Newspaper Page Text
MEMBER OF THE ASSOCIATED PRESS ALL TODAY'S NEWS TODAY. VOL. XXII. CALUMET, MICHIGAN, TUESDAY AFTERNOON, JUNE 10, 1013. NUMBER 192 MANY STOCKS HIT THE LOWEST LEVEL OF YEAR Minnesota Rate Decision Proves Hard Blow to Railroad and Industrial Shares LOOK TO CONGRESS FOR AID Railroads Have Hope That Rate Making Power Will Be Tak en From States OPINIONS ON DECISION DIFFER New York, June P The stock mai led was sharply depressed ul-the ')-it i it fir today n-s the rosiiit of tin- U- i l iii of the supreme cuiii'l in Ik- .Mil'liebC'til CUSe.' IlaillOad hi MP'S Hi'lt i.M in large amounts mid prices gave v.iv In all directions. Tin I ii'Kf -si lose a.-' luslaincd by tlio Ndi tin-in I'ai-ilic. in.. n" the railroads directly concern--.l in ihi' Minnesota case. Thai slock lr..ke IU to 10.". Amalgamated. Steel .in.! a number of ollu ra opened I lo I ints lov-i. . After Mm llrst tdiarp break. Hi" market rallied, rceuverlng f i -oil hull lo a voinl in many cat.18. Lowest Pricts of Year. MMiough railroad stocks were the ii.-ivl'tt sufferers, virtuitlly all to-ls Hailed in fell to t lie lowest of the cur, tic- losers extending more Mian four li'iiii". Ilruktis gathered on Mie flour han; before (lie ol enitis of Mie market, ivl.l.ii was the signal fur excited yell ii k. n Mic first downward nihil, large i ks of etoek were marketed. Lar;.;c MipoiHn orders liad been distributed i.l'.iro the opening of l In market and Hi ir execution checked Mie break ut ter the first sharp decline. T!ie effect of th Mlnnesola rale do- i .ii. heightened 1y ne-veral oilier '.ir; Ii factors, nil combined lo Rive is., -i.m-kef the severest shook in in.i'i'. month.. It was reported tin- at- imaev general would oppose iolli nlans for the iPxHolutiou of Mh- llarri 'iiii roat'H. Anollier unfiivoiable iu '' i ii..- whs the failure of KiiKlibcrt & .-" iilocsHei, annotmced on tin- London I'm k .-M-lianve today. KiiKb-bert. Mm-M-iiior member of tlie lirm. was kilb-d '...st Salmilav lili lie drove Ills aiilo-i'i-MI. Ilirongli a fence Into Mo- river Medu.iJ. Tlie Hill NloekH fell ie fciiil.s bvlov KKrd:i"K close. Boston Market Also Hit. Mo.l on. June 10. U.cal copper and "bold Kliare opened decidedly lower "ii the Hoton excliance toda. Not -ni b- 'Urlines from yenterd iyH los" v i le in oi-Mi Hulte. whb-li opened oil I'.-; Copper KaiiKe off 1'-: 'aliimel X Arizona off 1; Hotduii & Maine and I iiit.-, Maebluci'y both down I. Trad u;r. was active. Df.ision Simplifies Rate Making. Washington June I La yert wb' ; atbefed today Ht tlie hiipreiio' court l i listen to the application of piiie i I'l's lil.l down by Justice HukIics in Hi'- MiiineHolu rain cases to the rate Ms fiom Missouri. Arkansas. Ken-iii'-ky. Oregon ond Wetst Virninlii "ere f the t.lnloii that rate making 1otl. in the Mates and before '.tin- federal ; eminent had been reduced to a iiiimIi more tineurute hftsis tlian ever ! forr!. All sirts of opinions prevailed as to whnre the victory rested In the Mln-M-sota decluloiiB. Minnesota stele of-I'-lals, in dispatches, enpretised .leas i.re ovr Mie result, and Attorney (leu ia MtUeynoldn and niemberH of tlie interstate commerce commission snld they were fully untlstled. The pros l""t or ConKress taklus chaiKe of state ii't.-s :i iTct-t In? Interstate commerce in - iiieetly lent encouragement to Mi ililro.uls tlKtt tbey would escHiefrom fKiilatlon 1y forly-elght Hate coin ii:i;itnis. The attempt of tlie railroads to es tablish n cost of reoroilliclllff ,,f,,r I'loiuTty new. as equivalent to "f, 'id lie" on which they were entitled t rn rates, was regarded as dooinei 'I be federal court of Minnesota adoot .-.l thui t.uiM It nllowed a railroad t ....a. ii.. .i.- ;,n,.nni market value of ibe bind hy two. In order to arrive at ii int ..f mr,rr.,i.irlnt- a new right of way outtddo of the three I.Ik cltie.s of tint Ktale. Jiutle' Hughes held there was no place for hypothetical mu. -I Her In nxU. a "fair value" of ra toad property upon which the publ c him pay a return, and that the ral -ronds ought to b satisfied, if ra;r average market price" was Riven their land, free from hypothetical additions. That wruld permit railroads to enjo 'to benefit of the general prosperity or the cuuntrj by recelvhii? In return not nly upc, Us original Invttment bii. en the Increase In the value of their investment. Members of Congress Uted when a?ked their ppinlons whether Congress IS MURDERED IN HOME ShotJJjy Man Who Had Entered His Daughter's Room Ml.. June 10. C'liailoa 'clnr r iolill, WilM 1 liis home tin. illy after a iim n who Imu baffled i.indi.rt, ,i i munl'-icd i lllidllif.,ht ,y Liiii tin. sii.-rirr :nid pulice (,y cav- "tf no lows. Lindoft ittutbid home rrom the an nual cumnicm-i im-nt- concert of Knox Conservatory ..( Music at-II o'clock. II.- h id taken i:t i t In th... comm. At I o'cloik Ids daughtt r. ji. i was awakem-d l.y tia- niur.lr of a revolver against tcr foi-rhiad. A grub' voice, told ,t r t,j remain iuiel under tlnj penalty of death. She tried ttJ M.ream out tin man's lingers chit-lad lor throat. Llnd.ll, hearing a coiuntol i..ti, called "Whose i Ik-i 'Chore ttH ni reply find lie stilled lo enter his daughter's loom. Throe sliula were lircd by tin: lnt.rnd.-i-. all takini; clfet (. UNFROCKED CLERGYMAN IS WEDDED TO HIS AFFINITY Stanford. Conn., June Jere KieMle Cooke, the unfrocked Episcopal b iKj man, whoso wife recently ob tained a divorce, and Floreita Whulcy, wllh whom he eloped nix yearn ngo, "ere married in t,e parlors of a local hotel Mils morning In the presence of friends, who came here with the couple last eventiiK. Mr. and Mrj. Cooke re turned (, their homi. pi New- York hhorllv niter the .servl.e. Two children nave bet n born to the pair since their elopement. Hnee bin expulsion from the ministry Cooke has been worklni; 'is a house painter in New York. would Hoon exercise the power, found by the court to rest with it to regu late such state ratcH hh affect Indi rectly interstate commerce, were not inclined to coin' forth ut first blush villi a plan to revciw the policy o! tlie federal isoveruim-nt through Mu last oil" hundred years of leaving uch regulation In Mr Jamd of (lie Hales, Power of States Is Upheld. Washington. i. C. J mo- In - -Tin power ol the Mate to lix leasonable interstate r;'t.-s on interstate railroads tin I II Kta-h Mine as Congress i-liall choose to n-gulate these ratM wa.s up held laic yesterday by the supremo court oT the I'nlted States in the Min nesota freight and passenger rale c ascs. At the ramr- time the court liid down lai-reaehiiii; principles Kovcrn iii!; (be valuation of railroad properly for ratr-inakiiiK purposes, and, ac cording to these, held that the slate of Minnesota wool. I. conllseale the iropoily of the Minneapolis V St. Inils lailroa.l company by its maxi mum ft-'ighl and Z cent passenger fate law. It enjoined the slate (Tom en loiciij'T these laws as lo this load for the present. In the cases of the Northern I'a'.ill " and tircat Northern. Imwever. the court held Mia I I he c roads had failed to show that Mo- rates were "unreas onable" or "roiitlscnlory." and conse. Illclltly reversed the I'nlted State.l lilri-t court ior .Minnesota, which l.ad enjoined Mie enforcement as both onllseatory and a bunb n on intfr s.tale comuiei-ce. The decision, i"2aid.-.J as one ot me .....ut li.io..i'i:iot ever announced bv the courl. has been under considera tion for fourteen months. I Jail road commissions from eight slates and the governors or nil Mm- states filed briefs in support id the state in the cases, recognizing that the principles In volved affected Mieni all. Comment by McReynolds. Suninriri.lng Mm decision or the su preme court of the irnlled Stales In the Minnesota rale case. Attorney i;neral Mcl!e nobis said: "The (..nit hol.s that Congress, in the interstate commerce act, has not deprived the states of Hit right of llx- lug maxlmum Interstate rules. i io-j have the power. In contesting u still ra I e that fixed bv the state on Ho- run mi the rate Is confiscatory, the de cision Kays that the lmriieii oi piooi of conllscation fjlH upon the railroad l-l,, mi found that Mie Minneapolis ,V St. L"Ol. railroad had cKtaldlshed ti- it the rates aflVctinrr them were con-ns-atory. but that th- Northern IM villi' and Ureal Northern had fulled In such proof." Minnesota Officials Elated. ... ......i Mn . .lime H.Stttc offi cials and others connected wlMi ..I Minnesota ea.ses Ml'.! are Hated over the decision of the I'nlt ed ttes supreme court and were M.animous In declaring it ii great vic tory for the state. s a result of the decision several n,ilr Is operating hi Mlneapolls will pay Into the state treasury approxl matelv $3,000,000 In the h"l'' ' over- charges. When informed jf the courts decision. Coventor supreme Kberhart taid: .1. i Hi.. heM bit of news I have 11 ' . ...... .1. tluV.SU heard in long 1 1 11 "I"""-""" what we have ..iu.n tonienueu; no' . .1.1 . t i.o Ki.ite in reculate within ' ? ..'... It H a great victory and Minnesota ha. the honor of being tlie leader In making " ble." ' UNITED STATES SHOES WORLD Twenty Million Dollars Worth of Footwear Sold Abroad in the Past Year LESS THAN MILLION IN 1890 Present Importations Valued at Only Quarter of "Million CUBA IS THE LARGEST BUYER Washington, June 10. All the world lu cuinlnjr to the United States for toots and snoes. , ' Accordiiie; to a stateiuent Jn.-it is. biivd by the, bureau ut foreiun -and domestic commerce, department of commerce, bojts. and shoes exported from the L'nlred States in . Mm llscal ear which e.ids with llio current1 month, will aggregate -o miHioiis dol lars in value. ugTintit 5 million dol lars In ll'UO and less than 1 million dollars in Inyo. This total for laia Includes about IS million dollars' worth of leather boots and shoes, one third uf a million dollars' worth uf slippers, and approximately J million tlulldi's' worth of hoots and shoes ol rubber. In addition to this, nearly 2 million dollars' worth of bather boots and shoes went to I'orlo Rico and Hawaii. Meantime the importa tion ot boots and shoes into the United States during the current llscal year will amount to about $:.'.o,ouo. The average value ptr pair ol leather booty mid shoes exported during the fiscal year Vili was: Those for men's wear, $.11; women's. $1.7;:; children's, 78 cents, and (dippers, $l.o."i. The av erage import price of boots and tdior.s imported was about. cents per pair. Hundred Countries Buy Them. All the world takes American boots uuj shoe,!.. The number of countries, colonies, and dependencies to which the txpoits went last year aggregated approximately 10i. Cuba Is the larg est buter of lids class of merchandise. The value of boots and shoca exporletl 'o that Island from the I nitid States during the llscal year J:l, (he latest period for which details of distribu tion (o all countries are available, was pi'Htticully- 3 million dollars out of a toti'l of I'i million dollars' wen Mi of leather bint.-- and shoes exported in that year. 'Co Ca.iada the eximrts In thai year amounted lo -'a million dollars: laiKlaed, I'i million; !er inaiiy, practically I million; Panama, Muee-'iutU it in of w million; France. Austrla-lluncHi., the I'liilippine isl ands, and the. tbitisli West Indies, each ' riboul a half million dollars; Argentina and llul.x, cah one-third ot .i million, and I'ri.il. a .niarter of a million dollars. To all Kuropc the total w.is 4-. million dollars; to North America. '. million; lu South Ameri ca, I'i million; to iK-eania. nearly I million: to Africa, a. quarter of a million dollais nn.l to Asia, $S.,170. Extent of Distribution. J'he wide extent of dl.-;tributiun is shown bv Mie fat that the list of couuUhii named by the bureau of foreign and domestic commerce as the det.tliiutlom- vt the !; million dollars worth of leather boots and shoes ex ported in li'll! was, as above indicated, nearly I (. and among them India, the Straitu SctMcuui.ts, China. Korea, Siam, Helgian Kongo. I'ersia, Kgypt. MrlMsh, lYeiieh. Portuguese, and Spanish Africa; and lYeiieh and tier- man islands lit i lie ruenic. - in auui- t Ion to the foregxiing expti Is of leather boots and ihoes, in the fiscal year MM-, those of India rubber amounted to Sl.."2.X!o. distributed to iiOoul 70 countries, colonies, and de pendencies. The largest vnlues were to Ktiglund, 5taJ?,74.1; Australia, $:':';'.. f.1l: Turkey In Lurope, IIIA.COJ; und iSerniany. $10l'.20. The other coun tries named in the list included In dia. China, Keirca. Mritish islands in the Pacific, Liberia. LIgyTd. Tripoli. iiKf P.ermitda. The Imports of leather boots and shoes, which amounted to $225, lDf lu the fiscal rear were chiefly from the United KitiKdoii. $lli:.Sti; Turkey In L'urope, JSI.fl-'fi; Spain, $19,775; Canada, $1 K,t": Auslria-lllungary. J12.S0.; China. $r,.217; (Jermany, ,170, and l'rance, 4,4 PRINCETON CONFERS DEGREES Commencement Today Marks Close of College's 166th Year. Prim ftun, N. J.. June lo. The class of 1913 received their degrees at the one hundred nml tdxty-sixth annual commencement of Princeton univer sity this morning. The diplomas were presented by President John tlrier lllbhen In Alexander hall. Shortty after 10 o'clock the academic proces ion formed In front of Nassau hall and proceeded to Alexander hall, led by President ltihben and the trustees, th reclolents of the higher degrees and honorary degrees and the gradu atln class following. This afternoon the customary reception' was given at th home of President and Mrs. Hlb beo. , i I (Copyrlrht.) NEWSPAPER LAW IS UPHELD BY COURT It Is Declared, in Decision Today, to Bo Constitutional Washington, June In. Tin- supreme court today upheld (he constitutional ity of the newspaper publicity law, en acted as jMirt of tin- Mistal appropria tion. bill at the end of 112. A bitter fight was made ugitinst the law, which, it is said, affects more than 2."i,0'J0 -publications ol" the United Slates:. speaking-of 'the clause rerjuiring the marking- of paid nMeles as "advertising-." Chief JusliceSviiite said this re- (uiremei t was cognate with the policy of ths government, from If.s founda tion. o make the expenditure of vast Minis, to afford low mail rates to news- paper: tinici end bring some advifU.'ite re lo the public. NEW YORK ARCHITECT TO RECEIVE $60,000 1 FOR LIBRARY PLANS. Ietr.it. June I a. Cass Ullbcrt. of New Yoi.1 city, has been chosen by a Jury of experts as architect r the m w lietmlt pn'.iie library. Uilbcrt wa.s one uf the six competitors who submitted dcsK'ns to the Jnn. The successful designer Is to receive six per cent of tb.- U.noo.oiMj appropria tion for the library. The pew library will be built on upper Woodward avenue, between I'ai nsworth and Kirby av enues, and will b.? a constituent part of the Cine .Arts civic center for this section of tin- city. The new l-troit museum of nits will occupy a. slt- across ine street from the library bnilOinr. TWO MILITANTS ARE CHARGED WITH CAUSING $70,000 LOSS London. June In, Kilty Marion, an actress, and Clara, uiveen. a. win known militant suffragette, who has undergone several terms of imprison ment for outrages, were arraigned in police conn today on suspicion that they Ml lire to the stand at the Hurt irk ra.-e course jestcrday, causing a damage of $70.(K'0. I hey were re leased on bail. KILLED BY ST. PAUL TRAIN. John Turk Cot in Two at McKeever Sundsy N.ght at 7:30. John Turk, a brakeman. employed on the Chicago. Milwaukee & SI. Paul read was Instantly killed Sunday night at 7' 30 v. hen he fell under a train at McKeever. Turk was engaged In switching ears ind was walking ulong.the top of n freight train when he missed his footing- and fell tuider the wheels. The body has ben taken to his home In (Ireen Pay. REDUCE MINE FATALITIES. fSlrmlnchani. Ala.. June lo. Means by which the bss of life in coal mines can be reduced were brmuftot out In the addressee delivered this afternoon ut the sessions of tho Mine Inspectors' Institute of the United States, which Is holding Its national meeting here this week. Two hundred mine In spectors are present. Kvery coal mining camp of Inumrtanco In the United States is represented. TMtz-Carlton hotel. Philadelphia. Is to be doubled In slae, work on an ad dltlon to start In July. WHICH? DEITZ LUMBER PILE ROTTEN. Milwaukee Firm May Not Claim Tim ber at Cameron Uam. Couduay. Wis. June I a. p pre-.-ntatlve ( the Pi". ft Lumber com pany of Milwaukee, who is at Winter inspect Inc, the licit, lumber on the now famous ivit. farm at Cameron I aiii. declares tie- wood i. in. very poor ciiiiditioii and hardly worth haul int? to to n. 'I his lumber is Mm product of the while pine o-;.s that were Icl'l on llio l it laim by ba kwater when the '.Ve'erhai'.ser 'uniber eonipauy was tlrivlne lo;s on the Thornapple river alioat ten -ars n'o, and which lelti: tefuscd t let the lumber company re move, and which was the nu.se of the now notorious Lcitz cases in Sawyer county. PHILADELPHIA JACK O'BRIEN IS IN BANKRUPTCY COURT Philadelphia, June pi. Jos. V. A. I lagan, known as "Philadelphia Jack ' Prien." piiKilist and flu lit promoter, tiled a petition in bankruptcy in the federal court today. His liabilities arc I0.0"ii, an, i assets $ 1 o.immp. J e built a laixe ball in west Philadelphia to ilaRc six round bouts, but the ven ture was unsuccessful. Among the creditors is a .1. piddle, prominent in society, who, with ii'lbien, lias given a number r boxing showw to whh-h a .'elect few were ln Ittsl. They wcr given in the handsome home ol Bid die. lii.llleVs claim Is tlMO. RETURNS FROM EUROPE. G. M, Martini Spends Pletant Thiee Moohs in Native Land. C M Martini relumed yestfidav trom a three months' tour In fchnope, the purpose of vhich was to visit !!-.-fives in Lucca Paly, his land of na tivity. The tour Proituht Mr. Martini into l-'ranee, ;rm.i ny and Knglaicl af ter departing from Italv and ultogt tli- r, the journey va.-; pleasant. Our of Mie pleasing recol e. t i' ms to Mr. Mar tini was bi.s presentat i ii of l oppe'' specimens to a museum in Lucca and Ids etnerosity was highly lauded by the Italian press. An aunt with whom Mr. Martini visited i: ctill hearty dc spltp lor age of ;: vears und amoiur the routine of her life the attend.' church daily. The ciwt of living la as lofty in Lu rope as in America, says Mr. Martini and conditions abroad are similar t" those m America. I'tK-aniness Is ap parent In the i.ir: industrial renters where In- visited and -"imittons were le t as favorable as on hi.s last trie, nine ytr'is ago. Mr. Martini left Nw York, l ebruary 2s and sent six weeks lu Italy. While In Florence he met John IV Cuddihy. who will return i C.ilumel this week. Mr. Martini sail ed from Southhampton May 28 and the ii.' i i e homeward vovnge was msule dh'i?recib1e through intens" fog. WORLD'S "V" MEET OPENS, L'dlnbursh. .Pine 10 Pclrpateti from many counPleF. including Kngland. Canada ntM the Pnited Stftes, have, arrived in Ldtnburi;h to attend the world conference n,f the Young Men's Christian asstM-laMon. The conference will hive is formal opening tomor row and the sessions will continue until the end tf the week. FIREMAN IS BADY HURT. Chicago, June 10. Fire early today destroyed a three story building occu pied by a shavings and sawdust com pany, infilling a loss of $l?.,(Ko. Fire man William Lefleur was partially burled beneath debris when a wall was blown out by exploding sawdust. He suffered severe Internal Injuries. SLEEPING MAN IS KILLED WITH AXE Wife Tells Vague Story of Crime by Midnight Intruder Hal i ison ville, Mo., June- P. Arthur Kelt. i. a railway employe, livint; n.ai here, was nmrdi-rcd with an ate in his home last nuht. ami his seven -year-old daughter was m riously wounded. A blow also was alined at Mrs. Kel ler, but it struck tin. side of the. bid and awakened lur. Shi leaped I'roiri I Mm bed and sIvulcIiuk with tin- inur- ! mr, drove him from the house. She f-rave the alarm and neiuhbors and a posse are sHintiin? for the slayer. Family Life Not Happy. Vathan Kell.ir, a brother or tin- nun -e'ered iii!:n, testified, at the in.pieM that Arthur carried $l,t""" life insurance and that the, wife was the berietlciary According to other testimony I! v life of the Kellais had the not fain- b.-.r hapfiy. Mrs. Kellar was on the .'(and ai hour, l'er descripti.ui of the murder er was vague. Aecordint; to the nu thoiliies who went to tlie Kellar horn Sifter the murder it was brought out I that Mrs. Kellar. whin she appealed at a neighbor's and td1 of the tragedy carrier) a bloody axe in lo r hand, and wore night clothing. She said she had picked up the axe in the back yard No Need ot a Posse. The authorities who examined the K liar home and vicinity said they found ru. foot prints either in front '-r back "f the house. Sneriff Piatler (aid he believed Mure was no : .earchiinv for the murder, r tin poPfC. eed id liif.h a MANY SERVIANS LOST IN BATTLE WITH BULGARIANS London. June In. Many Servian 5 w ere k'lled in an encounter bet v. e. n Servian and I'.uk 't i in Poops near the small town of Uakeis, acordtng to dispatch today. Further reuiflti.ts xpected in the same vicinity a tin Servians on londay notified the p.ul F.arian commander that nnbfH I" evacuates Mie f . :i ( ol unlan bv evening the Serv ians v. ould bond'aio Istlp now o'i-upiiil by tin- Unitarian.'. OBSLRVE3 123rd ANNIVtRlAMy. Mas' busf 1 1 Medical Sweety Op'' Annual Reunion Tedy, IV.ston. June to. The -Vol ltMH of th" t.cjnd anniversary of Its fo - m - datioii is one of the b-adli.x featvi of the meeting of the Ma-sarhus,e,tt:-. Medical sc-cp-ty. which rp-ned uvie tivlay at the Copli.y-Pla7.ii h"til, f" icniait in :eiin tor two djyr This morning th'rc were elmie; at the Massachusetts Geneul ho'iutal end the Prtr Pent LrUham hospital d several separate meetings uf the su pervisors Pnd of the eoiwii. In th" afternoon s-tions mectincs were held and the annual meeting will be h Id tomorrow morning. At r"n tomor row Ir. Homer (lace, of Worcester, will deliver the annual discourse and in lh" afternoon a combined meeting f the sections of midicine and sur gery will be hold. The .program will loe with the annual dinner i tho Copley-Plaza bull room. FIFTY RUSSIANS DROWNED. St. Petersburg. June in Fifty per sons were drowned by the finking of a dilapidated ferry boat crossing the river Tchcptoa on Russian ascension day, June 5. according to a dispatch from Vlctaka, 0; 8. SUPREME COURT FAILS TO SAVE CHARLTON He Must Return to Italy to An swer to Charge of Murder ing His Wife DECISION HANDED DOWN TODAY Long Fight Against Extradition, Involving Treaty Interpre tation, Is Futile CRIME STIRRED WHOLE WORLD Washington, Jmi" P. rurier "harl fn must ! turn f- K.Uy to answer the hurge e.f h i iny nmrOcrcd h.is wife in Jin.'.-. I'M ii, at Lnke C"ti)o. The su preme court s' il.-. ided t"'Jay. Jcste e Linton delivered the opin ion. II- said Iirs that no error had I ."in eeminiitteel In excluding evidence of msnriiiy ;it Mie habeas corps's pro-i-eedir:tT: in the lower 'ourt, and that n.. error l ad l.en committed in mak ing a f'.riual (I'lnand f-n- Charltwn. Lurton Interpret Treaty. n il v main point in the case, whether, um.br the treaty of 1S6S, u.i Aui'-rican citizen ould ho extradited to Italy for a eiline committed ther I ai ti ul.uly sinci Italy vVill not ex tradite its .ociijocts for crime commit ted here, Lurton said tlA' refusal to surrender ciiizem: for ivtradition was of modi rn oriui-.i. Some American trcati'-s provided citizens shall not be Airaditeil white ethers aie silent. "The com lnslon Is" said Lurton, "tfiat tl.is poveriurient in niaklng ex- cption 'ii some treaties lhrt it would r"l ex'radltv Ps citizen, shows it was fully aware then- v.is no exception In favor ot citir.ens In other treaties where tie excettton was not made, n4 lu the treaty with Itjly." "h nl;. u h.i': been n pritener In the Iu'l!"'!i county. N w Jersey Jail for in al ly Cn ee year. Cri-n Stirred tho World. The killiny, of Mrs. Porter Charlton .' tirn d l'urope and A me-rk a as have few murders of recent years. With M e dise..v. rv of her crumpled body Muit'id into a trunk and sunk in Laka I'omo. Italy, where fdio h.id h.vn with liar husband to spend her honeymoon. both continents turned t-' sjec.rch for the murderer. The iu j-t rcat probhrn to solve was the V. h. rcabuutn jt the twenty-one years old husband who, as a bank ch.-rk in New York, had married the woman. i".ht yun older than him self and M: divorced wif .f Neville' II 'istle. a San Krar.v-lsco lawyer. His father. Pad Charlton, law adviser of Mu- bureau el Insular affairs and for mer k'rccident Taft's classauate, was rit!n in the c'-nvfetion that hi3 son. too. had been murd"ied. That ques- tb ai ' W itll ca."c. i'. !"' is :;. uved whrn Porter Charlton, bis ;nltials mark"d on hiii suit airive.i in a steamer from Itab, divy liter at Hobokin. N. J. Confessed to Murde, I iu?ht Mp-re appeared :t confea- ittng bis name, h Mi.- ac epuinco of th cemfes The n n 1 v:r a- a . soluUoii of the crime, then ilt !o. ? once the illfdomatic 'm of 'harlton's extradition. It Mlnuttei.l on all hands that Chaxl- Pi" Ail.' It-.n .on!. I not be tr:el In the United I si.'tes tor a rine committed In lt.il:'. ilis frl'-nd.s bead'd by Ida father, took ireaty. Months uf dipl. matic ex jttadit'd r..i Palv, b-L-ause Italy had M-l-.vavs jcfusetl. under the extnidltlen j i real y .: lM'.b 'o retu;;i Itnllar rub. J .ice '.. to tb- fnil'-d Snt'-ij lo answer . lor crii'U- eemuiir'.'.ii ic.ri.-. Paly Dtmsnded Priufner. pjv, lii'i'vr, m.tde 1 TcjoeM fee i the i.'Vlfconer. s-rttatv Knox pirr.ea t , wUi o tf;,i, thevebv m.ytit V" lt.-i pao infrrvettlou of tVi trc.ttv Mor.M.r of di:'pu-,attK iv- r i.in.-'v. ! i'"v :. .1-1,1,. .Ii.hu a. lil-Mr. of the Cmrt of 'yer and Teip.inei h: Hii'lK-H cocn ty. . J. s'Mir.s a tMeral cxtrc' dition urir.tTtr He, le-ld Charlton auV ject to extradition. Tho court de clined to receive evidence of Charl ton'i insanity, on the ground that un der the law of New Jersey defenses could ii"t be made ut ft preliminary hearing of the nature then before thi court. Anpealad o Supreme Court. Secretary Knov approve! that hold Ins:, taking lh? iif'ltlon tlint Inasmuch Chrtrltt n could not bo brought to ant-wer f"r the crime lu this country, the Cuilert States would adhere t Its interpretation of the treaty by surren dering him to Paly. Charlton's father then began the last flvht to save hi son from extradition. He nppialed to the Circuit Court of th. I'nlted States for New Jersey for Continued on 6th Pap, 3rd Column.