Newspaper Page Text
Labor Unions and the Church. Rev. Robt. F. Coyle's Questions Answer ed—Will They Be Consistent? The following Is a copy of a letter 1 which has been sent to the secretaries of the various labor organizations of the city. The Presbyterian church, as a na tional organization, has for some time i been conducting a labor department, and the letters appearing in the labor press of the country by Rev. Charles Stelzle are a result of this movement. While we will not attempt to go into the sub ject matter necessary to a complete an swer of the questions propounded, we will endeavor to show by "a few local illustrations some of the reasons why union labor has such poor representa tion in the congregations of the differ ent religious denominations. * the same conditions and reasons applying to the country as a whole. The letter follows: -Denver. Colo.. Oct. 1. 1909. “Mr W. D. Henderson. Secretary-Treas urer, City. “My Dear Sir—Convinced that there is a wide. and. I-fear, a grow ing gap be- workingmen and tbe church, and desiring to find out tne cause thereof. 1 earnestly and very respect fully ask you to assist me. I propose to preach a sermon on Sunday evening. October 10. on the church in its relations to th«- masses, and. so fnr as possible. I want t-» get at the reason for the separation ' between them. Why do tbev staivt opart”’ Will you kindly help me by rn twerlug the following questions? •*1 —What proportions of mechanics 1 and laboring men and women of all 1 sorts, according to your observation, habitually stay away from church? •*2—Are those who stay away hostile to the church or simply indifferent? “3—lf hostile, why? If indifferent. 1 why? ••4 What Is the chief fault which workingmen have to And with the M'lfUih ? “Trusting that you will favor m** with 1 nn early reply and thanking you In ad vance for the same. Cordially yours. "R. F. COYLE." Question No. I—lt1 —It can only be answer ed by saying that w.» are aware that a very large per cent of working peo- ' pie do not attend church. Question No. 2 Simply indifferent. Question No. 3—Can Ik* covered by | answering No. 4. "What is the chief fault which working people have to find with the church?" This last question can Ik* summed up in about one word—lnconsistency. Unfortunately. labor organizations have many members who are ainicicu with the same trouble, and do not prac tice what they preach, but we believe thnt as a whole they come nearer to fill- ' Ailing the principle advocated than the church. It appears to the writer from personal observations, that the rbureh. while they profess to worship a supreme being, really worship the almlgh y dol lar Some time since we noticed a church paper or program (local), where 1 the question of Christmas gifts had com** up for discussion, and the sense of those In control was thnt it was 1 n poor example to set The lx>rd loved a cheerful giver, and the young should l>e educated to give to the church and not receive. Along the satne line we have yet to see n weekly church pro gram or paper which does not lay stress 1 upon the fact thnt money is needed and ' urging everybody to give np liberally as 1 possible. The church collects money front those ' who belong In this country and send missionaries to foreign lands, import the 1 natives In many instances to this court- ' try. ostensibly to "save” them, but as ’ a wind-up some American is out of a 1 position and the foreigner has the Job 1 at much less pay. Foreign countries, ns n rule, have a 1 very stnnll proportion of real crime ns t compared with the United States, where 1 we are civilized and require n policeman 1 on almost every rorner to prevent every- * body front putting his hand Into every- * body else's pocket. Wo believe this 1 country offers n much bettor Acid to ex- 1 pend the missionary funds in thnn any p rther, and we should have the prefer- 1 ence. "Charity begins at home." 1 There are thousands of people nt home who nro deprived of the nccos- £ nlttes of life. While the church preaches t nsslßting the poor nncl helping the down- £ Ftffodden. we see few' exnntplos of carry- n r. ing thnt doctrine Into practical jpe r n- e fcilon. Owing to the fnct thnt most of t the churches. If not nil. are maintained a by those who nro financially nble to c “come across” with a neat little sum c each month, and who are really affillat- i ed with the church because of the po- V cunlnry benefit accruing therefrom, and I: not because of any real religion, the or t dlnary working clftßß does not fool v at homo In tho congregations assembled I we nro not able to present tho pros- t UNITED Labor Bulletin Boost the Label VO I IV. perous appearance in the way of fine clothes and consequently we are made to feel, by the reception accorded, that we cut but little figure. The church always wants to assist people to get better conditions, relieve suffering and distress, and wants every body to find time to visit the church services. When the printers were mak ing an effort to secure the 8-hour day. the Methodist Book Concern refused to grant the men what was but their duo. replaced the union man with non-union men. and are still making up a hard fight to perpetuate long hours and low wages. We will cite one local experience of comparatively recent date to show why the breech between the church ana the working people Is kept open, and the feeling of indifference or hostility is en couraged rather than otherwise. Some three years ago the Loundry Workers of Denver organized. They de sired the enforcement of the state law. under which they were entitled to an 8-hour work day. This class of workers are mad • up of women and girls, almost entirely, and are compelled to work long hours, ten as a rule, with frequent overtime rithout extra compensation. Their wages are so small that If they miss one day's work they stand a good chance of missing one day's meals. The home surroundings and environments ot many of these workers would be a sur prise to a great many of those who reg ularly attend church, perhaps in an au tomobile. and who never give a second thought to the overworked women and cirls who. at practically starvation wages, clean their linen and assist in • nabllng them to present a fine appear ance at the church services. It also developed that many of the proprietors of these sweatshop laundries were* pillars in the various churches. Their automobiles or carriages were at the disposal of the ministers for an In vestigation of the sanitary conditions of their plants. An Instance of the apparent dollar worship occurred at this time. The writer, being Interested in the success of the laundry Workers, became aware • jof the fact that a certain minister had I been Invited to accompany one of the • proprietors of a trust laundry” °n a tour of Inspection. The laundrvman was to ■ call for the minister the next day in an automobile and escort him through j the plant. It was our desire to acquaint tho minister with some of the things he would see. nnd also give him a “tip" on -onto things he would not see unless he was posted We accordingly called on him While In his private room the telephone rang. It proved to be some person on the other end who was 1 : forested In the formation of a new church society of some sort. The min ister was being consulted, and It was ■ omewhit of n surprise to us to !e\rn that “slates." when it comes to electing ; set of officers, was not conffned io po litlcal organizations. However, thin -lie i not impress us so strongly ns th*' Uir- ! thcr fact that it appeared that th** nor on’s principal qualification forth ' va rious offices to be filled w-as his ability .» "get the money.” The churches and the Woman's Club, whose members are also, almost with out exception, members of some church congregation, were induced to Interest themselves in the matter of securing the eight-hour day for women. They both wanted to know how they could assist. The International organization of tho Laundry Workers, like mnny other na tional or International labor organiza tions. have a label. Several of the local laundries granted tho girls the shorter hours with no reduction in wages, and signed an agreement to that effect with the local union of the girls, which en titled the laundry so signing such agree ment to the use of this label. Those who desired to assist were asked to in sist that this label nppenr on their laundry slip. If they made this demand and carried It Into effect it would moan thHt the other laundries would neces sarily have to make the same agree ment to get the label; otherwise It could not appear on the laundry slip For advertising purposes, tho White Swan laundry made a grand stand play that they were going to bo the flood Samaritan, nnd In the name or justice nnd humanity, grant the employes an eight-hour day. However. Mr. Loesby. the proprietor, refused to have any agreement signed with the union to se cure the label. Tho girls urged the church people nnd the Woman's Club members not to patronize the plant, knowing the eight-hour day would be but temporary, nnd they would have no means of knowing when tho long hours were again resumed without some defin ite means of Information. So long ns the label appenrs on the work It means DENVER, COLORAC O, OCTOBER 15, 1909 that the agreement is being fulfilled, and when that agreement is violated it would be withdrawn. Notwithstanding the plea of the girls, and the fact that other plants were op erating with the signed agreement, the t church people and club members began sending much work and using their in t fluence in favor of this laundry. ine plant run an eight-hour day but a very short time, and then resumed the long j hours with overtime and no extra com pensation. It is still running long hours, and the girl who does not like the sys } tem can go hungry- till she finds another position or endure the conditions forced ’ upon her without recourse, j If the church people really desire to assist a class of people who need assist ance. do a little missionary work toward f encouraging overworked women and girls to continue at manual labor to earn an honest living, they could do much 'j effective work of a missionary charae ! ter. promote morality and otherwise as sist in bringing about sanitary and hu mane conditions by seeing that they , patronize laundries which grant these conditions. If you do this other plants will not be long in following the exam ple set by those entitled to the label. { and make an agreement with the women and girls. They cannot run without work. You can also do much toward making friends with the workers and interest j ing them in your cause by interesting yourselves in ours to a greater extent. ! When you purchase a pair of shoe* with the union stamp on them you are as sured by the stamp that some poor con vict was not given a dose of the cat-o*- j nine-tails because he was unable to pro- I dure another pair of shoes with yours t in a specified time, in order to satisfy j the greed of a private contractor who has rented the convict’s services from some state and requires a stipulated pro duction for perhaps a salary paid to the s state of 40 cents a day. whereas a free workman would receive $4 for the same work. TRADES AND LABOR ASSEMBLY ♦ At the meeting Sunday of the Trades i and Labor Assembly much business of: • importance was transacted. I Delegates were obligated: From the’ ‘ J Stereotypers, three; Tobacco Strippers. | ' two; Bill Posters and Billers, four. The ’ attendance was much larger than usual. • I The Plumbers and Steamfltters pre > I seated n resolution commending Judge t Allen for his fairness shown in their • trial against the Master Plumbers’ asso • elation, where an injunction was asked ’ prohibiting the union from attempting to 1 induce strike-breakers to quit work. The • resolution was unanimously adopted. The water committee made quite an interesting report upon the municipal ownership of Hie water plant and had a ■ resolution adopted to be sent out to local • | unions to place in the city charter by • amendment the recall, initiative and re j ferendum. The committee expects to soon be able to put out a petition for the 1 necessary signatures for presentation to the city council that the amendment may Ibe initiated and an election held. They j ; also expect to soon hold a large mass j meeting to acquaint the people with the facts they have gathered. The Team Owners report their union ” In fine shape, also subscribed for the 1 United Labor Bulletin for their entire organization. You should look for the j ' drop on the bridles to insure getting 1 things delivered by union drivers Walters reported so much demand for ■ union help that they have hard work filling them, especially the Waitresses, as they are short every day. BUI Posters and Billers reported that the J. J. Curran bill posting firm no longer employed union labor, and they are trying to introduce the open shop policy. The Bartenders submitted a resolution regarding the stand Sheriff Nesbit has taken by closing the saloons on Sunday, which the delegates didn’t seem to thor ougly understand, but after a lengthy debate nnd the Bartenders had explained that they were not after a Sunday clos ing. but were nfter a six-day work week, anil they didn’t care if the saloons ever closed, the resolution was laid on the tnble. Bakers nnd Confectioners reported their organization growing very rapidly. They had raised their dues 25 cents n month nnd had elected a business agent, who would look after their Interests in the future. Broom Makers reported only one union shop In the city nt present, that being Seltzer * Pfounts. nnd the same can be obtained If the union people will de mand them. Bnrtendors initiated six new members at the last meet, their union Increasing very fast. A resolution was adopted withdrawing the Assembly’s delegate from the Cham ber of Commerce, « b it was felt that no i good results were being received from j the affiliation, as 1 ost of the members of that organizatlt 1 were people who I were in accord witMtl! employers' asso- I ciations and were alng more to exploit » mechanics than th y were for building : up Denver. LOCALS i STEAMFiTTERS HELPERS. BALL. Steamfltters’ Hel er.-, Local No. 367. will give their first| annual ball Novem ber 12 at Cadwell ball This being their first ball since the|r organization they i are not sparing ally expense to mane everything a great. 1 success. They will I serve refreshments, the same being free or all present. * This young Local las shown a wonder ful growth since th ir formation. Their work in behalf of all organized labor certainly is commet clai.le and their per sistent demand for the Union Label is typical of old veters ns They are always among the first to j come to the aid of | others in distress and can always nnd a few dollars to acc< mpany their sym patby for their fel tnv men. Although they have been on strike for the past five months, they si tl are very much in evidence. During alt this time of trou ble they have not bAn —as the masters' association would lilafit 'O see—Instead of receding and mbers they have added ten new onesjfo their Loea\ That in itself is demonstrative of their cause being right, and with the material which com poses their organization, and if they still continue to show the same push i and euergv along with their practicing ihe principles of the Golden Rule as j they are at present, their cause will stand against all wjio organize to ruin them and to grind them down into I oblivion. 4 4 4 4 4 Carriage and WWg Makers acid 1 their regular meetlr., \A*ednesday night 1 with a very good atu Jance. The mem i hership Is increasing and they expect >oon to start an active campaign toward, signing all the factories in the city. A K'tnmittee has been appointed to dev:®*'j ways and means to fully carry out th. plans. All the men hers have certified ihtir willingness to advance fuuds and also the National will have men on the ground to assist in tr work. We regret to announce the death ot one of our best members last week, our corresponding secreiary. Bro. Geo. Hil Her. The International has adopted a death benefit and the family of our de ceased brother will e the first to secure the same. Bro. Richard was elected to fill the vacancy. ♦ ♦ + A GREAT VICTORY. 4 The Plumbers ar. very jubilant over their victory last w ek in winning their injunction suit gainst the Master Plumbers* Association. Judge Allen could find no evidence against the Plum bers' Union. In an eloquent address hej lauded labor organ itions with praises, stating that they w. re the grandest i It: rational institute for the working people in the world; that they have done more to elevate the masses; they have estab :'shd a system of benefits Hi.i are the greatest protection o human beings of any organized bodies, and In all It was proven that the main object of the mas ter plumbers seem- d to be to destroy the Plumbers’ organization. But their efforts have been like many others — proven futile. Full details will be pub lished later. ♦ ♦ + THE OMAHA STRIKE. 4 In a report submitted to the governor of Nebraska the d puty labor commis siotter. after a thorough investigation of the Omaha street car strike, reports that all efforts have bee; exhausted in an at tempt to settle the same. He reports that the business men's organization has been and are the main ones who i\re as , slating the street car company; that during the past four years, out of a mem bership of 650 cat men. the Business Men's association, by their constant complaints against be union, have suc ceeded in securing the discharge of at least 450: that the purpose of the Busi ness Men’s assoclat an is the open shop , policy; that the strike-breakers have been paid $10 a day by the company; that the chief of police permits them to be well armed all the time, and con cludes his report n>- follows: “With this I ceased all efforts to re conclle the parties in the controversy, feeling that I had exhausted every moans at my command. “With some experience in labor strikes and Industrial disputes. I am compelled to say that the present strike In Omah:; has been conducted with less disorder than any strike of a similar nature with in my experience. The strikers are conducting themselves In a most orderly manner. True, there has been some disorder, but it has been caused by foolish sympathizers of the strikers. “It appears to me. your excellency, after a careful Investigation of the causes leading up to this strike, and a faithful efTort to bring it to an end. that an im partial investigation should be had un der the provisions of the statutes, said statutes being attached hereto and marked ‘Exhibit C.’ This, I believe, should be done for the purpose of mak ing a permanent record if for no other reason. Business is suffering, men are suffering, the general public is suffer ing. I believe this whose matter could have been settled without a strike The striking employes say that they have at all times been willing to submit every point of dispute to arbitration and to re t. rn to work in a body if assured of fair end impartial arbitration of the roint* l.-.cntioned. President Wattles has so far refused to submit anything whatever to arbitration. Very respectfully. ‘ WILL M. MAUPJN. “Deputy Labor Commissioner.” We can only say that this method in : practice by the Business Men's associa tion will soon bring ruin upon them selves. for labor unions stood many jolts and still are on the Increase, not withstanding all opposition. 4 4 4 4 WILL ASK ARBITRATION. ♦ Will Seek Legislation Along That Line at Extra Session. ♦ To secure an extra session of the leg islature for the enactment of a law pro viding for the creation of a state board of arbitration is the latest move con templated by friends or sympathizers of the striking street carmen. The proposition will be submitted to some of the strike leaders during the day and it is contemplated to have petitions circulated among the people of Omaha within a short time. Those who contemplate this move have figured that it will cost about 120,000 to $30,000 to hold a special session of the legislature, and if the governor should hesitate on that account it is contem plated to take up a collection to reim . burse the state. The plans, however, are as yet in the formative stage, but unless the strike comes to a sudden termina tion the petitions will be circulated. Governor Shallenbergcr has announced officially he will call an extra session for the purpose of passing a guaranty bank deposit law should the present law be declared void by the federal court. pn> vidlng the decision goes into details on j the weak points of the law. This deci sion is looked for within a short time, and if the governor decides to call the extra session immediately upon the filing of the decision the frienls of the strikers will request that the creation of a state board of arbitration be included in his call.—Omaha Bee. ♦ + ♦♦* THINK IT OVER. ♦ When a union elects a member to an official position, it does so not to make him a target for censure and abuse, but 'that he may be a center around which the members shall gather to make ef fective the work of the organization. This is a lesson that has not taken hard : enough hold on the minds of union mem j bers. I There is a peculiar perversity possess ing many union people that makes thorn i knock the men they have elected to of ; tlce. They seem to have an idea that because they have elected a brother to office they have a right to dog him to their heart's content. They treat him very much the same way the Indians used to treat their squaws, only worse. The Indian made his squaw do the work, but he didn't have much to say. whne the union men piles all the work of the organization on the shoulders of the of ficer and a heap of abuse o:i his head. If the union members who are guilty of this folly would have as much to say in the way of boosting as they have in the way of knocking, how easy would be the work of the officers and how success ful the organization!—Ex. ♦ ♦♦♦♦ Painters and Decorators No. 79 are very busy as present, and they expect with good weather to continue, there will be plenty to keep them going for tome time. ♦ 4 4 4 ♦ Don’t forget that the houses listed in these directory pages are union estab lishments. It is up to you to consult The Bulletin whenever you want any thing in any line. You will hare little trouble in finding a union place to fill vour wants. Of course, we want you to patronize the union house that is an ad vertl8er first. 4 4 4 4 4 Home-made, hand-made, union-made — the La Belle 5c cigar. DO IT NOW rsio. io The Slaughter of Employes By C. A. Irwin. Ti.»s is a commercial age. America has made great progress in legislating for the conservation of property and property rights, but laws for personal security have been very much neglected. Last year the factories and shops of New York killed twice as many people as fell in the Spanish-American war. Last year the railroads of this country killed nearly 8.000 people and injured more than 70,000. In 22 days of last August the surface roads of New York City killed or injured over 5.500 people; and in the year 1908 there were 3,781 fatal accidents, and over 50.000 personal injuries in the factories and shops of a single American city. The daily report of personal injuries has become so regular that it attracts little attention. Legislatures and courts will continue to ignore this tremendous , human slaughter until a healthy public rcntimeut is created demanding its pre vention. It is appalling that 90 per cent of per sonal injuries in this country would be easily preventable with proper reguia 'ions. and that the pecuniary loss for the other 10 per cent invariably falls upon the injured party instead of where it belongs—that is. upon the shoulders of him who set in motion the dangerous agency which produced the injury. It is often asked, "why is it that industrial accidents are so much more numerous in America than in other countries?” To answer this question it is only neces sary to compare American laws for per sonal safety with the same class of laws in other countries. America gives less legal protection to life and limb than any other civilized country. Thirty-five years ago the English par liament passed a law providing: "Where, after the passage ot tu»o «ct, personal injury is caused to an employe, who is himself in the exercise of due care and diligence at the time: *‘(1( By reason of any defect in the condition of the ways, works or ma chinery connected with or used in the business of the employer, which arose from or had not been discovered or remedied owing to the negligence of the employer, or of any person in the service of the employer, and entrusted by him with the duty of seeing that the ways, works and machinery were in proper condition: or “(2) By reason of the negligence of any person in the service of the em ployer. entrusted with exercising super tatendency whose sole or principal duty is. that of superintendence: I "(3) By reason of the negligence of any person in the service of the em ployer who has the charge or control of any switch, signal, locomotive en gine or train upon a railroad .the em ploye. or in case the injury results in death the parties entitled by law to sue and recover for such damages shall have the same right of compensation and remedy against the employer, as If the employe had not been an employe of or in the service of the employer or 1 engaged in his or its work.” After the passage of the foregoing act of parliament the English courts in obeu ience to English public sentiment very properly held that the law meant exact ly what its language imported and that thereafter an employe injured through the failure of his employer to furnish a reasonably safe place to work and reasonably safe conditions under which to work could recover his just compen sation. and that it was no defense for the employer to show that the employe knew of the danger: in other words, that he did not assume the risk. This decision of the English courts throwing the financial burden of a large class of industrial accidents upon the employ er where it justly belonged had a great influence in stimulating the owners of shops and factories to exercise diligence for the safety of employes. American laboriug men hearing of the English act and its effect, at once be* came zealous for its adoption in Ameri ca; and* it has been adopted iu nearly every state, but it has been rendered valueless in this country by additions, amendments and judicial construction, example, in Colorado the act was adopt ed. but it was also provided that no re covery should exceed $5,000; that no recovery should be had unless written notice was given to the employer of the time, place and cause of the injury; and that if the employe knew of the defect or negligence which caused the injury before he was injured and failed to give notice thereof he could not recover. These legislative amendments clearly indicate that it was the purpose of the legislature to deceive laboring men into the Idea that they were passing the Eng lish employers* liability act, and at the same time to cater to the business In Incorporating Denver Label League Bulletin , a iH Owned and published by the Denver Label League No. 1, in the interest of Organized Labor. terests by practically destroying the ef flcacy of the act, and American courts, like American legislatures, have been so careful of business and so reckless of men that they have Invariably construed this act. as amended, to mean exactly the opposite of what the English courts have always said it meant. This is as far as American legislation has gone to protect the persons of em ployes, but England did not stop w’tb that old employers’ liability act. Fifteen years ago Great Britain. New Zealand, Australia and British Columbia had all passed laws providing that employers should be absolutely liable for all in juries received by employes while en gaged in the service, without reference to any other question, the amount of -nch liability to be definitely fixed in each case by easily ascertainable condi tions. such as the nature and extent of the injury, the wage earning capacity oi the person injured, and. in case of death, by the age. expectancy of life and earn ’ ing capacity of the deceased. ! Such laws have wrought a wonderful change in the protection of life and limb j and they have placed the financial burden I upon the shoulders of the employer, where it justly belongs. They have also since been applied to injuries by public | carriers with like beneficial results. How different is the situation in this country. Legislatures and courts have not yet come to regard men. women and ■ children as entitled to the same consider ation which they give to business and property. The responsibility should be placed upon the people themselves. Pub lic sentiment in this country has not been educated upon this question. Labor unions have been so busy in trying to. get a fair day’s wages for a fair day’s, work that they have failed to give the safety of employes sufficient considera tion. If a worthy public sentimeut is to be created, it must receive its impetus from the laboring people. Society may be likened to an aged tree that is dying, at the top; nourishment must come—if it comes at all —from below. People who toil with their hands have been the boue and sinew of every real reform that has made for human progress. If you would secure adequate legal protection for em ployes. you must agitate and continue to agitate, in season and out of season, until a public sentiment has been created which legislatures and courts will have ; to recognize. Until this is done nothing can be accomplished. The stream can not rise higher than its source; legisla tures and courts reflect the public senti ment which creates them. In a free coun try nothing can withstand the will of an aroused public conscience. There has never yet in this country been any sustained and well-directed ef fort in this direction. In one of his late messages to Congress. President Roose velt recomended a federal law which should virtually embody the English idea of a fixed copensation for all industrial accidents coming under the federal juris diction. such compensation to be auto matically determined acording to speci fied conditions: but Congress was so busy discussing the proposed tariff upou ladies' hose and other equally important sub jects. that they could only pass a half hearted measure that will likely be de clared unconstitutional by the courts. However, the receut congressional act is a large step in advance of previous Amer ican legislation on the subject, and it is to be hoped that when the act reaches the Supreme court for interpretation there may be a majority of that court who will consider a man as much entitled to judicial recognition as a dollar. 4 4 4 4 4 TAILORS WIN CONCESSION. 4 The tailors who went out on a strike in Chicago Monday, have practically you their strike. Six firms employing about 200 Isdl*>s* tailors yesterday sigued the new wage scale of the union, and their men, who went on strike in the morning, retur." 9 to work. Ten firms employing a! out 300 men ure still tied up as a reaul’ «f the strike, but some of them are eape* leu to give in today. The tailors are caking a minimum scale of $22 a wee!., with time and one-half for overtime. Frank Wokurku. secretary of the I.mli<r** Tailors’ Union, said last night that Hu expected the strike would be ended In a day or two, as it is the busy and the employers cannot find skilled help to take the places of the strikers. 4 4 4 4 4 Switchmen of North America <iit **• Joying a very prosperous seatem Kx perienced man ure in demand. The*'- or ganizations is in fine condition. 4 4 4 4 4 If we don’t boost our own game. n«w*4 we expect others to do what we will J