Is : nut : th In \ skinned;* "A , man 'who doesn't : mlnd^ handling, dirty; bribe 'money 4 is ; not overtender of.conKcieiice^r'Aiman'.whohas band ed t; 10 v supervisors ' bribe"; money icatinot '\u25a0' be \u25a0 soft skinned. '« Halscy would* tell • you -in• a' minute ) If he ; could i havo J done so. • But % Halsey . is " Glass' , brother;" in "law -and cannot I talk.;} He .would have , been up to :> the ' d Istrlct [i attorney's ; ; office long'aßO^ pleading; fur Jan I immunity;" contracts if he could havo done'so.i.Why/didlbe' notdo so? Because he j would ; have • put'; his I brother Yin 'law in ;- the ' : penitentiary. .-..That's*- why > Halsey ;.\u25a0 Is ; taking. a chance and Is! notUalklng.f ' He i would have : hurried rafter, that; immunity; contract • long ago, > seeing they are; so easy jto get.;-. ,; sj \u25a0\u2666 All % through } this .' trial k. the i desire j has - been shown to (save Glass. Scott ; didn't ? take : charge until! March, l^ a ; month : af ter j the| passing ! of |the money; from jthe telephone? company; to; the 'pur chased | supervisors. , His I memory r got ? bad, t too; on £ the 3 stand.;; Los i <t; of <\u25a0 memory -; is * epidemic 1 around £ that J telephci bi building. ; :< He fc thought Halsey. went, to the Philippines; lnl June.fand* not i when i the ' grand : Jury. Was { In" session ; nearly i six I months ; before. But, Ms-memory got elearerlthe ; next [ day,*? after Ahe/Vad ) time ( to think { It ' over; i Then v he s remembered t that I US was r in '^January | that v Halsey '»\u25a0\u25a0• salary "i of S OOOf a ; i months was | changed ,toj a- pension 0f ; 5175.*.*;; t y .i^fl SCOTT KAKEB? ADMISSIONS \u25a0 -" : . Mr. "> Scott^also would! like\ to help \ OlassJ - ; He took the burden of that salary, change I npon ; him | »elf. - He? said -he nnver consulted Glass abuut ' i it.'^iHe did- It^of his own "i accord. :; .;\u25a0 . * : *i We got Sc6tt ( cornered f then. :v. It dawned ( upon him that « if, he, changed fHalsey's^salary* Into; a , pension :there i must.be; aVreason ; forjlt, of .'which 1 he \ was f cognizant;-- Then '• Scott -i decided ( to i let Glass » take I care vof himself S and 2 he* thereafter looked i out; for Scott. . '- :..''";; \- '\u25a0: 0« He | admitted fat once . that he j had 'consented Glass.^; Here; we have . the -evidence i that ' Halsey was \ taken 1 care fofi by 3 Glass,'* who? arranged"; to ! *i»ve'hlm sent'toHherPhillpplnesionraipensioß.t ! Here .also;-; is J the i evidence fc that S after rSabin's j Ufiath-;Glass;was;thesonlyman>torglVeMnstrue-" i tions. : All t had 'to report; to him.'y - ' . ; ;\u25a0; . So go \u25a0 around \ the ! circle^ any; way Tyou ; like nn4 you j. always ft come X back gto g the * same'g pom t— : Glass.; Glass; and: Glass only.-.' -v.'.?- - -• *<!£*? ; I help v you ?• ;.> is j asked. V":- : Nicholas gets $400 ; for his r election;; expenses. "Then;; Kranse goes E to ? lonergan I and i tells f him* about 'fmeeting ! him ? years \ ago *ons a | tra ln.iand | Lonergan 1 feels • like ; be i has! met' a" long lost If rlend.T* The < bakery wagon I driver .5 begins jto lllve Ilika-Ni ! millionaire. 1 i Halsey to Sdinaer.«-WiU>il<onergan , accept an j invitation to i lunch? .Willfa«dog ! ea t > meat ? iiWill «• he 1 : s,They # have fa % very i nice lunch jand 5 lonergan t Is> told \ all ? about) the % tele-" \u25a0 phone « and i to } him^ is t explained? the , advantages i that s the f Pacific^ telephone 5 oompany; en Joy s,"j and \is |ln formed f on| niany it polnta i con-* \u25a0\u25a0 cernlng a the £ superior^ equipment i of I the * Pacific company,^ which * does ?.not ; -care j to': face ; compe-" tltion.. • -. - • • . ': * \u25a0 ,S H«V ls |taken « into f the ; business . affairs^as Sa confidant, rj Did ?, the ?. general g manager i: and i» T v!ce president i knpwj anything « about fjUu this lj Halsey couldn t p get f any,* moneys unlens js Glassy ßigned the r; checks.'i.l The | president 'iotk, the 3 company,"! oabln,T.was f dead j and ! could | not J sign | anyj check.' I Glass * was % the % only> man %l% l with ,% authority,* to 6 'f n i c . b .!° ks - • Halsey) had feto J have ? moneyj foX ally t of p these S expensive S supervisorial J? guests^ ,w , here Idid \he i get sit? '1 Halsey 1 ! ! Balaryfof 5 1300 a* month I would ; not \ bVy t them } dinner i and < pay their;; election; expenses £ and give* them |i wads ?;iS. urre i!5 yy * t0 5 Uk * ' h <wne ' with i them.'SSßimsaH I mt Xhey v began J, nursing |f: these "S: n^w i- supervisors ,In i December.t a I month 1 bef ore! th/ey * took f office.-; Krause 1 got j Interested 1 In i thenO and'i their j cam- F£ f* $ w f*a«»^He I was |rery /sollcitoM ? at I to thelri welfare-Tg He ] began * going ! around 5 and i see- \ Ing i them | and I retoemberlnß- 1 them " aa '< «W ! lrttoda.l Halsey r sees \ ; Coleman,* a 4 nic«^ clean;® bright looking.^ fellow; -and ' takes ; ; him out to lunch. Overi the iwlne ;he^ suggests? that.' Coleman 1 ; ought to be ; friendly Ito 'the | telephone; company.*,^ - ; - .-• -yVcoiiMAi^QTnckLY' -weakens \u25a0 '- ..'\u25a0> Colemahj repliesSthat!c he '. saw ' no' reason for not v beingii friendly; -the 'administration ~ seemed to ' be J friendly:*^'*;-/ '-s -:SS.\ -':~—\v - " --.-.; - \ ; ; Ruef r was 7 tlie >- administration. :; It has not come t; out sat > this i trial S but > Kuef, seemed al ways ito t have /a i good's reason i- to ,: be f . friendly. Finally,'* Coleman \ accepted i $150 a i month from the i telephone t company -to ibe , f riemlly," too. . See howathe /worked? 'VHere was" . a bright young , fellow. \u25a0 He ; had i agreed to -bo . a friend. ~;Then \u25a0: Unlsey suggested : that he try; to get lon 1 the^ public i utilities \ committee^ r He = also urged \ to ] get \u25a0\u25a0 On i that f committee.' --Why ? The $ company \ needed . bright,"; f rieudly ' fellows .where >. tht-y I woulij ", do Uhe j most ; gooa, J anil ;. the franchise \ measure c was then ; pending \ before * the utilities ; coaim lttee.';; .-: They -'were > not t bo l anx ious 5 to ; ha vo l Valsh : thereriJ He * had '* reason not .to ' be i so i friendly.?; He' only? got f ?3,soo;> where the i other i. fellows \ got ; $5,000.'; -. ;\u25a0::'. il Now iwe : get \u25a0 along i about f January. 1 They ; are putting iup \u25a0 the defense lof = the horse i thief, down la "Arizona.! who * said -, he - got \ the * animal i from an \i om igo v; who h was i last • Been j bound Mexico-" ward; ;;f>. Who s authorized ; the issue ;« of ,; checks ? riekeruell.. ; -Where '; is ; Pickerneli ? ?'-\u25a0 In Boston." , Bnt;t~B3 a matter \u25a0of fact," that ! Isn't true. Pickernell " couldn't , Issue vor t Blgn * checks. As tho bank . officials v testlfied.-i nobody \u25a0 could "get the ; inobt-y - out \u25a0 of ; the \ bank J unless the ; check was \ ssigne t by ; Glass or s Zlmmer for " tbe ; presi dent; -' Who' was the' president? \u25a0 Sabin was , dead - aud ; Glass was" - the - acting -1 president. v\ ould t Zimmer; sigulchecks .for . $50,000 without consulting ? the i man \ for .J whom Ihe ; signed ? Pick flrnell:'f might j have? advised"; that i the" money be given ; Hulsey, ? but '•; Pickernell couldn't get ,. the money -;forihim. ;';•'", , ', c: "'WliyJ didn't: they, put :llalsi>y on the stand "to prore-thatf Plckprnell gotrthe. rmoney ' for himt Halsey lis ; here.' , -He .cannot be , worse ' off I than he, is, now.',- Why (lhln # ti they, ask 'him. "Didn't Pickernell give?. vou"; instructions r: Could they haye^'provecl.i thit \they;" were e often ;, together? No.ij they£ couldn't /.',«: Pickernell '-: never , got •; the money ?for j HaUey v anil ' never • gave . him instrnc-' tions, v>,That Sis > why i they \u25a0 could ; not; and also jvhy> tliey^did i not ' put s Halsey; on; the f stand.-, - \u25a0'-.\ Scot tj. was l awoy \ln - February } when i the ; deals liu- supervisors --were Jmade.U He r saidNhe c gave ho." lnstructions » and T, signed Ino "checks. ; If vhe UlfUtheylcouldVeaslly/proveit.v \u25a0 t ": f I BiitSßuxton; didn't ;>ell ; himself twice. When ho : got i $0,000 , from the Pacific :: telephone . com pany. :he i sto»Ml ; by.: the ; people ~ who\ had \u25a0' boug'- 1 him. '|. Boston: fought 'the '-Home' telephone com , pany •in .•. the \u25a0: chambers of * the % board f of ; super ,visors jj to -. prevent ,'-.the : 'Home -. company ,or :• any other .J corporation A from ; into ..San Fran clsco.t He. stayedvbought.:;He ;was ;loyal^to ;the man ; who S bribed . hlm.V This ' fact ; is \u25a0 corroborated by. • John " Krans«> i and :It J.ls ' evident '\u25a0 that ;, Bos ton"'" earned ' : hlsT: money. *= Krause ; has ;"; told > you that "\u25a0 five supervisors^- came | ia; there% after : they had k been \l telephoned to -or i had .:,\u25a0 been \ given messages '. thrcUgli 7 other -"\u25a0 supervisors •" to . come to • the ' office \of .' the \u25a0 telephone ; : company • in ' the Mills , building. iThe fact f; is "> still - further monstrated , t0 . .: be -i true <by :~: ~ Taylor,' the :\u25a0•' agent of " the ; buildlnff,s. who. ; told i how >h^ j had • phoned .to ."Drum and*,- how.- Drum 1 had' said i;; be would phone :\u25a0. to '.the-offieesTof ! the 'company, , and how thereafter"; the iempty.trooms fin ithei Mills buiW- Ing '\u25a0$ had 'JjJwjtn ;** secured •£ for ; these ,\ clandestine meetings j; 6f/\ bribe /-givers % 'and \u25a0\u25a0* bribe . takers; Agent J has \u25a0 told you - how - he- s had i sesn Drum ;i aha^Halsey v; aU the.;offlce9iln Uhe ( Mills bulldingSund'Show '\u25a0• tUevroomsphad t been occu pied 1 fori three.? or j four \u25a0 <iays.>; Box ton % tells : you liowl he swas5 was , In \u25a0 j these" offices ; lnT the Mills - build ing ; and"! hl»\ testimony/ is ;: amply • corroborated : by Taylor^; sulvDirum-. and-; C.ahnon.V', '-••'; .\u25a0\u25a0'\u25a0,'-' " ' . '• ' '% VlicTtMILM I BtoSiKO 'J'':. '; : . .; Why :^dia*tfci?y;«et^tmi)tj r troon7iT^in»the,' Milla ; building? :\u25a0;, Why '\u25a0; such': secrecy^ necessary.)-; In accepting .... the^j, visits ,j> of .;• the,? supervisoiV} ;\"Aa men 6f ; ordinary^ sense;- It is not 7 necessary ;for me |to '\u2666ell'ybifait'i'.waß' to^pay^.tUe^supcflsofa the : ; money . in^without.^ detection! *> They,; wanted a ; place iS?here\t^ey\wbuld.- bp^unobserT.ed.^-Tuu supervisors.; could j'hot's go : to J the >"t>f flees *t>f '. the telephone; buiklliig.^There* might* be detectives hanging * around.% The* supervisors "did * hot 7evcn take ya " chance iin vthe'W elevators £ of .'. the ; . Milln •building. - j Some -'. of £ them i" preferred c to ' climb Uhe . stairs, so ' that . no** onei could <'say" at ; which floor ;4 they 'stopped. ; Halsey * handed .* them the money , ; lv ; this office s in * the " : Mills ' buildingV/'AU Tthe > facts •: point ; to \u25a0 this ; as'- a j certainty.' Drum; Cannon , and Krause ~ corroborate '\u25a0 itr.v " - ;, : git i may ' be > said /of \u25a0 -Bpxton \u25a0 that -he was -an accomplice '\u25a0; and hia v testimony >. inust ':':. be' \u25a0\u25a0 cor roborated; We will % let ;lt* go at s that.Valthbugh , we'do rnot 'believe that^hej is an 'accomplice; be fore \ the ' law."; The corroboration' is h'ere.VThere is r plenty ?ot; it.- •'\u25a0~~';V^s- : .',~y %•\u25a0:\u25a0 - ' : '-- •' -- '\u25a0; - «? First, ':--; Boston „ received "I $3,000 ;\u25a0 for" his ;;vote. He % counted * It ; at • horned He' said r so. His " wife \u25a0 testified sto > it, :~ Boxtun * first i refused ? . to - answer my; question relatiugito' this,';, because,", although indifferent I to r his • own vfeelings.^he : did I not want ;to «- subject -- his v wlfe,'|? to^ ; tliof- hum Illation •--.\u25a0' of sharing j his {shame lln , open ; , .. / •'-- , '. :': '- \u25a0:. '\u25a0 . ? :f' M 2N}TELL^THEn^STaRrEB ;, '"/ '•\u25a0• I ' would i not t have j called r ItJstiini. to '.the 6tand ; if i Zlnnncr ihad^testlfiod.'iltVvras <,a'Vdis agreeable' i duty T and >; I . would.J ha veV'avoided .' It If p. possible.!-.: But: the. dt-fense} forced .-me .-to .do so." \u25a0 She: testified 'HhatJßoxtonigot; the' money, brought iit i homeland: "counted lit: ><. - ?\_ ; : ; : \u25a0They know; Boxton ;got ',tlte.imoney.>The": only defense iis V that I we « cannot J connect ; Glass - with the bribery, because Zimmer/won't^ testify.!-"'* . ".* ';.' As -I* have said,*. Mrs.", Boxton f corroborated ; the testimony {" of \u25a0 her i husband.": f Mrs.i Lonergan did tlie same ifor^ that; of ; her* husbanU. /i.v . . • • You t beard f the I evidence ? these > women :<: < gave. You heard " that "of * their ; husbands. { In ' conclusion I "will . say that . we f do : not ; want : a" verdict that is i not ; warranted : : by > the « facts.*? If J yon ' believe' that'tblsj; man;. Glass * is >guiltyAof , the^offeuse Ye ha vef sought ?to : prove^ against v him, > then doJyourSduty -as ;j citizens.^ Keep •'\u25a0 In < mind, this f act-^Glass £ was I general % manager/; of r the .- tele ' phone S company. {> The :'. telephone % company .d paM f 30,000 ito % the .? corrupt ; supervisors; ; Only • Glass could j authorize^ the ;• Iss>te -r of i the '"checks '.' \u25a0 on which 5 the, ' ; money .was - ; drawn," and only • he could glvefnalsey* instructions. "lf "you think- that :the evidence 7i» 1 convincing,*"; then : ; there ' is '. nothing but bring, in' aiverdict 6; -guilty. r';Ther«"!T-ls^naS'doiibt.;in T.my^uilndi butt* that >lther.'Glasߣor,**Zlmiuer .. feigned V those sf check*. Flftyj] thousand sdollars^was^ paid JoutJ between February; 113 V and 1 24;"* 1 1 i has jbeenytestlfietl 'that . lt^went "; to i the I supervisors | .through"^ tbej hands of t: Halsey.*;^ I f \u25a0; you *' decide < that * the;" c vlderice establishes \ that; then '\u25a0 I say . you • must ' flnfl ' Glass -guilty ." alone i or i with ; Zimmer. ( : Zlmmer has ; not , yet ; been f indicted;, ;-Ro it ; is » yonr^ tluty -to ; coti-" .vict^Glaiss; if^thattis - th'eCway you -view -the evidence, f \ :\u25a0 ».- •;, ;-'",';,:.;*:\u25a0 :'.-',"' " 'After, .in ihtcrmissioni of >flve minutes T. C. -, Coogan for the : defense took his Continued u; on j Page 3, „ Column' 1 • I —EXACT PROPORTIONS, TRUE I ;--\u25a0; B E A M 3, P E R F E C T. BUTTON- v ' %'.\ , HOLES, EXCEL tE N CE; IN (S \u25a0-\u25a0A iEVERY^DETAIW.:,, ; ; ; ; \u25a01 ': j UNEXCELLED FOR FIT, AND I "?; :\u25a0;\u25a0\u25a0.. wt Art;;-; -^•;'--..- -ij,^ < .; .- " \u25a0\u25a0;;. \ ..; . j WHITE -AND EXCLUSIVE- f ,\u25a0"\u25a0! FANCYvFABRIC3;;v "I > I '- : .r \ ;:.:'( :,: LOOK TOR CLOCTT tA»IL.= -. -. J :. C-\ v.^CLUETf,>REABODY-T4 r ;'CO.v«',i \u25a0 "\u25a0\u25a0 ''-I"-**".-- \u25a0 ':s \u25a0\u25a0\u25a0\u25a0-:\u25a0•\u25a0.' i.-: \u25a0;... :;-- : i .".-'.; .:U : ' ",..-\u25a0; -'-\u25a0'..'":\u25a0 __--.' -j. \u25a0\u25a0..;'\u25a0-: •' .'\u25a0\u25a0- ; -><''.-':. ;\u25a0,\u25a0;• ..:\u25a0;./.\u25a0;:-\u25a0>;\u25a0.,-.;,'.;-.\u25a0::>;\u25a0\u25a0:\u25a0,-'\u25a0".- \u0084..~~; Under the New Pure Food Law All Pood Products must be pore and ."• •' -". honestly labelled.*;"- - V-i " "-'"'' - J^Mspeß^a^ißgwiyMßfgiuiiLi-iiiiuiiiii m m. : '.* i '/.'.: \u25a0 Ts \u25a0 \'~, BURNETT'S VANILLA |.wh nny years ahead of the Law. r, It was ;. v- always t pure Vanillafs- Every \ bottle • now <: "i bears this label : i Guaranteed under the Food \ I and p Dngt I A et ijane f 30th?i 1 906," -i Serial ;\u25a0 Number. 9 /,' which has been mstlgnid to us f. \u25a0\u25a0 JOSEP H B U R N ETT CO., .O.TO h, hm^ I f' W s llAlu ITIvfWLJL*' x^.IiJL/ The Great Kohler & Chase Sacrifice Sale of Fine Pianos Is Fast Growing to; a Close— The \u25a0 Rush for Bargains Still Gpntinues Saturday the Last pay— Thousands of Dollars Saved by Our Cus- tomers at This Sale, and Some of Our Best Bargains Left- Open Evenings Until 9:3o— Corner Sutter and Franklin THIS IS MLJRRV UP TIME - Only ; two days more of the Sale. | There } never- was, there, never* will : be j such " an opportunity.^ as < this, ; and "z the shrewd? buyers," j good ; Judges J of" piano I /values - realize > it» fully ; and * are taking | advantage "of -the opportunity "now theirs. . \There are :no dull, days.' . \u0084* We have ; buyers ; ! here in the morning— qulte : a I : large snumber'in ; the 'afternoon | seldom an evening but what four , io% five customers;, who - can not . call j . during •'\u25a0".the f. 'day», select pianos. And j there^is". a* reason 'ifor'it-^-ybu can buy the very best makes" here during this sale at an awful sacrifice in price and j "orifteTms^''to* make "paying for them j very easyl ' j ;if in doubt. : just, come and see for j yourself-f-take v; ten 'minutes, of ; your timeltdday- and- make an Investigation, j It. will r pay '/youl to J «aye ; 5150. Good j new 'uprights isame^quality,' would cost i you J250, -.elsewhere— reduced to less ! than -one hundred dollars — the $300 ! styles tto: $147. - , $185, on terms to stilt, buys a flnej $350. piano.' :v^s276. "on easy terms, will send to your, home ; a :han(Jsome mahogany up- right, original ' price $ 4 50.'; \ V"; 5467,"; 0n. terms! to J.'sult. for your ! choice of '-,'two imahoganles and> very ! fine . French . : walnut designs, worth ! $750." : r ' '•j^m^^^SBB^f^SBBBSBS' • ; have. pianos today at all prices—^ worth J double.*'.. .Slightly.l. Slightly .1 used .pianos returned from .rentalsrJlso.'sl7s,,to $225, actual _value $350^,t0 ,s4oo>; .!„- , . - Player Pianos today and tomorrow San Francisco Bond and Mortgage Company CAPITAL $10,000,000 OFFICERS OF THE COMPANY President,; JOHN LLOTD v«- ,/ - rr> \ VID v -WALKiER Treasurer/ J.. DALZELL, BROWN . Vice , Presidents i . w" P , : pi rvmr Secretary. -KUFUSP;. JENNINGS J . : - _.\' ,'_ <^ °T f " GENERAL (COUNSEL : GENERAL, ATTORNEY W. J. BARTNETT. CHARLES W. SLACK ' M." E. CERF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE jjljj JOHN LLOYD - ;, J. DALZELL BROWN * • DAVID F. WALKER /RIJFUa; P." JENNINGS V :•;'-.. B. M. GUNN • - * 10,000 SHARES OF THE CAPITAL STOCK OF THIS COMPANY ARE ] P pFFERED/FOR; SUBSCRIPTION AT $100" PER i SHARE/ ;" ;This r Company: has been orgahizeii'to loan money on "income property in San -Francisco -on '.what Js- known as the bond and mortgage plan. This : involves the issuance of bonds secured by first -mortgages onincome prop- | erty'and the' sal eVpf^ guaranteed" mortgages. f;AN^ EXCEPTIONAL OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE MONEY. • S There is no investment safer than that .'offered by tHe SAN FRAN- : CISCO; BOND! ANDjMORTGAGE COMPANY, and owingto the excep- 'tionalv conditions the ; net earnings of ' its capital stock should considerably rexceed 12 per? cent per, annum. j^^The;SAN] FRANCISCO BOND, AND MORTGAGE COMPANY has ;;•:., 1. Interest (earned >on its paid up capital. - \u25a0 : .» ! 2:^ t Difference*between what it earns -on mortgages ami r what" it pay's r on bonds^ which "is iusually j1 }^ per ; cent. ',-3. Difference in interest on guaranteed mortgages sold by it, which is usually^! per cent; . • ':.:_„-.- \u25a0\u25a0~\\ Similar; companies irj '.'the East and foreign countries have had phenom- enal' success, earning from 12 to 16- per cent per annum. • • :-: - ' Stock subscriptions will be ; received in SAN FRANCISCO at the offices of ithe r Company,- 30 Montgomery Street, and until -July 31, 1 1907, at the fol- lowing \u25a0'places:'.* " . : San; Francisco NationaUßank. Merchants'^Exchangre Building The. Crocker jNationah ßank; Market and Post Streets - '•;\u25a0 - E.^H. Rollins &• Sons,, Kohl Buildingr. ; Safe? Deposit; and Trust- Company, at Its head office, California \u25a0: -^Streetat Monteromery,-or at any of Its four branch offlcesV .-..-- The National Bank, of the Pacific. Ciaus Spreckel* BuildinK ;^ Bank, 78 Jackson Street. lxyilus ' r State Savings and Commercial Bank, 1019 Fillmore Street. ' v,l Union National Bank,. Oakland. \u25a0" V And' In : Xew.- York <. City— >" - \u25a0 ; United Statea Mortfaffe and Trust Company 55 Cedar Street . Inter boro Bank- of tlfew York.- 49 Wall- Street.- - Street. \u0084 t. F.Hutton^ and Company," 33 New Street. "* :/ ; -.'.--- ;-"- ' '•'-. \u25a0' writefor; booklets Schools and Colleges ffillLS COLLEGE sehismV "Confers -degrees and grants diplomas; seminary coarse .'accredited ;to tbe University and leading Ea&terq [ collcgea.'^ Bare opportunities offered -In music,** , art 2 and f elocution. ,> Forty-second -year. Fall "term opens - August \u25a0 15,~ -1907. : Write \u25a0 for catalogue to MES.' C.-T. MILLS," President, Mills College P. V 'O;;" Cal.,;. ; ;•.---.;, v- I RVINQ INSTITUTE And California Conservatory of Music 2126 ' California st.*, . San Francisco. Boarding- nnd " Day i School " for I Girls, i.i '. Music, \u25a0 Lanpiasei*. Art and ; Elocution." ; Accredited ; by the uniTersl- ties. •- New \u25a0 term ; opens Monday; Aupust , 5." : ; \u25a0 : -- MISS \u25a0 ELLA- M. PINKHAM.-PrinqipaL \u25a0 CALIFORNIA CONSERVATORY ;0P : MUSIC ,£ Full corps of teachers -In 'all departments." Send for^ catalogue. ._\u25a0 HERMANN* ..GENSS. Director. \u25a0" SAINT ROSE ACADiY Studies Resumed Ist Monday la Anjtuat ;: Corner 'of ,' Pine, : and Pierce Sts. \u25a0 • -"'Conrtuetedby^DomlnlcanSisters. ""; Full r Academle ; Cour»e — Lanyuafre.', • Vocal \u25a0 and Instrumental i Music. i? DecoratlTe < painting ia ' OU, on ; Porcelain in t Pastel . and ; Crayon.; ; r. \u25a0•:\u25a0\u25a0 For i particulars^^ apply, at the , Academy. Miss Hairker^s School PALO ALTO^CAL. Board and : day; school. ;V Intermedlat*' and • pri- mary . department*/?' Certificate » admits to Stan- lord, s>Vassar;:*Welles]ey ; and ; Mill*; \u25a0\u25a0;.- Reopen* 'A*>- trust 2O.> New.bnilding. i thoroughly, modem, | steam heated,*)' ready I for : fall term ; - large ' grounds \u25a0 for Out of door eports.": : r -:~> -.;-•- -A* ; 3f Glrls'^bfliarflni and day* schdol. *, PrimarT,' Inter- mediate 'and ; academic : depts. ; Certificate" admits to University of California, Stanford and eastern colleges.^ Opens 'August ;7.* ? MKS>EDNA " SNELL I POOLSOy. MISS : MARY; E.i SNELL,": principals.' !:;;:,;:MISS::HAMLIN!S::' Boardins and day. acnool "for. girls' at 2230 Pacific avenue. Accredited to universities and colleges. Keopensi £ August > 12.","': Address ' Miss . S. \D. BAM- LIN, 1 2230 ! Pacific ; avenue;, San j Francisco. ,r . \u25a0 : Notre Dame College -.-^ / /:'':' : :: ' :>V "'AND/ .. \u25a0'\u25a0' . '-X'r "*.:\u25a0'; Conservatory of Musics ,r Studietf resumed ;* 3, i 1807,'> t ... ; ;2020 iWASHINGTOX ST. \u25a0'.' '-\u25a0- Conducted ?by * rel lgion» of the : Sacred • Heart. \u25a0 For particulars ; apßly . at ) tha academy. ' Refer- ences required. " -\u25a0\u25a0.•-...-;. at greatly reduced prices, which will bo given In person by our salesmen at tna store. - \u25a0' ';\u25a0•- ' . That Kohler & Chase prices ana -values arc attractive is attested by the fact that we have sold Inside the last . ten days over forty pianos t.> persons who were sent to this" store by -customers who had bought . piano* for their homes here during this sala —they knew .values and \u25a0 knew ttie house -and V knew we have never of- fered ; an unworthy piano,' not even for the effect that : a low price might havo. Present effect is one thing. .-.Reaction effect is r another— -and we want none of the reaction that .would corae from sell- ing poor pianos. We've distributed near- ly all our surplus stock "of new pianos —It was sell them or carry the ris»« of insurance ourselves— we sacrificed profits, and " in some cases even ', more, but, we have about "cleared. decks." and by Saturday's closing time at 9:30 p.*\m. will not worry about 'extra' risks, etc. We appreciate the hearty^ patronago given us by the public during this sale, and can assure one and all that never before and no : doubt never again will you buy, better pianos— if- as good— for anywhere .near^our sale prices. We were ; in a measure forced to re- duce our ; stock— and when we sacri- ficed profits we made nearly three hun- dred new, friends » for the store. Send your friends today or tomorrow — toda/ would be-better." If ,. at a write or wire— only today and tomor- row— this Is hurry up time. KOHLER & CHASE. B *"-'\u25a0' I"* TH^b I* IB '|m ' I \ '.^J *J i 2 1 \ J ™^ JP M 8 3 *Li« w ,f,.i81-l, A^i'jk»..i.' < A^A \u0084jt_ a i \F\ "J ri^i^tUf j.?? 310 "* "" nd Shorthand, Mtoin*. school. C*H oa or address E. P. HEJLLD PrtS. ! . . ; LL — f Bfelmont Schopi For Boys. BELMONT,"CALIFORNIA 5!.?* £f" that It fatrlj offer* THE LYCEUM . 2590 Pine st. corner Scott: begins its fifteenth L e KL? n Jkol7J k 017 -• wm 7 OU *° 4 ***** -t« <Z lilt school when you - c»n -\u25a0 be " prepared by ,na mow thoroughly .-la. li.if .that time? Excellent teach- ert; indWldoalattentlnn. Com« and b« with iiL .'--\u25a0\ . ' - - •L. H. GRAP. Ph. P.. Principal. Mt Tamal pais Military Academy i •-:.'•- j SAX »* RAFAEL '• ' : t>J ht ,r, mOS } tP^ll •flo&P** : mmtary school this aide of the Rockies. Opens Ansmst 14 r ARTHUR CROSBY. D. P.. Head Master. ! St.- Matthew's Military School- j (Episcopal) > BurllnKame. Cat. ~ I FaU'Tem Besln» : An)rnßt 15,1907. ' [ RET.'^WIUJAM ;A. BREWBB. A. \u25a0 8.. JSector. j Hitchcock Military Academy ! " _-sAXf rafael;-.: cal./ ' | room* for '"caiJets^Chrktmas term ; will commence on ''Anfujit 19. . j. • ,'. ; BpONE'S "UNIVERSITY SCHOOL BEHKE L E V \ Will - commence »t» ; twenty afto (23th) tmp B^/prfncTp".!. 1 " . **?:*;??**»'*- * POLYfECHNIC BUSINESS COLLEGE :' ANP SCHOOL OF MINES AND ENGIVFFftivr, « Oakland. , Cal.- (lnc. \u25a0 C-pI A " MoSfc- |!oSSSSS ! ANDERSEN ACADEMY" i m v ? I SI? XGTOV '*' Callrbrnla.;. ! Nojnbers ; « limited. / School .:•• salact. s.i mmh , -- i tankjo b« added to tha excenenrwntom^?^ 1 * ! WIULIAM WALKER A.NDEBSoarffi:^, j