Newspaper Page Text
THURSDAY The San Francisco Call JOHN D. SPRECKELS «. Proprietor CHARLES W. HORNICK General Manager ERNEST S. SIMPSON .Managing Editor AJdrw All Commonlcatlons to THE SAX FRAXCISCO CALL Telephone **KEARXY 86"— A*K for Tbe Cnll. TUe Operator Will Connect Yon With the Pf pnrtmeat Yoa WUh BUSINESS OFFICE Market and Third Streets, San Francisco Open Until 11 o'clock Every Night In the Tear EDITORIAL. ROOMS ...Market and Third Streets MAIN CTTr BRANCH 1651 Fillmore Street Near Post '.OAKLAND OFFICE— 46B 11th BL (Bacon 810ck)... {Skihon^vSSS^ 2375 • AIAMEDA OFFICE — 1435 Park Street. .Telephone Alameda 559 BERKELEY OFFICE — SW. Cor. Center and Oxford... Telephone Berkeley 77 CHICAGO OFFICE — 1634 Marquette Bldff. .C Geo. Krogness; Advertising Agt NEW YORK OFFICE — 805 Brunswick Bldgr. . J. C Wllberding, Advertising Agt WASHINGTON NEWS BUREAU — Post Bldg...lra E. Bennett, Correspondent NEW YORK NEWS BUREAU — 315 Tribune Bldg..C. C. Carlton, Correspondent Foreign Offices Where The Call I« on File England... 3 Regent Street PARIS, France... 63 Rue Cambon BERLIN. Germany... Unter den Linden 9 SUBSCRIPTION RATESt Delivered 'by Carrier, 20 Cents Per Week, 75 Cents Per Month, Dally and Sunday Single Copies, 6 Cents Terms by Mall, for UNITED STATES, Including Postage (Cash With Order): DAILY CALL (Including Sunday). 1 Year $8.00 DAILY CALL (Including Sunday). 6 Months $4.00 DAILY CALL — By Ssngle Month 7oc SUNDAY CALL, 1 Year $2.50 WEEKLY CALL. 1 Year $1.00 FOREIQV f Dally $8.00 Per Year Extra ir^rA^ $4.15 Per Year Extra POSTAGE $1.00 Per Year Extra Entered at the United States Postofflce as Second Class Matter ALL POSTMASTERS ARE AUTHORIZED TO RECEIVE SUBSCRIPTIONS Sample Copies Will Be Forwarded When Requested Mall subscribers in ordering change of address should be particular to give both NEW and OLD ADDRESS in order to insure a prompt and correct compliance -with their request. THE Merchants' association, perhaps unconsciously, advocates complete surrender and submission to the orders of the United Railroads. The street railway corporation Avill not exchange transfers, and if the people should vote for a municipal road on Geary street the same cor poration would tie up the affair in litigation for years. Therefore, the people must submit. They are bound hand and foot by the street railway monopoly, and the Merchants' asso- Monopoly s Bogus Threats ciation declares that the town must obey the orders issued from the office of the United Railroads. We may fully acquit the association of a clear sense of the meaning and implication of the words used in its "special bulletin" on the Geary street railroad bond issue. The association does not appear to realize the significance of a degrading surrender, made under threats, nor does it appear to understand that this threat is impossible of fulfillment and is merely thrown out for effects How effective this spurious threat has proved appears from its easy and unquestioning acceptance at its face value by the Merchants' association. The association declares its opposition to the proposed bond issue because "the United Railroads has positively stated that under no conditions would it exchange transfers with any municipally operated road.*' Therefore, the town must submit, and surrender its purpose, so that the monopoly of urban transit may be maintained. It is a strange attitude to commend responsible support, so strange that we are compelled to believe that the association does not realize the sense of its conclusions. »•» Again, the association in its bulletin says: "If the people should vote for municipal ownership and operation of the Geary street line it would mean that this important road would be tied up in litigation for a number of years." In a word, the city must take no step for delivery from the vicious domination of the public service corporations because they can and will make dishonest use of the courts to delay and obstruct the purposes of the people. The' same argument would apply with equal force to any move looking to the installation of a municipal water supply. Clear! v the association did not understand tfie force and meaning of its argument. Yield to trvery form of exaction? Tolerate poor service? Perpetuate monopoly and submit? Humbly obey the orders issued from corporation offices because they threaten to obstruct, to delay and to refuse concessions? Is this what the Merchants' association advises? - > We have said that the threat to refuse transfers is spurious and meant only for effect. That conclusion should be plain enough to be understood by the wayfaring man. The United Railroads must do business under San Francisco laws and regulations. The corpora tion will come asking favors because it must. Its present irrecon cilable attitude of hostility to public interests and advancement is impossible as a business proposition. .That question will solve itself as the years go by. The Geary street railway will be extended to the ferry and will run to the ocean. The existing monopolj* of the main thorough fare can.be broken in a legal way, and it will be broken. If exten sions are needed they can be created by the city when they arc needed. The' oppressive and intolerable monopoly which seeks to restrain progress by making threats impossible of fulfillment will be broken. Taken as a whole, the argument of the Merchants' association unconsciously supplies the strongest posible reasons in' favor of voting the bonds. The 'bulletin draws a picture of an oppressive and tyrannical monopoly, dictating under threat what course the people shall pursue. It is a policy of abject and unconditional surrender, inspired by fear of a pumpkin ghost. IT is a public duty for every man, rich or poor, to/pay his poll tax, subject to certain limited exemptions authorized by the statutes. The money collected on this account, is applied on an ; excellent purpose, namely, the support , of * the publft schools. ,It is not burdensome to -the poor man, because our laws extend special con sideration to people of limited means by ex empting $100 worth of property -from taxa tion. In fine, the poll tax is the only form of impost by wbich people in moderate circumstances; do their- part in supporting the. state and municipal governments. Assessor Dodge, with the -help of a special appropriation of $5,000, made for this purpose by the board of supervisors,. is making a strong effort to collect these taxes. We hope -that his deputies will be received "with consideration ans be made welcome, in their fulfillment of this important public duty^ The schools need V.the money, and no'man should, grudge his small contribution imposed by" law. In fact, the payment 'of poll tax should --inspire '-* a :serise- of exhilaration due to public duty well performed. $ > Pay Your Poll Tax, Mr. Citizen EDITORIAL PAGE OF THE CALL What The Chronicle Said About the Geary Street Railway and Its Stand Now JT n>ill be good for the voters of San- Francisco to consider the antics of the Chronicle over the proposed V In- 1902, on the eve of an election whereat a somewhaV 'similar proposition jailedj 'ailed [of the) necessary too thirds majority, the Chronicle declared itself unequivocally for the bonds and for municipal ownership and opera tion of ,s, s the Geary street line. . Now, on the eve of another such election, the Chronicle back tracks on every argument -it advanced in 1902. The Voters can figure out for themselves what has happened to the Chronicle since 1902. A Iso they can figure out for dhemselves who, fears the Geary street road, and why. . /-i/ -i Below are the utterances of the Chronicle in 1902 and 1909: \u25a0 , (From the San Francisco Chronicle, Nor. 27,1902) (From thcSan Fraacisco Chronicle, Jane 10,1909) THE GEARY STREET RAILROAD MUNICIPAL CORRUPTION This is not a matter of sentiment, but of business,, and shduld be quietly and . carcfullj' considered as such. There is something to be' said on both sides of the question, and the valid arguments on one side should be as carefully weighed as those on the other. To begin with, the alternative of municipal ownership will be to advertise for bids for a new franchise. Any real competition would be very unlikely, ami the road would ultimately pass to- the United Railroads, with very little profit to the city. /The question is whether any profit can be got by municipal ownership and operation. There is doubtless a large possible profit in operating a street railroad over the proposed route at a 5 cent fare. The supervisors estimate, upon the figures' submitted -by the city engineer, that besides taking care of interest and depreciation, the net receipts during the "40 years which will elapse before the last bond is paid will repay the outlay three times over. This seems to correspond with the estimate of the United Railroads company, which has capitalized its road at fully three times the cost of construction, with franchises running far less than 40 years. Aside from a possible profit by operatidn°,v either by contribution,to the .treasury or a reduction of fares, there is one unquestioned advantage of which we are certain— we shall get a modern road. The unsightly poles and dangerous wires will disappear. The power will be applied through a conduit in the street, as is done elsewhere in cities which are resolutely gov erned. In place of the wheel wrenching rails which now deface our streets we shall have the modern grooved rail, over which Wheels can pass with ease and safety. We shall doubtless, have the most ap proved patterns of cars, and generally an "up to date" road and equipment. This object lessson in our city can not but have a most powerful effect in securing similar improvements from the United Railroads, either from voluntary effort or by supplying the neces sary evidence that; requirements which may be by the city authorities are "reasonable", in the eye of the law. ANOTHER UNQUESTIONED ADVANTAGE WILL BE THE REMOVAL OF THE MOTIVE FOR THE CORRUPTION OF PUBLIC OFFI CIALS. It is the popular belief that these valuable franchises are usually obtained by corrupt means. It is known that no safeguards of the law can prevent corruption when both parties are willing. The dis graceful disclosures at St.- Louis, recalling similar revelations in other eastern cities, show plainly enough that neither wealth, standing in the community nor appearance of respectability is any guarantee' against the foulest practices by men possessing such attributes. Possibly the strongest argument for municipal owner ship of public utilities is the removal of the motive and the opportunity for bribery on a great scale. The possible minor peculations connected with mere opera tion are less dangerous and do not saddle the com munity with permanent obligations. There are, there fore, three advantages of which we are certain— the object lesson of a modern road, the removal of one motive for corruption, and the benefit of any incre ment arising from the growth of the city. We are of the opinion that we had better try the experiment. Graver . responsibilities may call forth •stronger effort. A management intrusted with the lives of our citizens can not be so indifferent as where mere property is involved. The people have solemnly declared their' intention to. acquire these utilities. It would show -great instability of character to shrink from the first opportunity to carry out our expressed intent. This particular experiment is quite within our means. We ' do not sec how there can be loss in the investment, and if there proves to be losss in operation the charter provides a .way out through leasing.* It is one . step toward a better control of our streets and street service by making possible the expiration of all franchises, at the same time, which is of the. utmost importance. There is a strong feeling in favor of municipal ownership which will never cease to exert itself until an experiment has been, tried. : VOTE BONDS FOR THE POLYTECHNIC SCHOOL 'Editor Call: The Polytechnic high school is our only public day school ' where mechanical branches are taught, , therefore the city may increase its ca pacity with time as circumstances and conditions require; Schools of quasi public character, like the Lick, }Vil merdlng and Cogswell, are limited as to location and in their ability to pro- * vide increased accommodation. We; can not therefore depend upon them for the future development of this kind of : training. 'The evolution of the times, : the progress t of 'the ; world in . mechanical-/ "and .'• \ industrial ; lines,., the Introduction of new inventions and the keen competition of different' na tions are such , that a theoretical and practical knowledge !of our industries has become one of the p great needs of. a progressive people." ' The early pioneers'. \u25a0were. directly in terested in mining pursuits. AVith the growth of. the state the second step" was; the' development of-- farming -and .gen- r eral agriculture. As ..'the state still further developed much attention wa s paid. to commercial training."; On .'.'• ac-';.' count- of . the.sparsely . settled '-condl-T: tion of the coast the 'demand for. an' industrialeducation for ; a long time did *not;make": ltself felt. the; coast has 'nowjgrown toward 'commercial: and in- L 'dustrial its great -cities: send- j The attempt to make it appear that a reformation ! 'of,'- the -municipal, government can lie - effected by ,< acquiring and operating what are called public'utilities < will not "'prove successful, because long . familiarity, ! with the shortcomings'of those who; serve ; the city < for a consideration has made us acquainted" with the J fact, that they are not so honest or/ industrious 'as ;'" an I equal number of men engaged in private 'pursuits., j Any one* making an assertion ,to the contrary may be . J plainly set-down as a. demagogue willing, to shut his < cyts to the facts in order to secure support for the J carrying out of schemes that, if once- inaugurated, J would produce greater trouble and more waste than < •the city has yet experienced. The claim is made that if the Geary street road ; is built at the public expense and operated by the municipality it will at once cease to be a source of corruption. It is preposterous to assume anything of the kind.' Nothing is more certain than an out- ! come exactly the opposite' of that predicted by those.. < who advocate municipal ownership. From the day ; that the issuance of bonds is authorized, should the ! proposition^carry, we may look forward t t6 intrigue,' ! fraud and waste. Unless all previous experience is ; reversed, there will be uneconomical construction, and J when the road is^mt.in operatioiv the probabilities are \\ that two dollars v will be expended for service where ; one should suffice. ; If anyone believes' that .this is an exaggerated -\u25a0! view of the case, let him make inquiry concerning ' the method of doing things in those departments of ; the _city government where, the necessity for the ! careiul exercise of business economies exists. If he '< does so he will find that work is never done at a ' \u25a0 ; cost approximating that which the careful' business- ! man deems proper; In the clerical positions, he will ' discover that instead of devices to reduce the labor ; of. the accountant, and to insure the' accuracy' of | accounts, there is a" constant effort to increase the ! number of employes and a decided tendency to so ' obscure matters that the tax payer can riot form a" < judgment as to whether his contributions are squan- ; dered or properly expended. If- the .work; is .'manual ! and the possibility of'using two men to do one man's '< work offers itself, it is never resisted. 'I« purchasing ; supplies, despite closely drawn specifications, there are i constant violations of the spirit and letter,of contracts '< in which "the city gets the worst of the bargain and ; officials profit by turpitude. As for civility and atten- \ tion, the, lack of it in public servants is notorious, ! and the increased security which strained construe- ' tions of the tenure provisions of bur civil service laws ; •give to municipal employes will still further accentu- ! the evil. . - . : [ Under the circumstances it is; preposterous to ! assume that public ownership of a street railroad ' wo.uld effect a reform of any kind whatever. Nor ; would it, 'as: is sometimes urged, save us- from the \ evil of strike's. On the contrary, it would increase ' the chances of their occurring. The experience of '• England and France conclusively demonstrates that ; high organization of the civil service results in placing ! the government at the mercy of its' employes. The < utmort vigilance is required in Great Britain to pre- ; vent coalitions of employes in the postoffice depart- ; ment for the purpose of compelling compliance with ; their demands by threatening to paralyze the business ; ofthe country, and only recently in France something ; in the nature of military intervention was required to' ! stop, public servants "from achieving their purposes ! by'the same methods. „ \u0084 -'\u25a0;\u25a0\u25a0' - ! No argument that has as yet been brought forward ' will satisfy -any reasonable San Franciscan that it ' would be good public policy for thecity to build and. ' operate the Geary street railroad. To do so we would ' have to add a couple of millions to an already heavy ; burden of taxation, deprive the city of the opportunity of having the line made part of a system enjoying the | valuable privilege of transferring to all parts' of SaA i Francisco, and, what is worse; than, all, -'we shoultf |! place a premium on inefficiency by giving the United^ ! Railroads an excuse for bad service, which it would ! certainly have if no more : was required of it than ! to do as well as a municipally conducted line. J ing out .their produce to the east and west, north and south, t he \ growing demand for industrial and mechanical lines of training and. the cry , of our mothers, "What shall. we do with our boys?" have become the great ques tions that' confront us today. ••\u25a0-';'\u25a0 \The;.questlon immediately before the electors of San Francisco and to "be voted upon on the 22d; of \u25a0 this month is . the " erection and : equipment "of ' a Polytechnic high school In San Fran cisco. The amount provided for. in the bond issue is sufficient to v furnish suit able buildings, and equipment, .enlarge thcscope of- the present school and enable its- students to receive such training in \u25a0 Industrial and mechanical work -as to enable- them to compete with the young men and \u25a0 women .of other', lands, arid' what is of .the highest Importance, become self-supporting at an; early age. 'This'' is .the crying need of ; the time: . .\u25a0\u25a0ilt.'.is therefore necessary^ that every voter of the city and county"' of San Francisco; should, consider, the \u25a0 estab lishment ;i of a .: new Polytechnic high" school as; one- of the ; paramount issues of our. city and should cast -his vote on'^the"; 22d ; of June; for? : , proposition No. ; - 2; , paul Jbarbieri* • •\u25a0•- -\ ••v. ; ;;;:.i:;^l626jHalght3streets^ San Francisco,: June fls,' k 1909. 1 .:. .. : Answers to Queries LOTTERY-0. S.. f FruitraK Cal. I* '«, w an ordinance In San \u25a0 Franclseb: that prohibits the printing; of lottPrrdrawingg? ' . -Ordinance- No. 286, approved ApriP 1. 1901. says: ;; "Section. 1. \u25a0•/\u25a0lt \u25a0' snail be unlawful for any person to publish/prlnt, pass, give or deliver >: to another, or /circulate or distribute any newspaper; magazine, writings, prints, bills/handbills, cards instruments^ or devices /which purport to be., or represent tobe, or which con tain copies, statements or memoranda of a lottery, drawing, or which purport to be. or r represents to"- be, or contain statements,, -declarations," : copies or memoranda, or. lists of .the. luck or win ning characters; numbers or figures in or of a; lottery, or in or of ;a lottery drawing. . \u25a0;•\u25a0.• :.,-; ' .> ,\u25a0:\u25a0\u25a0.-., <\u25a0 ."Seen 2. \u25a0\u25a0\u25a0 Any person violating any of the provisions of this ordinance shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor." \u25a0 \u25a0 \u25a0 \u25a0\u25a0\u25a0;' ."' • '\u25a0 •\u25a0 • \u25a0 • \u25a0 - K ILLEGITIMATE-Q.. City. ; Does an lUeglti mate v child' inherit the \u25a0.= property -of -father -or mother under j. the: lairs "^of California? ' * Such a, child 'inherits if ." ; the father recognizes^the child. ,: The child is an heir of the mother's property. /THE BAR— TV. G.R., Citx". Is there any \es fipr_aflc<at:that can: not,\ because of its* draft' cross , the bar . &f. - the ; entranco of San Francisco bay? ;7: ' ...... '. .:< f i : . \u25a0.\u25a0 . \u25a0 .. _. ;-,.,-. There; is not. The, greatest depth" at the .bar.: is 63 . fathoms,: or 378 • feet. FI.ATHEAD— W. i J. R., - McCJoaii. Cal. What department 1 can '- 1 urn I eh ; information .? about - the opening of . the Flathead . reservation In Montana ? .' The ' general; land" ; offipe. : "Washing ton,^r>.?c. v : r -i '\u25a0\u25a0 : - : :r- '-:-'."- ; -' - \u25a0 :.i PORTOLA : STICKER— M. . H. - V.. City. -Who posed J f or -\u25a0 the « picture :' on *\u25a0 the '• Portola festival sticker?'-', /;';_,\u25a0\u25a0 \u25a0. \u25a0" ; , ..' "'V-;,'-. -\-- ; *;j Ernie ;fikyward: of the< Princess" the ater company. ~ " \u25a0"_ • \ '\u25a0',-. '. ''. '\u25a0\u25a0 \u25a0• \u25a0'.\u25a0 "\u25a0. *\u25a0*'\u25a0'.\u25a0:+'- ,'r »^-"'--': ':* ---•"-;' <> BLOCK -MATCHES— Vr.'>A.V M.i-; Camino, : Cal. Where i were >. the' bloctt matches^ or,? as : they /are sometimes " : called, v; '.'Chinese n r matches," \u25a0 first As They Used To Look VICTOR HOWARD METCALF, lawyer, con gressman, first secretary of commerce and labor, secretary , of the navy under President Roose velt and banker— From a photograph taken 27 years ago when Mr. Metcalf was 28 years old and was prac ticing law in Oakland :\u25a0'":. :-: :-: The Insider Tells how force of habit led Captain Bruguiere, the new state bar pilot, to forget he was no longer commander in the army transport service Pilot Forgot His Role on Transport force of habit. . Before his appointment as pilot Bruguiere was for more than ten years a commander in the army transport service. The first ship that he was detailed to. take to sea as a pilot was the army transport Logan. The Logan passed out over the bar and slowed down tVawait the approaching pilot schooner Pathfinder that was to take Bruguiere off. The transport stopped. A yawl was launched from the Pathfinder and two. hardy Norse men propelled it toward the troopship. Under the lee of the Logan's lofty sides the oarsmen rested on their oars and looked up expectantly at the steamer's bridge. Bruguiere looked down at them, waved a friendly greet ing, rolled a cigarette and leaned against a stanchion at ease. A Jacob's ladder rattled over the ship's side. Bruguiere leaned over the bridge rail, and, with languid interest, gazed from the ladder to the drifting yawl. Sud denly he turned around: . "Where the dickens," he asked, "is that pilot?" . When Captain Stimson, master of the Logan, " realized that Bruguiere imagined himself still in the transport service, he laughed a cruel chuckle, and Bruguiere, woke with a jump and made record time from bridge to yawl, promised to buy Stimson a hundred of the biggest, .greasiest Havana cigars on the market if he would forget. Long Lives Prove City Is Healthful in awhile. It was called to my attention most forcibly the other day when I scanned the death notices in the morning paper. Out of 24 dead persons the ages of 21 were given. Of these 21, six were over 80 years of age, the figures being: 83, 81,, 88, 83, 86 and 89. Five more were over 70 years of age, as follows: 78, 75, 79, 75 and 7S. Itseems to me that for 11 out of. 21 to have attained and passed the prophet's three score year* and ten is a splendid evidence that our climate and habits of life conduce to longevity. It may prove interesting, for purposes of comparison, to give the ages of the other men and women in this obituary list of a single unexceptional day. They are as follows: 66, 65, 55, 54. 4 S, 44, 34, 30, 27 and 27. For the bene fit of the ladies, let me call attention to the fact that only two in this list were of their gentle sex, and both died at a ripe old age. Versifier Known as an Oyster Salesman San Francisco versifier, whose contributions to several magazines are distinct and apart fronv the greater mass of "stuff" published today, in that they contain some idea. As an afterthought, he added: "I sell them." *v> Which is a fact. He is about the only man in the world who has success fully sold oysters and woped the muse to financial gain. His poetical ambi- » 1 tions, on .leaving: the university, were tempered by the . fact that he had to -* make a living, and he accordingly went into the oyster business. Why he chose the soulless and prosaic oyster, neither' he nor anybody else know 3. HEALTH ORDINANCES AND THE DIRTY STREETCARS San Francisco, June 23, 1909. Editor Call: Ordinance No. 3064 of the health laws (approved .March. 15, 1897) prohibiting expectoration in street railway cars, section 2, reads as follows: ' • "All street railway companies shall keep posted <in a conspicuous place in their- cars a sufficient number of no« t'ices calling attention to the provisions of this; order." "•; Most of- the cars are thus . equipped, but' the sighs in some cases can not be read"o"n accouat of the . dirt that has covered them.. In inspecting these signs your eyes would naturally turn to • the whole car, with a result far from pleasant. The cars are all dirty, with the leather medal in favor, of those on; the : Fillmore street car line, which have not; been cleaned in months. An inspection of the_Jiealth laws shows no .ordinance- covering this .point. — Plas the public. or our board of super visors'; ever stopped to" consider the saying to the United Railroads by reason of the ;trollev franchise? < Prob-" JUISE 17; 1909 THEY are telling this story on Captain Bruguiere, the newly appointed state bar pilot. Incidentally it illustrates the Is San Francisco a healthful city? Of course, we all know that it is, but it does no harm to have the fact called to our attention- once "I am the only poet who can afford to eat oysters." Thus spoke' Thomas Springer, a youns ably 175 cars less per day are on our public- streets now than formerly. The speed of the electric over that of tha cable accounts for most this, but the re3ult is the same— a savins of not less than $500,000 per annum. Would it not he possible for an aroused pub lic demand or a waking up on the part .of our supervisors in this connec tion, compel the railroad company to put some of this gain into a cleaner and. more sanitary condition of their cars. But: to return to the original Idea of this communication. After a careful study for the last six months I have coma to the conclusion that 75 per cent of _ the conductors wet their fingers and pass you a dirty transfer. Seem ingly this does not come under the above mentioned ordinance. I refer the matter to "~ your "consideration, hoping; that your familiarity with city laws tjir else -an" appeal: in the right direction will stop, what to my mind, is as dangerous a menace .to the general health/ as expectorating on the floor of a, car.-' Yours. truly. A. 3L GRAVES.