Newspaper Page Text
Tij batiet * tott cams. a g, mrkrA f9mi r< **** FûUth f r ii4 UM > JfértbMt«' Nat o«l Imnranra Fifth District Court, »a. flic, PsrUh of Orleans. finalem fn of the Jury - -Br rehren*« . thTurttek 2315 of the Civil Code of Quitten» you will poirdtethat "vu*ry '2316 of the C'îvll Code of ,,J will perceive that "every i5 U «hntever of man that causes dutn •SL*» another obliges him bv whoso ''Crittt bVPlPM Vi fppll,r ,l ; lo ^ticlc 42* of the same cod« and vou And that "A corporation is an in Jliilneatbclv. created by law." which, nililnr the provision cf article 43« of " lil cwde, must act through its offleors ÎÜ whom H entrust * the direction and " r „ cf H» affulrtt, according to the Stute« of the corporation * Ka V are the heads. They may bind iS« corporation to which they belong, ' matters m* legally come rurvlew of their authority, ■ttrâf'iey obi guilty - ... of which jo all such matters as legally come «ithIn the P'U' low, of ttieir authority, hut beyoftd that tlioy cannot. A cor n*7f§f1on cannot w guhty of a slander, Ltwithstaridlng It is considered a legal uftKiD, but It m»y • aaiietion the îoldleation of a libel, and in sueR -—"* Wnini*« the ntihlisher niera becomes the publisher liiere liable iu like manner as an UdtittMfll. The reason of this , nil who In anywise aid, or *Tjm nop^yecd 1» the production of the «rrltlDC are regarded in law as the au itiof* thereof. As if one composes and , l 2zL*~ a second writes, and a third Oddi ia liable. "Not as 1« » •oswt&ne* said, because « corporation ÏSy act with malice, but because it has * rSwidlv for voluntary tuition, and is "££ribfe for si, di action.* * ■ eZecordlngly H has been held that a JSoratlon aggregate may well, in Its < 2Sior»tecapacity. cause the public« S*pof • tlenunatory statement under ctrcutiistams-s as would imply ffiloi' (I. C-* » bad intent,) in law sum . Satte support the tuition; and there k. niri-umstanees by which express 123kg, ia r«ct might be ,»roved, such ns JTZ.lt«> noristrtitloii ( ggregnte liaide iSimlot In its eoritorafe capacity." ITowamnd m Blander tnd Libel, see Lj-mand 2»ir., an<l 15. Vinos vs. Mer » yfcnt-' Mutual ttisurcmsi Company, «at wt reported. N»t. 2550 of the 8u •iJanw Oourt, 4« N. Y., 472.1 It 1« my Kay to lnstru<*t you as to the difference « WttoOn «lander a nd lila I. that you may ik,Bore readily understand why a cor , nontten may not he held liable for the fcfmrr. Slander is defined P» be "a fAptofOccMloned by sp< «v-h, and libel a WtDtitf ocoaaloncd by wr.tlng or effigy ' T«i will observe that language is d la one, lan ânusl I y common to »oth, the ttaatlva difference bring that •lander, I* effected by oral ciiagc; the other, libel, l»y language that j*written. The lutter Is regarded M oikulated, in most cases, to do » i U f SiH injury than the former, nnd •eoorrilutly It U an acci'pted doctrine that snolen language, which may give ' it of action, may, If reduced to r n — j , liave unite a contrary effect, (lownsond on Blander and Libel, sec. every slander, says this author, «.Til, there are two acts : (!) the com ttMlftg, and (2) the publishing. In mrylibel there are three acts; (1) the iposlng ; (2) th" w riting, nnd (3) the F Ji*hing. The act whien I« the ernten ilslsmeiit Id the wrong*, slander aud el, I» a wrongful publication of lan ___jrule of luw j«, thet no OIWI should, Hpjrout legal oxcuw, publish language MDoernlug another, or hi* affairs, «hioh Is calculated to Injure or d«m •ge hliu. In other word*, says the itbor already «jnotod, p. 115, "Every ' tjcatiou or lungnugc concerning a or tils affairs, which, as a necessary tarai and proslurate couMuucnca, on* v»ecim(iiry loss to - him, Is fm\\p « slander or a libel a slati If the publication be oral; a libel, publication 1>c bv writing. To «to either, the langimge must defkuiatorv, falte. Hud ihr w if h malice, tlon made Willi malice, 'or mallclouBlv. The fact of the ' nge being true, due ( n«»t prevent «mounting to m wrong. "In prose (Stlooit for libel the truth may l*o given 1« e\kl«ui«'e. and if It be m««le *o a|>j*«vir \the matter charged as libelous is, nd wo* publia hod w 4 th good motive* Md for justlflablo fad*, Ihe party •hoald lw a«i|uiU<Ml," Ray's Revised iLtetca n 7ST M.-. n<5âi Bv the. 123d Metntea, p. 7 ®i *««;. 3 S 41 . Vy the 123 d •eeUon of Hay*« Rcvletd Statute*, It id Mwml that r, 4 io client or other Person dMl be held fiable or responsible for r«Underoiis or libelous word* utter by hU attorney at law, but attorney* ju be themaelve* liable and r»*»pousl llortny «landarout» or libelous w«jrd* Wdby them." applying th«'.-«; general principle* I thecas«; l»« , f«>re you. It will be your f to ascertain what It is the plain idemaud, and wha. «I*<fen8«) tho dé liant* »et ut>. To save you the labor court will «täte the <;a*e, ns It is Mb Its province to do bo: The (tUNtlfff 1 allege that Paul Fourchy nud fte Mendiant*' Mutual Iusuraneo Com my of New OrleiiiiP aro Indebted in mfa unto them In tho sum of #uw,ooo W thi«, that, ac hocj aa It became Mown that they would claim of the •Mcompany ft« pro rata of lo»» by the tu which Imd previotndy consumed Mil nigh all the good", etc., on which {heyhud effected poL.-le* of insurance -fBNI pol . la various insnmncc companies, the Fourchy, acting r.s the President Of the «aid company, und the »aid coin P«oy Itself, through il» officers and Hutu, began mulicT«H'.sly und falsely to Are out and to pretend to the public wot their claim for Insumma was RMiukmt aud exaggerated, and •®. «tat»! and declared to differ peraoos from Jyne 1, 1874, to ldth of October ortho same year, the office of tho omi>any ami tho Md of Underwriter*, That on or fhont the l«tb October, 1874, tho do* ÇMontji caused to be published In the •tf,Orleans Bulletin r. false, malicious {•dUpelou* article, uarke«i D, which JJ 11 «vtdenee, and which they allege ®J5J«*dles». wanton, false, malicious y™ fihMou* In Ha entire s<;qp«; and ob w»L allege that tho authors of rc therein Insinuated an«l Intended to W 1 ™«« oa the public tho belief that, they, plaintiffs, themeehescaused their a . —...........--------- --- ------referanco w b*«et on tire cu »he evening of ! a That they thereby | KjMhÄy, IW4. ___________________ „ to cm tha public the jwjw tntt tho flro which occurred on ywpromkcs olglit Years before wa« of *om« fault of petitioner«; }*■* a Insinuate«} and was Intended to *• w® Public with the belief thut (Petitionen«) were not doing a ttsÆ*. L ant * b° n, ' 5 t buHln«^»», and Wtkelr book* were r.ot honestly kept : ™**ra*Y had preseRted an exaggerate«! tor lossee, r.ad then reduce«! ^■fiecauso ^ tlip^y \ ■ ero exu ggerated. a A th. 4 ' ««PMgRenrted. tJT" t« r tnitli, well known to de was that the first statement -------.....I thaüÜL WWP subject t«> ! of ^«unascertained sayings from the fire I «Wi*iiiKs »um mi) nrc i *j T ' 0 **l r .Reductions ; that i>eli- : jioiiu n udes false etatemeut, or false i it. bm ot anu nnt of sto«'k they *hi«k tt th© time of the fire, ÄÄ'ÄS 1 ' "fid to amount to 8132.891 <* gg '.tlatthe petitioners had kept false gjxnari?!?fi^hat they cheated fheircus th»y r»!ü j o* molasses, whereas &L knew better; that " l£ - do 1{| rpe gains at °* tDoir customers. In the aud of abort weig It, "j'.." w <?ight,aud by adulterating whisky with *41 the fact was-and was **- ™°*a to defendants -that poti ,--- *- -î OBb n »«i n,c? fur lws ot 1 wa«ed îivîiîi 1 ' s '* , " e é P ro< >f a» when ! hdactlon ~ em ' they knew that j wRctjojj w*6 made in the lawful WiMil of ^^iö^ewptintifcdtlöirÄ/ were inquljfinjf In an Illicit practica aim trade; that their claim was not sound and honorable, nor their business hon orably conducted. All these matters they allege were written nnd published by the said Fourchy' and the said Iruur nneccotnpany. 16 the New Orleans Bul letin, on the 16th of October, the nurp'-se of impressing public the belief tnafc aUch their (petitioners') conduct matters thus particularised in PB legations. They allege that the New -n---------- ----- .....-, Orleans bulletin had a large circulation; not only in New Orleans but »J*o in «ill parts of the United State*. _ 7284 of the docket of said Court ngain : t the London and Lancashire j *ai i s oi uw on neu r»iaies. They further allege, that in a suit in-1 stituted in the United Slates Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana, No. rire Insurance Company, defoudants filed an answer, wherein it was mail ciomsly nnd falsely and iibelously us 9or tcd that those petitioners had them selves fired their store or procured It to j \ >n done, whereby their loss was suffered „„ t j u . n j K f,t. of the 23fh May, A. D. 1874 i ttn d that said defendants reiterated said j O j, or gea ornllv from time to time after i 1 th „ f jat c . 0 f fifing «aid answer, to wit on ! the 28111 January, 1876. They aver that all the injurious statement* In the premises, by them set forth, made and published, tit the Instance and Insti gation of the defendants In this milt, were malicious, false and libelous, and tliut they have boot Injured thereby to the extent claimed, to wit : one hundred thousand dollars; and they peny for Judgment ïe sôbib» against Ibe sald Paul Fourchy and the Merchants' Mu- i tual Insurance Cc of New ()r iundred thou /ompany leans for the sum of one fr sand «lollers with costs To this demand the defendants plead the general denial, which places the plaintiffs on Ihe proof of all fhelr mate rial allegation*. And here I must In struct you to disregard any and ull alle gations charging Ihe Merchant«* Mu tual In*ur»n<-<> Company with the oral assertion nnd repetition of slander concerning the plaintiff*, if any you should find Iu their petition, for the reason that corporations ns such arc ln capabie of perpetrating a slander. |8ee Towuiond on H. and L.. jmge 452.J The member* In fhelr Individual capacity, although Pretending to act as th«agent*, etc., of the corporation, msv become personally liable. Your first, step In this Investigation will l>o to discover from the evidence before you whether« slander on the part of Paul Fotrchy has been committed against, the ftaintlffs according to the R aterlal alleaatlons In their petition. lOutd you fiirf affirmatively he alone a* au indlvIduA should be held liable therefor, ns thuto can exist no solidarity of obligation in any matter of slander between him nmrhocompany, although he be the présidait thereof. Your next step will be to ascertain whether a libel In* been published by him or by the conpany, or by both, ns alleged. If you so ind you should next determine whether he alone D liable therefor or whothettho company la. or whether both are. I you should find that both are their hiMlitj will be in HOl ><}/). Your next Inquiry will be to as certain what were the motive» of Ihe publishers or utlioiu of the, libel in publishing, If you find that, either or b<»th of hem did publish a libel «gainst plaintiffia« alleged. In conducting.this Invest igtj on y ou must <*)nflnc yourselves strichr to the ev| dence 1)«Tore you, «nd sbuld you dis cover from It, that, "the ratter charged as libelous was published itligood mo tive* ami for justifiable ends" (the truth of the charge* in th publication not having been pleadccb" defend ant»), it should go to mitigra only, and not to excuse •titlrcly. Thtburden of R oving t he "good motives hd justifia - e ends," was on the defeoant«, and if you fled that they have in'produced auch proof, then they »re priutned to have Intended the natural ad moxi mateconscquenccsofthe 11»**) tt'herc the language Is action«we andhé pub llcatlon d»>cR not amiear to be c* priv ileged character, it Is presume (.» be false *nd malicious; 1. e., without lawful excuse, bhollld Ju || n r| a that It is privileged, prim«* fa», ih«-1 h ?"ue.of proving malice In to«7V -« that j Q(| the defendHnt* werei actuate«! ; n»,« Uvea of personal «pit« or Ul will yras f per*«jual «pit* or hi-wuiwh« upon the plaintiffs. This 1* a que{,, rj for your exolustve considéra tl«*n, »ik ing a statement which in uni rue t«>hw knowl«*tig«» of tin; party making 1 1« evidence of malice. ,, lnl j, , , IP '■«1 j yu iin«i j » Tn realltv the inlention to lnjurffs ms lice, and "the act. by mean* of whh a bad Intent (s sought, to be realized,, a malicious «et, a,n«l the act Is done tr llclouely." (Townsend, p. 12t.) The i tention therefore of a person hi th Paul tual case not SK ot an act mStalnfcr»^ ordedu«;ed from the nc<-c»sary conee^j, * qucncea of It, and where the.«e ara nejthor more nor lea» than w{llfuluci«(. Mall«;e Ls an imputAtlou of law from the false and injurious nnturo of the charge. [4 Wend.] " Aa respect* a publication bv writing a libel uot ouly ih«* publish er but. all who in anywise aid or are con cerned in tho production of the writing, or w ljo knowing it to be libelous, pay for Its publication, aro liable«;-; publish ers; tue publication is the act of all concerned In the writing." (Town*«*ud on »lander and libel, sec. 116.] It follow.* that if you find from tho evidence t hat Paul Fourchy aided, or wo« lu anywise concerned in the com posing, wrltlug or publication of « li belous article against tho plaintiff* «» they allege he was, that he so «ct«;d without good motive* an«l without Jus tifiable cuds, they will l»e entitled to a venlict at your hands lu their favor. Au«I so I must charge you a» to the Merchant,!' Mutual Insurance Com pany, should you find that U ha», through its agent», aided, or was in anywise concerned in composing, writ ing, «»r in publishing any llbekm« article a» alleged und described in plaintiffs' petition. In such a case it licoomoe liable. I muat further charge you with ------referanco to petitioner« allegaiion as to ! a llbeloun plea having been filed in the | Circuit, Court of tho UnltodBtalea for ■ .X > ! M Jfi !» ___________________________________ ihis district, whoroln the Lou «km «nd T Lantaishlre insurance Cprapunlca, a I«., were «lefendunt«, and thes«* plain- ; A t IV.. ... ift..-. .-..illL-kA.,. V# Ma. 1 , fl^rl tiffs were tho petitioners. If you find from the evidence before you that, the Merchant«' Mutual Insurance Company, through Its representatives, fil'd an answer therein, which is libelous, ma licious and false, as alleged lu Ihe pe tition In thi* caec, it would place said company under and within the prlnci pie already explained rendering the I no company liable. The Supreme Court of I this State held, In the un reported cuse ..... vy... . ! of V. Vlnas vs.' tho Merchants' Mutual I Insurance Company, No. 2559 of the i insurance company, : docket thereof, t iiat an answer file«! by i it. to the alligations of a petition eon ' taiuing a prayer for ju«!gment ugainet It, rendered it a«;tionablo, because of its . f tW llbelous character. It Is not necessary to *he suceeseful prosecution of this ease that tho plain tiff should prove tho quantum of dam ages (if any) they have suffered in con se«iuence or Hie alloyed libelous piibli cation iu the New Orleans Bulletin, and the answer of the company in the suit j in the Circuit Court of tho United States. This principle ia settled, not only by the text ot the law, but also by the de cisions in several cases, among which w - — " An <.uhuuh iu ov«Y>a> umvs, niuvu» emuu 1 060 Miller vs. Holstein, W L. 389. 25 An. ! 175: Sanvinet vs. Walker et sls^, 24 An., J to j and Decuir vs. steamboat H. AHeo I étais. Xt is thereto» substance held ^at 1 it ft nôt §©ifi»fWe Xhetym to #m* pute, in money, the precis« Injury done iu the feeling*, the pride and standing of those who bear a good reputation and whose characters are respected ft I», therefore, your duty to eonslaef the general reputation and ckaraotenof the M __ ■ one in hJs trade or profession is action ............ ....... ... {nblo per er when it imputes to him fraud, I want of integrity or misconduct in the j line of his business or profession, wliere ' on J . , „ an i individual, In connection with his busl ! pe"*. whereby, his «.•liaraetcr In such i ime iji nis ousinessor proiession, wnere by he gains his bread." (Townsend or i slander and libel. Seen. 102 and 258:] j, Any charge of dishonesty against un business may be injuriously affected, Is j actionable.' You ure the judges of the ! l«w »nd of the facts. You should take ; ll *e law as given you by the Court. Its j application addresses itself to your de : liberate Judgments and approving con i consciences. You are the sole judges of ftr, d are to decide whether i ! hc y sustain the plaintiffs material al ! legation» or not. Also, whether Paul Fourchy has been shown, with reason able ana legal certainty, to have slan dered the plaintiffs as alleged. It is equally incumbent on you to ascertain and determine whether the alleged Il iads were actually perpetrated by either the said Fourchy, or by the com pany, or by both of them in concert. Neither should be condemned unless l * l Is has been doue ; H ud the plaintiff Is i cntjtled to a verdict against either or both, should you find the proof suffi «■lent, fn other w«»r«ls, you may flml f«»r plaiutlffH against either party, should ih«' pr«*of establish his <>r Ms complicity In In»' lib«d<>UB matters as charged. Yoii may find against plaintiffs, as to elf her l*»rty. »houhl vou find the evi dence Insufficient to fix his or M« com plicity in the matter* oh«rg«id us libel ous. Hln^uld you find that, either In (lie ttnUr.Un public)!lion or the allege«! pbonlingH In tlm (Jlrcult Court «if liai United States there was eoinplbdty be tween Paul F«mrehy and the defending company, their liability therefor is s«»li dary, if you should find them or either of titom I libelous. Your verdict »oust i«.' unanimous and tdmuld be written on t he back of t he petition, verdhit for t he Plaintiff* po much, or verdict for d« fendanl». as tho verdh t. Is for plaintiff or defendant, or should you Ikni that Only one of the defendants Is liable you should s«> state. Should you find that b«»th are liable f«»r the ullego«t libel, your verdict, should bo for *0 much in ivljdo against the defendant*. It I* my duty, gentlemen, to charge you that-lt was theduty of the plaintiffs to make out their cmso with legal cer tainty. It 1* not sufficient to warrant a verdict against, them, or cither of them, if you find the evidence goes no further than to make the verity of the allega tions only probable. The pr«>of must amount to a, reasonable certainty of the exletonco and verity of tlufir ali«igc«l causes of aidlon. If you find that the plaintiff* have failed io cstabllsii their case with l»gnl or reasonable certainty, such failure Is n*it cured by any uefwt iu the evl«l*«noo of tho «lefeh«laut*. On the«e point* *ee Mummy va. Haggerty, I« An. 2C8; JJyrne vs. Gray boo, Id., 45Ÿ ; lOAn. 121: 18 An. 28 ami Mfl; Briggs v*. Sltnonds, 17 An. 2»4; l Heu.'s Dig., No 4 . I. 2, ;i, et se<j. to 15 Inclusiv e. It. Is a maxim of ihe civil law that the party who alleges the uffirmaiiou «vf *ny proposition must i>r»rvc |t. An«l iu prac M«;e, you will *<>«afroni the al»ove cited «utliorlties, he must prove it with r* a »enable certainty. (2 An. IU08-11.) Wlnreone awnirs jtoslUVelv toy fact, and another negatively, tlmtr credibilit y «fid the corroborating circumstance* being equal, the one who «wears affirm atively }« to bo believed, Bv r«vtson in I ( ami s'de eeriainty wo generally understand that degree «»f "evi<l«n«:ewnl<;h satisfies i eil tho of t ! ,r î ri,,h . , ' f ,ho fact In dispute, to the oxclusion of every reasonable doubt, and which consti tutes full proof of the fa«!»,; absolute mathematical or metaphysical c«;r»aln ftylsnot essential." (1 Htiuklo'» F.v., M3.J The evhlenco last the h ,\ j Q(| f IP- M3.J The evhlenco should l*> of R,,, 'b 11 conclusive character, ho In j tj tendency at least, ex«Judes tli«> rea » ««nable probability of tho truth of auy Other hypothesis, Th« s<; general ideas you must apply to th« bvjdonce In the «■«be before you. If. after a careful ex amination ««f all »he evidence, a fair trad reasonable doubt should linger in your minds ns to the actual proof of j any material allegation, either as to Paul Fourchy, <«r the Merchant^' Mu tual Insnranco Uompanv, «>r a« to both solidarlly. it is your duty to give tho def«jiuJaufs, or either of them, as the case may be, the benefit of il. You are not bound to give the plaintiffs a v«»r * t P „ J ■^', a the phylmlff* «'yen any degi oof, award umro than la tflalmed. Ii a ■ ..... I, ,—j .X pw 3°i m J ly concerned as l heue ! PjntlfT» and defendant« aro. Permit jlly, gentlemen, act la this important > io »rn you would have other* act R^onsidcrution of friemiship. or of ! M V/v, malice or bias, to enter into, or »»«Mice your minds. Lot justice, im justice, be «i«<n«i by your verdict, ' "icavens fall. The «tas«; I* of great I'np'jjince to »lie litigating parties, and - '*ii watched with d»;ep Interest bv Jfi f ' Pss, and the public generally. It inia oqpicd much of the Court's value* !» ' « * H,, d toraly taxed your r»a ti«;nce,Qd you ara expected to render, such a nllct as good eonsci««nce mav i satictio and such as may bo charac terized the comprehensiveness of its 111 ^ ole«rne*8 of it* practical ___ _____ , MWt .^ HPWro . Icrodcntlajsoft.'^J^H^iTcame'tothe J ' ' Procecdln, 0 f ihe United Stiles Sengte Dec. 14, UHL ?;r>St. Louis RepnUicua.( ' , - hen laid before the Senate th«; root mjkibmUted by the Senator from I«<*uia,ft (Weal ) lout week, to *WV 'îl>totW. L. McMillan to withdraw hi^ppr» claiming a s«mt in Ti^'p I 4 ' na :nat«J r from L<<uislanu. Mr. Edmui inquired whether the ctjHenutofrom tlâoTornor of Louisiana ; a«;cordlng to I« or whether thev had Iwwtn < • I \ tVV 14 ifu .. _ - . . .. . * _ b«wn eubmltte«, v Ml . McMillan him self. I no continence «tierThose '"reden I tlals be withdrawn üot irndouhtedlv their withdrawal Md ! mît " . thecla(raof McMlV, Tlio Chalnna Mr. Ferry, replied: by tucS-MtbÄ 11 ■ l, ' d "° Mr. Thurman o p. wa , u matter of an end to . j , . . . - »v» c seat in this J' u * * î h««e no effect whatever on the cla 0 t I'inchbaek for f *2®-Iof the Senate had rejwrted that.j^j. t jj 0 body which elected Plnehljj nor that which ,cl, ' ltal Mr. pavlii inquire*! <here were DOt tW Th« ti?. McMtllian Î The Chair repli.d thij iero were ftv 0 sets, those presented . ihe senator -----.---- lut3 iy , ullw . from Kentucky and %thor sent di j re«'tlv to the Senate, Mr. Morton said then,. by such body as the McEne^LX*»^ This whole McEnery sham and a fraud. Mr. St8V0nS0U,of Kent»«. aaiH in a personal aspe«*t this raat?^ mountec } J to very little, but the Sent^bould be I very careful about fixing »rendent He tbought wljeu cçeieotià^Q^jjv aûtlidfttiçèted •%$ the Oorefnor bf a State Wéfe laid upon the toble, it, be game more than a personal matter, and the claimant »had no right to withdraw them. He took issue with the Senator from Indiana? Mr. ; Motion, as to the MeEoery gorsrawetit being a fraud J wns a fraud and the record would show it. He argued that the Senate was stop ped bv tho report of the committee from recognizing tb*j K«; I logg govern ment. Mr. Howe d«uiied that the Senate was est«jpped by the report of tho commit tee. Ho would not consider himself estopped by t he report of any commlt t«ie. Mr. Whyte said it occurred to him that the credential» of any person, after being once placed in custody of the Sen ate, couhl not be withdrawn. They came to the S«tnate front a »overeign Stute, an<i it wo» the right of a State to lay before the Senate of the United State» a certificate that »he had exer cise«! her sovereign power by electing a Senator of the United States. Without reference to the question whether Me* Enery or Kellogg was elected Governor of Louisiana, he argued that McMillan h«d no right, to come here and ask to withdraw his papers. He move«l that motion to grant the request to with draw be ref«'rrc«J to Committee on Privi leges and Elections. Rejected without division. Mr. Bayard inquired in whoso custody these credentials were fo be delivered, in case the Senate acceded to the r«; quest. They came from the State of Louisiana, and could not be delivered to Mr. McMillan. He read from the record to show that McMillan's creden tials were also presented by Mr. West and referr«!«! to the Committee on Privi leges and Elections. Mr. Howe ho ill he «||«J not desire to raise issue with any Senator on the other side as to the custody or value <>f these precious papers. Undoubtedly they came before the Senat«; In su«;h a shape as to place them on the Journal an«! make them (»art. of the record. He argu«'d that ft had always lsxm the practice of the Senate to allow papers in regard to claims to be withdrawn. No lnjuatlc«; would bo done by allowing the claim to be withdrawn, a tel he whs I n favor of it. Mr. Bayard said he believed In his soul that Mr. McEntffy was tho legal Governor of Louisiana and had been kept from his place by usurpation and Federal power. (Slight applause in the gallery hut promptly checked.] The question being oir the motion of Mr. W«>st to grant, ihe r«*«juest to with draw the' credentials, It was agreed to; 1 ayes 30, nays 28, ns follows ; Ayes: Messrs. Allison. Bout well, Bruce, Burnside, Cameron (Wi*.), Chris-1 tianev, Clayton, Conk ling, Conover. Cronin, Edmunds, Ferry (Mh'h.), Fre- ! llnghuyseii« Hamlin, Harvey, Ilitch cock, Howe, LngaJl», McMillan, M«»rr«-il j ( Vt.;, Morton, Patterson, Paddock, ! Robertson, Sargent, Sherman, Spencer, !.. West, Windoin an<l Wright. j Nays : Messr«, Bayard, Bogy, Uupen ton, Cockrell, fkxipar, Davis, Dawes, I Eaton, English, Goldthwaite, Gordon, j Jones, Johnson, K«'y, Kelly, K«>rnan, ! McCreory, MeDonald, Merrimon. Nor : wo<*«J, Randolph, Ransom. Haulsburv, * Steveim«»n, Thurman. Wallace, Whi te' ami Wlthera-28. ' y i CITY HEMS. Infanticide. Coroner Chantant vlew eil the b«idy «f 1 ho two colored chil«lren that wore ti«'d in a sack and washed n«h«»re in the parish «if ./«»Hereon, ami etat«.a that they must have bled to death and then have be«.>n thrown Into tho rtv«-r. Tho Inam st has lx'«>n poet glvtW.he police liiuo lo fom-L out tb«> pen#trator*. Mass Mketino. j wondn# next. * ---------- Wo h-orii that at the last meeting of tho Central Councilor the Property Holders' Union it w «* «letermiued to organize a gran«l mas* meeting of <jitiz*;ns and taxpaynrs int«r csted In tlm reduction ««f taxation, which meeting will be called as h«jou as the now budget Is announced. A large committee was appoint«'«! ami Is oetlv« ly at w««rk arrangplna f«»r the meeting, and the programme thereof will be an uoün«'/od iu tho isqs.'rs on Wednesday A Fugitive rnoM Justiuk.-L oot even ing Detective« Walsh an«l Cain roturned from Pontchatoula, wltli (ho escaped convict Wra. Carroll, whocscaiicd from (lie Mississippi State I'euitcntkury, where lie wo« incarooratod on a verdict of burglary ; ooiqmftted by blowing up u safe c*jntalnlng $!o,«k»i <«r ili»j Fr«;««l man's Savings Bunk, at Natchez, Missis sippi. The Rogues March.—T he notorious ibleves nnd burglars Jack Hartriet., Harry Clifton, Tom Sayers and TJddy Monahan, who woro arreste«!, wore marched out before the Metropolitan Police Brigade, which had a review at the time, aud were shown to each police man, who was instru«;<ed to arrest any ! of them whenever found. Dikd or her Wounns.-We are sorry to barn that M1 *h Anno Julia Plan chard, whose veil caught fire some ton •lays ego during a religious oeramonv «ff the Children of Mercy at the Church of St. Mary's Archbishop, died Friday evening at seven o'clock. To the 1s; reavod parante we tender our heartfelt sympathies. i THE COURTS. St'rEBIOR CRIMINAL COCRT. The following motions were made in j this Court on Saturday m«>rulng ; A motion to admit J. W. Ward, charged with Intent to commit murder In St. Bernard parish, to bail. The Court declined to take any action in the matter, but referred counsel to Judge Pardco, of tlm parish court from whence tho case was brought. In tho case of 1). R. Fendorson, charged with murder, who hus been convicted but a respite granted, a motion for a divolutive appeal, an«l for the purpose of having attached to the record certain proceedings in relation to ex-Jndge Braughn's capacity to try the co«e. This ceeo was takon under 1 advisement, and In the mean time tlm ! Supremo Court will pass on the matter, j George Morrison, charged with the \ murder of the mulatto girl Sarah John- j Hton, was again arraigned, and plead guilty a second time to tho charge, but j fho court would not ootertain hisr>l«*a, : and ordered a plon of not guilty to bo entered by the clerk, and the ca*o to b«j tried by a jury. John Smith, a cattle dealer from tho country, charged with carrying con oealod weapons, was arraigned, and: paid u lino of èit) on pleading guilty. Tho «iase of Charles J. Newhoube, ' charged with tho homickio of ono Lu- ! cas, in November. i»74, was going on ; wh«.'U this report cloaod. Fifth Ward Property Holders' Meeting. A very interesting meeting of this oi- j g anization took place on Thursday, l*th istant; President Geo. M*jrz In tho ; chair. Quite an animated discussion j sprung up on the question of "traitor*» ; in camp. Certain member« were open-; ly charged with being connected with tho tax ring and buying property at tax sales. A committee or five wa* ap pointed to investigate the charge und report at tho next meeting. A petition, which Is being signed by all tho unions, asking from the Legisla ture the repeal of act No. 30 of 1871, which gives 1)1 essre. Van Norden A Co. tho exclusive right to do the draluage work of-the eity atone dolkr-per cubic yard, when contracts ean be made and 1 the work done for one-fmirth of the sum, met with the heartv approval of the club. Also, a resolution pledging the mp. port ot the ward to the Mayor and Ad LOWER !.. „ BLANKET«, Bolng» «f the Police Board. At a meeting of the Pf^lice Board, on the 17th Inst, it was unanimously Jieeolvcd. That, this board indorse the action of the Superintendent in closing all bunko" games In this city. Kellogg asks Gen. Augur to keep an eye on East Feliciana. If Kellogg wishes tho General commanding this province to keep an eye on each parish that repudiates the fraud which he is— the General commanding will need an eye for each parish. Send on, General, and order fifty-seven from Washington. --- <#♦»» -- Little boys had better take our advice and not shoot their fingers off with dol lar pistols on Christinas, but save them f«»rthe glorious4lh of July, 1876, when they can exhibit the missing links to their own little boys in future days na a 1 .....— — ' ' .... , happy raminiscence of that occasion. --- Not desiring t«> give in extenso Ihe daily record of crime In tho city, we shall report merely t h«» narn«.;s of prison ers arrested ami where conlln«;«!, f«»r the benefit of friend* of tho partie» arrested. The latest r«')K»rt. w«» have from the jury in the Baylef & Pond case is they were playing cards, 'c OLD AND YOUNG, ORAVE AND OAY. MALE AND I-'EMALE, Special Notice. -To the Property H«>ld «' r »'Unlf>u«—Tim various Ward Union« arc by n-Holution of Iho Sric-dal CommlU«*', (M>i)oint< d r»v flip Coni rnl Couwll, r#wju d««**! to hoM w< in\ f V-V 1 1 Ü ir■* ' ban*, on WEDNES DAY EvENINO NEXT. 2»1 In«», ifusln«-«» of thn gr«*«<o»t laip-jrian«'«. , _ (:. If. TKBAULT. M. D. «M» n Chairman Executive CofnmltDv. CHEAPER THAN AUCTION CHRISTMAS PRESENTS Pim and POOR, ~rt~ j PRICES THAN AUCTION. * SHAWM DRESS GOODS FLANNELS, PANT STUFFS. FANCY GOODS. Etc.. Fi Cheaper than Auction. II HAS ELMAN & ADAMS, 5 * and ssa Mu«b7,Iüc street, «il» c«>rn«'r St. Andrew. CHRISTMAS PRESENTS. lute CHRISTMAS PRESENTS. 1875. FOR BOY8: TOOL CIIE8T8, « (ih h «wiaelri«; s«H of Oirrx'nlom' Tool«, FOR GÎBL8: TOY COOKING 8TOVE8. THE TOY CHARTER OAK 8TOVE Is b*Ah U**fnl and Ornameatal. BOLD BY . RICE. BROTHERS & CO.. n »n«I »1 f'xmp s* r 1 '—;.. BRANCH HTORE. 397 M»«in*tin«; slr<W. HARDWARE, STOVES AND HOUSE-FUR NTHHINO OOODH. ___ «lj» ïp H. T. LAWLER, OKRERAL COMMISSION MERCHANT, 75,77.79. M nnd (O TVten street, (lato Now Lev'll nenr Poydr«*, N«;w Orl'-ans. For the sale of NORTHERN AND WESTERN PRODUCE. Aaood su pair of the following nrtl«'1«'s always öd hand: PORK. BACON. LARD, FLOUR. BUTTER, CORN. OATH. BRAN, HAY, CORNMF.AL, POTATOES. ONIONS. BEANS, DRIED FRUITS. Eta, Etc. Cash Advan«v;d on nil Consignments (n«A Perishable.) Shlpmijnt* Advfine««! on ; must be insured in nr Open PolW. Fe j 1 ! j \ j j : Vrn«infti attention (levr«t«xl to »11 buHln«*« en tru»t<*l to mv onre. Aal» im Notice to Gas Fitters and Builders* OrncB N*w Ohi.kavh Gas Lioht Comcast, i Corner Baronne nn«l Omimon Htr«,^t*. / All One Fitter* an«I Bnilcinr* Join« buai uem within the an« *«ppll«*l bv tlila company are hereby n«>tin«jdtliot th«noised rul« v san«1 r«Hpila tloa* relut Ina to gm fitting will be enforc'd from and after January i, !«78, and that gnu will not bemippll«'*] to building* fltte«! up öfter that date byanyex«wpt pr«>r>«'rlr <jualffl«Hl pers«.aa, hold ing a «^•rtlflcote from the company. Copl«-* of the ml«* may be obtained upon ap plion »t this ofHee. THEOBALD V0RHT ALL. Oeueral Supijrintendent. Dre- m1«ef T. 1*7». __ dit) I» 2p_ LEEDS* FOUNDRY; [ESTA HUSHED TN IM » J Camar Oelord and Touhtr straata, NEW ORLEANS. We are prepared to ma nn fanera STEAM ENGINES, BOILERS, SUGAR MILLS «rrrixti ttttttt vti DRAINING MACHINES, SAW MILLS, COTTON FRE8SE8 j NEWELL SCREWS, GIN GEARING, FURNACE MOUTHS, LEEDS 4 CO. GRATE BARS, JUDSON'S GOVERNORS, and all kinds of Plantation aud Steamboat work, and every description of Machinery for the ! south. r.»nw v m i Wo bo« to call specif attention to our large j fetock of Sugar Kettles. Having purchased the : entire block of the 6ta«iker Iron Works of Ten- ; uossee, for which Mr. E. F. Laville)>euvro wm j formerly agent, (end the only genuine Tenne*- ' seo Kettle in tlio market,) wo offer the same for ! sale, as well a* those of our own manufacture A> Hed'icrt Haler, price lists of which we will be j? pleased to fondait oa application. disua t 1 BOUDAT PRESENTS. CHRISTMAS OITTS, —ai tax . ; NEW STORE. Nu, Aid Magazine Street, ! soriment of POCKET BOOKS and ~ k r i2S2,ffl3n««c*aMtr>*#. JAMES KIRKPATRICK, BOOKSELLER, PBTNTÏB A5P 8TATIÔNIJ1, WO Macadaa Itnat, K delVim TBICK8 «BCCLATINO LIBRARY. A QUESTION OF IMPORTANCE axron BtrrtNo koudat pkesicnts: Have You Oot a Piano or Organ in Your House? faiDily wsnls on«», and th« invssttneat w «T makla* your home r>l«*w»nt mi<l Sii .l® 1 napplor. JDo not i>uf off t»orchM ntll fhpy a«S too old to learn, or marry off ng until___ and leave you. NOW Is tii.i proper tlmê.'and i you ahoulrl call soon on th«» old ' - LOUIS GRÜNEWALD, iKh^vÀT^wl!lvn E ù s 3j^i RNABF^ plfy® (ÄTÄ TSfe , 80Jttâ» , rt), (JH ftlHTONf Fit (Pari») MUSIC BOX »). JiKASH INSTRUMENTS ATHINÔm He?* MüHIC In endl«U va Y «1 y r«y 1 u< ^.«1 price-., LA81 MONTHLY PAYMENTS on Planhe nn«l ner tl me, and I llohle firm of i Organ«. If ho d«'Slr*«I. IiOUIS GRÜNEWALD, „ .. . «RtfNEWALD HALL. it, tA 1». and 23 Baronne «treri, ___ __ . N«>ar Canal. dis lw CROCKERY. PAUL J. CHRISTIAN, CHINA, GLASS, HOUSE FURNISHING GOODS, No. «4 ......CAMP STREET......No. w. NEW ORLEANS. Low Prices d!9 It JEWELRY AND WATCHEB, AT THT C0RyKR CANAL AND ROYAL HTHEKT8. I j We have a verr full nnd «-«refullv selected stock of WATCHES. JEWELRY. SILVER AND PLATED WARE. CLOCKS. BRONZES. PORCELAIN, CUTLERY. AND FANCY GOODS. An«l we are determine«! to sell them »I. nri«T9 to satisfy th«« exaetin*. We will not, however, keep In our «took en In f«rl«»r »rti« - !«', nnd «-ustouier» rn/jv r«'lv with lute oertaintr upon III«» duality of the good« «;b tsln«yi from u». «llî»tjt 7 l>________ _______A. R. GRI SWOLD ft C O. >y t th I «llî»tjt 7 l>________ _______A. R. GRI SWOLD ft C O. H. J. RIVET, Fii'.'ceasor lo E. MONTEUSE & CO,, —Dealer In— Drag», Chemicals, ratent Medicines, —And — PERFUMERY. IMFOHTER OF FRENCH rROITIIETARY 0 MEDICINES. lYoprletor of the Celebrated P«'7(:h»«id Bidon«. General Agent f««r Louisiana of the Tex»» Cotton Worm Destroy«;r. Cor. of Blenvillo and CRartros Street«, ; NEW ORLEANS. A. W. HYATT, «119 Im ns .......Comp aireet.............. 38 STATIONER, BOOK AND JOB FB INTER, IJTHOGRArHER AND BLANK BOOK MANUFACTUBEB. Cotton. Bank, In*urance nn«l Mercantile Blink Book* ma«Je to any d«^lr«Ml pattern on tho Shortest Notice. Cotton Hal«*, Bill Hea«H Bill* of ladina. Letter and N'ite Heading*, Dray Receipt«, Invoi.. 1 ««. etc., Print'll or Lithr«raplie«l to Order. — Every de»crlptl«>n of — BOOK BINDING Execute«! Neatly, Cheaply, and with Die patch. Call and examine apeclmena. set eaUmates and leave your order*. A. W. HYATT. dels lm M Camp atreet. FACTORS' AND TRADERS' INSURANCE COMPANY, 77 C «read*let Street. AtwHs April 80, 187$, *1,486,214 88. Thl* Company isau«* Polldea on FIRE, RIVER AND MARINE RISKS AT LOWEST TARIFF RATES, E, A. PALFREY. Praldcnt. MOSES GREENWOOD, Vice President, THOS. F. WALKER, Secretary. TRUSTEES: j? -Isaac Schenk, Moses Grecnwcfod, W. A. Johnson, John L Noble, John Chaffe, Richard Mllliken. Samuel E. M«x>re. J. L Warren, B. T. Buckner. Samuol Friedlander. A. A. Yates. John I. Adams. B. M. Welmsley, A. Brittin, A. H. May. S. H. Snowden, T. Lrtt Lyon. Wax. C. Raymond. Jao,S. Preetidge, Samuel H. Boyd, Joseph McElroy, & B. Wheelock. Crrus Busaev. Wm. J. Behan, df? tm 6. T. Escblemaa. i A K WBI IIH .. J^T. CHARLES THEATRE, rDgsgement ter a limited period of (he pearJew LOTI A, ! Snppyr^q by tl favorite comedian Mr. I. the «nine SATURDAY --2^ •ctor Mr. ft 4 '. 1 A.VAÎ1C 'COM P A SY - Abbey's «nparlor a 1 WIJl b© presented the great drama of IIP, or Poiat Pjrado Light. ..................................... LÖTTA. GRAND LOTTA MATINF.E. • Chriatmn* Day) at noon. QLOBE THEATRE- " Tornor «>f Baronne ami Peril Ido s«T«'<'ts. VfAHHM ADAMS. P.aslfiee* and 8ta«o Maiific<.r. N F,W COM PAN V, NE# KVA PH NEW FEATURE« V ^ if ot *urît(J r Laura Markham, the Qne«m Mian«» ßroa the world-mnowned gymnaata. «r 8 CK? n /i r 11 " r r 1 ÎT al, »' ""U ak«Hw artist. Mr. thna. Oallngher, Iriati «.'«.median and Sketch 'Üîr^rnT'it ®v Br, n« «ml dan«« artists. i P, 1 / 1 «. M/s« ----- Si' iv it' 1 '.!. , v r> M«»opean «'omodiao. Mis» «tcein, scrifj-comi«' vocalist Mid Art. res». All the old favori!«'» r«'tnrnn<l. (Mt .vWie . « , Murphy. AP — --------. Mi»« A«Ia p«.V... . Warfield, Mij» Amelia Dean. Jno. La Fan« Män I Uv. 1 .* - , , ' ,fl DeYere. Marsh Adam». Mlaa i Kitty Lavarde.Irlah John Manning, Ml»« l,lhh|«> Alber ere. Tom H«*n«loy. ous (>it»ett. Grand «n«*«'«» of the ("AN CAN. SATURDAY. Dec. 25, ((Jhri«trn«i» Nlttht)after Uie nertirniance, will le> aiv«<n at this tnoatre, a Ore rid ritney Dr» «« an«l Maagimrade Balk Jfi «»«dive preparation, «o«)n t/f be Introdue««] Mndiini«' fh'iit/ « Female B athers. dt» FOR THE REST AND CHEAPEST TEA OR COFFEE Go to th« GREAT TEA DEPOT —An«l— STEAM COFTEE Mfi.T.q, 5................CAMP STREET................ft os* doob rnoM casai„ NOT ICF.—Goo«l« placed on boatd vossela, «tearnlfoat« or ears In this city FREE OF DRAYAGE. dl» It ..BUTTER gUTTER..........BUTTER.. 150 firkins Ch«>lce and M«'dlum GOSHEN BUTTER. to firkins Choi«»; and M«j«llum WESTERN BUTTER. For sole at low prie«*», to dose consignment». KEEP. RAYMOND ft CO.. del» at ___ 71 and 79 Poydras street. ci'RT E DKM«X-'BATS will not fall to ftatronlra *■ theonly pure,clear and ofTeijUxe » Pkmpk»t««Cod Liver Oil «wer offer«*! to the public, protected, not by a mere TRA DE «wiled patent medicines, but by_________ nt,N«>. 1MT4C—the only patent ever gran This SI „ , I/'W tun C/X II y pnrom _ >y the United btatefi form medi« nl preparation. t 1» highly recommended by Profeseora * and yyviani Jone» Pope, Fiufnf Ch'.ppln, Aaudet Alpuent«, Brlckell, Brun», f>« Mon nier, Mao«, Hava and other «llstlngufshed, physicians of New Orb'iinH, and h«e «'ailed forth ft m«»«t fifttter Ing report from tho A« a4eniy of Scionoes of Ha vana. w The «lK,ve mentioned patent.reportand r«VM>m mendation niay be soen at the sstatflshment. of th ______ whl«'h m»y undersigned, »bl« manufacturer of this Oil. nor* * " d!9 HuftWe had oi »II Druggist«. A. J AS. vn Cliartres streqt r J'L S.Vt'VE— (Formerly with M»^srs. Everett, Lane ft Co.,) STATIONER, PRINTER, BLANK BOOK I MANUFACTURER, LITHOGRAPHER, ETC.. 27 Commerd»! e«>rner St. Charl«w. Moderst« rates charged and aatlafactlon guar ; »nterri. eli» jm COMMERCIAL AND CLASSICAL ACADEMY. No. St. f hurlcs street, Scasion «.pr'n«xl MONDAY*! Heptemljor 8, i«7i. R. M. LUSHER. Principal. All (he EngJInh branebe«, (nein «Hug Motkem» t|e» «nd tl«* Natural H>-I<'neee, with The Modern and the Alje|e«it I,anguage», taught by « xpe t lope<yl te»i'li«Te, For t< rm-s et«*., apply «I the Academy, «let» im vv J O. COYLE A CO., COAL . 1 -l.n Gravier atre«*. <119 Itn New Orlean«. O. DONOHUE, lEs^pl'il."-li«M l»:A) STEAMBOAT AGENT. Offlee -76 Grftv l«;f %tr<'<A, N«jw Orleans. «Il» 1 w r JMIE SUREST CURB —FOR— RHEUMATISM AND RHEUMATIC GOU*» —I» the— CELEBRATED DUBANG'S REMEDY For aale by A. JAB, Dnigght, dl» SuftWetf _ ko CHARTRES ST. QGDEN ft HILL, H. N. Ck,dzv. Jap. D. Hn.u Æ ATTORNEYS-AT-LAW, Ho. 6 Carondalat Street. (Iii.du JJ R. FORMAN. Attorney at Law, No. 6 CARONDELET STREET. N«rw Orlean*. Ree/denee, 317 He«y>n(l, cor. Carondel«tt. dl» ly ^LFRED DAMARIN, . Succemor to Gain«» ft IWC« Branch Store. M2 MAGAZINE STREET, MOUSE FURNISHING GOODS, CHINA, GLASS AND CROCKERY. BUILDERS? HARDWARE. Etc. dl» lm New Orloan*. J^ROOK STEAM RICE MILL— C. H. ALLEN, 89, 91 and 93 Tolurapiiaalaa »treat, NEW ORLEANS. Thi* is the most extensive Mill in the South, and the «lunlity <A ««tir Rice nnRurpasHod. Mill ing rate*: No. J. Ye. per lb.; No. 2. He., perlh, Ha«'k.-i furnished on orders t«> Lock Box »78. New Ork ans. Eight sacks ol B%n r«,t>irBed to the planter for every ifio barrel»Rice received, dels imSu 0OBDAGE—PAPER—W'OODHMWARE. MANILA ROPE, from inch up to 9 Inch. SISAL ROPE, from \ Inch up te 3G inch, tow coils COTTON ROPE. S, *-W» X and < Inch«*. i TARRED CORDAGE, MABUQfC. BOUSLINR. WORMLINE, HAMBBOLBÎE and SPUN YARN. PACKING YARN. HASH CORD and OAKUM. 19,009 REAMS P VFEB, 11X13, 11X18, UMMWft 20X19 and 24-3«. ' 'F PAPER BAGS, from X ft up tom ft. A full stock of WOODENWABE. BRUSHES. AX HANDLES^ BROOMS. COFFEE MILLS. TWINES, TACKS. MATCHES. SIEVES. BASKETS. FISH HOOKS AND LINES. DEMIJOHNS, BLACKING. BLUEING, TOILET SOAPS, INK. FIRE WORKS. Ete., Eux, Etc. All for sale at lowest market price* by J. C. MORRIS, dl? lot 12 and u Tchoupitoalas stie'