Newspaper Page Text
•W VOt. XXIV., N0.186 At the funeral obsequies of the late Bishop Joseph B. Cotter in the St. Thomas pro-Cathedral at Winona, Minn., on Wednesday, June 30, the fol lowing eloquent and touching eulogy on the deceased prelate was bestowed by his life-long friend. Most Rev. John Ireland, the Archbishop of St. Paul: And so, dear friend, we must bid you farewell. We are powerless to re tain you. All that warm hearts could wiBh to have done, all that skillful hands could do, was bidden forward to arrest the march of the dreaded enemy, to ward from your cherished brow the stroke of the uplifted sword. Alas! nought availed. O death, the relentless foe of human loves and human hopes, terrible thou art in thy covetlngs, conquerless thou art in thy mighty warfare. None are found, who can resist none who may escape the jmJffity. warfare. The victims of death—they are whomsoever death or ders to fall—the old or the young*—the weak or the strong, the servant or Iho master. The victims of death—thoy are the children of Adam, whoever they hi, Whatever their prowess, whatever the deeds they are accomplishing, the praises they are winning from their fellows. "It is appointed unto men once to die." And when and where men must not divine. Theirs to halt and fall when the summoning trumpet sounds, and the monster leaps into the fray. And so, dear Bishop Cotter, your turn came, and you lie before us silent and motionless,. soon to -be snatched from our view and hidden from us in the darkness of the grave. Not long ago you were buoyant of health and strength it was thought that as the bishops of your ecclesiastical province in reaching out for its chosen prey. Yes, you have been smitten by the fell sword, and all- is over farewell, dear friend, farewell! Is this all there is of man—to be born, to labor and to struggle during a few fleeting years, and, then, to be hastened into {he grave? If so, van ity of vanities it is and what reason is there that we set value upon it, that we prize its opportunities, and strive for its gifts? O, vanity of vanities, truly, if there is no rebound from the victory of death, if no light shines beyond the darkness of the grave, if no meaning there is to life save that which earth bestows, save that which earth controls and measures! To the rescue, all-wise, all-potent Creator to Whose love we cling while we suffer and sorrow, in Whose mightiness we trust amid death's triumphant revel lings. To the rescue, our risen Sav iour, over Whose tomb was sung the exultant challenge—'-O death, where now is thy sting, where now is thy vic tory?" To the rescue, our christian faith, whose teachings, beauteous and uplifting as -the vision of the Heavens which they open to the abul. unravel *he great enigma and melts into brightest sunshine the gloom of human life, aye. and the gloom of the grave, death's last wild repair, whence it madly shrieks its. •victim shall never A FINE EULOGY ON BISHOP COTTER An Eloquent and Touching Tribute to t)ie Memory of the Late Prelate of Winona by the Archbishop of St. Paul. REVIEW OF HIS NOBLE LIFE AND ACHIEVEMENTS Today the Diocese of Winona Stands Forth as One of the Prosperous and Flourishing Dioceses of America. you would still stand erect even when edge of the manner of life of our de parted friend which is ours from' daily observation of words and acts, we bid him go forth to the throne of judg ment to hear the divine salute—"Well done, good and faithful servant enter now into the joy of the Lord." all others had fallen but you have been taken from the ranks, while oth ers, less valiant, more laden with years, remain among the living—so vain are our guessings as to. life's closing days. Work there was before you well you were doing it it demanded your pres ence it needed, we believed, your tire less heart and steadied hand but you were wrested from- it mercilessly and brightest of rivulets, moving ever forever—so regardless ia death of. with utter singleness of purpose, re human conditions and human plan-1 joicing ever in the effusion of sweet nings, so reckless and desperate is it est love, in the outpouring of others' )r (w hope for redemption. What is man, what is the purpose of his passage across the earth? Re ligion gives the reply, repeating in its message the revelation of eternal truth and simultaneously giving voice to nature's deepest instincts, to reason's loudest clamoringe. Man is a being of body and of soul, the body emerging from the dust of the earth, and unto dust returning, the soul, a spirit of the immediate breathing of the Almighty author of all things, fashioned to His own image and likeness, made to be immortal once created destined never to die. The stay of man upon earth Is the preparation for Eternity, the battle against evil being waged under the eye of the Omniscient, with help from His Omnipotent love, the measure of merit being that ,of the performance of duty, as prffjbribed by the! Supreme Master, the as the sour freed from the sebackles of mortality sees face ~£o face the great Judge, from whom issues the sentence of love if its inspirations have been lis tened to on the field of combat, or that of justice if those inspirations have been spurned and the arms of righteousness forsaken by the combat ant. Has man lived, as God willed— there the value of life there its pur pose thence its ending in bliss" for all eternity in the presence of the Al mighty God Himself. Must we mourn without consolation as we bid farewell to Bishop Cotter? As the mortal man. he has paid the penalty of his mortality: as the im mortal man, he has g6ne to the Eter- would, one by one,, be stricken down, thy promises beget, with the knowl-i The good priest makes the good bishop, A beautiful life was that of Bishop Cotter—pure of stain as the newly fal len snow, limpid in its coursings as love in return for his own, freighted every day with deeds of righteousness and of charity, the more resplendent of inner devotion to duty, the richer in services to religion and to humanity, as years deepened his powers of in fluence, and growth of opportunity opened wider range to the spread of his fragrant activity. He was the kindliest of men-r^-ever in this regard the self-same, wliether as the young man struggling with' the vicissitudes of the1' world, whether as the. priest working in a parish, or the bishop ruling over a diocese. He t»-on all hearts by. the sweetness of his love his will and purport of action was ever to please, to serve. He passed by do ing .good. No enemies had he: none could have been so vile as to hate on* so incapable of hatred, to revile one so incapable of doing injury, so in tent on efforts to avoid giving displeas ure. He was most, resolute in the accom plishment of duty, most self-sacrificing in the obedience to it. Need recall the earlier years of his priesthood in Winona, when the flock he tended was poor of the- poverty of pioneer settlers,' when the territory committed to his pastoral care was vast in extent, al- ter, amid the sombre shades of night? I remember one Sunday evening in Wi nona. 'He had said mass and preach ed in the parish church he had.driv en to say a second mass twenty miles away he returned drenched from the heavy rain, and within a few moments after a hurried change of raiment and a hurried snatching of a slender meal, he was in his chair for two hours presiding over a temperance society. And such for him, I learned, was one Sunday after another for many long years. Need I ask whether as bishop he refused himself to priest or people, were, they removed from his home by hundreds of miles. most inaccessible' in the rudeness of Its social betterment of all 'and of 'every roadways?- Did he-ever Complain? Did class of his fellow-men.- He was ever he ever hesitate to rush whithersoever the- enlightened and progressive citi- His, a keen divining of what was to be done, an intelligent grasp of cir cumstances, the tact to do well what ever came to his mind. Tears ago priests were few. and immediately aft er his ordination Father Cotter was put in charge of the parish of Winona and the adjoining missionary stations. No mistake made he no reproaches ever came from his superior. I recall the saying of the lamented Bishop Grace that the parish of Winona under the pastorship of Father Cotter was a surprise and a delight—so well were all things done. our beloved nesota, there was no hesitation as to who should lay its foundation and rear its walls into the noble structure that was to be the pride of religion in the valley of the Mississippi. The pastor' nal God. whom he served, as best hejof the parish of St. Thomas, who had might, while pilgrimaging upon earth.' proven himself to be the best of priests O eternal Judge, with the hope which was at once designated for the task, he was needed, amid the frosts of-win-i zen, ever the loyal*bn of America, ever the devoted helperbf every good cause in his communityi-' This the bidding of true manhood,, as-.'it is the bidding of true religion. iTixe- high esteem in which the people^ of Winona held As a bishop will he be chiefly known in the annals of the future. When In 1889 the resolution was to be taken to erect a. new diocese 'in Southern Min- whose office is but the enlargement of number of priests, the number of churches have more than doubled. And the priests, guided and stimulated by the example and the work of their bishop, are men whose praises are on the lips of the people. The' churches, planned as they largely were'by Bishop Cotter, are examplars of architectural art. The faithful laity gladly yielded to impulses coming from bishop and from priests—and, today, as Bishop Cotter's episcopal work closes its records, the Diocese of Winona stands forth as one of the prosperous, flourish ing dioceses of America, in the growth and development of which the Catho lic church reposes its most earnest hopes,' and which she extols before the world, as the tokens that the divine vitality infused into her nineteen cen turies ago still course through her veins, that she is still, as of old, thus mother of a glorious race of Apostles, still today the mother of christian men arid womeh whose'" professions and manner of life teil the divine source whence flow across their souls the graces of spiritual edification! His own flock was, of course, the chief care of Bishop Cotter. But so generous/ so large-minded was he that beyond the "confines of his flock his mind travelled in search of other fields! wherein to labor, of other opportuni ties to do good to fellow-man. A child of 'broaid humanity, nothing of avail to humanity' was strange to him—and among the foremost he gladly placed "himself in the combat for civic right eousness.- for charitable- work,' for the MINNEAPOLIS. MINN. SATURDAY. JULY 10, 1909 And zealous was he. The mere in the faith and this love of the Saviour routine of pastoral work was never his]—the. peace and the joyousness of rule. He sought out occasions of work Heaven. and once discovered, quickly were they I Farewell, dear Bishop Cotter—We put into profit. A special instance to sorrow that, we shall miss your be be noted is his preaching of total ab stinence, not only in his own diocese, but throughout the whole United States. In his parish of Winona while he was yet a priest, the cause of total abstinence flourished as in no othe parish in Minnesota. At one time presi dent of the American Total Abstinence Union and general lecturer he preach ed total abstinence in most of the large cities of the country where his name today is held in grateful rever ence. In the .cause of christian educa tion he was ever "tireless as- A priest he brought to the' parish tit St Thomas the Sisters of Notre Dame: as a bishop he stimulated the building up of schools in nearly all the districts of the diocese, and under his guiding hand the Semin ary of Winona for the education' of young women and the convent and Normal School of the Sisters' of St.1 Francis of Rochester ha:ve grown to their present .magnificent proportion!*."' the priesthood, a widening out upon-a] Quickly to us all. And what, imports larger scale the work of his parish. I for us is that we so live as to die. How true all this turned out to be in to the Lord, that we so plant In tears the case of Bishop Cotter, the Diocese of Winona today stands witness. The' serve the Lord as to merit for ourselves Bishop Cotter ts praise to themselves that they discern, and admire a noble character, as it«ds-praise, to him that he merited well of-all who knew him, of all who knew" his daily coming and going, his daily -work inspired with the best of motives, accomplished with most exacting energy and alacrity. And now the.'da-y is spent, the work is done the record, book is closed the Judge has calletli for the accounting. Speak, beloved friend, to the great Judge: "I havefOusiht the good fight, 1 have finished my. course. 1 have kept the faith." Veriest truth wilt thou speak, in rehearsing the words of the grea.t Paul. AliS veriest, truth wilt thou speak as thou farther sayeth: "As to the rest thereris laid up for me a. crown of justice- which the Lord the just Judge will render to me." "O death, where now Is thy sting, where now is thy victory?" The fight which death brirfifcs to what ip mortal in us is quickly changed Hnto peace and jo.yousness. as we recall what death leads to in him who lived well his part nignant. smile, your helping hand, your holy and wise counsel along the weary pathway over which we still must joki'fney forward. 'we sorrow, in what is our loss, even though we rejoice in what is your gain with thy God. Yes, priest, and a noble bishop. Not. always around the bier of death is grief so intense, so universal as It is today: not always Ib the dead 'so worthy of grief as Bishop Cotteis lg of oift-s. Dear Bishop 'Cotter. I must, in obe dience to rriy h««it,^eak m^ person al tj-.ibut*.'t^'yWii ^orllpi^-etihtyeBTr you were rrty friend and I- was ydurs. I knew you and 1 lovefl j'ou when you were still a. youth in the world 1 was one Of those who thought you worthy of the holy priesthood, who bade you betalte yourself to the school of sacred learning I labored with you side by side1 In the days of your, priesthood I chose you for presentation to the CATHOLIC PRIESTS A Splendid Tribute "£o Them From a Protest/it. In the introduction to his Com mencement address delivered at the University of Notre Dame this year| ly noteworthy because Mr. Taylor i» not a Catholic and his utterance! lecturer and an author of merit. He ly recognized by the Universities of Oxford, Edinburg and Paris. ty, the Rev. Dr. Cavanaugh, had said HWy See as first bishop of Winona, I plane presented by Randolph of Vir liave labored side by Hide there between us a word of discord, never was. I abl» to discover in you a cause of reproach. My deepest friend ship -was ever yours, and yours was ever mine. Life-long friends are few and precious. In your departure I lose a most loyal ally, a most devoted friend. My heart shrinks in anguish as you go from ine the remainder of my journey through life will be lonely because you shall not be with me. But, brethren, the end will come. I what we reap in gladness, that we so the tidings—Well done, good and faith ful servant. Brethren, our prayers are still ours the departed OIK- may need the re freshing dew of divine mercy. Be our -prayers offered to the throne of grace for dear Bishop Cotter, today and tomorrow. Kternal repose, O God, grant to his soul may never-fading light shine upon it—the light of Thy divine countenance, the light of Thy own divine love! in presenting the speaker, that the! late Father Stafford of Washington, had often expressed to him He re gret he felt that a scholar of such distinction had not. addressed, the-stu dents of Notre Dame. Mr.- Taylor opened his address with the following, high encomiums: 1 "Cold indeed would be my heart, were it not touched, deeply touched, by the very generous words of wel come in which I have been presented to you tonight by your esteemed president. In one thing which he has said, he has touched me in a tender part he has pronounced the brilliant and cherished name of one of my dearest friends of whom I have lately been deprived by the hand of death. "In the course of my life it has been my rare privilege to have known well three men of genius. The first was the Reverend Abram Ryan, poet priest of the South, whose master hand swept along the. grandest chords of the human heart. It was privi lege, as' a young man, to publish his poems in a. little book that has gone forth like a ray of white light 'into nearly every Catholic household In the United States. "The second man of genius that it was my privilege to know was the brilliant Spanish orator and states man, Emilio Castelar, who during my time in Madrid bore the same re lation to the literature of Spain that Victor Hugo in his best days bore tu the literature of France. the Honorable Hannls Taylor, form er Minister to Spain and a Jurist of international fame, paid high tribute constitution, when It was plain to my to Cardinal Gibbons and two Ameri can priests. The eulogy is especial- .. be an American citizen, with a patrio is valuable because ne is a scholarly. I first knew Cardinal Gibbons hen he was Vicar Apostolic of North Car olina— not yet a full bishop. I have studied the life of that, great man and if anybody were to ask me to say in a word what has been the tone of that, character, what has been the great basis of his power, I should say that beneath the great Catholic prelate has been the great patriot and Ameri can citizen he has touched the hearts of the American people, he has taught you. his children, that there is a double duty—io God and country. And he has always linked one precept with the other." The address was a learned exposi tion of the, real authorship of the American -Constitution. After trac ing the- historical evolution^ of federa tion from its earliest beginning down to the formation of the United States of America, Mr. Taylor showed that the. first attempt, at a. federal agreement in our country was a. hope lew failure, because it was based on the dead constitution of states that, were extinct- with no hope of resur rection. He then declared that three with you injRinia, Pine-kite .- of South Carolina the days of your episcopate. Never was1 and' Alexander Hamilton In the Ked- eral convention of 1787 we- lenti cal, and though a radical departure from any political system yet invent ed, each showed clearly from its structure, that It was derived from a common source. In his ki-mr-!i for the authorship of our constitution, Mr. Taylor came upon the document which he pronounces the greatest, political document in t.he history of mankind and which contains all that Is em bodied in our Federal constitution. This document, is the. product of one intellect and Its unquestionable author is Peletiah Webster, born at Lebanon, Connecticut, in 1725. Under the, title "A Dissertation on the Political Union and Constitution of the Thirteen Unit ed States of North America," he pre sented for consideration of the dele gates to the constitutional convention the system of federation which has re mained the government of the Unltel States from the beginning. This treatise has been printed by congress for general distribution. In concluding Mr. Taylor said: "Now as a Southerner, devoted to his section, proud of it, this struggle that I am making, I am not ashamed to say, for this old New England Yankee, cost me a. mental struggle, of no small ac count.. Down to the time that I found this great document, and comprehend dit, 1 had always thought that the author—almost the exclusive pride of the authorship of the Federal constitu tion—belonged to my people. But as a mind that, the pride of authorship be longed to a son of New England, I said t0 n^elf-Historical. truth can not be sectiona,: and no man tic heart in has received degrees from six Amer-i withhold any meed of. praise, which Is lean universities and has been official-1 After the president of the universi-' the cal\cIaim to 1 him' who wo»ld trv to due to any citizen in. any part of the Union' ,sh the ^ough the result may dimln- P"*tige.of his own section of Pe°P,e' The South must be con- tent w,th the fee,,n* of John natlon that ln ,he P6"0" Marshall she has given to the the great interpreter and ex pounder of its constitution." She—"Fred, do you believe that-the pen is mightier than the sword?" H#-—"Well, you never sew anybody a cheque with a sword, did you? Won Parliamentary Independence For Their Country When J. Bull Took His Soldiers Away For the American War. EFFICACY OF PHYSICAL FORCE DEMONSTRATED When the Colonial Revolution Was Over Cornwallis Sent to Ireland to Reduce That Country To a Province. Every student of Irish history knows how Grattnn obtained tile repeal ot Poyning's law ami secured parliamen tary independence for his country In 1782. When the British troops were withdrawn from Ireland to go to Amer ica during lhe Revolutionary war, the Irish parliament raised an army of 80,000 men to defend the country from foreign invasion. When fully armed and equipped, Grattan demanded free trade and parliamentary Independence for Ireland, and England gracious!." granted them! After the American war was at an end, and the Irish Volunteers had disbanded, England sent troops into Ireland, goaded the people Into the rebellion of 17RS, and then de stroyed the Irish parliament two years after by annexing it t.o that, of Great Britain. By this Infamous Act of Union Ireland ld£t. its, nationality and was reduced to a British province. Thomas Davis in 'his "Song of the Volunteer of 1782" says: When Grattan rose, none dared oppose The claim he made for free dom They knew our Swords, to back his words, Were ready did he need them. Remember still, through good and ill How vain were prayers and tears— How vain were words, till flashed the swords Of the Irish Vounteers. To Henry Grattan. the Irish patriot. who took England at. disadvantage and boldly demanded a free parliament independent of British Interference, an Englishman pays the following tribute: "No government, ever dismayed him the world could not bribe him h* thought, only of Ireland lived for 110 other object dedicated to her his beau tiful fancy, his manly courage and all the splendor of his astonishing elo quence." When Pitt and Castlereagh, by brib ery and corruption, were working for the Union of Ireland with England, Henry Grattan spoke against the in famous measure as follows: "The minister misrepresents the sen-| tlments of the people, i)8 consideration, they have pronounced |.UK)i their judgment in favor of a Union. Of this assertion not one syllable has any existence in fact, or in the appearance of fact. I appeal to the petitions of her Parliament, Constitution, liberty,' honor, property, are taken away by her own authority—there is, In such arti fice, an effrontery, a hardihood, an In sensibility, that can best be answered by sensations of astonishment and dis gust. "The Constitution may be for a time ruptlon however irresistible, to put down forever an an-.ient and respect able Nation. Liberty may repair her golden beams, and with redoubled heat animate the country. The cry of loyal ty will not long continue against the principles of liberty. Loyalty Is a noble, a judicious and a capacious prin ciple but in-these countries loyalty. MINNESOTA S HISTORICAL SOCIETY $2.00 PER YEAR the gCGptrfi or he has be-1 fore traduced their reputation. He' asserts that after a calm and mature HlmK.PS? What w|thered {ant own twenty-one counties in evidence. To af-I America but. such a policy? An at firm that the judgment of a Nation tempt to bind men by a Parliament, against is for to assert that she has wherein they are not represented!! said aye. when she. has pronounced no all to make the falsification of her sentl- continue to practice on the Catholics! ments the, foundation of her ruin and Has your pity traversed leagues of sea the ground of the Union to attlrm tljat t0 g|t roa8t of as so lost. The character of the country countrymen." His name will be fond cannot be so lost. The ministers of the iy remembered for ages to come Crown will, or may. perhaps, at lengtii Henry Grattan was born in Dublin, find that it is not so easy, by abilities Ireland, July 3, 1746: In ^767 he went however great, and by power and cor- to London, entering as a student in the iiJ 1, S Was distinct from liberty, is corruption, not loyally. The cry of disaffection will not, in the end. avail against the prin ciple of liberty. 1 do not. give up the country. 1 see her in a swoon, but site is not dead. Though in her tomb she. lies helpless and motionless, still there is on her lips a. spirit, of life, and on her cheek a. glow of beauty:— -j Thou art not conquered beauty'3 ensign yet Is crimson in thy lips anrl In thy cheeks, And Death's pale flag is not advanced here. "While ii plank of the vessel sticks together, I will not leave her. Let ths courtier present his flimsy sail, and carry the light bark of his faith with every new breadth of wind I will re main anchored here, with fidelity to the fortunes of my country, faithful.! to her freedom, faithful to In a speech delhered in the IriAh House of Commons, on February 22, 179,'t, on a. bill for the further political relief of the Catholics, Mr. Grattan said: "Von are struggling with difficulties, you imagine you are mistaken—you are struggling with impossibilities. In making laws on the subject of religion, legislators forget mankind, until their own distraction admonishes them of two truths—the one, that, there is a.. God the other, that there is a, people! "Conquerors, or tyrants proceeding from conquerors, have scarcely ever for: any length of time governed by those, partial disabilities: but a. people so to govern itself, or rather, under the name: of government, so to exclude itself—the i~ industrious, the opulent, the useful, that, part that feeds you with Its in* I dustry and supplies you with its taxes, weaves that you may wear, and plows,'] that, you may eat—to exclude a, body^ so useful, so numerous, and that for-t^j ever!—and in the meantime to taaljr them ad libitum, and occasionally to pWige their lives and fortunes!—for: what'.'—for their disfranchisement!—It'jj cannot, be done! Continue it, and yoiljj expect from your laws what it wero blasphemy to ask of your Maker. "Such a, policy turns on the inventor, and bruises him under the. stroke of ,hp sword or un(1er t|)e ac(.umu,ation s|nl!, him of debr and loss of domain. Need I go to In-' was the case of Ire- enslflvr() for a century, and and blasted with her Protes- Ascendancy, like a shattered oate scatllR(1 on itf! hm hy the flre of i*s-j intolerance? What lost England attempt as some would now down by the black boy en ihie Guinea—and have you forgot the man at home by your side, our brother?" Henr.v Grattan, like Emmet, Wolf® Tone, Curran, Lord Edward Fitzgerald and other Irish patriots, "was a Protes tant, who desired religious as well political freedom for his Catholic Middle Temple, and in 1772 was called to the Irish Bar. Becoming interested ln Trish affairs, he took his seat in Par Uament oh December 11. 1775. for this borough of Charlemont. His first speech, four days later, was a protest against the grant of $17,500' a 'year each to two absentee vice-treasurers ot Ireland. The British reverses lii AJ J, 1/ iv'ifil?